BlockBefore

Amador County, California - Chapter 37: Arroyo Seco Grant, 1881

From History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. 7,568 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

19 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

7,568 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 37: Arroyo Seco Grant

Claim Rejected - Claim Confirmed on Appeal - Character of Grant - Matters of Record - Letter from T. A. Heudricks, Attorney General - Final Survey - During Hancock Agency -

THE policy of making homes for the people of easy attainment has been so long established in the United States that few living have any recollections to the contrary. In New York the Patroon estates, and in Louisiana the Spanish grants, had hung like a pall over the inhabitants, but the majority of the people knew nothing of the relics of feudalism, which made one man the owner of the rents at least, of thousands of acres. When the great immigration poured into California in 1849-50, they found the valleys and plains around the bay and larger rivers in the pos session of a few men. General Sutter at New Helvetia, Charles Weber at Stockton, were near the mines first discovered, and first gave an idea of the scope of the princely estates, which afterwards, in the hands of professional land-grabbers, whose infernal resources seemed unfathomable, became such a source of oppression and robbery. The confusion in the early records of the California government; the loose manner in which the records were kept in the national archives in the city of Mexico; the difficulty of gain ing access to them on account of the distance, all conspired to render the grant system a fruitful field for the operations of rascals. Grants were manufac tured by the hundred after the treaty of peace with Mexico. In some instances the paper itself on which the grants were written, bore water-marks of a date subsequent to the treaty; these were of course re jected. Others as fraudulent, but more cautiously manipulated, were made to fit the lands made valua ble by settlement. The uncertainty of titles to the agricultural lands around the bay were, to the earlier settler of Amador county, far away matters. The first glimpse of the impending calamity came in 1853. Dr. E. B. Harris and H. A. Carter of lone were visiting the Legislature then in session at Benicia, to further the project of the organization of the new county of Amador. There they casually learned of a claim recently filed in the General Land Office with "!ONE" marked in the center of a plot of the claim. The reader will remember that "lone" was a name given to the valley almost by inspira tion. Who had any business with that name? A visit to the Land Office was next in order. There was the title

El Arroyo Seco

This purported to be a tract of land granted to Teodocio Yerba May 8, 1840, containing eleven leagues of land. Sierra Nevada mountains! Cosumnes river! Moqueleme river! Sacramento road! Which were the Sierras? Where was the Sacramento road? It may well be supposed that our friends had no heart for lobbying a bill through the Legislature for the di vision of the county of Calaveras. They returned home and called a public meeting, to announce the coming disaster. Charles Walker was made chairman. Judge Carter explained the situation. Some were for treat ing the claim with contempt. The uncertainty of the boundaries, the enormous area included in the description, were conclusive evidence of fraud. Others reasoned differently. If the grant had been fraudulent it would have been more carefully worded. Its uncertainty, the awkwardness of description, such as one might make who never had seen the country, or such as he might get from the Indians, was in favor of its realty. There was the Shaddon & Day lor ranch, the Pico ranch, and the Weber, only a little ways off.

A society or league was formed to contest the grant. It does not appear that any forcible or illegal means were thought of. Money was raised and legal talent engaged. A. C. Brown and EL. A. Carter were employed to engage a competent man to watch the affair. O. P. Sutton, a clerk in the Land Office was first employed, Thorntorn & Williams, two eminent land lawyers, being afterwards associated with him.

Claim Rejected

February 27, 1855, the claim was rejected by" the Commissioners appointed by the United States Gov ernment to try the validity of the Mexican claims.

On the 12th of May, notice of appeal from the decision of the Commissioners was filed in the United States District Court, followed by a petition for review on the llth of June. On the 21st of April, 1856, the decision of the Commissioners was reversed by Judge Hoffman.

Claim Confirmed

By this decision, Andres Pico was entitled to eleven square leagues of land, somewhere in the boundaries set forth in his grant. On the 3d of October, 1856, an appeal to the United States Supreme Court was perfected, and the transcript sent up. It does not appear that the Court ever took the case into con sideration. So far, in this matter, the people had a right to think the Government would watch their interests. The claims for land were against the Gov ernment, not against the people; but we can hardly consider the Courts and their officers as acting for the people, but for the speculators. It is now, after the lapse of a quarter of a century, difficult to ascer tain the true facts in the case. Whether Williams & Thornton did their duty during this stage of the affair; whether any attorney for the people made an appearance when the case was called in the United States Court, is not known; but, at any rate, on the 4th of May, 1858, the case was, on motion of Attor ney-General Black, dismissed, and the order for dis missal of suit filed in San Francisco.

