According to a historic resource evaluation completed in Palmdale is significant for association with the settlement history of Alameda County, Washington Township, and Mission San Jose. It is also important for association with the lives of persons significant in our past. Elias Lyman Beard, one of the earliest American settlers in Alameda County, first established the residential estate known as Palmdale in the late Juan Gallegos, the property s second owner, was the son of the first Costa Rican president and owner of one of the largest wineries in California at the time. Palmdale is additionally significant under the themes of architecture and landscape architecture. The estate features a Tudor Revival and a Normal Revival style house, both built in with matching detached garages.
Portions of the extensive designed landscape date back to the property s original owner, and many features developed under subsequent periods of ownership remain today to reflect the property s long history of use as a residential estate. 1 The property has been identified as a historically significant cultural landscape, displaying characteristics of both a historic designed landscape and a historic vernacular landscape, as defined by the National Park Service A historic designed landscape is a landscape that was consciously designed or laid out by a landscape architect, master gardener, architect, engineer, or horticulturist according to design principles, or an amateur gardener working in a recognized style or tradition.
The NPS defines a historic vernacular landscape as a landscape that evolved through use by the people whose activities or occupancy shaped it. 2 The estate as a whole has been identified as a historic district, and district contributors include both architectural and landscape features. See the site maps included in the appendix to this document for locations of major landscape areas, key buildings, district contributors and non-contributors, and tree locations. 1 Carey & Co., Department of Parks and Recreation series forms (Primary and BSO) for Palmdale (June page 9 of 18. 2 Defining Landscape Terminology, guidelines/terminology.htm (accessed 15 September PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO.
CA-112 (Page 2) This HALS documentation is being completed as part of the environmental review process for proposed new development on the property. Since the property qualifies as a historical resource under the California Environmental Quality Ave (CEQA), the City of Fremont required documentation of the historic landscape prior to alteration for new development. Description: Palmdale, a historic residential estate at Washington Boulevard in Fremont, California, was developed between the and the by a series of owners.
The acre property is currently owned and occupied by the Sisters of the Holy Family a community of Roman Catholic Sisters, who purchased the property in The site has a wide variety of buildings, structures, and landscape features, which date to one or more of the property s five ownership periods. A Historic Resource Evaluation (HRE) completed by Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill provides a detailed description of the property and its associated buildings, circulation patterns, and historic landscape features. This descriptive information is summarized below. See original document for full text.
3 Boundaries The acre Palmdale Estate originally occupied a much larger land area, but is today bounded by Mission Boulevard to the east and various modern residential developments on the south, west, and north. Historically, the estate was accessed via entry gates along Mission Boulevard, and this boundary served as the property s principal public face. Marking this boundary is a stone wall, which is topped with an ivy hedge. This wall extends from the northeast corner of the property to just south of where Mission Creek enters the property. The primary entrance gate is a double-leaf wrought iron gate with Palmdale spelled in metal panels across the face of the gate.
A secondary entrance gate (a single-leaf metal gate hinged to stone pillars) is located just south of where Mission Creek enters the property. Perhaps the most prominent historic feature in this area, however, is the row of fourteen mature Mexican fan palms that line Mission Boulevard along the outside of the stone fence. Circulation The historic primary entrance drive extends from the double-leaf entrance gate on Mission Boulevard to a loop accessing the Best and Starr houses and the Motherhouse. The loop was established in when the Best and Starr houses were constructed; sections in front of the Motherhouse were added or altered in when that building was completed.
Secondary roads 3 Nancy Stoltz, Denise Bradley, and Ward Hill, The Sisters of the Holy Family Fremont, California, Historical Resource Review (October pages Parenthetical and photographical references have been omitted from the summarized text; see original report for full text and references. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 3) lead to parking areas at the east and west of the Motherhouse, and to the connection with Bryant Terrace at the south (rear) side of the building. Originally, a secondary entrance drive provided access into the estate from the ancillary entrance gate at the south end of the Mission Boulevard boundary wall, but this access point no longer exists. The circulation routes through the parking lots and behind the Motherhouse are non- historic.
