Amador County, California - Chapter 23: Condition of the County at the Beginning of the Third Decade-- 1870, 1881
From History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. 5,858 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
17 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
- Chapter 23: Condition of the County at the Beginning of the Third Decade-- 1870
- A Few Statistics Political Parties In 1870
- Redemption Fund
- Condition Of Other Counties
- The Miners' League
- Death Op M'Menemy And Hatch
- Officers Elected In 1871
- Justices Of The Peace Financial Matters In 1872
- Tax Rates
- Election Returns For 1872 At The Beginning Of The Third Decade
- Congressional Vote
- Financial Matters In 1873
- Convention To Consider The Funding Project
- Political Matters Op 1874
- Financial Matters, 1875
- Conclusion Of The Butterfield Matter, 1877
- Political Matters In 1875
The text
5,858 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 23: Condition of the County at the Beginning of the Third Decade-- 1870
Condition of the County at the Beginning of the Third Decade - Statistics of the Wealth and Indebtedness - Politics in 1870 - Financial Condition - Redemption Fund - Condition of Other Counties - The Miners' League - Death of McMenemy and Hatch - Political Parties in 1872 - Election Returns by Precincts, 1871 - Persons Elected in 1871 - Financial Mat ters 1872 - Political Parties in 1872 - Election Returns for 1872 - Comparison of Vote with Previous Years - Financial Matters, 1873 - Political Parties in 1873 - John Eagon's Posi tion - Judge Gordon's Stand - J. T. Farley's Position - Elec tion Returns by Precincts - Officers Elected in 1873 - Alpine county Left out in the Election - Financial Matters in 1874 - The Funding Project - Political Parties in 1874 - Financial Matters in 1875 - Robbery of the Treasury May 9, 1S75 - Conclusion of Butterfield Matter in 1877 - Political Matters in 1875 - Officers elected in 1875.
ACCORDING to the reports of the Assessor the value of all property, personal and real, was $2,241,070. The county debt had been estimated as being less than $100,000, but as was written in the previous chapters of the history, it was constantly increasing, the sums paid not being equal to the interest, and con sequently no portion was applied to the payment of the principal. At the beginning of this decade the debt was nearly, if not quite, $200,000. It seems to be the fate of political organizations, as well as of individuals, to go into extravagant and wasteful expenditure in prosperous times, and pay up when times are hard. At the beginning of 1860 we found placer mining remunerative to a high degree; quartz mining established on a paying basis and agriculture and horticulture profitably employing a great num ber of men. The farms on the Mokelumne river, in Jackson, lone and Dry Creek valleys, as well as on the heads of the latter creeks, with their waving fields of grain, orchards, and vineyards, were all that could be desired.
Many causes combined to arrest this tide of pros perity. The Frazer river excitement drew away a great many miners. Still later the discovery of the Washoe mines caused another outflow of hundreds of able, industrious men. The copper excitement took a great many away from moderately profitable work; and, when copper failed in the subsequent years to prove remunerative, at least five hundred men were set adrift, most of whom left the county in search of some more promising place. During the years of 1861-64, the price of cattle of all kinds went down with a panic, so that many, who considered themselves well fixed, became poor men. The wine business, which promised so much, had proved an utter failure, every attempt to market the wine in the East resulting in loss; so that many per sons were induced to tear up their vineyards and give up the business. The orchards, which pro duced a great quantity of the finest fruit, were also poor property; for the emigration of many of the miners left no market for such products. The quartz mining alone saved the county from comparative poverty. The mines along the mother lodes, as well as in the eastern part of the county, on the Volcano
Mahoney and Hayward at Sutter Creek, and others at Diytown, Amador, and Plymouth, took out sums varying from ten thousand to sixty thousand dol lars per month. Large quantities of wood and lum ber were required, which furnished labor to as many
The gradual improvement in financial standing, through wise management, and a gradual and healthy growth in all the business industries of the country will appear as the third decade passes away.
