Nevada County, California - Chapter 30: Sketch of the Nevada County Bar, 1880
From History of Nevada County, California; with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks, and Manufactories .., published 1880. 9,259 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
9,259 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Nevada County, California; with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks, and Manufactories .., published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
By Hon. A. A. Sargent
The Attorneys who Have Constituted the Bar of Nevada County, and Many Interesting Anecdotes in Regard to Them, and to the Legal and Illegal Proceedings in the County.
From the earliest settlement of Nevada county its bar contained men of learning and ability. Rich mines hereabouts instantly attracted large numbers of people, who originated all kinds of mining enterprises and engaged in general business. The former were fertile in causes of litigation, giving abundant and profitable employment to the legal profession. Conflicting locations and boundaries of mining claims, and disputed water rights, were the abounding incentives to legal strife for many years; and many of the leading cases to be found in the California Supreme Court Reports originated in Nevada county.
Among the earliest lawyers in this vicinity were E. P. W. Ellis Niles Searls, Stanton Buckner, James F. Hubbard, Hiram C. Hodge, John T. Crenshaw, John R. McConnell, Lorenzo Sawyer, Thomas Freeman, Thomas H. Caswell, T. G. Williams, John Anderson, J. B. Townsend, William T. Barbour, T. J. Bowers, and William H. Lyons, all of whom came here in 1850; and James Irwin and R. M. Wood, who came in 1851, or early
Ellis was a clear-headed, popular man, and an excellent lawyer. He would probably have made his mark had he remained in this State. He represented this section in the Legislature in 1851, and, returning to Illinois in 1852, was a member soon after of the Legislature of that State. He was first Lieutenant-Colonel of the Fifteenth Illinois Regiment, the first regiment in the war from that State, and afterwards its Colonel, which grade he held when he was killed at the battle of Shiloh. His last words, as he fell shot from his horse, were, " Catch me, boys' " Ellis was a bold, fearless man, of powerful frame, and many stories are preserved of his personal exploits. In the summer of 1851 C. A. Frisbie had a saloon that stood on Main street, just above the present site of the South Yuba Company's office. Ellis' office was "just at the forks of the road, in which also he slept. He was accustomed to wear a red flannel shirt, red drawers and red stockings, arid at night to divest himself of his outer garments and sleep in his red under apparel to which he added a round red conical night cap, tapering to a point and hanging over backwards. The " boys " used to run late at night at Frisbie's, and W. T. Barbour, then District Judge, liked to keep them company. One night Judge B. got into an altercation with a gambler, and words ran high. The ! row waked up Ellis, and he rushed over without waiting to ! dress, to see who was being murdered, picking up as he ran a I stout pine root. As he rushed into the saloon he saw the gambler with Barbour's head in chancery, and pistol drawn, just about to kill Him. Down came the root in Ellis' hand on the head of the gambler, who fell like a bullock, when Ellis whirled round and van back to bed. He appeared and vanished so suddenly that nobody knew who it was, and it was not found out for some time after; but his interposition probably saved Barbour's life.
Ellis was once trying a case in the old court- room on Broad street, opposite the present National Hotel, in which he commented with great severity on the testimony of Dr. W . The doctor was a Tennesseean, an airy man, very punctilious on the point of honor. As Ellis addressed the jury a long har table stood between him and the body of the court room. Looking round, at .some exclamation in the auditorium, he saw W. draw a pistol and make towards him. Ellis at once drew from his breast a knife about a foot long and went for him, leaping over the table at a bound. W, made a rush to tt feelings bad been hurl began condoling with him, and depre eatod the attack, " Yes," said Judge Buckner, as he was called, - but did you hear my reply?" "No," said hia friend, "what was It?" "Why, I told him I wasn't," said the Judge, with an air implying thai the ratorl was quite crushing. A favorite gesture of Judge Bucknor was f" toclf the index finger of his right hand Into the Little finger of the left, and move the bands emphatically up and down. Whenever he assumed this attitude ho was read} for extended remarks, In arguing a petty criminal case before Justice Endecotl ho took hia Favorite attitude and sail I, " I w ill I10W show your I loimr that a man LS presumed to be innocenl until he is proved to be guilty." "The oourt admits that " said Endecott, who wasa thin, bony man, and who had been wriggling i" torture on a hard bench for a couple hours; "the court is with von in that, bul it doeanol admitthal there is any presumption thai the court's bottom is made of oast iron !"
