Placer County, California - Chapter 22: Political History of Placer County, 1882
From History of Placer County, California, published 1882. 5,994 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
13 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
5,994 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Placer County, California, published 1882. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 22: Political History of Placer County
Campaign of 1S6.5 - Death of Lincoln - Split in the Republican Party - Judicial Election - The Legislature - Registry Law - Campaign of 1867 - Political Changes - Meeting of Conventions - The Election - Judicial Election - The Legislature - Eugene Casserly Senatnr - Presidential Campaign of 1868 - Republican Victory - Campaign of 186'J - Negro Suffrage - Tlie Election - Judicial Election - The Legislature - Edgar M. Banvard - Campaign of 1871 - The Election - Judicial Election, 1871 - The Legislature - Sargent Senator - Dunnam's Election - Campaign of 1872 - 'Jrant and Greeley - Questions at Issue - The Election - Campaign of 1873 ^" Dolly Vardens '" - The Election - Judicial Election - The Legislature - Senators Elected - Campaign of 1875 - Complicated Parties - The Election - Judicial Election, 1875 - The Legislature - The Debris Question - Wdliam M. Crutcher -Campaign of 1876 - Centennial Year - Presidential Election, 1876.
Great political changes occurred between the close of the campaign of 1864 and the opening of the catnpaign of 1865. The last great battles of the Rebellion had been ftjught, the rebel armies surrendered, and as peace and good-will were promised by President Lincoln, he was assassinated on the 14th of April, 1865, dying the following day. The great triumph which had sent joy throughout the land was turned to sincercst mourning. The newspapers of Placer County, without distinction of politics, were issued in mourning and published articles of sorrow and abhorrence of the great crime.
The funeral obsequies of the murdered President were observed in all the prominent towns of the county, as well as throughout the State, on the 19th of April following the sad event. Business was suspended, public and many private buildings were draped in black, whole communities assembled in procession; sermons, poems, and orations were delivered, and the form of funeral observed with feeling and solemnity. This dark tragedy closed the terrible war. The Union was maintained and slavery forever forbidden in the territory of the United States. Many of the citizens of Placer had participated in the war, whose records are given in the chapter devoted to military affairs.
The political campaign of 1865 opened with timid and cautious action. The great events preceding it attracted the chief attention, and no question of importance seemed to demand the exertions of politicians. The Democrats were overwhelmed with the rebel defeat, and the success of the Republicans was conceded. There were two wings of this party, denominated the " Long Hairs" and "Short Hairs.'' A United States Senator was to be elected by the next Legislature and the principal strife was which wing should win the prize. Conness had been elected by the " Short Hairs," and the Federal offices were held by his adherents.
The officers to be voted for in Placer County at the political election in September were a State Senator, three Assembl^'men, county offlcei-s and Supervisors.
Split In The Republican Party
The Republican County Convention was held at Auburn June 27th and made nominations, which were claimed as a triumph of the " Long Hairs," and so distasteful to the defeated party that a call was issued for a " People's Union Convention," to meet at Auburn July 11, 1865, for the purpose of nominating Legislative and county officers. This Convention nominated candidates, "issued a platform, and organized as a party. The platform declared in favor of the State adojiting the Constitutional amendment abolishing slavery, and approved all acts of the late war, but opposed any change being made in the right of suffrage in this State. This last proposition was to oppose the granting of the right to vote to colored citizens, and was a pleasing plank to the Democracy. The new party also favored the "reconstruction " policy of President Johnson, which was violently opposed by the Republicans, and thus party lines were drawn.
The Democrats made no county nominations. The Herald, while not advocating the " People's Union " ticket, vigorously attacked its opponents, who were strongly upheld by the Stars and Stripes, at Auburn, and the Enquirer, at Dutch Flat.
The election was held September 6, 1865, passing verj' quietly, as is indicated by the light vote. The candidates and the votes received are as follows: -
The judicial election was ordered for the election of a Justice of the Supreme Court to succeed Chief Justice S. W. Sanderson. To make nominations for this and to choose State Central Committees, Conventions were held by the Republican and Democratic parties. The Republican Convention met August 16, 1865, at Sacramento, both wings being represented, but the " Long Hairs" in the majority. Silas VV. Sanderson and J. H. McKune were presented for nomination, the honor falling upon the former.
