BlockBefore

Placer County, California - Chapter 40: Church. Bench, and Bar, 1882

From History of Placer County, California, published 1882. 7,321 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

6 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

7,321 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Placer County, California, published 1882. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 40: Church. Bench, and Bar

An Eloquent .Sermon - A Financial Sermon - Cluirch Organization - Mormonism in Auburn - .James E. Hale - The Bench and Bar - The Judiciary - District .Judges - Superior Judge - County Judges - District Attorneys - Attorneys Registered in Placer County - W. H. Bullock - C. A. Tuttle.

The American civilization as known east of the great plains was transplanted upon the shores of the Pacific and in the mountain region of the placers by the immigrants of 1849, who came in one grand body, bringing with them, the customs, religion, and principles in which they had been taught in their old homes. Among the settlers were men of the world, professors of religion, ministers, lawyers, and doctors; men of ignorance and men of education; men of reckless character, and men of firmest purpose of right and honor; generally young or in the early years of middle life; few were aged, and vigor, manhood, and independence were the characteristics of all. The rough element, the stalwart yeoman, and the refined intermixed, forming a heterogeneous society in which every extreme was found. Ministers were, perhaps, the least among the professions, particularly in the mining regions, and the organization of church societies proceeded slowly.

Sunday, however, was usually observed; by some as a day of rest, devotion, reading or writing letters to the dear ones at home; by others, as a day of repairing and renovating garments, visiting the towns and stores for purchasing the week's supplies, selling gold dust, and enjoying all the sport obtainable. If no church bell called them to meet in Christian service, nor spire pointed to a better world, there were many whose thoughts on that day recurred to the duties in which they had been trained, and the Sabbath was held sacred, and its traditions preserved. Many have said that in early times there was no Sunday in California. This was not wholly true. There were ministers among the miners, and occasional services were held. Some of the ministers are reported as having fallen from grace and turned gamblers, and curious stories are told, but among the representatives of the cloth were true and stalwart men.

The following, one of the most eloquei\t appeals that ever rang among the forests and rocks of the Sierra, is reported as one of the first of the sermons to the miners. That gamblers, hard drinkers, and roystering characters comprised a large portion of the people will be readily believed. But a pioneer

Methodist preacher was among them and he sought to influence them to better lives. His audiences were small, and his efforts appreciated but by a few of those who had adhered to the faith. He therefore gave notice that on a certain Sunday, in a beautiful grove where was a gushing mountain spring, he would before preaching give a barbecue, and supply better liquors than the saloons of the neighboring town furnished its customers. The day came and a crowd assembled. The preacher began his service, when he was interrupted by a gambler known as a desperate character, with, "Mr. Preacher, I say you are a liar ! You promised us better liquors than we had in town. Now where is your liquor?"

-' There! " answered the preacher, in tones of thunder, and, pointing his finger at the matchless spring, gushing up in a beautiful fountain, with a sound like a shout of joy from the earth, " There," he repeated, "there is the liquor which God, the Eternal, brews for all his children ! Not in the simmering still, over smoky fires, choked with poisonous gasses, surrounded with the stench of sickening odors and corruptions, does j^our Father in heaven prepare the precious essence of life - the pure cold water, but in the green glade and grassy dell, where the red deer wanders, and the child loves to play - there God brews it; and down, low down in the deepest valleys, where the fountains murmur and rills sing, and high upon the mountain tops, where the native granite glitters like silver in the sun, where the storm-cloud broods, and the thunderstorms crash, and away far out on the wide, wild sea, where the hurricane howls music, and the big waves roll the chorus, sweeping the march of God - there he brews it, that beverage of life, health-giving water. And everywhere it is a thing of life and beauty - gleaming in the dew-drop; singing in the gentle rain; shining in the ice-gem, till the trees all seem turned to living jewels; spreading a golden veil over the setting sun, or a white gauze around the midnight moon; sporting in the cataract; dancing in the shower; sleeping in the glacier; folding its bright snow curtains softly about the wintry world, and weaving the many-colored sky, that seraph's zone of the syren, whose warp is the raindrops of earth, whose woof is the sunbeam of heaven, all checked over with celestial flowers by the mystic hand of refraction. Still always it is beautiful - that blessed life-water ! No poison bubbles on its brink; its foam brings not madness and murder; no blood stains its liquid glass; pale widows and starving orphans weep not burning tears in its depths; no drunkard's shrinking ghost from the grave curses it in words of eternal despair ! Speak out my friends, would you exchange it for the demon's drinU, alcohol?"

ter the following is told of one, who, in the story, is called "Old Jack Martin," and is represented as an eccentric character who crossed the plains in the flood of immigration in 1850.

