BlockBefore

New Milford Town (part 5 of 15)

Part 5 of 15 of the account of this town in History of the Towns of New Milford and Bridgewater, Connecticut, 1703-1882, published 1882. 15,975 words, covering 17 settlements. Source changes inside the text are labelled at the exact paragraph where the next book begins.

Contents

11 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter, on this part. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

15 pages

The source prints this as one continuous account. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs straight on across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The chapter

15,975 words

Reproduced complete and unedited from History of the Towns of New Milford and Bridgewater, Connecticut, 1703-1882, published 1882. The text is machine-read from scans, so expect recognition errors: misspelled names, dropped words, and stray characters. Nothing has been corrected, because correcting a proper name invents one. The headings below are the books' own; source changes are labelled in place.

The vote to return money upon the formation of other socier ties was occasioned by a petition from the South Farms (now in Brookfield), in 1743, for society privileges, to which New Milford had consented, and although it had not been granted was likely to be, in a few years ; and another movement of the kind which had already been started at what is now New Preston.

But it required much more than votes to build a meeting-house in a town so sadly divided in religious sentiments and principles of church government, and therefore the matter passed until April 27, 1752, when ano{her vote was taken to build the house: fifty-eight votes in the affirmative, and eighteen in the negative; and a committee was appointed to call on the County Court for a committee '* to affix a place to build a meeting-house upon." Thus the question rested until the 21st of November, 1752, when they put the matter in a shape to have soi^iething done.

"It was voted in said meeting that there shall be a meetinghouse for the public worship of God built in and for said town, sixty feet long, and forty-four feet wide, and twenty-seven feet the height of the posts.**

"Voted, that Nathaniel Bostwick, Esq., Capt. John Warner, Paul Welch, Esqr., Sergt. Daniel Bostwick, I^ns. Joseph Canfield, Lieut. James Hine, and Mr. Amos Northrop shall be a committee to go forward with the building of said meeting-house.*' These men were not to be stopped by trifles, being the generally-admitted leaders in the town, and all having wealth of their own.

Roger Sherman was appointed treasurer to raise the money, by a tax of two shillings, old tenor, on the pound, and pay out the same upon the order of the committee. Also, at the same time, they "Voted, that the shingles for covering the roof of said meeting-house, shall be eighteen inches long, five inches wide one with another, and three-quarters of an inch thick.

" Voted, that the clapboards shall be white oak, and be four feet and two inches long, and lie out four inches wide, being sufficiently lapt, and also be half an inch thick on the back, lap being taken out.

At the next session of the Assembly, (May, 1753,) a petition was presented, to obtain help in building this house, and in it the difficulties ar^d situation is cleary stated ; and the petition bears the evidences of the work of Mr. Nathaniel Taylor. Daniel Bostwick, and Bushnell . Bostwick were appointed to present this petition to the Assembly.

To the Honorable General Assembly of his majesties English Colony of Connecticut, in New England, to be holden at Hartford, in the County of Hartford, on the Second Thursday of May, A. D., 1753. '

The memorial of Stephen Noble, Samuel Canfield, & Paul Welch, Inhabitants of the town of New Milford in the County of Litchfield, and the rest of the Inhabitants of said New Milford-*Humbly sheweth :

"That there is need of Building a New Meeting-House for the Publick Worship of God in said New Milford for the Professors of the Presbyterian-Congregational order, as established by the Laws of this Colony ; And your Memorialists, having taken such measures as the Law directs for affixing and ascertaining the Place whereon to Build said Meeting- House, have proceeded to Raise a Tax on the Inhabitants, of said town, of two shillings on the pound in the common List toward Defraying the charges of Building the same ; And your Memorialists would humbly beg leave to inform your Hon" that there is about one-third part of all the Lands within the Bounds of said Township which belong to Non-resident Proprietors and lye unimproved : so that the Burthen of Supporting the Ministry & Defraying other- Publick charges is much greater on the present Inhabitants of said Town, than it would be if those Lands were Inhabited and improved and the owners of such Lands have had their Estates greatly advanced by pneans of said Towns being settled and Inhabited without their bearing any part of the Burthen and Cost of settling the same (except a small Rate when the former Meeting House, and ye Minister's House were Built about thirty Years ago,) and a Right of I^nd in said Township, which, at the time when said Town first began to be settled, was valued at but about five pounds, would now, without any Labour done on it, sell for Three thousand pounds or more : and your Memorialists would farther beg leave to Inform this Hon^'* Assembly that there are many, of the Inhabitants of said New Milford who dissent from the way of Worship Established by the Laws of this Colony & are by Law exempted from paying Rates for the Building of Meeting-Houses and maintaining of Ministers. So that the Burthen will be very great on ye Memorialists if they must be at the whole cost of building said Meeting-House ; And ye Memorial- - ists humbly conceive that it is highly Just and reasonable (hat the Non-resident Proprietors aforesaid should bear some of the Cost & Charge of Building said House, because of the advantage that will accrue to them thereby in Enhancing the value of their Lands, and when those Lands shall be set lied and Inhabited, it is likely that the persons that shall settle thereon will be benefited by said Meeting-House as well as the present Inhabitants of said Town. Wherefore your Memorialists humbly Pray that this Hon**'* Assembly will be pleased to Enact & Decree that all the Un* improved Lands within the s** Town of New Milford, which belong to Persons not Residing in said Town, - excepting such Farms as have on them Buildings and improvements voted in ye list, - shall be taxed at one penny Lawful! money on the acre annually for four years next ensueing, to be paid by the owners of s*' Lands (in Lawful] money or Bills of Publick Credit Equivalent thereto), toward Defraying the charges of Building said Meeting-House, or that said Lands may be taxed at such other Rate, and for such other term of time as your Hon" in your Great Wisdom shall think fit, for the use aforesaid, or some other way Grant Relief to your Memorialists who as in Duty Bound shall Ever Pray.

The record of the town meetings gives no certainty as to when the meeting-house was completed, but a vote, passed in December, 1754, returning the money collected from Newberry and New Preston societies, which societies had been formed according to anticipation, indicates the certainty of the house having been built in 1754. And the town also voted liberty for the ^' Sabbada house '' to be built near the meeting-house, and that the old meeting-house should be sold for the benefit of the town.

** The house in which we are now assembled, being the second meeting-house, was built in the year 1754, about forty-seven years ago. The first Episcopal church was built in the year 1746; the second, which is the one now standing, began to be built in the year 1765, was raised in 1766, about thirty-five years ago. It was finished and consecrated A.D. 1793. The Strict Congregationalists, usually called Separates, erected their house of worship in the year 1761, forty years ago, which is now standing. The Friends, commonly called Quakers, built their meeting-house not far from the year 1742, now standing, though in another place than where it was first set. Another communion of Friends, followers of Jemima Wilkinson, built a house oi worship in the north end of the town about fifteen or twenty years ago [1784], but it is now owned and occupied by the Epis- copalians of New PrestoYi. The Baptists erected a house of worship in the south end of the town called the Neck, eleven or twelve years ago, but it is sold and now used for another purpose."

"Feb. 7, 1754. Voted, that the meeting-house . . . shall be erected in the town street, east from Joseph Norihrop's dwelling-house and west from Samuel Comstock's well, where there is a heap of stones erected."

The well spoken of is still in existence, although covered ; it being under the sidewalk, directly in front of thie new Episcopal Church, at the corner of Main street and Whittelsey avenue.

"May 24, 1754. Voted, that the inhabitants of this society will raise the meeting-house (which they are about to build) ^by free-will offering;

" Voted, that the committee shall provide what liquors they shall think necessary to be used at the raising of the meetinghouse, at the cost of the society."

A vote was passed Sep. 17, 1754, that the society would " take the steeple of the new meeting-house into their care, and carry it on, and finish the same, with the rest of said house," indicating that the house was raised, and that the ecclesiastical society, which had been organized but a few months, accepted the work, and would finish the house which had been commenced by the town.

The accompanying plan represents the arrangement of seats in this the Second Congregational meeting-house. The numbers show the "dignity" or classification of the people as they sat in church. No complete list of the names of classified persons of this date can be found. The gallery of the house was not finished until the summer of 1763, just ten years from the lime ,they began to build the house.

"Dec. 24, 1756. Voted, that the old meeting-house which belongs to this society shall be disposed of as follows, viz. : Threequarters of the. body seats and two pews shall be given to the Church of England, and the remainder of the body seats to the Quakers in this society, and the pulpit to thdse of Newbury, and the gallery seals to those of New Preston society, which belong to New Milford, and the remainder to be .disposed of and the avails of it improved toward the new meeting-house in this society."

The second Congregational meeting-house having been erected in 1754, and completed in 1763, Mr. Taylor had occasion to be encouraged, although still in the midst of conflicting denominational interests. In 1761 the Separates built their house of worship, and began to make greater inroads into the old society and church.

Seven years later (in 1769) the effects of the Half-way Covenant had become so visible that the pastor and his church seem to have become really alarmed on that account, and assembled in a church meeting for some action as a matter of relief. We are told that, '* after long conference," the church came to several resolves, the first of which, viz. : "that there is no half-way covenant," appears to be in reality a denial of the principles on which the church had practiced for more than forty years, and a claim that all halfway covenant members should be admitted to the communion.

Then, in 1772, the church voted " that all who are in covenant have a right to vole in the church meetings," which was virtually the making them members without having ever admitted them as such, and without any profession of experience in grace ; and on this platform the church continued to practice, apparently, the membership growing less and less in number until the settlement of Mr. Stanley Griswold.

