BlockBefore

Litchfield County, Connecticut - Chapter 49, 1881

From History of Litchfield County, Connecticut, published 1881. 8,215 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

3 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

8,215 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Litchfield County, Connecticut, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Ecclesiastical History Congregational Chuuch, Plymouth

Thls church was founded May 17, 1740. Mr. Todd, its fir.st pastor, was born in North Haven, March 6, 1716-17, the seventh child and fifth son of Samuel and Mary (Tole) Todd, and grandson of Christopher and Grace Todd, early immigrants to the New Haven colony. The early records of the North Haven Church are imperfect, but Mr. Todd doubtless united with it during the pastorate of Rev. Isaac Btiles, father of President Stiles, of Yale. His family were of a religious character, as is proved by preserved relations or memorials of its members, in the days when each church member wrote out his or her confession of faith ; that of his sister Susannah, afterwards wife of Caleb Humaston, recounts the wickedness of her rebellion against God, and how, when awakened to a sense of her sin, the counsels of Rev. Mr. Stiles and the death of an aunt were blessed to her conversion.

Mr. Todd graduated at Yale, under President Williams, in 1734, at the age of seventeen, six of the fourteen in his class becoming ministers. A lately discovered document shows that he received and rejected a call to another church before he was ordained at Northbury, May 7, 1740. Eight months before he had married Mercy, daughter of Peter Evans, of Northfield, near New Haven, and he brought her on a pillion behind him, or on another horse, into this wilderness, where there was a small, feeble, scattered, but devoted flock, situated somewhat similar to the first Pilgrims at Plymouth, Mass. There were only bridle-paths through the woods then, and the streams had to be forded, the first cart bridge across the Naugatuck, at Thomaston, not being built till after 1747. The forests were hardly broken by the scattered clearings, and the impending war with Spain and France might bring down the Indians at any moment on the frontier settlements. Within the memory of most of the settlers they had so descended thirty years before and killed a man named Hall on Mount Toby, John Scott and his two boys being captured on Hancox meadow about that time and carried to Canada ; Mrs. Scott's own mother, sister, and brother's family had been previously slain in the Deerfield massacre in 1704. Even so late as 1722 one Harris had been shot and scalped by Indi^ans while working in a field at Litchfield, and in 1730 five houses in that new settlement were surrounded with palisades, while soldiers guarded the people at their work and Sabbath worship.

Mr. Todd's promised home was not begun on his arrival, and he set up his house on Town Hill, where the cellar hole is now seen in the lot near Elam

Fenn's, and where three old apple-trees are pointed out as of an orchard set out by him ; this was near his good deacon's, Moses Blakeslee, who had lately arrived from New Haven with his fourteen children. A spring flows near the old cellar hole, where tradition says Mr. Todd's first child, little Alathea, was drowned ; Mr. Hillard has found the tombstone of her sister Lucy, who died June 9, 1752, and an unmarked grave near it is doubtless the little Alathea's, said to be the first person buried there. After two or three years' delay, the society built Mr. Todd a house in Thomaston, which stood at the top of the hill where Mrs. Williams built later, on the old road running north, which turned off from the river road at Mr. Grillcy's corner. One living remembers the house, afterwards called the old maid's house, as three maiden sisters lived there. It is not known how long he lived there, but he moved on the hill when the church was there and the people lived here ; he had moved before 1746-47, for Barnabas Ford's will, dated Jan. 27, 1746, disposes of twenty-three acres on Bear Hill which he had of Mr. Todd, and in the deed of this green, Dec. 3, 1747, it was described as butting east on Mr. Todd's laud. His house here was in the garden this side of Riley Ives' house, and is remembered by the old people as the Evans House, where Eli Terry, the father of clock-making, began housekeeping with one chair apiece for himself and wife, and one cup and saucer. Mr. Todd's second child was Mary, who married Obed Foot, of this parish, and, on his death, Rev. Jonathan Leavitt, of Heath, Mass. Mr. Todd had eleven children, there being two Alatheas and two Lucys.

The great revival under President Edwards roused the New England churches from the cold formalism that grew out of the union of Church and State and other causes, and Mr. Todd went to study it at Stockbridge, probably by the advice of Joseph Bellamy, settled two years before at Bethlehem, a great friend of Edwards, and then in the midst of a religious revival, in which every man, woman, and child in the parish was under more or less religious concern. When Mr. Todd returned, established prayer-meetings, and labored with souls, many of his congregation rebelled against him, and abandoned his preaching. There was also temporal trouble. Two years before the society was organized a building had been built for public purposes, by subscription, west of the river, and owned by subscribers, in which the society was allowed to meet for public worship. That was never the society's meeting-house, for they never owned it; it was built and owned by proprietors, and occupied by the society for a time by their consent. The society's movement to build a meeting-house was not caused by their being voted out of this building; the society, instead, being voted out of it because it had resolved to build a meeting-house.

