| November 2002 | Tornado (F1) | Hartford City | 3 hurt, $250,000 | This tornado touched down 5 miles southwest of Hartford City and then moved into Hartford City before lifting. An NWS ground survey found F0 to F1 damage along its path with F1 damage to a supermarket and a motel. One home and 2 mobile homes were destroyed in Hartford City. 3 persons were injured, none seriously. |
| June 2011 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | $50,000 | Emergency management officials reported numerous trees and tree limbs down throughout Hartford City. Windows were blown out on some of the downtown businesses. |
| August 1998 | Flash Flood | Hartford City | $50,000 | NUMEROUS COUNTY ROADS WERE FLOODED ALONG WITH AGRICULTURAL LAND. |
| August 2007 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | $25,000 | Numerous trees, tree limbs and power lines down across the city and parts of the county. At least one tree fell onto an unoccupied vehicle. Winds were estimated by spotters at around 80 mph. |
| May 2000 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | $20,000 | Three homes damaged by fallen trees. Many other trees down. |
| June 2005 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | $15,000 | A one foot diameter tree limb and as a billboard were blown down north of Hartford City. Trees were reported down south through southwest of Montpelier. |
| July 2007 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | $10,000 | Several trees and power lines were down south of Hartford City. |
| June 1997 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | $5,000 | no account filed |
| March 2026 | Hail | Hartford City | $1,000 | Photo on Facebook shows hail up to 1.5 inches in diameter. |
| March 2026 | Hail | Hartford City | $1,000 | no account filed |
| April 2024 | Hail | Hartford City | - | The public submitted several pictures and reports of hail up to at least the size of quarters in and around Hartford City. |
| March 2022 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | The public reported trees were blown down. |
| July 2018 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Trained spotters reported a partially rotten tree was blown down. |
| March 2017 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | A trained spotter reported wind gusts to 60 mph along with hail of unknown size covering the road. |
| July 2015 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Several trees and power lines down in town. |
| July 2015 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Tree blocking State Road 3 in Hartford City. |
| July 2013 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | A trained spotter reported a tree was uprooted, with several large tree limbs blown down. |
| November 2013 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Emergency management officials reported trees and power lines down across the county. No significant damage was reported. |
| June 2012 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Emergency management officials reported three to five foot trees blown down across the county. Windows were blown in at several residences across the county as well as roof damage to barns. Siding was ripped off several buildings and welcome signs in town were blown over. |
| August 2011 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | A trained spotter estimated wind gusts to 60 mph. |
| August 2011 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Trained spotters reported estimated wind gusts of at least 60 mph. |
| August 2011 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Several trees and power lines were reported down in Hartford City as well as through the county. |
| August 2010 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Law enforcement officials reported numerous trees were blown down. |
| July 2006 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Large tree blown down across county road 800 east, south of State Route 26. |
| January 2005 | Flash Flood | Hartford City | - | Homes flooded in Hartford City. State Route 26 closed at County Road 200 E due to 4 to 5 feet of water over the intersection. The flash flooding occurred as a result of heavy rain and rapid snow melt. |
| May 2005 | Hail | Hartford City | - | Hail was reported ranging from nickel to the size of quarters. |
| June 2005 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Trees down in parts of the county, between Hartford City and Montpelier. |
| May 2004 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Emergency management reported trees down in Hartford City. |
| July 2003 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Law enforcement reported trees and power lines down south of Hartford City. |
| July 2002 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Law enforcement reported power lines down southeast of Hartford City. |
| September 2002 | Tornado (F1) | Hartford City | - | NWS officials reported the tornado touched down and lifted numerous times along the path. This tornado was produced by the same parent supercell that produced several tornadoes in the Indianapolis WFO CWA. Most of the damage occurred as it passed through Hartford City. A building at Ag Best, a fertilizer plant, was torn apart. Vehicles were also damaged at this business. The 4-H building suffered damage to its south and east sides. Numerous reports of trees and power lines were noted along the track, with trees falling down across from Southside school in Hartford City. |
| April 2001 | Hail | Hartford City | - | Golfball size hail reported across the county. |
| April 2001 | Hail | Hartford City | - | Power lines down. |
| August 2001 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Several large limbs down. |
| August 2001 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Large limbs down with some blocking road. |
| September 2001 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Two power poles and power lines blown down. |
| June 2000 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Trees and power lines down. |
| June 1999 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Several large branches and trees were blown down. |
| June 1999 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | Numerous trees and power lines were blown down along State Road 26. |
| July 1998 | Flash Flood | Hartford City | - | RESIDENCES FLOODED. WATER 1 TO 2 FEET DEEP ON ROADS WITH STALLED VEHICLES. |
| July 1998 | Hail | Hartford City | - | HAIL JUST NORTH OF CITY ALONG WITH TREES DOWN. |
| June 1998 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | NUMEROUS TREES DOWN ACROSS COUNTY |
| July 1998 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | NUMEROUS TREES AND POWER LINES DOWN THROUGHOUT COUNTY. |
| March 2026 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| March 2026 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| April 2026 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| April 2011 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| April 2011 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| May 2011 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| May 2011 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| May 2005 | Thunderstorm Wind | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| May 2005 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| May 2005 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| November 2005 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| May 2004 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| August 2003 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| March 2003 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| April 2001 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| April 2001 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |
| June 1999 | Hail | Hartford City | - | no account filed |