BlockBefore

Sullivan County, Tennessee - Chapter 22: The Church, 1909

From Historic Sullivan; a History of Sullivan County, Tennessee, with Brief Biographies of the Makers of History, published 1909. 8,180 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

6 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

8,180 words

Machine-read from scans of Historic Sullivan; a History of Sullivan County, Tennessee, with Brief Biographies of the Makers of History, published 1909. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 22: The Church

In the company of the pioneer was the minister - himself prepared for the trials of border life, and journeying with a cavalcade much as a chaplain goes along with an army - expecting to see hard service and to become accustomed to hard living. They came prepared not only to battle against sin with the gospel, but also to bear arms like the rest, not knowing when a service might be interrupted by an Indian foe. The preachers and the men members went armed to church.

While the Presbyterians were the first to have established places of worship in Tennessee, it is probable the first minister to preach on Tennessee soil was of the Episcopal faith, or one of the established Church of England.

When Col. William Byrd began his survey at Currytuck, in 1733, there went along as chaplain, Rev. Peter Fountain, an Episcopalian. In 1759-60 when Byrd was sent out to relieve Fort Loudon he left the company at Stalnaker's, the rest, however, went as far as Long Island and no doubt the chaplain went there too.

Charles Cummings and Joseph Rhea are known to have preached in Sullivan when, as chaplains, they accompanied the Christian expedition in 1776.

The first church to be erected on Tennessee soil was called Taylor Meeting House and was located near Gunning's, about four miles west of Blountville. Rev. Jacob Lake preached to the congregation that assembled there. This church antedates all other claims by a year if not

The following letter corroborated by records on the first county minute-book of Washington county, Virginia, establishes the claim of this church. No date was found showing the year in which the church was erected, but it was before 1777.

My Dear Brother: - After my kind respects to you I wish to say to you I have been well pleased with your letters in the Herald & Presbyter a paper I have been taking for many years, indeed I can say from its very beginning. I wish to tell you why I am interested in letters from East Tennessee it was my early Home I was born in Sullivan County near 75 years since and knew all the first settlers in that county and many in your county My father settled in 4 miles of Blountville west 1776 was identified with all the interests of the county till 1815 when we moved to Kentucky when he died John Jennings was his name. My grand Father and grand Mother were members of the first Presbyterian Church in Sullivan County and I think in the State and their bodies are buried in that old Church yard one mile East of where I was born known as Taylor Meeting House. I well remember when it was burned down. I was much interested in your giving an account of the Churches in your part of the State, and When I receive my H & P the first thing I look for is your letter The last one of my old friends I met was one that I knew from Blountville Samuel Rhea an elder in the Presbyterian Church met in New York in 1856 in General Assembly I had not saw him for many years he was a student when I knew him in Blountville at the Academy My father was teacher I became acquainted with Judge Luckey of your town 1836 at the General Assembly we were member, the first Presbyterian Minister that ever preached in East Tennessee Rev. Lake he took charge of Taylor church I can give you the names of many of the old members Rhea Taylors Anderson Potters Kings Nash Gammons Spurgens & Cole I hope you will excuse me for writing this letter I am an old man and you may find some one who knew me when a boy that would like to hear from me for I was well acquainted with all the leading families of Sullivan.2

2This letter was sent me by J. Fain Anderson, of Washington College, and I here acknowledge my indebtedness to him for many courtesies in the way of data concerning Sullivan County history. The letter was not received until this book was being prepared for the press, some already in type and therefore a full investigation of the history of the church, if procurable, was not permitted on such short knowledge of its existence.

Upon the receipt of this letter the records of Sullivan County were searched for a deed of conveyance, but none was found. The following however is recorded at Abingdon, the church being, as was then supposed, in Washington county, Virginia.

Ordered that David Steele be surveyor of the Main road from Steele's Creek to the Meeting House and that John Anderson Gent give him a list of tithables.

Ordered that Amos Eaton be surveyor of the Main Road from the Meeting House to Fort Patrick Henry and that John Anderson give him a list of tithables.

Following this church came two others - Upper Concord and New Bethel - the former near Vance's and the latter in the Forks. These two churches were organized by Samuel Doak, in 1780, and 1782, respectively. Upper Concord is now known as Weaver's - Frederick Weaver having given three acres of land, the ground around the church being used as a graveyard. Many of the first settlers are buried here - among them a soldier named Bean who was a victim of the accidental discharge of his gun, when returning home with the troops from King's Mountain.

At New Bethel is a graveyard wherein are buried ancestors of some of the best families of Sullivan County. The remains of William and Isaac McKinley, relatives of President McKinley, lie there.

In 1882, at the suggestion of Rev. R. F. King, a centennial was held, commemorating the one hundredth anniversary of the founding of the Forks church. The celebration lasted from August 23rd to 26th, and a histori- cal sermon by Rev. Samuel Hodge was the feature. Many thousands, including the ablest men in this section gathered there, venerating the memory of the old pioneer preachers.

