BlockBefore

Cottonwood Creek Bridge, Spanning Cottonwood Creek on Road 28, Madera

Cottonwood Creek Bridge, Spanning Cottonwood Creek on Road 28, Madera, Madera County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CA-325, with a 3,378-word written history.

From the record

“The Cottonwood Creek Bridge is one of the few remaining examples of a bridge designed by William M.”

Written record, HAER CA-325 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CA-325 · the record runs 3378 words · one of 11 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

3275 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-325. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Cottonwood Creek Bridge is one of the few remaining examples of a bridge designed by William M. Thomas, a prolific bridge engineer working out of Los Angeles, California. Thomas refined the three-hinged arch bridge design, often used in Europe but rarely in the United States. Although the design itself was not original, Thomas' s innovative method of construction involved precasting the arch rings in wooden molds at each bridge site. Thomas, along with partner and fellow architect W. S. Post, designed at least 17 bridges in California; in the process, he developed and eventually patented the system that bears his name. The Cottonwood Creek Bridge is the best known existing example of the patented Thomas System. Report Prepared By: Randy Baloian Applied EarthWorks, Inc.

North Fruit Avenue Suite 101 Fresno, CA Date: August COTTONWOOD CREEK BRIDGE HAER No. CA-325 Page2

Description

The Cottonwood Creek Bridge (41 is a three-hinged continuous concrete bridge constructed using a patented reinforced concrete slab system. The two-lane bridge is 200 feet long and 21 feet wide. The bridge deck is supported by seven chamfered piers and three arch ribs. The bridge was constructed on site using plywood molds. Small pieces of wood are visible in several spots along the arch ribs and piers, and the lines from the molds are still evident on the concrete. The concrete slab deck, which has since been paved with asphalt, was reinforced with a framework of articulated square twisted rods (rebar). The original guardrail is composed of whitewashed concrete post and pipe; the four end posts are decorated with chamfers and unadorned central panels on both sides.

Some posts appear to have been replaced in kind. Every third post is rectangular and approximately one-third larger; the remaining posts are square. One portion of the guardrail at the northern approach was damaged by a garbage truck in The damaged portion was replaced with a modem corrugated metal rail. The bridge has no shoulders or walkways. The structure is generally intact. The guardrail posts have begun to erode along the edges. Water damage evident in the arch ribs has promoted minor deterioration of the concrete. Both abutments show signs of pressure from the backfill behind them, which has caused some sections of the abutments to protrude.

Historical Information

Historic Context The Cottonwood Creek Bridge lies in what is considered one of the most productive agricultural regions in the nation. For early Euro-American settlers, however, the barren aspect of the San Joaquin Valley appeared to hold little potential for farming. Iin General Jose Castro received the first land grant in the area that is now Madera County during the Mexican administration of California. Named El Rancho de/ Rio San Joaquin, the 4 7,470-acre grant extended along both sides of the San Joaquin River.

Cattle ranchers, along with gold miners seeking their fortune in the Sierra Nevada, eventually displaced the indigenous Yokuts tribes, whose subsistence relied on the many rivers and creeks that flowed through the valley (Wallace California became a state in and the area between Cottonwood Creek and the Fresno River became part of Mariposa County. By the area was included in newly created Fresno County.

In the dissatisfaction with the county seat in Fresno led residents in the Madera area to petition for and successfully establish Madera County in The borders of the new county encompassed a variety of economic and geographical regions, including the Sierra Nevada and a portion of future Yosemite National Park, the ranches and mining towns of the foothills, and the agricultural lands of the valley. COTTONWOOD CREEK BRIDGE HAER No.

CA-325 Page 3 Although many miners turned to agriculture when their gold prospects dried up, only a few individuals were registered as farmers in an census (Clough Settlers arriving from the eastern and midwestern United States were unaccustomed to the Mediterranean climate and dry soils of the San Joaquin Valley, and early attempts to grow wheat without irrigation often met with failure (Fresno Weekly Expositor Such was the case of the Alabama Settlement, inhabited by southern farmers fleeing the dire conditions brought on by the Reconstruction during the late The town of Borden, located about 1.5 miles northeast of the Cottonwood Creek Bridge, was named for Dr.

Joseph Borden, a member of the ill-fated exodus (Madera Method Program Dry farming eventually proved disastrous for the transplanted southerners, and few remained on the land. As with other early valley farmers, however, those who stayed realized that successful cultivation depended on tapping a predictable water source, such as the Fresno River, to irrigate the dry land and selecting crops such as alfalfa as well as establishing orchards and vineyards that would thrive in the valley soils. Improved modes and avenues of transportation underlie economic development of urban areas in general and the success of such commodity-based industries as agriculture and livestock in particular.

