BlockBefore

Modesto, California - History (part 3 of 4)

From History of Stanislaus County California : with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1921. 15,901 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

34 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,901 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Stanislaus County California : with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1921. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Hence, your testimony could not be true ; and as to your assertion under oath, that you shot in necessary self-defense and because Driscoll, your friend, had warned you, Driscell swore positively that he did not do so. I concur in the justice and humanity of the jury. Hence the judgment of this court is that you be hung by the neck until you are dead. The court will inform you that Friday, the 19th day of March next, between the hours of 1 1 o'clock A. M. and 2 o'clock P. M. of that day will be assigned for the execution of the judgment."

Peculiar Efforts to Save Dona's Life Dona was returned to his cell in the basement of the courthouse. And to make his escape impossible, the sheriff placed a chain around his ankle, the loose end being fastened to a ring in the floor of the cell. He was placed in what was known as "the death cell," the only furniture being a small table and a bed. He was now visited at his request by Father William O'Conner of Stockton and several other priests. Many sympathizing friends visited him, also women who brought the condemned criminal flowers and delicacies. They had great sympathy for the live murderer, but not even a thought of the man murdered. A rather peculiar thing and something of a puzzle was the strong efforts of two of Stanislaus' leading citizens, Leonidas C. Branch and Miner Walden, to save the life of Dona. Branch at the time was county clerk and he and Walden claimed it their belief that Dona was an innocent man and had been railroaded to the gallows, as we now express it. It is said that they "crystalized a large public sentiment in favor of executive clemency." What they had done previous to this time, Thursday, March 17, is not of record. On that morning, however, they left Modesto for Sacramento for the purpose of pleading with Governor Pacheco for a commutation of Dona's sentence to life imprisonment. The two men stopped over at Stockton and the press the following morning, commenting on their object, declared, ''It is not a good season for commutations just now and it is believed that the Governor will not interfere." For those persons in Modesto interested in the affair it was a day of intense excitement. Hourly they expected a dispatch from Sacramento, but none was received until near dark. Then H. A. Gehrs received a dispatch requesting him to obtain the names of certain citizens signed to a petition for a reprieve and telegraph the names to Sacramento. This was done. Finding that they could not get a commutation of Dona's sentence to life imprisonment, Branch and Walden swore to an affidavit "that evidence exists and can be produced that will justify a commutation of Dona's sentence from death to imprisonment for life." Where these two men obtained that evidence was never learned, Dona's attorneys knew nothing of it. However, on Friday the executive directed the sheriff "to stay the execution until Friday, April 2."

The Hanging of Dona In the meantime, the murderer assumed the bold appearance of innocence and indifference usually assumed by hardened criminals, and at all times he appeared callous to his condition. He was found invariably to be self-possessed and smoking a pipe. In his death cell he frequently enjoyed a game of cards with the jailer or some of the prisoners. As the day of execution again drew near Branch and Walden again went to Sacramento to plead with the Governor, but he refused to interfere. The news was immediately conveyed to Dona. He received the information in a matter of fact manner and evinced no emotion over the result. In the meantime, as on the former date, preparations were made by the sheriff for the execution. The scaffold, which had been brought from Stockton in March, was erected by carpenters in the courthouse plaza, and around it was built a high board fence, excluding from public sight the gruesome scene. The enclosure was just large enough to admit about thirty persons, the law declaring that at least that number must witness the execution. A large crowd of morbid persons waited upon the outside to witness the hanging or at least see the body. On the previous evening Fathers McCarty and Riordan remained with the criminal throughout the night, giving him spiritual consolation. The following morning "the prisoner appeared cool and calm and apparently undisturbed." At three minutes past one o'clock, Dona, unassisted, ascended the steps of the gallows. He was accompanied by Sheriffs Rodgers and Means of Merced and Deputy Sheriffs Stimpson and Howell of Stanislaus County. On the platform the priest and the condemned man recited the litany for the dead. Dona was then asked by the sheriff if he wished to make any remarks. He declined to say anything. The rope was then placed around his neck, and the trap was sprung. The body dropped five and a half feet, death ensuing instantly. Drs. Jackson and Marks, examining the body twenty-three minutes later, pronounced Dona dead. The body was then taken down and placed in a coffin and at his request in his confession transported to Stockton for burial.

In his confessional letter Dona made the usual talk of men about to be hung for their crime. He said, "I thank you, Sheriff Rodgers, and all of your officials for the many acts of kindness extended to me. I thank my lawyers, also the ladies and gentlemen who took part in trying to have my sentence commuted, and I am willing to die for the crime imputed to me. I die fortified by the sacrament of the Catholic Church. My only request is that my corpse be delivered to Father O'Connor, to be buried in the Catholic cemetery at Stockton." His place of burial is now part of the location of the Holt Manufacturing Company.

The Hill'S Ferry Murder

Hill's Ferry in those days of "good times" was a very lively town of carousals and quarrels. None were more fatal or cold blooded, however, than the murder of an old man, John Shelden, a sheep herder. On August 18, 1875, he and a man named Richard Cullen were drinking at the bar. There were two other men present at the time. Shelden and Cullen had some hot words over an argument and Cullen, drawing a revolver, shot the sheep herder, killing him instantly. Cullen, who was a notoriously bad character and a hardened criminal, immediately left for Stockton. He first took the precaution, however, to tell the two men present that if they told of the murder he would kill them on sight. Fearing the threat, they kept silent. On arrival at Stockton, Cullen boarded the steamer and landing at Antioch, obtained work in the coal mines under the name of James Cassidy. Sheriff Cunningham of San Joaquin County was particularly interested in this murder because of its cold bloodedness in shooting down a poor old man, but was unsuccessful in his search. Finally one day he received a notice that if he would put up a special sum of money, naming the amount, the hiding place of Cullen would be revealed to him. The sheriff put up the money and he was informed that the Hill's Fern* murderer was working in the Antioch coal mines under the name of James Cassidy. A deputy sheriff was sent for the murderer and he was found in the jail at Martinez, arrested for assaulting a Chinaman. The charge of assault was dismissed and Cullen was brought to Stockton and then confined in the Modesto lock-up.

The Second Legal Execution

Cullen, who was known as "Little Dick" and sometimes as "Fighting Dick," was indicted for murder before the grand jury. He was tried in the October term, 1876, of the district court, Judge Samuel A. Booker presiding. The prisoner was defended by Thomas A. Coldwell and C. B. Fitzgerald. The attorneys made the best plea possible for the prisoner's acquittal, but the jury, after being out twenty-three hours, brought in a verdict "guilty of murder in the first degree" and fixed the penalty death. Judge Booker, who had served in many murder trials, either as attorney or judge, sentenced Cullen to be "hung by the neck, November 24, 1876, until he be dead and may God have mercy on your soul." This was the usual ending of murder sentences at that time. At the passing of the sentence Cullen "was cool and indifferent and took the sentence more as a joke than as a matter of life and death," said an eyewitness.

After his sentence, iron shackles were placed around his ankles to prevent his escape by any possible means. "Yesterday morning, November 24, 1876," says the telegraphic report, "Cullen's shackles were removed by the blacksmith, a barber was called in and shaved the doomed man, after which he partook of a hearty breakfast being in good spirits and quite cheerful. He refused to be interviewed, but learning that several officers were present from adjoining counties, he consented to see them, especially Sheriff Cunningham, whom he well knew. The evening previous to his execution Father Riordan had prayed with the condemned man and had visited him several times during his confinement. The death warrant was read to Cullen by the sheriff at 1 1 :30 o'clock in a room adjoining the jail. He then walked with a springy step and composed air to the foot of the scaffold. After stepping upon the trap and while his arms were being pinioned, he continued repeating the prayers of the church after Father Riordan. As the prisoner declined making any remarks, the black cap was drawn over his head and at 12:17 Sheriff Rodgers cut the rope that held the weight and the trap fell. In ten minutes he was pronounced dead by Doctors Jackson and White. The scaffold used at this execution was loaned to Sheriff Rodgers by San Joaquin County. It had been used in the execution of William Dona at Modesto in 1875, of James Murphy at Stockton and Estrala Mortimer at Sacramento. It was a scaffold invented by A. B. Bennett, a deputy sheriff under Thomas Cunningham. Present at the execution were several sheriffs, Baxter of Tuolumne, Morse of Alameda, Cunningham of San Joaquin and Harris of Sacramento.

Edward Bentley Murder

EDWARD BENTLEY MURDER Young Bentley, the son of Jefferson D. and Eliza Bentley, was born in Knights Ferry in 1860 and early in life engaged in the real estate business in Delano, Kern County. While on a business visit returning from Visalia, February 22, 1889, on the Southern Pacific, the train was held up about eight o'clock just south of Pixley by two train robbers. They climbed over the locomotive tender and covering the engineer and fireman with their revolvers ordered them to stop the train. It being something unusual for the train to stop at that place, Edward Bentley stepped from the car and went forward to see what was the trouble. One of the robbers, commanding him to halt, immediately fired a charge of buckshot into his stomach and arm. He exclaimed, "My God! I am shot," and fell to the earth. He was picked up and placed in the car and the train hurried on to Delano. Surgeons were immediately called and it was found that he was mortally wounded by seventeen buckshot in his stomach and arms. The young man died the following day and his body was brought to Modesto. The funeral took place from the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, Rev. B. F. Bunis delivering a very appropriate funeral discourse. The church was crowded with sympathizing friends and relatives. Very appropriate hymns were sung by the quartette comprising Miss Hayden, Mrs. Shuck, T. B. C. Rice and C. W. Eastin, with Mr. Goeffert at the organ.

