BlockBefore

Santa Barbara County, California - Chapter 25: High Tide of Prosperity, 1883 (part 3 of 3)

From HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. 9,680 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

8 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

9,680 words

Machine-read from scans of HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

The Press now charged that the maps had been changed; that the engraved map had the name of "Lindero Santa Barbara" placed nearer the bottom of the map than in the original, so as to convey the idea that the Prietos claim extended to the sea, and thus enlist nearly the whole community, as interested persons, into opposition to the grant, while in the original map on file the name "Lindero Santa Barbara" is on the nortwestern extremity of the San Rafael Mountains as they slope towards the southwest. On the new map it (Lindero Santa Barbara) is placed farther east, so as to make it appear that the words belong to the mountains opposite the town as they slope towards the southeast.

It was asserted that the term "Lindero Santa Barbara" referred to the old district of Santa Barbara, which was considered to extend from the district of Santa Ynez to the district of Los Angeles, embracing the valley of the Santa Clara.

Public Meetings Continued

Many meetings were held to consider the situation. It was believed that the land-grabbers, as they were called, would yet take the town. If the

Mexicans had learned to dread American law aa being a Pandora's box of evils, the Americans had learned to dread Mexican grants as a Trojan horse, which admitted into the citadel of jurisprudence, had all manner of evils in its belly which were likely to emerge and devour the substance of the country. When a great joy or grief comes upon the people of Santa Barbara, a public meeting and a general outpouring of rejoicing or lamentation seems to be in order.

An indignation meeting was held in front of the apothecaries' Hall, April 1st. S. R. 1. Sturgeon was chosen Chairman, F. A. Thompson and E. B. Boust Secretaries. C. A. Merrill, Chairman of the Settlers' State Central Committee, addressed the meeting and gave the history of this particular grant, which, from two and one-half leagues had grown to forty-seven leagues. Mr. Sturgeon took the stand and read the

"José Dominguez being first duly sworn, deposes and says: That he is a native citizen of Santa Barbara County, State of California; that he is now over seventy (70) years of age; that he was formerly owner of the 'Rancho Los Prietos y Najalayegua, by grant from the Mexican Government; that he was in possession of said rancho, or parts thereof, from the time when the grant was made in 1845 till about the year 1856; that he never had any dwelling house on said ranch, nor did he make any improvements thereon, except one small corral; that he never resided on said ranch with his family, and that said rancho lay at that time, and as this deponent verily believes still les, in the valley between the mountains of San Rafael on the north and the mountains of Santa Barbara on the south, and that no part or parcel of said rancho lies on the south side of the Santa Barbara Mountains; and that he never heard during all that time that Najalayegua, or any portion of it, lay on the south side of the Santa Barbara Mountains. And deponent further says that during from 1845 till some years after he sold to Chevasco in the year 1856, he resided on a tract bought by him from José Ygnacio Lugo, called Ficay; but that said tract of land lay on the south side of the mountains of Santa Barbara, and was no part or portion of Najalayegua, and was not included in this sale to Chevasco, but was, and still is, the property of this deponent. And deponent further says that the grapevine near Santa Barbara known throughout the State of California as the 'big grapevine,' and referred to in the letter of Levi Parsons directed to the Hon. Ira Harris, United States Senator, and dated March 9, 1866. is not within four leagues of the rancho of Los Prietos y Najalayegua; and this deponent believes that the said Levi Parsons knew this fact when the letter above referred to was written; this deponent knows by having had the contents of said letter carefully interpreted to him by a person in whom the utmost confidence can be placed as a man of honor and integrity. And deponent further states that the alder stakes referred to in a former affidavit of this deponent, and in an affidavit of one José Moraga, was a landmark on the line of Ficay, and was so stated to be by this depo- nent both to Chas. E. Huse and José Moraga, at the time they went to see said Jandmarks, and that said landmark was not stated to be a po'nt on the line of the Najalayegua at that time, nor at any other time; and deponent further says that he has had certain affidavits translated to him which were give him by the request of C. E. Huse during the month of March, A. p. 1865, and that said affidavits do not contain the matter represented by the said Huse to be contained therein; that this deponent cannot read or write, and believes that said affidavits were purposely misinterpreted to him by the said Huse, the word 'some,' on the fifteenth line of the first page erased, and the words 'one small' inserted before the signing and the word 'and' on the eighteenth line of the second page, the whole of the nineteenth line and first five words erased before the signing, by direction of deponent. his "Jose X Domincvez. mark

" Felipe Arrellanes, of the county of Santa Barbara, State of California, being first duly sworn, deposes and says: That he is a native-born citizen of this county, and that he is forty-five years of age, and was formerly owner of the rancho Los Prietos y Najalayegua; that some time in the year 1864 he sold said rancho to one C. E. Huse; that he had previously offered, as near as he can recollect, about the year 1858, to sell the same rancho to the said Huse, but at that time Huse refused to purchase it; that this deponent left all the papers referring to this rancho in the hands of said Huse for safe keeping, and that they so remained in his possession for several months; that »ometime during the summer of 1864 Huse asked deponent if he was still owner of the rancho above mentioned; deponent told him that he was; Huse then asked if deponent still wished to sell; deponent answered that he did, and that if Huse wished to see the property he was buying he had only to refer to the papers in his (Huse) possession, they having at that time been delivered to him (Huse) for examination by this deponent; that deponent did afterward, as above set forth, sell said rancho to said Huse. And deponent further says that some short time after the sale to Huse, he was in his (Huse) office, and Huse showed deponent a map he was making, or having made, this deponent does not recollect which, and which included lands to which deponent never made any claim. Deponent then told Huse that he (Huse) must be very powerful if he could get the land covered by that map; Huse replied, 'that was all right.' Deponent further says that the reason given by Huse for not purchasing in 1858 was that the lands were not situated as he supposed they were; that he supposed they extended south of the Santa Barbara Mountains. And deponent further says that Huse paid as consideration for this rancho one hundred dollars gold coin. That said rancho contains, as near as this gerouent can estimate from his knowledge of the boundaries, about two leagues, or two leagues and a half, of land. FELIPE ARRELLANES.

