BlockBefore

San Francisco Fire Department, Pumping Station No. 2, Van Ness Avenue at Bay, San Francisco

San Francisco Fire Department, Pumping Station No. 2, Van Ness Avenue at Bay, San Francisco, San Francisco County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143-, with a 7,068-word written history.

From the record

“A well preserved, representative example of an early century Steam powered water pumping station.”

Written record, HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143- · the record runs 7068 words · one of 382 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

198 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Van Ness Avenue at Bay, San Francisco, California Designed by: Marsden Mansden, City Engineer Owner: Rational Park Service (its of Van Ness Avenue at Bay, San Francisco, San Francisco County, California Pump Station No. 2 is located at latitude: longitude: The coordinate represents the structure s northwest corner. This point was obtained on December 6, using Google Earth There is no restriction on its release to the public. Date(s) of Construction: Architect/Engineer/ Builder: The building was designed by the engineering firm of Manson, Marsden, Caldwell & Co..

Civil engineer Manson Marsden held the office of San Francisco City Engineer from to During this time, he was involved with the city s water supply, concerning Hetch Hetchy Valley and Lake Eleanor, and the Spring Valley Water Company.2 Original Owner/ Occupant and Use: Owned by the City and County of San Francisco and operated under the jurisdiction of United States Army as part of the Fort Mason Military Reservation. Present Owner/ Occupant and Use: Owned by the City and County of San Francisco and operated under the jurisdiction of the National Park Service as part of the Fort Mason Historic District within the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, as of

Significance

6592 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

A well preserved, representative example of an early century Steam powered water pumping station. The site also retains historical significance because of its associations with the city's fire fighting system. It was built to help insure that San Francisco would not be subject to devastating fires such as those that-occured after the earthquake. History prepared by: Gordon Chappell, (in form of a National Register Nomination) Transmitted Gary R.

Arabak, by: 5V-Ti"Nn 1^ 306 -Rev i0 74* HAER CA-1 l.NMl.DSi All-.N m-.PAlU.Ml \I Ol- fill IMI-.KIUK FOR NPSUSE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE ^NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES RECEIVED INVENTORY NOMINATION FORM DATE ENTERED FOR FEDERAL PROPERTIES SEE INSTRUCTIONS IN HOW TO COMPLETE NATIONAL REGISTER FORMS TYPE ALL ENTRIES- COMPLETE APPLICABLE SECTIONS (THNAMF 2 k"* * Pumping Station No, 2, San Francisco Fire Department Auxiliary HISTORIC Water Supply System _ ANO/Ofi COMMON " ^

Location Streets Number

At northern end of Van Ness Avenue __NOTFOR PUBLICATION CITY. TOWN CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT San Francisco VICINITY Of STATE COOE COUNTY CODE California 06 San Francisco 075 ^CLASSIFICATION CATEGORY OWNERSHIP STATUS PRESENT USE DISTRICT ^-PUBLIC ^.OCCUPIED AGRICULTURE _MUSEUM _BUILDINGtS) PRIVATE UNOCCUPIED COMMERCIAL _PARK STRUCTURE BOTH WORK IN PROGRESS EDUCATIONAL __ R!VA TE HECiDCNCE SITE PUBLIC ACQUISITION ACCESSIBLE ENTERTAINMENT _-REUGlOUS OBJECT IN PROCESS YES: RESTRICTED ^.GOVERNMENT .-SCIENTIFIC _BEING CONSIDERED _YES: UNRESTRICTED ^INDUSTRIAL TRANSPORTATION NO MtUTARY _0THER: AGENCY REGIONAL HEADQUARTERS I If applicable) National Park Service Western Region Office STREETS NUMSER ' ISO Golden Gate Avenue Box

City. Town State

San F^^cisco

Vicinity of

California ^LOCATION OF LEGAL DESCRIPTION COURTHOUSE REGISTRY OF DEEDS. ETC. San Francisco City Hall, County Recorder's Office STREET & NU.MSEH Civic Genberj between polk and Van Mess CITY. TOWN STATE REPRESENTATION IN EXISTING SURVEYS TITLE Historic African ..nriij/jorln^ Record DA 11 " i i.Uf II/-I. ... s:AiF_ .COviNIY ..LOCAL DEPOStlOsr. -OR SURVEY RECORDS Librae of Congrc: CITY,

Town State

Washington HAER CA-1 DESCRIPTION CONDITION CHECK ONE CHECK ONE ^EXCELLENT ...DETERIORATED ^UNALTERED ^ORIGINAL SITE _GOOD _RUINS -.ALTERED DATE _FAIR _.UNEXPOSED D SCRi8ETH6 PRESENT AND ORIGINAL {IF KNOWN}

Physical Appearance

This building is located on the east side or Black Point on a corner of the Fort Mason Military Reservation at the foot (northern end) of Van Ness Avenue at the edge of San Francisco Rav, adjacent to the municipal Aquatic Par): Pi'jr. It oroched en bedrock on a si'oe leveled to accommodate the structure. In aadition to the main building there are a high smokestack, some underground fuel oil storage tanks, and a couple of large above-ground water storage tanks. The main building is a simple rectangle built of steel and- reinforced concrete in Mission Revival style architecture. The east side presents its public face, and the north end carries its entrance. On the north, three large windows match a series of four similai windows on the east.