Hiram C. Hodge was count} treasurer in 185] 3. He was also a practicing attorney, and was counsel for the only man who was ever judicially hung in tins county for stealing. The culprit, was a half-witted follow named Barrett. He stolea few articles of so little aggregate value that it is doubtful if his oourt of sessions, and sentenced by the jury to death, as the law then permitted, and was hanged in July, 1852. It has always been the impression among members of the bar cognisant of the facta, that he should have hem persuaded to plead guilty and lake the imprisonment the court would have inflicted, rather than be subjected to the risk of death at a time when juries were particularly vindictive against those who committed thefts. The poor fellow was probably entirely irresponsible for his acts, was anvrwanU postmaster at Nevada He was in tin and wan killed at Vick- Hon John R hid nnell died la»t year in Colorado He ng a member "f the Nevada bar, and considered of it-i members II the county, and subsequently it ral and a member of the Legislature a short tiiin- before hia death, elected from Lot Angeles county, t-» which be had removed He was ?erj studious and fond ol old and curious law. Hie used t<> wear a bare place in the carpet along the whole Length <<f his office, where he paced up and
He had as a client, Dr. W., whose litigation was often of an important character. On a trip Mow tin* doctor had l«>m>wvd si 000 of one «»f the Supreme Judgea After judgment in the I district ( '"in t. which was t-> l»- appealed to the Supreme ( fourt, \li< lonnell said to him:
II. m, Lorenzo Sawyer first came to Nevada in October, is-'.o. II, tayed about a month and went to San Francisco and engaged in law practice. After being twice burned out, he returned t.. Nevada in August, 1851, and practiced law here until August, L853. He returned then fcoSan Francisco, where he was electi d < 'it\ Attorney. January 25, 1862, he went to Virginia City. A telegram reached him there May 26, asking if he would take the bench of the Twelfth District made vacant by the resignation of Hon. A. Campbell. On his assenting the Governor telegraphed to him to come at once and stop at Sacramento for his commission. This he did, and opened his court at Redwood City June 2. This celerity was at a time when travel was by stage, over bad roads, and, of course, far slower than at present. That fall he was nominated by both parties and elected without opposition. In 18fJ3 the new Supreme Court was elected, under the amended Constitution. Sawyer being one of the new judges, drawing a six years' term. On the 6th of December, I860, President Grant sent his name to the Senate as the first United States Circuit Judge for this coast, and he was confirmed on the 10th of January, 1870, and has served in this important office acceptably ever since.
" Tom" Freeman was here but a short time. He had a broad Missouri pronunciation. After a visit at San Francisco, the fast he had ever paid to a seaport, and seeing the numerous ships in the harbor, many of the store-houses of those days good tiling oul of his other, as the minei t suppc ted him 1" ho a mining recorder, and brought their notices t«> be recorded, Such rdiog was faithfully attend) d to, and roes charged thereto that would be considered astonishing in those low< i da£ The profits of his horl lived office enabled Freeman bo"go ho well fixed," after killed another man in the streets of thai town. The populace fell upon him with pick handles, seised Prom a barral that stood by, and heat him to death
Col. R. M.Wood was a member of the Legislature Prom Contra Costa county. He was killed as one of Henry A. < frabVs party of invasion >>\' Sonera Mexico.
Thi seare believed to be all the lawyers who eameto N< rada City within the first two years of its settlement, dating Prom the time when it was called indifferently, "Deer Crces Dry Diggings," and "Ce tea" They held forth in a court room supported by post- and enclosed with red cloth. But two of them now live in the county, both at Nevada, viz , Hon. Niles Searls and John Anderson. Nearly all the others have left the State, and some are dead. In those day., they were young men, full of hope and energy. The few survivors are gray-haired veterans, .scarred in the battle of time. They were, however, but the advanced guard of the legal army, the main body of which followed close in their track.
In 1852 came James Churchman and C. Wilson Hill; in L853, EL a Gardiner, A- B. Dibble, Joseph Conn, and W. M. Stewart; in 1854, T. B. McFarland, Josiab Chandler Bean, Alexander Anderson, J. W. G. Smith, Geo. 8. ffiipp, Francis J. Dunn, 0. A. Tweed, A.A.Sargent, C.J". Lansing, Johns, E. W. Roberts, and John J. Caldwell; in 1855, A. C. Niles, I). Belden, II. I. Thornton, C. A. Johnson. During the same years, or soon after, came also James K. Byrne, W. F. Anderson, C. B\ Bmifh, J. S. Carpenter, S. E. Chase, E. W. Mazlin, M. Kirkpatrick, M. P. O'Connor, J. C. Deuel and J. G Palmer.
James Churchman was a brilliant and somewhat erratic man. He was a cotemporary and associate in Illinois of that famous school of lawyers in which were numbered Abe. Lincoln, S. ADouglas, E. F. Baker, Dick Yates, Lyman Trumbull, and others. Churchman was one of the best talkers at the Nevada bar, but not a pains-taking practitioner, and was often beaten by men far his inferiors in natural ability. He once read from the syllabus 0f fl reported case to establish a proposition. Dunn was his antagonist, and read from the text of the case to show that it ,11,1 not sustain the syllabus ; whereupon Churchman argue:! at length that the latter, rather than the text, was the authority. Ee held that, the reporter being there, and an officer of the court, would know what the court said and meant, while the text might bo full of the mistakes of the printer. His Honor, Judge Searls, did not take this view of the matter. President Lincoln gavo him the appointment of Consul at Valparaiso.
A. B. Dibble, for years the head of the firm of Dibble & Byrne, is still a resident of Grass Valley, has been actively identified with much of the litigation of his section of the county, and is accounted an excellent jury lawyer. Although Mr. Dibble has occasionally made himself felt in politics, we believe he has never held an office. He was once nominated for Congress, on which occasion an opponent published of him, and an associate on the ticket, the following false, defamatory and exceedingly improper matter, being the refrain of a long " poem : "
" Dibble is lazy and Skinker wont work, Dibble for Congress and Skinker for Clerk ; Dibble is little and Skinker is thin, Dibble is beaten and Skinker gone in."
Hon. William M. Stewart studied law in McConnell's office, and practiced here a number of years alone and as a member of the firm of McConnell & Stewart. He is a man of energy and intelligence, as his career shows. He was District Attorney of Nevada county and State Attorney General. He removed to Nevada State, where he was a member of the Territorial Legislature and Constitutional Convention. He was elected to the United States Senate from that State in 1864, and again in 18G9, serving in that body eleven years.
before the Court of Sessions, who had been indicted for mayhem \ in biting off an ear. The trial developed that the prosecuting witness had been the aggressor, and deserved what he got. Stewart began to lose interest in the result of the case, but his interest was revived by the testimony of Dr. J. R. Coryell, who was introduced by the defense as an expert. The Doctor swore that, as the ear was not quite bitten off, it being left hanging by a little skin, it would have been possible to save it. But, as°the victim was a laboring man, to whom time is valuable', they had cut it off to save the time it would take to cure it. Had it been a gentleman's ear, they would have saved it. It was usual to save gentlemen's ears, but to cut off laboring men's, to save time. Churchman, who defended, made an eloquent speech. When he had conclude.!, Stewart arose and said to the jury that the only question in the case was whether laboring men had a right to have ears, and sat down. The jury instantly found in the affirmative.