Kingsport has long been a home of the Presbyterian church - one feature alone would keep the memory of that church alive there - the sending out of four brothers as ministers, who have distinguished themselves in the work - Nathan, John, Robert and Lynn Bachman.

All the early churches were surrounded with graveyards.3 It was a part of the early religious life to appear solemn and anything that suggested death and "this world is not my home" was made as ever-present as possible. The songs were mournful and impressed one with the uncertainty of life and certainty of death. While attending church the sexes separated at the door and sat apart during the services. When musical instruments were suggested for the choir a wail of protest went up from some of the old line clergy. As recent as the organization of the Methodist church in Bristol, Bishop McTyeire, in giving his views about the introduction of a melodion in the church, declared, " When you brought that melodion in here you brought the devil in with it." Still later a debate took place between Rev. William Robeson and Dr. David Sullins upon the same subject, Rev. Robeson opposing the introduction of the organ, which he defined "a box of whistles."

The Presbyterian church had some of their strongest men in the field at the opening of this new country. Cummings, Doak and Rhea were educated men - learned in the classics. That church was demanding an educated clergy at a time when the frontier afforded no convenient way of supplying preachers of that kind. In this the Pres-

3In the Blountville graveyard there is erected a marble slab dedicated to tha memory of Samuel Rhea - "Persia Sam," as he was known, who died in Persiand is buried there. He was in that land as a missionary, sent out by the Pres byterian church.

byterians, while having a most liberal open door policy - the requirements for membership being a simple confession of faith - yielded an opportunity that in a way belonged to them by right of exploration. Other denominations were looking toward this field with the view of evangelization.

The Methodist and Baptist churches required no educational qualifications of their ministers - they simply wanted men of God and they pushed them into the byways of the western country with a rapidity and a disregard for sacrifice that well nigh stunned their religious contemporaries. The itineracy system of the Methodist church has been a power in the development and preservation of western civilization. Wherever there were three or more gathered together one of them was likely to be an itinerant preacher. They expected but little and got little for their services; they became the jest of the better provided men of the gospel; they went on unmindful of this and buried themselves in the wilderness, but their work made Tennessee the stronghold of Methodism in the South.

The Methodists became established in Sullivan County shortly after the Presbyterians. In 1774 Edward Cox came here from Maryland, where he had been converted under the ministry of Bishop Asbury, and settled near Bristol, a little later removing to the Holston river, near Bluff City. It was at his home the first Methodist society in the county and state was organized. Jeremiah Lambert was the first regularly appointed minister to take up work in the county, being appointed in 1783.

Acuff 's chapel, named for Timothy Acuff, was the first Methodist church built on Tennessee soil. Acuff donated the land for the church and graveyard.

Much of the history of all church organizations isin dispute. Strange though it may be, legal and military records being better preserved than the proceedings of the church.

The first conference of the Methodist church was held at Keywood's or Cawood's, on the Holston river.4 Bishop Asbury, in his journal, speaks of this conference as follows:

April 28, 1788. We reached the head of the Watauga; came to Greer's. The people are in disorder about the Old and New State; two or three men have been killed. At Nelson's, I had a less audience than was expected; the people having been called away on an expedition against the newstate-men. Preached on Hebrews, vi. chapter, 11th and 12th verses. Shortly afterwards, he preached at "Owens', on Psalm 148, verses 17, 18, 19, with some fervour. Came to Huff acre's and Keywood's where we held Conference three days; and I preached each day. The weather was cold; the room without fire, and otherwise uncomfortable. We, nevertheless, made out to keep our seats until we had finished the essential part of our business."

The Baptist church was established in Tennessee by Rev. Tidance Lane, in 1779. It got a firm hold in Sullivan County in 1786. In that year Kendrick's creek church was organized by Jonathan Mulkey and in the same year an association was held at Double Springs - Rev. Lane was moderator. From 1792-94 Thomas Murrell was moderator. In 1795 a church was organized at Long Island by Abel Morgan and Richard Murrell. Reese Bayless was moderator in 1833. Rev. William Cate was in the same position at Muddy creek in 1853, and Rev. Elkanah Spurgeon at Muddy creek in 1865. The first association held at Blountville was in 1870, by Rev. W. A. Keen. Among the early pastors of Muddy creek church were Elders Peter Kuhn, William Cate and Noah Cate, also Elder W. A. Keen and Rev. Noah Baldwin - the last named had also preached at Kingsport.

5Rev. Asa Ruth was one of the leading preachers of the Baptist church in Sullivan. He had the largest family in the county being the father of twentythree children. An obituary notice shortly after his death announced this fact closely followed by the text of the minister, " Man born of woman is of few days and full of trouble."

One of the greatest revivals ever held in Blountville was conducted by Rev. Ruth in 1869-70, the other preachers in the town co-operating. Over one hundred conversions resulted from this meeting, which lasted manyweeks.