" Mar. 8, 1769. At a church meeting legally warned to enquire of those who had owned ye covenant, the reasons why they did not come to ye Lord's Supper, and to attempt to remove their scruples and to know our sentiments with regard to admission : after long conference upon these subjects, the Church came to the following resolves :

" I. Voted, that this church looks upon it that there is no half-way covenant, but those who renew the covenant have a right to privileges in full.

'* 2. Voted, we look upon it the duty of the Church to use their influence and endeavors to convince persons of their duty and obligations to attend the ordinances u( the Gospel understandingly.

Not only did this subject assume a more and more difficult and unsatisfactory form in regard to those who owned the covenant for the sake of securing baptism for their children, but the relation of such baptized children to the Church was a question of increasing importance and difficulty. The Episcopal church, with its well-founded claims of acknowledged care over and for baptized children, was being introduced with considerable success into different communities in the Colony, and unless something should be done, appearances indicated much calamity to this Congregational church in New Milford, and therefore another church meeting was held.

*'Dec. 9, 1772. At a church meeting properly notified to be at the close of a lecture to converse upon, and attempt to settle some differences with regard to admission of members ; and also to come into some friendly measures with regard to admonishing baptized persons after they are of age, guilty of misconduct and some other things proper to be considered.

''After some conversation, the meeting was adjourned till Thursday, the 17th of the present month. Meeting according to adjournment, 4he meeting opened by prayer.

'* 2. Voted, that this Chui-ch look upon it a duty to take notice of, and in a friendly manner, to admonish baptized persons guilty of misconduct, with a view to bring them to make Christian satisfaction.

" The meeting adjourned to Wednesday, the 30th of the present month. Met according to adjournment, and the meeting opened by prayer. Nothing concluded with regard to admission of members different from former votes.

** I, Voted, that this Church looks upon it, that such conduct is wrong." " 2. Voted, that an enquiring committee should be appointed to converse in a friendly manner with those persons who have withdrawn from us, and report their re^^ons to the church. The committee appointed for the purpose were Dea. Bushnell Bostwick, Dea. Benjamin Gaylord, Capt. Sherman Boardman, Mr. Abel I line, and Lieut. Elizur Warner, with the pastor of the church.

In regard to the above remark that " nothing concluded with regard to admission of members different from former votes," it is proper to observe that since the Half-way Covenant had been fully adopted, in 1749, over 24 years, 153 persons, according to the Church Record, had been admitted to church -* fellowship," (not communion) by the Half-way Covenant, and were now declared to have the right to vote in church meetings, and how could anything be done contrary to former votes .^ Would a hundred persons condemn themselves by voting against themselves as to improving privileges in the church which they generally believed they ought not to enjoy ? So far as the record shows, only a very few of these 153 persons had joined the church in full communion by " renewing their covenant." It is not surprising, then, that as the church began to make efforts to recover control of itself, matters grew worse instead of better.

"Jan. 20, 1773. At a chtirch meeting properly notified, when the committee liefore ap|>ointcd reported to the cliurch the rcaBonn of ihc following {lersona who had withdrawn from our communion; viz.: Samuel Gomstock, Joseph Uartwell, Stephen Chittenden, John Wilkinson, Moses Johnson, Caleb Terrill, Jr., Capt. Isaac Bostwick and his wife, and Anna, the wife of Israel Camp. When, after much conversation, the matter was referred for further consideration.

"March 17, 1773. At a church meeting properly notified to be at the close of a lecture* it was proposed whether the church would reconsider the votes passed. Mar. 8, 1769, with regard to admissions? Voted very full that they would not.

"2. Voted, that the desires of persons to renew the covenant should be mentioned two Sabbaths successively, before their admission; and as this church don't think the reasons given by those who have withdrawn from us sufficient, are of the opinion it is most expedient for every private member, as he has occasion, to use all mild measures to reclaim them, as the reasons they offered were very genera] ; such as : the civil authority is too much blended with our ecclesiastical constitution and the lax method of receiving members, and that none but gracious- persons should be admitted. Nathan iKi. Taylor, moderator.

** April I, I77(> At a church meeting duly notified, it was agreed that a committee should be chosen to assist the pastor in examining persons who are inclined to renew the covenant before their desire is proposed, when the Deacons, Capt. Nathaniel Batchford, Capt. Sherman Boardman, Mr. Reuben Booth, Capt. Elizur Warner, Mr. Caleb Bennett, and Mr. David Hitchcock were chosen for the above purpose. At the same time it was agreed that public notice be given that at the close of each lecture, before the sacrament, the above committee should attend for the above purpose, and if anything special, would attend at other times, and that two at least of the committee might act if no more could conveniently attend, all which was voted. Na i haniel Taylor.*'

Mr. Taylor made the records in the church book as follows. In a certain part he entered the names of those who owned the covenant for the purpose of having their children baptized thus :

*' An account of some who owned the covenant after June 29, 1748. Gilead Sperry and his wife owned the covenant, and Zadock Noble and his wife, Asahel Noble and his wife, Gideon Noble and his wife, Ebcnezer Picket and his wife* and Samuel Brownson.

In this way be continued, the last entry of the kind being July 28 [1790, probably], the last previous to this date being September 20, 1789.

The membership of the church he recorded on pages in alphabetic order, - half a page to a letter ; and in these records there are two forms of words used ; the one is " admitted to church fellowship," the other is " admitted to church communion," or "admitted to full communion," or "joined in full communion."

Persons were received ** to full communion by letter," and "by acknowledging the covenant," but never is it said," by profession of faith " ; that is a phrase adopted since his day, so far as this record shows. . The last record of the reception of members was : " Sep. 20, 1789, Kason Knapp and his wife admitted to church fellowship." The last before this, was : "April 28, 1782. John Clark* and Elizabeth his wife admitted to church fellowship by letter from Milford. Samuel Wales, pastor."

From the year 1 770 to 1 790, only thirty-four persons are recorded as having united with the church in " fellowship " and "full communion"; that is, besides those who owned the covenant in order to have their children baptized. The whole number who united as members in communion with the church during Mr. Taylor's ministry of forty-two years was 130. The number who owned the covenant, and thereby were half-way members, was 228.

He recorded the baptisms with much care, the last he made being in 1796; and by comparison of the lists it is seen that whenever parents owned the covenant, their child or children were baptized. Having owned the covenant once, their children were baptized from time to time without re-owning the covenant.

Such were some of the consequences of having a church established and governed by the enactments of the state, for in the settlement of Mr. Taylor it was distinctly specified that he was to conduct the church according to the law of the state, or lose his settlement of £,\,QOO\ but, before twenty years had passed, the calamity of the Half-way Covenant was so great, that he and his church were almost desperate in their efforts to save themselves from threatening ruin, and therefore voted that the Half-way Covenant members should come to the communion and vote in church meetings.

There is a curious conjunction of two votes upon record, passed in town meeting in the midst of the controversy in New Milford upon the questionable propriety of the Half-way Covenant, which seems almost to have been designed as an amusing illustration of the calamitous effects of obedience to erroneous principles. The votes stand thus: "Dec. 14, 1761. Voted that there shall be a committee to divide the books called Saybrook Platform according to the sundry sects and parties in said town. Capt. Hitchcock, Mr. George McEwen, Amos Northrop, Gains Talcott, Nathan Gaylord, James Terrill, and Capt. Ruggles are chosen a committee to divide said books as their sundry lists arise in the list.

*' At the same time, Voted, that every person that shall kill a wild-cat any time in the year ensuing and within the bounds of New Milford, and produce the skin of th& head and ears on it before any of the authority of said town, they shall have six shillings lawful money out of the town treasury."

The most worthy Legislature had, doubtless, sent these bookK, printed by benefit of the public taxes, to be distributed gratuitously (in proportion to the tax-list), to instruct the people, who . apparently were in need of something of the kind different from what they had learned as to the beneficence of the Half-way Covenant ; but the inquiry arises with some force, how should the subject of *' wild-cats " be associated so closely with those books .^ Had the principles of these books, which had been dealt out by the appointed teachers, been like wild-cats among the people.^ While offering a premium for the animal wild-cat, were they sending forth moral and religious wild-cats a thousand times worse than the former ? Certainly, if the conclusions, or votes of the church meetings under the direction of Mr. Taylor mean anything, they reveal an unsettled state of religious opinions on this subject, well illustrated by the thought of wildcats upon the mountains.

It may furlhcr be stated that from 1770 to 1790, Mr. Taylor received into the church 34 persons only ; 9 of these were received (as he wrote) "to communion" and 25 were received '* to church fellowship.*' If these terms meant the same thing then the church membership was increased in twenty years by 34 persons only.

Of the 130 who had united during 42 years (from 1748 to 1790), how many had died or removed there is no means of knowing (except by gravestone dates), for no revision of the church record took place until after Mr. Griswold removed, but we know that according to the measure of human life a large proportion must have departed.

It should be remembered that during and immediately after the Revolutionary War the Connecticut Congregational churches gave up the Half-way Covenant to a large extent ; some of them as early as 1776, dropping all the names of Half-way Covenanters, and adopting the method of the Strict Congregationalists - to admit none except upon a profession of "change of heart." Mr. Griswold in his writings disapproved of the Half-way Covenant (at one time, at least), but made no issue with the aged senior pastor, and therefbre the matter was neglected or allowed to pass without attention until Mr. Taylor's decease, in i8cx), and Mr. Griswold's removal in 1802.