Plymouth

the west-side house, the society voted, Oct. 6, 1740, to get the Legislature to set a stake for a meeting-house, as it liad none of its own. This was not because, as Bronson says, the churchmen liad obtained a majority of the votes and tools exclusive possession of the house of worship. A protest of the proprietors of that building to the Legislature has been found in Mr. Satterlee's possession, in which they say that their obligations to Mr. Todd are as much as they can meet ; therefore they ask that the meeting-house be not built at present, but tliat their house be established as the place for public worship, which is sufficient for the present wants of the society, and is freely offered for its use. The protest is dated Oct. 8, 1740, two days after the vote of the society to build, and is signed by William Ludingtun, Jonathan Cook, John Sutlitf, Sr. and Jr., Barnabas Ford, John How, Isaac Castle, Thomas and Jacob Blasle, Ebenezer Richason, Samuel Jacobs, Caleb Huraaston, Phineas Royce, Daniel Curtiss, Gideon Allen, Jeremiah Peck, Sr. and Jr., Ebenezer Elwell, and Samuel Frost. The protest was never sent to the Legislature, but the next May, John Sutliff, Barnabas Ford, and John How, on authority of the proprietors, sent one, saying that they were behind with Mr. Todd's settlement and salary, and praying that further charges respecting a meeting-house be prevented at present. It is evident that the occupation of the west-side house was merely temporary and provisional, the society chancing to be organized there, iis there was no other public building in the parish limits ; it was not regarded as the meeting-house, nor did they intend to remain in it permanently. It was not the society of Wooster Swamp, but of Northbury, which mainly lay east of the river, where it proceeded to build as soon as it was in fair working order.

The west-side settlers naturally objected to the building, because tliey saw it would be done east of the river, and they tried to persuade the society to remain in their scliool-house. But when they saw that the society was determined to build and on the east side, a majority (not of the society, for that would have controlled it and defeated the project of building on the east side) of the proprietors of the west-side house (eleven of the nineteen) voted the society out of doors till it should have completed its own house; then this majority of the ])roprictors, knowing that the l^egislature would not organize an opposition Congregational Church west of the river, formed an Episcopal society. The minority of the proprietors of the west building, though opposed to building a mceting-hou.se east of the river, yet remained loyal to the .society, and were its pillars, - Jeremiah Peck, first deacon, John Sutliff, Sr. and Jr. (the junior being si.xth deacon), Caleb Huniiuston, and Phineas Koyce. The society had it-s first home on the hill, and here it has always been, nor would an Episcopal society have been formed in Thomaston then if the church had been built there. The conflict wius prinuirily of locality and only secondarily of ecclesiastical order.

The secession weakened the society, leaving half the number to do double the work, - to build Mr. Todd's house and a meeting-house ; there were only a handful of members left, and they were poor, just building their own houses and clearing their farms. But they did not break down under the heavy burden, and established the society on firm foundations. But Mr. Todd's house was built slowly, and his first year he gave in twenty pounds of his salary towards it ; but it was finished by December, 1742, for then the society, turned out of the school-house in the hollow, voted to meet there part of the year, he having, meanwhile, been living on Town Hill. The disruption of the society hindered it in building a meeting-house, and put a temporary end to society meetings and to its organization. But in May, 1741, in response to the appeal of John Bronson, Moses and Thomas Blakeslee, the Legislature directed Benjamin Hall and Capt. John Riggs, of Derby, to go to Northbury, warn a society meeting, and see that it chose proper officers. They were also to direct them where and how long to meet for Sabbath worship, and to see where and when it was best to build a meeting-house. At the meeting they warned for June 10, 1741, Joseph Clark was chosen clerk, Daniel Curtiss collector of the minister's rate, and Deacon Moses Blakeslee, Lieut. John Bronson, and Sergt. John Warner prudential committee .to fix a place to build a meetinghouse, and, meanwhile, they were directed to meet in the west school-house ten months, and in Joseph Clark's house in January and February, when it was difficult for those this side to cross the river.

The society applied to the Legislature for a committee, as directed, and, notwithstanding the protest of those on the we-st side, Capts. John Rogers and John Fowler were sent to select the meeting-house site at the society's expense, and set a stake twenty rods west of One Pine Swamp, and thirty rods soutli of the road running east from the river. The society voted to build there Dec. 3, 1744, having before this been turned out of the west side school-house, and meeting on the Sabbath in the houses of Joseph Clark, Sr. and Jr., and at Mr. Todd'.s seven months, including winter, on the east side, and five months on the west. Jan. 9, 1745, it was voted to ask the Legislature for a tax on the land to licl|> build a meeting-house, and at a meeting helil the next 24th of September, it was asked to confirm the middle stake, which the court's committee had set as its site ; it was then requested that the land tax be not imposed on members of the Church of England, Barnabas Ford, Thomas and David Blakeslee having protested against the taxation of their land. John Warner, the society's agent in this matter, repre.><cnts in his niemcirial tiiat about one-third of the society have become Episcopalians, and at his request the middle stake was nnide the site for the church.