These and a skylight which extends nearly the x'ull length of the building are sources of natural light, along with three small fan-lights high on the south wall. The scale is large: each window is at least 12 feet wide, and from sill to arched head about 20 feet high. These windows are divided into thirds both vertically and horizontally, but not into equal parts. The units thus formed are further divided into even smaller parts. On the east side of the building, high on the wall, there are small narrow windows near the corners. Both have little wrought iron balconies supported on decorative metal brackets. Directly below and at the first floor level there are three small windows.

The north end has blind windows set high on the wall at the corners and beneath at first floor level is a single window under each. The main door into the building is located here on the north side. This door was set into and is a part of the first arched window opening. Here the window was interrupted at mid-point by a shallow projection with the door occurring below that. The doer is in four parts and all may bo opened to allow for removal or installation of large equipment. The large arched windows are the chief decorative feature of the building, along with a Spanish-style roof projection supported by a series of paired metal brackets directly above the windows. This roof surface is finished with Spanish tiles, and its soffit and fascia are copper weathered to a green shade.

The Spanish roof may best be called an architectural element. It is composed of paired brackets for support, each at a triglyph ,-i~i ete with gattae, the drop-like truncated cone shapes. Both devices relate to the Doric Order. Spaces between tri carry a row of modified dentals. The brackets are exceedingly handsome. Each was fabricated of flat bar steel, about three or four inches wide. The bottom surface is shaped and each bracket is enriched with two openwork scrolls, This shallow roof ends well above and just past the last arched window. Here the architect used one bracket placed flat against the building surface as a finishing device. The soffit corners are decorated. A shaped mission-style parapet screens a simple built-up ridged roof and the large skylight.

The south and west faces of the building are utilitarian, with little decorative architectural relief. A tall smokestack located on the west side of the structure is free- standing on its own foundation. Today it is a simple concrete, cylinder, althou#i at one time it had a decorative collar near the top, and is thus altered from its original appearance. The finish surface of the main structure is stucco painted a light yellow or cream color. The base of the building is defined by a horizontal band of heavy moulding at sill height about five feet above grade. Inside, one corner of the room has a small separate office and a narrow stair which leads above it to an employee lecker room. Another corner is a maintenance area for the building, with tool- racks and workbench.

The walls are of reinforced concrete, and concrete pilasters on the north and south end walls support metal trusses. An overhead crane system, the roof trusses and trim in general are all painted darx green, while walls HAEE ,CA-1 Form No !(l-3'00a (Hev . UMTt-.DSTAlLS 01 THL INTERIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONALPARK SERVICE RECEIVED NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES DATE ENTERED INVENTORY -- NOMINATION FORM CONTI NU ATI ON SHEET ITEM NUMBER PAGE 1 are a crea.ii color, nearly white. Much of the machinery is painted a rich milk-chocolate brown. The floor surface is thought to be anti-magnetic red composition flooring, scored. There are large areas of the floor of metal plate, and others with open^mesh grills for drainage.

The building, both exterior and interior, is beautifully maintained, and gives every evidence of having been throughout its life. The main interior space of the building is filled with the station's machinery. On the south wall, where both fresh water for the boilers and fuel oil for the fireboxes is introduced are two Cochrane Feedwater Heaters built by the Harrison Safety Boiler Works of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, These are in the middle of the south wall. Just to the west of them, alcna: the wall, are three boiler water feed pumps, and north of these out in the bay are two similar fuel oil pumps with sir banks and fuel oil heaters, all of these pumps manufactured by the George E. Low Pumping ingine Co.

of San Francisco, The pumps were, respectively, builder's numbers 65Ui, and 85U2, in sequence of the numbers assigned to the three water and two fuel pumps. These pumps fed water and fuel oil to six: patented Stirling Boilers built by the Babcock and Wilcox Company at their Barberton itforks in Earberton, .Ohio. ach boiler had 3hX 34-inch tubes and was k2 inches in diameter, made of open hearth steel under Contract in Each boiler had two fireboxes, three steam drums and one mud drum, and they are Class M Number 17 type. They were built to operate at 200 pounds per square inch pressure, but in the mid-1960s the state boiler inspector ordered therrf cut back ten per cent to a maximum operating pressure of 180 due to their age.

Steam from the boilers was fed through cream-colored overhead pipes to four main pumps driven by Curtis Steam Turbines which had a horsepower rating of 750 and a speed of revolutions per minute, operating at 15 0 pounds pressure. These were non- condensing pumps. These turbines, in order of their assigned numbers north to south, carried builder's numbers and ach carried 12 oatent dates, ranging from Kay 15, I89U to May 25, srA were marked by the builder as "licensed to be used for all purposes except as a prime mover for marine and aerial craft." All were manufactured by the General electric Company oC Schenectady, New York, These steam turbines each drove a pump with a capacity of gallons per minute at a pressure of 300 pounds per square inch operating at revolutions per minute.

