BlockBefore

Charles Fernald House, 412 West Montecito Street (moved from 422 Santa Barbara), Santa Barbara

Charles Fernald House, 412 West Montecito Street (moved from 422 Santa Barbara), Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,42-SANBA,10-, with a 3,185-word written history.

From the record

“A nineteenth century Queen Anne house, with a "Gothic" flavor.”

Written record, HABS CAL,42-SANBA,10- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,42-SANBA,10- · the record runs 3185 words · one of 167 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

2945 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,42-SANBA,10-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

A nineteenth century Queen Anne house, with a "Gothic" flavor. This house was built for Judge Charles Fernald, a leading legal and political figure in late nineteenth century Southern California society. G. Physical History: 1. Original and subsequent owners: Charles Fernald from Hannah H. Fernald, from Florence Fernald from Santa Barbara Historical Society, present. 2. Date of erection: 3. Architect: Credited to Roswell Forbush, an American cabinet maker who came to Santa Barbara before I850. Forbush practiced in Santa Barbara as both a contractor-carpenter and as a cabinet maker. k Original plans, construction, etc.; None known. 5. Notes on alterations and additions: The original house of was a two story 30 * square brick structure.

The building was covered by a medium pitched hipped roof; a single story porch ran across the front of the house, a second single story porch ran across the south side of the house, and a wood lean-to kitchen was at the rear The original plan of the house is almost entirely obscured by later remodeling, but it would seem that it consisted of a hall to the south side and a parlor living room, connected by a wide opening to dining room to the rear. The kitchen was housed in a wood wing attached to the east side of the brick mass. Upstairs there were two bedrooms along the north side, and a hall along all or part of the south side.

This CAL - 240 Page 3 c^ conjectural reconstruction of the original house is supported by an drawing of the house and by the evidence of the structure itself (see attached plan.). The original house occupied the area of the present music room (without the north addition and the west bay window; the entry hall, without projecting vestibule{?); the passage to the rear of the entrance hall and apparently part of the present dining room. (Note how the original brick wall projects out 7* 0" between the dining room and the pantry), Whether the curved stair case as it now exists was designed at the time of the original house is open to question. Around the house was completely remodeled and enlarged.

The remodeling has been credited to both Thomas Nixon, a local architect-contractor, and also to the architect Peter J. Barber. The general style of the house and much of its specific exterior detailing is quite similar to buildings which are authenticated as having been designed by Nixon. The closest existing Nixon designed house would be the George Sexton Edwards house, built in (located at Santa Barbara Street). Regrettably little information has been recorded about Thomas Nixon. In an article on him (Santa Barbara New Press, March 20, it stated that he was an architect builder and mill owner and that he died in the"mid s." This same article also lists a number of his houses and other buildings, most of which are no longer in existence. The remodeling of ca.

was in fact a complete rebuilding, with the exterior and interior of the house being fully changed. On the south side of the house a library, dining room and porch were added. An angled entrance vestibule was added to the front entry; while the two rooms at the west side of the house were thrown together to form a single room. A bay with seat was projected off the new enlarge living room. The service area and kitchen to the rear of the house were also remodeled; with the present arrangement of pantry, storage and kitchen being realized at this time. On the second floor two new bedrooms were added, one over the first floor library, the other over the dining room. A second servant's room, etc. was placed over the kitchen. The roof was also completely rebuilt at the time of this remodeling.

The old low pitched hipped roof was replaced by a steeply pitched series of gable roofs, with elaborate sawed and turned wood work in the gable ends, pinnacles projecting from each of the gable ends, originally a scalloped mental roof ridge, and typically high, narrow panelled Queen Anne chimneys. GAL - 2^0 Page k HA' The character of the house , after this remodeling can be seen by consulting a perspective drawing of the house on the borders of the ca, panoramic view of Santa Barbara Several later changes were made to the structure- A bath and closet, together with a horizontal row of three windows was added between the southwest and southeast bedrooms.

The living room (now called the Music room) was enlarged by adding 6* 3" to its north side- There were undoubtedly some changes made at this time in the rear service wing for the ca. view of the house does not show the present single story wing off the east side of the kitchen. As late as the two French doors were placed in trie south dining room bay, a wood decked pergola was built onto the north side of the living room and a downstairs bath was provided at the northeast corner of the house. The house originally stood within a landscaped single block at Santa Barbra Street. The house faced west, and the property was surrounded by a low cast iron fence.