He had been an e.xhorter in the States, but the gold fever tore him from his theological studies and turned his feet toward the West. With pick, shovel, and pan he went to work in a gulch on the American River; but fortune was not lavish of her smiles in his particular case, and he soon found himself flat on 'bedrock,' with not a pound of flour or bacon in the cabin. In disgust he abandoned his claim and drifted down to Sacramento, where for a few weeks he earned a precarious livelihood. The mining fever again attacked him and drove him to the mountains, where in a few weeks he was discovered walking about the camps, preaching to all who would listen to his harangues, which were usually delivered from the top of a stump or the head of a whiskey barrel loaned him by some accommodating saloonist. At the close of each sermon be would pass a tin box, prepared for the purpose, around in the crowd.

At a later day he settled down as the regular Pastor of a charge in Dutch Flat, where a rude church had been erected by such of the miners as had not lost all of their religious inclinations in their search for gold. A rather good story is related of the manner in which the old man woke up his congregation on the matter of a little back salary due him. On a certain Sabbath morning an unusually large congregation assembled to hear him discourse. Before the beginning of the service Jack descended from the pulpit, and was seen to approach several brawny members of the congregation and whisper into their ears. When he returned to his stand the muscled worshipers quietly arose and stationed themselves at the door, after which the preacher calmly said: -

" My dear brethren, it is now about a year since I first showed up in this pulpit and headed you toward the living pastures on the straight and narrow gospel trail. I've tried to ladle out the square truth as I caught on to it in my skirmishes through the Holy Writ. In my prayers I have shown no partiality, but have wrestled just as hard when asking Heaven to open the eyes of ' Bummer Jim ' and turn him from his wickedness, as I have when imploring that the truth be made manifest to Colonel Ward, the owner of the Monarch mine.

"Now, I'm going to talk business to you, after which I will drive ahead with the regular service. I want money! 1 am going to have money, too, before I sling a word this morning. You are not doing the square thing with me, and you know it. When I agreed to look after your spiritual welfare, you promised me a clean 2,000 a year, but during the year jiasi 1 have received less than 1,000. Now, 1 have stationed a mob of business at the door, and the fir.-it impenitent sinner that tries to make a sneak on the open air, will be the leading character in a lively little incident that he will remember as long as he lives. A collection will now be taken up, and as I call each man's name, I want him to draw his bag and empty some dust into the box. Tony Arnold, just you circulate the box. Pass it there to Doc Wilson first. Now, Doc, spill yer dust and set the boys a good example. Tip 'er up - don't be afraid of dropping a grain or two too much. Contribute your mite, that your days may be long in the land that flows with milk and honey. Now, Aleck Jones, it's j'our turn. Thanks, that was a decent spill. Johnson, 1 saw the bulk of the wealth on your side of the table in the game at Kentuck's last night, and the church wants its percentage. Good enough - that's a fair share. Judge Mason, skin your weasel and pay toll, or don't travel. That's the ticket - nothing mean about you. Judge. Now, Shorty, chip in and give the glorious cause a boost - may the Lord be as liberal in shaking blessing.-t down on you. Your pull next. Arkansaw, ante and pass the buck. Hold on, that don't go. You didn't drop three grains into the box. Tip 'er up again, and may your blessings be choked off as you choke oft' the stream of dust."

Thus he went over the whole congregation. Not one of them had the " cheek " to refuse a contribution. When the dust was brought forward the preacher said; -

" The cause of the Lord and Jack Martin 'II not suffer now for several months, and I shall continue as heretofore, to herd your souls on the best theological grass to be found in the gospel ranges. The text chosen reads as follows: 'inasmuch as you did it unto one of the least of these, m}^ brethren, ye did it unto me.' "

From this text he preached such a povverful financial sermon, that several came forward after the service and wanted to double their contributions.

Church Oroanization

The first church organization in Placer County was at Auburn, in June, 1852, by the Methodist Episcopal Society. Rev. James Hunter officiated, having service at his residence every alternate Sunda3% at Auburn, and at other places on the other Sunda^-s. Mr. Hunter was succeeded by Rev. Mr. Brook, he by Rev. J. D. Blain, subsequently Presiding folder, and then by Rev. N. R. Peck, now the successl'ui horticulturist. Among those who have presided over the Methodist Church at Auburn are the Rev. J. H. Peters, Rev. J. B. Hill, Rev. Mr. Brooks, Rev. Mr. Nelson, Rev. Mr. Elliott, Rev. E. 11. Kins, Rev. H. D. Hunter, Rev. S. II. Todd, Rev. G. W. Fii,ch, and Rev. T. B. Hopkins.