These pumps were built by the Byron Jackson Iron Works, Inc., of San Francisco, under patents dated Nov. 11, January 29, and June 2, others pending. To supply electrical power both for the plant and for Fort Mason, along the east side (tbe pumrs nei.r-t- -d north to south rewr. the crnter, and -&he boilors boir.^; backed up alor.p the west wall) but some distance out from the wall, are three steam turbine-driven generators, powered by Curtis steam turbines, having builder's numoers according to their numerical sequence north to south of 78i 2, and These were condensing turbines, and their venerators produced a capacity of 100 kilowatts each at a speed of 3,oG0 revolutions per minute powered by steam at 150 pounds cor scuaro. 'inc.i p"er: ; .

'ach of .ti-^re Lurbinjs was manufactured ur., T eir.rrc.ecn paoen-os raj:;a;.,:" from May 15, I89U to June 8, licensed with limitations like those of the puizp turbines, and built by General klectric Company at Schenectady, Mew York. Attached to the various machinery and equipment is a variety of generally brass- ' ' HAER CA-1 (m No lf> 30Ca ev 10 74) (P. 5 ) LNni-DSTAil-SDhPARTMLM'Oi- 'I INTLRiOR FOR NPSUSE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE RECEIVED NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLAGES DATE ENTERED INVENTORY -- NOMINATION FORM CONTINUATION SHEET ITEM NUMBER 7 PAGE 2 encased gauges and meters and thermometers. The brass-encased thermometers were made by Hohmann & Maurer Manufacturing Company of R0chester, New York.

Many of the brass- encased pressure gauges were supplied by Charles C, Moore & Co., Fngineers, of San Francisco, and were "Crosby Gases1' supplied by the Crosby Steam Gauge and Valve Company under patents dated C-cemoer 23, August 28, and September 8, These carried builder's numbers, north to south in seauence, of 0UOO69, 6u007G, 6U0O77, 6U0071, 6I;C076, The plant has at least one Uf incn brass-encased steam gauge built by the La France Fire Engine Company of Lmira, Mew York. To measure the volume of water pumped, the plan is equipped with two 2It-inch Venturi Meters, which measure in thousands of gallons per minute. These, also brass encased, ware manufactured by the Builder's Iron Foundry of Providence, Rhode Island. They had a diameter of 2ii inches and a 13-inch throat.

They were shipped in June the north meter has Tube Number and the south meter was No. Attached to these were Type M indicator recorders, instrument no. 3u7 on the north line, 3li6 on the south. These carried the following patent data; Clemens Herschel, Oct. 17, Connet & JacKscn, Nov. 20, Connet, June 16, others pending. The generator turbines each had pressure gauges manufactured by the Ashcroft Manuf acturing Company of New lork under Patent 6300U9. Along the east wall is a large electrical switchboard made of imported gray Italian marble about If inches thick, on which are mounted various vintage General Electric switches, meters, and other appurtenances. The plant is basically as built in and as of the date of this form, operational. It will soon be altered, however.

The city plans to modernize it by removing the four pump turbines and replacing them with diesel engines, thereafter encasing pumos and engines with metal compartments to contain the noise. The boilers will be abandoned and left in place as museum pieces, but the overhead steam pipe lines will be removed. The generators and generator turbines vail be removed. One' of the pump turbines will be retained and set aside as a museum piece. The electrical switchcoard will be in place as a museum piece, its function replaced by a more modern switchboard. The smokestack, already altered from its original appearance, will be demolished. The subterranean fuel tanks will be excavated and rebuilt in place, and the ground acove them restored with plant cover after completion of the work.

The buUdimr itself, and the function it serves, will remain unchanged, but the manner in which it serves that function will be changed by a change in power from steam power to diesel, Jlas3 VI Land: -| acre (part of Fort Mason Historic District already, but nominated separately becaus'e of entirely different significance than that of Fort Kason) Recommended Level of Treatment: Preservation Estimated Cost of Treatment: . oim-tio 'p HAER CA-1 (P.

6) iev I ML: INTLR10K FOR NPS USE ONLY A NATIONAL PARK SERVICE RECEIVED NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES DATE ENTERED INVENTORY -- NOMINATION FORM NUATION SHEET ITEM NUMBER PAGE 3 Ownership: The building is owned by the City of San Francisco (Fire Department) and the land on which it stands is a part of Fort J'ason formerly under the jurisdiction of the U.S. Army but at present under the jurisdiction of the National Park Service (Golden Gate National Recreation Area).

The act of Congress approved June 17, by which the City obtained permission to building this pumping station on federal land, reads: Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That the consent of the United States is hereby given to the city of San Francisco, a municipal corporation existing under the laws of the State of California, to locate, construct, maintain, and operate a pumping station with accessory equipment upon the property of the United States at Fort Mason, in the State of California, upon the approval of the Secretary of War as to the location of the works and the design and character of the construction ana under such terms, conditions, and regulations as may from time to time be prescribed by him regarding the use of the reservation for this purpose and the operation and maintenance of the plant.