In August, the brick walls of the house were removed and replaced by wood studding, and the house was cut into three parts and moved to its present Montecito location. Charles Whitaker of Santa Barbara was in general charge of moving and restoring the house. It was moved by Frank Villalba, a Santa Barbara house mover. At its new site it was oriented in the same direction as at its original site (facing west); a new foundation was provided, and other minor changes were made. The fire places were all rebuilt and are no longer operative. Important old views: a. Pencil drawing of west and south side of original brick house, dated November 2k, and signed "E.G." collection of the Santa Barbara Historical Society. b. View of house from south, Panoramic view of Santa Barbara, published ca.

* Santa Barbara. c. View of south side of house, etching by Chapman Ford", in 36 Etchings by Henry Chapman Ford 1 selected and published by Edward Seldon Spaulding, Santa Barbara Historical Society. CAi - Page 5 CA^_ ~. d Photograph of house published to accompany article "The Fernald House.

* * Historical Document, ' Santa Barbara News Press, February 6, Historical Events connected with house J Judge Charles Fernald's life in this house is discussed in Cameron Rogers* A Country Judge in Arcady , Glendale, According to information supplied by the Santa Barbara Historical Society " Judge Charles Fernald was born in North Berwick, Maine on May 27, He came to California when less than nineteen years of age , arriving in San Francisco on June After a few months in the mining camps he returned to San Francisco, where he was employed .by the Post an< * Alta, leading publications of that time , and at the same time continued his law studies.

In Charles Fernald decided to return to New England, and on his way home he stopped off in Santa Barbara to visit friends- At that time Santa Barbara was being terrorized by an organized gang of bandits, which caused many of the county officials to resign. He was offered the position of sheriff, which he accepted, and remained in Santa Barbara. He later served as district attorney and was elected county judge three consecutive terms. In Judge Fernald was elected Mayor of Santa Barbara. He also carried on an active law practice and was admitted to practice in the State Supreme Court and in the Supreme Court of the United States, On August 7) Judge Fernald returned to North Berwick, Maine to marry Miss Hobbs.

They returned to Santa Barbara and later in that year he built this house for his bride. Five children were born to Judge and Fernald. They were - Beatrice(who married Robert Cameron Rogers), Edith (who died at the age of 7 years), Florence, Charles, and Reginald. Miss Florence lived in the family home until her death at the age of 91 References i L. The house and Charles Fernald Fernald, Charles, Papers, at the Huntington Library, San Marino, California. tos Angeles Times, July 20, Rogers, Cameron, A Country Judge in Arcady The Arthur H.

Clark,Co., Glendale, Calif., Santa Barbara News Press February 6, January 18, February 1, March 5, May 21, CAL Page 6 CAU 10 Santa Barbara News Press " August 25, August 26, January 11, i960 July 10, i960 Spaulding, Edward Seldon, 3 6 Etc hi ng s by Henry Chapman Ford. Selected and published by the author. Santa Barbara Historical Society, Santa Barbara, Storke, Yda Addis, Santa Barbara, San Luis Obispo and Ventura .Counties, Lewis Publishing Co., Chiago, pp. Thompson and West, History of Santa Barbara and Ventura Counties, California * Originally published in Oakland, republished by Howell-North, Berkeley, pp. b. Thomas Nixon Kroll, Francis Cooper, Memories of Rancho Santa Rosa and Santa Barbara.

Santa Barbara Historical Society, Santa Barbara, n <d, Santa Barbara News Press March 20, July 28, I963 David Gebhard August k, Part II: ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATIONS !~iA6S A. Names Charles Fernald House *U-SAM&4 ,c, Address: klZ Montecito Street ~ Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara County, California B. Number of stories: two C. Type of wall construction: Original house-brick (wood kitchen); later additions wood. D. Layout: Original house: side hall plan with rear lean-to kitchern Remodeled house: Central hall plan. E. General Statement s Architectural interest and merit. The remodeling of this house produced an elaborately detailed Queen Anne house. The wood detailing both within and without represents a highly original version of Queen Anne decoration. F. General Statement: Condition of Fabric.

