This Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) Level II documentation for the Santa Monica Post Office was prepared for current owner, 5th Street, The documentation was undertaken by Chattel, Inc., Historic Preservation Consultants (Chattel). The research and written documentation was prepared by architectural historian, Sarah Vonesh and historic architect Robert Chattel. The HABS photography was completed by Stephen Schafer of Schaf Photography. The documentation was completed between February and June SANTA MONICA POST OFFICE HABS No. CA-2918 (page 2) Part I. Historical Information A. Physical History 1. Date of Erection: Construction of the building began in September and the building was dedicated on July 23, 1 2.
Architects: Original drawings for the Santa Monica Post Office list Louis A. Simon as the supervising architect and Neal A. Melick as the supervising engineer from the Department of the U.S. Treasury, and Robert Dennis Murray as the local consulting architect. Information regarding Murray and his work is limited, but it appears that he was most prolific during the In while working as a draughtsman in the architecture department of the Los Angeles Board of Education, Murray was awarded a scholarship to study architecture at the University of Pennsylvania. 2 Later in Los Angeles in Murray and fellow architect Henry Carlton Newton formed the architecture firm Newton and Murray.
The firm designed a number of residences, schools, churches, libraries, and other public buildings in the Los Angeles area, including the Santa Monica Post Office. 3 3. Original and subsequent owners, occupants, uses: The original owner and occupant was the United States Postal Service (USPS). The USPS closed operation in the building June 29, The building was sold to the current owner, 5th Street, LLC in December 4. Contractor: The original building permit lists James I. Barnes Construction Company as the contractor. 5. Original plans and construction: Original drawings dated April 4, are extant and in the possession of the owner, 5th Street, Drawings include: a basement plan, first floor plan, second floor (mezzanine) plan, elevations, sections and details.
The Santa Monica Post Office was constructed as a T-shaped building comprised of two stories plus a basement occupying the northwest corner of Fifth Street and Arizona Avenue, facing east. 4 The main entrance is on Fifth Street and a mailing platform spans the central portion of the rear elevation on Fourth Court (alley). The walls are constructed of board-formed reinforced concrete with cast stone ornamentation concentrated on the front facade. A newspaper article in the Santa Monica Evening Outlook on February 24, included the initial architect s sketch of the proposed post office. Of the building, California Congressman John F. Dockweiler stated, I wish to congratulate Mr.
Murray, of the architectural firm of Newton & Murray, for their splendid interpretation of a structure that would be most fitting to the beautiful surrounding and general architecture design of southern California and the Santa Monica area. 5 1 Application for Building Permit, Building Department City of Santa Monica, Fifth Street, Building Permit No. 20 September 2 Awarded Platt Scholarship, Architect and Engineer of California (August 3 Architectural Work Honored: Newton and Murray Have Enviable Record in Southland Field, Evening Outlook, March 27, 5. 4 The building orientation is actually skewed relative to true north and faces northeast; however, for ease of description, an orthogonal alignment is assumed.
The assumed orientation is described as follows: the front of the building, which aligns with Fifth Street, faces east; the rear, which fronts on to Fourth Court, faces west; the side of the building that faces Arizona Avenue faces south; the side of the building that currently faces an adjacent property with a playground is assumed to be north. 5 Dockweiler Believes Bids on New Santa Monica Postoffice to Be Called in Next 60 Days, Evening Outlook (Santa Monica, CA), February 24, 3. SANTA MONICA POST OFFICE HABS No. CA-2918 (page 3) 6. Alterations and additions: The following alterations have been observed or documented by alteration drawings and historic photographs: Originally exposed concrete painted white with mica finish. Two inset bulletin boards added in the lobby area.
At this time, the north lawn and portions of the south lawn were paved to provide additional parking area. The mailing platform along the west (alley) elevation was expanded south and a new canopy was installed above the mailing platform. Interior lighting throughout replaced with fluorescent fixtures. By Evidenced in historic photographs, by the fountain had been removed from the east set back, the flagpole had been removed from the building parapet, a new flagpole was installed at former location of fountain, and railings had been added to entry steps. Plumbing Alterations. Flooring in basement corridors replaced, flooring in workroom repaired.