A Few Statistics Political Parties In 1870
This was a year of quiet, as neither national, State, or county officers were to be elected. The mutterings of the storm, that was prevailing in the East, were but little heeded in the off years. It took the loaves and fishes of the county offices to arouse the politicians to a full sense of the dangers impending over our Constitution, our country or our race. No livery teams were hired to carry the men, ambitious to serve their country in easy, lucrative offices, around to alarm the people. No twenty-dollar pieces were left at the saloons to pay for beer doled out where it would do the most good. In fact, everything was dis tressingly dull, and the people were allowed to attend quietly to their business.
Nobody knew exactly how it stood. It is true that quarterly returns were made by the Sheriff, Auditor, Treasurer, and Supervisors, and occasion ally the Grand Jury would have a spasm of economy and make an inquiry into the financial condition; but who among the Grand Jurors had time to look over the stubs of the outstanding warrants, to see for what purpose, or when they were drawn, or how much interest had accumulated, or whether even the interest had been paid! A few persons were con scious of the painful uncertainty and to these the county is indebted for the arrangements which not only brought the accumulating debt to view, but pro vided means for its gradual liquidation.
Redemption Fund
As early as February 7th the Supervisors, L. Mc- Laine, Henry Peck, and D. M. Goff, took the matter under consideration and recommended a plan which, however, was said to have been first suggested by James Meehan, the Treasurer, that sixty cents on each one hundred dollars should be raised to be used as a sinking fund for outstanding registered war rants. Meehan went to Sacramento and personally solicited the support of the members not interested in the matter, his position as Treasurer enabling him to explain the necessity of some such measure, to prevent the county from becoming bankrupt. Messrs.
Farley and Brown, Senator and Assemblyman respectively, ably supported the Bill, and on the 12th of March it became a law. It provided a sinking fund of sixty cents on each one hundred dollars which was sacred for this purpose; also that no war rant should be drawn unless there was money to meet it; a certificate of indebtedness, bearing no interest, being given when occasion demanded. Though the sum specially assessed was sufficient to check the accumulation of interest, and also assisted materially in bringing to light the different items, it was not until December 3, 1872, that the full amount of liabilities was known and reported, the debt having been estimated at one hundred and sixty-five thou sand dollars. To anticipate the result it was then reported that the outstanding warrants
Condition Of Other Counties
About this time, general attention was attracted towards some of the older mining counties, which, in former years, had contained much the largest share of the population. At one time, El Dorado county, now numbering less than ten thousand inhabitants, had fifty thousand. Tuolumne, Calaveras, and some others, aleo showed a great reduc tion. In Calaveras, the condition was much worse than in Amador. The population reduced to less than ten thousand; the assessment roll yearly decreasing; the debt, principal and interest, con stantly accumulating, so that five per cent, taxes was hardly sufficient to meet current expenses; was a condition calculated to depress and crush out all industrial energy. It was known that stock-men, who grazed their flocks in the mountains of Cala veras, would hold them in other counties, where the rates of taxation were lower, until the time for assessing was past, before they would drive them to their pastures. A tax rate as high as five per cent, was considered as a mortgage for all the prop erty was worth. Things were looking so serious that the Legislature felt called upon to investigate the matter before the question of State responsibility for county indebtedness, should meet them in the shape of a judgment.
In making these investigations, Amador was con sidered one of the counties possibly requiring the aid of the State. Happily, it has passed any such probable contingency.
The Miners' League
Any history of Amador county which failed to give an account of the Miners' League, would be lamentably deficient. This Society organized as a kind of mutual benefit association. It does not appear that any unlawful measures were at first contemplated; but organization gave the members an idea of strength and influence. Merchants joined the league, for fear of losing the trade of the miners; politicians, to make a few votes; and the lawless and desperate, to work against law and order in society. In Sutter Creek, it numbered about three hundred members, composed of Irish, Cornishmen, Austrians, and Italians, and had a membership of perhaps as many more in other parts of the county. They built a large hall, costing several thousand dollars. Luke Burns, who had had some experience in simi lar associations in Virginia City, was President, and L. J. Marks, Secretary.