A very natural inquiry arises, whether, when Mr. Griswold was settled here, this church then had one hundred members who had formally united in full fellowship with the church.

Chapter Xii Church Of Thk Separates

r753 - iSil INDNIIISS, used as an element of power, instead of law, would have saved the Church and the world milk^ lions of men, treasure, and great honor, and would have ' elevated the human race far beyond anything as yet attained. While law is nut to be discarded, yet it is proper to recognize the fact that it has been used, in a vast majority of cases, in the Church and out of it, as a matter of will, to gratify the anger and dictatorial feelings of men.

The beginning of the influences which were largely the cause of the formation and existence of the Separatists' Church, in New Milford, were started and propagated by the idea of compelling people to obey the regulations of a legal church, while still pretending that the gospel taught the spirit of freedom and kindness. This occurred in a town vote in 1745, upon thequestion of settling a minister, the Rev. Noah Wells. The proceedings were such on that occasion as to lead thirty-five influential men to pledge themselves against that action, and to induce two of the leaders to pledge themselves to prosecute the matter in the county court if tlie decision of the meeting should be carried out in the settlement of Mr. Wells. These leaders, Joseph Ruggles and William Drinkwater, afterwards became strong men in starting, sustaining, and upholding the Separate Church. They were men of decided ability, means, and public influence, although liiey did not long remain in the town. The First Church paid most dearly for the exercise of the power placed in its hands by the Civil authority or State law, for by it they gave opportunity for all the objections which were urged by the " New Lights " against the" Standing Order " (i. e., the legally established church) as not strict enough, and as uniting the power of the state with

The Separatists* Church of New Milford was organized on the 1st day of May, 1753, when there was "a meeting held at the house of Nathan Gaylord, when John Palmer, pastor of the Church of Christ at Scotland, and Jonathan Story, pastor of the Church of Christ at Norog, Long Society, being present, witnesseth the Church's coming together and making their confession of faith, which is as follows, and signing the Covenant, as may appear hereafter by their names being subscribed.*'

The Confession and Covenant, covering four sides of a foolscap sheet, are preserved, but, most unfortunately, the sheet with the names on it is lost, and hence no catalogue of the members is to be found. Some of the names, however, have been obtained through the records of the First Church and Mr. Griswold*s historical sermon. The Confession of Faith as here adopted is very much the same as has been generally used in the Congregational churches in Connecticut for fifty years previous to 1840 ; possibly a little more definite in extreme Calvinistic phraseology.

After the organization of this church, they were visited by lay-preachers as well as by pastors of churches, and meetings were held by lay-preachers, at which times they attended, and this fact was one of the charges brought against them, as recorded by Mr. Taylor, in the church book. '* He had absented himself from the communion of the Church and neglected the public worship of God on the Lord's day, attending upon lay-preaching, countenancing an unlawful and unchristian separation.**

This church continued to increase in numbers and influence, so that in 1759 ^^^y niade application, and obtained liberty of theiown, to erect a mccting-house, the town voting, December lo, 1759, *' that the Separates (so called) shall have liberty to erect a convenient house for their public worship in some proper place in the highway as shall be thought proper in said New Milford, for that and no other use, and Capt. Botsford, and Mr. Thatcher and Mr. Job Gould are chosen a committee to view the circumstances of the place, and to establish and stake it out."

''January 7, 1760. Then laid out a piece of land in New Milford, in the highway by the burying-place that runs northward up the town street easterly from Doct.

John Cirrington's home-lot, which land is to build a meeting-house \k\yovi for the worship of God for those i^ersons that arc called Separates, bounded as follows : beginning at the northeast corner at a heap of stones joining to the buryingplace, then running southwardly 60 feet, then westerly 40 feel, then northerly 60 feet, then easterly to the first place ; bounded east by the burying place.*'

The place was established in the eight-rod highway, then adjoining the burying-place in the village, but a part of that highway has since been added to the burying-place (now the cemetery), and hence the site is within the enclosure, at the left hand, immediately on entering the cemetery, by the carriage-way. Their meeting-house on this site was built in 1761, as stated in Mr. Griswold's sermon, which is undoubtedly correct, and remained there until about 18 17.

In 1754, this church, or its members, petitioned the First Society as follows: "Upon the memorial of Thomais Weller, Lemuel Bostwick, Eleazer Beecher, Ebenezer Hotchkiss, Nathan Gaylord, Jonathan Botsford, David Camp, Israel Baldwin, Michael Brownson, and Benjamin Phillips, inhabitants of. this society, showing that the said memorialists soberly dissent from the way of worship and method of supporting the ministry established by the laws of this Colony, and that they do maintain and attend the public worship of God among themselves, in a way agreeable to their consciences ; praying this society to show their minds, whether they are willing that the memorialists should be exempted from paying taxes for the support of the ministry and building meeting houses for the established constitution, etc. : Voted, that this society are willing that the persons named in the memorial shall be exempted from paying taxes for the future as they request, so long as Ihcy shall continue soberly to dissent from the established constitution as aforesaid, provided the Hon. General Assembly (upon application to them made) shall approve the same."

Eleazer Beecher and his wife, Lemuel Bostwick and his wife, Jonathan Buck and his wife, Ebenezer Hotchkiss, Ann, the wife of Joseph Buck, Ellen Mackeney. David Beardsley and his wife,

This was three years before the Separate Church was organized, and, after two years, Ann Buck, David Beardsley, and his wife returned, made satisfaction, and the church accepted them. In 1773 the following were called to account by the First Church as having separated from it :

Mr. Griswold also says (in 1801) of this church : "Their first Elder who preached statedly here, though he was not ordained over them, was Mr. Elihu Marsh. The second was Mr. Robert Campbell, who was the first that was ordained over them. He was ordained here twenty-nine years ago, continued about twelve years, and was then dismissed and left the town. Their third Elder was Mr. Barnabas Lathrop, who was not ordained over them, but came here about ten years ago, and preached with them about two years. He afterward joined the Presbyterian society, and died in this town April 10, 1796, aged 57 years. Their fourth and now oflficiating Elder is Mr. Daniel Hine. He has been ordained over them tour years."

Rev. Daniel Hine continued to preach to this church until about i8t2, when he resigned, and recommended his church to disband and unite with the First Church ; but, after giving up their church organization, they united with different churches. Several of them, residing in the north part of the town, united with the Baptist church at Northville. Mr. Hine, their last Elder, a good man, and faithful, resided in the town until his decease in 1835, in his eighty-sixth year, and here his descendants still remain.

Capt. Joseph Ruggl4^f then of New Haven, bought a Right of land in NewMilford for ;£2C»,in November, 1733, which he sold the next spring for ;£3CX), and bought another right for £^2$ (January 19, 1734). Upon this Right he had land laid out to him on the 1 8th of the next March: "Twenty acres, in several pieces, in Still River Neck." " May 27, 1735. Laid to Joseph Ruggles forty acres, in the Still River Neck, near to Newtown line, across Hop Brook ; also three acres in Still River Swamp, near the mouth of Four Mile Brook."

Mr. Ruggles settled in New Milford at the Half-way Falls on Still River, in 1733 or 4, and was a partner in the enterprise at that place called the Iron Works, where he resided until about 1750, when he returned, with some of his family, to New Haven to reside, but leaving several of his sons and daughters and their families here. The Ruggles family was an influential one in the town for more than one hundred years, and are said to have been peculiar in this respect, that, if any one family was unfortunate, the other families and individuals of the name would join in supplying the loss, and enable the family to go on in the ways of prosperity, as if no calamity had happened. That is. instead of struggling to be independent of each other, they always clung together, each to help the others. It is impossible for a pen to pass on without commending this spirit, which is so great a contrast to what is often exhibited in the world. Capt. Joseph Ruggles was a stirring, intelligent business man, - above the average, as indicated in several ways, especially in the matter of establishing schools at the South Farms, as the region where he resided was then called, and the matter of sustaining the Separate Church in its beginning at New Milford against the disciplining effort of the legal First Church ; for, in about 1 8 10, the old First Church became established on the foundations, almost precisely, in real fact, that Mr. Ruggles sustained in 1750.

('apt. IjaxaruH Ifuf/f/les^ son of Capt. Joseph, Sen., remained in New Milford when his father returned to New Haven, and soon af^er married Hannah Bostwick, and became an influential and estimable citizen, and departed this life in 1797. Philo Ruggles, his son, became a lawyer of note in New Milford, removed to Poughkeepsie, N. Y., where the family became very influential, and was much esteemed.

Capt. Joseph Haggles, Jr., son of Captain Joseph, died in 1802, aged 71 years. He was appointed by the Assembly, in 1 761, captain of the first military company organized in the society of Newbury, now Brookfield, and was for many years an influential business man.

Samuel Hnggles, another son of Captain Joseph, Sen., resided on his father's homestead, and his son Samuel and his daughter Lucia constituted an important part of the first company of missionaries that went to the Sandwich Islands. (See Biog.)

l)ea. Meazev lieechevczmt from Milford a single man, and settled' in New Milford before 1726, when he united with the First Church, and in October of 1729 married Frances Oviatt. He possessed great energy of character, was prominent in the transactions of the town, and was a successful farmer. He voted against what were said to be illegal proceedings in the effort of 1745 to settle Mr. Noah Wells, and was among the first, with his wife, who were cited before the First Church to make satisfaction for separating from that church, but as he lived until 1797, to the good age of 90 years, the censures of the church did not harm him seriously. If he could have lived about thirteen years longer he would have seen the old church fully established on the platform he adopted fifty years before. Mr. Griswold placed him as one of the deacons of the First Church, but Rev. Mr. Taylor made the following record in the church book, Mr. Beecher having officiated on trial as a deacon over two years in that church: - "February, 1750-51. At a church meeting regularly warned, it was fully voted in y« negative y' Eleazer Beecher should not be established in y« oflftce of a deacon ; he fell off to a party called Separates and could not be reclaimed." He was a deacon many years in the church of the Separates.

