Amador County, California - Sketches of Amador County Bar by J. G. Severance, San Francisco, 1881 (part 1 of 3)
From History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. 15,940 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
16 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
- Sketches of Amador County Bar by J. G. Severance, San Francisco
- Drops Of Judicial Wisdom
- A Disgusted Creditor
- Devout Deacons. '
- A Colored Advocate
- A Game Op Whist
- An Industrious Grand Jury
- From 1854 To 1880 Co. Assessor.7
- Supt. Scho
- Charles Bamert
- Edgae Bishop
- John A. Brown
- Anthony Caminetti
- James Gumming
- William O. Clark William 0. Clark
- Thompson Davis
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,940 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Sketches of Amador County Bar by J. G. Severance, San Francisco
AT a very early period in the history of California, subsequent to its acquisition by the United States, the Bar of "Old Calaveras" was justly assigned a position in the front rank of the legal profession. It was, with few exceptions, composed of men of push and genius; of acknowledged worth, integrity, ability, and wit; men possessed of learning and culture, acquired in the best of Eastern schools, and of large experience, gained by near association and contact with the ablest lawyers, jurists, and scholars of the commercial and manufacturing cities, and populous agricultural and mineral districts of the Atlantic States. That air of rusticity, and the lim ited professional experience which usually charac terize members of the profession in the interior of older settled sections, were wanting among these cosmopolitan argonauts. They were alike experi enced in, and qualified to skillfully deal with, intri cate questions of maritime, commercial, and internationallaw, as settled and adjudicated by author ity, and to cope with and adjust successfully such novel legal problems as the new industries, customs, and requirements of the newly acquired territory developed; they came prepared for city or country life, for metropolitan, bucolic or pioneer practice. They abandoned the homes of education and refine ment in the East, for the rude life of the Western El Dorado, in search of the Golden Fleece, and, if funds ran low because of the too angelic visits of clients, instead of listlessly awaiting the coming of a brief in their offices, they sought and found lucra tive employment on ranches, in work -shops, kitchens, mining claims, and other vocations, until a popular recognition of their talents gave abundant labor in their profession. Many a retainer of corpulent pro portions has been dropped into hands made hard and horny by familiarity with rough labor, or soft ened by culinary employment, and the grease of the dish-pan; and the intricate details of many cases of great financial importance have been imparted to counsel while engaged with pick and shovel at the sluices and the long-torn.
Ably and well has the Bar of "Old Calaveras" been represented in both the Senate and House of Representatives of the national Congress, and in both Houses of the State Legislature, by not a few of its members; many, to its honor and credit, have worn the judicial ermine. It has furnished gov ernors, and numerous faithful and competent officials for political positions, Federal, State, and municipal, and none have been found unworthy of the trust reposed in them. When, by the Act of the State Legislature of 1854, the little county of Amador was created out of a portion of Calaveras county, the former retained a fair and just proportion of the legal talent which had been embraced within the latter. A jealous, but friendly, rivalry was engen dered between the denizens of the two sections lying on either side of the deep gorge through which flowed the Mokelumne river, and which seemed to have been designed by Nature for a political boun dary line; and frequent contentions arose, in which the opposing clans acknowledged the leadership of the lawyers of their respective divisions. So equally matched were these generals in diplomacy and skill, that a segregation was acquiesced in, as the only method of adjustment, and Amador county was created, that each faction might have full scope for the exercise of its genius. A close intimacy and the kindliest feeling subsequently existed between the two Bars, which have at all times been so closely allied that great difficulty is experienced in record ing the history of the one, without including that of the other.
The more important of the early litigation in Amador county was concerning matters affecting the respective and relative rights of the miner, the riparian claimant and the agriculturist, up to about the year 1866, when the Supreme Court decided that the interest of a miner in his claim was realty, hence questions affecting such interest were not within the jurisdiction of inferior courts. All cases involving the possession of mining claims, their boundaries and priviliges were tried in Justices' Courts, irrespective of their values, subject to an appeal to the County Court. Consequently large fees were frequently paid to attorneys for conducting trials in these courts where the interests involved often amounted to thousands of dollars. The waters of the rivers and creeks were appropriated and conveyed in ditches and flumes to the mines by the construction of dams and tapping them at different points, and it fre quently became a delicate matter to properly and equitably adjust the rights of adverse claimants. It often occurred that beneath the most productive soil, forming the surface of a flat or bar, the bed-rock was richest in its deposits of gold. Hence many questions arose without well-established precedents, and legislative as well as judicial skill was frequently invoked to settle them in such manner as the better to subserve the public welfare and the individual interests of each. Senator Norman, of Calaveras county, introduced a bill, which was known as the Norman Bill, in the Legislature, which became a law in the year 1857, and which, in a great measure, served to reconcile disputes concerning the relative rights of the miner and agriculturist; and the final adjudication of many other litigious propositions arising in the courts of Amador, of a novel charac ter, have largely contributed to the settlement of vexed questions, and rendered certain what was before uncertain.
Following are the names of those who, as judges and lawyers, have taken an active part in the judi cial affairs of the county since its organization: Marion W. Gordan, W. VV. Cope, Robert M. Briggs, James F. Hubbard, S. J. K. Handy, James T. Farley, James W. Porter, A. C. Brown, Samuel B. Axtell, Thomas D. Grant, T. M. Pawling, H. A. Carter, John C. Gear, Charles Boynton, Judge Reynolds, J. G. Severance, George W. Seaton, John W. Armstrong, James H. Hardy, Alvinza Hayward, John Palmer, W. P. Buchanan, Alonzo Platt, W. T. Curtis, Claiborn Roarer, Henry L. Waldo, Nash C. Briggs, John AEagon, Wm. P. George, Fayette Mace, T. J. Phelps, A. C-iminetti, Silas Penry, George Moore, P. C. Johnson, L. N. Ketchum, J. Foot Turner, J. A. Robinson, Henry Cook, Moses Tebbs, George L. Gale.
Amador county was first included within the fifth judicial district, of which Hon. Charles M. Creanor, now of Stockton, was the Judge. This district was comprised of the populous and important mining and agricultural counties of Amador, Calaveras, Tuolumne, Stanislaus and San Joaquin, and, to dis pose of the enormous amount of litigation arising therein, required great energy, endurance, and dis patch. Court week at Jackson was an eventful season. Motions and demurrers for delay received but little consideration, and not to be ready wben your case was called was to have it very summarily disposed of. Jurors, witnesses, and litigants, from all parts of the county, were largely in attendance, and one case followed another from nine in the morning until far into the night, when, not infre quently, rest and recreation were only found at the poker table until morning. Hon. Tod Robinson, of Sacramento, was so constant an attendant on the courts of Amador, that a history of its Bar would be incomplete without mention of his name; and time and again have the Court House walls at Jack son rung with the eloquent voices of Honorables E. D. Baker, N. Greene Curtis, Frank Hereford, and others whose oratory has won for them a national fame, and still oftener have they resounded with the blows of the Sheriff's knuckles upon his unoffending desk, in his efforts to bring order out of the chaos provoked by some sally of wit on the part of Col. A. P. Dud ley, of Calaveras.
Judge Cre inor possessed the exceptional power and ability requisite to discharge the onerous duties that devolved upon him as the judicial head of so large a district as his, and infused into those who practiced in his courts something of his executive zeal. So quick of comprehension was he that but few explanatory words were necessary to convey to his clear, grasping and judicial mind all the salient points in the facts of the most complicated and cum bersome cause; so impartial and just in his decisions and conclusions that no charge of parsonal favoritism, bribery, fraud or dishonesty was ever hinted at; so prompt in the dispatch of business pertaining to the courts that no attendant thereon complained of unnecessary detention; so firm and rigid in court regime, that it is said of him he imposed a fine upon himself for being ten minutes late at court one morning; so courteous to the elder and considerate to the younger members of the profession, that he possessed the highest esteem and fullest confidence of all; it was but a natural sequence that his example had much to do in moulding the character and habits of those who practiced before him. No judge ever retired from the bench with a fairer record than Hon. Charles M. Creanor; and if any errors of judg ment are entered there, they are so obscured by the brilliancy of his sterling qualities that we pass them unnoticed.
As before stated, Amador was first in the fifth judicial district, with Hon. C. M. Creanor as Judge. In 1859, the district was divided, and Amador and Calaveras made to constitute the sixteenth judicial district, Hon. James II. Hardy being appointed the first Judge thereof. Hon. Wm. II. Badgley, of Cala veras county, succeeded Judge Hardy. Judge Badgley was a highly cultivated and polished gen tleman from the State of New York, and is now engaged in practice in that city. Judge Silas W. Brockway, a native of New York, an earnest laborer in his profession, an able lawyer, and pos sessed of great force of character, succeeded Judge Badgley in 1864, Amador being then in the eleventh district, composed of Amador, El Dorado, and Cala veras. Hon. A. C. Adams, now of San Francisco, succeeded Judge Brockway, and Hon. George II. Williams, of El Dorado, succeeded Judge Adams.
That this sketch may not justly be compared to the great play of Hamlet with Hamlet omitted, the brief biographies of such prominent members of the Amador Bar as could be obtained, are appended.