The immediate cause of the outbreak was the reduction of twenty-five cents a day on the wages of the hands working on the surface, in the Consoli dated Amador mine. After much discussion a gen eral strike was agreed upon, also a determination to enforce it everywhere, and not permit the working of the mines unless at the proposed rates. The schedule of wages demanded by the Miners' League made very little advance over the existing rates, but the right to make even a small advance im plied a right to control the working of the mines, and the mine owners refused to accept the rates. Members of the league to the number of two hun dred visited the different mines, and ordered the stopping of the work. They carried no arms that were in sight, though according to some reports they supplied themselves with clubs from the wood-piles of the mills. It is now contended by some that no threats or force was used; that the miners went rather as a committee of conference than as a menac ing party. They would not permit any work to be done, not even allowing an engine to be run to keep the water out. John Eagon, since State Senator, and James Meehan, as well as other prominent men, were members of the league. The former person accompanied the body of miners to the mills, as he asserted, to prevent them from committing any excesses, though others say, that having raised a storm he could not control he was swept along in the whirlwind. The mills at Amador, Sutter, and Oneida were all stopped. It is true that some of these mines, like the Keystone, Consolidated, Ama dor, and others, were paying mines, and could have paid higher wages and dividends also; but other mines like the Oneida had never paid dividends, but had always been worked at a loss. The wages paid varied from two dollars and a half a day for top hands, to four dollars for underground men. There was no plea that the wages were insufficient to sup port the families, or less than were paid in other laborious occupations, but it was intended to raise them to the Virginia and Gold Hill standard, where the expenses of living were much higher. The daily threats of destruction of life and property showed the existence of so much ill-feeling that the Governor was invoked for aid, and a body of volunteers, under General Cazenau, came from San Francisco and camped on the hill near the old Wolverine shaft. They had several pieces of artillery, and formed a regular military camp, sending out and relieving guards every evening for the different mines. Correspondents from the cities accompanied the troops, and reported the conditions every day.
Never, at any time in the history of the county, was the apprehension of danger to life and property so strong. The members of the league were men who were accustomed to danger, for what does a man care for life who risks it every day as a miner does. And then the mass of the miners felt amenable to no laws but their own. There is no class of people who have so little intercourse with the outside world, who have their own codes of ethics and modes of thought, as the professional miners. The threats of life and property, extended to other parts of the county. It seemed that the officers of justice were paralyzed. The newspapers of the county said little about it, as if fearful that a word might bring destruction upon them.
The result was a general prostration of business. The towns around the quartz mines had been the principal market for produce for some years, and when a thousand or more men were thrown out of employment and the money which was usually paid as wages ceased to circulate, the depression in business was universal, producing in some instances actual distress.
The soldiers remained in the county for several weeks, and prevented any destruction of pioperty. Some kind of concession was made which termi nated the siege, and the soldiers left, although the ill-feeling engendered by the operation remained for some time. The damage to the county by this affair can hardly be estimated. The mines of gold and copper, as well as other minerals, require the aid of capital to be made profitable. Capital must be pro tected, or it silently shuts itself up. In subsequent years, the memory of the Amador war diverted many thousands of dollars from investment in the county.
Death Op M'Menemy And Hatch
Several altercations grew out of the matter, one resulting in the death of two men and the wounding of a third. The following from the Dispatch of July 29, 1871, gives the only account of the matter to be found: -
" The wounds received by Hatch and McMenemy have both proved fatal. Both of the wounded men were attended by the best of medical aid, but human effort proved of no avail. McMenemy lingered until half-past twelve p. M., on Wednesday, when he died; Mr. Hatch, till halt-past four the. same after noon, when he breathed his last. He was conscious to the last, but unable to speak for some hours before his death.