A Baptist church existed for years on the Holston river, above Bluff City, in charge of Rev. Edwards. There was also one in lower Kingsport with Rev. Noah Baldwin as its minister.

The Lutheran church was organized in Sullivan County between 1790 and 1795, on Reedy creek. The first ministers of this denomination in the county were Revs. Paul Henkel and John G. Butler. Revs. Adam Miller and Jacob Zink were first to reside here as regular pastors. The church in this section became connected with the Synod of North Carolina until 1820, at which time the Tennessee Synod was formed, the churches remaining in this connection until 1861 when the Evangelical Lutheran Holston Synod was organized at Zion's church, in Sullivan County. Among the ministers included were Abel J. Brown, William Hancher, J. M. Schaefer, J. K. Hancher, J. B. Emmert, J. Fleener, A. Fleener, J. A. Seneker, J. Clovinger and J. C. Barb. Dr. A. J. Brown was not only the ablest representative the Lutheran church had in this section, but was one of the ablest in the South. He contributed largely to the church papers and was a profound debater.

The Christian church was first organized at Concord (Weaver's) about 1842. David T. Wright was the minister in charge. Among those who were early officials in the church were the Millards, Hughes, Nelsons, Love, Hatchers, Blevins and Warrens. For many years the members of this denomination in Bristol were one congregation, worshipping at their church on Spencer street, (Virginia side) but the increasing membership and the inconven- ience of the location made necessary the erection of a second church, which now stands on the corner of Sixth and Broad streets (Tennessee side) and is known as the Central Christian church. The Christian church from a small beginning has made a wonderful showing in the county within the last decade.

The Church of the Brethren has undergone more changes in name than any other denomination. It had a peculiar origin. In 1724, a German, for the purpose of religious contemplation, retired to a place of solitude some distance from Philadelphia, where he attracted many visitors and won followers to his belief and teachings. At various times they were known as the Brotherhood of Euphrates, Tunkers, Seventh Day Baptists, "Tumblers,"6 Dunkards and until recently German Baptists. In 1908, at their annual gathering in Des Moines, Iowa, they adopted the name of Church of the Brethren.

The annual meeting of this church in 1905 was held in Bristol during the month of June and attracted many thousands of visitors and church delegates from all parts of the country. The even tempered courtesy of the communicants and their unaffected devotion in daily life left an impression that will not soon be forgotten.

The organization of this church in the county was in 1850, three miles southwest of Blountville and was known as Pleasant Hill congregation. Elder John A. Bowman and M. M. Bowman were the first ministers and Henry Garst and Benjamin Wine were the first deacons. October 3, 1851, the church lot and burying-ground were donated by Elder John A. Bowman and Benjamin Wine and deeded to M. M. Bowman, Henry Garst and Jacob Lear, first trustees.

to promote the cause of Judaism, was organized in Bristol in October, 1903, the membership including every male Israelite in the city, which at that time numbered six persons, and was the first institution of its kind here. The officers elected for the first year were as follows: A. S. Gump, president; Abe Morris, Vice-president and H. J. Simon, secretary and treasurer. The congregation has grown steadily in recent years, its membership now numbering over thirty-five. The Jewish population, including all ages, numbers at present about one hundred and seventy-five. The congregation in 1906 purchased its own cemetery site near the old fair grounds. No house of worship has been erected by the Jews of Bristol, although steps are now being taken to that end. Devotional services are conducted in a hall on Sixth street, under the direction of a minister, recently elected - Rev. Dr. Lesser. Sunday-school exercises are also held every Sunday morning.

The Episcopal and Catholic denominations, although having many communicants, have never had an organized church in the county.7 In Bristol the Tennessee members worship in churches of their respective faith on the Virginia side.

The Salvation Army was organized in Bristol during 1884 by Capt. Emma Westbrook and Lieut. Elva Baker. The first meeting was held in Burson's church. Capt. Westbrook was one of the original seven who with Moore, the leader, were sent over from England to organize the Army in America. Moore had not been here very long before he undertook to apostatize his following and organize a new Army. This caused a disruption in the ranks. Capt. Westbrook remained loyal to the Salvation Army, but there was a lapse

7It is remarkable that, while an Episcopalian was perhaps the first Protestant minister to set foot upon Tennessee soil, it took that church nearly three-quarters of a century to come back again. The early settlers here were uncompromising in their hatred of the established Church of England and they did not seem willing to differentiate between the religion of George Washington and that of George the Third.

The present structure on Seventh street, devoted exclusively to Army work, was erected in 1903, the lot being donated by Maj. A. D. Reynolds.

The first Sunday-school in the county was organized at New Bethel by Rev. L. G. Bell, in 1830.8 Samuel Hodge and James Gregg, Jr., were the first superintendents. Rev. Daniel Rogan organized the first Sunday-schools at Blountville and Kingsport about 1836.

