BlockBefore

Modesto, California - History (part 2 of 4)

From History of Stanislaus County California : with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1921. 15,905 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

33 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,905 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Stanislaus County California : with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1921. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Five of the pastors of this church were the Rev. J. C. Simmons, L. G. Hargis, J. C. Pendergast, 1881, M. G. Burris, 1889, and Z. J. Needham, 1919. The first- named pastor, J. C. Simmons, father of the wife of L. J. Maddux, the attorney, was one of the pioneer pastors of California. In a reminiscent lecture of his ministry since February, 1852, he said: "The boy preacher was sent to Grass Valley by the bishop, who remarked: 'If you cannot sleep on bearskins and eat bear meat, you are not fit for a missionary.' On arrival I found a rough clapboard church and a clapboard shed as my home and parsonage. On one occasion I walked sixteen miles to a new diggings and found not a finished house in the place. I found a frame house without any floor, and this I occupied as a church. Empty boxes were used for seats, and empty bottles for candle sticks. There I began singing hymns and soon a crowd gathered around. Services were held at different times under trees, in bar-rooms, tenpin alleys and gambling houses, and many a time I preached with barrels and boxes, bottles, bowie knives and pistols around me." The first trustees were Maj. James Burney of Burneyville, who had charge of the Sunday School, J. D. Bentley and Andrew Lester.

The Baptist Church

The Herald some time since stated that the Baptist Church "was the youngest Evangelical Church in the city," having been organized seven years ago (1903). Mrs. L. H. Pratt, the widow of the deceased pastor, Rev. L. H. Pratt, says she has been a member for fifteen years and that the church was organized long before that time. It seems they were organized in the Congregational Church and there held occasional services. When the building was destroyed by fire, in 1890, the congregation moved to a building corner of Seventh and J streets. The building was later sold and a second building was secured, which was sold after a time to the Seventh Day Adventists. Again without a home, the Baptists, having Increased largely in numbers and wealth, concluded to erect a home of their own. Purchasing a lot on the corner of Eleventh and K streets they erected a handsome concrete edifice at a cost of $15,000. It was dedicated during the summer of 1911, there being a general church building boom about that time. The present pastor is the Rev. Edgar Gum.

The Catholic Parish And Church

The Catholics and the Episcopalians have what is known as parishes, and ofttimes a parish covers an extensive scope of territory. When Father William B. O'Connor was assigned by Archbishop Alemany in 1872 to St. Mary's Church, Stockton, his parish not only included Stockton and San Joaquin County but the entire county of Stanislaus. At that time there was neither parish nor church building in the county save at La Grange, the little French church which we have already noted. Father O'Connor, visiting Modesto occasionally, would hold mass in the homes of the Catholics, and in 1875 a parish was organized. Father O'Connor, who was a very zealous worker for church progress, soon began agitating the question of building a house of worship. Money was subscribed and collected for that purpose. A lot was purchased on Seventh Street near J Street, and a little chapel erected at a cost of $2,500. It would seat about 300 persons and, free of debt, it was dedicated June 23, 1878, by Archbishop Alemany, assisted by Father O'Connor. Seventh Street at that time had "just been laid out and was the main thoroughfare of the infant community."

The first resident pastor was Rev. Patrick Walsh, who was assigned in 1881 to the Modesto church. His parish included all of the towns of the county, Modesto, Turlock, Gustine, Patterson, Newman, Crows Landing, Oakdale, La Grange and Knights Ferry. Father Walsh was in charge about three and a half years, when he was taken sick, and died in the parochial home, Stockton, December 23, 1884. Father Walsh was succeeded January 9, 1885, by Father Thomas McGuire. He was the parish priest during the following ten years and during his priesthood a little parish church was built at Turlock. Then came Father Patrick Smith, January 28, 1894, ;md the close of his earthly work was the most tragic perhaps of any priest in California. Father Smith was a man of middle age and of a delicate constitution. On April 10, Easter Sunday, 1898, the church was crowded with worshippers who had come to celebrate Easter high mass. Father Smith was assisted by two altar boys, and as with the lighted tapers in his hands, he knelt during the consecration, he fell over on his side, dead. The congregation believed he had fainted. Four persons hastening to the altar carried the lifeless body into the rectory. The sexton returning dismissed the congregation, saying: "Father Smith will be unable to finish the mass." He died of heart disease hastened by weakness from fasting.

The next priest in order was Father W. J. Madden. His first mass was in April, 1898, and because of ill health he retired in 1903. While he was in charge, Oakdale was given a resident priest, Father Nevin. A division was also made of the parish. Father Nevin was placed in charge of all that part of the county east of the Santa Fe Railroad track while Father Madden took the west side of the roadbed.

Sixteen years is a long time for a priest or pastor to remain in charge of a congregation. It bespeaks a duty well done, a man beloved by his parishioners. Such is the record of Father M. J. Giles, whose crowning work is the beautiful church of St. Stanislaus with a parish of between 400 and 500 families and nearly 2,500 communicants. Born in Ireland, he attended the Black Rock College, Dublin. Coming to these United States he arrived at San Francisco in 1894. After having served as coadjutor in the San Francisco church of St. Francis, St. Rose and Star of the Sea, he was sent to Modesto in June, 1903. His first baptism was at Newman, July 11, 1903, that of John Souza, a son of Manuel and Mary Silveria Souza. His first marriage, in November, 1903, united John Podesta to Man' Brichetto. In 1904 Newman, Gustine, Patterson and Crows Landing missions were eliminated from his parish and Father Leal became the resident pastor,- residing at Newman. Turlock also was given a resident priest in Father Bailey. Notwithstanding these eliminations, his congregation rapidly increased and in 1912 a committee was appointed to consider ways and means for the erection of a fine edifice, one that would be a credit to the beautiful city of Modesto. The work was hastened and May 1, 1913, the plans were accepted for a reinforced concrete building of the Spanish colonial style of architecture to cost about $22,000. The inside measurement of the building was 46x112 feet, with two towers, each tower 75 feet in height. The first shovelful of earth was turned May 15, 1913, and the wall erected awaited the laying of the cornerstone. August 13, 1913, was an important church day in Modesto and thousands came from the entire surrounding country to witness the laying of the cornerstone. At eight o'clock mass was celebrated in the old church. Two hours later a special train arrived from Stockton having on board a delegation from the Young Men's Institute, the Stockton Drum Corps and the Young Ladies' Institute. A procession was then formed under the direction of W. H. Langdon, now judge of the Appellate Court, and they paraded the streets, led by the Modesto Brass Band. Returning to the church high mass was was celebrated in the open air, Father J. L. Cunha acting as celebrant. At the noon hour a lunch was served to all of the visitors from Stockton and the surrounding country, and during the afternoon there was a baseball game between the Young Men's Institute team of San Francisco and the Modesto Reds. At the same time a sacred concert was given by the' Modesto Brass Band. Late in the afternoon the cornerstone was laid by Archbishop Hanna of San Francisco, he also delivering a sermon in English. Father Cunha gave a sermon in Portuguese. Upon the cornerstone is engraved these words from the sacred writ: "Upon this rock will I build my Church and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it." '

The building was dedicated December 28, 1913, by Archbishop Hanna. At the celebration of high mass Father J. J. Cantwell of San Francisco was celebrant ; Rev. William McGough of St. Mary's Church, Stockton, deacon; Rev. Thomas McNaboc, sub-deacon ; Father M. J. Giles, master of ceremonies. The Rev. M. Gallagher of Oakland, Fathers Thomas Bailey of Turlock, and Dollard of Lodi were present. A special choir with W. W. Higgins as director sang Bateman's Mass in F. The building complete cost $23,500, the fittings $4,000, pews $1,500, and the memorial window, $1,000. The instrument used in the church was a small reed organ, but in February, 1919, a $2,500 pipe organ was installed.

The First Presbyterian Church

The First Presbyterian Church of Modesto was organized in the Methodist Episcopal north edifice March 30, 1879, by Rev. Thomas Fraser, a missionary of the Synod of the Pacific. He was assisted in the organization by the Rev. Thomas Cookson of the Methodist faith and the Rev. J. L. Jones of the Congregational denomination. The congregation held services for a few months in Rodgers Hall, with Rev. John B. Warren as pastor. Purchasing a lot at the corner of I and Fourteenth streets in 1880, they erected a neat building of wood at a cost of $4,300, the Presbyterian board of erection contributing $500 of that amount. The building was dedicated as a house of worship, January 2, 1881, and in a few years was free from debt, principally through the earnest efforts of Mrs. Matilda McHenry and of Mrs. J. S. Armstrong, the wife of Elder Armstrong. The people of the congregation continued worshipping in the little building until 1910. At that time there had been a great reformation in the city ; it was growing by leaps and bounds and the members concluded to erect a much larger and finer edifice, one that would be in harmony with the times. It was their purpose to erect an institutional church, embracing such features as a lecture room and Sunday school rooms, a social parlor, auditorium, swimming tank, gymnasium and all of the features of a first-class Y. M. C. A. It certainly was an innovation up to date. There is none other like it except the Institutional Church in Hollister, San Benito Count}-. The congregation now adjourned to Schafer's hall for worship and the old building was torn down. The new building, covering a space of 60x150 feet, was hastened to completion, and in January a $5,000 pipe organ was installed. The church was dedicated July 2, 1911, the dedicatory sermon being delivered by Dr. Lyman White of San Rafael. There was special music by the choir, the soloists being Mrs. Laura De Yoe Brown and Mrs. Grace Cox. In the evening a union service of all of the Protestant churches was held. The Rev. Lyman White again delivered the sermon and the Rev. Edgar F. Brown, pastor of the Methodist Episcopal Church, spoke in behalf of the sister churches. There were over 800 persons present, more than filling the auditorium and balcony. The edifice cost about $50,000. The charter members of the church are Mr. and Mrs. J. L. Armstrong, Mr. and Mrs. William H. Rice, Mrs. Alice Brock, Mrs. Mary E. Hammond, Mrs. Mary D. Crow, George W. Cameron and Mrs. Mary J. Crawford, who is the only living charter member. The elders of the church for many years past were J. S. Armstrong and J. S. Rice, 1879; Benjamin Drake, 1880; W. B. Cullom and W. B. Elmore, 1882; Henrv Voight and J. E. Ward, 1886; James Thompson, 1890; Dr. B. F. Surryhne, 1894; Edbert Stearns and G. P. Schafer, 1903; Dr. B. F. Surryhne and his wife, who united with the church in 1893, are still members.

