Nomination for Hay-McKinney and Bingham-Hanna House

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

Form No. 10-300 (Rev. 10-74) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES JUN 1 8 1976 INVENTORY -- NOMINATION FORM DATE ENTERED SEE INSTRUCTIONS IN HOW TO COMPLETE NATIONAL REGISTER FORMS TYPE ALL ENTRIES -- COMPLETE APPLICABLE SECTIONS AND/OR COMMON STREET & NUMBER _NOT FOR PUBLICATION CITY, TOWN CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT - VICINITY OF 21 - Louis Stokes PRESENT USE STRUCTURE -WORK IN PROGRESS _PRIVATE RESIDENCE ENTERTAINMENT XYES: RESTRICTED IN PROCESS GOVERNMENT -BEING CONSIDERED - YES: UNRESTRICTED OWNER OF PROPERTY LOCATION OF LEGAL DESCRIPTION REGISTRY OF DEEDS, ETC.

REPRESENTATION IN EXISTING SURVEYS DEPOSITORY FOR SURVEY RECORDS 035 039 CODE DATE BOTH TITLE LOCATION Ohio ACCESSIBLE Cleveland CLASSIFICATION OWNERSHIP Cuyahoga County Building STATE RELIGIOUS TRANSPORTATION HISTORIC MILITARY NAME INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT CATEGORY AGRICULTURE DATA SHEET SITE PARK PUBLIC 1219 Ontario STATUS Western Reserve Historical Society 10825 East Boulevard PUBLIC ACQUISITION OTHER: BUILDING(S) _SCIENTIFIC COURTHOUSE, _UNOCCUPIED -EDUCATIONAL _COMMERCIAL XMUSEUM _OBJECT PHO368822 RECEIVED JUN 3 0 1975 - FEDERAL STATE COUNTY _LOCAL Cuyahoga XPRIVATE X ORIGINAL SITE UNALTERED GOOD RUINS _MOVED DATE. DESCRIBE THE PRESENT AND ORIGINAL (IF KNOWN) PHYSICAL APPEARANCE

Description of the property

carver John Herkimer, the staircase was made for an 1875 residence museum, with many of the rooms furnished in various period styles. CONDITION UNEXPOSED (continued) DESCRIPTION DETERIORATED This is a pair of houses in the Second Renaissance Revival style, pedimented frame and an elaborate ornamental iron grill. A two-story feature is a long carved walnut staircase. Carved by Bavarian wood- FAIR east house. It also has a hipped tile roof which conceals the third story. has seven bays, the first story ones being arched and the second story roof.The cornice frieze is a delicate shallow relief of Greek fretwork.

which terminates on the north with a columned ambulatory.The garden ation.The chief interior feature is a two-story hall which opened from facade of the house has a center arched entrance, a second story of more correctly Renaissance in style.They contain paneled wooden ceil- and a breakfast room with a charming vaulted ceiling painted in the masonry construction.Its aspect is generally more sombre than the The house to the west isa large three-story mansion of limestone five arched windows and a third story of smaller square windows. The interior rooms open from a large entrance hall whose main ones rectangular, with an iron balcony on console brackets before each Ionic colonnaded bay with an iron roof railing.

The north elevation of XEXCELLENT XALTERED Its basic form is rectangular, and it has three bays on the south elev- one.The third story is concealed on the facade by a great tile hipped the house is U-shaped.It faces a formal garden in the Italian style, on Euclid Avenue and incorporated into this house in 19o8.The stair- On the east elevation there is a projecting wing with a semi-circular The wings of the "u' have several tiered tile roofs. CHECK ONE aporte-cochere on the west.There is a formal U-shaped staircase with brought from the older house.At present the house serves as a histor- style of Roman mosaic,and fresco.The.hall opens onto the original a rear servants' wing where some of the door casings were also wing on the north of the building housed servants' quarters and garages.