To achieve this end in the San Joaquin Valley, however, it was necessary to resolve the inherent geographical conflict between the valley's hydrology and the orientation of its commercial development. With a few notable exceptions, the courses of most rivers and creeks flow across the valley in an east-west direction, yet the valley's larger cities developed along its north-south axis. Travel routes thus must cross a seemingly innumerable series of rivers and creeks to link these cities and their markets together. The increasing reliance on the automobile required roads and bridges with greater carrying capacity. Madera County saw a flurry of building activity in with the construction of at least five bridges, one of which is the Cottonwood Creek Bridge. William M.

Thomas Built in the Cottonwood Creek Bridge meets Criterion 3 of the California Register of Historical Resources and Criterion C of the National Register of Historic Places as one of the remaining examples of a bridge designed by William M. Thomas. The architecture and significance of the bridge are intimately linked with the life history of its designer, one of California's most innovative bridge architects. Born in St. Louis, Missouri, in Thomas studied architecture at the Chicago Art Institute in the (Hudlow Upon returning to St. Louis, he worked as a structural engineer for the Louisiana Purchase Exposition and later designed terminals for the Terminal Railroad Association.

His continued employment in the railroad industry led him to Tucson, Arizona, where he served as a structural engineer and bridge inspector. By Thomas had moved to California to join the Union Traction Company (UTC), which operated an interurban line in Santa Cruz. While employed at UTC, he devised what became know as the Thomas Three-Hinged Arch or the Thomas System. Bridges featuring the three-hinged arch-an arch with hinges at each abutment and the crown-were by no means new and, in fact, had been constructed in Europe before COTTONWOOD CREEK BRIDGE HAER No. CA-325 Page4 In a journal article published some years later, Thomas duly acknowledged these precedents, citing 12 German bridges with the three-hinged arch.

Although the use of the three-hinged arch was not by itself original, Thomas implemented an innovative method by which bridges were built on site using wooden plank molds to form precasted arches. The arches were then hoisted into place and affixed at the hinges. Thomas also patented a reinforced concrete slab system; initially intended for the construction of warehouse flooring, it was adapted for use in bridge construction (Hudlow The importance of the Thomas System thus lies not so much in its individual elements, which by themselves are not particularly novel, but in their coalescence and application as a functioning whole. Built in by UTC, Thomas's first bridge-the Water Street Bridge in Santa Cruz-spans the San Lorenzo River.

The bridge has endured at least three episodes of modification (Santa Cruz Public Works Department and its original design has been severely compromised. This bridge foreshadows the Thomas System by featuring the three-hinged arch. Hosever, the Water Street Bridge displays closed spandrel arches, whereas an open spandrel arch bridge was the archetype of the Thomas System.

In addition, the araches were poured about mile from the bridge site and transporting them proved to be costly (Wehle Parks Interestingly, Thomas' s use of the three-hinged arch in the Water Street Bridge was based not on a predilection for the design itself but on the fact that it was the best option given the lack of bedrock at that section of the San Lorenzo River (Wehle Parks Thomas' continued use of the three-hinged arch perhaps was a result of his familiarity with the design and a desire to make improvements in its application. Thomas left UTC that same year and teamed with W. S. Post to found an architectural firm, Thomas and Post, specializing in precast reinforced concrete three-hinged arch bridges.

The Los Angeles-based firm went on to design at least 17 bridges in California using the Thomas System. During its early years, the firm continually looked for ways to hone Thomas' system. The firm's primary rival at the time was noted architect John B. Leonard, who often submitted bids on the same projects as Thomas and Post (Wehle Parks Although both Thomas and Leonard championed the use of reinforced concrete in bridge construction, Leonard advocated a fixed-arch bridge of monolithic reinforced concrete.

The two men apparently competed not only in the economic sector but in the architectural forum as well, with each submitting several articles to their respective publications: Leonard was an associate editor for Architect and Engineer of California, while Thomas was a frequent contributor to Southwest Contractor and Manufacturer. It was through this journal that Thomas discussed the advantages of his system, which he considered easier and less expensive. The three-hinged arch design required less concrete and steel reinforcement than fixed-arch bridges. Moreover, the arches were built on site, thereby eliminating the need for extensive transportation of bridge parts.

