BlockBefore

Battle Creek Hydroelectric System, Battle Creek & Tributaries, Red Bluff

Battle Creek Hydroelectric System, Battle Creek & Tributaries, Red Bluff, Tehama County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CAL,52-REBLU.V,1-, with a 64,395-word written history.

From the record

“The Battle Creek hydroelectric system was a typical turn-of- m the-century California hydroelectric system, characterized by high head plants, the use of the impulse wheel as a prime mover, and long water gathering networks.”

Written record, HAER CAL,52-REBLU.V,1- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CAL,52-REBLU.V,1- · the record runs 64395 words · one of 18 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

19526 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,52-REBLU.V,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Battle Creek hydroelectric system was a typical turn-of- m the-century California hydroelectric system, characterized by high head plants, the use of the impulse wheel as a prime mover, and long water gathering networks. Historians: Terry S. Reynolds, (principal) Charles Scott (assistant) BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 2) TABLE OF CONTENTS page List of Tables * 3 Abbreviations 5 INTRODUCTION 6 CHAPTER I. BACKGROUND: The Emergence of Hydroelectric Power in California . - 7 CHAPTER II. BEGINNINGS: The Emergence of Hydroelectric Power in the Battle Creek Region 21 CHAPTER III. VOLTA: The First Plant 28 CHAPTER IV. GROWTH AND DEPRESSION: The Early Expansion of the Northern California Power Company 41 CHAPTER V. SOUTH AND INSKIP: The Enlargement of the Battle Creek System 70 ^HAP TER VI.

COLEHAN: Completion of the Battle Creek Hydroelectric System 100 CHAPTER VII. DECLINE: The Northern California Power Company in Its Lean Years 126 POSTSCRIPT. The Battle Creek Hydroelectric System in the PG&E Years 159 APPENDIX I. Corporate Family Tree of Northern California Power Company , 162

Appendix Ii

The Battle Creek Hydroelectric System Basic Data 163

Appendix Iii

The Powerhouse Settlements of the Battle Creek Hydroelectric System 167 BIBLIOGRAPHY 169 BJU.TLC tKCiiiS. HAER CA-2 (page 3) LIST OF TABLES page 1. Variable Flow in California Streams: Two Examples 9 2. Fall of Rivers in the Eastern United States and California 10 3. Rate of Fall of Some Typical California Streams in Feet per Mile between 500 Foot Contours 10 4. California Hydroelectric Plants to (Major Commercial Ins t allat ions) 16 5. Growth of Hydroelectric Production in California to according to Downing 18 6. Output of Coleman Powerhouse on Battle Creek in millions of kWh per Month from to as an Indication of the Relatively Constant Flow of Battle Creek 25 7. The Volta Ditch System, (map) 32 8. The Northern California Power Company's Transmission System, (map) 48 9.

The Volta Ditch System, c- (map) 53 10. The Volta Ditch System, c. (list) 54 11. The South and Inskip Ditch Systems (map) 77 12. The South and Inskip Ditch Systems (list) 78 13. The High Voltage Transmission Lines and Substations of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, as of January 10, (schematic) 90 14. The Northern California Power Company's Transmission System, (map) 91 15. Load Factors of Various Eastern and Western Utility Companies in the Early Twentieth Century 92 16. Maximum and Average Load on the Northern California Power System, June-December 102 17. The Coleman Canal System, c. (map and list) 106 18. -Simplified Diagram of the Electrical Systems at Volta Inskip and Coleman 113 BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 4) page 19.

Dam Designed by Sutcliffe for the North Battle Creek Reservoir 115 20. Installation Record, Northern California Power Company, 119 21. Growth of Generating Capacity of the Northern California Power Company, 120 22. Earnings of the Northern California Power Company, 137 23. Interest Payments of the Northern California Power Company, 138 24. Mean Monthly Loads on the Northern California Power Company System, 139 25. Outline of the Transmission System of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, in (map) 141 26. Approximate Boundaries of the Transmission System of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, c.

(map) 148 EAER CA-2 (page 5) ABBREVIATIONS California Railroad Commission CSA California State Archives (Sacramento, California) California State Mining Bureau JE Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas Northern California Power Company Northern California Power Company, Consolidated PG&E Pacific Gas and Electric Company R/V Rates and Valuations Department Records, Pacific Gas and Electric Company BATTLE CREEK JAER CA~2 (page 6) INTRODUCTION The status of a particular technology at a particular time often can be best understood through the study of a specific example of that technology which is "characteristic" or "typical".

In some ways the subject of this study, the Battle Creek hydroelectric system, can be con- sidered a characteristic or typical turn-of-the-century Pacific Coast hydroelectric development. It shared many of the peculiarities which distinguished Pacific Coast (or more specifically California) hydro- electric engineering practice from hydroelectric practice in the eastern two-thirds of the United States and most of the rest of the world. These characteristics high head/low volume plants; long water gather- ing networks; the use of the impulse wheel; and long distance power transmission are reviewed in the opening chapter of this study.

To some extent the company which erected the Battle Creek hydro- electric system, the Northern California Power Company was typical of the many small power companies that emerged in the decades immediately following the development of electric power distribution. Established to meet a perceived need for electric power, Northern 'California slowly extended its tenacles into surrounding territories and expanded its generating capacity. Like many utilities in the early years of the electric power industry it suffered from periodic excess generating capacity, from the reluctance of certain classes of customers to electrify, from difficulties in raising capital, and from rate wars with other utilities.

Thus the importance of the Battle Creek hydroelectric system and the company which built it does not lie in their uniqueness (although there were some elements unique to both), or in the impact which they had on the electrical power industry or on hydroelectric engineering. Instead it lies in the fact that they were typical of the California electric power industry and representative of California hydroelectric practice at the turn-of-the-century. IS ; ge / ; CHAPTER I BACKGROUND: The Baergeace of Hydroelectric Power in California What elements distinguished a "typical" California hydroelectric plant in the early twentieth century from hydroelectric installations in the eastern two-thirds of the United States?

First, California plants were usually supplied with water by a system of canals or ditches miles in length. In the East, hy contrast, the artificial water network for a hydroelectric plant usually consisted of no more than a dam and a single, relatively short, head- race. California hydroelectric plants usually utilized medium to high heads (above 200 feet) with low water volumes (almost invariably below second- feet and often well below second-feet). The typical Eastern plant was a mirror image of this, operating with low heads and high volumes. East and West also depended on different prime movers. The prime mover most widely applied in California at the tum-of the-century was the Pelton or free jet tangential impulse wheel.

In the East the Francis mixed-flow turbine was avored and impulse wheels with their characteristic high pressure piping d jet nozzles were very rare. Finally, in the East the early electric power companies largely confined both their generating and distribution activities to urban areas. Most power generated was consumed locally (say within a 10 mile radius of the plant) and utilities were very heavily dependent on lighting for their power load. In California and much of the West, on the other hand, power was usually generated at a considerable distance from the consumer. As early as the transmission of electricity more than 30 miles was common In California, and by California plants typically transmitted power more than 100 miles.

Moreover, electric utilities in the West, far earlier than those in the East, cultivated a highly diversified power load. Many Western utilities developed an agricultural load (farm lighting, electric irrigation pumps) to complement their urban lighting and power loads. [1] Many of the unique features of California hydroelectric practice outlined above high head/low volume plants; the use of the impulse wheel; extensive water networks; long distance power transmission were, either directly or indirectly, influenced by California's geography. GEOGRAPHY Two elements of California's geography strongly influenced the nature of early hydroelectric development in the state rugged topography and highly seasonal (and often scarce) rainfall.

The latter was a deficit to hydroelectric development; the former an asset which offset it. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 8) Precipitation in California is highly seasonal, partially because the relatively cold Pacific Ocean off the coast yields few rainstorms in the sunmer months. Only in winter, when the ocean waters are warmer than the land, do moisture-laden clouds move inland with any frequency. Sacramento is typical. The. average annual rainfall is only around 20 inches. Very little of this falls during the sumoer months.

The average rainfall in the city during the six months between May 1 and October 31 is only around 102 of the annual average, and in the four months from June through September the figure is much lower [2] Because rainfall is concentrated in the winter months, the soil can not absorb the water and most runs off quickly. Without extensive water storage systems most California streams have highly seasonal flows, flooding in winter, reduced to a trickle or even dried up during the summer (see Table 1, following page). Moreover, in many areas, topographical conditions make even the construction of the needed storage reservoirs impractical or prohibitively expensive.

The highly seasonal and often scarce nature of California's rainfall is, however, counterbalanced for power development by the rugged nature of the state's typography. California is a mountainous state. The extreme northern part of the state is completely covered by the Cascade mountains, and the state is enclosed on east and west by two almost parallel ranges the Coast Range and the Sierra Nevada. In fact, almost two-thirds of California's surface area is rugged and broken terrain potentially suitable por the development of economical water power. Running along the Pacific shore is the Coast Range. The peaks of this system have summits some to feet high.

This system intercepts much of the moisture which moves inland in winter from the Pacific and thus contributes to the scarcity of water in the state's interior. Unfortunately, its relatively flat gradients make large water storage reservoirs impractical. The flow of the area's streams is erratic and the economic development of water power here is difficult (though not impossible). The Sierra Nevada, however, presents a different picture. The rain that escapes the Coast Range, much diminished in volume, is eventually intercepted by this chain. Its summits are much higher, from to feet above sea level, and its western slope descends at a relatively sharp angle.

Streams flowing westward from the Sierra quite frequently drop more than 100 feet per mile, in contrast to the 10 to 15 feet common to streams in the eastern United States (see Tables 2 and 3, two pages below). Over the ages these steeply descending streams have gorged out deep canyons which are separated by high ridges and plateaus which slope more gently westward than the streams. This creates a terrain ideal for power production. Water can be taken from a stream, led by flume, ditch, or canal to the top of a ridge or plateau and then along it until, some miles downstream, a fall of hundreds of feet has been developed. The water can be dropped, at that point, through penstocks and turbines, back to the original stream.

This approach to power generation makes up in high head or fall what California streams lack in fcVolume. HAER CA-2 (p>age 9 ) Table 1: Variable Flow in California, Streams: Two Examples Mean monthly discharge in second feet in Putah Creek American ]River Winters, GA Fairoaks , CA October 511 November December 745 January February 644 March 762 April 300 May June July 516 August 213 September 201 McGlashan and Henshaw, Water Resources of Califomia, part 1, Stream Measurements in Sacramento River Basin (Washington, Government Printing Office, [U.S.G.S. Water-Supply Paper pp.

BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 10) Table 2: Fall of Rivers in the Eastern, tfoleed States and in California length total fall (miles) (feet) fall/mile EASTERN RIVERS: Kennebec 138 7.4 Merrimac 110 269 2.4 Connecticut 375 5.4 Hudson 300 Passaic 86 240 2.8 Delaware 280 6.7 James 246 463 1.9 Mississippi 0.6 Ohio 963 702 0.7 CALIFORNIA RIVERS: Sacramento 399 Pit 196 Feather 136 Yuba 90 i American 118 Mokelumne 116 Stanislaus 113 Henry Gannett, Profiles ofr Rivers in the'. United States (Washington, D. C.: Government Printing Office, ItJ..S.G.S., Water-Supply Paper Table 3: Rate of Fall of Some Typical California Streams in Feet per Mile between 500 Foot Contours Pit River . 27 78 39 24 19 72 Feather R.

middle fork 114 63 74 73 83 94 22 Yuba River middle fork 74 88 96 89 139 139 250 357 208 104 American R. middle fork 83 111 178 208 227 218 208 22 7 88 119 Hokelumne R. 114 167 96 68 7? 96 132 147 208 218 192 Stanislaus R. north fork 96 250 333 357 208 132 139 104 125 357 227 Frederick H. Fowler* Hydroelectric Power Systems of California and Their Extensions into Oregon and Nevada (Washington, Government Printing Office, [U.S.G.S. Water-Supply Paper p. 15 BATTLE (JKfiJfcK. HAER CA-2 (page 11) Both the low volume of many California streams and the necessity of making up for this with high heads strongly Influenced the development of extensive water gathering or ditch networks.

Because water volumes in many streams were low, it was often necessary to divert and collect water from several streams some miles apart by a ditch network until a sufficient volume was available. Even this volume was often rather small. It often had to be led by ditch or canal or flume for thousands of feet up the side of or on top of a ridge or plateau before the head available was high enough to generate a significant amount of power. In addition to steep falls, the western slopes of the Sierra offer other characteristics favorable to power development. Much of the precip- itation that escapes the Coast Range falls on the Sierra at altitudes above feet in the form of snow. The moisture thus does not immediately flow away as In the Coast Range.

Instead it is stored and begins to run off only with the coming of spring and summer warmth. Although the quantity of water stored at high altitudes in the form of snow is not sufficient to give the streams of the Sierra a regular flow, it does help even out flow conditions, decreasing the period of deficient flow and reducing the artificial storage capacity required for efficient hydroelectric power generation. Thus the comparatively limited water supply available in the California Interior and the seasonal nature of California's rainfall, coupled with the state's rugged geography, have strongly influenced both the development f extensive systems for the storage, collection, and diversion of the available water and the erection of high head/low volume hydroelectric plants.

California1s geography also influenced the early development of long distance electric power transmission in the state. The streams flowing from the western slope of the Sierra Nevada, as noted, were best suited for power development because of their steep falls and relatively uniform flow. But the rugged nature of the region, its geographical isolation, Its poor soil, and its dry summers meant that the western slopes of the Sierra were sparsely populated, California's population and industrial centers were concentrated on the western edge of the state in the few spots where breaks in the Coast Range had provided passable harbors (San Francisco, San Diego, and, thanks to an artificialharbor, Los Angeles).

Since the best points for hydroelectric power generation and the largest power markets were many miles apart, California utility companies pioneered in the development of a technology suitable for long distance power transmission. As this technology emerged between and virtually every major California power company eventually sought, either through lines of Its own, or through interconnections with other power companies, to tap the large market for electrical energy of the states two major urban centers San Francisco and Los Angeles. And since power lines reaching westward from the Sierra crossed the rich agricultural areas of California's Central Valley, power companies, with small additional investment, could ,and did deliver electric service to agricultural areas very early.

In the East, where generating plants were located relatively short distances from the urban areas where their power was consumed, lines into rural BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 12) areas would have required a large additional investment. Hence Eastern hydroelectric plants, unlike California hydroelectric plants, seldom served rural areas. [3]

The Mining Tradition

California geogrpahy had a major influence on the unique tradition of hydroelectric engineering that grew up in the state around California's mining heritage, however, also had a significant impact on the emergence of this unique tradition in three specific areas: (1) the development of the extensive ditch or canal networks typical of many California hydroelectric plants; (2) the emergence of the tangential impulse or Pelton wheel, the characteristic prime mover of turn-of-the-century California hydroelectric plants; and (3) the evolution of a legal system favorable to the development of hydroelectric power in California. Following the discovery of gold in the mountains of California in the mid-nineteenth century, mining became a major industry in the state.

Mining has always required large volumes of water, either to wash away unwanted debris from the desired metals and ores, or, in conjunction with water wheels, to power pumps, hoists, and processing equipment. Many mines in the relatively dry interior of California were not adjacent to constantly lowing streams, and thus required rather extensive water gathering and torage systems. By the over miles of artificial water courses had been constructed to provide water to mines, and by the there were miles of them. Many of these ditches were later incorporated in the hydraulic systems of hydroelectric plants. For instance, one of the canals which provided water to the De Salba hydroelectric plant (completed in was the Butte Creek Canal.

The diversion dam that fed water into the canal and the canal itself were built in by the Cherokee Mining Company to provide water to nearby mines. The Phoenix hydroelectric plant in central California (constructed derived its water supply from an old mining ditch, and the Halsey plant (completed in Placer County was dependent for water on the Bear River Canal, originally constructed In the to supply water for hydraulic mining.

Finally, one of the earliest of the five hundred plus companies eventually welded into the Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E), today one of the nation's largest producers of electric power, was the Rock Creek Water Company, which in constructed a 9 mile long ditch in conjunction with a dam and reservoir to supply the water needs of the mining areas of Nevada County, California. Ultimately most of the hydroelectric systems of northern and central California included at least portions of ditch and reservoir systems originally developed for mining (or in some cases for irrigation).

[4] In addition to ditch networks for gathering, storing, and distributing water, the tangential impulse wheel, the prime mover most frequently used in early California hydroelectric plants, also emerged from the California mining industry. Most California mines in the late nineteenth century relied leavily on water power. It was relatively cheap and available. Steam power, 'he alternative, was sometimes used, but California has no coal deposits, so the usual fuel for the steam engine had to be imported at considerable cost. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 13) tfood could be used, but it was expensive, especially since most California woods are soft.

Oil, used later, did not become an important fuel in the state until after Thus it was water that usually powered the pumping, hoisting, milling, crushing, drilling, and sawing machinery used in or around mines. The traditional forms of water wheel the wooden overshot and under- shot vertical wheels were cheap and easy to build, but they were largely low head engines (applicable to heads under 50 feet only) and could not be used effectively under the high head/low volume water conditions common to California mining areas. The water turbine, which could operate under high heads, was built of iron and in the early years of California mining was beyond the ability and means of local craftsmen using local materials.

The result of this dilemma was the "hurdy-gurdy" wheel, a water wheel built from local materials with native skills able to utilize high heads. Unlike the turbine, it was built of wood, so that it could be fabricated by local millwrights for a reasonable price. In place of the buckets or flat radial paddles of the conventional wooden vertical wheel it had triangularly-shaped wooden blocks, arranged around the circumference of the water wheel like the teeth of a saw. These teeth were enclosed on the side with rims. Water, in the form of a free jet, was directed against the "teeth" or "buckets" of the wheel through a hole bored in a wooden block at the end of a pipe line or hose.

The early hurdy-gurdy wheels probably developed an efficiency of only 30 to but they were workable and adequate for low power needs. ^^ As the demands for more power and power in larger units increased with the growth of the mining industry, millwrights began to modify the hurdy-gurdy wheel. Bronze or brass tapered nozzles replaced the wooden blocks first used to direct water on the wheels. Some millwrights by the had also begun to replace the triangular wooden blocks of the wheel with cup-shaped buckets of iron. A portion of the water striking the bottom of the cups flowed up the sides and was dischraged laterally, causing less interference with incoming water than the flat edges of the old blocks. This experimentation eventually led to the highly efficient Pelton water wheel.

Around Lester Pelton, a California millwright, introduced a bucket shaped (in cross-section) like a cursive-script that is, the bucket had curved bottoms, inclined sides, and a raised center that split the incoming jet of water. With this arrangement there was little interference between incoming and outgoing water. The entering water struck the central "splitter", flowed down each of its sides into the interiors of the bucket, and then flowed up the inclined sides to be discharged laterally. The "Pelton" wheel's efficiency was almost double that of the original hurdy-gurdy wheel. [5] Certain elements of the impulse wheel or Pelton wheel were heavily influenced by other aspects of California mining, notably the hydraulic mining tradition.

Hydraulic mining, developed in California in the early to economize labor, utilized a stream or jet of water under pressure to wash away sand and gravel from gold deposits or to undercut hills where Jtuspected mineral deposits were located. It enjoyed considerable popularity Ahtil the when floods caused by the accumulation of debris from the process in stream beds led to restrictive legislation. The pressure pipes and nozzles used to bring water to and direct water against the impulse wheel are obvious direct borrowings from < hydraulic mining practice.

BATTLE CREEK EAER CA-2 (page 14) In addition, two of the methods used to control the speed of the Pelton wheel were also adopted from hydraulic mining equipment the pivoted ball-and- socket nozzle and the plate used to deflect water jets away from the wheel. [6] The tangential impulse wheel by the had become the characteristic water-powered prime mover of California1 s mining industry. It had been adopted by as the characteristic prime mover of the state's nascent hydro- electric industry as well. Ideally suited to the high head /low volume conditions frequently found in the West, the impulse wheel was scarcely ever found in the states east of the Rockies where the mixed-flow Francis turbine was the characteristic engine in hydroelectric plants.

By the Pelton Water Wheel Company, the leading manufacturer of impulse wheels, had sold wheels to power plants all over the world. Of these or 68% had been installed in California, Oregon, and Nevada (mostly in California). Only 183 or around had been installed in states east of the Rockies. [7] The impulse wheel was clearly characteristic of California practice. Besides a network of canals and ditches and a prime mover with a means for controlling it, early California miners also left the hydroelectric industry a favorable legal system. In the eastern United States ownership of land fronting on a stream carried with it the right to all the waters naturally flowing In that stream (riparian rights).

No one upstream could legally diminish or otherwise alter the flow of the stream by diverting or dding water. In California, early mining practice and the general carcity of water led to a different legal system the doctrine of "appropriation*1. In the mid-nineteenth century most of California's lands were public lands; no one owned the lands fronting most streams, especially in the mountainous mining districts. Since many mining claims were located some distance from water and there was no one to object, the early miners simply "appropriated" water from streams and diverted it by ditches or canals to where they needed it.

Customarily these miners posted notices similar to those used for staking out mineral claims on the spot where they intended to "appropriate" the water indicating the amount they would use. Moreover, these water claims were usually recorded in county files. If recorded and if the water was in fact put to use these claims gave their owners the perpetual right to a certain volume of water from a particular stream or spring. Such claims acquired the force of law in a number of western states and were considered by western courts to be superior to conventional riparian rights.

[8] The general acceptance of the doctrine of appropriation by California lawmakers end courts often allowed miners, and later the developers of hydroelectric power, to generate significant amounts of energy in spite of the relatively small size of available streams. Under the doctrine, for instance, an electric utility with appropriate water rights could divert and/or permanently diminish the volume of water flowing from a number of small streams without having to worry about suits from stream-front property Apwn ers downstream.

The utility could then collect and combine the flow Wfro 'from a number of small streams until a sufficient volume was available and BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 15 ) lead It to any point it felt necessary for power production, even if it meant diverting the flow into a completely different watershed. THE EMERGENCE OF HYDROELECTRIC

Power in California

Despite the steep gradients of California streams, the availability of the impulse wheel, and a favorable legal climate, most of California's early electrical generating plants were steam rather than water powered. The electric central power station first emerged in urban areas where returns on capital investment were greatest and, in California, these urban centers were on the seacoast, far from the mountain streams with the greatest hydropower potential. It was only following the emergence of alternating current and the ability to transmit power at high voltages that hydroelectric power became a feasible alternative to steam power in California's population centers.

Alternating current began to replace direct current in the mid-1880's, and by the early German engineers had successfully transmitted current 112 miles along an experimental line from Lauffen to Frankfurt at volts (12 kV) from a 225 kilovoltampere kVA) water-driven alternator. The emergence of long distance electrical power transmission was greeted with enthusiasm by California utility entrepreneurs. Plagued by the high cost of imported coal and the even higher cost of timber fuel, they quickly recognized that this new technology offered the possibility of tapping the ower potential of inland mountain streams. 9 California's first commercial hydroelectric plant was erected near Redlands, in the heart of the orange growing district in the foothills of the San Bernardino mountains.

In the president of a small Congregational college (Pomona College), Baldwin, organized a company, and in con- junction with William Decker, an engineer, erected a small plant which tapped San Antonio Creek. This installation, opened in or trans- mitted power to Pomona, a distance of around 14 miles. Its transmission lines were extended to San Bernardino, 30 miles away, in Operating first at volts and later at volts, Pomona was the third hydro- electric plant in the United States to transmit significant amounts of electric power for a considerable distance, and had for a time the longest commercial power line in operation anywhere in the world.

The success of the Pomona plant in producing power and in competing against an existing steam-driven electrical plant encouraged others to enter the field. In Decker was commissioned to design a similar plant for Mill Creek, in the same area. This plant, placed in commission in September of transmitted power 7.5 miles to Redlands at volts and then 23 miles to Riverside at volts. The Pomona plant had delivered only single phase alternating current; the Mill Creek plant was the first poly- phase alternating current generating station in California and one of the first in the world. At approximately the same time several California mining companies began to erect hydroelectric plants for their own use.

As Table 4 on the following page indicates, through the remainder of :he new hydroelectric plants were erected every year, with steadily higher outputs, steadily greater transmission voltages, and greater transmission BATTLE UKiSfiK HAER CA-2 (page 16) Table 4: California Hydroelectric Plants to (Major Commercial Installations) Note; Available authorities are often in disagreement about specific data relative to the early California hydroelectric plants (e.g., the year they began operation or their initial output). The compilation below thus reflects the authors' judgment of the relative reliability of conflicting sources in certain cases. Transm. Distance Turbine Type Head Output Voltage Transm . (I*impulse Name Year (miles) R*=reaction) 1. Pomona 412 480 10 29 I Mill Ck.

#1 377 750 11 23 I Bodie 350 120 3.5 13 I Utica 570 75 2.5 8 I 5. Folsom 55 U 22 R Yreka 40 150 4 R Nevada 206 600 5.5 15 I San Joaquin 11 35 I Big Creek 925 300 11 17 I 10. Newcastle 452 800 16 30 I Knight's Ferry 150 17 R Kern River 202 900 15 I | Blue Lakes 10 25 I Yuba 292 16 19 I 15. Azusa 401 16 23 I Auburn 300 16 36 I Santa Ana 735 33 83 I Phoenix 930 17 11 I Centerville 577 800 15 32 I 20. Utica (new) 527 8 I Farad 85 22 30 R Kaweah #1 ' 70 I Mill Ck. #2 627 250 33 23 I Colgate 702 40 140 I 25. Kitteridge 25 225 R Note: Many plants quickly added to their initial operating capacity and to the distance their power was transmitted. The figures given above are initial outputs and distances transmitted (within the first year of operation).

Authorities: Robert Doble, "Hydro-Electric Power Development and Transmis- sion in California," Association of Engineering Societies, Journal, v. 34 pp. Downing, "Report of Sub-Committee on Water Power Development on Pacific Coast," National Electric Light Association, Proceedings, Convention v. 3, pp. Whitney, "Hydroelectric Power Plants of California," California Journal of Technology, v. 7 pp. kFrederick Fowler, Eydroelectic Power Systems of California . . . (Washington, i.C: Government Printing Office, and Frank E. Bonner, Water Powers of California (Washington, Goverment Printing Office, pp. BATTLE CREEK AER CA-2 (page 17) distances. One of the more important Installations in this period was the Folsom plant, put oil line in July using water from the American River.

This plant transmitted the entire output from its four 750 kilowatt kW) alternators 22 miles to Sacramento at volts, then the highest transmission voltage in commercial use anywhere in the world. By Sacramento was receiving additional power from the .kW Colgate hydro- plant on the Yuba River. This power was transmitted over a 60 mile line at volts, and was then raised to volts for transmission an additional 80 miles to the San Francisco Bay area. Shortly after this, in order to transmit even more power into the Bay Area from plants located even further in the interior of the state, California engineers began ex- perimenting with 60 kV volt) transmission lines, at a time when transmission of power at even 10 to 20 kV was considered high in the eastern United States.

[9] By the hydroelectric industry was well established in California. The state had more than twenty-five major operative hydroelectric plants with an installed capacity of over kW (see Table 5, following page). Already the unique aspects of California hydroelectric practice were obvious. Most of these plants were high head plants, most used the Pelton or impulse wheel, and, already, these plants were transmitting power longer distances, at higher voltages, than comparable plants in the eastern United States (see Table 4, preceding page). It was against this background that the Battle Creek hydroelectric system emerged in the early years of he twentieth century in Shasta and Tehama Counties in northern California.

