Nomination for Winterringer Building and House

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

NPS Form 10-900 OMB No. 1024-0018 (Rev. 8-86) MAY 1 3 1988 and areas of significance, enter only the categories and subcategories listed in the instructions. For additional space use continuation sheets (Form 10-900a). Type all entries. 1. Name of Property Location street & number N/A not for publication city, town N/A vicinity zip code Classification Ownership of Property X private X building(s) Name of related multiple property listing: Number of contributing resources previously listed in the National Register - 4. State/Federal Agency Certification Signature of commenting or other official 5.

National Park Service Certification 1, hereby, certify that this property is: determined not eligible for the other, (explain:) Signature of the Keeper Date of Action 049 site REGISTER structure district Date NATIONAL object state public-Federal public-local Noncontributing Total Hilliard RECEIVED historic name National Register. Registration Form public-State See continuation sheet. National Register of Historic Places Brownson Building other names/site number National Park Service removed from the National Register. Signature of certifying official Winterringer Building and Residence determined eligible for the National entered in the National Register.

Number of Resources within Property United States Department of the Interior This form is for use in nominating or requesting determinations of eligibility for individual properties or districts.See instructions in Guidelines State or Federal agency and bureau 5344 Center Street As the designated authority under the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966,as amended, I hereby certify that this Category of Property National Register of Historic Places and meets the procedural and professional requirements set forth in 36 CFR Part 60. Cntered in tha In my opinion, the property 43026 county Franklin Ohio 6. Function or Use Current Functions (enter categories from instructions) 7.

Description Materials (enter categories from instructions) fronts directly on the railroad line in Old Hilliard, near where the depot a Gothic influence, is set back from the street at the rear of the hoodmolds, three oculus windows on the Main Street elevation, and an intact design, featuring a pair of multi-paned display windows flanking a central X See continuation sheet other Gothic Italianate sandstone Architectural Classification retains its original clapboard siding, wood trim and two-over-two windows.

include original six-over-six windows with segmental-arched brick windows have simple sandstone sills and a triple row of brick headers The Winterringer residence is a one and one-half story frame structure forming decorative segmental hoodmolds.The oculus windows display a The side elevation facing Main Street features five second floor windows The Winterringer Building is a rectangular brick building, two stories in Historic Functions (enter categories from instructions) The Winterringer Building and Residence consists of a brick commercial dentilled cornice which extends only a few feet around to either side of entrance with original double-leafed entry door is stored in the building.) which has a minor Gothic influence in its steeply pitched roofline with COMMERCE/TRADE/restaurant the first floor and two on the second story.Above the second floor is the floor was enclosed in a flat-roofed shed addition which was added before Describe present and historic physical appearance.

On the north side of the building, an original exterior stair to the second on this side was removed and is stored inside the building. (enter categories from instructions) 1890.Other changes to this elevation include concrete block firewalls commercial building and faces Main Street. COMMERCE/TRADE/department store pointed arches in the gable faces and in a central dormer.The dwelling (Only the rear facade has altered siding and windows.) DOMESTIC/single dwelling SOCIAL/meeting hall foundation limestone _asphalt was originally located. The c. 1880 Winterringer residence, which displays added in 1960 and frame additions added in 1983. One second floor window roof height with a limestone foundation.Significant features of the structure double row of headers as a surround.

building and an adjacent frame residence which was used by the building's pressed metal cornice.The main facade of the building has three bays on and a trio of oculus windows on the ground floor.Throughout the building, NPS Form 10-000- OMB Approval No. 1024-0018 Winterringer Building and Residence, Hilliard, Franklin County, OH section, where the house originally ended. In addition, the fenestration occurred on the first floor only, but the builders were careful to match and residence have been altered on the first floor during conversion to a essentially intact, but are currently not being used. restaurant use. Continuation Sheet National Park Service Inspection of the Winterringer residence reveals that the western-most certainly added after the house was constructed to provide a connection the addition closely with the existing house.