HAER CA X (P T) SIGNIFICANCE ~ - PERIOD AREAS OF SIGNIFICANCE CHECK ANO JUSTIFY BELOW ^nf HISTORIC - ARCHEOLOGY PREHISTORIC -SCOMMUNITY PI ANNI."-4G . LANDSCAP: ARCHITECTURE RELIGION _1-tOO-l-109 -ARCHEOLOGY-HISTORIC ...CONSERVATION _.LAW ' ....SCIENCE __ AGRICULTURE ^ ..ECONOMICS . __L!TERATUR " .SCULPTURE ARCHITECTURE .^EDUCATION ^MILITARY _SOClAL'HUMANITARIAN .-_ ART ^ENGINEERING _ MUSIC .THEATER COMMERCE ^EXPLORATION SETTLEMENT _ PHILOSOPHY . TRANSPOR TAi ION X - COMMUNICATIONS _. INDUSTRY _ POLITICS GOVERNS 5 NT _ OTHER iSPET'Cv, .-INVENTION SPECIFIC DATES to the present BUILOER/ARCHITECT Marsden Manson/Oaldwell & Co3

Statement of Significance

Pumpine Station Number 2 is of local historical significance in the categories of j'.nrineerinfz and Community Planning. It represents innovative planning and innovative design of an "earthquake-proof" fire fighting system for San Francisco which is auxiliary to the domestic water supply system, V.hile the entire system is unquestionably of local historical significance in the above categories, the greatest part of it consists of underground piping, hydrants, cisterns, reservoirs, fireboats, another pumping station and other facilities throughout the city on city land. This nomination addresses only that portion of the system located on Federal land, specifically Pumping Station No, 2.

This station, and the whole system, represent an outstanding achievement in engineering and community planning in San Francisco's history. The above statement of significance is based upon the following historical data, which must address the entire system in order to define the role of Pumping Station Ko* 2. On the morning of April 18, a major earthquake destroyed many buildings in San Francisco, but more important, caused numerous fires which ultimately merged into one vast city-destroying conflagration. Movement of earth during the quake, and falling buildings tcppled by the earthquake, caused about 300 breaks in the city water mains as well as over broken building service connections. Thus there were over leaks in the city's combined domestic/fire-fighting water supply.

The earthquake also cracked and drained many of the cisterns and reservoirs. Consequently, because of the earthquake there was no water available in many areas of the city with which to fight the fires. As a result, on January 28, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors authorised a study, undertaken by Assistant City Engineer H.O.H. Connick and Consulting engineer Ransom, to devise some sort of water supply that could prevent the situation from recurring in a future earthquake of equivalent magnitude. The Connick/rlansom study recommended a special auxiliary water system for fire-fighting use only, totally separate from the domestic water supply system normally used for fire-fighting, and designed to be as "earthauaKe-proof" as the engineers could make it.

On July 1, a bond issue of o5j was voted to finance construction of such a system covering acres in the northeastern part of San Francisco which constituted the major "downtown" commercial and industrial districts of the city and the area destroyed by the fire. The system consisted of a special all-cast-iron pipe line connected only to the sources of supply and to hydrants, laid as much as possible in solid land and on streets unaffected by'the earthquake, with bell and spigot joints in solid ground and double sol got joints connected by sleeves in unstable or filled land, all joints being leaded for "malleability, and all joints secured by wroupjit-iron bolts.

The system was designed in two major divisions, one largely on the reclaimed fill land south of Market Street, the other largely on the higher land in the "downtown" hills. There were to be five gate fotm No 10-^00a HAER CA-1 (P, 8) (Rev UNITLDSTATLS Dl.PARl MUNT 01 THL IN ThRlOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONALPARK SERVICE RECEIVED NATIONAL REGISTER 0?

HISTORIC PLAGES DATE ENTERED INVENTORY-NOMINATION FORM C0NTINUAT10NSHEET ITEM NUMBER 8 PAGE 1 valves which could close off the segments of the pipeline wnich unavoidable had to be laid through unstable eround (which generally was ground reclaimed by filling from the Bay), Normally, this high~pressure auxiliary water supply system would be supplied with water from the Twin Peaks Reservoir located at an elevation of 755 feet and containing about gallons, the Jones Street Tank, located at an elevation of 329 feet and containing gallons, and the Ashbury Tank, located at an elevation of 1 90 feet and'containing gallons, for a total of gallons.

Additionally, the system could be fed from two suction connections in the Golden Gate Park lakes, which contained gallons, and from municipal swimming pools and 137 storage cisterns of varying capacities which carried a total of gallons. As an additional emergency source of supply, if all of these fresh-water sources proved inadequate, failed, or were sucked dry in an emergency, there were to be two "earthquake-proof" pumping stations on or near the shore of San Francisco Bay which could pump salt water from the Bay into the auxiliary pipeline system, using virtually the whole Pacific Ocean as their ultimate reservoir, although limited somewhat by the availability of fuel oil and fresh water for the boilers which powered the turbine- driven pumps.