DATE formal garden on the east, which is flanked by balustraded walks and ceiling consists of shallow groined vaults. The rooms of this house are case ceiling is a sloping barrel vault in the Renaissance style.The a wide landing framed by massive composite columns in this hall.The connected bya modern museum wing.The house to the east is a large terminated bya fountain.The garden entrance of the house hasa AREAS OF

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

SIGNIFICANCE -- CHECK AND JUSTIFY BELOW -COMMUNITY PLANNING CONSERVATION SCIENCE XSOCIAL/HUMANITARIAN MUSIC PHILOSOPHY POLITICS/GOVERNMENT _OTHER (SPECIFY) SPECIFIC DATES 1908; 1918 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Statement of significance

Garfield, son of President Garfield, an important Cleveland architect In 1938 the Hay-Mc Kinney house was acquired by the Western wing in 1959. Architecturally, the Hay wing is a fine example of the early 1800-1899 1700-1799 1600-1699 1500-1599 1400-1499 EDUCATION ECONOMICS ART BUILDER/ARCHITECT RELIGION SIGNIFICANCE PERIOD ARCHEOLOGY-HISTORIC EXPLORATION/SETTLEMENT AGRICULTURE academic eclecticism. INDUSTRY SCULPTURE PREHISTORIC MILITARY LITERATURE The Hanna wing, as it is called, is a more academic eclectic essay X1900- earlier and more generalized classic revival and a later and more specific XARCHITECTURE ARCHEOLOGY-PREHISTORIC in the sixteenth century Florentine Renaissance style.Together the two residences still represent the classical ideals of the Renaissance library collections.The houses were connected by the harmonizing their intelligent maintenance as museum houses.

Architecturally they are related but illustrate the difference between the Reserve Historical Society for use as its museum building.In l940 Walker and Gillette _COMMUNICATIONS _TRANSPORTATION and Gillette, specialists in suburban residence work and also designers revival, especially with their formal gardens, interior integrity, and Abram Garfield; The west house was built for Harry Payne Bingham, brother of C.Hanna and her son Leonard C. Hanna, Jr.,philanthropist and nephew _ENGINEERING inhabited by families of considerable importance in the history of Cleveland. of Marcus A.Hanna.The architects were the New York firm of Walker of several New York banks.

_COMMERCE _THEATER anda member of the Group Plan committee.Mrs.Hay never actually - INVENTION The east house was built in l9o8 for Mrs.John Hay after the death This pair of mansions was built within a span of ten years and was - LAW steel manufacturer. Frances Payne Bolton, in 1918. It was later occupied by Mrs. Leonard twentieth century classic revival, executed by a first rank architect. lived in the house, and it was acquired by Price McKinney, a Cleveland the Bingham-Hanna house was also acquired by the Society for its

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

MAJOR BIBLIOGRAPHICAL REFERENCES Society (Cleveland, 1942), 13-27. 10 GEOGRAPHICAL DATA ACREAGE OF NOMINATED PROPERTY VERBAL BOUNDARY DESCRIPTION STATE - FORM PREPARED BY Eric Johannesen, Preservationist : May 1975 STREET & NUMBER CITY OR TOWN 12 STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER CERTIFICATION THE EVALUATED SIGNIFICANCE OF THIS PROPERTY WITHIN THE STATE NATIONAL - As the designated State Historic Preservation Officer for the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (Public Law 89-665).

I WE SIGNATURE DATE June 16,, 1975 FOR NPS USE ONLY | HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS PROPERTY IS INCLODED IN THE NATIONAL REGISTER ORGANIZATION 216-721-5722 CODE DATE TELEPHONE NORTHING Cleveland COUNTY EASTING NAME/TITLE ZONE Ohio Five acres UTM REFERENCES State Historic Preservation Officer Elbert Jay Benton, A Short History of the Western Reserve Historical hereby nominate this property for inclusion in the National Register and certify that it has been evaluated according to the 630, 961. LOCAL . [4,519.517,2.0 William Ganson Rose, Cleveland: The Making of a City (Cleveland, 1950), LIST ALL STATES AND COUNTIES FOR PROPERTIES OVERLAPPING STATE OR COUNTY BOUNDARIES ATTEST: Western Reserve Historical Society 10825 East Boulevard 414,910501 Form No. 10-300a (Rev.

10-74) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE RECEIVED JUN 3 0 1975 NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES JUN 1 8 1976 INVENTORY -- NOMINATION FORM DATE ENTERED CONTINUATION SHEET ITEM NUMBER 7 PAGE 1 extensive antique automobile collections of the Crawford Auto Aviation Mus eum. one which contains the main entrance to the whole group, and two removed and replaced by the connecting link of a second modern west side of the west house, the original porte-cochere has been smaller ones at the points where the wing joins the houses. On the and planned to harmonize in exterior design with the Renaissance wing added in 1965.This is a large rectangular windowless structure Hay, Mrs. John, and Hanna, Leonard C., Jr., Houses faced with limestone to harmonize with the house.It contains the The two houses are connected by a museum wing built in 1959 Form No.

