Sevier County, Tennessee - Chapter 19: The Capture of George Thurmer, 1899
From The White-caps : a History of the Organization in Sevier County, published 1899. 572 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
572 wordsMachine-read from scans of The White-caps : a History of the Organization in Sevier County, published 1899. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
George Thurmer is a noted criminal and a native of Knox county. At the time of his connection with Sevier county depredations, he had just returned from serving a term in the penitentiary for the murder of policeman Hoyle in Knoxville.
George was a shrewd fellow, a free drinker, an expert gambler and by no means a coward. These were the qualifications which recommended him to the White-caps as a suitable member for their mystic order. Soon after his arrival in Sevierville, standing within fifty feet of the court house, he took the required oath, which was administered to him by Catlett Tipton, the captain of the Sevierville band, who is now under sentence of death for the murder of Wm. Whaley and wife.
Soon after his admission to the order, John Burnett, an old pensioner, was robbed. George Thurmer, along with several others, was indicted for this crime. George succeeded in eluding the officers for some time, but was finally captured in Knox county by Tom Davis and returned to Sevierville, where he was placed in the County jail. For this capture Davis is indebted to sheriff J. C. Groner and C. A. Reeder who rendered him material assistance. George was too fine a bird to remain long in a cage. So, one day, when the jailer was just in the act of handing him his breakfast, George seized him while others took the keys from him, and they all made good their escape.
Again he eluded the officers for several months. But one day while down in a hole digging a foundation for a trestle, near Pineville, Ky., he was startled by hearing a harsh voice commanding him to throw up his hands. On looking up he saw an officer standing over him with a forty-four calibre pistol pointed square at his breast. George smiled and said " That's |all right, sir," and his hands went up. The officer was ex-chief of police of Pineville, Ky. He was then asked if his name was Charley Wilson.
By this time Davis was fast approaching from the other end of the trestle. Turning him around, the officer asked, " Do you know that man coming yonder? "
" Yes, by G - d, that's Tom Davis now. I dreamed last night he walked right up behind me in a saloon. I grew uneasy and was fixing to leave as soon as pay day come, but its too late, now. I guess I'll go back to Tennessee with Tom. He's a good fellow, and always pays my fare when we travel together. This is twice he has captured me, and if I ever get out of that old jail again he will never see me any more, for I will go up in a balloon, cut her loose and leave no trace behind."
The two officers had laid in wait for George the night before at Pineville, but he failed to put in his appearance. So, mounted on two good horses, they made their way down on the south side of the Cumberland river to a point just opposite the trestle, where George was at work. Fording the river before daylight and hitching their horses under the river bank they placee themselves one at each end of the trestle and waited for Thurmer to come to the works. George walked into the trap, was captured and returned to the Sevierville jail once more.
Provenance
Text from The White-caps : a History of the Organization in Sevier County, published 1899, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.