Nevada County, California - Chapter 32: The Death Penalty, 1880
From History of Nevada County, California; with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks, and Manufactories .., published 1880. 6,277 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
6,277 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Nevada County, California; with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks, and Manufactories .., published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Eight times has the extreme sentence of the law been | by the legal tribunals, and five times has it been executed. Twice the condemned criminal has taken his own life, ami
. Chinaman hanged himself in his cell prior :iis trial, another n«'\\ Ilea in jail under The punishment of death bj hangu uol and uncivilised and sometimes 1>> tin- bun ling "f unskillful hands becomes the essence ol hideous torture iked and hon ible murders have been committed u and bul six men have idemned to pay i)t.> t\ with tli.ii lives Thai the fat.- ->f these fevi has tontled train the commission >-f murder \-> not evidenced 03 the sad it would seem as it* some other mothod ol punish in. m should be devised than the barbarous practice "i hang* ing, a custom that will be looked upon by our postorit} witli the same horror inspired in us bj the tortures of the Inqul tion.
Thelawwhich permitted the jurj to bring in a verdict of guilty with tit.- death penalty attached for the orimoof grand larcenj remained on thi but littl< more than a year, and yet during that time wveral were condemned and executed under it 1 provisions 1' i b ml take to uppose that on) 1 1 of the I in Nevada count) . for arm) and branded with the Lett 1 " R," a 1 a rogue, foi thievi i-\ It is 0 mistake to uppo 0,8* most of the old n 1 dente do that he received this brand at Newtown rli hod a crowd. The first, man chosen bis ktecounsel, the butcher, who laid on the stripes unmerci folly ^ did also the others He was then warned to leave the i M in,, grand laro n.3 , ao \ erdicl wo n Qdered on thai one A.s was predicted, the jur) Pound him guiltj on the first om I'm- stealing 81357, and attached the death penalty. No verdii I waa given on the indictment for stealing the watch, and he was not hanged for stealing a ten dollar watch, as ao many erroneously believe.
The jail a1 Nevada Citj being not yet completed, he was convoyed bo Marysvillo, and confined until the time set for his execution, Friday, the sixteenth of July, 1852, arrived, and A.oting Sheriff Endicotl summoned a body guard, among whom were all the lawyers in the city, to guard the prisoner and to maintain order al the execution. The gallows had been erected on the flat on Deer creek, back of Mr. Marsh's residence, and which place has ever since been known as Gallows Flat. Thither the unfortunate man was conducted, and in the presence of a large concourse of people, and surrounded by the ristingfeud between Frank V. Moore and Alexan- ,i Grass Valley, lead to a tragedj which (inall. | i,, the death of both. Saturday night, February 21, 1857 WcClanahan waa sitting in Haywood's store, in
Valley, engaged in conversation, when Moore entered and asked him if he waa armed. He replied that he was not, and waa told to arm himself, as he, Moore, intended to shoot him. Thua warned, McClanahan retired and soon returned with a revolver; upon his return both he and Moore raised their revolvers and fired simultaneously, McClanahan being shot through the heart and expiring instantly. The light in the room was extinguished by the concussion, and while darkness prevailed some one whose identity was never discovered, stabbed Moore in the hack, inflicting a painful but not fatal wound. Moore was arrested, indicted and tried; during the trial an attempt was made by the defence to prove a conspiracy to Kill Moore, and the wound inflicted in the dark was cited as evidence of it; some maintained that the knife wound was given by Moore himself, in order to create sympathy for himself. The jury, however, brought in a verdict of guilty of murder in the first degree, and Moore was sentenced to be executed Friday, dune 19, 1857- He was out on bail upon the charge of committing rape at the time he killed McClanahan, and a few days prior to his trial for murder, he was convicted of the other crime and sentenced to a term of fifteen years in the penitentiary. Application was made to the Governor for a reprieve, in order to allow time for the perfection of appeal papers, and the execution was postponed until July 3, 1857. Another respite until October 9, was given, but all efforts for a new trial having failed preparations were made to execute the mandate of the law. Every precaution was taken by Sherhe poison had been supplied him by his wife the day before, and had been bo carefully concealed that it was not discovered when thesearch was made. The succeeding Monday the wife also ftttempted to destroy herself with the same fatal powder, declaring that she was determined to join her husband in Heaven': la-r life was saved notwithstanding her violent resistance to the physician.