J. W. ARMSTRONG was a blacksmith in early days in California, but took a notion that he could make a lawyer of himself, and commenced the study some twenty-two years since. He has been, and is, one of the most indefatigable students the world ever saw, exhibiting a most wonderful capacity for hard work. He commenced the practice in Amador county, some twenty years since, but, after some years, removed to Sacramento, where he has eucceeeed in building up a lucrative practice and a reputation for being one of the best informed men of the State. His acquirements are substantial and useful. Having little taste for the poetical adornments which orna mented the orations of Baker and other famous speakers, he deals in hard, incontrovertible facts, piling them up mountain .high, leaving no possible escape for his adversary. He is still in the prime of life, and has promise of many years of usefulness.
HONORABLE SAMUEL B. AXTELL was one of those cold, reticent men whoso suaviter in modo won the respect rather than the friendship of men. Indeed, he did not care for the friendship of many, and those such as could be of use to him. He was possessed of a high sense of honor, polished in manner, and uncompromising in his zeal when in pursuit of some purpose, and he always had a purpose in view. As an advocate, and especially in jury trials, he had few equals in method, terseness of expression, and clear ness of style. Educated at Oberlin College, in his native State, Ohio, his earliest forensic efforts, were in behalf of abolitionism; he afterwards went South, and there became imbued with Southern ideas and proclivities; settled in Jackson as early as 1853, and was elected the first District Attorney in 1854, and was re-elected in 1856, making a most excellent offi cer, firm arid unflinching in the performance of his duties, but never over zealous to the extent of per secution. He subsequently removed to San Fran cisco, and was there elected to Congress, where he was converted to Republicanism, having theretofore been a Democrat. He has never since returned to California, but was appointed Governor of Utah, and subsequently Governor of New Mexico, where his policy of Mormon conciliation became so obnox ious to the Government that he was recalled. His merits, however, seemed not to have been ignored, for recently the position of Receiver of Public Moneys in Idaho was tendered him, but whether he accepted has not transpired.
ROBERT M. BRIGGS. There has been no more active lawyer or politician in Amador than R. M. Briggs. His petite form seemed made up of a bun dle of nerves, as unconscious of fatigue as the wires of an electric battery, which seemed to flash to his brain and concentrate there all the vast vitality which nature had so bound together, whenever occa sion demanded. He was always ready for a speech, at the Bar or on the stump, and never failed to hold together and enthuse his audience. Unexpected bursts of eloquence were sandwiched between per tinent anecdotes in such profusion that his speeches were always received with unbounded applause. As an illustration of his oratorical power, the closing of a speech he made before the Fiddletown Scott and
Graham Club, in 1852, is given. After expatiating upon the character of Scott, his services in the wars of 1812, and with Mexico, he electrified his hearers with these words: -
"When the end of all things shall have come; when the last great trump shall have sounded; when the angel of death shall be standing with one foot on the sea and the other on the land, swearing that time shall be no more; when the solid mount ains of granite are rocking to their very foundations; the stars falling from their places in the heavens, and revolving worlds are wheeling into annihilation, then shall the names of Scott and Graham appear written all over the sky in letters of living fire \ "
In 1861 a monster mass Union meeting was held in San Francisco, at which, it was announced, promi nent speakers from every county in the State would be present. Briggs, who happened to be in the city at the time, was on the programme, from Amador. The meeting, which was a great success, was addressed by Colonel Baker and other noted ora tors, and immense enthusiasm was manifested by the enormous concourse of people present. The press of San Francisco concurred in the statement that by far the best and most soul-stirring speech of the evening was that of R. M. Briggs, of Amador. As no extended reports of the speeches were given, the friends of Briggs interviewed him to ascertain what he said that so eclipsed the orators of the Pacific. He declared that he could not recollect a word. He said that upon being informed by the committee that he would be called upon, he endeav ored to arrange his ideas into some form suitable to the occasion, and, toward evening sought to ascer tain at about what time in the evening he would be called upon, that he might be enabled to cut his fuse the right length; that the committee seemed to have entirely forgotten him, and he concluded he had been that he went to a neighboring saloon and imbibed brandy and water, one glassful upon another, to drown his disappointment, until he became - well - pretty well elevated.
Late in the evening some one came in and said, ''Briggs, they are calling for you." He started up toward the place of meeting on the plaza, where the speakers' stand was a narrow balcony. He was conscious that in his condition he would not be able to stand there a moment, but would fall headlong into the crowd below. He, therefore, took a drygoods box which was near at hand, and placingiton the sidewalk mounted it, remarking that he was one of the people, and did not desire to get above them - preferred to be with them and of them - and then commenced his speech. His remembrance of the occasion was confined to the vociferous applause and enthusiasm, the like of which, he says, he never heard. Sober persons present declared that the crowd had listened to Baker and others until they were fully charged, and only required to be touched off to cause it to burst forth into a terrific explosion; Briggs' union pyrotechnics, in which appeared the "glorious old flag," the "American eagle," "liberty and equality," " union now and forever," like the colors of a revolving kaleidoscope, was the torch. Briggs obtained the sobriquet of " Brother Crawford " by his forensic illustrations of his adieus, as well as those of others made to the Democratic party, by repeating a sermon of a divine named Crawford, in which was related the circumstances of his departure from the field of his former labors, and in which the preacher narrated how he visited each object with which long association had made him familiar and to which he had become endeared, and each in turn seemed to say to him, "Farewell, Brother Crawford!" that as he rode down the lane upon his horse, the trees and grain in the adjacent fields seemed to solemnly nod to him and say, " Farewell, Brother Crawford; " that the very stones of the wall that marked the lane seemed possessed of melancholy voices, which cried out, " Farewell, Brother Craw ford! " that his horse took fright at a hog that rushed across the lane before him, reared and plunged, and throwing his rider in the ditch, speeded down the road with heels flying in the air, seeming to snort aloud, " Farewell, Brother Crawford! "
Briggs was by no means deficient in talent as a writer, and as the editor of the local papers, attained a well-earned reputation. He once wrote for his paper a lengthy article on Mexican affairs during the French invasion, which was re-published in pamphlet form, and widely distributed in the Eastern States, and, not improbably, had an influence upon the Administration in taking its decisive position against foreign occupation. He was a native of Illinois, developed his muscle in the lead mines, was a dry-goods clerk in Galena, afterwards moved to Grant county,- Wisconsin, where he studied law, and was elected to the Legislature in 1851, and came to California in 1852. He was elected Assem blyman, and twice District Attorney, in Amador; was appointed Register of the General Land Office at Independence, and is now Superior Judge of Mono county, residing at Bodie.
HON. A. C. BROWN, born at St. Charles, Missouri, January 10, 1816, crossed the plains from Lancaster, Grant county, Wisconsin, when he was admitted to practice in March, 1849, and settled in Jackson in September, 1851, where he has ever since resided, and where he is now engaged in the practice of his' profession, having been admitted to the District Court in 1851, and to the Supreme Court in 1879. For three several terms he served in the Territorial and State Legislature of Wisconsin, and three times represented Amador county in the Assembly; was County Judge from 1877 up to the time the new State Constitution went into effect in 1880. He has ever been an active politician, not a radical, but professed Democrat, and a staunch supporter of the Union cause during the Rebellion. The father of a large family, and possessed of considerable wealth, chiefly invested in improved town property, he has ever been regarded as one of the substantial citizens of Amador county. More than once the fire-fiend has swept away his possessions, but his energy planned more imposing structures before the ashes were cold.
NASH CORWITH BRIGGS was one of the few young men raised in California who preferred study to such pastimes as the freedom of our early society tolera ted. He was born in Hannibal, Missouri, February 1, 1838, removed to Grant county, Wisconsin, in 1849, and, in 1852, came to California with his father, Hon. R. M. Briggs, and resided in Jackson from 1854 to 1864, where he studied law, and, being admitted by the District Court, formed a law copartnership with his father, in 1860. In 1834 he removed to Alpine county, and upon its organization was elected District Attorney in that year, was re-elected in 1866, and again in 1868. In December of the latter year he removed to Hollister, and upon the organ ization of San Benito county, in 1874, was elected District Attorney, and re-elected in 1876. He mar ried Miss Annie Barton, who was a native of Jack son, and has an interesting family at Hollister, where he is now associated in the practice of the law with N. A. Hawkins; was admitted to the Supreme Court in October, 1869.
HON. R. BURNELL, though a lawyer by education, was better known as a politician. He was a native of New York, was a stock-raiser in early days, hav ing accumulated something like fifty thousand dol lars in raising cattle on the Sacramento plains. His career as a politician is related in the body of this history, and need not be repeated here. After the termination of his political career he removed to Napa, where he formed a law partnership with his brother-in-law, Chancellor Hartson, with whom he remained until his death, a year or two since.
A. CAMINETTI is a young man of Italian birth and California raising. He commenced the study of law under the tuition of Farley & Pawling, was admit ted to practice in 1877, and two years later was elected Prosecuting Attorney, a position he has filled with marked ability. He is brilliant, thorough, and persevering, an easy and graceful speaker, with a good degree of that elasticity of temperament which enables him to adapt himself to circumstances. He has a promising future before him. He is Demo cratic in politics, and had his name on the ticket for electors at the last Presidential contest. He did good service for his party in the campaign of 1880.