Other parties swore to a similar state of facts. The son of the original grantee swore that the rancho was familiar to him since his boyhood; that he had never heard it spoken of as extending to the south side of the Santa Barbara Mountains; that his father never claimed anything on the south side; that the said rancho was distant from Santa Barbara three to five leagues, in a northerly direction, and that said Huse had proposed to him if he would make an affidavit that said lands included lands on the south side of Santa Barbara Mountains he would make him a valuable present; that the "big grapevine" was then the property of his grandmother, and was more than four leagues from the ranch of Los Prietos y Najalayegua.

The Rey. J. A. Johnson, editor of the Press, undertook to defend the grant, but was received with shouts of derision. Mr. Merrill replied in such a strain as to cause the District Attorney to propose an emollient resolution that, "If J. A. Johnson will hereafter advocate the cause of the people they will forgive him his past derelictions," which was unanimously carried.

Russel Heath then took the stand, and stated that he had never until recently heard that the ranch in question extended to the south of Santa Barbara Mountains, though he had resided here since 1849.

Poetry

The noise of the row over the Najalayegua reached the neighboring counties. The San Lais Obispo Tribune, corruscating with wit and sarcasm, burst into song -

'We had occasion to refer to villainy last fall, and to express the well-grounded opinion that the late Senator Conness, who now finds it convenient to absent himself from the State which he has so shamefully misrepresented, was an interested partner in the contemplated robbery of industrious settlers; moreover, that the then U.S. Surveyor-General was willfully and corruptly in the interests of marauders; that the U.S. Grand Jury had been packed and suborned; that the District Judge was wickedly corrupt, and that the Clerk was a peculating scoundrel and a compounder with the land thieves; charges Field and Hoffman with being vile scoundrels who deserve to be taken to the woods and hanged."

"It is intimated that C. E. Huse was in danger of being hung by a mob on account of his connection with Los Prietos, and that a guard of friends watched his house every night."

The Clouds Lifting

This was the title to an article on the Najalayegua grant. It was of a character with previous and contemporary publications. Referring to the excitement among the people, the Press says: -

"We rejoice that the storm has been raised. Such storms blow down decaying and rotten reputations. They do more! They show the strength of the spreading oak, whose sturdy arms could not be twisted off, and whose mighty roots only penetrate deeper and grow stronger in consequence of the storm, and God be thanked that we have men among us who possess these characters of oak, and resist almost with unruffled temper these fierce and angry assaults upon their reputation. Adroit demagogues, skillful pettifoggers, unblushing knaves, strolling adventurers, when combined and working together, can easily create a local excitement, and by sheer audacity and jackal howling may raise a storm about the ears of any man against whom they have a common and interested motive for working. And here we ask our readers to pause and reflect a moment. Who are the men that have been prominent in this ferocious attack against Mr. Huse? S. R. I. Sturgeon, E. B. Boust, W. T. Williams, Albert Packard, W. H. Norway, Wilbur Curtis, H. C. Victor, Chas.

. Merrill,..etc...Are..our readers. aware .that .each one of these men has a private motive of his own for making this fight? Let this point be investigated. Who, now, are some of the men who did not join in the cry? Dr. J. B. Shaw, Col. W. W. Hollister, E. Greenwell, John P. Stearns, Judge Maguire, Dr.S. B. Brinkerhoff, Judge Fernald, Thomas B. Dibblee, Henry Carnes, Col. B. T. Dinsmore, Jonathan Mayhew, and hosts of others who have known Mr. Huse for years. Comment is unnecessary.

"During the storm we have been quietly paying out line on these troubled waters. Being securely seated on the solid rocks of integrity, and protected by the overhanging cliffs of truth, we have enjoyed the prospect of hauling some fish after a little. We felt several stout nibbles occasionally, but preferred to wait until the hook was swallowed for certain. We expect to haul our lines in at our leisure. We judge, by the tugging at one line that a good-sized sturgeon has begun to feel the point of the hook. But we will not anticipate. We hear that market quotations rate Sturgeon at two cents. We shall be glad to contract with market men at half that price."

From the foregoing article it would seem that nearly all the people were arrayed on one side or the other. It was believed by some that the grant lines would be extended to include the town of Santa Barbara. It was also charged that the original title papers had been changed or destroyed while in the possession of C. E. Huse.

May 28, 1870. The agitation concerning the Najalayegua grant continued. Several maps have been published. All are obscure, and many of the people believe that the town of Santa Barbara will yet fall within boundaries of the grant.

These maps were published by the Times, which was under the charge of E. B. Boust. The cuts were said to be the property of Wilbur Curtis, who owned the hot springs which were included in the Prietos claim. Johnson, the editor of the Press, was desirous of publishing them, but Mr. Curtis declined, in no very polite terms, loaning them for the purpose. The letter was directed to the " #a-Rev. J. A. Johnson,' whereupon Johnson promised the public that Curtis would have enough of the matter before the press was done with him. In the Workingman's Journal of San Francisco was published the following

"It should be added that through all this desperate controversy (over the Najalayegua swindle) the Santa Barbara Zimes has stood by the settlers, faithfully and effectively, against the subsidized Press, the organ of the land-stealers, which is conducted by an apostate preacher, who appears to have turned tail on his Saviour in order to assist in spoilation of the poor. We are not acquainted with the peculiar structure or flexibility of oak limbs in Santa Barbara, but we think they might be turned to good account."

