Block
The nomination, in full
Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.
Columbus, Ohio 43211 1. No. 4. Present Name(s) East Broad Street Presbyterian Church 5. Other Name(s) 6. Specific Location 16. Thematic Category 28. No. of Stories 29. Basement? Yes k 760 East Broad Street 17. Date(s) or Period 30. Foundation Material 7. City or Town If Rural, Township & Vicinity 18. Style or Design 31. Wall Construction 8. Site Plan with North Arrow 19. Architect or Engineer (1908) Addition 1 Elah Terrell; Frank Packard 32. Roof Type & Material 20. Natractor or Builder Gable, Slate 33. No. of Rays Original Use, if apparent Side NA E BROAD STREET 23. Ownership Public Road? 36. Changes Private & Red 9. Coordinates in #42) 24. Owner's Name & Address, Moved O if known U.T.M. Reference 25. Open to 38. Preservation Site O Structure O Object O 26. Local Contact Person or Organization 39. Endangered? 11. On National By What? 27. Other Surveys in Which Included 13.
Part of Estab. Yes O District 40. Visible from Hist. Dist.? 41. Distance from and 12'; 420' 42. Further Description of Important Features An irregularly-massed Richardsonian Romanesque structure, with a voissoirs. Interior main sanctuary contains Tiffany windows within a shallow barrel-vaulted space in a Roman cross plan; a small chapel is north of the main sanctuary. Major alterations were made in 1907 and 1908, when, under the direction of well-known The Broad Street Presbyterian church congregation was an out-growth of the First Presbyterian church of Franklinton, the pioneer predecessor of Columbus.. Founded in 1797 by Lucas Sullivant. (2, p.1). It was begun at the " time East Broad Street was 4. Description of Environment and Outbuildings sddition to a small park to the west provide an open site for the church. 45. Sources of information 1.
Architecture Columbus, Robert Samuelson, et.al, 1976. 47. Organization K.H.Van Fossen, Date 49. Revision Date(s) 1887-1894 None Front 690.689.8197 Limestone/sandstone Underway? Long. County Northing Register? Zone Eligible? Franklin 2-1-59 Archieval Lat. Presbyterian Easting rectangular tower anchoring its southwest corner. All major openings OHIO HISTORIC INVENTORY Interior (Explain Ohio Historic Preservation Office Ohio Historical Center Resident Minister 46.Prepared by Cynthia Hunt Frontage on Road 1920-22 3. Location of Negatives FRA-442-19 (over) have a red sandstone semi-circular arch with massive radiating Lots #1,2,&3 of J.H.Anderson's subdivision Church 9/81. Columbus,Ohio 22. Present Use 35. Plan Shape Irregular Street Building *l tunity to expand ihe Presbyterian's church's influence Broad 43. History and Significance SEE ATTACHED 33089 Photo Richardsonian Romanesque Ohio 42.
continued Columbus architect Frank Packard, the church's east wall was extended and 3. 1975 Ohio Historic Inventory Form, FRA-442-19 by GHHL 4. Bill Arter, Columbus Vignettes, Vol. IV p.45 1922. architects, Elah Terrell and Frank Packard.One of the best examples of this beyond downtown Columbus"(1,p.175) The building is also significant for its with darker sandstone trim, use of round arches and dominant corner tower.Other Addition in c.1960s on north side of building. examples of the style include Orton Hall on The Ohio State University campus.(NR:7/16/70) architecture, representing Richardsonian Romanesque style by the local style in Columbus.Distinct stylistic characteristics include the light limestone the auditorium doubled in size.The Palmer Hall addition was completed in 43. continued their services. Its first service in their new, far from completed home in October, 1888.
University campus (NR: 7/16/70). . doubled in size. The Palmer Hall addition to the north was completed in 1922. Broad St. Presbyterian Church, E. Broad St. MRA, Columbus, Franklin County, Presbyterian was the moving force behind the Broad St. congregation. At that The Broad St.Presbyterian Church is significant under Criterion A as 1887 the basement had been completed and roofed in, and the congregation held Completion of both the Sanctuary and Chapel did not come until 1894,with the congregation was using the Broad St.Methodist Church (NR:11/26/80) for dedication in October of that year.
Iimestone with darker sandstone trim, use of round arches and dominant corner Dr.Marsten became pastor of the congregation in October of 1887,at that time The church is one of the best examples of the Richardsonian Romanesque Revival Construction of the Broad St.church building,known simply as The Chapel, time,East Broad St.was rapidly developing asa residential street,as were turn-of-the-century and under Criterion Cas an outstanding Columbus example of Richardsonian Romenesque Revival style architecture. representing the tremendous growth eastward of Columbus along Broad St. at the other eastside streets nearby, and Dr. Marsten saw this as an oppurtunity to fund raising for the new building was underway.
Established in 1887,Broad St.Presbyterian was an outgrowth of the First style in Columbus.Distinct stylistic characteristices include the light appears to have begun in 1887,and it proceeded rapidly.By Christmas Day of architect Frank Packard extended the church's east wall and the auditorium was All alterations were quite sympathetic to the church's original design, By September,1887,organization of the congregation was completed and it was Ohio Broad St. Presbyterian Church, E. Broad St. MRA, Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio 43. continued, p. 2 east and west windows, depicting "Christ Blessing Little Children" and "The Resurrection" respectively, were produced by the Tiffany Studios of New York dates from the 1907-1908 remodel ing.