The following alterations were made to the lobby in individual service windows were replaced with large service counters; new alcoves were added for rental postal boxes in the northern portion of the lobby; the northern entry vestibule was removed; a wall with sliding glass door was installed at the approximate center of the lobby dividing the postal box and retail lobby spaces; and new light fixtures were installed. Mechanical Alterations. By Evidenced in site plan and elevation drawings, accessible ramp had been added to the north entrance, a concrete masonry unit wall had been constructed around the north parking lot along Fifth Street, the north light well had been covered and decorative railing removed, and the mailing platform was expanded to the north.
Lobby and interior renovations including modification of south offices to provide additional retail space. Lobby renovation involving replacement of thirteen aluminum windows with new fixed wood windows, new recessed light fixtures installed in lobby ceiling, new counter in center of lobby area, new railing installed around lobby stairs designed to match exterior railings, ceramic tile wainscot replaced with marble, exterior painted. Postal boxes removed. Unknown Removal of south lobby entry vestibule. date Expansion of lobby and removal of former Money Order and Postal Savings office on north side of building. Removal of flange sign on west wall pilaster in lobby and installation of wood patch. Patch detail repeated on all pilasters. Replacement of lobby entry doors at east facade.
Replacement of original wood windows with aluminum sash windows on north, south and west elevations. Alteration of west (alley) elevation including infill of windows in north and south bay and installation of door in south bay. SANTA MONICA POST OFFICE HABS No. CA-2918 (page 4) Addition of concrete in east elevation setback. Addition of concrete monument sign at southeast corner of property. Addition of low concrete wall within south lawn. Addition of four concrete planters along the sidewalk in the east elevation setback. B. Historical Context Originally consisting of largely undeveloped ranch lands, the town site of Santa Monica was surveyed in the same year the Southern Pacific Railroad reached Los Angeles.
At that time, the town extended from the Pacific Ocean to Street on the east and from Colorado Avenue on the south to Montana Avenue on the north. Santa Monica s founders, Colonel Robert S. Baker and U.S. Senator John P. Jones, conceived the town as a railroad terminus and port; however, their vision was largely unrealized. During the Santa Monica reinvented itself as a resort community. Both tourists and health-seekers traveled to the beach town, many of whom became permanent residents. A building boom followed with new homes constructed in the areas closest to the ocean. The City of Santa Monica was officially incorporated in November as a result of the rise in population and development.
6 By a reliable interurban rail line, the Pacific Electric Railway, made it possible to easily commute to Los Angeles, further promoting growth in the city. Between and the population of Santa Monica increased from to and more than doubled again in the next decade to by 7 Greatest growth, however, occurred during the when automobile ownership in Los Angeles increased rapidly. Another influential factor prompting the city s growth during this time was the move of the Douglas Aircraft Company to Santa Monica in boosting the community s economic base, industry and population. Santa Monica s population had more than doubled by reaching Efforts to construct a local post office in Santa Monica were progressing by the beginning of and were led by Congressman Joe Crail.
8 In was allocated for the construction of the post office by the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, a financial support entity established by the government that year to stimulate lending during the Great Depression. 9 With funds allocated, property including five parcels, 250 x 150 , at the northwest corner of Fifth Street and Arizona Avenue was purchased for 10 Shortly thereafter, the local architecture firm of Newton and Murray was selected to design the post office building. 11 The Los Angeles based firm consisted of Henry Carlton Newton and Robert Dennis Murray, with Murray serving as the primary architect.
12 In March of funding for the building, now appropriated under the Public Works Administration, was reduced to 13 Murray simplified design plans for the post office to fit the constraints of the new budget, but residents reacted negatively to what they deemed to be a reinforced concrete warehouse a box-like building devoid of ornamentation and beauty, 14 Congressman John F. Dockweiler and Santa Monica residents joined together to launch a concerted effort to restore the original budget. 15 Various civic groups and representatives of the Santa Monica City Council presented arguments later that August to representatives of the U.S. Treasury Department for additional funds.
