Sullivan County, Tennessee - Chapter 30: The Removal, 1909
From Historic Sullivan; a History of Sullivan County, Tennessee, with Brief Biographies of the Makers of History, published 1909. 2,583 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
2,583 wordsMachine-read from scans of Historic Sullivan; a History of Sullivan County, Tennessee, with Brief Biographies of the Makers of History, published 1909. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 30: The Removal
The history of the Cherokee Indians is so intervolved with the history of the first settlers of our State that anything concerning that tribe interests our people.
The removal, in 1838, of these Indians from their lifelong homes surpasses in pathos any page of our national history. It is the blot on the Escutcheon. The cause of this removal was covetousness on the part of the white race - a longing for more land. The Indians were slowly, and almost for a song, ceding away their chosen land. Although the government in a treaty (1798) agreed to "continue the guarantee of the remainder of their country forever" the whites did not cease making inroads and encroaching upon the tribe's land. By a treaty made January 7, 1806 the Cherokees ceded the large tract between Duck river and the Tennessee, which included Long Island in Sullivan County and embraced nearly seven thousand square miles. For this immense tract they received two thousand dollars per year for five years, a grist mill, a cotton gin and a life pension of one hundred dollars per year for the aged chief Black Fox. After another treaty, made on March 22, 1816, they declared they would never give up any more land.
Gov. McMinn, of Tennessee, under instructions from Washington, was using his efforts to have the Indians removed. At a council in November, 1818, he represented to the chiefs it was no longer possible to protect them from the encroachments of the whites, that their lands would be taken, their stock stolen, their women abused, and their men made drunkards unless they removed to the allotted territory in the West. He concluded by offering them one hundred thousand dollars for their
A new civilization and a new form of government now sprung up - principally through the influence of John Ross, the last chief of the Eastern Cherokees. It became treason, punishable by death, for any one to sell lands without the consent of the council.
Another Cherokee - Sequoya - distinguished himself about this time by inventing the Cherokee alphabet. He was the Cadmus of his race. It was easily learned and even without the aid of schools communication became more rapid and intelligent. Sequoya was granted a pension by the government and was the only literary pensioner in the United States. The Sequoya trees of California are named in his honor.
John Ross was made chief in 1828 and is the principal author of a constitution which was the first to govern an Indian tribe. He held the position of chief up to his death in 1866, being thirty-eight years the head of the nation.
Their acquirements in the way of enlightenment seemed to avail them little. Georgia was pressing them for their lands and was resorting to all kinds of strategy - to secret schemes and open overtures, but all were met with firm refusal. "It is the final and unalterable determination of this nation never again to cede one foot more of land."
When, in 1827, the Cherokees adopted a constitution, the Georgia legislature passed a resolution affirming that the State "had the power and right to possess herself, by any means she might choose, of the lands in dispute and to extend over them her authority and laws."
Cause Of Removal
Up to 1815 all negotiations had been for land only. In this year a little Indian boy in his rambles along the Chestatee river brought a shining pebble, about the size of a small marble, to his mother. She carried it to the nearest settlement and sold it to a white man. It proved to be gold. The news spread and in four years this section was overrun with white prospectors.
In this same year Andrew Jackson was elected President. He was an Indian fighter and an Indian hater. Although the Cherokees, six hundred strong, were among his greatest allies in his battle against the Creeks, he now turned against them and would offer them no sympathy nor aid.
