This Historic American Engineering Record occasioned by the Sonoma- Marin Area Rail Transit: Haystack Landing Railroad Drawbridge Replacement Project follows the dictates of the Memorandum of Agreement between the United States Coast Guard, the California State Historic Preservation Officer, and the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit District. The cultural resources team was led by Meg Scantlebury, Senior Architectural Historian, ICF International. The contract work for the project was performed by ICF International, 620 Folsom Street, Suite San Francisco, CA HAYSTACK LANDING RAILROAD DRAWBRIDGE HAER No. CA-2316 (page 2) Part I. Historical Information A. Physical History 1.
Date(s) of construction: The Haystack Bridge was manufactured by the Pennsylvania Steel Company in and placed into operation at its current site in 2. Architect/Engineer: Pennsylvania Steel Company, Bridge and Construction Department. 3. Builder/Contractor/Supplier: Pennsylvania Steel Company, Bridge and Construction Department. 4. Original plans and construction: The original plans and construction for the Haystack Bridge resemble that of the extant structure with the exception of the electrical system installed in and the fenders in (which were replaced in The approach spans were also not included in the original plans and construction.
Installation dates for the approach spans have not been established, though the good condition of the timbers implies the spans were replaced in recent years. For a detailed description of existing original plans and as-built drawings, see the annotated list of sources below. 5. Alterations and additions: The single-track, steel Warren truss swing bridge replaced the original wooden swing bridge over the Petaluma River. The first wooden bridge was constructed in the late in conjunction with the acquisition of the Sonoma & Marin Railroad and subsequent completion of the rail line from Petaluma to San Rafael. B. Historical Context: The rise of the Locomotive Age in the United States occurred in the mid-nineteenth century as Americans constructed thousands of miles of railroad tracks.
Widely depicted in literature, paintings, and photographs, the railroad symbolized the young nation s rush to modernize and to secure its future. Settlers on the West Coast, including those who moved to California during the Gold Rush beginning in also viewed the railroad as a vital way to physically connect the state with markets on the East Coast and to bring prosperity and growth to isolated territories. The national priority of railroad construction influenced industrialists and financiers in California, particularly in Sacramento and San Francisco. Thus the idea of the transcontinental railroad, tying the country together with a gigantic sash of iron, from California to the East Coast took hold (Deverell The Central Pacific Railroad, owned by the Big Four Collis P.
Huntington, Mark Hopkins, Leland Stanford and Charles Crocker, formed the transcontinental railroad s western half. The railroad s groundbreaking occurred in in Sacramento, California, as tracks were laid eastward across the Sierra Nevada to Utah where it would connect with Union Pacific Railroad tracks being laid westward. The Central Pacific Railroad tracks were laid over the next six years as the Big Four used their extensive political connections to secure advantageous federal land grants and federally funded loans (Deverell During the process of developing the transcontinental railroad, the desire of local communities in California to develop their own rail lines grew in the interest of taking advantage of this connection to larger markets.
In particular, HAYSTACK LANDING RAILROAD DRAWBRIDGE HAER No. CA-2316 (page 3) rail lines along the state s north coast were rapidly developing to serve the timber industry and to transport building materials to the San Francisco Bay Area. As Leland Stanford hammered in the final ceremonial spike that joined the transcontinental railroad at Promontory, Utah in May railroad boosters were promising that railroads would bring economic prosperity and usher California into a modern era. Indeed, the state s railroads bolstered tourism and emigration and greatly increased its commerce, manufacturing, and trade.
It also vastly changed towns that lay along its path and led to population increases and infrastructure improvements, such as the installation of utilities and paved streets (Deverell As a whole, the railroad had a significant impact on growth and development both nationally and locally. The a portion of which runs through the entire APE, consolidated forty-two separate smaller lines constructed between and the early twentieth century in Sonoma and Marin Counties. Although the APE for the proposed project is located within Sonoma County, the history of the as it relates to both Sonoma and Marin counties is presented below.