Barney Garner Shoots Jerry Lockwood

In the early '60s there came to California from Tennessee, his native state, a young Irishman by the name of Barney B. Garner. He located at Knights Ferry and engaged in the honorable business of purchasing and selling wood. In 1867, however, he removed to Tuolumne City and opened a saloon. With the inherent qualities of a leader, he took a hand in politics and was soon recognized as a political boss. Although he could control men and obtain their votes, he could not control his temper, and when drunk was a very dangerous, bullying person. With his influence in politics and his ugly temper, many persons feared him, especially after his coldblooded murder of Jerry Lockwood. At this time, 1871, Barney had removed to Modesto, and on Front Street opened up the Marble Palace. For some reason Barney quarreled with Lockwood, who was a gambler and keeper of a house of ill-fame, and threatened to kill him. One day Barney hid in the disrenutable house, lying in wait for his victim, and just as Jerry came through the door Barney shot and killed him. He was tried for the crime and acquitted. We have already recorded Barney's act in slapping the face of W. E. Turner, the attorney, and this and many other acts caused the police to fear him.

The Marshal Kills Garner

It was Saturday evening, August 1, 1890. The Marble Palace was doing a good Saturday night business and as usual many persons had congregated in the saloon and on the sidewalk, talking over the affairs of state, little dreaming that the greatest tragedy of the county would soon take place and the law be upheld. Garner was abusively drunk and raising considerable disturbance ; finally the marshal walked in. He was a new man in the office, untried and inexperienced, but brave and fearless in the performance of his duty. Walking up to Barney, the officer said: "Barney, you must quit this." Barney replied: "You allow the fellows down the street to swear and fight and then you come up here and arrest me." The marshal had said nothing about arresting him but Barney believing that the marshal intended to arrest him, stepped back a couple of paces and put his right hand into his pocket, as if to draw a weapon and kill the officer. On the part of the marshal it was a case of self defense, for the officer in the performance of his duty has a perfect right to defend his life. Quickly drawing his revolver with his left hand, the marshal fired twice. One shot entered Garner's left shoulder, the other his head just above the ear, killing him instantly. Coroner Phelps and his deputy, R. L. Quisenberry, now residing in Stockton, took charge of the body and carried it to the morgue, then on H Street, between Front and Tenth streets. On examination of the corpse, the Coroner found in the right hand pocket a loaded Derringer pistol, half cocked. This was sufficient evidence of the intent of the saloonkeeper. The following day the body was taken to Barney's home, on I Street, in the alley between Ninth and Tenth. Coroner Phelps summoned a jury to investigate the case. They met in the office of Justice Whitby and comnrised some of the most respected, law-abiding citizens of Modesto, as follows: W. E. Daunt, John A. Witty, F. L. Shirran, John J. Dolan, D. S. Husband, W. J. Thompson, Cyrus Lee, W. K. McMullen, O. L. Wakefield, N. B. Williams and T. E. B. Rice. After hearing all of the evidence, they brought in a verdict: "We, the jurors summoned to inquire into the death of Barney B. Garner, find that he was killed by an officer in the performance of duty and that it was a justifiable homicide."

A Case Of Poisoning

A peculiar case, one in which the sympathy of the public strongly favored the prisoner, was that of Julia O'Meara, accused of attempting to poison her father, March 27, 1892. The young lady and her affianced husband, Chris Albert, who was in the employ of O'Meara on his ranch, were arrested for the alleged crime, and they were released on bail. O'Meara strongly opposed the marriage of his daughter and he declared that they had attempted to get rid of him. The case was called April 12, in Modesto, and the old gentleman testified that on the day named in the complaint, March 27, he found a pitcher of water sitting on the table and a tumbler very convenient for him to take a drink. It was something very unusual, but thinking nothing of it he took a mouthful of water. He immediately spat it out, it was so bitter. The following morning another very unusual thing happened. When he was called to breakfast, Julia, who poured out the tea on this occasion, had the tea already served. He drank some of it, although it was very bitter, was taken sick and had convulsions for nearly eight hours. The physician saved his life. Two other daughters, testifying, said that Julia and her lover had a long secret conversation previous to the poisoning of their father. Julia poured the tea. No one else could have poured it. The poison was strychnine, which was kept on the place to poison squirrels. The evidence also showed that O'Meara "was a harsh, exacting father and taskmaster." He compelled the girls to arise at four o'clock in the morning and compelled them to work in the field like able-bodied men. The district attorney, after a consultation with the father, dismissed the case. O'Meara was not very pleased with the turn of affairs, but a strong public opinion in favor of the daughter caused him to give his consent. It is probable that soon afterward he lost two of his best help, the hired man and Julia.

Suicide Of Isaac Brinkerhoff

SUICIDE OF ISAAC BRINKERHOFF In 1889, Isaac Brinkerhoff, one of the oldest residents of Modesto and a man quite wealthy, began acting in a strange, unnatural manner. He was taken before Judge Minor March 8 and examined by Doctors Evans and Wilhoit. They pronounced him insane, and he was sent to the insane asylum. His aged wife strongly opposed his being confined, and after a court trial he was discharged from custody and the faithful wife took him again to their Modesto home. On the morning of August 21, 1889, the old gentleman, arising at four o'clock, told his wife that he was going out to pick figs. He did not return at breakfast time and his son Charles could not find him. Then, quite anxious at his disappearance, Mrs. Brinkerhofr aroused the neighborhood, but he could not be located. About noon, however, an Italian named Guiseppi, on going into a shed about 300 yards from the Brinkerhoff home, found him hanging from the rafters; apparently he had been dead for several hours. He had obtained a rope, and placing one end around his neck, had stepped upon the tongue of a wagon, fastened the other end around the rafters and then swung off, strangling himself.

A Brutal Murder

A BRUTAL MURDER At Oakdale on Christmas evening of the year 1893, Edom Lowe was robbed and brutally beated to death by Charles Inglis. Lowe was employed on one of the ranches in the vicinity of Oakdale and visited the town to celebrate the day. Drinking frequently at the bar, he soon became intoxicated, but was in no manner boisterous or quarrelsome. Late in the evening Lowe left the saloon and Inglis followed after him. A few minutes later a scuffling was heard. No attention was paid to the noise. The following evening between seven and eight o'clock Lowe was found upon a side street, unconscious, with knife stabs in his left breast and his head horribly beaten up, as if struck by some heavy instrument. Suspicion was at once attracted to Charles Inglis, as he was a worthless fellow, a hanger on in the town, and had served a term in the penitentiary. Constable Swartzel arrested Inglis and after considerable search a knife was found. It was quite a formidable-looking weapon and the scabbard and blade were spattered with blood. It is supposed that Inglis attempted to rob Lowe, and in the scuffle he stabbed and beat his victim into insensibility. Inglis was taken to the Modesto jail, awaiting the outcome of Lowe's injury.

Another Cowardly Murder

This murder took place at Cottonwoods near Newman on the evening of January 9, 1891. A Mrs. MacDonnell was visiting her mother, Mrs. Pendelton. The family were sitting conversing in the parlor when an unknown person approached and fired a forty-four-caliber rifle bullet through the window. The ball struck Mrs. Mac- Donnell, killing her instantly. Footprints were tracked from the window to the home of E. T. Hale, some two miles distant, and he was arrested and taken to Los Banos. It was known that he had borrowed a rifle the day previous to the murder and a rifle was found in his home. The prisoner admitted having a rifle, yet he denied borrowing it. Mrs. John Hale, his sister-in-law, testified at the coroner's inquest, January 15, that she saw Hale carrying a gun from her husband's house, the day before the cowardly act was committed. The cause of the murder is unknown, and was a complete mystery except in this: Mrs. MacDonnell formerly worked for E. T. Hale's wife, and one day the two women, quarreling over wages, became bitter enemies.

Blacksmith Murders Purcell

In 1892 there lived in Oakdale an old blacksmith, fifty-eight years of age, named Andrew Boss. He had a good business but a bad reputation, and although a member of a splendid family, he was a black sheep. There was another man in Oakdale, a young man twenty-six years of age, by the name of Purcell. His family were good, law-abiding, respected citizens, but the young fellow was a hanger on around houses of bad repute. One day, the afternoon of October 15, 1892, Purcell wandered into Boss' blacksmith shop. Soon after this they began quarreling, a shot was heard and Purcell fell mortally wounded, the ball penetrating his left lung. Boss said Purcell was trying to steal his tools. Constable Swartzel took charge of the blacksmith and the physicians attended Purcell.

The Father'S Revenge

THE FATHER'S REVENGE In every town there are men of dissolute character who make it a part of their business to entice young girls into houses of infamy either for the gratification of their own lust or for profit. Such a person was John Kelley. Somewhere in the summer of

1879 he made the acquaintance at Sutter Creek of a fifteen-year-old girl named Speekman, the daughter of John Speekman, an old resident of the mining town. One day the girl disappeared, and coming to Modesto about August 5 she was met by Kelley and taken to a house of prostitution. The father by some means heard that the girl was in Modesto and he telegraphed the chief of police to arrest her. When the officer went to make the arrest the girl could not be found. She had been taken to Hill's Ferry. A few days later her brother, traveling on foot from the Creek, for the family were quite poor, arrived in search of the wayward sister. Kelley, meeting the young man, threatened to kill him if he did not return home. The young man then consulted Attorneys Hazen & Johnson. They advised him to return to Sutter Creek, obtain a warrant for his sister, and then, if necessary, take her by force. The boy returned, informed his father of the attorneys' advice and then swore out a warrant. The legal proceedings in some manner unknown were delayed. The father arose from a bed of sickness and also traveling afoot, arrived in Modesto, August 14. There was considerable excitement in the little town, for the "Regulators" had appeared and commanded every gambler, saloonist and disreputable to leave the town within twentyfour hours. The following morning when the northbound Southern Pacific steamed to the depot there was a rush of undesirables to get on board. The exodus was so great that the number surprised many of the citizens. In the crowd of sightseers was Speekman, intently watching to get a sight of his daughter. The depot then was at the corner of Front and I streets. The locomotive bell was ringing and as the conductor was about to shout "all aboard" two persons suddenly appeared from a nearby saloon, dragging or partly dragging a companion so drunk he was helpless. It was John Kelley. The companions succeeded in reaching the platform and as soon as Speekman saw his daughter's seducer he rushed forward and stabbed him four or five times in the breast with a penknife. Bystanders quickly grasped the old half-crazed father, but the act was so sudden that the victim had been mortally wounded. The two companions endeavored to board the train, taking the wounded man with them. He was bleeding badly and probably dying and the conductor refused him passage. The two men then boarded the cars and left Kelley to his fate. The wounded man was taken across the street into the Stanislaus Restaurant and attended by Doctors Ray and McLean. He died four days later. Speekman gave himself up to the police. He was immediaetly taken before Justice of the Peace C. W. Eastin and released under a fifty dollar bail, the citizens quickly putting up the bail bond. In the meantime the daughter had been brought over from Hill's Ferry and she returned home to Sutter Creek with her father.