Battle Creek

ZlAEK. CA-2 (page 18) Table 5: Growth of Hydroelectric Production in California to (Downing) Number of Average Output Total Power Plants per Plant Capacity (WO 1 480 480 2 : 615 2 615 4 7 9 15 19 20 23 27 Source: Downing, "Report of Sub-Committee on Water Power Development on the Pacific Coast," National Electric Light Association, Proceedings, Convention v, 3, p. The figures in this table do not correspond with tabulations made from Table 4 because of the abandonment or enlargement of some of the early stations and because data on many early California hydroelectric staticcis is given differently by different authorities. Bonner, Water Powers of California, p.

for example, lists the total power capacity of California hydroelectric plants for to as and kW, instead of the figures given above. HAER GA-2 (page 19) NOTES [13 Some of tfee unique aspects of California hydroelectric engineering are briefly ffieaticm.ed by Frank E. Bonner, Report to the Federal Power Commission on the Water Powers of California (Washington, p. 11. They are discussed in more detail by Federic A.C. Perrine, "Hydraulic-Power Development on the Pacific. Coast," Cassier's Magazine, v. 35 pp. [2] Perrine, "Hydraulic-Power Development," p. [3] A number of works discuss California's geography and climate and at least touch on the influence these factors had on hydroelectric development in the state, among these are Frederick H.

Fowler, Hydroelectric Power Systems of California and Their Extension into Oregon and Nevada (Washington, [United States Geological Survey, Water-Supply Paper pp. Perrine, "Hydraulic-Power Development," pp. Bonner, Water Powers of California, pp. and McGlashan and Henshaw, Water Resources of California, part 1 (Washington, [United States Geological Survey, Water- Supply Paper pp. [4] On the importance of the old mining ditches to the development of hydro- electric systems in California see Charles M. Coleman, and E. of California: The Centennial Story of the Pacific Gas and Electric Company, (New York, ate, pp.

and pas sum; Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, passum; and Downing, "Some Historical Aspects of the Development of Hydroelectric Power in California," unpublished manuscript, pp. 1-2 (PG&E Library). [53 The two best sources for the evolution of the impulse wheel are Durand, "The Pelt on Water Wheel," Mechanical Engineering, v. 61 pp. and Louis C. Hunter, A History of Industrial Power in the United States, v. 1, Waterpower in the Century of the Steam Engine (Chariottesville,Virginia, pp. [61 Durand, "Pelton Water Wheel," p. Coleman, and E., pp. For a review of hydraulic mining practices see: Augustus J. Bowie, A Practical Treatise on Hydraulic Mining in California (New York, 8th ed., [7] Pelton Water Wheel Company, The Pelton Water Wheel (San Francisco, ed. p. 74.

[8] Reviews of California's water laws can be found in: Fowler, Hydroelectric .Systems of California, pp. Perrine, "Hydraulic-Power Development," pp. and A.E. Chandler, "Western Laws of Electricity and Water," JE, v. 28 pp. [9] Information on the early history of hydroelectricity in California and ^ data on early California hydroelectric plants can be found in: Fowler, P Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. 1-2 and passum; P. M. Downing, BATTLE HAER CA->: (page 20) "iteport of Sub-Committee on Water Power Development on the Pacific Coast,""Kfitioa^i Electric Light Association, Proceedings, Conveatlm t v. 3] pp. Downing, "Historical Aspects," pp. Cctaaaj** andj., pp. 102 f f.; Robert Doble, "Hydro- Electric Power l&eselogsjemt.

and Transmission in California," Association of Engineering Societies, Jemreml, "v. pp. Whitney, "Hydroelectric Fewer Flaats of California," California Journal of Technologs., v. 7 pp. and the issues of the Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas (JE). BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 21) CHAPTER II The Emergence of Hydroelectric Power in the Battle Creek Region Shasta and Tehama counties were, like most of the rest of northern California, sparsely populated in the late nineteenth century. Tehama County, at the very northern end of California's Central Valley, including a portion of the Sierra Nevada on. the east and a portion of the Coast Range on the west, had an economy largely based on ranching and logging.

Red Bluff, the county seat and commercial center had scarcely people in North of Tehama County was Shasta County, a mountainous region drained by the Sacramento, Pit, and McCloud rivers. Shasta County was economically more diversified than Tehama County, largely because of substantial mineral deposits. But it, too, was thinly settled. In Redding, the county seat, had a population of under people. [1] Just at the turn of the century, however, Shasta County began to experience accelerated growth as her mineral resources began to be mined a large scale.

In surface deposits of copper, gold, and silver had ~eeen simultaneously discovered in the region, and these discoveries had set off a "speculative mania" as hundreds of mining companies were organized and wildcat exploitation of surface deposits began. Some of these companies were formed to mine surface copper, but gold and silver were the focus of most. The low grade of the copper ore (averaging only 8% copper), the higher value of the gold and silver found in the copper ores, the distance of Shasta County from both copper refineries and markets, a drop in the price of copper, and the high cost of reaching the richer copper veins below the surface combined to discourage serious or sustained copper mining.

[2] Toward the end of the nineteenth century, however, rising copper prices and the decline of returns from gold and silver mining encouraged some Shasta County mining corporations to consider exploitation of the richer copper ore deposits found at deeper elevations. The pioneer in this field was the Mountain Copper Company, which had evolved from a silver mine at Iron Mountain, a few miles northwest of Redding. With a liberal dose of British capital, Mountain Copper Company began mining copper on a large scale in [3] Within two years copper had become the foundation of the county's mining industry. By there were fifty-seven copper mines in Shasta.

In copper production had been only pounds valued at In the figures were pounds with a value of Shasta1 s copper mines had made California the fourth largest copper producing state. The Mountain Copper Company's mine was the seventh largest American copper mine and the ninth largest in the world. [4] The expansion of copper mining attracted other industries and stimulated population growth. Copper smelters were established to process the copper ores being mined. Logging grew rapidly since timber was needed not only for SAJLJ..UC1 WVEiiil*.

HAER CA-2 (page 22) mine shafts, but as a fuel (since coal was expensive in California) to roast and reduce copper ores and to fire the boilers of the steam engines used to power mine machinery- Redding, the commercial center of Shasta County, grew from a city of people in to almost by an increase of and continued to grow at a comparable pace In the early years of the twentieth century. [5] The massive expansion of mining and associated industries, coupled with the growth of the region's urban centers,began to place a strain on the area's fuel resources in the late Massive amounts of timber were being consumed to fire the boilers of steam-powered mining machinery and to operate smelters. The Mountain Copper Company alone burned around cords of wood annually.

[6] The growth of electric lighting in urban areas added to the pressure on fuel resources. Both Redding and Red Bluff by had small electric lighting plants. In Redding a wood-fueled Corliss steam engine and a small low head hydroelectric plant supplied the power. [7] Red Bluff had two power companies. One used a small nearby stream (Antalope Creek) to generate hydroelectric power; the other used a small oil-fired steam engine and generator. [8] The pressures placed on the local wood fuel supply by urban growth and, to a much greater extent, the mining and metallurgical industries were probably the primary incentive behind the Initiation of plans to develop hydroelectric power in Shasta and Tehama counties around the tum-of-the-century.

In Waller, a civil engineer, began surveying possible Hydroelectric sites on the Pit and McCloud rivers, north of Redding, for ^'eastern capitalists" who hoped to supply Shasta mines with cheap electric power. Joined by Sidney Sprout, an electrical engineer and a representative of the General Electric Company, Waller in began to canvass potential demand in the county's mining belt. Shortly after Waller,, Sprout, and Francis Smith, president of the Redding Water and Electric Light Company, formed the Mt. Shasta Power and Light Company. In early this company announced plans for a hydroplant on the Pit River. A 350 foot long dam was to raise the water level 50 feet, diverting water through a 12 to 15 mile long ditch to a point where a 150 foot head was available and hp (c.

kW) could be produced. [9] The Mt. Shasta Company's plans were later altered. By a site on the McCloud River was being considered instead. Ditches and flumes totalling miles in length with a capacity of second-feet were to divert water to a site where a fall of 145 feet was available. Plans were to install kW of generating equipment at first, expanding the plant later as load grew, A few months after the formation of the Mt. Shasta Electric Light and Power Company, A.F. Johns, an electrical engineer, also surveyed possible power house locations in the Pit and McCloud river basins. In early Johns was the prime mover behind the formation of the McCloud River Power Company. This company planned to erect a dam on the McCloud where a fall of 45 feet could be developed.

With a projected flow exceeding second- feet, Johns and his associates hoped to generate around hp (c. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 23) In canvassing the mining belt of Shasta County for potential power customers, however, Johns found that most companies were unwilling to sign a power contract unless his McCloud River Company could guarantee uninter- rupted service with backup generating capacity. To meet this demand Johns in June led a pary which surveyed possible power house sites on a small stream called Battle Creek, on or near the boundary of Shasta and Tehama counties. Shortly after,Johns and his associates created another new company, the Mt. Lassen Electric Company. This company purchased a substantial tract of land in the Battle Creek basin near Shingletown from Harry L.

Shannon and announced plans for a hp (c kW) hydroelectric plant. Located at the site of an old water-powered sash and door factory, this installation was intended to supplement the larger plant being considered for the McCloud River. The Battle Creek plant would provide backup service and allow the parent company to guarantee potential customers uninterrupted electric service. It would also protect the larger HcCloud River investment by forestalling competitors from developing Battle Creek, a stream with good hydroelectric possibilities. BAITLE CREEK Battle Creek was a relatively small tributary of the eastern side of the upper Sacramento River. Approximately 40 miles long with a watershed of 337 square miles, the stream had two principal forks North Battle Creek and South Battle Creek.

These split from the trunk of the stream round 12 miles upstream from the Sacramento. * Johns was perceptive in sensing the potential of the stream. Much smaller than the Pit and McCloud rivers and with a basin much more accessible to existing transportation systems, Battle Creek required much less capital to develop. This was a very important consideration in sparsely populated northern California at the turn-of-the-century and was a key factor in the failure of most early schemes to develop the Pit and McCloud rivers (including the plans of the Mt. Shasta and McCloud River companies). Battle Creek also had an advantageous geographical position.

Emptying into the Sacramento almost midway between Red Bluff and Redding, lines strung from its watershed could easily reach the mining regions of Shasta County, the agricultural districts bordering the Sacramento River to the south, and both of the region's major urban centers [See EAER drawing, sheet 1 of There were other things about Battle Creek which made it very attractive for early medium scale hydroelectric development. Like many California streams it had a steep gradient ideal for high head power systems. Originating on the western slope of Mt. Lassen,one of the last active volcanos in the continental United States, Battle Creek fell almost feet over a distance of less than 50 miles. Even more favorable for power development was the stream's relatively steady flow.

This was due to two factors. Much of the precipitation which fell on Battle Creek's watershed fell in winter in the form of snow. This snow melted slowly and drained off into the creek during the late spring and early summer, instead of running rapidly off in winter. Evening out the stream's flow even more was the ^volcanic nature of the area's soil. Mt. Lassen, in the distant past, had ; umped huge deposits of porous lava and ash over much of the Battle Creek BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 24) basin. These deposits acted like a sponge, soaking up and storing much of the excess winter rainfall and much of the spring and early summer snow runoff, only gradually returning the water to the surface through thousands of springs.

These springs continued to feed Battle Creek through the dry sum- mer and fall months. Together these conditions gave Battle Creek a reg- ularity of flow foreign to most California streams (see Table 6, following page). They made the construction of large and expensive artificial storage reservoirs a much low priority here and further reduced the capital invest- ment necessary to begin tapping the stream's power potential. By way of contrast, in some areas of southern California hydroelectric plants had to depend on storage reservoirs for flow for up to five months out of the year.

BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 25) Table 6: Output of Coleman Powerhouse on Battle Creek in millions of kWh per Month from to as an Indication of the Relatively Constant Flow of Battle Creek Note: Because of the complexity of the ditch system furnishing water to the Battle Creek plants it is difficult to estimate the volume of water available in the stream. However, since the Battle Creek plants are operated so as to use all of the water available, the power output is indicative of the relative amounts of water available to the plants at various times of the year.

January February March April May June July August September October A.22 November December (minimum month _ maximum month Note: The figures above do not completely reflect the natural flow conditions along Battle Creek, since there are several water storage reservoirs (although rather small) which are used to even out flow. Source: Pacific Gas & Electric Company, "Federal Power Commission; Applications on System," Exhibit I, in J.O. Burrage to A.H. Markwart, November 10, (Engineering Central Files, PG&E). This is cited hereafter as (for Federal Power Commission Application, Addendum: Scattered Readings taken on Battle Creek between and in the months of August, Septen&er, and October indicated flows of between 313 and 423 second-feet.

See McGlashen and Henshaw, Water Resources of California, part 1 (Stream Measurements in the Sacramento River Basin) (Washington: G.P.O,, [U.S.G.S., Water-Supply Paper pp. BATTLE GREEK HAER CA-2 (page 26) NOTES [1] Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. 71, 72, [2] Bulletin 23 [Lewis E. Aubury, Copper Resources of California] p. 25, and Bulletin 50 [Aubury, Copper Resources of California] pp. 32, 34, 38, 42; Report of the State Mineralogist, v. 20 p. and "The Copper Industry in Shasta County,' Overland Monthly, v. 56 p. [3] Bulletin 23 p. 9, and Bulletin 50 pp. also Report pp. [4] Bulletin 23 pp. 9, 51. [5] Bulletin 23 p. 53; Honn, "A County That's An Empire," Sunset, v. 10 p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. [6] Redding Free Press, January 18, ,7} Dave J.

Jensen, "Harnessing Shasta County's 'Liquid Gold'," Covered Wagon-1975 (Shasta Historical Society, Redding, California, pp. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. For Red Bluff's hydroelectric installation see Red Bluff News, February 10, 1899(The Tehama County Library, Red Bluff, has a photograph of this installation in its photograph collections indexed under "Electricity"); for the eteam plant see Red Bluff News, February 3, 1899,and June 23, plus the San Francisco Call, July 26, [9] For the activities of Waller,Sprout, and Smith see: Redding Free Press, December 19, January 22, March 6, March 10, and Redding Searchlight, February 21, March 2, March 6, March 11, June 20, Details on the company's plans for the Pit vary in the newspaper reports.

Grimsley, "Electric Power Plants in the Mining Districts of Northern California," Engineering and Mining Journal, v. 72 p. [ill For Johns' activities see: Redding Free Press, March 1, March 27, May 21, June 14, December 29, and Redding Searchlight, March 2, June 20, For the plans of the McCloud Company see Grimsley, "Electric Power Plants," p. The activities of Johns and the Mt. Lessen Company in the Battle Creek area are noted in the Redding Free Press, June 27, and the Redding Searchlight, June 28, BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 27) Hydraulic conditions in the Battle Creek basin are described by Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. Rudolph W. JTan Norden, "Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," JE, v. 25 pp. 107 and passum; Frederick S.

Myrtle, "Northern California Power Link of the 'Pacific Service1 Chain," Pacific Service Magazine, v. 17 pp. Wood, Gazetteer of Surface Waters of California, part 1 (Sacramento River Basin) (Washington, [United States Geological Survey, Water-Supply Paper pp. and White & Co., "Report on Northern California Power Company Consolidated by White & Co. (to Halsey & Co., Jan. 29, pp. The White & Co. report can be found in "Exhibits," application no. in the California State Archives, Sacramento . The White & Company report will hereafter be cited as White & Co., "Report",without reference to the specific California Railroad Commission document. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 28) CHAPTER III VOLTA: The First Plant The plans being contemplated by the Mt.

Lassen Power Company for Battle Creek never came to fruition. They were thwarted by Harry L. Shannon, the man from whom the properties and water rights which were to form the basis of the Mt. Lassen Company's Battle Creek plant had been purchased. Shannon was a mining engineer who had migrated to California in the early and had gained experience in hydraulic engineering work- ing with various mining companies. [1] A rather crafty and devious entrepreneur, he saw that there was money to be made speculating in hydro- electric power and set out to insure that he pocketed his share. In September three months after selling his properties near Shingletown to the Mt.

Lassen Company, Shannon purchased the 600 acre "Hestes estate" on Millseat Creek, a tributary of Battle Creek, along with associated water rights. Because the Hestes estate was adjacent to the lands Shannon had sold the Mt. Lassen Company and important for its plans, Johns and his associates attempted to block the sale. But they were unsuccessful. [2] Local papers reported that Shannon had purchased the properties as the representative of a San Francisco businessman, Marvin, who, in turn, represented unnamed, "eastern capitalists" interested in hydro- electricity.

[3] That Shannon intended to develop the new properties in this manner became clear when, a few weeks later, he secured a franchise to erect poles and transmit electricity throughout Shasta County, a fran- chise which had also been sought by Johns and the Mt. Lassen Company. [4] All of the lands, water rights, and franchises which Shannon had purchased were transferred on October 18, to a newly organized power company the Keewick Electric Power Company. [5] Shannon was named general manager.

The president and the prime mover behind the creation of the company was a San Francisco businessman, Hamden Holmes Noble [see HAER photo Born in Noble had migrated to San Francisco in After working five years as a clerk for a wholesale merchant, he had moved to Nevada and with his own capital engaged in mining and lumbering enterprises. He returned to San Francisco in joined the San Francisco Mining Stock Exchange, and built up a large mining stock brokerage. He became "one of the foremost brokers" in San Francisco, handling the accounts of a number of prominent California mining entrepreneurs.

A respected member of the city's financial circles, he backed a number of highly successful enterprises late in the nineteenth century, the Cypress Lawn Cemetary Association, which he founded in being among the most lucrative. [7] BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 29 ) Noble's long association with the mining industry made him perceptive to its needs and aware of the opportunities which it offered. His Intimate asso- ciation with prominent mining executives put him in a position to take effective action when a need or an opportunity arose. This occurred in when the Mountain Copper Company announced plants for a new copper smelter at Keswick, near their Iron Mountain mine. Recognizing that the smelter would need large amounts of power.

Noble, in conjunction with Lord Keswick, one of the principal stockholders in Mountain Copper, secured a long term power contract and organ- ized the Keswick Electric Power Company. [8] Armed with the Mountain Copper contract the infant company had little trouble attracting capital. Within a month of formation well over half of the shares of stock issued had been sold at a share, largely to Noble's friends and associates. [9] VOLTA: Construction Actual design and construction work for Keswick's plant, located on lands purchased by Shannon, proceeded "as fast as money can push an enter- prise".

By November of a Westinghouse representative had visited the projected powerhouse site, men had been set to work digging a ditch to convey water from Millseat and North Battle Creeks to the top of the plateau overlooking the site, and crews were chopping trees for use as transmission line poles. By the end of the Keswick Company had ordered electrical equipment from Westinghouse, signed a contract for the Installation of feet of steel penstock, and expanded the force of men and mules excavating its canal system. The magnitude of the project was also enlarged. Original plans had been to Install two 750 kW water wheel/generator sets. By early Keswick had decided to install a third set.

Completion of the entire plant was expected by July 1, The emergence of the Keswick Power Company undermined Johns* Mt. Lassen Power Company. But the properties near Shingletown it had purchased from Shannon formed the basis for a new challenge to the Keswick Company's plans. In November the Beckwith Power Company was organized, including among its directors several people earlier associated with the Mt. Lassen Company. The new company quickly formulated plans for a powerhouse on North Battle Creek above the Keswick Company's site and announced its Intention of selling power to Shasta County mines and smelters, as well as to a projected electric railroad to be built to transport lumber from the numerous Shingletown area sawmills to Red Bluff.

The Beckwith Company in late also set men to digging ditches to convey water to the site of its powerhouse. Both companies continued ditch construction into the winter of much slowed by cold and snow. But in April the Beckwith Power Company halted work. Why the com- pany collapsed is not clear, but lack of capital was the probable cause. Beckwith's collapse left Keswick alone In the field.

A thirty man force using dynamite, horses, scrapers, and plows had been employed through most of the winter of excavating ditches and a forebay reservoir, while other crews had surveyed the itght-of-way for the power transmission line from the powerhouse to Redding and from Redding to the small town of Keswick, BATTLE CREEK CA.-2 ,^-ge 30) adjacent to the Mountain Copper Company's smelter, These forces were augmented in the spring and summer as construction of the powerhouse and the transmission line began- Masons, mechanics, and engineers, imported from San Francisco, worked in conjunction with local unskilled and semi- skilled labor, so that during the peak of construction activity between seventy and eighty men were employed.

Most construction was organized and directed by the power company itself. However, the San Francisco engineering firm of Hunt, Benjamin, Meredith, and Corey was hired to super- intend the erection and the testing of the hydraulic and electrical systems, and the penstock was constructed and installed by Schaw, Ingram, and Butcher, a Sacramento pipeline company. Equipment for the powerhouse and material for the penstocks began to arrive in late Harcfe at Anderson, the railroad siding nearest the powerhouse site.

But from Anderson all equipment had to be carried 30 miles over rough terrain, Transporting heavy equipment over the dirt wagon trails and up the steep grades in the Battle Creek watershed caused severe problems and was primarily responsible for delaying completion of the hydroelectric plant beyond the anticipated completion date (July 1). For instance, one of the pound generators reached Anderson on July 10, and was loaded onto a large granite-wheeled wagon pulled by twenty-four horses for transportation to the powerhouse site.

In the hilly terrain around Black Butte the wagon broke, delaying delivery and requiring the transfer of the generator to a second wagon, pulled by thirty-four horses [see HAER photo While teamsters struggled to haul equipment to the powerhouse, Keswick Company employees under the direction of Harry Shannon and A.J. Rossi made steady progress at the powerhouse site and upstream on the plant's system of ditches. By early August the powerhouse was substantially completedj installation of equipment within had begun, and of the feet of penstock had been laid in trenches. By October 10 the plant's water-driven exciter system had been completed, and the plant was able to provide its own electric lights.

Stringing of power lines from the powerhouse to Redding began in late May or early June and by the middle of August 10 of the 29 miles had been stretched and work had begun on the 5 mile extension from Redding to Keswick, where transformers were already in place. Noble and a representative of the Mountain Copper Company visited the powerhouse, named Volta, to witness the riveting of the last two sections of penstock on October 16. Water was first passed through the penstock on October 20, Tests of the system, difficulties in stringing the transmission line over the mountainous area from Redding to Keswick, and problems with the installation of the transformers at Redding, however, delayed the start of commercial operations at Volta until late November.

Redding first received power from the new plant on November 28, and Keswick and the Mountain Copper Company*s smelters only on December 14. Power lines were soon extended 5 miles westward from Keswick to Iron Mountain, where the company*s mine was located. VOLTA: Layout and Design [See HAER drawings, sheets 3-7 of 20] Keswick's first powerhouse (Volta) was located a few miles from the small crossroad hamlets of Man ten and Shingletown, around 30 miles southeast of Redding. It was situated along Millseat Creek, a half mile above its junction with North Battle Creek. The site was excellent. Paralleling North Battle Creek for some distance north was a ridge, wide at Che top and extending with a very moderate slope eastwards towards its headwaters.

The fall from the top of the ridge to the powerhouse site was perfect for high head power development around feet In a distance of slightly over a mile. A writer who claimed to have visited "practically every water power plant of importance In the West" asserted that "nowhere" had he seen natural conditions so favorable to power development. Sufficient water rights for the powerhouse had been acquired with the properties Shaman &s4 purchased: inches (50 second-feet) could be diverted from Uort& Battle Creek; inches (75 second-feet) from Millseat Creek.

To s^pleae&t these waters, particularly during the dry months of summer and fall, Keswick had also purchased from neighborhood ranchers rights to withdraw waters from three small tributaries of North Battle Creek Berry, Alpine, and Gilpin Creeks plus a small percentage of flow from a number of already operative private Irrigation ditches with water rights on North Battle Creek. Altogether Keswick controlled far more water in than It needed for Volta's kW generating capacity, but this excess provided the company with a reserve for future expansion. To bring water from Battle and Millseat Creeks to the top of the ridge or plateau overlooking the powerhouse Keswick crews dug a ditch (called the Keswick ditch or Keswick Canal) around 3.5 miles long.

A dam of loose rocks diverted water from North Battle Creek into this ditch, which carried it in a southwesterly direction, intercepting Berry, Gilpin, and Alpine Creeks before discharging into Millseat Creek [see HAER photos 121 and A second diversion dam on Hi 11seat Creek channeled the accumulated flow (around 45 second-feet) Into the last segment of the Keswick ditch, which carried the water to a forebay reservoir overlooking the powerhouse. (See the table on the following page) The design of the Volta water system,as well as the powerhouse itself, can be best understood by considering the problems faced by a small power system. A power company with multiple generating plants can tolerate accidents which put a plant temporarily out of commission.

The company's remaining plants can pick up its load for at least a short period of time and continue uninterrupted service. A power company with a single plant, however, can not afford accidents. Any shutdown completely deprives all the company's customers of power, discourages potential customers from adopting electrical equipment, and discourages current customers from ex- panding their dependence on the service, all very serious problems for an infant industry. In the early twentieth century power interruptions also invited the invasion of one company's territory by other power companies willing or able to promise uninterrupted service.

Since Volta was the first and only hydroelectric plant of the Keswick Power Company in Keswick's engineers attempted, in designing the various elements of the plant, to minimize the possibility of complete plant shutdown. The routing of the Keswick ditch Is an example of the utility's attempts to minimize the possibility of breakdown and power interruption. The ditch completely avoided the use of flumes, tunnels, trestles, and steep hillside ditching, since all of these were susceptible to problems (e.g., landslides). The artificial forebay reservoir erected by Keswick at the top of the plateau overlooking Volta is another example. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 32) KOEKVOI* Lake Nora Table 7. The Volta Ditch System, Source: Electrical World, v- 44 p.

BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 33) Some California plants in areas where flew was fairly dependable used simple header boxes at the entrmce to a penstock (especially if there were other plants to hack it up). Keswick erected an earth dam feet long, 14 feet high, and 59 feet thick (at fcase) at the lover edge of a mountain meadow, creating Lake Nora, a combination forebay and storage reservoir. Named after Noble's eldest daughter, Lake Nora covered 3.5 acres and had a storage capacity of 15 acre-feet. Should the ditch system leading water to Volta fail due to blockage or should a section have to be shutdown for cleaning or repair, Lake Nora had sufficient volume to keep the plant operating for to ten hours.

[See HAER photo Water was carried from the foxebay to the power house through a pen- stock or pipe line almost feet long. The intake to the penstock was a rock-filled crib with large wooden headgate6 located near the middle of Lake Nora. Debris was filtered from the water through the use of grizzlies or screens made of iron bars. For 800 feet from the intake the slope was moderate and the water was carried in 42-inch diameter redwood stave pipe. This was not unusual in California hydroelectric practice. Pressures were low on this section and wood stave pipe was much cheaper than steel.

Where the ground began to slope sharply downwards the redwood pipe was terminated and linked to feet of 30-inch diameter lap-welded steel pipe [see HAER photos 152 and The penstock terminated in a 30-inch diameter, 47 foot long header which paralleled the north side of the powerhouse. Three supply pipes carried water from the header through two hand-operated gate valves to the nozzles of the impulse wheels. The Volta penstock followed good California practice in most respects. It was well anchored against movement, lateral or sliding, by being buried in a trench. To protect against sudden pressure build ups and possible rupture a stand pipe was installed near the transition from 42-inch to 30-inch diameter pipe.

Six automatic relief valves (enclosed in wooden housings to prevent freezing In cold weather) were distributed along the line where slope changed sharply. The penstock installed at Volta deviated from standard California practice in one significant respect. It used lap-welded rather than lap- riveted pipe. Lap-riveted pipe was generally (but not invariably) preferred in early California hydroelectric plants, because of its record of reliability. Instances of lap-riveted pipe bursting were rare. Lap- welded pipe, on the other hand, was regarded with suspicion. But lap-welded pipe did have some advantages. Friction losses were lower because there were no protruding rivet heads. In addition it was cheaper.

Lap-riveted pipe had to be thicker (and thus heavier and more expensive) than lap-welded pipe to compensate for the weakness introduced by the rivet holes. Since the pipeline was a major cost item in early hydroelectric plants, Keswick engineers may well have decided to take a few, hopefully slight, risks here to reduce expenses. The exciters and governors at Volta were supplied with water by a system independent of the main penstocks. The exciter water supply came from Hills eat Creek. Some distance below the Keswick ditch a small dam and canal diverted water from this stream into a small forebay. A 6-inch BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 34) pipe carried water from this forebay under a 400 or 500 foot head to two 18-inch diameter Pelton exciter wheels.