Shorter driveways lead from the main loop to access the Best and Starr houses and other secondary access roads throughout the property. Topography, Water Features, and Spatial Organization The property is generally level, but slopes down somewhat from the southeast corner to the northwest corner. Mission Creek cuts diagonally through the eastern portion of the site, and its original alignment has been altered within the property. Elias Beard added four ponds to the site during his ownership period, and later Juan Gallegos moved the Mission Creek s channel westward (from its original location) and added additional ponds. When the Best and Starr houses were completed in necessary alterations to the primary entrance drive created new subdivisions within the landscape.
According to Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill: The grading that accompanied the realignment of the creek s channel, the creation of the basins for the ponds (to the east, west, and south of the creek), and the construction for the internal roads modified the site s original topography and created several prominent topographic features; these include the two bowl-shaped areas located below (west) of the creek on either side of the Primary Entrance Drive and the broad level expanse of ground that provides a setting for the fronts of the Best House, the Starr House, and the Motherhouse. The arrangement or spatial organization of the property s cultural landscape was created over time within this framework of the internal roads, the site s topography, and the location of Mission Creek.
The resulting major landscape areas and their associated features are described below. 4 Major Landscape Areas and Features The two garden areas located between the Mission Creek alignment and Mission Boulevard are identified in the HRE as the Northern and Southern Pond Garden Areas. These gardens contain the two extant historic ponds, both of which are central features within these landscapes. A large, rustic stone fountain is the focal point of the Northern Pond Garden Area. The bottom is paved with concrete, and the edges are lined with are various sizes of lava rocks rather than the smooth concrete curbing found at the southern pond.
A small island (also edged with lava rocks) 4 This HALS documentation package will use the same terminology for the different landscape areas of the site as the HRE. See Photo Appendix for a site map. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 4) is set at the southwestern portion of the pond, and a small, decorative faux bois bridge is along the pond s northwestern edge. 5 There is a non-historic bench (wood slats attached to metal frame) mounted on a concrete slab at the southwestern corner of this garden area. A historic faux bois bridge spans Mission Creek providing access between the Northern Pond Garden Area and the Sunken Garden Area to the west. Access to this footbridge is currently restricted at both ends by non-historic metal gates.
The focal point of the south pond is also a large, rustic stone fountain located near the center. The pond is lined with concrete and a non-historic bridge (wood deck with metal railings) spans its north end. Both of the ponds are concrete lined and cracked, and therefore currently stand empty for much of the year. Between the north end of the pond and the entrance drive is a paved water channel that encloses a heart-shaped planting bed (the Heart Garden). Research indicates that this feature was constructed by Oscar Starr as a present for his wife Hazel. Three non- historic benches (wood slats attached to a decorative metal frame) are located around this garden.
Historic vegetation in the north and south pond garden areas includes the grass lawns around the ponds, the row of trees along the creek, and the palms that line the main driveway. West of the Northern Pond Garden Area is the Sunken Garden Area. Set north of the main driveway, this area includes a bowl-shaped depression that was formerly occupied by a historic pond, as well as a level lawn area to the north. The pond was drained during the Best-Starr ownership era. Landscape features in this garden area include a non-historic cast concrete fountain and garden pavilion in the center of the area, as well as stone steps and flagstone walkways to the eastern end of the garden.