THE MacCRELLISH FAMILY Public opinion, as fickle as the wind, shifts as quickly. In the Speekman affair there was not the least doubt of Kelley's guilt, and public opinion was just when it exclaimed, "It served him right." In the Robbins affair which we will now record, there was a strong doubt regarding his guilt, yet the public declared him guilty and threatened to lynch him. Then many declared him innocent of the crime, and later tame a doubt that has not to this day been cleared up. Before narrating the trial, we must first observe the principals in the affair, the MacCrellish family. They comprised the father, mother and two girls, Lulu and Dora, their ages eleven and fifteen. In 1883 the family removed from Mariposa County to Stanislaus County. They took up their abode in a small house in the rear of the wayside saloon of John H. Doane, about six miles out on the Waterford road, and the following year they moved into Modesto. The family were very profligate in character and at the trial facts were established "that Mrs. MacCrellish was driven out of another town for using her daughters as blackmailers." In that same trial the girls perjured themselves "and lied fearfully and described immoralities without an iota of shame or scruple."

In August, 1882, a man named John J. Robbins located in Modesto as editor of the "Farmer's Journal." He was incompetent for the position, it seems, and was soon "fired." He did not leave the town, as do most editors when discharged, and look up another job, but concluded that next he would practice law at Modesto. His wife came to Modesto and Robbins put out his sign as an attorney. He was a "fine looking man, over six feet in height and weighing about 200 pounds." His clientele did not keep him very busy and soon it was observed by persons in the vicinity of his office that he was fond of little girls, "and often asked them into his office, petted them and giving them candies told them stories." The youngest MacCrellish girl, Lulu, soon wandered past his door and in July, 1883, the police were informed that Robbins had taken undue liberties with her. The girl herself it seems gave the information, but with no other evidence the police could not make any arrest. Watching the case closely, however, they believed soon after that they had evidence sufficient to secure conviction, and on August 18 Robbins was arrested, he was taken before Justice C. W. Eastin, and released on bail of $2,500, J. P. Trainor of the Ross House and Dr. Tynan going his security. As soon as the arrest became known, "excited men stood on the corners and talked of lynching him." Robbins' friends, fearing that the mob might attempt it, advised him to leave town or he would be lynched. Taking their advice, he left on the first northbound train. As soon as his bondsmen learned of his departure, they surrendered him to the sheriff. The wires were made hot with messages looking for Robbins. He was intercepted and arrested by the constable at Lathrop. The sheriff and his deputy, Simmons, went on to Lathrop and got their prisoner. Fearing, however, that an attempt would be made to lynch Robbins if they returned with him to Modesto, they went on to Stockton and lodged him in the hotel "De Cunningham." Their prediction seemed to have been well founded, for the mob went wild and over 300 of them gathered at the depot awaiting the southbound train and Robbins. They fully intended to have a necktie party, in which the principal participant would be the prisoner. Robbins was confined in the jail at Stockton until August 30. At that time Sheriff Cunningham received word to release the prisoner. Public opinion was changing and although his bail had been increased to $5,000, twice the former amount, J. P. Trainor and Dr. Thomas Tynan again became his bondsmen.

Arrest of John H. Doane Two days after the arrest of Robbins, John H. Doane was arrested, charged with a similar offense against Dora MacCrellish. At the same time Albert Beck, a young man in the employ of William Brown, the photographer, was arrested charged with taking the photographs of young girls unattired. The two men were placed in jail and again the mob was furious and seriously talked of lynching both Doane and Beck. Fearing that the mob would attempt to get possession of the man and hang them, the sheriff "placed a guard of five men with Winchester rifles inside the cage with the prisoner to protect him." In the meantime Doane was released on bail. The preliminary trial of Doane was called September 18, before Justice of the Peace C. W. Eastin. The entire day was taken up with the examination of the girl Dora. Her testimony was unshaken, according to the Herald, "except as to minor details." Upon cross-examination, however, by the attorney for the defense, there was no direct evidence against Doane, and he was discharged from custody.

The Comments of the Press Soon after the discharge of Doane the Herald said : "There is no doubt that a serious offense has been committed, either rape or perjury. It is not in order to let the Robbins case go by default. An investigation would be a farce. But the people will not yield one jot of their opinion in the Robbins case any more than they have done in the case of Doane." The Farmer's Journal, August 24, published a rather peculiar statement. It said regarding the guilt or innocence of Robbins and Doane: "Although some have changed their minds, still the feeling is high and should the evidence turn against the prisoners, then there will be but little use for the superior court in the matter. The MacCrellish girls have told some pretty tough stories, still they have told enough truth to make the case a strong one." Then in the same article it declared : "The people who wanted to hang Robbins so fast have notably changed.

It is now believed that there is no foundation for the grave charge against Robbins." Four days later, August 28, the same paper said: "The sentiment of Modesto is fast assuming a different aspect and it looks as if the men who have been arrested are the victims of a nicely laid plot." A little later a correspondent declared: "The change in public opinion is wonderful. They believe there will be no case made out against the accused parties. There is a talk of tar and feathers for the MacCrellish family."

Robbins was placed on trial in February, 1884, in the superior court of Modesto, Judge A. Hewel presiding. There was an array of able attorneys, William E. Dudley of Stockton and W. E. Turner for the defense, and District Attorney John C. Simmons, John B. Kittrelle and W. O. Miner, later county judge, for the prosecution. After a three days' rigid examination the following jury was accepted: J. M. Board, Henry Gregg, R. R. Snedigar, J. M. Watson, John McGovern, S. LeClert, J. R. Mickey, J. F. Beausong, J. B. Brooks, A. M. Standiford, A. R. Anderson and Frank Jenkins. At the request of Attorney Dudley, but against the protest of Kittrelle, the trial proceeded with closed doors.

When the case was given to the jury, they retired and in a few minutes returned a verdict, "not guilty." Notwithstanding the verdict of the twelve honorable men and the depraved character of the two principal witnesses, many of the citizens believed Robbins and Doane guilty of the crime and we will again hear of them in the second raid of the Vigilantes.

The Gamblers' Rendezvous

If the accounts be true, Modesto in 1879 was not a very desirable place to live, especially for respectable families, as it was the resort of thieves, gamblers and prostitutes from all parts of the state. The cause of this immigration of undesirables was the splendid wheat crop of that year. To harvest the crop required hundreds of laborers. They made plenty of money and every Saturday night, coming in from the harvest fields, they would "buck the tiger, consort with women and get as drunk as lords." At the risk of repetition, we will give two accounts of the condition of things in that year, a condition which caused the organization of the Regulators. The first account referring to the abundant harvest says: "After two years of drought, two lean years that have become historic in the annals of the county, the wonderful bounteous crop of 1879 brought renewed life and hope and vigor, which gave an impetus to business of all descriptions. The wealth of garnered grain also brought to Modesto a flock of gamblers, women of shady character, together with men of other activities equally undesirable, who came hither to gain their illicit share of the profits of the industrious farmer and the wages of the rural worker. The opium joints and the gambling halls were permitted to run at full swing. The dance hall spread its baneful influence over the entire community, and from the very center of the town, the tenderloin crew rode in Modesto's saddle and controlled the town."

In August, '79, the Herald declared: "For years past Modesto has been the rendezvous of gamblers, thieves, rollers and gentlemen of that ilk, who seem to entertain the opinion that they were secure from molestation by police officrs and could ply their nefarious business without the fear of the law. They said that when they could not remain anywhere else they could come to Modesto and be safe from any annoyance. Dance houses and opium dens loomed up in the distance and these places were thronged nightly by these human hyenas, their orgies being kept up until a late hour. Drunken men were rolled and robbed on the streets, ladies were insulted, young lads were enticed into their dens of iniquity and numerous offenses committed."

The March Of The Vigilantes

criminal class. The organization of the Vigilantes was not a spontaneous uprising like that of a mob in a great city, but the work of men who had been planning the movement for several months. One account says their place of meeting was in an old warehouse on a high and knolly plot of ground between Modesto and Ripperdan, and that the members were called to meeting by verbal request or by messengers. Another account says that they met in the Odd Fellows Hall and that the members were notified of a meeting by secret cards or signs posted in the Modesto show windows. The time set for their raid was Thursday evening, August 14, 1879. That night the men "ssembled wearing black masks and grasping their trusty weapons - shotguns, pistols and swords - they quietly marched along H Street to Tenth and along that street to Sullivan's dance hall. The saloon was all ablaze with lights and a merry throng. Some of the fellows and girls were merrily dancing while others were drinking and carousing at the bar. On arrival at Sullivan's, the Vigilantes halted. Their brave captain then stepping forth demanded that Sullivan appear. The saloonist appeared and he was told to close his saloon ^and "git out." He skipped in short order. Long before this time, pandemonium reigned in the house, and the frightened women, unfortunate outcasts of humanity, ran in every direction ; some ran to their rooms and hid under their beds, while others, scantily dressed, ran down the street. Having won this battle with no loss of life, the valiant army next visited the alleys between G and H streets. Then they visited more houses on Tenth and Front streets. Everywhere the result was the same: the enemy fled in great dismay. Next marching to Johnson's dance hall, corner of H and Eighth streets, they notified that worthy to close his "shebang." He complied. Sure, for he remained in town and for a long time thereafter was one of the officers of the law in Modesto. Johnson, like Garner, had a political pull. Having visited the high-toned places where gentlemen congregated, the Vigilantes next visited the "heathen Chinee," as Bret Harte styled them in his poem. "Ropes were placed around some of the opium shanties, and with the combined tugging of the Vigilantes they were razed to the ground." The ruins were searched for pipes and other smoking paraphernalia, fan tan layouts and faro tables. These were placed in the public square and a huge bonfire made of them. There was at that time, you remember, a great hue and cry and the watchword of the parties was "the Chinese must go." They had no redress in the courts for damages, no influence nor votes, hence the destruction of their property. But the saloons where men were crazed with liquor and murders were committed, where girls were seduced" - they remained intact. The following day it seemed as if Modesto would be partly depopulated, so great was the departures of undesirables, some going to Stockton and some to Oakdale. The News declared, August 22: "Since the raid of the raiders, our streets have been quiet. The gay gamboliers and the demimonde, at least, are not so common a sight. The good citizens of Oakdale complain that the dissolute characters have located in their midst since the late raid at Modesto."

