Santa Cruz County, California - Chapter 4: The First Court House, 1911
From History of Santa Cruz County, California; with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911. 2,559 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
5 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
2,559 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Santa Cruz County, California; with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 4: The First Court House
The first court house of Santa Cruz county was located on the east side of wliat is now known as Emmet street in the upper Plaza. It was a frame building with a stairway on the outside. The building and lot were conveyed to the county by Thomas Fallon, who built it for a residence and used a portion of it for his business, making saddle trees and leather paraphernalia, for saddles were much in use in early days. Judge John H. Watson was the first judge, Peter Tracey first county clerk, Francisco Alzino the first sheriff. Watson resigned and was succeeded by C. P. Hester. When Hester's term expired Samuel Bell McKee was elected his successor. David Belden was the last judge of the old district court. In the superior court created by the new constitution, J. H. Logan was the first judge, succeeded by F. J. Mc- Cann, who died in office. Judge Logan was appointed to fill the unexpired term of McCann. Lucas F. Smith succeeded Logan and is now the judge of the supreme court, elected in 1898 and subsequently re-elected. J. H. Skirm is at present practicing, the only one alive of the old school of lawyers. C. B. Younger (deceased) practiced in the district a number of years, and Julius Lee, who also practiced many years, is also deceased, having passed away in 1910. It is claimed that Judge Hester was defeated on the ground that certain lawj^ers had a ''pull" with him, and that he always decided their cases their way. This has been charged against almost every judge.
early days were D. R. Ashley (afterward state treasurer), R. F. Peckham, A. S. Gregory and J. H. Coulb. Peckham and Coulb had an office at one time in the old court house. W. T. Wallace, M. H. Patterson and several others practiced before this court.
John H. Garber, whose death occurred a few months ago, was a young attorney at this period. He ran for district attorney on the Democratic ticket, and, much to his chagrin, was defeated. It was the best thing that could have happened to him, a turning point in his career. He left Santa Cruz and went to Nevada, where he gained fame and success. Of late years he resided in San Francisco and was a leading member of the bar in that city.
Court Notes
A noted criminal case was that of the People vs. Jesse I. Graham; an indictment was presented by the grand jury at the April term of the district court accusing Graham of the killing of Dennis Bennet on April 22, 1850. Entered on the indictment were the names of the witnesses and also of William T. Wallace, district attorney. Graham left for parts unknown soon after the homicide and the case was forgotten by almost every one except some members of the Bennet family. A bench warrant was issued for the arrest of Graham on April 26, 1888, thirty years later; he was arrested near Fresno and brought to this county for trial. The trial of the ease attracted considerable attention; the habits, customs and peculiarities of the time of 1850 were considered ancient history resurrected. An eye witness of the affray was brought from Arizona; his recollection of the event as given by his testimony was clear and distinct. The trial occupied several days. The jury could not agree upon a verdict, and stood ten for acquittal and two for conviction. The jury, it was reported, took into consideration the time that had elapsed since the commission of the offense and the lawlessness of early days, and the fact that the defendant had been living in the state for some years without any attempt of concealment on liis part, and his neighbors testifying that he bore a good character for peace and quietness, no doubt influenced the jury. The defendant was admitted to bail and the case dismissed and he was set free.
A case that rivals the celebrated case of Jarndyce vs. Jarndyce is on record in the district court and the superior court of this county. William H. Moore died in November, 1871, leaving a large estate. Probate proceedings were instituted which dragged along for many years, owing to conflicting interests by the heirs and others who had acquired interests in portions of the estate. Considerable litigation has ensued and the case is not yet settled. The judges that were on the bench have all passed away. The attorneys that were enlisted in tlie various suits have ceased their arguments and have paid the common penalty of all mankind.
