Sevier County, Tennessee - Chapter 30: Whipping of Mrs. Mary Brkeden and Her Daughters, 1899
From The White-caps : a History of the Organization in Sevier County, published 1899. 2,511 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
2,511 wordsMachine-read from scans of The White-caps : a History of the Organization in Sevier County, published 1899. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
In the write-up of the White-caps and their depredations in Sevier County, it has not been the purpose of the writer to give full and detailed accounts of all the minor offenses committed by them.
It would take a volume of more than one thousand pages to give such accounts, and do the subject justice, there frequently occurring more than a dozen whippings in a single night. Such being the case, the writer is content to give an account of only such whippings as proved fatal to the unfortunate victims.
The whipping of Mrs. Mary Breeden and her daughters, Bell and Martha, is a case of unparalleled cruelty, and shows the depravity of the human heart.
One Saturday night about the middle of May, 1893, the inmates of the Breeden home were aroused from their peaceful slumber by the footsteps of unknown parties surrounding the house and the captain of the band calling :
" Oh ! Jes, Oh ! Jes ! get up we want to see you." Jes was Mrs. Breeden's oldest child and only son, a young man of good character and exemplary habits, who struggled hard for the support of his widowed mother and her large family of children. The Whitecaps had not given the Breeden family any previous notice, as was their custom, and the unsuspecting young man opened wide the door of their humble cabin home.
Eight of their number came in the house and while four of them kept the young man covered with their revolvers, threatening to blow his heart out if he moved, the other four proceeded to drag Miss Bell, the oldest daughter, from her bed and took her out into the yard in her night apparel. Two men each taking her by the hand, held her arms outstretched at full length, while two others, one on each side, gave her a most cruel and unmerciful beating.
The young woman felt the sting of the cruel lash laid upon her bare back and made a desperate effort to free herself from the death-like grasp of hellish demons. But all to no purpose. She was powerless in the hands of this heartless band of base cowards whose deeds were as dark as hell its self. Her punishment was only more severe for the efforts she made to escape such cruel treatment.
In the meantime, however, Mrs. Breeden, with a motherly love for her daughter, was interceeding in her behalf, and begged them in the name of high heaven to spare her daughter's life. The reply came from the leader.
Again Mrs. Breeden interceeded in behalf of her younger daughter, which did no good however, but rather had a tendency to infuriate the mob.
Next in turn came Mrs. Breeden, who, in like manner, received the same punishment as her two daughters, except that it exceeded theirs in severity.
. Of all the heinous crimes committed by this lawless band, there is none, perhaps, that equals in point of brutality the whipping of old Mrs. Breeden, except the murder of William and Laura Whaley.
Mrs. Breeden had just passed her sixtieth year, and was a hard-working inoffensive old lady. She had evidently had a hard struggle through life to support her large family of children. And her two oldest daughters, Bell and Martha, who were rather handsome, had been her tender care for many years. And now, to stand by and see those two beautiful rose buds which she had so long watched over and cared for, plucked from the bush, as it were, when just bursting into full bloom of hope, and dragged from under the parental roof in their night apparel, and subjected to .a cruel beating, was more than she could endure. Although she realized the situation, and knew full well that to utter one word in their defence, was treading upon dangerous ground, yet moved by the impulse of a motherly love, she entered a protest against such cruel treatment. She strongly denied that her two daughters were living in adultery, as they were accused of doing, and branded them as base cowards for overpowering a woman. For this she was cursed and abused, and then, in turn, was dragged into the yard where she received a fatal whipping.
The scene of this whipping is one that will ever live in the minds of those who witnessed it, and which, no doubt, the perpetrators thereof would like to blot from their memories forever. Although they may attempt to escape from the recollections of this awful crime by roaming in distant lands, yet they can never escape those nightly visions that hover around the bedside and prey upon the mind of a heartless wretch who would commit a crime like this. They can never close their eyes upon such a ghastly scene, but like a fairy phantom, it will ever follow their wandering footsteps through the busy scenes of this life, and haunt them where ever they may be.
It was indeed a most heartrending scene. Enough to arouse the sympathies of the most hardened criminal, and melt into tears a heart of stone. The withes used in this whipping were black gum of an unusual size, being at least three-fourths of an inch in diameter at the larger end, and with the knots left on them. When they lapped across the shoulders of the poor unfortunate woman the knots cut great gashes in her flesh. She had upbraided them for their cruelty and cowardice in overpowering and punishing her two daughters, and they in turn determined to make an example of her to teach others what it was to reprove them for their lawless deeds. Blow after blow in quick succession was laid upon her body, while she screamed at the top of her voice for help. And while writhing in great agony, struggling alone to free herself from the clutches of this heartless band of desperadoes, one of their own men, whose heart was touched by the horrible scene came to her rescue.
He had stood back in the dark, and up to this time had taken no part in the proceedings. He boldly stepped to the front and in a commanding voice said :
A controversy arose between them, and they were about to proceed with the whipping, when he suddenly pulled from his pocket a revolver and said :
Although these words were spoken in a stern commanding voice, yet they fell upon the ears of the terrorstricken family like a gleam of sunshine in the midst of a raging storm. It had the desired effect upon his companions in crime. Although a White-cap, he is to be commended for this brave and courageous act.
The poor woman, now more dead than alive, was released and assisted back into the house with the blood trickling down her back, and dripping upon the ground.
