BlockBefore

Amador County, California - Chapter 21: Amador County at the Beginning of 1860, 1881

From History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. 10,282 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

20 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

10,282 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 21: Amador County at the Beginning of 1860

County Officers - Financial Situation - Political Parties - First Appearance of R. Burnell - First Appearance of Tom Fitch - Officers Elected in 1860 - Amador Wagon Road Voted On - Names of Amador Mountaineers - Financial Affairs in 1861 - Calaveras Indebtedness Denied - Enormous Profits of Officers - Political Parties in 1861 - The Amador Wagon Project Renewed - Vote on the Project, May 10, 1862 - Rates of Toll - Impeachment of James H. Hardy - Political Parties in 1862 - Great Fire in Jackson - Petition of M. W. Gordon - Supervisors Order the Building of a Court House - Political Parties in 1863 - French -Bar Affair - Officers Elected in 1863 - General Vote - Political Parties in 1864 - Vote of 1864 - Financial Matters - Political Parties in 1865 - Arrest of Hall and Penry - Election Returns by Precincts, 1865 - Seaton's Defection - Counting the Votes - Clinton Vote - List of Officers Elected in "1865 - Death of G. W. Seaton, and Election of A. H. Rose, his Successor - Finan cial Matters in 1865.

UP to this period, which seems a natural point in time for a review, Amador county met with unre mitting prosperity. The placers were yielding undiminished sums; the quartz mines were begin ning to show their inexhaustible treasures; agricul ture had assumed a permanent and profitable character; schools were established, and in working condition; churches, and other beneficiary institu tions were prosperous, proving that society was being built on a healthy basis; and, last though not least, the county finances had been generally economically managed, so that, notwithstanding the inevitable expenses of organization and commencing a govern ment, moderate taxes were sufficient to liquidate all expenses. According to the Assessor's report there were fifteen saw-mills cutting 11,500.000 feet of lumber per year; thirty-two quartz-mills crushing yearly 61,000 tons of quartz; six hundred miles of main canal, besides distributors; 10,000 acres of cul tivated land, yielding 6,000 tons of hay, 34,800 bushels of wheat, 46,000 of barley, 28,000 of corn, besides other produce. There were nearly 10,000 head of cattle, 1,700 head of horses, 6,000 swine, 60,000 fruit trees, and 300,000 grape vines.

This condition of affairs would justify a hope that prosperity might continue; but the failure of the placer mines, disastrous fires, injudicious manage ment of county finances, with unfortunate national affairs, so changed the current of events, that Amador came near taking her place among the bankrupt counties of California.

February 6, 1860, the Supervisors allowed J. C. Shipman one hundred and sixty dollars for acting as Clerk of the Board of Supervisors for twenty days, also seventy-eight dollars for acting as Clerk of the Board of Equalization. These allowances seem but the entering wedge to other and more extravagant appropriations, which followed in the course of a few years.

July 7, 1860, F. Eichling, Geo. L. Gale, and D. L Triplett, appointed a commission, by Board of Super, visors, to purchase a site for hospital grounds; which was done, for the price of sixteen hundred dollars. The erection of a suitable building on this tract commenced a series of debts which hung over the tax-payers for the next twenty years.

Report November 5, 1860

This method of making reports was not well cal culated to give the people any correct idea of the state of the finances. The interest on warrant 103 alone, now amounted to twenty thousand dollars or more; much of it was due, having accumulated to upwards of ten thousand dollars before any por tion of principal or interest was paid.

Some of the waves raised by the political storm that was raging in the Eastern States began to be felt in California. The prospect of carrying the Presiden tial election and sharing the official patronage induced the Eepublicans to put forth greater efforts, and for the first time in the history of the party, it looked possible to carry some of the county offices. The Democratic party seemed to be disintegrating, having divided into the Douglass and Breckenridge factions, while members of the old Whig party, con fident in their principles, thought to rally round them all the conservative elements and quiet the storm which threatened to engulf the nation. There are some questions that are so positive in their nature as to admit of no compromise; all or nothing being the only terms of settlement. The Eepublicans took strong ground against the extension of slavery, though denying any thonght of interfering with it where it then existed. The Douglass Democrats wished to leave it to the Territories and States to determine for themselves whether slavery should or should not exist within their boundaries, thus exclud ing the matter from Congressional action. The Breckenridge party contended that having been recognized by the Constitution as an element in the social compact of States, it could not be excluded from the Territories either by National or Territorial legislation without manifest injustice to the States wherein slavery existed. Each party endeavored to prove that a true interpretation of the Constitution would justify the proposed measures of exclusion, rele gation of the matter to the States and Territories, or general protection and recognition everywhere under the flag. Careful readers of the early history of the United States cannot fail to discover the ten derness, evasion even, with which the subject of slavery was treated. The word slavery had no mention in the Constitution, those opposed to it hop ing that it would cease of itself; those in favor of it satisfied with its partial recognition. Able writers on political economy assert that Constitutions are growths of public opinion; that no constitutional enactments can stand long against overwhelming public sentiment; that the courts and government shape the enactment when they execute the law, and, that public sentiment establishes the government. Three large parties accused each other of trying to subvert the Constitution, each professing to see, in the success of either of the others, utter ruin and destruction. We shall see, as history progresses, the truth of the principles alluded to, for the meaning of the Constitution was eventually fixed at a cost of a million of lives and billions of money.

First-class orators, as well as many who were not rated at all, traversed the country, not omitting Amador in their labors. Thousands of documents bearing on the question, were sent through the mails or circulated by means of committees.

R. Burnell, afterwards conspicuous in Amador poli tics, made his appearance for the first time. He was a lawyer by profession, from the central part of New York. Having accumulated considerable money by raising stock on the plains around Sacramento, he spent a Winter in the capital, took a notion to mingle in political affairs, and made Amador County a start ing-point. He was a man of graceful presence, pleasing address, a fluent speaker, with a good train ing in the New York school of politics, of which Martin Van Buren was the best specimen and ideal, whose political gospel was " neither give nor take offense." He rapidly made his way upwards, being first elected to the Assembly, where he was elected Speaker, and afterwards two terms to the Senate. He was also a prominent candidate for Congress.