Local and regional trends spanning population growth, increasing city infrastructure, and housing fueled their reasoning. Santa Monica s population continued to rise during the 6 PCR Services Corporation and Historic Resources Group, Historic Preservation Element, City of Santa Monica General Plan, September 11. 7 General Population by City Los Angeles County Los Angeles Almanac, 8 City in Fight for Post Office, Los Angeles Times, January 12, C8. 9 Site Debated for Postoffice, Los Angeles Times, September 23, 1. 10 Postoffice Site Chosen, Los Angeles Times, February 25, 8. 11 Architects Selected for Two Postoffices, Los Angeles Times, March 2, 16. 12 Architectural Work Honored, Evening Outlook (Santa Monica, CA), March 27, 5.
13 City Pleads with Facts, Evening Outlook (Santa Monica, CA), August 28, 8. 14 Santa Monica Gets Raw Deal on Postoffice, Evening Outlook (Santa Monica, CA), July 10, 15 Treasury Department Responds to Demand for Adequate Postoffice, Evening Outlook (Santa Monica, CA), August 15, SANTA MONICA POST OFFICE HABS No. CA-2918 (page 5) Great Depression (by approximately 17 percent between 16) and it was anticipated that growth of the Douglas Aircraft Company would draw in more residents. In addition, a housing shortage, increasing tourist population, increasing development near the coast, and growth of city systems and infrastructure also contributed to the argument for a more substantial post office building.
17 The budget was restored to by October 18 In Murray traveled to Washington and collaborated with U.S. Treasury Department Supervising Architect Louis A. Simon and Supervising Engineer Neal A. Melick to design a new post office. 19 The updated building was designed in the PWA Moderne style, a simplified form of the Beaux-Arts style that eliminated or reduced ornament to reduce costs and speed construction. The PWA Moderne style was the dominant mode of government construction under the New Deal program in the 20 Construction of the post office began in September by contractor James I. Barnes Construction of Santa Monica. 21 After eleven months of construction, on July 23, a dedication ceremony was held and the cornerstone was laid.
During the event, speakers recognized the exhaustive efforts of Congressmen John F. Dockweiler and Joe Crail and their immense contribution in the long fight to obtain a local post office. 22 The building remained in use as the main downtown post office in Santa Monica until closure on June 29, Part II. Architectural Information A. General Statement 1. Architectural character: The building was designed as a post office in the PWA Moderne style with Art Deco motifs concentrated on the east facade. PWA Moderne was a popular style for buildings funded under the federal New Deal program at the time. The overall form, massing and plan of the relatively simple concrete structure reflect the characteristics of the PWA Moderne style.
Specific features include: cast stone ornamentation above the two entryways including globes set over stylized eagle s wings, monumental pilasters on the east facade, stylized lettering over the central window reading United States Post Office, scalloped string courses above the water table and parapet, tri-banded cornice lines, low metal railings with chevron motif along east facade light wells, and ornamented lobby with stylized furniture. 2. Condition of fabric: Overall the building is in good condition and has been maintained over the years. B. Description of Exterior 1. Overall dimensions: The building consists of two stories of reinforced concrete construction including a basement, mezzanine, and mailing platform.
The facade of the building is nine bays wide and is rectangular and symmetrical in its layout and shape. The north and south side elevations are five bays wide. The building s overall dimensions are approximately 170 x 97 . 2. Foundations: The building sits on reinforced concrete foundation. A poured-in-place concrete water table is found at the base of the building. 16 Strong Case Made for Larger P.O., Evening Outlook (Santa Monica, CA), August 23, 1. 17 Ibid. 18 Santa Monica Victor in Fight for Larger Postoffice Structure, Evening Outlook (Santa Monica, CA), October 9, 1. 19 Enlarged Postoffice Plans Ordered by U.S. Treasury, Evening Outlook (Santa Monica, CA), August 22, 1. 20 Doug Robertson, U.S.
