BlockBefore

Siskiyou County, California - Chapter 18: Indian Difficulties, 1881 (part 3 of 4)

From History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. 15,938 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

5 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,938 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

1859, died February 15, I860; Eliza Jane and twin sister, born May 3, 1861, the latter dying on the same day; Nancy Emerline, born January 3, 1863, died January 2, 1864; Frances Ann, born November 29, 1864; William, born January 25, 1867, died October 25, 1868; infant son, born March 5, 1870, died same day; infant son, born July 14, 1875, died July 14, 1875; Alice Maud, born May 23, 1878. Of this family, Eliza Jane, Frances Ann, and Alice Maud, only are living. Mr. Townsend is engaged in stock-growing in Shasta valley, in which trade he has been quite successful. He is a member of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows lodge at Yreka. In politics he is a Democrat; in religion a Protestant.

John Miller

William and Eliza (Smith) Miller, the former born in Maryland and the latter in Pennsylvania, settled in Green county, Ohio, near Jamestown, where were born to them eight children : Johnson, Catherine Ann, Henry, George, Silas, John, Sarah Jane and Louisa. John, the subject of this sketch, was born March 15, 1834, and now lives with his sister Louisa in Little Shasta, in this county. Henry resides at Brownsville, Iowa, and Silas at Mechanicsville, Iowa. When six years of age, John removed with his parents to Cedar county, Iowa, and there remained attending school for short terms in winter, and working on a farm and in a grist-mill, when he was seized with the gold fever. He saw wagons going by the farm daily on their way to California, and could not withstand the temptation to join them. With an uncle and his brother George, he crossed the plains with an ox-team by the northern route, the Blue mountains and The Dalles. Being without money when he reached Oregon, he turned his hand to anything he could find to do during the first winter, and in the spring combined with some others and bought a horse on which to pack their blankets, and started on foot for the Jacksonville mines. He worked there for some time, and then came to this county and worked with his brother George on Humbug in 1854. That winter he returned to the mines at Jacksonville, and remained until June, 1855, when he and his brother located on the ranch in Little

Shasta, which is still his home. The two brothers were in partnership in stock-raising and farming until the death of George in 1867, since which time John has managed the business alone. He now has 1,400 acres ol land under a good state of cultivation, adapted to grazing and grain, well watered and fenced. He has a good, comfortable residence, a view of which is given on another page. The house is presided over by his sister Louisa, Mrs. Hart, whose husband died in the service of his country during the rebellion. She came to California and took charge of her brother's house, accompanied by her two sons, William George, born May 16, 1859, and Charles Edwin, born March 4, 1862. Mr. Miller is extensively engaged in cattle and horse raising, and is one of the eminently successful men of Siskiyou county.

William Miller

The subject of this sketch, son of George and Mary Christiana Miller, was born in Nassau, Germany, now a portion of Prussia, November 22, 1839. When he was seven years of age, the family emigrated to America and settled on a farm in La Salle county, Illinois. While en route to the new home, the mother died in Montreal. At the home in Illinois, the oldest daughter took the mother's place, and there William lived until nearly twenty years of age. He was then possessed with a desire to go to California, and sailed from New York in the spring of 1858, by the steamer John L. Stevens, landing in San Francisco May 2 2d. The passage was quick and pleasant, but one day being spent on the Isthmus. He came at once to Siskiyou county, and worked for a short time for John B. Rohrer, in Little Shasta valley, soon afterwards engaging in mining at Hawkinsville, both hydraulic and drift. In company with his brother Philip, Morris R. Betts, and two Frenchmen, he dug a ditch there, selling the surplus water to other miners. In 1861 he went to Shasta county, and engaged in silver mining at what is now Pittsburg. He remained there about a year, paying as high as fifty dollars a foot for interests in quartz ledges, and sinking all the money he had previously been able to save. He then returned to Little Shasta and purchased a farm, which, by his energy and business capacity, he was enabled soon to pay for, and upon which he still resides. He has yearly added to his property, and now owns one of the finest places in the valley, consisting of a good residence, farm buildings, and nine hundred acres of excellent land. The farm is well adapted for grazing and grain growing, and as high as forty bushels of wheat to the acre have been raised. When he commenced farming he paid two dollars and onehalf per bushel for wheat, oats and barley for seed, and he has paid eight dollars per hundred for potatoes. He can raise two and one-half to three tons of hay per acre, and has cut hay three times in one year. All is consumed on the place by cattle, of which he has a large number. His residence stands on section twenty-eight, and with his farm premises forms one of the illustrations in this volume. Mr. Miller is one of the successful men of the county, and owes the position he occupies to his own energy, hard work, and careful management. Mr. Miller was married June

4, 1876, by Hon. A. M. Rosborough, to Miss Maria Martens, of Yreka, daughter of Nicolaus and Maria Martens, of Hanover, Germany. After coming to the United States, Mrs. Miller stopped a few years in New York, finally accompanying the family with whom she lived to the Pacific coast. Her parents died in Germany. She had two brothers and three sisters: Anna died in Germany, and Lena in Philadelphia; Carl lives on a farm at Galena, Illinois, and Henry died in New York; Catarina is married to Henry Ducker, a groceryman, at 72 Sheriff street, New York. Mr. Miller is a Protestant in religion and a liberal in politics, giving his allegiance to principles and not party. He has seen Little Shasta valle}r advance from a thinly settled wild to the beautiful and cultivated valley as it is to-day. In 1879 Mr. Miller's aged father went to his long home from the old place in La Salle, Illinois, where he settled so long ago.

Josiah R. And Eliphalet B. Edson

Charles Edson was born in Woodstock, Windsor county, Vermont, August 4, 1799. He was of English ancestry. In his boyhood days he removed with his parents to Luzerne county, Pennsylvania, where, in later years, he made the acquaintance of and wedded Susan Stevens, daughter of Thomas and Lucy Stevens. They reared a family of nine children, five sons and four daughters, viz.: Harriet C. (now Mrs. H. C. Eddy, residing at the home at Gazelle, Shasta valley), Sarah B., deceased, Josiah R., Charles Thomas, deceased, Epaphras Wadsworth, now at Sterling, Illinois; Lucy A., now Mrs. Jerome Fay; Eliphalet B., Clinton A., now of Alameda; and Susan E., now Mrs. L. M. Foulke, of Nevada. J. R. was born near Muncy, in Lycoming county, Pennsylvania, the three youngest in Lee county, Illinois, near Dixon, and the balance of the family in Luzerne county, Pennsjdvania. Their father died at Dixon, Illinois, in the month of March, 1854; their mother at Gazelle, the present family home, on the eleventh day of October, 1880. Josiah R. and his sister, Mrs. Eddy, crossed the plains in 1852, direct to Yreka. In 1853 they purchased the ranch on which they now reside, known then as the Brady ranch, and one of the first located in Siskiyou county. In 1863, the balance of the family followed them to California, where they have since continued to live, except three years' absence in the East. The farm contains about 3,500 acres, is located on a beautiful plain in Shasta valley, on the California and Oregon stage road. The post-office is called Gazelle, Mrs. Eddy being postmistress, and is kept in their residence. Ever since the location of the place it has been kept as a public house, and well deserves the name of popular place. The house is surrounded with a fine lawn, flower gardens, and beautiful shade trees. A pleasing sight to the weary stage traveler, is this oasis on the plain. In religion, they are Protestants, in politics, staunch Republicans. Their grandfather Stevens was seven years in the revolutionary war. Two of the brothers were in the late war of the rebellion; Epaphras was with the Sturges rifles and on McClellan's body guard, and Eliphalet was in Sherman's army. From the residence the famous Mount Shasta is in full view, also the peak of Mount Pitt or McLaughlin, nearly 100 miles away in Oregon.

Gilbert Lanphier

Was the son of Nathan and Hannah (Griffin) Lanphier, of Waldo county, Maine, where Gilbert was born, August 16, 1812. His father died at Nashville, Tennessee, in 1817, after which Gilbert removed, with his grandfather, to Summit county, Ohio. Here he lived on a farm until sixteen years of age, when he went to learn the carpenter's trade with an uncle. He continued to work at his trade until 1850, when, early in the spring, he started across the plains to California with horses and mules, arriving at Sacramento July 20, 1850. His first move Avas to the Mokelumne river to mine; in a few months he went to Mariposa county, and from there, in company with Charles Moore, went to Downieville, arriving in the spring of 1851 ; late in 1852 he went to Shasta county, and in January, 1853, removed to Siskiyou county, and engaged in mining for about six years. In 1859 returned to his trade at Yreka, which he followed, with slight interruptions, until 1871, when he removed to Strawberry valley. During the years 1863-64 he was city marshal of Yreka. The years 1855 to 1859 he spent at Scott Bar. He was made a Mason in 1854, and is a member of St. John's Lodge at Yreka. He took chapter degrees in Akron, Ohio, in 1855 ; was made a Royal and Select Master at San Francisco in 1858, and a Knight Templar in 1859. He is a member of California Commandery No. 1, stationed at San Francisco, and was for three years Master of Owen Lodge at Scott Bar, and High Priest of Cyrus Chapter at Yreka for the same length of time; also held all the other offices of the chapter. He has been Junior Grand Deacon of the Grand Lodge of California, and was Royal Arch Captain of the Grand Chapter of California. He is at present deputy postmaster and agent of Wells, Fargo & Co.'s office at Berryvale. In religion he is a Protestant, believing in universal salvation. In politics he is a staunch Republican.