" AVe will not attempt to give any of the particu lars of this truly melancholy affair, as there are so many conflicting statements and rumors afloat that it is almost impossible to arrive at the truth of the matter. The immediate cause of the shooting, how ever, grew out of an attack made on Mr. Hatch the Friday night previous, at a concert given in Sutter Creek. The result has created much feeling and
Hatch was the confidential clerk of the Amador Consolidated Co. Bennet was his friend, who took up the quarrel that was forced on Hatch. He was obliged to leave the county. Hatch left a young wife to mourn her loss.
Wriggles worth, an engineer, who persisted in running an engine for pumping, after notice to quit, was set upon in the streets, and escaped through the kindness of a woman in the Exchange Hotel, who hid him away while the crowd was searching for him. He also had to leave the county.
A full set of county and State officers was to be elected and, consequently, the politicians began early to take advantageous positions and set their forces in the field. There were no great national issues to arouse public interest, but a combination, or perhaps a bidding for the vote of the Miners' League, hereto fore mentioned, gave a great deal of interest to the campaign. John Eagon, a member of the League, was supposed to control three hundred votes, which number would ensure the election of any one nomin ated by either party. Few of the better citizens of either party would countenance the proceedings of the League, but as one old politician said, three hundred votes were hard to pick up, so the three hundred were treated with distinguished considera tion. What diplomatic feats were performed; what promises made and broken none will tell. The elec tion returns form the best history of the transaction.
Officers Elected In 1871
District Judge - A. C. Adams. County Judge - T. M. Pawling. Assemblymen - H. A. Waldo, J. A. Eagon. District Attorney - R. M. Briggs. County Clerk - B. F. Richtmyer. Sheriff - H. B. Kelley. Treasurer - 0. Button. Surveyor - D. D. Reaves. Assessor - J. W. Surface. Superintendent of Schools - S. G. Briggs. Coroner - Charles Boarman. Public Administrator - A. Yoak.
Justices Of The Peace Financial Matters In 1872
This may be distinguished as the year of waking up, when every cranny and pigeon hole was ran sacked to find the amount of the county debt. In February the Treasurer estimated the debt as 8179,- 265.47. On the sixth day of June the report indicated outstanding warrants on -
"Upon a thorough examination of the registration of outstanding warrants against the redemption and hospital funds of the county, as the same appears on the books of the County Treasurer, it appears that the reports made of the indebtedness of the county for the past years have been incorrect, the true indebtedness being much greater than reported. The presumption is, the error was committed by report ing the interest paid as a reduction of the principal to that amount, when in fact it did not reduce it at all."
The Assessor, J. W. Surface, catching some of the economic spirit, doubled the assessment roll and aston ished the people with the amount of wealth in the county. Assessment roll for 1872: -
Tax Rates
Considering that the population of the county was something less than ten thousand, government was was quite a luxury, costing about $8.00 per capita.
This year furnishes an apt illustration of the often repeated assertion that the desire for office was at the foundation of the enthusiasm generally prevalent during elections. There were no county offices to fill, and it was difficult to kindle any interest in the mass of voters. The Presidential election was a far away matter in the chances to get a public appoint ment, arid few took any interest on that account. Then the nominations were singular. Grant, the Republi can nominee for President, in former days, was con sidered a Democrat, and Greeley, the Democratic nominee never was a Democrat; on the contrary, he had been during his whole life, fiercely aggressive on them; had charged them with all kinds of sins, indi vidually and collectively - sins political, moral and intellectual; but Greeley had quarreled with the administration, and he was thought a suitable candi date to make an inroad in the Republican ranks. A great many, who were former admirers of Greeley, were known to be disaffected, and, it was thought, would leave the Republican party. The Democrats had now conceded the payment of the national debt and the validity of the Constitutional amendments, so that there was really little difference of opinion, on national questions, to keep the people apart. The old Democrats reluctantly fell into the ranks with
Election Returns For 1872 At The Beginning Of The Third Decade
Greeley at the head of the column. It was a decided case of self-sacrifice for the benefit of the country. The younger Democrats suspended the rule and voted as they pleased. As might have been expected the vote was very light. Even the vote for Congress man was far short of the usual numbers.
