BlockBefore

Santa Barbara County, California - Chapter 25: High Tide of Prosperity, 1883 (part 2 of 3)

From HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. 15,908 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

29 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,908 words

Machine-read from scans of HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

"There are large bodies of ore in sight and easily obtainable, and experts still believe the mines may be worked with profit. The secluded character of the place, which makes connection with tide-water difficult, and the svarcity of suitable mining timbers, will probably operate unfavorably on the value of the mines for some years to come.

This was the property of the Santa Ynez Mining Company, with a capital stock of $1,000,000, while the Los Prietos Company organized with a capital stock of $10,000,000. The last named eventually absorbed the former, and now the property is held by one company.

Mono Cafion is farther up the Santa Ynez, and takes its name from the fanciful resemblance of a rock to the monkey; but tourists have chipped it off so much that if it ever had any resemblance it is now lost.

Though the mines are now silent and deserted, and the costly machinery and buildings going to ruin, yet it is confidently believed by mining men that when a railroad up the Santa Ynez shall mak»

"Some two weeks ago, during a heavy storm, word was brought in to our county authorities that a woman was lying out in the open air with a child that had just been born. Accordingly Mr. Rynerson, one of the Supervisors, at once dispatched a hack to bring her in, and she was taken to the St. Charles Hotel. She gave her name as Mrs. Gertrude Ward. From what we can glean of her adil it appears that she came from New York with her husband, and at Chicago, either intentionally or otherwise, she got separated from him, and was several miles on her journey toward California before she missed him. At San Francisco she got on board a steamer coming south, with the intention, as she afterwards stated, of jumping overboard. She got otf here and wandered off into the country, where she was overtaken by the storm and gave birth to the child. She appeared very despondent during her sojourn at the hotel, and yesterday afternoon ended her misery by taking a dose of poison. The story bears upon the face of it the case of a cruel desertion of a woman by the man who had sworn to protect and cherish her."

Child Lost At The Patera

"A little girl eight years old, daughter of Mr. Church, of La Patera, about 3 o'clock on Sunday last, went to the pasture and caught an old family horse and rode off a few miles to a neighbor's to visit some playmates. Becoming interested in the play, she forgot how rapidly time was passing, and Peeve too long. It was dusk before she started ome, and it became dark while she was still on her way. She could no longer see the road, but she had the wisdom to trust the affair to the horse, and he carried her to the pasture field. Unfortunately, however, his equine ambition extended no farther. He liked the pasture and remained there, and the girl, not during to trust herself to find her home in the black darkness, thought it best to remain in the field until morning. Meantime her parents, becoming very much alarmed, summoned the neighbors for miles around and commenced the search for the lost child. Every one pictured to themselves the little one being devoured by wild cats, bears, or wild hogs, and pushed the search with all possible energy. When found she was sweetly sleeping under a tree, unconscious of danger."

The City Government

A municipal system had been established in 1851, by Act of the Legislature, giving the usual rights to the city authorities to maintain peace, repair streets, and raise taxes to pay the necessary expenses. The latter should have been small, and the managers of city matters would probably never have made themselves rich, nor would the municipal offices have been much sought but for the immense landed property which was at the disposal of the authorities. This was early disposed of in a manner not always satisfactory to the citizens, as much of it fell into the hands of speculators. The Haley survey, mentioned elsewhere, was several times the means of rivalry in getting city offices. Later thero was street grading to attend to, also the opening of streets. During the time of the triad of papers - Press, Times and Index - the citizens who were divided into parties called the Press party and Times party, "up town" and "down town" also came in for a share of the interest. The tickets and votes for Councilmen were: -

Each party claimed to be a reform party. The Times claimed the ticket as the People's Reform ticket; called the first, the plunder, rule-or-ruin ticket. The Press denounced the opposition as Packard's ring.

«What claim, we should like to know, have the authors of these acts of plunder upon the taxpayers? Rather what unblushing effrontery for them to dare to offer themselves or their parasites for the suffrages of an outraged people! We have time and again pointed out actual robbery in the matter of street contracts and asked for an explanation. The ring has run the municipality on the rule-or-ruin principle. But the people of Santa Barbara have had enough of their pernicious rule. Oppressive taxes, swindling contracts, and the absorption of the splendid patrimony in lands belonging to the town by these miniature Tammanyites, constitute the sum of their stewardship. With sufficient valuable lands in her possession to have rendered her one of the most opulent little municipalities in the United States, and to have exempted the pee of her people forever from town taxation, anta Barbara has been plundered of her public domain, and her people oppressed with the burdens arising from municipal prodigality and corruption."

The last paragraph refers to the matter of the public lands of Santa Barbara, which were sold at nominal sums to actual settlers, as it was supposed. The most of them found speculative owners in a short time.

Mayor Richards, upon his retirement from the position of Mayor, made a valedictory address, containing items of interest regarding his administration of city affairs.

When he entered upon his duties he found a floating debt of near $7,000. The last administration had found it necessary to borrow $10,000 at 13 per cent. per month. The bonded debt of the city seems to have been $16,302, leaving the whole amount at the close of his administration at about $19,000. The City Council passed an ordinance making it necessary to have all corners, streets, aud lots conform to the Haley survey. He thought $50,000 was necessary for the completion of roads and drives in the vicinity of the city. He condemned the custom of appointing officers instead of electing them, aud complained much of J. P. Stearns, Treasurer, in not responding to orders for money, and of Mr. Russell, Superintendent of Streets, for not removing obstructions when requested to do so. The taxes remaining delinquent were but $50.

There was little inducement to hold office, as there were no salaries paid either to the Mayor or Councilmen for service. The place of Mayor was one of honor rather than profit. It was generally forced upon a man, although when distinguished strangers came, as the duty of welcoming them to the city devolved upon him, the position was rather desirable. Most of the prominent men were at some time or other elected to this office. When Mortimer Cook was elected Mayor he made the following statement of finances: -

Of this amount $1,186.10 was paid in a warrant to R. K. Sexton, on award of damages by Supreme Court in the case of Sexton vs. Town of Santa Barbara. He recommended making no debt except for permanent improvements, such as a system of sewerage, purchase of water-works, or similar projects.

On one occasion, when Cook was running against J. T. Richards, a little incident happened which showed the humor of the people. On the morning of the election several citizens, among whom were the two candidates for Mayor, also ex-Mayor Stearns, were waiting at the stand of a well-known bootblack for a shine. Stearns caught up the brushes and soon fitted Cook for the day's work by polishing him up nicely. Whether from the half hour he gained by this, the fine shine, or the friendship of such an active man as Stearns, Cook was elected. Richard's friends complained of the action of Stearns as an unfair proceeding; but the maddest man of all was the darkey, who wished that "gemplemen would mind their business and let de niggers alone."

Fire Engine

The first engine was purchased in 1874. Mayor Cook acted as agent in the purchase. When it was landed at the wharf the Pioneer Fire Company formed at Cook's Hall, and marched to Stearns' Wharf, where the engine was turned over to them. The ladies of Santa Barbara presented a handsome silk flag, Judge Maguire making the presentation speech, which was responded to by Clarence Gray. The procession was headed by a brass band. After |

Sycamore Canon Road

The difficulty of opening roads has been mentioned before. The road past Belmont (Judge Fernald's property) was a source of much trouble. The most practicable route was through a certain man's house, which as often as the road-makers approached, became an impregnable castle, compelling the workmen to seek safety in retreat. A way was finally found around, without destroying the house.

The Haley Survey

In 1851 the authorities of the city of Santa Barbara authorized Salisbury Haley a surveyor to lay out the city of Santa Barbara in blocks and streets, the blocks to be 450 feet square, and the streets to be sixty feet wide, excepting State and Carrillo Streets, which were to be eighty feet wide each. The initial point of the survey was, at the junction of these streets, marked by an iron pin. The city, as surveyed, made anice plot. The blocks were marked by redwood stakes two inches square and eighteen inches long, six inches being above ground with the number of the block uponit. People built houses and fences, and planted trees and shrubbery according to the stakes set by Haley. After some years many of these rotted away, or were removed, and when the question of the location of the lots came up. recourse was had to the iron pin at the junction of State and Cannon Perdido, as a starting point. It was found that, though the plot of the city, as mapped out, was regular enough, the streets were of different widths, though none were less than the prescribed terms. The blocks, also, were irregular, some being 464 feet on a side, though all were of the required size. It was said in defense of the laches, if we may so call it, that land was cheap, and that a few feet more made nobody poor; but when the measurements were made from the initial point, it turned the whole city awry. Costly buildings had been put upon State as well : as other streets, which would change owners if the survey was to be corrected from the initial point. The greatest variation seemed to have been in the streets in the southern part of the city, in the vicinity of . Haley, Castillo, and Montecito Streets. On one of otherwise improved the ground. When he found that a correct measurement would add something to the form of' his lot, he set his fence sixteen feet into the street, and here commenced-a contest participated in by the papers in their usual acrimonious style, that lasted for some years. The city officers were elected with reference to the Haley survey, sometimes in favor, and sometimes opposed to it, When the Haley party was in power, the fences were torn down, that is if the owners permitted it to be done, which was not always the case, for, in one instance the owner was behind the fence with a double-barrelled shot-gun, with such a belligerent aspect that the constable and his posse, who were sent to remove the obstruction, come to the conclusion not to remove the fence that day. In the case of Sexton the fence was removed, and the matter carried from one court to another at a great expense.

