Nomination for Fenwick Club Annex

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

Congressional District: 2 Donald D. Clancy Form 10-300 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR NATIONAL PARK SERVICE INVENTORY - NOMINATION FORM FOR NPS USE ONLY (Type all entries - complete applicable sections) AND/ OR HISTORIC: 426 E. Fifth Street 3. CLASSIFICATION - In Process - Preservation work PRESENT USE (Check One or More as Appropriate) - Transportation - Comments OWNER'S NAME: Archdiocese of Cincinnati,St. Louis Chancery, 29E.8th [5.

LOCATION OF LEGAL DESCRIPTION COURTHOUSE, REGISTRY OF DEEDS, ETC: DEPOSITORY FOR SURVEY RECORDS: 039 Hamilton Religious DATE STATE Commercial ACCESSIBLE Military Government LOCATION Both Social District Site Restricted OWNERSHIP CATEGORY NAME Agricultural Educational Cincinnati Unoccupied Private Being Considered Scientific Yes: STATUS CODE Public Museum Park REGISTER COUNTY Industrial Entertainment Cincinnati City Hall Structure Hamilton County Court House COMMON: Private Residence 061 Fenwick Club Annex NATIONAL NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES Public Acquisition: Court and Main Streets REPRESENTATION IN EXISTING SURVEYS Paul F.

Leibold, Arch Bishop of Cincinnati STREET AND NUMBER: ENTRY NUMBER OWNER OF PROPERTY Ohio TITLE OF SURVEY: CITY OR TOWN: 80l Plum Street TO THE PUBLIC DATE OF SURVEY: Other (Specify) Object (Check One) 1972 (July 1969) * Local Federal Building DESCRIPTION - Deteriorated - Unexposed I Unaltered - Moved [X Original Site Tuscan columns, entablature, and cast iron balustrade. The SEP 1 1972 CONDITION REGISTER Ruins NATIONAL physical connection to the club.

This is a three story masonry building, rectangular in the entrance.The entrance is marked by a portico with Roman a mansard roof which has dormers and a central gable over result of a remodeling, this entrance opens into a wide corri- Spirit, sometimes known as Fenwick Chapel because of its dor which leads directly to the main club building.To the right of the annex building is the Chapel of the Holy (Check One) X Excellent plan, with a stone foundation and brick with limestone banding RECEIVED above the foundation.There is a decorative cornice below Good S RAM PERIOD (Check One or More as Appropriate) X 19th Century - Prehistoric Religion/Phi- Conservation : STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Statement of significance

Erected about 1885, this building serves as offices for the Fenwick Club, a Catholic organization that provides living quarters, social, recreational, and cultural activi- Named for Edward Fenwick, first Bishop of the Cincinnati 1915 under the patronage of MT. Rev. Henry Moeller, D.D., SEP 1 1972 Commerce Military Communications Engineering losophy Architecture Aboriginal Education SIGNIFICANCE Transportation REGISTER NATIONAL Science ing. Agriculture Literature itarian Music Landscape Industry Sculpture Pre-Columbian twentieth century adaption of a Victorian apartment build- ties to area Catholics in an adjoining nine story building.

Urban Planning Political Theater Diocese and founder of the Dominican Order in the United Invention States, the club was founded by Rev.Charles E.Baden in present site in 19i8 upon completion of the nine story RECEIVED 1918-19=-Fenwick Club club made its home at 3i9 Broadway, but it moved to its (main building) Other (Specify) K Social/Human- SPECIFIC DATE(S) (If Applicable and Known) AREAS OF SIGNIFICANCE (Check One or More as Appropriate) Art structure.The annex building is a good example of a 1880's--annex building the third Archbishop of Cincinnati.For a short while the