The spirit of the church militant hovered over Sullivan County exactly one hundred years. But these warrior hosts were not always fighting sin - they were fighting themselves. Church was arrayed against church and the smoldering fires of disputes about church dogmas found an outburst in boisterous debates which often degenerated into street swagger. Church debates became frequent. A public debate took place in the Forks church between Frederick Ross and W. B. Rogers. During the discussion William G. Brownlow, who was a spectator, becoming dissatisfied with the way Rogers was handling his side of the question, arose in the audience and said: "Rogers, if I couldn't do any better than you I'd sit down." This debate lasted five hours. The controversial storm was always centered at Blountville. Here, just prior to the war between the states, the Presbyterians and the Methodists got into a dispute about the management of the school at the Institute. Rev. W. W. Neal, a Methodist minister, was in charge with two assistants, the Misses Thomas, who were Presbyterians. One very cold morning the fire in the assist- ants' room was nearly out. The Misses Thomas, not lacking in warmth of feeling for their side of the dispute, went to the fireplace and sat upon the wood and no doubt would have sat upon the views of the Rev. Neal had he been within reach. They then dismissed their part of the school and went home. John R. Fain, at whose home the young women were boarding, remonstrated with Rev. Neal and this brought about a fight between the two men. Factions became more antagonistic. Rev. Neal withdrew his forces from the Institute and opened a school in the Methodist church. Sympathizers from the country about Blountville came in to strengthen and increase the number of the rebellious forces. The students of the two schools would have nothing to do with each other. This state of affairs continued until the end of the school.

The war between the states quieted for a while the war between the churches, but the disputes arose again and became acute in Blountville. The Methodist church was the object of attack and the best mode of baptism to wash out sins was the doctrine most discussed. The Baptists took up the fight. Not only did the older people dwell upon the differences, but following their example the youths of both sexes became involved. The latter knew little of church doctrines, and so their disputes resolved themselves into banters about which church bell was the biggest or which steeple reached nearest heaven and other material things, often ending in one or the other side being worsted in a fist fight.

A servant girl, living in a family opposite the Methodist parsonage, one day poised herself on the stile, arms akimbo, head tossing to and fro, and challenged the cook of the preacher's family. "Yes, she shouted, "you read in the good book about John the Baptist, but you never hear of John the Methodist, ' ' and with a triumphant sweep of her hand retired to her cloister in the kitchen, thankful she was not like other people she knew.

young boarding-school girl was kept locked in her room and chaperoned to school by devotees of one church lest some one of an opposing faith should kidnap her. She had been persuaded that she would be damned in eternal perdition if she failed to be baptized according to the rites of the church which had her in charge. Her hysterical acceptance of this baptism brought on a controversy whose everness was almost intolerant.

Dr. J. T. Kincannon began discussing baptism in the pulpit from the Baptist standpoint. Three or four sermons followed. As would naturally result he criticised other modes of baptism This drew a sermon from Rev. William Robeson, preacher in charge of the Blountville circuit, defending the Methodist mode of baptism. On hearing of it Kincannon challenged Robeson to a joint debate, which challenge was promptly accepted.

The debate was widely advertised in the church papers and drew able divines and laymen from many sections of the country. It took place in the Methodist church on June 10th, 11th and 12th, 1874. Press representatives were there from most of the church papers of Tennessee and Virginia. They placed their tables in front of the pulpit and made so much show in the shifting of paper and other bustling movements that one spectator, unused to such scenes in the staid old church, was led to remark that it reminded him of the money changers in the temple.

The Baptist divine placed a banner on the wall, back of the pulpit, with baptidzo in partial conjugation thereon; this, to the unlettered, was an alarming mystic that meant much in his favor. Piles of commentaries, text-books and reference books lay all about. The speakers were allowed fifteen minutes each and the discussion was continuous from the morning hour until noon - then a recess for dinner, after which the speaking was again begun, the same time being allowed during the afternoon. No meeting was held at night. The referees

Each debater presented his side ably and to the satisfaction of the side represented, but in other respects there was nothing to make the event remarkable except the length of it. However, the audience, which packed the church to the doors, even crowding the gallery and windows, did not diminish during the three days.

The effect of this discussion was wholesome and far reaching. It silenced, perhaps for all time, the petty church disputes that had become annoying, and brought together in more friendly relation the various church people. And if these worthy men had never done else in their lives worth recording, this event alone deserves to be remembered as having united the people of that town and vicinity in friendlier lellowship than ever before.

The Camp-Meeting

The most popular and therefore the most numerously attended tent meetings in upper East Tennessee were at Bond's camp-ground, four miles southwest of Blountville. It was organized in 1842 by Rev. George Eakin, better known as "Father Eakin." The original tent holders at the time of its organization were John Barnes, John Fleming, John Denny, Benjamin Johnson, Moses Wright, Robert Easley, Noah Hull, Rev. Samuel Stevens, William Cole, William Hilton, Stephen Adams, William Lindamood, Looney Gammon, Alexander Standfield, William Snodgrass, David Snodgrass, William Barnes, Benjamin Yoakley, Rev. Blake Carlton, Rev. W. K. Cross, Peter Yoakley, John Hull, Rev. J. J. James, Joseph Spurgeon, Henry Yoakley, Jacob Snapp, Jacob Messick, William Deery, Rev. Thomas P. Ford, Frederick Carlton, Rev. Joseph McCrary and Martin Hawk.