Junaluska, one of the bravest of the chiefs who accompanied him, was heard to say, "If I had known that Jackson would drive us from our homes I would have killed him that day at the Horseshoe." When it was known the sympathy of Jackson was not enlisted for the Indian, depredations by the whites became general. Armed men went through the tribe, pillaging and burning. Laws were passed dispossessing the Indians of their homes without redress. Life became almost intolerable and property valueless to the Cherokee. He was not allowed to dig gold on his own land nor was his testimony permitted against any white man. He was helpless. The Supreme Court and the laws of Georgia conflicted. Georgia defied the courts. The issue became a national one and party lines were drawn.1 Such men as Henry Clay, Daniel Webster, Edward Everett, Wise of Virginia and Davy Crockett defended the Indian. Through all these trials Chief John Ross was very active in behalf of his people; so much so, he had, under threat, to seek refuge in Tennessee. He was later captured by the Georgia guard along with John Howard Payne, who was then stopping with Ross for the purpose of studying the Indian life. They were taken across the line into Georgia where Ross was held a prisoner for some time, but was finally released without explanation. '
The treaty of 1835, wherein about four hundred out of seventeen thousand Cherokees ceded all their lands west of the Mississippi to the United States for five million dollars, and a portion of land in Indian Territory was ratified at New Echota. A man named Schermerhorn was the government representative. He purported to be a minister of the gospel, but, on account of his underhand dealing, had to be warned that nothing but "fair and open terms" would be acceptable. The removal was to take place two years from the date of the treaty.
At the expiration of this time, however, only about two thousand of the Indians had left and it became evident that the removal would only be accomplished by force. Gen. Winfield Scott was given charge of these affairs with about seven thousand soldiers, four thousand of whom were volunteers. Sullivan County furnished her share and more wanted to go.
Troops were sent to various points in the Cherokee country, where they erected stockades in which to hold the Indians after they were corralled. From these stockades squads of soldiers armed with rifles and bayonets were sent through the mountains to bring in all Indians that could be found. Men going along the road or found in their fields were seized, and squaws engaged in their domestic duties were taken, while children, all unmindful of the approaching seizure, were often caught at play and forced to go. There were instances when a family, on being taken, looked back and saw their old home burning - set on fire by rowdy camp-followers; some on mischief bent, some for purposes of theft, some out of revenge. These ruffians were so ruthless in their thefts they even dug into the graves of the dead to rob them of metal ornaments.
One old gray-haired Indian, when told he must go, called his family, including his grandchildren, about him and all knelt down and prayed in their own language.
At one house which the soldiers surrounded, as was their custom to prevent escape, the woman of the home went to the door, called up the chickens to be fed for the last time, then, with her infant on her back and leading two other children, followed the men to her exile.
All the Indians were not so submissive. An aged man called Tsali (Charley) was taken with his family and the families of his three sons. His wife, being too old to walk as fast as the soldiers desired, was prodded with bayonets to hurry her along. The old man could not control himself. Talking in Cherokee to the others he quickly formed a plan to attack the soldiers at a given signal. This was done and each Indian grabbed the soldier nearest him - their guns were taken and one soldier was killed. The rest fled while the Indians escaped into the mountains. Many also escaped from the stockades and seeing it impossible to secure all, Gen. Scott made a proposition through Col. Thomas, agreeing that if they would surrender Charley and his party for punishment he would let the others alone until the courts could adjust the matter. Charley on hearing this came in of his own accord, accompanied by his brother and sons. He offered himself a sacrifice for his nation. All were shot.
After having collected nearly seventeen thousand of the Cherokees the long journey began. Some went by river, but the great majority went overland. A delay of several months was occasioned by the extreme hot weather. The march was resumed in October and continued through the entire winter.
of the exiles was a trail of death - from ten to twentydying each day. Among them was the devoted wife of Chief Ross who had to be buried by the roadside. When the end came in March, 1839, over four thousand had died from the effects of the removal.
It is hard for us now to harmonize our convictions with the events that transpired at this period, but the act recalls that of William the Conqueror, who, to satisfy his passion for outdoor sport, demolished the homes and churches of the peasantry for thirty miles in New Forest, and offered no return for the loss. It befell that in a short while three of his house met violent accidental deaths in this forest.
John Netherland was born in Powhatan county, Virginia, September 20, 1808, but his parents removed to Sullivan County when he was an infant and settled at Kingsport.
He had the advantage of a good education, being a pupil of Doak, under whom his academic course was completed in his fourteenth year - after this he had home training under Henry Hoss, an excellent scholar.