Congressional Vote
Page's vote was two hundred and two less than Grant's, and Greeley's vote two hundred and fortyeight less than Coifroth's. It is evident that many men of both parties failed to vote, and that personal preference;?, with many Democrats as well asEcpublicans, were stronger than party ties; also, that National questions were considered of less moment than the election of the right kind of men for county officers, as the whole vote fell short of the vote of the previous year as follows: -
Financial Matters In 1873
From this time, there seems to have been an earnest effort to pay off the debt, as well as to check county expenditures. The effort to make the pros pective value of the mines an item on the assessment roll, failed. The mine owners succeeded in evading it, sometimes by a technicality. In other instances, the Supervisors abated part of the tax, to avoid a doubtful and expensive lawsuit. The Keystone min ing property was assessed in bulk, the taxes amount ing to nine thousand dollars, which the company refused to pay, whereupon, J. W. Surface, the col lector, proceeded to sell the property. In the suit which followed, the Court decided, that, though the property was principally owned by one company, it should have been described and assessed as three separate properties; that, in consequence of this, the collector be restrained from selling it.
The assessment roll was reduced, to $3,186,750, and $18,176.90 taxes were reported as delinquent. The total indebtedness July 31st, was reported at -
Early in the season, it was evident that a nomina tion by the Democratic party was equivalent to an election, and the strife was principally in the prima ries. Nearly every town had a full set of candidates, who undertook to effect a combination which should have their own names on the slate. When the pri maries were over, the successful operators went into the Convention, each with his list of delegates, which he could trade or bestow on any other candidate as a consideration for votes given to himself. Some sturdy, independent men, finding themselves valued, labeled and consigned to certain parties, will rebel and fret, but a skillful manipulator will manage to conciliate them with the promise of a nomination another year, or something equally delusive, and so, year after year, a smart manager wriggles him self into office; and the man who studies political economy instead of men, who knows less of prima ries and more of the science of government, is left in the rear in the race. It may be said, however, in defense of this kind of political economy, that the best governments are the result of organizations which harmonize conflicting elements into a force working for the general good; that he who cannot lead, and is unwilling to follow, must stand aside. This season showed a change of positions of some of the leaders. John Eagon, one of the old Demo cratic war horses, who was wont to fall into the front line when a charge was sounded, now ranged himself with the Eepublicans. When he made his intention known, he excused, or rather justified, him self with the remark of a Eoman orator: " Tempora mutantur, mutamur," which may be translated, Times change, we change. In a rather lengthy address, the sentiment, above quoted, was elaborated into something like the following: "Fellow-citizens: I honestly defended slavery, not that I believed it advantageous to States or to the nation, but because I found it recognized in the national compact as an existing institution. I opposed the attempt to coerce the States who refused to submit to the election of of a President, and the establishment of an adminis tration hostile to the institution of slavery, not because I justified secession, but because I believed that reunion could be safely left to time and oppor tunity. The nation thought otherwise. Slavery has been abolished by the court of last resort; the Union has been re-established, though at a fearful price. I do not believe in prolonging a useless, strife. I am willing to accept the verdict, and abide the judgment of the Court. I am willing to forget the past, and join with any party to cultivate peace and friendship between the two sections, and repair the waste and desolations of the war."
Judge Gordon also took the stump for the Repub lican party. He had been longer a member of the Democratic party, because an older man; had been a Murat in the thickest of the fight, where his intel lectual sword was sure to cleave a broad way through opposing ranks. Though his judgment might have caused him to submit to, and advocate? the new order of political economy, his heart did not respond to the new slogan. His speeches lacked the usual fire and vim, and, in a few years after, he concluded to give his old age to the party of his youth.
James T. Farley, who had quietly taken the bit ter pill of defeat during the years of the war, was now in front. He had been prudent during the years of bitter strife; had tried to soften the asper ity and vindictiveness of both parties. He had remained with the Democrats when sure defeat awaited them. His uniform consistency won the confidence of the community. He also accepted the results of the war, and wished to cultivate peace and amity.