In addition to cost considerations, the system offered structural benefits: the hinges allowed the arches to adjust to temperature-induced linear extension and contraction, and settlement of abutments and piers. For this reason, it is advantageous where seismic activity is a problem [Wehle Parks COTTONWOOD CREEK BRIDGE HAER No. CA-325 Page 5 Thomas' modifications to his system culminated in the construction of his fourth bridge, the Kern River Bridge built in in Bakersfield. Thomas apparently felt that his system had arrived at perfection or at least an optimum level, since no further refinements are found in subsequent bridges. In Thomas received a patent for the system that bears his name. Another of Thomas' notable bridges was the Parks Bar Bridge in Yuba County.

Built in across the Yuba River, the bridge was determined eligible for the National Register of Historic Places as a distinctive example of an unusual method of construction (Wehle Parks The Parks Bar Bridge has since been demolished, leaving the Cottonwood Creek Bridge as the only known example embodying the characteristics of the Thomas System. The Cottonwood Creek Bridge was one of five Thomas System bridges built in Madera County (Wehle Parks Other bridges included the Ash Slough Bridge near Chowchilla; the First and Second Slough bridges south of Berenda; and the Patterson Road Bridge, which also spanned Cottonwood Creek.

Although little information could be obtained regarding the construction history of these bridges, it is interesting that all five were built in perhaps suggesting that they were part of a large public works project in Madera. Built by the Federal Engineering Company, the Cottonwood Creek Bridge still bears vestiges of its construction. Wooden planks and small pieces of the plywood mold remain embedded in the concrete and are visible in several spots in the arch ribs and piers; lines left by the molds also are evident in the concrete. III.

Sources

Baloian, Mary Clark, and Sandra S. Flint Finding of Effect for Replacement of the Cottonwood Creek Bridge on County Road 28, Madera County, California. Applied EarthWorks, Inc., Fresno, California. Submitted to Madera County Road Department, Madera, California. Clough, Charles W. The, Rich, Colorful and Exciting Historical Heritage of That Area Now Known as Madera County, California. Madera County Jubilee Committee, Madera County Historical Society, Madera, California. Fresno Weekly Expositor Farming in Madera, 5 October. The Madera Project, Madera Method Program website, accessed 7 August Hudlow, Scott M. A Historic Architectural Survey Report for the Cottonwood Creek Bridge Madera County, California. Hudlow Cultural Resource Associates, Bakersfield, California.

Submitted to Madera County Road Development, Madera, California. COTTONWOOD CREEK BRIDGE HAER No. CA-325 Page 6 Madera Method, The Dr. Joseph Borden: Transplanted Pioneer Method/ portrait_valleylO.html>. Madera Method Library California Histories, accessed 7 August. Santa Cruz Public W arks Department Water Street Bridge Fact Sheet wsbridge.html>. City of Santa Cruz website, accessed 7 August. Thomas, William M. The Thomas System of Three-Hinge Arch Bridges. Southwest Contractor and Manufacturer, 4 April. Wallace, William J. Southern Valley Yokuts. In California, edited by Robert F. Heizer, pp. Handbook of North American Indians, vol. 8, William C. Sturtevant, general editor. Smithsonian Institution, Washington, Wehle Parks, Bonnie Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) No.

CA-132, Parks Bar Bridge (Yuba River Bridge). Plans Thomas System Plans for Proposed Bridge on Cottonwood Creek on Section Line between Sections 7 and 8, Township Range 18E, Madera County, California. Thomas System Engineering Notes for Bridge on Cottonwood Creek on Section Line between Sections 7 and 8, Township Range 18E, Madera County, California. IV. PROJECT INFORMATION The Cottonwood Creek Bridge (No. on Road 28 in Madera County (see attached map) is scheduled to be demolished in (Baloian and Flint A Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) has been approved by the Federal Highway Administration and California State Historic Preservation Officer and accepted by the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.

The MOA requires the County of Madera, the current bridge owner, to mitigate project effects through Historic American Engineering Record documentation. Project Manager for the recordation was Barry Price of Applied Earth Works, Inc. Sandra Flint and M. Colleen Hamilton of Applied EarthWorks, Inc. served as Co-Principal Investigators, and William B. Dewey of Santa Barbara, California, was the project photographer. COTTONWOOD CREEK BRIDGE HAER No. CA-325 Page 7 U.S.G.S. 7.5 Minute Topographic Quadrangle Madera, CA Bridge Location T12S-R18E Cottonwood Creek Bridge Photorevised tN 0 2 1 Cottonwood Creek Bridge E'c:3 E----------3 E---------3 E----------3 ~ Mile ReP.lacement Project Madera County, California Contour Interval: 5 Feet Prepared by Applied Earth Works, Inc. ,~, , - - .. ~ .