at this time they met this side of the river the whole year, at Caleb Weed's in March and April, and at Joseph Clark's the rest of the time, the latter being voted twelve shillings in winter, and ten shillings in warmer weather. The church was not begun in October, 1746, for then it was voted to get and draw timbers for it. December of that year it was voted to meet each side of the river half the time, in the houses of Phineas Royce and Caleb Weed. Sept. 22, 1747, it was voted to allow the people to build Sabbath-day houses on the green, outside a line drawn by the society's committee ; it was also voted to cut and clear the brush from the green. This green was given the society for a place of parade, a burying-ground, and a place to build the church on by the town of Waterbury, which bought eight rods south of the meetinghouse stake, eighteen rods north, and sixteen rods west of it, of John Brinsmade, of Milford ; he presented an acre besides, and others gave four-tenths of an acre, making four acres in all, which was deeded to the society, through Caleb Humaston, Dec. S, 1747, and was described as butting west on Brinsmade's land, north on Humaston's, east on Mr. Todd's, and south on the highway, showing that the road ran there where it does now. In 1825 arbitrators decided that the green belonged to the society, and the town's only right, acquired by usage, was to bury in the burying-ground. The green was then an alder swamp, and when the second church was built, it was still so wet that some wanted the church at the head of the street, that proud Madam Ballany and Mrs. Wright might occasionally wet their feet going to meeting, as more common people had had to do.

The Northbury society grew through much tribulation. First it petitioned the town four times, - in October, 1734, September 29, and October 26, 1736, and -April 18, 1737, and the Legislature five times, - in May and October, 1737, May and October, 1738, and October, 1739. Then it was seven years after the society was organized before it began to build, and twenty-two years after that before its meeting-house was done. It was dignified Dec. 7, 1753, at which time David Potter gave the society a funeral cloth, which was kept at Mr. Todd's. In December, 1761, it was voted to floor the gallery, and the next December to glaze the house, liberty being then given to dig a well on the southwest corner of the green. In December, 1763, a committee was chosen to carry on work on the meeting-house, and to set a " horse house" partly on the green and partly on the highway. The final vote to complete the meeting-house was on Dec. 5, 1768, in the third year of Mr. Storrs' ministry. Mr. Todd never preached in it as finished, and all through his ministry the burden of it was on him and his people. This was a struggle on which the destiny of the society turned, and it made effort and sacrifice till the work was done. Mr. Todd's ministry was full of perplexity and trial, a divided people, an overwhelmed society, disturbance in church and State, a depreciated currency, and an increasing family. First, he could not get into his house, nor then into his meeting-house ; the people were too poor to pay his salary, which was often changed, and thrice he changed his home. He bore it nobly and unselfishly, surrendering twenty pounds of his salary the first year, and in 1745 he offered to give up all rates and contracts and live on what might be voluntarily contributed.

Finally, Feb. 12, 1756, he addresses the people, referring to the difficulties between them, which he traces to the trouble of his support, to meet which he offers to live on what the deacons may gather from a jjublic contribution taken once in two months at the close of evening service on the Lord's day, besides a grant of the ministry money to him if they please. The society accepted the offer, and they struggled on a few years longer. But the case was hopeless, and, on application, a committee of the Association of New Haven County, - Daniel Humphrey, John Trumbull, of Westbury, Benj. Woodbridge, of Woodbridge, and Mark Leavenworth, of Waterbury, lamented the difficulties and alienations between them and their pastor, which there was no hope of accommodating, and which they left with the judge of all the earth for decision. They recommended that a council be called to settle the matter or dismiss the pastor, and the latter was done in August, 1764. Mr. Todd was the apostle of Plymouth, and did pioneer work and established the society by wisdom, patience, endurance, humility, and self-sacrifice. He lived in advance of his time, believing in revivals, the voluntary support of the gospel, and the free fellowship of the churches, and much of the free, advanced character of the later town is due to the influence of his ministry. He was expelled from the New Haven Association for assisting at the ordination of Rev. Jonathan Lee, of Salisbury, in 1744, on the principles of the Cambridge platform, but his people did not reject him on that account. Like Moses he led his people to the border of the land of promise, but did not enter in himself, Mr. Storrs coming to find the people united and the church built. His last communication to the society was Dec. 24, 1764, where he acknowledged that his salary was settled to his full satisfaction. Like other pastors then, he kept the records of his own ministry and doubtless carried them away with him, so that but little is known of the details of his labors.

Research has brought to light in B. B. Satterlec's possession the original constitution of the church in Mr. Todd's handwriting, the four following rules for church discipline, creeds, and articles of iiiith being then unknown :

" That a minister shall not be obliged to prosecute an offender, before the person offended brings in the complaint in writing and signed by his own hand, with substantial evidence.

" That a Christian who prosecutes his hrother in the civil law for an injury doue him, before he hatli attended the gospel rule with him, shall be esteemed an offender and shall be dealt with as such an one."

After a pastorate of twelve years in Adams, Mass., and serving as chaplain in the Eevoliition, Mr. Todd died in Oxford, N. H., June, 10, 1789, aged seventy years.