Hon. Thomas B. McFarland was a miner at Shelby Flat before he engaged in his profession here. He was at one time a member of the Legislature, subsequently District Judge of this district; and more recently Register of the Sacramento Land District.
Francis J. Dunn was one of the most singular characters at this bar. He was a man of sturdy sense, somewhat uncultivated, who had picked up a fair knowledge of law, was pleasant and accommodating when sober, and opinionated and surly when in his cups. It cannot be denied that quite a number of those who practiced at the bar frequented somewhat assiduously the numerous saloon bars, and imbibed alcoholic spirits as readily as the Spirit of the Laws; and these were by no means the least brilliant and able among the profession. Many anecdotes were current in the olden time concerning the convivial habits of the limbs of the law. At early morning Dunn and Buckner met at Blaze's saloon, each with a market basket on his arm. Buckner said to Dunn, as he took his drink, "The early bird catches the worm!" "Yes," replied Dunn, "and a good many cocktails too."
' A party of men going along the Downieville road came across a well-dressed man lying by the side of the road. They roused him and inquired, " Who are you V "I am Francis J. Dunn; considered, and justly considered, the best lawyer in the State of California," said the disturbed one, struggling to a perpendicular. On one occasion, in replying to an argument, Dunn said : " The remarks of counsel remind me of a quotation from a classical poet. I cannot exactly recall the name of the poet, and I have forgotten the quotation ; bul, if I could repeat it. the court would see that it is a propos."
It is related that Dunn prepared his statements for the Supreme Court without much condensation or regard to method, copying all kinds of papers and orders into them. Before printed transcripts were in vogue such documents were rather confusing. It so happened that as Dunn was arguing one of his cases in the Supreme Court, Judge Murray, under some mistake as to the facts, said to the advocate that the court did not want to hear him any further; but, some time after, decided the case against him. Dunn soon had another case before the same tribunal, and commenced reading his interminable transcript, with motions, orders and evidence set out at appalling length. "State your case, Mr. Dunn," said Judge Murray; "it is not necessary to read the whole record." " No you don't, may it please your honors," said Dunn, "the Supreme Court told me that once before, and then decided the case against me. I am ffoing- to read this record and make the court understand me." This counsel did, to the horror of the court, which had then no limit for time, and the reading and argument occupied three days of the time of the court. It was not long thereafter that the Supreme Court fixed a limit to the length of counsels' speeches.
George S. Hupp has been a member of the Nevada bar for many years, his service having been interrupted only by a short residence in the State of Nevada.
Hon. Aaron A. Sargent came to Nevada city in 1850. While publishing the Nevada Journal he studied law and was admitted to the bar in 1854. He has served one term as District Attorney, six years in the House, and six in the Senate, at Washington.
Hon. C. J. Lansing served in the Senate in 1859. Hon. Edward W. Roberts is a Rough and Ready and Grass Valley lawyer of long standing, and served a short time as County Judge by appointment, and a term as State Senator in
Hon. Addison C. Niles has served as County Judge of Nevada county, and on the Supreme bench of the State. His term on the latter closed with the adoption of the new Constitution, and he has returned to practice at Nevada.
Hon. David Belden was a popular member of the Nevada bar. He was elected County Judge by one majority over H. M. Moore, a present Sand Lot orator, and subsequently was a State Senator from this county. He removed to Santa Clara county, where he was elected District Judge, and is the present Superior Judge of that county. He is noted as a wit and orator as well as lawyer. As illustrating his humor and independence we give a 4th of July address delivered by him in
Hoa Joseph HuU was once State Senator. Hon William W Cross Btadied law in Mc< onnellsomce ;mil prttotdoed nore mrawhil* Ho removed to Visalia, and ib tho Superior Judge of Kerncountj
With tfce able arraj of counBolin I860 51, there wasalack ti|. iudicia) ^ibunalB having jurisdiction of higher offenses. TUi; trn.ill)1N no^ knownas Nevada county was, unfal near thl. middleof 1851, a part of VTuba county, and tfarysville waa the county seal Tho great difficulty and costof tnaLsat suoh b distance, and a certain lack of confidence in the judicial authorities a* the countj seat, occasioned a tendency toward lynch trials V memorable trial of this character took place at Nevada City, in April. L8M, wherein three men, named Ulen, MiUer ana Ridgely, were tried for stealing $2,600 in gold dust from J. Chambers' butcher shoponBroad street found guilty ana publicly whipped. Ridgely was employed in the shop" ana originated the robbery. Allen was the son of a respectable man in Ohio, a gentleman by education, who had aavved with credit aa an officer in the Mexican war. Ho baa the plunder. The punishment of these two was somewha The penalty was inflicted next morning on a lull 80Utheasl of the town, the stripes being so well laid on by .-Butcher Bill" and a teamster, that the men lay 'curled up when i« was n> at the foot of the tree to winch they had | bound. They were compelled to leave town almost immediately. Ridgely was reported to have died from Ins terrible punishment "This example discouraged larceny for months, and it is remembered that thereafter miners could leave their gold with impunity in their cabins, and even in their sluice
