Sutter County, California - Chapter 32: Crimes and Punishments, 1879
From History of Sutter County, Califorina : with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories ..., published 1879. 4,560 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
4,560 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Sutter County, Califorina : with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories ..., published 1879. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
CRIMES AND PUNISHMENTS. ,,. , = murine of Washington Rideout-Jolm Jackson hanceil at ^nXSSu^Cl^^^urle^on, Ben-Case o, Robert Dinsmore.
The natural tendency of society, when left uncurbed by legal regulations is towards lawlessness. So it was in the early days of California. The population in the year 1848 and the greater part of 1849 was composed of a tine set of men, composed of the honest and intelligent element of the eastern cities and States. But the next tide threw upon our shores the refuse material troin the Atlantic side of the Continent, and a horde of dis- The change in society day or in the company of others. Legal proceedings were carried on under the old Mexican laws, and with the insufficient force of officers it was difficult to apprehend and convict a man of crime. The miners, realizing that fact and knowing the consequence of leniency toward the criminal class, took the law into their own hands. A crime was committed, the neighboring miners quickly captured the suspected person; a judge was appointed, a jury summoned and sworn; attorneys (unlearned in the law) were provided, and the trial proceeded with all the gravity and formality of a legally organized court. The testimony was heard, arguments made, and the case placed in the hands of the jury. Their decision was final, and upon it depended in most instances the life of the prisoner, for hanging in those days was the favorite prvnishment for murder and even Btealing.
Two cases of this kind occurred in Sutter county almost simultaneously, in 1852, one of which, that of the hanging of Washington Rideout at Nicolaus, is well remembered, and often alluded to by the old residents of that village.
In May, 1852, a MarysvJle negro named "Washington Rideout stopped at the Bellevue House, kept by Newbald & Hufius, five miles south of Nicolaus. Discovering Hufius to be alone, he became abusive because he did not have the kind of liquor he wanted. Hufius told him to leave the house, when the negro drew his revolver and shot him dead. He was quickly captured and conveyed to Nicolaus, then the county seat, where a mob took possession and were about to hang him, when they were persuaded to let the law take its course. He was confined on the government vessel that still lay in the river. A grand jury was summoned, an indictment found, and the case proceeded to trial within a few days after the commission of the act. The record of the Court of Sessions bears the following: -
"Whereupon, the defendant was brought into Court, and for trying the same, came the following jury, to-wit-.-Ira Bradshaw, C. "S. Tessue, Joseph P. Dillen, J. Lee, E. W. Riker, Nathaniel Eaton, .'John Holloway, Thomas Morrison, J. Gibson, A. L. Chandler, H. « Chandler and James Riker, and were sworn and empanneled.
"The defendant was then arraigned, and having answered to his " name as set forth in the indictment, pleads that he is - not guilty ' " of the charge alleged therein. W. B. Johnson, G. B. Upham, S. B. " Smith and Dr. Golder were called and sworn on the part of the " State, and McDufiy was sworn on the part of the defendant.
now comes the mob, being impatient of delay (the jury not "having as yet agreed upon their verdict), being led on by E. W- " High, and seized and forcibly took from the custody of the Sheriff, "the said prisoner, Washington Rideout, and having dragged him " out of the Court House, escorted him to the first convenient tree, "and hanged him by the neck till he was dead."
It had been the watchword of the mob to " hang him while the sun shines," and the jury had been out so long that the sun began to decline in the west. They went to the court room, then in the American Hotel, and High stepped up to the negro as he was seated between two deputies, and told him that his time had come. No resistance was made, and High took him by the collar and led him from the room. Rideout was taken to a large tree in front of Jacob Vahle's residence, a rope was tln'own over a limb, one end fastened around the prisoner's neck, and the other end seized by about fifty men, who, as the last rays of the setting sun shed their light upon the scene, ran the murderer up and fastened him there. The whole court, including the jury, adjourned to witness the execution. Rideout had a Spanish wife who was clinging to his neck, and through whose arms the body of her husband was jerked aloft. Thus did they hang him " while the " sun was shining."