Rev. Andrew Storrs was ordained and installed Nov. 27, 1765, and died while in office, March 2, 1785, after a pastorate of nearly twentj' years. He was born in Mansfield, in this State, Dec. 20, 1735, to Samuel and Mary (Warner) Storrs, and was greatgrandson of the Storrs who came from Nottinghamshire to Barnstable, Mass., in 1683. The family was strongly imbued with Puritan principles, and his parents were eminently godly persons. Rev. Dr. Richard Storrs, of Brooklyn, and Judge Storrs, of the State Supreme Court, are of the same stock. After a little more than a year of preparatory study, doubtless under Dr. Richard Salter, second pastor at Mansfield (who fitted young men for college, and at one time took twenty barrels of cider to pay for tuition), Andrew entered Yale, Oct. 24, 1757, and graduated with the class of 1760, so that he must have entered in advance or gained a class in the course; but little more was then required to graduate than is necessary now to enter college. From a diary of his found this spring in Milton, it transpires that he had poor health, which interrupted his studies and made him pay repeated vi.sits to Oblong, west of Sharon, in New York, and his trips there made him acquainted with this region, and he probably passed through Northbury. The year after his graduation Mr. Storrs united with the Mansfield Church, and was licensed to preach by Windham Association, May 18, 1762. A year after he married the widow of Rev. Freegrace Leavitt, of Somers, who married Dr. Bellamy, of Bethlehem, after his death.

Mr. Storrs' diary shows that he preached here first May 2G, 1765. In July of tliat year he made a trip to Eastern Massachusetts, and received the degree of A.M. at Harvard, a proof of his sui)erior scholarship. During the summer of 1765, Mr. Storrs continued preaching here, and on the first Monday in July the society decided unanimously that they wished him to preach for them. The first Monday in August they voted to give him a call to preach the gospel among them as a probationer, in order for settlement in the work of the ministry. On the 30th of September the society gave Mr. Storrs a call to settle, which he accepted. He brouglit Mrs. Storrs here on the 20th of November, and tlie next day wa.s observed as one of public fasting preparatory to the ortlination, which took place on the 27th ; Rev. Messrs. Leavenworth, of Waterbury, Bartholomew, first pastor at Harwiulon, Newell, of Goshen, Champion, of Litchfield, and Pitkin, of Farmiiigton, were present. In personal appearance Mr. Storrs was large, of commanding presence and grave and dignified demeanor; though never in robust health, he had a look of strength, and made a fine appearance in his new leathern breeches, with buckles at the knees and on his shoes. His voice was full and powerful, and one remembers that his grandmother told him he could be heard in the Sabbath-day houses. A fine marksman, he could bring down a squirrel from the top of the tallest tree, and his gun and elaborately marked powder-horn are still in the possession of the Stoughtons. He was of a calm and even temperament, and moved sei'enely through the Revolution, which his ministry covered. He built the house where Mr. Kelsy has lately lived, on laud bought of Caleb Humaston, putting it up in 1766. He set out the buttonballs and elms now standing there.

The only entry on the society records indicative of the Revolutionary struggle was a vote, Dec. 7, 1778, in consideration of provision running to an extravagant price, to furnish Mr. Storrs certain articles at specified prices. In 1774, when Congress resolved on non-intercourse with Great Britain, Phineas Royce was moderator of a special town-meeting in Waterbury, a mark of his prominence. At that meeting Nathaniel Barnes, Dr. Roger Conant, and Jesse Curtis, of Northbury, were on the committee to see tliat no tea, molasses, sugar, coffee, spices, etc., were brought into town and sold. At another meeting held January 12th, Stephen Seymour, Randal Evans, and David Smith, of Northbury, were on a committee to receive donations contributed for the relief of the poor in Boston, whose port was then closed by the British fleet. Northbury sent Deacon Camp, father of Deacon Camp, lately of Plainville, through the wilderness of Maine with Arnohl, to besiege (.Quebec in the winter of 1775. Daniel Rowe, grandfather of A. Markham on his mother's side, was at the battle of Saratoga, and was the first to reach Arnold after he was wounded. David Smith, who lived where the Quiet House now is, attained tlie rank of major, and when tiie several Waterbury companies were formed into a regiment in 1778, Jesse Curtiss, of Nortlibury, was nnijor. In the successful campaign in the French war, too, when Ticonderoga and Crown Point were taken, Waterbury furnisiicd a company, in which John SutlilT was lieutenant; in that war Daniel Potter wijs ensign, and Asher Blakeslec, Euos Ford, and others were engaged.

But this parisli was a stronghold of Toryism in the Revolution, a majority of the leading men west of the river holding fast to their British allegiance. Bitter enmities were engendered and violent acts committed, but we are to judge leniently ; the Tories were connected by ties of religious a.-<sociation and support with the mother-country, and their pastors, sincere men, taught them that the colonial cause was treason against government and God. While all the action against Tories was not justifiable, it was not to be wondered at as human nature is constituted. A Tory was hung up till almost dead on the green, and u hook was shown in an old tavern, which stood where Andrew Buel lives, where others were so hung. Devil's Lane was near that tavern, and County Sheriff Lord, of Litchfield, afterwards made arrests there, so that they said " the Lord came down from Litchfield and took the devil out of Plymouth," though he soon returned. One man from this parish was arrested for high treason, and executed at Hartford, March 19, 1777, though he was honest in his convictions and offered to voluntarily confine himself to his farm. This is the only one learned to have been executed in the colony, and the death j^enalty against treason was afterwards repealed. When this man was arrested, his father offered to furnish hemp for a halter to hang him with. This was about the middle of Mr. Storrs' ministry.

