BlockBefore

Siskiyou County, California - Chapter 18: Indian Difficulties, 1881 (part 4 of 4)

From History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. 4,870 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

2 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

4,870 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

During the night the Indians built a huge fire at their camp, but Major Thomas trained a gun on it, and scattered them and their fire in all directions. All the next day the shells were freely dropped into the lava beds, keeping the enemy on the anxious seat, while the soldiers cautiously advanced. There were occasional little battles at different points, but no severe fighting, the Indians evidently feeling their way about to see where they could find a weak point.

Early on the morning of the third clay, the lines were again advanced, with the expectation of capturing the stronghold. The men moved forward in squads of three, twenty feet between. They moved steadily forward until near the cave, and then with a yell sprang over the rocks into the stronghold. They had captured an empty cage, for the birds had flown during the night. They had escaped through a gap in the lines to the south.

A small band of them did not accompany the others, but occupied a position near the lake. From this point they fired upon some scattered parties of newspaper men, teamsters, and men with stretchers, killing Eugene Hovey, an estimable young man from Yreka. Before night they were dislodged, and the mutilated body of young Hovey was recovered, and conveyed to Yreka.

The loss in the three days' fight was six killed and twelve wounded. It was claimed at the time that sixteen "good Indians" had been made, but it was afterwards discovered that this was sixteen too

Peter Payson Peterson

The subject of this sketch is a native of Tondern, Germany, in the Duchy of Schleswig, where he was born March 13, 1825. He was the third son of Peter P. and Helena Catharina Peterson. Young Peter was sent to school at an early age, and when thirteen years old entered the high school, where he acquired the rudiments of the higher branches of learning. He was of a wild and reckless disposition that chafed under the restraints of school, and at the age of fifteen abandoned his school and other advantages and entered the commercial marine service. He sailed from Bremen as ship boy, ordinary seaman and able-bodied seaman for four years, visiting the ports of the Baltic and North seas and several times crossing the Atlantic. In 1844 he was induced to leave his ship in New Orleans and engage in the American service, there being better prospects for advancement. He eagerly grasped every opportunity on the voyage to learn to speak and read the English language, which he soon accomplished. In August, 1844, he sailed in a vessel loaded with cotton from Apalachicola to Liverpool. The second day out she sprang a leak that could not be overcome, a gale came up, and the captain beached the vessel on Santa Rosa island, on the gulf coast of Florida, the crew reaching shore on a raft of cotton bales. He returned to New Orleans and for three years sailed before the mast and as mate in various ships, chiefly between New York and Liverpool. Apprised of his father's death a year after it occurred, he hastened home in 1847. He then went to the Danish school of navigation at Tonning, where after a preparation of only three weeks he passed the examination and received a master's patent or diploma. He remained there that winter as assistant instructor, and in the spring of 1848 shipped in a Danish vessel for Rio de Janeiro and other ports, returning to Hamburg in the spring of 1849. He then went to Havre de Grace, and then to New York, as third mate of the American ship St. Denis, full of German and French passengers. He coasted all summer and then shipped as seaman on the Tuscarora from Philadelphia to Liverpool. On the return voyage, with 660 passengers, they stranded about midnight in a severe storm off the Delaware coast, south of Cape Henlopen. The passengers and baggage were saved, but the poor sailors lost everything but their lives. He went to Philadelphia hatless and shoeless, where he declared his intention to become a citizen, perfecting his naturalization in August, 1851. After a few weeks he embarked in the bark Venezuela, in the trade to Venezuela. In 1850 he joined Empire Lodge, No. 104, Independent Order of Odd Fellows, of Pennsylvania. In 1851 he went as second mate on two voyages to Rio de Janeiro, and then as chief mate on the brig Calvert, from Baltimore to the Atlantic ports. He was taken sick on board and left the vessel in New York, and was for a few weeks in the Staten Island hospital. He then sailed for San Francisco in the clipper ship Golden Gate. He left New York about the first of November, passed Cape Horn about Christmas, and reached San Francisco February 3, 1853. He went up the coast to Crescent City and back to San Francisco; then to Portland, Oregon, taking on a load of lumber at St. Helens. On his return to San Francisco he left his entire sea outfit, books, papers, etc., in charge of a supposed friend, and started for the mines via Crescent City and Smith river, with little money and no experience. For two years he mined with pnor success on Smith river, Sailor diggings, Jacksonville, and Cottonwood. He went from the last place in 1855 to Scott Bar, where he worked with varying success until 1872, gaining the good-will of all his neighbors. Being somewhat crippled by a sprained ankle, he resolved to become a school teacher, and prepared himself and successfully passed a rigid examination, and entered upon his new field of labor. He taught three terms at Sciad, one at Scott Bar, Franklin School of Scott valley, three terms, Union District in 1879, and Cedar Park School in 1880. As a resident of the county he takes great interest in all that tends to advance the prosperity of the people. He is a member of Evening Star Lodge, No. 186, Free and Accepted Masons, at Etna.