Was a native of Boston, Massachusetts, where his boyhood days and early manhood were spent. In 1850 he came to San Francisco. After remaining there about two years he removed to Portland, Oregon, and later to Yreka. He was a carpenter by trade, and soon established himself in that and a general hardware business. In 1861 he was married to Mrs. S. J. Belden, of Ohio. In 1866 they removed to Strawberry valley, and at once began improving the place that is now the home of Mrs. Fellows, and known as " Mount Shasta Hotel," located at the base of Mount Shasta, and one of the most beautiful locations on the road. Mrs. Fellows is postmistress and keeps a stock of merchandise for the accommodation of the neighborhood.

degrees beyond the liberty of action allowed by the stock-men, and when Fairchilds entered the cabin and beheld the young brave perched upon the bed, he flew into a passion and told him to leave or he would get kicked out. This cordial invitation to leave was accepted by the savage who stalked out in silence. A short time thereafter Lee Bird entered and said:

He did so, but it required considerable soft talking to mollify the insulted chief and heal his wounded honor, but it was accomplished at last, and the negotiations were proceeded with.

A treaty was entered into, between Fairchilds on one side, and Old Schonchin, Captain Jack, John Schonchin, and Patcheye, whereby title to the Butte creek country was conveyed to Fairchilds, with the privilege of ranging his stock still farther to the east unmolested, the Indians to aid him with stray cattle. For this grant and immunity from depredations, Fairchilds gave them money, cattle, and horses, to the value of three hundred dollars, refusing, however, to give them guns and ammunition. They asked for these, but he said that he could not give them without the consent of the great Chief at Washington, and they had to be satisfied without.

In 1865 a second treaty was made, extending the stock range still farther towards the east. Again, in 1866, a third treaty was entered into with the Modocs, by which John A. Fairchilds and P. A. Dorris were "-ranted the Hot creek, Cottonwood creek, and Lost river country, Captain Jack reserving a tract six miles square, at the mouth of Lost river, for a residence. The consideration was two hundred dollars. These treaties were all faithfully observed, and ever after the last one Captain Jack believed and said that he had sold the land to Fairchilds and Dorris.

In 1863, Patcheye was shot dead in Yreka, by a S iasta Indian named Bullhead. His band then joined the Hot creek band of Modocs, which, ten years lateiyjoined Captain Jack in the lava beds.

The government dealings with these Indians, to which can be largely ascribed the Modoc war, commenced in 1864. After considerable trouble and a great deal of talk, a treaty was signed, October 14, 1864, by the Klamath and Modoc Indians, and bv J.' P. Huntington and William Logan, commissioners appointed for that purpose by the government. Those who signed for the Modocs were Schonchin, Stak-it-ut, Keint Poos (Captain Jack), and Chuck-e-i-ox. By this treaty, the Indian title to all the land claimed by both - tr-i-bes was given to the government, and they agreed to live on the 19 J °

Klamath reservation, which was then set off for them. Certain annual distributions of goods were to be made by the government through the Indian agent, and all past offenses by the Indians were canceled and forgiven. Captain Jack always maintained that he never agreed to give up his home on Lost river and live at the reservation, and that if the treaty contained that provision, he had been deceived when he signed it. Old Schonchin, however, said differently, and with his followers lived peaceably on the reservation, when placed there.

The treaty was revised and ratified by Congress, July 2, 1866, and the amendments then made assented to by the Indians, December 10, I860. It was proclaimed by the President February 17, 1870.

Annually the Indians were called together at the agency and a distribution of annuit}^ goods made, until 1867, when, in consideration of the rapidly increasing settlement of people along Lost river and vicinity, it was thought best to locate them permanently on the reservation. They were accordingly collected there, but trouble ensued between the Klamaths and Modocs. The reservation was in the Klamath county, and they acted very insolently towards the Modocs, taunting them with being interlopers. Captain Jack and his immediate followers left, and once more took up their residence on Lost river while Schonchin and his band, being more than half the tribe, were removed from the vicinity of the inhospitable Klamaths, and located at Yainox, near the southern extremity of the reservation.

Thus matters stood until the fall of 1869, when A. B. Meacham, Superintendent, gathered them all upon the reservation again. There were then collected about eight hundred Klamaths or La Lakes, three hundred and fifty Snakes or Walpohpes, and three hundred Modocs.

Bitter complaints were made by Captain Jack, of the treatment of his band by the agents that winter. He says they were stinted in clothing and starved in food. As an instance: The government allowed a double blanket to each Indian, but when they were distributed by the agent, they were cut into single blankets and then each one divided in the middle, thus making one Indian's allowance do for four, or one-fourth for the Indian and three-fourths for the ao-ent. Food was so scarce that some of the band were compelled to kill their horses to keep from starving. This was the complaint of Captain Jack and his band, when they shook the mud of the reservation from off their feet in the spring of 1870, vowing that they would die before they would return. The allegations of dishonest treatment were denied by the agents.

When they left Yainox the seceding Modocs went to Fairchilds' ranch and begged for food. That gentleman says that they were scantily clothed, appeared half starved, and looked generally wretched and miserable. He gave them some flour and meat, and they rehearsed the story of their wrongs at Yainox. Soon after they went to Yreka and told their tale of misery to Judge Steele, saying that they wanted to live at their old home on Lost river, and could not be taken back to Yainox alive. Steele promised to do what lie could for them, and they went back to their old quarters pear Tule lake.

For more than two years they lived on Lost river, supporting themselves by hunting and fishing, living peaceably and minding their own business. Old Schonchin, with his followers, remained contentedly at Yainox without starving, and to them the agents point as proof that the charges made by Captain Jack were false, and only trumped up by him as an excuse for leaving Yainox and living on Lost river.

Judge Steele, to whom the Indians had communicated a desire so to do, corresponded with the land department, to see if the Modocs could not each file upon a quarter-section of land where they were living, for a homestead. In 1S72 he received a letter from the department, saying that such action would be allowed. This letter he sent to Hendrick Miller, on Lost river, with the request that he explain it to the Indians, and have them come to Yreka, and he would attend to the business for them. This was the state of affairs when Superintendent Odeneal and others persuaded the Indian department to order the removal of Captain Jack to the reservation, thus precipitating the Modoc war with all its expense of life and treasure.

There seems to be considerable difference of opinion as to the conduct of Captain Jack's band while they lived on Lost river. The settlers who lived along that stream, which is in the State of Oregon, claimed that the Indians were very insolent and extortionate, coming in armed parties to their houses, frightening the women and children, and demanding beef and flour for the rent of the lands which they claimed to own. On the other hand, those on the California side of the line had no difficulty with them in this regard and got along peacefully. That there was a difference in the treatment of the settlers is possible, and it arose from the imperfect idea the Indians had of the relation the Boston men bore to each other. Being divided up into tribes, more or less hostile to each other, they naturally supposed the whites to also be in the same manner distinct tribes. In this idea they were confirmed by the fact that Oregon and California had different governments and the residents were spoken of as Oregonians and Californians, seeming to have interests somewhat at variance. With the California men they had made treaties, with them they had fought more or less and been whipped. The stock-men had demonstrated time and again that they were not afraid of them, and had in this way won their respect. Indians wei*e not allowed in the cabin or to hang around the premises unless required for some purpose. They were occasionally employed in odd jobs and always paid. As the Lost river settlers were supposed to belong to a different tribe they did not reap the benefit of the fear the Indians entertained for the stock-men. Again, some of them were but late comers and did not know how to treat the Indians. They were afraid of them, the more so because their wives and children were with them, and in case of trouble would be at the mercy of the savages. Being in this state of mind, if one Indian came along they would probably swear at him and order him to leave, but if half a dozen should appear with their guns, their conduct would be much different. They would ask them in, give them something to eat, and treat them with great hospitality, and then, when their visitors had departed, would tell how they had been compelled to give food to the Indians. The red men wei-e not slow to comprehend the situation and take advantage of it. The consequence was that, although they never went around levying toll upon the settlers, yet the latter were led by their fears to think they did so, and in such a state of mind it is no wonder that the appearance of a band of armed Indians should frighten the women and children and make the settlers uneasy. The Indians were lazy and would not work. When provisions ran low, when fish and game could not be procured in sufficient quantities, they would kill a beeve, the stock-men being the principal losers and making no complaint. Captain Jack and his band lived quietly at their camp on Lost river, and although harmless were no doubt unpleasant neighbors to have.