Jonathan Hack came with his father Jonathan, Sen., from Wethersfield to New Milford, in 17 16, and married Betsey Bostwick in 1733, and had seven children. He and his wife were cited before the First Church to answer for separation from it, but did not return.

The Separate Church, 197

David Jieardsley and his wife, formerly of Stratford, came from Newtown and joined the First Church by letter in 1748. He and his wife returned to the First Church in 1752.

Jonathan Botsford, with his wife Betsey, came from Milford and united with the First Church in 1737, but voted against the so-called illegal proceedings in 1745, and afterwards drew off to the Separates. They were cited to make satisfaction and return, but they continued in the Separate Church.

Lemuel Bostwlck, son of John ist., came to New Milford and united with the First Church in 1727, and in 1729 married Anna Jackson of Stratford. He resided at first near the Great Falls, east side of the river, where he lived until after 1769, but later he removed to Lower Merryall, where he died, and where some of his descendants still reside. He was one of the choristers in the First Church some years, from 1741. He possessed a noble personal appearance, for which he was quite noted, and is reported as being a remarkably good man ; one of those whom everybody delighted to meet. He sang his. way on, until 87 years of age, then " departed this life." Anna, his widow, died at Hinesburg. Vt., in 1800, aged 92 years. A beautiful life ; happy home; length of days; - what record more complete ?

Dea. Khenexf*r Jlotehh'lss came, Mr. Gris wold's sermon says, from Long Island, and married, in New Milford, Hannah Terrill, January 10, 1 742. The records do not show when he joined the First Church, but he was cited to appear before it, with his wife and others, in 1750. He was afterwards deacon in the Separate Church, probably, many years.

Joseph llavtwell came from Stoughton, Mass., married in New Milford, Rebecca, sister to Roger Sherman, in 1752. He was cited to appear before the First Church in 1773, to make satisfaction for separation and union with the Separate Church, but he continued with the latter.

A question may arise as to why these persons who desired to join the Separate Church did not take a certificate from the First Church in the beginning, and thereby have no further trouble. The answer is that one lawful church, in those times, would not recognize another church within its parish by giving such a certifi- cate or permit. None of these persons, however upright their character, could obtain, or ever did obtain, such a certificate. The only effort to obtain one, was made by Captain Joseph Ruggles, Sen., after he removed from the parish, and he did not succeed. The only way persons could be free from membership in a lawful church, and repiain in the parish of said church, was by being expelled, with all the dishonor that such expulsion could bring to bear upon them. No relief could be found then as now by civil law to protect character, for the civil law was the church in real fact. It is historically true that a fair proportion of the men and women who went from the First to the Separate Church, were among the very best, most faithful, true Christians, in the town, and that they made the change in the only Christian way possible for them ; and hence the whole question of the doings of the old church in Connecticut in this matter is one of nothing but mortification and chagrin to a true Congregationalist.

Benajah Stones of Branford, purchased, in February, 1742. about seventy acres of land in the North Purchase, for £\oo, and in 1749, when residing in Woodbury, bought of Job Gould, of New Milford, 130 acres of land, with a dwelling-house on it, lying to the northeast of the Park Lane school-house, on the west side of the north and south road, the place being still known as the Old Stone Farm. He soon after bought more land in that vicinity, and in 1752 he purchased another seventy acres in the North Purchase for ;£200. His descendants still remain in the vicinity of the old farm, on the road direct from Park Lane to New Preston.

JElihu Marsh settled in New Milford, at the place now called Jerusalem, on Rocky River, where he resided until his decease. He officiated as the minister of the Separate Church in New Milford, and as such was of very great importance to that church, for they were not able to pay the salary of a regularlyinstalled minister, and Mr. Marsh had an independent property of his own. Whether he ever received any salary is unknown, but he probably served them as their minister several years while living in New Fairfield, and three'years after settling in New Milford.

" Bardsley ** in that year, and was summoned before the First Church in 1773. Whether he removed or died here is not known. His, son Stephen, Jr., married here, but seems to have removed soon after 1804.

John Wilkinson from England, settled in the town about 1743, and united with the First Church in 1770, and went to the Separates in 1773. He married here and had a large family.

Mosrs Johnson came from Newtown, and married Eunice Urownson ; had a family of seven children. Peter Johnson, perhaps a brother, was here and married, about the same time, but both families seem to have left the town about 1780.

Calelp TervlUf Jr., son of Caleb, born in New Milford, married Eunice Coggswell, of New Preston Society, in 1768, and resided, probably, in that part of the town, and had one son and two daughters.

dipt. Isaac Bostwick^ son of Lemuel, led the first company that went out of New Milford in the Revolution, to Boston, where they remained some months. After, if not before, the Revolution he became owner in a mill property at Lanesville, or the Great Falls, and was for a number of years a very influential man in the town. While town treasurer for a number of years, he became involved in money matters, and surrendered a large proportion of his property to the town to meet his deficiencies, in all which he was treated with great consideration and respect by the town authorities. The date of his death is not known. The family, some of them, and the widow, removed to Hinesburg, Vt. But few if any men were more active and influential in the town than he during Revolutionary times.

Dea. Nathan Gaylord, son of William the first, joined the First Church in 1727 ; went to the Quakers in 1731, but united early with the Separatist movement, became a deacon in that chlirch, and was well known and respected in the town. The Separate Church was organized at his house, a little way up the Aspetuck River, in 1753, and it is probable that the meetings of that * church were held at his house much of the time until their meeting-house was built, in 1761. He died suddenly in 1769, in the sixtieth year of his age, and the inscription on his tombstone in the New Milford cemetery is not without both beauty and sadness.

I>ea. Israel Baldtvln, Sen., came from Milford ; was the son of Samuel, and one of four brothers who settled in New Milford. Israel settled on the Litchfield road half a mile south of Theophilus Baldwin's, where he resided until his death.

Oamalfel Baldwin, another brother, settled in Park Lane, where he established a fine home, which he sold, with his farm, in 1748, to Roger Sherman for ;£i,SCX), and he removed to the north part of Sherman.

l>ea. Israel Baldwin, Jr., brother to Gamaliel, was a deacon in the Separate Congregational Church, and resided on the homestead of his father.

Ahfei BaldvuUf the fourth brother, settled on land laid to the father or brothers, in the northeast part of the town, where his descendants still remain.

Dea. John Beeeher^ son of Eleazer, 2d, and twin brother of Eleazer, 3d, born in 1773, is said by Mr. Griswold to have been deacon of the Separate Church, resided about a mile east of the old Beecher home, on what was then called the Bound Hill road. He and his twin brother were twins in all their business transactions as well as blood, each always referring to what his brother might think in regard to all bargains and work.

jyea. Ifirerius Sfllson married Anne, dau. of Dea. Israel Baldwin, in 1767; his residence was on Stilson Hill. He is highly spoken of. He died in 1802, in his fifty-eighth year. This family, which occupied a prominent place in the town for many years, is now without a representative in it, many of them having removed to other parts of the country.

David Camj}f son of Samuel, one of the early settlers in the town, came with his father, and married Sarah Terrill of Woodbury, and settled on the west side of Poplar Swamp, near the present Park Lane school-house. He died in 1782.

"December 10, 1787. Voted, that the fine which Joseph Squire is subjected to pay the town on trial for bringing in and entertaining unwholesome inhabitants, etc., be remitted, and he is by this vote released from paying said fine - he paying all costs of prosecution.** This referred, probably, to Tories, whom the town had voted could not be acceptable citizens in the town ; that is, those who had gone away, as quite a number had, during the war.

** December 27, 1790. Voted, that the town treasurer give up the note he holds against Liffe Sanford for ten shillings, which was given by said Sanford for a fine."

"December lo, 1792. Voted, that the town treasurer be and he is hereby directed to give up to Doct. Benjamin Warner and Reuben Warner, their two several notes of hand which beholds against them, which was given by them as fines for their two sons breach of the Sabbath."

"December 17, 18 10. Voted, that sundry notes of hand formerly given to the town treasurer for fines be relinquished, and the notes given up, viz. : one of Thomas Davis, one of Jacob Reed, one of Robert and Gains Norton, one of Eli Todd, one of Silas Lamson, one of William Conn, one of Paul Welch, Jr., and one of Harry Negro ; all dated 8th December, 1797."

New Preston

OVE for the woods and the wilderness must have been an almost innate quality of mind in the first settlers of the western part of Connecticut. When Massachusetts had been settled but about one hundred years, one of its strong families emigrated to the town of Preston, New London County, in Connecticut, which was a country more recently settled than the former, supposing that here they should find a home for life ; but scarcely a dozen years had passed before the father hears of the western lands in the forests of Connecticut, and removes with a part of his family now grown up, and again plants the standard of civilization in the picturesque, but then wild wilderness country, known now for many years by the name of New Preston, Litchfield County, Ct.

