BlockBefore

Nevada County, California - Chapter 31: The Court of Judge Lynch, 1880

From History of Nevada County, California; with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks, and Manufactories .., published 1880. 3,411 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

2 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

3,411 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Nevada County, California; with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks, and Manufactories .., published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 31: The Court of Judge Lynch

That it is one of the chief functions of a government to protect its citizens the one from the other, and to punish him who wilfully commits an act of violence, seems to us to be indisputable; and vet the time was when this principle was not recognized, and there exist to-day tribes of savages so far down in the scale of civilization and so little advanced from the condition of the brutes that they know no law but the law of force and no right but the right of strength. All the general government they ever have is a combination in times of danger to repel external foes. The killing or robbing of one man by another is considered a personal or family affair, a wrong to be redressed by the injured party, and one with which the government has nothing to do. Civilized nations have for centuries held that the protection of a subject at home is as much the duty of a government, as abroad, and the punishment for crime is the means now adopted to restrain its commission, b vth by placing the criminal where, for a season at least, a repetition of his offense is impossible, and by the warning of his example to stay the hand of others. The history of the evolution of this principle it is not necessary to give, nor to show that the theory upon which it is based and supported is not the same as the one which gave it birth. We now recognize the principle that the just power to punish crime and to protect society lies with the government, and that all good citizens, no matter what may be the provocation to mete out justice according to their standard and as passion and power may dictate, should bow to the majesty of the law, and uphold its supremacy with an unfaltering hand.

and the blood was leaping and surging through its veins; there mod to be some latent spell lying in the glittering sand that seized upon all that approached it. The life was intense, exciting, boiling; suchapeople could no more act with the calm deliberation of a settled community, than could the rolling and tossing victim of a fever reason with a sage. Men acted from impulse, not from reason, and when reason is dethroned by passion or prejudice, great injustice and wrong are invariably committed. The excuse the people of California have to offer for the deeds oi blood that stain the pages of her early history are the newness of the community, the incongruity and cosmopolitan character of the population, and the great law of self protection. The courts were but newly and imperfectly organized; the great door of justice stood but partly ajar and grated upon its rusty hinges; the people were feverish and impatient at the delays of law, and frequently meted out punishment swiftly and surely, but not always justly, for prejudice on an illegal bench and passion in the jury box are but illy calculated to dispense even and exact justice.

For several years a miners' court with Judge Lynch presiding was the favorite bar of justice to which an aggrieved person or community appealed, if, indeed an appeal had not first been taken to the arbitration of the revolver or bowie knife. For personal difficulties the latter was a favorite resort, but when a murder or robbery had been committed, the known or suspected guilty one was captured, a judge and jury selected and a trial proceeded with in the form, but without the sanction of law. To be suspected and tried was generally equivalent to conviction, for with their minds warped by prejudice and passion it took but slight evidence to convince a mob jury of the guilt of a prisoner. Circumstantial evidence and even the fact that the accused looked as if he might have committed the act, weighed heavily against him. The sentence usually passed for murder or robbery of an aggravated character was death, and for all other offenses whipping. The execution of the sentence was swift and certain, a rope was thrown over a limb of a convenient tree and many willing hands drew the struggling victim from the ground; when sentenced to be whipped a man was stripped of his clothing to his hips, bound to a tree and severely flagellated with a rope's end or mercilessly lashed with a whip made of leather thongs; he was then untied and invited to leave. Sometimes he was branded on the face or back, so that he might be known and watched wherever he might wander. How it must have harrowed the very soul of an innocent man to wander about from place to place with the brand of infamy upon his cheek, shunned and viewed with suspicion by all. The galling stripe and the searing brand might often have been applied to the back and cheek of many who were most eager to wreak vengeance upon their ill-starred victim ; but Justice is blind and mob Justice is not only blind but deaf,