In the Methodist Episcopal (Jhurch at Auburn a Sunday-school was organized in October, 1852, by Rev. James Hunter, the Pastor. This has been continued, having a large library and a good attendance.

The Methodist Episcopal Church at Dutch Flat was organized in 1857, by Rev. G. B. Hinckle, P. C, and Rev. S. B. Simonds, P. E. Among the first pastors of the church was Rev. T. H. McGrath, in 1860, who removed to the territory of Nevada, and there labored diligently in the service, organizing several church societies, but ultimately withdrawing from the ministry.

Since the first organization churches have generally been maintained in Auburn, but in September, 1837, the Herald makes the strange announcement that there was not a minister of any religious denomination at that time located in Placer County. The fact is also noticeable that in nearly all the marriages previous to 1870 the ceremony was performed by a judicial officer, indicating a scarcity of ministers, or an indifference to the religious character of the marriage tie.

The non-residence of ordained preachers did not deprive the people of divine service, as clergymen from other localites often visited the dirt'erent towns. Fine church edifices were erected in nearly every village at an early A&j in their histor3-, generally by the Methodists and Catholics, and at the present time there are but very few towns where there is not a spire pointing heavenward, and in the larger towns each of the principal denominations have their elegant place of worship, fully organized church societies, and regular service.

Mor.Monis.M In Auburn

In 1856 Auburn was honored by a representative of the Church of Latter Day Saints, in the person of Rev. Mr. Stuart, who proposed to establish himself permanently there as a teacher of the Mormon faith. At that time the only resident clergyman was Rev. Mr. Brooks, of the Methodist Episcopal Church, and the Rev. Mr. Stuart was encouraged in his efforts.

" We preached in the Court House yesterday to a goodly number of the respectable citizens of Auburn. They manifested quite a desire to hear, whether they will investigate is not for me to say, but for them to determine. We are determined lo do our duty, with the help of God, come what will. We have appointed Brother Charles Hardy to preside here; he is a worthy young man, a resident of this place. Brother Hardy is on his way to Salt Lake Valley from Au.stralia ; he intends slopping here till fall,- and while he remains he wishes to do all the good he can; we recommend him to the brethren, and all good men who wish to investigate our principles."

Ja.Mes E. Hale

Among the throng marching westward across the broad plains and towering mountains, towards the land of gold, in the eventful 1849, was James Ellery Hale, then an ambitious young lawyer, looking, with many of his companions, forward with hope at the bright prospect of wealth and fame that awaited him on the Pacific Coast. Since then the period of the average years of man has passed, and the pioneer still battles the way of life, bearing the honored marks of time upt)n his brow, and buoyant in spirit, bold in act, ready in speech as when he left the comforts of Eastern civilization to build up a new one in the unknown West. The frosts of many winters crown his head, but his body and mind retain the vigor of the prime of manhood.

Judge Hale first saw the light in the town of Smithfield, Bradford County, Pennsylvania, where he was born on the 15th of October, 1824. He passed his youthful years in his native county, there attending school and college, studying the profession of the law, and was there admitted to the bar. With a thorough education and a noble profession acquired, like an enterprising American youth, he went West, seekingfor the field of his future labors and triumphs the broad and fertile prairies of Illinois. In 1846 he settled in Knox County, Illinois, and there commenced the practice of his profession. As ho was becoming well established in his practice, the exciting news spread over the world of the discovery of gold in California, and the bright opportunity then opening at once impressed itself upon the young lawyer. Illinois was then a frontier State of the far West, and its people looked across the plains as the direct route to the Pacific, and large companies were formed to make the journey with wagons drawn by mules or oxen. The influence of many joining induced others, until it seemed as if the "Sucker State" would be depopulated of its young and most active men. The great rivers were convenient channels to carry the emigrants from all parts of the State far on their journey to the West, and this convenience and the passing of the hopeful and hilarious bands raised the excitement and swelled the crowds. Hale, joining one of these companies, hitched up his oxen on the west bank of the Missouri in the spring oj 1849, and drove out into the wilderness of an unnamed land. In the slow progress of an ox-team, Sacramento wag reached on the 26ih of October of the same year. That was the end of the journey, nearly all the immigrants pushing forward to that point after their long journey, calling there for letters and news from home, disposing of their jaded teams and getting outfits for the mines. From Sacramento Hale sought the mines of El Dorado and Plainer, making the latter his permanent home since February, 1852, his residence being at Yankee Jim's for some years. He came as a lawyer and has continued the practice, except when in office, during his life.