Character Op The Grant

As the claim to the. land is now confirmed, a little knowledge as to the character of the men concerned may not be out of place. Yorba, or Yerba, for it seems that he could not write his name, and proba bly did not know how to spell it, was connected by marriage with some of the higher families. Juan B. Alvarado was an intriguer, first a Secretary in the department of Customs; then a revolutionist, who by means of an arrangement with Isaac Graham, a Tennesseean, wriggled himself into the position of Governor. It is said of him that he gave to all his followers whatever land they asked for. The date of the grant is May 8, 1840. Sutter did not settle at New Helvetia until the latter part of 1839. His grant was not completed until 1841; Weber's not until 1843.

In the Autumn of 1841, the Mokelkos, a tribe of Indians living on the Mokelumne, below Lockeford, stole some cattle from Sutter. He organized an expe dition and attacked them, marching thirty miles in the night. This march would carry him across the Cosumnes, and in sight of the Jim Martin and Lyon range of hills, which are probably described in the grant as the " neighboring Sierras." But he did not obtain his grant from Alvarado until June, 1841. Pio Pico's grant covered the lower portion of the Mokelumne river. Charles Weber did not get his grant until some years after he had resided with Sutter, and not until after the termination of Suttcr's war with the Mokelkos, and a treaty of peace with them. He obtained permission to settle on the slough at Stockton from the chief, by agreeing to defend them against the Mexicans, the mortal enemies of the Mokelkos. In the subsequent revolutions, while Alvarado was striving to rnantain his position as Governor, it is said that Sutter assisted him mate rially with men, in return for which he not only gave Sutter a large tract of land, but granted to other persons, such as Sutter should recommend, in his capacity as Justice, other tracts. If the date of this had been but a year and a month later, it might have been genuine, but reason is against such a con-

Yerba's grant was made May 8, 1840, by Juan B. Alvarado; Butter's grant, June, 1841, by same per son; Guillermo Gulnac's for Weber, July 13, 1843, by Manuel Micheltorena.

The Hudson's Bay Fur Company had a tradingpost at French Camp (hence the name), south of Stockton, for many years, and left about the time that Weber obtained his grant, which induced him to locate temporarily on the Cosumnes, until he got on better terms with the Mokelkos.

Andres Pico, who bought of Yerba, was brother of the last Governor, Pio Pico, and is said to have been addicted to drink and gambling. De Zaldo was in 1850-51 a clerk in the Land Office. It seems more probable that the whole matter was cooked up in the Land Office after the discovery of gold, than that the grant should have preceded such settlements as Sutter's and Weber's. The fact that at the time of making the grant no Mexican dared show bis head east of the San Joaquin or Sacramento rivers, serves to confirm the former hypothesis. Governor Downey, who is believed to have a good knowledge of the nature of Spanish claims, denounced the Arroyo Seco as a rank fraud.

Know all men by these presents, That we, Teodocio Yerba and Maria Antonio Lugo Ins wife, for and in consideration of the sum of five hundred head of cattle, paid and delivered to us by Andres Pico, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, have sold, bargained and transferred and by these presents sell, bargain and transfer to the said Andres Pico and his heirs and assigns, all that tract of land situate and lying in the county of Sacramento, bounded and described as follows : " Situado asi a las Cordil leras la Sierra Nevada tene endo for limetes at Norte el vio de los Cosumnes al sur el do Moquelemes at aiccenle el camino del Sacramento Yal este Las Sierras immuratus," and known by the name of " El Arroyo Seco," and being the same tract of land granted to the said Teodocio Yerba, by Governor Juan B. Alvarado, 8th May, 1840, and containing, more or les.8, eleven leagues, together with all the improvements thereon, the rights, easements, and privileges appertaining thereto, to have and to hold for the use and benefit of the said Andres Pico, his heirs and assigns forever. And we for ourselves our heirs and administrators, hereby covenant with the said Pico, his heirs and assigns, that we will warrant and defend the said premises hereby conveyed, against the claims and demands of any person or persons claiming by, through or from us.

Maria Antonio X Lugo

This was the famous sale of the mines, and in cluded all of the quartz leads that were then known to be valuable, Spring Hill, Keystone, Herbertville, Amador, Union, Eureka, Badger, etc., also the town sites of Amador, Sutter and Jackson.