Nearly the whole force.of the papers was. spent.in the contest of the Prietos grant. The Press urged that, almost without exception, the opposers of the grant were men without property who were banded with the agrarians of San Francisco. Wm. H. Norway was charged with being at the head of the league.

"Their cry is, 'down with the land-grabbers!' meaning all men who own over a certain number of acres of land, and especially if that land isa Mexican grant. The ignorance and knavery of that journal (Workingman's Journal) in proposing to repeal an Act of Congress which has created vested rights, a thing which even the Constitution of the United States makes an impossibility, is a fair sample of the reasoning which appears in these agrarian journals. Let the people be on their guard. These levelers are capable of doing mischief. The ignorant and deluded masses of San Francisco who assemble in Yerba Buena Park and propose to hang the Mayor and sack the Bank of California, are the elements on which they work."

K. B. Boust is spoken of as the "small pot-house politician from Placer, well drilled in the arts of the demagogue, unscrupulous as human nature will permit, who essays to lead this interesting squad." Sturgeon was also spoken of as "a man of bad record, dropped by his own party." Mr. Curtis is termed the "silly old man, the unconscious tool in the hands of knaves."

" Our readers, and especially those at a distance, will rejoice to have the mask torn from these precious scamps and the fact revealed that all this hue and cry raised about our land titles had no foundation in fact, and the whole thing has been done to help on their political scheme."

The Press took up the fight and procured the affidavits of many individuals to show that Najalayegua was on the south side of the mountains, near the Santa Barbara plains. It pretended to account for the opposition of the City Attorney to the grant in the matter of the asphaltum bed of Goleta, which, by crowding the town survey back on the hills, would become subject to private ownership (possibly Packard's), worth $50,000 or more. There seems to have been no foundation for the charge, but some excuse had. to be found.

"Vicente Valencia testifies, February 23, 1865, that the Najalayegua Indians lived on the south side of the mountains, on the rolling hills, where Montecito is; that they afterwards moved over the mountains, and that the place where they moved was also called Najalayegua; that the cafiada Los Prietos was so called because the fathers caused a road to be cut up the cafion, and drove a flock of sheep through it; hence, the country reached by the cafion was called Los Prietos y Najalayegua. José Dominguez lived in a house at the place marked 4, and sold it to Chevasco, and moved to the house where he now lives (Big Grapevine).

~ "Raymundo Carrillo (fifty-four-years old), was born in Santa Barbara, held various offices under the Mexican Government; was for some years Alcalde; was Justice of the Peace and Judge of the First Instance, and Sub-Prefect. Recognize the instrument of sale by Don José Ygnacio Lugo to José Dominguez, January 14, 1843, of his title to the claim which he occupied in Najalayegua. They made the sale in my presence, according to the usual custom. The original certificate of sale was attached to the title given by Don Pio Pico to José Dominguez for the rancho Los Prietos y Najalayegua. Recognize the signatures of Pio Pico and José Maria Covarrubias as genuine; know the map to be correct; that the Las Prietos y Najalayegua extended to this side of the mountain, as was well known to every one. When I was Justice of the Peace here under the Mexican laws, I gave judicial possession of some ranchos here, as there was no surveyor here in those days. They did not measure land then as now; sometimes it was designated in the form of a cross, sometimes with monuments. Since the change of Government I have filled various public stations, before the Constitution was formed of the State of Calitornia. In the time of Governor Mason, a military Governor of the United States. I was Judge of the First Instance here. I have been a Notary Public, Treasurer of the county of Santa Barbara, Treasurer of the city of Santa Barbara, and am now one of the Trustees of Schools for the Third District of Santa Barbara."

Joaquin Carrillo

'Joaquin Carrillo having been duly sworn deposes and says: My name is Joaquin Carrillo; 1 am fiftytwo years of age; I was born in San Diego; I came to Santa Barbara in the year 1825, and ever since that year I have lived here. Under the Mexican Government I held various public offices. I was Justice of the Peace, Sub-Prefect, Prefect, Judge of the First Instance, and member of the Departmental Assembly to fill a vacancy. Under the Government of the United States I have held various public employments. JT was County Judge of Santa Barbara County during three years, until the year 1853, I was then elected District Judge of the Second Judicial District of the State of California, and I continued to hold that office until the year 1864, a period of eleven years; I am now one of the four Trustees of the town of Santa Barbara. I have just examined a copy of the Expediente and map of the rancho or tract of land called 'Los Prietos y Najalayegua,' granted to José Dominguez, which 'copy is certified by lL. Upson, Surveyor-General of the United States, in San Francisco, under date of the 12th of December, a. p. 1864. I recognize all the signatures which are in that Expediente as manifested in that copy. I have seen all these men write whose signatures are found in this Expediente, and I know their hand-writing except the Arguellos', and I know the hand-writing of the Arguellos from having had official correspondence with them. I recognize my signature on that document signed to a report made to the Prefect of the Second District. I made a report in favor of granting to José Dominguez the land that he petitioned for, as that report itself explains. I have examined the map which is in the Expediente, as shown in this copy of the Surveyor-General, and I have likewise examined the map annexed to the téstimony of Don Vicente Valencia. In my opinion the two maps are tor tho same tracts of land called Los Prietos y Najalayegua; but the map aunexed to the deposition of Don Vicente Valencia gives more minutise of the same land. When I was Justice of the Peace of the district of Santa Barbara I gave judicial possession of various ranchos in this district. The mode of measuring was to measure off two lines, one of them to represent the length and the other to represent the width of the rancho. When the land was level I sometimes measured the four sides, but when the land was difficult to pass over [ measured only two lines; or when the land was so broken or mountainous that it could not be passed over, in order to measure I made an approximate calculation of the distance. It was customary to put a monument or boundary (majonera o luidero) at each end of the line, when 1 could actually measure the line with a cord, and when we could not pass over with a cord by reason of the land being impracticable, we calculated the length and width, and set up a mark to indicate the extent of the rancho. I have just examined carefully the points designated as boundaries of the rancho Los Prietos y Najalayegua, in the main, annexed to the deposition of Vicente Valencia. According to these boundaries the form of the rancho would be a rectangle (supposing there are four leagues between the boundary marked 'N' and the boundary marked 'H,' and supposing there are two leagues between the boundary marked 'P' and the boundary marked 'R') of four leagues by two. When José Dominguez petitioned for this land of Prietos y Najalayegua, it was scarcely worth the labor of asking fer it. J. CARRILLO. "Sworn to before F. A. THompson, County Clerk."'