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

MAJOR BIBLIOGRAPHICAL REFERENCES 10. GEOGRAPHICAL DATA DEFINING THE CENTER POINT OF A PROPERTY DEFINING A RECTANGLE LOCATING THE PROPERTY OF LESS THAN TEN ACRES STATE LIAISON OFFICER CERTIFICATION As the designated State Liaison Officer for the Na- I hereby certify that this property is included in the tional Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (Public Law 89-665), I hereby nominate this property for inclusion in the National Register and certify that it has been evaluated to the criteria and procedures set GP 0 901.087 ATTEST LONGITUDE Name LATITUDE DATE Local COUNTY Cincinnati National ORGANIZATION Dayton Street STATE CORNER Its Neighbors. CODE Writers' Program of the Work Projects Administration in the Degrees Minutes Seconds NATIONAL REGISTER VERIFICATION LATITUDE AND LONGITUDE COORDINATES National Register. NAME AND TITLE: Rev. John H.

Lawoat, S.T.D., History of the Archdiocese of STREET AND NUMBER: level of significance of this nomination is: FORM PREPARED BY CITY OR TOWN: December, 1971 APPROXIMATE ACREAGE OF NOMINATED PROPERTY: less than forth by the National Park Service. The recommended State of Ohio, Cincinnati, A Guide to the Queen City and Degrees Seconds 039 Minutes Title Miami Purchase Association Ohio (Frederick Pustet Company, 192l). EDITORIAL REVIEW Federal Register entry _ ARCHEOLOGIST KEEPER Maps TECH REVIEW Acknowledge Re-submit Send-back Photos BRANCH CHIEF Working number National Register write-up 9.1.72.1378 Photos CHIEF, BRANCH OF REGISTRATION THIS FOICI IS TO BE FILED WITH THE NATIONAL RECISTER NOMINATION. KEEPER OTHER CONTROL DATE TECHNICAL REMOVE DECREASE ATTEST: INCREASE Maps BOUNDARY REVISION HISTORIAN State notified This property is removed from the National Register.

BRANCH CHIEF ADP Federal Register Control Cards KEEPER OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER Demo REVIEW UNIT CHIEF I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS BOUNDARY REVISION IS ACCEPTED ARCHEOLCGST NOVE State OH.HamltuM working Number Property Fenwick Cub Amney PROPERTY OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER Loc. HAMilONOhio County, State Fenwick Club Annex Hamilton, OH Nomination Form X_ Photographs (#1) USGS Map 73001458 Reference Number Property Name Missing Core Documentation The following Core Documentation is missing from this entry: COVINGTON QUADRANGLE UNITED STATES GEOLOGICAL SURVEY ROAD CLASSIFICATION DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR STATE OF KENTUCKY 7.5 MINUTE SERIES (TOPOGRAPHIC) UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY COVINGTON.KY.-OHIO SHEET NO.335 CINCINNATI OHIO HAMILTON COUNTY METROPOLITAN AREA METROPOLITAN TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY CITY OF CINCINNATI AND HAMILTON COUNTY Long.

84° 'Form 10-301 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR (July 1969) COUN TYT FOR NPS USE ONLY STREET AND NUM BER: SEP 1 1972 TO BE INCLUDED ON ALL MAPS 1. Property broundaries where required. 2. North arrow. 3. Latitude and longitude reference. 1954 039 Hamilton MAR NAME STATE 061 DATE REQUIREMENTS REGISTER NATIONAL Cincinnati 1:2400 CODE COMMON: ENTRY NUMBER SCALE: MAP REFERENCE SOURCE: NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES PROPERTY MAP FORM NATIONAL PARK SERVICE AND/OR HISTORIC: 426 E. Fifth Street CITY OR TOWN: Ohio LOCATION (Type all entries-attach to or enclose with map) 1972 Metropolitan Topographic Survey Fenwick Club Annex Story Mound State Memorial Chi1licothe Hami1ton County Waldschmidt-Camp Dennison District Mr. Danlel R. Porter, Director Columbus, Ohio 43211 Hon. Donald D.