10-300a (Rev. 10-74) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES JUN 1 8 1976 INVENTOR Y -- NOMINATION FORM DATE ENTERED CONTINUATION SHEET Hay/ McKinney and Bingham/Hanna Houses glazed fanlight, and is approached by a short flight of steps. The center elevations are articulated by slender vertical piers and paneling, and The eclectic interiors are virtually unaltered, and in the case interior. the additions. of location, design, materials, workmanship, feeling and association. As the entire group cannot be encompassed in one photograph, distinctive characteristics of an architectural type and period; they possess high artistic value; and they possess a high degree of integrity connects with the Auto-Aviation Museum.Entrance canopy on Hay House removed.

the corners are recessed to relieve the massiveness of the structure. character of the houses has been preserved through adaptive use. and connects to the west house.

entrance hall is a rear wing which surrounds the original Hanna garden removal of the porte-cochere on the west house at the point where it ship of the two houses, they have not materially altered the individual Although the museum additions have changed the original relation- The central museum wing has a large arched entranceway with a Both of the houses fulfill the National Register criteria: they are living in a remarkable manner.Also significant is the way the essential of the Hay House, have been enhanced by their adaptation as museum settings.The formal gardens of both houses are maintained ina the west house by a lobby with a glass facade.The stone-faced wall The second museum addition is a one-story building connected to pavilion has a hipped roof to harmonize with the houses.Behind the structural integrity of each one.The only major alteration has been the ITEM NUMBER RECEIVED MAY 2 7 1976 PAGE manner which conveys the quality of early 2oth century upper-class the accompanying rendering gives the best impression of the effect of associated with the lives of significant persons;they embody the Form No.

10-300a UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES JUN 1 8 1976 INVENTORY -- NOMINATION FORM DATE ENTERED ITEM NUMBER CONTINUATION SHEET Hay/ McKinney and Bingham/Hanna Houses Mus eum 1. Hay House 3. Hanna Hous e 4. Hanna Garden 5. Central Addition (1959) 6. Auto-Aviation Museum (1965) Auto North Entrance PAGE 2. Hay Garden Schematic Drawing (not a Measured Drawing) (Rev. 10-74) Hay, Mrs. John, and Hanna, Leonard Gry Jr., Houses Photos Inventory - Re-submit 5.27. 76 OTHER HAER CONTROL KEEPER ARCHEOLOGIST Review Federal Register Entry BRANCH CHIEF State Property National Register Write-up REVIEW UNIT CHIEF ARCHITECTURAL HISTORIAN 6.30.75 Send-back 8.1. 75 CONF. Ter Working Number 6, 30.

25.1202 Maps TECHNICAL INT:2106-74 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service WAso No.7 Inventory - JUN 1 8 1976 6.30.75.1202 Entered TECHNICAL OTHER KEEPER Send-back Maps HAER HISTORIAN Re-submit Review Ohio CONTROL Working Number Federal Register Entry SECOND CONTROL SHEET National Register Write-up BRANCH CHIEF REVIEW UNIT CHIEF State United States Department of the Interior National Park Service WAso No.7 6.11.76 IN T:2106- 74 Hay-McKinney and Bingham-Hanna Houses 2-6-76 6.18.26 DOE JUN 1 8 1976 NPS Number PROPERTY OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER OHIO Title: Form No. 10-301a (Pev. 10-7+) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR NATIONAL PARK SERVICE JUN 3 0 1975 NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPH FORM JUN 1 8 1976 SEE INSTRUCTIONS IN HOW TO COMPLETE NATIONAL REGISTER FORMS AND/OR COMMON VICINITY OF COUNTY Cuyahoga CITY.

TOWN Cleveland STATE Ohio PHOTO REFERENCE DATE OF PHOTO NEGATIVE FILED AT DESCRIBE VIEW. DIRECTION, ETC. IF DISTRICT, GIVE BUILDING NAME & STREET PHOTO NO. 1 Hanna House, west and south elevations, looking northeast. May 1975 LOCATION HISTORIC RECEIVED NAME Western Reserve Historical Society IDENTIFICATION PHOTO CREDIT Eric Johannesen Hay, Mrs. John, and Hanna, Leonard C., Jr., Houses DATE ENTERED FOR NPS USE ONLY JUN 1 8 1976 PROPERTY OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER Loc. NPS Number Form No. 10-301a (Pev. 10-74) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE JUN 3 0 1975 NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPH FORM JUN 1 8 1976 DATE ENTERED AND/OR COMMON VICINITY OF COUNTY Cuyahoga PHOTO REFERENCE DATE OF PHOTO DESCRIBE VIEW. DIRECTION. ETC. IF DISTRICT, GIVE BUILDING NAME & STREET Hay House, south and east elevations, looking northwest.