Allegorical figures are depicted in the five panels of the south transept The south window, depicting the Fifth Commandment, was designed by Mark The church's most outstanding features are its stained glass windows.The the Franklin Art Glass Company of Columbus, and installed in 1917.Lobby windows appear to have been made by the Von Gerichten firm, and modern windows in the tower, dating from 1973, came from Russellof Columbus by the Von Gerichten Art Glass Company also of Columbus City.The west window is probably original,while the east window likely ASO Form - 17 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR 'R" June 1984 NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES EVALUATION/RETURN SHEET East Broad Street Presbyterian Church (East Broad Street MRA) Fed. Reg. Date: .
Date Due: - nomination by person or local government owner objection Federal Agency: _ _J sample Drequest Lappeal A NR decision Reviewer's comments: _ see continuation sheet Nomination returned for: technical corrections cited below _substantive reasons discussed below 2. Location 3. Classification Present Use 4. Owner of Property 5. Location of Legal Description 6. Representation in Existing Surveys Has this property been determined eligible? 7. Description - unaltered -original site - moved J fair - boundary selection yes Accessible deteriorated ruins dates Status resubmission Condition Category Franklin County REJECT completeness alterations/integrity clarity unexposed Working No. Action: Substantive Review: Public Acquisition summary paragraph excellent 1.
Name Check one Describe the present and original (if known) physical appearance Recom./Critefia Ownership ACCEPT 66003397 Areas of Significance-Check and justify below Specific dates Statement of Significance (in one paragraph) summary paragraph applicable criteria justification of areas checked J relating significance to the resource relationship of integrity to significance justification of exception Other 9. Major Bibliographical References /10. Geographical Data /Acreage of nominated property 11. Form Prepared By 12.
State Historic Preservation Officer Certification The evaluated significance of this property within the state is: _state State Historic Preservation Officer signature J Maps Questions concerning this nomination may be directed to - GPO 918-450 Comments for any item may be continued on an attached sheet Period Builder/Architect context completeness Date clarity national local Photographs Verbal boundary description and justification 8. Significance UTM References Quadrangle name title Signed Phone: Columbus, Ohio 43211 1. No. 4. Present Name(s) East Broad Street Presbyterian Church 2. County 5. Other Name(s) 3. Location of Negatives 6. Specific Location 16. Thematic Category 28. No. of Stories Basement? Yes K 760 East Broad Street 17. Date(s) or Period 30. Foundation Material 18. Style or Design 7. City or Town If Rural, Township & Vicinity Columbus, Ohio 31. Wall Construction 8.
Site Plan with North Arrow 19. Architect or Engineer (1908) Addition X Elah Terrell; Frank Packard 32. Roof Type & Material 20. Contractor or Builder Gable, Slate 33. No. of Bays Original Use, if apparent Side NA Present Use E BROAD STREET 23. Ownership 36. Changes Private & Altered X 9. Coordinates in #42) 24. Owner's Name & Address Moved O if known U.T.M. Reference 25. Open to Structure O Building xa Object O 26. Local Contact Person or Organization 39. Endangered? 11. On National By What? 27. Other Surveys in Which Included 13. Part of Estab. Yes District 40. Visible from Hist. Dist.? 1e of Established District 41. Distance from and 12'; 420' 42. Further Description of Important Features An irregularly-massed Richardsonian Romanesque structure, with a voissoirs.
Interior main sanctuary contains Tiffany windows within a shallow barrel-vaulted space in a Roman cross plan; a small chapel is north of the main sanctuary. Major alterations were made in 1907 and 1908, when, under the direction of well-known The Broad Street Presbyterian church congregation was an out-growth of the First Presbyterian church of Franklinton, the pioneer predecessor of Columbus.. Founded in Sited in a residential/commercial area. A parking lot and small park to the east, in 45. Sources of information 46. Prepared by 1. Architecture Columbus, Robert Samuelson, et.al, 1976. 47. Organization 48. Date 49. Revision Date(s) 1887-1894 None Limestone/sandstone Front Register? 9/81 Northing Easting Site Franklin Zone Underway? Archieval Long. FRA-442-19 690.689.8197 2-1-59 Preservation Eligible? Resident Minister Interior (Explain Lat.
Ohio Historical Center Cynthia Hunt Richardsonian Romanesque OHIO HISTORIC INVENTORY (over) Frontage on Road rectangular tower anchoring its southwest corner.All major openings have a red sandstone semi-circular arch with massive radiating Ohio Historic Preservation Office Public Road? K.H.Van Fossen, Lots #1,2,&3 of J.H.Anderson's subdivision Less than one acre. Church 37. Condition sddition to a small park to the west provide an open site for the church. 43. History and Significance SEE ATTACHED 1971. Rusticated Presbyterian very good tree Photo 1797by Lucas was begun at the"time East Broad Street was (1908) 330/8 9 42. continued Columbus architect Frank Packard, the church's east wall was extended and architecture, representing Richardsonian Romanesque style by the local with darker sandstone trim, use of round arches and dominant corner tower. Other 3.
1975 Ohio Historic Inventory Form, FRA-442-19 by GHHL 4. Bill Arter, Columbus Vignettes, Vol. IV p.45 1922. Addition in c.1960s on north side of building. architects, Elah Terrell and Frank Packard. One of the best examples of this beyond downtown Columbus"(1,p.175) The building is also significant for its examples of the style include Orton Hall on The Ohio State University campus.(NR: 7/16/70) the auditorium doubled in size. The Palmer Hall addition was completed in style in Columbus.Distinct stylistic characteristics include the light limestone 43. continued of Richardsonian Romenesque Revival style architecture. time, East Broad St. was rapidly developing as a residential street, as were By September,1887, organization of the congregation was completed and it was Dr. Marsten became pastor of the congregation in October of 1887, at that time their services.