Post Offices in California Thematic Resources, National Register of Historic Places Inventory/Nomination Form, January 11, 22. 21 New Post Office Will Rise Soon, Los Angeles Times, August 22, 11. 22 City Hails Post Office, Los Angeles Times, July 24, 14. SANTA MONICA POST OFFICE HABS No. CA-2918 (page 6) 3. Walls: The exterior walls are painted board-formed reinforced concrete with cast stone ornamentation. 4. Structural system, framing: The current structural system consists of reinforced concrete exterior and interior bearing walls, structural steel frame embedded in concrete and a structural steel roof structure. 5. Porches, stoops, balconies, porticoes, bulkheads: At the east facade, the two main entryways are accessed by steps made up of granite blocks.
An accessible ramp with a granite veneer has been added at the north entrance. Concrete steps and a concrete ramp access the mailing platform on the west elevation. 6. Chimneys: One board-formed concrete chimney is located at the northwest corner of the roof. Concrete scalloped ornamentation, similar to ornamentation found elsewhere on the building, wraps around the top of the chimney. 7. Openings a. Doorways and doors: The east facade contains two entrances, both of which contain contemporary glazed double doors below transoms are set within monumental entry portals. The west elevation mailing platform contains four sets of double utilitarian swing doors and a single metal entrance door that accesses the interior workroom. b.
Windows: Fenestration consists of tall, paired, double-hung type windows with transoms in a six-light configuration, evenly spaced across the east, north, and south elevations. Windows throughout have been replaced within original openings. Windows on the east facade feature wood frames with replacement wood sash that imitate the original configuration but are inoperable. Windows on the north, south and west facades feature wood frames with replacement double-hung type aluminum sash. The west elevation contains smaller window openings along the center portion of the mailing platform and at the mezzanine level with replacement double-hung aluminum sash. Security grills have been added on the exterior at the windows on the north and west elevations. 8. Roof a.
Shape, covering: The building has a flat roof covered with rolled composition roofing. b. Cornice, parapet: The roof has a parapet that ranges in height from approximately 2 -0 to 3 - 0 with a scalloped stringcourse detail at the roofline above the tri-banded cornice lines. c. Skylights: Two monitor skylights with steel sash windows and operable metal louvers are centrally located on the east side of the roof above the interior workroom. Security grills have been added to the skylight openings. C. Description of Interior 1. Floor plans a. Basement: The basement consists of office spaces, utilitarian spaces, storage spaces, and mechanical spaces. The basement remains largely intact from when it was originally constructed.
On the east side of the basement, a double-loaded hallway provides access to a series of office spaces and two restrooms. An L-shaped hallway, divided from the east hallway by a set of double doors, is also double-loaded and leads to a work area, storage rooms, boiler room, and additional office spaces on the west side of the building. b. First Floor: The first floor plan consists of a public lobby, contemporary retail and mailing areas, and non-public spaces including a large workroom and mailing vestibule. The lobby runs north-to-south along the east facade and has been divided into two spaces by a non-original partition wall.
The northern half of the lobby contains contemporary projections creating alcoves that previously held postal boxes while the southern half contains retail counters. SANTA MONICA POST OFFICE HABS No. CA-2918 (page 7) c. Second Floor (Mezzanine): The mezzanine includes a break room, men s restroom, and lookout gallery. The lookout gallery is an H-shaped suspended catwalk, constructed of plaster over metal lath, that allowed postal inspectors to monitor employees in the workroom below. The interior of the lookout gallery is painted a matte black and includes observation holes in the floors, ventilation slots, observation slots covered by metal and glass panels along walls and wooden arm rests below observation slots.
The lookout gallery is accessed by way of two doorways, one in the mezzanine break room and one in the restroom, as well as two vertical passages with fixed steel ladders from the first floor workroom area. 2. Stairways: There are two stairways. A terrazzo staircase in the lobby provides access to the basement and is adorned by the original curved stainless steel handrail. A simple concrete staircase along the west elevation in the workroom provides access to the basement and mezzanine. 3. Flooring: Lobby floors are terrazzo with a rectilinear pattern of gray and salmon pink color terrazzo rectangles divided by zinc strips. The gray terrazzo is found in the center and accent strips of salmon pink terrazzo outline the lobby edges and divide interior bays. Some patches are visible.