Two grottos are located in this zone: one constructed of rustic stone with a small, mass-produced concrete statue of Christ, and the other depicting Saint Margaret Mary Alocquoe being visited by Christ (Sacred Heart Grotto). These grottos were added during the Best-Starr era, along with five others in the Memorial Garden; all are similar in construction, but have different religious statues and detailing. 5 Faux bois is a French term which translates as false wood involves creating three dimensional representations of wood and wooden objects (like the bridges, garden table and seats, edging details found throughout the Palmdale garden) that became popular in the U.S.
in the late and early century as a another expression of rustic garden furnishings often found in naturalistic designed landscapes of the period. Faux bois objects are created by applying various cement-based mixtures onto a steel framework or armature , and sculpting it to mimic the real material . . . It involves first building a steel framework (referred to by sculptors as an armature ), securing and forming metal mesh known as lath , then building up multiple layers of concrete, mortar and often pure cement paste. All the while, shaping, sculpting and detailing the material as it hardens . (Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill, PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 5) Other features in the Sunken Garden area include two faux bois garden seats, stone edging, and lava stone and faux bois edging.
A faux bois barbeque is located at the southwest edge of the garden, and a stone sun dial is set about 40 or 50 feet north of the barbeque. According to the HRE: The sundial is all remains of a larger garden feature from the Best-Starr Era which included a large circular planting bed around the sun dial and a wooden trellis around the edge of a portion of this bed. Historic vegetation features within the Sunken Garden Area include the lawn and the large trees (including the palms that line the north side of the Primary Entrance Drive, the row of trees that lines the west side of the creek, the coast redwoods located around the north edge of the former pond, and the large Monterey cypress located at the west edge of this area).
6 The Pine Grove Garden Area (located south of the main entrance drive and west of Mission Creek) is a comprised of a bowl-shaped depression and a sloped lawn area between the creek and the southern entrance drive. This garden area extends to the southeastern corner of the property, and the only structure here is a non-historic rectangular brick patio surrounded by non-historic incense cedar trees. Similarly, the only circulation feature is a stepping stone path (possibly historic) that connects to the pedestrian bridge over the creek to the Southern Pond Garden Area. Historic vegetation includes the lawn, the row of trees lining the west side of the creek, and palm trees lining the main entrance drive.
Also significant are the row of trees (palms and evergreens) along the southern entrance drive. The Memorial Garden Area is bounded to the north and west by the main driveway loop, on the east by the southern entrance drive, and to the south by the parking lot east of the Motherhouse. The west end of the Memorial Garden features stone-lined paths around a small artificial pond with a decorative faux bois bridge. Five grottos are arranged within this space and connected by the stone pathways. This garden was developed during the Best-Starr era, and was extended to the east during the Sisters of the Holy Family era.
Non-historic features installed during the SHF era include saw-tooth brick edged paths and beds, a wooden gateway at the east end of the garden, free-standing statues, memorial plaques, benches, the Peace Pole, and associated vegetation. Historic vegetation in this area includes the lawn and the large trees (Mexican fan palms, Canary Island palms, a Norfolk Island pine, an olive, a coast redwood, a giant sequoia, and a deodar cedar). The Central Green includes the grassy areas in front of the Best and Starr Houses and the Motherhouse building. The two beds to the north were created in when the looped driveway was established to provide vehicular access to the two residences.
The bed at the southeast corner was created when the driveway was extended in front of the Motherhouse in 6 Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill, PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 6) The primary vegetation features in these areas are the grass lawn and large trees. Notable trees include the Canary Island date palms around the edges of the two northern beds (Best-Starr era), and the Mexican fan palms in the northeastern bed (remnants of rows of these trees present when Best and Starr purchased the property in The trees in the southeastern bed include a large gingko (Best-Starr era or earlier) and two trees planted during the SHF era. A decorative stone wishing well (set atop a septic tank) is located in the northeastern bed, and was built by long-time Palmdale gardener Jack Pereira.
The narrow band of ground that extends across the front of the Best and Starr houses to the outer edge of the Looped Entrance Drive (the Best House and Starr House Public Landscape areas) includes small trees, shrubs, boxwood hedges, and perennials. Although these landscape areas date to all of the existing vegetation has been planted during the SHF era. The backyards behind the Best and Starr houses are separate large open spaces enclosed by a combination of fences and vegetation. Historic vegetation features remaining from the Best-Starr era include the lawns and a large Canary Island date palm in the Starr House yard. Pre-1927 vegetation features include the remnants of two parallel rows of Mexican fan palms located immediately west of the Starr House.
