BlockBefore

Redwood Creek Riprap, 1 Muir Woods Road, Mill Valley

Redwood Creek Riprap, 1 Muir Woods Road, Mill Valley, Marin County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CA-2357, with a 1,970-word written history.

From the record

“From to the Civilian Conservation Corps and Civil Work Administration (CWA) installed the riprap to preserve the route of Redwood Creek, as well as to protect the redwood trees and surrounding trails.”

Written record, HAER CA-2357 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CA-2357 · the record runs 1970 words · one of 240 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

266 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2357. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Muir Woods National Monument, 1 Muir Woods Road, Mill Valley, Marin County, California The area of this documentation is a one mile stretch of Redwood Creek. The subject area begins at the Entrance Plaza located at 1 Muir Woods Road and ends at Bridge 4 which is located at the intersection of the Bootjack Trail and the Main Trail on the northern bank and the intersection of the Ben Johnson Trail and Hillside Trail on the southern bank. The northwestern-most point of Redwood Creek containing riprap is located at latitude longitude in section near Bridge 4 (see photo key for section reference). The southeastern-most point of the creek containing riprap is located at latitude longitude in section L1A near the Entrance Plaza of Muir Woods.

These points were obtained on November 12, using GIS survey data (North American Datum There is no restriction on their release to the public. Dates of Construction: to Engineer: Custodians John Needham and J. Barton Herschler implemented the construction and NPS Chief Engineer Frank A. Kittredge approved the dam designs. NPS Associate Engineer W.E. Robertson requested more revetment work to be completed. Builder: Civilian Conservation Corps Civil Work Administration Present Owner And Use: Golden Gate National Recreation Area, National Park Service The National Park Service constructed the riprap for flood and erosion control as well as preservation of the surrounding redwood trees and trails.

However, in the National Park Service decided to remove sections of the riprap in order to return the creek to natural stream processes and enhance the Coho salmon habitat. REDWOOD CREEK RIPRAP HAER No. CA-2357 Page 2

Significance

1497 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2357. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

From to the Civilian Conservation Corps and Civil Work Administration (CWA) installed the riprap to preserve the route of Redwood Creek, as well as to protect the redwood trees and surrounding trails. The Redwood Creek riprap is a significant example of the NPS engineering and the work of the CCC and CWA. The riprap is at least eighty years old at the time of this writing and was constructed using some methods that are used to build riprap today, which explains why many sections are still in good condition. Description: Riprap and revetments are erosion control measures constructed with loose stones to be protective barriers against elements that may cause erosion and decay.

In Redwood Creek, rock-filled wire baskets were used as a temporary form of riprap before larger stones could be more permanently installed. Rock-filled wire baskets typically used smaller stones and were less effective than the boulders that were used in permanent forms of riprap. Brush dams and rock check dams were also implemented in Redwood Creek but these erosion control measures are not classified as riprap. Brush dams were used as a temporary solution as brush would be laid down across the creek to catch eroded material. Rock check dams differed in that they were mounds of small stones laid across the creek in order to reduce erosion and decrease the flow of the creek.1 The riprap varies throughout the creek, although many general features remain the same.

The stones are all shades of gray and brown and were quarried locally so it is likely the riprap was constructed using a few different types of rocks. The most common types of rock found in Marin County are basalt, chert, greywacke, and limestone. Stones that were overgrown with vegetation take on the green hues of the surrounding plants and can become camouflaged into the vegetation. The visible backing rocks range from about inches in diameter while the stones for the outer layers of riprap range from about inches in diameter. The stones can be spherical or have more jagged edges, however most of the rocks have a smooth texture due to the erosion.

The revetments were built because Muir Woods custodians and NPS engineers came to the conclusion that the preservation of Redwood Creek s route was important for the trails and the protection of the redwood trees from flood damage along the banks of the creek. Beginning construction in the an estimated linear feet of the stone 1 Natural Resources Conservation Service Wyoming, U.S. Department of Agriculture, "Rock Check Dam Fact Sheet," accessed December 3, REDWOOD CREEK RIPRAP HAER No. CA-2357 Page 3 revetments in Redwood Creek were constructed.2 The stones were quarried locally and crews brought the stones back to arrange them in the creek beds and blend them into the landscape. The use of backing rocks was one of the riprap installation techniques utilized by the crews.

Backing rocks are smaller rocks that are placed between the soil and larger rocks to act as a buffer to keep the soil in place. The larger rocks then face the erosion from the creek and the soil is protected. This method is used today when constructing riprap and is a testament to why the riprap is still in relatively good condition. The NPS made an important design decision to ensure that the stone revetments looked natural and did not impede the visitor s experience. The rocks were blended into vegetation and were dug into the banks of the creek. In NPS Chief Engineer F. A.

Kittredge noted that after less than a year, the erosion from Redwood Creek and vegetation growth hid and blended the stones with the surrounding environment.3 As time went on, much of the riprap became hidden due to erosion and vegetation. The riprap in Redwood Creek consisting of larger stones is in generally more intact than the other types of riprap and revetments. The smaller stones from the wire baskets and check dams have become dislodged and dispersed in many locations, though some areas are still intact. See the Photo Index for more detailed descriptions of the type and condition of riprap and revetments throughout the creek. History: When Muir Woods became a National Monument in William Kent owned more than acres surrounding the federally protected land.

Thankfully, Kent was very interested in the protection and growth of his new neighbor. He donated plots of his land and proposed many ideas to the park. In Kent proposed erosion control measures to maintain the creeks in Muir Woods, and thus began the planning process for the revetments.