Constable Spier Shoots A Disreputable Character

CONSTABLE SPIER SHOOTS A DISREPUTABLE CHARACTER In 1890 two shooting events similar in character took place, the one at Turlock with no dangerous results, the other at Modesto with fatal results. The first was of a man, just a common drunkard and unsavory character, the other a periodical drinker, a known murderer and a saloonkeeper high up in the political circles of Modesto County. Early in the morning on November 1, 1890, past midnight, when all respectable citizens are soundly sleeping, Seaton Boren was in a Turlock saloon, considerably under the influence of liquor. The name of the saloon I know not, for the press took good care in those days not to injure the business of any saloon. Anyhow, Boren was in this saloon and finally he became so noisy and quarrelsome that the constable was called in to quiet or arrest him. When Constable Spier attempted to arrest him he began to fight and in the scuffle he was shot in the thigh by Spier's pistol.

Drowning Of The Baker Boys

One of the most distressing accidents of Stanislaus was the drowning in September, 1889, of the three sons of C. C. Baker, who lived near the Tuolumne River, about eight miles from Modesto. It appears that the boys, George W., eight years of age, Oliver, eleven, and Christopher, thirteen years old, accompanied by a companion named Walter Garrison, started from the house about three o'clock in the afternoon for a swim in the river. About an hour later, J. L. Crossmore, who was in the employ of Baker, found young Garrison by the side of the house sobbing and crying as if his heart would break. Mr. Crossmore inquired: "What is the matter?" The boy exclaimed between his sobs: "The boys are drowned in the river." Mr. Crossmore gave the alarm and hurried to the river, accompanied by the father. A few minutes later R. B. Drew arrived. Solicitous for the condition of Mr. Baker, who had heart disease, he persuaded the father to return to his home. He was accompanied by his employee. Mr. Drew then entering the water with a long stick, for the river was low, began poking around. He soon came across the body of the eldest boy. He was in a deep hole made by the eddying of the current when the river was swiftly flowing. In a short time other persons engaged ;n the search and about sundown Ben Ducker found the body of George Baker. About nine o'clock that night he discovered Oliver's body. They were buried from the Christian Church and the Stanislaus Pioneer Society attended the funeral in a body, Mr. Baker being one of their members. The funeral was one of the largest ever held in the county. There was a strong and heartfelt sympathy for the grief-stricken parents and Mrs. Ben Ducker composed a very sj'mpathetic poem on the occasion. The following are the first eight and last four lines.

"They are sleeping, sweetly sleeping Your precious loved ones dear, They have gone to live with Jesus, And their voices no more you'll hear. They are sleeping, sweetly sleeping, Can you wish to wake them now ? Where not one trace of sadness Can cross their precious brow.

Thomas Owens Suddenly Disappears

THOMAS OWENS SUDDENLY DISAPPEARS In the sudden disappearance of Thomas Owens we see in a nutshell the faithful devotion of a wife through eight long years, the strong faith of a newspaper man in his honesty and integrity and the perfidy of a man unworthy of the love of a good woman or true friend. In 1889, Thomas Owens was appointed collector of the Modesto Irrigation District. He made good, was highly respected, believed to be honest and had in his possession at one time as high as $3,000 of the money of the company. In 1892 he suddenly disappeared. In looking over his account with the district there was a shortage of $695. Then he was denounced as an embezzler and a scoundrel for taking the district money and deserting a wife and two small children. The Herald defended the man and publicly declared there was no justification for the "foul slander." Owens' bondsmen were compelled to make good the deficit and the faithful wife, by selling the little home and other means, succeeded in paying the bondsmen their loss within two years. Mrs. Owens with her children, in 1895, moved to Stockton and succeeded in supporting the family by dressmaking. In May, 1900, Mr. Owens returned to his family and his own confession, as given to a press reporter, tells the tale. He said the cause of his departure was the fact that he had spent a part of the Modesto Irrigation money in aiding a friend in his campaign for the office of district attorney. When an accounting was called for he did not have the money and did not feel like asking his friends to help him out. He left ostensibly for Visalia without informing anyone of his intention. He went direct to Los Angeles and from there by steamer to San Francisco. Remaining a few days he then went to Napa and under the name of Thomas Oliver engaged in the carpenter trade. He remained there three years and sent not a word to his family. Then going to Oregon he assumed his right name and there remained until 1897. He then went to Dawson City and saw three or four fellows who knew him in Modesto, but they could tell him nothing about his wife. He remained in Dawson until the winter of 1899 and about eight months ago joined the Salvation Army and took a prominent part. Mrs. Owens had heard that he was in Dawson and wrote him a letter. He did not get it, as it probably was on the steamer Stratton, which sunk. She again wrote and he received it about December. He answered it and, receiving a second letter in February (1900) began making preparations to return to California and his family. The home coming, says the reporter, was a joyous one, though the daughters, then thirteen and fifteen years of age, had only a dim recollection of their father. The first of the article says, "The charge of embezzlement against Thomas H. Owens for absconding with funds "of the Modesto Irrigation District was dismissed today (May 7, 1900) by Judge Minor on motion of District Attorney Walthall. A lengthy petition signed by many property holders and respected citizens, asking that the action be dismissed, probably influenced Judge Minor's action."

A Vigilante Kills John H. Doane

A VIGILANTE KILLS JOHN H. DOANE When the law-abiding citizen takes the law in his own hands and breaks it, can he expect to have the criminal class respect and obey the laws? The Regulators in 1879 had threatened the lives of citizens and unmolested, destroyed the property of the Chinese. Following their work there was no change for the better in the criminal class. There were the usual shooting affairs, the same drunken carousals and the wide-open gambling, robbery and prostitution. Nor were the police authorities willing to or enabled to enforce the law. A series of events took place in May, 1883, which brought things to a crisis. One of these events was the so-called bridge riot. Near the Bridge House a party of five toughs led by the notorious Joe Buckner, familiarly known as Joe Long, robbed and brutally beat up two Frenchmen. Two months later a gambler named Muram shot to death a youth of sixteen years near Turlock. Then came the charges against Doane and Robbins by the MacCrellish girls. While the excitement was high and threats repeatedly made by the mob that they would hang the two men regardless of judge or jury, word was sent out by the Vigilantes of 1879 to reorganize. The Vigilantes committee reassembled at their old headquarters early in 1884 and very considerately awaited the action of the court in the Robbins trial. Doane had been discharged in the preliminary trial by Justice Eastin, there being considerable doubt regarding his guilt. Robbins was given a fair and impartial trial in February, 1884, as we have already noted, and a jury, some of Modesto's highly respected citizens, declared him not guilty. If the verdict of the jury was satisfactory to the Regulators, well and good, but if not satisfactory then "the death of Doane and Robbins had been decreed by them." Neither the decision of Justice Eastin in the Doane case nor the verdict of the jury in the Robbins trial was satisfactory to them, and they again proposed to usurp the authority of state. March 1, 1884, they sent out three anonymous notices to Doane, Robbins and John MacCrellish, "Leave this county within ten days, fail not on pain of death." Doane, unwisely, and yet within his rights as an American citizen, refused to obey the command of some unknown persons who simply made themselves known as "San Joaquin Valley Regulators." It is said, no doubt true, that he assumed a defiant air and defied this unknown party and that he became violent in his language and conduct. Doane was no coward, he was brave and reckless, and the threat of death hanging over his head made a fearless and desperate character. Then exhibiting the silly bravado of that class 6f men, especially under the influence of liquor, he came from his little place on the Waterford road into Modesto and showed the letter to his companions. They, just as unwise as he, plied Doane with more liquor and urged him to go and fight the gang that were trying to run him out of town.

Some politician once said: "God save me from my friends," and Doane may well have said, "Lord save me from my companions," for they were urging him on to his death. Thus intoxicated, he wandered up and down streets of the town, maudlin drunk, asserting that he was no coward, that he would not leave and that if the Regulators came for him, they would find him prepared to defend himself. In one of his drunken tirades he met on the street March 10 a highly respected farmer named W. C. Clark. Doane accused Clark of being a Regulator and would have shot him, but Mr. Clark with a heavy cane soon put Doane "hors de combat." A few days after Doane's unprovoked assault on Clark, the Vigilantes assembled at headquarters. It was the evening of March 19, 1884, a day which will ever be memorable in the days of Modesto. They had assembled, not for the purpose of arresting and confining Doane nor of banishing him from the county, but for the purpose of taking his life. Their intention was to take Doane alive, convey him to the bridge, hang him there and leave the body dangling from it, so reads the record. Twenty-five men were left at the bridge to guard it. Others were stationed along the road to Doane's house, which we remember was six miles out on the Waterford road. Another twenty-five, led by the captain, all on horseback, started for Doane's home to capture him and fulfill the design of the Regulators. Halting close to the place, they dismounted, these twentyfive men, seeking the life of an ignorant man then fifty-seven years old. What crime had he committed that he should suffer death? True, he had led a violent life in early days and had shot a man in Tuolumne County. But he had been punished for this crime by serving time in the penitentiary. Was he now to be hung for the same offense? No, he was to suffer death, says the printed account, because of the brazen conduct on his part and not so much the crime that he had committed against Dora MacCrellish. After dismounting, seven or eight of the Regulators, heavily masked, entered the door of the saloon. Four men were in the saloon - J. R. Briggs, Steve Girard and Doane, who were sitting at a table playing cards, and the barkeeper. The Vigilantes, with their weapons pointed at the heads of the frightened men, ordered them to throw up their hands. They quickly obeyed the command, all but Doane. He, realizing the situation, jumped from his chair and started for the back room, presumably for a weapon to defend himself. One of the Regulators fired a charge of buckshot into the body of the retreating man. The charge took effect in his back between his shoulders, and Doane fell dead. The Regulators then rode back to their companions at the bridge and in the darkness of the night reported their deed.