The most of these were town lots in Jackson. Contracts for sale were also made in many places in the valley. In most instances the sales were made to influential persons upon favorable terms, the object being to detach them from the party of oppo sition. This was particularly true of the sales to Green & Vogan, John Edwards, Charles Stone, and James P. Martin.

Soon after the confirmation of the grant by the District Court, Pico employed Sherman Day to sur vey and sectionize the ranch in accordance with the United States survey, making Mount Diablo a base and meridian point. The lines were run to include all the valuable farms and mines possible. Many thousand dollars were obtained for the mines. After all had been got from them that was possible, the claim to the mines was abandoned, new lines being run to include other farms. For some years it was a floating grant. The lines were run so as to include a greater area on Dry creek. An improvement in any direction was sure to bring the grant line around it.

Location Of The Tract

This was next in order. During the location of the claim, high up on the mountains, the United States had sectionized and sold some of the valley lands on Dry creek, Purkey being among the pur chasers. When the miners had been bled, the claim was again projected west on the lands recently sold by the Government, again making the United States a party to the affair.

For three or four years the people saw surveyor's lines run around their homes, Surveyor-General Mandeville being among those engaged. As he was supposed to be acting in his official capacity, a re monstrance against the crooked lines was forwarded to President Buchanan, but it seems that the article was not sufficiently explicit in describing the claim. Thomas A. Hendricks, Commissioner of the General Land Office, returned the following answer: -

Letter From Thomas A. Hendricks General Land Office

August 18th, 1857. SIR: There has been referred to this office a letter from you, dated 27th of June last, addressed to the President of the United States, complaining of a lo cation of a private claim, under a Mexican grant called the "Arroyo Seco," so as to cover the settle ments and improvements of yourself and others. The claim referred to is presumed to be that entered as No. 186, on the Docket of the Board of Land Com missioners, rejected by Board of Land Commissioners November 22d, 1853, but afterwards confirmed by the United States District Court, and the appeal dis missed in the United States Supreme Court, and therefore, stands finally confirmed.

The survey of this claim has not been returned to this office, and we have, therefore, no means of judg ing of the manner of its location. Though your let ter presents a case of hardship, and the policy of the Government favors the protection of the settlers on public lands, we regret that you furnish no such spe cific information in the matter as would justify action by the Department. When, however, the final sur vey of the claim shall be returned, it will be carefully examined, particularly in respect to the " zigzag form" of its location, as represented by you. Very respectfully,

Thomas A. Hendricks

The Arroyo Seco was filed November 1, 1852, and was numbered 441; was rejected February 27, 1855, so that the claim referred to by Commissioner Hen dricks could not have been the Arroyo Seco. Upon farther inquiry it proved that Mandeville had been employed and paid by the grant party while ostensi bly acting in an official capacity.

October 17, 1858, Mandeville wrote to the set tlers that he should not make a final survey until after he returned from Washington, to which place he was then going. He assured them that all should be heard.

The Final Survey

Was made in August, 1859. At the hearing of this, before Judge McAllister, a great many witnesses were examined as to the character of the country. The lagoon west of lone, on Buckeye creek, accord ing to some, was the valley intended to be covered by the grant. It was urged, with much reason, that the mountains between that lagoon and lone valley were the "Sierras immuratus;" others ridiculed the idea of calling the hills of the tertiary formation a part of the mountains. Judge McAllister decided, April 26, 1860, that the grant of land was west of the Lyons and Martin Mountains. This, for a time, seemed to have removed the load of misery from the residents of lone valley; from this time to December 10th was the golden opportunity, as we shall here after see. The survey was confirmed by Judge Hoff man, September, 1862. It is said that Hoffman ex amined the ground personally. This survey, and the new ownership which had occurred, fairly real ized the worst fears of the settlers. In order to make a connected history, it will be necessary to retrace our steps and consider the condition of affairs.