No church can remain long in existence without an income from some source. In this respect the Presbyterian Church was particularly fortunate; as a small amount of money, from $150 to $600, was annually supplied by the Home Board to assist in paying the pastor's salary until 1886. At that time the church became self-supporting. A little later, in 1896, a generous provision was made for the partial support of pastors by Mrs. Matilda McHenry, an early member of the church. At the time of her death that year she left a bequest of $15,000. Of this amount, $5,000 was to be placed in the building fund and $10,000 placed at interest as a permanent pastor's fund. The interest was to be used in paving pastors' salaries.

The first session of the board was held May 12, 1879, and Rev. John B. Warren was called at a salary of $1,000 a year. In six months he resigned. The pulpit was then filled in succession by Rev. Alexander Robert L. Beck and Rev. H. A. Newell. Rev. H. E. Mathena, elected in 1881, remained until 1884, when he was succeeded by Rev. John W. Atherton. He filled the pulpit until 1887, and he was followed by- William O. Melvena, H. C. Gillingham, whose resignation was requested in 1891, J. M. Thompson, E. B. Hayes and Enos P. Baker, each with a pastorate of three years. In May, 1901, the session extended a call to the Rev. E. A. Holridge. He accepted and remained in charge until July 1, 1903. In October, 1903, Rev. H. K. Pitman took charge and continued as their beloved pastor until the allied war Then,

The Danish Baptist

THE DANISH BAPTIST In a neat little cottage residence on Seventh Street near H Street, the Danish Baptists worship. It is the youngest religious denomination in Modesto, having been organized May 4, 1916, by the traveling missionary, N. L. Christensen. The charter members of the little church assembled that day in the home of L. C. Nielson in the Woods Colony. They were M. J. Petersen, Mr. and Mrs. James H. Petersen, Mr. and Mrs. M. West, Mr. and Mrs. Peter H. Petersen, Mrs. Andrew Christensen, Mrs. Peter Miller, Mrs. Haus P. Holm, Mr. and Mrs. L. C. Neilsen, Mrs. John Jensen, Miss Mark Kaas and Miss Louise Lindgreen. Rev. Peter Jorgensen, who took charge of the work January 20, 1917, is still in the field. The Sunday school was organized at the same time as the church, and Mr. L. C. Nielsen has continued from that time until the present time as its superintendent.

The Episcopalian Parish

On the corner of H and Fourteenth streets stands the neat little building of the Episcopalians. Rev. A. L. Walters is the rector in charge. It was organized in 1879 as St. Paul's Mission by the Rev. D. O. Kelley of Trinity Church, San Francisco. He was succeeded in 1880 by the Rev. D. L. Mott, the parish missionary until 1883. During his term as rector the little chapel was erected. No chancel was built at that time, but in 1909 the Rev. W. H. Harker became resident rector and a chancel was built, Mr. Harker doing the principal work. Still later choir stalls were built, the gift of Mrs. Frank Cressey, Sr. In 1912 the guild hall was built at a cost of $2,300.

According to the official report, the church was incorporated in 1885, with the following persons acting as trustees and officers: George W. Schell, the attorney, as president, Harry French, secretary, and A. M. Hill, treasurer. According to a press report the church was incorporated when it became a parish June 20, 1910. At that time Bishop Nichol appointed Rev. W. H. Harker to conduct the election of the following vestrymen: J. C. Naylor, Henry S. French, Frank A. Cressey, Sr., H. H. Hatton and Vital E. Bangs. The senior warden was J. C. Naylor and the junior warden, A. H. Williams. The vestrymen at this time (1920) are L. F. Baker, C. K. Garrison, C. W. Doner, O. H. Williams and A. L. Walters.

As we have stated, St. Paul's Episcopal Church was a mission only from its organization in 1879 until 1909. During those many years the congregation were obliged to accept the services of those who were willing to preach the gospel almost gratuitously. Nearly all of the supply came from the churches of San Francisco, being sent on the mission bv Bishops Kip and Nichol. Thev served in the following order: Rev. D. O. Kellev; 1879; D. L. Mott, 1880-83; Henrv Scott Jeffres, 1884- 85; Archdeacon Scrivner and W. H. Dver, 1886-87; Rev. Octavius, June 5, 1891; D. O. Kellev, 1899; H. F. Compton, May, 1907; C. S. Lindsey, March, 1908; Charles Mainan, 1908-09. The first parish rector remained until April, 1911. Then came Rev. W. H. Wheeler, who remained one year, followed by Rev. John Atwell, May to November, 1912; W. P. Williams, April, 1913, to May, 1915; Charles Hitchcock, July, 1915, to May, 1916; Oliver Kingman, May, 1916, to March, 1917, the present pastor, A. L. Walters, taking charge June 1, 1917.

With an ever-changing pastorate no church could rapidly increase either in spiritual influence or membership, but St. Paul's has held its own. In 1885 the membership of the church was fifty-seven, and the number of children, forty-four. The membership is now 218, with thirty-five children in the Sunday school. Confirmation services were first held in 1891, Bishop Nichol confirming three candidates. The first marriage in the county by an Episcopal minister was at Turlock, October 27, 1885, Rev. W. H. Dyer then united in marriage Herbert Dunn and Miss Tymlson.

The Methodist Episcopal Church

This church, said Branch, is the oldest religious organization in Modesto. Organized in 1871, it became the circuit headquarters, which included Adamsville, Dry Creek, Knights Ferry, Burneyville and the district surrounding Modesto. In 1875 the church was made a station and it has supported its ministers without any church board assistance since that date.

Another account, one handed to me by Henry F. Turner, says that the church was organized in 1864 by Silas Belknap with eleven persons, namely: Mr. and Mrs. J. F. McLaughlin, Mr. and Mrs. Jacob Long, Mr. and Mrs. L. H. Fincher, Mrs. Anna Monroe, Mrs. C. E. Henderson, Miss Carrie Moore, Len Crawford and S. E. McLaughlin.

Its first board of trustees were A. J. Hart, C. J. Cressey, Isaac Frye, Frank Kett and A. Calderwood. The church was incorporated in 1873 with Garrison Turner, Isaac Frye, Theodore Turner, F. F. and Albert Fuquay as trustees. The trustees in 1873 purchased lots at the corner of H and Fourteenth streets and erected a church of frame construction at a cost of $4,000 and a parsonage costing $1,500. A much larger and finer building was erected in 1889, the press stating September 27: "The Methodist Church is progressing rapidly to completion. The steeple and weathervane, surmounted by an immense bronze ball, are in place, and it already presents an imposing appearance." The fire across the alley in 1890 badly damaged the edifice and the church was rebuilt in 1891 at a cost of $10,000. The continued growth of the congregation compelled them to make additional room and a substantial rebuilding was carried out in 1906 at a cost of $15,000. Still more room became necessary and in September, 1910, more additions were made, together with a new heating plant :ind a $3,000 pipe organ. The entire work of rebuilding was performed by union labor. As an appreciation of that fact, a day was set and the unions of Modesto were commanded to attend the service on Sunday morning, January 15, 1911, in a body.

The church membership in 1881 numbered 108, with seventeen probationers, and now numbers 650. The Sunday school in 1881 numbered 185, which has increased to over 500. For twenty continuous years, up to and including 1911, Henry E. Turner was the Sunday school superintendent; the present superintendent is W. F. Ramont.

Seventh Day Adventists

SEVENTH DAY ADVENTISTS This organization several years ago erected a frame edifice on the corner of Sixth and J streets. The members are principally farmers and voluntarily they give their tithes to the Lord. A few years ago they sold their building to the Colored Baptists and erected on the site a neat, substantial, concrete house of worship.

First Church Of Christ, Scientist

FIRST CHURCH OF CHRIST, SCIENTIST Along religious lines, one of the most remarkable growths, especially in the large cities during the past twenty-five years is the growth of the Christian Scientists. It is the religion founded by Mrs. Mary Baker Eddy and rich and poor alike have accepted the doctrine as set forth in her book, Science and Health. In Modesto, meetings were held in the home of Mr. and Mrs. Spanker, corner of J and Thirteenth streets. After a time their numbers had so increased the house was not large enough and they assembled in the Masonic hall. Officially recognized, a Christian Science society was organized in 1909 and continuing their services until 1917 that year in September they obtained a charter for the "First Church of Christ, Scientist, of Modesto." Shortly after that they rented a small wooden building on Thirteenth Street near J, formerly a Protestant church, where they now hold services; they also maintain free reading room for the public.

Chapter Nine

The press is the moulder of public opinion all of the time ; the servant of a political part.v and of corporations the most of the time, and the greatest of prevaricators among men, sometimes. Hence we find the newspapers of the county joined to some party, favoring some corporation and at times "lying to beat the band." In March, 1850, there was published at Stockton a paper called the Stockton Times and Tuolumne Intelligencer. It was a Democratic newspaper and the proprietors intended to supply the wants of the citizens of Stanislaus (then Tuolumne County) with the news. As the county had no mail service this idea was quickly abandoned and the last name omitted as there was no way in which the paper could reach its subscribers. The first paper in the county was the Knights Ferry Bee which was published September, 1859, by W. J. Collier. In a short time the Bee passed into the hands of J. B. Kennedy, who stated that the paper would be published every Saturday morning "from the office, north side of the public square." It was a four-page, six-column paper and the price was twenty-five cents per copy or five dollars a year. Wholesale liquor houses and whisky shops, together with famous restaurants in Stockton and San Francisco, formed the bulk of its advertisements. In Knights Ferry, N. L. Buddington called attention to his splendid bar which was stocked with the choicest liquors and newly cushioned billiard table, the best in the town. The Bee discontinued its publication in less than fourteen months. Its successor was the Stanislaus Index. It was first published in 1861 by Garrison & Whicher, and it suspended publication shortly after the flood of January, 1862. Six years later and the miners were leaving the "diggings," for they declared the mines had "petered out" and they began locating in the valley and seacoast cities.