Historic features in the Best House Private Landscape Area include a faux bois table and chair and a wooden arbor (rebuilt) located at the southern edge of the yard and providing passage into the Starr House yard. Non-historic features include the concrete patio, a shed in the southeast corner, a wooden gazebo in the southwest corner, a stone pedestal (missing its basin), and a concrete birdbath. Historic features in the Starr House Private Landscape Area include a metal fence and gate across the end of the driveway and flagstone paving at the south edge of the yard. Non-historic features include the garden pavilion (a wrought iron/metal canopy supported by four metal posts).
The West Perimeter Landscape Area extends across the western border of the Starr and Best House backyards and contains three non-historic sheds and a variety of trees that serve to visually define the west boundary of the two backyards. These perimeter trees appear to date to the pre-1927, Best-Starr, and SHF eras. Historic trees include the Mexican fan palms, possibly several Monterey cypress trees, a large redwood, and likely some of the other larger evergreens in this area. The North Perimeter Landscape Area occupies the area north of the Best House Garage. Historically, this area contained an orchard or was used for other agricultural purposes. Today it contains two storage sheds, a gravel parking lot, and a vegetable garden all non-historic. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO.
CA-112 (Page 7) The parking areas along the south and west sides of the Motherhouse were expanded gradually but have been in their current configuration since at least the late The parking lots east and southeast of the Motherhouse were added between the late to early and replaced land that historically had been used for agriculture. The addition of these parking lots resulted in the removal of most of the historic vegetation features; the remnants that remain include the row of Mexican fan palms immediately east of the Motherhouse (part of the pre-1927 rows of palms that marked the edges of fields) and a large California pepper tree.
Buildings Starr House and Garage The Starr House is a large two-story Tudor Revival Style building, set on the west side of the property, about 100 feet south of the Best House. The wood-frame residence is generally rectangular in plan, with an asymmetrical front fa ade oriented northeast to face the central lawn. The steeply pitched, side-gabled roof is covered with slate shingles, and the exterior walls clad in textured stucco. A pair of two-story gabled bays flank the front entry porch, which is distinguished by an arched portico and arched wood entry door. The front gables feature decorative half-timbering and carved bargeboards ornamented with a vine and flower motif. A smaller single-story gable is set to the south of the front fa ade.
Two tall stucco-clad chimneys are present, one south of the main entrance, and one at the north elevation. The original wood windows are primarily fixed or casement sash in varying configurations with leaded glass or single pane glazing. Secondary entrance doors are located on the south and rear (west) elevations, and a covered porch has been added to the back of the house; no other significant alterations have been made to the house. A wood-frame, square plan, one-and-a-half story garage is located just south of the Starr House. Also Tudor Revival in style, this detached garage features a twin-peaked, steeply pitched gable end that faces the main house.
The north elevation has decorative half-timbering above the garage door opening, and small cross gables occur at the first floor on the side facades. Asphalt shingles cover the roof, and the walls are clad in textured stucco. Wood-sash casement windows are seen on both levels. Alterations include replacement garage doors, a new entry door on the west elevation, a small addition at the southwest corner, and some interior modifications. Best House and Garage The Norman Revival Style Best House is a two-story, wood-frame structure with an L-shaped plan. The hipped roof has an intersecting gable on the south and a variety of secondary roof forms at the front fa ade. Textured asphalt shingles have been applied over the original wood shingles, and rolled eaves simulate a thatched roof.
PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 8) Exterior wall surfaces are clad in stucco and the windows are primarily multi-pane casements with leaded glass. The house faces the central lawn to the southeast. The asymmetrical front fa ade has a prominent, two-story turret with a conical roof, set just north of the main entry porch. A projecting two-story hipped section dominates the north portion of the front fa ade and features an angled bay window at the ground level and decorative half timbering at the second story. At the south part of the fa ade is a two-story gabled projection with a larger angled bay window at the first floor. The simple front entry is located between the turret and the gabled projection, beneath a small eyebrow dormer.