Vs'late as September, 1855, a man, probably innocent of any offense, came near being hanged by mob law at Grass Valley. \ serious tire, supposed to have been the result of incendiarism, had burned up a large part of the town, and Frank Foster had been employed by the citizens as private night watchman to keep a lookout "for similar attempts. During his rounds he saw a man near an unfinished building striking a match and immediately arrested him. The man was an illy-dressed
^ery^riking illustration of the danger of mistake from Jo^was furnished at Rough and Ready .in the Sprmg « W51 W. M. Stewart and Jack Watson rode mto town one I', ;,u horseback, when they saw a man being led by a mob. The man was stripped naked except the. pantaloon. HaUo, said Watson to Stewart, « what are they doing that for^ I bet that is an innocent man. Dare you go into that , mob . Stewart, without stopping to think, said "Yes Thej d« mounted from their horses and ran into the crowd with p.sto to drawn, calling out « There is a mistake ! You have got the wrong man!" The mob were passing under a new building. on which there was no roof, but the sides were up and cross stringers, with some boards on them, and a ladder reaching to this platform. Stewart called out - Take him up the ladder, ! and the crowd, swayed by this seeming authoritative inter- I ference obeyed. " Now choose a committee and try him, I directed Stewart. A committee of six was chosen, when 1 Stewart told the man to make his statement. The man i related that he was on his way from Sonoma county to Nevada City to engage in saw milling; that he came into town the ! niaht before and put up at a hotel; that, besides some small amount of other money, he had in his pocket S300 in Mexican doubloons, which his accuser, who occupied the same wom,» ! and charged him with stealing from the latter; that he hadlett : his partner, Taylor, in Sonoma county. " What evidence have the acou sr, who 6b hed off on his mule for his life II' Followed a long way toward Deei en ik bj the excited crowd; In mule, which ho had und, but he escaped.
in such criminal cases. <'i\il suite gave lawyers enough employment. With the arraj of talent and youthful vigor in the profession in the earlj days, with vague tatute and novel surroundings, with perplexing questions that it took a dozen years to Bolve and some of which are yet debated, with an eager, crowding population, and the flushest of times, it is no wonder that worli was Boon and abundantly found For lawyers. A vigorous law suit, arose out ofa contested claim on the "Coyote Lead" at the threshold of settlement here. At an early day this lnu I, lying just back of Nevada City, had been' braoad bj miners from a ravine into the range of low-lying hills, and proved tobeof extraordinary richness. In 1850-51 i the who]e hill surface between Buckeye and Lost Bills "was dotted with Bmall claims, which were vigorously worked by moans of what were called "Coyote holes," the earth being drifted out and hoisted by ;i windlass to the surface.' With the waste dirt piled ai'ound the mouth of the pits, and the small crowd of workers to each, they looked like highly animated ant hills. The dirt was hauled in carts to Deer creek, where it/ was washed in " long-toms." * hie of the riches! of these olaimswas known as the " French claims," and was on Buckeye Bill, ownedand worked by J. Figuiere. now in the San Francisco post office, A. [soard, still living At Nevada, Pierre Dreydemie, Joseph Durand, K. MLathieu and one Mayet, all Frenchmen, of whom only Figuiere could speak English. From this claim as high as |912 per pan was taken out. This- exceeding richness tempted certain persons, among whom were two law v. i>. namely, Hiram C. Hodge and T. G. Williams, who had acting with thom Ti W. Colburn, his brother Charles, T. Etobson and Thomas. Barton. Those individuals coveted the possession of 'the lucky owners, and, in September, 1850, proceeded to the which was brought before Justice Kdwar.K Ihe suit was tried before a jury of six men, J. N, Turner, affectionately remembered aa ''Nick" being foreman. On the ferial Barton swore thai the defendants had stood by and een the French- j men take oul gold by the bucketful, and they " wanted a slice." Be said they thought the fipn I had enough of it, and
[t was time for American citizens i" have a show. The case was fiercely contested and excited a great deal of interest The jury found for the Frenchmen, and the public ratified the verdict w'nii gteal unanimity.