In good condition, considering its age and the fact that it was cut into three parts and moved to its present site. G-. Detailed Description General (see Part I, G, 5) for description of the sequence of remodelings and additions to the original house. See also accompanying plan. H. Overall Dimensions (see attached plan) Original house: Front (west side) 30* 9"5 sides 30* 9" Dimensions of kitchen wing unknown. Present house: Front(west side) 51* 0"; side 37f 6" Rear service wing: two story section: east side 20* 0" ; north and south sides 13* 1M, one story section: east side 20* 0"; north and south sides 19( 2" South porch 6 6" wide North Pergola 9' 9" x 28* 9" I.

Foundation: Original, cut stone foundation: Basement described in 19^9(Santa Barbara News Press, February 6, as deep, wide and lined with native stone." Cut stone was also used for the ca. addition, although only a crawl space was provided under all of the new addition to the house. A poured reinforced footing and concrete block foundation was provided when the house was moved to its present site on Montecito Street. J. Wall Construction: Original house: 12" thick solid brick wall, lime plastered on inside, red brick left exposed on exterior. Ca. remodeling: wood stud construction; lime plaster and some wood paneling, interior; exterior CAL - Page 8 , L , .,- covered with smooth tongue and groove horizontal -q^A^EA boards. These were painted with a sand paint to 1&_ imitate stucco.

The old brick section of the house was stuccoed over and painted. K, Porches, Stoops: Original house: two porches running along front (west side) and the south side of house; front porch with half-hipped roof, central gable; south porch with half-hipped roof, Ca remodeling: South dining porch: five sided porch; tongue and groove wood floored, four rectangular wood paneled piers support a flat roof deck which is surrounded on five sides by a wood railing. Added ca. North pergola; tongue and groove wood floor; partially surrounded by railing; four undecorated posts support lintel, which in its turn supports 15 exposed rafters. Service porch off north side of service wing: probably contemporary with one story addition to service wing. Front stoop: modern. L.

Chimneys: Original house: two chimneys, large in scale may be seen in the drawing of the house Ca. remodeling: One narrow, high chimney may be seen in the ca, view of th house. Present: either partially or completely rebuilt. M, Openings: Doorways and doors: The projecting front vestibule with its angular paneled wide door and leaded colored glass transome are most likely a product of the ca. remodeling; although the angular bay itself may have been part of the original house. The glass doors which lead from the dining room to the south porch are certainly century, as are the pair of glass doors which lead from the music room to the north pergola. N. Openings: Windows and shutters. Original house: Windows appear to be double hung windows with one horizontal and one vertical bar per sash.

Ca. remodeling: All major windows, double hung, single panes of glass in each section. Small windows in west living room bay, single pane, fixed. In a characteristic Queen Anne fashion, a number of the windows are grouped together with lower wood panels and upper paneled entablature and cornice. Ot Roof: Shape,covering. Original house: Medium pitched hip roof; probably covered with shingles. Ca. remodeling: Central high pitched gable roof; off which project four similar high pitched gable roofs; lower pitched gable roof covered two story kitchen wing; CAL - 2^0 Page 9 HASe flat roof over south porch; all covered with wood cAL shingles * 'Hz-SAMSA \o~ P. Roofs Cornice, eaves. Original house i Eaves appear boxed; both on main roof and on the eaves of the two porches Ca.

remodeling: eaves boxed in ; supported by small wood bracketts j elaborate cross and vertical beam and sawed wood ornament, plus pinnacle provided in each gable end. Q. Roof % Dormers, Cupolas: none R. Floor plan: (see attached floor plan) (Present House) First floor: Central Entry Hall 12' 6" x 15* 3" Music room (to north) 17' 11" x 28* 0" Library (to south of hall) 15* 6" x 26 0" Dining Room (to south of rear passage and east of library) 13' 8" x 26' 6" Second floor: Central stair hall 12* 6" x 13* 11" Northwest bedroom 12' 6" x 15* 11" Northeast bedroom 12* 6" x 12* 3" Southwest bedroom 15' 2" x 16* 11" Southeast bedroom 0" x 26* 6" S. Stairways: Main stairway: shaped, curved at corner of "L" 16 steps; 8" risers, 9" treads.

Carved railing supported by angular and lathed balusters; heavy, elaborate newel post at base. Similar rail and baluster around stair opening on second floor. Rear stairway: (off kitchen) Curved "U" shaped stairway; 17 steps, 7" risers, 9i" tread. T. Flooring! Original house: unknown Ca. remodeling; Complicated oak parquet flooring in principal first floor rooms; rest of house 1" x 6" tongue and groove soft wood flooring. U. Wall and Ceiling Finish: Lime plaster on brick (original section of house) and on wood lath in later section of house. Wood wainscoting (painted) paneled in hall and dining room. Ceilings all lime plaster on wood lath. V. Interior doorways and doors: All of the interior door trim and the doors would appear to be a product of the ca. remodeling.