From the earliest date of the golden era in California, Judge Hale has borne a conspicuous part in politics. In early life, as a Whig, ho took an active part in advancing its interests, attending its conventions, and " stumping " the county. Such a man, with ambition and energy, soon came to the front. In the political campaign of 1852. Hale was nomi- nated at the Whig State Convention as one of the Presidential electors, and by the County Convention for State Senator. In that year California gave a large Democratic majority, and Placer was one of the strongest Democratic counties. The Democratic candidate for the Senate was Joseph Walkup, who was elected by a majority of 552. In 185-1: he was elected County Judge on the Whig ticket, defeating Abram Bronk, Democrat, and Hugh Fitzsimmons, Broderick Democrat. This position he held until 1SG9, when he was succeeded by E. H. Vandecar, a Democrat. While holding the office of County Judge the Whig party had gone out of existence, the Know- 2s'othing party had grown into being, swept the State and disappeared, and a chaotic mass of elements was opposing the Democracy. These at last crystalized into the Republican party, and from that time Judge Hale has been one of its most prominent members. In 1863 he was elected to the State Senate by the Republicans of Placer, the county then being entitled to two Senators. His Senatorial term continued through four j^ears, during which time political matters of the most vital importance agitated the public. The great questions pertaining to the saving and the restoration of the Union, amendments to the Constitution, and the establishing of equal rights among men, found in Judge Hale a clear expounder according to Republican principles, and one ever ready to do battle for the right.

While a strong and active partisan when political questions were at issue, in all subjects of a non-political character his counsel was sought by people of all parties. In all eases he advocated the cause of the people and the material interests of Placer County. Throughout the history of the county frequent mention is made of his acts, from which a story of his life may be gleaned. In November, 1867. - Judge Hale was appointed by Governor Low reporter to the Supreme Court, which position he held until 1871. In 1872 came the Presidential Campaign, with Gen. U. S. Grant and Horace Greeley the op])osing candidates. James E. Hale was nominated one of the Presidential Electors on the Republican ticket and was elected. At the meeting of the College of Electors, Judge Hale was chosen to carry the vote to Washington. This journey was successfully made, the Judge being accompanied by his family, and remaining for a visit of several months in the East.

In the Judicial campaign of 1875, James E. Hale was the Republican, and T. B. Reardan, of Nevada County, was the Democratic nominee for the office of District Judge of the Fourteenth Judicial District, comprising the counties of Placer and Nevada. In Placer County Hale received a majority of 148, but the majority in Nevada for Reardan was 267, thus securing his election.

A Constitutional Convention was called to meet in 1878 to form a new Constitution for California. Each Congressional District was entitled to eii^bt deletfates to the convention, to be selected and voted for by the State at large. The different parties combined to nominate a non-partisan ticket to counteract the influence of the W^orkingmen's Party, which was looked upon as a party of impracticable ideas. James E. Hale was nominated as a Non-Partizan, and was elected a delegate at large to the Conven tion. The session continued 157 days and formed the Constitution, which was adopted by a vote of the people, Jlay 7, 1879.

Judge Hale, of Placer, is the Nestor of the Convention. Full of the conserved wisdom of the past, he has only to open his mouth to evolve speech as by machine work. Even the jerks of his hands, the pivoting and sweep of his venerable head seem automatic. The wiry gray hair upon his rounded poll stands out as if electritiod, and he were insulated upon a glass stool. The spectacles upon his eyes give him the drowsy look of that oracular bird which is deemed to attend upon the patron goddess of our State, whose effigy surmounts our rostrum. Hale sits down as if he were an old Dutch clock ready to be wound up again. He is a living witness to the ''conservation of force." But there beats not an honester heart within an old drab coat than that of Hale's. -' God's blessing on his frosty pow."

The new Constitution required an election of all State officers in 1871). among which were six Associate Justices of the Supreme Court. Judge Hale was one of the candidates nominated by the Republicans. In this campaign he vvas unsuccessful, being defeated by a combination of Democrats and Workingmen. The following year he was agp.in in the field as candidate for the Assembly from Placer. In this he was successful, serving the term with distinction to himself and usefulness to the State and his county.

