The City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant is being demolished as part of a redevelopment project, which entails constructing new, efficient, and flexible power generation. Documentation was requested by the City and prepared as a mitigation measure for demolition. The sponsor and cooperating organizations are the City and Photographs prepared by Stephen D. Schafer, Schaf Studio. Measured Drawings prepared by Alan White and Sam Malnati, AQYER, Written Data prepared by Emily Rinaldi-Williams and peer reviewed by Anna Maas, Stantec. CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History: 1. Dates of Construction: (Unit 1); (Unit 2); (Unit 3); (Unit 4); (Unit 5) 2.
Architect/Engineer: Daniel Anthony Elliott designed the original Steam Plant Building, which was completed in Elliott was born in Las Vegas, New Mexico in He attended the University of California at Berkley, earning an architecture degree in From through he served as a designer at the Los Angeles architecture firm of Gilbert Stanley Underwood before obtaining his architecture license and becoming an architect at the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California. He remained at the water district from through During World War II, he worked at Hoover and Montgomery, a firm that specialized in water-related infrastructure projects.
Following the end of the war, he formed his own architecture practice, one he maintained until his retirement in Other examples of his work include the Colorado River Aqueduct Pumping Plants completed in the Burbank Water & Power administrative building completed in and the Burbank Water & Power Olive Power Plant completed in 1 Romeo Raoul Martel served as the structural engineer for the original Steam Plant Building. Martel was born in Iberville, Quebec in then moved with his family to Pawtucket, Rhode Island six months later. He graduated from Brown University in with a degree in civil engineering.
After graduation, he taught civil engineering at Rhode Island State College and the Mechanics Institute in Rochester, New York, and then worked for a few years as an assistant engineer for the Sayles Finishing Plant, which owned several cotton mills in Rhode Island, before moving on to work for the Atchison, Topeka, and Santa Fe Railroad in Amarillo, Texas. Martel started teaching at Caltech in and later became a professor of civil engineering in a position he held until his retirement in While at Caltech, he also served as a consulting engineer for local municipalities in the area, including Pasadena, Glendale, Burbank, Riverside, and Los Angeles.
Martel was one of the first engineers at Caltech to specialize in designing earthquake-resistant structures and consulted on the seismic design for the Southern California Edison offices in Los Angeles, First Trust Building in Pasadena, Fruit Growers Exchange in Los Angeles, and Bridge Auditorium in Pomona. He also served on the building code committees for Pasadena, the American Standards Association, Structural Engineers Association, State Division of Architecture, and State Chamber of Commerce. 2 3. Building/Contractor/Supplier: The Combustion Engineering Company supplied Boilers 1A, 1B, and 2. Grieve Grate Company and American Stoker Company merged in to form the Combustion Engineering Company.
It originally manufactured mechanical stokers and grates for firing coal, and by the early had grown into one of the largest manufacturers of stokers in the United States. By the mid-1920s, Combustion Engineering began to diversify their business, expanding into the manufacture of steam boilers. Technological advancements pioneered by the company prior to World War II included tangential firing, the plate-type air preheater welded boiler drum, and the first boiler rated at 1 million pounds of steam per hour. In the Locomotive Superheater Company manufacturer of boiler equipment for locomotives and ships acquired Combustion Engineering.
The two companies later merged in 1 Burbank Water & Power Company, Los Angeles Conservancy, accessed April 21, and American Institute of Architects, American Architects Directory, (New York, NY: R. R. Bowker Company, 2 California Institute of Technology, R. R. Martel, Professor of Structural Engineering, Engineering and Science 19, no.6 (March 22 24; and Nurit Lifshitz, R. R. Martel Papers, California Institute of Technology Archives and Special Collections, accessed October 17, CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 3) under the name Combustion Engineering, Inc.
After World War II, Combustion Engineering was at the forefront of steam power generation technology and began selling nuclear power-related equipment in addition to natural gas and coal power generation equipment. Also, during this period, the company changed its name to C-E. Asbestos claims filed against the company brought it to the brink of bankruptcy in the early and it was subsequently split up and sold off to Alstom, Westinghouse Electric Co., and General Electric. 3 Babcock and Wilcox manufactured Boiler 3. George Babcock and Stephen Wilcox formed the company in designing and manufacturing water-tube steam boilers. Wilcox had previously patented a safer boiler design that also increased heating surface and water circulation.
Babcock and Wilcox was an early supplier of boilers to some of the first electrical power generating facilities in the United States and soon began to diversify their business into the manufacture of marine boilers. By the the company began to expand into the international market, and by the early twentieth century, it maintained continuous growth through acquisitions of a boiler cleaning business, seamless steel tube company, bent-tube boiler manufacturer, and boiler control/metering equipment manufacturer. Babcock and Wilcox continued to specialize in coal, oil, and gas boilers and marine boilers through World War II. In the the company also began manufacturing nuclear power generation equipment.
In Babcock and Wilcox built the world s largest boiler to date, which was a megawatt supercritical pressure unit for the Tennessee Valley Authority. They later built the first atmospheric fluidized-bed boiler in the United States in 4 Babcock and Wilcox became a subsidiary of McDermott International Inc. in before separating again as an independent company in 5 Under the name Babcock, the company remains a manufacturer of the latest power production technologies to this day. Riley Stoker manufactured Boilers 4 and 5. Robert Sanford Riley founded the company in in Worcester, Massachusetts as the Sanford Riley Stoker Company to manufacture a stoker of his own design for firing coal.
6 It quickly grew into one of the largest stoker manufacturing companies in the United States with upward of 500 employees by In the the company began manufacturing other types of stokers and acquired various related companies, such as the Iron Works and Underfeed Stoker Co., Murphy Iron Works, and A. W. Cash Co. 7 By the it manufactured steam boilers and related boiler parts, such as burners, economizers, superheaters, pulverizers, and waterwalls. 8 Riley Stoker continued to manufacture boilers and related boiler equipment through the postwar period. It was sold to Ashland Oil in the early and then to Babcock and Wilcox in as part of an agreement to cover all liabilities associated with an asbestos-related class action lawsuit.
The company continues to manufacture boiler parts under the name Riley Power Inc., a subsidiary of Babcock Power. 9 3 Historical Technologies, Building #3 Kreisinger Development Laboratory and Building #6 Hot Waste Dilution Vault, Combustion Engineering, Inc., Windsor, Connecticut (Windsor, CT: ABB, Inc., November 42 56. 4 Our History, Babcock and Wilcox, accessed June 20, 5 McDermott Plans to Separate into Two Independent Companies: Babcock & Wilcox and J. Ray McDermott, McDermott, December 7, accessed October 25, and Robert J. Cole, Babcock Agrees with Merger Pact with McDermott, New York Times, December 9, 6 Charles Nutt, History of Worcester and Its People (New York, NY: Lewis Historical Publishing Company, 7 Robert Sanford Riley, The Iron Age no.
19 (May 13, accessed October 17, 8 Steven E. Kuehn, Power for the Industrial Age: A Brief History of Boilers, Power Engineering no. 2 (February 5 19. 9 Ashland Stock Levels Off; Asbestos Fears Quieted, The Courier-Journal (Lexington, August 10, and Riley Power, Babcock Power, accessed October 17, CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 4) General Electric (GE) manufactured all five steam turbine generators. The original General Electric company traces its history back to the Edison Electric Light Company founded by Thomas Alva Edison in Edison invented the incandescent light bulb and initially formed the company to manufacturer and sell his incandescent lamps.
In the company designed and built the first commercial power station in the United States, generating power to fifty-nine residences in New York City. The Edison Electric Light Company later merged with two other electrical companies in the early to form the Edison General Electric Company. The company was a continual innovator of electrical, transportation, and medical technologies, including the x-ray machine, high-frequency alternator to send transatlantic radio-telegraph messages, ductile tungsten lightbulb filament, electric stove, home television, silicone, first jet engine in the United States, first licensed nuclear power plant in the United States, and Signa Magnetic Resonance Imaging System amongst others.
10 The company continues to operate under the name GE, but has divested some portions of the business with the power generation portion planned for spin-off as GE Vernova in 11 4. Original Plans and Construction: 12 The City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant, as originally completed in had two boiler units, Boiler 1A and 1B, and one turbine generator, Generator 1 that could produce a gross output of 20 MW. 13 It was constructed of reinforced concrete with a steel-frame structure. It was three stories in height and rectangular in plan with a one-story wing to the west.