Trustees Take Action Concerning The Haley Survey

"By the Act of the Legislature, organizing the town of Santa Barbara, José Maria Loureyro, Charles Fernald, Joaquin Carrillo, W. A. Streeter, and Octaviano Gutierrez were appointed a Board of Trustees for the town. In pursuance of the duties of their office, they passed the following

"By resolution passed in session of this day, 10th of March of the year 1868, was formed a Committee on Streets, composed of Mariano Lopez and G. Streeter.

"Sxo. 2. The Street Committee shall have the general superintendence of all the streets of the town, as marked on the official map of the town; and also of all the alleys and highways acknowledged as such by the ordinance approved on the 23d of September, 1850.

"Sxo. 3. Every person intending to erect any building or fence, or any other work, shall, before erecting such building, or fence, etc., procure from the Street Committee a certificate setting forth that such building, fence, etc., will not interfere with the line of the street. the public transit, the free passage, and in no way with the rights of the town.

"Sro 4. If any person shall erect any building, fence, etc., without having first procured such certificate as mentioned in Section 3, from the Street Commissioners, he shall be liable to a fine of not less than five dollars, and no more than fifty dollars, after being convicted before the Town Recorder, said fine to be imposed at the discretion of the Recorder, and shall be entered on the city funds.

"Sxo. 5. The Street Commissioners will have power to permit at their discretion, and when no detriment to the town interest is to be had, the fencing of part of the streets, the petitioner mentioning how long such fence will remain on such portion of the street, with the express condition that such portions of fenced streets shall not be included in the part of the town inside of the limits of ' Bafio,' ' Victoria,' 'Santa Barbara,' and the seashore, and it shall be understood this permission shall not be given to fence all or part of the public streets marked on the official map, neither the public passages designated on the ordinance approved on the 23d of September, 1856, and situated in the space included between the streets of ' Bafio,' ' Victoria,' 'Santa Barbara,' and the shore.

"Sxo. 6. The Street Commissioners shall be entitled to claim and receive from the interested parties, for each certificate allowed according with the above

"Sno. 7. In the case of any person or persons owning land situated on any of the streets as laid on the official map of the town, wishing to erect any buildiug, fence, etc., on such street, he shall, before the action of the same, give notice to the Street Commissioner, whose duty it shall be not to grant such permission without the approbation of the Common Council.

"Sxo. 10. This ordinance shall take effect from the time of its approval. " Approved May 18, A. p. 1865. " Josr M. Lourryro, President. "QO, GUTIERREZ, Secretary.

"The above ordinance, together with the other ordinances and proceedings of the Board of Trustees, was daly legalized by act of the Legislature, as follows : -

"Srorron 1. The Acts and Proceedings of the Trustees of the Town of Santa Barbara, created by an Act entitled 'An Act to Incorporate the Town of Santa Barbara,' approved February tenth, eighteen hundred and sixty-four, are hereby approved, ratified, and confirmed.

"The foregoing ordinance has never been repealed, or in any way modified, and is in full force and effect. Those who are fencing or locating lots may feel an interest in examining it.

Resolved, That the iron stakes set by the Town Surveyor in the year 1861 at the southwest intersection of State and Carrillo Streets, on easterly corner of Block No. 142, also the iron stake set on the easterly corner of Block No. 158, be from now henceforth the initial points of the town surveys, and of all locations of lots and streets. Satisfactory evidence shows that the aforesaid corners of blocks have been the initial points of the Salisbury Haley surveys, made in the years 1851, 1852, and 1853, according with the maps accepted by the then city authorities; therefore, the President and Board of Trustees of the Town of Santa Barbara do ordain that all surveys made thereafter that in any manner deviate from the said initial points, and vary with the courses and distances as set forth in said S. Haley's maps, are hereby declared null and void. And that all ordinances or parts of ordinances that are in conflict with this ordinance are hereby repealed.

"That the ordinance designated as ' Ordinance No. 28,' entitled 'An Ordinance Concerning the Town Survey, purporting to have been passed and approved the 3d day ot November, 1870, be and the same is hereby repealed and expunged. And it is further ordered that the Secretary of this Board at once draw lines in red ink around the same, on the margin of the record thereof, and write thereon the words, 'Expunged by order of the Town Trustees, February 2, 1871,' and that the President and Secretary sign the same.

"That the survey of the Town of Santa Barbara, made by Salisbury Haley, and heretofore accepted by the authorities thereof, is hereby ajproved and ratified, and that the same is hereby declared the official survey of the said Town of Santa Barbara.

"The Board of Trustees of the Town of Santa Barbara, not having heretofore prescribed the duty of the Surveyor, as by law required, and no order appearing in the minutes directing the location of blocks and lots within the corporate limits of said town:

" We do therefore declare all the locations of lots and blocks, and the surveys of the same, made by W. H. Norway, not made in accordance with the accepted survey of the said town, kuown as the Haley Survey, null and void.

Errors In The Haley Survey

" Report of the committee appointed to report upon the errors in Salisbury Haley's survey of the city of Santa Barbara, and what action the Board should take to remedy the same.

'"M. Harloe, R. K. Sexton, and J. E. Goux, the committee appointed, report that, having consulted with W. H. Norway, County and Town Surveyor, they have learned that an error exists in the survey of our town of Santa Barbara by Salisbury Haley in the year 1851; that there is a progressive difference in the size of town blocks from the starting point to the end of the town, which difference amounts to thirty feet, more or less, when reaching said end of the town. The result of such error is that the last block of said town near the sea-shore, on State Street, and the last block on Mission Stteet, are thirty feet, more or less, farther from the central point (on State Street between Cannon Perdido and Carrillo Streets) than they ought to be, and the blocks between the sea range and the coast range in the same proportion.

"The contract made by the city of Santa Barbara with S. Haley specifies that the plot of tae city of Santa Barbara had to be divided into squares of 150 yards, and each one surrounded by streets sixty feet wide, except two streets to be designated by Common Council, which shall be eighty feet wide, and which have been designated as State and Carrillo

'Streets. Said survey has been made by S. Haley, and the sum of $2,000 paid for the same, and the / maps showing said survey bearing Nos. 1 and 2 | received and accepted by the Common Council by a resolution or ordinance passed to that effect."

Before Judge Maguire

" Alternative writ of prohibition heretofore issued on order of County Judge, came on for hearing on Monday, the 14th of April, being issued on sworn petition of complainant, alleging that the Board of 'Trustees of the Town of Santa Barbara had ordered their Marshal to remove the fence of said complainant on Block No. 292, resulting, if carried out, in irreparable injury of the petitioner, by the destruction of various valuable truit and ornamental trees thereon growing, which could not be compensated in money, and that the Marshal's bond, if any he had given, was totally inadequate to respond in the amount of damage."

The Board filed an answer denying that the premises in question were a part of Block 292, and alleging that they were wholly in the street as laid down by the official map of the town. Evidence was taken by examination of witnesses and by the introduction of documentary evidence, and from such I find as follows: -

"That in the year 1851 the City Council entered into a written agreement with one Salisbury Haley, to survey and lay out the city in uniform blocks of 150 yards square, placing redwood stakes, of not less than two inches in diameter and eighteen inches long, sixteen inches in the ground, to be placed at the corner of each lot, a:.d further, that the streets, with the exception of two, be of the width of sixty feet each; also, requiring execution and delivery of the corresponding map. The survey was soon after made and duly accepted by the city; the monument or stakes placed at the corner of each lot, in conformity with the said agreement; but there seems to be considerable doubt as to whether Haley supplied the necessary map, as two were produced, some testitying that the one by Wrackenrueder, and others that by Brady, was the official map of the survey as accepted; but on another important point there was no conflict, to wit, that said Haley never filed any field notes of said survey; and here | must add that grave doubts axist as to the initial points placed by Haley in making his survey, and are far from being cleared up by the affidavits read on the hearing, as in none is there positive knowledge of said point or points at the placing ot same by Haley.

"Tt further appears that there is a line of blocks in said town, as platted by Haley, of 464 feet each, instead of 450 feet as designated, whilst others contain 457 feet; but that years back all of said blocks had the conventional stakes at each corner, and were then accepted by the city as the blocks of the official survey. Petitioner in 1867 purchased two blocks; one 292 is the one in question. Some sixteen years after the laying out of the town he employed a surveyor to trace his lines, and then erected his fences from Montecito to Castillo Streets in conformity with said survey, planting in due time the suid fruit and ornamental trecs. This survey, if starting from true initial points, and reducing the excess found in the blocks heretofore mentioned to the dimensions of 450 feet each, would have the inevitable result not only to change the fences of many, but of nearly all the lot owners of Santa Barbara, as well as to permanently injure and confiscate houses and other costly improvements, most of them erected years past, when the original stakes were yet as Haley placed them, as accepted by the city, and duly certified by ordinance; and as such duly conveyed to the various grantees. Further, it is a well-recognized principle, and definitely settled by our courts, that when monuments conflict with courses and distances, the former must govern and the latter be ignored. "One point more I wish to state, and not, I think, without significance to elucidate the question at issue; it is this: that though the blocks vary in size, there is not a tittle of' evidence to show that the streets as laid down and opened are not of the required width in the whole town of Santa Barbara. "Now, as a conclusion, from the foregoing I find that the premises in question are situated in the streets of Montecito and Castillo, projecting in the former from eighteen to nineteen feet, and in the latter six feet, and that the removal of the fences by the town authorities is in no sense the taking of private property without just compensation. "Therefore, the writ heretofore issued is hereby annulled and discharged, the peremptory writ prayed for denied, and the petition dismissed with costs. "Thus ordered in Chambers this 18th day of April, A. D. 1873. J. F. Maaurre, County Judge."