Clancy Location 1973 STATE PHR Name Date Entered 3/12/73 NRowland:mm ENTRIES IN THE NATIONAL REGISTER Cincinnati Also Notified The Ohio Historical Society Director, Northeast Region Scarlet Oaks State Liaison Officer Hon. William B. Saxbe Lloyd (John Uri) House Ross County Hon. Robert Taft, J. Fenwick Club Annex Hon. William H. Harsha the ohio historical society/ohio historical center/columbus, ohio 432ll/ telephone (614) 469-4663 June 25, 1973 Mr. Jerry Rogers 18th and C Streets, N.W. Washington, D. C. 20240 Dear Mr. Rogers: Ohio Canal Groundbreaking Site, Ohio Route 79, Heath, Cleveland Grays Armory, 1234 Bolivar Road, Cleveland, the city of Cleveland. We have enclosed a continuation Resor, William, House, 254 Greendale Avenue, Cincinnati, Goshorn, Sir Alfred T., House, 3540 Clifton Avenue, Cincinnati, Ohio, Hamilton County. Mr. Prentner and Mr.

Alexander, Jr., listed as owners, have sold the property to Dr. Cyril E. Schrimpf, 3540 Clifton Avenue, - Fenwick Club Annex, 426 E. Fifth St., Cincinnati, Leibold, Archbishop of Cincinnati. Mr. Leibold Cincinnati. your records. National Park Service Presbyterian Church (Congregational-Presbyterian Church) sheet also corrects some misinformation in the form as it was sent to Washington. Department of the Interior sheet with additional information about the armory National Register of Historic Places In the past few months we have been informed of some errors which have read Joe Prentner. location and with latitude and longitude listed. listed them below and we would appreciate having the changes made on The location on the map and the latitude and longitude are Interstate 7l and 17th Avenue near Ohio Routes 5 & 7, Kinsman, Ohio, Trumbull County. Ohio, Licking County.

Ohio, Hamilton County. Alexander, Jr. and Joe Prenter. The last name should concern properties which have been placed on the Register.I have Village of Heath;it should be the City of Heath. The owner is listed as the are any questions, please contact us. enclosures Sincerely, Thank you for your assistance in making these corrections.If there as the Archdiocese of Cincinnati at the address given. died recently and the owner should be simply listed JK/g1k Judith Kitchen Architectural Historian We regret the errors and apologize for the sloppy job done on the forms. Ohio Historic Preservation Office Ohio Historical Center I-71& 17th Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43211 (614) 466-1500 Carol Schull National Register of Historic Preservation Washington, D.C. 20243 Pinkham, Andrew, Farm, Bantam Vicinity, Clemont County; demolished by the Louisville District, Corps of Engineers, U.S.

Army, in December 1980. Sauer-Watson House, Defiance, Defiance County; demolished by owner in Two buildings within the Lytle Park Historic District, Cincinnati, Hamilton County; buildings identified as 27 and 29 on the district map have been Cincinnati Congregation of the Children of Israel, Beni Israel (also Allen Temple), Cincinnati, Hamilton County;demolished by Proctor and Gamble in 1980. Wilbur, J. B., House, Property #5 in Wellington-Huntington Road Multiple Resource Area, Wellington Vicinity, Lorain County; demolished by the Ohio Phillipps, Henry, House, Toledo, Lucas County; burned to the ground in Germantown Covered Bridge, Germantown, Montgomery County; after an end W430 Acting Keeper Department of the Interior November 1980. renominating it to the National Register. I regret to inform you of the demolition of the following National Register of May 1981.

post was kmocked out by a motorist in February 1981, the bridge collapsed Historic Places properties during the past year. July 6, 1981 Department of Natural Resources in December 1980. Daniel Dell Building). Dear Ms. Schull: demolished by the owners in 198l.Located on East Fifth Street these buildings were known as the Fenwick Club and Annex and the Olman Realty . Carol Schull on June 13, 1981. Cascade House, Nelson Township, Portage County; demolished by the Ohio Elwell, Augustus, House, Braceville Vicinity, Trumbull' County; removed samet prior to April 1980. W. Ray Luce WRL/DAS: dr Sincerely, State Historic Preservation Officer editions of the Federal Register. Exchange Hotel, Cardington, Morrow County; destroyed in a major tornado Department of Natural Resources in February 1980.

