Nomination for Krumm House

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

EXP. 12/31/84 National Park Service 1. Name and/or common street & number - not for publication city, town - vicinity of state Ohio _district x public _ unoccupied _ agriculture . museum - building(s) - private . commercial - structure - private residence . religious - In process X yes: restricted - government _ scientific - military -x other: vacant 4. Owner of Property Mr. Dwight Fullerton street & number 37 West Broad Street courthouse, registry of deeds, etc.

- yes x no November, 1981 - county - _ local Location both 039 Category Accessible code park educational site industrial Ownership entertainment historic object Public Acquisition Fullerton Property being considered Columbus Status Krumm Residence (7-81) county Franklin Type all entries-complete applicable sections Inventory-Nomination Form Franklin County Administration Building Present Use date entered House Ohio Historic Preservation Office 6. Representation in Existing Surveys 3. Classification National Register of Historic Places See instructions in How to Complete National Register Forms depository for survey records 5. Location of Legal Description For NPS use only United States Department of the Interior has this property been determined eligible?

4l0 South High Street transportation 975-979 South High Street NPS Form 10-900 OMB NO.1024-0018 Ohio X work in progress _federal X state date title Ohio Historic Inventory . deteriorated -unaltered - original site . ruins X altered _moved date .fair cutstone stringcourse running near top of the Ist story openings; shaped, carved stone (which include corbeling in exterior walls beneath them) and a cast iron fence which at the center of the wall, extending straight dwon from that point, perhaps originally board shutters on this wall. features remaining include: interior folding, louvered shutters in some of the rear windows, overrthe entranceway with cement steps approach, Permastone on facade foundation and porch/planter addition on front, ornamental iron railings along porch, up steps and original carved lintel over doorway- (facade and south walls) were cleaned, presumably sandblasted.

nomina Condition excellent unexposed In recent years, by previous owners, the exterior surfaces visible from the street Check one 7. Description rens along the frontage of the property and continues up street to end of block. longer proposed rehabilitation to the facade) include aluminum shutters, a painted metal hood of later wallcoverings. addition became a front entrance & stairway to the second story.Other changes to the The interior was remodeled with the conversion into a double in l9l8.Interesting today has cutout railing and square posts with carving atop on second story, and enclosed, Later cosmetic additions (traditionally insensitive and intended to be removed in with frieze windows, string course, double scroll wooden brackets and dentils.

The rear horizontal-siding with aluminum windows on first story.3) and a no-longer-existing single Describe the present and original (if known) physical appearance

Description of the property

Lintels on the south side of the house are more simplistic than those on facade, The residence was converted into double units in l9l8.At this time the southside with paneled door and enclosed frame entrance on the north side of house, 2) the enclosure shingles,1 chimney and 2 entrances on the southside with cement step approaches.An side are plain cut stone..Other original highlights are the 4 ornamental chimneys This property is one of few remaining late l9th c.residential structures scattered property at the time of that conversion include l)an exterior frame stairway escape) ofa double story frame porch on the south side of the easternmost rear addition which There is a small addition th to south side of the house and 2 rear (west) common lintels with labels and lug sills with carvedlabels running under the l/l light double side of the previous one and is only 1 stories,2x 2bays and has gable roof with slate X good is random coursed, more shallow and minus the watertable.

The building's hip roof is many as two garages were previously located to the rear of the house, but none are there now. extent date that such The central staircase in the entry was also removed.As chimneys, slate shingles and has a window in gable end.The other attaches to the west covered with original imbricated slate and projects out over an impressive entablature foundation with limestone watertable and basement openings.The rear (west) foundation hung windows. Some openings on the north and west sides are 2/2 light double hung. ceiling medallions and woodworking, and original stenciling was uncovered beneath layers leading to a cistern.

bond brick structure of Italianate character builtc.l885.It sits ona coursed stone along the once prominant s.High St.corridor of Columbus.All remaining elements of this detailing second story openings of which is a multi-paned single door) and wooden exterior gutter extends down on the west wall from the box gutters at the eaves and merges The Krumm Residence,975 South High Street, is a 2 story 6 bay X 8 bay stretcher The easternmost of these two is 2 x 2 bay, gable roofed with 2 but are shaped and have a carved "quilted"detail.LIntels on rear and north Areas of Significance - Check and justify below - prehistoric _ 1400-1499 _ archeology-historic . agriculture . sculpture - military _music X 1800-1899 .commerce - 1900- - industry * politics/government c. 1885 Columbus' City Solicitor for 2 terms from 1878 - 1883. Mr.