HON. II. A. CARTER is a native of New York, where he studied and practiced law previous to com ing to California, which was in 1849. He was the first District Attorney of Calaveras county, and has witnessed all tbe squabbles for the county seat since the time that Double Springs, with but one hou-<e, wasthe place of justice, and the jury-room the shade of a tree. His habit of advising litigants to settle with out a lawsuit has militated against his success as a lawyer, but has made him a most valuable citizen and neighbor. He has generally rested content with being the Pericles of his county, the man in whom all had unbounded confidence. He is a man of extensive and general information, communicative in his character, with a keen sense of the ludicrous, and tells a splendid story. He has spent the larger por tion of life in the cultivation of the soil, preferring the comforts of home and the companionship of his neighbors to the turmoils of politics or the law. He was seduced into running for the Assembly in 1875, traveled over the county, smoked and joked with his friends, told some of his best stories, and was triumphantly elected, fairly walking over the course. It will be perceived that his strength as a lawyer is in advising every one to keep out of lawsuits. According to lawyers themselves, Judge Carter, if he had turned the force of his character that way, would have excelled in the high courts as a judge in equity.
JUDGE COOK was a resident of Volcano for several years previous to the organization of Alpine county, and made quite a reputation as a safe and cautious counselor. He was well informed on general topics, dignified and courteous in his bearing, a gentleman of the old school. After the organization of Alpine he removed to that county, where he was quite prominent for several years. He has, in consequence of advancing age, mostly retired from the practice of the law.
HON. W. W. COPE. Amador has had but one representative upon the bench of the Supreme Court, and he, like all others of her citizens, when called upon to exercise official functions, was not found wanting either in ability or integrity. His professional experience in the semi-agricul tural and semi-mineral regions of the foot-hills, fitted him well to consider and intelligently decide the many new and difficult questions affecting these two great interests of our State, and both the farmer and the miner are much indebted to his wisdom and foresight in establishing legal rules adjusting their respective rights.
Judge Cope was born in Kentucky on the 29th of January, 1824, where he studied law, and was admitted to practice, coming to California in 1850. Like most early pioneers he believed that fickle for tune's blandest smiles were easier won in other vocations than a profession, and he did not engage exclusively in the practice of the law until the organ ization of Amador county in 1854, when he opened his law office at Jackson, where alone and in part nership with James F. Hubbard, and with R. M. Briggs, he took a leading position at the Bar. In
1858, he was elected to the Assembly, and was made chairman of the judiciary committee. An appre ciation of his services in that position was made manifest by his being elected Associate Justice of the Supreme Court the following year. After his election and previous to his entering upon the duties of his judicial position, Judge Terry, then Chief Justice, resigned, and Judge Cope was appointed to fill the vacancy. He remained upon the Supreme Bench until the 1st of January, 1864, having, as his associates during that time, Field, Baldwin, Norton, and Crocker. A short time after leaving the bench, he removed to San Francisco, where he is now asso ciated with J. Thomas Boyd, and is enjoying a lucra tive and high order of practice.
W. T. CURTIS came from Ohio in an early day, making his home at Drytown. He was a man of fine culture, gentlemanly in manner, and much more disposed to advise a peaceful settlement of a diffi culty than costly litigation. He usually made him self prominent in allaying, rather 4,han fomenting, the riotous spirit which so commonly existed in the mining towns in an early day. He was especially prominent in mitigating the not inexcusable anger of the population after the atrocious murders at Rancheria. He was a Republican in sentiment, and a candidate for District Attorney on the same ticket which was headed with the name of John C. Fremont, in 1856. He stumped the county for Fremont, speak ing in every place of any size. His candor and gentlemanly qualities were appreciated by friends and opponents alike, and he was always respectfully listened to. On the breaking out of the Rebellion, he joined the Union army as aid to an officer in high rank. From the best information attainable, he was killed early in the contest.
HON. JOHN A. EAGON is a native of Virginia, and came to this State in 1851, and from the first made his home in Amador county. He mined for a time at Lower Rancheria with considerable success, hav ing the good fortune to pick up a four-pound lump. He was engaged afterwards in mining near lone. It was during his residence there that he began to be known for his conversational powers, which indi cated his logical turn of mind, and led him to the adoption of the law as a profession. He has gradu ally worked up both professionally and politically, until he has become one of the leading men. As his name is connected with most of the prominent events in the county, related in another part of the history, it is unnecessary to repeat them here. He has a peculiarly earnest, nervous style of argument, replete with facts, but nearly destitute of humor, his speeches reminding one much of those of Silas Wright, in his best days. He is still young and vigorous, with no demoralizing habits, and is likely to go much higher before he pauses in his advancing career.
ginia. He was some time in the University of Vir ginia, but did not graduate, however. After spending some years in Missouri, he emigrated to California, arriving in 1850. lie commenced the study of the law in Volcano, his first cases being in Justice Stephenson's court in 1854. He early entered into politics, and became famous for his success in attaching the voters to his interests. He was elected to the Assem bly in 1854, re-elected in 1855, and made speaker. On the breaking up of the American party, he allied himself with the Democracy, where he has since remained. During the early years of the Rebellion, he was a Lecompton Democrat, and suffered defeat in company with other nominees of that party. After the union of the Republicans with the Doug las Democrats, his star began to rise, and he was twice elected to the State Senate by majorities far greater than the average of his ticket. His ability as a legislator is unquestioned; the same intuitive knowledge of human nature coming into use among the Solons of the capital as well as in a country town. Perhaps the best work, or at least the work involving the most comprehensive reasoning, was his report, as chairman of the Committee on Incorpora tions, on the bill regulating fares and freights. In 1878 he was elected to the United States Senate, and took his seat in 1879.
As a lawyer he is most efficient as a jury pleader. He has little of the overbearing character generally thought necessary in badgering a refractory or reti cent witness; never arouses the antagonism of jury or witness by an abuse of his position; yet few wit nesses can boast of carrying away any honors in a contest with him.
As a politician, he is strong in the ability to organ ize, uniting his friends and dividing his enemies. His private character is above reproach. He is genial in manner, sympathetic in feeling, making friends where possible. He is still on the sunny side of fifty, hale and hearty, having fortunately escaped the social perils which beset the paths of Califbrniun politicians. Having apparently many years of hard work in him, it is quite possible that he may attain one of the two higher positions possible in his polit ical career.
GEORGE L. GALE, though he did not often appear in court, generally having other business to attend to, was was one of them - i. e. the lawyers - in spirit and education. He was a native of Massachusetts, born, as he was wont to state, at the foot of Bunker Hill, and belonged to the true chivalry of the country, the "Bunker Hill chivalry," by which means he came to be known as Bunker Hill Gale. He was extremely original in his methods of reasoning, sharp rapid and incisive in his language, prompt in decision, and quick in action. To contend with him on any subject was to meet a rattling fire of musketry, brilliant thrust of rapiers, and pyrotechnical flashes that dazzled and confused the ordinary mind. He made a splendid Justice of the Peace, and his decisions were hardly ever reversed in the higher courts, though he was too brilliant to become pro found in the law, loving rather to deal with its puzzling technicalities. He would have filled the seat of paragraphist in a modern editorial room to perfection, his keen sense of the ludicrous and trenchant wit qualifying him for the position of critic. His sayings and doings would fill a good-sized book. He was once appointed sealer of weights and measures, and collected double fees by sealing them for the year past and then for the coming year on the same day. Upon being remonstrated with for exacting fees for two years, he told them, " either pay it or render yourselves liable to a fine for selling goods with unsealed weights and measures." The subjects, knowing Gales' strength in law technical ities, usually paid, though with much grumbling. He had no family, and died in obscurity a few years ago at Pine Grove.
JOHN C. GEAR was a young man who alternated the practice of law with mining and teaching school, in the vicinity of lone. He was brilliant and enthus iastic, with many qualities that go to make up an orator. lie died at lone before he had the opportu nity to make his mark in his profession.
HON. MARION W. GORDON is a native of Tennessee, of Irish descent. In early life he was a professor of elocution, and traveled extensively, lecturing on, and teaching the art. He was at different times con nected with some of the leading papers in Missouri, and was associated with many of the prominent pol iticians, in shaping the policy of that State after the overthrow of the Benton reyime. He came to Cali fornia in 1850, and soon after located in Volcano, forming one of the coterie of philosophers heretofore referred to, who discussed questions of the lofty character which have employed such minds as Hegel, Descartes, Comte, Mills, and Spencer. In Judge Gordon's case, however, he mingled hard work with hard thinking, arid in 1852-53 could be seen swinging the pick and shovel in the Volcano tail-race, which he, with others, cut through the deep flat. In 1853, in compliance with the wishes of many friends, he came before the county Conven tion for the nomination for member of the Assembly for Calaveras county, which he received. After a well-contested canvass he came out victorious, and took his seat in the Legislature one of the last of the old Calaveras delegation.* On the organization of Amador county he was elected to the position of County Judge, which he held for three consecutive terms.