The Democrats called a Convention to meet at Sacramento September 19ih to nominate a candidate for Supreme Judge, select a Slate Central Committee, and issue a platform of principles. The Convention met as ordered, and nominated Henry Hare Hartlej- for Supremo Judge. The platform pledged support to the National Administration in all Constitutional measures, and expressed its unalterable determination to oppose negro suffrage, and the political equality of the negro, " on the ground of justice to the white man as well as humanity to the negroes themselves."
The election was held October 18th, with the following vote in the State: Sanderson (R), 31,662; Hartley (D), 25,474. In Placer County the vote was Sanderson 1,449; Hartley, 859.
The Legislature
The Legislature met December 4, 1865, and oi'ganized by the election of S. P. Wright, of Del Norte, President ^ro tein. of the Senate, and John Yule, of Placer, Speaker of the Assembly. The Senate was composed of 31 Republicans and 9 Democrats; and the Assembly of 53 Republicans, 20 Democrats, and 7 Independents. The great question of United States Senator was settled without difficulty by the election of Cornelius Colo, to succeed James A. Mc- Dougall after the 3d of March, 1867. This was a " Long Hair " triumph.
Reqistry Law
The principal Act of the session was the passage of the '- Registry Law " requiring a registration of votei'3. This was prepared and introduced by Horace Hawes, Senator from San Francisco. It was bitterlj' opposed by the Democrats as a partisan measure. The Legislature passed an Act defining the western boundary line of Placer County, as it now exists. But little of importance was accomplished, and the session terminated April 2, 1866.
Under the Amendments to the Constitution, the State was relieved of an election campaign in the year 1866. Little was accomplished politically, but steps were taken for the reorganization of the Democratic party. The " Reconstruction " measures of Congress, the Amendments to the Federal Constitution, and the disagreement between Congress and the President, were causes for many changes from the Republican to the Democratic party; and among the prominent persons so changing were, H. H. Haight, of S.in Francisco, and P. H. Siblej' of Placer County.
Prepai'ations for the campaign of 1867 commenced early by the organization of clubs and committees, the discussion of political questions going on continually. There were to be elected a Governor, and all State officers, a Representative in Congress from each District, a Legislature which would elect a United Slates Senator to succeed John Conness, county and district ofiicers, at the political election, and a Supreme Judge and Superintendent of Public Instruction at the judicial election.
Meeting Of Conv'Entioxs
The Republican County Convention met at Auburn, June lOlh, and the Democratic on the 17th, and made nominations; and the State Conventions of the t\vo parties met at Sacramento June 12th and 19th respectively. The Republican State Convention was controlled by the ''Short Hair" wing, which nominated George C.Gorham, of San Francisco, for Governor, and John P. Jones, of Trinity, for Lieutenant-Governor. The nomination of Gorham was so distasteful to the other wing of the Republican part\', that an opposition ticket was made, with Caleb T. Fay, of San Francisco, as the candidate for Governor, and J. P. Jones, Lieutenant-Governor. The Democratic Convention nominated Henry H. Haight, of Alameda, for Governor, and William Holden, of Mendocino, for Lieutenant-Governor. Thus three tickets were in the field. In the Second District, William Higby, of Calaveras, was renominated by the Republicans for Congress, and the Democrats nominated James W. Coffroth, of Sacramento. The canvass was conducted with a great deal of energy, the Central Pacific Railroad Company lending its aid to Gorham, who in company with F. M. Pixley and Wm. M. Stewart, held meetings throughout the county.
The Election
The election was held September 4, ISfiT, resulting in a Democratic victory in the State, and a Republican victory in Placer County. The State vote for Governor was, Haight, 49,604; Gorham, 40,050; Fay, 2,088. Lieutenant-Governor, Holden, 47,969; Jones, 44,274. The largest vote was for State Treasurer, aggregating 92,776. In the Second District, Higby, 16,053; Coffroth, 14,789.