Finally, one or more fireboats stationed on the waterfront could not only fi^t waterfront fires using the salt water of the Bay, but could be connected to the high-pressure pipeline system to serve as an additional pumping plant. Due to the corrosive effects of salt water on the cast iron pipes, water was to be drawn from the Bay only in an emergency, as the system would then have to be extensively flushed out with fresh water for about six days.

Each of the two pumping plants was designed to maintain steam pressure in at least one battery of two boilers on a 2U-hour-a-day basis perpetually during the lifetime of the plant, and with a few special exceptions this has been the practice from completion of the system in to the present The first contract for cast iron pipe for the system was awarded in March, Pumping Station No, 1 was built on the western corner of the intersection at 2nd and Townsend Streets about two city blocks from the edge of the Bay, It housed eight Babcock and VJilcox boilers, and the turbines, pumps, and a generator, in a Mission-style reinforced concrete and steel building on bedrock foundation equipped with steel fire doors and shutters or fire curtains, It could pump at full capacity gallons per minute at a pressure of 300 pounds per square inch.

Pumping Station No, 2, the subject of this nomination form, was designed by employees of the city under the direction of City engineer Mars den Mans on and built by Caidwell & Company, It was erected principally in and all of its component machinery manufactured that year, and it went into service with the rest of the system in It is located at the foot of Van Ness Avenue at the northeast corner of Fort Mason Military Reservation on the shore cf San Francisco Hay, It was placed onU.S, Army land because that particular location offered solid bedrock foundation which, although the whole bedrock might shift some, would not likely fracture or shift during an earthquake as much as less stable ground. At that time, Fort Mason was not Form No- 1Q-300a iRev.

HAER CA-1 INTURIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONALPARK SERVICE RECEIVED NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES DATE ENTERED INVENTORY - NOMINATION FORM CONTI NUATION SHEET ITEM NUMBER 8 PAGE 2 supplied with electricity, the commercial system not extending that far northwest in the city by Consequently the Army, eager to obtain a supply of electricity to replace its gas lights, made it a condition of granting the city permission to build the pumping station on Army land that the plant include electrical generators to supply all of the electrical power needed by Fort Mason, Consequently, Pumping Station No, 2 was designed both as a steam powered pumping plant and as a steam powered electrical generating plant, using three comparatively small generators.

The plant supplied electricity to Fort Mason until 19U2, when the demand for power occasioned by World War II exceeded the plant's capacity, and commercial power finally was introduced into Fort Mason. Since that time, the generators at Popping Station No, 2 have served only as a standby power source for Fort Mason. In fighting a fire in the city, the fire department will draw normally on whichever hydrant is more conveniently located, a hydrant connected to the domestic supply or a larger hydrant of the high-pressure auxiliary system* If the two are equally convenient, both may be used.

The high-pressure system has one immediate advantage for the fireman: the reservoirs which feed fresh water into the high-pressure system by gravity are located at sufficient elevation in the city that -the water can be fed from high-pressure hydrants directly into the hoses used to fight the fire, whereas - water from the low-pressure domestic system must first be fed through a pumper truck which boosts its pressure. The cisterns actually constitute an additional backup consisting of many small fresh-water reservoirs located throughout the city which can be drawn on directly by pumper trucks should both the low pressure and high pressure systems fail. From to the present, Pumping Station No. 2 has, like Station No.

1, generally had two of its six boilers constantly under steam on a 2U-hour a day basis in case of emergency, and it requires only about 30 to 35 minutes for the plant to be fully operational and ready to pump salt water. In 193U the city drew up plans for an extension of the high-pressure pipe system and sold a issue of High Pressure Bonds to finance the construction. Consequently in the system was extended from its initial coverage of about 9.5 square miles to acres or about square miles, although pipeline coverage in the areas newly reached was not as dense as in the downtown areas originally covered. The extensions were in the Mission, Marina, Pacific Heights, and Richmond Districts and in the corridor between Golden Gate Park and the Twin Peaks.

Although planned as an aner-^ency system to serve in case of natural disaster, and built before the possibility of aerial saturation bombing of cities in wartime was envisioned, the existence of the high-pressure auxiliary water supply system was a great comfort to San Franciscans during the threat of bombing by the Japanese during World War II. A significant'impact of the auxiliary high pressure water supply system on the city has been experienced in property insurance rates. By the existence of this system had contributed to reducing the basic dwelling rate from about per of insured value for a three year period to A more precise measurement, the National Board of Fire Underwriters would reduce fire insurance rates for proper- HAER CA-1 (P.

10) : orm No l0-300a Rev UNITED STATUS DLi'ARTMLNT Ol THh INTLRIOR FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE RECEIVED NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES DATE ENTERED INVENTORY - NOMINATION FORM CONTINUATION SHEET ITEM NUMBER 8 PAGE 3 ties within three city blocks or a high pressure line from five to fifteen per cent of the insurance premium. Recently the city considered phasing out Pumping Flant No, 2, but the appalling increase in insurance premiums which would have resulted prevented this action. The pumping plants are designed so that Pumping Station No, 1 could operate for full capacity for 192 hours (eight days around the clock) without outside supplies, while Pumping Station No, 2 was limited to U8 hours (two days around the clock).