During the' time of the Moore tragedy, another unhappy man occupied a cell in the same prison, held upon the charge of willfully .taken the life of his fellow man. A man who was known as David Butler, but whose real name was Major C. Bolin, from Pike county, Illinois, murdered Robert Moffat, at Downieville, September 27, 1855. Upon affidavit that a fair trial could not be had in Sierra county a change of venue was granted to Nevada county, and here, after long delays, he was convicted of murder in the first degree, and sentenced to be hanged on Friday, October 9, 1857, the day upon which Moore poisoned himself. A respite was granted by the Governor until February 2G, 1858, to allow time for appeal, but all efforts in the condemned man's behalf proved futile. The gallows was erected upon the side of Lost Hill, about one-half mile from the court house. The prisoner and attendants were escorted to the scene of the execution by the Nevada Rifles, who formed about the gallows and maintained order. The hill was covered with a crowd of spectators, at least five thousand people from Nevada and Sierra county being present to witness the legal taking off of a fellow man. The act of execution was performed by Sheriff Boring, assisted by Sheriff Irwin, of Sierra county. The doomed man before the final adjustment of the noose, addressed the people and said that he knew that he deserved to die, and willingly offered up his life as a penalty for the crime he had committed. He advised them to shun whisky and evil companions, if they would not stand where he then stood.
Moore's Flat was the scene of a cold blooded murder, July 11, 1862. Two men named respectively Birckbeck and Echels had a quarrel six weeks previous, and Birckbeck was worsted jail and effected hi i cap ovidentlj with assistance from the outside rJii iron weri awed off, the heavy bar of a padlock on the corridor door -y ut, and the padlock on theoutsido d 'removed H occurring at mid-day and with
Sheriff Know Iton in a \ ery unpleasant position, and e\ en effort woj ina.lr to apprehend the fugative, bul for a long time withoul Buocess, Had Burke departed entirely from the State he would probabl) have never been recaptured, but the desire to remain in the vicinity of danger seema to have taken an uncontrollable hold upon him, and eight months after he had so cleverly escaped from confinement, he was recognized at A.uburn, Placer county, arrested and brought to Nevada City He was again sentenced March 81, 1863, to be executed April S, onl\ four days later a gallows was constructed byS Knowlton in the jail yard, and on the third ol April, 1868, in the presence of but a fta witnesses, Thomas Burke stepped upon the fatal platform and offered up a blood atonement for liis crime.
niter a long trial a verdict of murder in the first desrree was brought in against Robert Dodge, and April 15, 1865, he was sentenced to be hanged on the second of the following Juno.
m b man with his coat butt up to his chin, his hat drawn over hia a doublebarrel shot-gun partially concealed under his coal Still . a man answering to this description was Been to step off the porch al Ahern's. The next morning Dodge and another man that 11 would not be safe to continue hunting, as they might suspected, and expressed satisfaction al thi death of Hammock. The borrowed gun was returned, and, upon drawing the chai wasfotind to contain five bullets similar to those taken I the body of thi A Bullets of the same kind ..
trial. Upon his second trial, in March, 1866, hi was again convicted and sentenced to Ik- hanged May 30. Another applin i" the Su] stay of proi the judgment of the lower court was affirmed. October 24, 1856, aftex a confinement of nearly two years, he was brought up for sentence. In reply to the question, if he had anything to pro v.- it, that he was thirty-four years of age, in the prime of life, and with no one depending upon him, and was ready to die, that those who were persecuting him would not be contli. and requested that hia sentence He was then sentenced to be N is,:'- and remanded to jail When the 1 the eitj was thronged with r to witness the spectacle, but their desires met 1 itrj admitted but tVw to the h place When upon the h, in which he again protested hi 1 which lie had 11 mtly maintained In tha rous imp sprung \ quick plunge of 1 von I and thelitis! 3 bod} "I" Roberl Dodge swung in midair A. Chinaman named Ah Look murdered a brothci C \ allej in 187 1. and was Impri toned al 1 awaiting hia trial, when, on Sundaj night, Julj 5, I874.hu ended "life's fitful fever" 1>\ banging himself Thon tier of bunks in the cell, and ha removed the bottom of the lower ones and fastened the cord to the upper one and whon il 1 m " 1 thai of ' leorge But! 1 foi 1 ho murder of William Roberl tForeal spring Septembei 0, 1877 On the morning in question the two men had a diaputi in rcj ird to an I.. 1 thi Norambagua mine, and Butl , who had a