Felipe Lorenzana: "I was born in the City of Mexico. I came to California when Captain Noriega did, in the year 1801. Some priests came in the expedition. I remember the names of Father Antonio Ripol. and of Father Ramon Abeja, and of Father Niciso. I don't know what other name he had. He was a kind of President of the friars here in California. Father Luis Farjuada entered at the same time. Don Raymundo Carrillo had the military command here when I came to this country. I was about ten years old when I[ arrived here. Don Jacinto Lorenzana, my older brother, had charge of my person in the expedition when I came to this country. About ten years after my arrival, a little more or less, I entered into the military service here. I was one of the soldiers in the garrison of Santa Barbara, being occupied in guard duty, in fighting Indians, and in the other duties of a soldier. I built a house in Santa Barbara. I knew the deceased, José Ygnacio Lugo. He was an invalid soldier and was older than I. He had a house near my house, at. the distance of a few hundred yards, where his family resided. He had milk cows and used to keep them at the entrance of the cafion of Najalayegua, where he had a corral near the mouth of the cafion, on this side of the high range of mountains, that is to say, on the south side of' the range of that mountain. | have been many times with him to that corral where he had his cows. His cows used to pasture in the long cafion of the Najalayegua, on this side of the mountain range and on the rolling hills which are called Rancho de las Ortegas. I have examined to-day, with much attention, a map published in the newspaper which is called the Santa Barbara Times, which is said to be a copy of the map recorded in the archives of.Santa. Barbara, in. Book B of deeds, on page 511, and I see the old corral of José Ygnacio Lugo, the invalid soldier, engraved on that map, at the southeast portion of the map, and marked with the word 'corral.' This corral was on the south side of the mountain range, and not on the north side of the mountain range of Santa Barbara. In the corral he used to shut up his cows whon he milked them. He left there in the year 1843, or thereabouts, and then José Dominguez and his brother, José Maria Dominguez, entered into the same premises (finea) of José Ygnacio Lugo. I have aided Ygnacio Lugo many timesin putting the cows in that corral which I have described. I had cattle that used to pasture on de la Aliso, but it is many years ago. At that time those rolling hills were covered with trees, but there was a great conflagration, and all were burnt up. Many cattle and many horses of mine were burnt up in that conflagration. I am the same person to whom, jointly with Raymundo Olivas, the rancho of San Miguel was granted. FELIPE LORENZANA. "Sworn to before U. Yndart, Votary Public."

" Men of intelligence and keen sagacity never go out of the way to publish over their own signature a plain and unmistakable misrepresentation of important facts, without a sufficient motive or object in view. Our Town Attorney, A. Packard, Esq., as we have seen, has made a most remarkable misstatement of an important matter in his official capacity, and persistently refuses to explain himself. He had his reasons for making the statement that the Pueblo claim was confirmed for a large tract of land, containing about twenty leagues instead of four leagues, and for naming boundaries that were not named, as Pueblo lands, under the old order of things, or at any other time, except in his protest.

" First - If he could, by a bold assertion, make people believe, and the Land Commissioner believe, that the Pueblo lands extended to the top of the mountains, then, of course, the rancho claiming this side of the mountains and down to the plains of Santa Barbara, would appear in the light of a trespasser on the town lands. This, with his friends, he did succeed in doing. But why wish todo it? What object had he?

"Second - This enabled him to array the town against the Najalayegua grant, and get up a contest between them. But what was his object in that? It he wished for a pretext for delaying the town survey on its way to Washington, then he was successful. But why wish for delay? Why say that it would take two years or more to reach the case of Santa Barbara, and thus lead the people to rest satisfied with this state of things? Here is a reason: -

"Third - It now appears that he was interested, as the attorney of Pierce, Messini, et al., in a suit to drive back the claim of the Goleta Rancho from the beach, and thus leave the asphaltum banks open to the claim of the Pueblo, if the Pueblo survey was not yet confirmed, it being an easy matter for him, as Town Attorney, the survey being still in the custody of the town, to change the survey so as to include these valuable lands containing the asphaltum deposits, and his clients, Pierce, Messini, et al, were already before the Council as petitioners for this land, and so, a8 any one Can see, in the language of the country, they had a dead sure thing on the asphaltum beds, which are worth from fifty to a hundred thousand dollars!

"Now,.to.secure.this 'nice little thing,' it was necessary to keep up the fight with the Najalayegua claim, so as to delay the town survey long enough to gain the suit which would throw these asphaltum beds open to the claim of the town, and so, by a short and simple process, put these lands into the hands of his clients and himself'!