To operate longer than these periods, each station would require resupply of fuel Oil and fresh water with which to maintain operation of the boilers, '(The major part of the earthquake-associated fire occurred in a three day period). Each station draws salt water from San Francisco Bay through a tunnel six feet in diameter lined with reinforced concrete whose mouth is below the lowest low tide level in the Bay, Each station is connected with the high pressure pipeline system by two separate pipes, each laid along a different route so that if disaster should incapacitate one it might not affect the other, and each feed pipe is capable of handling the entire input of a pumping station.

The only time the San Francisco Fire Department neared the need to use salt water from the Bay was during the San Francisco Warehouse fire of April 28, at 62 Third Street (Third and Brannan Streets, practically next door to Pumping Station No, 1 at Second and Towns end). The first alarm was at 6:0U and the firemen drew on Jones Street Pressure in the high-pressure system as well as on the domestic low pressure system. By they were forced to call in Ashbury Pressure and at they were forced to use Twin Peaks Pressure. At immediately after an immense stock of bonded liquor on the third floor of the building had exploded into flame, third and fourth (general) alarms were issued and at the chief engineer of Fumpins Station No, 1 was directed to prepare to operate.

He reported the station fully operational at 35 minutes later. At a.m. the following day the first alarm of a second major warehouse fire two and a half blocks away at Ukh Townsend Street was turned in, followed by a second alarm at and a third at At that morning a six inch water department supply line from Summit Reservoir to West Bay was opened. Much of the fire in the first warehouse was behind brick walls and steel doors, and although controlled or contained in nine hours, was not out for five days. At 8 a.m. on the third day, April 30, water in the main Twin Peaks Reservoir had. drooped to a low point of U,80p,086 eallcns from at the beginning of the fire.

Had it dropped much lower, salt water from the bay would have had to be used in order to maintain some reservoir pressure in case of other fires in the city. Pumping Station No, 2, the subject of this nomination, was not directly affected. Further extensions and relocations of the system during the late led to modernizing the original piping and construction specifications and standards. In > the city replaced the steam boilers and turbines which drive the pumps with diesel-en^ines in pumping Station No, 1, and is preparing to do the same in Pumping Station No, 2, HAER CA-1(P.11. 2J3MAJOR BIBLIOGRAPHICAL REFERENCES A.J. Cleary, "Auxiliary Water Supply for the Fire Protection of San Francisco/' jfrigineering Record, Vol. 63, biv. h (July 26, pp.

"San Francisco's auxiliary '.'/ater-Supoly for Fire Protection, .jigineering News, Vol. 73, No. 7 (February 13, PP. Fred M, Hyde, "San Francisco's Auxiliary System", Fire and Water Engineering, Vol. LXVI, No. 10 (September 3, PP. k97-U99, [see continuation sheet) ^GEOGRAPHICAL DATA ACREAGE OF NOMINATED PROPERTY 1 UTM REFERENCES A LLJ ZONE LI i 1 , 1 t_L EASTING NORTHING ZONE EASTiNG J LU_U__J NORTHING C l I I I 1 i I 1 i 1 1 i I i L _L

Verbal Boundary Description

The boundary along the west, side is a line parallel to the west (southwest) wall of the building but forty feet away; the north and east boundaries are the curb of the street which leads into Van Ness Avenue on the south and to the piers on the north; the south boundary is the north line of the. stairway which climbs the cliff to Fort Mason* extended eastward to meet the street curb. This land is already a part of the Fort Mason Historic District on the. National Register, under different significance than this building, LIST ALL STATES AND COUNTIES FOR PROPERTIES OVERLAPPING STATE OR COUNTY BOUNDARIES STATE CODE COUNTY CODE STATE CODE COUNTY CODE J|FORM PREPARED BY NAME/ TITLE Gordon Chappell, Regional Historian April 10,

Organization Date

National Park Service, Western Region Office . (lag) &6-ia6$ STREETS NUMBER TELEPHONE _i50 Golden Gate Avenue Box CITY OR TOWN STATE San Francisco California [^'CERTIFICATION OF NOMINATION STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER RECOMMENDATION YES NONE STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER SIGNATURE In compliance with Executive Order 1 1 I hereby nominate this property to the National Register, certifying that the State Historic Preservation- Officer has been allowed 90 days in which to present the nomination to the State Review Board and to evaluate its significance The i-v^unted iovpf of siomficanre is National State Local. FEDERAL REPRESENTATIVE SIGNATURE TITLE DATE FOR NPS USE ONLY I HERESY CERTIFY THATTHIS PROPERTY IS INCLUDED IN THE NATIONAL REGISTER OATE DIRECTOR.