An amalgam of smaller rail lines in Marin and Sonoma Counties, the s main line runs between Tiburon, a town located along Marin County s eastern coast facing San Francisco Bay, and Eureka, the Humboldt County seat located on the Pacific coastline. When the railroad was first constructed in the nineteenth century, the San Francisco Bay was a principle port of the Pacific Coast, and an obvious destination for railroads stretching from the east, and for lines intended for local traffic in Northern California. Marin and Sonoma County residents wanted a railway, but were divided over the railway route. Most of the Sonoma County residents agreed that Healdsburg was a natural northern terminus. The towns of Petaluma and Vallejo were in direct competition for a rail route.
To insure a profitable outcome, a group of Petaluma residents chartered the Sonoma County Railroad Company on December 26, They envisioned a line to Healdsburg, with a spur to Bloomfield in western Sonoma County (Kneiss Two more companies formed to compete for this new line: the Vallejo-Sonoma-Santa Rosa Railroad and the San Francisco and Humboldt Bay Railroad Company. Soon the three were competing to win the route. All three companies expected to receive a subsidy of per mile from the county coffers. To solve the dilemma the state legislature decreed that the voters would decide which company received the subsidy. As a result, each company waged a strenuous campaign for the right to build the railroad.
County residents chose the Sonoma County Railroad on May 12, which sought to build the railroad through Petaluma. The group had limited success, however, and soon transferred their rights and subsidies to the San Francisco and Humboldt Bay Railroad Company, stipulating that the new company construct ten miles of track by November (Kneiss General O Connor initially formed the San Francisco and Humboldt Bay Railroad Company, but Asbury Harpending quickly took over 90% of the company. Grading proceeded north of Petaluma through the fall and winter of but by early the line was running short of funding.
The rails had nearly reached Santa Rosa when, in order to raise cash, Harpending and William Ralston (financier of the Central Pacific Railroad) held a unsuccessful auction of the San Francisco lands they had purchased. Construction of the railroad in Sonoma County came to HAYSTACK LANDING RAILROAD DRAWBRIDGE HAER No. CA-2316 (page 4) a halt (Kneiss The San Francisco and Humboldt Bay Railroad Company reorganized under the name San Francisco and North Pacific Railroad (Kneiss A few days before Harpending sold his interests in to Peter Donahue, an Irish immigrant who became a prominent and influential San Francisco industrialist, in June Sonoma County voters agreed to a subsidy of per mile to the first railroad company to complete ten miles of track.
They also agreed to issue in bonds to the California Pacific Railroad (which had already laid 163 miles of track in northern California) upon the completion of the first five miles from the Napa County line. Voters included a stipulation, however, that if the SFNP--or any other company--was able to complete a railway through the county first, no bonds would be issued to the California Pacific. owner Donahue moved with amazing speed, putting 100 workers on the line laying track (Kneiss Unlike Harpending, Donahue refused to use Chinese laborers, employing instead crews of mostly Irish workers (Stindt Regular service between Petaluma and Santa Rosa began October 31, The terminal of the railroad line was a brand new town built by Peter Donahue on Petaluma Creek, christened Donahue.
The rival California Pacific owners did not give up easily. They used 100 Chinese laborers to beat the through the county. To outpace the competition, Donahue rushed more Irish laborers to Santa Rosa. The California Pacific responded by adding 200 more Chinese laborers, and began covering a mile a day. Sonoma County residents cheered on their favorite and wagered on the contest winner (Kneiss The race suddenly ended when William Ralston convinced Donahue to sell to Milton Latham, owner of the California Pacific Railroad. Latham was one of the richest men in San Francisco, ex-governor, ex-senator, and head of the London and San Francisco Bank.
Donahue made a large profit on the sale of the railroad on April 1, Donahue agreed to finish laying track to the Russian River using his Irish work force. The became the Petaluma and Humboldt division of the California Pacific, which was relinquished to the Central Pacific and the Big Four. Incredibly, after so much trouble, the Big Four soon decided that the Sonoma County line would not figure in their long-range plans; by January Peter Donahue repurchased the line for one million dollars (Kneiss Donahue died in and control of the company passed to his son James, who passed away five years later. Control of the railroad passed from the younger Donahue estate to the California Northwestern Railway Company formed by Andrew Markham, Sydney V. Smith, and Arthur W. Foster.