On the sixth of July, 1872, Col. Elmer Otis, Ivan D. Applegate, L. S. Dyar, Indian agent at Klamath reservation and T. B. Odeneal, superintendent of Indian affairs, petitioned the commissioner of Indian affairs at Washington to have the Indians removed to the reservation. In due time Superintendent Odeneal received authority to effect the removal, peaceably if he could, forcibly if he must. On the twenty-fifth of November he sent I. D. Applegate and James Brown to the camp on Tule lake, to request the head men to meet him at Linkville on the twenty-eighth. They declined the invitation. He at once repaired to Fort Klamath and placed the matter in the hands of the military. Captain Jackson immediately started for the Indian camp with Company B, First Cavalry, thirty-five men. He marched all night and reached the camp at daylight on the morning of the twenty-ninth. Jack's camp was on the west side of the river near Tule lake, at what is called the natural bridge. On the east side of the river was another small camp in which were Hooka Jim, Curley- Headed Doctor, Long Jim and nine other braves, these three being the head men. To this camp went Oliver Applegate, George Fiock and seven or eight settlers, while Ivan Applegate and James Brown accompanied the soldiers to the main camp. When the troops arrived at Jack's place the only Indian seen stirring was Bogus Charley, who was visiting there, his home being in this county. Captain Jackson's appearance was a great surprise to him, and the object of his coming was unknown.

Scarface Charley, who had been down by the river with the intention of duck hunting, heard the voices and came up to see what the trouble was, having his gun in his hand.

military methods, and would not inform the Indian why they were there and why they wanted to disarm him. Charley still refused to surrender his weapon, and Bou telle drew his revolver, cocked it and aimed it at the Indian, repeating his demand for the gun. Charley also cocked his weapon and watched the officer's hand. When he saw Boutelle's finger press the trigger, he dropped to the ground, firing his gun as he fell, rolled rapidly down the hill to the river, shouting at the same time to Captain Jack to fly, as the soldiers had come to kill him. The soldiers also fired a volley at Charley as he fell, and it was supposed for some time that they had killed him. The camp bow was in great uproar and confusion. The warriors wakened from their sleep by the sound of firing, seized their guns and sought sheltered places from which to fight, while the women and children fled for safety or fell prone upon the ground to avoid the flying bullets. At the time the shooting commenced Captain Jack was just issuing from his lodge, unarmed, and with a blanket thrown loosely about his shoulders. No sooner did he hear the discharge of fire-arms and the warning words of Scarface than he drew the blanket over his head and squatted upon the ground. There he remained during the fight, being mistaken for a squaw by the soldiers. The fighting continued for some two hours, the Indians finally effecting their retreat with their families, having lost two warriors, a squaw and a half-breed girl nine years old. One of Jackson's men was killed and four were wounded, some of which afterwards died.

While the battle was raging here, a terrible tragedy was being enacted on the other side of the river. The settlers who had gone to the camp of Hooka Jim and Curley-Headed Doctor, met first an Indian called Miller's Charley. He was told that they had come to take him and the others to the reservation, and that they would not be harmed. Upon this assurance he surrendered his gun, but had hardly done so when the sound of shooting and the yells of Indians were borne across the river from the other camp. The Indians rushed out, and in the confusion both parties commenced shooting, Miller's Charley being wounded, and One-Eyed Watchman killed. The warriors clashed for cover from which to fight, while the squaws sought safety in flight, or remained prostrate in their tents. One of the squaws rushed out with her baby in her arms, and what was evidently a stray bullet cut its slender cord of life. Not knowing her baby was dead, and still clasping it in her arms, she mounted a horse, exclaiming, "Don't shoot, me squaw, me squaw!" They did shoot, and she was wounded in the ankle, falling from her horse.

Maddened by this apparently wanton attack and slaughter, Hooka Jim, who had the most cruel and blood-thirsty disposition of them all, persuaded the others to go with him and take revenge on the settlers. One of the attacking party, John Thurber, known as " Jack of Clubs," was killed while walking about the camp after he supposed the fight was over. Hooka Jim's band hastened to the settlements along the river, bent upon murdering all they saw; and now commenced a scene of carnage and massacre. The settlers had been promised that they would be notified in case any action was taken that might lead to trouble with the Indiansj but the promise was not fulfilled. After the battle commenced Brown was sent on this mission, but the time was too short, and he could not reach all, many falling victims to this almost criminal procrastination.

The Indians first met William Neese and Joseph Penning, who were riding along the road unconscious of danger. They wei'e both shot, Neese being killed and Penning severely wounded. Mr. Brotherton and his two sons were next killed, while the mother with her two younger sons barricaded the house and successfully defended it, being rescued two days later. Hendrick Miller and his hired man were killed, also John Schroeder. Mrs. Boddy and her three sons were killed, while the wives of two of them escaped by walking nine miles, scantily clothed, and sleeping upon the cold ground. In all there were fourteen settlers killed before armed parties could protect them and compel the Indians to seek safety in flight.

They made their way to the lava beds at the south end of Tule lake, whither Captain Jack and his band had already retreated. In order to comprehend fully the events which transpired during the next six months, it is necessary to have a good idea of the nature and formation of this rocky fastness. This is a mass of rocks some ten miles square, cut up with fissures, deep gulches, and high and abrupt cliffs, abounding in caves and almost untraversable save by those well acquainted with the trails and passages. Troops in here were as much lost as though in a jungle, while the Indians, familiar with all the secret passes and caves, could flit about from place to place, and pick off the unwary intruder in perfect security. The description given by Jesse Applegate, one of the first peace commissioners, cannot be improved upon : -

The stronghold of the Modocs is an irregular volcanic surface of basalt, trachyte, etc., more or less broken into upheavals from below, and cracked and 'fissured in the process of cooling. It occupies, with but few intervals, nearly one hundred square miles. If you can, imagine a smooth, solid sheet of granite, ten miles square and five hundred feet thick, covering resistless mines of gunpowder, scattered at irregular intervals under it; that these mines are exploded simultaneously, rending the whole field into rectangular masses, from the size of a match box to that of a church, heaping these masses high in some places, and leaving deep chasms in others. Following the explosion, the whole thing is placed in one of Vulcan's crucibles, and heated up to a point when the whole begins to fuse and run together, and then suffered to cool. The roughness of the surface remains as the explosion left it, while all below is honeycombed by the cracks and crevices caused by the cooling of the melted rock. An Indian can, from the top of one of these stone pyramids, shoot a man without exposing even so much as an inch square of himself. He can, without undue haste, load and shoot a common muzzle-loading rifle ten times, before a man can scramble ever the rocks and chasms between the slain and the slayer. If at this terrible expense of life, a force dislodges him from his cover, he has only to drop into and follow some subterraneous passage with which he is familiar, to gain another ambush, from which it will cost ten more lives to dislodge him, and so on adinfinitum.

From the high rocks in this great fortress of nature, the Indians could observe the movements of the troops five miles away, without being themselves seen. In this way, during the whole campaign, they were enabled to inform themselves of every maneuver, or change of plan of operations by the soldiers, while they moved in perfect secrecy, appearing unexpectedly in many places, moving rapidly from point to point, ready to take advantage of any careless- ness or exposure by their enemies. Added to this was the fact that they were nearly all armed with breech-loading rifles, and had a large supply of metallic cartridges. All these, and the additional fact that they were firmly convinced that their liberty and even their lives were at stake, must be borne constantly in mind when considering the events of this unparalleled campaign.

All was confusion and anxiety along Lost river and at Linkville. The settlers hastened to places of safety in all directions, some going to Linkville, some to Alturas, and others to various places. No one felt secure within a radius of fifty miles. Fourteen people had been cruelly murdered, and the murderers were still at large, no one knew where. They were liable to appear at any point and wreak vengeance on the unprotected heads of lone settlers. If their whereabouts was only known, so that the troops could watch them, there would be a measure of security, but the dreadful uncertainty was the most anxious feature of all. Their retreat in the lava beds was discovered in the following manner: -

On the night before the attack on the Indian camps, Samuel Watson stayed at Fairchilds' ranch at the lower end of Klamath lake. The next morning he pursued his journey towards Lost river, and wlien near that stream was met by Scarface Charley and Bogus Charley. They informed him of the fight, and advised him to return, saying that some of the other Indians who were not acquainted with him would be sure to kill him. This seemed to be good advice, and he acted upon it. Arriving again at Fairchilds' that night he imparted his startling intelligence. This created great uneasiness at the ranch, for the agents had promised to warn them in case of trouble, and now a battle had taken place without their knowledge. The Hot Creek Modocs lived near the ranch, and had they received the first intelligence of hostilities, could have committed many depredations. Besides this, thousands of cattle were roaming the valleys and hills, which the Indians could destroy or scatter so that it would be impossible to recover them.

Fairchilds descried an Indian in the distance, riding like mad towards the camp, and he pointed to him, saying to some Indian boys, "There comes an Indian with the news, you run down to camp before he gets there, and tell them that Captain Jack and tne soldiers have had a fight, and I want them to come up here and tell me what they know about it." Away ran the boys and reached the camp at the same time the messenger rode up with his startling intelligence, and soon several excited Indians hastened to the ranch. They knew nothing of the cause of the trouble, and wanted Fairchilds to explain. They looked upon him as a great Tyee, who knew all the plans of the whites, and he had a hard time convincing them that he was as ignorant as they of the cause of the recent unpleasantness on Lost river. An agreement was made that the Hot Creek band would remain peaceable, for the present at hast, and in case a war followed and they joined the hostiles, they would not molest the settlers. This having been done, Fairchilds and Nate Beswick, accompanied by Shacknasty Jim and another Indian, started for Lo>t river on a tour of observation, having first sent word through the valley that there was

When they arrived at Jack's camp abundant evidences of a battle were found on every hand, but not a human being could be seen. All the boats had been destroyed, and they were thus unable to cross the river. Going along the bank they heard voicqs on the opposite side, and called out, but received no answer. The two Indians being seen on the bank gave rise to the story that the Indians had returned the day after the light, and yelled at the people from across the river, a belief that had largely served to create the anxiety and fear of another raid which all the settlers felt.

