Amador County, California - Chapter 19: Rancheria Murders, 1881
From History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. 5,382 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
7 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
5,382 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 19: Rancheria Murders
Ill-feeling between the Americans and Mexicans - Frequency of Murders - The Band First Seen at Hacalitas - Up Dry Creek - At Rancheria - To Drytown - A Second Time to Kancheria - Slaughter - Departure of the Eobbers - Excitement the Next Day - Immense Gathering - Trial and Hanging of the Mexicans - Death of Roberts - Borquitas - Presence ot County Officers - Pursuit of the Murderers - Hunt Around Bear Mountain - The Murderers Overtaken - Death of Phoenix - Expulsion and Disarming of Mexican Population - Outrages at Drytown - Burning of the Church - Mass Meeting at Jackson - Review After a Lapse of a Quarter of a Century.
THIS affair happened something over a quarter of a century since. Many of the witnesses are dead, others are gone, and many have forgotten some of the important matters. Those who are" accustomed to criminal trials, know how contradictory testi mony may be among candid, truth-telling men, even while the events are fresh in the mind. How much more difficult then to get at the truth when a quarter of a century has rolled over the events, inevitably obliterating much that would be necessary to form a rational opinion of the murders, and the resulting events of the following month. A somewhat retro spective view of the relations between the Mexican population and our own, seems necessary, to get a correct view of the situation.
There never was a good feeling between the native population and the Americans. The indolent native, fond of his siesta and cigarette, proud of the smallest quantity of Castilian blood, and holding in utter abhorrence laborious occupations, had, at first, contempt, and then hatred, for the wild Ameri canos, or Gringos (green-horns), as the Americans were termed, who seemed to be endowed with an infernal energy that tore up all the ordinary routine of life, and made men almost maniacs, in the search for wealth.
ifornia was conquered. Years before that Alexander Forbes, an Englishman, now a resident of Oakland, who wrote the " History of California," as early as 1835, speaks of occasional parties of Americans who came from the frontiers of the United States, whom no danger could appall and no difficulty deter; who would be likely in time to take California and hold it as they had taken Texas, if some foreign power did not step in and forestall them. At the time of the war, there were some two hundred Americans who had often made their power felt. Isaac Graham, with some fifty or sixty men, had taken possession of the Capital (Monterey), and made Juan B. Alvarado, Governor. They were always in a quasi rebellion. Fremont with his battalion, had gone in force through the country, stubbornly refusing to be whipped. The Mexican Government had an article inserted in the treaty, that the rights of the Mexicans to their property in California should be respected. But this did not prevent the Americans, on the discovery of gold, from taking possession of the best lands, and parceling them out into farms and cultivating them. The native owner was wont to consider himself lucky if he could save even his houses and his herds. The latter, the Americans would drive off and slaughter by the thousand, with hardly a pretense of secrecy. In this way the herds of nearly all the old dons were exterminated. The titles to their lands were scarcely ever recognized until they had passed into the hands of the Amer icans. In the gold mines, they were treated as intruders, and the discovery of a placer was sure to bring a swarm of men about, who believed in " Americans ruling America." This ill-feeling often culminated in murder and robbery. Particular roads frequented by parties of Mexicans, were found to be dangerous to travel. Several persons had been murdered on the road between Drytown and Cosumnes. Murderer's gulch, north of the town, had witnessed several murders, which, as the people believed, had been traced to the native population. Several attempts had been made to banish them from the country, but when driven from one camp they would go to another. As the miners were roving about and the population changing, the expulsion was soon forgotten, and the natives would return embittered and sullen. Joaquin's raids through the country had not been forgotten, and when the news of the slaughter of six or seven persons at Rancheria had spread over the county, it is not strange that the community should bje terribly excited, and should be moved to deeds which were afterwards looked upon with regret.
The murders were committed by twelve men, one of whom seemed to be white, and one a black man, the rest appearing to be of the ordinary Mexican type. Some of these were men of education, others had been vaqueros in the valleys; and all perhaps felt that they had some grievance to avenge, for we cannot account for their subsequent career on any other hypothesis. They were first heard from at Hacalitas (hard camp) not far from the Q ranch, on the night of the 5th of August, 1855, where they stayed all night.