When Alpine county was organized, in 1864, it was joined to Amador as a Legislative district, which was allowed one Senator and two Assembly men. It was a mutual understanding that Alpine should have one Assemblyman, and Amador the other, and the Senator. This arrangement was observed for two Legislative terms, but in 1871 and 1873 the bargain was forgotten in the hurly burly of election, and Amador got the whole delegation. It happened, in this way, that Louis Miller, a Republi can, was elected to the Assembly, though the party to which he belonged was in the minority. In 1874 Alpine was joined to El Dorado for election purposes, and had no further political connection with Ama dor.
Convention To Consider The Funding Project
The Grand Jury which met at the February term, C. C. Belding, foreman, recommended a serious effort to put the finances on a better basis; proposed a general reduction of fche salaries of officers, and a funding of the county indebtedness at a lower rate of interest, and proposed a general mass-meeting on the 21st instant to consider the situation. The call for a convention was responded to by only a few individuals, who did not seem to have very clear ideas of how refunding the whole debt and issuing bonds bearing interest should lessen the taxes of the county, when a considerable portion of the indebted ness was not bearing interest. The movement was scouted by some as a measure in the interest of the bond-holders, and by others advocated as an eco nomical measure. Nothing resulted from it.
Political Matters Op 1874
As there were neither national, State, or county elections during this year, the chapter on political matters will be much like the one said to have been written by Dean Smith on the snakes of Ireland, which consisted of the single line, " There are no snakes in Ireland." No momentous events occurred to disturb the serenity of those who were comforta bly seated at their desks in the Court House. The newspapers kept up the usual rattle of squibs and fire-crackers, and continued to take in the cash for Sheriff's sales, patent medicines, and " new goods for sale cheaper than ever at the old stand. "
Financial Matters, 1875
Sometime in the night, the residence of the Treas urer (Mr. Butterfield) was entered, and his pants rifled of the key to the inner lock of the safe, the outer one being a Bussey combination lock. The robbers then went to the Court House, unlocked the office door, opened the safe, and took out fifteen thousand two hundred and forty-eight dollars, most of which belonged to the School Fund, consisting of fourteen thousand dollars in gold coin, one thousand two hundred and eight dollars in silver coin, and forty dollars in gold notes. The safe and room were then re-locked, and the prize carried away. There were two checks amounting to one thousand dollars, and some four or five hundred dollars in gold notes, which were not taken. When Mr. Butterfield awoke in the morning, he was affected with dizziness and a sickness of the stomach, and did not get up until after his usual hour of rising, and did not miss the loss of the pants until five o'clock.
When Mr. Butterfield discovered the loss of the key, he suspected that a robbery had been com mitted, and called upon several citizens to go to the Court House with him to examine the safe. They found the door of the office locked as usual; the safe was also in its usual condition, the outer door being locked, and apparently undisturbed. It yielded to the usual combination, but the larger portion of the money, amounting to fifteen thousand two hundred and forty-eight dollars, was missing. Some spots of candle-grease on the floor, were the only marks of disorder perceptible.
A meeting of the Board of Supervisors was called to consider the matter. A reward of three thou sand dollars was offered for the recovery of the treasure, and one thousand dollars for the conviction of the robbers. Some professional detectives were emplo}Ted to make a thorough investigation into all the circumstances connected with the matter. They decided that it was next to impossible for any one, not acquainted with the combination, to open the door without breaking the lock, or to shut it when opened. On inquiry, it was found that the combi nation was the one in use during the term of office of his predecessor, Mr. Button; that several persons besides the Treasurer knew the combination; James B. Stevens, the County Clerk, had once opened the safe during a temporary illness of the Treasurer, the combination having been written on a slip of paper for that purpose; that it was called off by another person in the hearing of several others - Mr. Stevens turning the handle to correspond with the letters called.