Upon their return to the ranch they learned that the Indians had been informed of Captain Jack's lurking place. A few days later, Fairchilds, Dorris, Beswick, and Murray, accompanied by the two Indians, paid Jack a visit in his stronghold. They found him occupying a cave in the rocks, about two hundred yards from the lake. This was so walled in by rocks, chasms, and precipitous bluffs, and so accessible to water, that it was the best spot in the whole lava region to withstand a long siege, and make a good defense. They spent the night in the cave, and had a long talk with Jack and others about their difficulty with the troops. Jack said he was ignorant of the reason why the soldiers had attacked his camp; that he had clone nothing, and could not undei stand why the soldiers should cnme and fight him; that he had murdered no settlers, but that the killing had been done by Hooka Jim and the band across the river, in revenge for the death of his baby; that he had had many opportunities to kill Boston men if he had so desired, but that he only wanted to fight soldiers; he did not want to fight at all, but if the soldiers came to the lava beds after him, he would fight them; that he would not go to Yainox, but wanted to live at his home on Lost river in peace. In his treaty with Fairchilds, Jack had reserved the Lost River camp for a residence, considering that he had sold the balance of the country to the stock-men. He maintained until the time of his death, that in the treaty of 1864 with the government, he had not agreed to abandon Lost river; and if the treaty said he must go to the reservation, he had been deceived when it was made. He requested Fairchilds and Dorris to go to the so'diers, and tell them not to come where he was or he would fight them. When the two embassadors arrived at the camp of the troops, they found there three companies of regulars, two having come in haste from Camp Warner, also two companies of volunteers from Rogue River valley and Linkville, and a number of Klamath or La Lake Indians. The volunteers, some sixty in all, were commanded by Captains Kelley and Heiser, acting under the orders of General Ross, in command of the Oregon militia, who was present. The location of Jack's camp was still unknown to the troops, and soon after their arrival at headquarters, they observed that details were being made for scout duty. Knowing that this would result in a conflict and the death of many of the troops, the two messengers concluded that the time had come for them to speak. Fairchilds addressed Captain Jackson, and said he had a message from Captain Jack.

William Davidson

William Davidson is a son of James and Orpha (Wells) Davidson, and was born near Wheeling, West Virginia, November 30, 1826. His parents moved to Ohio and later to Indiana, settling near La Fayette. In 1S50 he crossed the plains to Shasta county, and in 1851 went to Yreka. That winter he mined on Humbug, being one of the first in that district. In the fall of 1852 he went to Deadwood with the first discovery of gold there, where he mined with good success. He was also engaged in merchandising at the same place. In company with his brother, Dr. D. M. Davidson, in the fall of 1852 he settled on a ranch near Fort Jones, still keeping his store at Deadwood. He commenced a butchering business, and during the hard times of that memorable winter of 1852-53 had a contract to supply meat at Fort Jones for forty cents per pound. He was married in February, 1853, and moved to Scott valley and commenced farming. December 3, 1853, his first son, James M., was born, the first white child born in Scott valley. Mr. Davidson sold part of his first crop for fifteen dollars per bushel. In 1854, in company with D. M. Davidson and Charles

McDermit, he built the old iEtna mills at a cost of $35,000. He moved to old Etna the same fall, opened a store and built the Etna Hotel. In 1857 he built at that place the Scott Valley distillery, in company with his brothers, and was engaged in milling and distilling until 1870. He went to the northern mines in Idaho, but returned after a year's absence. In 1870 he engaged in the cattle business in Shasta county, and in 1872 removed to Fall River valley, where he still resides. Mr. Davidson has always been a firm Democrat, and taken a prominent part in political affairs, and is now serving his second term as supervisor of Shasta county. He was once the Democratic candidate for sheriff of Siskiyou county, but was defeated by the soldier vote. Mr. Davidson had four children, two of whom, James M. and Narcissa, are still living. James was educated at the State University, and is now Deputy United States Mineral Surveyor, and resides at Yreka. At a reunion of the Davidson family at the residence of I. S. Mathews, at Fort Jones, on the seventy-second birthday of Mrs. Orpha Davidson, there were present forty-five members from Scott valley alone.

The officers were quickly collected in a tent and Fairchilds delivered the message briefly. " There is no use of your sending scouts out to hunt up Captain Jack, for I can tell you just where he is." The position of the cave in the lava beds was then described, and he remarked in closing, " you had better keep away from there or you will get hurt; he says that if you go there he will fight you, and he means business."

"It don't make any difference, you can't drive them out with less than five hundred men, and if you go in there, its my opinion they'll walk your

A few days after this conversation, Colonel Frank Wheatun, of the Seeondr Infantry, arrived and assumed command. Headquarters were moved to Van Brimer's ranch, on the east side of Klamath lake and near, the lava beds. The Klamath Indians were sent back to the reservation, as the soldiers had little confidence in them, and Captain Jack claimed that they were committing depredations and charging them to the Modocs.

Great preparations were now made to expel Captain Jack from his stronghold among the rocks. By request of Colonel Wheaton a company of volunteers Was raised, chiefly of settlers, vaqueros and a few from Yreka. The company numbei'ed twenty-six men and elected John A. Fairchilds captain, and George Roberts, lieutenant. The Indians drove a good many cattle and horses into the lava beds, the former of which they killed, drying the meat for future use. They also busied themselves in strengthening their almost impregnable fortress. The anxiety to find them being over, a new fear that they would break out from their rocky retreat, and lay waste the country with tire and gun took its place. Alturas, Linkville, Ashland, Jacksonville and Yreka were all in daily expectation of the appearance of these half hundred warriors to sack and burn the town. The advent of Lee's army in Washington was no more feared and expected than was the appearance of Captain Jack's spartan band in the streets of Yreka. The fear also that other Indians would become hostile added to the general uneasiness. Shot-guns, rifles and revolvers were inspected and placed on a war footing. He who hail none borrowed of his neighbor who had two, and when Governor Booth sent up fifty old muskets, to be used in the protection of settlers, twenty were sent to the front, where the Indians were, and thirty were kept in the town, where the Indians were not and were not fools enough to come. It was probably all for the best, for these guns were suffering from a severe attack of antiquity.

And still the war went on. Troops continued to arrive until there were over two hundred and fifty regulars in the field. Several guns and three hundred shells were received from Fort Vancouver, and two guns were forwarded from Camp Bidwell. Captain Barnard was stationed with a detachment on the east side of the lava beds, the soldiers being thus on both sides of the hostiles. Quite a force had to be maintained at Fort Klamath, so great was thtv fear that the Modocs, Snakes and Klamaths there would become turbulent. The Piutes and Pit River Indians were carefully watched, to guard against any outbreak by them. Colonel Wheaton did not want to risk a battle until there was almost a certainty of success, as a victory by the Modocs would serve but to increase the uneasiness of the other Indians, and might lead to a general outbreak.

The first hostilities in the lava beds occurred on the twenty first of December. A wagon of supplies from Camp Bidwell, escorted by six soldiers, was sent along the Tickner road to Barnard's camp. When near its destination it was attacked by the Indians, who had been closely watching the camp for the purpose of picking off stragglers. Captain Barnard came to the rescue with his company and saved the wagons, although one soldier was killed and scalped and three were wounded, one of whom died. An Indian named Steve was killed in this fight.

All the preparations having been carefully made, a grand assault was ordered for Friday, January 17, 1873, by which it was expected to end the war with one hard blow. The plan of attack was to have Captain Barnard advance on the east and form a junction with the right wing of the main body on the south of the stronghold. The right wing was composed of the Oregon volunteers, the center of regulars, under Captains Perry and Mason, and on the left was Fairchilds' company. When this junction was formed there would be a line of troops on the east, south and west, while the lake would form the fourth side. They were then to close in upon the Indians and take them like a fish in a net. Captain Barnard advanced on the east, Thursday, to within two miles of the cave, losing several killed and wounded, among the latter being Lieutenant Kyle. One Indian was wounded, Old Shacknasty's Man. Friday morning dawned with a thick bank of fog hanging over the ground, that would have induced Colonel Wheaton to postpone the assault, had he been able to communicate with Captain Barnard. Not being able to do this he ordered an advance. The dense fog not only prevented them from seeing the enemy, but also from properly co-operating with and supporting each other. The advance was opposed at every point by a hidden and unseen foe. The troops charged over several almost inaccessible places, meeting a shower of bullets, but finding no enemy. So rapidly did the Indians change their positions and so incessant a fire did they maintain, although there were but about twenty good warriors there seemed to be many times that number. For a long time the troops fought their unseen foe, losing many in killed and wounded, without being able to inflict any injury upon the enemy. Failing to join the two commands on the south, it was determined to pass around the bluff on the lake shore and join Barnard in that direction. This movement was effected after tin- most severe fighting of the day. The lo3s during the day was ten killed and thirty wounded. Captain Perry was wounded. Two of the killed were Oregon volunteers, while four of the wounded, some of whom died, belonged to Fairchilds' company, and were George Roberts, Nate Beswick, Jerry Crooks and Judson Small. It was afterwards known that not any damage whatever was inflicted upon the Indians, who as fruits of their victoiy secured the guns and ammunition of the slain. After this defeat, for such it really was, the troops withdrew to their original positions. Whatever had been their opinion of the fighting qualities of the Modocs, they were now convinced that they had caught a tartar. The strength of the position and the ability of the Indians to defend it were more fully apparent than ever before. The news spread consternation for fifty miles around. Each dusky warrior became an invincible host in the imagination of the people, and as their opinion of the Indian prowess ascended, in the same ratio did their estimation of the ability of the military to cope with them descend. Wild rumors of hundreds of disaffected Snakes, Piutes and Pit River Indians flocking to Jack's standard filled the air.