were then the onlj Judicial officers known in these diggings, was a little slm'lnwv. or v.-n suh-.tantial, as the reader pleases ; ami some lawyers, En th< se days, certainly not in these, did not have supreme reverence for the1 tenth commandment. Witness the following incidents. Three or four miners had taken up a -et of claims "n Buckeye Hill, ami began a tunnel to reach the supposed iea'd. A party of lawyers in town either had a prioi ,,, or thought the claims desirable, and came to the ground where the miners were at work ami demanded possession. This was promptly refused, when the legal gentlemen raised a crowd in town, and returned to effeel their purpose byforce. In those daysthe average age of the citizen was about twentyfive, and it was not difficult to get up a crowd for any purpose. ! There was a good deal of recklessness, hut withal fairness, too, j in popular movements. The warlike crowd, ostentatiously armed, came surging on to the ground, and half a dozen eager spokesmen demanded possession in the name of the alleged owners, and began throwing tho tools off the claim. Tl upon a young miner, belonging to the assailed party, asked to be heard before further violence; for, he declared, if his party were not in the right they did not want the ground, and if they were they proposed to die on it. " That's right ! let's hear him :" shouted the crowd. Thereupon the young red-shirt i turned back to town in spite of the otfbrta of those who had induced them to come, leaving th.- orator and his partners undisturbed But it would be disrespectful to the legal pro
1 out of a justice court) to restrain tho defendants, i1 ita and employes, from further mining on said claim extracting an) gold then \ trial followed, whoroiu the justice, being duly prompted, held that, as it was "a proceed ing in equity," no jury could be allowed to the defendants; and he found them "guilty of unlawful detainer," nnd fined them "five hundred dollars for a breach of the peace," and the injunction was made perpetual. The onlj ction the ing ftmini at Pike Flat. So said the plaintiffs ought i> have protection, and his court wa there to give it, and he did not mean to allow a failure ol ju I ice if I" could help it,
$100,000. Jurisdiction was given to Justices in those days by statute in disputes in regard to mining claim , no matter what their value; the theory of the tatute being that il was the po ession, not the fee, of land, which was in dispute. A formidable array of conn 1 1 appeared in the case, being no le
White-sides, of Vuh;., si. Brown and Tom Bowers. The trial lasted three days and resulted in adi agreementof the jury. A new trial was commene.nl the next day and lasted ten days, during which forty witm amined, the jury render
A case of the infliction of whipping as a punishment of theft by sentence of a court tookplaceat Nevada City in 1852. A man grabbed a lot of money from a gaming tabli in Barkei Exchange on Main street. He was caught, tried befor. fl Justice, and sentenced to receive twenty lashes under a law that then permitted that punishment.. He was taken to the lot and tl was di covered thai ho had passed the evening at the dance liou < and then gone to Old Harriet's, where all further ii. i,, of i. mi was I" i Harriot and her fighting man were i 1 1 and charged before the Justice with murder. McConnell pro ooutod and Sawyer dcfendod The examination lasted Bovero] 'lavs Tho prosecution proved that Berry had money, braood hi-, movements tho night of hia death, as herein stated. showed that the wound on liis head must have been given while he was olive, and that it was made with some round, blunt weapon; thai there was a pair of scales on old Harriet's counter, and a large weight, which would produce such a wound; the condition of tho body, with anew, strong suit of clothes entirely missing; which, it was contended, it was impossible could be torn off by the stream, or at least, without greatly marring the body, which was intact, except the death wound on the head, The crj of murder was also proven, leaving .1 close knitted theory bj the prosecution, well-sustained by circumstances, that Berry bad Won murdered and stripped at Old Harriet's and thrown over into the creek. On the other hand it was shown that Berry lived at Gold Rim;
The flood referred to, which swept away the bridges in 1852, carried off as well a theater and other buildings which were built over the water. The owner of this theater had not found it a paying speculation, or had undertaken a work beyond his means, for he had left his mechanics and material men unpaid. , bad put a i> mechanics' liens on the property , and there were, besides, several mortgages upon it. One day there was a trial in progress before County Judge Caswell to determine the priority of Hens. While the court was so engaged there was a greal commotion outside, when the court and law vers all rushed out to see what was the matter. Th b era k was in full sight from the i treet in front of the court loom, and it was observed that the raging waters had knocked the props from under the theater, and it leaned over the water ai an angle of forty-five degrees. "There," said Sawyer, who was in the case, " there is a lean that will take precedence mi us all!" Pretty soon the theater went crashing down the creek over the rocks, and disappeared in the foaming waters. The interest in the lien case was visibly diminished.
In the summer of 1852 Rev. Adam Bland was pastor of the Methodist church at Nevada City. He was a zealous man, not remarkable for great gifts as a preacher, but popular and acceptable for his earnestness and sincerity. Among the constant attendants on his ministrations was Mrs. Miller, who was much more devoted to the services of the sanctuary than her husband, who preferred to pass the Sabbath at poker and other sportive games. One Sunday Mr. Bland took occasion to discourse against those men who neglect gospel ministrations for the gaming table, and let their wives attend church alone. He spoke with such particularity that everybody recognized to whom he referred. This came to Miller's ears, who took occasion to meet Mr. Bland near his church, then standing where the old graveyard now IS, and to give him a thrashing Mr Bland was a muscular Christian, and it so resulted that Miller was the one thrashed, and that soundly, though Mr. Bland always insisted that he only shook him against the jtting the worst of the encounter, Miller complained Dougherty, an eccentric Justice of the Peace, his brethren of the church, were present, and a general attendance of the wicked, all these glorying in the fighting parson, but ready to enjoy fun at anybody's expense. When the case ,, B railed for trial, McConnell, who was then District Attorney, did not appear to prosecute. " Mr. Sheriff," said the Justice, "call* Mr. McConnell. Somebody has got to prosecute this calls the District Attorney reluctantly appeared, and the facts were developed. The learned Justice summed up the case as follows: "I think this was a fair fight. Miller commenced it, and got a good licking. It was good enough for him. The prisoner is discharged." The decision was received with smiling approval by the ladies, and with hilarious applause by the ungodly, who speedily indulged in drinks all round, in which the Judge was Induced to share.