More Threats Of Hanging

J. J. Robbins, against whom there was no evidence of crime, only a suspicion of crime, March 1, 1884, received the following letter signed "San Joaquin Valley Regulators": "From date you are notified to leave this county within ten days. Fail not, on pain of death." Robbins, standing on his rights as an American citizen, resented this threat, and on the bulletin board in front of his office he published the following notice: "One hundred dollars will be paid for information leading to the detection of the cowardly scoundrel who addressed me an anonymous letter on March 1, signed 'San Joaquin Valley Regulators'." And he feared not to sign his name, J. J. Robbins. His friends persuaded him that the anonymous letter was a joke, and he removed the notice from the board. He soon afterward left Modesto.

The same command was given to John MacCrellish to immediately leave with his family. MacCrellish replied in the Evening News that he had not enough money to get food for his family, to say nothing of getting out of the county. He was perfectly willing to leave town if he could raise the funds. He also hoped that if there were such a thing as Vigilantes they would not hang him on an empty stomach. Sufficient funds were raised and he and his family left Modesto the day following the killing of Doane. ~-

Having got rid of the principal characters in the drama, the Regulators next turned their attention to the gamblers and their consorts. About thirty persons received the following notice: "You are hereby notified to leave Modesto within twenty-four hours and never return, under peril of your lives. Remember Doane's fate. - San

Joaquin Valley Regulators, March 21, 10:30 p. m." That allusion to Doane had its effect and many of the disreputables, leaving as soon as possible, remained housed for several days in a warehouse at Salida. On April 7, Saturday evening, the Regulators made another raid on Chinatown. They were followed by Constable Clark, who, approaching the captain within thirty feet, inquired: "How are you getting along?" "All right," the captain replied. Clark then went into the different houses and told the Chinese if the Regulators came in to be quiet and permit search. He then pleaded with the captain not to destroy the Chinese stores as the Chinese did not allow the whites to smoke opium. For his defense of the Chinese the captain hurled a beef bone at Clark, which struck him on the head, making a gash over his right eye. Blood freely flowed from the wound.

Another edict was published by the Vigilantes April 17, which said that certain persons ordered to leave are "lurking in the vicinity of Modesto. Now, therefore, all such persons are ordered to leave Stanislaus County immediately and never return, under penalty of death, and all persons are forbidden to harbor anyone under the same, penalty. All gamblers, pimps and prostitutes are forbidden to come into Stanislaus County. Remember Doane's fate." There was naturally much opposition to the work of the Regulators. Some of those who came under their ban were young men of the first families, who were the victims of the wide open town, more than toughs at heart. Most of the men, however, were the friends of Barney Garner and patrons of his saloon. Garner was freely outspoken in his denunciation of the Regulators. This called forth from them another letter addressed personally to Barney Garner April 23, 9 o'clock p. m. "This is to notify you if any disturbance is made, property destroyed or persons injured by the gang ordered out of the county, or any grain burned on the supposition that the owner is a Regulator, you will be held personally responsible with your life." Garner, as we have noted, was a prominent Democratic leader, and he took the letter to the Democratic paper, the News. The proprietor, J. D. Spencer, not only published the letter, but he deplored the attitude the Regulators had taken in seeking to threaten citizens who publicly expressed their opinion. He also deplored the bad name that the Regulators had given the town as a city of lawlessness and disorder. No threat was made against the News so far as known, but on the 21st of March the Farmer's Journal had been warned to modify its tone or take the consequences. The next morning following the death of Doane, although giving no report of the affair, it said: "If the people don't start in and pat the Regulators on the back then we are much mistaken. Every man, woman and ten-year-old boy in town feels that something must be done to purify the town." In another column it remarked: "It is about time that the Regulators were getting after the alley stock. After this, get rid of the MacCrellish family. It is to be hoped that they will put a stop to opium smoking." In still another column was this declaration: "The Journal is not in favor of violence, but in the language of David Crockett, 'Be sure you're right, then go ahead'." There was one saloonkeeper intimidated, if none other, and in the Modesto Strawbuck, May 6, 1884, he said: "To the San Joaquin Valley Regulators: Gentlemen: Since your notice was received my place of business had been closed. I had rented it, but the parties were compelled to give it up. I have endeavored to sell . it, but can find no purchasers. I have a stock of goods that are perishable and must do something with them, as I cannot lie idle and support my family. I find, therefore, that I must open my place, and at the same time I promise you that I will keep a quiet and respectable house, and at the same time grant you the privilege if you see fit, should I not stand by my agreement, to again serve a notice on me to close. Should you not answer this letter I will take it for granted that I have your permission and will proceed to open at once. - Respectfully, Moses Morris."

The Famous Tynan Property Suit

was alleged in the stepdaughters' petition that at the time of Dr. Tynan's marriage to their mother he owned unprofitable land on the Tuolumne river opposite Empire; had a small, unprofitable practice as a physician, and lived in a wagon on wheels. The land and the wagon comprised his entire property. Mrs. Tynan, their mother, died in 1881, leaving all of her property to her children in a will dated September 8, 1881. Up to this time Dr. Tynan had acted as the agent of his wife, and since her death he had acted as his stepdaughters' trustee. He acted wisely and honestly and gradually extended his operations. Among other transactions he purchased stock in the Modesto Grange Company and in the Grangers' Bank, San Francisco. In 1890 he erected the finest hotel in Modesto. It was a three-story brick building on the former site of the St. John house, and cost about $20,000. About that time the doctor's troubles began, for he again married and began selling his property and putting it into cash. The two stepdaughters, suspecting this, commenced suit for a settlement. In their petition they claimed that there had been no accounting during their mother's life, and as the property had belonged to them since that date they petitioned the court that the doctor be compelled to make an accounting and deed to them all of his lands and surrender to them his personal property. In his declining years, then over seventy years of age, the physician was greatly worried, for he was obliged to provide for a young wife. The suit came before Judge William Minor in April, 1892, with L. W. Maddux and James H. Budd of Stockton representing the stepdaughters. It seems that before the suit was settled Dr. Tynan disappeared. After waiting nearly a year the stepdaughters assumed that their stepfather was dead, and they petitioned for a probation of the property. They were opposed by the executor, Judge Hewel, who was represented in court by D. M. Delmas and P. H. Hazen of San Francisco and L. W. Fulkerth of Modesto. The daughters had the same counsel as in the previous suit. The case again came up before Judge Minor and was entitled "Woodside vs. Hewel," as found in the Supreme Court reports. The jury selected to try the case comprised S. W. Coffee, D. W. Bury, J. McDonough, J. W.'Earson, A. N.Standiford, S. Garlinghouse, Moses Sheakley, E. B. Stafford, George Wood, W. S. Spaulding and Jonas Bancy. The executor's attorne_vs endeavored to prove that Dr. Thomas E. Tynan was not dead, although his wife positively insisted that he had been murdered. "The plaintiffs," said the dispatch, "proved by an overwhelming evidence that Tynan was dead, and as the case stands there is no doubt of it." The case was on trial for twentythree days, including the three days of argument by the counsel. The jury retiring at 5 o'clock October 21, returned into the court the following morning. They disagreed as to the death of Dr. Tynan, but they unanimously agreed giving the stepdaughters three-fifths of the property, its cash value being about $150,000. It was alleged that Tynan was worth $250,000. Judge Minor, after carefully reviewing the evidence, declared Dr. T. E. Tynan legally dead. Regarding the distribution of the property, however, an unexpected event occurred - Dr. Tynan's return; and Judge Hewel taking the case to the Supreme Court, they declared October 10, 1895, that the property was community property between the husband and wife, and hence it could not be separated.

The disappearance of Dr. Tynan was one of the sensational events of that day, an event which for a time rivalled the train holdup by Evans and Sontag. He left Modesto October 13, 1892, for the purpose of going to San Francisco and transacting some business connected with the suit. On Saturday, the 15th, just before the closing of the bank, he drew out $5000, telling the clerk that he intended to make some improvements on his property in Modesto. A little later he wrote to his wife that he would be home on Monday. On the following day (Sunday) he left the Baldwin House, where he had lodged, and told the clerk that he was going home. From that time on, according to the belief of his wife, he had not been seen. She declared that Dr. Tynan had enemies and they had murdered him. About that time a headless body somewhat resembling Tynan had been found in the Stockton channel, but it was not the missing man. His photograph and a description of Tynan were circulated by the thousands throughout the United States. The description stated that he was of Irish birth, short, thick set, rather portly and weighed in his prime about 200 pounds. The most striking peculiarity of his personal appearance was his arm. It had been fractured and improperly set. As a result it dangled by his side when he walked. Detectives from San Francisco traced a man resembling Tynan in every respect from that city to Sacramento. He there purchased a ticket for New York and signed the name of E. S. Stanley. The detectives were positive it was Tynan. A man named Wilson telegraphed that he saw Tj'nan in Utah. The railroad ticket was produced in court and those familiar with Tynan's handwriting swore it was not his signature, yet strangely enough Stanley was the maiden name of Tynan's mother. The telegram from Utah was also discredited. By a singular incident Tynan was found. He was a Spiritualist, and while Slade, the famous Spiritualist, was in San Francisco, he visited Slade's seances. Tynan, again visiting the medium in Boston, was recognized as the long-sought Modestoan. The fact was telegraphed to Mrs. Tynan. After two years Tynan returned to California and said he had been living in seclusion in Boston to get rid of his family troubles. Then it was that Hewel carried the property suit to the Supreme Court and they reversed the decision of the lower court. Thomas E. Tynan died in San Francisco April 14, 1898.

