Demolished Significance San Roque Canyon Bridge is significant because of the commitment to concrete prelevant in California, the plate girder arch, as a type, is relatively rare. There are only two known in the State at this time, and since the other is a through arch span, San Roque Canyon Bridge is the only known one of its type in California. Report Preparation: John W. Snyder, CALTRANS Staff Architectural Historian ban Koque Canyon Bridge HAER No. CA-17 (page 2) San Roque Canyon Bridge, Bridge No. is described as steel stringer approach spans and three hinge steel plate girder arch spans on steel column bent and concrete seat abut- ments, all on spread footings.
Its five spans total 482 feet in length, 28 feet in width, and carry a two-lane, 22-foot roadway and a five-foot sidewalk between steel railings; its two arches span 18 8 feet each. The bridge was designed in by Ulysses Sumner Grant, a civil engineer in the Office of Santa Barbara County Surveyor Owen H. O'Neill; the bridge was built in by contractor C. B. Davison for Santa Barbara County. Development of this route began in as an attempt to relieve traffic congestion and provide a foothill route between Santa Barbara and Goleta. Construction on the route began in June and was completed in April The first proposal for the bridging of San Roque Canyon called for the salvaging and reuse of the Fourth Street Viaduct, then being replaced in Los Angeles.
O'Neill's design for this proposal called for three Pratt truss spans. However, no action was taken by the Supervisors on the bids subsequently submitted, and they eventually ordered O'Neill to prepare new plans. These were pre- c pared by Grant, then in the employ of O'Neill. Grant, apparently at the direction of O'Neill, prepared five different designs for study, of which the subject bridge was one. Others were: a concrete arch bridge, virtually a copy of the then-12-year old Arroyo Hondo Bridge; a twin-towered suspension bridge whose cables would have supported Warren-trussed deck spans; a trussed-arch suspension bridge which would have crossed the canyon with a single arch; and a design utilizing a pair of two-hinged trussed arch-spans similar in elevation ^ to the selected design.
Eventually, the present design was selected; P apparently the main factor was cost, estimated at for this design and higher for the others. Construction began in April and proceeded smoothly during that spring and summer. A labor dispute arose in September when it was revealed that subcontractor Minneapolis Steel and Machinery was employing outside labor in violation of a pledge by the contractor to ^ ? use local labor. However, the matter was resolved without delay to the steel work, which was completed on October 1, Work began on the deck and was apparently completed by November 9, since that date was selected for acceptance by the supervisors at their December 7 meeting. Designer U.'S. Grant was born September 9, in Laramie, Wyoming.
His father was a mining and civil engineer, and his mother the county school superintendent and teacher. His education was in the public schools of Laramie, and at the University of Wyoming where he gained a degree in civil engineering in He came to California that same year, and was employed by the Celite Company as a topographical engineer for six months. Moving to Los Angeles, he worked first for the Pacific Light and Power Company, and later did surveying work for the Southern Pacific Railroad in Ventura before returning to Santa Barbara and entering employ in the office of the San Roque Canyon Bridge HAER No. CA-17 (page 3) County Surveyor. He remained in that position until when he assumed private practice. He had a brief partnership with Francis Evans.
His work included Peabody Stadium at Santa Barbara High School, work for Johns-Manville in Lompoc, and runways for military airports in Santa Barbara and San Diego during World War II. In he was joined by son Mortimer Leslie Grant, who became a full partner in U. S. Grant died in In terms of engineering or technological development, the subject bridge fails .to exhibit significance. Plate girder arch bridges date to the turn of the century as a type; Grant's education would have included knowledge of the type. Research in Steel magazine for this period indicates other larger examples were being built and winning annual design awards.
Given that concrete was the tfsual choice for bridges in California after the first years of the Century, the use of steel here probably reflects the effects of the Depression, enabling steel to underbid concrete. (As an aside, even the State resorted to building three-hinged, trussed wooden arch spans during this period , of short funds; these were later replaced with concrete bridges as \^ funds became available.) However, these same factors of commitment to concrete and Depression-era contingencies combine to provide other significance for the bridge. Because of the commitment to concrete prevalent in California, the plate girder arch, as a type, is rela- tively rare.
Indeed, there are only two Juiown in the State at this time, and since the other is a through arch span, San Rogue Canyon Bridge is the only known one of its type in California. In applying National Register criteria, this bridge has integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling and association. It does not appear to be associated with events which have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history (Criterion A); its association with the Depression is peri- pheral. It does not appear to be associated with the lives of persons significant in our past (Criterion B). It has not yielded, and does not appear likely to yield information important in prehistory or /^ ^ history (Criterion D) .
It does, however, embody the distinctive characteristics of a type (steel plate girder multiple arch bridge) , period , and method of construction (on-site erection of prefabricated structural members, including field riveting)(Criterion C) . It does not appear to be the work of a master (Criterion C); U. S. Grant was a competent, if unimaginative, engineer insofar as bridge design is concerned, but cannot be construed to be a "master". National Register criteria clearly state that properties achieving significance within the past 50 years are not considered eligible, unless they are of exceptional importance. The subject bridge is less than 50 years old, though it is nearing that figure. A border- line case, it is difficult to assess exceptional importance.
How- ever, it is conceivable that the relative rarity of the type within this State may be the necessary qualifier. It appears that the San Roque Canyon Bridge may meet National Register Criterion C. San Roque Canyon Bridge HAER No. CA-17 (page U) References: Cochran, B.E., Revised Original Report, San Roque Canyon Bridge (unpublished report), dated August 21, Davis, Dave, The San Roque Canyon Bridge: a history (unpublished manuscript), dated June 14, Jackson, Donald, (staff engineer. National Architectural and Engineering Record, Washington, telephone interview, " January 29, Snyder, John W,, Evaluation of Arroyo Hondo Bridge (unpublished report), dated May 14, , History of Santa Barbara County, ed. by Owen H.
O'Neill, Santa Barbara, Harold McLean Meier, Steel, January 1930-December inclusive. c Santa Barbara Morning Press, March 28, April 14, September 15, September 17, September 22, October 1, December 8,