It had a first story elevated above grade, a mezzanine level between the first and second stories, a below-grade basement, a basement mezzanine, also below grade, and a stair penthouse at the northwest corner of the third-story roof. The building was freestanding with all four fa ades visible from the public right-of-way. 14 The primary fa ade faced east onto the railroad right-of-way and San Fernando Road. It was six bays wide with eight horizontal grooves in the concrete cladding across the entire primary fa ade. Entrances were at the two center bays on the first story. Each consisted of paired, fully glazed, hollow-metal doors with bronze push bars. Light fixtures and concrete pilasters flanked the door openings.
The remaining bays on the first story had rectangular window openings infilled with steel-frame window sashes. The windows had two operable hopper sashes over four fixed horizontal lights. A concrete string course divided the first and second story. Above the string course, each bay had a large rectangular window opening with concrete lintels that was infilled with glass block. The north and south fa ades or side fa ades comprised two three-story volumes with the west volume slightly setback from the east volume. On the north fa ade, the west volume was divided by three pairs of horizontal concrete bands bordering rows of window openings at each story one band below each window opening and one above. The windows were six-light, steel-frame sashes with a central operable awning sash.
The east volume on the north fa ade was divided by eight horizontal grooves and had a garage opening on the first story. The opening was infilled with a sliding metal garage door that had a single, partially glazed steel pedestrian door at the center. The south fa ade was similar in design to the north in that the east volume was divided by eight horizontal grooves and the west had continuous concrete 10 Karl Montevirgen, General Electric, Encyclopedia Britannica, accessed August 17, Eric Owles, G.E. s History of Innovation, New York Times, June 12, accessed August 17, innovation.html; and Timeline of Innovation, GE, accessed August 17, of-innovation#.
11 Sharon Terlep, GE s Stock Climbs After It Raises Earnings Forecast, Sets Power Spinoff for Spring, Wall Street Journal, October 24, 12 City of Glendale Public Services Department, Steam Plant (Architectural Drawing Set), in Glendale Water and Power s possession. 13 Glendale Water and Power Grayson Power Plant (Glendale, California: City of Glendale, undated), in Glendale Water and Power s possession. 14 Grayson Power Plant. CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 5) bands above and below the window openings, although only on the first story. There were two additional window openings at the second story of the west volume without the concrete bands.
At the east volume on the south fa ade, there was a window opening on the first story infilled with a four-light, fixed steel-frame sash topped by two operable awning sashes. Above the first story was a vertical group of five window openings infilled with paired awning windows. The rear fa ade with the one-story wing faced west towards the Los Angeles River. It was generally unornamented except for the concrete bands that wrapped around the northwestern corner of the building from the north fa ade s west volume to the west fa ade s north end. The windows between the bands on the west facade were six-light, steel-frame sashes with a central operable awning sash.
On the second story of the west fa ade, the window openings were infilled with the same six-light, steel-frame sashes with a central operable awning sash. The one-story wing to the west was also unornamented except for the concrete bands that wrapped around the northwest and southwest corners. All window openings were infilled with six-light, steel-frame sashes with a central operable awning sash. There was one entrance on the one-story wing off center to the north. It was a single, partially glazed hollow metal door. The building and one-story wing were topped with a concrete coping. Concrete platforms flanked the building to the east and west. The east platform referred to as the turbine deck extended across the entire primary fa ade.
A steam turbine generator (Generator 1) was housed in a metal structure near the platform s north end. The east platform also had a steel gantry crane approximately two stories in height. The west platform extended along the length of the one-story wing. It supported two boiler stacks. The interior had an open, triple-height space above grade where Boiler 1A and Boiler 1B were housed. The east end of the triple-height space was referred to as the firing aisle. It had concrete floors and exposed structure at the walls and ceiling. The firing aisle opened onto the boiler area to the west, which extended from the basement to the roof. It had metal-grate catwalks at the basement mezzanine, first floor, and mezzanine levels, and exposed structure at the walls and ceiling.
The boilers themselves extended from the basement to the second story. Operation and administration spaces consisted of a series of partitioned rooms at the building s northwest corner on the first through third floors. On the first floor was the control room (Control Room 1) that had concrete floors, walls, and ceilings. There was a single toilet room to the northeast of the control room and a maintenance room to the northwest. On the second floor, spaces were organized around a double-loaded corridor. A laboratory was to the west and a restroom to the east. The restroom had two toilet stalls, a urinal, and a shower. The corridor terminated at an office space to the north, which also had a large closet for record storage.
The finishes on the second floor generally consisted of concrete flooring, plaster walls with a metal baseboard, and plaster ceilings, except for the restroom which had ceramic tile floors. On the third floor, there was an unpartitioned office space with concrete floors, plaster walls, and a plaster ceiling. The basement was a double-height, space that extended below grade from the west exterior wall to the east end of the turbine deck. It had concrete floors, walls, and ceilings. A partitioned space was at the northwest corner of the basement and basement mezzanine levels, also with concrete floors, walls, and ceilings. Circulation consisted of four stairs, all with open, metal-grate treads and metal pipe handrails. One extended from the basement to the roof.
A second extended from the basement to the third story. Finally, the remaining two extended from the first story to the basement. 15 15 City of Glendale Public Services Department, Steam Plant (Architectural Drawing Set), in Glendale Water and Power s possession. CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 6) Associated ancillary structures built to the west simultaneously with the Steam Plant Building were a cooling tower (Cooling Tower 1) and below grade fuel oil bunker, chemical pump house, auxiliary cooling tower, and three storage tanks two for water and one for fuel. The Glendale Switching Station was constructed to the east. 16 5.
Alterations and Additions: The City began preparing plans for a second boiler unit as early as but a second boiler (Boiler 2) and steam turbine generator (Generator 2) were not added until due to the outbreak of World War II. Boiler 2 was installed within the original building to the south of Boiler 1A and 1B, while Generator 2 was installed on the turbine deck to the south of Generator 1. The new boiler and generator increased the plant s gross output by 20 MW for a total generating capacity of 40 MW. 17 To accommodate the installation of Boiler 2, a window opening was reconfigured into a door opening near the south end of the west fa ade and infilled with a single, partially glazed hollow metal-frame door.
18 An addition with a third boiler unit (Boiler 3) and steam turbine generator (Generator 3) with a gross output of 20 MW was constructed in 19 The city originally planned to build the three- story, four-bay addition south of Boiler 2; however, the Verdugo Wash bordering the south end of the property prevented this plan; therefore, it was added to the north fa ade of the building. At the same time, the first-story window opening on the building s south fa ade was resized into a door opening with paired, partially glazed hollow metal doors and a concrete stair added with metal pipe handrails. 20 The east fa ade of the addition mirrored the design of the original building.
At the first story, the two southernmost bays had steel-frame window sashes with two operable hopper sashes, and the remaining two northern bays had paired, fully glazed, hollow-metal doors. At the upper stories, all four bays had double-height, glass block windows. The turbine deck was extended north, and a third generator unit added to the north of Generator 1 within metal housing that matched the existing generators. 21 On the addition s west fa ade, the south end was clad in concrete, while the north end was clad in corrugated asbestos-cement panels. Boiler 3 s stack was at the center of the addition s west fa ade. To the north of the boiler stack was a partially glazed, single metal door and awning/hopper windows at the second and third floors.
Added near the south end, a freight elevator opened onto a concrete platform at the first story; its penthouse extended above the third-story roofline. Six-light, steel-frame sashes with a central operable awning sash were at each floor to the elevator s south. To the elevator s north was a partially glazed, single metal door with awning/hopper windows above. 22 Like the west fa ade, the addition s north fa ade was clad in corrugated asbestos-cement panels. It had a garage opening at the east end infilled with the original garage door salvage from the building. 23 16 University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB), City of Glendale (Aerial Photograph), UCSB Library, Geospatial Collection, accessed October 17, 17 Grayson Power Plant.
18 City of Glendale Public Services Department, Steam Plant: Openings for Ducts and Door on West Elevation (Architectural Drawing), Sheet E-28, in Glendale Water and Power s possession. 19 Grayson Power Plant. 20 City of Glendale Public Services Department, Steam Plant (Architectural Drawing Set), in Glendale Water and Power s possession. 21 Ibid. 22 Ibid. 23 Ibid. CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 7) On the addition s interior, the first-floor control room was extended north, and a freight elevator lobby and mechanical room added to the west. On the second floor, the restroom was extended and additional office space, a freight elevator lobby, janitor closet, and electric equipment room were constructed.