The 7imes attacked the decision of Judge Maguire; said that it was influenced by selfish motives; that it wus so decided because it would give him a portion of a lot. It also said the decision would not fix the Haley survey as the legal one. The tearing down of Sexton's fence was called an outrage by some, while it was defended by others.

In the District Court of the First Judicial District, County of Santa Barbara. R. K. Sexton, v8. THe Town or Santa BarBaRaA. Action to quiet title to Block No. 292, in the Town of Santa Barbara.

Findings Of Fact

1. That the plaintiff, on the 19th day of April, 1873, was seized and possessed of the land described in the complaint as Block No. 292, as laid down and marked on the map of the town called the Haley map, which was made by order of the authorities thereof, and adopted by them in the year 1851.

2. That said block was originally granted by the former authorities. of said town to one Wm. Foreman, in the month of January, 1852, as laid down and marked by said map, and that said grant has been ratified by an Act of the Legislature of this State; ard that the plaintiff claims title to the same through proper mesne conveyances from said Foreman.

Surveyor, located the said block as it was laid down, and enclosed the same accordingly, and in conformity with the lines of the streets so laid down on said map, and the block so remained enclosed unto the date of the commencement of this action.

1. That Norway, to ascertain the true location of said block, connectedly took the initial point of the Haley survey, on the Carrillo and State Streets, as his starting point, and being governed by the distanc2s as laid down on said map, and the courses which appeared to have governed the Haley survey, and that such was the most reliable and certain guide for the location of said block that did or now does exist.

5. That the said block as located by Norway embraces no portion of Montecito or Castillo Streets, and that defendant has no estate or interest in said block, or any portion thereof.

Decree

The issue in this cause, by consent of parties, having been tried by the Court, and a written finding of facts having been made, bearing date the day of - , 1873, and duly filed, and it appearing that the plaintiff is entitled to the relief prayed for in his complaint. It is therefore adjudged that the town of Santa Barbara, and all persons claiming under her by title accruing subsequently to the 19th day of April, 1873, be forever barred from all claims to any estate whatever in the premises mentioned in the complaint as Block No. 292, as enclosed and possessed by the plaintiff on the said 19th day of April, 1873, or any part thereof.

Findings And Decree Of Judge Murray

I find from the evidence adduced in this case, independent of that embraced in exhibit "A," being the judgment roll in the case of Sexton vs. The Town of Santa Barbara (suit to quiet title), as follows: -

1. That in the year 1851 the city of Santa Barbara was seized in fee of all the lands within its corporate limits, and that the defendant is its successor.

2. That in that year the authorities of said city authorized Salisbury Haley to survey its lauds, and lay off the same in blocks and streets.

3. That said Haley made such survey and returned a map thereof, and that the same were, in the year 1852, recognized by the city authorities as the official survey and map of said city, and the same have been continually so recognized up to the present time.

4. That said Haley established an initial point of said survey at the intersection of State and Carrillo Streets, and reported the same to the Board of Trustees of said city.

numbered, and were laid out in the field and marked upon the map as being 450 feet square; and that all strects were laid out as well in the field as on the map, as sixty feet wide, except State and Carrillo Streets, which were cighty feet wide. 6. That Block No. 292 of said map and survey is bounded by four streets. two of which are Castillo and Montecito Streets, and that it was granted in the year 1852 by said city to one W. Foreman; and that the plaintiff, on the 25th day of April, 1873, was and ever since has been seized and possessed thereof, being the premises described in the complaint, deriving title through mesne conveyances from said Foreman.

yards square; and laid down and marked on the map of said city, made by Salisbury Haley, as square number 292;" and that such was the form for a long time used by said city in the description of' lands, in conveyances given by her to private individuals.

8. That J. L. Barker was Town Surveyor of the Town of Santa Barbara in the year 1871, and as such he was directed by the Board of Trustees thereof to make a survey of Montecito and Castillo Streets, and made the same, which was by ordinance adopted and declared to be an official survey of the lines in the year 1851, which action of the Board was by act of Legislature of February 6, 1872, approved and confirmed.

9. That according to the said Barker re-survey, the plaintiff's fence encroached upon Montecito Street sixteen feet, and upon Castillo Street about five feet; but that the said Barker survey was erroneous, and the fences of the plaintiff were in reality upon the exterior of his block, and upon the true lines of Montecito and Castillo Streets, as surveyed by Salisbury Huley, and laid down by him on said map.

10. That the Board of Trustees of said town afterwards declared plaintiff's fences so encroaching, or supposed to be so, upon said streets, to be a nuisance, and gave the said plaintiff notice to remove the same in fifteen days, or that the same would be removed by the Town Marshal.

11. That on the said 25th day of April, a. b., 1873, the plaintiff being so seized as aforesaid, the defendant, by her Town Marshal, acting by and under the authority of said Board, with a band of men under his control and direction, and without the consent of the plaintiff, entered upon the said premises, and took down the fence enclosing the same, unlawfully, leaving the same open to the depredations of cattle and other animals.

12. That the said premises were surrounded, and had thereon many ornamental trees and shrubbery, which, by the said acts of the said defendant's servants, were greatly injured, and the value of the premises thereby diminished, and the said fences, so removed, rendered of little value.

Conclusion Of Law

I have arrived at the foregoing conclusions in the following manner: When the city of Santa Barbara assumed to deed to Foreman and others, under the official survey made by Haley, and described the blocks conveyed by her to them according to the numbers set down on the map, it must be held that she conveyed specific tracts already determined and located. The American system of town gurvey is exact and determinute, and leaves no resemblance to the manner of measurement from an initial point well established. The city is bound by her deed, and when the title passed to the plaintiffs predecessor, he and his heirs and assigns had full right to possess and enjoy the land, subject to no after readjustment of lines, except by due process of law. The plaintiff, desiring to fence his block, employed the Town Surveyor to point out his lines. This was done by starting the initial point of the Haley survey, and measuring thence the distances set down in the map for strects und blocks, until. at length the lines of the block named were accurately determined. The defendant's witness, Barker, who had himself been Town Surveyor, testifies in offect that such a measurement would produce the same result arrived at by Norway. His "re-survey" of the lines of Montecito and Castillo Streets was, in his own words, made as follows:

"JT did not start from any particular point. I started from any of the stakes of Mr. Haley, which 1 found, taking them as a basis, and made the survey as exactly as I could." Had Barker gone back to the initial point of the Haley survey, and thence measured, he would have found that plaintiff had fenced in the identical tract to which he held title. Barker's "re-survey" avails nothing. The town having once decided this block, cannot re-locate it. The question at issue is one of identification, merely, and I am satisfied that this has been made, and that plaintiff's fences, removed by the town, were upon his true lines. The defendant's attorney denies the right of plaintiff to recover on the ground that a corporation cannot authorize its officers to commit a trespass, and that, therefore, the defendant is not liable. In answer, I will cite Dillon on Corporations, sections 769 et seg. "If, in exercising its power to Open or improve streets, the agents or officers of municipal corporation, under its authority or directian, commit a trespass upon, or take possession of, private property, without complying with the charter or statute, the corporation is liable in damages therefor. In such cases, also, an action will lie against a city corporation by the owner of land through which its agents have unlawfully made a sewer, or for trees

Louisiana, which was several times before the courts in that State, was decided upon the same principle. The Mayor of a city tortiously and in defiance of an injunction, proceeded at the head of a posse of labbrers, and domolished a portion of the plaintiff's house, for the supposed reason that it was on public ground. The city corporation ratified the act by defending it. On the first appeal the court doubted whether the corporation could be made liable for the wrongful acts charged against its officers, especially as these were alleged to have been done by them willfully and maliciously. On the second appeal it was hat the town could not do in this regard, the Legislature could not do for her. Both must bow to the provision contained in the eighth section of the first article of our State Constitution. There was no testimony as to damage, except that given by the plaintiff's witnesses. These agree in assessing the damage at more than the amount claimed, to-wit: one. thousand dollars. Let judgment be entered in favor of the plaintiff for one thousand dollars and his costs and disbursements in this action.