'Here seems, then, to be an object which might account, perhaps, for the wonderful stretching, by Mr. Packard, of the town claim till it covers about twenty leagues of land instead of four, and his contracting and reducing the claim of Najalayegua grant to about three leagues instead of about twenty.

| One thing is plain, that he is the first one who introduced the agitation about land titles, and he inaugurated the matter by the most manifest and undeniable misrepresentations of the plain facts of the case."

Signs Of A Reaction In Congress

So many protests through individuals and newspapers could not but reach Congress. The House Committee on Public Lands (Mr. Julian, Chairman) agreed unanimously to report a bill repealing the Act confirming the Los Prietos y Najalayegua, on the ground of fraud, inasmuch as José Dominguez, the grantee, had no knowledge of the affair when it was being urged through Congress. But it is not easy to go back and rectify all mistakes. After a deal of fuming and fretting, the matter was dropped. The land was surveyed as being between the two ranges of mountains. The quicksilver mines failed to become valuable, the oil deposit seemed to avoid the place with the long and unpronounceable name, and now no one cares for the ranch. Wild animals, as when Lugo sold it to Dominguez, hold the land undisturbed.

Conclusion

Looking at the matter from the present time, it seems incredible that so much excitement, so much ill-feeling should have occurred on the subject. Not only the papers, but the citizens generally, took sides. Mr. Huse was the object of so much ill-feeling that at one time his assassination was imminent, and he was guarded by day and by night. The ill-feeling has now ceased to exist, and most of the operators in the matter are on friendly terms. The reader of the affair at a late day may feel like. making--a sweeping denunciation of the claimants for the great tract, but who of us, seeing a great fortune lying around hunting an owner, would not be tempted to take it?

The Ex-Mission Grant

The doubtful circumstances attending this tract of land are not less than those of the grant mentioned in the previous part of the chapter. The land formerly belonged to the Mission of San Buenaventura. After the secularization of the missions, some of them became so nearly abandoned that the stock and other property was allowed to be wasted or appropriated by any one who chose to take it. Many of the mis- sions were owing large sums of'money which seemed likely to be a loss to the creditors, hence the Government took possession of the property as trustees, to secure the payment of the indebtedness, and to furnish means of subsistence to the Indians and fathers. The following is a translation of the title made to José de Arnaz: -

"Being previously authorized by the Excellent Departmental Assembly to alienate the Missions tor the purpose of paying the debts of the same, and for the purpose of raising means for the defense of the country, in case of a foreign invasion, which, from reliable information, appears to be at hand [and in consideration of the fact that the Sefior Don José de Arnaz] has rendered important services to the Government, and also rendered [and aided] valuable aid in the preservation of the security of the Department, under the guaranty of being indemnified when the National Treasury sbould be released of its embarrassments [this gentleman having solicited for his personal benefit the Mission of San Buenaventura, with all of its lands, establishments, stock, and other property, belonging to said Mission], in payment of that which at different times he has loaned the Govyernment, and which it has received, amounting in the total to [four] (erased and interlined) 'five' thousand dollars, obligating himself besides, to pay up to the sum of twelve thousand, within the term of [seven] (changed to) eight years, counting from the first of January of the coming year. And in view of all that is necessary to be considered in exercise of the authority conferred on me (interlined) [by the Supreme Government and the decree of the 13th of April of the Most Excellent Departmental Assembly] I have determined to make a sale, real and effective and a perpetual alienation forever to the said Don José de Arnaz, of the Mission of San Buenaventura as has been agreed, with all that at present pertains to the same, and is recognized as belonging thereto, with its lands, establishments, real estate, and selfmoving property. In testimony of which, and in validation thereof, the following conditions are made: -

" First - He shall pay such creditors of the Mission of San Buenaventura as may properly prove their accounts, at the farthest, within one year, making the necessary deductions from the amount per contra.

"Second - From this time henceforth, forever, he shall provide what is necessary for the subsistence [and clothing] (interlined) of the Reverend Father Minister, who in all time may reside at said mission, and also for the support of divine worship, leaving for the use (interlined) [of said father the rvoms which he occupied as a habitation].

"Third - No one shall be able to allege deceit or fraud in this sale, on the part of any one, and whatever mistake may have been made it shall inure to the benefit of the purchaser, the above price being the just value of said mission, and there being no one who would pay more for the same.

" Fourth - [In consequence] (erased) there shall be excepted from this sale the Temple, and all the appurtenances corresponding thereto, in consequence.

" Fifth - The lands of which mention is made, and which are recognized as belonging to the mission, compose those of 'La Laguna,' ' Hueneme,' ' El Palo Alto,' the 'Siembras of Santa Paula,' the 'Cafiada of the Mission,' and all such as may not have been recognized as belonging to the establishment, and those that make a center with all of the real estate and movable property belonging to said mission.

" Being previously authorized by the Most Excellent Departmental Assembly to alienate the missions, as well for the purpose of paying the debts of the same, and to avoid the total ruin thereof, as for the purpose of providing means for the common defense, in case of a foreign invasion, which, from reliable reports, is likely to happen very soon; in consideration of the fact that the Seftor Don José de Arnaz has rendered important services to the Government, and has also given valuable aid towards the preservation and security of the Department under the just guaranty of indemnity when the National Treasury should be relieved of its embarrassments, and there being no means of raising the amount that the Government justly owes him, in payment of the sums which at different times he has loaned the Government - amounting in the whole to the sum of [five thousand] (erased and interlined) twelve thousand dollars [obligating himself, beside, to pay up to the amount of twelve thousand within the term of eight years, counting from the Ist of January of the present year] (erased), and in view of all that was necessary to be considered, in exercise of the authority with which I am invested by the Supreme Government, and the decree of the 13th of April last of the Most Excellent Departmental Assembly, I have determined to make a real sale and an alienation, effective and perpetual forever to the said José Arnaz, of the Mission of San Buenaventura, in accordance with what had been agreed, with all the appurtenances at present belonging thereto, consisting of lands, establishments, real and movable property. In testimony whereof, and in validation of the same, the following conditions are made: -

" First - He shall pay to the creditors of the Mission of San Buenaventura the accounts that may be properly proven within the term of one year [making the proper discount of the amount for purchase] (erased).