The tract of land called " New Milford North Purchase" was bought in 1722, of the agents for western lands, for Windsor and Hartford, and the whole of it was taken from Waraumaug*s Reserve ; for that Reserve was bounded, originally, on the south by the old township of New Milford. Hut the North Purchase was bounded, when laid out, east on the Reserve, so that this *' Purchase " did not extend as far east as the Reserve. The "Purchase" >yas six and a half miles in length, and one and a half in width, and the eastern boundary may have been half or three-fourths of a mile east of the present meeting-house at New Preston village. The northern boundary of that '* Purchase ** passed east and west near or a little north of the outlet of Waraumaug Lake, so that the present village of New Preston lies in what was the northeast corner of the New Milford North Purchase.

Plan Of The North Purchase

In dividing this tract among sixty-four owners, it was attempted to complete the work in one survey, making two tiers of lots the whole length, and thirty-two lots in each tier ; but when they were through with the first survey, there was so much land left that two other surveys were made, giving each of the sixty-four owners an equal amount each time. The thirtysecond and thirty-third lots in the first survey are said to have been at the east end of the purchase, and hence bounded east by the Reserve.

Considerable attention has been given to learn who first settled within the bounds of this North Purchase, without obtaining satisfactory knowledge on the question. For nine years after the deed was secured, no attempt, apparently, was made to settle any one on this land. Then the first division was made and a petition presented to the Assembly to have the tract annexed to New Milford and become a part of that township; but this failed, and all that was done during the next ten years was the buying and selling of some of the shares of the Purchase. In 1 741, by an act of the Assembly, this tract of land was made a part of New Milford township, and immediately land speculations became a specialty, and the transactions increased until 1747, when the settlement began at what is now New Preston village. Two or three years before this last date, a few settlers had located on the western part of this North Purchase, the locality being called Merryall, and it is possible that some had settled in the southwest corner of this tract at or near what is now Merwinsville.

^' Mr. JEilwcird Cogswell of Preston, New London county. Conn.," bought of John Baker of Woodbury, and Caleb Mallery of New Milford, Sep. 10, 1745, a tract of land in the North Purchase, the /'thirty-third lot in the south tier of lots," which must have been near the southeast corner of the purchase extending northward from the southeast corner, three-fourths of a mile, or to where the New Preston Cemetery now is. In the next three years he purchased other pieces of land in the vicinity, amounting in value - to several hundred pounds money. He at once erected what was called then the Iron Works, one-half of which he sold in 1747 to Matthew Whipple ; these works stand-

Satnuftl Cof/Htvell of Preston, New London county, bought of Caleb Mallery, June 9, 1746, **two shares ; - lots 30 and 31, for £zoo old tenor." The next day Edward Cogswell received a deed of land in the same vicinity, and the next spring both of these families were residing here, and therefore they probably settled here in the spring or summer of 1746.

p/avMh Keniiir of Preston, New London county, bought of Jerusha Boardman (widow of Rev. Daniel), "lot 32 in N. M. N. Purchase, Jan. 20, 1746-7, for ;£200 old tenor," and the next April purchased of Samuel Cogswell 187 acres, for ;^I50. He settled here that spring (1747), and made several other purchases of lands within two or three years. He had a family, and they remained in the vicinity many years. Jacob Kennie was an influential, benevolent citizen.

Zepluinlah Branch purch2LStd for ;£ 139, land of Samuel Cogswell and Edward Cogswell, and made his home here about 1749, and was in the place some years ; but all the family seem to have disappeared long ago.

Mattliew Wliiypiplef of " Ipswich in the county of Essex, in the province of the Massachusetts Bay, yeoman," purchased of Edward Cogswell, October 24, 1747, " one-half of the Iron Works in New Milford North Purchase, standing on a stream called Aspetuck, that comes out of a large pond, commonly called the West Pond ; also one-half of the stream from the dam southwardly ten rods, with all the appurtenances, privileges, and accommodations belonging thereunto, with the privilege of the iron ore, as I the said Edward Cogswell have of Elisha Williams and Martin Kellogg ; likewise, .... full liberty to use any spot of ground that is near said Iron Works that may be convenient to build a house or houses upon, necessary to the carrying on the half of said Iron Works ; also, land for a garden and orchard or pasture near the Works, on the west side of the river, not to exceed ten acres." *

Whatever there were of these Iron Works at this time, they had been erected within two years previous, probably within one, and the two partners, Edward Cogswell, and Matthew Whipple, composed the first manufacturing enterprise within the

Nathaniel Box worth of Rehoboth, county of Bristol, province of the Massachusetts Bay, bought of Jonathan Noble about ninety acres of land, the thirty-fourth lot, for ;£i30, old tenor, November 7, 1743. He did not settle on this land, but on the 23d of May, 1749, he deeded one-half of it, "for love and goodwill and divers other good causes," to his son Nathaniel Bozworth, Jr.. blacksmith, then already settled in New Milford. The boundaries of this thirty-fourth lot, in part, are: "Beginning at the southeast corner, . . . and running westerly by the highway till it comes to Steep Brook, and then bounded by said brook. Then beginning again at the said southeast corner and running northeasterly by the highway till it comes to a brook that runs across said highway into said Right of land, then by said brook westwardly until it comes within ten rods of East Aspetuck, then southwesterly ten rods for a corner, then northwesterly twenty rods, if it doth reach East Aspetuck River ; then northeasterly till it comes to said river, then down stream by said river southeasterly from said river to Steep Brook, including forty-five acres ; and I also convey to him fully one quarter part of the stream and land left and reserved, for building and improving water-mills and works, reserving a sufficient cart-way to and from the place proposed for said mills or works to the highway at the east side of said lot." The southeast corner of this lot must have been near, - perhaps a little northwest of - the Episcopal Church in Marbledale.

Henrif Dean of Preston, in the county of New London tanner, came to New Milford and purchased at this place. May i, 1749, of Edward Cogswell, land "on the east side of the stream called Aspetuck, near the new Iron Works," and in the description of boundaries is mentioned "a black oak tree, standing by the pond made to soak hydes in," showing that already the Tan Works were commenced.

Others, living in the northeast part of the town of New Milford, shewing this Assembly that they are situate at a great distance from the public worship in the towns to which they respectively belong, and praying liberty of this Assembly to hire an orthodox minister to preach among themselves six months in the year for such term of years as this Assembly shall think fit, with exemption from taxes, &c. : Resolved by this Assembly, that the said memorialists have liberty to hire an orthodox minister amongst themselves six months in a year for the space of four years next coming, with exemption from any ministerial charges in the towns to which they respectively belong for such of time only as they shall hire among themselves."

In the spring of 1753, a petition was sent to the Assembly, - as hereafter follows, - which resulted in the establishment of an ecclesiastical society, according to the boundaries of the petition, by the name of Nciv Preston^ which name was in honor of the fact that a number of the leading men had come from Preston in this state, and therefore it was agreeable and appropriate to call it New Preston.

"To the Honorable y* Generall Assembly to Ije IToldcn at Newhaven in y* Colony of Connecticut on The Second thursday of October Next A. D. 1753 -

The memorial of us the Subscribers Being Inhabitants of y* Northern Part of New milford and y* South and Southeast Part of Kent and a Place Called Meriall m y« County of Litchfield Humbly Begg Leave to observe -

That your Honr". Memorialists Live a Great Distance from y* Publick V^orship of God by Reason Whereof we Labour Under Great Difiiculty to attend Publick Worship With our families many of us having Considerable families of Small Children Which many of them by Reason of y^DilTiculty wee Labour under are Dcstitntc of the Jkncfit of Attending the Worshi]) of God in any Place by Reason Whereof this Honorable Assembly hath in times Past Ikcn Pleased to Grant to us the Liberty of winter Preaching Whereby we and our families have had the opportunity of Enjoying the Benefit of a Preached Gospel Amongst our Selves to Great Sattisfaction and that time being Limited and now Ended - thereupon your Honours memorialist humbly Pray that this Honora**'" assembly would be Pleased in your Wonted Goodness to Grant us Release from our Difficulty and Grant to us the Privilidge of Being an Ecclesiastical Society with the Powers and Privilidges that other Ecclesiastical Societys in this Colony here With the Limits and Boundarys as hereafter Discribed (viz )

Beginning at the Southeast Corner of the new milford North Purchis then Runing Southerly Joyning upon Woodbur)' Line one mile, from thence nining a West Line to the foot of the Long Mountain Southwest of Capt. Joseph Bostwicks, from thence a North Line to a Place Called the Rockhouse Cobble and so that Course to Meriall Line and then a Cross Meriall to Kent Line and then runing East to the Southwest Comer of James Lakes farme then Northerly to the Northwest Cor- ner of John Henderson's f&rme that he now lives upon then Runing East to East Greenwich Line then Runing South to the Southwest Comer of East Greenwich then Runing East upon East Greenwich Line to Shipauge River thence Runing Southardly on s** River to Woodbury Line Then Runing westerly on woodbury line to the first mentioned Bounds or such other Lines and Boundaries as your Honours shall think most Convenient, or to appoint a Com'*^ to Now Settle and asartain the Same or in some other way Grant Relieve to your memorialist as you in your Grate Wisdom think fit and your memorialists as in Duty Bound shall Ever Pray. Dated September y* 12th A. D. 1753.

Of these names, Joseph Miles, Nathan Hawley, Stephen Noble, John Bostwick, and lienajah l^ostwick, were from New Milford. Capt. Joseph Bostwick was within the boundaries of the society, and his name may be one of the two which could not be copied from the original petition at Hartford, they being covered by repairs on the manuscript. Two or three others may have been originally from New Milford, and living in ihc western part of the new society.