It was supposed that there were more Indians in this fight than had been known to be with Jack. It was afterwards ascertained that the enemy had placed great numbers of blocks of volcanic scoria on the edge of the rocks. These were dark colored and about the size of a human head, and at a short distance closely resembled the head of an Indian peeping around a pile of rocks. It was even declared that there were two hundred warriors engaged in the last battle, and it was expected that the effect of the Modoc victory would be to augment Jack's force to a small army, even if it did not cause a general Indian war.

General Canby, who in the absence of General McDowell was in command of this department, sent Colonel Gillem to the field to supersede Colonel Wheaton, whose only fault was that he had failed where it was impossible to succeed. More troops were forwarded, and mortars for the purpose of shelling the Indian stronghold, were brought with

On the morning of January 23d, they suddenly attacked an escort of twenty-two men moving two wagons to Barnard's camp. The attack was made four miles from the camp to which intelligence was instantly conveyed. The cavah-y came down at a gallop and crowded the Indians so hard that they abandoned their ponies and fled into the mazes of the lava beds on foot. Forty-five cayuse ponies were captured. The soldiers suffered no loss, but reported one Indian killed and three wounded, which was found to be untrue. One advantage the Modocs had in all their conflicts with the whites was their knowledge of the English language. They could hear and understand all the orders given by the officers, and could thus be ready to oppose any movement. All their orders or information shouted from one to the other, and they kept continually shouting to each other, were given in the Modoc tongue, and were as Greek to the troops.

The evidences of a long campaign were now plentiful, and the troops settled down to stay. Many people visited the front, and correspondents were maintained there by the "leading newspapers of the country. Every time an Indian coughed or an officer waxed his moustache the fact was telegraphed throughout the land, and appeared in the papers under enormous head-lines. The people read the exploits of these dusky warriors with astonishment bordering on admiration. They thought that these must be of no common clay to hold the flower of the army so long at bay. The situation was misapprehended by all not familiar with the place and the people. The Indians occupied a natural fortress that probably has not a superior in the world, and what to the soldiers was an unknown labyrinth, to them was as familiar as the streets of a city. They did no more than any half hundred determined men could have done in the same situation. It seemed, however, as wonderful as the exploits of the knights of old, and people in their far-off Eastern homes, I'ose in the morning and seized the paper to see by what exploit the Modocs had added new laurels to their wreath since last they read.

To the front came also many who were seeking not the " bauble reputation," but the " current coin of the realm." Stores and eating-houses were established, and the proprietors reaped a rich harvest. For them the war, long as it was, ended all too soon, and they were left to wail their disappointment. Supplies for them and the troops required many teams to haul them, ami the rates of freight from Redding, Yreka and Jacksonville were very high. Fire-wood sold for fifteen dollars, eggs one dollar a dozen, oysters one dollar a can, tobacco two dollars a pound, whisky twenty -five cents a drink; beef and flour were plentiful and cheap.

In February Donald McKay, a half-breed and a practiced seout, and fifty Warm Spring Indians, from the Warm Spring reservation in Oregon, were sent for. They ha 1 rendered good service in Indian wars farther north, and could be depended upon to do scout duty well and faithfully. Three boats were built on Lost river, to be used on the lake to prevent the Indians from obtaining water. It was thought that there was nothing in the lava beds but snow water, and in this way they could prevent the hostiles from procuring enough water for tJKrnselves and stock. _=. ^

In February, the government appointed a peace commission to investigate the condition and complaints of the Indians, and confer with the hostiles about a settlement of the present difficulties. The members of the commission wei'e Jesse Applegate, A. B. Meacham, and Samuel Chase - all connected with the Indian department. The military were instructed to suspend hostilities while the negotiations were pending, but to so dispose the forces as to protect the settlers. General Canby was ordered to go to the front with the commissioners, and take full command of the military, Colonel Gillem commanding under him. On the twentieth of February, the commissioners having all arrived at headquarters, Bob Whittle's Modoc wife, Matilda, and a squaw named Artinie were sent to Jack's camp to arrange for a conference. The following day they returned with a report that there were but fortyfour warriors in the lava beds. Jack sent word by them that he was glad to receive a message from the peace commissioners. He complained bitterly of the part the volunteers had taken in the fight, as he only wanted to fight soldiers. He had given orders that no settlers should be killed, and he did not think they had any right to help the soldiers fight him. He said he did not want to talk to women, but wanted the commissioners to pay him a visit, and they would not be harmed. She said they were Daked and cold, and nearly out of provisions. That there was dissension in their midst, some wanting John Schonchin for chief, while others preferred Jack.

Whittle and wife then paid Jack a visit, who said that he had lost but three braves since the fight began, and suffered no loss in the biff fight in the lava beds. He wanted Judge Steele, Judge Rosborough and John A. Fairchilds added to the commissioners, as they were his friends. An agreement was made to hold a conference on the twenty-fifth a mile and a half from the lava beds where there could be no ambuscade. General Canby telegraphed to Washington, and Judge A. M. Rosborough was added to the commission. It was impossible for Judge Steele to be there at the time appointed, and so on the twenty-fourth Fairchilds, Whittle, Matilda, Indian Dave, and Edward Fox, correspondent of the New York Herald, Avent to the cave to explain the situation. They remained all night, and counted sixty bucks capable of bearing arms. Jack said he did not like Meacham and Applegate, and wanted to treat with Canby, Fairchilds, Steele, and Rosborough - all of whom he considered great Tyees.

When Steele and Rosborough arrived in camp, Steele, Fairchilds, Fox, H. W. Atwell, correspondent of the Sacramento Record- Union, and another reporter, went to the cave, where they found Jack sick. They talked that night and in the morning with Jack and Schonchin, who made bitter complaints of the way in which they had been treated at the agency. Steele laid before them the terms offered by Canby, which were, to surrender and be removed to a more southern and warmer locality and be provided with a reservation by the government. They then returned to headquarters accompanied by Bogus Charley, Hooka Jim, Long Jim, Boston Charley, Duffy, Shacknasty Jim, Cuiiey- Headed Jack, and William, who went down to talk with Colonel Gillem and the commissioners. The visiting Indians returned to the cave on Tuesday.

Steele and the reporters again went to the cave and returned the next day with the same Indians to make final arrangements for a meeting with General Canby in person. The Princess Mary, Jack's sister, also came this time. They said that Jack and Schonchin both agreed to the terms offered by Steele and were sorry they would have to leave their country. The following message was sent by them from Canby to Jack : -

We are not mad, but sorry. Our hearts were sad because you opened your hearts to your enemies and closed them to your friends. I want Captain Jack and all who can to come here to-morrow. I will have tents, food, and clothing for them. It is not safe for Captain Jack to go to Yainox, for bad men will kill him. I will send to Yainox for his friends and have them come here. All his people at Yainox can come, and all who desire can go to the new country. I recognize Captain Jack as chief, and want him to come here so that I may treat with him and arrange particulars. If any of his people in the lava beds are sick and cannot come, I will send a wagon for them. I cannot send the soldiers away. They are his best friends and will not hurt him. I want them now, if they mean peace, to come out with clean hands to-morrow, and none shall be hurt. Captain Jack and some of his men can go and see the Great Chief, and look at the country he will give them. I promise this for

The messengers returned the next day, sayinothat Jack wanted three wagons to meet him at two o'clock Monday, the tenth, at the Point of Rocks, twelve miles from headcpiarters. Early Monday morning, Steele started with four wagons and their teamsters, for the place of rendezvous. When they ascended a ridge two miles from the Point of Rocks, no Indians could be seen at the appointed place. This was suspicious. If they were there in good faith, they should be in full view and not hidden. Steele halted the wagons and rode on alone, to see if the Indians were in ambush, but found no sicn of them for two miles beyond the point. He returned to the wagons and endeavored to persuade the teamsters to go on to the lake, but all but one, David Horn, refused to proceed. About this time an object was descried moving beyond the point, and Steele again rode on to investigate. He found it to be a man named Louis Land, from upper Oregon, who was journeying through the country, and was unaware of any trouble. He said that he had seen no Indians, and when informed of recent events, thanked his lucky stars that he had seen none. As it was useless to look further, the wagons returned to camp. Tents had been erected to accommodate the Indians, and an abundance of hay, firewood, and food, provided for their comfort, and the return of Steele without them was a great disappointment.