First Appearance Op Tom Fitch

This celebrated orator was sent into the country to try his strength of wing in the woods and chap arral. Though he had spoken once or twice on the steamer on which he was a passenger to this State, and again once or twice after landing, the general impression was that he was speaking a piece that some one had written for him. His appearance was boyish in the extreme. His plump and rather girlish face, his lips with the babyish cupid's bow still giving them shape, and his extremely youthful appearance, (not over twenty at least), did not impress one at first sight, or give any indication of his oratorical powers. The first meeting at which he appeared was in lone. Very few had heard of him, and it was supposed that the State Central Committee had sent, as they often had done before, some troublesome aspirant for oratorical honors, where he would do the least harm. James M. Hanford, M. W. Belshaw and two or three local politicians were announced to speak, and confident in their strength, inquired of Fitch which part of the evening he would prefer, and also how much time he Avould like to occupy, for it was intended to give the boy a chance for success. He rather dignifiedly answered that he would be satis fied with any arrangements that might be made; so he was generously allowed the closing speech ! After the several speakers had plodded wearily through the evening, the President introduced Thomas Fitch. The writer of this, who was present, recollects well the shade of disgust that passed over the faces of the audience at the prospect of sitting out another hour of dullness. He bowed dignifiedly to the Pres ident and audience. His boyish appearance was already gone, giving place to the ease and self-posses sion born of conscious strength. He. commenced with a few long, Ciceronian sentences, as stately and beautiful in structure as a. Grecian temple, and what was more, he kept them up for a full hour, never faltering for a word, never missing a note in the lofty song which he commenced, winding up with a bui-st of eloquence in favor of universal freedom that Colonel Baker might have equaled, but never surpassed. There was none of the school-boy in the oration. The sentences, ponderous as they were, came out of his mouth as if propelled by an intellectual steam engine. Had the people seen a train of cars dragged by a single pony, going a hundred miles an hour, their astonishment could not have been greater. The fol lowing night he spoke at Lancha Plana to a large audience, that had gathered, as much out of cui'iosity as anything else, to hear the prodigy. Those who had not heard him still contended that he must have repeated what had been written for him by some one else; but a circumstance occurred which set that question at rest. A few minutes before he ascended the stand the news came that Colonel Baker had been elected United States Senator for Oregon - Oregon, the home of Joe Lane, the immovable Dem ocratic State! The subject was one worthy the power of an orator, and Fitch did it justice. " The waves of public opinion, sweeping a continent in their course, are rocking the strongest citadels of slavery." Those who came out of curiosity remained, entranced. Perhaps he was the only man who ever spoke in Amador county that would hold every one of his audience to the close.

moral qualities were not of corresponding great ness. He sadly disappointed the hopes of his early admirers, and is now only a fourth rate lawyer.

Among the prominent speakers engaged in this campaign was James H. Hardy, candidate for Judge of the Sixteenth Judicial District, who ably sup ported the Breckenridge side of the question.

The general vote was : Lincoln, 995; Douglass, 1866; Breckenridge, 945; Bell, 178; total, 3984, being the largest vote ever polled in the county.

Amador Wagon Road Voted On

The discovery of the Comstock mines gave an increased desire for the building of a wagon road to Carson valley. The Legislature, by an act ap proved March 23. 1861, required the Board of Super visors of Amador, to call a special election of the voters of Amador county to submit to them a pro position to issue bonds of said county, not exceeding in the aggregate the sum of forty thousand dollars, to be expended in the construction of a wagon road, com mencing at Antelope Springs, in Amador county, on the ridge dividing the waters of the Mokelumne and Cosumnes rivers, and following thence the best practi cable route to Hope valley on the eastern slope of the Sierra Nevada Mountains, and for the purpose at the same time of electing one Eoad Commissioner in each Supervisor District of said county.

*J. W. Bicknell was nominated in the Convention by a bit of sharp practice. Alviaza Hayward, a friend of Bicknell's, went around among the delegates, asking them to give the old gentleman a complimentary vote, saying that he could not get the nomi nation, but it would please him to get a good vote. When the complimentary vote was counted, it was found to lie the requisite number to nominate him. There was no chance to retreat; so the Convention bore the joke as well as they could.

Calaveras Indebtedness Denied

"WHEREAS, By the quarterly financial report of the Auditor and Treasurer of Amador county, sub mitted to the Board on the first Monday of Decem ber, 1861, it appears that there was, upon that day, in the hands of said Treasurer, the sum of six thou sand one hundred and fifty-five dollars and four cents, credited to a fund known as the Calaveras County Fund; and,

" WHEREAS, It is the opinion of this Board that the object for which said fund was created, no longer exists (the debt formerly due from Amador county to said Calavcras county, having been fully paid).

fer from the said Calaveras County Fund to the Gen eral Fund of Amador county, the sum of six thousand dollars, and also that all such sum or sums as may be paid into the said Treasury after the said first Monday of December, 1861, upon said Calaveras County Fund, be credited to the General Fund of Amador county."

From the records of the Board of Supervisors, it appears that on the second day of December, 1861? they entered into an agreement with J. Foot Tur ner, by which the said Turner agreed to evade or satisfy the payment on the part of Amador county, of the sum of six thousand one hundred and fiftyeight dollars, then on hand and in the treasury, due to the county of Calaveras as a part of the Cala veras indebtedness on warrant 103, which he seems to have done, as he was allowed the commission of ten per cent, on the same, at a meeting of the Board September 1, 1862. Subsequently, however, the mat] ter came before the District Court. In the suit of Beals, the holder of warrant No. 103, against the Supervisors of Amador county, in 1864, the records showed that a writ of mandamus was issued from the District Court, S. W. Brockway presiding, to the Board of Supervisors of Amador county, requir ing them to levy a special tax for the payment of the balance of the Calaveras indebtedness, amount ing to $7,556.16, in accordance with a law approved April 27, 1855. The matter was appealed to the Supreme Court, where the decision of Judge Brockway was confirmed. The amount of the warrant when drawn, was $26,517.32; up to 1865, $31,292.83 had been paid on it when the county, by the advice of J. Foot Turner, refused to pay anything further. The judgment given by Brockway, $7,556.16, was avoided until it amounted to $11,000, making over $40,000 in all that was paid on the warrant, the costs, and attorneys' fees, swelling it to at least $50,- 000, before the demand was settled.