The arched entry door is framed with rusticated quoins. The two-story rear ell forms a distinct wing that extends into the rear yard. A large, three sided end bay on the first floor houses a conservatory, and a raised terrace sheltered by a tent-like structure extends from the rear elevation. The second floor room above the conservatory features several windows and a set of French doors that open on to a large balcony. Alterations include a raised red brick entry porch and access ramp at the front elevation and installation of the tent structure over the rear terrace. The wood framed, three-car, Norman Revival style garage is one-and-a-half-stories tall with a T- shaped plan.
Like the main house, its hipped roof is clad in a layer of textured asphalt shingles applied over the original wood shingles. Dormers project from the roof on the south and west. A two-story apartment, attached to the rear of the garage, is a later addition. A central double- hinged door is located on the south side. The Motherhouse The wood frame, Mission Revival style Motherhouse is located at the southern edge of Palmdale property, southeast of the Best and Starr houses. Constructed in the building has a square plan x 200 feet) with a square, open center court yard. The hipped roof is covered with red clay tile and the exterior walls are clad in smooth stucco.
The entry porches have projecting shed or gable roofs and the windows include sliders, double-hung and casements organized in groups of two or three. The front (north) fa ade has a projecting, one-story central entry portico with three arched openings. A bell tower is located to the right of the entry lobby area. A nine-sided projecting bay is set at the east end of the main fa ade, and the west side features a rectangular projection with a hipped roof.
According to the HRE, the Motherhouse has received a number of alterations since its construction in The east wing was remodeled with 22 bedrooms and 11 bathrooms in All the windows were replaced in A number of tenant improvements for an adult day care facility, the On Lok Lifeways Senior Health, were undertaken at the west wing PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 9) around that time, including the access ramp on the west side that was built in This facility was remodeled and expanded in 7 The Gardener s Cottage and Accessory Buildings The gardener s cottage and five accessory buildings are located at the southwest corner of the property just west of the Motherhouse.
The gardener s cottage, also known as the Reidy House, was moved to this location in and the other structures were either moved or constructed in their present locations that same year or later. The accessory buildings include a greenhouse, a wood frame barn, a modern shed structure, and two wood frame garages Sheds Five modern wood-frame shed structures are west and north of the Best House. An additional small shed is just south of the Best House. Three sheds are west of the pergola in the rear yard of the Best House, and two additional sheds are north of the Best House just west of the garage. All structures appear to date from the last 15 years, and each one has a single door, a gable roof, and vertical wood siding.
History: Palmdale has been the subject of various reports over the years, but two recent studies have been completed that together comprehensively document the history and development of the Palmdale Estate through the present day. They are the Department of Parks and Recreation series forms completed by Carey & Co., and the previously mentioned Historical Resource Review by Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill. These sources are quoted below and provide historical background information for Palmdale. Selected passages have been omitted from the text quoted below; see source documents for full text. E.L. Beard Era A native of New York, [Elias Lyman] Beard was one of the earliest American settlers in Alameda County.
At the height of the Gold Rush in he acquired a disputed title to the original [Mission San Jose] compound (excluding the church and priest s quarters) along with the mission orchards and vineyards, about acres total. Beard operated a general store in one of the adobe buildings, rebuilt one of the quadrangles for his family s home, and cultivated the mission orchards. He also built a mill along Mission Creek. In when Beard s original claim of acres was rejected and the Archdiocese of San Francisco regained title to the mission compound and adjacent land, Beard moved across Vallejo Street (Mission Boulevard) to the subject property. This land was likely 7 Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill, 19. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 10) part of his holdings. Finally, in Beard and his stepson Henry G.