The influence of these meetings went beyond the bounds of the camping places. They usually began on Friday and extended well into the following week -

The camp-meetings were held until the Civil War and were not revived until 1867-70. The tenters who rebuilt then were J. C. Yoakley, Rev. W. K. Cross, Jonathan Morrell, Jonathan Hawk, David Akard, H. D. Hawk, Jessie Adams, James Barnes, Sr., James Barnes, Jr., G. R. Barnes, E. C. Barnes, J. S. Cartwright, R. S. Cartwright, John Roller, David Roller, Bettie Holt, Dod Cross, James H. Baird, W. F. Yoakley, W. A. Boy, S. S. Hall, "Aunt" Betsy Carlton, Ellen Yoakley, Polly Yoakley, Betsy Bond, Polly Hawk, all noted for their religious zeal and power in prayer.

The result of these meetings was felt in commercial as well as in religious life. It is of record, but without explanation, that land in the vicinity of Bond's campground was worth ten dollars on the acre more than land outside of its inflence.

The social life too was strengthening, elevating and spiritual. Those old women, who gathered and tented there year after year had no ambition but to please and entertain and worship. Their tents were open so long as there was any place to stay and their tables gave up in profusion the best of their farm products. Their cooking became as famous as their religion. Young women have gone there to learn the secret of those tempting dishes and today many a table that is spread in Sullivan County offers delicious evidence of an art learned around the kitchens at the old camp-ground.

The lives of those old women, like "Aunt" Betsy Carlton, have been a benediction. Whether in the kitchen preparing the food or at the table serving it and begging you to have more or at the altar bending in prayer or in the sick room nursing back to health the ebbing life of a neighbor, they have been missionaries of unpretentious tenderness and care. Too few have been the years allotted to them, for in such hearts rests the real religion of the world. "Aunt" Betsy Carlton, born during the warring years of the seventeenth century and reaching far into the eighteenth, represents the type of Tennessee frontier women who played such a noble part in the struggle of our early days.

The ground upon which the tents of the old camp-ground stood still remains the property of the church, but the tents are gone and nothing remains but a memory to remind one of the scenes that transpired there.

The last sermon at Bond's was delivered by Rev. John E. Naff, a grandson of "Father" Eakin, who preached the first sermon there. The meetings were discontinued about 1895.

Ketron's camp-ground was established about the same time as Bond's - a year later perhaps. It was also known asjj Reedy creek camp-ground. Henry Ketron gave the land for the tents, church and burying-ground. The church was burned down in 1863 and the campmeetings at that place abandoned. Among the early tenters were John Ketron, Wesley Ketron, Watson Ketron, Joseph Newland, William Newland, Abner Hughes, Lot 0. Gott, Rev. S. D. Gaines and Philip Foust.

An exciting incident at this camp-ground was the fight that took place between Rev. W. G. Brownlow and Fayette McMullen. Brownlow had made some stinging criticisms of McMullen and the latter went to the campground and proceeded to "cane" Brownlow, who drew his pistol, but was prevented from shooting by the intercession of friends.9

This Indenture made this Fifteenth day of March 1847 Between Wm. Rockhold of the one part and Andrew Riley, Andrew Boy, Jacob Boy, Royston Boy, James B. Worley, Henry Kesler, Nathl Hix, Joseph

9Price says this fight took place at Brush creek camp-ground. The story was told me by a spectator of the difficulty, but reports varied as to Brownlow 's part. One claimed Brownlow snapped his pistol at McMullen, another that he shot him and still another that McMullen was shot three times and was killed.

Merideth and Wm Rockhold all of the County of Sullivan & State of Tennessee Witnesseth that the said William Rockhold this day in consideration of his high regard for the Methodist Episcopal Church and in consideration of his promises heretofore made to said Church hath this that tract or parcel of land whereon the Camp & Meeting house is situ ated on the river Holston in Sullivan County commonly called Rockholds Camp ground. Bounded as follows by Morrels line, Shells line & the river containing twelve acres - be the same more or less for them the said trustees to have and to hold in trust for said Church as long as said Church continue the same in the plan of their Circuit & to hold Camp Meeting on the said premises and it is further understood should it so happen at any time that either Andy Riley A. Boy, R. Boy, J. Boy, J. B. Worley, H. Kesler, N. Hix, J. Merideth or W. Rockhold the said trustees or any of them die, resign, leave said church or be expelled it shall be the duty of those in office to fill said veyquancy & when fild thair acts shall be as valid as the acts of those mentioned in this Deed and it is further understood & greed should it so happen hereafter that said church desist - the use of said premises as a place of public worship or drop the same from the plan of same circuit in said Church then the said premises reverts back to said Rockhold his heirs &c. In testimony whereof I have hereunto subscribed my name.