Krumm, a Columbus native Schwenker, Fisher, and Hartshorn." Mr. Krumm was the original owner and occupant of architectural details include an impressive entablature with freize windows, string course, double scroll brackets and dentils (metal); shaped carved stone lintels, four details inlcude interior shutters, ceiling medallions, woodwork, period mantels and 1600-1699 transportation architecture 1500-1599 education conservation communications engineering theater Period humanitarian invention science Specific dates law The property has Italianate features and reflects the German influence which along the once prominent South High Street residential corridor in Columbus. ornamental exterior chimneys, an imbricated slate roof and an iron ornamental fence. other (specify) The Krumm Residence has been listed on the Columbus Register of Historic Properties _economics 8.

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

Significance establishing his own very successful law firm, still in existence today as "Krumm, The Krumm Residence is significant for its affiliation with Alexander W.Krumm, Mayor of Columbus.After Mr.Krumm's political was committed to 1700-1799 Statement of Significance

Statement of significance

(in one paragraph) significant as one of the few remaining late l9th c. residential structures scattered social/ literature -art .exploration/settlement _ philosophy on the second floor, include narrow wood strip flooring, period mantels and woodwork. and prominent attorney began his practice in partnership with John H. Heitmann, then religion Significant exterior landscape architecture Builder/Architect Unknown for its local historical and architectural significance. predominates in the adjacent Gernam Village Historic District.S stenciling beneath layers of later wallcoverings).2oth c.details, primarily the house and his family remained in the property until 1954.The residence is also was remodeled in 1918when the house was converted into a double unit.Remaining 19th c.

*Sanborn Map, 1922 (vol.2,p.189) *Columbus Maps, 1879,1889, 1890, 1907,1937 *Interviews with Phyllis & Sam Krumm Jr. (descendants) Quadrangle scale 1:24,000 of record in Plat Book 3,p.43, Recorder's Office, Franklin County, Ohio. - state 11.

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

Form Prepared By name/title Kathy A. Mast, Historic Preservation Consultant January 15, 1982 street & number Ohio 43221 _ national 665), I hereby nominate this property for inclusion in the National Register and certify that it has been evaluated according to the criteria and procedures set forth by the National Park Service. Northing county Easting date code Columbus organization Zone Attest: title telephone614-457-3582 Chief of Registration *Columbus Building Permit Records List all states and counties for properties overlapping state or county boundaries 12. State Historic Preservation Officer Certification State Historic Preservation Officer signature Less than one acre. 9. Major Bibliographical References Acreage of nominated property UMT References 991-B Manor Lane *A Centennial History of Columbus and Franklin County, 190l, Lewis Publishing Co.,p.348-9.

city or town As the designated State Historic Preservation Officer for the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 Public Law 89- The evaluated significance of this property within the state is: I hereby certify that this property is included in the National Register 10. Geographical Data *Baist's Property Atlas, 1889, 1920. Verbal boundary description and justification Lot # 12 and 12 feet off of the south side of lot#l3 of Keeper of the National Register For NPs use only *Cal@well's Atlas,1872 *The Industries of Ohio, Columbus, 1878, Historical Quadrangle name Southeast Cols., Ohio Refugee Lands, as the same are numbered and delineated on the recorded plat of said subdivision Frederick MIchel's Subdivision of a part of half section No.29, Township No.5,Range 22, Xlocal Krumm House, Franklin County, OHIO, Fed. Reg.

Date: - RETURN - sample _ see continuation sheet _ substantive reasons discussed below Name 2. Location 3. Classification Present Use Public Acquisition Accessible 4. Owner of Property 5. Location of Legal Description 6. Representation in Existing Surveys 7. Description _ deteriorated _ unaltered _ moved resubmission dates completeness clarity REJECT Reviewer Substantive Review owner objection unexposed Action: summary paragraph Condition Ownership National Park Service alterations/integrity nomination by person or local government United States Department of the Interior ruins excellent Working No. Federal Agency: Status NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES original site Category Date Due: Cneck one good - technical corrections cited below appeal request fair Nomination returned for: boundary selection Check one 8. Significance justification of exception 9.

Major Bibliographical References 10. Geographical Data Quadrangie name - UMT Reterences 11. Form Prepared By .state - Date - context Signed completeness checked clarity Maps Photographs applicable criteria Other summary paragraph the resource 12. State Historic Preservation Officer Certification Comments for any item may be continued on an attached sheet relating significance to Specific dates Acreage of nominated property Verbal boundary description and justification State Historic Preservation Officer signature justification of areas relationship of integrity Questions concerning this nomination may be directed to Bullder Architect netional Period Columbus, Ohio 43206 Kathy A. Mast 991-B Manor Lane January, 1982 Streetscape-Northwest 975-9 South High Street KRUMM RESIDENCE Columbus, Ohio 43206 Kathy A.