Ellsworth were granted clear title and patent to about acres of former mission lands. The bulk of Beard and Ellsworth s property consisted of three adjoining parcels designated as surveys 1, 28, and 38 of the Land of Ex-Mission San Jose. 8 By Beard and Ellsworth had sold most of their acres to James R. Keene; Beard retained ownership of 368 acres adjoining his estate. By La Societe Francaise Deparges et de Prevoyance Mutuelle had purchased Keene's property as well as Beard's, who had recently declared bankruptcy. Founded in San Francisco in La Societe offered assistance to ill and impoverished French immigrants by operating hospitals and insurance programs. It seems the organization purchased the land on speculation because it was quickly sold.
In the spring of La Societe subdivided the property into 52 parcels, ranging in size from 5 acres to 913 acres, and sold much of the land to Juan Gallegos. Beard laid out a palm-lined drive and four ponds (two of which remain extant) but beyond that much of fabric of his original gardens was altered by successive owners. Some of the site s mature trees (such as the Mexican fan palms) may date from this era. Although the precise origin of the name has never been determined, it appears that the estate first came to be known as Palmdale during Beard s ownership. 9 Juan Gallegos/Palmdale Wine Company Era Juan Gallegos belonged to a prominent Costa Rican family. His father, a Spanish nobleman, had been sent by King Carlos of Spain to govern the colony of Costa Rica.
In he became the country's first president. Juan Gallegos was born in Costa Rica in June In he married Julia Montealegre, the 18-year-old daughter of another former president of Costa Rica, Jose Maria Montealegre who had come into power in at the head of a revolutionary movement, serving as president until He helped draft a new constitution, reduced the national debt, and instituted a postal stamp system. He also amassed a fortune as a coffee grower. In Juan and Julia Gallegos, accompanied by the elder Montealegre, left Costa Rica for California, settling in San Francisco.
By there were seven Gallegos children - Adele John Robert Teresa Julia Anita and Sophie Maria Montealegre died in Mission San Jose on September 26, 8 Carey & Co., Department of Parks and Recreation series forms (Primary and BSO) for Palmdale (June page 6 of 18. 9 Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill, 5. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 11) Estimates of [Juan Gallegos property holdings] vary from source to source; most accounts cite a figure of or acres. An examination of county maps from the years gives an idea of how the Gallegos parcels were distributed.
The heart of his holdings, including the former Beard estate (Palmdale), comprised 612 acres within the vicinity of the Southern Pacific tracks in Irvington (where he built his winery), as well as several other large parcels east of Mission Boulevard, extending up and around Mission Peak. These tracts totaled less than acres (suggesting that the higher estimates cited earlier are exaggerations). Gallegos established one of the largest wineries in California on his property in Mission San Jose and Irvington. He laid out over 600 acres of vineyards north of Washington Boulevard and adjacent to his Irvington winery. Erected in this building was a massive three-story structure of stone and brick, measuring 240 feet by 110 feet.
Built against the bluff at Osgood Road and Washington Boulevard, with caves dug into the hillside, the structure could be entered at the third-story level from the higher ground, where grapes were dumped into tanks for washing. After fermentation and processing (utilizing an ingenious gravity system) the wine was loaded onto rail cars on a depressed spur track. The building also generated its own electricity and steam. In its first full year of production, the Gallegos Winery produced gallons of wine. In the journalist Charles Howard Shinn, son of a pioneer Washington Township horticulturist, stated that the winery was recognized as one of the very first in the state, whether for capital invested, for quantity handled, or for quality of the product.
The winery at Irvington crushes not only the grapes of the Gallegos vineyard but also many of the grapes in the district. Shinn noted that Gallegos had more than 640 acres planted in wine grapes, making it the largest of approximately forty vineyards (and ten wineries) then operating in the vicinity of Mission San Jose, Irvington, and Warm Springs. 10 In a complicated series of transactions in most of Gallegos' property, including the vineyards and winery, was transferred to the Palmdale Company, a firm that was partially owned by his wife's cousins Carlos and Francisco Montealegre. In the winery was incorporated as the Palmdale Wine Company.