During Hancock'S Agency

For the purpose of acting as a partner and giving more authority to his deeds, Henry Hancock bought of Andres Pico one-fifth of the grant for sixty thou sand dollars, deed dated April 20, 1859, and redeeded it for the same consideration the same day. The first deed was filed April 28, 1859, the second, June 9, 1860. Andres Pico also sold to De Zaldo a further interest of two leagues, for five thousand dollars. De Zaldo sold his entire interest in the grant to Pio Pico, commonly called Governor Pico, brother to Andres, December 10, 1861, for four thou sand dollars. As at this time the principal contest was on the location of the grant; many efforts being made to compromise the matter, and end the con test. January 7th, Pico had written to the settlers assuring them of his good will, and asked them to consult with each other, so as to come to some amicable understanding. In May, Hancock com menced acting as agent for Pico and De Zaldo. May 27th, he wrote that a further contest would only waste their mutual substance, which would go to enrich strangers. A report becoming current that, in case the survey was confirmed, those who had been most active in opposing the grant, would have to pay a high price, Pico assured them that all should have their land at the same rate. During the time while the confirmation of the survey was pending in the United States Supreme Court for the Northern Dis trict of California, a number of the settlers, H. A. Carter, W. H. Harron, W. K. Johnston, assisted by O. P. Sutton, of their counsel, acting for the settlers, entered into an agreement with Pico to the follow ing effect: -

Agreement

One-fourth at the time of completing the sale, and the balance to be paid within ninety days after a United States patent or its equivalent should be recorded at the county seat, without interest until the ninety days had expired. All indebtedness to be secured by mortgage. Pico to extinguish all liens and taxes outstanding on the land, so as to give the settlers a clear title. The settlers were to withdraw all opposition to the confirmation of the survey now pending in the Supreme Court of the United States for the Northern District of California. In case of disagreement as to the class of the lands in question, each party interested was to name one person, and these two a third, if necessary to effect a classifica tion.

This was about one-fourth of the price at which the lands were valued, yet very few seemed to be willing to accept the terms. If the land was theirs, they wanted it without paying a greaser for it. Ten dol lars an acre for a person who had already taxed himself twice that, to oppose the grant, was no easy matter to raise. It was hard to bring the men to concert of action. The moderate terms which Pico offered were considered as indicating a consciousness of a weak case, and so the matter remained unde cided.

Sale To J. Mora Moss & Co

Pico, as well as the settlers, had become exhausted with the long effort. Twenty-three hundred head of cattle had been driven into market and sold, to maintain the suit, and a mortgage for thirty-five thousand dollars was resting on the grant, as an evidence of further expenditure. Tired of the profit less contest, and, perhaps, disgusted with the dilatory action of the people, he sold on the 10th day of December, 1861, to J. Mora Moss, H. W. Carpentier. E. F. Beales, Herman Wohler, and others. This firm was composed of men who had become noto rious in connection with land grants. They had even then acquired the reputation of hesitating at nothing which would forward their suits.

Bribery and perjury were openly talked of. The suits, or contests, whatever they may be called, still at this date, 1881, overshadow whole communities and paralyze the industries of cities and towns. Look at the cases of the Sobrante ranch, and the water front of Oakland. When the news of the sale came, and afterwards the confirmation of the survey by Judge Hoffman, September, 1862, "Hope for a season bade the world farewell."

No astonishment was felt when, in 1863, Attorney- General Bates dismissed the appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States, and swept away the last ground for hope. If the Central Pacific Rail road Company can make the Sierras reach within five miles of Sacramento, perhaps Mora Moss & Co. may drive them back as far.

As a last- resort, a memorial in a few words was addressed to President Lincoln and Attorney-Gen eral Bates, asking that the case might be again put on the calendar for a hearing. The paper was signed by several hundred persons, nearly all the residents of the county.

To Hon. Abraliam Lincoln, President of the United States, and Hon. 6'. M. Bates, Attorney-General: - We, the undersigned citizens of the United States havmgfailed every where, and under all circumstances' in our efforts to obtain justice in a matter of the deepest moment to ourselves and families, now as a last resort, appeal to you. Failing in this, we will endeavor to reconcile ourselves to our hard fate, and at once quit our humble homes, and make room for those who, by means of their greater wealth, have been able to tire us out and obtain our little farms and poor homes, which have cost us long years of toil and privation.

Most of your petitioners emigrated to California at an early day, bringing with us our families and all we possessed, intending in the far-off land to make homes for ourselves and our children.

We located where we now reside, in Amador county, and upon lands then claimed by none but Indians, arid as we honestly believed, owned by the general government.

Here at the foot of the mountains, under the laws of the State of California, we took up for ourselves homes in small parcels, varying from fifty to one hundred and sixty acres each. Being upon mineral land we have enjoyed our possessions uninterruptedly, save when the miners saw fit to prospect and mine within our enclosures.