Lavo'eTournainonl In fruokw Buried Treaaun and Death Th« Exploita ,,, Boojamiu Rood Twontj foui Btabe Moko assault and Battery - Mni-derod bj Lamp I Igbl i Deepei iti Stoeel Figh ' i J for Blood 1 1,.. Froul Croi k Cm II I 's,",t During a Spree,
In L850 the BociotVj although rough and boisterous, swayed i.\ passion and acting upon Impulse, was Far better than it was a fow years later, and as few homicides were committed as in most, yean ol the subsequent history of the county. Among the thousands there wen a faro bad ones, some extremely depraved, but the citi ens had a custom of executing summary justice upon those who willfully took life or property, which deterred bheni from the commission o( overt acts. As yet no resort had been made to lynch law here, bul it had been done necessity for action, and the men would not be found wanting. The sentimenl of the people supported it and their hands would have upheld it ; this fcliey all knew, and it had a healthful effect upon the Community. Neither was there so much fighting and especially so much verbal abuse as is noticed at the present time. Men kept eivil tongues in their heads, for all went armed, and an insult was instantly avenged. No man called another a liar or applied to him a vile epithet, unless he the condil I ociety. The country suffered from an invaby "Sidney Ducks," discharged and fugitive convicts from the British penal colonies of Australia. Also then- was a great influx of gamblers, thieves and blacklegs from the East, the drift wood brought in by the breakers of the gold excitement. The first tide of emigration to the gold fields was composed oi men who came here to dig wraith from the boi] or tp engage in intelligent ones. They counted in their ranks represents tivesof all the learned professions, men educated in all branches 0f mercantile business, mechanics of all descriptions, farmers, sailors and laborers of everj class. They came to make money, and to work for it. But when the news was sent hack that the thousands who came out in 1849 and 1850 had spread all over the country, had developed thousands of mining localities, and built thousands of mining- camps, where gold was plentiful and spent with a prodigal hand, then it was that the thieves and cut-throats who prey upon society and fatter* upon the industry of others, Hocked to the coast to live a life of plunder and rapine and gather spoils of the reckless and extravagant miner. Theft and robbery then became prevalent, murders more frequent and a feeling of insecurity gradually settled down upon the community. Then it was that the Vigilance Committee was organized in San Francisco, and kindred associations sprang up in almost every town in the State. They served in some measure to check the commission of crime, but they were held together by a rope of sand, and as soon as the occasion which drew them together had passed, they also vanished like the morning mist. They vanished but to reappear whenever circumstances demanded their interference, played their brief part and again disappeared. As the courts became better organized, the means of communication between localities much improved and society more settled, the vigilance committee disappeared entirely, except here and there published statistics that showed the number ol people in the s.a.e who had died by violence during the eight mpnjhs commencing January 1". 1855. The total number wa4 four hundred the beginning of the period, for murder, but the example seems to have had no effect, for the murders increased in number beyond that of any period since the first grain of gold was washed from the. mountain streams.
It is neither desirable nor possible to chronicle all the deeds of blood committed in the county, nor in fact any considerable portion of them; but those that at the time attracted great attention, the circumstances of which are peculiar and interesting, or which contain the clement of deliberate murder, these pages will endeavor to faithfully record.
The first is the cowardly and cruel assassination of Dr. Lennox, of Missouri, in December, 1850. While that gentleman was in his own house, surrounded by friends, with whom he was engaged in pleasant conversation, a shot was fired from the street, the bullet entering the unsuspecting man's body, inflicting a wound from which he died in an hour. The murderer made good his escape, and it was fortunate that he did so, for the jail was located at Marysville, which was entirely too distant to convey prisoners, and he would have been swung from the limb of a tree.