high, not a Modoc having been slain in the battle. Old Shacknasty's Man was found dead in the cave, having died from the effects of the wound received in the other battle. The head was cut off and taken to camp and claimed to be the head of John Schonchin. This was soon found to be a mistake by those familiar with that warrior's features.

The captured fortifications challenged the admiration of the military. Across the main plateau had been built a gallery, commanding the approaches from all sides. From this they could sweep the ground where the caves were for five hundred yards. After carrying the crags, the troops had still this open space to cross before they reached the stronghold, a feat there were not men enough there to have accomplished, had they been opposed. The loss of life here would have been fearful. Fifty men could hold this place against a thousand, but the " double-shooting guns " and the lack of water had constrained the garrison to vacate, which they easily did, their non-combatants having been sent to a place of safety several days before.

The whereabouts of the savages was now a question of great interest, not only to the soldiers but to the settlers for miles around. So long as they were safely cooped up in the caves, they ceased to be an object of fear to the people, but now that they were again an unknown quantity, all the former uneasiness and anxiety returned, followed by a stampede for places of safety. It was feared they would break up into small bands and commit ravages in many places. In this emergency McKay's Warm Spring scouts did good service. They soon found that the hostiles were still in the lava beds, and were occupying a position nearly as strong as the old one, and about six miles south of it. The}'' did not remain inactive, but emerged from their retreat in small parties, filing upon scouts and couriers, attacking provision trains, and even firing into headquarters. Their boldness and the rapidity with which they moved from point to point completely puzzled and nonplussed the military. They maintained that two thousand men would not be sufficient to surround the lava beds and capture the hostiles, in a place where one thousand men could lie concealed in a small area, and where the besieged could fly to new strongholds as fast as driven from the old ones. More troops were sent for, and the government began to realize what a contract it had taken.

As it was every one knew better how to fight them than did those engaged in the work, and there was not a newspaper editor in the country who did not tell just how the thing could and should b e done. The " phunny man" lapsed into innumerable paragraphs and some even descended to poetry. The " sweet singers" all through the land trained their lyric pens on the event, and poetry of all kinds, grave, gay, sarcastic, blood-curdling and tear-provoking, crowded the newspaper columns. The following is a fair sample of the style most affected:

Lava-Linden'

Fire, Gillem, all thy cannons brave, Till Scarf ace Charley, in his cave, And Captain Jack shall find his grave, With all his bloody chivalry.

Among all the nonsensical propositions put forward in the papers there was one good one. This was, to offer a reward of one thousand dollars for each Modoc head. There were plenty of men who understood how to fight Indians, who could have been thus induced to go into the lava beds and maintain a bushwhacking war with them until they were exterminated or surrendered, the troops meanwhile scouting around the outside to protect the settlers. This seems cruel, but it was far less cruel than the method they were employing, which had resulted in nothing but the death of more soldiers already than there were Indians engaged in the fight. From a financial point of view, also, it would have been a wise course to pursue.