The judicial election was held October 16, 1857, resulting as had the political election, with a Democratic majority in the State and a Republican majority in Placer County, the vote in the county being as follows: -
The result of the election was received with great rejoicing by the Democrats, who celebrated it by public meetings, illuminations, and firing of guns; and with general satisfaction by the majority of the Republicans, who considered it a proper reproof for an injudicious gubernatorial nomination.
The Legislature met on the first Monday of December, and was composed of nineteen Democratic and twenty-one Republican Senators, and fifty-one Democratic and twenty-nine Republican Assemblymen. This body elected Eugene Casserly United States Senator to succeed John Conness, whose term expired March 3, 1869.
Presidential Campaign Op 1868
In the campaign of 1868 a President, Vice-Presdent, and Representatives in Congress were to be elected. National Conventions were held by the Republicans in Chicago in May, nominating Gen. Ulysses S. Grant for President and Schuyler Colfax for Vice- President, and by the Democrats in Julj^, in New York, nominating Horatio Sej-mour for President and Francis P. Blair for Vice-President. In the Second District Aaron A. Sargent, of Nevada, was nominated for Congress by the Republicans, and James W. Coffroth, of Sacramento, by the Democrats. The canvass was active and bitter. The success of the Democrats the preceding year had inspired hopes of success, which gave life and interest to the struggle. The leading papers of Placer were the Herald and the Stars and St7-ipes, the former edited by ex-Lieutenant-Governor Walkup and the latter by ex-Judge Fellows, both talented writers and strong partisans, and were able to arouse an iulense feeling in the county.
The election was beld ^^ovember 4, 1868, resulting in a complete Republican Victory. The electoral vote of the United States was. Grant, 214; Seymour, 80, and 23 vacancies. The vote in California was, for Grant, 54,592; and for Seymour, 54,078. In the Second Congressional District the vote was, for Sargent, 18,264; Coffroth, 15,124. In the First District, S. B. Axtell, Democrat, was elected over F. M. Pixlc}^, and in the Third, James A. Johnson, Democrat, over Chancellor Hartson.
The great battles for principle have been fought in the campaigns preceding the election of General Grant to the Presidency, and parties have, in the year 1869, taken their stand upon them. The question of negro suifrage is the only modern one that divides the parties, and this is contained in the Fifteenth Amendment to the Federal Constitution. The election of 1869 is for a Legislature to either adopt or reject this Amendment, and a struggle was made for the supremacy.
Conventions were held as usual and nominations made by the two parties. The political election for Legislative, county and district officers was held September 1, 1869, resulting as follows; -
The judicial election was held October 20, 1866, resulting in the election to ihe Supreme Bench of Judges Crockett and Wallace, the Democratic nominees, and in the Fourteenth District of T. B. Reardan as District Judge, the vote being, Reardan, 3,941; McFarland, 2,472.
The Legislature was largely Democratic, the Senate having 27 Democratic and 13 Republican members, and the Assemblj' 66 Democrats, 11 Republicans, and 3 Independents.
The Legislature organized by the election of E. J. Lewis, of Tehama, President pro (em. of the Senate, G. H. Rogers, of San Francisco, Speaker, and W. Dana Perkins of Placer, Sergeant-at-Arms of the Assembly.
Among the Acts of the Legislature was one " to protect litigants," by which the District Judge should designate the newspapers in which legal advertisements should be published in his District. This was intended to help the Democratic papers, as all the District Judges were Democrats. The Placer Herald was appointed the official paper of Placer County hy Judge Reardan on the 6th of April, 1870. Two bills were also passed enabling certain counties to grant subsidies to railroads, intended as assistance to the Southern Pacific Railroad, but were vetoed by Governor Haight, for which he was censured by the railroad organs, and as heartily lauded b^- the anti-monopoly papers. The Legislature also passed an Act amendatory of a former Act passed in 1866 authorizing the Supervisors of Placer County to sell the stock held by the county in the Central Pacific Railroad Company of California, for which bonds to the amount of $250,000 had been issued in 1864 and '65.