The Modesto News

THE MODESTO NEWS Among those whose fortunes were blasted by the exodus of the miners was a young man named J. D. Spencer, who was then publishing in San Andreas a paper called the Mountain News. A Virginian by birth, he returned to California the second time with his family in 1853 and began mining in Calaveras County. In 1862 he engaged in the photographic business and three years later became an editor in charge of the Woodbridge Messenger on the banks of the Mokelumne River. Young Spencer, then twenty-five years of age, entered into politics and strongly espoused the Democratic party. In November, 1867, he published the Mountain News. At that time indications were that Stanislaus would soon become a large and flourishing county and having no paper he concluded to locate in Tuolumne City and publish a Democratic paper. Landing there early in 1868, on February 14, the first copy of the Tuolumne News was issued. It was a four-page, six-column paper and published every Friday morning in the upper story of the Ross House, the hotel being upon the main street of the town. The News in its politics was thoroughly Democratic, "yet at the same time warmly enlisted in the progress and advancement of the county. By its boldness the land office ring at Stockton was broken up and it next boldly urged the repeal of the 'no fence law,' thus securing the new settlers from the heavy expense of fencing their lands before their crops could be raised."

"The News" Moved to Modesto Mr. Spencer soon learned that he had made a mistake in locating in Tuolumne City and immediately he began making preparations to move to the new railroad town. In the last issue of his paper, November 29, 1869, he said: "We came here three years ago assisted by friends expecting that the Tuolumne would be navigable for at least ten months of the year. Now the railroad will kill the town and we intend moving to Modesto. There we can daily get the news and issue a daily and a much better paper." Tuolumne City at that time had a population of about 300 people and one-half of the county's population lived within thirteen miles of the town. There were other inducements which caused the removal of the paper to Modesto, namely, a deed to two town lots free of cost. About this time, Miner Walden, assemblyman from Stanislaus, concluded that his future political interests and those of the Neivs were identical. Going to the agent of the contract and finance committee of the Southern Pacific he induced them to deed two lots to J. D. Spencer for a home and printing plant. Although the News was antagonistic to the railroad politically and as a corporation, they agreed to deed Spencer the land, as a good paper would help to advertise and boom the town. In the spring of 1870 the printing plant was loaded upon wagons and moved to Modesto. Branch, in recording this event wrote: "When the News office was located on its present site, there were not a half a dozen shanties in the town of Modesto. It stood alone, isolated, facing the east, with no view or prospect to break the monotony of the broad, sweeping plains, until the unobstructed vision rested on the snow-clad peaks upon the Yosemite." The office was located in a deep swale or slough, rendering it almost impossible to reach it during the rainy season. The name of the paper was changed to the Stanislaus Neivs and the first number was issued December 2, 1870. It was issued as a four-page, six-column paper with a subscription price of five dollars per annum. The advertising rates were three dollars per square one insertion of ten or less lines. Contract rates on quarterly contracts were considerably less than the regular rates. Among his first advertisers may be found the firm of George W. Schell and J. J. Scrivner, attorneys and real estate, Knights Ferry ; Thomas A. Coldwell, district attorney, Knights Ferry; Abraham Schell and A. Hewel, residing in the county seat; John B. Hall, W. C. Buckley, Warren S. Montgomery, Stockton; Maj. James Burney, notary public, Burneyville, and B. G. Wier, justice of the peace, Tuolumne City,

Spencer continued publishing the Neivs as a weekly paper until December, 1884, when he branched out December 1, 1884, as the Daily Evening Neivs. The price was, one year, five dollars; six months, three dollars; three months, one dollar and fifty cents. It was published as a four-page, five-column paper. In the first issue the editor said : "The Daily Evening News makes its formal bow to the public today. It is here in accordance with the overwhelming call of the popular sentiment of the people of this county. In politics every one has a right to expect that it will be strongly, boldly and aggressively Democratic. In the issuing of a daily it is no secret that strong Democratic friends, numbering among them the wealthiest, truest and best citizens, have generously assisted in this daily publication to offset the politics of Republicanism, preached in our daily press." The paper had a circulation of 800 or 900, says C. P. Rendon, with J. D. Spencer as editor; James Madrell, reporter, and C. P. Rendon as compositor. Rendon, who later was district attorney of San Joaquin County for twenty years, was born in Stanislaus County at La Grange, and learned the printer's trade on the Wheat Grower at Oakdale. He was later employed on the Modesto Strawbuck and later on the Republican, then conducted by H. I. Bradford. Rendon began reading law with Thomas A. Coldwell, a Modesto lawyer. In March, 1889, Spencer took in as a partner W. D. Crow and they published the location of their paper as "corner of I and Eleventh streets, opposite the court house."

In 1881 Spencer purchased a new cylinder press and in 1890 he was compelled to erect a new building. "We are cramped for room, as the building we are in is one of the first moved from Tuolumne City and only eighteen feet wide, is too narrow for our new machinery. It has been moved to an adjoining lot and a new building, hard finished throughout, 25x75, will be erected." He was in his new office March 24, and his expenses in publishing a daily were quite heavy, $800 per month. His employees represented five families and four-fifths of the money was spent in Modesto, he stated. The expense was too heavy and the paper went back to a weekly edition. Five years later, December 13, 1895, Spencer died in Modesto. For several years after his death the paper was published by the Spencer estate with R. D. Maddrell as managing editor. In time he retired and J. H. Cavill took charge, the News being issued as a four-page, eight-column paper.

When J. D. Spencer's son, Herbert, became of age he sold a half interest in the paper to O. E. Perigo, and young Spencer disagreeing with Cavill in regard to the management of the paper, Cavill retired and opened a print shop on I Street. In July, 1911, Perigo sold his half interest to J. W. Guyler, an employee in the office, and A. W. Cowell, former editor of the Stockton Mail. Mr. Cowell was appointed secretary of the irrigation company, and retired from newspaperdom. A corporation was then formed. Spencer sold out and two gentlemen from Reno, Nev., E. T. Sherman and S. T. Morgan, bought up the principal stock and are now conducting the News.

Modesto Herald

MODESTO HERALD Long before his death the editor of the News had had many a political fight and many a heated contest with its Republican opponent, the Morning Herald. And, says the local historian, "in the days of fierce, journalistic rivalry and enmity, the editors of the local press were not on speaking terms." Following close after the establishment in Modesto of the News, a newspaper was issued by S. Marcey, in 1873, called the Modesto Mirror. It was independent in politics. In the spring of 1874 the Mirror was purchased by h: F. Beckwith who bought it from Marcey. In the "local option" campaign some" years later the Mirror advocated the "dry" side of the question, which resulted disastrously to that paper. The material was later purchased by H. E. Luther, and that gentleman, January 28, 1875, issued the first number of the Morning Herald. Then the paper was incorporated and H. E. Luther's health failing, Charles Maxwell took charge of the paper and bought up all of the stock. Maxwell seems to have been a successful newspaper man. He enlarged the Herald from a six-column folio to a six-column quarto and in August, 1879, refitted the office with new material, all except presses. The business increased rapidly and in August, 1880, he moved to the second story of the Baum Building, southeast corner of H and Tenth streets, in the business center of the town. In its new quarters the paper was again enlarged to a seven-column quarto. Republican in politics we cannot imagine the cause of its success, for it was a Republican paper in the midst of a strongly Democratic city and county. Notwithstanding the fact that the Herald was the largest and best paying plant, its opponent, the Neil's, got all of the "political pie." It received all of the city and county printing regardless of who was the lowest bidder and in 1876 the Herald charged that the News had received $209.75 for printing election notices. The Herald's bid was $70.50 for the same work. Although the law plainly declared that the supervisors of each county shall give all county printing to the lowest bidder, the supervisors in 1878 again gave the work to the News. The Neivs' bid for the work was almost double that of the Herald's bid. It was altogether too raw, and Maxwell of the Herald brought suit against the supervisors, asking that the Neivs bid be set aside. The case came up before Judge Booker of the district court and he declared the Neil's bid was null and void.

Hanscom Shoots Himself Sometime in the '80s the Herald came into the possession of A. E. Wagstaff, an old newspaper -man who was very aggressive, with S. L. Hanscom as editor. From that time on things were quite lively in Modesto for the Herald scored men and party right and left for their illegal and "rotten work." In consequence of this fact Hanscom's life was threatened and to protect himself he always went armed. Unfortunately, on April 3, 1888, he was shot by his own weapon. He carried in his overcoat pocket a self-cocking revolver and in sitting down in his office that day it was accidentally discharged, the ball passing through the fleshy part of his leg about two inches below the knee. In January, 1889, the San Francisco Chronicle said in playing for subscriptions: "Stanislaus County is among the best-governed counties in the state." The Herald , commenting upon the article, said : "The 'only trouble with the above is, it isn't true. Today and as far back as we can remember Stanislaus has been pilfered and robbed in every imaginable way by a set of Democratic thieves, typical of whom is Johnny McCarty, whose red head is about to flash like a meteor across the bay to San Quentin. How soon his successors will follow him, time will tell." -

Brown Attempts to Shoot Editor Hanscom was called to account for his plain statements by an infuriated young man named George Brown, a son of T. C. Brown, chairman of the board of supervisors. It appears that Supervisor Brown was dominated by A. S. Fulkerth, and when a certain proposition came up before the supervisors the Herald said in its edition of July 25, 1889: "Brown of course, has to vote as Fulkerth tells him. Fulkerth knows too much about the crimes committed by a son of Brown's for the later to refuse to do Fulkerth's slightest commands." Over a week later, on August 8, while Hanscom was sitting in his office, young Brown entered. Stepping up to Hanscom s desk he threw down a copy of the paper of July 25 and pointing to the article inquired : "Are you the author of this?" "Yes," replied Hanscom. Brown then quickly drew a revolver and pointing it at Hanscom's head, fired. Hanscom, fortunately, had thrown up his hand a moment sooner and the ball passing over the editor's head, lodged in the wall. Hanscom then grappled with the attempted assassin and parties hurrying into the room found the men grappling- with each other, both with revolvers in their hands, trying to use them. The two men were disarmed and Brown was taken to jail. In the meantime parties on the street heard the shot and some cried out "murder" and others yelled "fire!" The bell was rung and the whistle blown and in a few minutes the firemen and a big crowd were on the street. A reporter from the News office attempted to interview Brown in the jail. He was, however, so maudlin drunk that little information could be obtained. He said that he would not have resented any reflections upon himself, but his father was too good a man to be abused and vilified and he would not permit it if he could help it.