The names of all the men within the limits of the society are not on this petition ; the reason is not apparent. Nathaniel Bozworth was one; his brother William received land here in 175 1, from his father ; and Edward Cogswell and Zephaniah Branch do not appear. William Cogswell came a few years later, but was here in 1757.

New Preston, 21 1

icl Bozworth, Zephaniah Branch, and several others, resident in New Preston at that time, were adherents to the Episcopal Church ; "and hence as early as 1766 or 7, an Episcopal house of worship was erected in that place - a further account of which may be seen in connection with the sketch of St. Andrew's Church, of Marbledale.

"Dec. 21, 1754. I, Jacob Kene, . . . in consideration of love and good will towards the society of New Preston, and in view of setting up or accommodating the public worship of God in said society, ... do freely give . . . one acre of land to erect a meeting-house upon for the public worship of God, , . . part of the farm I now live upon, . . . that part on which the County Court's committee have affixed a stake for the meeting-house of said society, together with a two-rod highway from said stake southeast, unto a ten -rod highway that is between the ist and 2d tier of lots in the New Milfprd North Purchase."

This was the site of the first meeting-house on New Preston Hill, it being but a little distance from the present church edifice at that place. In December, 1753, the society voted to lay a tax of twelve pence on the pound to hire a minister for the season ; and to build two school-houses by subscription, for the use of the society. In November, 1754, it was voted to build a meeting-house 36 by 26 feet, with five windows, of twelve lights each. In December, 1766, it was voted to build another meeting-house forty by fifty feet, which was inclosed three years later, but was not entirely finished until 1798.

The Rev. Noah Wadham was the first settled minister in the society, beginning in 1757. He was induced to resign his place and accept the position of pastor in the settlement of the first colony in the Wyoming Valley, Pa, in 1768. The Rev. Jeremiah Day was the next pastor in New Preston, beginning in January, 1770, and continuing until 1806. This family have l)ccome very widely known through their professional positions for many years in Yale College.

During the labors of the Rev. Charles A. Boardman, from New Milford, for twelve years, from 18 18, the New Preston Society was known as one of the most efficient and successful of Western Connecticut.

On Febniary i, 1757, Benjamin Mallery, of Kent, and James Terrill, of New Milford, as a committee of the New Preston Society, purchased of Samuel Cogswell, for twenty shillings, lawful money, a certain j^iece of land, " bounded west by Joseph Whcaton's, south and east by said Cogswell's land, and north on highway ; " said land is purchased and devoted for a buryingplace for the east end of New Preston.* For this land a warrantee deed was given, without reservation or consideration except as above stated. The ten rod highway running through the north purchase east and west, passed this burying-place on the north side.

The following secured the site of the first school-house, which doubtless was near the present one, near the dwelling of Mr. Gould C. Whittlesey ; -

"December 13, 1762. Voted that the inhabitants of New Preston Society may have liberty to build a school-house on the highway near Captain Nathaniel Bozworth's shop, in the most convenient place as they shall judge, so as not to incommode the public road."

Captain Bozworth's. blacksmith's shop stood, probably, north side of the highway, a little way west from the present schoolhouse, in New Preston Village.

In that part of the New Preston Society which lay within the bounds of New Milford township, the following names are found on the assessment list for 1800:

The total assessment of that part of Newbury (now Brookfield) Society, lying within New Milford township, in 1787, the last assessment before the organization of the town of Brookfield was ;^2,37i 22s. 6d.

The Revolution

ONG was the struggle for American liberty, but glorious was the victory. The beginning of the conflict in New Milford witnessed the most perfect loyalty to the king, as was the fact everywhere in the colonies ; but by the arbitrary course of the British ministry, the tide soon turned in favor of entire independence. "At a town meeting legally warned and holden at New Milford, in Connecticut, on the 20th day of September, A. D. 1774: "1st. Samuel Canfield, Esqr., was chosen moderator for said meeting.

"2d. Preamble, &c. This meeting with hearts full of loyalty and duty to our rightful sovereign. King George the III, and with the warmest desires to hold, enjoy, and transmit inviolable to the latest posterity our sacred and inestimable charter rights and privileges, and moved with the most poignant grief at the present truly alarming and dangerous situation of the American colonies in consequence of the unconstitutional measures lately adopted by the British Parliament, and now actually carrying on against our brethren at Boston, in the province of Massachusetts Hay, whereby duties and taxes arc imposed on the Americans without their consent : Do think it our duty to make public our sentiment in those matters, to the intent that a firm union may be preserved through the American colonies, which union we apprehend necessary to our common safety; wherefore we do unanimously and firmly resolve and declare :

** I. That we look upon the cause of Boston, in its consequences and essential connections with, to be the common cause of all North America.

III. That all legal and constitutional means ought to be used by all Americans to remove those unconstitutional measures now carrying on against the American Colonies.

IV. Therefore we will join with the Towns in this and the sister Colonies in all reasonable and lawful measures that shall be thought best by the Hon. General Congress now sitting, to assert, maintain, and defend our common rights and privileges.

V. That we fully acquiesce in the Resolutions come into by the Hon. House of Representatives at their session at Hartford, in May last, and order the same to be entered at large in the records of this town as being fully expressive of the sense of this meeting on the important subject to which they refer, that future generations may have access to them on every proper occasion.

VII. That Samuel Canfield, William Cogswell, and Daniel Everitt, Esqrs., Dea. Abraham Camp, Capt. Sherman Boardman, and Messrs. Abel Hine and Josiah Starr be a committee to receive and answer all letters, and to collect and communicate all necessary intelligence, and to receive and forward such contributions that may be made in this town for the abovementioned purposes, and order these resolves to be printed in the Hartford paper, or Connecticut Courant, and that any four of the members have power to act.

VIII. That we disapprove of all riots, tumultuous and unwarrantable meetings, mobs and combinations among ourselves, under color of defending our privileges."

On the 1 2th of the next December (1774), a committee of Inspection was appointed "according to the General Congress advice, and also according to the concurrence thereto by the Hon. General Assembly holden at New Haven in October last past \'

The Re Vol Utton

All the above titles are given the same as in the records of the town, and reveal the standing of these men, and hence the dignity and commanding influence of the cause they were to represent, in the estimation of the people of this town.

The battle at Concord, Mass., on the 19th of April, 1775, was the opening of the war, and troops were called from all parts of the country, but hostilities were not pressed by the British during that summer.

Capt. Tsnae Jlosfirtrk was sent with a company of soldiers from New Milford to Boston in the autumn or winter of 1775, and remained there during January and February. A book containing ihc weekly report of his company for six or eight weeks is still preserved in the possession of Mr. John R. Bostwick, which informs that the company belonged to .Col. Webb's Regiment, and were at "Winter Hill," near Boston, during January (1776), and in Roxbury during the next February. The names of the men are not on this book, very much to our regret, but the number of officers and men was sixtyfive, several of them being without arms. Isaac Bostwick was Captain of the militia company of the " South End ; " that is, south of an east and west line crossing the town at the Congregational meeting-house.

Captain Bostwick's Company had not returned home when another company was ordered to New York ; this is called " Captain Couch's Company, in Col. Andrew Ward's Regiment ; " most of the officers and men being of New Milford. The book of accounts kept by Benjamin Bostwick, Jr., as Clerk in this company, is still preserved, and is in the keeping of Col. Wm. J. Starr. The company was in the service two months and twentythree days, - from Feb. i, 1776.

The Revolution, 219

Mar. 31, 1777. "Voted, that a committee be appointed according to the advice of His Hon^ the Governor, &c., for the purpose of furnishing the quota of soldiers in the Continental service for said New Milford.

. *- Lt. Zadoc Noble, Capt. Joseph Ruggles, Jr., Ens. Jeremiah Canfield, Mr. Ithiel Stone, Dea. Israel Baldwin, Mr. Thomas Brownsdn, and Mr. Zachariah Sanford, were chosen the committee.

"Voted, that the town of New Milford will give twelve pounds lawful money, bounty, for the first year's service in addition to all encouragement already given to such inhabitants of this town as shall enlist into the Continental service for three years, or during the present war, within ten days from this time, including those who belong to this town who have already enlisted, subducting only their wages from the time they enlisted to this day, and such private donations as they have received.

" That for the second and third years, said soldiers who shall so enlist shall have six pounds lawful money pr. year lo be paid out of the town treasury."

After making provisions by which to supply the money to pay these engagements, the committee entered upon their work ; and the tax collectors, Joseph Mygatt and Daniel Hine, upon theirs; but these were only the beginning of troubles, expenses, and privations.

" William Cogswell, Esqr., and Capt. Ebenezer Couch to be a committee to procure said salt and fetch to New Milford, and that the said committee shall apply to the Selectmen for money to bear the expense of transporting said salt from Boston to said town."

oxen or horses, by which means it is probable it was secured in this case. It is said in the record, " to transport some salt which belongs to this town," that is, salt which had been apportioned to this town by the Colonial government, since it was so scarce that the government took charge of the distribution to keep it out of the hands of rapacious speculators. Such was only one of the straits into which the Colonies were thrown in the early part of the great struggle for liberty.

" Capt. Sherman Boardman, Mr. Samuel Warner, Mr. Simeon Baldwin, Capt. Benjamin Brownson, Capt. Ebenezer Couch, Mr. Ithiel Stone, and Dea. Ebenezer Hotchkiss shall be a committee to procure clothing for the soldiers in the Continental service."