Campaign Of 1871
The camiiuign of 1871 involved the election of a Governor, and State officers, two Justices of the Supreme Court - one to succeed Judge Sanderson, who had resigned, and one to succeed Rhodes, whose term would expire - a Member of Congrese for each district, Legislative and district officers. The candidates for Governor were: H. H. Haight, Democrat, and Newton Booth, Republican. The passage of the Act "To Protect Litigants," had rendered the Democratic Administration unpopular with the Independent and Republican press of the State, and the veto of the railroad subsidy bills, bi'ought the power of the railroad company against the 'Governor. The declarations of the Democratic State Convention were decidedly anti-suhsidy. Mr. Booth was also regai'ded as an anti-subsidy candidate, but Romualdo Pacheco, the Republican candidate for Lieutenant-Governor, was classed as a friend of the railroad company. The declaration was made immediately after the nominations, that should Booth be elected, he would be removed, either by election to the United States Senate, or the appointment to a foreign mission, leaving the friends of the railroad company in control of the State Government.
The Democratic State nominations were: For Governor, H. H. Haight; Lieutenant-Governor, E. J.Lewis; Secretary of State, W. B. C. Brown; Controller, Dr. R. O. DeWitt; Treasurer, Antonio L. Coronell; Attorney-General, Jo Hamilton; Surveyor- General, John W. Bost; State Printer, John T. Barry; Clerk of Supi'eme Court, T. Las]>eyere; Harbor Commissioner, John Rosenfeld.
The Republican nominations were: For Governor, Newton Booth; Lieutenant-Governor, R. Pacheco, Secretarj' of State, Drury Melone; Controller, J. J. Green; Treasurer, Ferdinand Baehr; Attorney- General, J. L. Love; Surveyor-General, Robert Gardner; State Printer, Thomas A. Springer; Clerk of Supreme Court, Grant I. Taggart; Harbor Commissioner, John A. McGlynu
For Governor - Newton Booth (R), 61,819; Henrj' H. Haight (D), 5G,800; the Republican majorities ranging from -1,304, for Pacheco, to 5,601 for T. A. Springer, for Slate Printer. Three Republicans, S. O. Houghton, from the First District, A. A. Sargent, from the Second, and John M. Coghlan, from the Third, were elected Repi'eseutatives in Coigress. The vote in the Second Congressional District was: For Aaron A. Sargent (R), 18,065; James \V. Coffroth (D), 15,378.
The judicial election was held October 18, 1871. resulting in the election of the Republican candidates by majorities from 10,214 to 14,638. The vote in Placer County was as follows: -
The two houses of the Legislature were of opposite politics, the Senate being composed of 22 Democrats, 17 Republicans and 1 Independent, and the Assembly 55 Republicans, 24 Democrats and 1 Independent. James T. Frtrle> was President pro tern. of the Senate, and Thomas B. Shannon was Speaker of the Assembly. The duty of electing a United States Senator, as successor to Cornelius Cole, devolved upon the body in Joint Convention. Among the prominent candidates was Judge James E. Hale, of Placer County; but the Republican nomination fell upon Hon. A. A. Sargent, then member of Congress, but whose term would end as the term of Senator would begin, and Sargent was elected.
" On Friday evening, after the election, our returns elected Dunnam Sheritf by two majority, but Monday's canvass gave Starbuck three majority, and the Republicans fired three guns for these three majority. Dunnam demanded a recount, and when all the tickets were counted, Dunnam was one ahead. Here the Supervisors had exhausted their authority under the law, and should have declared the result, and directed the certificate to issue, but a recount was demanded by Starbuck's counsel, an* illegally allowed by the Supervisors, the hope that a further handling, shaking and rubbing of the tickets might remove some of Dunnam's stickers from the Republican tickets, being, we suppose, relied on to defeat him.
" The handling of the tickets proceeded at intervals through the week, and in spite of everything the stickers would stick, and at the end of the week the canvassers were compelled to declare Dunman elected by two majority. This news spread rapidly, and by dark a large crowd had assembled on the plaza, anvils were planted, powder procured, and pop went the guns; and they kept popping and repeating the popping until a late hour at night, and at each pop the air reverberated with the shouts and cheers of Dunman's host of friends. The guns were the largest we ever heard by anvils, but this fact is explained by the make of a peculiar ring, not like the Court- House ring, and the use of J. M. White's cast-steel anvil and Schultheis' sporting powder.