County Hospital
''Over the hills to the poorhouse." In the first years of the county government the supervisors of each district were allowed a certain amount of money to be used by them for the support of indigent persons. There were not so many claiming aid as there are at the present time. As the years rolled on indigents and unfortunates increased and a county liospital and poor farm was established. At one time the prisoners in the county jail were fed at the rate of sixty cents per diem, while the inmates of the poorhouse were starved by contrast at about thirty cents per diem. Complaints were made to the board of supervisors monthly of the treatment received, the poor food and ill treatment generally. In 1885 a new system was inaugurated by which supplies were purchased under the direction of the hospital committee of the board of supervisors, and the inmates received the benefit of this system and have been and now are treated humanely. Very many persons, especially the old Calif ornians, have a "holy horror" of being sent to end their days in the county hospital, preferring to eke out a miserable existence on the pittance allowed them by the supervisors.
Under the present management the inmates have no cause for complaint; they are well cared for, have medical attendance when sick and are treated like human beings. Without any cares or anxiety they live to a ripe old age. One inmate who once owned ten acres of land right in the heart of Watsonville has been a boarder for several years, compelled by his own imprudence to accept a home in the poorhouse. On being asked how he was treated, answered "Just as good as I deserve; we all get good treatment here."
The expenses for taking care of the inmates of this institution average about thirty-five cents per day; this includes provisions of all kinds, clothing and medical attendance. The average monthly number of inmates during the year ranges from sixty to seventy. This institution is conducted on humane principles and reflects credit on the officials of Santa Cruz county.
A suggestion has been made to the board of supervisors to establish an old folks home, for a class of people who have some means and could afford to pay for accommodations at a reasonable compensation; where they might be allowed to end their days among their own surroundings, in a home similar to the Old Peoples Home in San Francisco, but not so expensive. This idea was placed before the board of supervisors some months ago. A communication on this subject was published in three of the newspapers of the
Men Of The Ante Ora Period
Among the first residents of Santa Cruz county was Eliliu Anthony, who arrived in California in 1847, moving with his family to Santa Cruz in 1848, and built the first wharf in Santa Cruz; he established the first foundrj^ P. H. Devoll first reached this coast in 1830. In 1868 he returned to California and in 1872 settled in Santa Cruz and died here. John Daubenbis arrived in California in 1843 in company with John Hames; they built a flour mill and a saw mill on Soquel creek. During the early period of the state John Daubenbis kept open house; all travelers were made welcome.
Francisco Alzino, a native of Spain, came to California in 1846 and to Santa Cruz in 1847; he was the first sheriff of Santa Cruz county. His widow survives him, hale and hearty at eighty years of age. The son, Enoch Alzino, has been the trusted janitor of the court house for twenty-five years. Supervisors and other officials have been changed during this period but "Tokey,'* as he is generally called, keeps his position because he is trustworthy.
William Blackburn came to Santa Cruz in 1845, and served as alcalde and county judge. Isaac Graham (Zayante), who settled on the Zayante Rancho in 1841, built the first sawmill in California. Paul Sweet arrived here about 1840, and started the first tannery in Santa Cruz county. Joseph L. Majors came here in 1832, and in 1839, he married Marie de Los Angeles. San Augustine Rancho was granted to Majors in 1841, and he was elected county treasurer in 1850.
William Trevethan came here in 1835. William Hardy came here in 1845, and lived on Beach Hill for many years before his death. Jose Bolcolb Rusner came to California in
1814, and occupied the office of alcalde a number of years ; he owned the Refuzio Rancho at one time, and died in poverty in 1866. A. A. Hecox arrived here in 1846, served as alcalde, also as county treasurer. Guy Omnes, native of France, who arrived in 1843, was a lumberman. Lajeunesse, generally called Ligeness, Canadian, arrived in 1844 or thereabouts ; he was a lumberman. Job F. Dye crossed the Rockies, arriving in this county in the '60s.
William Ware, who came here very early, was associated with Isaac Graham. Prewett Sinclair, who crossed the Rockies in 1830, was a trapper and hunter ; he made his home in Santa Cruz many years, and voted at the first election in 1850. At one time in his life he had a dispute over some land with one Dr. Vanderberg; Prewett took down his old rifle and proposed to go for the doctor. He happened to consult Judge Peckham, his lawyer, about the propriety of taking a shot at the doctor; Peckham told him that was not the right method and advised him not to attempt it ; Prewett took the advise in good part but thought his way best to settle such disputes, frontier style.