Sxction 1. Whenever any survey shall hereafter be made by the City Surveyor he must, in the location of the streets, blocks, or lots, take the line of State Street for his base line, and he must take for his starting point the iron stake at the southwest intersection of State and Carrillo Streets, on the easterly corner of Block No. 142, or the iron stake on the easterly block of No. 158, at the intersection of State and Cafion Perdido Streets, and that he must allow sixty feet for the width of each street, except State and Carrillo, for width of which he must allow eighty feet, and for each block he must allow 450 feet, as provided and laid down on the official map of the city, and the City Surveyor must make all surveys and locate streets and blocks to conform to the location of the same on the said map, with the line of State Street for-his base line, and of the aforesaid iron stakes for his initial point.

Src. 2. All surveys heretofore made, and all location of streets, lots, or blocks which are not in accordance with the provisions of this ordinance, are hereby declared to be void, and no city block, lot of land, or street shall hereafter be established or located by the City Surveyor, or in any other manner except as herein provided.

Src. 3. The City Surveyor is hereby directed to erect or place suitable permanent monuments of stone or iron at the points designated in Section 1 of this ordinance, and to report to the Common Council his action in the matter, and give a particular description of said monuments, and their courses and distances from such other points as will accurately determine their location.

Src. 4. Ordinance No. 32, entitled "Ordinance to approve and ratify the survey of the town of Santa Barbara," passed and approved February 11, 1871, is hereby repealed.

Src. 5. Ordinance No. 35, entitled "An official survey of the lines of the old Haley survey of Chapella, State, and Anacapa Streets, passed and approved November 9, 1871, is hereby repealed.

Haley Survey Settled Old And New

The usual results of a local dispute were repeated in this case. The conflicting interests, the ignorance of the principles on which such cases must be finally settled, and the different views of equity entertained by interested parties, brought out a great deal of abusive language as well as humor. It was asserted that the measurements were made with a rope which was longer at noon than in the morning; that the compass used was taken out of a wrecked vessel that came to grief because the instrument had to have the assistance of a handspike to point to the north. Everything must have an end. The loud and persistent talk did not decide the question. When the case came before the Supreme Court, in the case of Penry vs. Richards, No. 5,688, the judges decided that the stakes set by Haley were the lawful landmarks; upon which W. C. Stratton, City Attorney, informed the Council that the stakes set by Haley must be considered the legal bounds of streets and blocks, so ended the contest regarding the " Haley Survey," OLD AND NEW.

The long evenly graded streets with planked sidewalks, the rows of brick buildings filled with costly goods, the drays transporting the packages of foreign merchandise, the churches, the institutions of learning, the arrival and departure of steamers, the numbers of first-class hotels, like the Morris House, the Occidental, and Arlington, thronged with guests, the numbers of gay equipages darting about the streets, the crowds of strangers coming and going, the three daily papers that endeavored to swell every minor event into something of importance, all showed the transition state of the city, and the ultimate loss of all that made up the Santa Barbara of twentyfive years ago. Although the new phases had been looked upon as desirableimprovements, and were really 80, yet there were some feelings of regret as the old landmarks began to blend into the dim past. The editor of the /ndex thus poured out his lamentations:

" Walking along Santa Barbara Street a few days ago, in the morning, we passed a native Californian's home. Two women were sitting, laughing and chatting on a porch beneath the tiled roof of a long low brown adobe; a man sat singing a soft Spanish air to the accompaniment of a guitar; several fruit trees and a cactus grew in the open ground before the door; five or six horses saddled and bridled, stood tied beneath the trees; two dogs were sleeping in the sun. To us Americans who are forever struggling onward in a ceaseless march of progress, it is a pleasure sometimes to stop and look for a moment on those who live in the simple enjoyment of the natural blessings of existence. These adobes with the lite they contain, come upon us in the midst of our Yankee enterprise more like the pictures of the rude poesy of primitive life, such as we read of in the history of by-gone years, than as any part of our surroundings. They are the remains of old Santa Barbara, that are dissolving as the figures of a dream before Santa Barbara the new. If, as the old recedes, we could snatch from oblivion but one of these adobes, just to show the character of the old town, to be preserved as the picture of the primitive pastoral age of Santa Barbara, we would do so. But the inmates should be retained as well as the adobe. Without the Californian, the house would tell but half the story. It would be like the frame without the picture. No part of the dwelling or its surroundings should be touched. No plasterer should desecrate it with his trowel; no whitewasher should mar it with his brush, and we would keep the dogs about the door; and the horses with their riders should come and go; and the guitar shouid be heard as it is now, and of an evening the bonfire should be lit, and dancing should begin, and dancers should be seen through the lighted windows, and mirth should be there, and the house and its inhabitants should be like the spectre scene of long ago. Strange legends should grow up aroundit. Children should pass it with whispers. Poets and artists should come to feed on its inspiration, and in time some southern Hawthorne should weave its story with his own, and embalm it with immortal memory."

Spanish Grants

Chandler's Letter - Los Prietos y Najalayegua - Legal Proceedin s - Dominguez' First Petition - Confirmation of Dominguez' Title - Value of the Grant - Abstract of Title - Side Claim - In C ougress - Parson's Letter - Dominguez' Statement - Confirmation - Town Titles - Packard's Protest - |

Public Feeling - The Survey - G. Howard Thompson's Letter - Decision of the Commissioners Regarding the Survey - Survey Rejected - Public Meeting - Public Meetings Continued - Affidavits - Poetry - San Francisco '' Times' - The Clouds Lifting - Counter Affidavits - ' Press' Editorial - Sigus of a Reaction in Congress - Conclusion - The Ex- Mission Graat - Editorial in the '' Alta."

Ir is hardly possible to give, in the short space permissible in a history of this kind, any correct idea of the nature of the Spanish Grants. A large volume would be required to give a correct and complete history of even the Najalayegua, the history of which involved Congress and many of our Judges in its operations. It has been thought best to give as full an account of this matter as space would permit, touching lightly on others which were scarcely inferior to it in interest. It may be observed of this grant that there was no doubt of its being genuine, the parties concerned all living until the great contest concerning it had been ended. Many of the grants are justly believed to have been manufactured after the occupation by the Americans, the former Government officers lending the use of their names for the purpose. In some instances the titles were made on paper bearing a date in the watermarks of the paper subsequent to the purported execution of the papers. The archives containing the Mexican documents were kept in the Surveyor-Generals' office at San Francisco, and the records being in Spanish, many clerks of the native race kad to be employed. The whole process of obtaining land had been extremely simple, involving very few preliminaries other than clerical work, so that with access to the archives grants could be manufactured without trouble. It is a serious charge to make against the Governors, but there seems little doubt of it. The Arroyo Seco grant purported to have been made by Juin B. Alvarado, May 8, 1840, antedating some years the grants of Sutter at Sacramento and Gulnac (Weber) at Stockton.

It was described as bounded on the west by the old Sacramento trail or road, south by the Mokelumne, north by the Cosumnes, and east by the neighboring Sierras, containing eleven leagues. But for the latter clause the territory might have been large enough for a kingdom. Now the striking features ot the matter are that the names given to the rivers were not known in 1840; that the Arroyo Seco, from which the grant was named, was not known by that or any other name until after the discovery of gold. In 1840 not a Mexican had ever seen the Arroyo Seco grant, much less set his foot upon it, for it was inhabited by Indians, who were at constant war with the Mexicans, and had successfully prevented the formation of any ranches east of the San Joaquin River, and even Gulnac himself, three years later, only got a foothold some thirty miles nearer the settled county by entering into a treaty with the Indians to assist them in defense against the Mexicans. In this instance some thirty or forty families were turned out of the houses and homes they themselves had built up out of a wilderness, the soldiers enlisted to defend the Union being The claim was pushed by Andres Pico, brother of the Governor, and by De Zaldo, who was a clerk in the Surveyor-General's

It is by no means intended to imply that there were no genuine grants; on the contrary, the most of them were undoubtedly good and true, but the laxity in the methods of making a grant worked a double disadvantage, a wrong to the colonists who had a title to the land, and to the settler on public lands who beheld all of his improvements swept away by the fraudulent claims. Many of the original holders, who had occupied the land for a quarter of a century, were compelled to endure the expense of a long and tedious litigation, carried on by landgrabbers who fought the confirmation at every step. Riots and loss of life were not unfrequent, while bribery, perjury, and all kinds of similar offenses were freely charged upon Judges, Legislators, and other officers.

Rumors from time to time regarding the frauds, practiced in most instances by speculators who had bought the Spanish claims, in regard to the settlement of the grants, reached the General Government. On one occasion Secretary Chandler responded as follows in regard to the Rancho Lomas de Santiago: -

Chandler'S Letter

"JT have given the subject my careful consideration, and have been aided by a very full argument, submitted by the attorneys to the defendants for the bill of complaints. The case made by the bill,shows that the Board of Land Commissioners and the decree of the District Court, confirming the grant, were procured by fraud and forgery, and that the grant itself was wholly void. It shows also that the presont owners of the rancho bought with fall knowledge of the fraud, and are not entitled to consideration as bona fide purchasers. Where the confirmation of Mexican grants appears to have been obtained through forgery or fraud upon the Courts, to the wrong of the General Government, I shall be disposed to advise the institution of appropriate action on the part of the United States for the recovery of the lands so obtained, provided they remain in the hands of the perpetrators of the fraud, or have been conveyed to others who have a full knowledge of the wrong. I am not disposed in any case to recommend that the possession of a bona fide grant purchase be disturbed. Assuming the facts to be as stated in the bill of complaint, I have the honor of advising that suit be brought in such form as shall

In this instance the claimants were a great railroad company. Whether the frauds were perpetrated by their agency or by parties who sold to them, is uncertain; but the facts that the grant had been made after the treaty of peace, and also an attempt to erase the date and substitute an earlier one, were apparent. Though there was no doubt that many improper means had been used to settle the land claims, there was an aversion to disturbing them, as likely to bring more evils than benefits in prolonging litigation.