Construction of the Broad St. church building, known simply as The Chapel, its first service in their new, far from completed home in October,1888. dedication in October of that year. I imestone with darker sandstone trim, use of round arches and dominant corner University campus (NR: 7/16/70). doubled in size. The Palmer Hall addition to the north was completed in 1922. Ohio Presbyterian was the moving force behind the Broad St. congregation.At that All alterations were quite sympathetic to the church's original design, the congregation was using the Broad St.Methodist Church (NR: 11/26/80) for Major alterations were made in1907 and 1908.At that time Columbus Completion of both the Sanctuary and Chapel did not come until 1894,with turn-of-the-century and under Criterion Cas an outstanding Columbus example Presbyterian Church of Franklinton. Dr.
Francis Marsten, pastor of First recognized by the Columbus Presbytery. By that time it had already been The church is one of the best examples of the Richardsonian Romanesque Revival style in Columbus. Distinct stylistic characteristices include the light architect Frank Packard extended the church's east wall and the auditorium was employing materials, detailing and proportions very similar to the original. Broad St. Presbyterian Church, E. Broad St. MRA, Columbus, Franklin County, fund raising for the new building was underway. other eastside streets nearby, and Dr. Marsten saw this as an oppurtunity to The Broad St.Presbyterian Church is significant under Criterion Aas representing the tremendous growth eastward of Columbus along Broad St.at the 43. continued, p. 2 Resurrection" respectively, were produced by the Tiffany Studios of New York dates from the 1907-1908 remodel ing.
Allegorical figures are depicted in the five panels of the south transept The south window, depicting the Fifth Commandment, was designed by Mark The church's most outstanding features are its stained glass windows.The City.The west window is probably original,while the east window likely and installed in 1917.Lobby windows appear to have been made by the Von Broad St.Presbyterian the Franklin Art Glass Company of Columbus, east and west windows, depicting "Christ Blessing Little Children" and "The Russell of Columbusby the Von Gerichten Art Glass Company also of Columbus Gerichten firm, and modern windows in the tower, dating from 1973, came from NPS Form 10.900-a OMB NO. 1024-0018 Multiple Resource Area East Broad Street MRA Franklin County, UHIO 1. Broad Street Apartments Ly Keeper 2. Broad Street Christian 4. Central Assurance 8.
Garfield--Broad 9. Heyne--Zimmerman House 10. Hickok, Frank, House Item number Company Apartments Attest Name National Register of Historic Places Commercial Building Date/Signature State Inventory-Nomination Form National Park Service Historic District dnr-11 Church United States Department of the Interior Cambridge Arms Continuation sheet Thematic Group Nomination/Type of Review (3-82) Patuick Anduus 3/12182 Page Expires 10-31-87 WASO Form - 177 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR ("R" June 1984) NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES EVALUATION/RETURN SHEET Fed. Reg. Date: 2/288 Date Due: _ nomination by person or local government owner objection Federal Agency: - Lappeal -sample LJrequest Discipline pisteriam -see continuation sheet Nomination returned for: - _ technical corrections cited below _substantive reasons discussed below 1. Name 3. Classification 5.
Location of Legal Description 6. Representation in Existing Surveys 7. Description -excellent - unaltered J original site J fair yes moved Ownership Category alterations/integrity clarity resubmission dates REJECT deteriorated Action: good RETURN completeness 2. Location summary paragraph boundary selection Public Acquisition Describe the present and original (if known)physical appearance Has this property been determined eligible? Accessible Substantive Review: Franklin County Reviewer's comments: 4. Owner of Property Condition NR decision East Broad Street Presbyterian Church (East Present Use Broad Street MRA) Check one ruins Working No. Status ACCEPT 32787 Statement of Significance (in one paragraph) - summary paragraph J relating significance to the resource J context - relationship of integrity to significance - justification of exception - other 9.
Major Bibliographical References 10. Geographical Data Acreage of nominated property Quadrangle name Verbal boundary description and justification 11. Form Prepared By 12. State Historic Preservation Officer Certification The evaluated significance of this property within the state is: State Historic Preservation Officer signature Questions concerning this nomination may be directed to Signed _ Phone: _ GPO 918-450 Comments for any item may be continued on an attached sheet completeness Builder/Architect Date state clarity Maps Specific dates Photographs UTM References 8. Significance justification of areas checked applicable criteria title _local national Areas of Significance-Check and justify below Period Cynthia L.
Hunt Photo #5 COLUMBUS Spring 1981 Facade (South) and West Elevation OHS (negatives) HISTORIC RESOURCES OF EAST BROAD STREET, 760 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43205 E. Broad St. MRA Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio April, 1986 Negs: OHPO West E. Broad St. MRA Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio April, 1986 Negs: OHPO addition Eo Broad St. MRA Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio April, 1986 Negs: OHPO original and 1908 addition Eo Broad St. MRA Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio April, 1986 Neg: OHPO 1960s addition Photographer: B. Powers Entrance Main E. Broad St. MRA Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio April, 1986 and 1908 addition. Negs: OHPO Multiple Property Cover Sheet Reference Number: _64000619 Multiple Property Cover Sheet Please refer to the map in the for this property Ohio Historic Preservation Office 1985 Velma Avenue Columbus.