In 1854 Niles Searls was nominated for District Attorney by the Democrats and C. Wilson Hill by the Whigs. A couple of fellows had stolen some horses on the Yuba above Washington, and were arrested and brought to Nevada for preliminary examination, before Justice Dougherty. The stolen horses were found in their possession- The boys, Democrats and Whigs, agreed that Searls should prosecute and Hill defend, as a trial of their quality, and their fitness to be elected District Attorney; and it was so arranged that they were appointed for these duties by the court, which was not, however, in the secret of the arrangement. An immense crowd filled the court room, the respective political parties confident in their champions. Searls introduced his evidence, and made out a clear, clean case of stealing. Hill called several witnesses and had them sworn. The first question be asked was if the witness had known the defendants in Providence, Rhode Island, and what their character was for honesty there. "What do you expect to prove by that?" demanded the Justice. " The prisoners' good character," replied Hill. "Good character!" squealed out old Zeke. " Good character! when they were found with the stolen property in their possession ! Good character, when they are tart bj the unfortunate facl thai the prosecuting lawyei oi ivoly inebriated, and the other lawyers were not far bohind in that regard. Thi ,t behind a light pine furniture skip again, A few -lays before D. had had < before the same justice, the decision in which did not p] him, AJluding to that case he said, " I dreamed a dream the other night, that an old fool of a justice decided thatadogis property." [Whack.] ' Don'l pound m\ table, Mr, D.n "Maj It please your honor [whack], I will pound your table!1, of this Bort of thing. I have something better to do than to listen to this drunken gabble." "Yaas, you have, have you said I), with a sneer, " Who are you' Know it all.don'l youi The other lawyers had been grinning, and rather helping ou< the absurdity of the thing; but this intervention was too much forthein, and they thought il necessary to frown down furth r levity. Thooase proceeded until il came to D/s turn toaddresa blwjury, when he began as follows; " Gentlemen of the jury; and when I say 'Gentlemen of the jury/ 1 mean eleven of you; tor there is one of you who is wry far from being a gentleman I" Haw the juror wh'o had criticised D.s conduct of the case jumped up and pulled off his font, to give him a tin-ashing. Peace was restored with great difficulty, and tin- case concluded.
11' is only Fair to Mr. Dunn to remark that hi- eccentricities, when under the influence of liquor, color the memories <>\' him. perhaps to the unjust exclusion o\' other more worthy impressions. Bis practice was large, and ho was quite successful in conducting it. Ee was understood to be scrupulously and even belligerently faithful to his clients, and his convivial habits were broken by long spells of sobriety. IK- was not the great toper at the Nevada bar, but was probably the most eccentric man when inebriated. That liquor was a potent agent in olrivi! machin liquors imbibed by the court* jury, parties, lawyers and aiders, should b< charged as costs, and abide the result of the The plaintiffs proceeded with their cast and quite liboral use of the resources of the bar p bj all bands \\ hen it came to d< 6 udant'a turn it was found that the main witness, an old Scotchman, had been made ring drunk, as it was Buspected, bj the other side; and was in such a wild, .-ra/.y condition, thai il seemed doubtful if he would gel to his Henses in a week, The only chance for the defendant, it was concluded, was to break the- whole thing up in a row, and for thai the materials were abundant, A big Kentuckian and as big New Worker, on the jury, were pretty far gone, and i boa ted oi his native State, and came near fighting the thing
When it again met the jury were in Buch a condition that the plaintiffs wanted to adjourn until morning. Stewart said \o: if getting folks drunk is your t^ame. there will be enough of it," and audaciously argued to the Justice that if an adjourn d\k combat, and the jury wen- SO drunk that it made little difference. Roberts commenced the argument, and was followed by Conn, the jury drinking all the time to their hearts' content, in which they were encouraged by suggestion and example from defendant's side. Gardiner followed, and then Stewart, exhausting mosl of the night. When Dibble came to speak some of the jurymen told him to "dry up," and some got to disputing with each other and giving the lie. They were too drunk to hurt each other. When the jury retired, they asked for whisky. " Yes," said defendant's lawyers, "that is in the stipulation," and a demijohn was sent out with them. The next mornings sun saw the jury lying loose all round town. They had separated without agreeing on a verdict This was what the defendant's side had intended when it was found
Brown's bar The plaintiffi were do! able to paj the bill and »W ,,llt for o I w mi kepi his claims on Boston Ravine, and thiawaa his first Mart in Nevada county. II .picntly became a wealthy and influential citiien ^i Qra \ J romini ul foi years in all political . oted to the stat.- Senate, and was killed some years since l>\ beino thrown from his bugg^ on the Eureka road, His popularity was vi and his generosity a proverb, His untimeh
Nevada, called the Nevada Rifles, for renl of theii armory, al Slain and l Commercial streel Flui .hurt/, a brewer, had owned the building and rented it to the company, He moi ad il to Lones, who ton i lo ed and boughl in the property, of which he took a kind of forcible poss< ion. He afterwards brought thi i suil to recover rent Rufu . Shoemal 1 1 County Clerk, and ,-it one time editor of bhi Gra i Volley Union, a portlj gentleman, was captain of the oompany, Belden drew the follow-in- i wh\ h | insoiied in Pull witle.ui. apologj for its [i ogth, b il i o plote with humoi Hank Benerr was ;i member of the Rifles, and igned ai attorney though uol a lawyer, as anyone could practice in mi Peter Mushaway, Esq.," referred to in the answer, was a well known local character, half pauper and wholly bummer. Tin- " King of hmifu" wiim J C, Malbon, Brat city marshal. The exhibits were prepared by John Patti son, the local Nast, ;n"l were drawn on yellow paper, with proper embellishments The case was tried before Justice E, of which the pleadings may he seen by the CUrioU to fchi da The reader will notice that, with all the extravagant humor of the answer, the pleader kept an eye to a good defen c