Only a few days after the murder of Hulius, and before the execution of Rideout, a cruel murder was committed and summary justice -was executed upon the murderer. Martin Bader and wife were living on the west side of Feather river, in Sutter township. On the night of June S, 1852, they gave shelter to John Jackson, a Norwegian. The next day Bader went to Hock Farm, and upon his return was met at the gate by Jackson, who presented a revolver and told him he would never leave the place alive. He fired the revolver at Bader, but missed, and Bader ran into the house to get his gun. Jackson then mounted Bader's horse and rode away. Upon search being made, the body of Mrs. Bader was found hi a pond back of the house, with two bullet holes in her head. The Norwegian was soon captured near Shanghai Bend, and taken by the enraged settlers to the scene of his crime, where they hung him to a tree that stood in front of the house. These exhibitions of mob law, coming so closely together, were very severely commented upon by the newspapers at the time, and, although it would have been better to have allowed the law to take its course, yet there is no doubt that the two wretches l-ichly deserved then- fate. Being removed as it is, from the location of the mines, and its population consisting chiefiy of farmers so proverbially peaceful and law abiding, Sutter county bus been the scene of but few of the exciting incidents that characterized the early history of the mining counties and the larger cities. A few murders have been committed, thedetarls of which it is not necessary to recite. There have but two persons suffered the extreme penalty of the law at the hands of the public executioner. An Italian was hanged in October, 1857, by Sheriff 8. E. Kennard, and John Wright in March, 1873, by Sheriff Samuel Mc-
In the matter of duels, Sutter county has been « more sinned against "than sinning," for all the duels fought on her territory have been by residents of other counties.
The code of honor was frequently resorted to as a method of healing wounded feelings, but the practice soon sank into decay. Many of these meetings were held so secretly and the results were so trifling that the afiairs never became generally known. Some however were subjects of general comment for a long time. Probably the most celebrated duel, or rather incipient duel, which has occurred in the county, is that between Judges Field and Barbour. The latter was Judge of of the Tenth District Court, and in some manner a feeling of enmity sprang up between the two gentlemen. This spirit led to innumerable little squabbles and nearly culminated seriously. Geo. C. Gorham wrote a severe stricture on Judge Barbour and handed it to O. P. Stidger, editor of the Herald, for publication. The same day, as Judge F'eld was proceeding to his office, with his arms full of books, he was assaulted by Judge Barbour, who claimed that his opponent had caused the publication of the offensive article. The parties being separated, by some diplomatic efforts Judge Barbour was forced to send the challenge. This left Mr. Field with the privilege of selecting the weapons and manner of meeting. It was at first proposed to fight with knives in a dark room, but Judge Barbour would not accede to this, claiming that it was cruelty. Finally it was decided to have a meeting with lire-arms, on the opposite side of Bear river. Charles N. Fairfax acted as second for Judge Barbour, and Gordon N. Mott for Judge Field. Although both parties appeared on the ground, an actual conflict was avoided. Albert Turner and Wm. Houser, of Marysville, agreed to settle a quarrel iu the honorable way, and adjourned to Sutter county for that purpose, June 10, 1858. The Sheiifl interfered, however, and they started for Butte county, but finally returned to Marysville. They met near the Hospital the next morning with seconds and surgeons, and had five shots at each other, with shot-guns loaded with ounce balls, distance fifty paces. At the last fire Houser was badly wounded in the right arm. A duel occurred in 1853, in which Richard Rust, editor of the California Express, challenged 0. P. Stidger, editor of the Herald. They met two miles below Yuba City. They used revolvers, at a distance of ten paces. One shot was fired and a bullet went through the coat of Stidger. The cause was some articles appearing in the Herald criticising some in the Express, and the motives of the editor in publishing them.
The last resort to the " code honorable," was made by Thomas Burn, and John Davis, of Marysville. They had a quarrel over gome ,j0. mestic difficulty, in which Davis received severe chastisement. He challenged Bums to the fiel 1 of honor, and they fought a duel Jan. uary 8, 1871, a few miles below Yuba City. Revolvers were used at thirty paces, and after the exchange of four harmless shots, the honor of these gentlemen was completely satisfied, and they retired from the field.
Joaquin Murietta, who for a long time was the terror of travelers, and lonely settlers, never operated to any extent, in this vicinity. He had a sister living in Marysville, whom he frequently visited. He was there for a considerable time, in 1850 and 1851, and was known as a notorious character, After the killing of Joaquin, considerable doubt existed as to the identity of the dead robber. His head was amputated, and with the hand of Three-fingered Jack, was exhibited throughout the State. While in Marysville, Joaquin's sister visited the exhibition, and after gazing upon the head, remarked in Spanish to a gentleman within the hearing of Judge 0. P. Stidger, " that's not my brother." When asked who it was, she smiling replied, "It is Joaquin Gonzales." This would seem to give some credence to the rumor that the real Joaquin Murietta had escaped.