Ohio 43211 November 17, 1986 SINCE 1885 760 East Broad Street Columbus, Ohio. Barbara A. Powers National Register Coordinator BAP: dwh Sandy Davles, Regional Coordlnator State Senator Richard C. Pfelffer, Jr. SOCIETY HISTORICAL 514/466-1500 MORPC Sincerely, Re: 760 East Broad Street, East Broad Street MRA, Franklin County, placement of your property on the National Register. Dear Sir: Broad Street Presbyterian Church forms and written comments which we have received concerning the Mayor of Columbus being sent to Washington, D.c.,for federal evaluation.You will be State Representative Otto Beatty Jr. the National Historic Preservation Act as well as the effects Treatment Extension Act of 1980,and the Economic Recovery Act of 198l. Park Service, United States Department of the Interior.
The nomination Enclosed is information regarding the benefits of listing as outlined in I am pleased to inform you that the property listed above has been given hich may result for depreciable propertles which are listed pursuant to approval by the Ohio Historic Site Preservation Advisory Board as qual ified significance of the property under the National Register criteria are now the Tax Reform Act of 1976 as amended by the Revenue Act of 1978,the Tax for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places of the National -- FACT SHEET -- properties recognized by the federal government as worthy of preservation for identify, evaluate, and protect our cultural and historic resources. The CRITERIA FOR EVALUATION structures, and objects that possess integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association, and: A.
that are associated with events that have made a significant B. that are associated with the lives of persons significant in our past; or C. that embody the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or method of construction, or that represent the work of a master, or that possess high artistic values, or that represent a significant D. that have yielded, or may be likely to yield, information important owned by religious institutions or used for religious purposes, structures that have been moved from their original locations, reconstructed historic buildings, properties primarily commemorative in nature, and properties that ELIGIBLE for the National Register, unless they are integral parts of historic commercial, industrial, and rental residential buildings, instead of historical significance.
and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual in prehistory or history. Ordinarily cemeteries, birthplaces or graves of historical figures, properties This provides for a 20 percent investment tax credit for rehabilitating national policy to coordinate and support public and private efforts to Act of 1986 revised the historic preservation tax incentives authorized by The quality of significance in American history, architecture, archaeology. engineering, and culture is present in districts, sites, buildings, Treatment Extension Act of 1980,and the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981. provisions of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966.
distinction; or a10 percent credit available for rehabilitation of non-historic, The National Register of Historic Places is the official list of historic THE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES RESULTS OF LISTING IN THE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES Congress in the Tax Reform Act of 1976,the Revenue Act of 1978,the Tax contribution to the broad patterns of our history:or architecture, archaeology, engineering, and culture.
Overseen by the National districts that do meet the criteria or are of exceptional architectural or their local, state, or national significance in American history, National Register, certain federal tax provisions may apply.The Tax Reform Eligibility for federal tax provisions:If a property is listed in the have achieved significance within the past 5O years SHALL NOT BE CONSIDERED Act of 1980 provides federal tax deductions for charitable contributions for Consideration in planning for federal, federally licensed, and federally historic properties listed in or eligible for the National Register. For further information, please refer to 36 CFR 800. coal is located. For further information, please refer to 30 CFR 700 et seq. available: Presently no funding is available.
RIGHTS OF OWNERS TO COMMENT AND/OR TO OBJECT TO LISTING IN THE NATIONAL REGISTER historic district, a majority of owners must object for the district to not be formally listed, federal agencies will be required to allow the Advisory agency may fund, license, or assist a project which will affect the property Preservation Officer, Ohio Historic Preservation Office, Ohio Historical Society, 1985 Velma Avenue, Columbus, OH 43211, by the date on the attached upon request. Qualifications for federal grants for historic preservation when funds are letter.
Council on Historic Preservation to have an opportunity to comment before the regardless of the portion of the property that the party owns.If a majority historic values in the decision to issue a surface coal mining permit where determination of eligibility for listing in the National Register.If the Historic Preservation Officer anotarized statement certifying that the property and the owner. For further information, please refer to 36 CFR 67.
Surface Mining and Control Act of 1977,there must be consideration of non-residential buildings built prior to 1936.The Tax Treatment Extension attached letter.A copy of the nomination is available from the above address 1966 requires that federal agencies allow for the Advisory Council on Historic Site Preservation Advisory Board considers this nomination on the date in the If you wish to comment on the nomination of the property to the National Register, please send your comments to W. Ray Luce before the Ohio Historic nomination to the Keeper of the National Register of Historic Places for a Consideration in issuing a surface coal mining permit:In accordance with the Historic Preservation Act and 36 CFR 60.Any owner or partial owner of private property who chooses to object to listing may submit to the State of private property owners object, a property will not be listed.
In a Preservation to have an opportunity to comment on all projects affecting listing. Each owner or partial owner of private property has one vote notarized objection must be submitted to W. Ray Luce, State Historic conservation purposes of partial interests (easements) in historically property or district is then determined eligible for listing. although not or district.If you choose to object to the listing of your property the assisted projects:Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of Ohio Historic Preservation Office 1985 Velma Avenue Columbus. Ohio 43211 SINCE 1885 February 3, 1987 Ms. Carol Shull, Chief National Park Service Department of the Interior 1100 L Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20240 New Submiss ions Ohio Farm Bureau Federation Offices Conner, Alexander, House St. Peter and St. Paul/San Pedro Y Broad Street Presbyterian Church (E. Broad St.