Now comes Henry Kiierr, especially retained for this eau i and answering personally and severally for each of the defendants therein sued, how to this Court that the judicial iniquity of this attempt of plaintiff is unparalleled and bis impudence unprecedented in the history of men. Defendant further show through the said Knerr, their learned counsel, that language and the forms of speech are unable to convey their true feelings and the wrongs they have suffered at the hands of this plaintiff; to attoin to him, bho said plaintiff] as landlord, as will more dearly appear by reference to Exhibit B, made pari of this answer Bui defendant Arm in their integrity of pui po e, unaoduced bj Battery, aa undismayed by disaster, they have over resisted bia importunities; that they have never rocogni nd him as their landlord, and that, completely disgusted with his present oourae, it ia their settled intention to never racoj in q him In anj capacity whatever. And the defendants further ahovi that during the term and time in which said plaintiff chargi these defendants with the occupation of said promises, the same were held and occupied under a lease from aaid plaintiff bj one Madam Clark as a dancing school, and that these defendanta were evicted and ejected by Baid Ma-lam Clark, the lessee of said plaintiff These defendants, proceeding bo uarrate the facts connected therewith, show that, being naturally men of sanguinary propensities, thej did march, arrayed in gorgeous apparel, very wonderful to behold, and with divers fearful weapons, to the said hall, to the end that a certain doughty warrior, one King of Pungo, should instruct ttunn in the slaughter of men. And defendants show that, as they draw near to said hall, they hoard music and the sound of revelry, whereupon, with the speed of an antelope, or of divers antelopes, said defendants did incontinently rush toward said
And defendanta further answering, show that during the term of aaid occupancy, as sued upon by said plaintiff, said premises and building were out of repair and inaccessible, on jut of the ruinous condition thereof, and that said defendanta were utterly unable to occupj the same on account of their ruinous condition, and that the said plaintiff did suffer and permit said premises to thus become untenantable, well knowing the condition thereof; and defendants aver that, although aa brave as lions, they are as wise as serpents, and well knowing the premises, and that if the premises fell upon said defendants, there would not be a grease spot left of any one, Bave and except their captain, said defendants did with bul Borne haste, retreat from said building, \ 1 1. 1 deft adants show that the weapons and munitions of war owned by these defendants, and in said building, would have been utterly lost and destroyed but for the exertions of a certain courageous individual, P. Mushaway, Esq., said Mushaway removing, at the peril of his life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, the said munitions of war and commissary stores therefrom, said Mushaway being hereby referred to by these defendants as Exhibit K. and made part of this answer. Said defendants further refer to Exhibit D, herewith filed, as more fully explaining the condition of said premises and the exertions of said Mushaway. And defendants further refer to Nos. I and 2 of Exhibit E, as more fully explaining the condition of >aid premises, the whole thereof being hereby made part of this answer.
And defendants show that, in consequence of the condition of said premises., these defendants have suffered loss and injury in the stun and to the amount of seven thousand four hundred and thirty-eight dollars and eighty-one cents, in manner and form following, to wit: These defendants show that during the year L858, the Indians upon the frontiers of California, and in the neighboring State of Oregon, did proceed to kill and massacre the white population then and there living. See Senator Gwin's letter to Mr. Buchanan, hereby referred to and made part of this answer. And these defendants show that had said defendants been sufficiently trained in the art ami science of war, these said defendants would have been employed by the Government to exterminate said Indians. And said defendants show that they are informed and verily believe that had they taken the field, said Indians would now be extinct and wiped out, and that the feats of horrid war performed by these defendants would have redounded tn their glory and the national honor, in the sum above set forth. And defendants refer this Court to Exhibit F, as more fully illustrating the intentions i^\' 'dies- defendants, said exhibit being made part of this answer. But defendants show that, upon account of the ruinous condition of said building, defendants were not trained; and not being trained, were not taken; and not being taken, did not perform those featsj whereby they have suffered loss and injury in the sum and to the amount above named.
And defendants finally answering, deny that they are or any of them are indebted to said plaintiff in the sum set forth, or in any sum whatever. And they further say that said building was in a ruinous condition, unlit for occupancy, at the times sued upon by said plaintiff, wherefore they pray to be dismissed with costs and money disluiisements. HeNIIY Knerk,
To the answer were attached ludicrous illustrations of the points made by the document, drawn on yellow paper and marked Exhibits A to F. The exhibits were severally as follows : -
Exhibit JJ. Represents Lones employing his blandishments to induce ye valiant warriors to accept a lease which he holds in his hand, and is endorsed " Non attornment."
Exhibit 0. No. 1 represents Madame Clark confronting the gorgeously arrayed militia boys, while No. 2 shows the doughty warriors in full retreat, the valiant King of Pun&'o descending head foremost from a window, shrieking, " Make way for your commanding officer." The whole being endorsed " Dancing School, or the relation of Madame Clark vs the Nevada Rifles."
Exhibit D. Represents the building in the last stages of dissolution with the sign " Look out for falling bricks," ami is endorsed " Condition of the building - wall falling - Gregory & Sparks removing - population fenced out - Peter Mushaway Esq., removing the 'munitions of war' with a long pole from the second story window - rats and 'other insects' decamping in haste."
Exhibit E. No. 1, Picture of building cracked and broken, propped up on all sides, endorsed " Appearance of the building at the close of the term of the Rifles' lease. No.. 2 shows a Chinaman in full possession of the few bricks that remain standing."
Mrs. E.E.Fisher Watches, Diamonds & Jewelry
found guilty and the case was appealed to the Bupi Court, A j» touliai ii j a\ it treatment by that tribunal that the court a turned thai the only question in the case whether or uo1 ' 'bineso testimony was admissible.