On the third floor, a freight elevator lobby and additional office space were constructed. The basement and basement mezzanine were extended north below grade. Similar interior finishes to the building were used throughout. 24 In an addition with a fourth boiler unit (Boiler 4) and steam turbine generator (Generator 4) with a gross output of 44 MW was constructed on the north fa ade of the addition. The addition was three bays wide and three-to-six stories in height. The east end was three stories and the west end six stories with a five-story penthouse at the south end of the east fa ade. 25 The east fa ade s lower three stories mirrored the design of the building.
Paired, fully glazed, hollow-metal doors were at the first story s center bay, flanked by steel-frame window sashes with two operable hopper sashes. All three bays had double-height, glass block windows above. The east fa ade s five and six-story portions were clad in flat asbestos-cement panels. The five-story penthouse had battens along the east fa ade, while the six-story portion had bands of concrete trim at the southeast corner. Free standing, all capital, metal letters spelled out City of Glendale, Public Service Department, Steam Electric Generating Plant across the top of the east fa ade. Additionally, the turbine deck was extended north, and a fourth generator unit added to the north of Generator 3 within metal housing that matched the existing generators.
26 The lower three stories of the addition s remaining fa ades were clad in corrugated asbestos-cement panels and the upper levels clad in flat asbestos-cement panels. On the west fa ade, two door openings were at the first story, one at the second story, and two at the third story. All had partially glazed metal doors. On the north fa ade s east end, a garage opening was infilled with the garage door again salvaged for reuse. 27 The interior finishes of the addition were similar to the rest of the building. The basement was extended north below grade and had concrete walls, floors, and ceiling. The firing aisle on the first floor had concrete floors and exposed structure at the walls and ceiling.
The boiler area had metal grating at the basement mezzanine through sixth floors and exposed wall and ceiling structure. 28 In an addition with a fifth boiler unit (Boiler 5) and steam turbine generator (Generator 5) with 44 MW gross output was constructed on the north fa ade of the addition. The addition was similar in its design to the addition. It was four bays wide and three-to-six stories in height. The east end was three stories, the west end six stories, and a one-story wing extended from the northwest corner. 29 The east fa ade s lower three stories were clad in concrete. Paired, fully glazed hollow-metal doors were at the first story s outer bays with two steel-frame window sashes in between.
The upper stories were clad in flat asbestos-cement panels, and the addition s sign was 24 Glendale Public Services Department, Steam Plant, 25 City of Glendale Public Services Department, Steam Plant (Architectural Drawing Set), 58, in Glendale Water and Power s possession. 26 Ibid. 27 Ibid. 28 Ibid. 29 Ibid. CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 8) relocated to the north end of the addition s east fa ade. The turbine deck was extended farther north, and a fifth generator unit added to the north of Generator 4. 30 On the addition s remaining fa ades, the lower three stories were clad in corrugated asbestos-cement panels and the upper stories in flat asbestos-cement panels.
Five door openings with a single, partially glazed metal door were on the west fa ade two on the first story, two on the second story, and one on the third story. On the north fa ade s east end, a garage opening was infilled with the garage door. To the west of the garage opening was a single-light, fixed window. The one-story wing at the northwest corner was clad in smooth stucco. A single, partially glazed metal door was on the wing s north fa ade and two single- light, fixed windows. 31 The interior finishes of the addition were again like the rest of the existing building. A second control room (Control Room 2), restroom, and staff break room were added in the one- story wing. These spaces had linoleum floors and smooth plaster walls.
The ceiling of Control Room 2 was covered by a metal diffuser suspended on a metal frame. The remaining spaces had acoustical tile ceilings. The basement was extended north below grade and had concrete walls, floors, and ceiling. 32 The City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant has been minimally altered since the construction of the addition. Changes made to the exterior include the resizing of all door openings on the east fa ade and infilling with new roll-up garage doors, and the replacement of the metal sign letters on the east fa ade s sixth story with plastic letters.
Interior alterations include the installation of linoleum floors and acoustical tile ceiling in Control Room 1, linoleum, carpeting, and clay tile floors in second floor spaces, and construction of new interior partitions on the third floor. A bathroom and storage closet were partitioned at the south end of the firing aisle, and a kitchenette added on the east wall of the firing aisle outside Control Room 1. Boilers 1A, 1B, and 2 were decommissioned in the early and preserved in place, although Generators 1 and 2 were still in use. Boilers 3, 4, and 5 were retrofitted with landfill gas burners, emission control systems, and continuous emissions monitoring systems to meet California s South Coast Air Quality Management District requirements.
Additionally, Boiler 4 s waterwall tubes were replaced in 33 Outside the Steam Plant Building, additional structures have been added to the property over time to support the facility s operation and maintenance. Units 6 9 were constructed as exterior freestanding units. Units 6 and 7 simple cycle gas turbines, were built to the Steam Plant Building s northwest. Units 8A and 8BC a combined cycle unit that utilized three new gas turbines supplying steam to Generators 1 and 2, were constructed to the Steam Plant Building s west. Unit 9 another simple cycle gas turbine, was added to the south of the Steam Plant Building.
Units 6 and 7 were later demolished in early Simultaneous with each new steam turbine generator unit, four cooling towers were added to the Steam Plant Building s west Cooling Tower 2 Cooling Tower 3 Cooling Tower 4 and Cooling Tower 5 Like Cooling Tower 1, Cooling Towers 2 4 had an associated below grade fuel bunker. Cooling Tower 1 and 2 were subsequently replaced in and Cooling Tower 3 was replaced in To the east of the Steam Plant Building, the Glendale Switching Station, also known as the Glendale Rack, was expanded in and to accommodate the added units. A second switching station the Kellogg Switching Station 30 City of Glendale Public Services Department, Steam Plant (Architectural Drawing Set), in Glendale Water and Power s possession.
31 Glendale Public Services Department, Steam Plant, 32 Ibid. 33 Matthew Williams (Power Plant Operations Supervisor, Grayson Power Plant), in interview with the author, Glendale, CA, March 20 22, CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No.
CA-2399 (Page 9) was built in and expanded in the The original Kellogg Switching Station was later demolished and replaced with new gas insulated bus technology in 34 Other associated ancillary buildings included a chemical pump house between Cooling Towers 1 and 2 built in the a chemical storage building west of Boiler 4 and 5 s stacks that was built in the a circulating water pump house south of Cooling Towers 3 and 4 constructed in the a chemical pump house east of Cooling Tower 5 constructed in the a maintenance building east of Cooling Tower 1 constructed in the a control house associated with Units 8A and 8BC built in the and control houses associated with the Kellogg Switching Station built in the Various water and fuel oil tanks were added between the and Remaining ancillary buildings are occupied by the Electric and Water Services Departments and are not associated with the City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant.
35 B. Historical Context: Steam-Powered Electrical Generation in Los Angeles County As Los Angeles County experienced rapid growth in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the demands for electricity increased dramatically. Privately-owned companies generated most of the electrical power in the region during this period, and the earliest Southern California electrical power plants were powered by water or steam using coal as fuel. The San Francisco-based California Electric Light Company (now Pacific, Gas & Electric) constructed one of the first power plants in the City of Los Angeles in although within a year it was taken over by the newly formed Los Angeles Electric Company.
36 The plant on Alameda and Banning streets used coal-fired, steam-engine generators to illuminate downtown Los Angeles streetlights. Other early power plants included the Los Angeles Steam Plant No. 1 constructed in Pacific Light and Power Company s Redondo Beach steam plant in and the Glenarm Power Plant constructed in Pasadena in 37 With the completion of the Glenarm Power Plant, the City of Pasadena was one of the first municipalities in the region to generate electricity for municipal power distribution. 38 The City of Los Angeles followed suit with the formation of the Bureau of Power and Light in and the completion of the San Francisquito Power Plant No.
1 in 39 Glendale and Burbank also provided municipal power distribution to their residents by and respectively; however, these cities only distributed power supplied from privately-owned sources rather than generated electricity like Pasadena and Los Angeles. 40 Technological advances in the early twentieth century led to the growing use of fuel oil and later natural gas in addition to coal with steam-powered turbine generators replacing the steam-engine generators of the previous century.
These advances increased steam-power generation s capacity to generate 34 Matthew Williams, March 20 22, UCSB, and and United States Geological Survey (USGS), City of Glendale (Aerial Photograph), accessed October 17, 35 Matthew Williams, March 20 22, UCSB, and and USGS, 36 Daniel Prosser, Municipal Water and Power, Los Angeles Citywide Context Statement (City of Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, 7. 37 First Electricity in Los Angeles, Water and Power Associates, accessed October 17, cipal%20power%20pole,1; and Pasadena Water and Power, City of Pasadena, accessed October 17, 38 Who We Are, Pasadena Water and Power, accessed October 25, 39 Prosser, 11.