We cannot describe the jollification, except by saying it was the heartiest, liveliest, bost-humorcd, whole-souled, political jollification ever held in Auburn. There was no pent-up Utica there. At about two o'clock next morning the party adjourned, and all is serene, and B. D. Dunnam is Sheritf. and will be again during the next two years."
With the campaign of 1872 again recurred the Presidential election, and by an Act of Congress the election of four members of Congress in California was fixed for this year. The nomination of General Grant for the Presidency' by the Republican Convention was regarded as a foregone conclusion, and a branch of the party opposed to such nomination called a Convention to meet at Cincinnati, May 1, 1872, styling itself the Liberal Republican Party.^ This Convention nominated Horace Greeley for President and B. Gratz Brown for Vice President. These nominations were indorsed by the Democratic National Convention, which met at Baltimore on the 9th of July. The Republican Convention met at Philadelphia, June 5th, and nominated Gen. U. S. Grant for President and Henry Wilson, of Massachusetts, for Vice-President.
Questions At Issue
The questions at issue were the charges of corruption, weakness and avarice against Grant and his administration, the jealousy of oifice-hoklers, and the desire for otfieial positions. The main question was " anything to beat Grant," and the singular spectacle was observed in politics of the extremes of two opposing parties joining under the names of Liberals to defeat the Republican Party. A few Democrats adhered to their party, and nominated Charles O'Conor, of New York, for President, and Charles Francis Adams, of Massachusetts, for Vice-President.
The Democrats of the Second Congressional District also nominated a former extreme Republican for Representative in Mr. Paschal Coggins, of Sacramento, and the Republicans nominated Mr. 11. F. Page, of El Dorado. The Stars and Stripes newspaper, previously an advocate of the Republican party, became, in this campaign, the advocate of Greeley and Brown, and the Placer County Argu,% was established as a Republican paper, under the editorship of Mr. James B. McQuillan.
The election was held November 5, 1872, resulting in the success of the Republican candidates, the electoral vote of the United States being 286 for Grant and Wilson and 80 for Greeley and Brown. In California the vote was for Grant 5-1,020; Greeley, 40,718. O'Conor, 1,068. The Representatives in Congress from California elected were Charles Clayton (R), from the First District, H. F. Page (R) from the Second, J. K. Luttrell (D) from the Third, and S. O. Houghton (R), from the Fourth. The vote of the Second District gave Page a majority of 961 over Coggins.
The election of 1873 was for Legislative, county and district officers. The Legislature would elect a L^nited States Senator to succeed the term of Eugene Casserly, which would expire March 3, 1875. The chief political question was that of opposition to the power and management of the Central Pacific Raili-oad Companj' and the election of Governor Booth to the Senate. For this a party was organized calling itself the Independent People's party, with the expressed object of opposing " monopolies, rings, corruption and extravagance in office." This organization bore the common appellation of " Dolly Varden." The new party held a Convention at Auburn, called by the members of the late Democratic and Liberal Republican County Committee, and nominated a ticket composed of eight Democrats and five Republicans.
The statute for the election of Supervisors had been changed by the last Legislature, and now the county was divided into five districts, electing a Supervisor in each, who were required to draw lots for the length of term each should holil. The system, however, lasted only through one term, and in 1875 but three Supervisors were elected, taking office iu January, 1870.
Toe Elf,Ct10N
The judicial election for Justice of the Supreme Court to succeed Belcher was held October 15, 1873. The Republicans nominated Samuel H. Dwinelle, of vSan Francisco; the Independent People's party nominated E. W. McKinstry, of San Francisco, and the Democrats S. B. 3IcKee, of Alameda. The Republicans also nominated Anson Brunson to succeed Judge Crockett, who had been elected for an unexl)ired or short term; but the Court had decided that there was no short term, and therefore there was but one Judge to be elected at this election. The result in the State was the election of McKinstry, receiving 28,901; Dwinelle, 16,189; Brunson, 15,078; McRee, 21,850. The vote in Placer County was as follows: - Justice of Supreme Court - E. W. McKinstry (I D), 1,052; Samuel H. Dwinelle (R), 386; Anson Brunson (R), 368; Samuel Bell McKee (D), 97.