He began the study of law in 1828 and was practising in 1829. Early in life he became interested in politics, and in 1833, when but twenty-five years old, was elected to the state senate from the district composed of Sullivan, Hawkins and Carter counties. While in this body he attained high rank among his colleagues.
While he was a member, one of the leading questions of the day came up - that pertaining to the removal of the Indians from their eastern homes to the territory set apart for them beyond the Mississippi. In an eloquent speech, in which he appealed to the humane side, he took a stand against the removal.
A revision of the state constitution in 1834, by which the eligible age of a state senator was placed at thirty, threw him out of the race. In 1835, however, he was elected to represent Sullivan County in the legislature. It was while serving as representative that he furnishes an example of high integrity in office. He refused to vote for a resolution, asking our senators to vote for the expunging clause, which referred to an act of censure passed upon Andrew Jackson. Sullivan County endorsed it in a primary and asked Netherland to vote for it, but rather than go against his principles he resigned his commission and returned to private life.
John Netherland
When in 1859 the Whig or what was then known as the "Opposition" party wanted a candidate for governor, Netherland was unanimously the choice of the convention at Nashville. He accepted although he knew he had little chance of success. Isham G. Harris was his opponent and defeated him - Netherland, however, ran far ahead of his ticket. Along with Thomas A. R. Nelson and Andrew Johnson, Netherland took sides with the Union during the Civil War and while he suffered, as many others on both sides, he did not harbor hatred, but advised tolerance and good feeling when the battles were over.
His last official act was as a member of the constitutional convention of 1870, although he was afterwards tendered a foreign mission by President Johnson, which he declined.
It is more as a lawyer than as a politician that his memory will be preserved. He was one of the strongest advocates in this or any other state.
During John Netherlands last days as a practicioner at the Blountville bar the venerable appearance of the man seemed to add weight to all said. Besides his legal knowledge he knew human nature. He was a well informed man, reading much and committing to memory - his favorite writings were the Bible and Robert Burns, from which he would often quote. No jury could resist his style of delivering a message to them. He would
He was especially forceful in criminal practise and the prisoner was well favored who secured him as counsel. When he was acting in a murder case - defending a prisoner
- groups of men could be seen entering the court-house. The farmer found it possible to postpone his work, the business man left his counter, the carpenter his bench and even the school boy, always ready to rebel against listening to discourses of any kind, hurried to the courtroom - all drawn thither by the report that "John Netherland closes for the defense."
He was once engaged to defend a young man charged with murder. There are two periods of life that appeal to any jury - youth and old age. He would often say, "I quote from the good book - the greatest of all books - the book upon which all human law is founded." This time he plead for mercy. He told the story of Absalom, the young man who mutinied, and how, despite the grave charge, the king plead for his life on account of his youth. "And David," said he in concluding, " 'numbered the people that were with him and set captains of thousands and captains of hundreds over them. And David sent forth a third part of the people under the hand of Joab and a third part under the hand of Abishai and a third part under the hand of Ittaii. And the king stood by the gate side and all the people came out by hundreds and by thousands. And the king commanded Joab and Abishai and Ittaii, saying, deal gently for my sake with the young man Absalom' - gentlemen of the jury, deal gently with the young man."
But for his cheerful spirit, that never forsook him, his last days might have gone out in gloom. Himself a great sufferer from bodily affliction, his cup of sorrow was filled by the unhappy fate of his household. His favorite kinsman had passed from earth; his son and namesake, John, had died from pneumonia, the result of exposure in rescuing his father from drowning; his wife, the companion of his long life, was dead and his daughter, Molly, had been killed by being thrown from a runaway horse. And as the old jurist sat on his sunny porch one afternoon, his long stem pipe held in a palsied hand, which, with his increasing emotion, tossed the ashes in his lap, he thus sorrowed. "Sam," he said to his companion, "old John's gone - and young John's gone - and Sarah's gone - and Molly's gone "
Provenance
Text from Historic Sullivan; a History of Sullivan County, Tennessee, with Brief Biographies of the Makers of History, published 1909, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.