The following morning, Monday, August 6th, they left the camp and made their way towards Drytown, first robbing a China camp, leaving the Chinamen tied. They passed some white men without disturbing them, however. It happened that George Durham, foreign tax collector, had started on much the same route and found that all the China camps from there to Eancheria had been robbed. He got a very good description of the numbers and appearance of the men, and found that they had been at Eancheria at Francis' store; also saw their camp just out of the town. He warned Francis against the men, saying that he thought they were the same men who had recently committed some depredations at Tuttle's store in Tuolumne county, and told Francis that he was in danger of being robbed. Durham then went towards Drytown, passing their camp. There seemed to be some difficulty among them, as two were well stripped apparently to fight, but were quieted by a tall, slender man, who seemed to be recognized as a chief. Two of the party followed Durham as if to attack him, but turned back after going a short distance. At Drytown, Durham en gaged Cross, the constable, to assist in collecting the tax from the Chinamen at Milton's ranch, as they had dodged him before when he went alone. They got back to Drytown about dark, and went into Mizener's store. While there Judge Curtis came in and said that a Spanish woman had come to his office and told him that the town was full of robbers; that she was afraid that they were all going to be robbed. The description of the party corresponded with the party which had been seen at Rancheria, and Cross and Durham resolved to visit the place on Chile flat where the robbers were taking supper. On coming to the house, they had left, but were found a short distance to the rear. Both parties, as they met, commenced firing, some thirty or forty shots being exchanged. The Mexicans were on an elevation, and Durham and Cross were in a depression; these circumstances as well as the darkness prevented any fatal results, one person only, a Mexican, being wounded. Both parties now withdrew, the Mexicans going to their camp on the hill a half mile away, and Durham and Cross to the American part of the town. It was now evident that no small job was on hand. Twelve desperate men thoroughly armed would take the town. The citizens had heard the firing and many of the bullets had struck the buildings, though without doing any damage to persons. Although this was in 1855, only a few years away from the time that the men crossed the plains each with his rifle in order, but few fire-arms could be found. When these had been gathered up, it was learned that the banditti had decamped and gone toward Rancheria. Whether it was a ruse to draw the armed party away from the town or not was uncer tain, but it was now evident that one or both places was to be attacked. It was also evident that, but for the premature alarm, Drytown would have been the first victim, and probably Rancheria afterwards. Two persons, Robert Cosner being one, volunteered to go to Rancheria to inform them of the danger. They avoided the road, going up Rattlesnake gulch; but while the party were discussing the matter the Mexicans had done the work. On the arrival of Cos ner and , the robbers appeared to be leaving the town on the opposite side. There were no lights and a dreadful silence prevailed. They called aloud sev eral times before they heard any reply. David Wil son was found hiding in a ditch; when he heard their voices he said: " My God! The whole town is slaughtered; my brother Sam is killed, and I don't know how many more." At Francis' store they found Dan Hutchinson, his clerk, dead behind the counter, also Sam Wilson and - - . Francis was missing but was found not far away with both legs broken and several severe wounds, but still alive. It seemed that he had fought them to the last and eventually ran out of the back door on the stumps of his legs. While searching for Francis they found the dead body of an Indian. The safe was blown open and the contents, about twenty thousand dol lars, abstracted. At Dynan's Hotel they found Mrs. Dynan dead, shot through the body, and Dynan wounded. Mrs. Dynan seemed to have been shot while putting her child out of the window. Francis died the next day. One leg was amputated and the other set with the hope of saving his life. After death it was discovered that his back bone was nearly severed, apparently by a blow from an axe. Altogether there were six men, one woman and an Indian killed" and two men wounded. It seemed that the party divided, a part going to each house, com mencing the attack at about the same moment. At Dynan's a party were playing cards when the house was attacked. Dynan escaped up stairs and through the windows. A man by the name of Foster, the simpleton of the party, had wit enough to throw himself under the table and remain there until the trouble was over and thus saved his life.