Los Prietos Y Najalayegua

The first occupant, or, as we should say, "squatter," was José Lugo, an invalid soldier, who had taken up the land and had resided on it for some years.

"T certify in dué form that in my presence Mr. José Ignacio Lugo, an invalid soldier, effected the sale of the lands belonging to him to Mr. José Dominguez, which lands are situated in the Najalayegua, for $20.00 in silver currency and two barrels of aguadiente (native brandy), which said money the

The above map is closely copied from the original on file in the Surveyor Generals office at San Francisco, and is a fair sample of the Disenos usually accompanying a grant.

said Dominguez delivered to the vendor in this Tribunal, which I certify to and affirm for the reason that the contracting parties have resorted to my Tribunal, and I give this certificate to the said Dominguez, for his security and other necessary purposes, in Santa Barbara on the 14th day of January, 1843. KaymMuNpDO CARRILLv."

There was a house on the land built by Lugo, in which he resided, and to which Dominguez removed when he bought the land. In some of the old maps of Santa Barbara this house and land is designated as belonging to Dominguez. About this the contest afterwards raged.

your Excellency, respectfully represent: That needing a tract of land of my own for cultivation, and on which to place the stock that I possess, I implore your Excellency to be pleased to grant me that which is shown apon the annexed map, the same being vacant and lying within the limits of the town (Poblacion) of Santa Barbara.

Monterey, June 7, 1841. Let this petition be referred to the Prefect of the Second District, to the end that he may cause the necessary reports to be made in relation thereto. ALVARADO.

Mexican Grants

"T, José Dominguez, a native and resident of the District of Santa Barbara, before your Excellency respectfully present myself and say: That having in the ycar 1841 petitioned for a place called 'Prietos y Najalayegua,' situated in the district in which I reside, the respective Expediente was formed, but by order of the Governor and predecessor of your Excellency, the proceedings were suspended until the government should be established, and as the same is now radically established, I pray your Excellency to be pleased to issue to me the corresponding title for said place and order that the judicial possession be given me which may secure my right of property in the land. Although it is true that for the last three years I have been in possession of the land by having a house and stock thereon, by virtue ofa provisional title given me by the Seftor ex-Governor, Don Juan B. Alvarado.

Wherefore, I reiterate by petition, hoping from the goodness of your heart, to receive this favor, for which purpose I present herewith the Expediente referred to, which is concluded, together with the corresponding map, swearing, etc.

In the foregoing petition the report of the civil authority of Santa Barbara, with all other matters necessary to be considered in conformity with the law of the 18th of August, 1824, and the regulation of the 21st of November, 1828, I declare José Dominguez owner of the land named Los Prietos y Najalayegua.

Let the corresponding title issue, and let the Expediente be reserved that this concession may be submitted to the Most Excellent Departmental Assembly for the approval thereof.

Provisionally authorized by the Maritime Custom House of the Port of Monterey in the Department of the Californias for the years 1840 and 1841.

[Juan B. Alvarado was the Mexican Governor of California, from 1838 to 1842. Owing to an unsettled condition of the government of northern Mexico, Dominguez' petition did not receive any further attention until January, 1843. This fact-is referred to in Dominguez' second petition, which appears below.]

In obedience to the foregoing Superior Decree, and in accordance with the laws and regulations on the subject, let the Justice of the Peace of the District of Santa Barbara report if the land petitioned for herein pertains to any corporation, community, or individual; if it is included within the ten leagues bordering on the sea coast, or twenty leagues bordering on a foreign territory; if the petitioner possesses sufficient means to stock said place, and the necessary requisites to entitle him to be heard on his petition; with all other matters that may serve to throw light uj on the subject; and when these proceedings shall have been taken, let the Expediente be returned to this Prefecture for the necessary ends. ARGUELLO. JosE R. ARGUELLO, Sec'y.

The petitioner herein possesses all the necessary legal requisites to entitle him to be heard on his petition; he has stock to place on said land, and is worthy, in consideration of his personal services, to receive what he asks; the land he petitions for does not pertain to any community or individual whatever; it is situated within the ten leagues bordering on the sea shore, but is not within the twenty leagues bordering on a foreign territory, referred to in the law on the subject, and is alone occupied by wild animals.

"ANGELES, May 8, 1846. "Tn the session of to-day, this Expediente was referred to the Most Excellent Departmental Assembly, and ordered to be referred to Committee on Vacant Lands. Pio Pico. "AUGUSTINE OLIVERA, Secretary."

"Str; The Co.nmittee on Vacant Lands have carefully examined the present Expediente instituted by the citizen José Dominguez, of the land of Prietos y Najalayegua, which was granted to him by the Superior Departmental Government, in accordance with the laws on the subject; wherefore, the committee submit for the consideration of your Excellency the following proposition: -

"That the concession made to the citizen José Dominguez, of the place of Prietos y Najalayegua, in the jurisdiction of Santa Barbara, be approved to the extent as shown by the map in the Expediente, according to the title issued on the 24th of September last, in accordance with the law of the 18th of August, 1824, and Article 5th of the Regulations of. the 21st of November, 1828. Committee Chamber, in the City of Los Angeles, May 26, 1846.

" WHEREAS, the citizen José Dominguez has petitioned, for his personal benefit, and that of his family, for the land known by the name of Los Prietos y Najalayegua; the necessary proceedings having been taken, and the investigations made, as required by the laws and regulations on the subject; by virtue of the authority conferred upon me, by decree of this day, in the name of the Mexican nation, | have determined to grant him the said land, declaring to him the ownership..thereof by these presents, subject to the approval of the Most Excellent Departmental Assembly, and under the following conditions: -

"Ist. He may enclose it, without prejudice to the crossings, roads, and servitudes; he shall enjoy it freely and exclusively, devoting it to the use or cultivation that may be most convenient, but within one year he shall build a house upon the land, which shall be inhabited.

"2d. He shall solicit the respective judge to give him judicial possession by virtue of this title, by whom the boundaries shall be marked out by the necessary landmark.

"3d. The land of which donation is made is strictly pureEgEt) that which is shown upon the map in the Expediente. The judge who may give the possession will cause the same to be measured in accordance with the ordinances, and will inform the Government as to the number of square leagues contained in the tract.

"Tn consequence whereof, I order that this title, being held as firm and valid, be registered in the respective book, and be delivered to the interested party for his security and further ends.

Value Of The Grant

The Los Prietos y Najalayegua was considered of so little consequence in the early years of Santa Barbara that it was not presented to the commissioners for confirmation, as the subsequent claimants asserted for the reason that the interested parties were too poor to bear the expense. if the claim justly extended to the plains of Santa Barbara, it included places which, from the very settlement of Santa Barbara, had been valuable. If the grant was between the two ranges of mountains, and between the San Marcos Rancho and the Carpenteria Creek, there was little value in the grant, and nothing to induce a presentation of it to the Board of United States Land Commissioners. During the time the grant title was forgotten or unthought of, the discovery was made that the Najalayegua Indians had at one time lived on the south side of the mountains near Montecito; that a tract there was sometimes called by their name. This fact, which might, with good management, be made to include some of the Santa Barbara lands in the Najalayegua, and the discovery of quicksilver, brought the corpse of the grant to its feet - a giant - which threatened to swallow all the country, including town, mountains, quicksilver, and petroleum mines.

Abstract Of Title

First - Possessory claim of José Lugo sold to José Dominguez January 14, 1843, for a consideration of two kegs of brandy and $20 in silver currency.

Side Claim

There seemed to be a side claim in the matter, from what source or circumstance is not related. The old Najalayegua joined the San Marcos, once in the possession of R.S. Den. Perhaps some possessory rights were acquired in that way, at any rate the title was made to converge with the other, in Mr. Huse.

Francisco Badilla and wife, Rafaella Garcia, to R. S. Den, March 26, 1857; consideration, $2,000. The boundaries were: "On the north by the mountains of San Rafael, on the south by the mountains of Santa Barbara, on the east by the Najalayegua. and on the west by the San Marcos, containing two leagues of land, more or less;" purchased from Dominguez, by title, October &, 1845.

In Congress

"Mr. Conness presented the memorial of José Dominguez, praying to be confirmed in the title granted to him September 24, 1845, by Governor Pio Pico, and approved by the Departmental Assembly of Alta California June 3, 1846, of the land known as Los Prietos y Najaluyegua, in the county of Santa Barbara, California, which was referred to the Committee on Private Land Claims.

"Mr. Thayer, from the Committee on Private Land Claims, reported back Senate Bill 189, to confirm a certain grant of land to José Dominguez, in California, with a recommendation that it do pass.