Enormous Profits Of The Office-Holders

It is said that the offices of Sheriff and County Clerk were worth from fifteen to twenty thousand dollars per year. The latter was also Recorder of Deeds, and acted as the Clerk of the Board of Super visors and Equalization; also, as Auditor of Accounts, for all of which he drew high pay. At a meeting of the Board of Supervisors, February 6, 1861, present, James H. Allen and George McWilliams, it was ordered that the Auditor, J. W. Bicknell, be paid, as salary, two hundred and forty dollars per month, in quarterly installments; though October 9th, follow ing, his salary was reduced to one hundred and sixtyfive dollars per month. The following items from the records of the Board of Supervisors will show how the money went: -

October 3, 1862 - (Page 435, Vol. B, minutes of Board of Supervisors.) Allowed J. W. Bicknell quar terly salary as Auditor, $495; quarterly salary as Clerk of Board of Supervisors, $167.50.

November 8th - Allowed for acting as Clerk of Supervisors, $96. Each of the Board also allowed themselves, November 8, 1862, $48, as members of the Board of Equalization.

July 1, 1861 - George F. Tripp, allowed fees in criminal cases, $2,155, a fourth claim - $810 - being rejected. For a few minutes' services as interpreter, involving no loss of time worth mentioning, $5.00 was allowed. $24 was allowed for moving a person twelve miles.

June 2, 1862 - C. Y. Hammond and other Super visors allowed each $32 for services on the wagonroad election, which services should have been included in the ordinary duties of Supervisor. The Chairman was allowed $25 per month for signing road receipts.

July 7, 1863 - Board of Supervisors allowed them selves $8.00 per day for twenty-three days, for act ing as members of the Board of Equalization.

All services rendered seemed to be the subject for special fees. It is not strange that candidates should spend a thousand or two in trying to get a nomination when a nomination was equivalent to an election, or as much when the result of the election was doubtful.

Soon after the election of Lincoln, the old land marks, which had stood for many years as guides to the various political crafts, went down out of sight. Men who had for a quarter of a century anchored to the Whig or Democratic doctrines, found themselves without soundings. Professed politicians, who were accustomed to weigh public opinion and move accordingly, were now unable to tell where the surging waters and contrary currents would permit secure anchorage. When everything is in confusion, it sometimes happens that a single commanding voice will turn a wavering crowd to its own course. The steady disruption of the Southern States, the boldness of their friends in California, who certainly evinced no fear of consequences, made the prospect of cutting out California from the Union, quite imminent. The newspapers, usually, are but the mouth-pieces of public sentiment. During this uncer tain condition of affairs, the Ledger, which, since 1856, had been acting with the Democratic party, while speaking of the breaking off from the Union of Southern States, remarked: " For the present the interests of California seem to be, to remain with the old Union."

This sentiment prevailed to a great extent among the politicians. Among the first to raise the alarm of danger, was E. M. Briggs, a Douglass Democrat, who called public meetings in different parts of the county, and proclaimed to the people the designs of some of the ultra-Breckenridge Democrats to carry California out of the Union. He made speeches in his peculiar style of oratory, in several of the larger towns; introduced strong Union resolutions, with no uncertain sound, which were usually adopted. At lone he was met with a solid Union club of one hundred, from Muletown, headed by the president, Jack Miller, who pledged his company to the main tenance of the Union, though some of his political friends persuaded him afterwards that he was a little premature in his promises. There is no doubt that these demonstrations, made previous to the firing on, and surrender of, Fort Sumter, helped to shape public sentiment, so that when the time came for an expression of public opinion, it was overwhelmingly in favor of the perpetuity of the Union. The Fourth of July celebrations in the different towns of the county were hearty and enthusiastic - nearly the whole population participating.

The Douglass Democratic Convention at Sacra mento, which met to nominate a candidate for Governor, took strong Union grounds, denouncing hesitation as cowardice, and doubt as treason.

The three parties put forward full sets of candi dates. All professed to be in favor of union. The Eepublicans favored the maintenance of the Union by prosecuting the war until all rebellion was crushed out, at whatever expense; the Douglass Democrats, by conducting the war according to the Constitution, with Democratic generals under a Democratic admin- istration, believing that genuine Democracy was a cure for all the ills that could befall a State. The Breckenridge Democrats were supposed to be, to some extent, in sympathy with the Rebellion, but they confined their arguments mostly to charging the Administration with numerous faults, and a systematic violation of the Constitution. Axtell, Farley, and Eagan were able speakers, and repre sented the Nation as having been hurried into a needless war by the infatuation of half-crazy fanatics, who, unless prevented, would ruin every thing to give liberty to a race that was little above the beasts of the field in intellectual and moral devel opment. It was their object generally to represent the South as the aggrieved party, that was willing, even anxious, to return to the Union when their rights were secured to them. Occasionally a speaker, like the Hon. A. B. Dibble, of Nevada, would take up the old story of negro equality, and draw a lively picture of a

But the more thoughtful knew that two opposing civilizations had met in the " irrepressible conflict;" the one based on the rights of all men to pursue their own substantial happiness; the other, on the customs which made privileged, classes of kings, nobility, and hereditary masters, with the concom itants of subjects and slaves. It must be confessed that in the history of the ages that have gone before, the privileged classes have usually won the field.

The relative strength of the parties, as manifested by the vote for Governor, was: For Stanford (Repub lican), 1,299; Conness (Douglass Democrat), 1,258; McConnell (Breckenridge Democrat), 827.