The Next Day
The news rapidly spread. By nine the next morn ing perhaps five hundred people were present. The atrocious character of the murders, the unprovoked and causeless attack, raised the anger of the mass of the people almost beyond control. Some were for an immediate war on all of the Mexican race. Parties were engaged in arresting and bringing in all in the vicinity. It is difficult now to ascertain whether any trial was held or not. There was no organization of the crowd which was continually coming and going. A few elderly men, among whom may be mentioned two Hinksons, acted as a sort of jury, to give a form of deliberation to the affair. Judge Curtis is said also to have taken part in the proceedings. These men were noted for their moderation and prudence. They probably prevented the crowd from doing much worse than it did. "Let us proceed cau tiously; let us be just; let us hang no innocent men," said they. They were men in whom the people had confidence. Some thirty-five men were brought within the rope circle and guarded. A motion was put to hang the whole of them, all but a few voting for it. They were then asked to give the men a trial. This was reluctantly consented to; and a com mittee - it could not be called a jury - set themselves to ascertain the evidence against the men. All that could be found was that James Johnson, a miner who lived iu a cabin near by, and looked out through a crack in the door when the shooting was going on, thought he heard a Mexican, called Port Wine (because he was always drunk, or nearly so, on port), shout ing for Mexico. Another one had placed a light in the road in front of his house. The third one was seen running around with the banditti during the shooting. This was on the testimony of one man who thought he saw it through a slight opening of his cabin door. The committee reported that this was all that could be found against any of them. It was determined to hang them immediately. Port Wine was a half-witted man, almost incapable of commit ting a crime. He cried and begged, to no purpose; ho was hung while his wife was begging for him, two others being hung at the same time. The jury, whose names it is impossible to learn, must not bo blamed in this matter. It is impossible to tell what any one would do until they are tried. Hundreds of exasperated people were clamoring for the death of somebody. It is likely that the hanging of the three appeased, to some extent, the thirst fer vengeance. William O. Clark, a well-known citizen of Drytown, made a speech advocating a trial by law, by the Courts, and made an appeal to the people to place themselves, in imagination, in a foreign country, and about to bo hung for a crime some of their own countrymen had committed; but the people were in no mood to hear finely constructed sentences, and he was silenced. It was even proposed to hang him for being friendly to the Mexicans. A Mrs. Ketch um was particularly active in creating a sentiment against Clark. The balance of the party arrested were liberated on condition of leaving the camp within four hours.
Death Op Roberts
About this time a terrible accident occurred. A man by the namo of Roberts, or Robinson, who had been one of the most violent in demanding a whole sale hanging, shot himself in the breast, dying imme diately. There are so many conflicting reports that it is with reluctance the subject is mentioned. One person says they were about to go home, and Rob erts was taking the gun towards him, neither angry nor intoxicated, when it went off, striking him in the breast. Another one says that Robinson - or Roberts - was violently demanding the death of another prisoner, which was not immediately assented to, whereupon he said he would settle the question himself, snatching up the gun with the result heretofore stated.
William Sutherland, whose veracity no one will question, relates the following circumstances in regard to it: A young Spaniard by the namo of Borquitas, General Castro's business agent, happened to be visiting Sutherland's at the time of the mur ders Being a well educated man, speaking the English language fluently, he remarked that he might be of assistance in ferreting out the criminals, and would go up to Rancheria. When he got there, he found himself one of the criminals, or, at least, he was reckoned among the criminal class. During the affair, trial it could not be called, he conversed with one of the accused. Becoming convinced of the innocence of the party of any complicity in the murders, he told the people so; whereupon, it was proposed to hang him (Borquitas) also. It was then that Roberts undertook to shoot him, with the result of death to himself. Sutherland then told Borquitas that he could do no good by staying and risking his own life; that he had better leave. Tak ing the advice of Sutherland, he left in the con fusion, caused by the death of Roberts.
It is said that Judge Gordon, S. B. Axtell, District Attorney, Judge Hubbard, and others, were present; but as the hanging took place before noon, and the Court met at ten, as usual, on the morning after the murders, it is almost impossible that they should have witnessed the hanging, though they probably were present during the afternoon.