Judge Hale was, while ori a leive of absence visiting the East, married July 23, 1856. in Knox County, Illinois, to Miss M u-y Hart Pierce, a native of Smithfield, Pennsylvania. Immediately after the marriage he returned with his bride to California. Two children were the fruits of this marriage, both dying young. The sad notices of their death reading, that Clayton Douglas, only son of J. B. and Mary H. Pierce Hale, died October, 7, 1863, aged two years, four months and twenty-two days. Another soon following, saj's: Died at iuburn. December 5, 18C3, of scarlet fever, Nellie Pierce, only child of James E. and Mary H. P. Hale, aged six years.

In 1849 Gordon N. Mott and 1'. W. Thomas settled in Auburn, and mingled mining and law practice together. Otis L. Bridges commenced the practice at Auburn early in 1850. James S. Christy, H. O.

Ryerson, and R. D. Hopkins also commenced the practice in the latter part of 1850. Christy had first located at lllinoistown, and 0. A. Tuttle was located at Bird's Valley. It must not be supposed that practice supported all these lawyers, but mining and law together engaged their attention. Nearly all catcs were tried before a jury. The currency was gold-dust by the ounce. Many humorous and some exciting scenes took place in the courts.

A teamster had hauled a load of goods with oxen to Spanish Corral, where Ophir now is, eai-ly in 1850. He was taken sick and called a physician from Auburn. The physician visited him five times, but on the last visit took his gold scales and demanded his pay, six ounces for each visit. The teamster gave him sixteen ounces. The doctor returned to Auburn and attached the teamster's cattle for the remainder of his fee. Mott was for the defense. The jury found that as the doctor had taken his gold scales on the last visit be went as a collector and not as a doctor, and that he was also exorbitant in his charges, and made him refund one ounce to the teamster and pay his own costs. It would not have been safe for the doctor to have refused to comply with the verdict. Mott remained at Auburn till 18,53, and then removed to Marysville. He was afterwards one of the Judges in Nevada Territory, and also a Member of Congress from that Territory. Bridges had been Attorney-General of the State of Maine. He was proud of this distinction, and was continually alluding to it. Thomas was humorous and loved to draw out Bridges on this matter, and then ridicule him. Bridges left Auburn in the latter part of 1852. James E. Hale was at Millertown in 1850, but in 1851 went to Yankee Jim's and commenced practice there. Hugh Fitzsimmons settled in Auburn in the latter part of 1850. In 1851 he was elected County Judge. He was a native of New York and was a cultivated gentleman. B. P. Myres also came to Auburn in 1851.

In 1852 Myres and Ryerson were on opposite sides of a case before Jordan, Justice. Some language deemed insulting passed, and the attorneys engaged in a fight. While the battle raged Ryerson's client moved the Justice to adjourn the court, and Myres' client objected. The Justice failed to decide the motion and the trial proceeded.

Ryerson was a native of New Jersey and a man of fine education, and a well-read lawyer. He returned to New Jersey in 1855. His brother has been one of the Supreme Judges of that State. Myres possessed a keen and analytical mind. The two were generally pitted against each other in 1852-53. In the upper part of the county, M. E. Mills had also settled at Yankee Jim's in 1852, and C. J. Hillyer had located at Iowa Hill in 1853. In cases brought there Mills, Hale, Hillyer and Tuttle were employed. These suits often involved mining property of many thousand dollars in value. Christy was a native of Illinois, a well-read lawyer and a man of fine literary taste. He was passionately fond of novels, often reading the entire night. He died at Auburn in 1853. Hopkins was a native of Maryland. He was elected District Attorney in 18-51, and held the office for several years. He now resides in San Francisco. Jlills was a man of fair ability, but a man of an infinite fund of words. He would consume hours in argument, drawing fine distinctions on points of law, which it was sometimes diflicult for the Court to comprehend. He was District Attorney in 1854-55, and died at Auburn in 1858, a victim of the intoxicating bi->wl.