A consultation was held, and Steele agreed to go in again and see what was the matter. He was accompanied only by Atwell, the other reporters remarking that "they didn't own any Indians in there," and would remain in camp. Bogus Charley, the most treacherous of the Modocs, betraying during the war both the wdntes and his own people, was at the camp, and accompanied them in. When they reached the chasm that leads by a long route up to the cave, Charley said "good-bye," and rode away from them. This was a bad sign, but they rode on to the usual place of tying the horses, wdiich was a wide place in the chasm where some sagebrush grew. Here they met Frank Riddle, the interpreter for the commission, and his Modoc wife, who had preceeded them, and who warned them that the Indians were in a bad frame of mind. Steele was convinced of this, but it was too late to turn back, and so they went on. When they reached Bogus Charley's camp, they found a squaw, wdio grunted her ignorance of her lord's whereabouts. It was now dark, and they preferred to go to the cave and brave the Indians there, than to wander about in the darkness at the mercy of any who might chance to feel an inner prompting to shoot them. Riddle objected to going, but was persuaded to do so.

Their advent into the cave was received with a grunt and then a deep hush full upon the circle of warriors gathered about the smouldering fire. Steele had a squaw throw a stick of wood on the fire so that he might have lightly which to scrutinize the countenances of those about him, and then the two white men seated themselves in the circle of warriors. As the flames leaped up towards the opening in the cave above, and shed a lurid glare upon the objects in the cavern, they revealed a circle of scowling and malignant faces. It did not require one deeply versed in Indian physiognomy, to see that those' were the faces of bitter enemies. Steele commenced to talk. He told them of the preparations Canby had made to receive them, how grieved he was that they had not come, and asked them why they had broken their word. While he was talking his eye was observing everything in the cave. He counted sixty-nine warriors, twenty-five of them being strangers that he then supposed to be Snakes, but afterwards discovered were Klamaths from the reservation and Pit River Indians. It was very evident that these visitors were largely responsible for the condition of affairs. They were there encouraging the hostiles with offers of assistance. Besides this the messengers who had been at headquarters had heard of the indictments found by the grand jury of Jackson county, Oregon, against nine of them for the murder of settlers, and had heard threats of hanging the whole band.

Schonchin replied to Steele in an angry and excited manner. He accused him of acting with duplicity, and refused to treat on any terms but an extinguishment of all past offenses and permission to remain where they were. His remarks were applauded by all but Jack, Scarface, and a few others. Jack made a speech in favor of peace, and Bogus Charley went up to him and crowned hiin with a squaw's cap, calling him a coward and a woman, an act which was also applauded. Steele again spoke and said that he was not a chief, and could agree to no terms for them, but would lay any proposition they might make before General Canby. The conversation was carried on by him in the Chinook jargon, it being translated by those who understood it for the benefit of the others. He understood the Modoc tongue, but the Indians did not know it, neither did Riddle who had departed from the cave. By this means he was able to understand all the remarks that were freely made by the warriors. Schonchin now began haranguing about the Ben. Wright massacre, accusing the whites of base treachery, until Steele told him to shut up, as he had heard enough. All the while a warm discussion was going on as to whether the two men should be killed or not. Some were in favor of doing it then, while others said that it was best to wait until they could get the chiefs into their power, as Steele had told them he was no Tyee. The faintest sign of fear or intimation that the character of the conversation was understood, would have sealed their death warrant. Steele watched Atwell with great anxiety. He was fearful that he might get an inkling of the situation and betray the fact, but the knight of the quill sat on a stone as stoical as the most impassive Indian. Satisfied that his companion was in blissful ignorance of his nearness to the grave, he turned again to the scowling savages. Schonchin had been talking almost incessantly, and now, in a fit of passion, asked Steele if he was not afraid to sleep in the cave as he did the last time. He replied that he was afraid of nothing, that his heart was good and he was not afraid to die, that he was going to sleep if he did not live till morning.

cave they would let him go, in the hope of being able to get the chiefs in their power. When he was asked if he could and would bring the commissioners and Canby to the cave, he promised to do so, and the council broke up. Scarface had whispered to Steele to sleep on his mat, which lay near a big rock in the cave, and when the talk was finished after midnight, he turned and gently kicked the owner of the mat, and said,

The other Indians withdrew to their various camps, which were in other caves or among the rocks outside, leaving the two men with Scarface and Captain Jack. The mat was made of two rushes, and was just large enough for the two visitors. Scarface lay across the end at their head, and Jack stretched himself at their feet. Ellen's Man mounted guard on top of the cave with two Henry rifles and all the ammunition he could pack about him. This was necessary, as an enemy from the outside could shoot down into the cavern and kill any one sleeping there.

The night passed quietly away, and in the morning, having renewed his promise to bring Canby, Rosborough, Meacham, Applegate, and Chase to the cave, Steele took his departure with his companion. They mounted their horses and worked their way carefully up to a ridge about two miles from the cave. When they surmounted this, and a long stretch of good road was spread out before them, Atwell bioke the silence by saying,

When they reached camp they rehearsed their adventures, and Steele told the commissioners of the promise he had made to save their lives. He said he would never go back, and he strongly urged Canby and the others not to go to the cave and never to put themselves in the power of the Modocs, as it would be equivalent to their death. He then returned to Yreka. Judge Rosborough went to Shasta to hold court. Applegate and Chase left in disgust refusing to have anything more to do with the negotiations.

The situation was not comprehended by the authorities at Washington. They thought peace could still be made, and would not permit hostilities to be resumed. The commission was recognized, and consisted of General Canby, Judge Rosborough, A. B. Meacham, T. B. Odeneal and Rev. Dr. E. Thomas, of Petaluma. Odeneal declined and Reservation Agent L. S. Dyar was appointed.

Was born at Barnesville, Pike county, Georgia, October 3, 1852. His father was James Nutting, still living near Marietta, Cobb county, Georgia, and engaged in farming, aged about fifty-five years. His mother's maiden mame was Epsie Adeline Holmes. She died in her fortieth year, in November, 1872. When sixteen years old, the subject of our sketch finished his school days at the private school of Profs. Baker and Manget, at Marietta. In January. 1870, he went into the bank of John H. James, Atlanta, twenty miles from his home. He continued there four years. He left the bank in January, 1874, and began studying medicine in October of that year, and also attended lectures at Atlanta Medical College, of the regular school. He graduated near the head in his class in 1876. In anatomy and surgery he ranked the highest among all graduates for ten years. For two successive collegiate years he held the position as demonstrator of anatomy with considerable credit to himself and the institution, being one of the city physicians at the same time. In 1878 Dr. C. M. Hill, of Etna, withdrew for his old home in the southern part of Georgia. Dr. Nutting, then in his twenty-sixth year, corresponded with him and took his practice, which he still holds to the present day. The practice is very extensive, he being obliged to travel much by night and day. Although quite a new-comer, the doctor, by prompt attention to business, by his skill as a surgeon and physician, and gentlemanly bearing to all classes, has become quite popular and bids fair to remain as a permanent citizen of the county. The other members of his family are: - Millard H., teller in the Atlanta National Bank, the eldest ; James R., a cotton buyer at Atlanta ; Lutie A., wife of Mr. Brown, a planter near Marietta, Georgia ; and Minnie F., now at her father's home.

thirty-four in all, but did not molest the Indians. On the twenty- first of March General Canby and Colonel Gillem went on a scout with the cavalry to the lava beds, and were met by Indians on a bluff. The Modocs said they wanted two men to come up and talk. Dr. Cabaniss and Edward Fox, the Herald correspondent, advanced, and were held as hostages while Jack, Scarface and Curley-Headed Doctor went out and met Canby and Gillem. Jack stated his terms to be let alone and be permitted to live on Lost river. Nothing was accomplished by this interview.

Thus time wore on. About the last of March Dr. Thomas arrived at headquarters. When he passed through Yreka he had a long conversation with Judge Steele about the situation, and was warmly urged not to put himself in the power of the Indians.

Messengers kept going back and forward between Canby and Jack, but to little effect. The Indians evidently striving for delay in the hope of receiving the assistance promised them by other tribes. On the third of April, Judge Rosborough, the last of peace commissioners arrived in camp, arrangements having been made for a grand council to be held the following day. A council tent was erected some distance from the camp, in which to hold the conference. About nine o'clock the next morning, Boston Charley came in and said Jack would not go to the tent, but wanted Meacham, Fairchilds, Rosborousdi and Riddle to meet him on the lake shore. They went, and Jack stated that his terms were to have the soldiers removed and himself given a reservation on Lost river. Meacham said he could not have a home on Lost river, as he would be in perpetual trouble with the settlers. Jack then insisted that he should be allowed to live in lava beds or on Hot creek, and said to send his proposition to Washington, and when an answer came back they would have another talk.