Judge Gordon is a man of varied accomplish ments and general information. Scarcely any topic can be introduced which has not been read up by him. Mesmerism, animal magnetism, clairvoyance, and all the modern occult sciences have been, at times, assayed in his mental laboratory. His midnight lamp was often burning when all else was buried in deep slumber. As a politician he had few superiors. The habit of judging men and organizing them into solid parties was to him a matter of instinct, accomplished without serious effort. His ability to adapt his speech to the capacity of his hearers was remarka ble. A scowling face was discerned, and the latent opposition neutralized by a happy allusion. Whether before a crowd of rough miners, a body of school teachers, a convention of musicians, or an assembly of wary politicians, this faculty never failed him. As a lawyer, he dealt rather in the general princi ples than in the technicalities. His love for general ization, and a consequent knowledge of the laws of equity, enabled him to easily perform the duties of Judge. In Congress his general information and knowledge of the human heart would have enabled him to have taken high rank. That he never went to Congress is a matter of regret. That so many, vastly his inferiors, have found their way there, is, and will be, a mystery. Though his mental powers are still vigorous, he has retired from active practice, and is spending his old age in dignified leisure.
THOMAS D. GRANT was born, and educated for the law, in the State of New York. His early associa tions were with such legal luminaries as Judge Spencer and lawyers of his ilk, from whom he imbibed a true respect for, and due appreciation of, the honor and dignity of his profession, which he regarded above all others. This, coupled with his proverbial honesty and integrity, inspired a public confidence that secured to him a very desirable clientage. When the writer of this was first nomi nated for District Attorney, he was associated with Judge Grant in practice. The Judge was bitterly opposed to politics, and declared if the candidate persisted in running for office, he would dissolve their copartnership, and defeat him if possible. The young aspirant did persist, and a dissolution fol lowed. When the votes were counted it was found that out of seventy-eight votes polled at a precinct down in the deep gorge of the Mokelumne river, six or eight miles from Jackson, where the Judge resided, the writer received more than seventy, although he was an entire stranger in the locality. Believing that this large vote was not wholly due to the fact that he was unknown, bo instituted inquiries, and ascertained that the Judge, - being too heavy (some four hundred avoirdupois) to ride on horseback, and the roads being altogether too steep for a carriage, - had secretly walked down and back to the Bar, where he had formerly mined, and was loved and respected by all, and stuffed - not the ballot-box - but the voters, with the theory that the candidate was worthy of their suffrages. This is given as illustrative of the character of the man. Although he was rude and rough at times, in his words and deportment, his heart was in size proportionate to his Falstaffian physique - over-flow- ing with true sympathy and noble impulses - its beatings the power that moved his hands to the performance of generous deeds. When he died, in Jackson, 1859, the community lost one of God's noblest works - an honest man.
HON. JAMES H. HARDY had the brain of some fabled Lycurgus, and possessed the fecundity of a Jupiter's; the bare assertion that "Jim" Hardy sprang therefrom fully armed for the legal arena would require strong refutation. No one could tell when he applied himself to his books, and yet he was an animated encyclopaedia of legal decisions, from the earliest to the latest. When he was upon the bench, attorneys become careless and would simply state that the Supreme Court had so decided, and wait for the Judge to tell them the title of the case, and in what volume it could be found. He possessed, in a marked degree, the two qualities, one at least of which is essential to success in the legal practice, but seldom found combined in one - eloquence and a clear knowledge and comprehension of the law. In the absence of a native talent for these, he could scarcely have reached the prominence at the Bar he attained, since he preferred the social companionship of his host of friends to the studious application most men find essential to a legal reputation. Judge Hardy was born in Hamilton county, Illinois, on the third day of April, 1832; first studied law with his father, and afterwards with Hon. S. S.Marshall; was admitted to practice in Illinois, where, notwithstand ing his extreme youth, he acquired quite an extensive reputation as a lawyer, and came to California in 1852, locating at Sacramento; subsequently, he removed to Jackson, and, upon the creation of the Sixteenth Judicial District with the counties of Amador and Calaveras in 1859, was appointed Judge of the new district, to which position he was elected by a flattering majority, at the next following election. As a Democrat he always took prominent part in poli tics; was District Attorney of Sacramento county, and ran as a Breckinridge elector in 1856. In his numer ous "stumping" excursions through the State, he always denied that he was out electioneering, but asserted that he was hunting for an ox which he lost while crossing the plains in '50. It is related of him that his first appearance in court at Sacra mento was upon the recommendation of a friend who had known him in Illinois. "Jim" was found hard at work in a bakery, and at first declined to take the case, alleging his lack of recent practice, etc., but after much urging went into court without changing his garments, white with "miller's dust." The opposing counsel, who was somewhat overbearing and pompous in his manner, inquired who repre sented the other side. Young Hardy was pointed out to him, when he sneeringly asked, " And who is Mr. Hard}T? I have not the pleasure of his acquain tance." Hardy immediately caught up a large volume lying upon the table, and hurling it at the interrogator, with great force exclaimed, " not require any further introduction the next time we meet!" Hardy was fined fifty dollars for contempt, but proceeded with his case, convincing his oppo nent, as well as others who listened, that "Jim" Hardy was not to be despised even in his baker's uniform.
SAMUEL J. K. HANDY was a native of Maryland, of the Virginia school of gentlemen, polished and accomplished, blending dignity and kindness together. He was prominent before the State Convention, in 1856, as a candidate for Congress; failing in which, he left the county. His present residence, if living, is unknown. As he was somewhat advanced in years at the time of his residence here, it is likely that he has accomplished his work.
ALVINZA HAY WARD probably had at one time some aspirations for a professional career, but rich quartz mines absorbed his attention, so that ho had little time for thoughts of the law except as it concerned his own extensive business. He will be remembered as the man who developed the richest gold mine on the coast, and in that connection his history is related in another portion of this book.
JAMES F. HUBBARD was formerly a surveyor, but concluding that he could see to better advantage through the intricacies of the law than through the theodolite, he threw aside the chain and compass, and commenced Blackstone and Kent. His hopes and anticipations were fully realized, and, in due course of time, he took his seat at the Bar, and built up a most valuable practice. He was in company with several of the prominent lawyers at Jackson at different times. Though not considered a bril liant pleader, his opinion was highly valued. About the years 1862 or '63, he removed to San Francisco, where he practiced with fair success for a few years, finally returning to New York, his native State.
HON. P. C. JOHNSON.* Though Mr. Johnson occu pied the attention of the county for some years, very little is known of his antecedents. He came into the county from El Dorado in 1855, in company with T. A. Springer, who established the Yolcano Ledger that year. Though admitted to the Bar he scarcely ever appeared in court, giving most of his attention to literary matters. He was a brilliant writer, and was connected with the Ledjer for many years as assistant or chief editor. He was elected to the Legislature in 1859, and died at the house of T. A. Springer in Jackson, in 1862. Though possessed of Miany excellent and brilliant qualities, they were impaired by a social weakness, which eventually terminated his life.
L. N. KETCHUM was brought into public notice in 1857, when he was elected to the State Senate, being then a resident of Clinton, where he had been mining. He made his mark as a legislator, and then
*His name does not appear in the continuous history as .mem ber of Lejislature for that year. The accounts were made up from the Supervisor's records, which were very imperfect - EC.
studied law. Possessed of great colloquial powers and an excellent education, it is not surprising that be met with success in his new vocation. He prac ticed, however, but little in Amador county, but removed to Siskiyou county, where he enjoyed a fine practice and was elected District Attorney. He died at Yreka several years ago.
FAYETTE MACE was admitted to the practice of law many years since, but owing to his extensive operations in saw-mills, quartz-mills and farming, he has given the law little attention since, except as it was incidental in his business operations.
HON. GEORGE MOORE, the present Superior Judge of Amador county, was born in Davisville, Boyle county, Kentucky, February 14, 1850; graduated at Centre College in the class of 1870, and after pur suing the study of law for two years under the tuition of Hon. M. J. Durham, of Kentucky, attended the law school of Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachu setts, and was admitted to the Bar in 1874. In the political campaign of 1876 he was appointed one of the Tilden and Hendricks electors, and came to Cal ifornia in the Fall of 1877, settling in Amador county. He entered upon the discharge of his duties as the first Superior Judge of Amador county, under the New Constitution, on the first Monday of January, 1880. He married Mrs. Y. B. Lackey, also a native of Kentucky, in 1879, and now resides in Jackson.
JONATHAN PALMER was admitted to practice on the organization of the county. His residence was in Oleta (then Fiddletown), and he divided his time about evenly between mining and the study of the law. He acted as Justice of the Peace as early as 1852. He was a man of solid rather than showy acquirements, and in the matter of oratory was eclipsed by R. M. Briggs, who was a resident there at the same time. He was one of the discoverers of the famous American hill, and to the fact of having a rich claim is probably due the little interest he took in legal matters. He has drifted out of sight in recent years.