Mast KRUMM RESIDENCE 975-9 South High Street 991-B Manor Lane Columbus, Ohio 43206 991-B Manor Lane Facade/South Side Detail-Northwest Kathy A. Mast 975-9 South High Street KRUMM RESIDENCE vaiuary, 1982 Columbus, Ohio 43206 January, 1982 Side (North Elevation)-Southwest KRUMM RESIDENCE 991-B Manor Lane 975-9 South High Street Kathy A. Mast 975-9 South High Street Columbus, Ohio 43206 January, 1982 KRUMM RESIDENCE Kathy A. Mast 991-B Manor Lane Columbus, Ohio 43206 January, 1982 Facade(East Elevation)Detail-West 991-B Manor Lane 975-9 South High Street KRUMM RESIDENCE Kathy A. Mast Columbus, Ohio 43206 Kathy A. Mast Rear (West Elevation)- East KRUMM RESIDENCE 975-9 South High Street 991-B Manor Lane Columbus, Ohio 43206 KRUMM RESIDENCE 975-9 South High Street Kathy A.

Mast 991-B Manor Lane Columbus, Ohio 43206 January,1982 South/West Side Detail-Northeast 975-9 South High Street 991-B Manor Lane KRURM RESIDENCE Kathy A. Mast Columbus, Ohio 43206 January,1982 975-9 South High Street South Side Detail-North 991-B Manor Lane KRUMM RESIDENCE Kathy A. Mast Columbus, Ohio 43206 Kathy A. Mast January,1982 KRUMM RESIDENCE 975-9 South High St. 991-B Manor Lane Columbus, Ohio 43206 January, 1982 Side (North Elevation)-East KRUMM RESIDENCE 975-9 South High Street Kathy A. Mast 991-B Manor Lane KRUMM RESIDENCE 975 S. High Street Kathy A. Mast 991-B Manor Lane, Cols. July 1982 Detail of original stenciling Kathy A. Mast July 1982 KRUMM RESIDENCE Detail of original stenciling 99l-B Manor Lane, Cols. 975 S. High St., Cols. OH Kathy A. Mast July 1982 KRUMM RESIDENCE Detail of original stenciling 975 S. High St., Cols. OH 99l- B Manor Lane, Cols. 975 S. High ST, Cols.

OH Kathy A. Mast July 1982 Detail of original stenciling KRUMM RESIDENCE 99l- B Manor Lane, Cols. Kathy A. Mast July 1982 Detail of original stenciling Krumm Residence 99l- B Manor Lane, cols. 975 S. High St., Cols. OH Kathy A. Mast July 1982 Detail of original stenciling KRUMM RESIDENCE 975 S. High St., Cols. OH 99l-B Manor Lane OHIO-FRANKLIN CO. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR SOUTHEAST COLUMBUS QUADRANGLE UNITED STATES SOUTHEAST COLUMBUS, OHIO Franklin County, Ohio 975 S. High Street, Col'» ROAD CLASSIFICATION Nº952 5_W82525/75 August 10, 1982 Ms. Carol Shull 440 G Street, NW Dear Ms. Shull: was approved by the state review board but I have questioned its basic Miller, Orlando, House AUG 1 6 1982 Ratterman, Bernard, House Ray Luce form.

Resubmission County; the Wright House, Hamilton County; and the Ropes Building, Cuyahoga Hamilton Churches Portage Franklin Clermont Name Stark NATIONAL New Submissions County Ropes Building Wright House Ohio Historic Preservation Office YWCA National Register of Historic Places Diver House and Storebuilding Roas-Ihhardt Farm and Winery Enclosed are ten new National Register nominations and one resbumission. Snow Houses Chief of Registration eligibility on a signed continuation sheet that is enclosed with the Krumm House We are recommending that four of the nominations receive a substantive Washington, D.C.

20240 Department of the Interior Grace Church First Reformed g First Lutheran we feel have been addressed in the nomination form.The Miller House Sincerely review: the Krumm House, Franklin County; the Miller House, Franklin Ohio Historical Center 1-71& 17th Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43211 (614) 466-1500 Hamilton County. Questions arose on the Krumm House, Ropes Buildings, Please let me know if you have any other questions. RECEVED All the appropriate notification procedures have been followed for the and Wright House during the ERTA Part 1 certification process which