I ' I I ,I I ~ i E - I ~ ~i : ! t I ;. ., .i: I --~JI . .. ... .. . : i I ,, 8 gged ~Z "ON 3DOilUI OOOM.NO.L.LO:J ~ :b_ - - - ..- tr n m , x w r - w II z 6g~Ud ~z "ON 3DOUUI OOOM.NOJ,J,O:J COTTONWOOD CREEK BRIDGE HAER No. CA-325 Page 10 State DX i:,:1v=n Qf ijg Of ~lifiml'li!li . .t D. . ib ,\~ :f01':A:1 Ei"H,ti' l'!OJdl:rtiitm '!ir"* .. ~ap..,,"fmID:c. IOeJft. Fi ion for aoq,1Eit4 (h IIA'!B+ 1 ~ . to. Jlf.t:!11:Dii'. C. OlfG9'!!,t4l~~ei. ~ra!i: == ~ d ~ ! f 11-,a; __ ,Jun.,;~11.l(!Ra. 1 A;.o........_ . . tr hlv l6...19'11U la!u~ ., ~ i?1bbt XI b I I f if._ e ;te. l! l 19.U :rii.a~..,, " . , I ._ _ _ _ _ _ i .. _ ... . . . . . , ~ ~ u i r . , . - s , . 5 ! l l l ' t ' , H " ~ . r . ~ ~ - ~ ' mxrre i-fi ~ I ! . I E~~ f,, - _: =: ~- ,-nwonsw- nn' - -ij,,cs,,,,, r ,.f,..a. .a-----. - I - - ..

" Jg ,xo-3 emzww r 1 w w=r I mj ~~-~re t 21C nwemwc ser:cz = :1t n re a I a.; I '- s - jjt :e:x mr:i1'm".I~ t I: -:I-. ::: ,: :. -r: , =: - - - >~. ,,m M" i !N!O I l l ! & > ~ ~ - - - - _ . 5 .. -' " - ... ,. :::.-.,.,;i: ,,iwl,liij?.Aj--.. . . . ~ - - . - - ~ ~ ~ ... -i I zt 'jr - f u.------- , wonw - -fi " """ @' I W M 4 3 : 1 w ' -,1 , w:s rrt ~-~t-~~1'".!e e? * 4 COTTONWOOD CREEK BRIDGE HAER No. CA-325 BRIDGE ALTERED Page 11 Rmia!Nu. .41.e.. e n: "'e n .. , ~ llPOlT OIUGiNAL ~fOfi ' ,Etu r of ~ a . l M al;, 7 1 ,UOfll"'l'tt'"-l!.~ :Gamtrd~~ two !11~'!!!-u!!!h ,Uld O <rDOrtW WlDI i.ldMAW.. - --A.urouma~~ N~,o. - - - .,m _ ... SptmL.SoG.th ,.,o.. f!.o::tJ!l.., l, o :e,.2 0 If' J. it - -- ~agt:L o RaMiw.q w.uith .O._&~ . , ~4LQ.U.r.to ~ ~l'lJfflt'.11uwffl~lw ~B.

~ ; -nn~~h:~~-i;,- J!,:u.rn;.~..,1 !1.,a: .'&/<U$:~-=--~-,io-~w-. 'Wlddi.---hi.r._. ~!t,e Qg ,(lldJo.~qt 8Wiilml Qf ~i~.biN C.ount-1 ('tnma. .. aw "~JUI.el .. oh!k~_!,!'!,!,_!!llow.1 s ff &~;!!!ift clet.fll:.DH,. v~~i..wi~itd."it... --- (Sediapm1) 7 DtteEu,li&~--Ul.t-.. - ~ - , -........Co.atn.ei:.No... --- I>c,i.~ f t ~ ~ ..Pau:!q.~ -=- FbfiL.... field ol111o.lrbd.. J.n ~tl ~ - a - tile "- - - - - - - - - - - ~ - ~tt:~$..a'A>"" ''I'? I + ~--l-......-.~T.li..__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ - ai: llidere C6i:iitj ,l!'Of!H lib-23 u,. rue ~~ HI -, - ~ ~,,i~J 'Jl.i~,f of--- ' ~".'fl.W'IM"4MD COTTONWOOD CREEK BRIDGE HAER No. CA-325 Page 12 il'TJ.H or~l"a111111A DIM!Wfflll:MT Tlh'IHl"'l:IHTIITlllii . . IRIDGI- REPQRT lr;J.daa, --- tiMIII l\ll'II ~r " '" 43 _ .. _ _ _ _ _ ,.