Justices Of The Peace Amador Wagon Road Revived

The increasing importance of the Nevada mines, the discovery of the veins at Markleeville, Silver City, and other places in the eastern part of Amador county, the transportation of enormous quantities of goods over the Placerville route, and the conse quent prosperity of that portion of El Dorado county, traversed by the road, induced the friends of an Amador tramontane road, to make another effort. Accordingly, in answer to the requests of a large number of petitioners, the Legislature granted a second trial, specifying how the road should be built, in case the people voted for it. An election was held May 10, 1862. About sixty per cent, of the popu lation voted, the measure being carried by less than half of the voters in the county. Towns along the proposed line of the road, or connected with it, voted nearly unanimously for it. Towns outside, like Lancha Plana, were equally opposed to it. The question was decided by a vote of 1,307 for, and 542

Vote By Precincts

The franchise for building this road was granted to C. D. Burleson, James Tullock, E. B. Wooley, Geo. Johnson, R. M. Briggs, David Coblentz, M. Tynan, and Leroy Worden. The county was permitted, by Act of the Legislature, to assist these parties to the extent of twenty-five thousand dollars in bonds bearing twelve per cent, interest per annum, payable in one, two, three, four and five years from date. In case the county donated these bonds, the road was to be finished by the 1st of October of the same year, or the franchise was to be forfeited. The road was to be sixteen feet wide, and the maximum grade eighteen feet to the hundred. Tolls were per mitted as follows: -

For each loaded wagon, one dollar; for each ani mal attached, twenty-five cents; loaded pack-ani mals, each twenty -five cents; pleasure carriages and buggies, one dollar; empty freight wagons and unladen pack-animals, half rates. The tolls were to be reduced twenty per cent, at the end of five years.

The route was divided into five sections, begin ning at Antelope Springs, thence to Tragedy Springs, which formed section No. 1; thence to the crossing of the outlet of Silver lake, which formed section No. 2; thence to Carson Spur, No. 3; to Summit lake, No. 4; and Hope valley, No. 5; the road at the latter place intersecting the Big Tree and Carson Valley road. The payment of the bonds was provided for by taxes as follows, levied on all property: -

1867 - Thirty cents on each $100. When the vote was found to be in favor of the road, quite a rush was made to get favorable locations for public houses, and several fine buildings were erected at different points along the road. Saw-mills were con structed with the expectation of supplying both the W ashoe mines and the Sacramento market. On com pletion of the road a stage line, in connection with the Sacramento and Stockton lines, took passengers to Silver Lake and other way places. Quite a trade sprang up over the road, the farmers carrying their fruit and produce to Washoe. The travel had to be abandoned as winter came, on account of the snow, which fell to the depth of from three to twenty feet, the last named being the usual depth at Silver Lake. The deep snow very often crushed the houses and destroyed the furniture. A fine house near Corral Flat, owned by Goldsworthy and Mayo, was de stroyed in this way. The road did not answer the expectations of thepublic. Thetrade was not diverted from the Placerville road, and, on the completion of the railroad to Nevada, both roads fell into compara tive disuse. The lower portion of the road is used to take lumber from the mountains, and, in Summer, a few visitors to Silver Lake give a little life to the higher portion.

Impeachment Of James H. Hardy

Hardy was Judge of the Sixteenth Judicial District comprising the counties of Amador and Calaveras. He was a man of undisputed talents, great inde pendence of character, amounting to recklessness. Like all men of that character, he took no middle course, was always in one extreme or the other, and made hosts of friends as well as enemies. Early in the contest he took the side of the South; often boasted of being a rebel, expressed the opinion that the Government had gone to hell, drank to the success of the Southern Confederacy, and conducted himself generally in a way hardly suitable to the position he occupied. 'Early in the session of the Legislature of 1862, Judge Campbell of Calaveras, prepared articles of impeachment, numbering some twenty or more, charging him with malfeasance in office on divers occasions; one specification being a charge of violating his oath of office in procuring the dis charge of David S. Terry, on his trial for killing Broderick. The article alleged that a change of venue had been made to Marin county, where Hardy was holding Court; that, with his knowledge and consent, the clock had been put forward; that he opened Court at ten according to the clock, although it was much earlier by the true time; that the trial was hastily and indecently hurried through, with out giving time to get the witnesses on the part of the State; that, although the important witnesses were then on the way from San Francisco, and, even in sight on the bay, being detained by con trary winds (there then being no steam-ferry), ho refused to continue the Court, and ordered the jury in the absence of the witnesses, to find for the acquittal of Terry, setting him free. On this charge, the Assembly, sitting as a High Court of Impeach ment, was evenly divided, standing eighteen to eighteen. On the charge of uttering disloyal senti ments, and using language unbecoming his high posi tion, he was found guilty, and suspended from per forming the duties of the office.

The disruption of the Douglass Democracy, became apparent early in the season. The efforts put for ward by the South to maintain the Confederacy, and, by the Administration to break it down, con vinced the most skeptical that peace could come only by the utter defeat of one or.' the other. The Democracy now assumed a stronger tone. The Dispatch, their ably edited organ, did not hesitate to avow its sympathy for the Kebellion, and kept in its columns the Kentucky resolutions of 1798, which held to the right of each State to judge of any infrac tion of the compact by any other State, as well as the right to choose it own remedy therefor, mean ing that each and every individual of the family of States had a right to step out, at its will or con venience. About this time, the " Knights of the Golden Circle " were organized in different parts of the county. Their meetings were generally held in out-of-the-way places, and as quietly as possible. The object of the organization was probably made known to but few of the members even, the design being to have the material well in hand to use in case an opportunity offered, rather than the execu tion of any well-digested plan of aiding the .Rebellion, or carrying the State of California out of the Union. A hundred and twenty-eight men had monthly meetings in the hills west of the Blue Eidge, near where Stony creek comes into Jackson creek; though, it is said, that a few meetings were held near Buena Vista. The " organization was met by another, the "Loyal League," and also by the organization of the " Home Guards," who were sup plied with guns and ammunition by the Govern ment. The fact that' the population of California was composed of people from all the States, ren dered it quite certain that an insurrection would be attended with a fearful destruction of life and prop erty. Property is always a powerful conservator of the peace; and it was much harder to arouse the people into a war of ideas than it would have been ten years before, when the farms, residences, and valuable stores, had not yet made their appearance; and no insurrection occurred.

When the Republican Convention met, a petition, signed by three hundred Douglass Democrats, was handed in, asking the Convention to drop the name "Republican," disorganize, and form a Union party. As there was nothing in a name, and the objects of the two were essentially the same, the request was acceded to. It will be remembered that the Doug lass Democrats in the county, only a year before, had a much larger number of votes than the Breckenridge Democrats; the relative numbers of the parties on the vote for Governor being for Stanford, 1,299; Conness, 1,258; McConnel, 827.