LEast Broad St. Historic District (E. Broad St. Heyne-Zimmerman House (E. Broad St. MRA) East High Street Historic District Please contact me if you have any questions. FEB 1 0 1987 SOCIETY Greene HISTORICAL 614/297-2470 County Knox Sincerely, Enclosures Lucas MRA) WRL:bp Enclosed are three new National Register nominations and four resubmissions. State Historic Preservation Office National Register of Historic Places Franklin San Pablo Historic District Dear Carol: All of the appropriate notification procedures have been followed for the new W. Ray Luce 760 East Broad Street - Columbus, Ohio 43205 - (614) 221-6552 Carol Shull, Chief National Register of Historic Places National Park Service Department of Interior Washington D.C. 20013. Designation of Broad Street Presbyterian Church to the National Registry of Historic Places Dear Ms.
Shull: It has come to our attention recently that Broad Historic Preservation Office attended the Session meeting of to the National Registry of Historic Places and answered questions by Session members concerning the impact of the proposed designation on the ability of Broad Street Church to After careful deliberation, we have decided to object our Church as a historic landmark, it is our conclusion that the adverse impact of this designation on our future flexibility is significant enough that we must resist the Ministers: Thomas D. York - Gerald J. Gregg - Martha M. Shiverick engage in future activities with the building. the Broad Street Presbyterian Church on February 9,1987.She Broad Street Presbyterian Church March 9, 1987 Street Presbyterian Church has been nominated for the National explained the history of the nomination of Broad Street Church to this designation.
Although we appreciate the interest in proposed designation. Clerk of Session NANCY M. SCHRAY NOTARY PUBLIC - STATE OF OHIO Senior Minister MY COMMISSION EXPIRES DEC. 17, 1989 Presbytery of Scioto Valley Notary Public Very truly yours, MICHELE ANN DALEY MY COMMISSION EXPIRES JANUARY 6, 1990 Barbara Powers DWA/sls 760 East Broad Street - Columbus, Ohio 43205 - (614) 221-6552 Carol Shull, Chief Department of Interior Re: Designation of Broad Street Presbyterian Church to the National Registry of Historic Places Dear Ms. Shull: Preservation Office attended the Session meeting of the Broad After careful deliberation, we have decided to object to Church as a historic landmark, it is our conclusion that the truly yours, Clerk of Session cc: Presbytery of Scioto Valley Barbara Powers Ministers: Thomas D. York - Gerald J. Gregg - Martha M.
Shiverick DWA/dm Broad Street Presbyterian Church National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Washington D.C. 20013. March 9, 1987 Presbyterian Church has been nominated for the National Register of Historic Places. Barbara Powers of the Ohio Historic the history of the nomination of Broad Street Church to the on the ability of Broad Street Church to engage in future activities with the building. this designation. Although we appreciate the interest in our adverse impact of this designation on our future flexibility is significant enough that we must resist the proposed designation. It has come to our attention recently that Broad Street MAR 1 3 1987 David W.Alexander, Ohio Historic Preservation Office *1985 Velma Avenue Columbus. Ohio 43211 March 16, 1987 SINCE 1885 760 E. Broad St. Dear Mr. Alexander: Barbara A.
Powers National Register Coordinator SOCIETY Sincerely, 614/297-2470 HISTORICAL Broad Street Presbyterian Church Street Presbyterian Church on the National Register of Historic Places.The If I failed to mention this at the session meeting I attended on February 9,1987, Please contact me if you have additional questions. Clerk of Session it is explained in the National Register fact sheet which was included in the to certify that the party is the sole or partial owner of the private property. David W. Alexander notification letter sent to the Church on November 18,1987. Thank you for sending a copy of your letter objecting to the listing of Broad National Park Service requires that letters of objection be notarized in order Ohlo Historic Preservation Office 1985 Velma Avenue Columbus. Ohio 43211 March 16, 1987 SINCE 1885 David w. Alexander 760 E. Broad St. Dear Mr. Alexander: Barbara A.
Powers SOCIETY HISTORICAL 614/297-2470 National Register Coordinator Sincerely, Broad Street Presbyterian Church Street Presbyterian Church on the National Register of Historic Places.The it is explained in the National Register fact sheet which was included in the notification letter sent to the Church on November 18,1986. Please contact me if you have additional questions. National Park Service requires that letters of objection benotarized in order If I failed to mention this at the session meeting Iattended on February 9,1987, Clerk of Session Thank you for sending a copy of your letter objecting to the listing of Broad to certify that the party is the sole or partial owner of the private property. United States Department of the Interior NATIONAL PARK SERVICE P.O. BOX 37127 RECEIVED APR 1 O 1987 WASHINGTON, D.C.
20013-7127 IN REPLY REFER TO: been entered in the National Register of Historic Places beginning March 15, 1987 and ending March 21,1987. For further information call (202) 343-9552. STATE, County, Vicinity,Property, Address,(Date Listed) ALABAMA, DeKalb County, Valley Head, Winston Place, Off AL 117 (03/19/87) FLORIDA, Lake County, Mount Dora, Lakeside Inn, 100 N. Alexander St. (03/19/87) KENTUCKY, Mc Craken County, Paducah, St. Mary Academy Complex, Bounded by Fourth, Fifth, Monroe, and Jefferson Sts. (03/17/87) MAINE, Hancock County, Sullivan vicinity, Gavin Watson Site, Smelt Cove, E. Sullivan (03/18/87) MIC HIG AN, Barry County, Hastings, Shriner-Ketcham House, 327 Shriner St. (03/17/87) MICHIGAN, Huron County, Port Austin, Winsor and Snover Bank Butlding, 8648 Lake St.