"Mr. Tuayer: This is one ot those claims which the United States, by the terms of the treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, are bound to confirm if the evidence is clear and properly substantiated. The Committee have examined it and believe it should be confirmed. I will ask the clerk to read the following letter, not so much for its bearing upon the case as for its reference to a very singular natural curiosity which exists upon this estate."

Parsons Letter

"Hon. Ina Harris - Dear Sir: I beg to call your special attention to Senate Bill, No. 198 and the accompanying document. I was in the county of Santa Barbara last September, and visited the rancho in question as: a matter of curiosity, to see a large grapevine growing ~on it, said to be the second largest in the world. I measured it myself and found it covering a superficial area of over eight thousand feet. This single vine is about the sole product of the entire rancho, the lands being very hilly and semi-mountainous in their character. I found the mother of the petitioner and the entire family, grandchildren and great grand-children, most of them living under this celebrated vine, the sale of the grapes from it being about their only support; last year the product of this single vine being about six tons of grapes, as they told me. The old lady died last fall upon the property, at the age of one hundred and nine years, she and her husband having lived undisturbed upon this property for upwards of sixty years. The vine was planted by the old lady some fifty years ago. I tound the family very poor and enjoying the respect of all the parties in the county. I visited the vine and family in company with Mr. Sparks, an American, who had lived in the county since 1832. He verified the correctness of all the statements of the family, and from what I saw myself, and from what was told me by very respectable citizens of the county, I have no doubt ot the truthfulness of all the statements of Josée Dominguez in his petition. In my judgment, there cannot be presented a case calling more tor the equitable interposition of the government to protect the grant of the former government to his family, than this, and I earnestly ask you that you will examine the papers and make an effort in their behalf. Levi Parsons."

Considering that Levi Parsons was the man who undertook to get the whole water front of San Francisco, and who had, in various other ways, shown wonderfully avaricious traits, his sympathy for poor men is very refreshing. He writes as though he was only casually acquainted with the matter, when the fact was he had resided in Santa Barbara for a year, and knew that the act was not for the benefit of Dominguez, who had parted years before with his title to the Najalayegua, and by the very act would be driven from the big grapevine.

Inthe memorial to Congress respecting the matter, Dominguez was made to say that he was born upon said land and has always lived thereon with his family; that his father and mother resided here for more than sixty years, up to the time of their death, leaying children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren, who still reside there and have no other home; that he did not submit his grant to the Land Commission of the United States, appointed by an act of Congress in the year 1851, for the reason that he was not aware of the existence of that commission, he being an obscure and humble individual and wholly ignorant of the English language; and if he had known of its existence he was too poor to pay the high fees which were at that time charged by attorneys in California.

Mexican Government as good and valid, and was told that it would be upheld by the treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, made between the United States and Mexico; but he is informed that his title ought to be submitted to the authorities of the United States for recognition; whereupon your petitioner prays that he may be allowed to prove up his title before the proper courts of the United States authorities as may be necessary and just in the premises.

Confirmation

The grant was confirmed by act of Congress, approved June 12, 1866. The big contest then came as to the survey or boundaries of the grant. Pringle claimed that it was bounded on the south by the pueblo lands of Santa Barbara. In the strife' which ensued, the boundaries of Santa Barbara became a subject of controversy. The town was entitled to four leagues, bounded on the east by the Carpenteria Creek, on the west by the Dos Pueblos (two towns). It was found impracticable to extend the pueblo lands to Dos Pueblos on account of prior location of individuals, so the tract was necessarily made wider so as to include the four leagues. To this Pringle objected that it would encroach on the lands granted to the Najalayegua. The following correspondence ensued:

Town Titles

Sir: Pursuant to your personal request yesterday, I have the honor to transmit herewith a copy of the decision of this office, dated 21st inst., in the case of 'Pueblo Lands ot' Santa Barbara' in California. "Very respectfully your obedient servant, "Jos. S. Witson, Commissioner."

"SHERMAN Day, Esq., SuRVEYOR-GENERAL, San Franoisco, Cat. - Sir; Upon examination of the papers accompanying the returns of the survey of the Pueblo lands of Santa Barbara in connection with your~ report thereon, dated April 13, 1870, I find that the claim of the Mayor and Common Council of said city to said Pueblo lands was rejected under date of August 1, 1854, by the Board ot Land Commissioners appointed under the Act of March 3, 1851, and upon appeal being taken to the District Court for the Southern District of California, said appeal was dismissed for want of prosecution, and it was ordered that the decree of the Board should stand as a final decree, the certificate of the Clerk of the Court showing that this decree of said Court was filed in his office, August 8, 1860. But subsequently it appears that the District Court rendered another decree in the case, certified by the clerk to have been filed in his office March 6, 1861, wherewith, confirming the Pueblo title, and the United States appealing to the U.S. Supreme Court from this decree of the District Court, in its December term, 1863, rendered a decree wherein it was ordered that the cause be dismissed.

The decree of the District Court, confirming the Pueblo title, rendered final by the dismissal of appeal by the Supreme Court, specifies the 'ands of which confirmation was thereby made as follows, viz.: ' Bounded on the east by the Arroyo de Carpenteria, on the south by the sea-shore, on the west by the rancho of Dos Pueblos, on the north by the Sierras, containing four leagues, and no more, within the boundaries aforesaid.'

«" Pursuant to the said final confirmation of the claim, and the Act of July 1, 1864, entitled 'An Act to expedite the settlement of titles to lands in California,' a survey was maae by G. H. Thompson, U. S. Deputy Surveyor, in May, 1867, under instruction from the Surveyor-General, said survey containing 17,8262, acres, or 81,43, more than four square leagues, being now before this office for approval.

"The area of this survey conforms sufficiently to the terms of the decree of confirmation, and the boundaries are also found in conformity therewith, excepting the western boundary, which, according to the said decree, should be the rancho Dos Pueblos, but in the survey is the rancho Goleta, lying on the east of the former rancho; but the latter having been finally surveyed under the Act of June 14, 1860, and patented March 10, 1865, extending from the ocean to the mountains, it was found impracticable to locate the Pueb'o lands in exact conformity with the decree in this particular, the nearest practicable conformity having been observed by the Deputy Surveyor, both as regards boundaries and quantity.

"Upon advertisement of this survey in accordance with the provisions of the Act of July 1, 1864, an objection thereto was filed in the office of the Surveyor General by E. J. Pringle, as owner of the rancho, Los Prietos y Najalayegua, claiming that said survey conflicted with the proper location of said rancho, and that the cause of said conflict was the failure to establish the boundaries of said Pueblo lands in accordance with the final decree of confirmation, and that if the survey of the said Pueblo lands were extended westward to the Rancho Dos Pueblos, thore need not be any encroaching on the north line of said survey upon the southern limits of Los Prietos, as claimed by him, in order to include the land confirmed to the city of Santa Barbara within the confirmed boundaries.

"As the survey in question (that of the Pueblo lands) is found to be in the nearest practicable conformity with the final decree of' confirmation, consistent with the action of the judiciary approving the location and survey of the rancho La Goleta, which latter rancho also covered part of the land within the boundaries specified in said final decree, but which has been finally surveyed under the Act of June 14, 1860, and as the only opponent of the survey has not presented any evidence in support of his allegation of error in the same, your decision that said survey should be approved is hereby confirmed.

" You will therefore notify all the parties in interest of this decision, and should no appeal therefrom be taken within thirty days of serving this notice, you will inform this office of the fact; but should such appeal be taken within that time, upon its expiration you will forward all the papers which may have been filed with you bearing upon such appeal, in order that the same may be submitted for the decision of the Department. Very respectfully,

A reply to this letter was filed by A. Packard, as attorney for the city of Santa Barbara, showing the impracticability of extending the survey to Dos Pueblos, and that the nearest possible approximation to the terms of the decree had been observed in locating the boundaries of the Pueblo lands; and further claiming that contestant is not of right entitled to object to this survey, because unable to show that his claim of Los Prietos y Najalayegua, if properly located, would approach the surveyed limits of the Pueblo lands of Santa Barbara.

Public Feeling

When it was learned that the survey for the owners of the Najalayegua contemplated including the lands adjoining the town site, a general feeling of alarm prevailed. If the title to the grant was good it antedated the rights of the town, and was likely to override everything. Albert Packard, the City Attorney, set forth the following as the boundary of the town: - -

"In the year 1780 the Pueblo of Santa Barbara organized, and its boundaries established as follows: On the north by the summit of the Coast Range of mountains, on the east by the Carpenteria Creek, on the south by the Pacific Ocean, and on the west by the rancheria or Indian town known as Dos Pueblos; and thereafter the Legislature of the State of California duly incorporated said town; and under the provisions of an act of Congress. passed March 3, 1851, entitled 'An Act to ascertain and settle private land claims in California,' the claim of said town was presented and finally confirmed to said boundaries."

The Press denounced this as utterly false; that the description sounds very much like an original. Perhaps, as in many other cases, the town was to select lands within these limits.