Drugs.Qils &. Chemicals

Howard, and encouraged b> W ithei , who wa the real thief, i, odStndloj biod him to a tree and proceeded to give him liiu |fl boa. While they were still laying the laahea on theii victim back, which waa quivering and bleeding from thirty cruel blowi Judge E W Roberta and several other gentlemen rushed into the i rowd thn si the men right and left and madi their way to the tree The} told tho "bounds" thai they should uol whip an innocent man, and that the guilty thief was Withers, who stood trembling by B3 their fearless conduol the) oovorawed bhe men thai they were able to unbind Studley and conduct him to a placeof safety without opposition. On tin* first da} of March, 1851, a man with a small band of mules crossed the South Yuba bridge al Bridgeport and pro oeeded towards the Middle Yuba river Not long after his departure 0 rumor became current in the town that the man was a thief and the mules stolen property. Three or four men, li-.l by a determined character named Spur, immediately started in pursuit, and overtook him at the Qri Ij Canon tloust on Qri !\ Canon. Be was brought back to Bridgeport, and preparations were made for his trial. A miners' court was organ 1 ad and the man placed upon trial, which proceedings lasted four days. Be was adjudged guilty by the inch jury, and was sentenced to be hanged on the fourth day after the decision.

So great was the interest in the case thai people gathered here in great numbers, some coming from Yuba and Butte counties, and great preparations were made to enforce the execution of the sentence, To prevent a rescue at least a thousand men guarded every avenue of approach to the town question of the supremacy of the law waa put to a m The county officials had all taken their oaths of office, the »01d Red Court House" had been provided, on the con Main and Church streets, but the courts had not yel opened Thi election was held on the fourth Monday in is.'.i, and about the first of June, Nevada City escaped the .1" a lynching acene bj the courage and firmness of its newly elected officials.

r S. Gregory, well known as a hotel man in the city, had brought with him bo l ialifornia a number of Negroes, and one of bhi se, a large woman, was abusing Mi Gregory, on the daj in question, as Alexander Brown, usually called Sandy Brown, Sandy was enraged at the sighl 1 1 e Negn abusing a white woman, entered the bouse and administered a severe chastisement to her. Sandy was a sporting character and passed down to a saloon, taking no further thought of the occurrence. He was met in the saloon a Bhort time after by a man named Smith, who began to abuse him and threatened to whip him for striking a woman. In the fight which ensued, Sandy was overpowered by his opponent and just as Smith raised him in his arms to dash him to the floor, he drew a revolver and shot his antagonist in the hip. Iiumediately there was great excitement* and Sandy hastened to Gregory's B and delivered himself to the newly elected Sheriff, John Gallagher, claiming protection from the mob. Men were mounted upon hois - by Hurst of Davis & Hurst, and dispatehed to the mining camps in the vicinity with the intelligence that a gambler had shot a miner. Miners 1 egan to hasten into the city, crying vengeance, and the prospects for a hanging wereathigh tide The I founty Jndge elect, Thomas H. Caswell, was lying ill in his room, when he received word from the Sheriff that a mob threatened to hang a man, and asking his assistance. Judee Caswell instantly arose and went to the hotel, and taking

Judge Buckner appeared before the crowd and addrei ad the people advising them to remain quiet, as Sandy would receive a trial, and if found guilty would be punished. The crowd shout I 1 I the Judge come out and tell a Accordingly Judge Caswell appeared and b ored them thai the Grand Jury would meet the next week Brown would be indicted, and should have a fair and impartial trial, ami turning to one of the leading spirits, a large and powerful man, he continued, " Valentine Butech, I want you to select o

1 week for trial." A.t this juncture there was a or} of' Be wants to get him off," followed bj veil to 'Hang the Judge!" The day had been won, however, by enliating