At Acuff 's camp-ground was the earliest camp-meeting held in the county. It was in the vicinity of Acuff 's chapel. The tents were built of logs and covered with bark. But little is known of its history.

Temperance

The history of temperance in Tennessee is as old as the history of the state. James Robertson, the "Father of Tennessee," declared that "the conversion of crops of grain into spirituous liquors is an unwarranted perversion, unservicable to white men and devilish for Indians," and expressed the hope "that there may never be any waste of grain by distillation, or waste of estates or ruin of soul by drinking liquor."10

The early advocates of temperance were not practical. They could not realize the difference between ethics and ether. They depended upon prayer rather than upon politics, and in consequence the old Prohibition party was never in itself successful. When St. John was a candidate for president on the Prohibition ticket he received two11 votes in Bristol and one12 in Blountville. As early as 1785 a part of Tennessee declared for prohibition and later the entire state was in the prohibition column.

In the early years of the temperance movement great demonstrations were made and the organization of temperance societies was prevalent. The Washingtonian Society was the first introduced, its object being the same as those following, such as Good Templars and Band of Hope.

Doss Leedy, the old stage driver, once drove a temperance band wagon from Kingsport to Arcadia and Blountville, and along the way testimonials to the cause were prepared.

At Blountville temperance enthusiasts bought out the "groggery," with the bad will of the owner, and as there was only one barrel it was taken with its contents to a grove at the east end of town. Here a great concourse of people had assembled. A keg of powder was placed beneath the barrel and while the crowd stood in suspense a fuse attached to the keg was lighted - in a little while the flying staves and flames gave evidence that the liquor was no more.

The tenseness and religious severity of the scene was appeased by the put in of a local wit, who, surrounded by a company of fellow sympathisers, protested loud enough to be heard, "boys, that's a damned waste."

paign of 1853. James Odell and John Spurgeon were candidates for representative. Odell represented the anti-temperance sentiment. The real issue, however, was a row of cherry trees. These trees had been on Spurgeon 's farm and grew along a roadside, the public each year helping themselves to the crop. This trespassing soon became a nuisance and the trees were cut down. This incident Odell used with telling effect, relating how Spurgeon deprived the poor people of his cherries - how he cut the trees down rather than let them have any. Odell was elected, but more on account of the cherry tree story than his anti-temperance platform.

The churches early began to take a hand in the regulation of the liquor traffic. At the Cold Spring church it was decided that the distilling and drinking of liquor was a growing evil and that the manufacture of it by the elders should cease. But this restriction was too sudden and absolute and less prohibitive measures were adopted. All members, but one, were to abandon the making of whiskey and he was to do the "stilling" for the congregation.13 Drunkenness was a rare thing in those days.

The business men of the nation came to the rescue of the temperance people. The railroads were the first to declare against drinking. Human lives depended upon the sobriety of their employees and abstinence became a qualification required by all employers. Other lines of business followed. The old political parties, that had year after year incorporated in their platforms, "we are opposed to sumptuary legislation," had their ears to the ground, and now abandoned "sumptuary," hurriedly espousing r 13This church is not given as an exception. The practice was prevalent if not legalized among the members of various churches of that day. The following story furnishes another picture of the times: One of the ministers who preached to the Cold Spring congregation was in the habit of taking a pack of hounds to church and announcing from the pulpit that all those who desired to join in the fox chase could meet him early Monday morning at his stopping place. One Sunday a favorite hound followed the minister into church, crawled up in a window and fell asleep. It was some distance to the ground and a worshipper seeing the dog there pushed him outside. The preacher saw the act and, although in the midst of his sermon, walked down from the pulpit and was about to strike the offender when friends interfered. The minister then went back and resumed his discourse.

the cause of temperance. This action was a partial solution of the question - there were plenty of men in both parties who were ready to align themselves with the cause, but when it came to a test they could not turn their backs on the party with which they had been so long associated.

The country people, when given an opportunity, have stood for temperance. The brewers and distillers, seeing the wave of public sentiment, tendered their services to help reform the saloon. But the saloon-keepers have never been able to control an opportunity; they have, by their excesses and ridicule and boasting, made once flouted prohibition a refuge and a respected issue, and they come each year within closer view of the saloon's inevitable end.

Edmund Pendleton Gaines

Sullivan County's most noted military man was Gen. Gaines. At one time he was considered for the place of commander-in-chief of the United States army.1

He was a descendant of Edmund Pendleton, who at one time was president of the Virginia Court of Appeals. This Pendleton had purchased a large tract of land in Sullivan County - some five thousand acres - one of the first entries, and thither his nephew James Gaines, the father of Edmund, removed when the latter was in his thirteenth year. Here he was brought into association with influences, like the Indian depredations, that determined him upon a military career.

Three years later he began to devote himself to the study of law, but about this time W. C. C. Claiborne, recognizing his work in a military way obtained an appointment for him in the regular army under Col. Butler. In 1801 he was selected to make a topograghical survey from Nashville to Natchez.