Mr. Burnell joined the Union party. The move ment seems to have been preconcerted throughout the State, as from this date the Douglass party dis appeared. The Democratic party ceased to wear any qualifying prefix, and became, thenceforth, the " Simon Pure." The old and well-known war horses, Farley, Gordon, Axtell, and Eagan, still held their, places as leaders in the ranks; but Porter and Briggs were now found with the Republicans. It will be seen that Wm. H. Badgely, who had been appointed to fill the unexpired term, made vacant by the impeachment of James H. Hardy, received the unani mous vote of all parties.

Election Returns In 1862 The Great Fire

On the 23d of August, 1862, will be more particu larly described under the head of " Jackson," in the township histories. The principal interest at this point of our view is the destruction of the county buildings. It will be remembered that the town of Jackson donated the Court House, costing some ten thousand dollars, to the county, the jail being after wards added at an expense of more than six thousand dollars. On the morning of the 24th, the county was without a place of meeting for the Courts. Rooms were hired in different places for transacting the county ^business, at high rates - one hundred dollars per month being paid for the use of a hall in which to hold Court. The offices of Sheriff', County Clerk, Treasurer, and District Attorney, were kept from necessity in inconvenient and improper places. These circumstances induced Judge Gordon to set forth the necessity of erecting county buildings, and the powers of the Supervisors in the premises, in the following petition: -

Petition Of M. W. Gordon

"To the Board of Supervisors, of Amador county, Cali fornia: Your petitioner, a resident citizen and tax payer of said county, respectfully represents to said Board, that, by article eleven, section five, of the Constitution of said State, the Legislature thereof "have power to provide for the election of a Board of Supervisors in each county; and that these Super visors, shall jointly and individually perform such duties as may be prescribed by law." Your peti tioner states, that, in pursuance of said law, the said Legislature, at its sixth session, by ait Act approved March 20, 1855, did create and establish, in each of the counties of this State, a Board of Supervisors.

" Your petitioner says, that, both by the said Con stitutional provision and by the provisions of said law, the sole power over the property of each county, is given to the Board of Supervisors, and is pro hibited to the Legislature of the State, the Legisla ture having the power to provide only for the election of a Board of Supervisors, who shall perform such duties as may be prescribed by law.

" Your petitioner says that amongst the duties pre scribed by law, to be performed by said Board, (Wood's Digest, page 692, section 91), is the duty " To cause to be erected and furnished a Court House, jail, and such other public buildings as may be neces sary, and to keep the same in repair." It is true, that section 16, page 696, says: "The Board of Supervisors shall not, for any purpose, contract debts or liabilities, except those fixed by, or in pursuance of law; and whenever debts or liabilities shall have been created, which, added to the salaries of county officers and other estimated liabilities fixed by law for the remainder of the year, will equal the revenue of the county for current expenses, no allowance whatever shall be made of any account; nor shall any expense be incurred other than the salaries and fees expressly prescribed by, or in pursuance of, the law." But it will be observed that the erection and furnishing of a Court House and jail are fixed bylaw in section 91, clause 11.

" Your petitioner says that the granting of the powers in said Act to the Board of Supervisors by the Legislature, and the specification of the duties to be performed by said Board excludes the Legis lature from all power over the : airs of each and every county in the State, and iixes those duties exclusively on the Board of Supc visors.

" Your petitioner says that, by article 514, section 2, page 127, Wood's Digest, Jac son is the county seat of Amador county; and tnat, by article 670, section 59, page 154. the Court House must be situated at the county seat.

" Your petitioner says that the Court House and county jail of Amador county was destroyed by fire on the 23d of August, 1862; that these public buildings are necessary for the conducting of the civil and criminal business of the county, and that the public business cannot be transacted without them; that, as already shown, it is the duty of the Board of Supervisors to proceed, as soon as practicable, to erect and furnish a Court House and jail at Jackson, for the use of said Amador county.

"Your petitioner, therefore, 'moves the Honorable the Boajd of Supervisors of Amador county, on the 3d of October, A. D. 1862, to hear this petition, to examine the law and the facts in said petition alleged; and upon the allegations herein being proved, that said Board will decide upon erecting, as soon as practicable, a Court House and county jail, on the site of the late Courc House and jail, not to exceed in cost the sum of twenty thousand dollars.

On the 4th of October the Supervisors invited pro posals for the building of a Court House and jail, according to plans presented, but on opening the bids at the following session they were found too indefinite for acceptation, and new ones were called for, according to a plan presented by S. D. Mandell, architect of the M. E. Church of lone. It will be seen that during this year the debts were made which hung over the county for twenty years, bonds being issued for Amador wagon road, twenty-five thousand dollars; for Court House and jail an indefinite sum; for hospital, also uncertain.

October 3d, the Commissioners reported the com pletion of the wagon road, and the full amount of the bonds authorized to be issued was paid over to the contractors.

The doubtful result of the war, the loss of friends and relatives on one side or the other by nearly all, begat an ill-feeling between the two parties that, at times, looked like the forerunner of hostilities. The Ledger and Dispntch now flung terms of reproach, more true than polite, perhaps, but bitter and unre lenting. It was difficult to tell whether national issues, personal animosity, or desire for office, was the greatest motive in the conduct of the campaign. Men would be found first on one side and then on the other, as one or the other of these motives pre vailed, and, it would seem, buried all doubts by an increased or simulated enthusiasm for the side adopted. An old politician expressed the sentiment that each side accused the other of all kinds of venal ity, and knew themselves guilty of it. Every tech nicality was used to further the interests of the dif ferent individuals.

French Bar Affair

Occurred this season. At night the poll list num bered twenty-six, but, during the counting, it swelled to one hundred and thirty-eight, with votes in the ballot-box to correspond. Jim Saultry was credited with planning and executing this brilliant raid on the enemy's ranks, which, however, failed to elect anybody. The names were said to have been taken from a Panama passenger list.