a metal cross beam for support.The interiors of the Winterringer building The commercial and residential buildings were connected at the first floor portion contains two windows and entrances to the building through the Several items made this change clear:The attic story of the west gable around the turn of the century by the Winterringer family.

pointed-arch window can be seen in the west elevation gable of the central a pair of segmental-arch windows on the first floor and a pointed-arch making it an inaccessible feature that was for visual effect only.A does not extend back to connect with the ridge line of the lateral section, National Register of Historic Places removed and replaced with the existing vestibule during conversion to United States Department of the Interior of the west gable differs slightly in size and number of panes over 4) level by removal ofa portion of the brick bearing wall and installation of gable of the to the commercial building)was almost The residence features a symmetrical main facade, with two gabled Section number _ 7 Page 1 gabled projection to either side.A wood porch at this location was projections connected laterally by a central section.Each gable features pub and restaurant use.The second floor spaces of both buildings remain with the adjacent commercial building.This appears to have been done 8.

Statement of Significance

Statement of significance

Certifying official has considered the significance of this property in relation to other properties: Applicable National Register Criteria Significant Dates , 1880 State significance of property, and justify criteria, criteria considerations, and areas and periods of significance noted above. the Winterringer Building, c.

1870, features an original storefront, a pressed century, is modestly Gothic influenced with steeply pitched gables and pointed stand, along with a handful of commercial buildings, a small number of buildings are the many frame, middle class and working class houses from city's newer developments, Old Hilliard retains much of its rural character LX) See continuation sheet Architecture Unknown Significant Person nominated to the National Register for their architectural significance and as additional acres of farmland are developed.In sharp contrast to the Cultural Affiliation evolved slowly as a railroad town and agricultural center during the next arch windows.Attached to the family general store/grocery/post office, the Period of Significance The Winterringer property is one of four in Hilliard which are being Hilliard began to take on the character of a suburban bedroom community.

In recent years, Hilliard has experienced tremendous growth as the city's Center and Norwich Streets.The grain elevator and lumber yard still The Winterringer Building and Residence are significant under Criterion C within Architect/Builder Hilliard's commercial and architectural development before the turn of the century. Areas of Significance (enter categories from instructions) house contributes to the overall character of the property which represents both the 19th and early 20th centuries. contribution to the development of the town asa rural agricultural the railroad line some ten miles west of map),the community Hilliard," as the original town is called, as shown on the attached map.

Old Hilliard represents the original settlement of"Hilliard's Station"as C.1870 Criteria Considerations (Exceptions) statewide boundaries were expanded through annexation and development.The town's scattered 19th and early 20th century buildings which remain on Main, In 1988,Hilliard has become a city of 10,500 which is continuing to grow nationally it was platted in 1853 by John Hilliard.Laid out in a grid pattern around community of the 19th century.The buildings are located in01d population increased from only 610 in 1950 to over 5,600 in 1960,and Mlocally NPS Form 10-000e OMB Approval No 1024-0018 Winterringer Building and Residence, Hilliard, Franklin County, OH of Italianate-influenced commercial architecture in Old Hilliard.

Features further to the west on Main Street, but its character has been compromised character, the Tidd Funeral Home on Norwich Street exhibits detailing been significantly altered, however, through conversion to business use. The Winterringer house retains integrity of materials, design, and railroad with Main Street, its construction was an important reflection of family for over 100 years, until 1983. general store, serving the farming and railroad community by offering as the location of the Hilliard Post Office for many years, including the Continuation Sheet such as the pressed metal cornice and original window treatments are National Register of Historic Places arched three-bay storefront provides a contrast to the later storefront of The Winterringer building provides an early and remarkably intact example the significance of the railroad to Hilliard.