HON. THOMAS M. PAWLING, a native of Philadel phia, whose lawyers have been traditionally the " hardest to puzzle " of any of their class, located at Volcano in 1855, where he was law partner of Hon. James T. Farley; was elected County Clerk in 1858, and upon the expiration of his official term resumed practice at Jackson, with J. G. Severance as his part ner. Upon the discovery of the mines in Esmeralda county, he removed to Aurora, where he acquired considerable wealth, but returned to Jackson in 1865, and again formed a copartnership with Mr. Farley, and continued his practice until 1871, when he was appointed by Governor Haight to fill the position of County Judge, made vacant by the death of Hon. J. Foot Turner, to which office he was subsequently twice elected by the people. Judge Pawling made no great pretentions to oratory, but excelled as an " office lawyer," and had few superiors in the prepara-
T. J. PHELPS.IS a native of Kentucky; came to Cal ifornia in 1849, and to Amador county, as since organ ized, in 1852; residing in Oleta until elected District Attorney in 1873, a position he filled with distinction for four years. Mr. Phelps has been identified with the material interests of the county since his resi dence here. He was one of the first to recognize the practicability of conveying water to the mines - the ditch from the north fork of Dry creek in which he was part owner being not only among the first, but among the most profitable of any that were ever con structed in the county. As a lawyer, Mr. Phelps is a counselor rather than an advocate, and much more disposed to heal dissentions than promote them. He has ever been distinguished as an upright and honor able man, modest and unassuming, but equal to any emergency that has ever called him to action.
SILAS PENRY is a native of Texas; coming to Cal ifornia at a very early age, he has made himself what he is in this State. He is still quite young, both in years and in his profession, but has the prom ise of being brilliant and useful. His life has been somewhat shadowed by the unfortunate affair re sulting in the death of Elisha Turner, an intimate friend of his. On his trial the courts and public sen timent exonerated him of all malice, and it is quite certain that no other blame can attach to him than that of thoughtlessly using his weapon in a case of mutually angry words. It is believed that he will outgrow his self reproach, and attain the position to which his talents entitle him.
ALONZO PLATT was from the State of New York: was one of the original movers in the matter of the organization of Amador county, and one of the com missioners appointed by the Governor to establish the new county government and call an election for county officers. lie was consi lerable of a politician of the old school, and came up for office several times; but as he did not have the plasticity of character necessary to succeed, he was distanced in the race by Messrs. Parley, Gordon, Cope, Brigg.sand Axtell, and withdrew from public notice.
J. W. PORTER is a native of Pennsylvania; came to California in an early day and engaged in mining, perhaps rather to obtain the means of gratifying his love of reading than with the expectation of making a fortune. Jt was observed of him, however, that much of his mining was experimental, rather to prove or disprove some theory regarding the deposits of gold, than as a means of acquiring immediate wealth. The hole which he sunk in the head of Soldier's gulch, one hundred and fifty feet deep, under the impression that gold would be found all the way to the bed-rock, was a case in point. The gold was found to that depth, proving his theory, but it was not in sufficient quantity to make his dis covery valuable. His reading was largely ancient history, which caused the remark to be made, perhaps with some degree of truth, that he was more of a Roman than an American citizen; at any rate, he has many Roman virtues, such as sobriety, stern integrity, fortitude, and none of those weaknesses which endear some of our public men to the average voter, for no man could say that he had tried him drunk and tried him sober, for he was always sober. His aversion to the ordinary method of conducting a political campaign has prevented him from seeking office, for but once was he ever tempted to have his name placed on a ticket, when he ran for County Judge against M. W. Gordon, coming within a few votes of being elected. He refused to electioneer; some of his friends remarking that Porter would not solicit a vote if that one would elect him. His peculiar character of mind eminently fitted him for a judge, but did not fit him for getting the position which depended so much on personal popularity, though his utter contempt for human weakness might have made him a severe judge in criminal cases. Once while pleading before a Justice's Court, in the early fifties, in Volcano, he was interrupted by a half drunken Irishman with threats of personal violence unless he ceased his offensive remarks. Porter bore the interruptions for a while, but as the court did not seem inclined to protect him he caught up a black-snake whip, which was near by, and lashed the Hibernian until he cried for mercy, after which he proceeded in his speech without apparently noticing the interruption. As might be expected, Mr. Porter remains a single man.
Instance, or as it was called, Alcalde, in some of the earlier settlements in 1830, and, in consequence, claimed a membership with the Bar, and was admitted to practice upon the organization of Ama dor county. His legal acquirements were rather limited, but in the chaotic condition of society twenty-five years since, he obtained some practice in the inferior courts, lie was not remarkable for any thing but pretension, and soon dropped out of sight.
J. A. ROBINSON is a native of Ohio, was born in 1838, removed to Illinois in 1858, enlisted April 23, 1861, in the Eighth Regiment of Infantry, Illinois Volunteers, and served under General Oglesby until discharged for disability incurred in the service. He came to California in 1863 and settled in Jackson; was at different times County Clerk, and Assistant United States Assessor, for Amador county. He completed his law studies, and was admitted to practice in 1866; removed to San Francisco in 1871, where, for several years, he was chief clerk in the United States Surveyor-General's office, under Hardenburg and his successors. He is now practicing law in San Francisco, making land cases a specialty, his long training in that business giving him great familiarity with the origin and perfection of land titles. He resides in Oakland, and has several times been before the public in connection with municipal offices. His training and natural temperament peculiarly fit him for investigations of complex land titles, and he is enjoying a remunerative and exten sive practice.
HON. GEO. W. SEATON was a lawyer, politician, and quart/, miner of considerable note in the early days of Amador. He, like many members of the old Whig party, joined the Know-Nothing, or American party, and afterwards both Democratic and Republican par ties by turns. He was elected to the State Senate in 1865 by the .Democratic party, but perished in the explosion of the steamer Yosemite, on the Sacra mento, before taking his seat. He was a man of strong will and great energy, and when a move was decided upon it never failed for want of persist ent action. His style of speech was, like the man, more forcible than elegant. He made no pretensions to learning or elegance, but appealed to the com mon sense of his auditors. He was better adapted to the forum than the Bar.
JOSIAH GOULD SEVERANCE is a native of Maine, born September 30, 1832. He prepared for college at Hampden Academy, and entered at Bowdoin in 1852, but, at the solicitations of friends, withdrew without graduating, and entered upon the study of the law in the office of Hon. Hannibal Hamlin, at Hampden, where he remained for about a year, when he entered the law office of Hon. John E. God frey, for years and now Probate Judge of Penobscot county, at Bangor; was admitted to the Supreme Judicial Court of that State in 1855, and arrived in San Francisco on the first day of January, 1856, and first located in the then flourishing mining town of Lancha Plana, Amador county. He was elected a member of the Board of Supervisors in the Fall of 1856, and in 1858, District Attorney by the Douglas Democracy, having as his opponents Hon. S. B. Axtell, Breckinridge candidate, and John C. Gear, the straight Republican nominee; was active in the organization of the Union party in the county, in 1862, and was made chairman of its first County Central Committee ; ran for the Assembly, much against his will, that year, and, with the whole ticket, was defeated, coming, however, within twentynine votes of an election. In the Fall of 1862, he married Miss M. J. Tiel, of Jackson, and removed to Calaveras county, where he was elected District Attorney the following year, and re-elected in 1865. For some time he edited the Amador Ledger, and was the proprietor and editor of the San Andreas Register. He is now engaged in his professional practice in San Francisco, where he has taken but little part in politics, although he there served for a time as assistant District Attorney, under D. J. Murphy, Esq., and ran on and was defeated with, the straight Republican ticket, as Delegate at Large to the late Constitutional Convention.
MOSES TEBBS was a young man of rather promis ing abilities who came to Volcano in 1855. Remain ing but a few years he went to Alpine upon the organization of that county, where he was heard from occasionally in connection with political mat ters. His present residence is unknown.
HENRY L. WALDO was a native of Missouri, and made his way to California by way of Oregon. He early chose the law as his profession, and alternated study with hard work whenever he had the oppor tunity, sometimes studying with his friends, sharing their hospitalities, and at other times becoming a habitant of a law office. His progress in his profes sion was rapid. In 1869 he was elected District Attorney, which position he held to the close of the term, performing the duties to the satisfaction of all concerned. He declined a re-election, justly con cluding that he could find a more honorable and lucrative position elsewhere. Ho now holds a high judicial position in the Territory of New Mexico. As an officer he was courteous, firm and upright, swerved from the right course neither by blandish ments nor fear. During the excitement attending the lawless action of the Miner's League at Sutler Creek, he was informed that he would prosecute the rioters at the risk of his life. He turned to the belligerent leaguer and invited him to commence operations then and there, for he should perform his duty.
[The biographies of the members of the Bar are somewhat limited, owing to the difficulty of obtain ing reliable data. Some are too moJest to narrate the prominent events in their lives; some, perhaps, are apprehensive of a too critical review of their careers, some are negligent, and others have gone to that region from which no correspondence is permitted. If some things important are omitted and others exalted to undue importance, we can only say that after awaiting letters and information some time, the demand for copy compelled us to close the sketches with what we had on hand.]
Drops Of Judicial Wisdom
whilom Justice of the Peace at Rancberia: During the progress of a trial by jury in his court, the expression, non compos mentis, was used. One of the jurors, with a laudable desire to fully understand the case, asked the Court the meaning of the term used. " It is," said his honor, with becoming dig nity, "the process by which the attendance of wit nesses from another county is obtained." As wit nesses were present from El Dorado county, the answer was satisfactory.