"Second - From this time henceforth forever, he shall, on his own account, furnish whatever may be necessary for the support and clothing of the Reverend Father Minister, who may in all time reside at said mission, and also for the support of divine worship, leaving for the use of said father the rooms which he at present occupies as a dwelling.

"In this sale no fraud or deceit can be alleged by any one, and whatever mistake may have been made, it shall inure to the above, the price being the just value thereto, and there being no one who would pay more for the same.

"Sixth - The lands of which mention is made, and which we recognize as belonging to the mission, comprise La Laguna, Hueneme, Palo Alto, Los Siembras de Santa Paula, La Cafiada de Mission, and all such as have not been granted by just title by the Government, and which are recognized as the property of the establishment of which sale is made,

"In consequence whereof, by these presents, I declare the above-mentioned Sefior the legitimate owner of the said Mission of San Buenaventura, under the conditions set forth; wherefore, he can take possession of the same from the present time. And in witness whereof. for all time, I give this document as a formal deed, which shall be recognized and regarded by all the military authorities of the Mexican nations in this and the other departments, and even by the General Government of the same, duly authorized by my signature and that of' the Secretary of State, on this common paper, for the absolute want of sealed paper, on the eighth day of June, one thousand eight hundred and forty-six.

"In the city of Los Angeles of the Department of the Californias (on the fourteenth day of the month of May), witnesses being Don Vicente Guerrero and Casildo Aguilar, who are present.

"Received of Don José de Arnaz the sum of $13,000, for the purchase which he made of the Mission of San Buenaventura, in coin, to my entire satisfaction, and for his security I give him this in the city of Los Angeles, on the eighth of June, 1846."

There were no names signed to the deed, or the receipt for money. The writing was in the hand of Cayetano Arenas, the private secretary of Governor Pico.

"The sales of the missions made by the Sefior Don Pio Pico, as Governor, are annulled in all of their parts, as also, all that has been done outside of his authority in relation to the matter.

It will be observed that the decree annulling the sales made by Pico made no mention of the ex- Mission, so that no inference can be formed that that tract was sold.

On the 5th of December, 1845, the Government offered to lease at public lease, to the highest bidder, the Mission San Buenaventura, whereupon it was leased for the term of nine years to Don Narciso and Don José Arnaz, for the sum of $1,630 a year. (Vol. XI. Missions, p. 983.)

"The Mission of San Buenaventura is leased for nine years to the highest bidder, with 1,407 head of cattle, 19 yoke of oxen, 2,150 head of sheep, etc., etc., together with some movable property, as is shown by the inventory; one orchard at the mission with 582 fruit trees tn good condition, one vineyard at San Jose with 2,000 vines in bad condition, one vineyard at San Martin with 3,800 vines in bad condition. It has four square leagues of land, a little more or less. Ramon VALDEZ.

When Colonel Stevenson took possession of Lower California he found the ranch rented to José Arnaz and Narciso Botello, with the condition that one portion of the products should go to the support of the Indians, one to the fathers, and the other to the lessees. From information received by Stevenson, he was led to believe that the property had been misappropriated, or sold outright, without regard to increase, or the probability of returning the same amount at the termination of the lease as was received, and he desired an accounting or report of the property sold and on hand.

"Sir: I have been advised that some time since, you relinquished your interest in the lease of the Mission of San Buenaventura, but I will nevertheless thank you for any information you may possess relative to the property and effects of the Mission at the time you took possession or relinquished it. Your late partner, José Arnaz, exhibits a bill of sale for said Mission, executed to him by the late Governor' Pico, which it is supposed was given without any valuable consideration. Can you furnish me with any information as to his ability to purchase such a property ? Lam also informed that you were also a member for the last Territoria) Assembly, which passed, July 4th and October 28th, 1845, certain acts, authorizing the leasing and sale of certain Missions, and which, in its last session, in October, 1846, decided the sales of certain Missions made by Governor Pico, were null and void, they having been made without proper authority.

" Sir: I have received your official note of the 16th inst., requesting of me information as to what knowledge I possess of the lease of San Buenaventura, its interests, etc. In reply I would say that, though I do not recollect the precise dates, the Department Assembly, in 1845, decreed the sale of four Missions and the leasing of others. I recollect that both measures took effect, D. José Arnaz and the subscriber becoming lessees of Santa Barbara, of which establishment we took possession in the same year, and therein we received the amount of 1,300 head of cattle, 20 yoke of oxen, 100 and odd tame horses (as I do not recollect exactly, nor the number of breeding mares, but I think there were 400), 1 jack, 12 mules, wild and tame, 1,900 sheep, 30 fanegas of wheat, 19 or 20 tanned hides, 5 stills, three of which are in bad order, $130 of soap, 20 of cards, 10 or 12 jennies, some oil, instruments of agriculture, blacksmithing, saddlery, looms, ete., not remembering the amount of each article of said property on hand; and I was in the possession thereof, in company with Sefior.