matters with o high bond and bo terrorised the people thai ,,,, dared to oppose them in anything, The) picked uuorrolB "i'li trangei and brutally boat them thej paid l,lt nothing, '"it when in want of clothing or any article gjmph wonl into tha iton and made their selection, and the proprietor thoughl himself fortunate if they departed in peace .tn,l ,,,11. 1 One daj in the spring of 1853, Borne of them, among whom was Dick Fisher, entered a Jew clothing store and, becoming offended al the proprietor, took possession of the oatabli hmont and soon dopo&ited the thoroughly terrified Hebrew, with his whole stock in trade, in the middle of the street. Quito a crowd collected to witness the raid, bui no one Foil himself specially called upon to interfere. A man named \uli made the remark, " I should think some one would shoot them sometime/' which remark was reported to the bully, Fisher, who declared his intention of whipping the presumptuous man, Later in the day Fisher entered Gay lord's store, where Ault was standing, and proceeded to put his threat into execution, when Ault drew his revolver and fired upon him. Fisher beat a hasty retreat followed by Ault, who kept up a continuous fire until the defeated bully lay dead at his feet The spell of terror was broken, and the other bullies, recognizing the fact, shook the dust of the place from off their stolen boots, and Little York know the "Decker Famih " no more forever that gentleman !> ing up >n thi fl >i in apparently dead. Upon examination, his I found to I- 1. 1 1 il.';\ cut and 1 ith a knit*.- u hile 1 floor. The wounds upon 1*1 - arms were supposed to l given while endeavoring to ward off blows aimed at his head. No robbery had been committed, and the appearances indie that the deed had hut just been perpetrated 03 someone who way. being frightened awaj by the men who found their unconscious \ ictim before time had been given to secure any plunder. Mr. Rich was so severely injured thai no physician was Rent for until the following morning, and twenty hours had ela] ed en from Nevada - ing on the brink of eternity lor a number of days, hi b improve and finally recovered, but was unable t 1 clear up the mystery thai surrounded the bloody deed. A Belgian, named Nevils, was arrested a few days after the occurrence, in Sa mento, by Marshal Plumer, of Nevada City. He had departed from Alpha on the night of the atteu assination, and this, with a few other circumstances turned suspicion in his directi n He was conveyed to Alpha, examined by a Justice of the Peace and committed for trial. So excited were the officers, placed a rope about his neck and endeavored to frighten him into making a cont- m act which would have assuredly sealed his doom. He ^till protested bis innocence, and was at last redelivered into the hands <>t" the officers, who conveyed him to Nevada City and safely lodged him in the county jail. When the case was brought to the attention of the grand jury, so slight and circumstantial was the evidence against V that body refused to indict him, ami he was set at Liberty. He never received any satisfaction for his rough handling by the mob, unless he considered the fact that they did not hang him satisfaction enough; it was a close call. Who assaulted Isaac Rich was never known.
iven to speration and w bo had 1 much confidence in him than l>\ his own p m a) in vi bii h to pros ide foi I ..f the family dependent upon him, his n tmedothn their happy home. The children, the oldi 1 bui five yi at ol found in different rooms, while the wife laj on the md the father and husband upon thi flooi of the parloi
M,U(S of tin a returned home and book an active part in the itrugglo, while othora whoso patriotaani or courage was nol oqual to that offbrl remained here and were a constanl Bouree
II, amuiod himself bj hurrahing for Jeff. Davis, shooting al the stars and stripes and threatening to shoot any abolitionist who should attempt to arresl him. Thia begantogrow monofconoua to the oitiaenB of North San Juan, where the champion for his arrest, July 28, L8G4. The officers, with the warrant, prooeddedto the residence of the older Quinton, the paternal progenitor of the champion, and In attempting to make the arrest, were resisted by the young man, whereupon he was shut, and killed His father and two brothers departed from the place with their families. A. few months later, Judge 0. l\ Stidger, who waa then editor of the Nevada Gazette, and had bean very bitter in his Btricturea upon such chivalric gentlemen as Quinton, had occasion to visit North San Juan. He returned on the morning of September 9, I So'-*, occupying an outside seat with the driver, being the only passenger until lifter tlu- occurrence to be narrated. At a point in the road about three-fourths of a mile from North San Juan, a bullet whizzed past his ear, between him ami the driver, the report of a gun was heard and the smoke from the discharge.! weapon was seen curling upwards from a clump of bushes that stood just inside of a fence surrounding a field on one side of the road. The stage driver instantly whipped up his horses, and they were soon beyond the reach of another bullet, No other cause could be asigned for the attempted assassination than the