40 The Development of Electric and Water Services in Burbank, Burbank Water and Power, accessed October 25, CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 10) electricity, allowing it to keep pace with Los Angeles County s growing municipal, industrial, and domestic demands. Steam power generation remained part of California s power production throughout the early twentieth century, though it declined considerably in the period leading up to World War II as large hydroelectric generating plants came online throughout the state. As early as hydroelectric power accounted for 69% of all electrical power generated. In that figure had risen to and by hydroelectric sources provided 89% of California s electricity.
41 Major utilities began to question the reliability of hydropower during one of California s persistent droughts, which began in and continued, on and off, for a decade. Concurrently, in the new natural gas discoveries were made that provided both Northern and Southern California with ample fuel for steam electric power generation. The confluence of these various factors drought, new steam generator technologies, and new supplies of natural gas prompted California utilities to begin constructing large steam plants. Steam plants built across the state generally were located on inexpensive land with geological formations that could provide a good foundation and were close to a water supply, fuel supplies, and load centers to reduce transmission costs.
By oil and gas-fired steam power plants accounted for more than half of all new plants under construction in California. The oil and gas-fired steam generation capacity jumped from kilowatt in to over 1 million kW six years later. 42 Like elsewhere in California, Los Angeles County municipalities began to construct larger power generation facilities in the and The City of Pasadena extended their electrical power distribution system by constructing the Santa Anita and Maryland power substations during the and the Glenham substation in the early In the City of Burbank added the Magnolia Power Station, the same year as the City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant.
43 Post-World War II California residential and industrial development increased, and power companies responded with more hydroelectric and steam power electrical generation. Steam power generation, however, proved to be more cost effective. As a result, municipalities and other companies began to build power generation plants close to population centers, utilizing steam turbines to generate power to meet the increased demands for electricity. By hydroelectricity accounted for only 59% of the total power generated, falling to 27% in By the steam powered generation accounted for the majority of all electricity generated in California with hydroelectric and nuclear plants accounting for the remainder.
44 History of Grayson Power Plant By the turn of the twentieth century, the town of Glendale had already experienced rapid growth due, in part, to the promotional efforts of Edgar D. Goode and Dr. D. W. Hunt and their Glendale Improvement Society. The opening of the Pacific Electric Railroad in connecting Glendale to Los Angeles, spurred further growth in the area. 45 In Glendale incorporated as a city approximately acres 41 James C. Williams, Energy and the Making of Modern California (Akron, Ohio: University of Akron Press, 42 I.C. Steele, Steam Power Gains on Hydro in California, Civil Engineering (Transmission Agency of Northern California, January 17 21. 43 First Electricity, Water and Power Associates; Pasadena Water and Power, City of Pasadena; and James C.
Williams, 44 Database of California Power Plants, California Energy Commission, May 1, accessed November 19, List of Inactive/Retired Power Plants California Energy Commission, accessed November 19, and James C. Williams, 45 City of Glendale, Popular Annual Financial Report, June 20, accessed October 17, CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 11) in size with a population of around residents by 46 Power generation in the newly incorporated city began in earnest after the citizens voted in favor of a bond to purchase the privately-owned Glendale Light & Power Company in and establish the Glendale Public Service Division. By the system was already strained as energy output was a mere kW.
To supplement, the city purchased additional electricity from Pacific Power & Light, now part of the Southern California Edison Company. 47 Glendale began annexing neighboring communities, boosting the city s population to over residents by 48 They included Whiting Woods, Verdugo Mountains New York Avenue (in the La Crescenta area), Upper Chevy Chase Canyon, and several smaller annexations, which enlarged the city to square miles by During this same period, the population expanded to in and in 49 Due to all the annexations and general population increases throughout the region, the Glendale Public Service could not keep pace with the city s growing electricity demands as early as the mid-1930s.
50 During this period, Glendale did not have a power plant of its own but rather purchased its power from Southern California Edison Company, Los Angeles Bureau of Power and Light, and after its completion in supplemented this supply with hydroelectric power from the Hoover Dam. Due to quickly increasing demand, the City determined that it would need its own power plant to supplement power purchased from privately-owned utilities. 51 Glendale began planning for the construction of a new power plant in However, the Los Angeles Bureau of Power and Light and the Southern California Edison Company immediately opposed the City s plans to construct an independent power source. Despite this opposition, the City spurred by industrial entities pushed forward with a million budget.
The City secured the services of engineer Daniel A. Elliott and structural engineer Romeo Raoul Martel to design the Grayson Power Plant, referred to then as the Glendale Power Plant, Glendale Power & Light, or City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant. Elliott designed the Steam Plant Building (later known as the Boiler Building) in the Streamline Moderne style to house two boilers (Boilers 1A and manufactured by Combustion Engineering Company. 52 The original design laid claim to reportedly being the world s first earthquake-proof power plant, with an approximate deep concrete basement, turbine generator on an uncovered open deck with a metal covering over the generator to protect it from inclement weather, and a building shell built of light steel and concrete walls.
53 While its status as the world s first earthquake-proof power plant could not be confirmed, the building was designed with an ordinary concentric braced frame to resist the effects of earthquake forces. 54 The Steam Plant Building was also an early example of a power plant with an 46 General Population of the City of Los Angeles County, Los Angeles Almanac, accessed October 17, and More Demand for Energy Anticipated, Glendale News- Press, November 23, 47 City of Glendale Public Services Department, History (City of Glendale, April in the Glendale Public Service Department s possession. 48 Overview of Glendale History, City of Glendale, accessed October 17, city/visitors/historic- and General Population, Los Angeles Almanac.
49 Overview of Glendale History, City of Glendale; and General Population, Los Angeles Almanac. 50 City of Glendale Public Service Commission, Annual Report of the Public Service Commission (City of Glendale, in Glendale Public Service Commission s possession. 51 Purchased Power City Makes Own Energy Since Glendale News-Press, November Glendale Public Services Department, History. 52 Burbank Water & Power, Los Angeles Conservancy. 53 Power Plant Built in Open: Glendale Will have First Completed Quake-Proof Setup, Los Angeles Times, June 30, 54 Black & Veatch, Final Boiler Building Assessment Grayson Power Project, Glendale, California (Glendale, CA: Glendale Water & Power, June 21, 2. CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No.
CA-2399 (Page 12) outdoor freestanding hydrogen-cooled generator. 55 During the Great Depression, the development of power plants with freestanding generators, boilers, or both weatherproofed under some type of covering or structure grew in popularity due to the reduced time, materials, and cost necessary to construct them. The use of hydrogen for cooling machinery emerged around the same time with the first hydrogen-cooled generator installed in at the Dayton Power & Light Company plant in Dayton, Ohio. 56 Only ten hydrogen-cooled generators had been constructed in the United States by with another twenty- seven under construction in that year, including at the City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant.
57 Glendale s Generator 1 is noted in contemporary periodicals as the first hydrogen-cooled generator that was installed outdoors. 58 At its start-up in the plant was capable of producing 20 MW of power. To meet increasing demands for electricity, the City almost immediately secured funding for a second unit, but its installation was delayed by World War II rationing. 59 A second unit was finally added in which included an additional 20 MW generator and single boiler increasing the plant s combined capacity to 40 MW. 60 By Glendale s population had grown to 61 Due to continued rising demand, a third unit (Unit 3) was constructed in within an addition on the north fa ade for a cost of over $3 million.
Babcock & Wilcox Company manufactured the new boiler unit, which utilized advances in engineering and technology for increased steam pressure, allowing for greater operating efficiency. 62 By the Grayson Power Plant generated a total of kW-hours, supplying most of the City s power needs with the exception of supplemental power supplied by the Hoover Dam. 63 As demand kept growing, four more units were constructed between and Unit 4 Unit 5 Unit 6 and Unit 7 Boilers 4 and 5 were housed within new additions to the north and the turbine deck extended to accommodate two new steam turbine generators. Units 6 and 7, both simple cycle gas turbine units, were later located to the north of the Steam Plant Building in separate stand-alone enclosures.
Simultaneous with the installation of Unit 6, the City renamed the power plant to the Grayson Steam-Electric Generating Station or Grayson Power Plant after the City of Glendale General Manager and Chief Engineer, Lauren W. Grayson. At the time, Grayson was the City s longest serving employee with over twenty years of service. His most notable achievement was in bringing power to Southern California through the Pacific Northwest Intertie. 64 Unit 8 (8A and was constructed in These combined cycle gas turbine units produced more energy, more efficiently and with fewer emissions than previous units by generating electricity not only from their gas turbine generators, but also by using the hot exhaust gas energy to produce steam and generate electricity via Generators 1 and 2.