The most notorious robber that roamed over the territory in this region, was Tom Bell. The description of this person is best given in the words of Judge Edward McGowan, as published in the San Francisco Evening Fost.
Tom Bell was in stature nearly six feet, well proportioned, combining in his frame strength and action; of a sanguine temperament, quick in his motions, being never at rest, sandy hair and a full crop of it, bgn goatee to match his hair in color. His nose, which was originally «U formed and large, was mashed in the bridge, almost level with face. This defect, rendered his countenance, which was othermse rather prepossessing, somewhat repulsive and even hideous, viewed in connection with his lawless practices. His eyes were light blue, of that class which approximates so nearly to a gni}. in its restless wanderings was constantly sparkling with mte i^ Bell was a native of Alabama, and received a medical education. a* it is said, practiced that profession when he first came which, as well as I can ascertain, was in 1850. HeafterwaroS i- «w> with his demands. It was known that he had associated aasawBSfx wit - kirn several persons scarcely less noted than himself, one of whom, ast au escaped convict named Bill Gristy, alias Bill White, and one ' tk with Walker inNicaragua, when the gang was broken in upon detachment of the Sacramento and Marysville police, near Sacrato was the only one who escaped. He was cruel, cunning, and bloodsty This scoundrel was in Bell's band for three months. The band was supposed to number from six to eight, and they ranged the country Il'ong the f oothills from the Yuba to Granite city. Their- depredations were mainly confined to the several roads crossing in the neighborhood between Granite and Gold Hill, in Placer county. The country was rough, broken and covered with an impenetrable chapparal, in the recesses of which an "army with banners " might securely hide. Their outrages in this favorite field, followed each other in such rapid succession, that scarcely a day had passed during the summer of 1856, without furnishing a newspaper item from the calendar of their exploits, but in no instance, I believe, did they shed blood. The plan of the chief was to frighten the traveler into terms, and avoid the cruelty of his murder.
On one occasion Bell and Gristy, with one other, made an attack upon a gentleman who was traveling from Downieville to Marysville, with a large sum of money in his possession. The traveler resisted, fired upon his assailants, and finally fled from them towards a deep canyon in which, if he could reach it, he knew he was safe from pursuit on horseback. Just as he was about to reach his goal, Gristy fired with a navy revolver, and shot him in the thigh, knocking him down. The robbers relieved him of his money, and instead of dispatching him, or leaving him to die from the hemorrage of his wound, Doctor Bell kindly and expertly took up the severed artery, bound up the wound, and just at that moment, hearing a wagon pass, Bell turned to one of his subordinates and ordered him to attend to the teamster. The wagon was stopped, the driver relieved of his cash, and the wounded man placed upon a mattrass, hastily made in the bottom of the wagon, and the parties dismissed, with the injunction to " dri, e slow and pick their road." The wounded man requested Bell to tie his (the traveler's ) horse behind the wagon. Bell refused, but asured him that he should have his horse, as he seemed attached to him, awl that he would turn him loose in the woods, after stripping off Ml bridle and saddle, which promise he faithfully kept.
He Marysville Express gives the following account of a most daring attempt to n,b the Camptonville stage: - "On Tuesday afternoon, about 4:30 o'clock, as the Camptonville e wan proceeding to Marysville, and when near Dry creek, it was
"stopped by six mounted highwaymen. They were after the treas- " ore, whicii amounted to 81 00,1 II 10. Near the point of attack the road "forked, and Mr. Kideout, gold dust dealer of Camptonville, was on "one road ami the stage on the other. Mr. Rideout was stopped by "the robbers, who all presented their arms and commanded him to dis- " mount. He hesitated, when one of them threatened to shoot him. "On the threat being made he dismounted, and went towards the " stage on the other road, across the ravine. The robbers called him " back and demanded his money. Being satisfied that he had none, " his treasure being on the stage, they took his horse, and allowed " Mm to cross over to the stage. The robbers then command.;*! the "driver of the stage, John Gear, to stop, and threatened to kill the " first man who should oppose them in their designs. Mr. Dobson, " messenger for Langton's Express, immediately drew on the robbers "and commenced firing. His first fire took effect on the spokesman " of the robbers, and unhorsed him. Mr. Rideout had by this time "got to the stage. An indiscriminate fight now commenced between "the robbers and passengers'. As many as forty shots were fired on "both sides. The robbers, finding themselves so stoutly opposed, " retreated, leaving the passengers victors of the field of battle. The " driver. Mr. John Gear, was shot through the right arm above the " elbow. ' Mrs. Tighlman, wife of a barber in Marysville, was shot in the " head, the ball entering over the right eye, and penetrating the brain. « Mr. John Campbell, another passenger, received a glance shot over " the eye. Another passenger was shot in both legs. The stage is rid- " died with bullet holes. When the stage was stopped and the firing "had commenced, one white man and four Chinamen, passengers, left, " and ran back on the road which had been passed over. They have "not been seen since. When the stage was about to resume its top, "and after the first party had retired, a Mexican, who was mounted, " commenced firing from the opposite side. Mr. Dobson returned his « fire and unhorsed the assailant. At this time, two other men were "concealed in the thicket, who were not mounted. They were all .members of the same gang. It is supposed that only two of the a party were disguised. All were Americans save the one Mexican « first spoken of. These particulars have been received from Mr. Gear .. and Mr. Rideout, and they may be relied on as authentic.