Port Wine had a good claim, which was considered forfeited at his death, James Robinson, on whose testimony he was hung, taking possession of it the same evening. He worked it for a few days, but finding work a burden, he sold it for two hundred dollars, which ho spent in a week's spree, shortly after.
Phoenix, and some of his deputies, visited the Bceno of the disturbance, in the early mornin^. After looking at the mutilated bodies, he merely said, " Follow me." A party was immediately organ ized to pursue the banditti, Avhich, as before stated, left Rancheria, taking the road towards El Dorado county. This proved to be a false scent. They went as far as Indian Diggings, and, finding them selves off the trail, returned to Jackson. There they learned that the gang had crossed the Mokelumne at Diamond bar. Phoanix, Cross, Porrin, Sherry, Eichelberger, and Durham, went to Mokelumne Hill that night. They there learned that Sheriff Clark, Paul McCormick, and six-fingered Smith of Camp Seco, had attacked the murderers at Texas bar, on the Calaveras, and had wounded and cap tured one of the party, who had told the history and names of the others. His name was Manuel Garcia, and he had been a vaquero for Charles Stone, at Buena Yista. He was sent to Jackson with Eichelberger and Perrin. The crowd had assembled to receive him; parting to the right and left, and closing up after him, they escorted the prisoner to the tree, which was already provided with a noose. When his head was placed in it, the buggy was moved along, and the body left dangling. This was the eighth time the tree had borne its fruit.
It was now ascertained that the balance of the party were concealed around Bear mountain. Two days spent in hunting failed to find them; and then the officers went to Jenny Lind -where they learned that the Mexicans were camped near Reynold's ferry on the Stanislaus. A large number of Mex icans at Jenny Lind were disarmed, to prevent any assistance reaching the banditti from that settle ment, and the pursuit continued, but somebody had given notice of the approach of the officers and the party had left going towards the Tuolumne river. A guard was set at Reynold's ferry, but the robbers did not attempt to cross. The next day the officers visited Tuttletown, Sonora, Campo Seco, and Jamestown. At the latter place they again struck the trail, and found some of the horses, which had been stolen at Rancheria, dying of exhaustion.
The reader will bear in mind that the ground at this season of the year (August) is hard as a rock, receiving scarcely any impression from a hoof or a shoe passing along; and besides the Mexicans traveled in the night time, concealing themselves in the thick chaparral, with which the hills around Bear mountain abound during the day, so that closely following the trail was out of the question; but it was now evident that they were nearing the objects of their search. Chinese Camp and a Mexican camp, at what is called Old Chinese Camp, were visited. At the latter place was a large dance-house near the hills, the thick chaparral coming down close to the house. It was out of the question to get any correct information with regard to the party they were in search of, but they concluded to stop awhile and watch events. Drinks around and the usual hospitalities followed, as a matter of course. While some of the party engaged the senoritas in conver sation, others kept a general lookout. A girl at the door was seen making signals to some one in the rear, as if to go away. Durham sprang to the door, and saw some of the men they were in search of. Phoenix was anxious to capture them alive, and to this reluctance to kill them, was due the fatal result; but shooting commenced at once. It is difficult to recall events in their order, in which two or three seconds make a failure or success of a movement; but in the affray Phoenix was the first to fall; his slayer the next - the latter though severely wounded, still kept fighting, being finally dispatched by a blow on the head with an axe. The party dispersed in a short time, the officers holding the ground. A boy, who had witnessed the affair from a distance, told the officers that he had seen a wounded man crawl into a cloth shanty, blood stains indicating the cor rectness of the statement. The man was told to come out, but as no answer was received, the hut was set on fire, as it was deemed dangerous to follow him in. Not until it was blazing all over, so that it was thought impossible for any living being to be there, did he appear. He rushed out, covered with blood, clothes and hair on fire, with a pistol in each hand, shooting as he came. He was more frightful than dangerous, and was soon quieted. Phoenix was shot through the heart, dying immediately. He was buried by the Masonic order at Sonora. He was, perhaps, thirty years old, of social character, openhearted, holding malice towards none, and was universally esteemed. He was in poor health at the time, hardly fit for such an enterprise, as he took upon himself to lead. On his return from the unsuccessful search in El Dorado, he was urged to rest; was told that, considering the disturbed con dition of the county, his presence was needful - which was true. But he replied that if he should decline pursuing the murderers, his courage would be called in question, and he started the same evening. His attempt to capture the men alive, was a fatal mis take. It was no kindness to the party, for, in the excited condition of the people, every one taken was sure to be hung without a trial.