65 Unconventional at the time, the new system cost $20 million 55 News of the Industry, Electric Light and Power 18, no. 3 (March 74; Power and Electrical Developments in Power Plant Engineering 46, no. 2 (February 49. 56 News, Electric Light and Power; and Power and Electrical Developments, Power Plant Engineering. 57 D. S. Snell, The Hydrogen-Cooled Turbine Generator, Electrical Engineering 59, no. 1 (January 35 50; and National Electrical Manufactures Association, A Chronological History of Electrical Development (New York, NY: National Electrical Manufacturers Association, 96. 58 News, Electric Light and Power; and Power and Electrical Developments, Power Plant Engineering. 59 L.A.
Power Projects Suspended by Los Angeles Evening Citizen News, August 22, and Glendale Public Service Commission, Annual Report. 60 Third Generating Unit Plant Set to Operate Next April, Glendale News-Press, November 12, Steam Plant Third Unit Completed Kilowatt Hours More Energy Available, Glendale News-Press, and Glendale Public Service Commission, Annual Report. 61 General Population, Los Angeles Almanac. 62 Third Generating Unit, Glendale News-Press. 63 Glendale Public Service Commission, Annual Report.
64 City of Glendale, Resolution in Designating Steam Plant to Grayson, in City of Glendale s possession; and Lauren Grayson, Longtime City Official, Dies, Glendale News-Press, 65 Jack Cook, Power Plant Director Keeps a Close Watch over Glendale s Lifeline, Daily News, CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 13) and lessened air pollution. 66 Further environmental improvements to the power plant included the construction of a phosphate removal and treatment plant in The treatment plant was connected to the Los Angeles-Glendale Water Reclamation Plant by a pipeline, which directly pumped raw reclaimed (recycled) water to the treatment plant for phosphate removal before it was pumped to the Steam Plant as water for the cooling towers.
67 In the mid-1990 s, Boilers 3, 4, and 5 were retrofitted with landfill gas burners, and from to the Steam Plant burned landfill gas from the Scholl Canyon Landfill with natural gas to generate power. 68 Boilers 3, 4, and 5 were also retrofitted with emission control systems and continuous emissions monitoring systems to meet California s South Coast Air Quality Management District requirements. Boilers 1A and 1B and 2 were subsequently mothballed in the s; however, Generators 1 and 2 were still utilized with steam supplied from the Units 8A and 8BC heat recovery steam generators. 69 Unit 9, a gas turbine generator, was the last unit to be added to the property in at a cost of million. It replaced Units 6 and 7, two of the older, outdated units, which were then demolished.
Unit 9 primarily consists of a gas turbine generator, fuel gas compressors, and an emissions control system to treat the exhaust gas to reduce emissions. The unit is fueled with natural gas and operates during peak hours. In the City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant generated approximately 7% of the power needed for the City. The remaining power came from a combination of both local and remote generation (owned and leased), coupled with spot market purchases from a variety of suppliers throughout the western United States. 70 PART II. STRUCTURAL/DESIGN/EQUIPMENT INFORMATION A. General Statement: 1.
Character: The building, addition, and lower three stories of the and additions exhibit characteristics of the Streamline Moderne style, including horizontal orientation, flat roof, unadorned smooth wall surfaces, metal windows without window surrounds, glass block, and speedlines or horizontal lines. Streamline Moderne first emerged in the early evolving from the earlier Art Deco style, and is generally considered to be the next phase in the Modern movement. Like Art Deco, Streamline Moderne aimed to serve as a visual expression of modernity, technology, progress, and the future but was adapted from the earlier style to account for the economic constraints of the Depression era.
With the onset of the Great Depression in highly stylized Art Deco buildings and their close association with wealth and opulence fell out of favor and the rise of the stripped-down Streamline Moderne took its place. The most notable predecessor of the Streamline Moderne style is the Mossehaus, an office building in Berlin that was redesigned by architect Erich Mendelsohn in 71 Mendelsohn s design incorporated contemporary materials such as aluminum and reinforced concrete as well as featured a curved corner fa ade meant to evoke a futuristic form. The Streamline Moderne style was further popularized in the early through the work of industrial designers such as Norman Bel Geddes and through expositions and fairs like the Century of Progress World s Fair held in Chicago in 34.
72 66 Mason Ralph, City Installing New Generators, Burbank Ledger, January 1, 67 Julie Rees, Reclaimed Water Brings Power to the People, Glendale News-Press, March 31, 68 Scholl Canyon Landfill, City of Glendale, accessed October 17, 69 Matthew Williams, March 20 22, 70 Rostamik Chetin (Mechanical Engineer II, Glendale Water and Power), email to author, July 6, 71 Architectural Resources Group, L.A. Modernism, SurveyLA Los Angeles Citywide Context Statement (City of Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, August 66 67. 72 Ibid., 65 67. CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 14) Streamline Moderne drew inspiration from contemporary industrial design in its references to the aerodynamic forms of airplanes, ships, trains, and automobiles.
The style embraced a streamlined aesthetic that forged a strong visual connection with the idea of progress in the Streamline Moderne buildings were simpler and more utilitarian in their form and materials than the preceding Art Deco style. It incorporated characteristics of the International style, such as horizontal orientation, unadorned smooth wall surfaces, and bands of windows, while modifying the International style s geometric forms in favor of rounded corners and curved surfaces that emulated a windswept appearance. Other common characteristics of the Streamline Moderne style include flat roofs, metal casement windows without window surrounds, and speedlines at wall surfaces, such as horizontal moldings and continuous sill courses.
The lower three stories of the and additions east fa ades repeat the Streamline- Moderne style characteristics of the building with the exception of the glass block windows, which are missing on the addition. However, besides the east fa ade s lower stories, the design of the and additions are generally utilitarian and of no particular style. These additions have unarticulated wall surfaces clad in asbestos-cement paneling. They feature no ornamentation besides three horizontal moldings at the addition s southeast corner. 2. Condition of Fabric: The building is in good condition. B. Description of Exterior: 1. Overall Dimensions: The City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant is asymmetrical in plan with asymmetrical fa ades that feature setbacks and projecting volumes.
From grade to roofline, the building and addition are " in height. The and additions rise from " to " in height. The building is long and generally " wide at the east end and " at the west end. The turbine deck to the Steam Plant Building s east is " wide and the same length as the building. 73 2. Foundations: The Steam Plant Building has a reinforced concrete wall foundation with step- tapered concrete piling. 3. Walls: The walls of the building and addition are generally concrete. The east fa ade and east end of the south fa ade feature horizontal inset grooves, while the rest is smooth and unornamented. A portion of the addition s rear is clad in corrugated asbestos-cement panels.
The lower three stories of the and additions east fa ades are also concrete and have horizontal inset grooves. The remainder of the and additions are generally clad in either corrugated or flat asbestos-cement panels. The addition s one-story wing is clad in smooth stucco. 4. Structural System, Framing: The building has a steel concentric braced frame. The portion has riveted connections, while the newer additions have both riveted and bolted connections. 5. Porches, Stoops, Balconies, Bulkheads: The turbine deck extends along the length of the Steam Plant Building s east fa ade. It is approximately above grade, constructed of concrete, and surrounded on three sides by a metal pipe railing. Access to the deck is to the east via three concrete stairs with metal pipe railings.
Metal tracks extend along the length of the deck to the east and west upon which a roughly two-story-tall steel gantry crane can be moved in a north-south direction. The gantry crane is generally stored at the north end of the 73 AQYER, Grayson Power Plat Boiler Building, Architectural Drawing Set, CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 15) tracks. At the center of the deck are five steam turbine generators, Generators 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5. Each steam turbine generator is within a removable metal enclosure that can be lifted off the generator using the gantry crane. The enclosure consists of a rectangular-volume with a rounded-corner stepped roof, a central half-cylindrical volume, and a smaller half-cylindrical volume.
Two metal moldings extend across the east and west sides of the enclosure. The primary entrance a single metal sliding door is at the north or south end, depending on the generator. Secondary openings on the enclosures have single metal slab doors. There are three boiler stack decks approximately above grade along the Steam Plant Building s west fa ade one beneath Boiler 1A, 1B, and 2 s stacks at the south end, one surrounding Boiler 3 s stack, and one surrounding Boiler 4 and 5 s stacks. The north boiler stack deck is constructed of concrete and metal grating. It is accessed via four stairs, each with open-metal-grate treads and metal pipe railings. The center boiler stack deck is constructed of only metal grating.