Although Major Thomas had done good work with his artillery, he thought that he was too inactive, and solicited command of a reconnoitering expedition. He was given command of a force that started on the morning of the twenty-sixth of April towards the Sand Butte cave. There were in all sixty-six officers and men, Major Evan Thomas, in charge of the force, Batteries A and K, Fourth Artillery, Lieutenants Albian Howe and Arthur Cranston, Lieutenant Harris, Company E, Twelfth Infantry, Col. T. F. Wright, Assistant Surgeon B. Senig with assistants.

The command advanced towards the Modoc camp until noon, when they halted for dinner in a small hollow or sage-brush plain. On one side was quite a high hill of scoria, about five hundred yards long, extending east and west. On the east end of this was a long ridge of lava rock, while on the west end were masses of rocks. It was between these two that the command commenced to take its noonday meal. The Indians were secreted in the lava ridge on the east and in an old crater in front of the hill. The Indians had hidden themselves when they observed the approach of the soldiers. The officers were congratulating themselves upon having seen no Indians, and a signal corporal was sent to the ridge on the right to signal headquarters. They had advanced but a short distance when they were fired upon, while at the same time a volley was poured in from the left upon the soldi. 'is who were munching their rations. Great was the confusion caused by this unexpected attack. Colonel Wright ordered a portion of Company E to fall rapidly back and occupy the ridge below, to cover the retreat of the troops. A party of Modocs, however, had anticipated this movement and occupied the position, pouring from it a deadly fire upon the detachment. Completely surrounded now, the troops abandoned all discipline, and each one sought safety for himself. Some sueceeded in fleeing beyond the range of bullets and hastened towards camp, while others gathered in little parties in hollows among the rocks, and fought desperately all the day.

McKay's Warm Spring Indians were a few miles distant, and hastened to the rescue ^f. the doomed band ; but upon their approach were fired upon by both par_tijg, and. dared not advance. ยป The Indians continued to pour their fire into t%e ltollows occupied by the men, being so close that they even threw rocks at them, until they supposed all were killed. Only one Modoc lost his life in this affair. A private, named Benham, lay in a hole with several dead men around him, and heard an Indian call out for them to come and fight like men, and also, "Boys, come out and go home; we don't want to kill all of you." Getting no response, the savage stepped boldly out from his hiding place, and was laid low by a bullet from Benham's rifle. The soldier was instantly fired upon and mortally wounded. This was Indian Ike, who had killed no one that day, and in his eagerness to shoot this soldier had pushed ahead of Hooka Jim, and met his death in consequence.-

From the beginning the firing could be heard at the camp, and about two o'clock stragglers began to arrive with the intelligence that Thomas had been defeated, and cut to pieces. Major Green was at once dispatched with a force to the scene of trouble, but owing to a want of knowledge of the ground and situation of the combatants, did not arrive until daylight. The Indians had effected their retreat, and the troops could do nothing but look after the dead and wounded. All the officers but Lieutenant Harris were killed, and he died a few days later. Surgeon Senig was wounded, and suffered the amputation of his foot. Lieutenant Cranston and five men were found lying dead in a hole, several clays after the fight. There were twenty-five killed and seventeen wounded, among the former being Louis Webber, of Scott valley, who was with the surgeon.

On the third of May, General Jefferson C. Davis, who had been assigned to succeed General Canby, arrived and took charge of operations in person. He was an able and energetic officer, and enthused the troops with new energy and courage. They sadly needed it, for they had lost all confidence in their officers, who simply led them out to be slaughtered, without accomplishing anything.