A day or two after these occurrences, Marshall Wood, of the town of Columbia, telegraphed the party that ho»4iad arrested forty or more Spaniards, and thought that some of the men they were in search of, were among them. On visiting Sonora, Durham recognized one of the party, a well-dressed, educated, young man, who had formerly lived at Dr3Ttown. At first, he understood no English, knew nothing about the matter, but upon being called by name, Manuel Escobar, and being told that Garcia, the one taken at Camp Seco, had given the names of the whole party, he commenced cursing in good English, and did not deny his connection with the murders. He was taken to Jackson, and hung, being the tenth and last hung on the famous tree. A photograph was taken of the scene, and the picture lithographed, some copies of which are still pre served by the people of Jackson.
Shortly after this, an old Mexican from Algerino Camp, told the officers that the man who had killed Phoenix, came to his house wounded in sev eral places, he thought fatally, wanting to be taken care of; that he did not wish to harbor him, as he thought that the Americans would kill him if they found it out, and so told the wounded man, who, however, threatened to kill him if he refused assist ance. The old Mexican had put him down a shaft which had a short tunnel connected with it, in which the wounded man was hiding. Durham and his party visited the place, and called upon the man to come out; receiving no answer, some brush was thrown into the shaft and set on fire, shortly after which the report of a pistol was heard. He had shot him self rather than surrender. When the fire had gone out, he was brought out dead. He was shot in five
Expulsion And Disarming Of The Mexican Population
The excitement all through the county was such that business was nearly suspended. Extravagant rumors of the intention of the Mexican population to rise and take the county, got into circulation. The same excitabilit}^ that demanded the hanging of a whole nationality, formed a good material to float impossible stories of an insurrection. The second day after the murders, a great number of people came around Rancheria. The Mexicans had left the day of the hanging. It is said that some of the wives and friends of the executed had hardly time to bury the dead. VV^hen the crowd came the second day they destroyed all the huts and houses belong ing to the Mexicans. It was then resolved that they should leave the country. A large body of those that had been expelled from Rancheria were en camped in Mile gulch, which runs north into Dry creek, its head being near the town. Thither the party proceeded. An indiscriminate shooting com menced. Some Indians, who seemed to be watching the Spanish, were told to kill all they could. Some were known to be killed - it is hoped, however, not as many as were reported - but the whole people left as rapidly as they could. One Mexican was seen packing two trunks on each side of a donkey. The overloaded animal could not keep up and he was obliged to abandon them. They were broken open and found to be filled with shirts and finery, appar ently goods plundered from Francis' store. The Indians drew these on, one over another, until they would have on five or six each. This prevented the Indians from killing many of the fugitives, though when questioned about it afterwards, they said they had killed ocho, meaning eight. Some were found dead in holes and shafts, others at springs, where they had dragged themselves after being wounded. Several persons say they have seen the hogs devour ing the bodies of the slain. Pork was at a discount during the season, on that account. At Sutter Creek an extravagant rumor got into circulation that five hundred men were coming to take the town. A committee of safety was organized, and some fifty or sixty Mexicans who were mining on Gopher flat, were arrested and brought to town. One man was unfortunate enough to have some connection, in some way, with the Rancheria affair. He was traced into the Mexican camp and a thorough search made for him. It was about to be abandoned when a large pile of clothes, just ironed, lying on a bed, attracted attention. Underneath was found the man. He was dragged out and hung on a gibbet made by lashing wagon-tongues together, forming an A, the wagons being locked to prevent separation. The fifty on Gopher Flat were ordered to leave, which they con sented to do provided an escort was given them, for they dared not leave the town disarmed and alone. They were escorted across the Mokelumne river. At that time nearly the whole of the street below the bridge, was occupied by the Mexican population. They were ordered to leave and senoras and senoritas, as well as the children (of which there was a con siderable number), were seen climbing the hills on their way out of the town. At Nacalitas, the camp where the banditti stayed the Sunday night previous to the outrage, the people were disarmed and ordered to leave. One white man was left to make out the passports, the others leaving for a similar duty at another camp. The Mexicans at Hacalitas pleaded utter ignorance of any knowledge or participation in the operations of the murderers, but went without making any resistance. A company from Dry town went towards El Dorado county, disarming and driv ing all the Mexicans away. Men came back with numbers of revolvers and other arms taken from them.