H. Burnett, Governor of California. We have been favored with the perusal of these letters. They are dated at Oro, the head quarters, at present, of General Green. Serious Indian troubles are announced on that frontier. A volunteer company, under command of Capt. Nicolaus Allgeier, had prepared to march against the savages, and other parties were being formed. The Indians are reported to number several hundred and to be headed by white men and some Chilians. An engagement is said. to have taken place on Deer creek, a few days before, in which four whites and fifteen Indians were killed. General Green has very wisely determined to take the field, both for the protection of the citizens and to prevent excesses on their part. He recommends that the Adjutant General should be ordered to his head quarters, with instructions and authority to make a further call upon the malitia, and TJ. S. troops, should the emergencies require it. We are further advised that some two hundred Indians were seen near Johnson's ranch, on Friday. A party of thirty went out from Nicolaus, and killed four of them, one of the party being slightly wounded hi the forehead. A teamster from Nicolaus was found dead in the neighborhood, with fourteen arrows in him. His wagon and merchandise had been burnt up, and four pair of oxen killed. The repeated outrages in every direction will induce a more general militia organization throughout this part of the State. We learn that a volunteer company of young men is being now formed in Sacramento City. They will be the first to tender their aid, should future developments require the further call upon the Militia, which is anticipated in the above correspondence."
General Green arrived in Sacramento Tuesday, May 28, 1850, and was to leave immediately for Washington to represent the state of Indian affairs to the President. He made the following report to
To His Excellency, Peter H. Bwrmtt, Governor and Commander-in- Chief, California Militia: SIR - Aftermy dispatch to you on the 16th instant, I moved with Capt. Allgeier's, and Capt. Charles Hoyt's mounted volunteers, on the 1 7th, upon Bear river. On the afternoon of the same day, Lieutenant Bell, of Capt. Allgier's company, with ten men, being out upon a scout, encountered a large number of Indians, killing five and bringing in six
On the 18th, I moved in the direction of Deer creek, and scorned the country where a number of Indian depredations had been committed. We found the Indian villages newly deserted, and thentrails leading south, in the direction of Bear river.
villages in this neighborhood deserted, and the white settlement abandoned; trails still leading south, which we followed to Bear river, and encamped upon the same.
On the 20th, leaving a camp guard with the horses, we crossed the river on foot to visit a large village on the south of said river, which we found deserted, and the trail recrossing the river. Upon our return I was informed that a large number of Indians, between two and three hundred, had assembled upon an elevated conical hill within two miles, a position evidently taken to give battle. After examining their position I ordered Captain Hoyt with twenty men to take station at the foot of the hill upon the left, and with Captain Allgeier, lieutenant Bell and the balance of the men, in all thirty, I charged up the most accessible side of the hill upon the right into the camp, and drove the Indians upon Captain Hoyt's position, where a smart skirmish ensued. We pursued them for several miles in the_hills and ravines, killing and wounding a number and took eight prisoners. Their' chiefs report eleven of their men killed, besides wounded. We had none killed. Wounded, Captain Hoyt, Lieutenant Lewis and Mr. Russell. My Aid, Major Frederick Emory, was accidentally shot through the thigh by the discharge of a rifle. All doing.well. The day previous, in attempting to capture one of their spies, his determined resistance caused him to be shot, and in camp we found his remains upon a funeral pile nearly consumed. Here we foond a large amount of supplies, consisting of beef, sugar, tea, and other articles robbed from the wagons, and the clothes of the murdered teamster, Matty. On the afternoon of the same day I sent the following note, with a flag of truce, to the chiefs, by an old woman who had been
To the Indian Chiefs Weima, Bolder. Poolhl, and Olivers: - Your people have been murdering ours, robbing their wagons and burning their houses. We have made war upon you, killed your men and taken prisoners your women and children. We send you this plain talk by one of your grandmothers. When you cease to rob and murder our people we will cease to make war upon you, and then you can come in and get your women and children, who will be taken care of in the meantime. H you wish peace come down to Johnson's old ranch, on Bear river, and report yourselves to Captain Charles Hoyt, who will protect you until your Great Father shall speak.