Each of these impulse wheels powered a 45 kW Westlnghouse dc generator which energized the field coils of the three main generators- There were three governors at Volta, one for each of the generating units, all Lombard type Activated by water pressure, they regulated the speed of the main water wheels by manipulating their pivoted ball-and-socket nozzles* diverting all or a portion of the water jet away from the wheels and out the tailrace. The governor water supply was taken from the spillway of the exciter forebay and stored in a large tank. A 6-inch pipeline led water from this tank under either a 160 foot head or a 250 foot head (authorities differ) through duplicate strainers to each of the governors.

Because of the small size of the pipes used to supply water to the governors and exciter impulse wheels and due to the even smaller diameter of the nozzles which discharged water onto the exciter wheels, governor and exciter systems were very prone to blockage by leaves and other debris. It was to minimize this danger that an independent hydraulic system was used with the governors and exciters at Volta. With an independent supply problems in the governor and exciter water supply could more easily be delt with without having to shut down the main water supply and thus the entire plant. The water for these systems was taken where the water was "crystal clear" and hence less likely to clog small lines than the general water supply.

To further insure the purity of the water used for governors and exciters, Keswick installed a revolving screen in early The flume carrying the exciter and governor water to the exciter forebay was emptied over a rotating cylindrical screen, 54 inches in diameter by 5 feet long with 1/2 or 3/8 inch mesh. A second flume, placed inside this screen and A a right angle to the incoming flume, picked up the filtered water and delivered it to the exciter forebay. To further insure that the governor water was clear, its pipeline was equipped with dual strainers near the powerhouse. The duplicate ar- rangement allowed one set of strainers to be removed for cleaning while the other was still operative.

The use of two exciter sets at Volta also provided insurance against plant shutdown due to clogging. Should one exciter nozzle become plugged, the other wheel could continue to operate the plant. In addition, one of the exciter sets was coupled to a 50 hp induction motor. This motor was linked to the plant's bus bars and operated at synchronous speed with the attached dc generator during normal operation. But if the water wheel nozzle became jammed with debris, the motor would automatically pick up the load and operate the exciter with current from the main generators without the water wheel. This would allow operators to clean the injured nozzle without shutting down the plant.

Thus the governor and exciter systems at Volta, like the ditch system, were designed to minimize the possibility of complete plant shutdown and interrupted electrical service. The powerhouse at Volta was a massive rectangular structure approxi- mately 86 feet long, 47 feet wide (outside dimensions). Its concrete foundations were laid on stone and hard earth. Its 2 foot thick walls were built up from porous lava rock quarried feet from the site and laid with lime mortar with unpointed joints. The tailraces, wheel pits, and BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 35) floors were poured concrete, but the floor spaces around the gate valves, tailraces, and tail pits were simply covered with cast iron plates on cast Iron frames for easy access to hydraulic apparatus.

Steel trusses (later replaced by wood trusses) carried a galvanized iron roof and a ceiling of suspended sheets of galvanized iron, [see HAER photo 7] The powerhouse was divided longitudinally into two rooms by an interior fire wall. On the north side of the building, towards the in- coming penstock, was a transformer and switchroom around 12 feet wide. The south side of the building was occupied by the 28-foot wide generator/ Impulse wheel room. Both rooms were provided with large doors for the easy installation or removal of equipment. The generator room contained the housings for the three hp Felton impulse wheels. These wheels had rotors 64 inches in diameter, were mounted on dual bearings, and had extended shafts terminating in heavy cast iron flanges.

Their axles were arranged along a common center line across the length of the room. Each of the impulse wheels was linked by flexible rawhide coupling to a 750 kVA, 500 V, revolving armature Westinghouse generator. These machines were operated at 400 rpm and were similarly mounted on two hearings with an extended shaft terminated by a flange, [see HAER photos 19, 21, 23, 24 for Volta interior In A flexible coupling was used to link independently mounted water wheels and generators because if the alignment of shafts was not perfect a rigid connection would have caused problems.

The flexible linkages (leather strips 10 inches long by 7.5 inches wide by 3 3/8 inches thick) running from pins on the generator flanges to pins on the impulse wheel flanges permitted a slight displacement in shaft alignment due either to foundation settlement or slight error in the original setting of the machines. Both the selection and the arrangement f the generating units at Volta were probably designed to further minimise the possibility of complete power interruption. The 500 volt Westinghouse generators, for instance, were a conservative selection, the low voltage providing a good guarantee against generator problems due to insulation breakdown.

The use of three small units instead of a single large one insured that problems with one generator or one water wheel would not shut down the plant and enabled Keswick to use two units to provide service while the third was kept in reserve for emergencies* Finally, the extended shafts linking water wheels to generators were arranged so that adjacent units could be interchanged. If problems developed with one wheel, its generator could be disengaged and linked up to an adjacent wheel. If problems developed with a generator, its water wheel could be switched over to another generator. Leads from the three main generators were connected directly to the switchboard by cables running in ducts beneath the floor. This was possible because of the low voltage of the generators (only 500 volts).

Simple knife switches at the switchboard were used to link the generators to the stations double transformer bus bars. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 36) Volta had ten 600 kW Westinghouse oil insulated, air cooled, single phase transformers arranged tn banks of three with the extra unit held in reserve. Although the smaller and cheaper water cooled transformers were becoming standard in California at the time, air cooled transformers were not uncommon. Air cooling was adequate for small power units and less subject to problems (e.g., clogging of the water circulation system by mineral deposits).

The Volta transformers stepped the voltage up from 500 to Lines from the transformer secondaries led through high voltage oil switches, designed to protect both generators and transformers from overloads due to current surges or excess voltage, to lightning arrestors, and then out through the walls to a switchyard. Lines initially led from the switchyard 30 miles to Redding, then 7 miles further to the Mountain Copper Company's Keswick smelter, then 6 miles beyond to the Mountain Copper Company's mine at Iron Mountain. As the first of the Keswick Electric Power Company's hydroelectric plants and the cornerstone on which future expansion would be based, Volta was designed, as we have noted, to minimize the possibility of shutdowns.

In Noble's words, it was constructed "as thoroughly and substantially as possible". While not a large or important plant by later standards, it was a rather large and modestly important plant by contemporary standards. On a list of thirty-one major California hydroelectric plants reviewed by one author in Volta operated under the sixth highest head, was fifth in the distance its power was transmitted, and operated at the seventh highest transmission voltage. On a list of 106 California hydroplants published In Volta ranked sixth in power output (Volta's installed capacity had been doubled by this time). Volta was in most respects typical of turn-of-the-century California hydroelectric practice. It was high head feet), low volume (c.

45 second-feet), had a ditch network miles in length, and used impulse wheels Instead of Francis turbines. Typical also of California practice was the station's use of banks of single phase transformers and water-activated rather than pump activated governors. The station's rotating armature generators were a little unusual. But the rotating field generator was just beginning to emerge as the standard design in and the low voltage of the Volta units certainly made the rotating armature design acceptable. Even the rather picturesque rubble stone construction of the powerhouse was not uncommon among early California hydroelectric plants. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 37) NOTES [I] Bailey Millard, History of the San Francisco Bay Region, v. 2 (New York, p.

[2] Redding Free Press, September 8, Redding Searchlight, September 9, [3] Redding Searchlight, September 8, [4] Redding Searchlight, September 9, [5] "Deed of Trust: Keswick Electric Power Company to Mercantile Company of San Francisco, Trustee," June 1, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document "Deed:Keswick Electric Power Company to Northern California Power Company Consolidated," October 26, pp. 4-5 (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document [6] Shannon was credited by local papers with organizing the new company and enlisting the necessary financial support (Redding Free Press, November 1, Redding Searchlight, November 16, and January 18, What his exact role was is unclear. [7] San Francisco: Its Builders Past and Present (San Francisco, pp.

("Hamden Holmes Noble") and San Francisco Chronicle., December 20, [8] Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Transcripts [of Hearings], cases v. 3 (February 2, p. 122 (testimony of Edward Whaley, Secretary of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated) (CSA); and Decisions, v. 11 (September 1, to November 30, pp. [9] Redding Free Press, November 1, Redding Searchlight, November 23, [II] Redding Free Press, November 1, Redding Searchlight, November 16, November 23, and December 12, Redding Free Press, January 18, Redding Searchlight, September 5, says originally only two generators were to be installed. For the July 1, completion date see Redding Free Press, January 7, See also George J. Henry, "Some Recent High-Head Pelton Water Wheel Installations," JE, v.

11 (January p. 34. Red Bluff News_, November 23, Red Bluff Daily News, November 21 and November 22, Red Bluff Daily Peoples' Cause, February 15, BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 38) Red Bluff Dally News, January 21, January 22, January 23, January 30, February 13, and February 24, Red Bluff Daily Peoples1 Cause, February 15, Red Bluff Dally News. May 3, Redding Free Press.

January 18, Redding Searchlight, March 8, Red Bluff Dally Peoples1 Cause, February 15, Red Bluff Daily News, April 17, Redding Free Pre_ss, October 17, Red Bluff Daily News, July 22, Red Bluff Daily News, March 29, Redding Searchlight, July 14 and August 9, For the progress of construction at Volta see: Redding Searchlight, July 17, July 18, August 2, and September 5, Redding Free Press, August 1 and August 13, Red Bluff Daily News, July 25 and September 5, Red Bluff Daily News, October 25, Redding Free Press, October 17, Redding Searchlight.

October 17, Redding Searchlight, October 2, Redding Free Press, November 1, November 26, and November 28, Redding Free Press, November 29 and December 16, Information on the layout and design of the Volta hydroelectric plant in was largely drawn from the following sources: "The Northern California Power Company's Transmission," JE, v. 12 pp. "The Northern California Power Company's Systems I," Electrical World, v. 44 pp. "The Water Power Plants of the Northern California Power Co.," Engineering Record, v. 50 pp. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp. (primarily p. "The Volt Transmission Installation Supplying Current to Mines by the Northern California Power Company," Mining Reporter (March 26, pp. White & Co., "Report," pp.

and the Valuation Survey Field Books relating to Volta (dating from period especially Field Book 1 and Field Book 4 "Northern California Systems - I," p. "Deed of Trust: Keswick Electric Power Company to Mercantile Trust Co. of San Francisco, Trustee," June 1, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document Redding Free Press, September 29, and January 18, Redding Searchlight, February 3, BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 39) For information, of the Keswick Canal c. and after see: "Northern California Systems - I," pp. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Valuation Survey Field Book H-l "Valuation Detail Folder no. 5" and "Computation Folder no. 40" "Northern California Systems I," p. The data on Lake Nora is drawn from: Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p.

"Valuation Detail Folder no. 5," p. 37 Valuation Survey Field Book H-l and PG&E, "Federal Power Commission, Applications on System " (attached to Burrage to A.H. Markwart, November 10, in PG&E Central Engineering File) [This will hereafter be cited as for Federal Power Commission, application.] "Northern California Systems-I," p. "Water Power Plants," p. "Northern California's Transmission," p. On the Volta penstock see: "Northern California's Transmission," pp. "Northern California Systems - I," pp. "Water Power Plants," p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. and Valuation Survey Field Book 4 pp. and esp. See, for example, Jollyman, "Practice in High-Head Hydraulic Plants," National Electric Light Association, Convention Proceedings, v. 3, pp.

and Galloway, "The Design of Hydro-Electric Power Plants," American Society of Civil Engineers, Transactions, v. 79 p. Galloway in "Hydro-Electric Power Plants in California," JE, v. 29 p. asserted: "I have never known one [lap-riveted penstock] to fail". Cory noted in commenting on Galloway, "Hydro-Electric Plants in California," p. "it wasn't an easy thing in and even as late as and to get the money necessary to build these plants Thus money may have been a primary consideration in the decision to use lap-welded pipe. The Volta exciter and governor systems are described in "Northern California's Transmission," pp. 35; "Northern California Systems - I," pp. "Water Power Plants," pp. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. and Valuation Survey Field Book 4 pp.

"Northern California Systems - 1," p. "Water Power Plants," p. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," p. For the layout of the Volta powerhouse in see the articles in note above and in particular Valuation Survey Field Book 1 pp. also PG&E drawings and BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 40) For the water wheels and generators used in the installation see the items cited in note above and in particular Valuation Survey Field Book 4 pp. also PG&E drawing Only very sketchy descriptions exist of the Volta electrical layout. See the articles from JE, Electrical World, and Engineering Record cited in note above. 1st Annual Report Doble, "Hydro-Electric Power Development in California," fig. 2, following p. 76. "Some California Power Stations," JE, v. 19 p.

Volta is listed as "Northern California Power Co., 2d Station" and its "electric horsepower" is given higher than it should be hp instead of around But this does not significantly alter its rank. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 41) CHAPTER IV GROWTH AND DEPRESSION: The Early Expansion of the Northern California Power Company INTRODUCTION In the early twentieth century, in the first flush of expansion, it was not unusual for electric utilities to overestimate the possibilities of the area where they hoped to market power and install considerable excess generating capacity. [1] The Keswick Company fell into this trap.

As a result Keswick and its successor companies were caught up in a series of cycles in which over-installation of generating capacity forced the utility to aggressively develop markets for its power. Success in these marketing efforts and other favorable portents then seduced company officials into again overestimating future market possibilities. This led, once again, to the installation of excess generating capacity, thus beginning the cycle anew. This cycle of over-expansion, strenuous marketing efforts, and overly- optimistic forecasts of the future was repeated several times between and when Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, Keswick's successor, was absorbed by the Pacific Gas and Electric Company. In part Keswick's dilemma reflected the nature of the region.

Northern California was a sparsely populated and largely unindustrialized region at the turn-of- the-century- Hydroelectric plants were usually erected in such areas not to satisfy an existing demand but to meet an anticipated demand. And because anticipated demands do not always develop into actual demands, many optimistic forecasts were doomed to failure. BACKGROUND TO KILARC: The First Cycle of Expansion, Disappointment, and Aggressive Marketing, E.H. Noble, the president of the Keswick Electric Power Company, acknowledgedshortly before Volta went on line that his utility would have considerable excess generating capacity, but optimistically hoped that this surplus would be short lived.

[2] Volta was to go on line with kW, increasing to in early when its third 750 kW generating unit was in place. The guaranteed load of the new company was probably under 750 kW in late and more than two-thirds of that was supplied to a single customer Mountain Copper Company. Thus, even before the Keswick Electric Power Company began selling current, it was forced to aggressively cultivate a market for its power. Much of the utility's marketing efforts were directed towards the mining Industry of Shasta County, for the company had been created specif- ically to serve Its needs. The mining industry, moreover, offered Keswick BATTLE CREEK HABR CA-2 (page 42) a very attractive power market. Rydroelectricity was competitive.

Keswick could deliver power from Volta at a price one third to one half that of the power derived from the wood-fired or, occasionally, oil-fired engines which most mines and smelters were using. [3] Mining offered utilities an ex- cellent load factor (the ratio of average load to peak load) since mines, worked in three shifts, twenty-four hours a day, had relatively constant power demands. Finally, the current i ed by mines did not have to be "brought up to the same degree of nicety as ordinary", so less expensive regulating equipment was needed. [4] Although Keswick had some success in finding new customers in the mining areas of Shasta County, mining did have one well recognized shortcoming that made it necessary for the utility to seek a non-mining load as well.

Mining was a volatile enter- prise. Busts followed booms in rapid succession. One could never predict the price of metals from one year to the next or when a rich vein of ore would play out, causing a major customer to curtail or completely shut down operations. Urban electric lighting and power systems offered an obvious path towards load diversification and the Keswick Company followed it. In March months before the completion of Volta, the Keswick Conpany had purchased the Redding Electric light and Power Conpany and the Redding Water Company for These gave Keswick an established power market in a major city directly in the path of the transmission lines which were to link Volta and the Mountain Copper Company at Keswick, plus water rights on nearby Cow Creek.

[5] To finance this acquisition Keswick issued in bonds, which were purchased by the Mercantile Trust Company of San Francisco. Keswick signed in June a "Deed of Trust" , pledging its properties, water rights, franchises, and equipment as collateral. [6] To further diversify their power market and to further reduce the company's excess generating capacity, Noble and his associates in early extended power lines south into Tehama County. In Keswick had secured an option to buy the Tehama Electric Company plant in Red Bluff, but had been unable to secure sufficient capital. In early negotiations had been renewed, but with little success. [7] In February, however, the Tehama Company's plant burned, plunging more than half of Red Bluff into darkness.

Keswick was able to secure the Tehama Company's burned-out plant and undamaged distribution system for [8] This purchase gave Keswick another established market. But, perhaps more importantly, it provided the utility with a gateway for reaching down the Sacramento River Valley to the agricultural settlements south of Red Bluff and towards the very lucrative power market of the San Francisco Bay area. [9] Construction of a 30 mile line linking Red Bluff, through the small river towns of Anderson and Cottonwood, to the Volta-Redding line at Palo Cedro began in February with a crew of one hundred men. It was completed on April 20, when Red Bluff received its first power from Volta. The Tehama Electric Company did have some lines extending south from Red Bluff to Corning.

But Keswick engineers found these lines seriously deficient, requiring reconstruction, so immediate expansion south of Red Bluff was not possible. The expense of building Volta and the power lines to Redding and Keswick had nearly exhausted the authorized capitalization of Noble's company The indebtedness incurred in buying the Redding utilities in. eliminated the possibility of bringing in new capital through a bond issue. Thus the decision to purchase the Tehama Electric Compa&y and to build new power lines linking Volta with Red Bluff and points soath m 4e & . least a minor reorganization of the utility necessary. However, capital was also needed for other projects. Keswick had had some success in.

late a&d early in reducing the excess generating capacity of the.Volta plant, and prospects seemed excellent that the company's excess capacity might soon be completely eliminated. For the mining industry In Shasta County had been a banner year. Production rose sharply in both mines and smelters resulting in a substantial increase in actual and anticipated demands for electric power. The Bully Hill copper mine and smelter, eventually the second largest copper property in Shasta County, initiated operations in and offered Keswick the opportunity to secure a major customer. With copper prices rising, a number of mining and smelting companies in the region planned to expand their plants and power loads.

With future market prospects bright, Noble and his associates were not satisfied with merely eliminating Volta*s excess capacity. They wished to bring more capital into the enterprise and expand the company's generating capacity to meet the rising power needs of the area. In order to do this, and finance the purchase of the Eed Bluff utility and the extension of lines south, a major reorganization of Keswick was required. Cn March 12, the directors of the Keswick Electric Power Company incorporated the Northern California Power Company, capitalized at Stockholders in the Keswick Company were offered worth of Northern California stock for each share of stock in the original company (Keswick stock had been sold for per share).

In addition, a syndicate including Noble, Edward Coleman, and Antoine Borel, offered Keswick stockholders who did not care to make the stock exchange cash for each share of stock in the old company. There were no takers. Every share of Keswick stock was exchanged. The syndicate also offered to purchase any stock left in the treasury after Keswick stockholders had exercised their option. To raise additional money, the new company immediately authorized a bond issue of This entire issue was purchased by the Union Trust Company of San Francisco on June 1, The money raised by the reorganization enabled the Northern California Power Company to complete the power line linking Red Bluff to Volta via the switching station at Palo Cedro.

It also provided the funds for the reconstruction of the Tehama Company's lines south Af Red Bluff and the extension of these lines in the summer and fall of further south through Corning and Orland to Willows in Glenn County, where power was wholesaled to the Willows Water and Light Company. Lines were also erected in late southwest 12 miles from Redding to Horsetown, where Northern California had secured in August a contract for 300 hp to run BATTLE RABR CA-2 (page 44) electric motors for gold dredging operations and north 18 miles from Palo Cedro to Belamar, location of the Bully Hill mine and smelter.

Northern California's plans for expansion initially centered not on Battle Creek, state the Volt a plant was located, but on a much larger stream, the Pit River, Hx Mu&mt; Sorthern-.California placed surveyors on the Fit and filed claim em 250 Q09 iae&es second-feet) of water. Shortly after 'Noble announced plans for && immense hydroelectric plant. A large dam was to divert second-feet of water into a canal 28 miles long. This water would he used ws&et a head of 130O feet to generate as much as to hp, a capacity second only to the power being developed by the combined output of the stations around Kiagara Falls. Thia power was to he transmitted 260 miles to San Francisco.

This plan, however, was fotmd to he impractical after further study and was probably too ambitious for the utility in any case. Northern California soon moved its small Pit River crew to another site and made some tentative plans for a much smaller project. But even this involved too great a capital outlay for the company. This mini-force was maintained on the Pit after to insure that the company's water rights were protected. But the utility transferred most of its efforts to a more rea- listic and less expensive expansion option in mid-1902. Before the fall of Northern California had begun to finalize plans for the construction of a much smaller power plant to back up Volta.

This plant was to be located 20 miles north of Volta on the south bank of Old Cow Creek, a tributary of the Sacramento River north of Battle Creek. The property and water rights for the plant had been acquired with the purchase of the Redding utility companies in Although a contract for two generators for this new plant was awarded to Westinghouse in August and even though the design details of the new plant seem to have been largely worked out by December, work was pushed at only a very slow pace. Early plans to complete the plant by July were scrapped.

The slow pace of construction on the new plant, to be named Kilarc, can probably be attributed to a sharp downturn in Northern California's prospects in late and early A labor dispute idled the company's largest customer - Mountain Copper for the last month and a half of and well into In addition, world copper prices dropped sharply, causing companies in Shasta County's mining district to curtail operations and cancel or postpone plans for expansion* Production of copper in the region dropped from almost pounds in to around pounds in These developments "very materially" reduced Northern California's anticipated revenue and made expansion of generating capacity less urgent. They also demonstrated, quite graphically, the risks involved in over-dependence on the mining industry.

In late and early In an attempt to secure a market for the excess generating capacity of Volta, and to further lessen dependence on mining, Northern California began to seek new markets "where income will be more permanent" in an aggressive manner. The company initiated a campaign to actively promote the use of electric pumps for irrigation in the Sacramento River valley in the southern part of its territory. This campaign by the end of had had "some success"* BATTLE. CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 45) The utility also secured a contract to supply wholesale power to the Willows Water and light company. In addition, in March Northern California Power bought the Red Bluff Electric Light and Gas Company, giving it complete control of lightingin Bed Bluff.

In the spring of there were some signs of improvement In the company's position. Increased agricultural use of electric power seemed a certainty. The company's foothold in the Shasta County mining belt had steadily expanded. A contract, for instance, had been secured with the Bully Hill mine and smelter at Delamar, requiring the extension of power lines to that point from the switching station at Palo Cedro. In addition, the Balaklala Copper Company was planning a hp kW) smelter. Northern California hoped for the contract to supply it with power. With of Volte's hp (c. of kW) under contract, Noble recommended to stockholders in March that construction of the Kilarc plant be carried out immediately, since there were "excellent prospects" for new business. His recommendation was accepted.

In May Northern California purchased two sets of impulse wheels for Kilarc from the Pelton Water Wheel Company to go with the two generators contracted months earlier with Westinghouse. Plans were made to extend power lines from the Bully Hill substation 20 miles to the site of the new plant. These lines were to serve two ends. They would provide electricity for construction work and would allow immediate connection of the new plant into Horthern California's transmission network. Developments toward the end of seemed to demonstrate the wisdom of decision to expand. Besides "some success" in acquiring an irrigation load, the company secured important power contracts with the Balaklala mine and smelter and with the Belle Vue Irrigation Company at Anderson.

Lines were built in and early to both of these enterprises. By February of Northern California Power had a transmission network of 220 miles. This system had connected horsepower kW) and a capacity of only hp Although the actual peak load was still safely below the capacity of the system, it was steadily increasing. Work on Kilarc was thus pushed agressively through the spring, summer, and fall of and on Into the winter of Winter conditions delayed construction, but by March company officials were predicting that the new plant would be operative with two weeks of good weather. Their prognostications were a little too optimistic. The ditch system for Kilarc was completed in June, but the penstock and equipment installation was not compelfefeed until July.

Kilarc began generating power only on July 22,

The Kilarc Plant

Kilarc*s design was very similar to Volta's. The powerhouse was constructed of massive rubble masonry with a corrugated iron roof carried on steel trusses [see HAER photos Like Volta water was supplied to the powerhouse from a combination forebay reservoir, able to supply the plant with water for up to eight (or sixteen according to some sources) hours BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 46) should problems develop with the ditch system. Like Volta, the governors had an independent water supply and the main penstock was partially wood stave and partially lap-welded steel pipe. Also, like Volta, the turbines and generators were placed along a common center line running the length of the powerhouse.

The units themselves were basically similar in design to Volta's two-bearing Pelton impulse wheels linked to two-bearing generators by flexible rawhide coupling. Even the head at the two plants was almost identical feet at Kilarc vs. feet at Volta. But there were some differences. The ditch system at Kilarc was longer and more suceptible to problems than that at Volta, largely due to the more difficult nature of the terrain. Cow Creek runs through a steep rocky canyon. Diverting water from the stream with a small concrete overflow dam and leading it to the top of the plateau which overlooked the powerhouse re- quired the use of a long flume which ponderously crawled up the precipitous side of the canyon. The total length of the main Kilarc ditch was around 3.7 miles.

This included feet of flume; feet of ditch; and two tunnels totaling 324 feet. This system carried, normally, around 65 second-feet of water. There were other differences between Volta and Kilarc. At Volta the generators, transformers, and high voltage switching gear were all contained in a single building, normal California practice at that time. At Kilarc the generators and water wheels were housed in one structure; the trans- formers and high voltage switching gear were placed in an adjacent building. There was a single penstock as at Volta, and it was terminated by a header running parallel to the length of the generator room, with branches to the impulse wheels. Kilarc, like Volta, had water-driven exciters linked to induction motors.

But, unlike Volta, the exciters at Kilarc were supplied by branch pipes taken off the main penstock header, instead of by a com- pletely independent water supply. The impulse wheel units at Kilarc and Volta were dissimilar. At Volta the units had single rotors. At Kilarc each water wheel unit was composed of two Felton rotors mounted 3 feet apart on the same shaft, covered by the same hood. The capacity of these dual rotor units was hp. One of the rotors was supplied with water by a simple deflecting nozzle. The other rotor was supplied by a deflecting needle nozzle, i.e., a nozzle equipped with a movable needle in its throat whose movement altered the volume of water allowed to flow through the unit. In normal operation the plain nozzle constantly delivered its full flow to its rotor.

A water-activated Lombard "Q" governor regulated the speed of the unit by moving the needle of and/or deflecting the second nozzle. As at Volta the Kilarc water wheel units were separately mounted on dual bearings and drove Westinghouse generators mounted on dual bearings through flexible rawhide couplings at 300 The Kilarc generators were, however, larger than those at Volta kVA vs. operated at a higher voltage volts vs. and were of the rotating field rather than the rotating armature variety. It would have been possible at Kilarc to have used four single rotors, each linked to a generator of the capacity used at Volta. The decision to use the double rotor units and the larger BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 47) generators was undoubtedly dictated by economic considerations.

It was much cheaper to purchase a double rotor impulse wheel and one large generator than two single rotor Impulse wheels and two small generators. Had Kilarc been the first power station of the system, the larger number of units would have been needed to provide a reserve in case of problems. But with Volta available as backup, Northern California Power could adopt the more economical equipment Installation at Kilarc. The high voltage of the generators at Kilarc required a different wiring arrangement. The dual 220O volt busses at Kilarc were linked at the switchboard to the primaries of the transformers through oil switches Instead of simple knife switches. The transformers at Kilarc stepped the potential up from volts to volts.

Oil switches, controlled from the switchboard linked the transformer secondaries to the outgoing circuit to Delamar (Bully Hill) and later to a second circuit leading south to Volta. The Kilarc plant was one of the earliest to use remote control for high voltage switches. The addition of Kilarc to Northern California's system gave the utility, according to one author^ "the most flexible plant in the State," allowing uninterrupted, reliable service. With a total generating capacity of kW, Northern California Power Company had become the most important utility in the northern third of California and second only to California Gas and Electric (the forerunner of the Pacific Gas and Electric Company) in the entire northern half of the state.