March 2, 1785, Mr. Storrs died (and now lies in this yard), two years after peace had been declared with Great Britain. Five years before, in 1780, Westbury and Northbury had been incorporated as a new town, named Watertown, and transferred to Litchfield County. These parishes were then the richest part of Waterbury, the grand lists of the several societies standing in 1749, Waterbury first, £12,181; Westbury, £13,427; Northbury, £10,070. One of the richest men in this society in the early times was Jeremiah Peck, first deacon, whose property inventoried at £3702 when he died in 1752. Earlier than that Barnabas Ford, the great land-holder, was one of the wealthy men. He owned all Thomaston when it was Fordton, his rule seeming to have been to buy all land joining his; he bought all Mr. Todd's land in the hollow before 1746, as appears by his will.

The only church record of the first five years of Mr. Storrs' ministry are three votes, - admitting members of the Church of England, in good standing, to occasional communion, forbidding the pastor to receive complaints against members, unless presented in writing and signed by two witnesses, and appointing Sergt. Jesse Curtis to tune the psalm. The church had seventy-seven members when Mr. Storrs began his ministry, and one hundred and seventy-eight united with it while he was pastor. When Mr. Hart had been here twenty years, he said of him that the aged people remembered him with affectionate reverence as a wise man and faithful pastor. Mr. Hart himself had formed a high opinion of his understanding and heart, and said that he was distinguished by good sense, wisdom, and prudence. Rev. Mr. Champion, of Litchfield, preached his funeral discourse, and said of him that, having lived greatly beloved, he died equally lamented, and quitted this benighted world to the inexpressible sorrow of his disconsolate surviving partner, and to the universal grief of his church and congregation. He says that he was endowed with a good natural genius, improved by a liberal education, and refined by divine grace. Descended from a reputable family, his personal appearance was august and venerable ; his eye betokened sensibility, uncommon composure, and mildness of temper. Blessed with a commanding voice, his delivery was graceful, solemn, and affecting. Sound judgment, singular prudence, great stability, and Christian candor entered deep into his character.

Besides his pastoral labors, Mr. Storrs fitted many students for college, and instructed young men for the ministry, after the custom of the times. Mr. Storrs had no children, and Oliver Stoughton, a nephew of his wife, lived with him, doing chores and going to school. He came into possession of the place on Mr. Storrs' death, lived in it during Mr. Waterman's ministry, and sold it to Mr. Hart on his marriage, moving himself to Town Hill ; his son, Andrew Stoughton, thirteenth deacon of this church, was father of the late and present deacon of that name.

Some time before Mr. Storrs died he was taken with a pain in his left side, which extended down to the foot, as well a.s to the shoulder and neck and across the body, contracting the whole left side, so that his body bent to the left. - He was also troubled with a cough and fever, and could get no relief from physicians. The course of his disease was so serious that he desired to have a post-mortem examination of his body, which was had. The left lung was found contracted to the size of a goose-egg, full of knotty hard parts, lying in the upper part of the breast, to which it was fast at the back. The left side of the breast below it was filled with five pints of watery matter. The ribs on that side were very brittle and the flesh hard, and full of horny kernels from the size of a pea to that of a nutmeg, not connected with one another or with the bones of the body. One bone of the size of a chestnut was found in the cavity of the breast, and the bowels adhered fast to the left side, but no corrupted matter was found, nor were any of the other organs of the body apparently affected.

Simon Waterman, the third pastor here, was born in Norwich, Jan. 17, 1737, to a family that originally came from Norwich, in England. He was brought up in Bozrah, where he doubtless joined the church, though there are no church records of that time. He graduated at Yale in the class of 1759, the year before Mr. Storrs, whose friend he was in college, and who probably mentioned him to his people as his successor before he died. The first church in Wallingford called Mr. Dana, of Harvard, without applying to the Association for advice or to the Consociation for ordination. A minority applied to the New Haven Association, which had excommunicated Rev. Messrs. Todd, Leavenworth, of Waterbury, and Humphreys, of Derby, and which now excommunicated the Wallingford Church, recognizing the minority as the church, which called Mr. Waterman as its first and only pastor. Being unable longer to support him, he was dismissed May 3, 1787, by his church, which threw up its organization and returned to its old fellowship, a- result which Dr. Bacon regards as to his credit, as some men would have exasperated the quar- rel and made it incurable. While at Wallingford, in 1774, Mr. Waterman was the first missionary sent out by the Congregational Association to the back settlements in Vermont and Northern New York, largely settled from this State. This was the iirst missionary movement in the colony, and Mr. Waterman was one of the first three home missionaries. During his pastorate here, in 1797, he went on a similar mission, and made a third trip to Central New York ; thus this church had an early part in the work of home missions.

Mr. Waterman was settled here Aug. 29, 1787, the year the adoption of the federal constitution opened a new era of consolidated national life. He brought Eunice, his wife, to whom her father, Benjamin Hall, a magistrate, had married him July 26, 1764, and six children, two having died in Wallingford: Eunice, who married Dr. Wells, of Berlin, was nineteen ; Amanda, who married Aaron, son of Gen. David Smith, fourteen ; Philomela, who married Maj. Wright's nephew Benjamin, and went to Rome, N. Y., then an Indian wilderness, eleven ; Mary, who married Gen. David Smith's nephew Walter, eight; Simon, six; and Joshua, three. It was a pretty family, welcome in a parish where the minister's family had been childless twenty years. Mr. Waterman lived in the Warner house on South Street, next to Mrs. Smith's, and set out the great elms now towering before it. His home life was pleasant, with happy gatherings of young folks, with courting in the parlor as the years went on. Not one of that family is now alive. Mr. Waterman stood well with the ministers in the State ; he was considered an able support of orthodoxy, and the Litclifield County Association regarded it a favor to receive him as a member. He preached the funeral sermon of Rev. John Trumbull, of Watertown, and at Dr. Bellamy's funeral was .assigned the distinction of walking with his widow. He was dismissed in 1809, and resided here till his death in 1813, three years after Mr. Hart came here.