While the railroad continued to expand during the specifically between Ignacio and Glen Ellen, and through further extension to Guerneville into the Russian River logging country, the decade also saw severe financial problems. The Panic of damaged railroading interests all over the country, and by the company was on the auction block. In early Arthur W. Foster rescued the faltering rail line. Foster incorporated the line with the CNW and began new construction north into timber country. Again, financial instability threatened the CNW and it was absorbed by the Southern Pacific in (Stindt Another major player became interested in the North Bay Area railroad potential.
The Santa Fe Railroad began to incorporate smaller lines to acquire a share of lumber and milling country between Eureka and the Bay Area. By the Santa Fe had purchased enough local lines to become entrenched in Northern California s coastal timber belt (Stindt The Southern HAYSTACK LANDING RAILROAD DRAWBRIDGE HAER No. CA-2316 (page 5) Pacific took control of Marin and Sonoma county rail lines, and incorporated a new railroad to compete against the Santa Fe s timber lines in (Stindt Despite the competition, both lines were conscious of the immense costs involved in building separate, competing lines. While one road might prosper, two would prove uneconomical.
The competing firms joined forces and formed the with 402 miles of track on January 8, The tourist trade became a central business objective for the as hauling agricultural products was no longer profitable (Stindt The became a favorite of Bay Area dwellers seeking the redwood forest experience, and resorts were built to accommodate the tourists. The railroad expended significant resources to meet these demands in Marin County. Sausalito replaced Tiburon as the main southern terminal and tracks were added between San Rafael and San Anselmo.
The Fourth of July celebrations demonstrate the popularity of the rail line, when an estimated San Franciscans were ferried across the bay to Sausalito to catch the train north to vacation destinations (Stindt In the Southern Pacific bought out Santa Fe s interest, and the became a wholly owned subsidiary. The ensuing Great Depression made freight transportation nearly nonexistent, and the company abandoned the branch lines (Stindt Passenger service also declined and the unveiled new, more comfortable cars to combat this decline. The company lowered fares tremendously, with a round-trip fare for San Francisco-Russian River travel. Automobile traffic blossomed in the and further reduced the passenger railroad business.
From the mid-1930s on, the automobile replaced the train as most American s choice for tourist-related travel. The abandoned over 138 miles of track during the Depression (Stindt The s Depression-era woes were tempered with America s entry into World War II. The Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor resulted in a restructuring of transportation priorities and all the engines and cars were pressed into service. Even steam-powered locomotives worked during the war years. The Redwood Empire line began to haul lumber and critical war supplies to San Francisco area factories.
Due to the high number of Napa and Sonoma county mercury mines, the shipped large amounts of this material during World War II (Naughton After the turbulent and the passengers who once frequented the altered their own modes of transportation. By the early1950s, it was clear to leadership that locomotive usage was on the decline. While locomotive use had fluctuated in the past, this time it was clear that the growth of the automobile, long-range trucking, and even buses would have a permanent, nationwide effect on railroading. Passenger service, once the goal of the was no longer a priority. While the transport of lumber was sustained during the post-war economic boom, several passenger-oriented branch lines were dropped.
The last complete round trip between San Rafael and Eureka took place in November (Stindt Other issues beside profit motive helped shape the future of the In July a fire ravaged the railroad s Puerto Suello tunnel, located just north of San Rafael, which caused the 1,359-foot tunnel to collapse (Stindt Because of the fire, the sought to discontinue service from San Rafael to Tiburon, stating that industries located south of the tunnel HAYSTACK LANDING RAILROAD DRAWBRIDGE HAER No. CA-2316 (page 6) could be adequately serviced by existing barge service. This decision initiated five years of litigation that resulted in a denial of the s petition to abandon the line.