In California as a whole, Northern California Power Company was ranked as the fourth leading utility (behind California Gas and Electric and the Edison and Pacific Light and Power Companies of southern California). The Northern California transmission system in is illustrated in the table on the following page. EXCESS AGAIN: The Northern California Power Company, Kilarc was completed in the midst of a very disappointing year for the Northern California Power Company. The hopes of the previous spring proved false. The hp kW) smelter which was to have been erected by Balaklala Copper (b- was not constructed. The gold dredger at Horsetown, which at one point had 700 hp in electric motors installed, shut down.

Farmers adopted electric pumps for irrigation "very slow And Mountain Copper, the major customer, had cut its power consumption by 33% as a result of a prolonged fire in its mines. Thus, once again, Noble's utility found itself with a large surplus of generating capacity. In late and early the average load on circuits was around kW The company*s Battle and Cow Creek plants had an installed capacity of kW (c. so around kW hp) was simply allowed to run to waste for lack of a market. Plagued with excess generating capacity, Northern California Power was forced, once more, to aggressively cultivate new power markets. Again their efforts brought some success.

Late in the company signed a ten year power contract with Mammoth Copper Company, which was in the process BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 48) MT. SHASTA MINI HORXtTOWN Table 8. The Northern California Power Company's Transmission System, Source: Electrical World, v. 44 p. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 49) <; erecting a smelter at Kennett. Power lines were extended north a few iijtiles from Keswick to this customer in early Another contract was signed with the Great Western Gold Company. This company was erecting a small 200 hp kW) smelter at Ingot, between Delamar and Kilarc. To link this smelter and Great Western's "Afterthought Mine" into the transmission system a line was run from Delamar to Ingot .where a sub- station was established.

Lines were extended in westward into Trinity County to the gold mining area around French Gulch and from Kennett to the mine and smelter at Balaklala. In addition, in Northern California Power purchased the Belle Vue Irrigation Company at Anderson, installed a new electrically-powered pumping plant and set out to "educate irrigationists in the use of electric power" with this facility, Another power market seriously courted by Northern California during and was railroad electrification. As early as during the construction of Volta, there had been speculation that on conpletion of that powerhouse another would be constructed specifically to supply power for a railroad to carry the products of Shingletown area sawmills to the Sacramento and the main line of the Southern Pacific Railroad.

In interest revived and local entrepreneurs, apparently with the support of Noble and other Northern California Power executives, hired surveyors to examine the territory between Shingletown and Cottonwood to determine whether a railroad was feasible. Noble committed himself to the purchase of a large block of stock in any company formed to construct such a railroad provided the railroad was electrically powered and provided the railroad company signed a long term power contract with Northern California Power Company.

But disputes over whether the railroad should be steam- or electrically-powered and disagreements between Noble and local entrepreneurs over financial matters and control of the enterprise led Noble to withdraw the offer in the summer of Thus this market for Northern California's power failed to mature. Northern California, however, had developed alternative plans. In early active preparations were made for the extension of transmission lines down the eastern side of the Sacramento River through Chico to the gold dredging territory of the Feather River between Oroville and Marysville. Power demand was high in this area end higher electric rates prevailed than in Shasta and Tehama counties.

Extension was made even more attractive because several groups were considering the erection of electric railroads in the area. Further, Northern California, in advance of actual construction, had been able to secure power contracts with several area gold dredging companies. Expansion south of Chico, however, meant invading the territory of another utility, the Valley Counties Power Company, a subsidiary, for all intents and purposes, of the Pacific Gas & Electric Company. Fearing that competition from Northern California Power might lead to a ruinous rate war, PG&E offered to purchase wholesale up to hp (c. kW) from Noble's company.

Since sales of this magnitude would substantially accomplish the goal sought by Northern California reduction of excess generating capacity the offer was accepted, the invasion aborted. The two companies signed & power contract in December Linkage with PG&E's grid not only insured the sale of up to hp in excess generating BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 50) capacity, ?: > ; *le^ -ffered Northern California potential future access to the rapidly . owing power market in the Bay Area. As the Red Bluff Daily News jubilantly proclaimed: "The trolleys on Market Street [San Francisco] may be operated by power generated in Shasta County".

The contract with PG&E (through its subsidiaries Valley Counties Power Company and Bay Counties Power Company), however, required Northern California to construct a 66 kV transmission line from Volta to Chico, where the grids of the two companies were to link. Due to the purchase of land and water rights in the Battle Creek area, the cost of constructing Kilarc, and the steady expansion of transmission lines between and the utility had exhausted both its capitalization and the proceeds of the bonds it had issued in To circumvent this dilemma and to carry out the construction of the Chico transmission line and to make other improvements under consideration Northern California officials in March of formed the Battle Creek Power Company.

Capital for the undertakings planned was secured in by selling in Battle Creek Power Company bonds. Northern California received all of the capital stock of the new company (making it a subsidiary corporation) in exchange for guaranteeing the bond issue with its assets. With these funds Northern California completed a line between Volta and Kilarc[5$],and work began quickly on the linkup with Pacific Gas and Electric. To protect the transformers (three, kW, oil insulated, water cooled,Westinghouse units) necessary to step up the potential of the main Northern California transmission system from 22 kV to the 66 kV of the Volta-Chico line, as well as the high voltage switching gear necessary to operate the new line, Northern California erected a switch house at Volta.

Work began on the structure in April and was competed before the end of the summer. Located approximately 20 feet north of the Volta powerhouse, the new 43 foot by 76 foot structure was architecturally similar to those previously erected by the utility at Volta and at Kilarc. [See HAER photos 6, 9, 16, The 70 mile long Volta-Chico 66 kV transmission line was completed in July of At the time it operated at a potential among the highest of any regularly used commercial transmission line in the world. In addition, the transmission grid formed by the combined Northern California and PG&E systems was the "longest continuous transmission system in the world".

The extreme ends of the system, Kilarc powerhouse and San Francisco, were miles apart by wire- At about the period Northern California was linking its grid to the PG&E network, the company began to enjoy additional success in expanding its load In the agricultural regions along the upper Sacramento River valley. Beginning in and perhaps even earlier, Northern California had encouraged the development of irrigated sugar beet farming on lands near Tehama. These efforts were rewarded when a sugar refinery to process the beets and an alfalfa mill, as well, were constructed in the area. Transmission lines to serve these industries were strung from Orland on the Red Bluff-Willows line 12 miles east to Hamilton City in In BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 51) addition.

Northern California also obtained a contract to supply electricity to the Central Canal Company, a large agricultural irrigation enterprise in Glenn County. The PG&E contract and the company's growing agricultural load had virtually eliminated the excess generating capacity problem by or Noble announced in March that sale of hp kW) more than Installed capacity was "in view". Hopes for continued success in the agricultural area, the PG&E contract, and similar portents of prosperity encouraged tn early to develop new hydroelectric power once again. The most economical of several alternatives was expansion at Volta. Access roads and power for construction were readily available there.

Moreover, Keswick and Northern California had considerable water rights in the area, having purchased or appropriated more water than was necessary for the initial kVA capacity of the plant. VOLTA: The First Expansion [See HAER drawings 3-7 of 20] In late the western end of the Volta powerhouse was extended approximately 27 feet to house a new generating unit. The north wall of this addition matched the north wall of the original structure, but because the new unit was larger than the earlier units, the south wall of the new section of the powerhouse extended 6.5 feet beyond the original wall. Although the addition was basically constructed In the same manner as the original structure, there were some minor differences.

Mortar joints were pointed rather than unpointed and stone arches rather than lentils were used over the windows. Moreover, the galvanized iron roof for the new section was carried on wood rather than iron trusses. Construction of this extension began in June The new pound, kVA Westinghouse generator arrived in November, having been hauled by two steam-powered traction engines from the railroad siding at Anderson. The impulse wheel being fabricated for the powerhouse was destroyed by the San Francisco earthquake and fire in April Thus the generator, although Installed before the end of remained inoperative until a replacement wheel could be delivered and Installed in April The expansion of Volta involved more than merely extending the power- house to accomodate a new generating unit.

An entirely new water system had to be constructed. To supply water to the new unit erected a new forebay reservoir and a new penstock. It would perhaps have been cheaper to enlarge the existing reservoir Lake Nora and install a second penstock from it. But installing a completely separate system had sig- nificant advantages. Enlarging Nora would have put Volta out of operation during construction. By building a completely independent system for the new unit, Volta was able to continue generating power (and hence revenue) throughout the construction process. The new forebay reservoir was located about a half mile northwest of Lake Nora, the original forebay reservoir.

NamedLake Grace, for Noble's second daugher, it, too, was formed by throwing a long embankment around the lower margin of a mountain meadow. The dam was feet long, 67 feet thick BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 52) at the base, and 16 feet high. It flooded an area of around 8-5 acres 3.5 for Lake Nora) and had a larger storage capacity (25 acre-feet vs. 15 acre-feet for Nora). Construction of the lake was begun in mid-1906. It was completed before the end of the year. Water for this new reservoir was provided by a new ditch system erected, like the reservoir, in The main supply was taken from the west bank of North Battle Creek, near the point where it was joined by Deer Creek, about 5 miles upstream from the intake of the Keswick ditch which supplied Lake Nora.

Additional water was brought to the intake site from Bailey, Beer, and Manzanita Creeks on the opposite side of Battle Creek. A series of ditches and flumes diverted water from Bailey Creek and Manzanita Creek into Deer Creek. A flume picked up this water, plus some Deer Creek water, carried it across Battle Creek, and added it to the supply available from North Battle Creek near the intake site. This system of ditches and flumes was slightly over 3 miles in length. The water from Manzanita, Deer, and Bailey Creeks, plus water di- verted from North Battle Creek was carried towards Volta by the Upper Mill Creek Canal. It was almost 7 miles long and included feet of ditch and feet of flume. Its capacity was nearly inches (50 second-feet).

The Upper Mill Creek Canal eventually deposited its water into Millseat Creek. This water was diverted from Millseat Creek several miles downstream into the Lower Mill Creek Canal, which carried it feet to Lake Grace. (See the tables on the following pages for the Volta ditch system c. Linking Lake Grace to the new generating unit was a penstock similar in design to the Lake Nora penstock, but longer (around feet vs. Wood stave pipe 48 inches in diameter took the water, screened by grizzlies, from a wooden intake crib located near the center of Grace and carried it for approximately feet until the terrain began to fall off sharply. For the remaining feet to the powerhouse the penstock was approximately half lap-riveted steel pipe, half lap-welded steel pipe.

It decreased in diameter from 36 to 24 inches. The static head on the new pipeline was some 50 feet higher than the maximum static head on the old line feet. [see HAER photo The three original generating units at Volta were Pelton impulse wheels and 750 kW, 500 V Westinghouse generators, each mounted independently on dual bearings with extended shafts linked by flexible rawhide couplings. The new generating unit was much larger. The generator was a Westinghouse V, kVA unit with the by-now standard rotating field arrangement. This generator was mounted on a shaft with two bearings. The impulse wheel which powered the generator was manufactured by the Abner Doble Company of San Francisco, chief rival of the Pelton Water Wheel Company in the Impulse wheel field.

The Doble wheel had an 86-inch diameter rotor and was rated at hp. It was mounted, without independent support, on an extension of the generator shaft which overhung one of the bearings, [see HAER photos 25, 26, 27 for views of this unit]. This arrang-ment, described as "single overhung"had been introduced by the Abner Doble Company at the Blue Lakes, California, plant in It was a highly efficient means of trans- mitting mechanical power from the wheel to the generator and eliminated the BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 53) <& Table 9. The Volta Ditch System, c. &<& &<# *F Macumber Reservoir! Manzaaita J^reek "S Upper Mil Xanaj Upper Mill Creek Canal feeder canals Baldwin Cana-V %servoir1 jower ,# .11 C) Can a; Lake Grace .&, 10 Lake Nora J? Volta Powerhouse^ THE VOLTA WATER SYSTEM, c.

approximate length length capacity dimensions Name (route) (mi) (second-feet) (width x depth) Upper Mill Creek Canal Feeders 1. Loomis Mill Canal (Bailey Ck-Deer Ck) 10 3.5 x 2 2. Armstrong #1 (Deer Ck-Deer Ck) 10 3.5 x 2 3. Mansanlta C3u (Manzanita Ob-Beer k) 10 3.5 x 2 4, Armstrong #2 (Deer Ck-Dpper Mill Ck. ...Canal) "" 10 3.5 x 2 Battle Creek to Volta Fo:rebay Ditches 5. Upper Mill Creek Canal (No. Battle Ck.-Millseat 30 7x3 6. Al Smith Canal/No. Battle Ck. Canal Co. Canal (No. Battle Ck.-Millseat 45 7 x 3.5 7. Lower Mill Creek Canal (Millseat Ck-Lake Grace) 45 6x3 8. Keswick Canal (No. Battle Ck-Lake Nora) 45 6x3 9. Baldwin-Lake Grace Canal (Baldwin-Lake Grace) 2 2.3 x 2.2 10. Baldwin-Millseat Ck. Canal (Millseat Ck- Baldwin) 5 11. Shingle Ck. Canal (Eagle Ck.-Baldwin) 2 851 3 12.

Misc. Small Canals (governor ditch; exciter water ditch; Lake Grace to Lake Nora seepage ditch, etc.) 2.5

Sources

44761 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,52-REBLU.V,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The data on the dimensions, length, and carrying capacity of the ditches in the Battle Creek system In the period are given variously by different authorities. Thus none of the above figures are necessarily precisely accurate* but they can be regarded as good approximations.

Primary resources used were: Folwer, Hydroelectric Systems of California; the Field Books of the valuation surveys carried out by the Northern California Power Company and now in the PG&E Rates and Valuation Department storage collection; the "Report" on the Northern California Power Company by the White & Co.; the and applications of PG&E to the Federal Power Commission for the Battle Creek plants; and the articles published in various engineering periodicals dealing specifically with the Northern California Power Company's plants (see bibliography). 55) problem of shaft alignment which had required the use of flexible tillages.

The single Doble wheel was supplied with water from a fixed neadle nozzle 6.5 inches in diameter, instead of the deflecting nozzles used to power the earlier Volta units. Deflecting nozzles, while adequate for small "units, were expensive and difficult to handle in larger units like the kVA Volta #4. The increased volumes of water and pressures encountered witlr larger power units placed severe stresses on the seals In the ball-and-socket Joints of the deflecting nozzle. Moreover, the amount of power required to acve a deflecting nozzle was considerable with larger units. Because it required less power to move the needle of a needle nozzle than to sove an entize nozzle, the needle nozzle also had cost advantages.

The entire governing system, including the governor itself, could be made lighter and hence cheaper when speed was regulated by altering the volume of flow through the nozzle with a needle, instead of deflecting a portion of a jet off the wheel by moving the entire nozzle. The needle nozzle had the additional advantage of being more efficient than straight nozzles under partial flow. The primary difficulties encountered in early needle nozzle systems involved sudden increases in penstock pressure due to a sudden drop in load and the subsequent reduction of flow through the nozzle by the governor- activated needle- To avoid this problem a by-pass system was used to maintain flow volume through the penstock.

The fourth unit at Volta thus had not only a 6.5 inch diameter fixed needle nozzle, but also a 4.5 inch by-pass needle nozzle* As the main needle nozzle, activated by a Lombard "Q" governor, reduced flow to slow down the wheel, the lower by- pass needle nozzle (which jetted water below the wheel and out into the tailrace) was opened, insuring that a constant volume of water would continue to flow through the penstock, avoiding pressure surges. Although the needle nozzle/by-pass nozzle system was designed to aJlow the governor to act quickly on the needle, the speed regulation of Volta #4 was not "wholly satisfactory". Problems with this arrangement here and elsewhere made the combination needle nozzle/jet deflector system more popular.

The decision to buy the new generating unit from Doble instead of Pelton, the manufacturer of all the earlier Northern California units at both Volta and Kilarc, may have been the result of a visit made by Noble to the Louisiana Purchase Centennial Exposition at St. Louis in The Abner Doble Company's single overhung impulse wheel exhibit won a Grand Prize at the Exposition, the only Grand Prize awarded to any machinery manufacturer west of St. Louis. This achievement may well have led Noble to consider switching manufacturers when plans were being laid for expansion at Volta.

Doble equipment was certainly competitive in quality with Pelton1 s, and the Doble company had pioneered in the introduction of not only the single overhung arrangement, but also the needle nozzle and the elliptical bucket. To provide excitation to the field coils of the new generating unit a new exciter set was installed. It was similar to the earlier Volta sets In output (45 though it was powered by a small (36 inch) Doble impulse BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 56) wheel, instead of by a Pelton Impulse wheel- This unit was not coupled with an induction motor as the earlier units. Also its water supply was taken off the new penstock* It did not have an independent supply like the exciters in the older section of the powerhouse.

Because the new generator operated at volts and older generators operated at they could not be linked to the same hus bars and the new unit had to be operated from a completely independent switchboard. The higher voltage also made it necessary to use remote controlled oil switches (located above and to the rear of the switchboard) to connect the new generator to its transformers (three, single phase 875 kW General Electric models which raised the voltage from to which were located in the extended section of the transformer room. High voltage Kelman oil switches linked the secondaries of the transformers to outgoing transmission lines. Kelman switches were among the first commercially successful high voltage switches.

The pantograph movement which broke the circuit hori- zontally in a tank of oil worked quite well in the 40 to 75 kV range and made Kelman switches very popular in California practice early in the twentieth century. In expanding Volta in the Northern California Power Company could have made the new installation compatible with the old, could have installed several small generating units interchangeable with the older units, instead of a single large unit which could not be interchanged and even had to be operated from a separate switchboard. The new unit, with its independent water supply, forebay, and penstock, and with its independent switchboard and bank of transformers was, in effect, a plant by itself.

Volta after was practically two hydroelectric plants operated under the same roof and was often considered as such. This arrangement was rather unusual, but is explicable by cost considerations and the backup generating capacity which the company had at Kilarc. One generating unit of large capacity was cheaper than ammiberof smaller capacity; the larger number of units and interchangeability were no longer vital because Kilarc or the three older units could pick up the load if problems developed with the new unit. The higher operating voltage of the new generator reduced both transmission losses within the powerhouse complex and transformer costs.

Because extensive water storage reservoirs were less critical on Battle Creek than on most other California streams, Noble and his associates had neglected them in the initial construction of Volta. This reduced the capital required to begin operation. With an established investment and additional capital available from the bonds of the Battle Creek Power Company, Northern California officials now decided to insure full output at Volta through the dry months by adding a large storage reservoir to its water system. The site selected was Macumber Flats, a large, soggy meadow on North Battle Creek around 9 miles northeast of Volta, just above the point where Deer Creek joined the main stream.

The company had purchased the necessary lands for the project much earlier in Construction on the Macumber Reservoir began in late or early aided by imported Portuguese laborers, and was completed by June of Twenty additional acres were cleared and at the downstream end of the meadows a masonry, earth, and rock dam was erected. The masonry BATTLE CHEEK HAER CA-2 (page 57) portion of the dam was 187 feet long and 27 feet high. Placed directly above the stream bed of North Battle Creek, it contained the spillway and the gates which controlled the egress of water. The earth and rock portion of the dam consisted of embankments feet long by 12 feet high, with cubic yards of fill. The dao created a reservoir which covered 150 acres and had a storage capacity of around 120O acre-feet.

A small storage reservoir for Kilarc (Buckhom Lake) was also erected in

The Struggle Foe

SuPREMACi ON I0WER BATTLE CREEK, The expansion of Volta and the construction of the Macumber Reservoir In and were in large part the result of PG&E's willingness to buy excess power from Northern California in order to prevent that utility from invading its northern territories and touching off a ruinous rate war. The danger of competition from invading utilities was such more serious for Northern California Power than for PG&E because its territories were much more sparsely populated and, as the company had already discovered, had scarcely sufficient business for a single power company. Yet, as early as Northern California was faced with the spectre of com- petition.

Two coapanies in that year announced plans to erect hydro- electric stations to supply power to the Shasta-Tehama County area. One of the potential competitors was the Shasta Power Company, represented by Harry L. Shannon, former General Manager of the Keswick Power Company. Shannon had resigned as General Manager of Keswick early in of his own volition, leaving the post to E.V.D. Johnson, Noble's son-in-law. In however, he reappeared in northern California and filed claim to the waters of Bear and Hat Creeks, the former a tributary of the Sacramento between Battle and Cow Creeks, the latter a tributary of the Pit River. Soon after Shannon began erecting a hydroelectric plant using these waters and located on Snow Creek, a tributary of Bear Creek.

Work on this plant proceeded very slowly, hampered by labor, capital, and materials shortages. But the threat to Northern California was clear, for Shannon declared in We do not, now, intend to confine our operations to supplying power to Redding patrons. From Palo Cedro we will run a line south to Red Bluff and further, and get right into the enemy's territory. From Redding another branch will go to Kennett. The Shasta Power Coimpany means business . . . When the Shasta Power Company finally began stringing its transmission lines towards Redding in and across Northern California lines already in place, Northern California sought injunctions to prohibit Shasta from beginning operation and from crossing right-of-way.

The courts refused to grant the injunction but supervised a settlement which permitted Northern California lines to have the superior (i.e., higher) position at crossings and charged the younger company with the costs of raising Northern California's wires so it could pass under. The Snow Creek plant of the Shasta Power Company went on line finally in the summer of but with an output of only kW. BATTLE CREEK HAER. CA-2 (page 58) A second company which emerged to challenge Northern California was the Northern Light and Power Company, Incorporated in February This company erected a kW plant on South Cow Creek whinh went on line in the spring of Like the Shasta Power Company, it extended its lines to Redding and began to compete with Northern California for lighting business.

Because the output of the Shasta and Northern plants was small and because, initially, they only challenged Northern California in the Redding area, the early effects of this competition were small. Only a small proportion of Northern California's revenues came from lighting and from Redding. The major company load was north of Redding where Northern California supplied power for the motors of mines and smelters, and Northern California was not immediately challenged here by the new companies. A third competitor posed potentially a much more serious threat. In the Mt. Lassen Water and Power Company had been organized.

This company announced plans to convey water from North Battle Creek and two Battle Creek tributaries, Baldwin and Darrah Creeks, to a site on the "Horseshoe Bend" of Battle Creek, a few miles downstream from the junction of the north and south forks. There the company hoped to erect a powerhouse to generate hp (c. kW) under a 450 foot head. These plans never came to fruition. In however, J.A. Whitehead, a local entrepreneur representing unnamed "English capitalists", began buying options to lands with Battle Creek water rights in the same area. In December Whitehead formed the Pacific Power Company, opened an office in Red Bluff, announced that his company had purchased the Battle Creek assets formerly owned by the Mt.

Lassen Water and Power Company, and unveiled tentative plans for a large hydroelectric plant- Pacific Power's plant was to be built along much the same lines as the plant earlier proposed by Mt. Lassen. Water would be diverted from both north and south forks of Battle Creek, plus Baldwin and Darrah Creeks, to a point a short distance west of the junction of North and South Battle Creeks where a 500 foot fall was obtainable. The new plant was to have an output of around hp (c. The directors of the Pacific Power Company attempted to reassure the management of that they did not intend to enter into direct com- petition. They claimed their primary market would be irrigation pumping and electric lighting, not mining and metallurgical operations, the heart of Northern California's revenues.

And the Redding Courier Free Press commented: "It is not probable that the future operations of the newly incorporated Pacific Power will directly effect the business of any of the existing power companies". The Northern California Power Company, however, viewed things dif- ferently. Pacific Power's plant, unlike those being planned or constructed by Northern Light and Power and Shasta Power, would have an output sufficiently large to threaten Northern California throughout its territories, territories which had insufficient business for two companies. Even if Pacific Power did confine its activities to agriculture and lighting, as promised, the new company was unacceptable to Northern California management.

Northern Calif- ornia had struggled for years to encourage electrification in the agricultural BATTLE CHEEK HAER CA-2 (page 59 ) regions around the Sacramento River and did not wish to see another company harvest the benefits of its labor. Moreover, Northern California probably viewed Battle Creek as its own private preserve, off limits to other utility companies. Thus Northern California quickly engaged this inter- loper in a life and death struggle. Following Pacific Power's announcement of its intention to erect a plant on lower Battle Creek3 Northern California altered its expansion plans. Originally Noble and his associates had considered increasing their systems generating capacity on North Battle Creek, upstream from Volta, where they possessed secure water rights.

To counter Pacific Power's plans, Northern California Power now announced that it intended to construct a large hydroelectric plant just downstream from the Pacific Power Company's powerhouse site. Northern California had purchased the necessary land earlier from the Southern Pacific Railroad and in had filed for an appropriation of water at the site. Northern California's new Battle Creek plant was to be radically different from their earlier efforts at Volta and Kllarc. Previously, to economize on capital, Northern California had avoided the use of massive dams to develop high heads. Instead it had relied on small diversion dams and long ditches which were much cheaper to construct. However, for lower Battle Creek Northern California now planned a massive masonry dam.

It was to be located just below the confluence of the north and south forks of the stream and a short distance below the site of the projected Pacific Power Company plant. The dam was to be 90 feet thick at base, 133 feet (later 154 feet) high, and 700 feet long. It was to be one of the highest dams in the United States and the only dam of its type of such magnitude in the world. A heavy timber "false dam" was to be erected on the site first, diverting water around the foundations while the permanent structure was built. The powerhouse was to be located on the north side of Battle Creek, near "Horseshoe Bend", 6 miles below the dam. The 368 foot fall which could be developed here would be sufficient to generate hp (c. Two hp (c. kW) and one hp (c. kW) generating units were to be installed.

Estimated costs for the project were far higher than with either of the earlier plants The real beauty of the plan, however, lay in the fact that the Northern California dam would flood the site of the Pacific Power Company's powerhouse. Once the decision was made to contest Pacific Power on lower Battle Creek, Northern California moved quickly. Before the end of January a crew of fifty men was working on the dam site, clearing ground and constructing camp buildings. Plans were to increase the force to 250 men as weather permitted. In March the engineer in charge of construction at the site, E.W.

Sutcliffe, travelled to San Francisco to contract for water wheels and generators for the powerhouse and to purchase air compressors, air drills, electric hoists, derricks, and electric rail- road equipment to speed up excavation and construction. A power line was strung from Volta to provide current for the drills, hoists, compressors, and the railway. Electric lights from this line were used to illuminate the work sites, allowing construction to proceed twenty-four hours a day.[101] BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 60) The work was impeded first by harsh winter weather, then by spring flooding and adverse political decisions. In March, for instance, Northern Calif- ornia's temporary wooden dan, only partially completed, was swept away by high water.

And in April the Tehama County Board of Supervisors denied the power company permission to use steam traction engines for hauling equipment and supplies from Red Bluff to the dam site. This forced the company to use slower horse-drawn wagons which caused less damage to the roads with their lighter loads. The Pacific Power Company also commenced work at its site upstream. Although its resources were inferior to Northern California's, Pacific Power officials were convinced they had nothing to fear. They believed they had controlling water rights in the region, for Whitehead had purchased not only the water claims of the older Mt. Lassen Water and Power Company, but a large number of private water rights as well (many in exchange for Pacific Power stock).

The waters claimed by the Pacific Power Company were not, however, as secure as the company's management led potential investors to believe. Dhder California law parties filing a claim on (appropriating) water must begin to erect works to utilize that water within sixty days of filing. Moreover, work associated with preparations to use claimed water must be pursued with "reasonable diligence"* In cases of conflicting claims to the same water the basic maxim followed by the courts was that "the [actual] use of the water alone fixes the right" and validates the claim. There were circumstances which made it questionable whether Pacific Power (through Mt.

Lassen Water and Power) or Northern California had worked with "reasonable diligence" to make use of waters they had filed appropriation claims on earlier on lower Battle Creek. The Mt. Lassen Company had, some years earlier, appropriated a certain volume of water on lower Battle Creek. But, unable to develop it immediately because of lack of capital, the company had set one man to work breaking trail, piling stones, and in other ways attempting to carry out the appropriation of water with the "reasonable diligence" required by law. When this man left the site for a longer period than normally allowed by law, Northern California agents had jumped the claim with a man of their own, pursuing the same tactics. When this man left briefly, Pacific Power Company, having purchased Mt.