Chinese Cook Murders Wife Of Rancher

CHINESE COOK MURDERS WIFE OF RANCHER A sad tragedy was that of the death of Mrs. Guy Kilburn, the wife of the wealthy rancher, at her home about two miles above CrowTs Landing. She had had in her employ for about twenty years a Chinese cook. Suddenly becoming insane, he attacked her January 29, 1910, with a knife, and stabbing her in the abdomen he inflicted wounds from which she died in half an hour. Mrs. Kilburn's son and his wife endeavored to prevent the murder, but the terrible deed was accomplished before they succeeded in overpowering the crazed heathen. Ah Sam was securely bound and taken to the Modesto jail. In the struggle with the knife the Chinaman in some manner cut himself severely, and he died in the county hospital the following day from the effects of the wound.

Dr. Horr Suicides

DR. HORR SUICIDES One of the oldest pioneers of the county was Dr. B. D. Horr, who located a ranch on the Tuolumne River in 1849. Of Southern birth, he was well educated, social, benevolent, and always cheerful and happy. A politician, he was most of his time in office or pulling the wires for his friends. Unfortunately, he was an inveterate gambler and a heavy drinker, and frequently he would gamble and drain the social glass until the early morning hours. Early in February, 1869, he was on a continuous spree and on the evening of the 3rd he again sat down to the gambling table. Playing cards throughout the night, luck was against him and he bet his last dollar and lost. About four o'clock he left the gambling table and going outside took an overdose of morphine and when found a short time later he was dead.

Disappearance Of George French

DISAPPEARANCE OF GEORGE FRENCH One of the mysteries of Modesto's history was the disappearance of George French a prominent Mason and a bookkeeper in the employ of Tucker & Perley, searchers of records. He left Modesto February 5, 1890, with his family to attend a religious convention in San Francisco, taking with him about $800 to complete a business transaction. They arrived safely in the metropolis and two days later he told his wife that he was going to Sacramento on business. From that day to this he has not been seen by his family or friends, although he was once reported as having been seen in Portland, Oregon.

Masonic Lodges

La Grange Lodge No. 99 was the oldest Masonic Lodge in Stanislaus County until its removal in 1873 to Merced. A dispensation was granted in January, 1856, by Grand Master William H. Howard to form a lodge. A charter was issued to the lodge dated May 8, 1856. The first officers were Abigil Elkins, worthy master; John Myers, senior warden; John B. Hocket, junior warden; C. M. Wells, senior deacon; J. Simons, junior deacon; W. F. Stafford, secretary; Thomas Paine, treasurer, and Uriah Nelson, tyler.

Summit Lodge No. 112 was instituted at Knights Ferry. The grand master granted a dispensation January 13, 1857, to form a lodge. Its first regular communication was held February 7, at which were present M. C. Edwards, worthy master; Stephen Bishop, senior warden, and Andrew J. Lane, junior warden. The following officers were appointed by the worthy master: Andrew McSorley, senior deacon; Isaac Snodgrass, junior deacon; Thomas W. Lane, secretary, and Henry Palmer, treasurer. Petitions for the degrees in Masonry were read by George W. Dent and W. E. Steuart and for affiliation from James A. Whetstone, Joseph Honigsberger and J. H. Skirm. All of the necessary, steps for the establishment of a lodge were taken and a note for $500 was given towards the erection of a hall. A charter was granted May 14, 1857, and June 13, a lodge was duly opened under the authority of J. K. Shafer, acting deputy grand master. The following officers were elected and installed : M. C. Edwards, worthy master; Stephen Bishop, senior warden; Andrew J. Lane, junior warden; Henry Palmer, treasurer; William E. Steuart, secretary. J. A. Whetstone, senior warden; William Palmer, junior warden; Jefferson D. Bentley and John Tason, stewards, and Andrew McSorley, tyler. The additional charter members were George W. Dent, Henry Harmon, Joseph Honigsberger, J. H. Skirm, W. H. Read, J. H. Snodgrass and Joseph Dillon.

The Masons of Knights Fern' occasionally celebrated St. John's day and annually they gave a ball - the social affair of that vicinity. Their ball of January 13, 1877, will long be remembered by many now living, who were among those present. Thomas Lane, E. Dettlebach, Josie and L. C. Branch were present from Modesto, A. S. Emory and wife from Oakdale, and from the pretty little town itself came Judge and Minnie Valpey, Anna and Kate Williams, Ada and Minnie Parker, Gussie Rawlings, Mattie Stone, Anna Roberts, Minnie Gobin, Nellie Burns, Belle Crabtree, Myra Arnold, James Warner, George Arnold, Louis Voyle, David Parker, Daniel Crowell, Samuel McAllister, Orrin Pool, John G. Booth, J. S. Williams, Charles Rawlings, James Stinson, John and J. A. Waston, William Ferguson, Daniel Logan, James Eusler, Alfred Dingley and James McCluery.

Stanislaus Lodge No. 206 was granted a dispensation to form a lodge, May 10, 1870, by Leonidas Pratt, grand master. Their charter dates from October 14, 1870, with the following charter members: S. A. Cleveland and George Buck, past grand masters, George French, Henry G. James, George W. Toombs, John W. Laird, Ruffin C. May and Robert M. Phillips. The charter members assembled in Tuolumne City in the home of Robert M. Phillips and elected the following officers: S. A. Cleveland, worthy master, died 1888; George Buck, senior warden, died 1891; H. G. James, junior warden; Robert M. Phillips, secretary; John W. Laird, treasurer; George W. Toombs, senior deacon ; Rufus C. May, junior deacon ; Charles W. Allrich, tyler. The fellow crafts men were John H. Hayes and Frank Mathenep and the apprentices, John H. Finn, William Grollman, Benjamin H. Haislip and Samuel B. Shaw.

The present officers of the lodge are George R. Stoddard, worthy master; George L. James, senior warden; Clarence W. Sikes, junior warden; Francis E. Heple, secretary; James Alfred Davis, treasurer, and Carl W. Showman, Herbert M. Hatch and W. D. Whitmore, trustees. Among the past grand masters we note S. A. Cleveland, 1870-1-2, died 1888; William Grollman, 1873-4-5-81-2, died in 1884; Jesse J. Chapman, 1876; Elihu B. Beard, 1877; Charles L. A. Hewel, 1878; John D. Spencer, 1879, died 1896; T. W. Drullard, 1880; W. H. Hutton, 1 885-6-7 ; Walter B. Wood, 1888-9-90; L. H. Fulkerth, 1891-2; Tohn H. Ward, 1893; George R. Stoddard, 1895.

Removing from Tuolumne City March 20, 1871, their meetings were held for a season in the James building, a wooden structure at the corner of H and Eleventh streets. In the meantime William Grollman was erecting a fine two-story building on Tenth Street. The second story was fitted up especially for the Masons and March 11, 1876, they held their first meeting in their new lodge rooms. They remained in this hall many years, until 1908, for the "hard time" failure of crops and the depression of business affects secret associations alike with individuals. About that time, however, a Masonic Hall association was formed with C. D. Swan as president and Thomas H. Kewin as secretary, and purchasing ground on I Street, 60x80 feet, adjoining on the east the Modesto Bank, thev erected a splendid three-storv building at a cost of $60,000.

From that time on the lodge grew and prospered rapidly and in less than six years began the discussion of a Masonic building erected especially for Masonic purposes. Another Masonic association was formed, and purchasing a lot corner of J and Fifteenth streets, a two-story concrete building was erected, 50x97 feet, at a cost of $30,000. The first story contained an auditorium, reception room, ladies' parlor, billiard room and kitchen. The second story was devoted exclusively to lodge room work. For the second time in the history of the county the Masons performed the beautiful ceremony of laying a cornerstone. At three o'clock, August 11, 1917, the lodge met in secret session in the old hall. An hour later a procession was formed composed of Stanislaus Lodge, the officers of the grand lodge and Electa Chapter, Order of Eastern Star, and preceded by the band they marched to the new site. The cornerstone was then laid with appropriate ceremony by Grand Master Francis V. Kresley, assisted by the following grand officers pro tern: W. H. Hatton, deputy grand master; Samuel Latta, grand senior warden; George T. McCabe, grand junior warden; George Stoddard, grand treasurer; Alfred Davis, grand senior warden; W. H. Kirk, grand junior warden; L. D. Fulkerth, grand senior steward, and W. O. Whitmore, grand junior steward. During the exercises appropriate selections were played by the Modesto Band and vocal selections given by the choir of Electa Chapter. In the cornerstone the following articles were deposited: the names of the officers and members of Stanislaus Lodge No. 206, Modesto Chapter No. 49, and Electa Chapter No. 72, O. E. S. There were copies of the Evening News and Morning Herald, a copy of the city charter, and the names of the directors of the Masonic Hall Building Association, namely, Alfred Davis, W. H. Kirk, V. D. Whitmore, Charles Kinter and Thomas M. Mantz.

Modesto Chapter No. 49, Royal Arch Masons, was granted a dispensation March 20, 1875, and was chartered March 24, 1875. Edwin A. Sherman, in his "Fifty Years of Masonry" said it was chartered April 12, 1876. Those signing the petition tor a dispensation were W. J. Houston, S. A. Cleveland, Isaac Ripperdan, Thomas A. Wilson, Alexander Burkett, J. D. Teckler and S. V. Wardrobe. William John Houston was the first high priest, S. A. Cleveland, first king, and H. G. James the first scribe. Thomas Kennan Beard was high priest in 1895 and up to that time the lodge had had eleven high priests. In that year, also, Adolphus Hewel was grand high priest of California, having been the high priest of Modesto Chapter from 1879-84.