Hill Be round the body of Jam* L Cooper lying prone open the bridge, aUut twenty feet from the north end Hie ad with frost and bore the appearance oi having bun there the entire night Theback and upper portions oi the ,,,,.. terribry ctri and mangled, apparently with a hatchei or axe. Mr Nixon returned to tin- top of the rid-.- and pro of two men to watch by the body of the man, while he went on to Nevada Citj to notify the authorities. Upon reaching the scene of the murder, the offioen, proceeded to the cabin of the deceased, situated ai the fool of the precipitous hills skirting the Suba, and mure than a mile from any human habitation. Lying inside the door of the cabin waa discovered the body of Joseph Kyle, a partner (lt- deceased Cooper, and bearing wounds similar to those «m the murdered man lying upon the bridge. The cabi,, bore every indication of having witnessed a terrible struggle between the victim and his assailants. The safe door bad been forced Open and several hundred dollars extracted, trunks bad been Chopp'ed into with the bloody axe and the cabin thoroughly rifled. Fifty dollars were found in Cooper's pocket, which thevillains had overlooked. Upon examination of the bodies, ( looper was found to have received eight terrible gashes upon the head, any one of which was sufficient to cause death. Kyle's head was nearly severed from the body, and he had also received a blow from the axe upon the breast, the murderous weapon being burried up to the eye. The Board of Supervisors immediately ofl'ered a -reward of 82,000 for the arrest and conviction of the murderers. Governor Low offered an addtional reward of 81,000, and the friends of the murdered men increased the amount to §3,500, but the murderers were never detected, and the bloody deed still remains wrapped in mystery as with a shroud.
During the course of a drunken row at Camp 20, on the line of the C. P. R. R., in May, 1867, John Hennessy was killed. Two of the participants, John Brannan and Mary Gallagher, were arrested and indicted for murder. In September a nolle prosequi was entered in the case of the woman, but Brannan, who was only twenty-one years of age, and was said to have already killed three men, was placed upon trial. The evidence was not sufficient to convict him and he was discharged. While awaiting his trial he made his escape from the jail, but was retaken two days later, nine miles from Nevada City. About a month after his acquittal, November 7, 1S67, in company with John Kelley and two others, he entitled to absolute exemption from any reference to the circumstances that would cast any reflection upon lum, and therefore these cases and many others are omitted from this
While indulging in a game of cards at Forest Spring?, Thomas Alcorn and a man named Shaddock began to quarrel. Eli Hanna, who was present, took up Shaddock's side of the controversy and in a fight which ensued between him and Alcorn he was knocked down with a rock. He tried to borrow a pistol, but failed, and the quarrel apparently ended. Alcorn went to the ranch of A. Bowen nearly three miles from the scene of the altercation, and Hanna went to J. Bowen's house, about half a mile farther. Here he procured a shot gun, loaded it with slugs and retraced his steps to A. Bowen's place. It was now midnight and Bowen and Alcorn were sitting in the dining room, when Hanna, who had left his gun standing in the porch, entered and demanded of Alcorn why he had hit him with a rock. Alcorn replied, " Let me alone, or I will hit you again." " No man can hit me with a rock and live," said the irate Hanna, and stepped back through the door, raised his gun and shot Alcorn dead. Hanna fled and remained in the woods all night, but returned in the morning and surrendered himself. He claimed that from the time he was hit with the rock until he found himself roaming about in the woods he had no knowledge of what transpired. The trial was concluded July 29, 1868, and a verdict was rendered of murder in the second degree, with a recommendation to the mercy of the court. The court showed the mercy he thought the prisoner entitled to by sentencing him to a term of twenty-five years in the penitentiary.