*- Voted, that the inhabitants of New Milford shall be divided into twelve districts . . . and that the said districts shall furnish their respective quotas as shall be assigned to them as aforesaid ; and, on the faihire of each or either of said districts in furnishing the clothing allotted to ihem as aforesaid, then in case a warrant for impressing clothing be granted it shall be divided to the districts that are deficient in proportion to the deficiencies."

The Re Vol Ution, 2 2 1

The extreme measures which seemed necessary at the time are revealed in two votes, one being for three shillings tax on the pound of money, and the other " that the selectmen shall be and are impowered to deliver back those guns to such disaffected persons of this town as have been disarmed, according to their discretion."

Several persons went from this town and joined the British army to fight against their own kindred and country ; and worse, some joined in bands or companies as Tory "roughs," and passed from place to place as bandits, having secret liiding-places ; and hence, out of self-preservation of life and goods, the precaution was wise and 'right to take the arms of certain persons from them. For holding sentiments of loyalty to the King no one was ever disturbed, so far as yet learned ; but when they threatened the burning of dwellings, and the destruction of property and life, it was proper to defeat their intentions in such designs. Two brothers by the name of Fairchild joined the British army, and after some months returned to their sister s house in New Milford, on furlough. While visiting, the sister called their attention to some new window-curtains as very nice. They remarked, " Only so much more finery to be burned." The sister asked, "Are you going back to the. British army.^" They said, " Certainly ; we are only off on a furlough." " Well," said she, " such being your sentiments, I do not wish ever to see you again. Do not ever come back to this town."

In June, 1780, upon the call from Congress for more soldiers, the town voted that ** every soldier who shall voluntarily enlist to serve in the Continental Battalions for the space of six months, or until the first day of January next (unless sooner discharged) shall be paid out of the town treasury of said New Milford by the first day of January for every month they are in said service, four bushels of wheat, or an equivalent thereto in money in addition to the bounty and encouragement already given by the State."

In addition to this they voted to give three bushels of wheat or an equivalent in money to all militia-men who might be called to servo one month, in addition to all other pay, and when they should serve more than a month, then three bushels of wheat for every month. The same was also granted to the detachment which was then under marching orders from New Milford to West Point for an unlimited time. Two months later the town offered ten bushels of wheat per month for every soldier who should enlist for four months, and in the next November a committee was appointed to classify the inhabitants of the town " in order to raise recruits for three years or during the war." In December of the same year (1780) the town placed the whole matter of raising recruits in, the hands of a committee to do the best they could, and the town would pay the bills and carry out the engagements they should make. Under this arrangement the work was performed so well that in January, 1 781, they voted " that this town entertain the highest sense of gratitude to the officers and soldiers who have served in the Continental army, for their patriotic spirit in entering the service, for their soldier-like behavior, for their patience and fortitude in suffering many hardships and discouragements which nothing but an ardent love of liberty and their country could inspire, and that this vote of thanks be recorded as a testimony of our gratitude."

Having passed this most just and proper expression of appreciation, they proceeded to make further arrangements for filling the ranks for the next summer's campaign, which proved to be their last act of the kind, since the war ended, with the surrender of Cornwallis, in October, 1781 ; and we have seen the day of the celebration of the centennial anniversary of that

But the conflicts and consequences of the war were not past, if the fighting by the armies was, for the town found reason, in the irresistible remembrance of the past, to record the following action :

"It is supposed that many of the people of this town who have left their country's cause and joined the enemies of these states, are now desirous of returning to their usual homes : - this meeting, after fully debating upon the subject, and considering those men who have thus in a critical season voluntarily left their own country's cause and theieby deprived it of their help and assistance which might be expected from them, are of the mind that all those persons under the above description, cannot, agreeable to the feelings and opinions of the people of this town, l)e accepted and received again as inhabitants of this town. Unanimously voted.

"Voted, that none of those persons who have voluntarily gone over and joined the enemy, shall be suffered to abide and continue in the town during the present situation of our puBlic affairs." To carry out these resolutions, a committee was appointed of those men who knew what the terrible struggle had been, and the consequence was that several never came back, and never obtained any benefit of the possessions they once owned in the town. In February, 1782, fifteen acres of land belonging to Samuel Miles, having been confiscated by the state, was sold at auction for seventy pounds money.

" Received, Litchfield, 28th Sept., 1779, of the First Society in New Milford, by the hand of Col. Samuel Canfield, ninetyfour pounds, sixteen shillings money, which was contributed by .said society for the relief of the suffering and distressed inhabitants of the towns of New Haven, Fairfield, and Norwalk.

"March, 1780. Voted, that the society's committee receive either the principal or interest of the donation notes at the rate of twenty-five shillings in continental money, for one shilling lawful money, or old way, as is due upon said notes, until the time of the next adjournment of this meeting."

l<^)cnezer lioHtmich was Orderly Sergeant during the Revolution, and in 1788 removed to Hinesburg, Vt.; from there afterwards to Elizabethtown, N. Y., and thence to Rootstown, Ohio, in 1803, where he died.

Jjt. Isvael Ihfhliviii was lieutenant in the Revolution in Col. Silliman's regiment, - appointed June 14, 1776, to be marched directly to New York.

Col. Joslah Htavr served in the Revolution, and for a time was keeper of the military stores in Danbury. In May, 1776, he was appointed captain in one of the regiments, being raised for the defence of this and other united colonies. In June, 1776, he was appointed Lieut.- Col. of 2d Battalion then to be raised,

- his commission, dated Jan. 9, 1777, signed by John Hancock, being now in possession of his grandson. Col. Wm. J. Starr. . He went north, was at the siege of St. John's, and on his return received a commission as colonel, Aug. 10, 1780; was at Monmouth, Germantown, and with the army during that terrible winter of suffering when it was short of supplies. He died Oct. IS, 1813.

Be^fjamin Wheaton was taken prisoner with his brother Joseph, - suffered with him, and died from the effects of the imprisonment. His brother Sylvester went to bring them home ; finding them, he carried one out of the city in his arms, then went back for the other, and on his return, found the first one dead, and the other did not live to reach home.

John Drink water, son of William, died Sep. 8, 1755, at the camp at Lake George, being a soldier under Capt. Benjamin - llinman [of Woodbury].

At the commencement of the Revolution, he again became a soldier, and continued through the war. He died at Charlotte in Vermont, Feb. 28, 1848, aged loi years and 4 months. One record says, he died in 1 844, aged 97 years.

Hexekiah Baldwin was lieutenant in the French War, and went to Crown Point and Ticonderoga. He shot an Indian and obtained his powder-horn, a large one, which was treasured carefully many years by his nephew Noble. He removed from New Milford, but to what place it is not known.

The following papers were sent to the Gazette of New Milford for publication in June, 1882. In sending them, Mr. Isaac Huntting of Pine Plains, Dutchess Co., N. Y., says: "Some old papers in the possession of the descendants of James W. Smith, who fifty years ago was a resident of this town, have a musty tint, and yet in many respects are interesting for what is written and printed thereon. Among these are some military papers, having an especial local interest in New Milford and Western . Connecticut, and also to some extent a general national interest. They date back to the French and English war in this country in 1758, and were accumulated and used by Capt. Joseph Canfield, the paternal grandfather of Sarah Canfield, the wife of James W. Smith, heretofore mentioned. He appears to have been a man of thorough method and system in his business, and died possessed of a large landed estate in New Milford,"

" Whereas it is proposed to raise some independent companies at their own charge and expense to assist the army in the expedition to Crown Point, this may certify then that if such companies appear and desire commissions for proper officers, I shall be ready to give them. This I thought proper to signifie for encouragement of such as are inclined to serve as aforesaid.

This letter was found among Capt. Canfield's papers, but whether he engaged in the war at that time is not known. Several young men went in that year (175 s) ^ soldiers as far as Fort Edward, where they died, and it is probable that there were more than those who died.

In the spring of 1758, Capt. Joseph Canfield raised a company which served in the campaign under Col. David Wooster (afterwards General), and many of the original enlistment papers have been preserved. The form of enlistment was thus: "Ephraim Guthrie, of New Milford, in Litchfield county : I do acknowledge to have voluntarily inlisted myself a soldier to serve his Majesty King George the Second in a Regiment of Foot raised by the Colony of Connecticut to be commanded by Col. David Wooster of New Haven, for invading Canada, and carrying War into the Heart of the Enemy's Possessions. As Witness my Hand in Kent the 2d day of April in the year of our Lord 1758.

"These certify that Ephraim Guthrie, y® above signer, came before me, one of his Majesty's Justices of the Peace for the County of Litchfield, and acknowledged to have voluntarily enlisted to serve his Majesty King George the Second in the above Regiment. He also acknowledged he had heard the Second and Sixth Sections of the Articles of War against Mutiny and Desertion read unto him, and taken the Oath of Fidelity mentioned in the Articles of War.

In the enlistments preserved, in some cases the blanks for the Colonels commanding are not filled, - those filled have " John Read, Esq.," "David Wooster," and "Colonel of the fourth regiment."

The following is a list of the names of tlicse soldiers, their residence, date of enlistment, the regiment and the Justice ceriifying, as they appear upon the papers :

The French War

Daniel Pike, April 25, Dover, Dutchess Co., 4th regiment. Certified to by Paul Welch, [New Milford] Justice of the Peace in Litchfield county.

These arc all the enlistments on these papers, but may not comprise all of Captain Joseph Canfield's company, neither is it certain that all these were in his company. A much mutilated fragment of his muster-roll for 1758 contains the officers of his company.