Hanscom, who had been a county school teacher and later a reporter on the Neivs, in 1890 purchased the Herald. He celebrated the event by an attack on Judge Hewel, one of the attorneys in the county since 1864. Hewel, a German by birth, was a prominent politician in those days of packed conventions, fraudulent voting, and when the purchasable votes of Front Street carried many a candidate into office. He was deputy county clerk in 1865; county clerk in 1866-67 and elected county judge in 1879. Hanscom "bearded the lion in his den" and through the Herald he accused the Judge, while acting as an election officer, of folding the ballot of John Hays and depositing it in the ballot box while the said John was so drunk he was unable to know what he was doing. Hanscom also charged the Judge with dishonesty while acting as an election clerk, 1870. Judge Hewel sued the writer for $40,000 damages to good name and fame. The suit was called February 16, 1890, with Judge M. H. Harris of Fresno presiding. L. J. Maddux and General J. R. Kittrelle appeared for Hanscom and James H. Budd of Stockton and P. J. Hazen for the plaintiff. The jury sworn in to try this remarkable and interesting suit according to the law and the evidence, comprised N. E. De Yoe, John James, S. Shackelford, E. Gatzman, D. A. Brown, C. M. Brockworth, N. M. Parsons, J. F. Davin, Frank Medina, E. Richardson, L. B. Farrish and Moses Sheakley. The jury brought in a verdict in favor of Judge Hewel and the Neics in commenting on it said: "By the above verdict Judge'Hewel is completely vindicated and Hanscom, the vile traducer of his character, is branded as a liar, a perjurer, a base libeler and a depraved wretch."

Soon after this Hanscom retired from the newspaper business and located in San Francisco. The plant was purchased by T. C. Hocking, formerly of Grass Valley, and December 23, 1893, he returned home on a visit. The foreman of the Herald for twenty-five years was John J. Porter. His health failed in 1905, and leaving his position November, 1911, he died at the I. O. O. F. home. Mr. Hocking, soon after his purchase of the Herald bought a lot and erected a single-story brick building, the location of the Herald at the present time.

Chapter Ten

Stanislaus enjoys an honor bestowed on no other county north of the San Joaquin River save Sacramento, namely, a state treasurer, L. C. Richards, a resident of Grayson, and two state school superintendents The first state superintendent, John G. Marvin, elected in 1850, resided at Empire and Paul G. Hubbs, elected in 1853, lived near the present site of Oakdale on land purchased from Maj. James Burney of Burneyville. Marvin in his first school report, 1851, said there were 150 children in Tuolumne County, and not a public nor a private school. In 1855 Superintendent Hubbs reported two schools in Stanislaus County, one in the Branch school district with R. B. Hewey and W. D. McDaniels as teachers, and one in the Burney district, Robert McColloch and J. D. Neil, teachers. In the Marvin district in 1856 a third public school was opened, the teacher being Mrs. Mary Sharp. At that time only twenty-five children attended school, although according, to the school census report there were 168 children in the county. In the following year there were 197 children and yet only two schools with three teachers. The report of 1860 is not very satisfactory, but there were 125 children and they received $94.50 school money from the state school fund.

Earliest School Districts

Mr. E. R. Crawford, one of the teachers of the late sixties, in giving his reminiscences to the Oakdale Graphic in 1901, said: "My knowledge of the schools goes no further back than 1866. At that time there were only nine school districts, namely: Adamsville, Empire, La Grange, Knights Ferry (now called Emory), McHenry, Salida, Farmer's Cottage, Jackson and Washington, now called Langworth.

"The schoolhouses with very few exceptions were nothing more than rough boards nailed upright to scantling. Some were battened but without lining, others were without batten and in the summer sun the cracks would widen an inch or more, thus relieving the teacher of the ventilation problem and offering glimpses of the outside world to those within.

"Knights Ferry had a good schoolhouse; it was burned a short time ago but rebuilt. There was a brick building at Langworth built in 1862 or 1863 by subscriptions and entertainments at Lone Star. W. H. Brown was the first teacher of the school. The teachers (in the county) as I recall them were Vital E. Bangs, L, W. Crawford, William Jamison, John C. Lillie, H. J. Turner, Mr. Chedister, Miss Carrie Moore, Mrs. Allen and myself. T. T. Hamlin was county superintendent, succeeded by Maj. James Burney. This dear old man was honored and loved by teachers and pupils as he had a smile and good word for every one."

Private Schools

The first private school in the county was established in 1 853 by John W. Laird. The teacher was an Irishman, James Sylvester by name. The children from two families comprised one-half the school, namely, Elvira, Mary and John W. Laird, Jr., Joel, George, John and Nancy Smith together with John M. Whitman, Mary Kemp and John Green. Young Green was a boarder from afar, for his home was in Tuolumne County.

A second private school was taught in 1854 by Mrs. Mary Sharp. The school was located about a mile above Empire City. She advertised in the paper that she would teach all branches of the English language at twenty-six dollars per month, including board. The lad}' purposed establishing a female seminary in the spring of 1855, if sufficient encouragement be given. "Few in our state are more competent to conduct a school," wrote a correspondent. She had but few scholars because of the scarcity of children and the sparsely settled family population, so in 1856 she began teaching the district public school in Empire.

First Public School

FIRST PUBLIC SCHOOL There were a few people living in the vicinity of Orestimba Creek who realized the value of an education, and in 1854 by private subscription they raised money sufficient to establish a school at Newsome's Bridge and employ a teacher. The building was a rough-built shanty, made of pine or redwood boards, and in use in summer only. A friendly, neighboring tree had to make up for all of the deficiencies of Toof. About the same time a district public school was established at Knights Ferry. The pupils were children of the Dent, the Lane and the Magee families. For want of a better location, the school was opened in one end of a stable. Horses occupied the upper end. The "stable" school was only a temporary affair, however, as the citizens soon collected enough money to build "the little school on the hill." Another school overcrowded from the first day, was the school established in the Bel Passi district. It was thought necessary to start a school in that district and they took possession of a little shanty erected in 1869 by L. C. Branch. He erected it to "bunk" here once a month, as the law required, and thus secure the title to a quarter section of land. Of course it was a small room for a school. The teacher in describing it said : "I was obliged to stand in the doorway while teaching, and look in." John Tulloch, the veteran quartz miner, understanding the condition of affairs in Buena Vista, in 1869 erected a school building opposite the town, for the use of the children in that vicinity. In that same year a brick school building was erected at Tuolumne City through the efforts of the ladies of the town. The Neivs in writing of the ladies' work said, September 29, 1869, "One of the greatest requirements of our place is a first-class schoolhouse. Some considerable sum has been collected already for the building of a schoolhouse and the ladies will give a grand festival at the coming fair for that purpose."

Legislative School Laws

We have already noticed the little district school at Modesto located at the southeast corner of the block, corner H and Tenth streets, later (1876) the location of Samuel M. Oaves' drug store. Charles Light, born at La Grange, and then a boy of fifteen, said : "There was one small schoolhouse at Modesto on the hill. Not more than thirty persons attended this school at one time. They ranged from youngsters to grown-up people and were of all nationalities except Negroes, Chinese and Japs."

Before the town had been many months founded the more intelligent citizens began discussing the proposition of a large and comfortable school building for their children. As the town was not incorporated the trustees had no authority to collect taxes or make any contracts for a large school building such as was desired. The Legislature, however, could give them that power, and April 1, 1872, Thomas J. Keyes, then senator from Stanislaus County, introduced a bill which passed, declaring that "the Board of Trustees of the Modesto School district shall publish an advertisement in the weekly paper calling for plans for a schoolhouse." After the plans and bids for the building were accepted the trustees were authorized to levy an assessment on all taxable property.

There was a blockade somewhere. Perhaps the assessment would not bring in sufficient money to build a school and purchase a suitable piece of property and probably the supervisors refused to obey the law. In the matter of property, however, the contract and finance committee of the Southern Pacific came to the trustees' assistance and deeded the town the west quarter of block on Fourteenth Street between I and H streets. A new law was passed June 9, 1874, by the Legislature, which was signed by Gov. Newton Booth, declaring that "the board of trustees must as soon as expedient, advertise for school plans; said school shall be erected on a portion of Block by the trustees." The supervisors were authorized to issue bonds not to exceed $20,000, said bonds to be put into a separate fund in the county treasurer's office and known as the Modesto School District building fund. The people were authorized to elect an assessor and a collector for assessing and collecting the bonds.

Modesto'S First School Building

The Modesto school trustees having the lot presented by the Central Pacific Railroad Company and the money from the sale of bonds began immediately the construction of a school building on Fourteenth Street. The building was two stories in height, constructed of brick, with a porch along the entire front of the building, and with wide front steps for the entrance. In the center of the building was a belfry, and in it the traditional school bell, which when rung could be heard throughout the town. The building contained nine rooms with plenty of light in each room but with none of the conveniences of the school rooms of the present day. Each room in winter was heated by a large stove and a pump in the yard furnished the drinking water. The cost probably was about $15,000 and it was completed in time for the fall session of the schools. The first teachers in the building from 1872 until 1876 were Wm. H. Robinson, principal, with Mrs. Owens, H. F. Turner and Win. B. Howard as assistants. It seems, however, from a late report, that Mr. Crane and Miss Maddux were teachers during those years. They had enrolled 27S children. The old "red brick" school building remained in use until 1906 when it was replaced by the present beautiful structure. When the belfry of the old schoolhouse was torn out the rafters were seen thickly covered with the knife-carved names of hundreds of the pupils of the school.