"Uncle Jake" Emminger was also Justice at Ranch eria, and was very proud of his patriarchal beard, which he allowed to fall below his waist on Sundays and Court days, but carefully folded up on ordinary occasions. lie was also proud of his politi cal achievements in his township, where, by some coup de main, he obtained thirty-four votes out of a possible sixty-seven in the whole township, and was, therefore, elected. It is said that he once sentenced a Chinaman to jail for life for stealing chickens, but afterwards excused the error, as being of the heart and not of the head, by claiming that had a shorter term been imposed his constituency would have hanged the culprit. In a case before "Uncle Jake" the defendant presented and read an affidavit for change of venue. The Court listened patiently, stroked his long beard gravely and thoughtfully for a few minutes, then said: "The affidavit of the defendant is overruled, and judgment rendered for the defendant, "if I must have my case tried by tliis Court, I demand a jury!" "What in h - , sir, do you expect to prove by a jury?" demanded the Judge in his most severe manner.
"Judge" Hugh Robinson, an Irish gentleman of the old school, was for many years Justice of the Peace at Clinton, and mine host of the chief cara vansary of the village. It was not a temperance tavern, and so great was the liberal hospitality of the " Judge," that even the Governor of North Carolinia would have ceased his chronic complaint of "a long time between drinks," had he been his guest. S. B. Axtell and James F. Ilubbard were once pitted against each other in a case before him. The testi mony all in, the brief and terse argument of Mr. Axtell was listened to by the Court with marked attention, but the " linked sweetness" of Judge Hubbard's reply proved too much for the "Judge's" active tempera ment, and under the combined influence of somno lent logic and cordial hospitality, he fell asleep. Judge Ilubbard had him aroused, and, in a some what indignant manner, remarked that if his ca^e was not properly considered he would appeal it to a higher court. "Appeal to h - , and be damned to ye!" cried the "Judge;" "judgment for the plaint iff, and this court is adjourned ! "
A marriage ceremony was once performed by one of the local Justices, so brilliant in its character that the name of the distinguished official, and the time and place, ai*e omitted, that the honors may be equally divided. The candidates for matrimonial uncertainties presenting themselves before the magis trate, he ordered the bridegroom elect to hold up his right hand, and, in his most impressive manner, said: "You do most solemnly swear that you are twenty-one j-ears of age; that you will support the Constitution of the United States, and of the State of California; that you will be a true, faithful, and obe dient husband, and that you have not voted before this day, so help you God." AVhat was said to the woman was not related.
The case of Owens vs. Shackles, et al., was brought in Justice Palmer's court, at Lancha Plana, in Jan uary, 1856, to determine the right of po>session to a mining claim. Henry Eno, who had been County Judge of Calaveras county, and was afterwards County Judge of Alpine county, was attorney for the plaintiff. The trial was had by jury, who ren dered their verdict that the claim did not belong to either party. Without waiting for any action by the Court upon the verdict, there was a gen eral rush of attorneys, clients, and witnesses for the disputed ground. It is said that Judge Eno, whose gra}' hairs were streaming in the wind, raised by his Iroquois pace, would have won the race and (bound ary) stakes, had not Shackles caught him by the coat-tail, and flung him aside, thus winning the race and suit, with Owens a very good second.
Apropos of Judge Eno, a story is told which may not be out of place here, since his practice was quite as extensive in Amador as in Calaveras. While he was County Judge of Calaveras, a young man was tried and convicted before him, of a felony. Judge Brockway defended the prisoner in his usual able manner, and upon the arraignment of his client for sentence made a most feeling appeal to the Court for leniency, moving his auditors to tears, and apparently producing a deep impression upon the Court. After waiting a short time for the excitement to subside, Judge Eno said: " Prisoner, stand up! You have been indicted by the Grand Jury of this county for the crime of burglary, to which indict ment you pleaded ' not guilty.' You have been fairly tried by a jury of your own selection, who find you guilty of the charge contained in the indictment, having been ably and well defended during that trial by eminent counsel. Your counsel has made a most touching and eloquent appeal to the Court for its sympathy and indulgence, calling attention to the apparent fqct that you are but a boy in years; aver ring that this is your first criminal offense; that you are the only son of one of our most respected and worthy citizens, and the idol of an almost broken hearted mother; that the result of a long incarcera tion would be ruin to your future, which might be fair and even brilliant. The Court is deeply impressed with these facts, and its sentence, there fore, is, that you be taken by the Sheriff of this county to the State prison at San Quentin, and there be confined to hard labor for a term of fourteen years; and I only wish I could make it longer."
The prisoner was, however, pardoned a short time after, and, to the credit of Judge Eno, be it said, he signed the petition for the pardon and exerted him self in that behalf.
A Disgusted Creditor
While Judge Gordon was County Judge SLndexofficio Judge of the Probate Court, and Jerry King was Public Administrator, two Swedes were drowned in the Mokelumne river, leaving, as was supposed, some property. King was duly appointed administrator of their estates. A few weeks after, an original specimen of humanity, with unkempt hair of an indescribable hue, crane neck and leathery features, his general appearance suggesting the idea of a dried-apple on the end of a ramrod, presented him self before Judge Gordon, and making an awkward bow of unusual vigor, and slinging his well-worn sombrero beneath his arm with the air and punctilio of a soldier presenting arms, his mental thermom eter evidently at fighting point, said,
Judge Gordon ever ready to gratify his disposition for a quiet joke, and discovering rich croppings therefor, concluded to prospect, and answered,
Pat - "An' d'ye say that, now? Then it's Pat Rooney's son '11 give hisself no more trouble aboot it, at all, at all. Bedad, an' if it goes through the coort, it's meself that '11 niver see a cint. Ach, hone, I thought afther only one man's stalings, faith, tbere'd be some left - but if it's got to go through the coort, Holy Virgin, it's me own father's son that '11 niver get a cint. Good day ter yees, gintlemen; it's no more I'll bother me head aboot it, at all, at all! "
Devout Deacons. '
About the year 1860, an Episcopal clergj-man made an effort to establish a society of his form of worship at Jackson, and secured the court-room for the meeting. Of course it was popular, and it became the intellectual members of the community to identify themselves with the movement; hence, many members of the Bar who had been conspic uous by their absence from any church for years, were in attendance. It was necessary that deacons
H - - were among the elect. During service they were unable to find the places in the book for re sponses, and B - asked of II in an audible whisper,
A Colored Advocate
J. W. D. Palmer, a most genial and intelligent gentleman, from Kentucky, and formerly connected with the press at Louisville, has been Justice of the Peace at Lancha Plana for years. In his court an action to recover the possession of a mining claim, situated in the basin of a hill, was brought by Hon. George Wagner, who had represented Amador in the Assembly, against a colored man named Smith, who had dug a "tail-race" through the rim rock of the hill into the basin, through which to run off the debris in sluices. Mr. Wagner was represented by Mr. Severance, and Smith appeared in propria persona. The testimony all in, Smith proceeded to sum up as follows: "Yer 'oner, I will please to state to dis Court dat 1 jist spent my bottom dollar on dat ar tail-race; an de statoots uv dis State says dat 3"ou can't steal away my prop'ty. My oppoleon has gone and payed a silver-tongued lawyer to come here and cheat me out ob dat tail-race, but I'll please to state to dis Court dat it can't be did. No sar! Now dars George Wagner, kase he's 'lected to de Legislator when people was scace down dis way, he thinks he can run ober de poor African!" In spite of his eloquence he lost his case.
A Game Op Whist
One evening during court week, Tod Robinson and Judge Carter engaged in a game of whist, in the "Young America," upon opposite sides. After playing for some time, Judge Carter dextrously exchanged cards with Judge Robinson, and got a very good hand by that means. The act was wit nessed by the spectators, but passed unnoticed by Judge Robinson. Trick after trick was taken by Carter, to the audible amusement of the lookers-on, when Robinson, irritated by the laughter exclaimed, in that clear, cut silver speech, for which he was noted, " Gentlemen, am 7 the butt of your merri ment?" He soon discovered that Carter had played a trick on him, and, rising to his full height and assuming his most dignified and tragic style, said, "Judge Carter! [pause] Squire Carter! [pause - in a louder tone] Mister Carter! [contemptuously] Carter! [then in a tone of withering irony] Old Carter! You have played seven-up with Bill Hicks and Jim Martin on a rawhide until you are wholly unfit to play with a gentleman, and I'll leave you, sir!"
An Industrious Grand Jury
A careful reader of our history will not need tell ing a second time, that gambling was alarmingly prevalent in early days. The Legislature passed laws making gambling a penal offense; but in the chaotic state of society, about the beginning of the sixties, the laws against it were considered more as moral maxims than as imperious rules, and gambling went on much as ever. It happened that a Grand Jury, more than usually conscientious was convened, and when they were sworn to bring to notice all known violations of the statutes, gambling was of course included. A few cases were brought in, and the persons indicted. This led to more, and the whole week was spent in obtaining evidence of the act, until the numbers amounted to over three hundred. The District Attorney urged the uselessness of the course, as no trial jury would convict a man of a State's prison offense merely for betting a quarter on monte or faro, but the Grand Jury thought otherwise. Blank indictments were printed so that the jurors themselves could fill up the blanks, and the work went on. One case was brought to trial, and a day spent in the vain effort to obtain a conviction. The District Attorney here told the jury that he was unable to obtain a conviction, and asked legal assistance. Fifty dollars was raised among the grand jurors, and the services of Tod Robinson obtained. lie exerted himself to the utmost, still the verdict was "not guilty." Sat urday noon had arrived, and the Grand Jury were still at work, increasing the list until it seemed as if half the county would be put on trial. The Dis trict Attorney communicated his dilemma to Judge Gordon. He said nothing, but gave that peculiar some little business had been disposed of the Judge asked the usual question, "Mr. District Attorney, have you any farther business before this Court?" Upon being answered in the negative, he ordered the Court adjourned sine die. The Grand Jury met the following Monday morning to continue the busi ness, but were informed that the adjournment of the Court had ended their life as a Grand Jury. Some were able to look at it as a good joke; others went home resolving that if they should again get on the Grand Jury, they would begin with the Judge first.