To supplement his income, Gallegos raised, packed, and sold prunes and other fruits (there is a label in the collection of the Fremont Local History Museum for "Selected Seedless Limes, Gallegos Estate, Mission San Jose"). Gallegos also raised horses and cattle on his hill land. Most sources state that he suffered financial reversals in the due to a depressed wine market and the destruction of his vines by plant lice. 10 Carey & Co., page 6 of 18. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 12) In the Palmdale Company subdivided the former vineyard into 48 parcels ranging in size from 8 acres to nearly 32 acres (with most parcels in the acre range).
Occupying most of the area bounded by present-day Washington Boulevard, Driscoll Road, and Mission Boulevard, the 612-acre tract was bisected by two new roads, Olive Avenue and Mission Avenue (now Palm Avenue). The second largest parcel in the tract, Lot No. 48, covered acres at the northwest corner of present-day Washington and Mission Boulevards. This parcel, which included the old Beard-Gallegos residence and gardens, called Palmdale, was sold to a new owner. Gallegos and his family moved across the street into another house owned by the family. He died in that house in at the age of 72, having broken his back falling down some stairs. The following year, the Palmdale Winery was destroyed by an earthquake.
11 During his ownership of the property, Gallegos shifted the route of Mission Creek eastward to its current alignment, added two ponds, and, as a lover of trees probably added to the garden. Some of the site s mature trees may date from his ownership era. 12 Lachman/Metzger Era Lot No. 48, containing the 27-acre remnant of the Palmdale estate, was purchased around by a San Francisco wine merchant named Henry Lachman, who moved onto the grounds. Following his death around the property passed to his relatives the Metzgers, who sold the estate to the Starr and Best families in 13 Henry Lachman continued to improve the grounds [during his tenure at the property]. Following his death the estate passes to his heirs, the Metzgers, who seem to have done little in the way of improvements.
14 Best & Starr Era The estate was acquired in by two sisters from San Leandro, Hazel Wagness Starr and Irene Wagness Hansen. Hazel was married to Oscar L. Starr, an executive with the Caterpillar Tractor Company of San Leandro. Irene, divorced and already rich from playing the stock market, married one of the company's founders, Best, in (The Best Tractor Company merged with the Holt Manufacturing Company in to create the Caterpillar Tractor Company). The Starr and Best ownership (which lasted over 20 years) resulted in many features now associated with Palmdale, including the grottos, bridges, benches, and a sundial as well as the two large Period Revival houses in 11 Carey & Co., page 7 of 18. 12 Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill, 5. 13 Carey & Co., page 7 of 18.
14 Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill, 6. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 13) their landscaped setting. The houses appear to have been designed by the same, unknown, architect. The gardens were extended to the north (to the current boundary) and Olive Avenue was extended through the grounds to a new entrance on Mission Boulevard (no longer in use). In April soon after the purchase, the San Leandro Reporter commented on the property: The new owners of Palmdale are more fortunate than perhaps they realize. True, they are going to build two magnificent English style country homes in the open space facing the fountain and artificial lakes near the main highway; but there is little they can do to improve upon the exquisite gardens or the terrain immediately surrounding their new homes.
Many decades of thoughtful planning and faithful care have already done that to the utmost. 15 Many of the site s buildings and landscape features date from this period including the Best House and garage, the Starr House and garage, the seven rock grottos, the lava rock wall along Mission Boulevard, the heart-shaped garden that is located between the two extant ponds, a sundial, and examples of faux bois site furnishings. The Bests also drained the pond that was located east of the Best garage. Some of the mature trees, including the palms that line the looped drive in front of the two houses, date from this era.
16 Sisters of the Holy Family Era (1948-present) On September 1, the Sisters of the Holy Family, a religious order established in San Francisco in purchased the two houses and approximately 12 landscaped acres from the Bests and Starrs. Like each previous owner of the estate, they purchased with the land, the water rights and reservoir on the east side of Mission Boulevard. On February 16, the Board of Directors resolved to purchase an additional 15 acres of property from the Starrs to prevent their water supply from being used by future buyers. Renovations to the houses took place and the Sisters moved onto the Palmdale site in August, using the property as a residence and training site for new sisters.