The Public School Cornerstone In the northeast corner of the present Fourteenth Street school, there is laid a small granite stone and inscribed upon it the figures 1872-1906. I cannot understand the meaning of the date 1872 unless it stands for the date of the foundation of the first Modesto public school, for the cornerstone was not laid in the little "red brick" until St. John the Baptist's Day, June 24, 1874. However, on that day the Grand Lodge of "Masons, who had been requested by the Modesto school trustees to lay the cornerstone of the new school building, assembled early in the afternoon in the Masonic Temple, the James Building, corner of H and Eleventh streets. Isaac S. Titus, the most worshipful grand master, called the lodge to order and appointed the following grand officers, pro tern, to assist him in laying the cornerstone: Wm. Grollman, deputy grand master; J. J. Chapman, senior grand warden; A. Hewel, junior grand warden; Elihu B. Beard, grand treasurer; L. B. Walthall, grand secretary; George Belknap, grand chaplain; J. D. Spencer, errand orator; Georee Buck, grand marshal ; John W. Laird, grand Bible bearer ; W. J. Houston, grand senior deacon; John H. Hays, grand junior deacon; H. M. Ross and John Visher, grand stewards, and H. G. James, grand tyler. A procession was formed comprising Stanislaus Lodge of Masons, the Grand Lodge and the public school children accompanied by their teachers, Miss Maddux and Mr. Crane, and to the soul-stirring music of the Modesto band they marched to the new building site. On arrival the ceremony was opened by prayer bv the grand chaplain. Maj. James Burney, county superintendent of schools, stated the object of the gathering and invited the Grand Lodge to officiate in the laying of the cornerstone. The grand master in a short address informed the senior grand warden that "it is my will and pleasure that the Grand Lodge do now assist me in the performance of this pleasing duty. This you will communicate to the iunior grand warden and he to the craft." When informed that a cornerstone had been prepared, the grand master requested the erand secretary to read the contents of the casket to be deposited in the cornerstone. The articles were as follows: A list of the officers of the state Grand Lodge of Masons, Stanislaus Lodge No. 206, Modesto district school trustees, a copy of the Stanislaus News, San Joaquin Valley Mirror. Pacific Methodist South Church Discipline, by-laws and list of officers of the Farmers. Savings Bank of Stanislaus, a trade dollar of 1874, a half-dollar of 1873, a dime of 1873, and a twenty-dollar gold piece. The casket was then placed in the cavity and sealed up with the beautiful ceremony of Masonry. When this was completed an oration was delivered by the grand orator, J. D. Spencer, and the Masons then returned to their hall.

The number of children in Modesto according to the school census on May 31, 1889, was 862. Of this number 666 were of school age namely, between five and seventeen years. The number attending the public schools was 528, and twenty-six were attending private schools. In that year school room was at a premium and in September the Neics asserted : "The schools are overcrowded and the trustees are compelled to rent the Congregational church with Ida Dennett, the daughter of the Rev. Westley Dennett, as teacher. They are compelled to charge for scholars outside of the city limits as follows: grammar grades, three dollars per month, third grade, two dollars and fifty cents per month and all below that grade two dollars per month." At that time the Sixth Street school had been established. It was in an old house that had been removed from Tuolumne City. It was located where now stands the present fine structure and was used as a school building for many years. The teachers on the West Side at that time, 1889, were W. E. Lindsey and Mary Aull. Miss Aull had then been teaching for ten years, as she was a teacher in the brick school in 1880-81, together with Clara Pendergast, Louise Crow, Berry H. Howard and Principal D. S. Braddock. There were in the building 289 scholars, 149 being boys. Two of the pupils in the principal's class were Laura Garlinghouse and C. C. Young, now lieutenant-governor of California.

In the red brick schoolhouse the grammar grade course of study only was taught until 1883 when the principal at that time, R. S. Hohvay, established a high school course of study. It was a three years' course and included all of the studies usually taught in the high schools of the state at that time. Forty pupils entered the class, but they kept dropping out until only three boys and seven girls completed the work. The course was completed in May, 1886, under Prof. J. F. Wayman, R. S. Hohvay in the meantime having accepted a position in the State University at Berkeley. The ten who graduated were Leah Elias (now Mrs. Louis Harris), Ella Wood (Mrs. Ella Hancock), Laura Garlinghouse (Mrs. George Springsteen), Stella Finley (Mrs. W. H. Frazine, now deceased), Belle McMullin (Mrs. George Wood of Ceres), Tille and Aggie Lewis, who with their classmates became teachers in the public schools, John B. Zimdars, now practicing law in San Francisco, James G. Thompson, now practicing medicine in Oakland, and Sol P. Elias, Stanford graduate of law and now manager of the D. & G. D. Plato establishment, and local historic enthusiast of Stanislaus County.

The graduating exercises of the class took place May 27, 1886, in Rodgers Hall. It was a very important event and the room was more than crowded with the friends and relatives of the graduates. The newspaper said the following day: "The ladies kept coming until the gentlemen were crowded out of their seats and back and back until they were crowded out of the hall, not even having standing room." None in that hall were happier nor prouder than the graduates and over the front of the stage the audience read their motto, Finis Coronat Opus, "The end crowns the work." The diplomas were presented to the class by Attorney C. C. Wright, a former school teacher at La Grange. The program which was quite lengthy, comprised a piano solo, by O. E. Zimdars ; essay, "The Tendency of Our Government," Sol P. Elias; essay, "Something of Nature's Law," Tillie Lewis; reading, "The Execution of Montrose," Laura Garlinghouse; quartette, "Come Rise with the Lark"; a study, "The Princess," Stella Finley; recitation, "The Knight and the Lady," -Leah Elias; zither solo, Laura Horn; "Class Chronicles," Aggie Lewis; essay, "Finished," Belle McMullin ; soprano solo, "Rose of the Alps," Ella Snowden ; oration, "The Power of Wealth," James G. Thompson; essay, "Aim of Life," Ella Wood; essay, "The Growth of Society," John B. Zimdars; solo, "Fly with Me," from the opera "Ernani," Mrs. Ella Hoag; address, "Books and Reading" by C. C. Stratton of the Pacific University; presentation of diplomas by C. C. Wright.

The citizens of Modesto although indifferent and neglectful regarding the civic and moral affairs of the town were very progressive and wide-awake regarding school matters and in December, 1899, a petition was circulated for a "special election for the purpose of submitting the question of establishing a district high school." A sufficient number of signatures for calling the election were easily obtained. The News in commenting upon the petition said : "Although the high school studies are taught in the Modesto public schools and a special tax is voted each year to employ teachers, in addition to the lower grades, and while the high school is on the accredited list of the State University, the advantage of having a separate school cannot be underestimated." The tax was voted by the people and without losing any time the trustees purchased a block of land where now stands the departmental school. It was at that time the baseball ground and owned in part by the German Bank of San Francisco. Plans were drawn for a large two-story brick building with a high concreted basement. The work was commenced in November and the building completed on March 30 of the following year. The building and block cost $21,000, the block alone costing $1,500. It was first occupied in September, 1900, by the high school and eighth grade pupils, eighty-one scholars in the two grades, Thomas Downey then being principal of the high school. For seventeen years this building was known as the high school building. In the meantime the children had increased to thousands and for their school accommodations three more handsome grammar school buildings had been erected, the Sixth Str^t and the Washington Street schools on the "west side" and the Seventh Street building on the "east side." The high school building had become an out-of-date, obsolete affair. Another bond election was carried and the school trustees in 1919 erected another beautiful and up-to-date high school, on the banks of the Tuolumne River at the end of I Street. More school room is required and an extension will soon be constructed.

Graduating Class of 1890 The teachers in the brick school in 1890 were Thomas Downey, principal; J. C. Levengood, vice-principal; Mary McLean, Ida Dennett, E. A. Weaver, Laura Garlinghouse, Elma Hanscom and Mrs. E. McClure. The graduating or commencement exercises of the high school class of that year were again held in Rodgers hall and the room was "filled to suffocation." The stage was handsomely decorated and at its apex, lettered in gold, was the class motto: "Do That You Do." Upon a maroon background in white flowers were the words, "Class of '90." The program commenced with a piano duet by the Misses Johns and Parsons; chorus, by the Class; oration, "Education," H. M. Hardin; essay, "Self Reliance," Anna M. Vesey; vocal solo, Zelda Turner; essay, "William Pitt," George E. Perley ; essay, Belle Christman; cornet solo, D. C. Smith; essay, "Our Inventions," H. M. Cavill ; piano duet, Prof. H. Hintze and Allie Cressey ; essay, "Struggles of Life," B. F. Lewis; vocal solo, Nettie Beaty; address, "Farewell," Ida Ross.

The High School Alumni The alumni was organized in 1886, the ten graduates of that year being the charter members. They held their meeting annually in the brick schoolhouse. Their first president seems to have been George P. Schafer, and as he was absent at their regular meeting, June 22, 1887, Tillie Lewis presided as president. The officers elected for 1889-90 were John B. Zimdars, president; Sol P. Elias, vice-president, and Belle McMuIlin, secretary. The alumni then numbered thirty members, the number being increased to thirty-five by the election to membership of George E. Perley, H. M. Hardin, Anna M. Vesey, Wm. H. Cavill and B. F. Lewis, graduates of 1890. It seems to have been the custom of the alumni, during the first few years for the alumni to hold their yearly receptions in the home of some one of the graduates. It was a pretty custom and in 1893 the graduates met in the beautiful home of the Misses Turner on Sixteenth street. A short program had been prepared, comprising a piano solo by Millie Parsons and Lucy Kittrelle, and vocal solos by Zelda Turner and

Laura De Yoe, later one of the most accomplished vocalists of the valley. The program closed with a selection by the quartette, Laura De Yoe, Ida Ross, J. M. Walthall and Herman Rice. Among the guests of the alumni was Blanche Hewel, Helen Ogden, Myrtie Conneau, Lois Garlinghouse, Nellie Gridley, Belle Hewel, Lulu Ingle, Mary James, Mora Stevenson, Bertha Toombs, Edith Turner, Sadie Millman, Eddie Walthall, George Ingle, Walter Chadwick, Charles Hilton, George Jamison, Hugh Walthall, Earl Tulloch and Jacob Weil. Quite a number of those present were graduates of the high school of 1893, pupils of Thomas Downey.