(03/19/87) NEW MEXICO, Bernalilllo County, Albuquerque, Monte Vista Fire Station, 3201 Central NE (03/19/87) NEW MEXICO, San Juan County, Aztec, Lower Animas Ditch (Aztec New Mexico Historic MRA), Lower Animas Ditch from Church Ave. to Lovers Lane Historic District (03/19/87) NEW MEXICO, San Miguel County, Las Vegas, Acequia Madre (Las Vegas New Mexico MRA), Roughly from Gallinas River to intersection of S. Pacific & US 85 (03/19/87) NEW MEXICO, San Miguel County, Las Vegas, Lincoln Park Historic District (Boundary Increase) (Las NEW YORK, Dutchess County, Millbrook vicinity, Lynfeld, South Rd. (03/19/87) OHIO, Butler County, Oxford, Alexander, Dr. William S., House, 22 N. College Ave. (03/18/87) OHIO, Cuyahoga County, Cleveland, Hilliard Apartment Building, 2804 - 2906 Sackett Ave.
(03/17/87) OHIO, Franklin County, Columbus, East Broad Street Historic District (East Broad Street MRA), Along VOHIO, Franklin County, Columbus,East Broad Street Presbyterian Church (East Broad Street MRA), 760 E. Broad St. (03/17/87) OHIO, Franklin County, Columbus, Heyne-Zim merman House (East Broad Street MRA), 973 E. Broad St. (03/17/87) OHIO, Jefferson County, Mingo Junction, Central High School (Mingo Junction MRA), 110 Steuben Ave. (03/17/87) OHIO, Jefferson County, Mingo Junction, Central Public School (Mingo Junction MRA), 109 St. Clair Roughly Commercial St. between MeLister and Highland Aves., May, and RR tracks (03/17/87) /OHIO, Jefferson County, Mingo Junction, North Hill Historic District (Mingo Junction MRA), Bounded by Logan, George, Western, and Alley W of Logan Ave.
(03/17/87) (03/19/87) MAR 2 7 1987 OHIo,Knox County,Mount Vernon,East High Street Historic District,Roughly bounded by E. Chestnut St.,S.Catherine St.,E.Vine St.,and S.Gay St.(03/18/87) Vegas New Mexico MRA),Roughly bounded by Douglas & Grand Aves.and Gallinas & 12th Sts. The Director of the National Park Service is pleased to inform you that the following properties have KENTUCKY, Anderson County, Lawrenceburg vicinity, Old Prentice Distillery, KY 513 (03/19/87) E. Broad St. between Monypenny and Ohio Aves.
(03/17/87) OHIO, Jefferson County, Mingo Junction, Com mercial Street Historic District (Mingo Junction MRA), April 14, 1982 Broad Street Presbyterian Church 760 East Broad Street Columbus, Ohio 43205 I am pleased to inform you that your property, listed below, is being considered by the Ohio Historic Site Preservation Advisory Board for nomination to the National Register of Historic Places, the Federal by the National Historic Preservation Act (P.L. 89-665). Listing in the National Register provides the following benefits to historic properties: Consideration in the planning for federally assisted projects. Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 provides that the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation in the National Register, certain tax provisions may apply.
The Tax Reform Act of 1976, as amended by the Revenue Act of 1978 and the Tax Treatment Extension Act of 1980, and the Econamic Recovery Tax Act of 1981, contain provisions intend- ed to encourage the preservation of depreciable historic structures by allowing favorable tax treatments for rehabili- tation, and to discourage destruction of historic buildings by eliminating certain Federal tax provisions for demolition Economic Recovery Tax Act replaced the rehabilitation tax incentives available under prior law with a 25% investment tax credit for rehabilitation of certain historic carmercial, combined with a 15-year cost recovery period for the adjusted tified rehabilitations receive additional tax savings because Extension Act of 1980 includes provisions regarding chari- table contributions for conservation purposes of partial interests in historically important land areas or structures.
properties. Ohio Historic Preservation Office Dear Members: basis of the historic building.Historic buildings with cer- government's official list of prehistoric and historic properties of historic structures. Beginning January 1, 1982, the they are exempt from any requirement to reduce the basis of Eligibility for Federal tax benefits. If a property is listed worthy of preservation.The program was created by Congress in 1966 be given an opportunity to comment on projects affecting such Fage 2 Consideration of historic values in the decision to issue a surface Mining and Control Act of 1977. Qualification for Federal grants for historic preservation when funds are appropriated by Congress.
Owners of private properties nominated to the National Register of Historic accord with the National Historic Preservation Act Amendments of 1980 and the party is the sole or partial owner of the private property, as appro- with one owner, the property will not be listed if the owner objects. nominations with multiple ownership of a single property, the property will not be listed if a majority of the owners object. Each owner or because the owner or a majority of owners objects prior to the submission of a nomination by the State, the State Historic Preservation Officer shall submit the nomination to the Keeper of the National Register for a determination of the eligibility of the property for inclusion in the listing, although not formally listed, Federal agencies will be required comment before the agency may fund, license, or assist a project which will affect the property.
If you choose to object to the listing of your If you wish to make other corments on the nomination please send them to the above address. Conments must be received before the Board considers note that a copy of this letter is being sent to public officials in 760 East Broad Street W. Ray Luce State Historic Preservation Sincerely, your area for additional comments. Officer Historic Preservation Officer, at the above address by June 1l, 1982. to allow the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation an opportunity to Places must be given an opportunity to concur in or object to listing in priate, and objects to the listing. For a single privately owned property partial owner of private property has one vote regardless of what part property, the notarized objection must be submitted to W. Ray Luce, State this nomination on the above date.