Floors in the first floor workroom are end-grain wood block. Other flooring materials include concrete, linoleum, gray ceramic tile, and carpet. 4. Wall and ceiling finish: Walls and ceilings in the lobby are clad in wood v-joint boarding with geometric designs. The wood ceiling is suspended and supported by a structural steel framing system, independent of the roof structure above. Non-original orange-red variegated marble wainscot is found below the wood paneling in the lobby. Beyond the lobby, walls and ceilings lack ornamentation. Walls throughout are constructed of reinforced concrete. Walls in some areas have a plaster finish while the majority are concrete with a smooth finish that have been painted. Restrooms contain tile wainscot clad in glazed gray tiles.
A suspended ceiling has been added in retail areas along the south elevation on the first floor and in the basement office spaces. 5. Openings a. Doorways and doors: Historic interior doors are generally double-panel wood doors that have been painted. On some doors the upper panel is a glass light with wire glass. In the basement, a pair of double-panel wood doors that access the Civil Service office (located at the northeast corner of the building) have starburst glass lights in the upper panels decorated with emblems and lettering reading Civil Service.
Other doors found within the building include: thick painted steel doors that access the historic vaults within the workroom; a non-historic Dutch door accessing the north side of the lobby from the workroom; an unpainted double-panel wood door located at the janitor s closet in the lobby that features more decorative molded panels; and a non-historic sliding glass door with an aluminum frame dividing the lobby. b. Windows: Windows are set within the exterior concrete walls with simple interior trim. In the lobby, surrounds are made up of thin V-shape molding in a natural wood finish to match the surrounding wood boarding. Windows in former office spaces have flat, wide wood trim. Surrounds in utilitarian and non-public spaces have flat, wide wood trim with a beveled edge.
The lobby historically contained individual service windows that have since been removed and replaced with long service counters. Skylights on the roof provide natural light into the first floor workroom. The basement office spaces along the east elevation receive natural light through high-placed windows located in the light wells along the east facade of the building. 6.
Decorative features and trim: Decorative features are primarily located within the lobby and include: decorative wood paneling at the walls and ceiling in a natural wood finish with stylized geometric designs including zigzag motifs above lobby counter areas; wood trim throughout painted in a deep red hue; pilasters evenly spaced along the east and west walls dividing the space into seven bays; wood grilles with rounded edges at upper wall areas; tall Art Deco style wood tables SANTA MONICA POST OFFICE HABS No.
CA-2918 (page 8) with stainless steel bases; stainless steel and etched glass ceiling light fixtures; non-historic marble wainscot, eight inset wood-framed bulletin boards along the east wall; and a non-historic railing around the stair with chevron ornamentation designed to imitate the exterior railing surrounding light wells along the east facade. The restroom on the mezzanine level retains original marble shower and changing stall enclosures. 7. Hardware: Few original doors retain original architectural bronze and stainless steel hardware including knobs, push plates and hinges. Much of the stainless steel hardware that once existed in the lobby area has been removed. 8. Mechanical equipment a. Lighting: The lobby contains six original stainless steel light fixtures.
The large rectangular fixtures hang down approximately 6 -2 from the ceiling and include a stainless steel zig- zag detail. Etched glass covers appear to have replaced original opal glass covers. On the northern side of the lobby, the light fixtures have been truncated to accommodate postal box alcoves. On the exterior, six inset light fixtures with opal lenses illuminate the two entrances and United States Post Office signage on the east facade. b. Elevators: The original dual-entrance freight elevator, manufactured by Shepard Elevator Company of Cincinnati, is located along the west wall in the workroom and provides access to the basement and mailing platform. 9. Original furnishings: Five original Art Deco style wood tables with stainless steel bases are found in the lobby.
The tables are bolted through the floor below. One table in the northern portion of the lobby has been truncated for accessibility. All table tops have been replaced with a composite material. D. Site 1. Historic landscape design: When the post office was originally constructed, it was surrounded by manicured lawn on three sides. Within the east setback, a planter and fountain were placed behind a low U-shaped wall centered in front of the building. A Canary Island Date Palm (Phoenix canariensis) tree was located within the south lawn; however, the tree was recently removed due to disease. The landscape surrounding the post office has been significantly altered since its construction. Today, the only landscape feature that remains is a small portion of the south lawn.