Years after our location, and when the eastern border of the tract was found valuable because of its mineral deposits, and when the whole face of our section had become a community of happy families, the rumor reached us that a Spanish grant covered our homes.

We consulted and employed lawyers; we have ex hausted ourselves and been beaten. Now we think we are wrongfully defeated, and appeal to you for interposition in our behalf, so far as is consistent and proper.

Then came the location of the grant. Surveyor- General Mandeville located the grant, extending the eastern boundary into the foot-hills of the Sierra Nevada, to a point (improperly as we insist) which embraces our homes within the location.

About this time the grant changed hands, passing from Andres Pico to the present proprietors, con sisting of the following gentlemen : J. Mora Moss, H. W. Carpentier, Surveyor-General Beale, and Her man Wohler.

This party, men of great wealth, procured a re hearing of the case before the Hon. Ogden Hoffman, District Judge of the United States District Court.

dismissed, and we are therefore deprived of a fair hearing before the Tribunal of last resort, whither we supposed we were advancing according to the rules and practices of the Courts of our country, and from which Tribunal we were fondly hoping to re ceive the relief from litigation and oppression from which we have suffered so long.

Now all we ask from you, gentlemen, is that the case may be reinstated upon the calendar, treated as a new case, and passed upon by the Court. The de cision of that high Tribunal, though adverse to us, will be cheerfully acquiesced in.

First Attempts At Dispossession

Soon after the dismissal of the appeal a United States patent was obtained, and an attempt was made to dispossess the settlers. It was wisely resolved not to bring the people of the county into collision with their own officers, and a man by the name of Benjamin Bellock, said to be a Peruvian citizen, was put forward, so as to throw the case into the hands of a United States Marshal, though Bellock's inter est must have been very remote, as his name does not appear on record as an owner of any part of the grant. The Marshal put in an appearance one day, and was in the act of evicting Thomas Rickey when quite a number of men (the Marshal estimated them at fifty), armed with rifles and pistols, went along to see how the thing was to be done. It is said that Turner, one of the settlers, used some threatening language, but no violence was used. The appearance of opposition was expected, and, perhaps, desired. The Marshal went back to San Francisco.

Settlers' League

This has been referred to before. Its organization was a secret one, and the proceedings were never published. Public notices were printed in an odd kind of type, and were signed with a numeral as Secretary. It was supposed that the members num bered three hundred or more. It was not known, of course, what measures were contemplated. Resist ance to dispossession was openly talked of. It was thought that the grant company would have to pay the expense of keeping the soldiers in the field. Others said that we should be compelled to yield; that successful resistance to one company of soldiers would only bring a regiment, to oppose which would be an insurrection, another rebellion; but that we might murder the proprietors, and annoy those who should undertake the cultivation of the land, so as to make it worthless. The feeling was very bitter, and a little indiscretion might have brought on bloodshed.

The Soldiers Have Come

On the eleventh of February the sullen boom of the cannon, heard for miles around, announced the arrival of the soldiers. Why the cannon was fired does not appear, but every one knew the meaning. There was no gathering, no appearance of resistance. What might have happened if a smaller number had commenced the dispossession, can only be imagined.

The seventy -five might - coujd have been beaten, but these were the " boys in blue," who had been battling so bravely for the Union, who had borne the flag aloft mid shot and shell in many a bloody field, who had saved our country. It is quite likely that grief as well as anger pervaded the league, and no resistance was offered. The people were deter mined to lose no point by vacating voluntarily, but quietly suffered their goods, household utensils, their wives and children, to be removed into the streets, in the storm, even, for the eviction took place in Feb ruary, the month of rains. Some formed camps, others went to the houses of friends, and some went back to the houses from which they had been ejected. The fastenings were slight, and perhaps it was expected that they would return, though as tresspassers. A man by the name of Clark, venera ble, respectable and prudent, was made custodian and superintendent of the property. So far, the dis possession of the settlers had gone on without violence. The dispatches sent to the principals were congratulatory.