The infant days of Truckee were days of trouble and its paths rocky and full of thorns, so over -run was it with bad men and fallen women. Between two of the latter class, Belle Butler and Carrie Smith, existed a feeling foreign to love, and Carrie, accompanied by her favorite knight, George Prior, celebrated the glorious anniversary of our independence in I860, h .hi and icratchlng of physiognomi< an ued daring which Bollo approached with murdei in her eye and revolver in her hand. She hold the p ho back of tho struggling ' Sarrie
[n the year 1867, John McNichola and Pal Doolin resided with their families at Mooro'a Flat, and, although nei woro none the leas friends McNichols had aboul $5,000 in monoy, and his wifo Fearing that he would spend it while on a drunken spree, carried it to neighbor Doolin 's, and with the lady of thai house buried it in the cellar in a tin kettle When wanted again 03 Mrs McNichola the buried treasure was not to be found, the Doolins asserting thai while thej were awaj from home one day, some one passed through the back -lour of the house and tho trap door of tho cellar and appropriated the treasure Tho Doolins were arrested, bul discharged for want of evidonce. Thej afterwards removed to Von Bet This was the beginning of trouble between the families, and McNichols followed Doolin from place (o place, threatening to kill him. Finally tin tho nineteenth of December, I860, Doolin shot and filled McNichols, at Von Bet, claiming that fear for his life impelled him to tho deed, although at the time of the shooting there was no immediate provocation. He was tried the following April, the jury failing to agree upon a verdict 11 i^ second bol boou returned with a revolver and began t<< abuse Qonnison The latter an - and advam - -i toward Reed, holdi chair in front "f him for a shield, and shoot," when Reed fired with fatal effect, the Kali passing under the chair and into Gunnison's body At the trial the jury a verdict of manslaughter, much to the astonishment of the judge, who said that a verdict of murder in the first d< ten yean in the penitentiary, was given the convicted man In 1878 he received a pardon from Governor Irwin.it being claimed that if kept longer in prison he would die of consumption He returned to Nevada < Sty and passed the rim.- awaj in idleness and drinking until September 15, 1879. 1 pon that day John McCartj and a friend were in Clark & Egan's saloon, made some expression thereto, Reed entered and Baid, " 1 don't want you to talk tike that." McCarty made some frivolous remark and passed into an inner room. Reed then went out, but won returned and entered the ruom Met 'arty had ^one into. A Bound of Bcuffling waa immediately heard issuing from the apartment and the voice of Met "am crying out for assistance, saying that Reed had stabbed him. Reed then rushed out, bi aring a bloody knife in his hand, which he threw down in the street Ee was immediately followed from theinnei room by McCarty, the blood streaming down from fearful u-1p > in his face and throat, who seized a glass from the Counter and hurled it unsuccessfully at the retreating figure of
As a sample of the queer verdicts a jury sometimes gives, the following case is in point. Thomas Dowling and William Twomey quarrelled at Moore's Flat, in 1872, and Tworoey stabbed Dowling twenty-four times with a bowie knife, fourteen of the thrusts entering the body. The -wounds were not fatal, and when "twelve good men and true" heard the case, and had the location of each several cut indicated to them, they retired, scratched their heads, probably played innumerable hands of poker, and then returned with a verdict of "ass and battery." Twomey was sentenced to pay a fine of $500 Such jury trials are an aggravation to the spirit and lead to and form an excuse for mob law. Upon no theory hut that of murder; and if in aelf-defanse he should have bean acquitted, the jury oooM at least have added the words M with a deadly u " t-> their verdict his life Upon the evening of November 7. 1872, William Stanton was in the cowhouse putting aome hay in tho manger, thedarkncsB being dispelled bj a light bold by his brother's wife, when the double report of a gun waa hoard and ha feel dead t.> the ground, came rushing In and found the n the floor, and near by a shot gun belonging to the Stanton family, both barn la but jusl discharged The poekota of the murdered man bad been hastily rilled ->(' mum si 80 It. apposed that the ahot was fired by a Negro Darned Bate man Gaines, instigated bj Mrs Stanton, who waa holding tha light Mi Stanton waa held on the charge of murdei and
This order, howevei wa afterwards revei ed, Qainoa being tried for the murder and a nolle prosequi entered In Mrs, Stanton case, he giving testimony against tha Negro. She said that she saw < laino immediately aft r the ahootmg but not before, and that he made her promise to conceal bhia know] edge; that he robbed tho body and secreted the money where, by hia direction, '-lie afterward found it Qainoa waa tried three times, each trial re tutting In a di agreement by tho jury. Me was held fur a fourth trial, but afterward di icharged.