_ _ _ ., _ _ _ _ _ _ _ BV!SEP OJ:IGmAL :DROM' P ..U..C, ~- 1,j.jjiit-W-lt.tP!!"!!'"!"' -- --- _...._.u,.,,F,Jlf-"'"- - ~'' M l.4Jclillon --- * Ci! _ alUidiltttt'"~" 1ia N . il!I tnnl'lilpttm"i!~~.~.!:~ .. ... \ ~ CN!U o.,;. mi. Borth of Avmiwa 10) """'""-~----.a... ur1~~~1tll(,.~~ i;-liti.f'~,~tlt!!f-- ._.,.........,.,oa.i -- -- --~in, lll)l.:i STRL!CTUM4. DATA AN1> Hl!mllilY Sys.teas} . Federal e'?'_..__ Nit. I' ludt_ .. B)I " " " - - - - - - - - - - ~ ef lllllflllunl .. -- - - .,-..,a-,.~ --- --~iii f . 0 Dt fOJ'lld 80. OOWit.Y . _. SD. .- -- .. -- - pfaniJ AvtW.~ ii.,:,~~+- M rlal!I ~ 9f.r.4er (4) on. RC i06l.1.Dim C2) be1rt;3 a(ld RC a1*tr11tut'ts ~ l. 6 251 1 @ (Soutft tic- l'lo:rth} ~ - ~ - - - - - - .. - - .. - ..~..&-li.cl1n:n~,""~----- -...;~.a.,1,.1."""a:nn.~~ . 200 0 ... .

On); ,-- .Stotw . - ... H-h<i Ottlan LL ~-~~oijo~"'d~tu,n~ AM~ OPlfwHnt-~~? ~~ .. - - . ltfl'!nu .. A .. DEBCRIPTlON ml a.nuCT\IM .. o. Pw - 20 .. 1~ - o. 2: 1 st .. .. 0 .. 1 cu 1.l'idltft - - ...i;Ju~u,,n~nn-~lf -- -----..,;,.Mi~"'IIJH:~'J''n-- -- u,~w n:e,. . . Wifl:Ji, T~ __ ., . ... _~~ . . , - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ "~IJM.k . __ 2 .,. _ lilldfilfl H . ... -- --- Rall . _ . . . . . . . . . 'UfiiJilpa b:ed VI& C l ~ IDYtf 4~ uu~.. - - -.. --- -- -- ~.. . . .. ~i. J2 I Wf.dtlli -- -- - "11Mna ~ . .-- --- - ""' -- Cte;l :etaf --- ----.nua:$ll'11:'/M~ 1 '" -- wanaen~ -~ !i11nt.;t-.~!1,u-~1!1'"t--- .. --- ., - -- - ~IPT:IOM Utl!DEB 9'H11UC:fllli .. . ~ -- off'.Ul101.i. .-1i.:kx.~fj~it1.1' -- .., --- "-._ilitfil<>if- .."o- - --- * .. -" ~,;.j,1k.'.llio'i.lJ".tHH!~< . Cldlllaa:11: 92 - - - . .

.- Hilrla:.1----..r.~,HU l>" ~.l!'UUli~I!'!'! .. -- -. . --. . ~.wr,-.....;a...1i.Utmr ~"' m. __ - . CJ ht Ir. Ho. "" -- . k I Cf.alld-- -- ' .i:l'o!"'-"li'tnu&0:--~t " --- -- -.i~~ii1.i.,;sj,;.-i,~-~ "- ~ 90: ,rl>'.t'OIJ!il'T,.

In context

Madera, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Madera County, California 204 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Madera County

10 records

The federal survey recorded these other structures elsewhere in Madera County. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Wassama VillageHALS CA-622,155 words
Sierra National Forest Supervisor's HeadquartersHABS CA-2864720 words
Camp Barbour BlockhouseHABS CAL,10-MILL.V,1-37 words
Fort Miller BlockhouseHABS CAL,10-MILL,1A-35 words
Fort Miller BakeryHABS CAL,10-MILL,1E-33 words
Fort Miller Officer's QuartersHABS CAL,10-MILL,1B-33 words
Fort Miller FordHABS CAL,10-MILL,1F-31 words
Fort Miller HospitalHABS CAL,10-MILL,1C-29 words
Fort Miller Mess HallHABS CAL,10-MILL,1D-29 words
Fort MillerHABS CAL,10-MILL,1-23 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CA-325. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.