Mr. Hart says that Mr. Waterman came hero to do good, and the first Sunday after his installation, the state of piety being low, the covenant and confession of faith being reail, he prevailed on the members to stand before the congregation and testify their a.ssent to it. Mr. Hart says, also, he was a man of active habits, a good preacher, and truly devoted to the spiritual interests of his people, being ready, even at his advanced age, to discharge parochial duty in fair weather and foul, by night and day. One powerful revival occurred during Mr. Waterman's ministry, and one or two sea-sons of less interest. He received two hundred and twenty members, one hundred and seventy-one by profession. Of medium height, he was thin, very straight, of active motions, nervous temperament, and an excellent horseman ; graceful in bearing, elegant and courtly in manner, a master of ceremony, he wa.s one of the most stylisli of the pastors of this church. He used to walk up the broad aisle bowing and smiling on either side, the people rising and bowing to him as he passed. Reaching the pulpit, he first turned and bowed to the bass on his right, who filled the front gallery seat on the south side, and rose to bow in return. This parade was repeated with the treble in front, and with the counter and tenor on the left. The dignity and courtesy of this old-time style told with benefit on character and life. This was carried to -exce-ss by the president of Yale, small in stature but great in dignity, who, in passing into the chapel between two files of seniors, ranged outside the door according to custom, slipped and fell flat on his back in the mud. The students were overcome with laughter. Rising and casting a withering glance upon them, the prex burst out, "Young gentlemen, do you not know how awful a thing it is to laugh in the presence of God, and much more in my presence?"

Traditions of Mr. Waterman's masterly horsemanship are numerous, and he made a very fine appearance on horseback. He rode a sorrel marc, and went " like a streak," erect as a ramrod, wearing his three-cornered hat, and with his pipe in his mouth. He was a true and high type of the old colonial minister and gentleman. His lot was caiit here in the stormy political times of Jeff'erson and Adams, when the feeling between Federalists and Republicans divided members of the same church. Mr. Waterman, in common with the clergy and most educated men in New England, feared that the triumph of the infidel Jefferson would prove the downfall of religion, and his strong expression exasperated the Jeli'ersonist.s in his congregation and caused trouble. One of them gave him ten dollars to allow him to publi.sh one of his political sermons, thinking its strong tone would react on him ; but the publisher would not take it, saying that it was so strong it could not be answered, and would hurt Jefferson. Some seceded from the congregation on account of this political preaching, which was then usual. An election .sermon wa.s preached at the time of the State elections, sometimes when town-meetings were held, and always on public fa.sts, when the clergy were allowed and exi)ectcd to discuss public ((uestions. When the news of the election of Adaois as President and JetVerson as Vice-President reached Litchfiehl in 1796, Rev. Mr. Champion, an intense Federalist, in his Sunday morning prayer implored the blessing of the Holy Spirit on the President, and a double portion on the Vice-President, " for thou kiiowest, (> Lord, that he needs it."

The second nipcting-hnuse was built during Mr. Waterman's ministry, and was a source of trouble. The vote for a survey to find the middle of the town was passed March li, 1 783, during the last of M r. Storrs' ministry, and it was found to be on Town Hill, where the .stake for the meeting-house was stuck in front of Nathan Beach's house. M r. Storrs' sickness and death interfered with liuilding then, but when Mr. Waterman was .settled the enterprise was renewed, though there was trouble about the site at first. Jan. 11, 1790, it was finally voted to build the meeting-house on a rock a little southeast from the house where Samuel Lewis then lived, at the head of the road leading from the old meeting-house eastward. The 23d of the next December it was voted to build a steeple, and the 22d of October, 1792, it was voted to dispose of the old house; on the 2d of the following December liberty was granted to erect horse-sheds. Dec. 7, 1806, a committee was appointed to confer with Mr. Waterman regarding his uneasiness, with satisfactory results, for no further trouble was had until March 16, 1807, when another committee saw him in reference to a communication of his to the society. Sept. 25, 1809, it was finally voted to dismiss Mr. Waterman, and he was dismissed by a Council on the 14th of November, he to retain the whole salary for that year, and the society to pay him seven hundred and fifty dollars in three annual installments.

Mr. Waterman died after a short illness, while on a visit to a bachelor son in New York, who had left home at the age of fifteen to serve a mercantile apprenticeship with Messrs. Cutler & Smith, in Watertown, and later in life did business in New Orleans and New York. Mr. Waterman's remains were brought to Plymouth, where his wife had died on the 10th of the previous March ; a son, Simon,' having also died in Berlin on the 7th of the previous September.