The double sliding doors separating the library and the dining room, the dining room doors to the central passageway, etc. contain an interesting zigzag molding at top of the upper and lower panels CAL - 2k0 Page 10 HABS W. Interior trims A zigzag pattern was used very often ^^AtJKA throughout the house on doors , wainscoting, etc. Wood m cornices were used in the dining room, library and music y "' rooms and in several of the upstairs rooms. X* Hardware: With the exception of the exterior glass doors in the music room and the dining room, and several of the doors in the service wing, the remaining doors, locks9 handles and butt hinges would appear to date from the ca. remodeling, Y.

Lightings It is recorded that because of the fear of fire upon the part of the Fernalds that candles were used in the house during the century (Santa Barbara News Press , February 6, Z. HeatingtThere are four fire places in the present house; those in the dining room and in two of the upstairs bedrooms must date from the ca. remodeling. A fireplace was provided for the library in the ca. remodeling, but the design of the present fireplace which is quite "Craftsman" is similar in style to the Craftsman-like pergola on the north side of the house. Both probably date from ca. AA. Site-General Original site: an entire city block, bounded by Santa Barbara Stree, Haley Street, Garden Street and Gutierrez Street. BB.

Orientation: Original site: house faced west: At the front of the house there was a flat raised earth terrace four steps above the surrounding ground level. The walks to the house, approached from Santa Barbara Street, running on the north and the south side of the earth terrace, ca. 10' from the west side of house, the walks turned at right angles, ascended four steps which led to the upper walk. The steps of the entrance stoop were at right angles to this upper walk. The yard and garden of the Fernald house were famous for the variety and the quality of its plantings. CC. Enclosures: Low iron fence around street side of property {probably the result of the ca. remodeling). DD. Out buildings: None presently known. E . Walks and drive ways (see BB) FF.

Landscaping: Original site (see BB; and ca. drawing of south elevation of house). m David Gebhard APPROVED; S B> - DATE: S*uX 1 f Charles S. Pope, AIA

In context

Santa Barbara, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Santa Barbara County, California 294 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Santa Barbara

24 of 117 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through Santa Barbara building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Cold Spring Canyon BridgeHAER CA-229813,314 words
Santa Cruz Island Historic Ranching DistrictHABS CA-288811,810 words
Santa Rosa Island Historic Ranching DistrictHABS CA-27385,962 words
La Casa de la GuerraHABS CAL,42-SANBA,8-4,471 words
Hunt-Stambach HouseHABS CAL,42-SANBA,11-2,407 words
Trussell-Winchester AdobeHABS CAL,42-SANBA,9-2,039 words
Knox Brick HouseHABS CAL,42-SANBA,14-2,029 words
Narciso Canedo AdobeHABS CAL,42-SANBA,12-1,895 words
Buena Ventura Pico AdobeHABS CAL,42-SANBA,13-1,745 words
San Roque Canyon BridgeHAER CAL,42-SANBA,15-1,303 words
V.E. Wood Auto BuildingHABS CAL,42-SANBA,25-1,229 words
Larco BuildingHABS CAL,42-SANBA,22-1,207 words
Mission Santa BarbaraHABS CAL,42-SANBA,5-524 words
Albert Hayman CottageHABS CAL,42-SANBA,21-470 words
T.J. Young CottageHABS CAL,42-SANBA,26-449 words
La Casa de Joaquin CarilloHABS CAL,42-SANBA,6-368 words
El CuartelHABS CAL,42-SANBA,3-367 words
710 Anacapa Street (House)HABS CAL,42-SANBA,17-318 words
Covarrubias AdobeHABS CAL,42-SANBA,7-299 words
326 West Ortega Street (House)HABS CAL,42-SANBA,16-262 words
Yorbe-Abadie HouseHABS CAL,42-SANBA,1-207 words
Miranda HouseHABS CAL,42-SANBA,2-171 words
Mrs. A. L. M. Vhay HouseHABS CAL,42-SANBA,4-143 words
1962 Willys 'Jeep' CJ-6HAER CA-232083 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,42-SANBA,10-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.