The next week the fti 1 Grand Jury met and Indicted Brown, who was safely delivered for trial by bia guard Judge Caa well had been requested i<\ friends Dot to try the case in person, as it ha. 1 been threatened that if the man wan ae.niiiir.lili.> Judge would not li\«- twenty-four hours, He declined to be intimidated, opened his court with a speech in which he alluded to the threat and assured the people that any attompl at law lessness would be put down with a strong arm, and called fh< Thi evidence showed so plainly that Brown had acted in Belf-defense, that the jury of miners, actuated 0 they always were,even in their lynching exploits, by the pirit of justice, brought in a vordiet of acquittal, ami Sandy Brown was dis red to walk the street unmolested, One day in the ummei of 1851 a team driven by two men wound i' way slowly along the crooked mountain road, near ; of the present town of Spenceville, One of them, a young lad, loitered behind the wagon, and when his companion had disappeared around a bend in the road, two [ndiam appi ared out of the thicket, and one of whom shot the young loiterer. The teamster heard the shot and returned only to find his companion lying wounded by the roadside. He was immediately conveyed to the Indiana Hon-, kept by his uncle, Mr. Vvaldron, was hold, and Wemah agreed to have the guilty men brought \n Runners were senl out, who returned on the third day wlili two Indians, whom Judge Roberts proceeded to examine before committing them for trial. The examination commenced at nine o'clock in the morning and was uot concluded until midnight While the regular inquisition was progressing, the orowd of over ii\<( hundred men selected a jury to determine tli,- guilt of the prisoners independently. This miners' jury listened to the evidence and reported their verdict to the people. Judge Roberts committed one of them named Collo, but discharged the other, making a short speech to the crowd, who permitted the innocent one to depart unmolested

Collo was committed to the back room of the house, in charge of Constable William D. Blalone. The band of twentyono adventurers, who had remained through the proceedings, then marched into the house, passed through the front room where Judge Roberts was sitting, and demanded the prisoner. An appeal was made to the bystanders for assistance, but no one responded, and the Constable could make no resistance. One of the men jumped upon the table and announced, wJmade to stand upon the box. A rope was fastened to an overhanging limb, the noose adjusted about the victims neck, and when all was ready the support was removed from under , ;iU(1 , .,(i1()) the murderer, swang in mid air, meeting an Qlegal but a well deserved death.

The village of Newtown on the fourth of March, 1852, witnessed the most cruel and heartless exhibition of mob violence that stain the pages of Nevada's history. A robbery had been committed and a Negro named Brown was arrested upon suspicion of being the guilty party. Upon his person found a sum of money nearly as great as the amount

A jury of twenty-four and a presiding judge were chosen, and the few scraps of circumstantial evidence were brought out in dress parade before the predetermined jury, who declared the man to be guilty and left the degree of punishment to be fixed by the crowd. The turbulent mob that surrounded the court clamoured for his death, and it was so decreed. A rope was placed about his neck, and the Negro was led to a tree which is still standing near Mrs. Schardin's residence. Brown was mounted in a wagon, and the end of the rope was fastened to a limb of the tree. The rope was a little too long, and when the man was pushed off from the wagon, the limb bent sufficiently to allow his toes to touch the ground. As he hung there slowly strangling, his breast heaved as he gasped for breath and his body writhed in agonized contortions. One of the mob, more compassionate than the rest, oerhaps, climbed the tree and ieaped upon his shoulders, in order to break his neck. The rain was falling in torrents, and the gymnastic hangman fell sprawling in the mud.

hang him decently if they were determined upon his death. A sailor then climbed the tree and fastened the rope to a higher and stouter limb, the noose was again adjusted about the victim's neck and he was pushed from the wagon. He was left to hang struggling in the air for some time, when he was cut down. A physician gav< ftb0ve -round live minutes the man would revive, and he was therefore hastily dumped into a grave that had been dug and was half full of water, and quickly covered from sight. _