The Best House contained the Novitiate, and the Starr House served as the professed house, where about 20 sisters resided. On April 9, the Sisters of the Holy Family deeded the property to Holy Family College, and the Best House was used for classes and library facilities until October 29, when Holy Family College was closed and merged with and into Sisters of the Holy Family. The property has undergone substantial development under the ownership of the Sisters of the Holy Family, including the construction of the Motherhouse convent building. The Sisters quickly outgrew the space offered by the Starr and Best Houses, and started 15 Carey & Co., page 8 of 18. 16 Stoltz, Bradley, and Hill, 6. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO.
CA-112 (Page 14) raising funds to construct a new Novitiate and convent building. They were aided by Mat Whitfield, who grew up on the property because his father was the ranch manager for the Metzger family. Architect Martin Rist was the designer of the new convent, and was likely recommended to the Sisters of the Holy Family by Harold Collins of St. Cecilia Catholic Church in San Francisco, who had constructed a new church designed by Rist in Martin J. Rist was a San Francisco architect who worked in the office of William Curlett starting shortly after the earthquake and fire. His work around the Bay Area ranges from residential to religious, and includes University Mound Ladies Home a red brick Georgian Revival convent, St.
Cecilia Catholic Church a Spanish Colonial style building in San Francisco, and several houses in Atherton and Beresford. During the process of designing the Motherhouse, Mother Perpetua, who was the Superior General, was constantly concerned about the cost estimates. Shortly before the design was completed, Martin Rist suddenly died. Wahamaki & Corey, architects from Hayward, CA, completed the design for the Sisters, making revisions to reduce the cost. Construction of the Motherhouse began in by Jack Reardon, who was responsible for building multiple churches in the Fremont area around the same time, and was completed in In the the Sisters filled in one of E.L. Beard s lakes, which was cracked and leaking, creating a marshy condition.
In the City of Fremont determined that the front gate to Mission Boulevard, could no longer be used. Because flood control was needed, the City of Fremont imposed a water district easement on the property in and in a concrete wall was constructed along the creek. The site history includes the addition, demolition, and relocation of various structures, including the Reidy house, which was moved onto the property in Possibly originally built in the building was pieced together prior to being relocated to Palmdale to be used for administrative purposes, and later as a residence for the retired gardener. In a four car garage was constructed at the southwest edge of the property, and in the swimming pool at this same corner of the property was backfilled and the pump house was removed.
17 [A parking lot was added in this location at that time.] This HALS documentation package was completed in relation to proposed alterations to the Palmdale campus. The proposed project entails adding three one-story senior housing facilities and 79 single family homes to the southern third of the project site. The senior housing, to be used by the Sisters of the Holy Family, would be located along the northern and western edges of the property, directly behind the Best and Starr houses. A new road branching off the main 17 Carey & Co., page 8 of 18. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 15) entrance drive from Mission Boulevard would pass along the western edge of the property to provide access to the senior housing.
Additional new circulation would be added in the southern portion of the site for the new single family houses. The Starr and Best houses are proposed to revert to single family homes. The proposed project entails removal of the Motherhouse, the Reidy House, a metal barn, and a four-car garage. None of these structures has been deemed historically significant. The photo documentation in this package provides an overview of the historic Palmdale site, with a concentration on areas and features that are subject to change in relation to alterations on the property. The new development has been designed with sensitivity to the historic district and preserves the majority of the historic features of the property in place.
A 5.5-acre core area parcel comprising the major landscape features between the Best and Starr houses and Mission Boulevard will be created as part of the proposed project. This parcel will be placed in a conservation easement and will be owned and managed by a non-profit organization funded by the Sisters of the Holy Family through the sale of the southern portion of the property for residential development. PALMDALE ESTATE HALS NO. CA-112 (Page 16)