Otis Ashley arrived in California in 1846; he lived on the Zayante Rancho, near Felton, from 1856, engaged in the lumber business and had twenty years of litigation. Lambert B. Clement came to California in 1845, and was justice of the peace at Soquel for several years. Joseph Pellissier landed at Sausalito in 1845, and lived in the Pajaro valley, Monterey county; he married the daughter of Vallejo. Moses A. Meder, who came to California in 1846, owned considerable land at one time in this county. Eli Moore came to this state in 1847 ; he owned a large tract of land up the coast, also property in the city of Santa Cruz.
place in the history of the state. Others liave reaped the benefit of their labors and profited by their experiences. Witli one or two exceptions the probate court was not kept busy settling the estates of the pioneers.
Pioneer Days
It must be borne in mind that many of the people that thronged to California in the golden era, especially those who hailed from **away down east," were provincial. They had never traveled outside of their own locality to any extent until they made up their minds to leave for a far distant state and an unknown country. For a person to have ventured 50 miles from home was deemed an undertaking in the year of grace 1848, hence their ideas of their fellow citizens of the south were rather narrow. The western people accustomed to travel were broader in their views of mankind. One elderly person I call to mind whose realm was bounded by Royalton, Vt., deemed that place the center of the universe. Another younger man from Boston knew that city by heart, but outside this his knowledge was limited. He was not aware of any steamships traveling to Charleston, opposite Boston. A ten-acre field was a large farm to some of them; they did not seem to grasp the areas of California ranches; their ambition was to realize on their ventures here and return to the land of their fathers to enjoy the fruits of their labors; very few expected to stay any length of time, and had they been successful and realized their ambition the^^ would have made a trip east if for nothing more than to see the old folks. Fate decreed otherwise and the majority became old settlers and pioneers and rejoiced that they became actual and bona fide residents of the Golden State.
crop of potatoes was raised on this land; potatoes that year brought as high as sixteen cents per pound. Flour in the month of December that year was $50 per barrel. Encouraged by the success of this potato crop many persons migrated from Santa Cruz to the Pajaro valley where J. Bryant Hill in that year had been very successful in farming. He was the first American to start the plow in the Pajaro valley on the Sal-si-puedes rancho that he had leased from Don Manuel Jimeno.
Shipping was carried on by sailing vessels from Santa Cruz to San Francisco. At this period several schooners were wrecked on the beach at Santa Cruz. At Aptos a brig went ashore loaded with grain and potatoes, quite a valuable cargo thus being lost. In 1853 the potato crop was a failure owing to the large quantity raised and no market ; prices went down to nothing. The population of the state at this time was not large enough to absorb the immense amount raised and they rotted on the ground; this was a decided set back, as many had depended on the proceeds of this crop to make a stake and had calculated to go home; thus all their hopes were dashed by the collapse of the market. Some never recovered from this misfortune, became reckless and disheartened, others by perseverance and pluck weathered the storm and buckled in again. The latter suffered severe hardships, as it was some years before they realized anything from their labors as fanners; money was scarce and not much in circulation, ''no credit" signs hung up in several of the stores. Not until 1857 did times improve, potatoes and other farm products were bringing good prices. About this time better times were in evidence, as noted by the change in dress; frock coats and white shirts were worn and in some cases plug hats. Very little progress was made in improvements, the redwood shanties still being in vogue, though in- dustries were being started in the shape of saw mills. Isaac Graham, a pioneer, is credited with having erected the first saw mill on Zayante creek in 1842 or '43. Pewett Sinclair, another pioneer, operated a mill on the Corralitos creek, and a very crude affair it was. In the early '50s government land, that is, section land, was being looked up and located. At first this land was taken up by squatters without any attempt to prove up by way of preemption ; the land offices paid but little attention at this period to what was going on in land matters.
Provenance
Text from History of Santa Cruz County, California; with Biographical Sketches of the Leading Men and Women of the County, Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present Time, published 1911, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.