A copy of the nomination is on file coal mining permit where coal is located, in accord with the Surface property who chooses to object to listing is required to submit to the State Historic Preservation Officer a notarized statement certifying that in our office and will be made available to you upon request.Please WRL: jb Arpil 20, 1987 Carol Shull, Chief National Register of Historic Places Department of Interior Washington D.C. 20013. Dear Ms. Shull: Davld W. Alexander Thomas D. York Barbara Powers Ministers: Thomas D. York - Gerald J. Gregg - Martha M.
Shiverick Enclosure Broad Street Presbyterian Church Office has requested that we send a notarized version of my RECEIVED APR 2 1 1987 Very truly yours, Church to the National Registry of Historic Places Designation of Broad Street Presbyterian National Park Service 760 East Broad Street.Columbus, Ohio 43205.(614) 221-6552 responsive to your request. Barbara Powers of the Ohio Historic Preservation letter of March9,1987.I trust the enclosed will be 760 East Broad Street - Columbus, Ohio 43205 - (614) 221-6552 March 9, 1987 Carol Shull, Chief National Register of Historic Places Washington D.C. 20013. Designation of Broad Street Presbyterian Dear Ms.
Shull: It has come to our attention recently that Broad to the National Registry of Historic Places and answered After careful deliberation, we have decided to object our Church as a historic landmark, it is our conclusion that Ministers: Thomas D. York - Gerald J. Gregg - Martha M. Shiverick engage in future activities with the building. proposed designation.
National Park Service Broad Street Presbyterian Church Historic Preservation Office attended the Session meeting of flexibility is significant enough that we must resist the Department of Interior Street Presbyterian Church has been nominated for the National proposed designation on the ability of Broad Street Church to the Broad Street Presbyterian Church on February 9,1987.She Church to the National Registry of Historic Places the adverse impact of this designation on our future questions by.Session members concerning the impact of the explained the history of the nomination of Broad Street Church Clerk of Session Presbytery of Scioto Valley Barbara Powers Notary Public day of April, 1987. Senior Minister Very truly yours, NANCY M SCHRAY Thomas D.
York Subscribed and sworn to before me this NOTARY FURLI DWA/sls 760East Broad Street - Columbus, Ohio 43205 - (614) 221-6552 April 21, 1987 Carol Shull, Chief National Register of Historic Places National Park Service Department of Interior Washington D.C. 20013 Dear Ms. Shull: designation of Broad Street Presbyterian Church for the Amendment principle of separation of Church and State. Powers, National Register Coordinator, that Broad Street objection to this designation and, without waiver of any other objection we may later assert, I want to bring to your National Register Coordinator, wrote me and indicated that our action before we have even had a reasonable period of time to Ministers: Thomas D. York - Gerald J. Gregg - Martha M. Shiverick APR 2 8 1987 procedures involved in this designation.Ms.
Powers advised me As you know from my prior correspondence, our Session Broad Street Presbyterian Church respond to the technical clarification brought to our attention to the National Registry of Historic Places Designation of Broad Street Presbyterian Church about your agency's encroachment upon our Church and ask that by Ms.Powers.Although Ms.Powers was kind enough to bring immediate attention our serious concerns about the timing and following Sunday worship on March 22,1987,some 5days after Church office and I did not receive it until immediately first time inmy telephone call today with Ms.Barbara A. 1987,and to renew our previously voiced objection to the I am writing to follow-up to my letter of March 9, you view this letter in the context of the important First of March 17, 1987.
One day before that designation, of which concerned that an agency of the government would take this Presbyterian Church has already been listed on the National Register of Historic Places. I am writing to express our that Broad Street Presbyterian Church was officially listed as your office had apparently already listed the property on the National Register of Historic Places.We are deeply concerned letter of objection needed to be copy of her Carol Shull, Chief April 21, 1987 Page 2 this technical issue to our attention, it is obvious that your decision listing the property occurred before we had an One of the reasons I had not yet responded to Ms. of Scioto Valley relative to their position on the proposed Presbytery is invalid.
we respectfully suggest that all parties would be better served by allowing us a timely opportunity to address the concerns Minister of Broad Street Presbyterian Church, to execute the renewed letter of objection and to rescind your proposed designation of Broad Street Presbyterian Church to the National Registry of Historic Places. Clerk of Session Thomas D. York Barbara A. Powers, National Register Coordinator Enclosure Frances Nagy, Executive Presbyter Ohio Historical Society of the proposed designation, although accordingly submit herewith a notarized copy of the previous should have been notified of the proposed designation and any I have been advised by Ms.Powers today that there are Russell P. Herrold, Jr., Esq. identified by Ms.Powers in her March 16,1987,letter.We APR 2 8 1987 opportunity to respond to her request for a notarized letter.
To my knowledge, the Presbytery has never been it unquestionably has a legal interest in the property. Powers' letter was the necessity of inquiring of the Presbytery attempt to list the property without prior notice to the designation. DWA/sls prepared to appeal the listing through all appropriate avenues, letter of March 9,1987.Because I will be retiring soon as U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR HERITAGE CONSERVATION AND RECREATION SERVICE TELEPHONE REPORT 2. ADDRESS (Tel. No. if needed) FHR-8-227 OFFICE 614-224-0922 TIME OF CALL 2:00AM 5. SUBJECT, PROJECT NO.. ETC. 4. DETAILS OF DISCUSSION June 1978 1. CALL L TO: TITLE DATE CALL]TO:FROM(Name) Chomeve- Ohio Historic Preservation Office 1985 Veima Avenue Columbus. Ohio 43211 April 27, 1987 SINCE 1885 Columbus, Ohio. W. Ray Luce Enclosure Sandy Davies, Regional Coordinator State Representative Otto Beatty, Jr. State Senator Richard C.