The property was sold in similar to the Winterringer house and dates from the same period.It has through both lack of development and recent preservation of buildings which National Park Service The attached Winterringer residence is a modest Gothic influenced building, commercial structure from this period is the c. 1872 Westerweller Building The commercial structure appears to have been used from the start as a character of the building. addition on the main facade do not diminish the overall architectural The Winterringer building was originally constructed about l87o by Orin S. 1873 to John W.Winterringer for $l,200,remaining in the Winterringer United States Department of the Interior used asa generalstore until 1965 when it was converted toa pub. Section number _ Page - Important character-defining elements of the building. The segmental- the Italianate Odd Fellows Building (1883).

The only other brick of the style. groceries, notions, boots and shoes, and men's furnishings. The second story contained a simple meeting room which was used by fraternal with pointed-arch gable windows and steeply-pitched gables characteristic by alterations and additions. organizations and for a time by village council.The building also served period from 192l to 1936 when Frank Winterringer became postmaster.It was were central to its early community life.

While most frame houses in Old Hilliard are vernacular in NPS Form 10-900 OMB Approval No 1024-0018 Winterringer Building and Residence, Hilliard, Franklin County, OH Continuation Sheet National Park Service expanding it to connect with their commercial building around the turn of This combination of the general store and the owner's residence makes the National Register of Historic Places the home until 1983, when it was purchased by the present owner. The Winterringer family built the adjacent house about 1880, eventually in the Hilliard community. United States Department of the Interlor Section number _ Because of their integrity and character, the buildings Page have architectural signficance as well as important historical associations Winterringer property one of the more significant properties in the Old Hilliard area.

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

Major Bibliographical References Atlas of Franklin County, 1873. Franklin County Directories, 1893, 1898, 1930. Sanborn Insurance Company, Maps of Hilliard, Ohio, 1922, 1929, 1946. Sifrit, Esther. Interview with granddaughter of Winterringer, 2/17/88. Previous documentation on file (NPS): N/A -preliminary determination of individual listing (36 CFR 67) Primary location of additional data: has been requested X] State historic preservation office Other State agency recorded by Historic American Buildings Survey # 10. Geographical Data Ben jamin D. Rickey & Co. _ date - (614) 221-0358 street & number - _ telephone _state _ zip code 43215 Other University Columbus Easting Northing Zone Columbus Citizen. Local government organization the property.

Boundary Justification Federal agency designated a National Historic Landmark recorded by Historic American Engineering UTM References Acreage of property Verbal Boundary Description Specify repository: See continuation sheet previously determined eligible by the National Register previously listed in the National Register 391 Library Park South city or town "First White Settlers Came to Hilliards in 1807,"July 22,1956. Record # Lot #12,City of Hi1liard Miller, Mary. "The Quartoquecentennial of A Pride Community - 1978, Hilliard, Ohio," 1978. Taylor, William A. 11. Form Prepared By 14 413,3156 The boundary includes the entire city lot which has historically been associated with name/title Less than one acre. Centennial History of Columbus and Frankling County, Ohio,1909.

Ohio ANNEXED TO FORM PRESENT-DAY CITY OF HILLIARD HIGH SCHOO SCHOOL (ORIGINAL VILLAGE BOUNDARIES) Winterringer Building and Residence, Hilliard, Franklin County, OH 1. Winterringer Building 2. Odd Fellows Hall 3. Hilliard Methodist Church 4. Merryman House OLD HILLIARD Franklin Nor Madison Grant Wayne LOCATIONS OF PROPERTIES NOMINATED TO THE NATIONAL REGISTER: Columbia WASO Form - 177 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES EVALUATION/RETURN SHEET Working No. - Fed. Reg. Date: Date Due: _ nomination by person or local government owner objection Federal Agency: - -appeal Lsample Jrequest Reviewer's comments: _ see continuation sheet Nomination returned for: _ _technical corrections cited below _substantive reasons discussed below 1. Name 2. Location 3. Classification Public Acquisition 4. Owner of Property 5.