In time the alumni association became so large in numbers with yearly additions from the graduating classes that it became cumbersome and uninteresting and it was discontinued. It was reorganized on June 18, 1921, with 115 charter members. Sol. P. Elias was elected president, Charles Wherry, vice-president and Florella Finney, secretary and treasurer. Seated around the banquet table toasts were offered and speeches made by Thomas Downey, the veteran in school work; Charles Morris, vice-principal of the high school ; W. E. Faught, city school superintendent, and E. R. Utter, teacher in the high school. The following teachers were made honorary members of the association: Professors R. S. Holway and Thomas Downey, W. E. Faught, E. R. Utter, C. S. Morris, Miss Alice Lyon, Mrs. Carrie Dexter Utterback and A. G. Elmore, county school superintendent. The following are the charter members of the reorganized alumni association: 1886, Sol P. Elias, Mrs. Louis Harris (Leah Elias) ; 1889, H. B. Rice; 1890, Isabel Christman Kinnear; 1891, Charles W. Barnett; 1892, Mabel Perley Stone; 1895, Lourein Fuquay Elmore; 1896, Louis Le Hane; 1898, A. G. Elmore, Olive M. Turner Dennett; 1901, Irene N. Kiernan, Ethel Beard Hoover; 1902, Mrs. Edgar Annear, Mrs. Francis J. Bangs, Clara E. Finnev, Blanche Wickman, Mrs. W. E. Faught; 1905, Elveda Turner Morris; 1907, J. I. Hammett; 1908, Neil M. Cecil, R. I. Guy; 1909, Florella K. Finnev; 1912, Laura Watson, Isabel Laughlin; 1913, May Philbrick, Grace Gray, Clara M. Keeley, Mr. and Mrs. Loren S. Hadlev (Rubv Hart), Mr. and Mrs. H. D. Grundy, Marion Downev, J. S. Marriott; 1914, Marie Wren, L. E. and Alice Jones; 1915, Melville D. Harris, Isle Downey, Evelvn Sorem, C. S. Morris, a teacher 1921 ; 1916, Anna Alway, Doris Dozier, Harrell Watson, E. R. Utter, De Witt R. Lee, Hugh H. Griswold; 1917, Simon W. Holtham, R. B. Austin, Isabel Crow, Millie McLaughlin, Lillis Watson, Wood J. Guyler, Walter Andrews, Leland D. Simpson, M. C. Fulkerth, I. C. Downer, Howard Campbell; 1918, Esther Chapman, Maryon R. Bell, Charles H. Bell, Marjorie and Charles Wherrv, May McLaughlin, E. Roe Fisher, Almeda Gant, Velma Griffin, Mrs. Charles S. Morris, Mrs. E. R. Utter; 1919, J. Paul Moore, Sam H. Winklebleck, Esther C. Tully, Jessie Stinson, Hugh Brinkerhoff, Carvell N. Clark, Carl J. Vogt, Sara Thompson, Alberta B. Peterson, Rose Ginatti ; 1920, Lenora Jane Holtzer, Ora May Jennings, Dewey E. Wheeler, Connie G. Gunn, Lawrence R. Kelley, Donald E. Liebendorfer, Wilbur G. Parry, Warren Harris, Velma Green, Jane and Alma Alway, Lavilla Cox, Francis Gray, Agnes Dowdy; 1921, Carol R. Cox, Lela Wallis, Ellis Milton, Ian Mensinger, John G. Palstine, Edna Sorem, Harry G. Nickle, Eleanor Dennett, Mr. and Mrs. C. A. Hansen, Clyde Scott, D. D. Mc- Queen, Esther Beard, Nellie Mott, Myrtle Marriott, Vera Green, Mabel Sorem.

Since the graduating class of 1886, hundreds have been crowned with the same scholastic honors and as we have recorded the first class, why not the last class, the graduates of June 17, 1921, at the Modesto theater? The baccalaureate program follows :

"Coronation March," from "The Prophet," by Meyerbeer; Selection from "The Bohemian Girl," by Balfe, High School Orchestra. Prayer by Rev. H. S. Brewster; Hymn, "Come, Thou Almighty King," congregation and choir. Scripture reading by Rev. E. H. Gum; "Gloria" from "Mass, in C," Mozart, combined Glee Clubs. Sermon by Bishop W. R. Lambough ; Hymn, "Now the Day is Over," Barnby, Congregation and Choir. Benediction by Rev. C. P. Morgan. Postlude, selected. High S( hool orchestra.

Commencement exercises were held at the Modesto theater. Rev. H. K. Pittman of San Francisco delivered the address, and diplomas were awarded by City Superintendent W. E. Faught.

School Day Memories It seems regretful, ofttimes, that these ancient buildings may not be preserved. The many pleasant days in the old school will ever remain in the minds of the pupils who there attended school during those thirty odd years. These memories cannot be destroyed. From that building graduated the first high school class of ten, three boys and seven girls. Proud, exceedingly proud were they of their scholarship. Prof. R. R. Holway, Mr. Wyman, David S. Braddock, Thomas Downey and many others sent out their graduates to begin life's battle. There for many years the Teachers' Institute was held and there many delightful entertainments were given. Many socials were given in the homes of the scholars' parents. One of the graduates of the first class says, in writing of Professor Holway: "He was a firm believer in a sane and active social life for the school folks. He and his estimable wife, formerly Miss May Gordon and one of the teachers in the grammar school, promoted a number of pleasant gatherings among the younger folks that are yet remembered by the pupils of that day. These parties extended all through the high school year and were the rule throughout Mr. Holway's principalship in the Modesto school. These functions were held at the homes of the pupils and were simple affairs consisting of pleasant games and other amusements. They served to create a desirable intimacy between the school and the home, between the parents and the teachers, a condition that prevailed in Modesto thirty-five years ago."

The first institute in Modesto was held March 21, 1871. "The town was then only six months old and the accommodations were not of the best." Prof. Ezra S. Carr of the State University and Prof. Charles Allen of the State Normal School were present and delivered some able addresses. There were twenty-eight teachers from the county in attendance. The state superintendent, O. P. Fitzgerald, also present, in reporting the institute said: "It was a great success, all things considered."

At this institute there were over forty teachers, among them Mary Aull, Clara C. Pendergast, Louise S. Crow, Mrs. A. C. Walden, Viva Lane, Mrs. A. G. Bradbury, Abba Hurley, Emma Donnels, Anna Pulsifer, Fanny Jones, Ella Lewis, Lizzie W. Swan, Eva Aull, Mary McAlpine, Helen Pettit, Priscilla Edwards, Lucy Bruton,

The first association assembled at Langworth, January 3, 1868. It was organized under the direction of the county superintendent, Thomas T. Hamlin. He was elected chairman and Thomas Blake, secretary. The historian gives us no further information regarding this meeting. It seems, however, that they again assembled April 14th in the "little brick" schoolhouse, with Hamlin again acting as chairman. They gave a short program comprising an essay, "Education" by W. R. Also; essay, "Schools," E. R. Crawford ; reading, "The Old Log House," L. W. Crawford ; essay, "Knowledge is Power," Thomas Blake; essay, "A Mother's Love," Carrie Moore. The association soon after this meeting disorganized because of a lack of attendance and indifference to its objects. Eleven years later, however, they quickly reorganized, meeting November 14, 1879, in Modesto. They assembled and were somewhat worried over a proposed legislative act to revoke all teachers' certificates. This being a county history we cannot go into the detail of the act. They were, however, quite alarmed and declaring the association formed for "mutual improvement and protection" they strongly protested against the passage of such an act. The association organized by electing W. H. Hatton, now a Modesto lawyer, as president; Vital E. Bangs, vice-president; N. C. Hanscom, secretary, and Mary Aull, treasurer. J. D. Spencei was present. The Senator addressed the association and asserted that he was opposed to any annullment of teachers' certificates. Unanimously the teachers adopted the resolution that a committee of three be appointed to draft a memorial to the Legislature against any legislation tending to revoke the teachers' certificates. W. H. Robinson, Vital E. Bangs and John R. Kelso were appointed on that committee.

Four years later the institute assembled October 21, 1875, called together by the county superintendent, Maj. James Burney. The opening address was made by O. P. Fitzgerald, state superintendent, a minister of the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, and author and the editor of the Methodist denominational publication. Other speakers and essayists on the program included the following teachers: Fanny Lewis of Crows Landing; J. Walter Smith, B. C. Haislip, J. E. Marks, Mary Aull, Man- Madden, Miss Owens of Modesto; Miss Belknap and Jennie Hogan, later of the Stockton schools, and William H. Howard, county superintendent-elect.

In December, 1880, the teachers again assembled at the call of the county superintendent, William H. Robinson. There was then better accommodations for public gatherings. The institute assembled the first day in Rodgers' hall and that afternoon adjourned to the public schoolhouse. The institute continued in session four days. It was organized by the election of the following officers: W. H. Robinson, ex-officio president; Vital E. Bangs, vice-president; John R. Kelso, secretary, and Fanny Jones and Mary Edwards, assistant secretaries. The program comprised lectures by State Superintendent Fred W. Campbell and Professor Allen, essays by the teachers and a general discussion on the best methods of teaching.

Chapter Eleven Crimes And Tragedies Of Stanislaus

The pioneer days of every country are marked with a riot of vice and crime, including drunken carousals, gambling, sensuality, robbery and murder. In the sparsely settled territory the criminals seem to outnumber the law abiding class, and they have but little fear of arrest or punishment, for the committing of crime is easy and detection and punishment difficult. In Stanislaus County there was no speedy means of communication, no mail service, telegraph or telephone lines and no organized police service. A man could easily commit a crime, jump upon a horse and speed away to the mountains or hide in the river bottom and work his way out of the county. The officers of the law, few in number, were ofttimes not over zealous in the performance of their duty. Sometimes, if a friend or influential citizen were the guilty party, they would make but little, if any, effort to arrest him and his trial in court would be a farce. But now, with our quick means of sending out information by wire, the press, the automobile and aeroplane, and our well-organized police force in every county, it is almost impossible for almost any criminal to escape arrest. But he goes unpunished just the same. By the manipulations of shrewd attorneys, bribed jurors and perjured witnesses the same results are accomplished and the guilty escape punishments just as they did in the earlier days, when the sheriff furiously rode in the wrong direction. In this chapter we have compiled a few of the hundreds of crimes committed in Stanislaus County. We will read of a few convictions and many acquittals.