The Legislature met December 1, 1873, and organized by the election of William Irwin, Democrat, President p-o fern, of the Senate and M. M. Estee, Republican, Speaker, and Wm. M. Crutcher, of Placer. Sergeant-at Arms of the Assembly. The parties were represented by 18 Republicans, 14 Democrats and 8 Independents in the Senate; and 19 Republicans, 27 I)emocrats and 34 Indei^endents in the Assembly. The combinations for organization and the election of a United States Senator were announced to be monopoly and anti-monopoly, or friends and opponents of the railroad company. Soon after the organization of the Legislature the resignation of Eugene Casserly as United States Senator was made known, making it necessary to elect a Senator for the unexpired term. The election of Senator for the full term was effected December 20th, after many ineffectual ballotings, the final vote being: For Newton Booth (Ind), 61; James T. Farley (D), 37; James J\IcM Shaftcr (R), 20; and on the 23d John S. Hager, Democrat, of San Francisco, was elected to servo the unexpired term of Senator
The campaign of 1875 was interesting from the complication of parties, the secrets of political manipulation exposed, personal animosities engendered, the power of monopolies in the control of nominations, and the i-esults. In no campaign in the history of the State were the parties more subordinated to personal and selfish control. Thoi-o were to be elected a Governor and State officers, Members of Congress, a Legislature, county oiflcers. Superintendent of Public Instruction, District and County Judges, and Justices of the Peace. Three State and Congressional tickets were in the field. The Republican State Convention met at Sacramento June 14th, and to the general surprise was organized, under the motion of George C. Gorham, by the election of A. A. Sargent as Chairman. T. G. Phelps, of San Mateo, was nominated for Governor; J. M. Cavis, of San Joaquin, Lieutenant-Governor; 0. II. Hallett, of Butte, Secretary of State; J. J. Green, of Marin, Controller; W. M. Beckman, of Sacramento, Treasurer; E. D. Sawyer, of San Francisco, Attorney-General; Robert Gardner, of Humboldt, Surveyor-General; Grant I. Taggart, of Shasta, Clerk of Supreme Court, and Ezra S. Carr, of Alameda, for Superintendent of Public Instruction.
The management of the Convention, and the nominations, to a great extent, were so offensive to many Republicans that an Independent Convention was called, which met at Sacramento on the 22d of June and made the following nominations: For Governor, John Bidwell, of Butte; Lieutenant- Governor, Romualdo Pacheco, of Santa Barbara; Secretary of State, Wm. Roush, of Placer; Controller, Lauren E. Crane, of Sierra; Treasurer, Ferdinand Baehr, of Shasta; Attorney-General, Peter Van Clief, of Yuba; iSui-veyor-General, Edward Twitchell, of Sacramento; Clerk of Supreme Court, Paul Morrill, of Sacramento, and for Superintendent of Public Instruction, J. M. Guinn, of Los Angeles.
The Democratic State Convention met at San Francisco, June 29th, and nominated: For Governor, Wm. Irwin, of Siskiyou; Lieutenant-Governor, James A. Johnson, of San Francisco; Secretary of vState, Thomas Beck, of Monterej^, Controller, J. W. Mandeville, of Tuolumne; Treasurer, J. M. Estudillo, of San Diego; Attorney-General, Jo Hamilton, of Placer; Surveyor-General, William Minis, of Yolo; Clerk of Supreme Court, B. D. VYoolf, of San Francisco; Superintendent of Public Instruction, O. P. Fitzgerald, of San Francisco.
the Republican nominees were entirely under the control of the railroad company, and that the Democratic candidate for Governor had been given the nomination by the same company in reward for services while State Senator.
By an Act of the Legislature of 1874, Placer County was deprived of one Senator and two Assemblymen, leaving but one Assemblyman to elect in 1875; also for the election of three Supervisors to take office on the first Monday of February, 1876, one to hold two and the other four years, and thereafter the terms to be four years each. The office of collector was returned to the Sheriff.
The Independents and Republicans made nominations for Assembly and county officers. The political election was held September 1, 1875, resulting in the success of the Democratic State nominees, by the following vote: For Governor, Irwin (D), 61,509; Phelps, (R), 31,322; Bidwell (Ind), 29,752; Lovett (Tern), 350. H. F. Page was re-elected Member of Congress from the Second District.