We now turn to the young man "Jesse," who was closely guarded by four well armed men. He had stood by and seen his two sisters ruthlessly dragged from their sleeping couches, and the unmerciful whipping which followed. Now he was forced to stand by and witness a scene which was most touching and
No doubt the young man's mind went back o'er many years, and the halcyon days of childhood rose up in a vision before him as one by one he recalled the passing events mingled with joys and sorrows, when by day he played 'round the door of their lowly cabin and at night was rocked to sleep in the arms of an affectionate mother. These same arms, that so often had been clasped around her first born and only boy, now held outstretched by two strong men, while two hellish demons applied the cruel lash that forever sealed the fate of Mrs. Breeden and sent her to an untimety grave.
Quick as a flash he tore loose from one of the men who had .him in charge, in a determined effort to rescue his mother. Instantly four revolvers were thrust in his face, one' of them so close that it almost touched his cheek. At this juncture, while looking down the barrel of the gleaming revolver he recognized his own weapon which he had taken to Jesse Robinson's shop for repairs only few days previous.
Thus the young man was powerless to render assistance to the bewailing mother. Had it not been for the timely interference of one of their own men, as stated heretofore, no doubt Mrs. Breeden would have been left lying prostrate upon the ground a lifeless corpse.
When the neighbors appeared on the scene next morning they found short pieces of the withes, some four or five inches long, which had broken off and were lying upon the ground, wrapped with hair and stained with blood.
They found Mrs. Breeden suffering terribly from her ghastly wounds. During the night the blood had dried and left her clothing sticking fast to her back. Several applications of warm water were made before it could be removed, and even then not without undergoing great pain.
To say that the neighbors who witnessed this scene were indignant, would be putting it in exceedingly mild terms - they were simply furious. White-caps were denounced in the most bitter terms and threats were freely made.
Shortly after this occurence an organization sprang up known as " Blue-Bill's," so called by the Whitecaps, the purpose of which was to defeat the plans of the White-caps. As stated in d preceeding chapter, they differed from the White-caps in the fact that they took no oath and wore no masks. They did not care to cover their faces to put down a crime like that of white-capping.
The term " Blue Bill " applied not alone to those who joined that organization, but any good citizen who had courage enough to denounce white-capism, was by the White-caps called a " Blue Bill."
lingered along between life and death for a little more than two months, and on August the 4th., 1893, breathed her last. Dr. J. A. Henderson, who was not her family physician, but, one of the most skillful physicians in Sevier County, was called in a few days before she died. After a careful examination, he told her she could not hope to live but a few days. And gave it as his opinion that the unmerciful whipping which she had received on that fatal Saturday night was the sole cause of her untimely death. She told him that the Furgason boys were along that night and that one or both of them had done the whipping and were responsible for her death. The sad story detailed by this poor unfortunate woman, while lying upon her death bed, with only a faint hold upon life, touched the heart of Dr. J. A. Henderson. It no doubt was the incentive and moving power that actuated him in his perilous undertaking of organizing an armed force to put down white-capping.
As has been stated in a previous chapter, he was the organizer and leader of an armed force call Blue Bills, And up to the time of his death, perhaps, did more toretard the progress of white-capism than any other one man in Sevier County. He was a shrewd man, and a natural born leader, and the White-caps would sooner tread upon the tail of a deadly rattler than to know that he was on their trail. He was a veritable thorn in their flesh.
When Dr. Henderson returned to Sevierville and related the circumstances of the whipping and death of Mrs. Breeden, it touched the hearts of all who heard it,, and many of them signified their willingness to go at a moments warning to meet the White-caps on their raids, and avenge this cruel deed.
The alleged cause for this whipping was that the Breeden girls were living in adultery. And from the best information that can be had we do not doubt the truthfulness of this accusation as to Miss Bell, while some say that Miss Martha was a virtuous woman. The two Breeden girls were very intelligent and were rather good looking. Miss Martha was married soon after the whipping to a respectable and substantial citizen and has ever since lived a virtuous life. The old lady who died defending the virtue of her two daughters, was herself never accused of being a lewed woman.
About three years after the first whipping another attempt was made to whip the Breeden girls, who were then living on Patrick Johnson's land in the house with their brother Jesse Breeden. The door was battered down, and Jesse well remembering the fate of his mother, made his escape at a back window. He went dashing down the road in the direction of Johnson's yelling for help. Johnson asked him what on earth was the matter.
Johnson was no friend to the White-caps, and snatching his trusty revolver, hastened to the scene of the trouble. The house sets close by the roadside on the East, and two or three White-caps were left on the lower side of the house to guard the road. They saw Johnson coming and opened fire on him at once, but without effect, as he still kept coming.
The main body of the White-caps were on the upper side of the house making preparations for the whipping. Those on the lower side unable to hold their position, called for help :
Up to this time he had not fired a single shot, and now began to pour it into them as fast as he could pull the trigger. The White-caps fired one more volley and fled in dismay, leaving " Pad" master of the situation.
I will follow them one step farther before I close this chapter. The White-caps had shot out their ammunition and went immediately in search of more. They called at James Brown's store at Sinking Springs, for a new supply. Mr. Brown had retired, but thinking it was some of his neighbor boys, got up to get it for them. The night was dark and he unlocked the store door, walked behind the counter and lit a lamp. Imagine his surprise when he found his store standing full of masked men instead of neighbor boys. They demanded from him a full supply of ammunition, saying:
" We have shot out once to night, either at a man or his image we don't know which for we could not hit him, but we are going back to try him again."
"We don't have to buy it" replied the leader, walking towards the back end of the house where Mr. Brown's Winchester was setting. Mr. Brown took in the situation at a glance and in an instant stood grasphis gun while the White-caps went flying out the door.
The writer well remembers the circumstance, but cannot now recall the day of the week, but it must have been Friday night, at least it was an unlucky night for White-caps.
Provenance
Text from The White-caps : a History of the Organization in Sevier County, published 1899, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.