On the sixth, Boston again came in with a proposition for Canby, Gillem and the commissioners to meet Jack and seven others at a cave in the lava beds. Steele's warning of intended treachery led to the rejection of this and all similar proposals, until the fatal step was taken that led to a realization of the value of that warning. Judcre Rosborough was compelled to return to Shasta to hold court, and could participate no further in the actions of the commission. Boston again came in on the seventh, and proposed a conference of five on each side the following day. This was accepted, but the Indians failed to appear, sending the excuse that one of the braves was dead. Boston again came on the ninth, and said that Jack wanted to surrender, but Schonchin would not consent. On the tenth, both Bogus Charley and Boston Charley appeared, and proposed that a meeting be held on the following day at the council tent in the glade, both parties to be entirely unarmed. The terms were accepted and Bogus remained all night in camp, while Boston went back with the news. During the long suspension of hostilities, the Indians in their frecpient visits to the camp had been treated with unvarying kindness. They had been given food, clothing, and tobacco. In fact, so much better had they been treated than the soldiers and friendly Indians, that complaints and murmurings were heard. It was thought by this

The morning of the fatal eleventh of April, 1873, broke fair and calm. After breakfast, during which the two messengers (Boston having returned in the morning) sat at the same table with those they soon after assisted treacherously to murder, preparations were made for the coming council. Fairchilds was fearful of treachery from the way the two Indians acted, and asked them if they did not want him to come also. They said no, they only wanted Canby, Gillem, Thomas, Meacham and Dyar, besides the interpreters. He talked with them a little more, and then warned the commissioners that in his opinion they were going to certain death. Riddle and his Modoc wife, Tobey, both gave the same opinion. It was suggested that they take revolvers along, but they said that was a violation of the agreement. Meacham and Dyar were loth to go, being now satisfied that treachery was intended, but Canby, no less certain of the fact than they, thought his duty and honor as a soldier required him to go, and Dr. Thomas said that it could not be possible that the Indians would act in bad faith after the great kindnesses that had been shown them, and that God would watch over and protect them in their mission of peace. He believed what he said, and it cost him his life. General Canby preserved his soldier's honor at the same fearful price. Meacham and Dyar were both uneasy. They feared treachery. Riddle gave them a last warning: "Gentlemen, 1 have been talking with my wife; she has never told me a lie nor deceived me, and she says if you go to-day you will be killed. We wash our hands of all blame. If you must go, go well armed. I give you my opinion because I do not want to be blamed hereafter." Fairchilds also added a word: "It is my firm conviction that if you go out there to-day you will never come back." Meacham and Dyar were both convinced. They endeavored to have the interview abandoned, or to have them go armed, or to at least have Fairchilds go along with a revolver, but Canby and Thomas would not listen to the propositions. They were a breach of faith, and honor with the soldier was more than life. Canby was then entreated to promise to rpmove the soldiers from the country, if it was demanded and the Indians were armed, but he looked up resolutely and said: " Gentlemen, I will never promise anything I do not intend to perform." The sentiment was echoed by the venerable minister, and the brave soldier anil Christain disciple staited on foot for the council tent. The one arrayed in his full uniform, marched boldly to his death at the call of duty ; the other, a man of peace, followed trustingly whither the voice of his God led him. With these went B gus Charley, with his ride on his shoulder. He was the most treacherous ami cruel of them all, but had completely won the good Doctor's heart bj pretending to have become good, or playing what is commonly known as the " pious dodge " upon'the old gentleman. To him and Boston the kind hearted man had but the day before given new suits of clothes, and it wag hard to believe that he now walked by the venerable man's side with murder in hishearfc. Meacham and Dyar both put little derringer pistols in their coal pockets, and leaving directions with their friends of their disposition in case of death, mounted their horses. Meachani was chairman of the commission, and was ashamed to remain after the other two had gone. Dyar was too proud to stay away. Accompanied by Tobey on horseback, and Riddle, who said in case of trou hie he did not want to be bothered with a horse, they set out towards the council tent. Gillem remained behind to command the troops, who were held in readiness for an emergency. Leaving them on their way, let us see to whom and to what they were going.

Ever since the adventure of Steele and Atwell in the cave, a month before, the murder of the commissioners and the head officers had been a bone of contention among the Indians. The majority were in favor of it, while Jack, Scarface and a few others violently opposed it. There were two considerations that led to the action - revenge for the Ben. Wright massacre, which was the ruling motive of Schonchin, who was present at that event, and a belief that the death of the Tyees would end the trouble, and let them make peace on their own terms. So little did they understand the nature, power, and resources of our government, they actually believed this would be the result of the death of Canby and the commissioner's. It was largely owing to this dissension among the Modocs that negotiations were delayed, broken off, and resumed so many times.

When Boston Charley returned to the cave with the news that the commissioners had agreed to meet five of them unarmed the next day, a heated discussion arose between the twro factions. Schonchin was eager for the murder, while Jack insisted that it should not be done. They gathered around him, put a woman's hat on his head, and threw a shawl over his shoulders. While thus arrayed they taunted him, said he was a squaw and a coward, a traitor to his people, that he had established a principle that the majority should rule, and now he would not abide by it. Stung to the quick by these taunts, he stood up among the reviling circle of demons and gave his assent. Having now undertaken the task, he claimed the right as chief to manage the whole affair, and kill General Canby himself. Plans were carefulby laid. It was decided that Captain Jack, Schonchin, Hooka Jim, Black Jim, Ellen's Man, and Shacknasty Jim, should go to the tent armed with revolvers. These, with Boston and Bogus, who were to come with the whites, would make eight, three more than the stipulated number. Besides this, Slolux and Watchin-tate were to be secreted near by with several rifles, and were to rush up when the signal was given. To each of the five expected victims, Canby, Gillem, Thomas, Meacham, and Dyar, were apportioned two of the Indians. Scarface Charley refused to have anything to do with the affair, and gave notice that if Riddle was killed he would take vengeance upon the slayer of his friend ; and during that whole terrible scene he lay near by, his rifle in hand, ready to execute his threat. A plan was also laid to decoy the LiWe Tijee, Colonel Mason, from his camp on the east side of the lava beds, and murder him. Curley-Headed Doctor, Curley-Headed Jack, and Steamboat Frank, were assigned to this duty.

The plans being perfected, each one took his station. A fire was built behind the council tent, so that the movements could not be observed from camp, and the six murderers lay down by it to await the coming of their victims. Soon Bogus Charley and Boston Charley appeared and announced the approach of the unarmed men. Jack made a last appeal to them to forego their design, but Bogus Charley exclaimed, " Kill these men and the war will stop. It will frighten the soldiers all away." With a sigh the chief said, " So be it, then, but it will cause the destruction of my people, and my blood will pay for the act." He had but just finished speaking when Canby and Thomas walked up to the fire, and were cordially welcomed with hand-shaking and words of friendship. Canby distributed cigars, and they all sat about the fire and smoked in silence. Soon the balance of the party arrived and met with the same hearty welcome, even before they could dismount. Meacham left his horse untied and took off his overcoat. It took but one glance to see that there were eight Indians instead of five, and that they all had revolvers under their coats. Whatever may have been his opinion before, even Dr. Thomas was now well aware that treachery was intended. All appeared restless except Canby and Thomas, the former too proud to exhibit a want of confidence and the latter too full of trust in Providence to feel fear. The massacre was almost precipitated before the talking began by the intrusion of a Mr. Clark who came up unexpectedly while hunting horses. The Indians sprang to their feet when they observed him, and nothing but the coolness of the whites postponed the work. Mr. Clark was requested to retire, and then the talk began. Seated about the fire were the commissioners and the chief Indians. Riddle interpreted the remarks of the Indians into English, while Tobey made the words of the white men intelligible to her countrymen. Meacham opened the council by saying, " We have come here to-day to hear what you have to propose. You sent for us, and we are here."

Captain Jack replied, " We want no more war. We are tired, and our women and children are afraid of the soldiers. We want them taken away, and then we will make peace."

" General Canby is in charge of the soldiers," was the reply. " He cannot take them away without a letter from the President. We are all your friends. If you will come out of the rocks and go with us, we will leave the women and children in camp on Cottonwood or Hot creek. We will need the soldiers to make other people stay away, while we look up a new home for you."

While this conversation was being carried on at the fire, Hooka Jim wandered restlessly about. He went to Meacham's horse, which had purposely been left untied and secured him to a sage-brush. He then put on the owner's overcoat, and buttoned it up to the chin exclaiming, " me old man Meacham now, Bogus you think me look like Meacham?" This action was not resented, as he had hoped it would be, and thus the inevitable trouble was again postponed. Hooka Jim's actions told only too plainly the bloody intentions of the savages. Dyar strolled carelessly to his horse and pretended to arrange the trappings on the saddle, keeping his face towards the tire. Riddle did the same at his wife's horse. They intended to have the cover of the animals when they started on the race for life they knew must soon be made. Tobey stretched herself out at full length upon the ground, to be out of the way of flying bullets.