The south deck is constructed of concrete and accessed via a concrete stair with metal pipe railing to the north or an open-metal-grate tread stair to the south. The primary entrance on the north fa ade has an asphalt-paved concrete vehicle ramp with metal pipe railings. There is a concrete stair with metal pipe railing at the secondary entrance on the south fa ade. At the freight elevator entrance just south of center on the west fa ade, there is a loading dock as well as a second asphalt-paved concrete ramp with metal pipe railings. The loading dock has a metal post and chain safety barrier and an open-metal-grate tread stair. The ramp has metal pipe railings. 6. Chimneys/Stacks: There are six boiler stacks on the west fa ade.
Each is associated with one of the boilers Boiler 1A, 1B, 2, 3, 4, and 5. All are steel cylinders with associated metal ducts and equipment. Boiler 1A, 1B, and 2 s stacks are near the south end of the west fa ade and roughly four stories in height. Boiler 3 s stack is near the west fa ade s center and just under six stories in height. Boiler 4 and 5 s stacks are near the west fa ade s north end and over six stories in height. Surrounding Boiler 4 and 5 s stacks are exterior metal stairs that provide access to door openings at the west fa ade s north end on the first through fourth stories. The stairs are constructed of metal grating with open-metal-grate treads and metal pipe railings. 7. Openings: a.
Doorways and Doors: The primary entrance to the Steam Plant Building is at the north fa ade s east end. A large rectangular garage opening is infilled with a sliding metal door. The garage door has a partially glazed, single metal slab door for pedestrians at the center. To the west of the primary entrance is a secondary entrance to the one-story wing with a partially glazed, single metal slab door. There is also a secondary entrance at the south fa ade s east end. It is infilled with paired, partially glazed metal paneled doors. All doors have chicken-wire glass and metal lever hardware. Seven openings are regularly spaced on the east fa ade. Each is infilled with a metal roll-up garage door.
The southernmost and central garage doors have single metal slab doors for pedestrian use with rectangular viewports. Nine additional door openings are located along the west fa ade. The three southernmost are partially glazed, single metal panel doors with multi-light, chicken- wire glazing. The opening just south of center has a partially glazed, single metal slab door. The remainder are partially glazed, single metal panel doors with two-light, chicken-wire glazing. All nine have lever hardware. An entrance to the freight elevator is near the center of the west fa ade. A large rectangular opening is infilled with horizontal sliding metal doors.
There are also door openings at the second and third stories adjacent to Boiler 4 s stack and at the second through fourth stories near Boiler CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 16) 5 s stack. Each opening is infilled with a partially glazed, single metal panel doors with two-light, chicken-wire glazing. South of the fourth-story entrance at Boiler 5 s stack is a large rectangular garage opening infilled with a roll-up metal door. b. Windows and Shutters: The Steam Plant Building has five different window types all within rectangular openings that vary in size. On the first story of the east fa ade are thirteen six-light steel windows with operable awning sashes at the upper two lights.
Above the first-story window openings on the east fa ade are thirteen fixed glass block windows within a steel frame that stretch from the second to third story. Four single- light, fixed metal-frame windows are at the north fa ade s west end, and one single- light, fixed metal-frame window is at the west fa ade s north end. At the south fa ade s east end are five steel windows, each with two operable awning sashes. The remainder of the window openings on the west and south fa ades are ten-light steel windows five-over-five with the center six lights forming an operable awning sash. 8. Roof: a. Shape, Truss Type, Covering: The Steam Plant Building has volumes of various heights, including a three-story volume, six-story volume, and one-story wings.
Each has a flat roof covered with composition roll material. b. Cornice, eaves: The third-story roof and one-story wing on the west fa ade are surrounded by a concrete parapet with concrete coping. The six-story roof and one- story wing on the north fa ade are surrounded by a concrete parapet with metal coping. The roofs of the building and addition have a metal pipe railing near the north end of the west fa ade. There is also a metal pipe railing at the west fa ade of the six-story roof. c. Dormers, Cupolas, Towers, Clerestories, Monitors: A stair penthouse, a freight elevator penthouse, and four hatches are on the roof of the building and addition.
The two penthouses each have a rectangular volume, concrete construction, single door opening with a partially glazed metal door, and a flat roof. The freight elevator penthouse has nine-light steel windows with an operable awning sash. A set of stairs with open, metal-grate treads and metal pipe railing lead from the freight elevator penthouse to the roof. The skylight hatches comprise a corrugated metal cover on tracks. Three water storage tanks and three air conditioner units are also on the third-story roof. A short elevator penthouse is on the six-story roof. It is constructed of concrete and has metal coping and a domed skylight. An open stair surrounded by a metal pipe railing is to the west of the elevator penthouse.
Two additional roof hatches comprising corrugated metal covers on tracks flank the stair. C. Description of Interior: 1. Floor Plans: The Steam Plant Building is three-to-six stories in height with two subterranean floors the basement and basement mezzanine. There are six floors above grade at the north end of the building and three floors at the south end. Above grade interior spaces are organized into three primary volumes the firing aisle, boiler area, and central office core. The firing aisle is a double-height space on the east side of the first floor. It extends from the north exterior wall to the south exterior wall. The space is accessed via the main entrances on the north and south fa ades or via the seven garage openings on the east fa ade.
The firing aisle opens onto the boiler area on the west side of the building. There are six boiler units Boiler 2, Boiler 1B, Boiler 1A, Boiler 3, Boiler 4, and Boiler 5 (linearly arranged and CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 17) listed from south to north on the west wall). Boilers 4 and 5 each extend from the basement to six stories in height, while the remaining units extend from the basement to two stories in height. The boiler area is generally open from the basement level to the roof with catwalks located at each floor, including the basement mezzanine and mezzanine levels. The central office core is three stories in height and extends from the firing aisle to the west exterior wall between Boilers 1A and 3.
Each floor comprises a series of partitioned spaces used for operation and administration. On the ground floor is the control room, known as Control Room 1. It is a long rectangular space on the east side of the office core. To the west is a restroom, an office, and the freight elevator lobby. The second floor is arranged around a north-south corridor with spaces partitioned to the east and west, including offices, a restroom, staff breakroom, and storage closets. There is also a freight elevator lobby at the northwest corner of the second floor. The third floor comprises two large, interconnected rooms with three smaller spaces partitioned to the east and one to the west.
In addition to these three primary volumes, there is a second control room at the north end of the ground floor to the west of the firing aisle, known as Control Room 2. Partitioned within this space is a restroom and a staff break room. There are also two small, partitioned spaces within the firing aisle at the south end of the ground floor used as a restroom and a storage closet. Most of the first subterranean floor known as the basement mezzanine is open to the boiler area above. Also at the basement mezzanine are a series of spaces used for plant operation beneath the office core. The second subterranean floor the basement comprises two large, interconnected rooms where the condensers and other related equipment are located.
Several small, partitioned rooms are to the east and west, all used for plant operation or storage. 2. Stairways: Circulation comprises ten stairways within the Steam Plant Building one to the south of Control Room 1; one between Boilers 4 and 5; two between Boilers 3 and 4; one to the north of the office core and one to the south; two between Boilers 1A and 1B; one between Boilers 1B and 2; and one to the south of Boiler 2. All are open-riser stairs with metal grate treads and metal pipe handrails. The two northernmost staircases flanking Boiler 5 extend from the basement to the sixth floor. The stair to the south of Boiler 4 extends from the first to the sixth floor and the stair to the north of Boiler 3 extends from the basement to the third floor.
To the office core s north, the stairs extend from the basement to the third floor, and to the south, they extend from the basement to the roof above the third floor. Between Boilers 1A and 1B and Boilers 1B and 2, the stairs extend from the ground floor to the basement. The stairs to the south of Boiler 2 extend from the basement to the third floor. Additionally, a freight elevator is to the northwest of Control Room 1. It has sliding horizontal metal doors on the basement through third floors. A passenger elevator is between Boilers 4 and 5. It has a metal sliding door within a metal frame on the basement through sixth floors. 3. Flooring: Flooring primarily consists of concrete, linoleum, carpet, tile, and metal grating.