Lassen's claims, moved in and set thirty-five men to work digging ditches. Northern California, as we have seen, responded by setting crews to work slightly downstream, on the properties they had purchased from the Southern Pacific Railroad, claiming the same water rights. The cloudiness of both companies' claims made it very likely that the courts would recognize the appropriations of the company which first actually began to use the water to generate power. Recognizing this the chief enginer for the Pacific Power Company, Strutt, planned to build his power plant in two stages. Strutt planned to install a 500 hp (c. 375 kW) generating unit in a small structure within eight months, adding additional units at a later date in a larger building.

He hoped this would enable Pacific Power to begin generating current before Northern California's dam inundated the site and, due to earlier use of appropriated water, provide grounds for an injunction which would prohibit Northern California from completing its dam and flooding the site. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 61) Through and on into the two power companies fought each other in and out of court. Pacific Power, confident of the validity of its claims to Battle Creek waters, sued Northern California for damages from the flooding that would result when the Northern California dam was completed.

Northern California, believing its appropriation was legal and that it had pursued work at the site with "reasonable diligence", sued to condemn the land and water rights claimed by Pacific Power. Meanwhile ditch laborers for the two companies actually engaged in combat, as both sides continued to rush their construction efforts. [Ill] The Pacific Power Company began to falter early in the summer of In June, troubled by lack of capital, allegations of financial chicanery, and the disappearance of its president, Pacific Power suspended work on Battle Creek and discharged its labor force.

Rumors that Northern California had absorbed Pacific Power were denied as stockholders attempted through the summer months to raise the needed to complete the small powerhouse designed by Strutt and construct a transmission line to Red Bluff. These efforts failed. The des sive blow came in In March the courts ruled that Northern California possessed a valid claim to the waters of lower Battle Creek and, upon payment of damages totalling could condemn the land and water rights held by Pacific Power. Northern California's directors balked at the amount of the judgment and both companies appealed for a new trial, delaying resolution of the issue for some months. With this decision the Pacific Power Company co!3apsed, and Northern California's rights in the area were confirmed.

When Pacific Power1 s construction efforts lapsed in June Northern California also reduced its work force in the area, indefinitely laying off 200 workmen. Northern California's decision to halt construction was, no doubt, partially influenced by the collapse of Pacific Power's immediate threat and the need to avoid further expenses until the courts had definitively settled the issue of water rights. But other factors contributed. Northern California had been unable to sell an additional in Battle Creek Power Company bonds to finance construction at "Horseshoe Bend". This put the company in financial straits. Even though had already been spent on the dam, at least twice that amount was required to compete the dam alone and much more for the power canal and powerhouse.

Thus the "Horseshoe Bend" project was indefinitely postponed and the partially completed Battle Creek dam was abandoned. Another factor which had an important influence on Northern Califor- nia's decision to temporarily abandon the "Horseshoe Bend" plant was a shift in the focus of its expansion plans. In Northern California survey crews had located several sites on South Battle Creek where power could be developed at a lower cost. Company engineers like H.A. Tedford subsequently filed appropriation claims on South Battle Creek waters, while the company purchased large tracts of land and water rights to supplement these claims. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 62) NOTES [1] Daniel W. Mead, Water Power Engineering (New York, 2nd ed., p.

[2] Redding Searchlight, August 24, [3] Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. 30; San Francisco Call, June 1, [4] Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. 35. [5] Redding Free Press, July 9, Redding Searchlight, March 13, Red Bluff Daily Peoples1 Cause, March 13, Jensen, "Liquid Gold," p. 6; "Deed of Trust: Northern California Power Company," June 1, p. 13(PG&E, Secretary's Office, document 2257-a). [6] "Certificate of Proceedings Authorizing the Creation of Bonded Indebtedness of Keswick Electric Power Company," March 5, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document "Deed of Trust: Keswick Electric Power Company to Mercantile Trust Co.

of San Francisco, Trustee," June 1, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document San Francisco Call, June 11, [7] Redding Free Press, February 14, [8] Red Bluff News, February 7, Red Bluff Daily News, February 4, Redding Free Press, February 17 and February 18, [9] Redding Free Press, February 19 and March 6, Red Bluff News, February 21 and April 25, Red Bluff Daily News, March 30 and April 22, and Redding Free Press, February 19, contain articles dealing with the construction of the line to Red Bluff. Red Bluff Daily News, July 4, Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Decisions, v. 11 p. 41. For copper production records see, Report of the State. Mineralogist pp. On Bully Hill see Bulletin 23 pp. 9, 48.

The contract between Bully Hill and is noted by Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. and Decisions, v. 11 p. 41. For prevailing prices of copper see United States, Bureau of the Census, Historical Statistics of the United States: Colonial Times to pt. 1 (Washington, p. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 63) Redding Free Press. Mfctf-A 6, Red Bluff Dally Neva. May 2, "Northern California Power Company: Bylaws " (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document CRRC,"General Order 38 Report of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, " (CSA); Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Redding Free Press.

March 6, "Northern California Power Company: Certificate of Creation of Bonded Indebtedness," May 26, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document "Deed of Trust: Northern California Power Company," June 1, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document 2257-a). Red Bluff News, August 29, 1st Animal Report for a detailed description of the dredger at Horsetown see "The Northern California Power Company's Systems IV. The Mammoth Suction Dredge of Horsetown." Electrical World, v. 44 pp. San Francisco Call. September 6, San Francisco Chronicle, September 6, White & Co., "Report," pp. Plans for the projected powerhouse at Kilarc were described in "Northern California's Transmission," pp. in the December issue of the Journal of Electricity and a completion date of July was mentioned.

A note that a contract had been awared to Westinghousa for the generators of the new plant appeared in Red Bluff News, August 8, 1st Annual Report for copper production stastics see Report, pp. for copper prices see Bureau of the Census, Historical Statistics, p. 1st Annual Report 2nd Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 42. The Willows Water and Light Company was purchased by in 1st Annual Report Red Bluff News. March 6, 1st Annual Report and 3rd Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 42; Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. 1st Annual Report The peak load, however, was only hp at maximum and average peak load was only hp. "New and Important Pelton Installations," JE, v. 13 (May p. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 64) 2nd Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 42.

2nd Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 42. 2nd Annual Report Ibid. Red Bluff Daily Keys, "May 15 and June 5, San Francisco Chronicle, July Data on the design and layout of the Kilarc plant was drawn largely from the following sources: "The Northern California Power Company's Systems II. Kilarc Hydroelectric System," Electrical World, v. 44 pp. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp. and Valuation Survey Field Books 10 11 and 12 (E-6) "Northern California Systems II," p. "Northern California's Transmission," p. "Northern California Systems I," p. The transmission system of in is reviewed in "The Northern California Power Company's Systems. III. High-Tension Transmission System," Electrical World, v. 44 pp.

See the article on the Horsetown dredger cited in note above. 3rd Annual Report 4th Annual Report 3rd Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 42. Red Bluff Daily News, October 9, Red Bluff Daily News, November 16 and November 23, and also August 18, Red Bluff Daily News, August 26, August 27, and August 30, There was talk of constructing electric railroads between Red Bluff and Redding or Red Bluff and Chico in and Northern California Power obtained a "very favorable" twenty-five year contract to supply current to a projected Redding and Red Bluff Railway Company. But these roads were never built. See Red Bluff Daily News. June 26, and 4th Annual Report 3rd Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 42.

Battle Creek

Ki;^" CA 2 4th Annual Report Red Bluff Weekly Sentinel, December 29, Red Bluff Dally Hews, May 16, Red Bluff Weekly Sentinel. December 29, Redding Free Press, January 26, 4th Annual Report JE, v. 16 (Jan. p. xxiv. 4th Annual Report Transcripts [of Hearings], cases v. 3 (February 2, pp. (CSA); Decisions, v. 11 p. 41; Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Redding Free Press, February 21, Red Bluff Daily News, February 14, 5th Annual Report For information on the switch house at Volta see Red Bluff Daily News, April 18, Redding Free Press, April 17, White & Co., "Report," p. 54; and Valuation Survey Field Book 1 , esp. pp. Red Bluff Daily News, January 26, Redding Courier Free Press, August 9, Blanchfield's Western Electrical and Gas Directory, (San Francisco, c. p.

154 [Copy in the California State Library, Sacramento]. Red Bluff Daily News, June 25, and January 26, 4th Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 43. 5th Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 43. 4th Annual Report The data on the alterations made at Volta and the machinery installed in is largely drawn from: Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp. passum; Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. passum; Valuation Survey, Field Book 1 pp. and Field Book 4 (E-28) passum; and PG&E drawing Red Bluff Daily News, June 6 and June 15, Redding Courier Free Press, November 23, Redding Courier Free Press, April 20, 5th Annual Report The data on Lake Grace are drawn from: Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. "Exhibit L"; Valuation Detail Folder no. 5, pp.

BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 66) Red Bluff Dally News., April Redding Courier Free Press, December 17, Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. PG&E drawing White & Co., "Report," pp. plus scattered information in the items cited in note above, and Valuation Survey Field Book 16 Upper Mill Creek Canal is reviewed on pp. of the Field Book. For data on the new penstock line see, in particular, Fowler, Hydroelectric Systeas of California, p. and Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," p. ifomberger, "The Development of the Tangential Water Wheel," JE, v. 14 p. 49. See, for example, the comments of George J. Henry, -"Some Recent Tangential and Turbine Water Wheel Practice," JE, v. 22 p. The water wheel unit is best described in Valuation Survey Field Book 4 pp.

68, See also White & Co., "Report," pp. and PG&E drawings and White & Co., "Report," p. 43. This may have been because by-pass nozzles frequently caused pressure waves in the penstocks, making good regulation difficult. Red Bluff Dally News, June 25, Abner Doble Company, "Doble Tangential Water Wheels," Bulletin no. 7 [San Francisco, California, p. 8. For the emergence of Doble as a rival to the Pelton Water Wheel Company see Durand, "Pelton Water Wheel," pp. My primary sources for the electric system at Volta in were, Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. White & Co., "Report," pp. and Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp. For instance, JE, v. 19 (October 26, p. and v. 22 (January 2, p. 17. Redding Courier Free Press, February 27, 5th Annual Report JE, v.

18 (February 23, p. 2nd Annual Report JE, v. 18 (April 20, p. Red Bluff Daily News, February 28, Scrapbook,"p. 4. The Scrapbook" is a book of newspaper clippings relating to the Northern California Power Company located in the PG&E Library. The clippings date from between and Many of the clippings are undated and practically none of the clippings are referenced to the newspaper(s) they were drawn from. BAm-E C . T. HAKR &. (page 6/; Data on the Macumber Reservoir vas drawn largely from: Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. "Exhibit L"; Computation Folder no. 48, pp. 1, 4 Valuation Survey Field Book 16 pp. also Computation Folder no. 555 Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p.

5th Annual Report Redding Free Press, January 20 and February 6, San Francisco Chronicle, July 13, Scrapbook", p. 42. Redding Courier Free Press, March 6 and April 12, Redding Courier Free Press, March 6, Redding Courier Free Press. October 31 and December 17, Redding Searchlight. December 1, JE, v. 18 (May 25, p. Redding Courier Free Press, April 8, and February 6, Electrical World, v. 49 (February p. Scrapbook," p. 2 ("Northern Light and Power Comply* February San Francisco Chronicle, June 3, Red Bluff Daily Mews, June 4, Red Bluff Dally News. August 23 and December 28, Redding Courier Free Press, December 17, December 22, and December 26, Red Bluff Daily News.

January 6 and January 27, Red Bluff Daily News, December 28, and January 6, Redding Courier Free Press, December 26, Red Bluff Daily News, November 9, Redding Searchlight, October 11, Redding Courier Free Press, December 27, White & Co., "Report," pp. Details on the large dam planned by the in for lower Battle Creek can be found in: Red Bluff Daily News, January 4, JE, v. 18 (January 19, p. 66 f (February 16, p. (April 6, p. White & Co., "Report," pp. and Scrapbook," p. 5. Redding Courier Free Press, January 16, Red Bluff Dally News, January 3, JE, v. 18 (January 19, p. 66. Red Bluff Dally News, March 6, The 5th Annual Report reported that contracts for generators and water wheels had been let. BATTTS HAER CA-... (pa&i 63) Red Bluff Daily Sega. March 6, Scrapbook," p.

5 ("Battle Creek Power Company, Redding Courier Free Press. January 16, Redding Courier Free Press, March 27, Other notices of weather Impeding work at the site include Red Bluff Daily News. January 27 and March 21, and JE, W 18 (February 16, p. Redding Courier Free PressT April 4, Red Bluff Daily News, April 3, April 11, and May 7, Scrapbook," p. 20 ("Traction Engine Not Liked in Xdussa* Red Bluff, pril Redding Courier Free Press, December 29, and January 30, Redding Searchlight, January 31 and February 13, Whitehead declared at one point: "X am now the possessor of the controlling water rights for the development of hydraulic power on Battle Creek." (Redding Searchlight. January 31, For California water laws see note [8] of Chapter I, especially Chandler, "Western taws," pp.

and Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. See also JE, v. 18 (February p. "Battle Creek Power Litigation," JE, v. 20 p. 69. Red Bluff Daily News, February 19 and March 12, Scrapbook," p. 5. Red Bluff Daily News, January 30, Scrapbook," p. 52 ("Pacific Power Controls Water"). Redding Searchlight, February 14, Red Bluff Daily News, February 26, Redding Courier Free Press, May 31 and September 13, JE, v. 20 (February 1, p. 69. [Ill] Redding Courier Free Press. May 14, Red Bluff Daily News, June 11 and July 16, Red Bluff Sentinel, August 7, Red Bluff Daily News, July 4, Red Bluff Daily News, March 4, Redding Courier Free Press, March 5, Redding Semi-Weekly Searchlight, March 6, Scrapbook," p. 65 ("Motion Filed for New Trial").

Red Bluff Daily News, June 28, The reports of layoffs were initially denied by see JE, v. 19 (July 27, p. 81. 6th Annual Report White & Co., "Report,'fcp. 47 spent), 96 spent). Transcripts [of Hearings], cases v. 3 (February 2, p. 123 (CSA). BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 69) 6th Annual Report JE, v. 19 (September 28, p. (October 26, p. (November 9, p. Red Bluff Dally News, October 11, H.A. Tedford to E.V.D. Johnson, November 4, in Jeffcoat Letter Book, pp. The Jeffcoat Letter Book contains copies of letters dating between August 13, and July 31, It was apparently kept at the Volta powerhouse. Most of the letters are simply instructions to order or ship materials needed for maintenance, construction, or repair.

BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 70) CHAPTER V SOUTH AND INSKEP: The Enlargement of the Battle Creek System The future looked bright for Northern California Power Company at the end of and early In The small rival utilities which were installing or had installed plants on Snow Creek (Shasta Power Company) and South Cow Creek (Northern Light and Power Company) seemed to pose no immediate threat. The most dangerous of the potential rivals ~ the Pacific Power Company had been completely crushed in its attempt to occupy Battle Creek. hold on Battle Creek had subsequently been strengthened by court decisions, additional water appropriations, and large purchases of area land. In addition, the prospects seemed very good for significant increases in power sales In the near future.

Copper prices, which had declined sharply in began to revive in and had climbed steadily upwards between and This had brought increased mine production In Shasta County [1] and, as a result, a steady expansion of the electric power market. For example, Mammoth Copper increased its power purchases from the Northern California system by hp (c. kW) between and and Balaklala in the same period installed motors drawing an additional hp (c. [2] All over the mining belt new mines were being opened and already established customers were expanding their electrical plant. Optimism abounded. [3] Further increases in electric demand in Shasta's mining area seemed assured, encouraging Northern California Power to again consider a major espans ion of generating capacity.

Another factor encouraging expansion was some seemingly promisingwork being carried out by Noble in smelting iron ore with the aid of electricity. As early as Noble had conceived the idea of using cheap hydroelectric power to smelt the iron ores of Shasta County, readily accessible but long unexploited because there was no coal in the area. This vision was one of the motivations behind Noble's early plans to harness the Pit River. But the highly experimental nature of the electric reduction of iron ores made power sales to the Bay Area market a more realistic plan at that time. [4] In however, using his own financial resources, Noble began experimenting on the electrical reduction of iron ores.

He located his smelter near the confluence of the Pit and McCloud Rivers and named the site Heroult, in honor of Paul Heroult, the French metallurgist who had developed an electric furnace which had successfully reduced iron ore on a laboratory scale. Local papers were enthusiastic about the venture. They closely monitored its progress and a Redding paper informed its readers that Noble's success would transform their city into the "Pittsburg of the BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 71) 'Test", that Shasta County would "someday control the iron and steel industry of the world".

[5] Noble reported to Northern California Power stockholders in early that if his experimental plant were successful the company formed to exploit the process on a commercial basis would "become a very large consumer of power". [6] Noble's engineers, with direction from Paul Heroult, erected a kW, three phase experimental smelter with a capacity of 20 tons per day [7] This smelter was started on July 4, and successfully produced small amounts of pig iron. Noble jubilantly pronounced the experiment a "commercial success," incorporating the Noble Electric Steel Company to raise capital for the construction of a commercial electric iron smelter which would have a capacity of tons per day.

[8] Further, Noble reported in early to Northern California stockholders that he and his associates In the iron producing venture would be expanding the Heroult smelter as "fast as we [the Northern California Power Company] can guarantee them power". The Heroult smelter, Noble declared, would soon consume more power than "all the rest of our system". The growth of the venture would be limited only by "the amount of power we can furnish them". E9] Despite the fact that previous expansions had led to problems with excess generating capacity and compelled the utility to aggressively seek out new power markets, Northern California's management decided in late and early to undertake yet another expansion program.

Copper mining was flourishing and would probably continue to flourish, increasing the need for power. Noble's steel plant at Heroult needed large amounts of power and, potentially, could consume any amount of power the company could possibly deliver. Expansion would also serve to discourage competition in the area, by preventing any gap from developing between regional power demands and regional power supply. Finally, the construction of new plants on Battle Creek would forestall rival companies from developing some very favorable sites still available on that stream. The expansion plan developed by Northern California management in and was very ambitious.

In the summer and fall of as the Pacific Power Company was collapsing, Northern California had initiated extensive surveys on the south fork of Battle Creek. These surveys had located two additional hydroelectric sites (besides the already existing plant at Volta and the projected plant at "Horseshoe Bend"). Shortly after the company began to purchase lands and water rights on South Battle Creek and in the area around Manton, just south of Volta, between the north and south forks of Battle Creek. For instance, in late Northern California bought the Hazen properties, which included acres of land and inches second-feet) of water from Eipley Creek, a tributary of the south fork of Battle Creek.

The system envisioned by Northern California for Battle Creek by this time included four powerhouses. The existing station at Volta would head up the system. Volta* s water plus additional water from South Battle Creek would be conducted to a second power house to be erected on the old Hazen properties, 5 miles south of Volta on the south fork where a head of 516 BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 72) feet could be developed. Water from this plant would then be carried 5 miles further downstream, combined with additional water diverted from North Battle Creek, and, under a head of 378 feet, used to provide power for a third powerhouse.

This water, discharged, once again, into the south fork of Battle Creek, would be diverted and used yet another time at the temporarily abandoned '*Horseshoe Bend" site on the main trunk of Battle Creek. Construction there was to be delayed pending the final outcome of the litigation with Pacific Power Company and the other property owners in that region. This ambitious expansion program required a major infusion of new capital into the company. The gained from the sale of Battle Creek Company bonds had been exhausted in the expansion of Volta, in the construction of the high voltage line to Chico and the Macumber Reservoir, and in the struggle with Pacific Power at "Horseshoe Bend".

An attempt to sell an additional.$500,000 in Battle Creek Power Company bonds to finance construction at "Horseshoe Bend" in had failed when the anticipated purchaser backed down. This had placed Northern California in severe straits. In order to continue operations at "Horseshoe Bend" and in order to purchase the properties and water rights in the Battle Creek basin necessary for any expansion program, the company had had to suspend dividend payments (begun in and increase its short-term borrowing. These loans had enabled to continue its operations at "Horseshoe Bend" until the collapse of Pacific Power and permitted the purchase of the Willows Water and Light Company.

Further expansion required the consolidation of Northern California Power Company's growing debts with long term financing and the infusion of new capital. To accomplish this, the company's directors created a new company, the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, incorporated on August 24, The new company issued in stock for in shares, valued at apiece. Northern California, Consolidated, absorbed the bonded indebtedness of its predecessors (Northern California Power Company and its subsidiary, Battle Creek Power Company) and acquired its stock at $20 per share, using stock of the new company as payment.

To consolidate debts and to finance an expansion program, the board of directors of the new company (substantially the same as the board of the old company) authorized the issuance of up to in bonds. These infusions of capital permitted the expansion program to begin. VOLTA: The Second Expansion The first step in the Northern California expansion program was the installation of yet another generating unit at Volta. The west end of the powerhouse was extended an additional feet in the spring and summer of and another kVA generator was installed in November or December, Increasing Volta?s capacity from kVA to kVA. The water supply for this new unit came from water rights which had been acquired piecemeal by the company over a number of years.

The company had, for instance, acquired 50% ownership of the waters of an BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 73) Irrigation ditch, called the Battle Creek Canal Company ditch or the Al Smith ditch. The sain trunk of this ditch, with a capacity of around 35 to 45 second-feet, was miles long and linked North Battle Creek with Millseat Creek. In Northern California had purchased the Schooling property, which included 160 acres and half interest In the Schooling irrigation ditch. In addition, Northern California had acquired part of the flow from a number of other small ditches. Water from all of these ditches was diverted Into either Lake Nora or Lake Grace by the Keswick or Lower Mill Creek ditches. The new unit drew its water supply from both the Lake Grace and Lake Nora penstocks.

A branch was taken off the newer Lake Grace penstock above the powerhouse and carried over to the new unit. This branch was joined by a "Y" connection to a branch which led from the older Lake Nora penstock. Although the maximum static head on the Lake Grace penstock was 50 feet higher than that on the Nora penstock, the two equalized well because of the higher friction losses on the longer Grace penstock. The new generating unit was basically similar to the unit added in It was a dual bearing, single overhung unit. The General Electric kVA, volt generator was powered by a Pelton impulse wheel with a 76 inch diameter rotor, rated at hp.

[see HAER photo 28] Water was directed on the wheel through a 6-inch deflecting needle nozzle, a system which attempted to combine the advantages of both the needle and the deflecting system. When the wheel's speed needed to be reduced, the governor (a Replogle mechanical governor driven off the shaft of the generating unit) would deflect the nozzle. The volume of water flowing through the nozzle could then be reduced by slowly closing the hand-operated needle valve. This was intended to combine fast speed regulation with economy of water. Excitation was furnished by a new 45 kW unit powered by a 90 hp impulse wheel with a Inch rotor. Water was provided this unit through a needle nozzle by a branch of the Lake Grace penstock.

The control board for the new unit was similar to and placed adjacent to the board of the unit. [for Volta's interior after the second expansion see HAER photos 18, 20; for later views of both Interior and exterior see HAER photos (exterior) and 22, (interior)] Volta1 s enlargement, however, was just the first stage of the Northern California expansion program. As construction crews worked on Volta final plans were being made for a new plant, designated "South", and preliminary plans were being made for another, designated "Inskip". SOUTH: Construction During the winter of the head of Northern California's engineering corps, H.A. Tedford, began the preparation of specifications and construction plans for the second of the Battle Creek powerhouses South.

He was joined in this task in by Strutt, formerly chief engineer for the Pacific Power Company, but now employed by the Northern California Company. By the summer of plans were complete for South and nearly complete for Inskip, BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 74) Actual, ruction work on the South powerhouse site began in October ;;& on the ditch system a month later. Even earlier, however, Tedford had organized Northern California's construction forces and set them to work. These crews constructed a 10 mile long access road from Man ton to South and from South along the route of the ditch which would eventually connect ittothe second powerhouse at Inskip. Construction camps were laid out along the roads and at both the South and Inskip powerhouse locations.

Power lines were strung from Volta to com- pressor plants established along the route to provide power for air drills. The ditch system for South traversed rocky and rugged terrain and included long secions where flumes and tunnels were necessary. This precluded the use of steam shovels. Hence most of the excavation work on the South ditch system was carried out by hand. Workmen used only Burley (or Burleigh) air drills, dynamite, picks, and shovels. Tripod-mounted Burley compressed air drills drove the holes required for blasting the rock with dynamite.

Derricks lifted the blasted rock and dirt out of the cut and hand-held drills cleaned up the ditches and excavated the stone used in building the powerhouse and the occasional rubble masonry retaining walls used at canal intakes, diversion dams, and waste weirs. The rocky terrain covered by the ditches required blasting with dynamite almost every inch of the way. Northern California ordered dynamite in loads of 10 tons and blasting caps in batches of As one local paper noted: "The booming of dynamite" became "the most familiar sound to be heard in the Manton country". To shorten ditches and reduce excavation Northern California was compelled to drive a number of tunnels on the South ditch system. All passed through solid lava rock.

Laborers drove the tunnels from portals only; the shallow rock ceilings prevented the use of shafts even on the longer ones. The dimensions were the minimum necessary for construction about 8 feet wide by a maximum of 8 feet high (the roofs were arched). These relatively small dimensions and the absence of shafts caused some ventilation problems on some of the longer tunnels. Tedford had to bring in electric blowers to increase air circulation, noting in April "We have to get air in each of the tunnels as soon as possible". In spite of round-the-clock excavation, tunnel work advanced at an average rate of only around 15 feet per day. At previous plants, Northern California had purchased prefabricated penstock sections and had these shipped to the site.

At South and Inskip, however, Northern California erected pipe fabricating plants on the grounds and purchased flange-steel sheets, punched, sheared, and scarfed for fabrication into penstock pipe. When the sheets were delivered company crews rolled them into pipe and riveted them. Penstock steel and generating equipment for both the South and Inskip plants began arriving in Red Bluff, 46 miles away, in March By July over 400 tons of equipment was sitting in the yards awaiting shipment to the powerhouse sites.

To move this material Northern California purchased a 50 hp, 60 ton capacity Best steam traction engine [see HAER photo Through the summer and fall of this machine hauled most of the heavy BATTLE GREEK HAER CA-2 (page 75) materials needed at the construction sites, Including hundreds of tons of plate steel for the penstocks tons for Inskip's penstock alone) and the large base plates for the generators (the two base plates for the In skip generators weighted 34 tons each). In addition to the large equipment, thousands of pounds of smaller items were shipped In.

In March in preparation for the upcoming construction season, for instance, Ted ford ordered rivets, 13 tons of rivet coal and coke, 20 tons of nails for flume construction, blasting caps, and thousands of feet of hard drill steel, along with miles of 2-inch, 3-inch, and 4-inch pipe for distributing compressed air. The peak of construction activity came in the summer of At this time the Northern California work force, a diverse mixture of Anglo- Saxons, Irish, Greeks, Mexicans, Portuguese> and Italians, totalled men with a monthly payroll of This force was much larger than that used earlier at Volta due to the much more difficult nature of the terrain and the larger ditches necessary for the larger volume of water to be used at South.

Skilled labor, such as the Italian stone masons, received about for an eight hour day. Helpers and laborers earned between and Most of the labor force lived in one of the ten or more Northern California labor camps set up In the area. These camps were little more than a "street of large tents" with a central dining hall for meals. After a visit to camp #4, in the wilds along South Battle Creek, the Manton correspondent of the Red Bluff Daily News remarked: "There are no wild animals around this camp. They had all been killed off by the biscuits". Because of the large work force and the dangers of construction when dynamite was in heavy use, the Consolidated Company converted the city hall of the tiny hamlet of Manton into a hospital, staffed by a company doctor and nurse.

The doctor reported treating up to 400 patients per month in the summer of but as of October listed only two fatalities. Although the number of deaths incurred in constructing South and Inskip is not certain, at least three more were killed by dynamite blasts or rock slides before the job was completed. The heavy construction around South powerhouse dramatically altered life in nearby Manton, previously a "quiet and sparsely settled" orchard town. As the Redding paper noted: The development work now in progress by the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated has changed things completely at Manton. Men of all trades and many professions are there and for many miles around the town the hills and canyons teem with laborers.