Pfeiffer, Jr. SOCIETY HISTORICAL MORPC Sincefe 614/297-2470 Preservation Advisory Board. Broad Street Presbyterian Church WRL/BAP/ipg Register status under provisions of the National Historic Preservation Act Register of Historic Places. document prehistoric and historic places in Ohio which qualify for National State Historic Preservation Officer Enclosed is information explaining the purposes and goals of the National 760 East Broad Street, East Broad MRA, Franklin County. Dear Sir: Mayor of Columbus The nomination was made in connection with a state plan to identify and 760 East Broad Street of 1966 as amended.A11 nominations are approved by the Ohio Historic Site We are pleased to inform you that 760 East Broad Street has been entered Department of the Interior.
(NR listed 03/17/87) into the National Register of Historic Places by the National Park Service, Ohio Historic Preservation Office 1985 Velma Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43211 SINCE 1885 July 10, 1987 National Park Service Department of the Interior P.O. Box 37127 concerning the nomination of the Broad St. Presbyterian Church, Columbus, Barbara A. Powers National Register Coordinator SOCIETY Sincerely, HISTORICAL 614/297-2470 matter. ECEIVE Patrick Andrus Franklin County, Ohio to the National Register of Historic Places.A National Register of Historic Places chronology of events concerning the nomination is also included. Enclosed are copies of the notification letters and other correspondence Dear Patrick: Please contact me if you have any additional questions regarding this Washington, D.C. 20013-7127 Barbara Powers SINCE 1885 July 10, 1987 National Register.
Voted to give preliminary consideration to period until June 11, 1982. for general overview (significance section). (21 regional offices covering app. 5 counties each, NRs and survey major part of job). When that regional system was reduced, due to budget constraints, to 5 regional offices covering app. 15-20 counties with less NR concentration, the additional work on this nomination as well as many others became part of the daily workload ownership checked for changes (Broad St. Presbyterian Church 10/30/86: Nomination forwarded to NPS in Washington. of NR listing and status of nomination. 3/10/87: OHPO recieved copy of objection letter of church sent to Carol Washington. nomination. HISTORICAL SOCIETY MEMORANDUM DATE: FROM: 12/86:Broad St.Presbyterian Church nomination returned from Washington MRA, additional mapping and photography, and additional information acerage not indicated.
Patrick Andrus additional technical information for individual properties, Nomination required additional work -statements of significance and 11/17/86:Notification 1etters and NR fact sheet with information concerning 2/3/87:Broad St.Presbyterian Church nomination resubmitted to NPs in SUBJECT:Broad St.Presbyterian Church (East Broad St.Multiple Resource Area) Session of Broad St.Presbyterian Church to discuss ramifications be notarized. E.Broad St.Multiple Resource Area nomination for eligiblity to statements of significance and description for district included in owner objection and NR provisions sent to property owners. 10/86: A11 additional work on E. Broad St.MRA completed.Property 3/16/87:Letter sent to church explaining that 1etters of objection must Nomination had been started under OHPo's old regional office system indicated as owner of record on City of Columbus base maps).
of NR staff in central OHPO. 3/19/82: Ohio Historic Site Preservation Advisory Board (OHSPAB) reviewed 6/11/82: OHSPAB gives final approval to E. Broad St. MRA. 2/9/87: Barbara Powers, National Register Coordinator, met with General Shull. Page 2. had been listed. 4/21/87: OHPO received copy of notatrized objection letter from church to their reasons why church should not be listed. 4/27/87: OHPO sends notification letter informing church of NR listing. 4/10/87:OHPo received NPS notification that Broad St.Presbyterian Church Carol Shull. SEP 3 Dear Hr+ Alexander: Clerk of Seeeion 760 East Broad Street fron the Ohio State Hietorie Preservation Office the Chie Mr.David W.Alexander the Taticael Register.
notice, as required by regulationa, of ite intention to nominate Church building on March 3, 1982, at which tine the Beard voted coing to be considered for nomination by the State Review Board That letter, a copy of which wae included in the Society, included notice regarding the right of ownere of private regulatione do not require that the State Historie Preeervation identifying property ownere. considered the eligibility of the Broad Street Presbyterian seventy-five days before the State Review Board meeting.
Board (ohio Historic Site Preservation Advisory Board) first intent to nominate this property were addressed to the Broad record that the Broad Street Presbyterian Church building was requirement to provide the cwners ofprcperties the right to No official objeetion to the nomination was filed end the Stete November 11,l986,notified the Church that the processing this nomination, the Ohio Historical Society consulted 14, 1982, object to the nomination at least thirty but not more than the Broad Street Presbyterian Church.All notices regarding the the property to the Netional Register.The chronology provided Society failed to provide the ovners of the property timely Street Presbyterian Church at 7eo Fast Broad Street. 14,l982,the Ohio Hiatoricel Society notified the cwner of requirenente of 36 CFR 60.6have been followed.The State Review ce: Dr. W.
Ray Luce 1985 Velma Avenue 413 RF FNP:PWA:wa:09/02/87 343-9536 Sys64: (PWA) broad Record Center Resources Division SHPO Basic File Retained in 413 formally object to the nomination by notarized letter.No euch chooeee with the property. Thank you for your interest in this matter. important resource by ite listing in the National Register may in place any reetrictions on the Church's ability to do whatever it Columbus, Ohio 43211 We eppreciate your concerns that the recognition of this give the Federal governnent eny control over the property cr thie property from the National Register. formal objection was received by the National Register prior to our listing of thie property in the National Register on March Carol D.Shu11