However, the work did not begin until which was after Kent s death in Upon his death, some of Kent s land was added to Muir Woods and the rest became part of Mount Tamalpais State Park.4 In under Custodian John Needham, the NPS constructed about 500 linear feet of brush dams in Redwood Creek by lining the banks with brush to help combat flooding and erosion before revetments could be put 2 National Park Service, PEPC Planning, Environment & Public Comment: Muir Woods Salmon Habitat Enhancement and Bridge Replacement Project, accessed October 23, 3 John Auwaerter and John F. Sears, Historic Resource Study for Muir Woods National Monument (Boston: Olmsted Center for Landscape Preservation, 4 Ibid, REDWOOD CREEK RIPRAP HAER No. CA-2357 Page 4 in place.

The NPS later elaborated on the work by constructing rock-filled wire baskets to create durable, yet temporary, revetments.5 In September the new Custodian J. Barton Herschler continued his predecessor s revetment projects. He started off using the same construction methods as Needham and by had installed an additional 576 lineal feet of wire basket revetments. In the NPS hired the CCC to work at Muir Woods. With the CCC s arrival the revetment work was further developed into more permanent features and built on a larger scale. The CCC began by building brush dams, which was a temporary design until rock check dams were proposed later that year. The design was approved by NPS Chief Engineer Kittredge and in the CWA began building the first rock check dam in Redwood Creek near Bridge 1.

The CWA quarried 135 truckloads of stones for the dam from the former Kent Estate. The CCC and CWA also continued to implement rock-filled wire baskets in Redwood Creek. In Herschler and Kittredge came to the conclusion that these rock- filled wire baskets were not sufficiently withstanding the erosion, resulting in the decision to construct permanent revetments in Redwood Creek. The NPS built the new revetments in areas that suffered from significant flooding and erosion, such as near bridges and along the banks. They did this by utilizing backing rocks which were slightly dug into the banks of the creek behind larger stones.

In the fall of after the construction of the first rock check dam, the Civil Work Administration was discontinued and the CCC continued the erosion control work.6 In Redwood Creek experienced a large flood, and the NPS Regional Office Associate Engineer W. E. Robertson concluded that more revetments would increase efficiency as the as the unprotected areas were damaged by the flood. He identified twenty-eight locations in Redwood Creek that most needed revetment work and proposed these areas be constructed with larger stones than previously used. The CCC went on to build square yards of stone revetments in these locations.7 In March the NPS began to worry that the speedy construction of the revetments could have a negative impact on Redwood Creek.

In order to monitor the revetments impact on the environment, the NPS decided to slow down construction and focus the CCC s efforts on blending the stones into their new environment. The NPS goal was to make it appear as if these rocks had always existed along the creek so as not to be noticed 5 Auwaerter and Sears, Historic Resource Study, 6 Ibid, 7 Ibid, REDWOOD CREEK RIPRAP HAER No. CA-2357 Page 5 by visitors.8 By most of the revetment work at Redwood Creek was completed. However, the CCC continued to work on other waterways in Muir Woods.9 Today, while the revetments continue to add flood control, they have also been proven to be detrimental to the salmon habitat in Redwood Creek. The salmon need flood areas out of the current to rest on their journey upstream.

Since the riprap is keeping Redwood Creek in an essentially straight line, there are few static pools for the salmon to find refuge. As a result, an estimated to linear feet of historic riprap, or at most 48 percent, are subject to removal.10 Some of the highly visible riprap will be maintained while riprap that is shielded in vegetation will be removed.11 Historians: Olivia H. Manfredi, Cultural Resources Intern, Golden Gate National Recreation Area, National Park Service and Kristin L. Baron, Architectural Historian, Golden Gate National Recreation Area, National Park Service, prepared the HAER report. The HAER records were prepared in All HAER photographs were taken between August and June

Written history

53 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2357. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Muir Woods Salmon Habitat Enhancement project required the removal of the historic Redwood Creek riprap, resulting in an adverse effect to the historic resource. The HAER recordation documents the historic resource and is a mitigation measure per the Memorandum of Agreement between the NPS and the California Office State Historic Preservation (signed

Sources

87 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2357. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Auwaerter, John, and Sears, John F. Historic Resource Study for Muir Woods National Monument. Boston: Olmsted Center for Landscape Preservation, National Park Service. PEPC Planning, Environment & Public Comment: Muir Woods Salmon Habitat Enhancement and Bridge Replacement Project. Accessed October 23, Natural Resources Conservation Service Wyoming, U.S. Department of Agriculture. "Rock Check Dam Fact Sheet." Accessed December 3, 8 Auwaerter and Sears, Historic Resource Study, 9 Ibid, 10 National Park Service, PEPC Planning, Environment & Public Comment. 11 Ibid. REDWOOD CREEK RIPRAP HAER No. CA-2357 Page 6

In context

Mill Valley, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Marin County, California 169 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Mill Valley

24 of 37 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through Mill Valley building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1-25,606 words
Mount Tamalpais State ParkHALS CA-1074,082 words
Lytton SquareHALS CA-1453,006 words
Druid HeightsHABS CA-2920-D2,514 words
Druid HeightsHABS CA-2920-B2,203 words
Druid HeightsHABS CA-2920-E2,144 words
Druid HeightsHABS CA-2920-C2,135 words
Druid HeightsHABS CA-2920-A2,027 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1T-51 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1S-47 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1Z-46 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1B-45 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1G-45 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1A-44 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1D-44 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1P-44 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1V-44 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1W-44 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1H-43 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1I-43 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1Y-43 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1C-42 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1O-42 words
Mill Valley Air Force StationHABS CAL,21-MILVA.V,1F-41 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CA-2357. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.