The judicial election was held on the following 20th of October. Placer and Nevada Counties, comprising the Fourteenth Judicial District, were required to elect a District Judge, and for this office the Republicans nominated James B. Hale, of Placer, and the Democi'uts, T. B. Reardan, of Nevada. J. M. Guinn had withdrawn as candidate for Superintendent of Public Instruction, and E. S. Carr was elected.
The Legislature met December 6, 1875, and organized by the election of B. F. Tuttle, of Sonoma, as President ;ยป-o tern, of the Senate, G. J. Carpenter, of Kl Dorado, Speaker, and W. Dana Perkins, of Placer, Sergeant-at-Armsof the Assembly. Both bodies were largely Democratic, the partisan representation being 23 Democrats, 9 Independents, and 8 Republicans, in the Senate; 65 Democrats, 11 Republicans, and 4 Independents in the Assembly.
The Debris Question
During the session the -'debris question" was introduction in the Assembly by C. P. Berry, of Sutter, with the remarkable statement that the mining debris annuall}^ washed into the bays at the mouth of the Sacramento River was equivalent to a solid body of earth one mile square and forty feet in thickness, and that at the rate minmg was going on in fifteen yeai-s Suisun Bay would be filled; and that but thirty-one years would be required to complete the destruction of San Pablo Bay. He also estimated the value of land destroyed by the debris at $6,350,000; and the expense of leveeing made necessary b}' it at $2,000,000. The statements were regarded as extravagant and the intervening years have so proven them. The question is elsewhere noticed in this work. Among the persistent questions appearing in the Legislature was one fixing the rates of fares and freights on railroads, but like its predecessors, was defeated by the friends of the railroad company.
William M. Cr0Tcher
Few names among those who have been active in business and politics in Placer County are better known than the one that heads this notice. William McDowell Crutcher was born December 19, 1828, near Elizabethtown, Hardin County, Kentucky, coming of old Vii'ginia stock, his father having been born in the Old Dominion in 1803, his mother being a native of Kentucky. Hardin County in the days of our subject's youth was then far advanced in prosperity and enlightenment, well endowed with schools and academies, and in these Mr. Crutcher received his education, graduating from the Elizabethtown Academy, in 1847. There he remained, absorbing the elements of probity and manhood, so characteristic of his section, until 1853, when he transferred his home and allegiance to California, crossing the plains, and arriving at Placerville on the 20th of September of that year. His first field of enterprise was in Shasta, where he engaged in mining, and there remained until the Ist of April, 1854, when he removed to Placer County, which has been his home from that date. The rich and promising mining town of Wisconsin Hill vvas the place he sought, and there he delved until, in 1857, he removed to Iowa Hill, and thence, in 1859, to Auburn.
There were attachments, however, that drew him back to Iowa Hill, for there he was married - seeking the "Happy New Year" for the happy event - to Miss Mary Elizabeth Currier, the ceremony being performed by the Rev. Mr. McClay, the Methodist Episcopal Clei-gyman of the place. The fair bride was a native of Quincy, Massachusetts, daughter of Judge John B. Currier, Associate Justice of the county, then of Iowa Hill, but now a resident of San Francisco. The day of the wedding was auspicious of the happy and prosperous future as the pleasant home in Auburn gives proof to the many visitors who are so royaljy entertained at that hospitable mansion. Mrs. Crutcher is a most refined and worthy lady, adding to her many accomplishments that of being a skilled musician, an adornment to the social circle of which she is a prominent member, and, with her husband, fond of society and the entertainment of friends.
The social and political career of Mr. Crutcher has been steadily onward and upward, and consistent. As soon as the proper age would permit he became a member of the Order of Free and Accepted Masons, joining that venerable Order in Garrettsville, Meade County, Kentucky, and during his long period of membership has filled nearly all the chairs of the Lodge.