The eastern part of the county, up among the pine trees, had rather uncertain boundaries, and pleasure parties, or others could, according to the existing law, get up a precinct* almost anywhere, and shape or influence elections. When the tempta tions for fraud were so great, and the opportunities so frequent, nothing less than divine strength would take the just course, and we have to look in centuryold annals for politicians of that character.

Complaints, that the collecting of taxes by the Sheriff gave too much importance to that office, hav ing become general, the Legislature provided for township Assessors and Collectors; and for six years, from 1863 to 1869, the latter method was in use.

At the election for Supervisors, held in 1863, quite a contest occurred as to the boundaries of Amador County in the vicinity of the Summit. The follow ing extract from the Ledger will show the animus of the affair: -

".Out of curiosity, however, and for the purpose of branding Copperhead demagogues with the eternal and ineffacable stamp of burning infamy and dis grace which of right belongs to them, the recount was made, and that same count did disclose and fasten upon the so-called Democratic party of Amador county, the most disgraceful, hellish, diabolical, and deep-dyed villainous scheme to commit a crime upon the body politic that ever disgraced the criminal calendars of the whole world. The bare thought of what he has done to the " tool " employed to execute it, must be a coal of fire in his brain, an enraged adder in his heart. He must feel as if every hair of his head were a serpent, like the hair of Eumenides, and his aids and abettors, the devil's scanty leavings, over whom, in their last hours, black despair shall sit, with carrion birds and secesh owls hovering over their heads."

Having given a sample of the editorial style of the Ledger, the Dispatch must be equally favored. In the edition of June 4, 1864, referring to Lincoln, it said: -

"Is it possible that this long-shanked, flop-eared, jimber-jawed, mule-countenanced, backwoods, railsplitting boor is wiser, purer, more far-seeing, and understands better the power.8 of the Government than the great Father of bis country, who presided over the deliberations of the Convention that made it?"

Officers Elected In 1863

From the minutes of the Board of Supervisors it appears that some doubt existed as to who was elected Supervisor from District No. 3. E. B. Woolley and E. A. Kingsley both appeared and claimed the seat. The latter had acted as Super visor one month, and drawn pay therefor. On the 22d of November, Bishop and Gregory recognized E. B. Woolley as the member, Kingsley filing a pro test thereto. The latter appeared for several days as a claimant to the seat. November 6th, he was allowed thirty-seven dollars salary and mileage, Woolley retaining his position.

During this season the Court House, which was to cost $18,900, was swelled into a $50,000 structure, by the changes from the original plan, involving stone basement and water tables, and stone steps in front and rear.

March 3, 1863. - "Ordered (by the Supervisors) that the steps to the Court House be made of stone instead of brick, as specified in the original plan; also, that the balustrade of the steps be made of stone, and that the top step be made four feet wide." A special superintendent, Francis McGrath, was employed to measure and examine the work.

February 3, 1864. - The Supervisors ordered a warrant to be drawn for $9,174.76, in favor of Mat. Canavan, assignee of Epley, Canavan, and Meloney, he having obtained a judgment in the District Court to that amount, as a balance due on the Court House contract. Farley and Armstrong, attorneys for the county, were allowed $500.00 as fees.

During 1863, townships eight and nine were organized east of the Sierra Nevadas, out of terri tory that was afterwards incorporated into Alpine county; also the election precincts of Silver Mount ain, Mogul, Mineral City, and Markleeville. The uncertainty of the boundaries of these precincts, especially on the Calaveras side, was the source of much trouble until the final separation of the terri tory from Amador county. Communication could only be maintained in the Summer months. In the Spring of 1864, the delegates attending the Conven tions for nominating delegates to the Electoral Con vention, came over by way of Placerville. The county of Alpine was created March 16, 1864, by Act of the Legislature, out of territory of El Dorado, Amador, and Calaveras. By this Act, the eastern boundary of Amador county was fixed at Hope valley, Kirkwood's house being just within Amador. Alpine county was to issue two warrants in favor of Amador, for $5,000 each, payable out of the gen eral fund, and bearing interest at the rate of six per cent, per annum, payable in one and two years, as her part of the common debt. The two counties were made one district, for choosing Legislative officers.

Biennial instead of annual sessions of the Legis lature having been established, and the election of members of the Legislature made to correspond in time with that of the county officers, there were no local interests to fan politics into the usual white heat; but the great questions of union and freedom, which had convulsed the nation for years, were still in abeyance and proved ample enough to arouse the highest feeling and bring out a full vote. The habitual leaders, having no inducements to accom modate their sentiments to those of the public, were comparatively candid in expressing their opinions. At 'the Convention held to elect delegates to the Electoral State Convention, John Eagan, J. T. Farley, E. Stewart, Long Primer Hall, and A. H. Eose, opposed the prosecution of the war as unjust, uncon stitutional, and inexpedient under any circumstances. The sentiment, afterwards incorporated into the National Democratic platform, that ''four years of war having demonstrated the impossibility of con quering the South, hostilities should cease, with a view of peaceable separation, if satisfactory terms of union could not be agreed upon," was generally advocated. M. W. Gordon, however, was opposed to acknowledging the independence of the Confed eracy, under any circumstances, but believed the Union could be restored, only by employing Demo cratic generals, under a Democratic Administration, with a Demoratic President. He would prefer Thomas H. Seymour, of Connecticut, for President, but would accept Grant, McClellan, or Sherman.

These sentiments did not suit the majority of the Convention, but M. W. Gordon was a man of too much talent andjnfluence to be slighted or left out in the cold, and J. T. Farley, with his usual skill and tact, advocated his having a place in the delegation. James Meehan, J. T. Farley, M. W. Gordon, and E. Cosnerf were sent from the county at large, and T.

Those of our readers who are not old enough to remember the famous campaigns of " Tippecanoe and Tyler too," of 1840, may form some idea of that memorable affair, by the processions, bon-fires, and illuminations of this season. Every town had its turn, but, as usual in all such excitements, the active, the aggressive, swept the conservative away, and the Union demonstrations were the most brilliant and noisy. Long processions, with all trades and employ ments in active operation, were the usual beginnings of a political meeting. Eail- splitting, tailoring, shoemaking, blacksmithing, weaving, printing, and every thing that could be done on wheels, were made parts of the display. Abraham Lincoln split a lot of rails once, and the three or four stalwart men swing ing the mauls, were sure to bring out the enthusiasm. There was a touch of the humorous in these dis plays, which would have been enjoyable, but for the solemn fact, that a million of our noblest and best, were, at the moment, locked in a death struggle. The whole nation went on a frolic in 1840, but no such shadows of death rested on the people as in 1864. But, as a politician expressed it, the party that could do the most of this work, would get the bulge, and it was done.