Sir\ Pursuant to the orders I have received from Governor Fitch, I do hereby order and direct you to march with the company under your command to Albany, after you arc furnished with arms and other necessaries for the march, in order to be there ready for service of the campaign. You will take care to provide one team for the baggage of your company. You will also direct that one officer of your company remain behind to fill up the number of your company, and to do that as

Not the least entertaining among these scraps of paper are those pertaining to the impressment of guns for this company. To this end the Justice issued a warrant, and the gun was taken and appraised and paid for, or returned. Capt. Canfield's memorandum of these reads :

One gun and bayonet impressed from Garwood Cunningham, appraised at £2 5s.; also belt and cartridge, 5s. 6d.; also one cutlass, I2S. marked G. C, delivered unto John Brownson.

A gun and cutlass, impressed from Elisha Stoddard, was delivered unto Abraham Brownson. One impressed from Abijah Mitchell was delivered to Daniel Read. One from Eldad Spencer was delivered to John Wolton, Jr. One impressed from Peter Walker was delivered to Daniel Manville."

Military Officers

"N. B. That night the fight was at Ticonderoga, the abovementioned belt and bayonet was left, and never been found since, which was appraised 6s. by the appraisers aforesaid.

This careful preservation of all his papers by Capt Joseph Canfield, indicates his correct business habits, and the preservation of these papers 120 years by his descendants, signifies the perpetuation of the same:

"For several years, viz.: till the year 17441 there was but one military company in the town, - which was formed and organized somewhere between the years 1715 and 1720. The officers were as follows :

[The second set alx>ve were appointed in October, 1738, and hence if Stephen Noble served twenty years, as is probable, then the company was first organized in

" A troop of horse was formed of New Milford, Woodbury, and Litchfield, so long ago as the year 1744, which continued about 10 or 12 years, but there was not any captain in this town.

Another troop of horse belonging to New Milford, Washington, and Warren, was formed in the year 1790, of which the captains belonging to this town have been as follows, viz.:

" Another company of militia was formed out of those already mentioned, in the year 1793, belonging to that part of the town called the Neck [now Bridgewatcr], of which the captains have been as follows, viz.:

The dividing line between the two military companies running east and west, was one passing at the first meeting-house, and this was what gave the names " North End " and " South End.**

" Whereas Mr. Noah Smith of New Fairfield hath a Negro named York, who is a slave for his lifetime, who has for his lawful wife an Indian woman, who was freeborn, named Lavina; which Indian woman being extremely uneasy, almost to a degree of desperation with her situation, being wife to a slave, hath practiced of late to rove about from place to place, away from her husband's master*8, thereby making her husband uneasy and less serviceable to his master,*' therefore the said Noah Smith agreed Jaq. 19, 1769, to liberate said York, upon the condition that the wife of York, Lavina, should work for John Cannon, '* late of New Milford," for five years from date, to earn fifteen pounds money, and she pay for her own clothing, sickness, and medicine if any, until the five years should be fully completed, during all which time the slave York was to work for his master Noah Smith. The fifteen pounds money was to pay Mr. Smith for his property, York. Some of the stipulations were : " The goods of her said master she shall not embezzle, waste, nor them lend without his consent. She shall not frequent, nor play at games at taverns or ale-houses. From the service of her master she shall not at any time depart, nor absent herself without her said master's leave, but in all things as a and respect I have for my Negro servant named Dan .... do grant unto the said Dan Negro his time and freedom after my decease, upon his procuring a sufficient bondsman for his security, if need be ; and I also give him one bed and covering known by the name of Dan's bed, and one certain horse-colt coming two years old of a bright bay ....

In 1757, Mary Robburds gave Dan his freedom upon his paying her jQi 2s. $d. "annually, on the first of December during my natural life," and added to the horse a saddle, and bridle. The next year Dan bought of James Bradshaw a tract of land, twenty-five acres, adjoining the southwest corner of Wood Creek meadow lots, and so soon began to show himself a man and an industrious citizen. All honor to Mary Robburds, Sen.

"New Milford, May 28, 1774. This is to certify all persons whom it may concern or that have the curiosity to enquire, that I Partridge Thatcher, upon the special request of Amos Lewis, a negro man and my then negro girl, did, on the 23d day of August, 1773, desire the Rev. Mr. . Richard Clarke, minister of the Church of England at New Milford, to marry them, and on the same 23d day of August, 1773, he, the said Mr. Richard Clarke, at my house in said New Milford, did, according to the form of solemnization of matrimony appointed by the Church of England, marry the said Sibyl, and the said Partridge Thatcher did, in said marriage then and there, give the said Sibyl (who was then my negro-girl) to be married to said Amos, designing thereby to give her her freedom from that day forward, and accordingly they were then married ; and I do further by these presents, l>ona-fide declare that the said Sibyl, ever since the time of said marriage, hath been Wholly free according to the common freedom of English women, and is so now and shall forever hereafter enjoy the same freedom that free-born women, natives of

Two other persons were made free by him, both papers bearing the same date, - Dec. 30, 1780 ; in one of which he says : "I, Partridge Thatcher, of New Milford, in favor of freedom, do declare that from the day of the date hereof my negjro man Heber, Jacob's son, shall be forever free;" and in the other he says : " I Partridge Thatcher, of New Milford, in favor of freedom, do declare that my negro man Peleg, Jacob's son, when he shall arrive at the full age of twenty-five years, which will be on the 4th day of December, in the year of our Lord 1782, shall be forever free, and shall enjoy the same freedom that other men of this country commonly enjoy."

These papers were evidently drawn by Mr. Thatcher himself, and were held by the parties two years before they were recorded. The first of the three was retained ten years before being recorded ; and these facts show the individuality of these acts ; that Mr. Thatcher being '^ in favour of freedom" as the sole reason why he made these persons free, was moved by his personal sense of right, justice, righteousness and Christianity, to execute these papers and secure freedom to these persons. Let it then be remembered that Connecticut men did not free their slaves for the sole reason that it did not '^pay to keep them" as has been so many thousands of times alleged. All these slaves were young, and in market in that day would have brought from three to five hundred dollars each; and to retain on a farm, such as Mr. Thatcher had, were worth in clear gain annually, at a small estimate, each of them from fifty to one hundred dollars. But besides the above three Mr. Thatcher liberated two others.

''These may certify all that it may concern, that I, Partridge Thatcher, of New Milford, in favour of Freedom, do declare that from the day of the date hereof my negro man Jacob Gratis and my negro woman Dinah, Jacob's wife, shall both of them forever be free and shall both of them enjoy the same freedom that other men and their wives, that were free-born of this country, commonly enjoy, so that neither I nor my heirs nor assigns shall ever have any demands for the future on them or either of them but shall esteem the said Jacob and Dinah free as abovesaid : Provided, that the abovesaid Jacob and Dinah take my youngest negro boy Cyrus to live with them, and take a fatherly and motherly care of him from the day of the date hereof until he shall arrive at the full age of five years, which will be in the year of our Lord one thousand seven hundred and eighty-three, on the 28th day of April in said year, and at their own expense and cost during said term, provide for him, the said Cyrus, in sickness and health with sufficient meats, drinks, washing and lodging, and also complete clothing suitable to his age and condition, and when he shall arrive at the full age of five years, said Jacob and Dinah shall return said Cyrus to me sufficiently clothed as abovesaid, all at their own expense and cost, as witness my hand and dated this 30th day of March A.D. 1781.

"These Certify; That Capt. Sherman Boardman, of New Milford, in the county of Litchfield and state of Connecticut, having applied to us the subscribers, being a major part of the selectmen in and for said town of New Milford for this present year, for liberty and license to emancipate and make free his Negfro Slave named Nehemiah, and we having enquired into the age, ability and circumstances and character of said Negro Slave, are of opinion that it is likely to be- consistent with the real advantage of said Negro Slave to be set free, and that it is probable that said Nehemiah will be able to support his own person, and that he is of good and peaceable life and conversation, and the said Sherman Boardman hath liberty to emancipate and set at liberty his said Negro Slave Nehemiah as above requested, according to a certain stale law of this state entitled An Act in addition to and alteration of an Act entitled An Act concerning Indian, Mulattoes and Negro servants and slaves : - ^and if the said Sherman shall on receiving this certificate emancipate and set free said Negro Slave, Nehemiah, he the said Sherman Boardman, his heirs, executors and administrators shall be and hereby are forever discharged from any and all charges or cost which may be occasioned by maintaining and supporting the said Negro Slave Nehemiah, after his being so made free as abovesaid. In testimony whereof we have hereunto set our hand this 19th day of September, A. D. 1780, and in the fifth year of the Independence of the United States of America.

" New Milford, Sept. 19, 1780. These may certify all concerned that I have and do hereby emancipate and set free my Negro servant Nehemiah, agreeable to the liberty granted by the Selectmen of the town of New Milford as above written, as witness my hand in presence of

John Treat of New Milford, liberated his " Negroman named Mingo by virtue of the laws of this State," July 3, 1781, and the act was duly accepted by the Selectmen, on the 23d of July, 1 78 1, and recorded.

Davis Baldwin was bom in New Milford Aug. 8, 1777, where he resided until a short time before his marriage, the home of his father, Isaac Baldwin, being in the vicinity of Northville. His father was in the battle of Danbury in the Revolution ; was a carpenter and farmer.

Provenance

Text from History of the Towns of New Milford and Bridgewater, Connecticut, 1703-1882, published 1882, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive. The settlements listed against this township are matched by point-in-polygon test of each Geographic Names Information System coordinate against the Census Bureau's county subdivision boundary, not by name.