Thi point, without aid from the record, ii raised and decided [<>i it ill tt bold that the Chinaman is an [ndian, and o eluded Prom the witness stand by the law of the State that, "no black, or mulatto person, or [ndian shall be allowed to fivi evidence In favor of, or against, a white man" The ethnological reasoning by which the Court arrived at it- con elusions reads curiouj l\ enough, but iliis derision is a standing evidence that the influx of Chinese was looked uponal that
"The anomalous Rpectaole of a distincl people Living in out community, recognizing no laws of tliis Stat.*, excepl through Qecossityj bringing with them their prejudices and national feuds, in which they indulge in open violation of law ; whose mendacity is proverbial ; a race whom nature lias marked as inferior! and who are incapable of progress or intellectual development boyond o certain point, as thoir history lias shown; differing in language, opinions, color and physical conformation, between whom and ourselves nature has placed an impassible difference! is now presented, and for them is claimed, not
'The elder lawyers of the Nevada bar remember thatacloseh contested case, which might have turned either way on the merits, was lost by a witness over-swearing himself. Some valuable mining claims were in question and the right depended largely on priority o\' location, After a fair ease for the plaintiff had concluded the defendant introduced among i ther proceeded very smoothly until it came to cross-examination, when the plaintiff's Lawyer Led the witness book over his testimony, asked him if the notice produced was the original notice, who put it up, where he got his tacks, etc. The witness swore to putting up that notice, ami gave all the particulars. He recognized the notice; was positive of that.
The too-willing witni a was here compelled to admit that he eoidd not writ.- even hi- name. In his eagerness to help his side he had been betrayed into assuming too much. < »f co his testimony, however true it might otherwise be, was hi
A somewhat similar storj is related of the practice of Lord Erekine. Se was opposing the proof of a will. The subscribing witness described the scene of the execution of the will by the deceased. Erskine asked him if the deceased signed with his own hand; if he sealed with his own hand; where the wax .it ; where the taper to light it; who held the candle, etc. The witnesses told where the wax and candle to melt it were brought from ; that he held the Candle and saw the wax melted on the document and impressed with his own seal by the deceased; when Erskine held up the will and showed to the tn June, 1856, Amos T. Laird and Thomas Chambers contracted with Moore \" Foss, saw mill men, to construct a dam forty feet nigh on Deer creek several miles above Nevada < 'it v. There was a flat above the gorge in the creek where the dam was to lie erected, and such a dam would flood about an hundred acres. The purpose was to hold back the water for use in mining during the summer. The dam was built of logs and timber set on end so as<to bear against the pressure, and sheathed with plank. Of course it gave way as soon as it began to get full of water, which it did on the 15th of the following February, during a sudden storm and freshet. The accumulated water rushed with great force down the creek and swept away all the buildings on the margin of the stream at the Main and Broad street bridges, as well as doing other damage. A large number of suits grew out of this occurrence, in which Laird & Chambers and Moore & Foss were joined as defendants. The plaintiffs recovered damages in the District ming the three \\ itn< i to 1 he alibi - parafc and n ithoul the hearing of each othei Each of them b tiflod thai Briscoe slept in their cabin the night of the robbery [f thi wn true Briscoi could not have participated in the crime The pro ecu tion a l ed bui on qui tion of ca h \\ ith whom did Bri coi my bunk." No credit could be given to uch testimony and the alibi tailed to save the defendant, Bui a nhori time after Bri coe had been Bafel) lodged in the State's prison, a robber) three friends wen u pected of being the robboi . They were arrested, and under a stone in the cabin, a lot of gold dust was found tied up in a watch pocket that had evident!) been cut from a pair of pant-. Thi poi I taken to the jail and and the foot print »ft i robber were left around the luiccs.One boot heel mark attracted especial attention b one ideofitwas deeply indented and showed coat i nails, A boot bi longing to Jacobs, with a heel tapped byhimself,ju t fitted tin mark. But, to conclusively prove the guilt of the defen pro e cuting counsel, who were thi ami as in the preceding ca - called all the bankers in town, who were familiar with the gold dust from all the localities far miles around, and they examined the dust found in the cabin with a micro cope, identified it by certain bits of rose quartz sticking to it, and by ii general qualities, as gold from th< Goodman diggings, which resembled
, ., annihilated the plaintlfl Like Brown, in Bret Earte's Sooli u of the Btaiiulaus, who wnsl.it in the abdomen by a oh u nil of old rod and tone, old contest*, where skilfully planned attacks were mel by M.iiuii defense, and the ECnighta of the taw covered themselves with gloi j and filled their pockets with fees, it is nol thereby Intimated thai thelogal tournamente here were generally less iii.it \\u oocs Lona] Farcical pirii displayed, and herein adverted in was o prevailing mood al the Nevada bar. The distinction which so m:iii\ of its liinnln-is have won iii this and other communities! as shown bj the slight sketch we have given of the political and judicial honors bestowed upon them, is .->. sufficionl answer to any such suspicion.
Neither are the Instances related of a resort to lynch law characteristic of the early Battlers of tins county. The community, as a rule, writ' scrupulously law abiding. Only supposed necessity for self-defense was allowed to influence towards popular punishment, and the cases where such means of repressing crime were adopted were very few. Testimony to this i« given by one of the early settlers and members of the bar, in an able address delivered in June, 187!), at the Nevada county reunion, Mr. Ma/Jin said: -
" Of all the noble men in the State, Nevada county possessed a. large portion M* the noblest, mosl intellectual and best. They were foremost in organising society upon sate and sure foundations. There wore, and have been, less scenes of violence, less of that species of crime peculiar to newly settled communities in this than in any of theother counties in the State. The spirit of the citizens of Nevada brooked no disobedience to law. Very early men began to look upon the county as their
,tydid its foil share inlaying broad and deep the foundations of a prosperous and enlightened comn.unitv. Its members were the leaders of public thought, and behind no class in the community in public-spirited action. wen trained here for wider fields of exerl anrl oot that, wherever the lot of these may have
Provenance
Text from History of Nevada County, California; with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks, and Manufactories .., published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.