Arnaz, up to the beginning of June, 1846, when I separated, selling him my interest. Ou my retiring as I stated, the security we had also retired, who was Don Antonio M. Lugo, said interest in consequence remaining in charge of Arnaz, without the security the law on the subject provides. The Assembly, of which body I was a member, meeting in October, 1846, ascertained that the Governor, Don P. Pico, had sold some of the leased Missions, one of them being Santa Barbara. Considering this act as an abuse emanating from arbitrary will, since such power had not been given to the Governor, it passed a decree, annulling, in all respects, said sales of Missions before leased. In virtue of which decree, the Governor which last presided in the person of Capt. José Maria Flores, passed an official order to Don Arnaz, then in Santa Barbara, to present himself in this city to give fitting security; and that on his compliance with this requirement. he should be acknowledged as lessee, but never as purchaser. This was not done, and then Government found itself compelled to appoint a Trustee, viz.: the parochial eure of that parish, Presbyter D. José Maria Rosales, to secure said interest until said security was furnishec. This was the state of Arnaz's affairs at the end of last year, and everything was paralyzed. Arnaz, in consequence, laughing at these dispositions of Government, and continuing in Santa Barbara without right. As respects that part of your note as to the means Arnaz might have to purchase that establishment, I cannot answer, as I do not know what means he had, or might have got hold of.

Colonel Stevenson finally furcibly took possession, putting the property in the custody of Isaac Callahan, who took in William A. Streeter, now living in Santa Barbara, as a partner. This affair occurred in the latter part of 1847. After the expulsion of Arnaz from the ranch, a new claim was set up, that the ranch had been sold to Arnaz by Pio Pico, for the sum of $13,000. This was the first that was known of thé sale by the public. In the strife that ensued regarding the Ex-Mission, many affidavits were taken regarding the conditions of the renting, which, in one instance, appeared to be for $1,630 per year.

"William A. Streeter, being duly sworn, says: That my name is William A. Streeter; am sixty-one years ot age; have lived in the county of Santa Barbara since the year A. D. eighteen hundred and fortyfour. In eighteen hundred and forty-five, the Mexican Congress authorized the leasing and selling of the Mission landsin California. The Mission of San Luis Rey and the Mission of La Purissima were sold. The Mission of Santa Barbara was leased to N. A. Den and D. Hill, and the Mission of San Buenaventura to José Arnaz and Narciso Botello. At the time José Arnaz received the lease of the Mission of San Buenaventura, the Americans were not in possession of the southern part of the State of Culifornia. When Colonel Stevenson arrived in the southern part of the State of California, he found that the said José Arnaz was removing property from off the lands of the Mission of San Buenaventura. After discovering this, said Stevenson took possession of the Mission lands, in the name of United States. The Mission lands ot San Buenaventura, in eighteen hundred and _fortyfive, consisted of what is now known as the Ex-Mission of San Buenaventura Rancho, or of very near the same extent of territory.

"Tn the latter part of the year of eighteen hundred and forty-seven, Colonel Stevenson leased the said property of Mission of San Buenaventura to Isaac Callahan; said Callahan and myself wero in partnership, but the lease was.made to Callahan alone.

"At the time Callahan took possession of the property under his lease, said Arnaz did not set up any title or right to the ground, except by lease from the Mexican Government, which was given by Pio Pico as Governor for the term of nine years.

"Said José Arnaz sold the Mission ot San Buenaventura, in the year of eighteen hundred and fifty, to Dr. Poli, and for the first time claimed to be the owner of the said property.

"JT now have in my possession letters and other documents relating to the matter set forth in this affidavit, which I am willing to produce if necessary.

Many affidavits were presented from different parties to show that the cession of the grant to Arnaz was made after the American occupation. One will be sufficient to show the character of them: -

" Josefa Arenas, being duly sworn, deposes and says, 1 am fifty-six years of age, have resided in this town, San Buenaventura, in the county of Santa Barbara, for sixteen years last past, and am a native of Los Angeles, California. I know, of my own knowledge, that José de Arnaz and Narciso Botello had the Ex- Mission of San Buenaventura leased for several years, and until Colonel Stevenson took possession of the whole Mission establishment, cattle, horses and lands, and everything belonging to the said establishment. Colonel Stevenson then leased the whole establishment to a man, the name IJ do not recollect. J hada step-son by the name of Cayetano Arenas (now deceased), who was acting as Secretary for Governor Pico, when the said Pico was Mexican Governor of California; said Arenas told me repeated times that the grant of the Ex-Mission of San Buenaventura was a fraud; that he (Cayetano Arenas), made the deed and dated it back, and then went to Los Angeles and testified before some court to the genuineness of said deed, for which one Dr. Poli was to give him a deed for the Potrero on which he (Cayetano Arenas) then lived, but which the Dr. Poli failed to do before he died, and then his successor ejected him out of the said Potrero. Said Cayetano Arenas also told me that the deed made to Arnaz. purporting to have been made by Pio Pico, was all in his (Arenas') handwriting, and dated back to make it appear legal.