The section reopened for service in at a cost of million (Stindt More branch line closures marked the including a attempt to abandon the line from Ignacio south to San Rafael (Stindt This application, like its predecessor was dismissed. Rail service south of San Rafael halted in due to the abandonment of the tunnel between San Rafael and Larkspur (Stindt Financial woes during the forced the Southern Pacific to place the on the market. By the asking price had dropped from $12 million to $5 million, just above the scrap value of the line. The Southern Pacific purchased the (MP to Willits) in (Stindt In the Southern Pacific line from the town of Outlet, north of Willits, south to the town of Ignacio, in Marin County, became publicly owned.
SMART owns the line from MP in Healdsburg south to MP in Corte Madera. The North Coast Railroad Authority (NCRA) has upgraded the existing railway between Highway 37 (Novato) and Windsor for freight service, which has begun limited operations, as of July HAYSTACK LANDING RAILROAD DRAWBRIDGE HAER No. CA-2316 (page 7) Part II. Structural/Design Information A. General Statement: 1. Character: Warren truss railroad drawbridge represents innovative structural engineering for railroad bridges in 2. Condition of fabric: The current condition and fabric of the Haystack Landing Railroad Drawbridge dates to built on creosote-treated timber piles with treated timber pile bridge approach spans and fender systems.
The current condition of the bridge is impartially deteriorated to the point that several, if not all, timber spans, piles and fenders require replacement. B. Description: The Haystack Landing Railroad Drawbridge is identified as milepost of the SMART line. The bridge was originally recorded as a steel Pratt truss, but has since been correctly identified as a Warren truss. The bridge s truss is a series of triangulated steel components riveted together to create a rigid structure. In a Warren truss, diagonal components are under tension while vertical components are under compression except for the end diagonals which are under compression and the vertical members adjacent to them which are under tension.
The two truss plans are united at the base by a platform of floor beams connecting each truss at the bottom chord and stringers running the length of the bridge and intersecting the floor beams. The floor structure is covered by a deck of rails, perforated steel, and wood planks. At the top the trusses are connected by a steel lattice forming portal bracing. Two sets of top lateral bracing of lattice beams crossing from end posts to vertical components are set above each bay at the ends of the bridge at the top chord. The Haystack Bridge is a vertical truss swing span bridge that was built in by the Pennsylvania Steel Company for the Northwestern Pacific Railroad. The swing spans include two identical trusses, each 90 feet long, joined by bolted eyebars at the top chords.
The truss spans, the pivot pier, and the control house date to The electrical system was added in The fenders were added in and were largely replaced in The dates of construction for the approach spans were not established. The good condition of the timbers, compared with the heavily deteriorated timbers on the pivot pier, suggests that the approach spans were replaced in recent decades. C. Mechanicals/Operation: The bridge may be seen as comprising seven elements: the double truss swing spans; the pivot pier, or center pier; north approach trestle; south approach trestle; fenders on the upstream and downstream sides of the bridge; and the various mechanical and electrical equipment components that help the bridge operate.
In addition to the swing spans, the bridge may be seen as comprising six additional elements: north and south approach spans, the pivot pier, upstream and downstream fenders, and the control house. Photograph HAER-CA- HAYSTACK LANDING RAILROAD DRAWBRIDGE HAER No. CA-2316 (page 8) through HAER-CA-2316-05 show the relationships between and among these various elements. The determination of eligibility prepared for FEMA documented that the elements of the bridge were built at different times. D. Site Information: The Haystack Landing Railroad Drawbridge Bridge is identified as milepost of the SMART line. The bridge is sited in Sonoma County, California over the Petaluma River near the City of Petaluma, at River Mile approximately 330 feet downstream of the U.S.
Highway 101 (US bridge, 120 feet northeast of Petaluma Boulevard South, and approximately 10 miles upstream of the river mouth at San Pablo Bay. HAYSTACK LANDING RAILROAD DRAWBRIDGE HAER No. CA-2316 (page 9) Part III. Sources of Information A. Primary