LOCATION Hay, Mrs. John, and Hanna, Leonard C., Jr., Houses STATE Ohio May 1975 RECEIVED HISTORIC Western Reserve Historical Society IDENTIFICATION NAME PHOTO NO SEE INSTRUCTIONSIN HOW TO COMPLETE NATIONAL REGISTER FORMS NEGATIVE FILED AT TYPE ALL ENTRIES ENCLOSE WITH PHOTOGRAPH JUN 1 8 1976 Loc. OHIO looking E Form No. 10-301a (Pev. 10-7%) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPH FORM JUN 1 8 1976 DATE ENTERED SEE INSTRUCTIONS IN HOW TO COMPLETE NATIONAL REGISTER FORMS AND/OR COMMON VICINITY OF PHOTO REFERENCE DATE OF PHOTO DESCRIBE VIEW. DIRECTION, ETC. IF DISTRICT, GIVE BUILDING NAME & STREET 1ooking east. Hanna and Hay Houses, showing 1959 connecting wing, Ohio IDENTIFICATION HISTORIC LOCATION STATE NAME Hay, Mrs.

John, and Hanna, Leonard C., Jr., Houses Western Reserve Historical Society May 1975 PHOTO NO. NEGATIVE FILED AT JUN 1 8 1976 Form No. 10-301a (Pev. 10-7%) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE JUN 8 0 1975 NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPH FORM JUN 1 8 1976 DATE ENTERED SEE INSTRUCTIONS IN HOW TO COMPLETE NATIONAL REGISTER FORMS AND/OR COMMON VICINITY OF STATE Ohio PHOTO REFERENCE DATE OF PHOTO NEGATIVE FILED AT DESCRIBE VIEW. DIRECTION. ETC. IF DISTRICT. GIVE BUILDING NAME & STREET LOCATION Hanna House, garden elevation, looking west. IDENTIFICATION May 1975 Eric Johannesen NAME PHOTO CREDIT RECEIVED Western Reserve Historical Society PHOTO NO COUNTY Cuyahoga JUN 1 8 1976 PROPERTY OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER Loc. Form No. 10-301a (Pev.

10-7%) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE JUN 3 0 1975 NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPH FORM JUN 1 8 1979 DATE ENTERED SEE INSTRUCTIONS IN HOW TO COMPLETE NATIONAL REGISTER FORMS Hay, Mrs. John, and Hanna, Leonard C., Jr., Houses AND/OR COMMON _VICINITY OF COUNTY Cuya hoga STATE Ohio PHOTO REFERENCE DATE OF PHOTO NEGATIVE FILED AT DESCRIBE VIEW. DIRECTION. ETC. IF DISTRICT, GIVE BUILDING NAME & STREET LOCATION HISTORIC IDENTIFICATION RECEIVED May 1975 Western Reserve Historical Society NAME Hay House, garden elevation, looking south. PHOTO NO PHOTO CREDIT Eric Johannesen DOE JUN 1 8 1976 Ohio canopy before removal.

Hay House entrance, showing Hay and Hanna Houses Sanford Elroy Sanford MAY 2 7:1976 Sanford (Now museum Empire Room) Ohio Elroy Sanford PROPERTY OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER Hay and Hanna Houses JUN 1 8 1976 Former Music Room, Hay House Cleveland Cuyahoga JUN 1 8 1976 MAY 2 7 1976 Sanford Ohio PROPERTY OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER Elroy Sanford Hay and Hanna Houses Herkimer staircase. Hay House hall, showing 1875 JUN 1 8 1976 MAY 2 7 1976 looking North. Ohio Score of Hanna House on right, Hay and Hanna Houses Auto Museum entrance; corner PROPERTY OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER PHOTOGRAPHERS Lo to R.: Auto Museum, Hanna MAY - 7 1976 Cuyahoga House, Central addition, Hay Ohio Cleveland House. (artist's rendering) Hay and Hanna Houses Elroy Sanford W.RHS Form No. 10-301 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR NATIONAL PARK SERVICE JUN 9 0 1975 .

NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES PROPERTY MAP FORM JUN 1 8 1976 DATE ENTERED SEE INSTRUCTIONS IN HOW TO COMPLETE NATIONAL REGISTER FORMS TYPE ALL ENTRIES -- ENCLOSE WITH MAP AND/OR COMMON CITY. TOWN VICINITY OF MAP REFERENCE U. S.G. S. East Cleveland Quadrangle 1:24, 000 TO BE INCLUDED ON ALL MAPS 1. PROPERTY BOUNDARIES 2. NORTH ARROW 3. UTM REFERENCES INT: 3464 - 75 1970 Cuyahoga REQUIREMENTS Cleveland LOCATION COUNTY DATE RECEIVED Ohio NAME SOURCE STATE SCALE Western Reserve Historical Society FOR NPS USE ONLY (Rev. 10-74) HISTORIC Hay, Mrs. John., and Hanna, Leonard C., Jr.,Houses EAST CLEVELAND QUADRANGLE DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR GEOLOGICAL SURVEY EAST CLEVELAND, OHIO Hay, Mrs. John 17 449/050 East UNITED STATES 4595/720 North OHIO-CUYAHOGA CO.

N4130 - W8130/7.5 Leonard C., Jr., 2370000FET GEOLOGICAL SURVEY EAST CLEVELAND, OH MAY71976 NATIONAL DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR OHIO-CUYAHOGA CO REGIS IER CLEVELAND AUG 1 Dr. Thomas H. Smith Columbus, Ohio 43211 ) unable to evaluate the effect of the alterations and additions If you have any questions concerning the nomination, please do not (Sgd.) William J. Murtagh Regional Director, Midwest Region FNP: W Jandl:fdf 7-22-75 Enclosures H34-PR PR Mott The Ohio Historical Society Acting Director description of their appearance and a statement addressing itself additional photographs of these later structures as well as a full Hay/McKinney and Bingham/Hanna Houses in Cleveland as we were Sincerely yours, additions affect the historical and architectural integrity of the Director's Reading File Keeper of the National Register to the questions raised in the above paragraph.

If the State wishes to resubmit this property, we would appreciate Interstate 7l at 17th Avenue hesitate to call or write this office. Dear Dr. Smith: BASIC FILE RETAINED IN PR two houses. After careful consideration we are returning your nomination for the added in 1965 and the 1959 connecting museum wing and how these especially concerned about the "large rectangular windowless structure" with the documentation submitted to the National Register. We are bcc: JUN 1 8 1976 Centerville vicinity Hon. Robert Taft, Dr. Thomas H. Smith Hon. Charles W. Whalen, JI. INT: 2950-75 6/23/76 Location STATE Name MMott/row Ashland Cleveland Montgomery County Director Cuyahoga County Date Entered Regional Director, Midwest Region Ashland County Center Street Historic District Interstate 7l at 17th Avenue State Historie Preservation Officer Also Notified Hon. John M.

Ashbrook ENTRIES IN THE NATIONAL REGISTER Kellog, Ethol, House The Ohio Historical Society Hay-MeKinney and Bingham-Hanna Houses Hon. Louis Stokes OMB Approval No. 29-RO218 BER TYPE - PREAPPLICATION 19 77 (Mark ap- NOTIFICATION OF INTENT (Opt.) 4. LEGAL APPLICANT/RECIPIENT 5. FEDERAL EMPLOYER IDENTIFICATION NO. B. Applicant Name : State of Ohio : Ohio Historical Society b. Organization Unit : 1982 Velma Avenue c. Street/P.O. Box d. City : Columbus -. County : Franklin b. TITLE 8. ZIP Code: 43211 h. Contact Person (Name Thomas H. Smith, SHPO, 614-466-1500 & telephone No.) 8. TYPE OF APPLICANT/RECIPIENT John Hay & Leonard C. Hanna Houses: John I- Higher Educational Institution J- Indian Tribe F-Other (Specify) : 9. TYPE OF ASSISTANCE riate letter( 12. TYPE OF APPLICATION Cleveland, Ohio 1 million 14. CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICTS OF: 17. PROJECT B-Decrease Dollars PROJECT START d.