Mr. Charles H. Porter, then a junior in Yale College, spent the month of January in the place, and by the blessing of God upon his labors Christians were greatly revived, and many persons were hopefully converted. Two young ministers - viz., C. S. Sherman and David Dobie - followed up the labors of

Mr. Porter, and in the six months between the organization of the church and the settlement of the first pastor thirty-nine persons were added to the membership by profession of faith in Christ.

Aug. 8, 1838, was a great day with this people. In the forenoon the completed house of worship was dedicated, and in the afternoon three young men were ordained to the gospel ministry, one of whom, Nathaniel Richardson, was installed (first) pastor of this church. The preacher upon this occasion was Rev. Dr. Noah Porter, of Farmington. The ministry of Mr. Richardson extended to July 2, 1840.

Rev. Merrill Richardson was the second pastor. He came to this field with the experience of a year's preparatory labor in Salisbury, Vt. He was installed Oct. 27, 1841, and was dismissed July 1, 1846. He was installed pastor of this church a second time. May 16, 1849, and was dismissed Jan. 18, 1858. His entire term of service was thirteen and a half years, - a period nearly three times as long as that of any other pastor of this church. He died Dec. 12, 1876, being at that time pastor of the First Congregational Church of Milford, Mass., and, in accordance with his own desire, his body was brought here for burial.

During the time between the periods of Mr. Richardson's labors. Rev. Judson A. Root was nominally pastor. He was settled Oct. 7, 1846, and dismissed May 16, 1849 ; but ill health had incapacitated him for the performance of the duties of his oflBce after April 30, 1847, at which time he resigned the pastoral charge. He continued to decline until his death. During a portion of the time in which Mr. Root was pastor. Rev. Samuel J. Andrews was employed as a supply. He acted in that capacity about six months.

After the last dismissal of Mr. Richardson, Edward A. Walker, a student from Yale Theological Seminary, supplied the pulpit. In connection with his labors an extensive revival began, which continued under the efforts of his successor. There had been an increase of solemnity in the parish before the departure of Mr. Richardson, who was confident the church was on the eve of a revival. Mr. Walker was instrumental in the great enlargement of the Sabbathschool, and in the resuscitation of the female prayermeeting.

John Monteith, Jr., was ordained pastor Oct. 27, 1858. His ministry is a memorable era in the history of the church ; a great accession of converts was received, - sixty-four in 1858, seven in 1869, four in 1860.

Following upon Mr. Monteith, who was dismissed July 31, 1860, the dismissal to take effect the first Sabbath in September, came another minister directly from a theological seminary, A.Hastings Eoss, who supplied the pulpit for six months.

After Mr. Dimock, Rev. H. H. McFarland supplied for six months, and was succeeded by Rev. Franklin A. Spencer, who was installed pastor June

24, 1863, and was dismissed May 1, 1865. A revival attended his labors, and upwards of thirty were added to the church by profession of faith.

Rev. E. M. Wright began labor as acting pastor, March 11, 1866, and resigned April 17, 1870, broken down in health and spirit by the sudden death of his wife.

Henry B. Mead was ordained June 7, 1871, and dismissed May 12, 1874. During his ministry there was an accession of thirty-three by profession of faith.

Of the seventeen ministers named, six have already cease to live and labor among men, viz. : Messrs. Porter, Merrill, Richardson, Root, Walker, Dimock, and Wright.

The following figures exhibit in part the growth of the church. Starting with a membership of forty-five in 1838, it had an enrollment Dec. 31, 1850, of one hundred and twenty-eight; Jan. 1, 1858, one hundred and forty-nine ; Dec. 31, 1860, two hundred and nineteen; Dec. 31, 1865, two hundred and thirty-one; Feb. 1, 1879, two hundred and seventy-seven.

During the forty-one years of its existence it has had the privilege of furnishing four candidates for the gospel ministry, viz. : Edwin Johnson, lately pastor of the Second Congregational Church of Bridgeport; Linus Blakesley, pastor of the First Congregational Church of Topeka, Kan.; Horace R. Williams, pastor of the Congregational Church of Almont, Mich. ; and Mosely H. Williams, engaged in the work of the American Sunday-School Union, Philadelphia.

The Sabbath-school preceded the organization of the church, being first held in the old red schoolhouse in 1834. There were four classes, taught by Milo Blakesley, Philo Lewis, Miss Rhoda Swift (now Mrs. James Hunter), and Mrs. Sherman ({uernsey. The session was at nine o'clock in the morning, giving an opportunity to attend the morning service at Plymouth.