1ly 6, 1981 TELEPHONE REPORT DIVISION: 7A PHONE: REPORT: OFFICE OF ARCHEOLOGY AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION DATE: Ohio Historic Preservation Office Ms. Carol Shull, Acting Keeper Department of Interior W 430 in our original submission, we are satisfied that all elements of these structures new structure. Enclosed is a copy of a newsletter with additional information. certify that a property has been demolishedor has lost those characteristics We do not have the staff or time to notify owners or obtain owner's consent for We appreciate your consideration of these revisions and look forward with you to the publication of the National Register regulations. W. Ray Luce State Historic Preservation Officer WRL :vb X.c: Rodney Little integrity.

Sincerely, Enclosure September 22, 1981 Peter King Reconstruction may be possible in this case, but the extent and degree of changes demolitions and notify owners and document a case for removal due to lost of On the other hand, in most cases, newspaper articles or demolition photographs have been completely eliminated from their original sites through demolition, National Register of Historic Places the National Register. We are also concerned that the documentation requirements any possibility of rebuilding the structure:the Germantown Covered Bridge. for alternations, but frankly do not see any need to notify owmers of properties fire or some other means of removal. In only one case, as we noted, is there the Register will soon contain numerous properties which do not exist. which have already occurred will require a reassessment and renomination of the are not available.

We urge that the regulations be changed to allow a SHPO to Washington, D.C. 20243 This is in response to your recent request for additional information on ten We can see a need to notify owners before properties are removed from the Register which have been completely demolished that their property will be removed from to be certain that a property has been completely demolished before delisting it. Fenwick Club NATIONAL PARK SERVICE WASHINGTON, D.C.

20240 IN REPLY REFER TO: MAR - 3 1982 Dear State Historic Preservation Officer: In accordance with the interim regulations 36 CFR Part 60.15, properties cannot be removed from the National Register until the State Historic Preservation Offieer has notified the affected owner(s) and chief local elected officials and given them an We have been notified about a number of properties that should be removed from the Register cannot proceed with the removal of properties listed on the attached sheet until you have informed us that the necessary notification requirements have been satisfied. for owners and officials to comment on the proposed removal.

A removal petition must set forth the reasons why a property should be removed on the listing in the National Register because the qualities which caused it to be originally and prior to listing; (2) additional information shows that the property does not meet the submitted by the Federal Preservation Officer. Petitions should include the SHPO's If you need further information or assistance, please let us know. We appreciate your cooperation in this matter. Sincerely, Register nomination or listing process. Carol D. Shull United States Department of the Interior grounds established in the regulations.Grounds for removal of properties from.the National Register which have not undergone notification procedures.

The National National Register are as follows: (1) the property has ceased to meet the criteria for National Register criteria for evaluation;(3) error in professional judgment as to whether opportunity to comment. We suggest, although the regulations do not require it, that you provide at least 30 days Acting Keeper of the National opinion on whether the property should be removed based on the appropriate ground. listed have been lost or destroyed, or such qualities were lost subsequent to nomination the property meets the criteria for evaluation; or(4) prejudicial procedural error in the properties from the National Register, but the petitions are submitted by the State Historic Preservation Officer except for those pertaining to Federal properties which are from the National Register only on the first ground.

Please note that any person, Properties listed in the National Register prior to December 13, 1980,may be removed organization or State Historic Preservation Officer may petition for the removal of Pinkham, Andrew Farm, Clermont County Sauer-Watson House, Defiance County Fenwick Club and Annex, 01man Realty (Daniel Dell Building), Lytle Park Historic District, Hamilton County Wilbur, J.B., House, Property #5 in Wellington-Huntington Road Multiple Resource Multiple Area, Lorain County Phillipps, Henry, House, Lucas County Germantown Covered Bridge, Montgomery County Exchange Hotel, Morrow County Elwell, Augustus, House, Trumbull County Hamilton County Cincinnati Congregation of the Children of Israel, Beni Israel, Cascade House, Portage County OHIO