From 1854 To 1880 Co. Assessor.7
[') Vice T. W. Pawling, deceased; appointed in February. |2) Vice Henry Peck, deceased. (3) The offices of County Clerk and Recorder combined, except in the years 1862-63-61-65-66-67. *) Appointed August, 1855, vice W. A. Phoenix, who was killed in the difficulty at Chinese Camp. [5) Appointed November 25th, vice B. B. Redhead, deceased. ;6) In the election held September 6, 1865, L. Rabolt was elected Treasurer, but it being proved that he was not a citizen, Otto Walter, competitor, was appointed to fill the vacancy. C1) Township Assessors during the years 1862-63-64-65-66-67-68. [*) Superior Judge.
Supt. Scho
Is a native of the city of New York; born on the llth of July, 1841. Being left an orphan at the early age of one year, he was taken to Rochester, where he lived about ten years. His education was obtained in different portions of the great " Empire " State, his occupation, after he was old enough to work, being farming. In 1860 he came to Califor nia, by way of the Isthmus of Panama, landing in the city of San Francisco on the first day of March. The second day of the same month found him at Sutter Creek, Amador county, which he has since made his home. He has been engaged in various kinds of business since arriving at this place, princi pally teaming, lumbering, and stock-raising.
For the first six years he followed the former bus iness, and then engaged in the lumber trade, which business he still conducts, having the only lumber yard in Sutter Creek. A good portion of the time he has several teams on the road, hauling lumber from his saw-mill, better known as Tarr's mill, situ ated about ten miles above Volcano.
He is largely interested in stock-raising, dealing in and raising horses, mules, and cattle, extensively. Mr. Allen has in the neighborhood of three thousand acres of land adjoining Sutter Creek, all under fence, and well supplied with the necessary arrange ments for the prosecution of his business; has numerous barns for the shelter of his stock. He also has some fifteen hundred acres of mountain range, to which he drives his stock when the feed fails around his home ranch. Taking into consideration his being left an orphan when so young, Mr. Allen is a self-made man, and has accomplished what many others have failed to do. His honesty, integrity and punctuality have always been prominent features in his dealings with his fellow-men.
He was married July 11, 1870, in Amador City, to Miss Annie E. Bradbury, a native of the State of Maine. Their union has been blessed with five children, four of whom, two boj's and two girls, are still living, their oldest child, a daughter, having died.
Was born in Perry county, Pennsylvania, December 15, 1826, where he resided until the Spring of 1839, when, with his parents, he removed to Iowa. While there he learned the carpenter's trade, though prin cipally engaged in farming. In 1850 he was swept off by the great California wave, which sent such a vast number of the best and most energetic across the plains to build up a new State. After resting and looking around awhile at Sacramento, he went to Rough and Ready, in Nevada county, where he remained one year, engaged in mining. From thence he moved to El Dorado county, making that his home until 1876, being engaged in mining ditches until 1856, when he bought into a saw-mill, which, in connection with the selling and transportation of lumber, he carried on until the year mentioned, when he finally located on the present farm, which he had previously purchased. It is situated three miles north-east of Plymouth, and contains three hundred and twenty acres of ground highly improved.
Mr. Baird was married September 14, 1868, to Miss Mary Ann Brown, who -died May 1, 1877. The family consists of Mr. Baird and an only son, now twelve years of age. He is a man trusted by his neighbors, and is a member of the Board of School Trustees of his district.
Charles Bamert
Was born at Baden, in Germany, April 2, 1830. The first five years of his life were passed in his native country; but coming to America at that early age, his first recollections are consequently located in this country. Upon his arrival in America, he went with his parents to Ontario, New York, where he remained until 1852. During that time he attended school and acquired a common school education.
In the year last named, he came to California, reaching San Francisco in the month of July. His first occupation was that of a miner, in Ophir dis trict, in Placer county, where he experienced the trials and privations usually connected with that kind of life in those days. For eight years he fol lowed that business, and in 1860 settled on the Mokelumne river, where he has since resided. Mr. Bamert has a fine ranch containing seven hundred acres, and is also largely interested in other tracts of land in connection with other parties. He has been extensively engaged in stock-raising, but more recently has turned his attention to the sheep bus iness, in company with Pardeau & Borden. For thirteen years Mr. Bamert has been engaged in gen eral merchandise, being first interested with Messrs. Woolsey & Palmer, afterward purchasing their inter- ests in the stock of goods, and conducting the busi ness himself. His natural ability foi1 the trade has manifested itself throughout his years of experience and he ranks at the present time with the prosper ous and successful business men of the county. He was married in 1876, to Miss Leah Shclburn, and their union has been blessed with two children, now aged three and one years respectively.
Edgae Bishop
The subject of the following sketch is a native of New York State, having been born at Warrensburgh, Warren county, in 1839. Upon reaching his major ity he left the familiar scenes of his childhood, and began the battle of life for himself, his objective point being California. His first location in this State was at lone, Amador county, where he was engaged in trade from 1861 to 1866. In June of the last named year, he removed to the city of San Fran cisco, and for about fourteen years was widely known as a successful grocer of that thriving city. In the Spring of 1880, Mr. Bishop returned to lone and pur chased the stock and trade of Daniel Stewart, and is in possession of a large, thriving business.
Is a native of the State of Maine; was born in the town of Calais, Washington county, January 7, 1826. At the tender age of three years he removed with his parents to the city of New Orleans. Louisiana. In the " Crescent City " he received a liberal educa tion, and resided there most of the time until 1850, at which time he came to California. Like nearly all the early pioneers of the " Golden State," his aspirations led him to seek his fortune in the mines, and his first occupation after reaching his destination was consequently that of delving in the earth in search of the precious nuggets. After a short time in his first location, he sought other places where it was believed dame fortune had deposited a larger supply of wealth for him; and, possessing a rambling nature, visited different parts of the State during the succeeding eleven }Tears. In 1861 Mr. Blyther con cluded to settle down, as he was a firm believer ia the old adage that "a rolling stone gathers no moss," and in the last-named year located on the' ranch, where he is very pleasantly situated at the present time, owning one of the best places on the Mokelumne river; though containing but two hundred acres, it is well cared for, and conducted on the true principle that land in order 'to be remunerative, must receive a certain amount of attention. He was married in 1866 to Mrs. Child, who had one child by. a former marriage, that now lives with his parents, a bright, active young man of nineteen years. Mr. Blytheris a courteous gentleman, and in connection with his rep utation as a good farmer, has the good- will and esteem of his neighbors, and is what might be called a selfmade man.
John A. Brown
Was born in the town of Warsaw, State of Missouri, on the 25th of November, 1848. When he was a mere infant his parents came across the plains to California with ox-teams. The first recollections of which our subject is master, are of life in the golden State. His education was obtained in the schools of this State, and speaks volumes for the country that but a few years since, was known only to the hardy pioneers and the " dusky sons of the forest." The first location of the family after reaching the land of promise, was on Bear river, near Marysville. One year later they removed to Amador City, and soon after moved on to a farm near Sutter creek, where they remained fourteen years.
The subject of our sketch attended school until about twenty years of age, and at the early age of twenty-two 3Tears was elected as a Justice of the Peace, holding the office nearly two years. He was engaged in various kinds of business after leaving school, and put in some time prospecting; he also studied law for a couple of years, but during this time he had an ambition to become a civil engineer and surveyor, arid accordingly fitted himself for that profession.
In 1878 be received the appointment of County Surveyor, to fill the vacancy caused by the death of that officer, and the same Summer received his papers appointing him a United States Deputy Surveyor. Since receiving his first appointment as County Sur veyor, he has continued to fill that position to the present time, and has dispatched the duties of his office with entire satisfaction to his people and with credit to himself. In 1879 he made a survey of all the public roads of this county, and is at present engaged in making an elaborate county map. Mr. Brown is an accomplished and thorough gentleman in all the associations of life, and also fully appre ciates the fact that his profession requires the atten tion, that he so readily gives to it.
Anthony Caminetti
Was born at Jackson Gate, in Amador county, July 30, 1854, being one of the first children born in the county. His parents are natives of Italy. The first ten years of his life were passed in his native place, and at that age he went to the city of San Francisco, and attended school, for three years. In 1867, he returned to Jackson, and entered the employ of his Uncle, B. Caminetti, as clerk in his store. In this last position he remained about three years, and attain went to San Francisco, and entered the law office of Quint & Hardy, as clerk, .and remained in that capacity until the completion of the first trial of Laura D. Fair. He soon after entered the State University, at Oakland, where he pursued his studies until October 31, 1873, at which time he returned to Jackson, and commenced reading law in the office of J. T. Farley. In May, 1877, he was admit ted to the Bar of California, and, during the same year, was elected as District Attorney. During the Legislative session of 1875-76, Mr. Caminetti filled the position of Assistant Journal Clerk of the Senate. He was at once recognized as a leader in politics, and in 1880 received the nomination as alternate elector on the Democratic Presidential ticket. In social life he is a genial gentleman, enjoying a large circle of friends, and though young in years, carries a well-balanced head; and we may expect to see him honored in a manner becoming his talents.