OFFICE: OF ARCHEOLOGY AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION ATTEST:

Date Keeper

Of THE NATIONAL REGISTER -orm No 10300a HAER CA-1 (P. 12) Pev FOR NPS USE ONLY NATIONAL PARK SERVICE RECEIVED NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES DATE ENTERED INVENTORY NOMINATION FORM CONTINUATION SHEET ITEM NUMBER PAGE 1 "The San Francisco Auxiliary Water. Supply System for Fire Protection," The IJ .S, Piper, Charles R, Boden, "San Francisco*s Cisterns,"s California Historical Quarterly, Vol. l , No. h (December, pp. ~~ ADDENDUM TO HAER No. CA-1 SAN FRANCISCO EIRE DEPARTMENT, PUMPING STATION NUMBER TWO / >1- - Van Ness Avenue at Bay p'/iCK San Francisco San Francisco County ^,_ _ . ^ California XEROGRAPHIC COPIES OF COLOR TRANSPARENCIES HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD National Park Service U.S.

Department of the Interior Washington, ADDENDUM TO: HAER CA-1 SAN FRANCISCO FIRE DEPARTMENT, PUMPING STATION NO. 2 HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143- Van Ness Avenue at Bay San Francisco San Francisco County California COLOR TRANSPARENCIES HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior C Street NW Washington, DC ADDENDUM TO: HAER CA-1 SAN FRANCISCO FIRE DEPARTMENT, PUMPING STATION NO. 2 HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143- Fort Mason Historic District Van Ness Avenue at Bay San Francisco San Francisco County California PHOTOGRAPHS WRITTEN HISTORICAL AND DESCRIPTIVE DATA HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD National Park Service Interior Regions 8, 9, 10, and 12 U.S.

Department of the Interior 333 Bush Street San Francisco, CA Addendum to: San Francisco Fire Department, Pumping Station No. 2 HAER No. CA-1 (Page 13) HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD SAN FRANCISCO FIRE DEPARTMENT, PUMPING STATION NO. 2 This report is an addendum to 12 pages previously transmitted to the Library of Congress. Pumping Station No. 2 is of local historical significance in the categories of Engineering and Community Planning. It represents innovative planning and innovative design of an "earthquake-proof" fire fighting system for San Francisco, which is auxiliary to the domestic water supply system.

While the entire system is unquestionably of local historical significance in the above categories, the greatest part of it consists of underground piping, hydrants, cisterns, reservoirs, fireboats, another pumping station and other facilities throughout the city on city land. This 1 Gary R. Araback and Gordon Chappell, Historic American Engineering Record: San Francisco Fire Department: Pumping Station #2 (National Park Service, 1. 2 Guide to the Marsden Manson papers, BANC MSS C-B The Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley: San Francisco Fire Department, Pumping Station No. 2 HAER No. CA-1 (Page 14) nomination addresses only that portion of the system located on Federal land, specifically Pumping Station no. 2.

This station, and the whole system, represents an outstanding achievement in engineering and community planning in San Francisco's history.3 Description: Please see National Register Nomination: Pumping Station No. 2, San Francisco Fire Department Auxiliary Water Supply System, prepared by Gordon Chappel for a detailed description of Pump Station No. 2 and its systems from construction through After the creation of the National Register Nomination, modifications to the building largely took place in the mid-1970s to modernize the plant.

In as part of the work necessary to perform a building upgrade, the California Office of Historic Preservation participated in a Section 106 consultation that culminated in the signing of a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with the National Park Service concerning the treatment of Pump Station No. 2.5 In this, four pump turbines were removed and replaced with diesel engines, the smokestack was removed for structural safety, and openings in the west wall were infilled. The mitigation for converting the pumps from steam to diesel in the MOA required that all of the electrical switchboard, boilers, and the steam- drives auxiliary machinery that did not interfere with the network were to be preserved in place.

All obsolete piping related to the steam power function was removed, and the terminal connections were disposed of. One pump turbine was set aside for preservation. As of the building's foundation, walls, and roof require substantial seismic retrofitting. Planned modifications to the pump station will address seismic deficiencies, while some decommissioned equipment and fixtures will be relocated and/or preserved in place for display and interpretive purposes. Some of the equipment inside the building along the perimeter walls will need to be removed in order to perform this work.

The proposed work is to include the removal of the rear portion of the steam boilers, which will allow the space to be used for a new conference room compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), as well as providing access to the west wall for structural reinforcement. The steam boiler facades will be structurally braced and remain in the existing location. The narrow band of glazed tiles within the boiler corner columns at each end of the facade will be preserved. The original electrical panel will be anchored and remain approximately in its current location. The base of the pumps will be seismically anchored.

History: The Earthquake and the Auxiliary Water Supply System 3 National Register of Historic Places, San Francisco Fire Department: Pumping Station #2, San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, National Register 4 Ibid. 5 Garavaglia Architecture, Inc., Auxiliary Water Supply System, Pump Station No. 2: Finding of Adverse Effect (San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, San Francisco Fire Department, Pumping Station No. 2 HAER No. CA-1 (Page 15) After the earthquake and subsequent fires, which resulted in the loss of 80 percent of the entire property value of the city of San Francisco, city leaders looked to prevent such a disaster from reoccurring.

The scale of the destruction was in part due to the fact that the municipal water system, which had been determined to be inadequate in the years before the temblor, had failed.6 Water mains and pipes throughout the city broke, and many of the cisterns and reservoirs cracked. As a result, water pressure dropped and a system that was stretched to its limit under normal circumstances could not provide enough water to extinguish the fires that broke out. Rebuilding the devastated city, however, proved difficult. Insurance underwriters were reluctant to insure a city so prone to catastrophic damage; as a result, property rates skyrocketed to the point where some residents and business owners could not obtain coverage.