Vote Of 1864 Financial Matters, 1864

On the 7th of June, the Treasurer reported out standing warrants over and above sums in the Treasury to apply on General Fund, $74,159.42; on Sierra Wagon Road Fund, $15,125.00; on Road fund, $1,467.35; making a total of $90,751.77.

This estimate does not include interest, which would swell the amount to $100,000. The extrav agance of the two previous years, laid a foundation for the permanent debt.

The following December the amount of the debt, exclusive of interest, was estimated at $111,139.94. Before the taxes were collected, it was apparent that the levy was insufficient to meet current expenses, and a new schedule was made out, as follows: -

This, the last year of the bitter strife, witnessed the most exciting scenes of all. The year opened with the defeat of the rebel armies in all quarters, and soon saw the surrender of the last of them* Whether from indiscreet rejoicing on the part of the Republicans, or embittered feelings on the part of the Democrats, or both, the Democratic news papers became more bitter and vituperative than ever. Public opinion was in a highly excited con dition in consequence, and when the news of the assassination of Lincoln was flashed across the Conti nent, the danger of riots, and destruction of life and property, was imminent. Human nature is much the same the world over. It is but two hundred years since our ancestors thought it expedient and right to burn, slay, destroy, torture, and harass, all who differed with them, either religiously or politi cally, and, notwithstanding all our boasted improve ment, the desire to do so is still an active element in our characters. The animus of the parties may best be shown by extracts from the papers.

"The first act of Lincoln's administration was stained by falsehood, and shortly afterwards by deliberate, palpable, tongue-blistering, soul-damning perjury."

"The first officer under our Government, whose moral conduct should reflect the virtues and dignity of a great country, and be an example for all classes of people to imitate, stands before the world with the brand of perjury upon his brow!"

" The rebels fight for the priceless boon of liberty as did their fathers of the Revolution; the merce naries of the federal army, for Government green backs."

"If to sympathize with a brave and gallant peo ple who are struggling to throw off the yoke of a merciless despot, * * * be seeessionism, then we are secessionists."

"Abraham Lincoln, the self-confessed perjurer; * * * the buffoon; the vulgar joker; the spiritu alist; the abolitionist; the man who believes the negro his equal."

Arrest Op L. P. Hall And W. M. Penry

A company of cavalry had been stationed in lone valley to eject settlers from the Arroyo Seco grant. After the assassination of Lincoln, persons were arrested in different parts of the State for sympathy with the Rebellion, or for treasonable expressions. The Dispatch had been one of the ablest and most outspoken Democratic papers in the State, and although not coming within the boundaries of giving " substantial aid and comfort to the enemy," it had advocated the right, if not the policy, of secession; had eulogized the President and officers of the Con federate States; had abused the Union President in severe terms, and had, in fact, been a magazine of Southern ideas and arguments, on Northern soil. Some of the ablest articles in defense of the South had come out in the Dispatch] in fact, there was no writer in the county, on the Union side of the question, that was a match for the editor of the Dispatch. It was quite natural that the wrath of the Union men should seek victims in the editors and writers of the paper, though it was not charged that it had ever sanctioned the assassination of Lincoln. On the morning of the 8th of May, about daylight, the persons mentioned awoke to find themselves sur rounded by a troop of cavalry under the command of Captain Starr, acting presumably, under the com mand of General McDowell, at San Francisco. The printing office was closed up, and two or three hours afterwards the entire party left for Camp Jackson, in lone valley, our friends walking through the hot sand, with the thermometer at 100° in the shade. From thence they were taken in irons to Fort Alcatraz, where an eighteen-pound ball with chain, was attached to the legs of each man. They had the choice of hard labor on the works, under guard, or confinement in the sweat-box, and wisely chose the former. They were kept here, in company with other sympathizers, until about the middle of the following month, when peace, law, and order were so far established, that it was considered safe for them to be at large. It is said that neither of the men ever had the remotest suspicion of the cause of their incarceration !

In justice to the Dispatch and its conductors, it must be said that they picked up the cudgels of war fare at the place where they dropped them at the time of the arrest, and when they resumed the pub lication of the paper, which they did on the 23d of September following, it had lost none of the vigor which characterized it through the four years of the great Rebellion.

L. P. Hall, who was arrested with Penry, was one of the most original men ever connected with the press in Amador county, or, perhaps, in the State. He was able to stand up to the case and set up his most vituperative articles without manuscript, a feat that few editors or printers are capable of. He was thoroughly aggressive in his character, and if he had been on " Southern Soil " at the time of the breaking out of the Rebellion, his temperament would have been as likely to have carried him into the opposition as anywhere. He was previously the editor of the Equal Rights Expositor, at Visalia, a paper as pro nounced in its disloyal sentiments as the Dispatch. It was suppressed by the order of General McDowell, and the editor, and three others arrested with him, set free on taking the following oath: - STATE OF CALIFORNIA, ) County of Tulare. \

California, Citizens of the United States, do solemnly swear that we will support the Constitution and Gov ernment of the United States against all enemies, whether foreign or domestic, and that we . will bear true faith and allegiance, and loyalty to the same, any ordinance, resolution, or any State Con vention or law of any Legislature to the contrary, notwithstanding; that .we will give no aid, assistance or encouragement, by word or act, to any person or persons, or pretended Government, engaged in rebellion against the Government of the United States. And further, that we will do this with a full determination, pledge, and purpose, without any mental reservation whatsoever, so help us God. - (Signed) L. P. HALL, *

John Gaver, of Sutter Creek, who had written many of the articles in the Dispatch, was arrested about the same time, and subjected to the same treatment. He was charged with rejoicing over the assassination, which, however, he denied, or asserted, that if he did, he was drunk, and unconscious of what he said. He was arrested on complaint of 0. L. Chamberlain, F. Tibbetts, and T. Frakes.