In 1804 he was appointed collector of customs at Mobile. In addition he was appointed agent of the Postmaster-General, the duties of which office was to inspect the post-offices of his district and find out who were implicated in the plot with Aaron Burr. While stationed at Fort Stoddart it was reported to him that a person of distinction was seen traveling in the district and suspecting that it was Burr, for whose arrest a proclamation had recently been sent out by the President, he at once determined to intercept him.

lPresident Adams is credited with having remarked once that he was afraid to appoint either Gaines or Scott commander-in-chief, as the appointment of either might result in a duel - they being irreconcilable enemies.

Gaines' arrest of Burr was quite dramatic. When the officers approached Burr he assumed a startled pose, demanding upon what authority a citizen was thus stopped upon the highway. The arrest was made with positiveness, but with a courtesy due the rank of the distinguished citizen. Burr was sent with escort to Richmond.

Although only carrying out orders, Gaines, all through his career, felt the effects of the Burr influence against him, and it invariably asserted itself when he stood for promotion.

Gaines shortly after this event decided to resign from government service and take up the practice of law, but the probability of war with England made it necessary to grant him only temporary leave. He began the practice of law in the counties of Washington and Baldwin, Mississippi. It was not long, however, before a summons came for him to assist his country against the advance of the British.

He was now thirty years of age. It was this war that brought him fame. In his memorable defense of Fort Erie he was made so conspicuous by his bravery that Congress voted him a gold medal, while the states of New York, Tennessee and Virginia presented him costly swords in token of their appreciation.

In this war he arose from rank to rank until he reached that of Major-General, the highest authorized by law. At the close of the war he was assigned to a command in the South, on the borders of Georgia and Florida, where the negroes and Indians were giving trouble and there he was associated with Gen. Andrew Jackson in the Seminole War.

Gen. Jackson appointed Gaines president of a court martial, to try Arbuthnot and Ambrister - the former being hung and the latter shot. These executions were strongly condemned by Jackson's enemies and called for a thorough investigation, in which the officers were exonerated.

Gen. Gaines was relieved of his command in 1846 because, without authority, he was supposed to have summoned volunteers to aid Gen. Taylor in the Mexican War, but a court of inquiry, that had been convened at Fortress Monroe, on the 20th of July the same year, acquitted him.

He died at New Orleans,2 June 6, 1849, seventy-two years of age. Gen. Gaines was married three times - his last wife being the widow Myra Clark Whitney, daughter of Daniel Clark.3

The Battle Of Erie

2Jefferson Davis was once on Gen. Gaines' staff. Later when on a wedding journey to New Orleans he called upon the General. Gen. Winfield Scott had just published his book on military tactics and as he had recently returned from a visit to Europe his book was full of foreign phrases. On being asked by Davis what he thought of the book, Gaines replied: "The English language is sufficiently copious to explain any idea Gen. Scott ever had. "

3Daniel Clark was a native of Ireland and came to New Orleans as Consul in 1766. Here he became entangled with a beautiful, French woman named Zulime Carrier, by whom he had a daughter, born in 1806. Shortly before his death, in 1813, he left this daughter in the care of a Philadelphia family named Davis, who brought her up in ignorance of her parentage. In 1830 Davis, who was then a member of the Pennsylvania legislature sent home for certain papers and Myra, in searching for them, "discovered letters that partially revealed the secret of her birth. In 1832 she married W. W. Whitney, of New York, who followed up the clew, discovered an old letter containing an account of a will made by Clark before his death giving all his estate to Myra and acknowledging her as his legitimate child. The will could not be found, but other testimony was found that disclosed the fact of its one time existence and of a secret marriage between Clark and Miss Carrier in Philadelphia in 1803.

Whitney brought suit against the city of New Orleans to recover property that had been willed to his wife. It was hotly contested, but Whitney died before a decision was reached.

In 1839 the widow married Gen. Edmund P. Gaines, of Sullivan County, who entered into the case as enthusiastically as his wife. It was carried through all the courts and dragged its slow tapeful length along, but was lost. Gen. Gaines died in 1852; his widow never gave up the suit. She had secured some new evidence and while losing in the lower court, the United States Supreme Court sustained her claim. The value of the property was $35,000,000. The city appealed the case, and the breaking out of the war delayed judgment until 1867, when once more judgment was rendered in her favor. In her lifetime she secured more than $6,000,- 000 and the suit became the sensation of the country.

The English now turned their attention to Fort Erie. Gen. Ripley was in charge of the fort, while Gen. Drummond was directing the English forces against it.

Gen. Gaines, in August, 1814, was sent to Fort Erie and at once took command. He began by acquainting himself with the condition of the defences and his efforts and interest put new life into the garrison.