Shooting Op Herman Wohler

Wohler was perhaps the smallest owner in the grant, and, likely, the smallest capitalist in the com pany, and was probably put forward to manage the eviction on account of having no moral weakness or humane feelings which should prevent him turning a multitude of men, women and children out of their homes. If he had feelings to gratify, if he wished to avenge the long and persistent fight the settlers had made for their homes, his opportunity was ample. His pitiless face was seen everywhere directing the soldiers in their work - the only one in the whole crowd who did not show disgust with the business. Every man who had been driven out marked his overbearing and unfeeling demeanor. The dispos session was complete. The Arroyo Seco steal was a fixed fact. Any settler now who wished to have his rights would have to wade through an awful quag mire of law and technicalities. A big dinner was given, to celebrate the successful termination of the matter, which was attended by some of the county officers, among whom was the District Attorney, Briggs. Hare, stewed in wine, was said to be one of the extraordinary dishes set at this entertainment. The celebration was generally known, and was con sidered, in view of the distress of the people, heart less, and even insulting. It passed off, however, without disturbance, the guests leaving about ten o'clock p. M. Wohler was about retiring, and went to raise the window, to let out some of the cigar smoke which filled the room. While he stood for a moment looking into the darkness, the report of a rifle, in the direction of the blacksmith shop, was heard; he felt the sting of a ball in his chest and fell back seriously wounded. It was supposed to be mortal, but he so far recovered, in a few days, as to be removed to San Francisco.

The news that a man had been shot in lone on account of land matters, soon found its way over the State, and throughout the East. The settlers were now put on the defense. Those who were unac quainted with the previous facts denounced it as an atrocious act. Those who knew something of thecircumstances, which have been related in this his tory, will find some reasons for a mild sentence. "To forgive is divine," they say. Forgiveness may be an attribute of divinity, but, though the lone Valley people are, perhaps, as moral and as well-behaved as any community in the State, they have never made any pretensions to a divine nature. Let no one pass judgment on the act until he has first put himself in the place of a settler, ejected, with his wife and chil dren, from a home which he has wrested from a desert.

Wohler recovered from this wound, and died about two years since in Sonoma county. The agent, Clark, put in possession of the property was prudent and obliging, as far as his position would permit, renting the land to the former owners at a nominal figure. In a few years the ill-feeling seemed to abate, the new owners were-permitted to occupy the lands in security, and peace and industry once more re sumed their sway.

The Last Effort

To get justice was made at the session of the Legis lature in 1865-66. Through the instrumentality, prin cipally, of A. H. Rose, State Senator from Amador county, Congress was memorialized on the subject. On hearing it read, many members of Congress denounced the system of grunts as a store-house of fraud, but nothing beneficial to the settlers ever came of it.

Memorial To Congress

That at the time California was acquired by the United States, a tract of arable land, containing pome fifty thousand acres, well watered and exceed ingly fertile, had remained, from its secluded position and its distance from the sea-coast, if not undiscov ered, entirely unoccupied by civilized man. The tract lies near to the Sierras, and is surrounded by low hills, and beyond them sterile plains, and it is quite probable that up to the time when gold was discov ered it had never been visited by white man; it is entirely certain that no vestige of civiliza tion was ever found on it. In 1848, when General Sutter prospected for gold two miles above in the foot-hills, the principal stream which irri gates and fertilizes'this valley had not even a name to designate it. It has been known from that time as Sutter creek. The same is true of its second principal stream, named for an early miner, Jackson. Another, still, from a miner, Amador; and, curiously enough, the grant, which will be hereafter mentioned, takes its name from a stream christened by the Mexican miners, after eighteen hundred and forty-eight, Arroyo Seco, or Dry creek, and the vil lage in which they lived is still known as Dry town. The valuable belt of mineral lands embracing the villages of Drytown, Amador, Sutter Creek and Jackson, lies ten miles to the above and to the east of this valley, and was prospected by Amador, Sutter, Jackson, and others, in the fall and winter of 1848-49, and at that time the valley was entirely -unoccupied.