LOCAL 19 78 $ 16,014 20. FEDERAL AGENCY TO RECEIVE REQUEST (Name, City, State, ZIP code) 21. REMARKS ADDED Dept. of Interior Wash., D.C. 20240 a. To the best of my knowledge and balief, No re- the applicent and the applicant will comply THAT P with the attached assurances if the assist- 8. TYPED NAME AND TITLE b. SIGNATURE C. DATE SIGNED SHPO and 24. AGENCY NAME 26. ORGANIZATIONAL UNIT 27. ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE ADDRESS 31. ACTION TAKEN 33. ACTION DATE - b. REJECTED c. RETURNED FOR Stephen D. Newman - d. DEFERRED 202 523-5472 b. FEDERAL AGENCY A-95 OFFICIAL it has been or is being made.

STANDARD FORM 424 PAGE 1 (10-75) 02-006-0046 day 31-4389673W FOR 424-101 BENEFITING Year FUNDING DATE ASSIGNED ENDING CERTIFIES CONTACT ADDITIONAL TOTAL STATE Federal Wash CATION HCRS IDENTIFICATION E-Augmentation OTHER FIER Months 9,014 GRAM PROJECT RECEIVED Year month day District Historic Preservation A-New PROPOSED FUNDING REPORT OF FEDERAL ACTION A-Basic Grant SENTATIVE 7,000 STARTING E-Cancellation C-Revision Ohio CERTIFYING FEDERAL AGENCY Blank FEDERAL ASSISTANCE H-Community Action Agency (From APPLICATION CANT'S Enter appropriate letter C-Increase Duration .WITHDRAWN ance is approved. D-Insurance 19. EXISTING FEDERAL IDENTIFICATION NUMBER Renaissance revival style house of architectural C.STATE Ohio State Clearinghouse (Nane and telephone no.) A-State Same as #35 Grants Adm. Div.

REPRE- propriato B-Interstate D-Decrease Duration of then-deceased Secretary of State John Hay; and historic significance; built 1908 for wife AMENDMENT G-Special Purpose A-95 ACTION 15.TYPE OF CHANGE 12cor IDENTI- A-Increase Dollars F-Schccl District APPLI- f. Stato 10. AREA OF PROJECT IMPACT (Names of cities, counties, States, etc.) XX No are attached: true and correct, the document has been Thomas H. Smith, Director 28. FEDERAL APPLICATION DENTIFICATION [X . AWARDED Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. built to design by Abram Garfield Second D-Continuation Dept.

Leave D-County Catalog) B-Renewal C-Substate Enter appro- Year month House Development (preservation/rehabilitation) 39-8A54 data in this preapplication/application are BE SUBMITTED TO B-Supplemental Grant E-Other Response b.lf required by OMB Circular A-S5 this application was submitted, pursuant to in- county code HAY-MCKINNEY & BINGHAM-HANNA HOUSE West. Reserve Hist. Society - deteriorated -unexposed Ounexcavated ACCESS first' C RCHEOLOGY -historic- - LITERATURE-17 'oldest' O AGRICULTURE -3 - HEALTH-27 - MILITARY - 18 - INDUSTRY- - MUSIC- 19 'only' O - ART-5 EDUCATION -10 - - INVENTION - 14 - PHILOSOPHY - 20 - TRANSPORTATION - 25 Pabram garfieldn S) interior decorator: @builder/contractor: IF ADDITIONAL SPACE NEEDED.

NUMBER& PUT ON REVERSE ETHNIC ASSOCIATION INSTITUTIONAL GROUP 035 artist: XARCHITECTURE-4 OTHER NAMES MIDWEST master builder: NATIONAL REGISTER DATA SHEET 3functions 3artisan: Dmoved YOH VCUYAHOGA WESTERN RESERVE HISTORICAL SOCIEN 06-18-76 12)SOURCE of NOMINA Oruins - Unknown ]fair CLAIMS: explain - LAW- 16 - RELIGION- 22 - SETTLEMENT-29 ] COMMUNICATIONS-7 -EXPLORATION -12 - SCIENCE- 23 - URBAN PLANNING-31 - CONSERVATION - 8 - ECONOMICS-9 - SOCIAL / CULTURAL-30 SeCOND RENAISSANCE REVIVAL Dreconstrueted JARCHEOLOGY - prehistoric-2 C. Hanna, prominent plulauthropist. engineer: Xaltered Xoriginal site ENTERTAINMENT-26 historic events: ENGINEERING-11 vicinity of landscape architect/ garden designer: Xgood 1908--1918 Dexcellent NOT INTACT-O 6architectural style(s): RECREATION-28 O NOT APPLICABLE-8 architecy MUSEUM SAVED? YES BNPS REGION VCLEVELAND