They are sleeping in barns, under trees and in out- buildings, wherever they can find room to spread their blankets. The hotels are filled up, new stores have sprung up, and every citizen has felt the new impulse and finds many easy that a few months ago was awfully The teamster, the blacksmith, the landlord and bartender too are working overtime to handle the business. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 76) The checks issued by Northern CailZwrn:^. < payable to Barham's general store at Manton. This steW. tsrtoacted over in business in The frenzy of activity in the Manton area began to slow down only late In as South approached completion.

SOUTH: Layout and Design [see HAER drawings, sheets of 20 ] The water for the powerhouse at South was drawn from two distinct and independent sources (1) Volta1 s tallrace (and North Battle Creek) and (2) South Battle Creek - in roughly equal amounts. The water brought in from Volta was carried by the Cross County Canal; that from South Battle Creek in the South Battle Creek Canal. The Cross Country Canal began at the Volta tailrace where it picked up part of the discharge from Volta and carried it by flume across North Battle creek where it was joined by a feeder from that stream.

Northern California was unable to divert all of North Battle Creek's and Voltafs water because of unowned water rights which compelled the company to release slightly over 20 second-feet of water during irrigation season to downstream users. The Cross Country Canal, with the combined flow from the Volta tailrace and the Battle Creek feeder, followed the south side of the canyon formed by Battle reek until it reached the top of a plateau, almost a mile south of Volta. Continuing generally southward the canal picked up additional water from Bailey and Rock and Digger Creeks and from several small irrigation ditches. Northern California had largely avoided the use of expensive siphon, tunnel, and flume construction in its earlier plants.

But the terrain along the routes of the South ditch system was much more severe than in previous projects. They could not be avoided if the ditch system was to be kept a reasonable length. In late Tedford estimated that the use of two tunnels and two inverted siphons on the Cross Country route would reduce its projected length from miles to miles. Flume, however, was used instead, accomplishing the same object. Altogether the Cross Country Canal had feet of ditch, averaging 6 feet wide by 4 feet deep, plus feet of wood flume, carried on timber trestles with a channel averaging 5 feet wide by 4 feet deep.

The capacity of the Cross Country Canal was around inches second-feet), [see HAER photo The Cross Country Canal terminated about three-quarters of a mile from the South forebay where it joined the second of the major ditches bringing water to the new powerhouse the South Battle Creek Canal. The South Battle Creek Canal secured its water supply from a small masonry diversion dam located on the south fork of Battle Creek, about 5 miles upstream from South powerhouse. This ditch was approximately the same length as the Cross Country Canal, feet feet). The South Battle Creek Canal, however, traversed much more difficult terrain. The Cross Country Canal had required the removal of cubic yards of rubble, only around 33% solid rock.

The South Battle Creek Canal was to require the removal of cubic yards of rubble, 82% solid rock. In order to reduce the tdia length of the South Battle Creek Canal, Tedford had considered using siphons here too. But to reduce expenses the siphons were replaced here, BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 77) Table 11. The South and Inskip Ditch Systems Lake ^* Grace.^-^* Lake Nora fcock CIS Volta powerhouse^ North Battle Ck. Feeder- \ Feeders from Bailey ^ and Rock Creeks <SS Col email Canal Cross Country Canal Union, powerhouse Ck. l South' Battle Creek *l A ?- '1 m THE SOUTH WATER SYSTEM, c. approximate length length capacity dimensions Name (route) (mi) (second-feet) (width x depth) North Battle Creek Feeder (No.

Battle Ck.-Cross Country Canal) 686 50 Cross Country Canal (Volta tailrace- Union Canal) 90 6x4 Misc. Cross Country Canal Feeders 3.5 (Bailey& Rock to Cross Country Canal) 20 South Battle Creek Canal (So. Battle Union Canal) 100 7x6 Union Canal (jet. Cross Country & So. Battle Ck. Canal - South forebay) 190 x 4.5 THE INSKIP WATER SYSTEM, c. Ins kip Canal (So. Battle Ck- Inskip Forebay) [incl. Ripley Ck. feeder] 200 8x5 Eagle Canyon Canal (No. Battle Inskip forebay) 70 7x4 m-0 as on the Cross Country Canal, by wooden flumes on timber txestlvas^ When completed the South Battle Creek Canal had ten tunnels, all 7 feet wide with a maximum height of 6,5 feet and all cut through self- supporting basaltic lava. These totalled feet in length.

The longest was feet, the shortest 15 feet, [see HAER photo In addition, the South Battle Creek Canal had eleven sections of wood flume totalling feet in length and eighteen sections of ditch (averaging 7 feet wide at bottom and 6 feet deep) totaling feet in length. The canal's carrying capacity was around 90 second-feet. The Cross Ceuotry and South Battle Creek ditches were merged feet from the South foreb^r to form the Union Canal. This short ditch was feet wide by 4 feet deep, had a capacity of 190 second-feet, and was equipped with a masonry waste weir just before it terminated at the South forebay. The South forebay differed significantly from those at Volta and Kilarc.. Xt was not a storage reservoir.

It was, instead, a simple header box, a rectangular masonry structure 26 feet wide by 41 feet long, admitting water from the Union Canal on one side, delivering it to the South penstock on the other. A set of timber gates operated by rack and pinion controlled the admission of water to the header box; a set of grizzlies or trash racks screened the water. The floor of the header box was divided by submerged walls into three sections ,each "V" shaped and sloped. Silt and sand which settled to the bottom of the V*s was periodically flushed out by gate valves which ran through the walls. The decision not to erect a forebay reservoir at South was in- fluenced by several factors. Cfce was the terrain. The ridge above South did not favor the construction of a forebay like the plateau above Volta.

Even a very small reservoir, like Lake Nora, would have required a large amount of excavation and embankment work, and would have significantly elevated the cost of the project. Moreover, a forebay reservoir was not as critical at South as at the earlier plants. Since South's water supply came from two distinct souces by separate ditches, one or the other of these ditches could be closed due to accident or repair without closing the plant down. It could continue to use water from the other ditch, operating on half power, until the damage was repaired or the repairs completed. Finally, because South was part of a larger system of powerhouses, a failure of its ditch system would not interrupt service. Volta and Kilarc or the link with the PG&E system at Chico could pick up the load.

The simple header box used at South was not unusual in California practice. Many small hydroelectric plants that were parts of larger generating and distribution networks had them. South had a single penstock of lap-riveted steel, almost 200O feet long, [see HAER photo This pipe was tapered from 72 to 48 inches in diameter as it fell 516 feet from the forebay to the powerhouse. Laid above ground, it was underpinned with loose rock and held secure on the slope by three rubble masonry anchors. As originally constructed the South penstock had neither a stand pipe nor air valves.

This arrangement could have caused serious problems from vacuum formation in cases when the headgates were closed and water drained from the penstock and was criticized BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 80) by the company's engineering consultants in as "not good practice". At Volta and at Kilarc Northern California had made heavy use of prefabricated lap- elded steel penstock, probably because of its lower cost and lower friction: losses. At South, however, all lap-riveted con- struction was used. The key to tills alteration of construction policy seems to have been cost.

Although prefabricated lap-welded pipe was 15 to 20% cheaper than prefabricated lap-riveted pipe, it was possible to reduce costs even further by purchasing steel sheets, already punched, sheared, and scarfed for rolling into pipes and fabricating the pipe on site. Savings came not only in purchase price, but also in trans- portation costs. It was much easier and cheaper to transport flat steel sheets, particularly over the rough roads of the Battle creek basin, than prefabricated pipes* Purchasing somewhat thinner steel sheets for lap- welded pipe and rolling and welding these sheets on site would, of course, have been cheaper yet.

But because welding was much more difficult than riveting and hidden flaws in a poor on site welding job were difficult if not impossible to discover, this option was generally regarded as too risky. As the lap-riveted penstock approached the powerhouse it entered a cast steel This split the single 48-inch diameter pipe into two 36-inch diameter pipes which passed through gate valves and were terminated in 9-inch diameter stationary needle nozzles. These nozzles were among the largest ever constructed. The South powerhouse was very similar in appearance to the earlier Northern California plants at Volta and Kilarc. It was a rectangular structure 69 feet 3 inches long by 37 feet 5.5 inches wide (outside dimensions).

Massive walls of rubble masonry 2 or more feet thick, penetrating to bedrock 9 feet below floor level, carried steel trusses and a corrugated iron roof. The workmanship was excellent: the mortar joints were tight, the corners neatly squared, dressed arches covered windows and doors, [see HAER photos The interior of the powerhouse was divided into two sections. The generator room was approximately 53 feet long by feet wide and occupied the east end. On the west were four bays. Three housed transfor- mers, the fourth the remote oil switch for the generator. Above these bays was a gallery where the high voltage switching gear was located. There was but a single generating unit at South.

It was a Westing- house kVA, volt, rotating field generator, operated at 225 rpm by two hp Doble impulse wheels with 66 inch diameter rotors. Cne rotor was mounted on each side of the generator where the shaft overhung its two bearings. Speed regulation was carried out by a water-activated Lombard governor, type It controlled hollow cylinders (cylindrical deflectors) through which the jets of water from the nozzles passed. To decrease the speed of the water wheels the governor tilted these cylinders, deflecting all or part of the water from the buckets of the impulse wheels. The needles of the nozzles were hand rather than governor operated and would be slowly closed when it was necessary to conserve water.

Slow closure by BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 81 ) hand Insured that there were no sudden pressure buildups in the penstock line. Water for the governor came from a separate pipeline, which tapered from 4 to 2.5 inches In diameter, and ran to the governor from the forebay. This water was screened twice, once near the forebay, again near the governor. [for interior views of South powerhouse see HAER photos To keep the large kVA generator cool through the hot summers of the Battle Creek basin* Murphy, a company employee designed a rather novel system. He erected a sheet iron casing around the generator frame. A large pipe of sheet iron led from this casing to the tailrace below. Tailrace suction drew cool air over the generator windings, into the casing, and down into the tailrace.

[see HAER photos 54] This system was later Installed on ^neiaors at Volta and Inskip. The exciter which provided direct current to the field coils of the South generator differed somewhat from the exciters installed at Volta and Kilarc. Like the earlier exciters, the South exciter was water powered through a small (78 hp) impulse wheel. But unlike the exciters at Volta and Kilarc, it had no governor. Speed regulation was completely dependent on hand manipulation of the needle nozzle control valve. If the load on the generator dropped due to the opening of an oil circuit breaker, a loading resistance automatically cut into the exciter circuit to furnish an artificial load to the exciter and keep the exciter wheel's speed within safe limits until the operator closed the needle valve by hand.

Another way in which the South plant differed from the earlier plants of the Consolidated Company was in its use of a single generating unit to develop all the available power. Volta had five units; Kilarc two. Good practice in a power system dependent on a single powerhouse was, as already noted, to have multiple units, so that an accident to one water wheel or generator would not close down the entire system. la multi-plant systems, however, it was good practice to install the largest size generating unit possible. A single large generating unit was far cheaper than several smaller units, and the backup capabilities which a multi-plant system offered made the larger number of units unnecessary. Electrically there was nothing radically different about the South plant.

It was basically similar to hydroelectric plants throughout the West. The transformers were three, single phase, oil insulated, water cooled,General Electric kW models which stepped the voltage up from to The air cooled transformers of the type initially installed at Volta had been superceded around by water cooled models which cost less and, due to better cooling, had a longer life. Water cooled transformers did have higher operating costs, but in areas where water was readily available this was not a major consideration* The generator at South was linked to the bank of transformers by a Westinghouse remote control oil switch, activated from the switchboard and placed in the bay in the southwest corner of the powerhouse.

The transformers were linked to outgoing transmission lines through a Kelman BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 82) high voltage oil switch and a disconnecting switch placed in the gallery over the transformer and generator switch bays. After passing the Kelman switch and disconnecting switch, the lines were taken out through a window to an adjacent switchyard with the usual pole top disconnecting switches. From the switchyard a 66 fcV line led to Volta. Later a line was run west to the newer plant at Inskip as,well. Water flowed through the South powerhouse penstock as early as August 17, But this water was drawn solely from the Cross Country ditch. The troublesome task of tunnel construction delayed completion of the South Battle Creek Canal for weeks afterwards.

in November of was the final tunnel on that canal, the foot long tunnel, completed. South was able to go on line in January of adding kVA to the existing kVA capacity of the Consolidated Company's power system. INSKIP: Construction As elements of the South hydroelectric system were completed, Northern California moved its men and equipment to Inskip and its ditch system, where construction had been proceeding at a slower pace. The company also attempted to beef up its crews to speed up construction. But sparsely-populated northern California had no ready supply of surplus labor. Thus an attempt in November to find laborers, shovelmen, tunnelmen, muckers, and compressormen" failed, with officials com- plaining that men disappeared 'Hfhen work steps onto the stage to meet them".

Nonetheless, by October the walls of the powerhouse at Inskip had been completed and crews rushed to finish the structure and move the machinery inside before the winter rains began. During the winter of Northern California sharply reduced its labor force as snows made outside work Impractical. In December 800 men were laid off. But a full crew was retained to finish up work on the interior of Inskip powerhouse and 180 to 200 of the "best laborers" were kept at work on the tunnels of the Inskip water system. The lay offs caused some trouble in nearby towns. Dismissed workers appeared in Red Bluff, began drinking, and soon "taxed the capacity of the jail". "Each day," one Red Bluff paper complained, "another installment arrives".

The new arrivals "carried their blankets", appeared to be "broke", and chose to "linger about the town". Other furloughed workmen stayed closer to the work site, drinking and lingering around Manton, hoping, apparently, to find work when construction activity picked up in the spring. The construction costs of South and Inskip weighed heavily on the Consolidated Company's available capital. As expenditures increased, Noble began to monitor progress closely, making daily visits to the con- struction site. Management discontent with construction costs and progress led to a major shake up in February of The company requested and received the resignation of W.A. Smith, superintendent of ditch and tunnel excavation, and dismissed a number of foremen and dozens of laborers.

A local newspaper commented: "Inskip work will heareafter be BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 83) under closer supervision and under competent hands. There will he In the future less bosses and more work. This will greatly cut expenses and lessen the labor". At about the same time E.V.D. Johnson, General Manager of Northern California Power, appealed to the Tehama County Board of Supervisors to reject an application for a saloon license. The saloon was to be erected near the Ins kip site, and the company feared that the men they intended to have on the payroll in the spring would have their work performance impaired by having alcohol so readily available.

In an attempt to further reduce labor costs and to expedite excavation work on the Inskip ditch system, Northern California decided to experiment with a more mechanized construction plant on the last 1.5 miles of the ditch linking South with Inskip. In March the utility received its first steam shovel, a Marion with a 1.5 cubic yard capacity bucket* It was put to work immediately. By May the Inskip Canal was finished. INSKIP: Layout and Design [see HAER drawings, sheets of 20 3 There are two primary ditches that provide water to Inskip: (1) the Inskip Canal and (2) the Eagle Canyon Canal. The former is the more im- portant of the two conveyances. It originates at a 32 foot high rubble masonry overflow dam on South Battle Creek, a short distance downstream from South powerhouse.

This.dam diverted most of the available water into the ditch. The Inskip Canal was, like the other canals of the Battle Creek system, originally unlined. It had a capacity of 125 second-feet. A typical cross section of the ditch was 5 feet deep and averaged 8 feet wide. Roughly paralleling the course of South Battle Creek, Inskip Canal was approximately miles long and like the South Battle Creek Canal of the South system was a mixture of tunnel (eight sections), ditch (eleven sections), and flume (1 section), [for a view of a waste weir on the Inskip ditch see HAER photo To reduce construction costs the Consolidated Company should perhaps have used more flume and less tunnel on the Inskip ditch, since the cost of the latter was three times that of the former.

But Northern California's construction policy was to sacrifice economy for permanency. As one observer noted: It has been the policy of this company to do its work in a manner to insure permanency and low cost of upkeep. With this in view, it has steadfastly refused to use timber flume for carrying large amounts of water, if it were possible to obviate its use. It has even gone so far as to drive crescent'shaped tunnels where timber flume might easily have been employed at one third of the initial cost. The eight sections of tunnel on the Inskip ditch totalled feet in length. The longest was feet, the shortest 96 feet. They were the BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 84) '.mvwsi;;^ as- ?.Ke tunnels on the South Battle Creek Canal 8 feet wide tfith a luaxiaium height'of 8 feet.

And, like the earlier tunnel work carried out by the company, all tunnels were unlined and driven entirely with hand labor. The eleven sections of ditch on the Inskip Canal totalled feet. Of this total around 63% or feet were excavated by hand. The remaining portion was excavated with the aid of the steam shovel. This gave the Consolidated Company an opportunity to compare the costs of the two systems. Final estimates indicated that the portion of the canal excavated by hand had cost the company around per linear foot. The section excavated with the aid of the steam shovel had cost only approximately 49% less, convincing the power company of the advantages of mechanical excavation.

The water brought from South Battle Creek through the Inskip Canal was supplemented by additional water, approximately 70 second-feet, diverted from North Battle Creek through the Eagle Canyon Canal. This canal originated at a 12 foot high, 72 foot long rubble overflow diversion dam on North Battle Creek near the point it entered Eagle Canyon. Flume work carried the water from North Battle Creek up the south wall of Eagle Canyon on timber bents spaced 3 feet apart set on a bench cut into the side of the south wall of the canyon. After reaching the top of Eagle Canyon the canal travelled in a generally southwesterly direction towards the Inskip forebay. The Eagle Canyon Canal was feet long and contained six tunnels, six sections of flume, and one long section of ditch.

The six tunnels totalled feet in length and were smaller than the tunnels on the South Battle Creek and Inskip Canals. The six sections of flume totalled feet in length. The longest section was feet long and was the section which carried the water up the side of Eagle Canyon, [see HAER photos The feet of ditch on this canal were all excavated by hand. The Inskip Canal was completed first. The last of its tunnels was driven through in March and ditch excavation was completed by May. Inskip went on line on June 10, operating with water from this canal only. Work on the Eagle Canyon bench and flume delayed the completion of the Eagle Canyon Canal through the summer of Its waters joined those of the Inskip Canal only in October The Inskip and Eagle Canyon canals met at the Inskip forebay.

As at South, this forebay had no storage capacity. It was simply a masonry header box. 12 feet deep by 52 feet long by 36 feet deep. The box was divided into three sections, each approximately 16 feet wide and 36 feet long. The first two sections were opposite rack-and-pinion operated entry gates, had sloping floors, and were separated by a submerged concrete barrier. Valves in the forebay wall here, as at South, allowed the sand and grit deposited in the bottom to be periodically flushed out.

The third forebay compartment was separated from the other two by trash racks which screened floating debris from the water and contained the 72-inch diameter penstock entrance* [see HAER photo BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 85) The Inskip penstock was a mixture of redwood stave pipe and lap- riveted steel pipe. For the first feet the slope from the Inskip forebay was gentle and redwood stave pipe was used* When the slope dropped off sharply towards South Battle Creek and the powerhouse, riveted steel pipe, around feet, was used. The redwood stave pipe was fabricated out of tinier cut and finished in a mill owned and operated by Northern California, using only the beet red fir from the heart of the tree.

The lap-riveted steel pipe was fabricated from steel plate at a company pipe ship at the Inskip powerhouse site, [see HAER photos 158 for fabrication work at Inskip] The usual precautions were taken to prevent pressure buildups in the pipe. There was a stand pipe and two automatic pressure relief valves, [see HAER photos 13, 144 for views of the Inskip penstock] The foot long penstock, after falling 378 feet, was terminated In a receiver embedded in concrete lying alongside and parallel to the length of the powerhouse. The first section of this receiver was the same diameter of the incoming penstock, 6 feet, and had three 27-inch feeder pipes taken off at right angles to one of the generating units in the adjacent powerhouse.

The receiver was then tapered to 42 inches diameter and three more feeder pipes, 21 inches in diameter, were taken off at right angles. Near the end of the receiver a 12 inch tap was taken off for the exciter wheels. In most California hydroelectric plants, and in hydroelectric plants generally, the incoming penstock reaches the powerhouse along a line perpendicular to the longest side and to the center line of the axles of the generating units (if impulse wheels are used). This arrangement reduces losses in hydraulic efficiency due to sudden changes in the direction of flow. The Inskip penstock with its perpendicular feeders violated this basic practice largely because of the terrain in the area.

The extensive amount of excavation and levelling wort which would have been required to reposition the powerhouse perpendicular to the penstock made the more usual and more efficient option too costly. The Inskip powerhouse was very similar to South in design. The walls of 2 foot 3 inch and 2 foot 6 inch thick rubble masonry were carried down to bedrock. Steel trusses carried a corrugated iron roof on steel trusses over the shell. Windows and doors had dressed stone arches. The structure was rectangular, 125 feet long by feet wide and, like South, was divided transversely into two sections a large room contained the generating machinery; a smaller two story section housed the trans- formers and high voltage switching apparatus.

[see HAER photos for the exterior of Inskip; for the interior] The most unusual feature of the Inskip hydroelectric plant was its generating units. There were two, placed on a common center line which ran the length of the building and paralleled the penstock and its receiver. The upstream unit had an output of kVA; the downstream unit kVA. Both units had three rotors 48 inches in diameter, [see HAER photo 66] The three wheels of the larger unit were supplied with water from three 27-inch diameter pipes tapped off the upstream portion of the receiver and led through 27-inch hydraulic gate valves; the wheels of the smaller unit BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 86) were supplied with -vater from three 21-inch diameter pipes equipped with 21-inch hydraulic gate valves.

The generator and the triple rotors of both units were mounted on the same shaft- There were three water-cooled bearings, one on either end of the shaft and one between the generator and the housing for the triple rotors. The larger of the two triple rotor units had two 6-inch diameter nozzles for each rotor. The rear or upper nozzle was a fixed needle nozzle; the needle was operated by screw and hand wheel. The forward and lover nozzle had a plain tip. The small generating unit had only one nozzle (a 6-inch diameter needle nozzle) per rotor. The speed of these units was governed by a water-activated Lombard governor, type which controlled a set of U-shaped hood deflectors.

The water supply for the- governors was tapped off the penstock near the forebay, led to a governor water storage tank, where the water was screened with 1/2 inch wire mesh, and then into the governor feeder pipe. This pipe, 3,5 inches in diameter near the storage tank, reduced to 2.5 inches as it neared the powerhouse, paralleled the penstock. If the water wheels began to rotate too fast, the governors, through a rocking arm, tilted the deflecting hoods (one for each nozzle) so that they intercepted the jets and deflected them wholly or partially from the impulse wheels. The "somewhat novel" triple rotor units were used at Inskip because of the relatively low head at the site feet) and economic considerations.

Under a head of 378 feet the velocity of the water jets and hence the velocity of the impulse wheels (half that of the water jets for maximum efficiency) would be relatively low. This made it difficult to install a single large unit like at South. For medium-to high-power generators to kVA's In the most desirable speeds were or 514 Above these speeds the cost of generators went up very steeply; below these speeds the cost of generators was also higher, though it was possible to purchase lower power units operating at or 300 This presented Northern California's engineers with a dilemma.

A single overhung unit like Volta units 4 and 5, in order to operate at 400 would have had to use a rotor with a small diameter and this unit, with only a 378 foot fall, would have been able to deliver less than kVA. To make use of the kVA available at the Inskip site, eight to ten single overhung units would have been required, along with associated equipment (gate valves, nozzles, governors, switchboards, etc.), a con- siderable expense, especially since the powerhouse necessary to house that number of units would have been quite large. On the other hand* in order to operate a single large generator, Northern California would have had to use a rotor with a very large diameter to develop the necessary power.

The larger rotor, because its peripheral speed was fixed in relation to the speed of the water jets, would have had a much lower shaft speed. The low shaft speed would have compelled the company to use a very low speed generator. And low speed generators were not only more expensive than generators with speeds of from 300 to 500 but much larger ( higher transportation costs) and less efficient. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 87) The generating an^iw-- adopted at Inskip was a compromise between these two extremes. The&a woi-;. ways to increase the output of impulse wheel units where speed requlz:sJ* nts were fixed. One way was to install multiple nozzles. This would bring more water against a single wheel.

Two jets striking against the buckets of an impulse wheel in two different locations would double the power of the wheel without altering shaft speed. The other way was to install additional rotors of the same diameter (and hence the same peripheral speed) on the same shaft, as, for example, had been done at South with the double overhung arrangement. At Ins kip Northern California engineers adopted both of these options. This allowed them to reduce the number of generating units necessary to tap the kVA of power available under the 378 foot fall to only two and also permitted them to use a reasonably high generator shaft speed rpm),thus avoiding the more expensive, less efficient slower speed generators* How successful the triple rotor units were a4: Inskip is open to some question.

Their efficiency was low. Tests carried out In on the larger unit indicated that its maximum efficiency was obtained at about half gate, but dropped off very sharply beyond three-quarters gate to only around 60% at full gate. The smaller unit with the single nozzles performed better. Its peak efficiency was around 87% and dropped only to 82% at full gate. Interference in the form of splashing and spray between the dual nozzles on the larger units and, possibly, differing jet velocities between the two nozzles were probable causes. Low efficiency was not the only problem with the triple rotor, dual nozzle design. Later critics noted that this arrangement also com- plicated the governing of water wheel speed.

Regulation problems and low efficiency led, in the second decade of the twentieth century, to the demise of the triple rotor/double nozzle unit. However, since first cost was more important than efficiency to the Northern California Power Company, plagued as it often was by excess generating capacity, the shortcomings of the larger Inskip unit were probably not too severe from a strictly practical point of view. It is, nonetheless, quite possible that Northern California engineers erred in adopting impulse wheels at Inskip. There was an option besides triple rotor units which might have allowed them to avoid the dual hazards of multiple units and slow-speed generators the Francis turbine.

Because Francis turbines deliver optimum efficiency when their peripheral velocity is 75 to that of the incoming water, instead of 50% as in an impulse wheel, they have a higher rotational velocity for the same power output. In addition, because water acts over the entire circumference of a turbine, instead of on only a portion of the circumference as in an impulse wheel, turbines can handle larger quantities of water and hence deliver larger power for equivalent size. Thus,the Francis turbine might have enabled Northern California to utilize the kVA of power available at Inskip in a single unit, without the necessity of having to utilize a slow speed generator. then, was a Francis turbine not selected for Inskip? In part it was due to tradition.

The Francis turbine was developed and initially manufactured in the eastern part of the United States where falls were low .iAXTLE CREEK CA-2 :;-.i.-ige 88) (usually under 50 feet) and flows were large. The stock turbines long offered by most eastern manufacturers were simply not Assigned to handle the high water velocities and low volumes used in CaJi.forn.ia hydroelectric plants. When Francis wheels were first applied to high head conditions, the grit, sand, and silt carried with the water at high velocities had an abrasive effect on the closely spaced buckets and quickly pitted the runners, sharply decreasing the efficiency of the units after a few weeks of operation.

Because the nmners of a turbine fit tightly within the draft case, turbines were easily clogged and runners further damaged by roots, leaves, sticks, and other trash which entered the penstock. The pitting problem and damage caused by debris entering the wheel made the replacement of entire runners a too frequent occurrence and made operating costs for turbine installations high. In addition,vortices created by the flow of water at high velocity through the turbine runners and down their draft tubes early caused major problems with vibrations. The impulse wheel was largely immune to these problems. Its simple rugged construction and free discharge operation made it much less susceptible to damage from dirt, grit, roots, and leaves.

It had as good or better efficiency than the early high head Francis turbines, especially at part gate. And repairs were much simpler and cheaper usually involving the re- placement of a single bucket instead of an entire runner. Moreover, impulse wheels had evolved specifically to meet high head conditions and were thus the dominant tradition in California. Francis turbines were only slowly adapted to California and the high head conditions found there. Some of the early experiments with them were failures. For instance, in a kW generator was installed at the Bishop Creek No. 5 plant powered by a turbine operating under a head of 407 feet. The runner quickly wore out. Thus, as late as Francis turbines were regarded as an unknown quantity in California for heads of greater than 400 feet.