Thomas was a native of Maryland, but came to California from New Y'^ork City. He was proud and impetuous in his tempera nent. He had been admitted to the bar in New York. He spent most of his time in conversation in the saloons and on the streets, read but little, and depended on absorbing his law during the session of the courts. His large acquaintance gave him a good practice. He was by nature a politician, and in a political controvei-sy was bitter. In a speech which he made during the election of 1854 he denounced a certain gentleman as a gambler. Dr. Dickson was the bearer of a message from the gentleman to Thomas. The latter refused to receive it because the sender was not a gentleman. Dickson then sent a peremptory challenge to Thomas, which was accepted. He killed Dickson at the first fire. Dickson was a native of Mississippi, and a refined and educated gentleman. The aftair cast a shade over Thomas' subsequent life. He became District Attorney, an<l then a Senator, and died at Auburn in 187-, broken in purse and spirit. After 1854, owing to a decision of the Supreme Court, limiting .Justices' jurisdiction, legal business was mostly transferred to the District Court. About this time Hale, Mills, and Hillyer removed to Auburn, and for several years the practice was divided between the three, and Myers, Thomas and Tuttle. Many important questions arose, and the Bar of Placer County was justly regarded as an able one. Tuttle and Hillyer formed a partnership in 1857, and the latter removed to Auburn. Hale became Countj'^ Judge in 1854, and Myres District Judge in 1859. Hillyer removed to Virginia City in 1863. He has acquired a great reputation as a lawyer, and was employed by the firm of Mackay, Flood and Fair in 1878-79-80 to attend to their mining interests at Virginia City. He now resides at Washington. The county of Placer has generally been fortunate in its judiciary. This, however, has not always been the case. In 1858 a County Judge was elected who was from the Mohawk Valley, N. Y. and had been a clerk in a store. After his election he went into a lawyer's office to prepare for the discharge of his duties. His first case was this: A family at Todd's Valley consisted of a step-father, his wife, and two daughters of the wife by her first husband, aged thirteen and fifteen years. The step-father had married the mother when the girls were young - mere babies. An industrious well-to-do blacksmith, about forty years old, married the eldest girl without the consent of the mother. vShe procured an indictment against the clergyman for performing the ceremony. Tattle was for the defense. Thomas, the District Attorney, called a witness to prove the marriage, and the mother to prove that she had objected to it. and rested. Tuttle called the second daughter, when the following colloquy took place: -

Tuttle - I expect to prove by her that the stepfather has raised the girls, and has stood in loco parentis and been their guardian, and gave his consent to the marriage.

The witness retii'ed and Tuttle took his seat. There was a painful silence for three or four minutes, when the Ju<lge saiil, " Why don't you goon ? " Tuttle answered, " The Court refuses to let our witness be sworn." There was a short pause, when the District Attorney told the jury that the testimony was all on one side. The Judge then instructed them to find a verdict of guilty. The jury retired, and in tive minutes returned with a verdict of not guilty.

Fitzsimmons, when he ceased to be County Judge, removed to Forest Hill, where he practiced several years and then went to GoM Hill, State of Nevada, where he now resides.

Jo Hamilton was one of the pioneer lawyers of Placer County, locating at Auburn, where he has resided for many years. In 1860 he was elected District Attorney, and again in 1862. In 1871 he was elected Attorney-General of the State, and re-elected in 1875. Gen. Hamilton is one of the leading Democrats, as also one of the best-known lawyers of California. Since retiring from the office of Attorney-General he has resumed practice at Auburn.

The following anecdote is told, which indicates thestanding of this gentleman among the heathen of California. A Chinese notable traveling in the country, acting as an interpreter and general agent among his countrymen, presuming to occupy a position similar to that of an American attorney, when asked as to his means of obtaining an honest livelihood, he responded, "Me big lawyer; me alle same Jo Hamilton."

W. H. Bullock commenced practice at Michigan Bluffs in 1856, and W. H. Norton at Lincoln some two j-ears later. Mr. Bullock is a native of Massachusetts and a graduate of Williams College. Norton came to California from Wisconsin. Both gentlemen have been practicing at Auburn several years. H. H. Fellows commenced practice at Auburn in 1863. He was a man of a fine legal mind. After serving as District Attorney and coming into the possession of a good practice, he died, another victim of intemperance. His sad end was lamented by many friends. C. A. Tweed, who had been pra'-ticing at Dutch Flat for some time in 1864, formed a partnership at Auburn with E. L. Craig. Mr. Tweed was afterwards appointed by President Lincoln one of the Territorial Judges of Arizona. J. M. Fulweiler commenced the practice at Dutch Flat in 1868, and soon after removed to Auburn.

Judges Myres and Hale are the Nestors of the Bar in Placer County, for they have practiced there continuously since 1852. C. A. Tuttle removed to Oakland in 1868, but has since retained a portion of his former practice in the county. J. T. Kineade has been practicing at Auburn for several years. Hale and Craig have been partners for several years, and Bullock and Norton have recently formed a partnership. W. B. Lardner, a young lawyer, commenced the practice at Auburn in 1878, and W. A. Hughes in 1880; and J. E. Prescott also settled at Dutch Flat in 1879. Lardner is now District Attorney, and Myres is Superior Judge.