Location of Legal Description 6. Representation in Existing Surveys Has this property been determined eligible? 7. Description J excellent -unaltered J original site summary paragraph moved resubmission Category ruins completeness dates Condition Ownership unexposed alterations/integrity Status Discipline REJECT RETURN deteriorated Recom./Criteria Reviewer clarity Action: Entered in the Winterringer Building and House Substantive Review: boundary selection Franklin County Accessible yes Check one NR decision fair Describe the present and original (if known) physical appearance Present Use National Regiaten ("R" June 1984) V ACCEPT 6-9-88 MAY 13 1988 good 8. Significance Other 9. Major Bibliographical References 10. Geographical Data Acreage of nominated property Verbal boundary description and justification 11.

Form Prepared By _national _local State Historic Preservation Officer signature Questions concerning this nomination may be directed to Comments for any item may be continued on an attached sheet Date completeness context Signed state clarity title applicable criteria Maps Quadrangle name UTM References Phone Builder/Architect relationship of integrity to significance Specific dates The evaluated significance of this property within the state is: 12. State Historic Preservation Officer Certification relating significance to the resource justification of exception Photographs summary paragraph justification of areas checked Statement of Significance (in one paragraph) Areas of Significance-Check and justify below Period TOWNE PUB OTIE'S Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 Neg- at 391 Library Park, Cols. 1ooking north 5344 Center Street Winterringer Bldg.

and Residence View of commercial bldg., Photo #l BOOTS& SHOFS GROCERIES Post Ouice + Rural Carriers Hilliards NOTIONS Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 Neg. at 391 Library Park, Cols. 5344 Center Street Historic view TOWNE PUB OTIE'S Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 Neg- at 391 Library Park, Cols. Photo # 3 View of main facade, looking NE Winterringer Bldg. and Residence 5344 Center Street TOWNE PUB OTIE'S Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 Photo # 4 Detail of main facade Winterringer Bldg. and Residence 5344 Center Street Neg. at 391 Library Park, Cols. TOWNE PUB Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 - Neg- at 391 Library Park, Cols. View of main facade, looking NE Winterringer Bldg. and Residence 5344 Center Street Photo #s DLD HILLIARD DAY Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Photo by J.

Williams, 9/87 View of SE elevation winterringer Bldg. and Residence 5344 Center Street Neg. at 39l Library Park, Cols. Photo # l Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 Neg- at 391 Library Park, Cols. Photo # 7 Winterringer Bldg. and Residence Detail of SE elevation windows 5344 Center Street Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 Neg. at 391 Library Park, Cols. bldg-, looking west Winterringer Bldg. and Residence View of residence and comm. 5344 Center Street Photo # & RESTAURANT HILLIA Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 Neg. at 391 Library Park, Cols. 1ooking NW View of residence main facade, Winterringer Bldg. and Residence 5344 Center Street Photo # 9 Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 Winterringer Bldg. and Residence Looking west at residence 5344 Center Street Neg. at 391 Library Park, Cols.

Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Hilliard, Franklin Co., Ohio Photo by J. Williams, 9/87 Neg- at 391 Library Park, Cols. 1ooking south Winterringer Bldg. and Residence 5344 Center Street View of rear of property, Photo # / 7.5 MINUTE SERIES (TOPOGRAPHIC) P HILLIARD QUADRANGLE UNITED STATES GEOLOGICAL SURVEY HILLIARD, OHIO DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR ROAD CLASSIFICATICN N400C - W8307.5/7.5 Ohio Historic Preservation Office 1985 Velma Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43211 SINCE 1885 Ms. Carol Shull, Chief P.O. Box 37127 Washington, D.C. 20013-7127 W. Ray Luce WRL : emn SOCIETY 614/297-2470 County Enclosures HISTORICAL Franklin Tripp-Bauer Building New Submissions Scioto National Park Service Sincerely Department of the Interior Winterringer Building and Residence Dear Carol: Please contact me if you have any questions.

MAY 1 3 1988 OHIO Enclosed are two new National Register nominations.All of the appropriate State Historic Preservation Officer notification procedures have been followed for these new submissions.