The firing aisle and basement have concrete floors, as does the central office core s third floor, and spaces on the basement mezzanine. Linoleum floors are in Control Room 1, Control Room 2, staff break room off Control Room 2, north-south corridor on the second floor, and select office spaces on the second floor. Carpet is within select office spaces on the second and third floors. Restrooms on the second floor of the office core and in Control Room 2 have ceramic tile floors. The staff breakroom on the second floor has clay tile floors. Finally, there is metal grating at the above and below-grade catwalks within the boiler area and basement mezzanine. 4. Wall and Ceiling Finish: Walls throughout the firing aisle and boiler area are unfinished, so the building s structure is visible.
The remaining walls are generally either smooth or textured plaster, except for in the restrooms where they are partially clad in ceramic tile. Ceilings within CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 18) the firing aisle and boiler area are also unfinished. Elsewhere ceilings are usually finished with acoustical tile or plaster. 5. Openings: a. Doorways and Doors: Doors throughout are typically partially glazed metal doors within metal frames. Some feature chicken-wire glass, while others have clear glazing. Restrooms and storage closets have solid metal doors without glazing. Hardware usually consists of brass doorknobs or metal levers throughout. b. Windows: The exterior windows are visible throughout. There is no trim, window dressing, or surface finish.
Interior windows are at the central office core and Control Room 2. On the north and south walls of Control Room 1 are nine-light metal windows with chicken-wire glass and operable hopper sashes. On the east wall of the central office core s second floor are a row of multi-light windows with chicken-wire glass and operable awning sashes and a two-light window with chicken-wire glass and an operable hopper sash. Two single-light fixed windows with metal frames also flank the entrance to Control Room 2. 6. Mechanical Equipment: a. Heating, Air Conditioning, Ventilation: There are two central air conditioning systems, one services Control Room 2 and the other services the central office core.
The equipment for Control Room 2 is within the first-floor staff break room and outside at grade near the northwest corner of the building. The air conditioning equipment for the central office core is within the first-floor staff break room and on the roof immediately above. For spaces serviced by the air conditioning system, vents are positioned on walls near the ceiling and consist of metal grates within metal frames. A ventilation system supplies the basement. Air intakes consisting of concrete bulkheads with metal vents are along the east end of the turbine deck. There is no dedicated heating system. Heat is generated as a by-product of the boiler units when they are in use. b. Lighting: Lighting throughout generally consists of fluorescent strip lights.
Some strip light fixtures are hanging, while others are flush, and some have a plastic diffuser. There are pendant lights with metal shades throughout the firing aisle, boiler area, and basement levels. Control Room 1 has flush fluorescent strip lights with metal diffusers. Control Room 2 has fluorescent strip lights covered by metal diffusers suspended below on a metal frame. c. Plumbing: There are five restrooms. One single-stall restroom is on the first floor at the southeast corner of the firing aisle. Single-stall restrooms are also on the first floor west of Control Room 1 and on the office core s third floor. The remaining restrooms have multiple stalls. One is to the southwest of Control Room 2 and the other is at the southeast corner of the office core s second floor.
Plumbing fixtures throughout are purely utilitarian and have no ornament or unique design. All toilets and urinals are porcelain with a manual flush. Some sinks are porcelain, while others are enamel metal. All are wall mounted. The second-floor restroom has three shower stalls. There are three kitchenettes, one in the firing aisle east of Control Room 1, one in the staff break room west of Control Room 2, and one in the staff break room at the south end of the second floor. D. Machines: The City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant has six boiler units. Boilers 1A and 1B are Combustion Engineering Company boilers first put into service in They produced superheated CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No.
CA-2399 (Page 19) steam at 600 lbs per square inch (psi) and 825 degrees Fahrenheit ( F). 74 Boiler 2 was also designed and manufactured by the Combustion Engineering Company. It was put into service in and has the same operating conditions as Boilers 1A and 1B psi, 825 F). Boilers 1A, 1B, and 2 were decommissioned in the and abandoned in place. Boiler 3 is a Babcock and Wilcox boiler put into service in At full load, it produces pounds per hour of superheated steam at 900 F and 860 psi. 75 Boiler 4 is a Riley Stoker boiler put into service in with a steam generating capacity of at 955 F and psi. Boiler 5 was also designed and manufactured by the Riley Stoker Corporation. 76 It was put into service in and produces of superheated steam at psi.
77 There are five steam turbine generators, each associated with one of the boilers. Generators 1, 2, and 3 are of 20 MW capacity each and were installed in and respectively. Steam is supplied to Generators 1 and 2 at 650 psi, 825 F, and at 850 psi, 900 F for Generator 3. Generators 4 and 5 are each rated at 44 MW and were installed in and Steam is supplied to these units at psi, 950 F. All five units were manufactured by General Electric are hydrogen cooled to reduce windage or frictional losses within the generator. 78 Each of the five steam turbines has an associated condenser for cooling the turbine exhaust steam. All condensers are two-pass units meaning the cooling water passes twice through the space where the steam is cooled.
The Ingersoll Rand manufactured the condensers for Units 1 and 2, Foster Wheeler, Inc. manufactured Unit 3 s condenser, C. F. Braun & Co. manufactured Unit 4 s condenser, and SWECO manufactured Unit 5 s condenser. 79 There are five deaerators, each installed simultaneously with the associated boiler unit, that are used to remove air from the water before it reenters the boilers. The deaerators for Units 1 and 2 were manufactured by Worthington. Vulcan Manufacturing Co. produced the deaerators for Units 3 and 4, while Unit 5 s deaerator was made by Chicago Heater Co. 80 For all of the boiler units, water is pumped through feedwater pumps before entering the boilers. Boilers 1 and 2 each have three closed, vertical-type feedwater heaters manufactured by the Lummus Company.
Boiler 3 has three open-type, vertical low pressure feedwater heaters by Vulcan Manufacturing Co. Boilers 4 and 5 each have one high-pressure, closed horizontal, U-Tube-type feedwater heater originally made by Southwestern Engineering Company and three open, vertical-type low pressure feedwater heaters by Vulcan Manufacturing Co. 81 A auxiliary generator is to the east of Control Room 1, which restores power to the Steam Plant in the event of a power outage. Installed in the auxiliary generator was manufactured by Crocker- Wheeler Electric Co. and is coupled to a Terry Steam Turbine. E. Site Layout: The City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant is roughly near the southeast corner of GWP s Utility Operations Center.
The Utility and Operations Center is approximately 23 acres and has a variety of buildings and structures that support the utility s electric and water systems operation and maintenance. 74 Grayson Power Plant. 75 LG&E Power Systems, Plant Condition Assessment and Life Extension Strategy (Glendale, CA: City of Glendale, October 3. 76 LG&E, 4. 77 Ibid., 5. 78 Ibid., 8. 79 Ibid., 12. 80 Ibid., 15. 81 Ibid., 17 18. CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 20) Three additional gas turbine units are located outside of the Steam Plant Building. Units 8A and 8BC are to the west and Unit 9 is to the south. Five cooling towers, each associated with Units 1 through 5, are to the west and northwest. Cooling Towers 1 and 2 are near the southwest corner of the property.
Cooling Towers 3 and 4 are to the north of Cooling Towers 1 and 2 separated by Units 8A and Cooling Tower 5 is to the north of Cooling Tower 4. There is also a small auxiliary cooling tower to the west of Boiler 1B s stack. The cooling tower chemical pump houses are between Cooling Towers 1 and 2 and to the southeast of Cooling Tower 5. The circulating water pump house is to the south of Cooling Towers 3 and 4. Near the southwest corner of the Steam Plant Building, there are seven water storage tanks one reverse osmosis product water storage tank and six demineralized water storage tanks. Two additional storage tanks are to the north, one is to the west of Boiler 3 s stack, and one is to the west of Boiler 5 s stack.
To the east of the Steam Plant Building are two switching stations that direct electricity to sub- transmission lines for distribution the Glendale Switching Station and Kellogg Switching Station. Buildings and structures to the north and northwest of the Steam Plant Building are used by the Electric and Water Departments to operate and maintain Glendale s municipal distribution systems and are not associated with the City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant.
Buildings associated with the Steam Plant Building include a maintenance building east of Cooling Tower 1, chemical storage buildings to the west of the Boiler 4 s stack, chemical and circulating water pump houses associated with Cooling Towers 1 5, a control building for Units 8A and 8BC to the northwest of Boiler 1A s stack, and switching yard control buildings to the northeast of the Steam Plant Building. Part III. Operations Process A. Operations: The City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant utilizes boiler-based steam units to produce electricity. Each of the boiler-based units operates as a closed system to produce high pressure/high temperature steam which passes through its respective steam turbine to convert thermal energy into kinetic energy.