The first successful medium head Francis turbine installation in California came only in at the Centerville plant of the Pacific Gas and Electric Company. Thus, when Inskip was on the drawing board in late and early Francis turbines had yet to prove themselves under medium heads and were generally regarded as fit only for much lower heads. As late as one writer warned that the lower efficiency and greater complexity of the dual nozzle/triple rotor arrangement was a lesser evil in some cases than a Francis turbine which required frequent runner replacement. [ 89 ] The electrical plant at Inskipjnresented no really unusual features and was basically similar to that at South.

There were two sets of generator bus bars and four sets of remote control generator oil switches (located in a fire proof compartment in a corner of the generator room). The generator switches were operated from the switchboard and were arranged so that either of the Inskip generators could be thrown on either bus. There were two banks of three single phase, oil insulated, water cooled transformers. These were in bays placed on either side of a passageway H^i^Y- which linked the front entrance of Insklp to the iterator *Moai. The General Electric kW transformers stepped up the voltage from the of the generators to Linking the secondaries of the gener- ators to the outgoing transmission lines were two Kelman high voltage oil circuit breakers.

These were located in a gallery above the transformer cells. From the Kelman switches the lines passed through disconnecting switches and through a window to a switchyard with pole top disconnecting switches outside* When Inskifs went on line in Northern California possessed four hydroelectric plantj three on Battle Creek (Volta, South, Inskip) plus Kilarc on Old Cow Creek. The company's generating capacity had doubled In less than two yearrs from kVA to kVA. Carrying power from these plants was a. system of transmission lines 480 miles long and serving an area roughly 95 miles long from north to south and 40 miles wide (see the tables on the following pages). The load on this network was regulated at the Volta switch house, supplemented by the central switching station at Palo Cedro.

Transmission loops or parallel lines insured that most of the major substations were reached by at least two transmission lines, a factor which made the system "extremely flexible". The transmission lines were generally well constructed, and the substations, while leaving something to be desired in the way of refinements and first class high voltage switching gear?were at least adequate.

Making the system even acre efficient was its "remarkably high" load factor, something noted by just above everyone who closely investigated the Northern California system In the last half of the system's load factor had varied from a low of to a high of Most utilities had load factors no higher than 30 to 60% (see table BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 90) Kilarc Power House Mammoth Keimett M?ne Balaklala Mine Washington Mine Palo Cedro Sw. Station Horsetow South Power House Cottonwood]! Red Bluff-SE- Tehama) ProbertaX Central Corning;; inal * Volts Volts Orland^ Germantown^[ i Hamilton ?C Chico Xwillows Table 13.

The High Voltage Transmission Lines and Substation of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, as of January 10, (Not drawn to scale) [Source: White & Co., "Report," facing p. 17] BATTLE CEStf HAER CA-2 (page 92) Table Load Factors of Various Eastern sasd Western Utility Companies in the Harly Twentieth Century Company Load Factor Eastern: Niagara Falls Power Company Commonwealth Edison, Chicago New York Edison Philadelphia Electric Boston Edison Western: Pacific Gas and Electric Great Western Power Sierra & San Francisco Power Pacific Light & Power Los Angeles Gas & Electric

Northern California Power Company

Source: Downing, "Report of Sub-Committee on Water Power Development on the Pacific Coast, National Electric Light Association, Convention Proceedings, [v. 3] for all companies except Northern California Power Company. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, plate XX, following p. for BATTLE CREEK BLAERCA.-2 (page 9 3) NOTES [I] ftr Increased mine production see Report pp. or Report p. on copper prices see Bureau of the Census, Historical Statistics, p. for increased revenues see 5th Annual Report [Gross income rose 17% from to [2] 5th Annual Report Redding Courier Free Press. March 14, JE, v. 18 (April 13, p. Scrapbook," p.

3 (.'Northern California Power Company, March 25, (3] For instance, the Redding Courier Free Press seconded Mining World's assertion: "The outlook for is better and brighter than for many many years." (Redding Courier Free Press, January 30, [4] San Francisco Chronicle, September 6, [5] For instance, Redding Courier Free Press. March 7, For local reports on the progress of work at Heroult see: Redding Courier Free Press, June 26, July 3, July 13, July 16, and August 16, [6] 5th Annual Report [7] Redding Courier Free Press. July 11, Redding Searchlight. January 27, Alfred Stansfield, The Electric Furnace for Iron and Steel (New York, pp. [8] Redding Courier Free Press, August 15, [9] 6th Annual Report 6th Annual Report JE, v. 19 (September 28, p.

Tedford to Johnson, November 4, in Jeffcoat Letter Book, pp. [II] 6th Annual Report 1st Annual Report Red Bluff Daily News. October 11, JE, v. 19 (August 28, p. (November 9, p. 415;(November 26, p. and Scrapbook," p. 28 ("Northern California Power Plants" and p. 31 ("Many Power Sites Are Filed 1st Annual Report apparently initially planned to construct only one powerhouse on South Battle Creek. It was to be located just south of Inskip Butte and 1 mile above the crossing of the Manton to Red Bluff Road (Red Bluff Dally News, October 11, But extensive purchases of Battle Creek properties and water rights allowed the company to redesign the system to include two South Battle Creek powerhouses 1st Annual Report 6th Annual Report Redding Courier Free Press.

October 31, Red Bluff Daily News October 31, BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 94) Transcripts [of Hearings]. cases v. 3 (February 2, p. 120 [testimony of Edward Whaley, Company Secretary] (CSA); "Articles of Incorporation of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," August 24, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document "Preamble and Resolutions of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," September 12, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document Red Bluff Daily News, October 17, "Creation of Bonded Indebtedness of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," November 18, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document For the second expansion of Volta the basic sources are: Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. passum; Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp.

passum; White & Co., "Report," pp. and scattered remarks in the Valuation Survey Field Books relating to Volta. Redding Courier. Free Press. December 17, JE, v. 21 (December 19, p. H.A. Tedford to Edward Whaley, July 12, in Jeffcoat Letter Book, p. 20. White & Co., "Report," p. 35; Computation Folder no. 36, supporting Valuation Folder no. 5 ("Al Smith Ditch"). 5th Annual Report For a discussion of the various irrigation ditches, some partly owned by in the Battle Creek area see: White & Co., "Report," pp. and Redding Courier Free Press, February 26, For data on Volta unit #5 see: White & Co., "Report," pp. 42, Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. passum; Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp. passum; PG&E drawing and Valuation Survey Field Book 4 esp.

pages 66, Tedford to Johnson, November 4, in Jeffcoat Letter Book, pp. For example, Tedford to Noble, October 20, notes some of the work Strutt was doring with Tedford on stream flow measurements (Jeffcoat Letter Book, p. Red Bluff Daily News. August 14, October 28, and November 15, JE, v. 21 (November 28, p. Red Bluff Daily News, August 14, JE, v. 21 (December 19, p. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 95) Tedford to Whaley, March 25, in Jeff coat Letter Book, p. 55; Van Norden, "The Coleman Plant," JE, v. 27 p. for descriptions of canal construction. [28 Red Bluff News. August 14, Red Bluff Daily Peoples1 Cause, April 2, [29 Red Bluff Daily News, August 14, [30 Tedford to Whaley, April 13, in Jeffcoat Letter Book, p. 66.

[31 Red Bluff Hews, August 14 and August 15, [32 Red Bluff Daily News, November 15, and August 14, Red Bluff Weekly Peoples1 Cause. March 20, Redding Courier Free Press. December 17, [33 For the transportation of supplies to the plants see: Red Bluff Weekly Peoples' Cause. March 20, March 27, April 3, and April 26, Redding Courier Free Press, July 9, Jeffcoat Letter Book, p. 114 (entry: "Repair List for Best Engine #250,"March 8, [34 Computed from requisitions in the Jeffcoat Letter Eook. pp. 34, 39, 52, 53, 66, 71, 79, 80, 82, 97, 102 (Tedford to Whaley). [35 Red Bluff Daily News. August 11, Redding Courier Free Press, August 19, [36 Valuation Survey Field Book 1 p. 67. [37 Red Bluff Daily News, October 23, [38 Ibid. [39 Redding Courier Free Press, August 14, Red Bluff Daily News.

March 29 and August 14, [40 Red Bluff Daily News. October 30, [41 Red Bluff Daily News. October 28, and August 4 and August 5, Redding Courier Free Press. October 28, and August 4, Red Bluff Weekly Peoples* Cause. October 30, [42 Redding Courier Free Press, August 14, [43 Ibid. [44 Scrapbook," p. 51. [45 Basic data on the South powerhouse and its ditch system are provided by: Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp. White & Co., "Report," pp. 57; Valucation Survey Field Books, especially 6 and 5 PG&E drawings BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 96) and on site Inspection. White & Co., "Report," p. 37. Tedford to Johnson, November 4, in Jeffcoat Letter Book, pp. also Tedford to Noble, October 20, ibid., pp.

Tedford to Noble, October 20, in Jeffcoat Letter Book, pp. In addition to the material on the water system found in the items in note see: Valuation Survey Field Books 3 5 , 6 7 14 and Computation Folders 16 through 20 Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Carl J. Rhodin to White & Co., July 6, In Carl J. Rhodin Papers, California Water Resources Library, Berkeley, California. For descriptions of the South forebay and penstock see Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," p. and Valuation Survey Field Book 6 pp. Galloway, "Hydro-Electric Plants in California," p. for example. Galloway stated that he did not know of a single lap-welded pipe which had not been patched and banded and strongly condemned its use. Ibid., p.

362 (comment by H. Homberger). Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp. Valuation Survey Field Book 5 esp. pp. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. Valuation Survey Field Book 6 pp. passum; Van Norden, "Northern California Power CoDpany," p. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Valuation Survey Field Book 6 pp. Crellin and Maryatt to Milford, July 9, (in PG&E, Engineering Central Files, no. 430:"South"). See, for instance, Galloway, "Design of Hydro-Electric Plants," pp. (comment of E. Newman). Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Van Norden "Northern California Power Company," pp. White & Co., "Report," pp. Valuation Survey Field Book 6 pp.

Redding Courier Free Press, August 17, Red Bluff Weekly Peoples1 Cause, August 21, BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 97) jfed_Blu ;. Ncveafcer Red Bluff Daily News, November 7, Red Bluff Weekly Peoples' Cause, December 18, Redding Courier Free Press, December 9 and December 22, Red Bluff Daily News, December 10, December 18, and December 21, Red Bluff Weekly Peoples' Cause, December 18, JE, v. 24 (February 5, p.

Red Bluff Daily News, August 21, Red Bluff Weekly Peoples* Cause, December 18, Red Bluff Daily News, December 30, Red Bluff Daily News, December 5, Red Bluff Daily News, February 27, Red Bluff Daily News, December 21, Redding Courier Free Press, December 22, Red Bluff Daily News, April 7, Redding Courier Free Press, March 22, Red Bluff Daily Peoples1 Cause, March 21, Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," p. For basic data on Inskip see; Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp. White & Co., "Report," pp. 58; Valuation Survey Field Books 7 8 and 17 (E-30). Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," p. Ibid., p. Combination Folder no. 24, supporting Valuation Folder no.

2 For the Inskip canal system see Valuation Survey Field Books 7 and 8 plus Computation Folders no. 22 and 24, supporting Valuation Folder no. 2, plus the items in note above. Red Bluff Daily News, March 24, JE, v. 24 (May 7, p. JE, v. 25 (July 2, p. 19; Valuation Survey Field Book 7 p. 1; Scrapbook," p. 2. For the Inskip forebay and penstock see Fowler and Van Norden [note above, and, in particular Valuation Survey Field Book 8 pp. passum. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 98) For t: i.'vpawtt 'hGufl at Inskip see the items in note above, In particular Valuation Survey Field Book 7 pp. The Inskip generating units are briefly described by Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. and Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," p. See also White & Co., "Report," pp.

Valuation Survey Field Book 17 pp. and PG&E drawings and Jollyman, "Practice in High-Head Hydraulic Plants," p. Galloway, "Design of Hydro-Electric Plants," p. Galloway, "Design of Hydro-Electric Plants," p. Alton Adams, Electrical Transmission of Water Power (New York, p. Heinrich Homberger, "Efficiency Test, Units No. 1 & 2, Inskip Power House, December 1st and with attached letters dating from (PG&E, Engineering Central Files Galloway, "Hydro-Electric Developments on the Pacific Coast," American Society of Civil Engineers, Proceedings, v. 48 p. notes the difficulty of governing the multiple rotor, multiple nozzle units. On the abandonment of the design see Galloway, ibid.. p. and Galloway, "Design of Hydro-Electric Plants," pp. Mead, Water Power Engineering, pp.

Pelton Water Wheel Company, Palton Water Wheel, pp. Galloway, "Hydro-Electric Plants in California," p. "Up to about the reaction turbine was not considered as suitable for heads above 300 feet": Mead, Water Power Engineering, p. "Successful Francis turbines for operating heads exceeding 400 feet were an unknown quantity prior to Arnold Pfau, "High-Head Francis Turbines and Their Operating Records," JE, v. 40 p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of C liforniaT pp. Comment by H. Homberger in Galloway, "Design of Hydro-Electric Plants," p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California ,p. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp. Valuation Survey Field Book 17 pp. White & Co., "Report," pp. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," pp.

BAI7LE CE2EK HAER CA-2 (page 99) Transcripts [of Hearings], application no. 62, v. 1 (June 24, p. White & Co., "Report," p. 21. White & Co., "Report," p. 21- BATTLE CREEK HAM CA-2 (page CHAPTER VI COLEKAN: Completion of the Battle Creek Hydroelectric System With the completion of Inskip, Noble and his associates were faced with the choice of continuing their expansion program by developing the abandoned "Horseshoe Bend" site on lower Battle Creek or awaiting further developments. A number of factors encouraged the Northern California management in to continue the expansion policy they had initiated at Volta in and continued with the construction of South and Inskip in and One encouraging factor was the continued growth of the copper industry.

Copper production skyrocketed between and rising from almost pounds to almost pounds. [1] Northern California's revenues from her copper customers reflected this growth, increasing from in to in [2] The Mammoth Copper Company in was using an average of hp [c. kW] continuously. The same company had hp (c. kW) of motors connected to the Northern California system and was considering the installation of an additional hp (c. 750 [3] Another encouraging factor was the "very friendly" relations between the Northern California Power Company and Pacific Gas and Electric Company. The sale of power from the grid to the PG&E grid initiated in had worked out so well for both companies that in December of they signed a new twenty-five year contract.

This contract committed Northern California to deliver a minimum of hp (c. kW) continuously to the PG&E grid at Chico and permitted Northern California, at its own discretion (but at a lower price), to deliver up to additional horsepower. [4] Revenues from PG&E sales had risen from in to in and had the potential of going higher. [5] Further encouragement for expansion c&ae from Noble's experimental iron smelter at Heroult. Noble's furnace, E ected in and powered by three phase current, had produced a small ai unt of pig iron, but later proved unable to operate successfully ien beefed up to commercial scale. The major problems with the unit wei clogging of the shafts or chutes which fed raw materials into the furn :e and the rapid oxidation of electrodes.

Thus Noble's early proclamation:, of commercial success proved premature. Noble, however, persisted. In Dorsey Lyon of Stanford designed for Noble a single phase experimental electric furnace which used 160 kW and had a different configuration than the earlier furnaces. It produced 1 ton of pig iron per day. In this experimental furnace was enlarged to consume kW of power. Despite some difficulties in 2AI7LE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page securing sufficient electric power to keep this furnace operative through the sucmer of it smelted enough iron to convince Noble, once again, that the process was on the verge of commercial success. Plans were made, in iate to expand production facilities at Heruult-on-the-Pit.

[6] In early the old smelter was shut down and construction began on four new furnaces with a potential power consumption of at least hp (c. [7] Noble informed stockholders of the Northern California Power Company of the planned plant expansion at Heroult in November He noted that his steel company would soon begin consuming "a great deal of power", perhaps as much as hp (c. kW) , [8] more than the entire output of Volta, then the largest of the Northern California hydroelectric plants. If an additional incentive were needed for expansion, it was provided by the summer of For the first time in its history, the demand for power in Northern California's territory was greater than the utility's ability to supply it.

The heavy seasonal demands of irrigation customers and the growing demand for power from copper mines and smelters had forced the company to curtail the power available to the experimental smelter at Eeroult [9] and to repurchase some power from the PG&E system. Through late the demand for power exceeded the company's capacity to deliver it. And even when South and Inskip came on line in the company had little excess generating capacity. Through and on into the Consolidated Company's installed generating capacity was around kVA. The average demand on the system was around to kVA. Since 25% was a logical reserve to have on hand to insure uninterrupted service during peak loading con- ditions, Northern California had'little unnecessary capacity.

With Noble planning on expanding his iron smelters at Heroult, with the copper industry thriving, and with peak summer loading overtaxing the existing system, the erection of yet another plant en Battle Creek seemed to be almost a-riecessity. The decision was apparently finalized in late or early Noble,coordinating his activities at Heroult with his activities on Battle Creek, timed the completion of the new iron furnaces to coincide with the opening of the new hydroelectric plant. In November of Noble informed Northern California stockholders that he had "no hesitancy" in saying that within three months of completion the entire hp Jsf the planned new plant would be sold. Once the decision was made to erect another plant on Battle Creek, there remained the question of where.

The obvious location was the "Horseshoe 3end" area-of lower Battle Creek, the site of the con- frontation with the Pacific Power Company. Plans had originally called for a tall masonry dam across Battle Creek to develop 150 feet of head, which would be further increased by a ditch system leading water diverted by the dam to a powerhouse-- 6 miles further downstream on the bend itself where W could be developed. Neglect and spring floods had damaged much of the work which had been done at the dam site, but the company had already put into the structure and some of the masonry work was still viable. Moreover, a engineering review of the plans concluded that the dam site itself was "well chosen and satisfactory" BATTLE CREEK ! ' 1 l i r 1 ! (page ! i I i : ) I i i _ ! = ! i i -.

1 i , i i i i 1 ! - , ! 1 LU___ : i ' i j ' " I i ! i i ' i 1 ; 1 : i : ', i J : ! i i ft i i j i 1 i j j i i j 1 ! 1 i 1 i | i 1 1 : | ) i ! i 1 r j i i 1 1 1 | ; I i 1 i j- r C * i. T C i tl I c9 MJ <b h* J^ u> 3 C - 1 wi " 1 ^ : a5 C& <3 O i <D o c> O c& e c) ; o j c> i o j o i s 1 * r-\ f O f-1 i c> f- I o rPI - 3 i i1 i ! j j ! t o j i Sr 1 1 i | 1 r ' i i 1 ( 1 3 ! 1 1 I 1 ft i i i t i i | I i i jo i / ! | | j i ! i i 1 O / / P) <> c ! ih* i i / / ; i i f ! i i | ! { ; i i 3 I C ! i * ! [ 1 ft \ 5? i j ;* rr 1 * i i i t 1 ; i j 1 ! / ! o / iH* : i I 1/ s y i | ; j i \a rr fc 9 OS ' en ; i r f > ^ i i i i 1 i- O n 3 "fl :W ' S 9 3 -2 1 i :U 3 n / ; i ! 11 05 fl ; i \ ;0 i ! i i i i i ^ Hi 0 i i i i i ^v 1 v x. 1 i i i i i | i 7 ! TJ1 i 1 ! i i \I \ i i l - - ta i !M 1 t i / \ i i !

Hi m O a*;0 ?! m i i j i ! i i ! i f n i i i ! Oj 00 i j i i^-* . i | ca \i\ ' rt 0MO i i i ft : rr ! i i i i i %l 3 I* N> H O i j j ; i i 1 i i .V O T3 5 ft M - i !\ ! ;' x' ? j i "-* !ro <U 3 ft 1 (0 J ; 1 i ' o I H i / ft 3! II-* o 0 ;0 < I ft i i c^ | ! N i !^ N i i i ft 8- ! ;M H O r (3 HI <b t \ \\ X | j ft *1 - , 1 1 i PS <-3 W i 1 1 O i : i i M o-3 i \ ft *0 = \ n O * ft o i ft pi 3 i } ft M 1 i t rf ft 1 'N \ H O 1 ft ; i j i BATTLE KAEK. CA-2 (page The same engineering study, however, had urged the Consolidated Company to consider other options, especially since it would require at least an additional to repair, and complete the dam.

One such option involved abandoning the massive masonry dam and obtaining the 150 feet of head it had provided by extending a canal an appropriate distance upstream. In this option had not been feasible because the lands and water rights required were not in company hands. But this sit- uation had changed by In February of the Northern California Power Company had reached an out-of-court settlement with the Asbury Estate, the largest and most desired property on lower Battle Creek. Under the settlement the utility purchased acres of Battle Creek property, in- cluding all the land needed for a right-of-way for conveying water from Inskip powerhouse. The purchase also permitted the utility to divert additional water from two tributaries of Battle Creek, Darrah and Baldwin Creeks.

After reviewing the options Northern California engineers decided to abandon the Battle Creek dam. The 150 foot head ifwas to create was secured by extending the intake for the power canal of the new plant all the way upstream to Inskip. The company also decided to move the location of the powerhouse 1 mile downstream from the original "Horseshoe Bend" site, gaining an additional 110 feet of fall. The new locations of the powerhouse and intake, along with additional water rights secured by the company since permitted to design the new hydroelectric plant for a generating capacity of kVA, instead of the kVA hp) of the plans. The new plant was named "CoTeman", after Edward C.

Coleman, former proprietor of the Sierra Lumber Company and one of the directors of the Northern California Power Company. Perhaps because Coleman was to have more than twice the capacity of any previous Northern California hydroelectric plant, the company turned to outside consultants to design much of the new plant, instead of relying on its own engineers. Strtitt, the former Pacific Power Company engineer who had assisted H.A. Tedford in the design of the water systems for South and Inskip, was retained to work on the water system for Coleman. But Tedford, who had supervised the construction.of both South and Inskip, was given little role in the design or construction of the new plant.

He was assigned, instead, to supervising the operation of the existing plants of the Northern California system. The design of the Coleman powerhouse and the selection of its equipment was entrusted to the San Francisco con- sulting engineer Rudolph W. Jan Norden. Van Borden was a prominent west coast engineer. M graduate of Stanford, he had joined the Central California Electric Company, a Sacramento based firm, and had risen to the position of chief engineer by the early When PG&E acquired the Central Company in Van Norden became a division superintendent. He remained with PG&E for only a year, moving to San Francisco in to set up private practice as a consulting engineer.

The design of Coleman was a minor benchmark in his long and distinguished career* In the he served as technical adviser to the U.S. Secretary BATTLE CREEK EASE CA-2 (page of the Interior on the construction of Boulder (Hoover) Dam, Altogether in his lifetime Van Norden designed thirty hydroelectric plants and fifty high COLEMAN: Construction Construction work began on Coleman in July just as Xnskip went on line. The success of the steam shovels in excavation along the last portion of the Inskip ditch encouraged Northern California to expand its mechanical plant in order to speed up construction of Coleman and reduce labor costs.

Thus a second steam traction engine and a second steam shovel were added in the summer of Two additional steam shovels were added in Two derricks powered by compressed air, and six electric derricks were used to remove rubble from the ditches after the steam shovels had passed. In addition, Northern California made extensive use of compressed air and electric drills. [see HAJSR photo 155 for construction work on the Coleman Canal] The steam shovels used by Northern California in the construction of the Inskip and Coleman ditch systems were not actually powered by steam. Compressed air fed into the steam shovel's boiler system was used instead. Because current used to power the compressors was surplus electricity, the compressed air cost the company "practically nothing".

Coal to produce steam, on the other hand, would have had to be imported at considerable expense. To provide compressed air for the steam shovels, for the compressed air derricks, and for the compressed air drills, Northern California erected four compressor plants along the ditch line from Inskip to Coleman. To provde electric power to these plants as well as to the electric drills and derricks used in excavation a power line was run from Inskip to Coleman early during construction. Although this line was intended to operate at* only volts during construction, it was designed to carry volts so that Coleman could immediately be tapped into the Northern California system when it was started up.

Northern California was able, to make extensive use of a mechanized plant during Coleman's construction for two reasons. First, there were no long sections on the Inskip-Coleman canal which required labor-intensive flume and tunnel construction. Second, the terrain along the route was gently roiling and relatively accessible. It would have been much more difficult to use steam shovels in the more mountainous terrain further upstream. Mechanization and the much reduced amount of labor-intensive flume and tunnel work in the ditch system of Coleman permitted Northern California to reduce the number of construction camps and the size of its work force. During the construction of Coleman the company employed a maximum of 730 men in four camps.

This force constructed the miles of canal leading from Inskip to Coleman. Inskip had required the construction of of around 7 miles of canal OL smaller capacity than the Coleman Canal, yet had required 370 more men. BATTLE HAER CA-2 (page The transportation of supplies for the Coleman plant was simplified because the new plant was readily accessible from Anderson, a small town on the Southern Pacific Railroad only miles away. This town became as lively as Manton during the construction of South and Inskip. The Redding paper reported that the Coleman labor force had added greatly to Anderson's commerce, filling up not only the merchants1 and barkeepers' cash registers, but also the town's jails.

In spite of the use of a mechanized plant to reduce construction costs and the reduced transportation costs afforded by proximity to Anderson, the construction of Coleman weighed heavily on the Consolidated Coim^any's financial resources. The proceeds form the reorganization and several subsequent bond issues had been, exhausted by the costs of South and Inskip. In order to pay mounting construction costs, Northern California ceased paying dividends on March 31, (it had paid record dividends amounting to in and in The company shortly afterwards began to divert funds from its sinking fund and took out a number of short term loans.

These actions enabled Northern California to complete the powerhouse at Coleman in June and to complete the water network for the plant in November The first water reached the new plant on November 19, and, after tests of the system, Coleman went on line on November 24. Northern California in July in order to pay the short-term loans taken cut to complete Coleman, floated a five year bond issue for COLEMAN: Layout and Design [see HAER drawings, sheets of 20 ] The ditch network which provided water to the Coleman hydroelectric plant was similar in design and construction to the systems of the other plants on the Battle Creek system. It was, however, less complex. A single main canal carried water, diverted just below the Inskip powerhouse, over 10 miles to the plateau overlooking Coleman.

The diversion dam at Inskip was larger than most of the Northern California diversion dams. Erected of rubble masonry 1/8 mile below Inskip, it was 15 feet high by 110 feet long, [see HAER photos Although the dam was well built, it was discovered after completion that its foundations had not been carried to bedrock as supposed. The result was some minor seepage underneath. Also, wooden flashboards were originally used in the center of the structure to hold back the water.

Criticism of this design by an engineering consultant in led to the replacement of the flashboards by solid masonry construction- Because there were no conflicting water rights on the south fork of Battle Creek below the diversion dam, practically all of the available water was diverted by the dam into the Coleman Canal by a masonry retaining wall on the north side of the dam. As this wall turned into the banks of Battle Creek the flow was passed through a set of sluice gates and passed by a set of waste gates. The Coleman Canal roughly paralleled the north side of the south fork of Battle Creek for 2 miles beyond the Inskip diversion dam. This section was largely ditch, [see HAER photos 147 for views of the Coleman Canal] But it included the only tunnel of the entire Coleman water system.

Located a short distance from the diversion dam, this tunnel was 12 feet wide by 9 feet high and was only 367 feet long. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 1 W nJ i-3 o 25 1 (S CO a o1 3 & 1 M> O o 0 (- I a* l S toH- n -h t- ft a 5 to * 1 M- ! 3 M a rt H- 9 E- s 5 * "s H KIA ! liv? | 1 J it 1 0 i o s* *n 3 rt O c Oto, * 0. i x H* O n o **! ft Ml tn 0 3 rt P l-T ro * * raT^ \ i i' o\\ 1- \ V ^v NSA i^y x 1 i 3> A O ^ ft H _j m \\ rt M 0 a* #^\ / *** \v ft C J-* to ^-\ j \\ o> \\ O- B ID (5 n 3 ft ^ s-/ CO o 5 Z \ /I ^ \ 9 "T Sf^ Q* CO O S \c\ x% tt >i O * ID CO PI 3 ^ f -B B- JO 5 rt fT H C 8- o a (8 rt 1^ \ <; *rf ??* * 1 1 1 * ft t a I cr (D &\ ' * ! V 1 '. t- i O- ^2a t. .- i Co f- / ' 3* <J1 ( ft & U) fO 03 W u w fT 1 ^ vsA to O (O pf "t v H* r* 1_* O 00 ^ Q NJ.