The Survey

The Najalayegua grant having been confirmed, the location of it occupied the attention of the authorities and the parties interested. Surveyor-General Hardenberg, previous to Stratton's appointment, had been instructed by the General Land Office to locate it north of the Santa Ynez Mountains, and accordingly had employed Wm. H. Norway to make the survey. James 'T. Stratton, the new Surveyor-General, thought the rancho was properly on the south side of the Santa Ynez Mountains, adjoining the town of Santa Barbara, but did not presume to act counter to the instructions of the Department. The following facts seemed to have governed him: -

First - That there is no question as to the location of Los Prietos, or of the Carpenteria Creek, and that the only disputed point is the location of the Najalayegua.

Second - In 1843 José Dominguez bought a house and land from José Lugo, which, in the certificate of sale of the Alcalde Carrillo, is described as being in

Third - Dominguez says that he immediately moved into the Lugo House after purchasing it, and was occupying it at the date of the grant of the Los Prietos y Najalayegua, which was made to him in 1845.

Sixth - A few years ago Dominguez swore that he had never lived over in the Santa Ynez Valley. He now states that he sometimes lived there, but that his permanent residence was in the Lugo House, known to be in Montecito, and described in his certificate of sale to be in Najalayegua.

These conflicting and indefinite claims might have, and probably ought to have, had the effect to reject the whole claim as not worthy of attention, but for the fact of the act of Congress, '' The Surveyor-General is directed to proceed and survey said lands in accordance with the original title papers on file in his office, and when the said survey shall have been approved by the Commissioner of the General Land Office, a patent shall be issued for the lands.

The location of the rancho on the north side of the mountains would detract from the value of the claim, while locating it on the south side would make it include an immense number of improved places.

Laurens Upson, the Surveyor-General, had directed his Deputy, G. H. Thompson, to make a survey according to the act of Congress, furnishing him with the disefio for data from which to make it. The letter itself will be the best history of the result : -

" WitBur Curtiss - Dear Sir: Yours of the 28th of June is at hand. In reply to the questions you ask me I would state that on the 25th diy of April, 1867, I received instructions from L. Upson, at that time U.S. Surveyor-General, directing me to make a survey of the Mexican land grant called Los Prietos y Najalayegua, in Santa Barbara County, in accordance with the act of Congress confirming the claim. All the data furnished me by the Surveyor- General, by which I was to be guided in making the survey, was a copy of the original disefio, which is now on file in the archives in the office of the U.S. Surveyor-General.

said instructions, 1 went to Santa Barbara for the purpose of making the official survey of the grant. After making an examinatian of the county in which the grant is located, I returned to San Francisco without making any survey of the claim, and made a report to Mr. Upson, the Surveyor-General, setting forth my reasons for not making the survey, which were substantially as follows: The data furnished me by the Surveyor-General, I did not deem sufficient to muke a correct location of the grant, as it did not name the quantity of land to be embraced in the survey, nor did it give any defined boundaries within which the grant should be located. The disefio, the only thing furnished me in making the survey and location of the grant, shows the land granted to embrace a valley between two ranges of mountains, with Carpenteria Creek shown as the eastern boundary of the grant, and the Parajo de los Prietos as the western boundary. Now the Arroyo Carpeateria and Parajo de los Prietos are both well-known landmarks, and easily found and identified upon the ground, but instead of finding a continuous valley between these two well-known objects, as is shown in the disefio on file in the United States Surveyor-General's Office, I found a continuous range of steep, brushy, and broken mountains, the Parajo de los Prietos being in the Santa Ynez Valley on the north side of the mountains, and the Carpenteria Creek rising and taking its whole course on the south side of the mountains, through the plain of Carpenteria, until it reaches the sea. Not being able to recognize the topography shown in the disefio with that found on the ground, and there being no quantity anywhere expressed which should be included in the survey, 1 thought it advisable to report the facts to Mr Upson, the Surveyor-General, and ask for something more definite by which to be guided in making the survey and location of the grant.

" After returning from Santa Barbara, the parties in interest in the grant engaged me, in my private capacity, to make them a survey according to their wishes, and being guided in the same by the evidence which they produced, consisting of some twenty-five affidavits of different persons, which affidavits described each boundary very clearly and minutely. How this survey ever got into the United States Surveyor-General's Office, or before the Commissioner of the General Land Office at Washington, 1 do not know. I myself never made a return of -it to the United States Surveyor-General, nor did IL ever write out the field notes in the prescribed form required by that office. and a copy of the field notes (informal), and handed them as directed by the parties who made the sur-: vey, to a draftsman with whom said parties had made a private contract to make for them a map from said field notes. After the field notes left my hands, I had nothing more to do with the matter; I heard nothing more of it, and knew nothing more of it. As I before stated, I do not know how this survey ever got before the Surveyor-General, and do not now think it ever was directly before him, or that he ever looked upon it, or considered it before him as an oficial survey. I presume that the attorney for the parties in interest must have filed the copy of field notes and map on file in his office, as an exhibit to show what they claimed under the grant and confirmation. I never understood it to be before him, or the Commissioner in the Land Office, in any other way than as a mere exhibit, filed by the parties in interest, showing what they claimed, and I am sure Mr. Upson never considered it anything more, as he kept no record or copy of the map when he sent it on to the Commissioner at Washington, nor did he put any certificate or seal, or anything of the kind to it, all of which is customary in sending up to Washington the plats, ete., of regular and official surveys. On the contrary, he treated this as an exhibit, and not as an official survey and map.

"«.. . In making a private survey, I am under no Official authority, and no act which I do is official. Under such circumstances, I will make any survey or run any lines which any one wishes done, and will pay for; and such was the survey which I made of the Los Prietos y Najalayegua - -a private survey - made at the request of and paid for by the parties in interest, and under no official authority or instruction from either the U. S. Surveyor-General nor the Commissioner of the General Land Office.

Regarding The

"The Confirmatory Act of 1866 does not prescnbe, by reference to prior acts or otherwise, the manner ot taking testimony for the purpose of determining the boundaries of this claim, but when the law commands a thing to be done it impliedly authorizes the performance of whatever may be necessary for executing its demands; and hence, under the provisions of the Confirmatory Act, in this case directing a survey to be made, and its approval by the Commissioner of the General Land Office, this office will examine all the testimony now before it, if necessary to a correct location of the grant within the boundaries shown by the disefo, which we have seen is the only original title paper giving a description of the exterior boundaries of such grant.

"The disefio shows a tract of land which, according to the scale attached, contains one Mexican league from north to south, and about three Mexican leagues from east to west. As shown thereon. the eastern exterior boundary is the Arroyo de Carpenteria; the western the Paraja de los Prietos; on the north and south the exterior boundaries are designated by marks evidently intended to represent hills or mountains. Through the center, and running east and west, is shown the 'Najalayegua Cajon.' Within the objects thus marked are also marks, evidently designed to represent trees and hills or mountains, and also a place marked ' Lomas Muertos,' dead hillocks or hills.

"We are fortunately able to determine with certainty the location of ' Paraja de los Prietos.' Its location on the Thompson and Norway surveys agrees with its location on the survey of Rancho San Marcos, and that such location is correct is admitted by both claimants and contestants in this case. The location of this place as a western boundary also establishes that the cafion Najalayegua of the disefio is the cafion through which runs the river Santa Ynez. I am also convinced that the marks on the disefio designating the width of the cafion Najalayegua represent the immediate valley of the Santa Ynez, as shown on both Norway's and 'Thompson's surveys. The true north and south boundary is more difficult to locate, though according to the disefio the boundaries are the first continuous range of hills or mountains running parallel with the Santa Ynez that are found going north and south from the narrow valley through which that river flows. On the north such a continuous range is shown on the part of Thompson's survey about eight miles south of the northern line of the rancho as there represented, but on the south no such range appears on said plat north of the Santa Ynez or Santa Barbara Mountains. The exact location of the northern boundary I shall not attempt to define further, for it cannot be established with certainty without more information with regard to the topography of the country than is contained in the record, though such boundary, as thus indicated, may easily be found on the ground by a surveyor; but on the south I am convinced the marks on the disefio were intended to indicate the range known as the mountains of Santa Ynez or Santa Barbara. This appears as well from the report of Mr. R. C. Hopkins, and the various surveys of that locality, as from the affidavit of Dominguez, the grantee ot the Mexican Government. Hence, I adopt, as the true southern exterior boundary of this rancho, the northern foot of the said range of mountains.

"The theory of the claimants in this case that the southern slope of this range is included within the grant of Najalayegua is, in my opinion, untenable. In the case of the Rancho Caslamayomi, decided by this office December 15, 1873, and attirmed on appeal August 13, 1874, by the acting Secretary ot the Interior, it was held that where the calls for boundary were hills or mountains, the foot of such hills or mountains was meant, and I see no reason why the same rule should not apply where, instead of being clearly described by words, such a boundary is indicated solely by rough scratches of a pen. An example of this kind may be found in the case of the Rancho La Goleta, the disefio ot which shows on the north a portion of the identical mountain now claimed by Najalayegua, yet the grant of La Goleta extended only to the foot of the mountains, and to that extent only was it surveyed and patented by the United States.