The many important cases that have occupied the courts of Placer it would be impracticable to detail in this volume, but many are referred to in the different chapters.

Attorneys Registered In Placer

William Horalio Bullock is a native of Massachusetts, having been born in the old " Bay State" in 1828. There he remained until the years of manhood, acquiring the education and profession that have been so important to him in after life. In 1851 he came to California and sought his fortune in the mines, chiefly at Lowell Hill, in Nevada County. After an experience of six months in the gold region, he returned to his native State, where he remained until 1855, when he determined to make his future home in California, and hither he came, landing in San Francisco in October of that year. He then settled in Michigan Bluff, where he remained in the practice of law for nearly ten years, subsequently removing to Auburn. In 1875 Mr. Bullock was elected District Attorney as an Independent, he being a Democrat.

W. H. Bullock, candidate for District Attorney, is one of the best nominations made, and for this reason, Mr. Bullock is one of the best read lawyers in the county; and apart i'rom the important nature of

Ill 1877 he was re-elected on the Democratic ticket, holding his position until 18S0. when succeeded by W. B. Lardner. The administration of Mr. Bullock was claimed as attended with more ability, more general quiet, and less expense than any administration of the office for years preceding. Since retiring from public office he has resumed the practice of his profession in Auburn, and is now one of the most prominent lawyers at the Bar of Placer County.

C. A. Tittle

Charles A. Tuttle was born in LeRoy. (xenessee County, Xew York. November 5, 1818. His parents were Harvey and Lucy (Taylor) Tuttle, the father born in Barkhamsted. and the mother at Hartland, both in Litchfield (bounty, Connecticut. They were married in 181G. and removed to LeRoy. The paternal ancestors of .Mr. Tuttle emigrated from England in l<i'2-t. and landed at Portsmouth. New Hampshire. On his mother's side he traces his ancestry to Capt. John Brown, who was killed in battle at Lake Champlaiii during the French and English war in 17.'J0. .John Brown, of Ossawatamie, was a grandson, and Lucy Taylor, Mr. Tuttle's mother, was a granddaughter of Capt. John Brown. The subject of this sketch has inherited the strong and positive traits of character exhibited in the Brown family, as will be readily observed by all who are familiar with his political course. The principles of libertj' of conscience and the inalienable birthright of man are born in the blood and bred in the bone, and with the determination and courage of his ancestors he has always been ready to express and act upon his opinions.

While a child of seven years, in a boyish attempt to use an axe, ho cut his right knee, and from the wound he became a cripple by the stiffening of the joint. His father, who.se ideas of a son were strength and skill to assist him on the farm, told him with a mournful face: Now j'ou will never be good for anything, and I must send you to school." After receiving the usual instruction in reading, writing, arithmetic, geography, and grammar, at the public school, he prepared for college at a private school in the village of LeRoy, under the instruction of the Rev. Mr. Metcalf, the Episcopal clergyman of the village, and entered Hobart College, at Geneva, N. Y.. in July, 1840.

From his earliest recollection, when told he would not be good for anything. Mr. Tuttle had formed the resolution to become a lawyer, and at the end of two years he left college and entered the law office of Gardiner & Delano, at Rochester, New York.

In October, 1845, he was married to Maria L. Batchelder, daughter of Enos Batchelder, a farmer in LeRoy. Soon after marriage Mr. Tuttle and his wife removed to Milwaukee, Wisconsin, where he was admitted to practice in the United States Territorial Courts, and commenced the practice in company with S. P. Coon, who was elected Attornej'- General of Wisconsin in 1849.

In the winter of 1849, Mr. Tuttle determined to remove to California, and in March, in company with three others, left Milwaukee for Independence, Missouri. From this point the party, on the 26th of April, commenced the long journey across the plains, arriving in California late in July. On the 28th of Jul}', 1849, he arrived at lUinoistown, and shortly after engaged in mining at Barnes' Bar, on the North Fork of the American River. There were but few people in that region at that time. Mr. E. T. Mendenhall had located at Illinoistown. Dr. F. W. Todd, now of Stockton, and F. Hill, of Oregon, had settled at Todd's Valley, Capt, Thompson and Archie McDonald were at Bird's Valley, Yankee Jim" was mining in a gulch where the town now bears his sobriquet, and Capt. Tichenor was mining in a gulch in the locality which afterwards became Michigan Bluff. On the rivers were a number of Oregonians and sailors who had left their vessels in San Francisco, and a few Americans who had come by way of the Isthmus of Panama.