On the seventh of May, a wagon train, escorted by fifteen men, was attacked by the Modocs, seven miles from headquarters, and in the rear of Colonel Mason's camp. Three men were wounded, seventeen animals captured, and the wagons bm-ned, before assistance arrived. The same day McKay's scouts penetrated to the new stronghold and found it deserted. They saw the remains of twenty-five camp-fires, a natural cistern, from which the water had been exhausted, this being the probable cause of the evacuation, and the trail of the savages leading south towards the Snow mountains. This was a move that had long been feared, and great exertions were made to head them off. On the night of the ninth, Captains Hasbrouck and Jackson, with one hundred and twenty cavalry and the Warm Spring Indians, camped about twenty-five miles from headquarters and south-east of the lava beds, near Saras or Dry lake.

During the night, the Modocs, who were hovering in the vicinity, thirty-four strong, leaving their horses some distance in the rear, crept cautiously up to the camp. Just as day was breaking they fired into the camp, killing one soldier and wounding eight. They expected to stampede this force as ..they had that of Major Thomas, and to aid in this had sent a small detachment to cut off a pack-train that was bringing them water. This movement failed, and \^was followed by a quarrel which resulted in the division of the hostiles a few days later. The Warm Springs, headed by McKay, rushed up on the flank, and saluted the astonished Modocs with a volley. Crying out, " The Warm Springs ! The Warm Springs ! " they fled, closely pursued by the scouts and troopers, who kept them running until after dark. So hotly were they pursued that they had not time to get their horses, which fell into the hands of the pursuers. Some of them were loaded with ammunition, and a; this was supposed to be their reserve supply, it was thought, as it afterwards proved, that this loss deprived the hostiles of the sinews of war. One Warm Spring and one Modoc, Ellen's Man, were killed.

Troops were stationed in the lava beds to prevent them from regaining their old strongholds, and the next day Captain Hasbrouck and McKay ran them into a rocky fastness some twenty miles south-west of the original stronghold, where Hasbrouck endeavored to keep them while he sent for reinforcements and mortars to shell them out. For several days a brisk skirmish fire was maintained. The place was then surrounded and the troops closed in, only to find for the third time that their prey had eluded them. The entire cavalry force was then sent out to scour the country and find Captain Jack, who had developed so strongly the qualities of the Irishman's flea ; three times had they put their hand on him, " and he wasn't there."

While these events were happening, Colonel Gillem was superseded by Colonel Wheaton as second in command, a tardy acknowledgment of the injustice done the latter by his removal after the January fight.

A trail was found leading towards Sheep mountain, and while the lava beds wrere closely guarded to prevent them from regaining a position there, Captain Hasbrouck followed them, coming up with and attacking them at the Hole in the Ground, a few miles from Fairchilds' ranch, killing an old squaw named Limpy. They fled to Indian Springs and sent in word that they would surrender to Fairchilds if he would promise them their lives. Having satisfied them on this point, Fairchilds went out four miles, on the twenty-second of May, and brought them in. They proved to be mainly the Hot Creek band, seventy in all, sixteen braves, of whom the principal ones were, Shacknasty Jim, Hooka Jim, Bogus Charley, Bill Shacknasty, Steamboat Frank.

Curley-Headed Doctor, Curley-Headed Jack, Watchin-tate, William, and Little John. They were cold, hungry, and nearly naked, having fought until it was impossible to hold out longer.

They said that Jack, with twenty men, had gone towards the Pit river and Goose lake country, and Major Green, with two detachments, commanded by Captain Jackson and Captain Hasbrouck, was sent by two routes to the country east of the lava beds. Headquarters were moved to the peninsula on the east side of Tide lake, known as Boyles camp, and the captured Indians were also taken thither.

And now comes an example of the beauty of the Indian, and especially of the Modoc, character. Bogus Charley, Hooka Jim, Shacknasty Jim and Steamboat Frank, agreed to assist in the capture of their late companions if they were guaranteed immunity from punishment. Hooka Jim and Bogus Charley were the two worst Indians in the tribe, the former being the leader in the Lost river murders, as well as assisting in the massacre of the peace commissioners, who were so treacherously led to their death by Bogus. These Indians, with General Davis and John A. Fairchilds, reached Green's camp, seventy-five miles east of the old headquarters, May 26th, and the next day the Modocs were sent out upon a scout. They returned the day after with the information that Jack and his band were on Willow creek, twenty miles to the eastward.