In 1849 it attracted the attention of enterprising men, who found it as nature had left it, unoccupied and unclaimed. They believed, and were justified by all appearances in this belief, that this was public land, belonging to the United States. They were principally Western men, who had from their youth been familiar with the beneficent system of land laws in the new and unoccupied Territories of the Union, and they settled at once in the beautiful val ley, each making out, as near as he could, his hundred and sixty acres, and felt as certain of his right to do so, and as secure of his possession, as any heir could be to his ancient inheritance. They knew the country had been ceded to the United States; they knew the lands were public lands, for there was neither occupant nor claimant - not a vestige of a house, not a hoof of stock, nor a settlement nearer them than Sutters Foi't, forty miles distant. These lands were exceedingly fertile, and convenient to the best market for farm produce in the world, the mines of California.. As soon as the capacity of these lands to produce both grains and fruits had been tested by these hardy pioneers, they became at once exceedingly valuable. Improvements were com menced of the most permanent character; orchards and vineyards were planted; beautiful and expen sive dwellings were erected ; steam-power was introduced; large mills for converting their grain into flour were built; hotels, stores, and villages sprang up from the plain as if by magic; extensive ditches and costly aqueducts, both for the purpose of irrigation and working the mines upon the borders of the valley, were constructed, while churches and school-houses told plainer than words could convey, who were the settlers of lone valley " and this waste land, where no man came or had come since the making of the world," blossomed as only California valleys can under the hand of experienced culti vation.

This picture is not overdrawn, and but feebly con veys an idea of the prosperity, progress, and refine ment of the settlers in this valley, for the first ten years of their California life. The value of the im provements which they had placed upon the lands could not have been less than eight hundred thousand dollars. From that date words will fail to depict the calamities of these most unfortunate families. Their lands and improvements have been taken from them without any compensation whatever. A Mexican grant to the whole of the valley has been confirmed. The land has peen patented to strangers by the United States, and pioneers, the early settlers, the men who bore the heat and burden of the day, have been stripped of their all, and many of them in the decline of life turned literally out of doors.

All right-thinking men naturally ask, " Is there any redress for this calamity ? Can any compensa tion be made these families for their great loss?" In plain words, ought the general government to stretch forth its powerful arms for the relief of this distressed community ? If it can be shown that they settled these lands under encouragement from the United States, all questions will be at an end. That many of them did so is a fact recorded in the archives of the government.

To establish the right of this community to relief from the general government, it will be necessary to give a brief history of the Arroyo Seco Grant, upon which a patent to their lands has been issued.

It appears from the records that in the year 1852, on the 1st of November, Andreas Pico filed a peti tion before the Land Commissoners for eleven leagues of land, known as the Arroyo Seco Grant, and lying in whole or in part, as the petition states, in Sacra mento county, but giving only certain external boundaries, which embraced a scope of country con taining at least six times the required amount of land; and at this time it must be borne in mind lone valley and the lands referred to in the memorial, lay not in Sacramento but in Oalaveras county, which barely cornered on Sacramento. The question is now, not whether Pico had any valid grant, but did his claim for eleven leagues of land, lying in whole or in part in Sacramento county, impart any notice whatever to the settlers of Calaveras county ? If they ever heard that such a petition had been filed before the Land Commissioners in San Francisco, they certainly never once thought it referred to their valley, for the boundaries claimed by Pico, as well as the county, seemed clearly to exclude them. Pico's eastern boundary came only to the foot-hills, which rise, sharply defined, to the west of lone. It is confidently asserted that this claim was never at that time heard of in the valley; if it ever was, the next news heard from it was that it had been rejected by the Land Commis sion on the twenty-seventh day of February, 1855. Six years had now passed in undisturbed possession, with no adverse claims to the lands on which they resided; for Pico stated in his petition to the Land Commissioners, that there were no adverse claimants to the lands which he desired, and as there was at least fifty leagues of land vacant and unoccupied within the external boundaries which his petition set forth, it neither imparted notice nor gave a hint of danger to these bona fide and actual settlers. Pico said: "Somewhere in that space of country bounded on the north by the Cosumnes river, on the east by the foot-hills, on the south by the Mokelumne river, and on the west by the old Sacramento and Stockton trail, I claim eleven leagues of land, and the land I desire is vacant, unoccupied land - there is no other to claim it." And his claim could have been satisfied four times over and never have touched them. Ought they, as the most scrupulously prudent men, to have thought the shaft was aimed at their peace? They did not think it was, and they continued to build, and improve, and enter into the fruit of their labors. They had the most unbounded confidence that the general government would now, as she always had, protect her hardy pioneers.