Electa Chapter No. 72, O. E. S. of Modesto, was organized June 29, 1883, by Worthy Patron Minard S. Thresher of Home Chapter No. 50 of Stockton. The following were the charter members: Erastus Eagleson, Mary Ann Cameron, George W. Cameron, William Henry Hatton, James Henry Maddrill, Mary Martha Trainor, Etta N., Susie and Mattie Trainor, Alice Price Stone, Jennie F. Stone, T. W. Drullard, Alice May and Lucinda Rodgers, Josie and Mollie Gridley and Amanda Eagleson. The first officers of the Chapter were Mary Ann Cameron, matron; Brother Cameron, patron, and Mrs. Josie Gridley Wood, conductress. Mary N. Cameron, although living in Tucson, Ariz., still retains her membership in the Chapter. Susie Trainor Miller and sister and Amanda Eagleson are living in San Francisco. Mrs. Josie Wood is living in Modesto. W. H. Hatton, still residing in Modesto, was patron for several years. George Russell Stoddard served as patron for fourteen years continuously, and Mrs. Wakefield served as secretary for twenty-one successive years. Alice Stone Dozier, a past associate grand matron of the California Chapter, is now secretary of the local chapter. Mrs. Dozier, one of the most active members of the Chapter, served two terms as matron and has filled every office in the Chapter to which women were eligible, except conductress. The Chapter now, writes Mrs. Dozier, has 150 members and there have been during its existence 351 initiates.

Independent Order Of Odd Fellows

INDEPENDENT ORDER OF ODD FELLOWS La Fayette Lodge No. 65, the first Odd Fellows Lodge in the county, was instituted at La Grange June 14, 1857, by T. Rodger Johnson, the grand secretary. The charter members were Arthur Shearer, Lewis M. Booth, Luther Childs, Samuel Du Bois and William Floto. They had twenty-four members at their first grand lodge report. Eleven years after the instituting of LaFayette Lodge, two Odd Fellows, Henry K. Covert and J. A. Brown, then living in Tuolumne City, concluded to organize a lodge. Inquiring around, they found several Odd Fellows and a meeting was held at the steamboat landing. A short time afterward a second meeting was held in the carpenter shop owned by Alexander Glenn, eleven Odd Fellows being present. At this meeting all the arrangements were effected and November 10, 1868, Wilder Lodge was instituted, the Lodge adopting the name of Wildey, the founder of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows. They assembled in the second story of a brick building owned by Miner Walden, the first story being occupied by a livery stable. The Lodge was instituted by George Buck, denuty grand master, with the following as charter members: J. P. Martin and H. K. Covert, past grands of Yosemite Lodge No. 97 ; Miner Walden, past grand LaFayette Lodffe No. 65 : Henry Wilson with a transfer card from Progressive Lodge No. 134; William Ollrich of Mountain Brow Lodge No. 82, and J. A. Brown from Oregon Lodge No. 3. The following officers were elected and installed : Miner Walden, noble grand : H. K. Covert, vice-grand ; J. A. Brown, secretary; William Ollrich, treasurer; John P. Martin, warden, Henry Wilson, inside guardian. Soon after Modesto was founded the lodge was removed to the railroad town. Their first meeting in Modesto was held March 18, 1871, in the H. G. James building on the southwest corner of H and Eleventh streets. The Masons, as we have noticed, assembled for their meeting in the same hall. The members were among the most progressive citizens of the town and in 1872 they erected their neat building on the southwest corner of H and Tenth streets. For a short period while the Grollman building was being erected, the Masons there held Masonic meetings. The hall is still in use. The present officers of the Lodge are L. E. Elliott, past grand ; W. C. Fisk, noble grand ; R. C. Been, vice prand ; H. M. Briggs. secretary, and George P. Schafer, treasurer. H. M. Briggs has been secretary of the Lodge for twenty-six years and J. R. Brouehton was treasurer for the same period. The Degree of Rebekah The Rebekahs are now a separate branch of the order, but until 1895 the degree was given in the subordinate lodge. The degree was first conferred in Wildey lodge January 23, 1870. Charity Rebekah Degree Lodge No. 28, the first Rebekah degree lodge in the county, was instituted at Modesto July 1, 1875, by R. A. Hathaway, deputy grand master. He was assisted in his work by James Berry, George Perley and James C. James, past grands. The lodge in 1884 surrendered their charter.

Golden Gate Rebekah Lodge No. 110 was instituted January 17, 1887, by P. H. Medley, deputy grand master. There were thirty-one charter members, the deputy grand master being assisted by George Perley, James Berry, W. W. Granger, W. A. Donkin and P. P. Stiles, past grands. The present officers are Sylvia Johnson, past noble grand; Ella Halford, noble grand; Hattie Young, vice-grand; Jennie Wallace, recording secretary ; Rebecca Tucker, financial secretary, and Alice Wallace, treasurer.

Grand Army Of The Republic

Grand Post No. 9, G. A. R., was instituted in 1879 by T. W. Drullard, post commander, and I. S. Loventhal, adjutant. The post, as first numbering several hundred veterans of the Civil war, has now been reduced to less than forty in number. Each year they celebrated Memorial Day, May 30, and for several years past William H. Thompson, now adjutant of the post, has been directing the memorial exercises.

Ancient Order Of United Workmen

ANCIENT ORDER OF UNITED WORKMEN Ancient Order of United Workmen, Empire Lodge No. 112, Modesto, was instituted June 23, 1879, by Eugene Lehe of Stockton, deputy grand master. The lodge was organized with a membership of sixteen charter members. Seven candidates were initiated on the night of the lodge's organization, a team from Stockton assisting the district deputy in the work.

Knights Of Honor

Knights of Honor, Modesto Cedar Lodge No. 1992, was instituted January 23, 1880. It was instituted with twenty charter members by William J. Gregg, deputy supreme dictator.

Native Sons Of The Golden West

Modesto Parlor No. 11 was instituted October 26, 1881, by the following grand officers, pro tern: William H. Langdon, past president; Hugh H. McNoble, president; W. E. O'Connor, first vice-president; Frank H. Lee of Oakdale, second vice-president; William H. Hosmer, third vice-president ; A. J. Turner, secretary; Fred Jung of San Francisco, treasurer; Louis Harris of San Francisco, inside sentinel; J. L. Jackson, outside sentinel; W. L. MacLaughlin, marshal. The initiatory work was conducted bv Orestimba Parlor No. 142 of Crows Landing, assisted by W. E. O'Connor and W. H. MacLaughlin of Stockton. Hugh McNoble, W. H. Hosmer, A. J. Turner and J. L. Jackson were from Stockton.

The Grand Parlor met at Modesto April 19, 1916. The grand officers were met at the depot by the Modesto Parlor and escorted to the Hotel Hughson, where they were given a hearty welcome to the city by Mayor D. W. Morris. That afternoon they were taken on an automobile ride through the irrigation district. At Oakdale they were given the keys of Oakdale by John B. Curtis and tendered a barbecue in the Oakdale Park. That evening in Modesto the streets were cleared and there was dancing until midnight. During the visit of the Grand Parlor a tree was planted in Graceada Park with appropriate ceremony, in remembrance of their visit. The sandstone tablet at the foot of the tree savs: "Dedicated to the Grand Parlor, N. S. G. W., April 19, 1917."

Native Daughters Of The Golden West

NATIVE DAUGHTERS OF THE GOLDEN WEST Morada Parlor No. 199, Modesto - Morada being the Spanish name for home - was organized December 18, 1912. For several months previous the native sons of Modesto had been desirous of having a Native Daughter parlor and they appointed a committee of three, Edward Hunsucker, Joseph Cross and Hugh Benson, to provide a list of names from which charter members might be selected. Mrs. Clara Marchal, district deputy of San Joaquin, was enlisted in the work and for several weeks she labored perfecting the parlor. The parlor was instituted by Mrs. Olive Bedford Matlock of Red Bluff, grand president, assisted by Alice Dougherty, grand secretary, and Mrs. Mamie Peyton of Stockton, past grand president. The parlor was started with twenty-one charter members. There were forty-five names on the roll, but many of them were away on holiday vacation while others were absent because of business.

The lodge was instituted with the following named officers: Katherine Hunsucker, past president ; Nellie Dunlap, president ; Florence Davison, first vice-president ; Mabel Cleveland, second vice-president; Cora Campbell, third vice-president; Alma Wakefield, recording secretary; Louise Chase, financial secretary; Evelyn Dunlap, treasurer; Kate Gillette, marshal; Florence Dugain, inside guardian; Bessie Trudgeon, outside guardian ; Rose Briggs, organist, and Sireta Muney, Hattie Hughson and Edith Bower, trustees.

About twenty-five members of the Stockton Parlor No. 6, N. D. G. W., visited the new parlor and the Stockton team initiated their candidates for membership. The parlor made the trip over the Tidewater Southern and the coach drawn by a locomotive was one of the original coaches used on the Central Pacific on the route between Sacramento and Ogden. It was the first excursion trip over the Tidewater road. The Stockton team comprised Mary Murray, past president ; Mrs. Lucie Lieginger, president; Mrs. L. Petersen, first vice-president; Mrs. Clara Wenger, second vice-president; Mrs. Mae Parker, third vice-president; Mabel McDonald, marshal; Mrs. H. Avery, inside sentinel; Miss M. Avery, outside sentinel. The splendid work of lodge organization concluded with a banquet at which the Native Sons were guests.

Benevolent And Protective Order Of Elks

BENEVOLENT AND PROTECTIVE ORDER OF ELKS As the Elks would not permit of the organization of any lodge in a citv of less than 5,000 inhabitants, on March 19, 1901, about twenty citizens of Modesto joined the Stockton lodge. It was a great occasion in which Senator C. M. Belshaw of Sacramento lodge presided and Major J. F. Whitmore of Modesto was one of the speakers. However, in 1912, Modesto had increased wonderfully in population, and the Modestoans concluded to organize a home lodge. Assembling in the Masonic hall July 15, 1912, they elected the following officers to serve in the new lodge: C. D. Swan, exalted ruler; Geo. H. Bertram, esteemed leading knight; Dr. C. Grove, esteemed loyal knight; J. A. Trowbridge, esteemed lecturing knight; J. A. Dunn, secretary; John C. Lesher, treasurer; Myron Warner, tyler, and W. A. Downer, J. J. McMahon and Z. E. Drake, trustees.