After the assassination of Lincoln, more than one Union meeting was held to consider the expediency of demolishing the Dispatch establishment, but better counsels prevailed. It is quite likely, however, that the arrest of Penry and Hall, and the suppression of the paper for awhile, saved the material from destruction. The excitement gradually wore away, and better feeling began to prevail.

Seaton'S Defection

There was a full set of county officers, as well as members of the Legislature, to elect, and the politi cians set about arranging these matters. The national question having to some extent been settled, per sonal ambitions and antipathies began to be more manifest. When the Republican Convention met, R. Burnell was nominated, after some opposition, as candidate for Senator. G. W. Seaton, who had been acting with the Republican party for years, arose and denounced Burnell as having tried to throw the State into the hands of the secessionists, by voting for giving the seat to a Democrat in a contested election case. This affair had happened some years before, and, if true, Burnell was only voting to decide who was elected, the politics of the man, properly, having nothing to do with his right to a seat. It is likely that personal antipathy was the ruling motive, for Mr. Seaton had supported Burnell in Convention and on the stump, after the occur rence of the contested election case; but, at any rate, he announced his intention of defeating Mr. Burnell if it cost ten thousand dollars. As he had a very rich quartz vein just then to draw on for funds, the threat was very serious. He immediately announced himself as an independent candidate for Senator, and took the stump. The Democrats left the nomination for the Senatorship vacant, with the understanding that Seaton's name was to be used. The contest of course was very spirited, Seaton's gold mine being a powerful influence in his favor. It is not supposed that votes were directly pur chased, but money, which Seaton had in abundance, would purchase fire-works, orators, music, gun-pow der, and whisky, which certainly have the power of moving many people in their political opinions.

It is generally believed too, that in the early days the Italian vote was practically purchasable, that is to say, that from fifteen hundred to twenty-five hundred dollars would buy the influence of one or two men, who would control the greater portion of the Italian vote, which was numerous enough to decide, in many cases, the election. (It is said, now, by those best acquainted with the Italians, that that condition no longer exists; that individual indepen dence is becoming as common with them as with other nationalities.) When the contest was over, Seaton was elected. Amador and Alpine had remained one district for the election of members of the Legislature, Alpine being allowed one member and Amador the other three. O. F. Thornton and Harvey Lee were candidates by the respective parties, Republican and Democratic of Alpine county - Lee being elected. The following table of the returns will be interesting, as not only showing the names, and popularity of the different candidates, but also as showing the names of many precincts which were abolished when the registry law was established, this election being the last held under the old law: -

Counting The Votes

It is difficult to gather the facts in the matter of the counting of the votes. There was much illfeeling about it, and many charges of fraud, and much filing and counter-filing of protects. Judge Badgely asked that the Supervisor votes for District No. 1 be canvassed, which was r6fused. The two candidates were James Carroll and C. Ingalls. The custom had prevailed, whether lawful or not, of holding elections in the camps in Arizona and Utah, where the volunteers from Amador were stationed, and returning their votes as from a precinct. Though these soldiers were known to be of both parties, the returns were generally all one way. It was alleged by the Democrats that no fair election was held; that the officers made out the returns to suit them selves. The Democrats further urged that voting in Arizona for officers in Amador, was carrying the doctrine of constructive residence a little too far; that it was unconstitutional. The Eepublican argu ments in favor of counting their votes, were rather necessity and expediency, than law. They showed the absurdity of the Union men all going to the war, and having no voice in the choice of officers, and leaving the secessionists in the rear to rule; and the votes were counted, though protests were filed by D. Worley, John Eagon, A. C. Brown. Henry Lee, James Carroll, E. M. Bradshaw, and John Surface.

There were also other irregularities. At Clinton, D. B. Spagnoli acted both as Inspector and Clerk. There was no appearance of fraud in the matter, though the proceeding was evidently illegal. Here was a chance for a contest. The vote was generally six Eepublican, and 'sixty-four Democratic, making a difference of fifty-eight votes. If the soldiers' vote was rejected and Clinton accepted, most of the Democrats would be elected, otherwise, most of the Eepublicans. J. W. Armstrong, now a noted law yer in Sacramento, then a young man, taking his first flights in law and logic, contended for the legality of the Clinton proceeding, and asserted the principle, that the statute permitted what it did not prohibit. The returns from Lower Eancheria hav-. ing no certificate attached, were rejected.

Successor

This was caused by the explosion of the steamer To Semite, October 12, 1865, between Sacramento and San Francisco, W. A. Rogers, of Jackson, being killed at the same time. A more particular account of his life will be given in the account of the Amador Bar. This accident necessitated the calling of another election, which was fixed on the 2d of December. A. H. Rose was nominated by the Democrats and O. N. Morse by the Republicans.

Quartz again, as was said, influenced the election. Rose had money to loan where it would do him good. The M. E. Church Society at lone borrowed some $1,500. It was not charged that this purchased any votes, but having shown a disposition to accommo date the church, he was a good man and ought to be supported. He also obtained quite a support from the recently ejected settlers in lone, inducing them to think that Congress could be persuaded to remun erate them by a memorial which he promised, to get through the Legislature. His part of the contract he fulfilled; the memorial, containing a concise, wellwritten history of the Arroyo Seco grant, being trans mitted to Congress with the official seal of the State on it. These things are not related to cast reflec tions on Mr. Rose's method of conducting the canvass, but to show, as a soldier would, how battles are lost and won.

Miner Frink's seat was contested by A. C. Brown, who received but two or three votes less in the elec tion than Frink. Brown proved that two or three illegal votes were cast for Frink, and obtained the seat.

Frink afterward got a position in the office of Internal Revenue, but a year or two later, was found dead in his bed at the hotel, in San Francisco.

Financial Matters

This did not include interest which was then accu mulating at the rate of about ten thousand dollars per year, which would have carried the debt up to about one hundred and thirty thousand dollars.

Report Of An Expert, 1865

E. G. Hunt was appointed to examine the state of the finances, and reported receipts from all sources, from March, 1864, to December, 1865, as follows: -

Provenance

Text from History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.