There were no records kept during those years, but it is remembered that Deacon Milo Blakesley was first elected superintendent, followed by Warren Goodwin, Phinehas Hitchcock, James Ednuinds, witii Mi.ts Hannah Goodwin as assistant. Deacon S. B. Terry, with Miss Eliza Bunnell (Mrs. Carpenter) as assistant, Warren Goodwin, X. C. Boardman, Gaius A. Norton, and perhaps others, each serving one or more years. In May, 1857, R. D. H. Allen was elected, and it was decidcil in the fall to continue the school through tlie winter. Tiie .school had numl)ered about forty in 1845, and forty-five in 1849, as we learn from private memo- ' randa. During the revival of 1858, and under the ministry of Rev. E. A. Walker, the school received a new impulse, calling into its membership nearly the entire congregation. The school was reorganized, R. D. H. Allen was again elected superintendent, B. S. Beach chorister, which position he has since filled with little or no intermission, and A. H. Beach was elected secretary, acting also as assistant superintendent, to which position he was elected in 1859. Mr. Allen continued to hold the office of superintendent until February, 1865, with the following assistants : O. D. Hunter, appointed Oct. 26, 1860; W. H. Scott, Feb. 1, 1863 ; and A. H. Beach, Feb. 8, 1864. During all these years Mr. Allen had charge of a class of young men, and at his request A. H. Beach acted (perhaps with .the exception of one year) as an extra assistant by relieving him of many of the details of the superintendent's office. During one year, also, Miss Margaret McClintock assisted, having the arrangement and oversight of the younger classes. Feb. 10, 1865, James C. Mix was cliosen superintendent, and M. D. Holcomb assistant. Both having removed from the place, J. P. Crawford was elected superintendent, Oct. 29, 1865, and selected W. H. Scott for assistant, who has served in that capacity ever since.

Mr. Crawford was succeeded in 1866 by James Hunter for five successive years, and he by N. T. Baldwin for two years. F. W. Mix, appointed in 1873, has held the office until the present time. Since 18.58 the numbers on the roll have varied from two hundred and forty to three hundred and fifty, and the average attendance from one hundred and thirteen to two hundred and twenty-eight. Of the entire number (three hundred and ninety-two) received into the church by profession since its organization, two hundred and forty-three were from the Sabbathschool. The school has succeeded remarkably in retaining the interest of our people of every age and iwsition. It has received the earnest, active co-operation of our most prominent business men. It has done much to mould and guide the religious thought of our coninuinity, and ha.4 turned the minds of many to Christ and His salvation.

The house of worsliip was erected with funds secured by a subscription bearing date Sept. 13, 1837, which amounted to ^3.558. A small additional sum was raised sulxsequently to complete the building. The chairman of the building committee was Wyllys Atwater, and the builder wa.s Riley Scott, who is still a member of this church.

In 1853, in the period of the ministry of Rev. Merrill Richardson, an enlargement of the capacity of the house of worship became neccs.Hary, and the galleries were introduced, for which the sum of four Inindrcd and sixty -seven dollars wiw provide<l by subscription.

renovated, and the lecture-room and ladies' parlor constructed underneath. The total outlay was something more than eight thousand dollars, including the cost of the organ, which was contributed by the Sabbath-school. The chairman of the building committee was O. D. Hunter. Services of rededication were held Nov. 6, 1878.

The deacons of the church have been as follows : Milo Blakesley, Eli Curtis, Silas B. Perry, Gains A. Norton, R. D. H. Allen, and Ira H. Stoughton.

The present officers of the church are as follows : Pastor, Leverett S. Griggs ; Deacons, R. D. H. Allen, Ira H. Stoughton ; Standing Committee, pastor, deacons, clerk, Sunday-school superintendent, N. Taylor Baldwin, James Hunter, George H. Plumb ; Sabbathschool Superintendent, F. W. Mix ; Assistant Superintendent, Walter H. Scott; Treasurer, Deacon Ira H. Stoughton ; Clerk, W. T. Goodwin.

St. Peter'S Ciiukch

This church was organized in 1740, in Plymouth Hollow, now Tliomaston, where the first church edifice was erected. The rectors previous to the war of the Revolution were Theophilus Morris, James Lyon, Richard Mansfield, James Scoville, and James Nichols. The society was reorganized after the Revolution with the following members : Solomon Collins, Abuer Blakeslee, Titus Barnes, Asher Blakeslee, Eli Blakeslee, Hosea Blim, Moses Blakeslee, Samuel Blakeslee, Philo Bradlee, Amos Bronson, Ebenezer Bradley, Noah Blakeslee, Jude Blakeslee, Ebenezer Bradley, Jr., John Brown, Thos. Blakeslee, Joab Camp, Abishai Castle, Zadok Curtis, Amasa Castle, Ezra Dodge, Samuel Fenn, Ebenezer Ford, Jesse Fenn, Lemuel Funcher, Cephas Ford, Barnabas Ford, Isaac Fenn, Enos Ford, Daniel Ford, Amos Ford, Cornelius Graves, Benj. Graves, Simeon Graves, Zacheus Howe, Eliphalet Hartshorn, Eliphalet Hartshorn, Jr., Jesse Humaston, David Luddington, Zebulon Mosher, Chancey Moss, Jacob Potter, Samuel Peck, Jr., Samuel Potter, Gideon Seymour, David Shelton, Ezekiel Sanford, Jr., Abel Sutlift', Jr., Samuel Scoville, Jr., Jesse Turner, Wm. Tuttle, Thos. Williams, Eli Welton, Thos. Way, Ogrius Warner, Thos. Williams, Jr., Samuel Way.

The present church edifice was erected in 1796, and consecrated Nov. 2, 1797. The rectors from that time have been Nathan B. Burgess, Roger Searle, Rodney Rossiter. After Mr. Rossiter the following officiated about six months each : Robert W. Harris, Joseph T. Clark, Gurdon S. Coit, Norman Pinney, and Allen C. Morgan.

Provenance

Text from History of Litchfield County, Connecticut, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.