Kinetic energy is then used to generate electricity using the electric generator connected to the steam turbines. Outside the Steam Plant Building, Units 8A and 8CB are gas turbines operating in combined cycle and Unit 9 is a gas turbine operating in simple cycle. For the Steam Plant Building s boiler-based steam units, the process begins at the boiler, which heats water to produce steam. The boiler is heated by igniting a mixture of fuel and hot air. Historically, natural gas was burned in all six boiler units during the day, while fuel oil was burned at night because the fuel oil produced visible soot.
The use of fuel oil was discontinued around and landfill gas was later used in Boilers 3, 4, and 5 to supplement the use of natural gas between approximately and Hot air is blown into the boiler through an air intake system on the west side of the building. Once the air and fuel are combined, the mixture is ignited using a series of burners mounted on the inside face of the boiler. The burners of Boilers 1A, 1B, and 2 were originally ignited manually using a hot metal rod to light a pilot light. After ignition, the resulting combustion gas flows through the boiler transferring heat to tubes containing water and eventually through an air preheater that heats incoming air before finally exiting out the boiler stack on the west fa ade of the building.
Within the boiler, hot water flows through thousands of tubes picking up heat from the hot combustion gas flowing through the boiler. At the top of the boiler, the resulting steam-water mixture enters a drum, where the water portion is separated from the steam. The water recirculates through the boiler tubes, while the steam flows through a different set of tubes called the primary and secondary superheaters. Superheating the steam increases the efficiency of the overall boiler-steam turbine cycle while also eliminating water droplets which can reduce the efficiency of the steam turbine. The resulting superheated steam is conveyed through a piping system to the steam turbine associated with the boiler.
The five steam turbine generators are located on the turbine deck to the east of the Steam Plant Building. The turbine comprises a series of cupped blades mounted on a shaft. The turbine blades are smaller at the high-pressure end where the steam enters, and the blades get progressively larger up CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 21) to approximately in diameter as the steam flows through the turbine, losing pressure. As the steam flows through the turbine, it pushes on the cupped blades and rotates the shaft. The rotating shaft in turn spins the attached generator. The generator is comprised of stationary copper coils called an armature or stator within which a rotor rotates a current-carrying conductor that produces the necessary magnetic field.
The rotating magnetic field causes electrons within the stator to move back and forth, inducing an alternating electric current. To prevent the generators from overheating, all five units are equipped with non-contact hydrogen cooling systems. The generator is within a hydrogen-filled chamber. Surrounding the hydrogen chamber are cold water-filled pipes. The cold water is pumped through the pipes, cooling the hydrogen, which in turn regulates the generator temperature. Hydrogen is used because its small molecular size results in reduced frictional energy losses as the rotor rotates. After the steam is exhausted from the turbine, it is condensed back into water via a condenser located in the Steam Plant Building s basement.
The turbine exhaust steam flows over tubes in the condenser through which water from the cooling tower flows. As the steam condenses on the surface of the tubes, it falls to the bottom of the condenser as water. The cooler temperature of the cooling water in contrast to the temperature of the steam allows the condenser to create a vacuum, increasing the power extracted by the steam turbine. The condensate from the condenser is then pumped through the feedwater system and its series of regenerative feedwater heaters and deaerator. The feedwater heaters heat the condensate to help improve cycle efficiency and allowing the deaerator to remove excess oxygen to prevent highly oxygenated water from damaging pipes.
New water is also added into the regenerative feed water system to replace water losses. The water from the regenerative feed water system is then pumped back into the boiler to begin the process all over again. The city delivers water to the boilers from its own potable water supply. To minimize corrosion damage to piping, tubing, and equipment and maintain efficiency, the water in the boiler and feedwater heaters needs to be as close to absolute purity as possible. Therefore, the city s water is run through a reverse osmosis and water treatment system to remove minerals, oxygen, and other impurities detrimental to the steam plant systems. Water is chemically treated to maintain the water s pH levels, protecting the piping systems.
Because excess oxygen is also corrosive to metal, oxygen scavengers are used to remove as much of the water s oxygen as possible. The treated water is then stored in tanks, one for each boiler unit, and used to replenish losses to the boiler s water supply. The water for the cooling towers is predominately supplied through the city s water reclamation program and from its potable water supply or well water within the power plant site when recycled water is not available. It flows through a closed system and does not mix with the water for the boilers. Within this system, the condenser cooling water is chemically treated with bleach to prevent bacteria growth and is cooled via the cooling tower associated with each steam turbine. Water is sprayed from the top of each cooling tower.
As the water travels downward, cool air is propelled upward via fans. The cool air causes some of the falling water to evaporate and the evaporation removes heat from the water, cooling it. The controls for Units 1, 2, 3, 4, 8A, and 9 are in Control Room 1, and the Unit 5 controls are in Control Room 2. These systems primarily manage the firing of the boiler, controlling fuel, air, and water intake and measuring steam output and boiler pressure. The controls for each steam turbine-generator are along the east end of the firing aisle, adjacent to their corresponding generator unit. They manage the required amount of steam flow to generate the desired electrical output and measure the turbine bearing temperature to ensure the bearings do not overheat and damage the system.
Finally, the auxiliary generator provides power to the Steam Plant in the event of a power outage. If the Steam Plant loses power, steam is piped from any of the boiler units that were in use at the time of the CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 22) outage. The steam turns the auxiliary generator s turbine, generating electricity to power the steam plant. 82 B. Technology: Generator 1 is an early example of an outdoor hydrogen-cooled turbine generator. Hydrogen was first proposed for use in cooling electrical machinery in the Journal of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers in because of its chemical properties, which allow it to absorb heat more efficiently than air or other coolants.
83 One of the first uses for hydrogen as a cooling medium was a 12,500-Kilo-volt-amperes synchronous condenser installed in at the New England Power Company facility in Pawtucket, Rhode Island. 84 The first hydrogen-cooled turbine generator was later installed in at the Dayton Power & Light Company plant in Dayton, Ohio. 85 By ten hydrogen-cooled generators had been placed into service with another twenty-seven under construction across the United States. 86 Hydrogen later became widely used as a cooling medium in the postwar period. Contemporary periodicals note that Generator 1 was the first installation of a freestanding hydrogen- cooled generator on the exterior of a building.
87 The advantage of installing freestanding generators outdoors was that instead of constructing one large building, smaller buildings or semi-covered shelters could be used to weatherproof the equipment resulting in time, material, and financial savings. 88 Outdoor power plants were especially appealing to developers during periods like the Great Depression and World War II when funding was scarce or construction materials were in short supply. While Generator 1 is noted as the first hydrogen-cooled outdoor generator, it was not the first outdoor generator to be installed at a facility. One of the earliest outdoor generators a kW mercury generator was constructed in by the General Electric Company in Schenectady, New York.
89 It had a removable steel housing that influenced the design of subsequent outdoor generators like those at the City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant. The housing was large enough that workers could enter the structure and perform routine maintenance, but also entirely removable if major repairs were required. 90 C. Workers: The City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant is in operation twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. There are generally two work shifts per day. Each shift is staffed with a team of two workers per operating boiler and turbine-generator unit. One serves exclusively as the boiler operator, while the second serves both the boiler and the generator. There is one switch board operator per shift who oversees boiler controls and answers the phones.
An auxiliary operator manages the cooling towers and associated water treatment system. The shift supervisor oversees the workers on each shift and manages the day-to-day power plant operations. The power plant is managed overall by the superintendent and operations supervisor. Administrative staff assist in general operations and management. D. End Product: Electricity generated by the City of Glendale Steam Electric Generating Plant is distributed to the city via the switch racks to the east. 82 John Escudero (Superintendent, Grayson Power Plant), in discussion with author, Glendale, CA, March and Matthew Williams, March 83 Edgar Knowlton, Chester W. Rice, and E. H.
Freiburghouse, Hydrogen as a Cooling Medium for Electrical Machinery, Journal of American Institute of Electrical Engineers 44, no. 7 (July 724 84 Snell, 35 50; and National Electrical Manufactures Association, 96. 85 Snell, 35 50; and National Electrical Manufactures Association, 96. 86 Ibid. 87 News, Electric Light and Power; and Power and Electrical Developments, Power Plant Engineering. 88 Robert Henderson Emerick, Some Aspects of the Outdoor Power Plant, Power Plant Engineering 47, no. 5 (May 72. 89 Emerick, 74. 90 Ibid. CITY OF GLENDALE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT HAER No. CA-2399 (Page 23) Part IV. Sources of Information A. Primary