"With respect to the theory of claimants, attention 1s called' to the fact: First, that in February, 1843, while Dominguez' application for a grant was pending, he bought of one Lugo a tract of land on the southern slope of this mountain and within the limits of Najalayegua, as now claimed. Second, that the Najalayegua, as now claimed, on said southern slope, surrounds the buildings of the Mission of Santa Barbara, and bounds on the north the Pueblo of Santa Barbara, whereas in the Expediente of Najalayegua the tract petitioned for is described as 'alone occupied by wild animals,' and no mention whatever is made either of the buildings or lands of the said mission or of the lands of the said Pueblo. Third, that although the Rancho La Goleta was petitioned for and granted in 1846, after the date of the grant to Dominguez, and although a portion of the mountains now claimed as Najalayegua was made a boundary of La Goleta, yet no reference is found to Najalayegua in the Expediente of La Goleta, though the other tracts bounding it, namely, Nicholos Den's rancho, Dos Pueblos, and the mission property, are thereon clearly described. That the Hxpedienté of Najalayegua would give no further description of the southern boundary of that grant than a few marks of a pen on a rudely-constructed map is highly improbable, if, in fact, that boundary was such well-known tracts of land as the mission lands of the Pueblo of Santa Barbara; nor is it probable in the Expediente of La Goleta the north boundary of that rancho would have been designated generally as mountains, if, in fact, the north boundary had been the Najalayegua. The fact referred to in argument that only one slope of this south boundary was shown on the disefio proves nothing, nor does it, in my Opinion, raise any presumption that such slope was intended to be included in the grant. In absence of anything in this case spegially to show such a design on the part of the maker of this disefio, no such presumption could arise, unless it were shown to be a general custom in making such maps to thus represent hills or mountains intended to be petitioned for. Asa matter of fact, however, these disefio were usually maqae by the petitioner for the grant, or some one of his neighbors, and hence such disefio is sui generis in its designations of natural objects. It may be added that it was formerly the practice of engravers on steel to shade one side only of designations of mountains. [See map of China 1st American Ed., printed in Philadelphia in 1832, of 'New Edinburgh Encyclopedia.'] The eastern boundary, as shown on the disefio, is the Arroyo de Carpenteria, and the record shows that the Carpenteria is a well-known stream, running wholly south of Santa Barbara or Santa Ynez range of mountains, and along the northwestern boundary of the Rancho El Rincon, granted by the Mexican authorities June 22, 1835, and patented by the United States, November 22, 1872. It is thus evident that going from Santa Ynez River we cannot reach the said Carpenteria Creek without crossing over a mountain range from 2,000 to 5,000 feet above the level of the sea, and which we have already determined to be the south boundary of the Najalayegua. The reason for this difference between the location of Carpenteria on the disefio and its actual location is found in the affidavit dated May 8, 1874, of Dominguez, in which he states that 'the Arroyo Carpenteria was marked on said disefio by guess as being in that direction, and without my personal knowledge of its exact position.' Either the Carpenteria Creek or the said mountain range must therefore be rejected as a boundary, and in rejecting one of these boundaries this office must retain that which best satisfies the intent of the grant and confirmation. This, in my opinion, is the Santa Barbara range of mountains, for omitting altogether the statement contained in Dominguez' affidavit, before referred to, that he 'claimed no land on the south side of the mountain bordering on the Pueblo lands of Santa Barbara,' I am satisfied that the Najalayegua never reached the southern slope of said mountains, and hence never reached the Carpenteria. In addition to what has already been said relative to the extension of the Najalayegua south of the mountain range, attention is called to the fact that the Arroyo Carpenteria is one of the boundaries of the Rancho El Rincon, which rancho has been granted and its boundaries measured under the Mexican Government, years before the Najalayegua was petitioned tor by Dominguez, yet the Expediente of Najalayegua contains no reference to El Rincon. The eastern boundary of Najalayegua will be about the same, whether such boundary be found by running a line due north from Carpenteria Creek, or by finding the point on the east where the southern boundary intersects the range of mountains coming down from the north, and marked on Thompson's plat, 'San Rafael range of mountains.' It is evident, however, that the cafion 'Nallagua,' of the disefio, could not extend further east than this San Rafael range, and I therefore adopt said range on the cast as shown by the plat of Thompson's survey as the true eastern exterior boundary of this claim.

"It -is--therefore-decided: by this~office: that the exterior boundaries of the Rancho Los Prietos y Najalayegua are as follows: On the north, the southern foot of the first range of hills or mountains running east and west, north of the narrow valley through which runs the river Santa Yuez; on the south, the northern foot of the range known as the Santa Barbara or Santa Ynez Mountains; on the west, the point established as a western boundary by Thompson's and Norway's surveys, and on the east, the San Rafael range of mountains, as shown on the plat of United States Deputy Surveyor Thompson's survey of Najalayegua. Within these boundaries the claimants may select, in compact form, the eleven square leagues to which they are entitled, provided such selection be made within a reasonable time. If, however, the claimants neglect or refuse to make such selection, you will proceed to make a survey of this rancho at the expense of the United States, in accordance with the instructions of July 8, 1874, from this office, said survey to contain eleven square leagues, with the exterior boundaries above set forth.

"You will give notice of this decision to all parties in interest, allowing sixty days from the service thereof for appeal to the Hon. Secretary of the Interior, and at the expiration of said sixty days you will make the usual return to this office.

Survey Rejected

"SHERMAN Day, U. 8S. SuRVEYoR-GENERAL, SAN Francisco, Cau. - Sir: I herewith return the plot and papers in the case of Rancho Los Prietos y Najalayegua, the title to which was confirmed by special act of Congress, approved June 12, 1866, Stats., Vol. 14, p. 589, and survey directed to be made by the Surveyor-General of the State of California, in accordance with the original title papers on file in his office.

" Your predecessor forwarded an unapproved survey containing 208,742), acres, or more than furtyseven square leagues, expressing the opinion. that the original grant, being one under the colonization laws of Mexico, could not exceed the quantity of eleven square leagues; that a correct survey, under the title papers, would embrace about three square leagues.

"To bring the matter promptly before thi office for definite action, you are instructed to make, at the expense of the parties interested, such a survey as in your opinion conforms to the requirements of the statute, and which you can approve, and after notice, as required for surveys, under the Act of July 1, 1864, you will make the usual return, with your opinion.

"In regard to the unapproved survey sent up by your predecessor, it is duly necessary to say that it is condemned by every principle established by judicial or departmental rulings, and in this connection I insert for your guidance an extract from a decision dated 31st of December last, by the Secretary of the Interior, in the case of Beaubin and Miranda, ar fol- lows: 'It is therefore my opinion; and you eee | receive it as a rule for this and like cases, that where a Mexican colonization grant is confirmed, without measurement of boundaries or of distinct specification of the quantity confirmed, either in the statute or in the report upon which confirmation was made, no greater quantity than eleven square leagues to each claimant shall be surveyed and set off to them; that such quantity shall be surveyed in tracts of eleven square leagues each. The general position or place of such tracts to be selected by the grantee, and the tract to be then surveyed as compactly as possible.

Public Meeting

Wuereas, The reception of certain news of the rejection of the survey of the grant known as Los Prietos y Najalayegua, by the Commissioner of the General Land Office, is a matter which calls for the unqualified approbation of all good citizens and every honest man; therefore,

Resolved, That while we, as citizens of Santa Barbara County, renew our support to the Government and its officers for the strict impartiality and justice with which this great wrong has been so aly defeated, we cannot refrain from expressing our decided disapprobation of the parties interested in securing the approval of the survey for forty-seven leagues of land, when they were entitled to, if any, but three leagues.

Resolved, That we highly recommend the honorable course pursued by the Santa Barbara Times newspaper in opposition to the confirmation of the survey; that in so doing we, the people, are convinced it acted strictly in accordance with what it believed to be in harmony with the justice and good of the public, without any mercenary motive whatever.

Resolved, That the Santa Barbara Press, in apologizing for the course taken by the interested parties who have endeavored to defraud one of the best and most liberal Governments, is deserving of the censure and contempt of fair-dealing men, and that we hope the masses, those who earn their bread by the sweat of their brows, will no longer be deceived by fair promises which are made only to be broken.

The news was announced with bonfires and the firing of cannon, which last, according to W. T. Williams, announced the death-knell of the swindles of the public.

The Press retorted that it was well that the par- ~ ties pledged themselves to the support of the Government; that, judging by the old files of the Dutch Flat Enquirer, Mr. Boust had eminent need of making such a resolution of reform, and much more to the same effect. The committee were called hot-headed ignoramuses and were described in a travesty on an

The whisky-mill charmer," who, for lack of brains, had undertaken to put down the Santa Barbara Press for "daring in the midst of tumult which they had helped to stir up, to say a word which would lead to a knowledge of the facts on the unpopular side of the question.

The Workingman's Journal of San Francisco took up the matter. One of the editors, Chas. A. Merrill, went on to Washington, as was said " to aid in combatting this piece of roguery."

"We have charged Mr. Boust as guilty of knowingly and willfully misleading and deceiving the people of this place with regard to these maps (maps of Prietos)."' [And much more of the same venomous sort. ]

It was now asserted by some that the south linesin the map were intended to represent the mesa south of the town, in which case the town would be included in the grant.

Provenance

Text from HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.