The commands of Captain Jackson and Captain Hasbrouck were sent out after them. With the former were Fairchilds, McKay, twenty-eight Warm Springs and two of the renegade Modocs. With Hasbrouck were twenty Warm Springs and the other two traitors. Arriving at the creek about two o'clock in the morning, the commands separated, Jackson going up the right bank, and Hasbrouck up the left. As Jackson arrived on the ground first, the Modocs succeeded in crossing the river and making their escape, the bluffs preventing pursuit by the cavalry. Jack's sister, Mary, and six squaws were captured here, and Boston Charley came in and surrendered.

In the morning the trail of the fugitives was found and followed by the Indians and troops for twenty-seven miles, the Modocs being overtaken at dusk on the bluffs at the head of Langell valley. The troops charged up the slope, when the Indians came out and said they wanted to surrender. Scarface Charley came into the lines, gave up his gun, and asked permission to go back for his family, Major Green granted this, telling him to have the others come in or he would charge them, and then went into camp for the night. Doctor Cabaniss and Boston accompanied Scarface, the Doctor soon returning with the report that the Indians were afraid to come through the lines in the dark, but would do so in the morning. When morning came, however, only Scarface, Boston; Schonchin, and eight others, with their families, were there. Captain Jack and the others having departed for other scenes. His lease of liberty was short, having fled directly towards a detachment under Captain Ferry, that had been sent out to cut off retreat to the south. With Perry were Warm Spring George and four others of McKay's scouts, who captured a Modoc scout about three miles from where Jack had

A few others were still at liberty, and these, with a number of scattered ones who had not participated in the hostilities were soon taken and conveyed to'Boyles camp on Tule lake. On the fourth of June, more that six months after the first tight, the Oregon volunteers captured Black Jim and four other braves, with lour squaws ami four children, ten miles east of Lost River springs. These were turned over to General Davis, and the great Modoc war was at an end.

General Davis sent out into the woods, and had twenty juniper logs cut and trimmed for the purpose of hanging some of the leaders, but before the preparations were completed a courier arrived from Yreka, with dispatches from Washington, ordering him to hold the prisoners until charges could be investigated. A few days later, he was instructed to try them by court-martial.

According to the report of the Indians they had but forty-six men capable of bearing arms when the war commenced. Five braves, two boys, and three squaws lost their lives. Opposite these figures can be placed the statement that mure that one hundred and fifty soldiers were killed and wounded, three for every Indian in the fight, and the secretary of war reported that the war had cost 8338,009.78, exclusive of pay and equipment of troops. After this report was made a great many claims were allowed, and there still exists claims amounting to thousands that never will be liquidated.

On the seventh of June, the few remaining Indians of the Hot Creek band, consisting chiefly of old men and squaws to the number of seventeen, were conveyed from Fairchilds' ranch to Boyles camp. John A. Fairchilds and a number of citizens, with Bogus Charley and Shacknasty Jim, were mounted and rode on ahead, while James Fairchilds followed with the Indians in a wagon. The escort soon left the wagon far behind, and when James Fairchilds arrived at the crossing of Lost river, he met Captain Heiser's company of Oregon volunteers, who demanded Hooka Jim. They were told he was in Boyle's camp. A distance farther on two disguised men stepped into the road, one in the rear and one in front, presenting their rifles, and ordering Fairchilds to stop.