Politically, he started in life as a Whig, having been born in a locality where, if a person did not subscribe for the Louisville Journal and vote for Henry Clay, he would be socially ostracized. Upon the collapse of the Whig party he became a Democrat and a strong advocate of the principle of antimonopoly. In these ranks he has trained these many years, and good need has Placer had of her firm and brave monopoly-resisting citizens. The political and financial history of the county shows the war they have engaged in and the results accomplished. As evidence of his ability in political matters is the fact of his being Chairman of the Democratic County Central Committee for a number of years, and the many positions he has held proves the confidence reposed in him by the people.
His first office was that of Deputy Sheriff, to which position he was appointed by Sheriff King in June, 1857, which he held during the term, performing most efficient service in the arduous duties then required of fighting criminals, collecting foreign miners' licenses, and others of like dangerous and annoying character. These adventures would constitute a romantic story of early California life. The fight with and death of " Rattlesnake Dick," in which Mr, Crutcher was wounded, and his companion, George M. Martin, Deputy Tax Collector, killed, is told elsewhere in this book. With the expiration of the term of Charles King as Sheriff, June 2, 1859, and the accession to the office of L. L. Bullock, Mr. Crutcher was continued in the office as deputy during the two terms of that officer. At the election in 1862 Henry Gooding was chosen Sheriff, as a Union Democrat, and upon taking office Mr. Crutcher was made Under Sheriff, and continued in that position until, by a change in the election laws, his principal was cut short of his full term, and in the following year the Republicans obtained full control. For some years the political elements permitted Mr. Crutcher to attend to his private affairs, which he industriously and successfully improved; but a change in the political tide brought him forward, and in 1873 he became Sergeant-at-Arms of the Assembly, and in 1875 was elected on the Independent ticket as Member of that body, serving with honor through the twenty-first session of the Legislature.
Such has been the active and honorable career of Wm. M. Crutcher, now a stalwart anti-monopoly Democrat, a prosperous business man, and an esteemed citizen of Auburn.
The residence of Mr, Crutcher (illustrated) is situated upon a beautiful site in the eastern part of the village of Auburn, on a ten-acre plat, highly cultivated, being so located as to be easily irrigated by the water from a spring owned jointly by Mr. Crutcher and George W. Reamer. The same spring also supplies water for the railroad company's large tank at the depot grounds. Mr. Crutcher has growing upon his place an infinite variety of fruit trees, including two varieties of persimmons; many kinds of choice grapes; black and English walnuts; sixty orange trees, and all sorts of shrubbery that can be found in the nurseries which will withstand the frosts of this altitude.
The campaign of 1876 was interesting as the Centennial year of American Independence, and also as it brought again the election of a President of the United States, and, in California, of four Members of Congress. The Republican State Convention for electing delegates to the National Convention, to meet at Cincinnati June 16th, met at Sacramento on the 25th of April. Hon, W . C. Norton, of Placer, pi-esided. The National Convention met at the appointed time and nominated Rutherford B. Hayes, of Ohio, for President, and William A. Wheeler, of New York, for Vice-President. The Democratic State Convention met at San Francisco May 24th, and appointed delegates to the National Convention which met at St. Louis June 27th, and nominated Samuel J. Tilden, of New York, for President, and Thomas A. Hendricks, of Indiana, for Vice-President,
In the Second Congressional District H, F. Page, of El Dorado, was nominated by the Republicans, and G. J, Carpenter, of El Dorado, by the Democrats, for Congress, In consequence of the death of J. VV. Mandeville, State Controller, the Republicans nominated D. M. Kenfield, of Tuolumne, to fill the position, and the Democrats named W. B. C. Brown.
Presidential Election, 1876
The election was held November 7, 1876, resulting in the election of Hayes and Wheeler, they receiving 185 electoral votes and Tilden and Hendricks 18-1. The disputes and settlement of this election belong to the national histoiy.
The vote of California was: For Hayes, 79,269; Tilden, 76,465; Peter Cooper, 47, and others, 19, making a total vote of 155,800, Ln the Second District Page was re-elected to Congress, receiving 20,815 votes, and Carpenter 15,916,
The Representatives in Congress elected were: First District, Horace Davis (R); Second, H, F.Page (R); Third, J. K. Luttrell (D); Fourth, P. D. Wiggin ton (D).
Provenance
Text from History of Placer County, California, published 1882, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.