Affordable insurance was available for those who rebuilt with fire-resistant elements. For the city of San Francisco, improvement of its firefighting and water systems was necessary before municipal rates were reduced.7 Months after the earthquake, a study of the system led by Assistant City Engineer Connick and Consulting Engineer T. W. Ransom resulted in not only an improved municipal water supply system, but also an auxiliary system for firefighting. This system would be separate from the municipal supply, specifically for the San Francisco Fire Department.

When the domestic supply was low, a high-pressure system would pump water from the San Francisco Bay into the auxiliary supply.8 The design of the proposed system would be built in such a way that it would be resilient to earthquakes and fires. In San Franciscans voted on a bond issue to finance construction of what would be known as the Auxiliary Water Supply System, or AWSS. The initial area covered by the AWSS was limited to downtown, where the most devastation had occurred in As financing became available, the system was expanded to the remainder of the city. By property insurance premiums had decreased by 50 percent in some cases, depending on the building's location from a high-pressure auxiliary line. Pump Station No. 2 Pump Station No.

2 was designed in in collaboration with City Engineer Marsden Manson and the firm of Caldwell & Company; the station went into service the following year. The location--along San Francisco Bay, at the northeast corner of the Fort Mason Military Extension--was selected because of its solid bedrock foundation, which 6 Stephen Tobriner, Bracing for Disaster: Earthquake-Resistant Architecture and Engineering in San Francisco, (Berkeley: University of California Press), 7 Ibid., 8 A. J. Cleary, "Auxiliary Water Supply for the Fire Protection of San Francisco," Engineering Record, Vol. 68, No. 4 (July 26, San Francisco Fire Department, Pumping Station No. 2 HAER No. CA-1 (Page 16) would be more stable in an earthquake. As Fort Mason lacked electrical service, Pump Station No.

2 was designed as both a steam-powered pumping plant and a steam-powered electrical generating plant. This dual purpose continued until when the increased need for electricity during World War II led to the introduction of commercial power to Fort Mason. Various moderations and alterations have taken place at Pump Station No. 2. In the late the system was modernized; in the the original boiler and turbine power sources were upgraded with diesel engines.

Sources

133 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Araback, Gary R. Historic American Engineering Record: San Francisco Fire Department: Pumping Station #2, HAER CA-1. National Park Service, National Register of Historic Places, San Francisco Fire Department: Pumping Station #2, San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, National Register Cleary, A. J. "Auxiliary Water Supply for the Fire Protection of San Francisco," Engineering Record, Vol. 68, No. 4 (July 26, Garavaglia Architecture, Inc., Auxiliary Water Supply System, Pump Station No. 2: Finding of Adverse Effect (San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, Guide to the Marsden Manson papers, BANC MSS C-B The Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley: Tobriner, Stephen.

Bracing for Disaster: Earthquake-Resistant Architecture and Engineering in San Francisco, Berkeley: University of California Press. Historian(s): Information compiled by: Alison Garcia Kellar, Senior Architectural Historian, and Renee Nickenig, Architectural Historian, of Garavaglia Architecture, Inc., December

Written history

78 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The plan to seismically retrofit the building will have an adverse effect on the historic property according to the Memorandum of Agreement created in The HAER documentation for this property is an agreement between the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, San Francisco Maritime National Park, Advisory Council for Historic Preservation, San Francisco Public Utilities Commission and the California State Historic Preservation Office to mitigate, in part, the adverse effects of the seismic retrofit at Pump Station No. 2.

In context

San Francisco, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Francisco County, California 67 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in San Francisco

24 of 381 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through San Francisco building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
San Francisco Oakland Bay BridgeHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,141-127,296 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHAER CA-227086,796 words
Ship BalcluthaHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,200-80,588 words
Market StreetHALS CA-16434,536 words
San Francisco Cable RailwayHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,137-30,695 words
Aquatic ParkHALS CA-11328,000 words
George Washington High SchoolHABS CA-293919,932 words
Sloop Yacht KathleenHAER CA-229919,410 words
Fort FunstonHAER CAL,38-SANFRA, 214A-16,940 words
Schooner C.A. THAYERHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,199-16,891 words
North Beach PlaceHABS CA-272716,167 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,211-14,693 words
Pier 16 & Bulkhead BuildingHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,142-14,202 words
Jewish Community Center of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,204-14,088 words
Knights of Pythias BuildingHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,172-13,633 words
City of Paris Dry Goods CompanyHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,135-11,407 words
Ferry EUREKAHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,194-11,248 words
Hunters Point Naval ShipyardHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,195A-10,629 words
Hunters Point Naval ShipyardHAER CA-227310,046 words
Steam Tug HERCULESHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,201-9,787 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,177-9,564 words
California State BuildingHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,202-9,200 words
Fort MasonHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,9A-9,188 words
Presidio Water Treatment PlantHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,197-8,476 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,143-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.