Meacham saw by Canby '"s countenance that he realized the danger they were in, and asked him to speak, with the hope that he would promise to remove the troops and thus avert their impending doom. The inflexible soldier stood erect, and in a voice slightly tremulous, from the intensity of his emotion, slowly said, "Tobey, tell these people that the President sent the soldiers here to protect them as well as the white man. They are all friends of the Indians. They cannot be taken away without the President's consent. Tell them that when I was a young man I was sent to move a band of Indians from their old home to a new one. They did not like me at first, but when they became acquainted with me, they liked me so well that-they made me a chief, and gave me a name that signified "fiiend of the Indian." I also moved another to a new home, and they too, gave me a name that meant " the tall man." Many years afterwards I visited these people, and they come a long distance to meet me and were glad to see me. Tell them that I have no doubt the Modocs will some day like me as those people did, and look upon me as their friend."

Dr. Thomas then said: "Tobey, tell these people that I believe the Great Spirit put it into the heart of the President to send us here to make peace. We are all children of one Father. Our hearts are all open to Him. He sees all we do. He knows all our hearts. We are all your friends. I have known Mr. Meacham fourteen years, I have known General Canby eight years, I have known Mr. Dyar five years. I know all their hearts are good. They are all good men. We do not want any more blood shed. We want to be your friends. God sees all we do. He will hold us all responsible for what we do."

During these talks Jack sat speechless and irresolute. He seemed loth to give the signal for the bloody work to commence. His companions were restless and eyed him with impatience and distrust. He finally arose and walked slowly away from the fire. Schonchin sprang into his place, and in an excited manner exclaimed: " Give us Hot creek and take the soldiers away."

He was assured that Hot creek belonged to Fairchilds and Dorris, and they would probably refute to sell it. In a threatening manner he exclaimed fiercely, " Take away your soldiers and give us Hot creek, or quit talking. I am tired of talking. I talk no more."

While this was being interpreted, Captain Jack, who had returned to the little group around the fire, gave the signal, and the Modoc war-whoop rent the air. At the same time he drew a revolver from under his coat and presented it at Canby 's head, exclaiming " Ha-tuk!" (all ready). It missed fire. Quickly revolving the chamber, he again pulled the trigger, and buried a bullet in his victim's head.

The general did not fall, but essayed to escape, pursued by Ellen's Man. He soon fell, shattering nis jaw on the rocks, and was then cut in the neck by a knife. Watch-in-tate and Siolux at this point arrived with the rifles, and Ellen's Man, grasping one of these, sent a bullet crashing through the prostrate man's brain. He was then stripped of his clothing and left naked on the rocks.

Simultaneously with Jack's attack upon Canby, Boston Charley shot Dr. Thomas in the breast. Ifpartially fell to the ground, begging them to shoot no more as he had a death wound. He was allowed to rise by his two pet Indians, Bogus and Boston, who were now making their return for the kindness he had shown them. They tripped him down, taunting him with his religion. Three times they permit him to rise and three times they push him over, jeering him the while. Bogus then seized a rifle from Siolux and buried a bullet in the brain of him who hail thought of nothing but kindness to his murderers. The body was denuded of its outer clothing and left where it fell.

No sooner did the whoop of the Modocs sound, than Tobey crouched close to the ground, and Riddle and Dyar started at the top of their speed. Dyar was pursued by Hooka Jim, who dropped quickly to the ground when the fugitive turned and pointed his pistol at him. Dyar then resumed his flight, and ran so swiftly that the pursuit was abandoned. At the same time Riddle was running at the top of his speed towards the camp, followed by Black Jim. The pursuer fired rapidly, but to no effect. Riddle escaped, and Scarface Charley needed not to use his avenging' rifle.

To Schonchin and Shacknasty Jim had the work of killing Meacham been assigned. When the signal was given Schonchin drew a revolver and knife, but was too slow. Meacham drew his revolver and placed it against his opponent's breast, but it would not explode. In his haste and excitement he had only half cocked it. It was too late to correct the fault, Schonchin's bullet passed through his coat and grazed his shoulder. He fled, pursued by Schonchin, who fired rapidly. The Indian emptied his revolver and drew another. Tobey sprang up and seized him by the arm, exclaiming, " Don't kill him. He friend of the Indian." Siolux then came up and struck the squaw on the head with his gun. It was snatched from his hand by Shacknasty Jim, who took deliberate aim at the fleeing man. The squaw struck down the weapon, but he again took aim and fired, wounding the man in the shoulder, just as he leaped over a pile of rocks, behind which he fell. Thrusting his pistol over the edge of the rocks, Meacham took aim at Schonchin, and was at that instant wounded in the forehead by a bullet. Aiming again he fired his only shot, and Schonchin fell on the rocks wounded. At the same time several bullets found lodging in Meacham's body, and he fell back apparently lifeless. Shacknasty Jim ran up and began stripping him of his clothing, while Siolux advanced and placed the muzzle ofagun to the wounded man's head, but Jim pushed it away, saying "You need not shoot, he is dead. He won't get up."

The Indians were then called together by Jack, and with the spoils of their victims started for tin' cave. But Bogus Charley was nut satisfied; he wanted Meacham's scalp. Drawing a knife, he stooped down and commenced the operation, when Tobey exclaimed, "The soldiers arc coming," and thus frightened him away to join his companions, who were hastening to their stronghold.

While these events were happening at the council tent, still another tragedy was being enacted at Colonel Mason's camp at Hospital Rock. A white flag was observed beyond the picket line and reported to Lieutenant Sherwood, officer of the day, who reported the flag at headquarters. _ Colonel Mason was suspicious of treachery, but Major JBoyle, commander of the camp on the isthmus, on the east side of Tide lake, was there, and requested permission to go out and investigate. This was granted, and accompanied by Lieutenant Sherwood, he walked toward the rocks upon which the little emblem of peace was fluttering. Steamboat Frank rose up from the rocks and asked for Colonel Mason, and was told he would not come out. He then wanted the two oflicers to come up into the rocks. This was refused, and Boyle catching sight of a gun peeping over the top of the rocks, started on a run for camp, exclaiming to his companion, "Run for your life." Two volleys were fired in quick succession by the concealed savages, Sherwood falling at the second one with a bullet in his thigh. The troops from the camp instantly charged, and the treacherous devils fled to their stronghold.

The message, "Boyle and Sherwood attacked under a flag of truce," was instantly signalled to Lieutenant Adams, in charge of the signal station at Gillem's headquarters. The intelligence was communicated to the commanding officer, who sat down and was writing a note to Canby informing him of the event, when the startling cry came again from the signal station, " The Indians are firing on the commissioners."

The consternation in camp was great. Many of the soldiers started on the run for the council tent, but were called back by the officers and made to form in regular line, while the long roll was sounded. Precious minutes were thus wasted before the men were started in double time, deploying in skirmish line as they ran. With them went the surgeons and reporters. They first met Dyar, who breathlessly exclaimed, "They are all killed but I." Soon Riddle came running up saying, " They have killed them all but me." Then Tobey was met, who said, " Canby, Meacham, Thomas, all kill."

On rushed the troops, but when they arrived at the council tent they found no enemy. In their stead there lay the inanimate forms of the brave soldier and the white-haired peacemaker, covered with blood, the one entirely stripped of its clothing and the other nearly so. Tears sprang to the eyes of that rude soldiery, while the friends of the murdered men wept with the depth of their emotion. Tenderly the bodies were lifted up, covered with coats and canvas cut from the council tent, and borne in sorrow to the camp. Meacham was found covered with wounds. Restoratives were applied by Dr. Cabaniss; the wounded man was placed on a stretcher and carefully carried to the hospital, where he recovered in due time.

The soldiers did not stop here. Cautiously they advanced momentarily expecting to receive a volley from their unseen foe. The caution was needless, for the Modocs, content with what they had accomplished, had retired to their retreat in the rocks, to rejoice over their hellish work.

All thought of anything but a vigorous prosecution of the war was now abandoned. The fifty Warm Spring Indians under Donald McKay arrived, and preparations were made for a combined attack on the stronghold.

On the morning of the fifteenth of April Colonel Mason advanced on the east, the Warm Spring Indians on the south and Colonel Miller with the main body on the west. The plan was for the three divisions to unite and close in upon the hostiles, the lake forming the fourth side. It was practically the same plan of attack attempted by Colonel Wheaton. The artillery commenced dropping shells into the camp of the enemy, creating the greatest consternation. These " double-shooting guns," were a mystery to the uninitiated savages. They did not like them, although little damage was done by these, except to knock the rocks about and make the stronghold an exceedingly uncomfortable place to stay in, they had the effect of keeping the Indians on the move and taking away the confidence and sense of security they had previously enjoyed. One of these shells was picked up by Shacknasty Jim's brother and a son of Curley-Headed Doctor, exploding in their hands and blowing the two boys to atoms.

The lines advanced slowly on all sides, the most severe fighting being the capture of a bluff on the lake shore. The men crept along until at the base of the hill, and then charged up with a yell, the hostiles beating a precipitate retreat. This point was one from which the Indian camp could be shelled to good advantage, and the troops rested here for the night, Major Thomas bringing his artillery to the spot. Contrary to expectation the forces had not been able to effect a junction, and they camped for the night in the positions they had gained.

Provenance

Text from History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.