The lodge was instituted August 9, 1912, in Masonic hall by District Deputy J. L. Cram of Petaluma. He was assisted in his work by some forty or fifty Stockton Elks. The new lodge was hailed as Modesto Lodge No. 1282, B. P. O. E. As soon as the lodge was instituted and the officers installed, the lodge adjourned to Stockton, there to complete their work. The officers of the Modesto lodge, their candidates and the members of the Stockton lodge, forming a procession of about fifty automobiles and kd by the Modesto band on a truck, started for Stockton. Leaving about four-thirty they arrived in time and were escorted into town by a large delegation of brother Elks. All of the Modesto Elks and initiates wore a button bearing the words "Modesto Lodge No. 1282, B. P. O. E., August 10, 1912." Beneath the words was an inverted champagne bottle bearing the label "Modesto, extra dry" - this referring to the recent election when the people voted the town dry. The entire elkdom assembled in the Elks' hall at nine o'clock with Judge Charles W. Norton, exalted ruler of Stockton

The presiding officers then presented the Modesto Lodge with a beautiful American flag for use on their altar. Oakland Lodge presented them with a beautiful electric lamp, four feet in height. San Jose gave them a specially manufactured ballot box, and the Berkeley Lodge a handsome large Bible. Alameda, Petaluma, Richmond, San Mateo and the Hanford lodges each gave the new lodge some useful gift for the lodge room. George H. Bertram responded and accepted the gifts. At eleven o'clock W. H. Langdon responded to the toast, "The Absent Members." The entire party then retired to the banquet hall, where a fine spread was enjoyed.

Soon after the organization of the lodge, John Tully made a ,proposition to erect a three-story brick building on his lot on Tenth street, between G and H, and fit up the second and third stories for lodge purposes. The Elks accepted the proposition on a five-year lease, with a ten-year lease if they so desired. The building was completed in August, 1913, at a cost of $40,000. The entrance to the second story is by marble stairway which leads to a cozy club room, fitted up with easy chairs and lounges. This room, fifty feet square, also contains a billiard and pool room. The lodge room occupies a part of the second and third story, fifty by sixty feet, with a large center glass dome figured with Elk emblems. One the third floor is the banquet room and kitchen. The fitting up of the lodge rooms cost approximately $10,000.

The Elks' first memorial service was held in the Modesto Theater Sunday afternoon, December 7, 1913. The service was held in memory of J. R. High and Thomas A. Pillman, the two members of the organization who had died since the institution of the lodge. The exercises began with the grand march from "Aida" by the orchestra; hymn by the Temple Quartette, Dr. J. P. Snare, F. L. Wisecarver, H. B. Rice and Ray Bradbury; opening exercises by the lodge; prayer, Rev. W. P. Williams; quintette, "Nearer, My God, to Thee," Mrs. Laura De Yoe Brown and the Temple Quartette ; Eulogy, L. W. Fulkerth; soprano solo, "Fear Ye Not, Oh Israel," Mrs. Laura Brown; poem, "Thanatopsis," C. D. Swan; original poem, G. A. Martin; oration, T. B. Scott; song, "Aloha," Mrs. Laura Brown and quartette; Doxology, "Praise God From Whom All Blessings Flow," audience; recessional march, orchestra; "Our Brotherhood," P. H. Griffin; "Auld Lang Syne."

The Modesto Choral Society

THE MODESTO CHORAL SOCIETY This musical organization, one of the best and largest in the interior of California, held a preliminary meeting May 11, 1909, in the Plato Opera House, Dr. B. F. Surryhne acting as chairman. After considerable discussion they concluded to organize a society and adjourned to meet again May 14 in Dr. Surryhne's office. On that evening the singers again assembled and, adopting a constitution, elected as officers Mrs. Laura De Yoe Brown, president; Mrs. Lammermain, secretary; Mrs. John W. Ross, treasurer, and Mrs. Frank Cressey, Jr., and Dr. John P. Snare, executive committee. They voted to immediately commence practice under the direction of Professor Twicher and sing at the Modesto Fourth of July celebration.

The club gave its first concert January 28, 1910, in Plato's Opera House on Tenth street, between H and I streets. The program, all home talent, comprised an orchestra selection, "Soldiers' Chorus from Faust"; contralto solo, "Lover's Spring Time," Miss Cox; violin solo, Mr. Burgen ; reading, Miss Haley; "Sextette from Lucia," Mrs. Laura De Yoe Brown, Miss Cox, Whitmore, Rice and Jackson ; Chorus, "Unfold Ye Gates," from The Redemption ; address, L. L. Dennett.

In 1911 the society planned for a big musical festival to continue for two days, May 4 and 5. Plato's Opera House had been changed into a rooming house and the club erected a temporary pavilion on I Street, opposite the court house. The pavilion seated 2000 and two evening performances and a matinee were given. The chorus comprised some 250 voices, the best singers in the county, and an orchestra of forty pieces, together with several imported singers. The local soloists were Mrs. Laura De Yoe Brown and Miss Grace Cox, sopranos; John Bates, baritone, and Professor

Twicher, conductor. The imported singers were Mrs. Vela Ruggles Jenkins, soprano of the First Presbyterian Church, Oakland ; Mrs. Jennie Le Nois Schultz, alto ; Jonas H. Anderson, baritone; Charles Bullotti, tenor; Fred Zeb, solo flutist, and H. Holmes, solo 'cellist. The first evening was called Oratorio Night, and selections were sung from the Messiah, Stabat Mater and Jerusalem. The second night was Opera Night, all of the selections being sung from operas by Verdi, Strauss, Gounod, Sullivan, Donizetti and Offenbach.

The Story Of The Southern Pacific Depot

The Southern Pacific Railroad passing along Front street erected a small freight and passenger depot on the southeast corner of Front and I streets. The little red depot was destroyed by fire in the early '80s. The company then erected the present freight depot. As the city grew and prospered after the introduction of water to the fertile lands, the citizens began building beautiful homes and business blocks, laying fine streets and erecting handsome buildings. At this time, 1912, the business men had erected a handsome arch across I Street near the depot and they requested the Southern Pacific Company to remove the old dilapidated depot and erect one in keeping with the beautiful city. "Oh, yes," said the company, "we will replace the old shack with a handsome depot, provided you pass an ordinance closing I Street." The citizens were up in arms immediately, and no wonder. I Street was the principal business street of the city. It was well paved and the direct highway to Paradise City. And now the Southern Pacific requested them to close the street, ruin all business traffic and obstruct the beautiful view to the west. The company sent a smooth-talking committee to Modesto to show the trustees that the closing of the street would increase the value of property in that vicinity and improve business, but the level-headed fathers failed to appreciate their arguments. A few years later the Southern Pacific sprung another plan for a depot. They succeeded in having the trustees call a vote of the people on the closing of J and Front streets for the purpose of erecting a depot. The proposition carried and in 1915 the present handsome depot was erected.

The Memorial Arch Of Prosperity

The leading citizens of the city, including the women, believed it would be an excellent idea to erect ornamental structures along the leading streets of the city beginning on I Street. The idea met with a hearty approval and in May, 1911, the business men assembled in Schafer's hall and the committee reported a design shown in water colors. It was not satisfactory, for in August they offered a price of fifty dollars for the "best design or arch over I Street near the depot." A design was selected and erected in 1912. The arch spans I Street 'at the intersection of Front Street. It is constructed of structural steel and rests on two solid granite pillars twelve feet in height. It is seventy-five feet in width and twenty-five feet center height. The money was obtained by subscriptions, varying in amount from five dollars to one hundred dollars, and cost something like $1 ,200. In the bow of the arch are these words that may be read from either side, Water, Wealth, Contentment, Health. The arch can be illuminated at night and in four words it tells the story of the condition of Stanislaus County since the Sierras' waters began irrigating the land.

Merchants' Association

In the same year that the memorial arch was erected a merchants' association was organized for the purpose of securing a better harmony of action, promoting trade, securing protection from dead-beat customers, unworthy advertising schemes and innumerable donations from every conceivable thing under the sun. The movement was started by John D. Turner, hardware merchant, and March 2, 1912, about thirty merchants assembled in the city hall and formed the association. At a subsequent meeting the organization was perfected and John D. Turner elected president and Frank D. Hanscom, secretary. A number of directors also were chosen, they to have full control and manage the affairs of the association. The membership embraced all classes of citizens. This promiscuous membership for some reason was not satis- factor}' and in June, 1913, a reorganization was effected. Under the new organization none but merchants and professional men were eligible to membership.

In the previous year, February 2, the merchants of Modesto entertained for a few hours an excursion train of San Francisco merchants out on a junketing trip to "shake the glad hand," form new acquaintances and drum up trade. They arrived at Modesto about 2:30. It was raining heavily, but nevertheless they were greeted by hundreds of citizens and the Women's Improvement Club, each visitor receiving a buttonhole bouquet. The party were shown the splendid progressiveness of Modesto and their entertainment concluded that evening with a smoker in the Masonic hall. W. H. Langdon was toastmaster of the evening and addresses were made by George Stoddard, L. L. Dennett, Sol Elias and other local citizens.

The Merchants' Association held its first banquet July 19, 1913, in the Modesto Grill on Tenth Street. It was a very enthusiastic gathering and much of interest was brought before the association by those who responded to the toasts. Frank A. Cressey, the manager of the Modesto Gas & Electric Light Company, was the toastmaster. Responses to the toasts were made by the president of the association, John Furner; the secretary, Frank Hanscom ; A. L. Cowell, the editor of the Evening News; C. M. Clary, Sylvain Latz, C. F. Gailfus, Sol P. Elias and W. H. Killian, editor of the Morning Herald. The president and the secretary reviewed the work of the organization and the future plans for carrying out their business to the best advantage.

Provenance

Text from History of Stanislaus County California : with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present, published 1921, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.