Stealing By The Wholesale

The great crime of the county numerically was the stealing of horses and cattle. There were regular, organized bands of men controlled by a leader who stole thousands of head of cattle. They were driven into the "pocket," a point of land lying between the Stanislaus and Tuolumne rivers, their marks and brands changed and in the thick brushwood it was impossible for their owners to ever find them. The leader was known far and wide as the "boss" cattle thief. He had his counterpart in an organized band who stole horses all over the state, many of them blooded and valuable animals. A Stockton attorney, then a young man living in the county informs me that at one time there were over 500 stolen animals in the county. One of the leaders' hired men complained that he was given, to work in the harvest field, a new team of horses almost even' day. The horses would be brought in and taken out at night. To write of an event in general terms is not very interesting or conclusive, but to give names would be unjust to their families now living, who are in no manner to blame for the deeds of the relatives.

The Murder Of Sheriff Works The Murder Of Frank Lane

THE MURDER OF SHERIFF WORKS The first murder recorded in Stanislaus County is that of George Works, a former sheriff of Tuolumne County. The murder took place August 7, 1854, at Adamsville, then the county seat. It seems that a well-known desperado named Eli Lyons, who boasted that he had killed sixteen men, was quarreling with another man over the election contest. Works, who was a man fearless of danger, stepped up to Lyons and endeavored to quiet him. The desperado then deliberately drew his revolver and fired two shots at Wo'rks, both shots entering the ex-sheriff's left breast. Works, who was quick on the trigger, drew his revolver and fired four shots at Lyons before he fell. None of the shots hit Lyons. Works died the following day. Immediately after the shooting Lyons went to the blacksmith shop about fifty yards distant and there procured a shotgun, fled into the bushes on the river bank and was lost from sight. Lyons was a man about thirty-two years of age; he was well known, as in Stockton the year previous, 1853, he killed a man named Fredonia. THE MURDER OF FRANK LANE About April 10, 1858, four fine mules and a horse were stolen near San Leandro, Alameda County. The owner advertised a description of the animals, offering a reward, and a description of three suspicious looking men who had been seen traveling along the road with the animals. A few days later a stockraiser named George Wilson, who was living near the Arroyo la Puerta, was looking for some lost cattle, and suddenly came upon three men in camp. Wilson immediately recognized them as the horse thieves described in the circulars posted over the country. The men did not see Wilson and immediately he rapidly rode to the ranch of Samuel Clarke, where a rodeo was taking place. He informed the men of his discovery and Frank Lane of

Knights Ferry, George Wilson, Samuel Baldwin, Alfred Ward immediately started in pursuit of the robbers, followed a few minutes later by Samuel Clarke, William Patterson and R. D. W. Hitchcock. As the advance party came on to the thieves, who were just riding from camp, Wilson called out to them to halt.

Two of the men obeyed the command, but the third man drew up his shotgun and firing at Wilson, missed him. The Lane party returned the fire and as the three robbers were heavil}' armed the bullets flew thick and fast. Wilson fired and one of the robbers fell but was only slightly wounded. The Lane party was completely defeated. Lane was shot in the breast, neck and arms with buckshot and died in twenty minutes. Ward received a charge of shot in his right shoulder and Baldwin was badly wounded in the back by buckshot. By this time the rear guard came up and the robbers retreated to the dense chapparal, dragging their wounded companion with them. The dead and the wounded were taken to the ranch of John McMullen and Wilson rode with all speed to Stockton for a physician and surgeon. Dr. Wm. Kendall responded, reaching the ranch about midnight. The two wounded men, Ward and Baldwin, recovered in a short time.

Hunting for the Criminals Frank Lane was a very popular young man, and his father, Maj. Thomas Lane, was equally popular in Stanislaus and San Joaquin counties. When the murder became known, a number of his warm friends advertised the following: "$1,000 reward will be paid for the delivery of the robbers, dead or alive, who killed Frank Lane." This reward was offered bv R. B. Smith, Davis Porter, Wm. Lane, John White, W. H. Lyons, Ross C. Sargent, Jeremiah Sarles, John R. Bradley, W. C. Bradford and Captain Sweeney. Several different parties began scouring the country in search of the thieves and murderers. We will follow the trail of one man only, the brave colonel, Edward Potter. He followed the trail for over two weeks, sometimes losing it and then again finding it, and May 5 he tracked them to a point near Mariposa. The robbers were located in an almost impenetrable fort among huge rocks and dense underbrush. With a party of seven men, including Sheriff Crippen of Mariposa, Potter advanced to the robbers' retreat. Dismounting from his horse, he bravely advanced upon the trail and the only two men in the stronghold, Anderson and Monroe, began shooting at him. He called to his men and there was a lively hail of bullets. It finally became too hot for the robbers and, running in different directions, they endeavored to escape. Monroe, reaching Potter's horse, jumped on his back and hurried away. He was closely pursued and shot with a double-barreled shotgun, dying in about five minutes. Anderson, who was wounded in the shoulder by a rifle bullet, succeeded in escaping. Running down the gulch he hid in the crevice of a rock. He was found two hours later as, burning with fever from his wound, he crawled out to get a drink of water. He was drinking from his shoe when discovered.

The Mariposa Gazette said. May 8, 1858: "The robber who was wounded and captured is now in jail, and will be taken to Stockton for trial. His name is Anderson, and he is from Ohio. Monroe, the man killed, was from Michigan, and Swan, who escaped, is from New York." He was not taken to Stockton but, unfortunately, was taken to the jail at La Grange, that place as we remember being the county seat of Stanislaus County. A few days later, on May 22, R. W. L. Hitchcock visited the jail and immediately recognized Anderson as one of the party who killed Frank Lane.

Major Bradley also recognized the robber from a description given of him by Hitchcock previous to the time Hitchcock saw Anderson in Jail. Then what happened? As there are no living witnesses and as the perpetrators of mob law were sworn to secrecy, we must depend on the San Joaquin Republican, which said, May 30: "Notwithstanding the fact that the strongest efforts were made to keep the affair a secret, we have learned beyond a doubt that the party which went from Knights Ferry to La Grange, with the intention of hanging the murderer of Frank Lane, succeeded in their object. The party comprised about sixty-one men armed to the teeth, and the capture of the prisoner was made so quietly that most of the citizens of the town were not aware of what was going on. The culprit was hung on a tree immediately opposite the jail. The party then returned to their homes. The reason assigned for the hanging was that some of the witnesses whose evidence was all important for the conviction of the prisoner, were about to leave for Fraser River, and their absence would have assured the acquittal of the prisoner."

The Murder Of A Spaniard

A deliberate and premeditated murder took place September 25, 1858 at Islip's Ferry, on the Stanislaus River. The two men were vaqueros. The Spaniard, Phillip Swearis, was in the employ of Francis Latois, who lived on the south side of the Stanislaus. He and Antonio Ferreas, working for Burton Hope, being together and drinking quite freely, engaged in a fight. The two Spaniards were separated and Swearis went home. That night, Swearis, swimming the river in his clothing, carried with him, holding them above his head, a pair of dry trousers. On reaching the north side of the river, he cast off his wet pants and drew on the dry ones. Then quietly walking to where Antonio was soundly sleeping, he struck him a heavy blow on the head, crushing his skull and instantly killing the sleeping Spaniard. The murderer then awoke another Spaniard and, telling him of the deed, fled to the river bank. It was as the correspondent said, "a horrible murder." The murdered man left a wife and five children in Sonora, having been engaged in herding and driving cattle for Burton Hope.

A Mysterious Murder

In the long list of murders in California, many desperadoes have suddenly departed without any clue to their executioner. In fact, but little if any effort was ever made to find who it was that killed them. The public in general declared, "That saves the county the expense of hanging them and perhaps the life of some good man." Mysterious was the death of a desperate character named Thomas Murray. He was not only a desperado, but a man without any regard for law and order, especially when drunk, which was most of the time. He was a terror to the neighborhood and one of his pranks was whenever he wanted anything in a store or saloon to go and demand it without paying for the article. The storekeeper who dared to question his right would find a cocked revolver pointed at his head. On Friday evening, October 16, 1868, Tom was on a "high old spree," and he became so boisterous that the constable put him in irons. The next morning Tom was comparatively sober and was at supper that evening. Sunday morning he did not appear, and in searching for him a party found him dead, lying in a straw stack about three miles from Tuolumne City.

Frank Bollinger Killed Mysteriously

FRANK BOLLINGER KILLED MYSTERIOUSLY Another unknown murder was that of Frank Bollinger the following year, January 26, 1869, in the street of Tuolumne City. He also was a terror to the neighborhood, and there was not a tear shed at his funeral. "It is no wonder that he was killed, the only wonder is that he was not killed sooner." On the evening previous to his death, Bollinger and two companions began drinking heavily and the desperado, carrying a double shotgun and a pistol, declared that he had four or five men "spotted," that is, marked for death at his hands. Who those men were he did not state. About eleven o'clock that night, however, Bollinger walked out to the home of H. K. Covert, who lived on the edge of the town. Covert was in bed soundly sleeping. He was suddenly awakened, however, by hearing some one shouting, "Ralph! Ralph!" Looking out, he saw Bollinger standing by the window with a shotgun in his hand. Covert went back to bed, but a minute later, hearing the cocking of a gun, he speedily rolled onto the floor. Then again came a cry, "Henry! Henry!" which was Covert's correct name. The cry was immediately followed by a charge of buckshot and "it literally tore the mattress to pieces." A few minutes after the gun report was heard, Bollinger, gun in hand, entered the City Hotel saloon. Mr. Dudley, the proprietor, endeavored to get Bollinger to give up his gun. But the man was sober enough to keep possession of a hot rifle. After a time Dudley succeeded in getting him to bed. The following morning Bollinger arose and after taking a couple of drinks at the bar, he started down the street. When opposite Covert's he turned as if to walk into the saloon. That moment a shot was fired from the saloon and Bollinger fell, wounded by a shotgun, seventeen shot entering his body. He died three hours later. Two men were in the saloon. The coroner's jury brought in a verdict that Frank Bollinger "came to his death from violence from some person or persons unknown."