"José Fernandez Gomez, being duly sworn, deposes and says: I resided in the town of San Buenaventura, Santa Barbara County, California, ever since the year 1858. J] knew a man by the name of Cayetano Arenas, deceased. I lived in the said Arenas' house for some time, and frequently stopped with him, and had a good deal of business with aie He, the said Cayetano Arenas, told me repeated times that he had been Pio Pico's clerk or secretary, while the said Pico was the Governor.of California. Mr. Arenas, in speaking about Dr. M. R. Poli, formerly owner, or pretended owner, of the ' Mission Grant,' told me several times that although the people of the town had such very high opinion of him (the said Poli), he, the said Arenas, thought a good deal of him as a doctor, or a professional man, butindividually he had some very important business with him and had fuiled to fulfill his promise. He, the said Arenas, told me that the doctor had offered him one hundred acres of land, designated inside of said Ex-Mission, title known asthe ' Potrero, that he had gave him the possession of the same and promised him to give him a title as soon as Arenas would give him a testimony before a certain court, which I do not now recollect. The testimony he was to give, was to the effect that the supposed grant was a genuine one given by Pio Pico while Governor of this department of California. The original grant, as it appeared, was, as he told me, in Arenas' own hand write, but that it was alla fraud; that he (Arenas) bad manufactured the title in the year 1848, and that he had dated it back in order to make it appear, as he thought, legal. That at Dr. Poli's request and offer he, Arenas, went and testified that the grant had been given by Pico while authorized as Governor of the Depurtment of California Alta, but it was not so; that he was conversant with the Mexican laws, as he had an opportunity to know them on account that he had been (up to the time that the Amcricans took possession of the country), always em) loyed as secretary of some court or officer, and that the Mission establishments (as they called them) were advertised for sale at public auction, and that this one he knew had never been so advertised; that when he gave his testimony he was well satisfied that he was not telling the truth, but that he had done it in order to get the piece of Jand that Poli had offered him and the possession of, but that the doctor aforesaid, after he had used him to obtain his statement, or testimony, always refused to give bim a deed for the piece of land above referred to, and that after the doctor's death his successor ejected him out of the premises. 1 stopped with him while he lived in the above-mentioned Potrero, and had very frequent conversations with him regarding the title of the said Ex-Mission Grant, which he always termed a fraudulent one.

"]ix-Mission San Buenaventura. Sold to José Arnaz January 8, 1846. Sold to M. A. R. de Poli in 1850. Presented to Land Commissioners November 11,

1. That the original to the Ex-Mission of San Buenaventura and the original receipt for the payment of the purchase money are found in the archives of the Mexican Government.

2. That the Supreme Court of the United States has, by repeated decisions, declared that archive evidence was the best evidence as to the genuineness of the Mexican title.

3. That after over sixteen years of li igation in all the courts of the United States, and after the record has been twice before the Supreme Court of the United States, no taint of fraud has attached to the title.

4. That purchasers have a right to rely on the records of the courts, and are not expected to inquire as to the genuineness of grants, nor the motives which may have induced the acts of the public officers.

5. That the present cluimants purchased the unsold portions of said claim in 1866, subsequently to the first dismissal of the case by the Attorney-General of the United States; that they, although innocent purchasers, were once more compelled to defend the title in the Supreme Court, and again obtained a decree in its favor.

6. That they as innocent purchasers, relying on the final decree of the Supreme Court of the United States, have sold to other innocent purchasers, since the date of said decree, some forty tracts, many of which have been subdivided and resold to other innocent purchasers, and that previous tosaid decree some thirty-five tracts were sold by former owners, which also have been subdivided and sold to innocent purchasers.

7. That the Senate of the United States has heretofore established a precedent in a similar application, on which the Committee of Private Land Claims, of which the present Attorney-General of the United States was Chairman, reported adversely to the passage of the bill.

8. That the Supreme Court of the United States, in the case of the Rio Estanislen, refused to reopen the question of title before the survey went to patent upon the ground that the title having been confirmed, and the United States having had ample time to pruduce their proof against the same, the question of title was forever settled as against the United States and all parties claiming under it. We deny that there is any evidence in the title to the Ex-Mission San Buenaventura or that it would have been invalid under the laws of Mexico."

Undue Influence

Asin all the other grants of doubtful title, there were rumors of collusion between the claimants and the officers of the courts who adjudicated the affair. The following persons were interested in the grant to the extent named: -

While the matter of a survey was under consideration, which was al] that stood between the people and a patent, a public meeting was held to protest against the issue of the patent until the whole matter could be reviewed.

In response to the petition of the settlers Senator Windom introduced a bill providing for a readjustment of the mission matters. Senator Sargent presented a letter from Lauren Upson, Surveyor-General, protesting against disturbing the settlement; that the statements made by the settlers were erroneous. Upson took much interest in maintaining the grant.

"A bill has been introduced by Senator Windom directing the Attorney-Gencral to institute a suit to establish the title of the United States to the ex-Mission San Buenaventura lands. The bill also provides that no action shall be taken by the Interior Department regarding surveys, until the case is determined. The petition presented by Houghton alleges that the decision of the Supreme Court on this title was procured by the means of fraudulent stipulation between the counsel for the claimant and Attorney-General Speed. without any examination of the record.

"The case in Congress seems to hinge on the question as to whether there was complicity between the claimants and the attorney of the Government to secure the confirmation of the grant. That fact established, the case will probably come back to the courts, when the whole case will again be tried. Failing to reject the grant, the contest will be upon the survey and the cutting down of the bounds of the grant to four leagues."

The last phase in the matter was a suit commenced in behalf of the State of California, by Joe Hamilton, Attorney-General for the State, that the lands escheat to the State as having no lawful owner, This, however, was soon abandoned.

The land is being sold and cultivated. Some doubts still remain in the minds of the people, but the fact that some hundred persons have bought portions of the land in good faith and improved it seems to act as a bar to any investigation that 'vould be likely to disturb the peace and settlement of the land.

These two articles on the subject of grants are not given asa full history, but only to give an idea of the careless way in which land was alienated in years past. Young men have started in life studying the Spanish grants, and have grown old and gray without reducing the work to a system. Gross fraud has marked the grant operations from the inception. Peace will ultimately come by the Act of Limitation, which fixes the title in those who have had peaceable possession for a term of years.

Provenance

Text from HIstory of SAnta Barbara County, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.