Was born in Carroll county, Ohio, December 3, 1839. He resided in that State until 1846, when he removed with his parents to Keokuk, Iowa, where he lived until 1862. When but little past his majority he discovered that it was not good for man to live alone, and took himself a wife, Miss Phebe Smith, who has blessed him with six children, four girls and two boys; all but one girl now living, who bid fair to inherit the virtues and industrious habits of both parents. May 7, 1862, himself and wife, packing their worldly estate into a wagon, started for Califor nia with an ox-team, full of hope and determination that if hard work would wrench good fortune out of the California chaos, they would have a share of the gold and other good things. The daily plodding through the sands and climbing of mountains ter minated, and one evening they let their eyes feast on the green valleys of lone, which formed such a con trast to the alkaline plains of the two thousand miles they had so wearily traversed. They rented a farm and orchard in the interior of the valley, and sunrise and sunset saw him either at work on his place or on the way to market. In those days all kinds of farm produce brought a good price, and in a few years he had accumulated several thousand dollars, enough, as he thought, to give him a good start in the West, for like most early comers to Cali fornia he had not learned to consider California an inviting home. In 1872 he pulled up all his stakes and removed to Kansas, with the intention of making that State his home. But, alas! he had not calcu lated for the cold winters. He did not like the idea of having his heels freeze while his toes were toast ing at a fierce fire; one winter of it was enough. The following Spring he was on his way to Cali fornia, and reached it in due time a wiser, if not a wealthier, man, for this bit of experience had made quite a hole in his litlb capital. But the word fail had no place in his vocabulary. He was not long in getting under way, and soon bought the place on which he now resides, it being in the neighborhood of the noted Q ranch, containing some of the best land in the famous lone valley. In addition to farming his own place he has been engaged in threshing for the many farmers in his vicinity. His love for machinery and knowledge of mechanics has enabled him to make many improvements in the steam power and separators, one of which is likely to become extensively adopted. This is an attach ment to the engine to raise the grain to the separator without the aid of horses. As the machine is under the control of the engineer, it makes a saving of both horse and man power. It is needless to say that Mr. Carlile has secured a patent for the improve ment, it being the first in this direction. Our readers will better understand the nature of the improve ment by consulting the engraving in the body of the work. Coal in considerable quantity is found on his ranch, and the same stream of gravel that has made good diggings on the Coffin place, also traverses his.
James Gumming
Few men have a more varied or extensive expe rience than Dr. Gumming. A volume of interesting incidents might be written without exhausting the subject. He is a native of Tennessee, first seeing the sunlight February 10, 1813, among the mount ains of the eastern part of the State, which has pro duced so many extraordinary men, such as Andrew Johnson and Parson Brownlow, Grainger county being his birthplace. He received a liberal educa tion, both classical and scientific, being a graduate of the University of Knoxville. He afterwards studied medicine, graduating in the Transylvania University of Kentucky. He spent some years in the practice of medicine in Decatur, Alabama, but, in consequence of ill-health, was forced to leave that section of country, removing in 1836 to Peoria, Illi nois, where, in addition to the practice of medicine, he engaged extensively in real estate transactions. He rapidly accumulated property, soon becoming rich. January 17, 1842, he married Miss Mary Ann Dorsey, daughter of Captain Chas. S. Dorsey, of Kentucky. It was remarked that the richest man had married the handsomest woman in four counties, this seeming anomaly arising from the fact that the Dorsey residence stood on the corners of four coun ties. Miss Dorsey made him an inestimable com panion, and still retains much of the beauty which forty years ago made her the queen of all the prairie flowers. They have had three children, none of whom are living to inherit the beauty of the mother, or the intellectual qualifications of the father.
different parts of the Union, his longest stay being made in New Mexico, near Santa Fe, where he engaged in trade, and also in government contracts. His knowledge of the Spanish language, and the character of the peons, enabled him to render the Government efficient service. His experiences among the ignorant and prejudiced, but not by any means bad, natives would make interesting and valuable reading matter, if the doctor could be induced to commit it to paper. In 1859, he so far closed his business in New Mexico as to permit his leaving the Territory and becoming a citizen of California. He was among the first to take passage by the line of overland stages established about that time. Soon after arriving in this State he purchased the prop erty known as the brick flour mills, which he enlarged and otherwise improved, until he can do as good work as is done in the State. The mill has both water and steam-power, the water-power being obtained by a ditch which taps Sutter creek about two miles above the town, the steam-power being used when the water is low. Dr. Gumming is a noted inventor, he having constructed the first plow that would scour in the fat prairies of the West. He has patented two important improvements in the turbine wheel, one of which was to contract the openings so as to utilize the whole fall with a small head of water. lie has also some thirty other pat ents, which have been generally adopted. He has occupied many positions of honor, such as army surgeon, member of the Illinois Legislature, magis trate, etc. Fort Gumming was named in his honor, lie has not accepted any official position in Cali fornia.
William O. Clark William 0. Clark
A personal acquaintance with the subject of this sketch enables the writer to give more of the history of this natural orator than he would be likely to communicate to any one for publication. He was born in Madison, Indiana, January 21, 1817, and con sequently has seen most of the strides that Indiana, as well as other western States, has made in popula tion and wealth. He came to California in an early day, and found ample material in the abundant dramdrinking of California to arouse into action all his powers of oratory, and he early sounded the tocsin of alarm, and proclaimed the evils of intemperance in every town, from Siskiyou to San Diego, organiz ing temperance societies in every possible place, lie is possessed of a sanguine temperament that throws all power available into a contest when once a decision is made, and he made his influence felt wherever saloons existed. He is said to have spent several fortunes in the cause. He has been G. W. P. of the Sons of Temperance for many successive terms. In 1872 he made a trip around the world, visiting England, France, Sicily, Egypt, the Holy Land, India, China and Japan, carrying the temper ance colors all the time, and lecturing upon it whenever practicable. He has resided in Drytown, except when traveling on his special mission, for twenty-six years. Ho suffered heavily in the great fire of 1857, but saved something from the general wreck. The brick store he claims to be the oldest brick structure in the county. Other brick buildings were erected before his, but went down in some of the numerous fires which visited every town. He was married in 1857, to Miss Julia Appleby of Ottawa, Illinois. She was noted as combining extraordinary beauty with a vigorous intellect, and in a suitable sphere would have taken high rank. There was little room in Drytown a quarter of a century since, however, for the exercise of those gifts which in the centers of population would have made her a queen of society. They have one child, a son, living. Mr. Clark amuses himself in his intervals of business, by cultivating the hills around Drytown in grain, and demonstrating their ability to produce something besides grapes.
Thompson Davis
"Was born in the State of Missouri in 1833. At the age of twenty years he emigrated to California, set tling atPlacerville (Hangtown), in El Dorado county, where he lived for two years, when he came to Vol cano, where he mined for one year; thence to Oleta where he lived for two years; thence to Upper Rancheria, where he also mined for two years. Placer mining becoming rather precarious, he tried farming in Buckeye valley, near Carbondale, for ten years. He then engaged in the mercantile business near Drytown for eight years. In 1879 he removed to Plymouth, where he erected a store and enlarged his business. He has since made this place his home. He was married in 1866 to Miss Maria A. Davies. They have four children.
AVas born in Bristol, Hartford county, Connecticut, on the 19th of April, 1828, where he passed his early years. At the age of eighteen he went to New York City, where he was employed as a clerk in a dry goods establishment. On the 25th of January, 1849, he sailed from the latter city in the ship Tuhmaroo, Captain Richardson, master; and on the first of the following July, landed in San Francisco. He at once left for the mines, his first location being on the north fork of the American river, where he remained until the Fall of that year. He then removed to Amador creek, and was engaged in the same business until the following Spring. From 1850 until 1859 he was engaged in merchandising at Amador, Rancheria, Sutter Creek and Volcano, in company with Levi Hanford, having establishments at each of those places. Mr. Hanford had charge of the stores, Mr. Downs generally remaining in the city purchasing and forwarding goods. They were eminently successful, the firm of Hanford & Downs becoming well known over the State. From 1860 to 1873 he was part owner and superintendent of the Lincoln quartz mine at Sutter Creek, Leland Stan ford being a partner. He made the mine a paying institution. The succeeding four years he spent in traveling, making several trips to the Eastern States, as well as traveling extensively through California. In the Summer of 1877, in connection with J. M. Hanford, he opened a mine near Volcano, now bear ing his name, which they have worked successfully ever since. Mr. Downs is also owner of the Golden Eagle mine, near Sutter Creek, which he is now prospecting. He was elected to the Assembly of the State Legislature in 1879-80, an office he filled to the entire satisfaction of his constituents. He has recently built a fine residence at Sutter Creek, where he intends making his permanent home. He was married in his native town, in October, 1856, and has three sons aged respectively eighteen, sixteen and thirteen years.
Provenance
Text from History of Amador County, California, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.