The Rooney-Cockery Homicide

THE ROONEY-COCKERY HOMICIDE In that same year, same month, December 20, another murder took place less than six miles from Tuolumne City. This was at Paradise, another case of whisky. A man named Michael Rooney, "a very industrious blacksmith of Paradise City," and Thomas Cockery, the butcher, were in a saloon having the social drinks together. In a short time they were both under the influence of liquor and they began fighting. Friends separated them and it was believed that ended the affair. The next day, Cockery, who it appears got the worst of the fight, was around looking for the party who whipped him. In his search he entered Wilson's saloon and while taking a drink with another party suddenly started for the door. Just then the door opened and Rooney entered. They immediately commenced fighting, Cockery with a pistol in his hand and Rooney with a knife. After 'striking at each other two or three times Cockery fired and Rooney fell into the corner crying out, "Murder! Murder!" He died the following day. At the inquest held by Justice Walthall, acting for Coroner Covert, the jury brought in this verdict: "We find that Michael Rooney, age twentysix years, came to his death in a saloon in the basement of the Wilson building by a pistol ball fired by Thomas Cockery. We, the jurors, William B. Johnson, Robert Rutledge, Thomas van Dusen, Alexander Pease, A. M. Hunter, Thomas S. Bentley, E. W. Chapman, Peter Rudge."

The Knights Ferry Murder

At I. D. Morley's ranch near Knights Ferry a murder occurred November 12, 1869, over a piece of land, which was claimed by both parties. During the difficulty Frank Mulligan shot Jacob Keller with a shotgun, three balls entering his breast. There were no witnesses to the shooting and Mulligan claims that he fired in selfdefense. An examination was held before Justice Reedy of La Grange and the facts were brought out that although Keller had a revolver he made no attempt to use it.

The Murphy-Rodgers Homicide

THE MURPHY-RODGERS HOMICIDE Another murder was committed Friday evening, July 7, 1871, in front of the home of Richard Threlfall, at the Blue Cottage, six miles from Knights Ferry. The evidence at the inquest before Coroner Covert shows that the murder was committed from a very trifling incident, a piece of tobacco. A man named Thomas Murphy accused another laborer by the name of Rodgers of taking his tobacco. Rodgers quickly denying it, asserted that he had money enough to buy his own tobacco. Angry also at the insinuation, he further remarked that if Murphy repeated the charge he would slap his mouth. The latter then drawing a butcher knife from its sheath, stabbed Rodgers in the left breast and fled from the scene. The wound was fatal. The killing took place between seven and eight o'clock in the evening. Rodgers was a member of the Summit Lodge of Masons and the following morning twenty-one men started out in different directions to search for Murphy. In the circulars that were sent out broadcast for his arrest he was described as "a large, stout-built Irishman, about five feet eight inches in height, with prominent cheek bones, flat nose, large and full lips, wide mouth, narrow chin and eyes with a peculiar appearance. He walks a little lame."

The Murder At La Grange

Charles Light, who was born at La Grange in 1861, tells of a murder at that place when he was a young man, which has never been erased from his memory. The fight was between Chris Thompson, a laborer, and the hotelkeeper, George Davis by name. Bad blood had existed between them for a long time, and one day Davis, meet- ing his enemy upon the street, killed him with a shotgun. Davis was tried for the crime of murder, convicted and sent to San Quentin. His unfortunate family then moved to Modesto. Davis, at the expiration of his term of imprisonment, returned to Modesto and later died in the county hospital.

The Wood Choppers' Quarrel

Another case of too much whisky was the murder of Moses A. Bryant by Charles Everson, March 2, 1871. The two men were partners in the wood-chopping business and that week were engaged cutting wood for a Mr. Wells on the Tuolumne River near Modesto. The last seen of Bryant was on a Thursday previous to the murder. The following day a strange event happened in which Everson was the principal actor. He went to Tuolumne City, purchased several bottles of whisky and becoming much intoxicated, broke into a house and stole some clothing. He then stole a horse and saddle and bridle and hurriedly rode away. His actions aroused suspicions and inquiry was made for Bryant. Searching parties started out and about eleven o'clock Sunday morning he was found in the Tuolumne River about four miles below the town. The murder caused much excitement, as Bryant was a musician of considerable note and left a wife and two children.

The First Execution

It has been related that in the early '50s many persons were hanged in Stanislaus County by mob law, and as Branch said in writing of the old jail at La Grange, "many a horse thief and murder has been confined within its cells, and several have cut through its walls and escaped ! Others were taken out by the Vigilantes and hung to a tree." One of the last-named individuals was a member of an organized band of horse and cattle thieves. These men had been pursued by the sheriff's party into the Coast Range Mountains. In the sheriff's posse was Frank Lane, a son of Major Lane of Mountain Brow. In the fight which took place with the thieves, Frank Lane was killed. The bandits were all killed except one. He was captured, taken to La Grange, and confined in the jail. One night in June, 1858, a company of men assembled with blackened faces and, breaking in the door of the "calaboose," they took the cattle thief out and hung him to a tree. He was found the following morning by the authorities. At the coroner's inquest the jury brought in the usual stereotyped verdict, "hung by some persons or person unknown."

The Later-Date Cattle Thief

THE LATER-DATE CATTLE THIEF Thirty-five years later the people had become more civilized and they believed that hanging was too severe a punishment for cattle stealing. A case in point was that of Frost Fagan, a well-known farmer near Oakdale. He seems to have been possessed of a strong desire to increase his stock by stealing other people's cattle. He had been arrested several times for cattle stealing but was each time acquitted because of his splendid family connections. Frost was the "black sheep of the family" and on December 12, 1891, he was again tried for cattle stealing. He had the best of counsel, but his previous career told against him and, convicted of the crime, he was sent to the penitentiary.

The Fagan-Meneoman Tragedy

THE FAGAN-MENEOMAN TRAGEDY On October 20, 1872, J. R. Fagan, employed on the ranch of G. T. Davis, about three miles from Turlock, commenced scuffling with a man named McCarty. It finally ended in a fight. A peaceful citizen named Edward Meneoman interfered and pulled Fagan away from his opponent. This act so enraged Fagan that, drawing a revolver, he shot Meneoman, the ball entering about four inches to the right of the navel. Doctors Samuel, McLean and Hart were immediately notified by telegraph of the shooting and they arrived from Modesto on the evening train. They pronounced Meneoman fatally wounded, in fact, he was dying when the physicians arrived. On the same train came Sheriff Rodgers. Throughout the night he searched for the murderer, Fagan, who had immediately fled from the scene bareheaded and on foot. The

Murders His Friend

In 1876, Centennial year, there was another homicide at Turlock, the little town just coming into notice. William Morrow and John Fox had been engaged for a long period of time with a threshing outfit. Being of congenial natures, they became good friends, but whisky caused them to quarrel. Going into Turlock August 20, they entered a saloon and began drinking. Glass after glass of liquor they poured down and then got into an argument, which ended in a fight. They were separated by those who were present in the saloon and this, it was believed, ended the trouble. But they came together again and began fighting, and in a few minutes Morrow, drawing a small pocket knife, stabbed Fox in the breast. He died the following day and Morrow was taken to jail to await the verdict of the grand jury.

Another homicide that year was one which took place July 4, 1876, at Oakdale. A man named Melone was in one of the saloons, and he began drinking freely, celebrating the day, finally becoming very boisterous and quarrelsome. Anticipating an unusually large business that day, the proprietor had employed an extra barkeeper. As Melone had become a nuisance, the barkeeper attempted to put him out of the place. The man showed fight and the barkeeper struck him "a terrific blow" in the face with his fist. Lying unconscious for several hours, he died, probably from concussion of the brain.

The Murder Of James Connolly

Another of the cold-blooded murders of Stanislaus County was that of James Connolly December 22, 1874, at La Grange. He and a man named James Kerrigan were in a saloon and both apparently strangers to each other. Connolly, pretty well intoxicated, was having a heated conversation with a third party when Kerrigan, who was known as William Dona, suddenly drew a revolver and, shooting Connolly in the back of the head, killed him instantly. The cause of the murder was not positively known. It was suspected, however, that Dona was a deserter from the British army, and that Connolly knew of Dona's desertion. Hence, to prevent his desertion being reported to the British Consul at San Francisco, Dona killed his man. In his confession to the sheriff just before his execution, Dona stated : "I write to make known to you and the world that my name is not William Dona, but James Kerrigan. The name Dona I assumed when I deserted from the British army in 1859."

Dona made no effort to escape and he was immediately arrested and taken to Modesto, and imprisoned in the county jail, at that time in the basement of the present courthouse. He was indicted for the unlawful killing of James Connolly. The case was called in the district court January 21, 1875, Judge Samuel Booker of Stockton presiding. The prosecuting attorney was J. J. Scrivner, and the prisoner was represented by two able counsels, H. A. Gehrs and Thomas A. Coldwell. The jurors in the case were all reliable and well-known citizens, namely, B. S. Turpen, L. A. Church, Thomas D. Harp, L. B. Farrish, J. F. Kerr, Joseph Islip, W. C. Dale, Jefferson D. Bentley, W. A. Clark, John James, William Lesher and Samuel Gibson. The prisoner's attorneys claimed that the murder was committed in self-defense, and to prove the absurd plea they put the prisoner on the stand. He swore that Connolly made an attempt to draw a weapon. It was a short trial - less than two days - the jury bringing in a verdict of guilty of murder in the first degree. At that time the only punishment for such a verdict was hanging.

Provenance

Text from History of Stanislaus County California : with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1921, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.