Outrages At Drytown
There were but few Mexicans at Drytown, the Spanish population being mostly Chilenos; hence, the name Chile Flat, the portion of the town where they lived. Though speaking the same language, the Chilenos and Mexicans had very little to do with each other; and, consequently, the Chilenos were not charged with any complicity in the out rages at Rancheria, and were generally living on good terms with the people of Drytown.
On the following Sunday, about dark, some fifteen or twenty men on horseback, came into Drytown, and set fire to the Chilenian part of it, and in a few minutes the whole was in a blaze. The people, most of whom were poor, some being women and children, ran in dismay to some of their friends, among the Americans. It is said that William O. Clark's house was filled with crying women and children, who had fled from their burning homes. One man, by the name of Williston, usually called Boston, from his native city, set fire to the Catholic church, which was soon in ashes. The persons engaged in this evening's work, seemed to have had all their plans laid before coming into town, appar ently consulted no one, and permitting no interfer ence. Some of the citizens of Drytown have been charged with assisting the rioters, but a thorough investigation fails to connect any one of its citizens with the affair, which was generally condemned as cruel and wanton.
Convention, Or Mass Meeting, At Jackson
A meeting was called to consider the propriety of outlawing all of the Mexican population. Some of the more violent approved of the measure, but the hanging of the men at Jackson and Rancheria, the excesses committed at Mile gulch and vicinity, had caused the more thoughtful to doubt the pro priety or necessity of turning all the blood-thirsty loose, with license to kill Mexicans wherever they could be found, for such would be the result of out lawry. R. M. Briggs, especially, violently opposed the measure, and it was abandoned. Most of the Mexicans had left the county, and the necessity of such a measure, was questionable on several grounds. W. O. Clark, who opposed it, perhaps in imprudent words, came near being lynched, his speeches at Rancheria, the day after the murders, being remem bered. Many of the Mexicans who fled the county on that occasion, settled near Jenny Lind, in Calaveras county, where they have made peaceable and quiet citizens.
General Feeling A Quarter Op A Century After
There are few, and the number is few, who helped to vindicate justice, as they term it, who are proud of the part they took in the matter. But the more thoughtful look at it as one full of excesses to be re gretted. There are many who believe that the three persons hung at Rancheria the day following the out rage were entirely innocent of any complicity in the crimes committed. There appeared to have been two classes of the Mexicans, the caballeros or horse men and the peons or laboring class. The first were accustomed here, as they were in Mexico, to help themselves to whatever they wanted of the peons. who occupied much of the former position of the blacks in the Southern States, having no rights which a caballero was bound to respect. It is said that when ever these gentry were known to be in a Mexican camp, or expected, the lights were blown out and everything kept as quiet as possible so as to at tract no attention. Old residents say that though a Mexican with a crowbar and bataya might steal an axe or a piece of meat, he was never known to commit an outrage. The fact that half a dozen white men would go to a Mexican camp of ten times their number and disarm them does not prove them very belligerent. It would seem that most of the crimes, and they were many, committed by the Mex ican population may be justly charged to the caballeros. who were generally gamblers and horse-thieves, or worse; who never worked for themselves but appropriated the results of others' industry, not hes itating at murder when necessary to accomplish their object.
Provenance
Text from History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.