The detectives were of the opinion that no robbery was committed on the night in question; that it had been abstracted at a time, or at different times, pre vious to the 9th and 10th of May, by parties who were familiar with the combination. The wildest rumors were immediately afloat concerning the loss of the money. It was said that a syndicate of Court House officers with some outside friends, had been using the funds to speculate in stocks, which, at that time, were making and breaking fortunes for hun dreds of lucky or unlucky men. As ten thousand dollars or more of the school funds were frequently left in the safe for months, tlie use of it in a certain venture would do the county no harm. The ab straction of the money with the intention of return ing it, was not stealing. All this and much more was put forward as probable excuses for abstracting the public funds. In fact, it was confidently stated that a fortunate speculation was once made by a former Treasurer in that same way.
saw-mill and could erect several houses, if necessaiy, without taxing the mill above its powers, but he had to bear a share of the public rumors. The using of the old combination, which was known to several persons, was a matter which merited blame, and suspicion must necessarily rest upon all who were familiar with the combination and had access to the safe.
Some of the efforts to find the money were ludi crous enough to set the public on the grin. Dr. Randall of lone, who is a firm believer in his power to call spirits up, or down, from the ethereal deep, and gather knowledge from their more than human wisdom, announced his ability to find the missing money, but the sibyls either knew nothing about it, or set him to digging in the wrong places, for its location is still a mystery - to the public.
June 17, 1875. - At a special meeting of the Board of Supervisors, to consider the loss of the county funds, it was ordered that proceedings be immedi ately commenced against the Treasurer and bonds men, for the missing funds.
It may be as well to anticipate the result, and make a connected history of the affair. At the close of Mr. Butterfield's term of office, two experts, employed to investigate the accounts, reported as follows: -
This was incorporated into the judgment, which was obtained against the Treasurer and bondsmen, which, with costs, amounted to twenty-two thou sand two hundred and ninety-two dollars and fortysix cents.
"It was held by the Court that the custodian of the county funds was responsible to the county for them in all cases, except by acts of God, or a public enemy, in which cases there might be a doubt. As these conditions were not included in the plea of the defendants, they would not be considered. The Court ordered judgment to be entered against defendants for full amount of loss and costs, amount-
Conclusion Of The Butterfield Matter, 1877
At a meeting of the Board of Supervisors in the early part of 1877, to take into consideration the Butterfield judgment for twenty-two thousand seven hundred and one dollars and thirty-one cents, it was ordered that the proposition of the defendants' attorne}Ts, Farley and Porter, to pay the sum of six thousand dollars, in three annual installments with out interest, be accepted, the payments to commence April 1, 1877. This compromise was considered best because the sureties resisted the payment of the full amount, and a long and costly suit being the alter native. It was further said: " If we compel the sureties to pay the deficit, no future Treasurer could ever get bonds!"
health was much shattered by the unfortunate affair, it is nearly settled. Public opinion, much against him at first, has become nearly unanimous that he was more sinned against than sinning; a victim rather than a criminal. No clue has yet been obtained to the missing money, though it is gener ally thought to have gone into Flood and O'Brien's bank, through stock speculations.
Political Matters In 1875
The uniform success of the Democratic party during recent years, left the struggle principally for the nominations. Personal popularity was the basis for success in the Convention. Although the national questions were discussed to some extent on the stump, it was done rather in obedience to custom than for any particular interest the people took in the matter. Judge Carter, Democratic nominee for the Assem bly, was noted for suavity and pleasing address, and in his progress through the county, mostly let poli tics alone and dealt in personal reminiscences. Dunlap was a merchant in Sutter Creek, and though not a speaker, had the confidence of the community. Green well, his adversary in Sutter Creek, and Brown of Jackson, though men of eloquence and ability, failed to make any inroad on the solid Democratic vote. Brown was in charge of the Amador ditch, and was expending much money in the county. Peck and Aitken, candidates for County Clerk, were both good men, who stood high in the community; also in the societies to which they both belonged. Vogan! who does not know his bland face, twinkling with humor, which has carried sunshine along all the stage-roads since '49? There were no personal objections to the candidates on either side, and when the vote was counted the results were not unexpected.
Provenance
Text from History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.