On the 13th Drummond began a cannonade, which was continued until the next day. When this ceased, on account of the little damage done, it was clear that the British general would make a direct assault. Gaines therefore detailed two sets of men - one to be prepared against a surprise attack at night and the others on duty by day. A shell from the enemy, on the evening of the 14th, exploded in a small magazine and made a deafening noise. The British, thinking that they had destroyed the main magazine of the Americans, prepared to follow this up with another well directed blow.

At two o'clock on the morning of the 15th the American pickets announced the coming of the enemy, who expected to find the Americans asleep - but in this they were mistaken. When the advance columns came up a brilliant rocket was fired into their midst, disclosing their whereabouts and enabling the Americans to fire with more accuracy. The English did not lack for bravery and made five attempts to scale the walls, but each time were driven back with great loss - the grape and cannister doing deadly work. In one of these attacks Drummond, who was preparing to deal with the foe "showing no mercy," was himself the sufferer from his own rash order. After having denied Lieut. Macdonough quarter and killing him, the officer executing the order was slain in the same way. Having shown no quarter he received none. The battle raged all along the lines until dawn.

attack when an explosion was heard and there was great confusion and retreat. The bastion, which had been filling up with soldiers, was exploded, sending bodies high into the air. At this the British broke ranks and left the field. When the enemy retreated there were found to be two hundred and twenty-one killed; one hundred and seventyfour wounded and one hundred and sixty-six prisoners. The American loss was seventeen killed; fifty-six wounded and eleven missing.

Both sides prepared to renew the struggle, both having received reinforcements. The British daily threw shells into the fort to the annoyance of the garrison and on the 28th a shell fell through Gen. Gaines' office and, exploding, destroyed his writing desk and wounded him so severely that he was forced to give up his command, and was sent to Buffalo. Gen. Jacob Brown, although in broken health, succeeded him. The fighting was desultory after the first victory and camp fever, brought on by heavy rains in the marshy camp of the British, aided the Americans in accomplishing the defeat of the enemy along the Canadian borders.

Nathan Gregg was born August 5, 1835, on the Watauga river, two miles below White Store. He spent the routine life of a country boy, working on the farm during the season, which usually extended from January 1st to December 31st. He, however, attended the district school and obtained a fairly good education. He then took up the carpenter's trade, which he followed until the beginning of the Civil War.

Coming from fighting ancestry - his grandfather being in the Revolution and his father an officer in the War of 1812 - he early enlisted in the service of the Confederacy. He joined Capt. Willetts' company, made up mostly of Washington county (Tenn.) men, and was chosen lieutenant.

He was desperately wounded April 6, 1862, in the battle of Shiloh, where so many of the South 's brave sons gave up their lives. His captain (Willetts) was killed in the battle.

During the following summer he enlisted again - this time in Col. John Crawford's regiment, and was elected lieutenant-colonel. This regiment was known as the Sixtieth Tennessee.

He was captured in the battle of Big Black River Bridge, near Vicksburg, Mississippi, on the 17th day of May, 1863, and was taken to Johnson's Island and held as a prisoner until near the close of the war, when he was exchanged, upon which he returned home. Col. Crawford resigned his command in 1864 and Col. Gregg was promoted to a full colonelcy and given charge of the regiment - remaining with it until the close of the war. His regiment was disbanded April 12, 1865, at Christiansburg, Virginia.

Nathan Gregg

During his military career he had the reputation of being a humane and courageous officer. He returned to his home at the close of the war and in 1870 was elected sheriff of Sullivan County - was reelected in 1872 and again in 1874. He was elected three times to the legislature from Sullivan County, in 1876-78-82. He was a member of the legislature, which became historic for its settlement of the state debt, when such men as Butler, Gregg and others became famous in their efforts for a just settlement, as did the name "Smith of Fentress" become a byword and a reproach.

In the legislature Gregg became a leader, and in his political life, while a man of forceful nature - commanding in stature and style, he was more shrewd than statesmanlike.

Once, when anxious to get a bill passed, which he knew the speaker of the house did not favor, he had a dainty letter, written in a feminine hand, sent in to the presiding officer, requesting his presence in the lobby at once. The speaker, not divining any trick, excused himself, and his successor, being in sympathy with Col. Gregg, had the bill passed during the absence of the regular officer.

During the first administration of Grover Cleveland Col. Gregg was appointed Pension Agent, with offices at Knoxville, Tennessee. This was the last political office he held.

At one time he was urged to become a candidate for governor, but he rather discouraged the suggestion, modestly admitting his lack of educational qualifications - he having had only limited opportunities during his youth. He was gubernatorial timber nevertheless - his splendid moral character and honesty in handling public trusts making him valuable.

He had peculiar ideas about charity and would not subscribe even small amounts, always excusing himself by saying that one could never tell when it was deserving.

Col. Gregg never fully recovered from the wound he received in battle and this no doubt hastened his death, which occurred at his country home July 15, 1894, in the sixtieth year of his age.

Provenance

Text from Historic Sullivan; a History of Sullivan County, Tennessee, with Brief Biographies of the Makers of History, published 1909, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.