In February. 18.50. Mr. Tuttle went to Stony Bar, on the North Fork of the Middle Fork of the American River, and there he tried his first California law-suit before a tribunal of miners. One Capt. Smith, a Scotchman, and several sailors, also Scotchmen, had built a cabin on Stony Bar, and mined there during the winter, and had located the bed of the stream for summer mining. A company of Ohio men came to the bar in March, looking for diggings. These men posted notices up and down the river, calling a miners' meeting to decide whether foreigners should hold claims. On Sunday a large crowd assembled. Mr. Tuttle volunteered to defend the Scotchmen. He addressed the audience and used all the arguments he was master of to show the injustice of forcing the Scotchmen to abandon their claims. There were some present who had been in the Mexican war, and these said, "we fought for this country and it is ours by right." The meeting decided that the Scotchmen could not hold a claim, and the Ohio men took possession.

In 1851 Mr. Tuttle went East, and in the summer of 1852 returned overland with his wife and settled at Bird's Valley. In the political campaign of 1853 he became the Democratic candidate for the Senate, and was elected. This was his first acquaintance with politics, and with the public men of this State. At the session which followed he made the acquaintance and became the friend of David C. Brodcrick. The Supreme Court of this State had about this time decided that no appeal could be taken from the State Court to the Supreme Court of the United States. At the session of 1855 Mr. Tuttle. in connection with Judge Whiting, of Monterey, prepared a bill to enforce such appeals in proper cases. His speech on the bill was published and generally circulated, and to the surprise of everyone the bill passed. The law will be found in the Statutes of 1855, page eighty. This act laid the foundation for the controversjbetween the advocates of States' Rights and their opponents, which was carried on in this State, and which aided much in the formation of the Republican Party. Mr. Tuttle retired from the Senate at the close of the term in 1855, an adherent of the Republican Party, then organizing in the East. He canvassed the northern part of the State in 1856 for Fi-emont, and in 1857 he presided over the Republican State Convention. In the spring of 1856 he formed a partnership with C. J. Hillyer in the practice of the law at Auburn. Mr. Hillyer was a graduate of Yale, and an able lawyer. The firm transacted a large business until 1863, when Mr. Hillyer went to the Territory of Nevada and settled at Virginia City. He now resides in Washington, D. C.

In 1860 Mr. Tuttle was on the Republican Electoral ticket, canvassed the Stale in advocacj^ of the party, and had the honor of casting his vote as Elector of California for Abraham Lincoln for President. In 1863 he was appointed by Governor Stanford Reporter to the Supreme Court, which position he held till the fall of 1867, when he resigned. As Reporter his work comprised ten volumes, from the twenty-second to the thirtj^-third of the California Reports. They are spoken of in the highest terms by the profession.

In the fall of 18G7 Mr. Tuttle was elected to the Legislature from Placer County. In the winter of 1868 he removed to Oakland, because a change of climate was deemed necessary for the health of his wife. Mrs. Tuttle visited the East the following summer for her health, and died at Brooklyn, New York, in October, 1868.

Mrs. Tuttle was a grailuate of the LeRoy Female Seminary, and a lady of refinement. She had early studied under Mr. Stanton, an artist, and left a number of paintings, which now adorn the walls of Mr. Tuttle's residence. She left three sons, two of whom are now memljers of the bar.

In 1871 Mr. Tuttle was appointed by Governor Haight one of the revisers of the work of the Code Commissioners, and in company with Sidney A. Johnson was engaged ou that labor until the passage of the Codes in the spring of 1872. In the summer of 1873 he was again appointed by the Supreme Court Reporter of its decisions, which position he held until the spring of 1878. During this period he published thirteen volumes of reports. In 1875 he was nominated by the Independent Party for Congress, but failed of election.

Although Mr. Tuttle's life-work has been tbat of a lawyer, yet he takes a deep interest in politics, and has positive opinions on all political questions. He still resides in Oakland, but retains considerable practice at Auburn, being much attached to Placer

County, and intends to return there and pass the remainder of his life. There is probably no one living who was more completely identified with the early history of Placer L'ounty, or who is better acquainted with its mining and other resources than Mr. Tuttle.

Provenance

Text from History of Placer County, California, published 1882, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.