,\ mo i di Derate and fatal Btroot duel occurred in Truckcc aboul nine o'clock in the evening September 5, L878i between Andy Fugate and Jack White, two of the de poradoea that had for several years infested the town. Bad blood had e iiJ between the two men for wroe time, there being "a woman In the case," and when they met that evening on Front street, Fngate inquired of White if he waa *' heeled," and receivingan affirmative answer, drew hia revolver and said "Sail in then." They did sail in, and bo did the by tandei .sailed into atora doors, down basement , up tail-ways and even groveled upon the. sidewalk in their anxiety to avoid stopping the bulleta that began to whiz and sing along the atreet, But few ihota ha/] been fired when White fell off the sidewalk, badly wounded. Fugate then walked np to the prostrate man and deliberately fired several shot, into his body at -short range. Notwithstanding this, White raised himself with hia last expiring strength and fired three bullets into vital portions of Fugate'a anatomy. After the charges in the revolver, were all emptied these two desperate men, grinding their teeth with rage, and while drawing the last faint breathe of life, Knapped at each oution, lias so entirely Failed of justice as the celebrated Trout Crook Case. At the time of its occurrence there was a Congressional Commi ion on the waj to this Si kte bo inquire into the Chinese question, and the act committed at Truckee especially unfortunate in that point of view, as tending to prejudice the minds of the investigators and to confirm the claim that was made that the objection to the Chinese came alone from the ruffian element. The act was also condemned by thinking men and law-abiding citizens throughout the State, who recognised the fact that the Caucasian cause was injured instead of aided by every case of violence towards the Mongolians, The Caucasian League to which it was sought 1 1 attach responsibility for the act, and to which the men who committed the deed belonged, also condemned it and disavowed after the meeting of the Caucasian League had adjourned, on the night in question, the idea of raiding these I Ihinese cabins was suggested, and met with instant favor among the men who were then together. They then procured guns and coal oil and started up Trout creek to the 3cene of the murder. What afterwards oc :urred has been already related. Notwithstanding the assistance given them by these confessions, the detectives 'were still unable to make any discoveries in Truckee. Seven of those implicated b\ McCullough and Getchell were indicted for murder, and a test case was made on the indictment of J. O'Neil.
So much excitement had hern created by the case and so much interest was taken in it, that eminent counsel was employed on both sides, and every effort made by the prosecution to convict the defendant. Getchell and McCullough were placed upon the stand and told their stories, corroborating each other in every particular. The defense placed some fifty witnesses upon the stand, by whom every material statement made by the two prosecuting witnesses was overwhelmingly contradicted and an alibi proven for each of the implicated men. A bristling hedge of protecting testimony was thrown about the accused parties, upon which no impression could be made by the prosecution. The most delicate and deceptive eateh question was readily answered, and in such a way as to leave no vulnerable point open for attack. At last the prosecution abandoned the ease in despair, and 0 Ned was acquitted byTe jury, whiles '; was entered m the other ttout midnight of September 6, 1877, a dispute occurred n nxA]iivA pQllaid and onQ Gilbert in the bar room of ttlt. Pacific Bote!, Grass Valley. Pollard was verj abusive.and M QUbert retired from the room, applied a vulgar epithet to him \, this Fry, the barkeeper interfered and rebuked Pollard when the latter closed the door, asserting bis intention to haveii out with Fry. Then- was but one other man in the the decision, but almost immediately heard the report of a pistol, andreturning to the room with assistance, found that K,N had been btafy shut in the deck. Upon bhe trial the prisoner endeavored toshowthat he had shot Fry in self-defense, but a verdict of murder in the first degree with imprisonment it',- was rendered by the iurv. and Pollard received his
We close the record with the deed committed early Sunday morning, December 7, 1879. A number of young men bad been up nearly all night having a good time, and were in Clark & Eagan's saloon.. Nevada < lity, when James II. Byrne, between wliom and Robert White, a member of fche party, there had with him. They at first declined but afterwards assented, when Byrne refused then to permit them to drink. Hot words ensued, and Byrne drew his revolver threatening to shoot White, but it was taken away from him. The quarrel continued and Byrne received a cut over the eye from some glassware that had been thrown by some one. At this juncture Byrne managed to regain possession of his revolver and shot White, the bullet entering the skull over the right eye. Byrne was sobered by the act and expressed deep contrition for what he had done in a fit of drunkenness: White lingered for several weeks between life and death and finally recovered.
The foregoing list of bloody deeds presents a frightful array of crime for one small county in thirty years, but were all the cases of shooting and stabbing faithfully recorded the list would swell to more than four times the size. No attempt has been made to keep track of the broils in which wounds, fatal or otherwise, have been received, and many cases of - violent death are reserved for the chapter entitled " Robberies and Noted Highwaymen." Murders have been almost an everyday occurrence, and so long as there are in a town as many saloons as places of legitimate business they will ever continue to be so. That to reduce the number of saloons is to reduce the amount of crime is a fact disputed but by a few.
Provenance
Text from History of Nevada County, California; with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks, and Manufactories .., published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.