L be made very useful tothe mine, if ***"? - *£ tion of justice extended to them. Heretofore a few persons have monopoly much of their labor, by giving them a cabco start per week and the most indifferent food. This is not only wrong, but highly disgraceful, when they would be content with the pay of onefourth of the wages of the white men.
I have sent these chiefs over on the north fork of the Amencan river, to bring in others now hostile, to Brigadier General Eastland, ( on Bear rive., who will in the absence of farther instructions from | your Excellency, endeavor to bring them to terms. I have the honor to be, very respectfully, your obedient servant,
Thos. J. Green, Major General, First Division, California Militia. Town of Kearney, Bear River, Yuba County, California. Whereas, numerous depredations and murders have been committed upon the persons and property of the American citizens in this vicinity by native Indians belonging to the tribes of the undersigned Chiefs; and whereas, it became the duty of the undersigned Thomas J. Green, Major-General of the First Division of California Militia, to pursue and punish said depredators and murderers; Now, therefore, in the absence of higher authority, I, Thomas J. Green, Major-General, as aforesaid, on behalf of the people of California and the Government of the United States, on one part, and the head Indian Chiefs, Weima and Buckler, and Sub-Chief, Poollel, on the other part, representing fully and completely their several tribes, do enter into the following solemn treaty of peace and friendship, to wit: -
Article 2. Should any Indian belonging to either of the beforementioned tribes commit any murder, robbery or other offence against the persons or property of the American citizens, the offender or offenders shall be promptly delivered up to the proper authorities for punishment.
Article S. Should any American citizen or foreigner commit any wrong upon the persons or property of the beforementioned tribes, they shall be punished therefor as the law directs.
Article 4- To prevent any hostile feelings arising between the whites and Indians, as well as to prevent the friendly Indians from being mistaken for those unfriendly, it is hereby stipulated, that the people of the beforementioned tribes shall not carry arms while in the settlements of the whites.
Article 5. To cultivate warmer friendship and acquaintance between the white people and the Indians the latter are guaranteed the free use of the gold mines, and the full value of their labor in working the same, without charge or hindrance; and any contract made between the Indians and whites, before competent witneiBaj. shall be recoverable before any Court of competent jm-isdiction
Article 7. The Government of the United States shall have six months from this date to confirm, amend, or annul the treaty; and should said Government of the United States confirm the same, it U hereby stipulated that each of the beforementioned tribes shall receive a semi-annual annuity of one thousand dollars, to be paid to them respectively for the term of ten years from the date thereof.
The county has had one defaulting Treasurer, Robert Dinsnwre. ^ k< was the incumbent of that office in 1867. It had been for some m the custom of the Board of Supervisors to annually make an ins of the Treasurer's accounts and count the money. February J. the Board were about to do this, when the privilege was refused t K by DJnsmore. The next day they made a formal demand and ag»» met with a refusal. Legal proceedings were at onoe commerce* »" an order was made by Judge Belcher, of the District Court, 11, requiring Dinsa.ore to opeu the vault for the ii>slHVt"'' Hoard on the twelfth. The Hoard went there at the appoint* but found no one there, lfinsiuoiv having \amshed " suns." The Sheriff opened the vault and it was found to COO munificent sum of five dollars and tweun ti\e cents. dred dollars was immediately offered for the apprehension of but was not productive of his arrest. Acommittee appointing an examination of the defaulting Treasurer's books, reported March 8, as follows :-
$11915.90 The District Attorney was instructed to commence proceedings against Dinsmore's bondsmen. A compromise was effected with these gentlemen, by which it was arranged that they should pay $110 on each $1000 for which they stood bound. The amount paid May 4, 1867, was 86319, and eventually nearly the -whole loss was made good.
Provenance
Text from History of Sutter County, Califorina : with Illustrations Descriptive of Its Scenery, Residences, Public Buildings, Fine Blocks and Manufactories ..., published 1879, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.