On the 12th of May, 1855, notice of appeal from the Land Commission was filed, followed on the llth of June by a petition for review; and on the 21st of April, 1856, the Court reversed the action of the Land Commission, and confirmed to Andreas Pico eleven leagues of land, somewhere within his said external boundaries. No survey had yet been made; the grant had been confirmed, but not located. And it must be steadily borne in mind that there was abundance of land to satisfy the grant, and leave the settlers alone. Would not the United States undoubtedly see that this was done? Before proceeding, however, to the history of the surveys, we will complete the legal history of this calamitous grant. On the third of October, 1856, an appeal to the "United States Supreme Court was perfected, and the transcript sent up, and, without ever com- ing to a hearing, was, May 4, 1858, on motion of Attorney-General Black, dismissed, and the mandate of dismissal filed in San Francisco on the 3d of Sep tember, of the same year. This, of course, ended the litigation. It must steadily be borne in mind that the United States, during all this time, was the party in interest, and, by her highest officers, man aged this important suit, involving, it is true, only the price of the land, some sixty thousand dollars; to her citizens - her children - the increased value of improvements and cultivation, amounting to nearly or quite a million. We have now reached the Autumn of 1858, ten years subsequent to the discovery of gold, and nine since the valley was first settled. Many of the farms were worth a hundred dollars an acre, and, in the character and value, of their improvements, would not suffer by comparison with the most highly cultivated sections of the older States.

The United States had surveyed and laid off into townships and sections nearly the whole of the valley, and have actually sold, as the records of the Land Office at Stockton show, four thousand nine hundred and ninety-six and forty-nine one hundredths acres; the balance had been all, or nearly all, pre empted. We now ask, in all candor and kindness, if the United States could have so located these eleven leagues of land belonging to Pico, so as not to disturb these settlers, and did not do it, ought she not to reimburse them for their losses? To determine this question, so vital to their hopes, let us proceed with the history of the surveys.

Sometime during the Summer of 1856, Andreas Pico himself came with surveyors into the district, and proceeded to select and mark out his eleven leagues. It would seem that if any person knew where the land was he, the grantee, was most likely to possess this information. "He located his eastern boundary ten miles further east than the line of the present survey, and included within his boundaries all the rich belt of mineral lands heretofore spoken of, and with the invaluable mines, assumed owner ship of the thriving villages of Amador, Sutter Creek, and Jackson, the county seat of the new county, which, in 1854, had been carved from Cala veras. He established his boundaries by permanent monuments, and proceeded to sell and deed lands, as the records of Amador county will show, to numer ous purchasers, across all this range. The wealth iest and most intelligent quartz miners in this State bought his title.

It will be remembered that this survey of 1856 left out a large number of those persons who are now included in the present survey, and these facts are stated to render the position impregnable that these settlers believed, and were justified by the facts surrounding them in this belief, that they were upon the public lands of the United States.

In the meantime to render this belief a certainty, the United States surveyed all the valley lands to the west of Pico's location, and sold them to these very men who now are memorializing Congress for relief.

But time rolled on; the survey had not yet been confirmed; the mines were growing poorer and the valley richer, and Pico in his great anguish, when he discovered that he had not included within his lines all the valuable property between the Cosumnes and Mokelumne rivers, and the old Stockton trail and the foot-hills, proceed at once to change the lines of the survey.

In August, 1859, that grant was surveyed by the United States Surveyor-General for the State of California, J. W. Mandeville, Esq. The eastern line of Pico's first survey was carried ten miles west, and of necessity, included many of the settlers who had purchased these lands of the United States. It must constantly be borne in mind that this was a floating grant] that there was at least six times as much land contained within its exterior lines as the grant called for; that all the lands outside of this valley were vacant lands, and that this survey was per sistently and openly made to include the most val uable farms, and was made by a United States Sur veyor-General, and confirmed by a United States District Judge.

This survey was confirmed September, 1862. An appeal was taken from the order of confirmation, and this appeal, on motion of Attorney-General Bates, was dismissed February 3, 1863. Not until this date were the settlers left without hope.

Soon after this confirmation, a patent was issued, and a company of United States dragoons ordered into the valley to assist the United Status Marshal in ejecting the settlers. Let us quickly draw a veil over this sad picture, and state at once the plan we propose for redress.

We appeal to Congress, and respectfully pray that a commission of disinterested and qualified men be selected and authorized, at the expense of the gen eral government, to visit the land in question; to inquire into and ascertain all the facts of the case; to take testimony in relation thereto, and to award to each settler such amount as may be deemed by said commission to bejust and right. And Congress is further requested to make such appropriation as will be necessary to carry out the objects of said commission.

Such proceedings on the part of Congress your memorialists believe to be consonant with reason and justice, and to be sanctioned by precedent.

Provenance

Text from History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.