Beekman s Flat was a small mining camp on the north side 0| Deer creek, about five miles down that stream from Nevada Git, and distant about one mile from Newtown. Four partaers located on the Hat in the winter of 1851-2 and worked imtil the following summer. Every thing seemed to move smoothly between the partners and not a cloud crossed their horizon," until one bright, summer day one of them accused :umtlu,r named Pope of stealing a jar of gold. The excitement was intense; a crowd collected on the flat, angry and excited, for a theft of gold dust was the most heinous crime in a mining camp A miners' court was instantly organized in the largest log cabin on the Mat, and a man over six feet in higlit and about sixty years of age was chosen for a judge. The only testimony offered was by the complainant, who said that he had buried in their cabin a quart pickel jar full of gold dust, that it was gone, and that Pope must have taken it as he was the only other man who knew of the hiding place. The most earnest denials of the prisoner availed him nothing, and he was convicted and sentenced to be hanged the next morning at nine o'clock, provided he did not confess and restore the stolen dust, when he would be delivered to the authorities. The man had not stolen and could not restore the gold, and as the time drew nigh for the execution of the sentence Pope's chances for escape seemed few. He had been taken to Newtown and placed under a guard of six men for safe keeping, and into that place came pouring crowds from all the mining camps in the neighborhood to witness the execution. These gathered in knots to discuss the situation. Many were opposed to hanging by mob law, and especially upon circumstantial evidence, but they were in a "minority. They made unavailing speeches to the crowd, and preparations were made to execute the sentence of Judge Lynch. About half -past eight o'clock Sheriff Endicott and District Attorney John R McOonnell came riding into town, having come at a break neck speed from Nevada City, whither a friend of the prisoner had gone with the intelligence that an innocent man was about to be hanged for stealing. They prevailed upon the crowd to let them take the prisoner to Nevada City for trial by the legal authorities, and then conducted him thither, where an examination revealed the fact that there was no evidence against him. He was discharged from custody, and at once left the State, thoroughly disgusted with miners' courts and people's j uries.

Among the early population of Grass Valley were a number of men from Baltimore, who associated together and formed a mutual alliance of offense and defense. They called themselves the "Baltimore Boys," but were known to outsiders as the

Judge Roberta commenced speaking to thecrowd, and Baid the man should not be hung if it could 1"- prevented, and oertaiul) should not unleasa majorit) of those presenl were in favor of it, He unmediatol) put the question to thecrowd who voted thai the man should noi be hung Judge Roberts then Baid: " I am the * Jounty Judge, and I order « ionstable Banks to arrest thai mmi" Bill Banks, the Constable, was also a Baltimore man, bul be rushed in with the part) and threw the noose from Doyle's neck, untied his hands, and moved oui ->t the crowd, warniug them thai the prisoner was in the custod) of the law Before the " Baltimore Boys" had full) Prom their astonishment, the part) had gathered around Doyle, and all had started down Main street on a keen run. Exasperated at being thus robbed of their prey, the " Hounds rushed after the retreating men, and struck madly and wildly over the shoulders of the guards in their efforts to reach Doyle with their knives; but all in vain, for he was safely housed in N. H Davis' office. While the excited crowd were raving on the outat Um

Th< whipping are quite nun The circumstances «-f the whipping *-f three men in V Cit) in the spring of 1851 are detailed by Hon A \ Sargent in our chapter on The N pven an mi of i!"- attempted lynching in Grass Valley immediately after the great fir-- in 1855, and the resci f Mr. Owona from a mob in Rough and Ready in L851 \i Newtown in 1851, a mannamed Jonea waa whipped for breaking into a Btore, and in the spring of 1852, Barrett who was afterwards ban in Nevada City, was whipped. On the morning of the great fire of March 11. 1851 ai Nevada City, a man was given twelve lashes for stealing a sack of Hum-. In little York, in Is man Btole a specimen valued at $300, and upon conviction the citizens was severely lashed and permitted t" vanish from ,; in 1854, a m.-.n found -"iffy of stealing nuggets on Kentucky Flat was given thirty lashes and requested to town In November, 1850, a man named Napoleon Collins found guilty <>f stealing a mule in Grass Valley, and had thirty-six lashes laid upon his bare back. At Rough and i;, ady, Is-"'" a man was sent no d to receive thirty nine lashi - for stealing, hj the Committee of Justice that then administered affairs in thai town. He received bis punishment and in lition a kick and warning never to appear in town again. Other cases of whipping occurred, l"it the particulars have not been learned.

Provenance

Text from History of Nevada County, California; with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks, and Manufactories .., published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.