The man's authority was not as good as that given by bluff old Ethan Allen., when the same question was asked him at Fort Ticondi roga, for he said, " By mine. I'm going to kid these Indians and you, too."

which killed Little John, the mules ran, dragging Fairchilds with them by the reins, in which he waa entangled. Five more 3hots were rapidly fired, and

Teche Jack, Policy, and .Mooch were killed, and a squaw severely wounded. At this point the men were frightened away, and tic balance of the women

No investigation was ever made of this cowardly and brutal murder, and the matter was hushed and covered up as much as possible. Yet the fact remains, and has scarcely a palliation. If there is one it is that the settlers murdered were citizens of Oregon, that the grand jury of Jackson county had indicted nine of the Indians for murder, and that the military authorities refused to deliver them up for trial, claiming them as prisoners of war. This is. however, but a faint excuse, as the murdered Indians belonged to the Hot Creek band, and had nothing to do with the killing of the settlers.

Secretary of War, Washington, D. C. : As to the Modoe outlaws now in the custody of the United States military authorities, I most respectfully request, that those now standing indicted in the Circuit Court of Jackson county, for the crime of murder, who are not amenable to military execution, be delivered to the civil authorities of this State for trial and punishment. If they have a legal defense, based either upon amuesty or denial of their guilt, let the defense be pleaded before the proper tribunal.

The camp and prisoners were moved to Fort Klamath, General Wheaton being left in charge, while the majority of the troops were sent to the various posts from whence they had come. Curley- Headed Jack, against whom there was no charge of murder, secured a pistol and committed suicide.

The court-martial for the trial of the murderers of the peace commissioners was finally formed, and consisted of Lieutenant Colonel Elliott, First Cavalry; Captain Mendenhall, Fourth Artillery, Captain Hasbrouck, Fourth Artillery; Captain Pollock, Firstr Cavalry; Lieutenant Kingsbury, Twelfth Infantry; and Maj. H. G. Curtis, Judge Advocate.

The leading witnesses were Meacham, who had fully recovered from his wounds, and Frank Riddle and wife. The trial lasted from the fifth to the ninth of July. Captain Jack, Schonchin John, Boston Charley, Black Jim, Watch-in-tate (misnamed Barncho), and Slolux were found guilty and sentenced to be executed. Of the others, Hooka Jim, Bogus Charley and Shacknasty Jim were entitled to their lives for the services rendered in capturing their companions, while Ellen's Man had already met his death in battle.

Captain Jack did not want to die. He claimed, and with truth, that he had been forced into the murder by the others, the worst two of whom, Hooka Jim and Bogus Charley, were not to be punished. It was not justice, and he thought they should take his place. He even went so far as to offer the post of distinction to a minister who had been telling him how glorious he would find the happy hunting grounds to be, and how glad he would feel to reach them. Jack said that if he thought so he could take his place, but the minister declined the honor.

On the day before the execution, the sentence of Watch-in-tate and Slolux was commuted to imprisonment for life in Alcatraz, on the ground that they were acting under orders. They both died in confinement. At the time set, General Wheaton executed the sentence at Fort Klamath, upon Captain Jack, Schonchin John. Black Jim, and Boston Charley, in the presence of two hundred soldiers, one hundred and fifty citizens, three hundred Klamaths, and the Modocs. Thus, as he had said, did Jack's life pay for the sins of his people.

The sheriff of Jackson county made application to General Wheaton for the surrender of the Lost river murderers, but it was denied. October 4th, Judge P. P. Prim issued a writ of habeas corpus, upon which return was made by General Wheaton that the men were held by the United States government as prisoners of war, and the- court had no authority to issue a habeas corpus.

This ended the clash of authority, and soon after orders were received to move the Modocs to Fort Russell, Wyoming Territory. One hundred and fifty-five, including forty-two men, were taken upon this order by Captain Hasbrouck, the Indians who had remained peaceably on the reservation with Old Schonchin, being allowed to stay there, and are there yet.

Scarface Charley, the best educated and the most civilized of them all, was invested with the chieftainship. Before they arrived at their destination, it was changed, and they were located upon four thousand acres in the north-east corner of the Shawnee reservation, in Indian Territory. A school was established among them, agricultural implements were furnished, and though they have considerably diminished by death, they have since lived peaceable and industrious lives, raising nearly enough food for their own support.

Provenance

Text from History of Siskiyou County, California, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.