Paved parking areas and other hardscape features have replaced historic landscape features. The planter and fountain were removed at an unknown date and replaced with a flagpole surrounded by in-ground plantings. The lawn to the north of the building was paved over to accommodate parking. The lawn previously found between the sidewalk and building is now concrete with diamond- shaped stone inserts. Raised concrete planters and a large concrete monument sign have been added along the sidewalk. Mature Ficus trees line the sidewalk at the curb, largely blocking views of the building from the east. 2. Outbuildings: None. SANTA MONICA POST OFFICE HABS No. CA-2918 (page 9) Part III. Sources of Information A.
Architectural drawings: Original architectural drawings and the following alteration drawings are in the possession of the current owner 5th Street, Treasury Department, Public Buildings Branch, United States Post Office, Santa Monica California, April 14, General Services Administration, Drawing Title: Mailing Platform and Driveway Extension, February 16, General Services Administration, Drawing Title: Fluorescent Lighting, March 4, General Services Administration, Drawing Title: Plumbing Revisions, May 20, General Services Administration, Drawing Title: Floor Covering Repair & Refinishing, March 27, General Services Administration, Drawing Title: New Service Counter and Box, Lobby, etc., July 2, d Autremont-Helms & Associates Consulting Engineers, United States Postal Service, Mechanical Drawings, December United States Postal Service, Main Post Office, Santa Monica, CA, Project, Drawing Title: Floor Repair & Painting, December 14, B.
Early Views: National Archives and Records Administration a. Front and Rear View, U.S.P.O. Santa Monica, California, August 15, Photograph. National Archives and Records Administration: RG 121 Public Buildings Service, General Correspondence and Related Records, Santa Monica, Cal., P.O. Box No. Front and rear views shortly after finished, unpainted. (2 photographs). b. Treatment of Exterior Concrete Mica Finish, U.S. Post Office, Santa Monica, Calif., August 3, Photograph. National Archives and Records Administration: RG 121 Public Buildings Service, General Correspondence and Related Records, Santa Monica, Cal., P.O. Box No. Front and rear views, after painted. (2 photographs). Santa Monica Public Library a. Bartlett, Adelbert.
Dedication of the Santa Monica Post Office, July 23, Photograph. Santa Monica Public Library Image Archives: Carolyn Bartlett Farnham Collection. b. Bartlett, Adelbert. Postmaster Phillip T. Hill at the Santa Monica Post Office dedication, July 23, Photograph. Santa Monica Public Library Image Archives: Carolyn Bartlett Farnham Collection. Santa Monica History Museum a. Outlook Collection b. Bill Beebe Collection c. Exterior under construction. Circa Santa Monica History Museum. d. Beebe, Bill. The dedication of the Santa Monica Post Office. Negatives. Santa Monica History Museum: Bill Beebe Collection. (3 photographs). e. Lobby Looking East. Santa Monica History Museum. f. Workroom Looking East. Santa Monica History Museum. SANTA MONICA POST OFFICE HABS No. CA-2918 (page 10) g.
Beebe, Bill. Santa Monica Post Office Building on Fifth Street. Negatives. Santa Monica History Museum: Bill Beebe Collection. Views at night. (2 photographs). h. Beebe, Bill. War Bond Effort. Negatives. Santa Monica History Museum: Bill Beebe Collection. (8 photographs). i. Beebe, Bill. Stamp Machine. Photograph. Santa Monica History Museum: Bill Beebe Museum. Interior views of lobby. j. Beebe, Bill. Girl Scouts Receive Commemorative Stamps. Negatives. Santa Monica History Museum: Bill Beebe Collection. Early lobby views. (2 photographs). k. Beebe, Bill. Lobby at Christmas time. December 8, Santa Monica History Museum: Bill Beebe Collection. (2 photographs). l. Beebe, Bill. Flag Raising at the Santa Monica Post Office. Date unknown. Negative.
Santa Monica History Museum: Bill Beebe Collection. m. Civil Rights Rally. Circa Negatives. Santa Monica History Museum: Outlook Collection. (4 photographs). C. Selected