/ * <,| S (0 ~\ u Hi \l \ \ w !; W \ \ 09 S ^^ * \ \ O iC""\ ' *5 *\ \ \ \ 1 % \' \ M VN \*i ~i>! o W DO A t T ft a* o 3* o rt n J j\ i'i 3 ^1 '? i ^ i V> i ! to I-* Y 09 s: o \;^ \1 Hi 01 ft o a. Ul fJ CD -j \v J \ i w rr f 0 O* rt m I >-* u ( 1 ' Co i O ft ^ o (5 \i i II IS -S* . // /* 'M* * \ J b i Is - ho \* \ ^V* j'y ^ // _^x \V ^ \^i v 1 t-* r-* \ A v jo i 1 M^* Aw1 cr. H* C M * W F* O- rt a. g t? //^i i //' M/ fl Ut ui P* ft H K 3 O 03 y/ a* n. Ln y-S X OS M ff/ c P> * CT* rt /o a rt **> fl> O- O g W ft> ft 3 Ml O tJ 0) ft MiC ft s* rt f( ft ft (0 (D ST Jji rt ft f* os ^i^B .

1 N-* CD a H ) rt 3 13 3- Jh l9S3.e3 rs 3 j 1 to -^f ~ BATTLS CZEXZ EAER CA-2 (page The Coleinan Canal reached the north fork of Battle Creek just above its junction with the south'fork, around 2 miles east of Inskip. Tc cross the North Battle Creek valley Northern California engineers used an inverted siphon, a construction not found on any of the company's other water systems, although* as we have seen, it was considered for South . The 76-inch diameter riveted steel pipe used for this siphon was fabricated in sections at the Inskip penstock ship. The foot long siphon was carried across North Battle Creek's valley under a maximum head of 80 feet on rubble masonry piers. A 55 foot long Howe truss carried it across the creek bed itself.

After crossing to the north side of Battle Creek the Coleman Canal was obstructed by the valley of Baldwin Creek, a small tributary of Battle Creek. Thus approximately feet beyond the exit of the first siphon, the Coleman Canal entered a second. This siphon was feet long and operated under a maximum head of 115 feet. The first portion of this siphon was feet long and constructed of reinforced concrete pipe. The second section was feet long and was constructed of riveted steel pipe. The two sections were joined in a 10 foot by 10 foot by 12 foot block of concrete which enclosed an expansion joint. The downstream or steel portion of the second siphon was of more or less conventional con- struction and was 86 inches in diameter.

Steel girders 40 feet long and 24 inches deep carried it across Baldwin Creek [see HAZR photo The upstream or reinforced concrete section was 87 inches in diameter and was rather unconventional. Two considerations seem to have induced Northern California to experi- ment with reinforced concrete pipe at siphon #2. It was probably hoped that concrete pipe would have a longer life than steel pipe, since it was not susceptible to rust. The company may also have hoped that concrete pipe would be cheaper, especially since it could be laid on the ground and did not have to be elevated to avoid ground moisture like steel pipe. The concrete pipe was formed" on the site.

The reinforcement consisted of steel - rods laid longitudinally across the top and bottom of the pipe and a cylindrical layer of wire mesh Cits weight varying with the head) . These were held in place during construction by wooden forms, [see HAEH photos Ehodin, an engineering consultant employed by the White Engineering Company, praised the steel pipe section of the second siphon as "an excellent piece of work". He also considered the concrete pipe to be a rather "remarkable" piece of work.

But he felt the concrete construction was !,experimental,,) that the reinforcement was inadequate, and that the design was "very light" and bordering on hazardous, At the entrance to the second siphon the water in the Coleman Canal was augmented by water from a ditch feet long which included renmanis of the defunct Pacific Power Company's construction activities. It contributed a small volume of water, largely from springs and from Darrah Creek, a tributary of Baldwin Creek. Additional water was added to the Coleman Canal at the outlet of the siphon by a flume from Baldwin Creek. There were plans to use the Baldwin Creek flume to add some North Battle Creek water to the Coleman C nal here. This water was to be diverted by dam from North Battle Creek into a 2 mile long ditch.

This ditch was to BATTLE CREEK KAER CA-2 (page carry the North Battle Creek water to Darrah Greek.* It would then flow with Darrah Creek water into Baldwin Creek where it would be picked up by the Baldwin Creek flume. But the North Battle Creek - Darrah/Baldwin Creek feeder was apparently never constructed. A canal to divert North Battle Creek water into the Coleman Canal was added to the system only in the And this canal, called the Wildcat Canal, was located en the south side of North Battle Creek, rather than the north side, and delivered water to the Coleman Canal before it entered either of the siphons. After passing through the second siphon the Coleman Canal paralleled the main trunk of Battle Creek for the remaining 8 miles to the Coleman forebay.

Due to the addition of water from Darrah and Baldwin Creeks the canal was larger here. Above the first siphon the ditch had been around 11 feet wide by 5*5 feet deep, with a carrying capacity of around 275 second-feet. Below the siphons the ditch was approximately 16 feet wide by 6.5 feet deep and had a capacity of nearly 300 second-feet. From siphon #2 to Coleman there were no tunnels, no flumes, and no siphons, only ditch. And this ditch, as the other ditches in the original''Battle Creek system, was unlined save for a few sections where a dry rubble rip rap was used to buttress weak canal walls. It was, on completion,one of the biggest power ditches In the state.

On the plateau overlooking the Coleman powerhouse the Northern California Power Company erected a forebay reservoir similar to those at Volta. The forebay reservoir was more of a necessity at Coleman because, unlike South and Inskip, there was only a single water supply canal. The reserve capacity of a forebay reservoir would allow repairs to the ditch system to be~carried out. The forebay reservoir at Coleman was formed by erecting an earth and rock fill dam feet long, 69 feet wide at base, 11 feet wide at crest, and 20 feet high. This dam flooded acres and provided a storage capacity of acre-feet, sufficient to operate the power plant for around ten hours.

At the lower end a masonry header directed water-into the penstock entrances, [see EAER photo The grizzlies for screening the water supply were not placed immediately in front of the penstocks like at the other plants, but in the canal where it entered the forebay. The Coleman plant had two penstocks over. feet long, with a vertical fall of 482 feet. These penstocks, like those of South and Inskip, were of lap-riveted steel, fabricated from sheet steel in the company Ts own shops. The pipes were 72 inches in diameter on leaving the forebay and were tapered to 60 inches as they. travelled down the slope,and each was equipped with two "air valves. At Coleman, as at South and Inskip, the penstocks were not buried but ballasted with boulders and anchored in concrete blocks.

However, in order to avoid an abrupt hump in the terrain as they approached the powerhouse, both were led through short tunnels. There were three generating units at Coleman It was therefore necessary to convert the two penstock lines into three before they entered the powerhouse. This was done by installing a "saddle" connection on each of the penstock lines. A 60-inch diameter continuation of each BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page of the penstock lines, tapered to 48 inches just ab-ove the powerhouse^ provided water to two of the units. Two branch lines of 48-inch diameter taken from the "saddles" of the two main lines were combined by a "Y" connection to create a single 48-inch diameter line for the third unit.

Just outside the powerhouse four hydraulicly-cperated gate valves were installed, one for each of the main pipes and one for each of the branches on the "Y" connection. The water supply for the two water-driven exciters used in the Coleman plant was taken off of the two converging branches of the "Y" connection by means of saddles and 12-inch diameter pipe. These two pipelines were united by a "T" connection, carried into the powerhouse and divided again by a "Y" connection, the branches of the "Y" leading to the two exciter wheels. Although this made the exciter piping system a little complex, it also gave the system flexibility, since both exciter wheels could be operated off of either'penstock.

In designing the powerhouse at Coleman, van Nofden set for himself the task of creating "an installation entirely modern in electrical and mechanical equipment and so arranged as to afford the highest operating efficiency, both from the point of operating costs, low depreciation and high grade service at absolutely the minimum cost of installation". In keeping with this philosophy he located the powerhouse 300 feet north of Battle Creek and linked it with that stream by an artificial canal. There were two factors behind this decision. The location selected shortened the length of penstock necessary to reach the powerhouse.

It also permitted Northern California to create a receiving pond with easily maintained levels for draft tubes* The powerhouse was a rectangular steel franestructure erected on a solid block of concrete_ carried to sandstone with large doors on either end for the easy installation and removal of equipment. It was architec- turally very different than the other powerhouses on the Battle Creek system. Smooth cement plaster walls around 2 inches thick and reinforced with "hyrib" steel wire mesh replaced the more than 2 foot thick rubble and mortar walls used at Volta,.South, and Inskip, Coleman had the usual corrugated iron roof, but it was topped by a 5 foot high monitor running around 5/7 the length of the structure.

The monitor not only improved the appearance of the structure, making it less box-like, but insured adequate ventilation during the long hot summers. The Coleman powerhouse was considered by Van Norden to be more architecturally "modern" than the earlier Battle Creek structures, and in the words of a later observer was "an excellent example of modern construction", demon- strating that "architectural grace may be united to high-grade engineering designing at a very small additional expense". Unlike the other powerhouses in the Battle Creek system, built of native stone, Coleman did not blend into the surrounding landscape well. But it was still an attractive structure, [see HAER photos The 116 foot 6 inch long by 59 foot.

6 inch wide powerhouse was divided into two sections* The largest section was the generator room, around 35 feet wide, extending the length of the building. This room contained three BATTLE CEEEX EAER CA-2 (page turbine-generator units placed on a common center line parallel to the main axis of the structure. The two exciter units were located between the second and third main generating units. [see EAER photos for views of the. Coleman interior] There was "a "basement" or tunnel 8 feet high by 12 feet wide which ran the length of the generator room.

This permitted easy access for inspection of the Coleman piping system and contained, in addition to the pipes leading from the penstocks to the turbines and exciters, pipes to supply the transformers with oil, pipes to provide the governors with oil, the compressed air piping system, the transformer and bearing cooling water pipe systems, and by-pass valves for draining water from the lowest point of the penstock and filling the draft tubes with water. The smaller section of the powerhouse was divided into three floors and housed the transformers, high voltage switching gear, and other auxiliary equipment. The first floor contained four transformer bays, two at each end of the powerhouse.

Station auxiliary equipment rheostats to control the current delivered to the generator field coils, the motor driven pumps for the governor system, the air compressor used for pumping transformer oil and driving tools was located in the center between the transformer bays. The area to the rear of the transformer bays was used for storage and as a work shop. Ten feet above the first floor of the non-generating portion of the Coleman powerhouse was a second floor. The switchboard was placed at the center of this floor. A 4 foot balcony extending outward from the switch- board over the turbine-generator floor allowed the plant operator to keep both the switchboard and all of the power generation apparatus in view.

Behind the switchboard,-in the space between the two story tall transformer bays, were an office, a telephone booth linking Coleman to the other Battle Creek plants, a dressing room, and a lavatory. There was also a fire proof door which led to a long* narrow room which contained the high voltage switching apparatus seven sets of General Electric Type 66 kV, oil circuit breakers with associated disconnecting switches. Ten feet above the second floor was a third floor. This floor formed the roof of the transformer bays and was only as wide as those bays.

It contained the generator and transformer remote controlled oil circuit breakers (General Electric Type K4) with associated disconnecting switches, [see HAER photo -From this floor operators could view both the generator room, two stories below on one side, and the high voltage switching gear, one flight down on the opposite side. The three generating units at Coleman differed significantly from those used at the other Battle Creek plants. Francis turbines were used ^instead of impulse wheels.

The Coleman units were horizontal-shaft models, with a single, 34-inch diameter runner- Manufactured by the Allis-Chalmers Company, each was rated for hp at 450 rpm and equipped with a draft tube and pressure relief valve, The Coleman turbines were regulated by Allis-Chalmers governors of the Escher-Wyss type. These controlled the speed of the turbines by opening or closing the wicket gates entirely surrounded the cir- cumference of the turbine runners. Vr A Escher-Wyss governors operated with oil EAEH CA-2 (page III) pressure provided by motor driven pumps, instead of by water pressure as the Lombard governors used at the other Battle Creek stations.

If turbine speed went beyond a certain point a collar on the governor would open a valve, allowing oil under 250 psi pressure to act en a mechanism which would begin closing the wicket gate to reduce turbine speed. The closed oil pressure system had several advantages over the water-activated systems used in the earlier plants. One of the principal advantages was freedom from clogging by debris. The motor-activated system also per- mitted the use of higher operating pressures. This was necessary at Coleman because the force required to open and shut the large wicket gates was much greater than the force required to operate the jet deflectors or needles of an impulse wheel. One of the disadvantages of a motor-operated system was higher cost.

Another was that generator speed problems were often mirrored and even made worse by the ele-ctric motors activating the governors. But this tended to be a critical problem only on small systems, where problems with one unit had major effects. The Northern California system was large enough by the time Coleman came into operation to reduce the, magnitude of this problem* The three generators of the Coleman plant were mounted on the same shaft with a Francis turbine All three were All is-Chalmers manufactured machines rated at kVA at volts and had rotors equipped with centrifugal fan blades for ventilation. The generator rotors were mounted between bearings.

Each Francis turbine runner was placed on an extension of the generator shaft which terminated in a thrust bearing on the far side cf the turbine casing. Excitation for the field coils.of the generators was provided by two exciter sets. Each of these was driven by an overhung 350 hp Al 11s-Chalmers impulse wheel with needle nozzle, direct connected to a 225 kW Allis-Chalmers dc generator. Small oil pressure governors regulated the speed of these units. Coleman was both the first and the only hydroelectric plant of the Battle Creek system to. use Francis turbines. The primary reason behind the .

adoption of Francis turbines here may have been the success of the medium head Francis turbines installed at Centerville, not too far to the south, in The decision may also have been influenced by the adoption of Francis turbines by other plants between and some of which were operating under conditions "very similar to those found at the Coleman site. The decisive factor behind the decision to use the Francis turbine at Coleman, however, was probably the engineer who designed the plant Rudolph W. Van Norden.- Quite early in his career Van Norden had become an advocate of the use of turbines instead of impulse wheels under medium head conditions.

In a discussion of a paper before the Electrical Trans- mission Association in he had urged consideration of turbines, noting, In addition to smaller space requirements, that with turbines it was possible to theoretically determine operating characteristics prior to installation and testing. With impulse wheels, he argued, it was impossible. The different sizes and operating peculiarities of nozzles, buckets, and rotors made it impossible to calculate or determine operating characteristics without on-site experiment.' BATTLE CREEK EAZR CA-2 (page The electrical system installed at Coleman was somewhat more complex than the systems of the earlier Northern California stations and differed in a cumber of particulars.

For Instance, although the Coleman transformers were oil insulated and water "cooled like those at South, Inskip, and Volta, they were three phase rather than single phase. Van Norden's selection of three phase transformers in place of banks of single phase transformers was contrary not only to prior Battle Creek practice, but to California practice generally. Banks of three single phase trans- formers had long been preferred because problems with one transformer would not completely cripple the output of a generator. The load could be shifted to the other two units in the bank. But three phase transformers did have some advantages over single phase banks. A three phase transformer occupied less space than a bank of three single phase transformers. It was also cheaper by a modest amount.

Finally, by equipping a plant with a reserve three phase transformer (as Van Norden did at Coleman) the major disadvantage of the three phase system could be reduced, if not eliminated. The leads from the generators at Coleman were-'carried in 3-iach fiber ducts through the generator floor to the low voltage switching apparatus on the third floor. After passing through a set of remote control oil circuit breakers, an equalizing bus, and another set of oil and discon- necting switches the current was delivered to the transformers. The high voltage current from the transformer secondaries was led through the back walls of the transformer bays to the high voltage switch gallery on the second floor. Here the current was passed through a high voltage oil switch and two disconnecting switches.

From these switches the current was led to another set of equalizing buses . The outgoing transmission lines were tapped off of these busses, led out through another pair of disconnecting switches and a high voltage oil switch, then through 18-inch diameter wall bushings to an adjacent switchyard. From the switchyard lines eventually led to Cottonwood, Hamilton City, and Inskip. See the table on the following page for a simlified diagram of the Coleman electrical system-and a comparison with Volta and Inskip- Every effort was made to insure that the more complex electrical system at Coleman did not confuse the station's operators. The transformer circuit breakers and disconnecting switches were placed directly above their respective transformers.

The transmission line circuit breakers were placed directly below the relevant lines. All disconnecting switches were placed above their oil switches and provided with horizontal rather than vertical swing to prevent accidental disconnection. When Coleman vent on Tine in November of it was one of the larger hydroelectric stations in California with its kVA installed generator capacity. It raised the potential output of the Northern California system from to kVA.

Increasing Storage Capacity

The Northern California expansion program between and in- cluded not only the construction of three powerhouses on Battle Creek, but also a significant increase in the system's storage capacity to maintain output during summer and fall months when natural stream flow declined. EOTXE CHEEK EAER CA-2 (page Table 18.

Simplified Diagram of the Electrical Systems at Volta Inskip and Coleman G: generator T : bank of three single phase transformers T: three phase transformer x: knife switch or disconnecting switch o: low voltage oil circuit breaker 0: high voltage oil circuit breaker VOLTA G x outgoing G x transmission lines G x- equalizing bus INSKIP x outgoing b transmission v lines equalizing bus COLEMAtf G o x* 0 x- -x Q- t :goxng G'" o " '- x- T- .0 x- x 0- t jns mission 1 es G o x- -x- o- -T- 0 x- equalizing equalizing bus bus BATTLE CREEK EAER CA-2 (page Extensive reservoir building, as already noted, could be postponed on Battle Creek because its flow was relatively stable.

But it still flusu- ated, and a study of the Northern California system by the White Company in January had recommended that "every effort" be made to increase storage facilities. The first major storage reservoir on the Battle Creek basin, Macumber, had been constructed in and To further increase storage capabilities two additional major reservoirs were constructed: one at Manzanita Lake in and the other on North Battle Creek between and Manzanita was a natural lake located around 9 miles due east of the Macumber Reservoir on Manzanita. Creek, a tributary of Deer Creek.

In Northern California had purchased 280 acres of land, including the lake and associated water rights from A.W, Smith to avoid litigation over his plans to convey water from Manzanita out of the Battle Creek watershed to the Snow Creak hydroelectric plant. The company also purchased water rights on Manzanita Creek below the lake's outlet from the Keeran Brothers, who had been using the flow to power a sawmill. In Northern California crews erected two dams on the lake. M earth dam 10 feet high at the center, 8 feet wide at the crest, and 500 feet long blocked the outlet of the lake and raised its water level by 5 feet. A second and much smaller dam or dike, only 5.5 feet high, was erected to contain the additional water within the lake.

In the main dam was sheeted with timber on the water face. Water was tapped from the lake about 20 feet below the surface by tunnel. These modifications gave Northern California a water storage capacity at Manzanita estimated at between 500 and 900 acre-feet. [see EAER photo The water from Manzanita was carried to Deer Creek and from there to the Upper Mill Creek Canal. A second major new reservoir, called the North Battle Creek Reservoir, was located 6 miles upstream from Macumber where North Battle Creek passed through the narrow outlet of a gorge. The lands at the site had been purchased by Northern California between and [59 J Original plans for the reservoir, made by Northern California engineer E.W.

Sutcliffe, called for a large combination loose fill, dry rubble, and concrete dam 658 feet long, 75 feet thick at base, and 100 feet high, placed on a foundation of solid bedrock. (See table on following page) This structure would have formed a reservoir covering 600 acres with a storage capacity of -almost" acre-feet. Flow from this reservoir was to be controlled by a conduit shaped like the letter The lower or horizontal portion of the "L" was a conduit extending through the body of the dam. The upper or vertical portion of the "L" was a rectangular timber conduit. The side of the conduit towards the water was to be slotted so that boards could be added or removed as the water level rose or fell or as more or less water was needed downstream.

Construction began on the dam in [see EAER photo and had reached a height of 30 feet by early when the basic design of the structure was condemned by Carl Rhodin of the White Company, who had been called in to review construction plans on several company projects. EAER CA-2 (page NORTH BATTLE CREEK DAM roft NORTHERN CALIFORNIA POW*R CO. OCS14NCD r E. w. luTcum, ieos (JE, v. 25 p.- Table 19. Dam Designed by Sutcliffe for the North Battle Creek Reservoir BATTLE CHEEK EAEB. CA-2 (page Bhodin felt that the dam, if constructed as designed, would be "light and unstable", despite the excellent material and workmanship that had gone into the early stages of its construction, and was "almost sure to fail". .

Ee also feared that insufficient steps had been taken to insure that the damTs foundations rested on bedrock- Bhodin not only objected to the basic configuration of the dam and possible foundation deficiencies, he also objected to the "L" shaped outlet control. He considered it to be of "unique and dangerous design" and "about as insecure and dangerous as can be built". Arguing that the design adopted by the company had "many obnoxious features", Bhodin filed a "vigorous protest". Because the summer of had been rather Northern California was "anxious" to lose no time in finishing the structure. Bhodin was thus asked to suggest modifications to the existing structure which would make it workable.

Bhodin suggested the use of more conventional pipes and gate valves to release water from the reservoir in place of the conduit and the construction of additional overflow facilities. For the dam itself Bhodin suggested that a trench 5 feet-deep be dug in front of the structure's existing foundation. This would insure that the dam was linked to bedrock. Using this trench as a base the dam would have its water face reinforced with a wall or layer of reinforced cyclopean concrete. To provide better resistance against horizontal pressures, Bhodin recommended, in addition, extensive back filling on the downstream side of the dam. Bhodin1 s modifications would have enabled Northern California to raise the structure to the planned 100 feet, but at heavy additional expense.

As we have noted, the utility had begun to run into financial problems in so the funds to make these modifications were not available. Thus the existing structure was slightly modified, following some of Bhodin's suggestions, and raised only to around 45 feet. Bhodin reviewed the modified structure in December and concluded that it would probably be stable, but added that "it is not certain". When construction stopped and the North Battle Creek Dam and Reservoir were placed in operation in Sutcliffe's grand design had been stunted. The dam was only 46 feet high, although wooden flashboards were used at the crest to increase' its height to 56 feet. Sutcliffe had designed the dam to be 100 feet high- It was only 465 feet long, instead of 658 feet.

Moreover, the reservoir covered only 105 acres and had a storage capacity of only acre-feet. The reservoir which the Consolidated Company had origianlly considered was to have had a surface area of almost 600~~acxes and a storage capacity of almost acre-feet. In addition to Manzanita and North Battle Creek, a smaller reservoir was erected in and a short distance above lakes Grace and Nora. This reservoir, called the Baldwin Reservoir, was formed by an earth fill dam feet long, 25 feet high, 7 feet wide at crest and 84 feet wide at base. Feed with water by ditches from Millseat and Eagle Creeks, the reservoir flooded 23 acres s^d stored almost 175 acre-feet of water. Connected to both Lake Grace and Lake Nora, Baldwin served as an equalizing reservoir.

- ' BATTLE CE2EK EAER CA-2 (page Although most of the Consolidated Company's resources were con- centrated between and on improving the Battle Creek hydroelectric system, some thought was also given to increasing the generating capacity, of the Kilarc plant on Old Cow Creek and to erecting a second plant on that stream. These plans involved using the water from Dry Burney Creek, a tributary of the Pit River* Northern California engineers planned to erect an earth fill and concrete core dam 900 feet long by 35 feet high at the narrow outlet of the Tamarack Valley though which Burney Creek flowed. This would create a storage reservoir of acres, 2 miles long, 1.5 miles wide, capable of holding acre~feet.

A foot long tunnel driven through a low lying natural ridge at .the southwest corner of the proposed reservoir would divert the water from the Pit River watershed into Cow Creek above Kilarc. The additional water from Burney would have permitted to increase Kilarc's generating capacity from to kVA and would have enabled the utility to erect a second plant with kVA capacity further downstream. began construction work on the Tamarack-Galley reservoir in But construction was suspended in mid-1910 to concentrate the company's resources on the completion of Inskip and on Coleman and to reduce expenses by obviating the need for duplicate construction equipment. As the Coleman Canal neared completion in the spring of some construction activity in the Tamarack Valley was resumed.

But the company's monetary problems forced a suspension of work at the site in late or early Along with its water storage facilities, Northern California expanded and improved its transmission and distribution systems between and In and 60 kV lines replaced the original 20 to 22 kV lines linking Volt a through Palo Cedro to Kennett.[70] In 60 kV lines were extended south from Hamilton and Willows to College City in Colusa County via Maxwell, Williams, and Arbuckle. And in Northern California began delivering power to Butte City on the eastern side of the Sacramento. The companyTs transmission network which had been only around 250 miles long in had almost doubled by The capacity of many of these lines had been increased. In all of Northern California*s lines were 22 kV.

By around 43% were 60 or 66 kV. The system had forty-sis substations, and Northern California had begun in and to install meters, to replace flat rate charges on lighting. The flurry of construction activity which ended in following the completion of Coleman and the stoppage of work at the North Battle Creek reservoir substantially completed the Battle Creek hydroelectric system. By this point the system included more than fifteen storage and diversion dams, seven reservoirs, and more than 60 miles of artificial water courses. Water collected from the Battle creek watershed and stored at Lake Mansanita, Hacumber, or the North Battle Creek Reservoir was passed successively through the powerhouses at Volta, South, Inskip, and Coleman.

Altogether between Lake Grace, overlooking Volta, and the tailrace at the Coleman plant there was a vertical drop of slightly over feet. The system of dams, ditches, penstocks, and powerhouses developed by the Northern California Power Company utilized around 87% of this fall or feet. It was a superb "system. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page As Noble triumphantly proclaimed in "At Colenian we use the water for the last time. We have taken from it all but its wetness". There was not room for another plant on Battle Creek* Above Volta the flew in the available streams was too scanty and the terrain too rough to make an additional powerhouse economically attractive. Below Coleman there was insufficient fall for hydroelectric development.

In between there was only the Northern California Power Company's Battle Creek hydroelectric system. BATTLE CREEK HASR CA-2 (page Table 20. Installation Record, Northern California Power Company, Installed System Capacity Total Date** Plant in kVA in KVA Novesiber-1901 VOLTA May VOLTA 750 July KILARC* April VOLTA December VOLTA January SOUTH July INS KIP November COLEMAN February SO. COW CREEK* (purchased) SNOW CREEK* (purchased) May SNOW CREEK* (abandoned) *not a plant in the Battle Creek hydroelectric system **date plant went on line; not "date the generator(s) was installed BATTLE CREEK HAZR CA-2 (page NOTES [1] Report pp. [2] 6th Annual Report 1st Annual Report White & Co., "Report," p. 74. [3] White & Co., "Report," pp. ii, 3, 75. [4] Ibid., pp. vi, 3, 76. E53 Ibid., p. 74.

[6] Van Norden, "Electric Iron Smelter at Heroult on the Pitt," JE, v. 29 pp. Stansfield, Electric Furnace, pp. Redding Courier Free Press, March 26, June 4, and December 22, Redding Seai-Weekly Searchlight, March 6, [7] 2nd Annual.Report [8] 1st Annual Report 2nd Annual Report [9] Redding Courier Free Press, July 25, December 10, and December 27, White & Co., "Report," chart facing p. 21; Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, Plate XX (between pp. Redding Courier Frae Press, February 11, Apifl. 17, and Septea&er 5,' 2nd Annual Report 2nd Annual Report White & Co., ."Report," pp. 47, 50, 96. Ibid., pp. Ibid., p. 48.

Redding Courier Free Press, February 16, Reading Searchlight, February 14, Red Bluff Weekly PeopesT Cause, February 20, 1st Annual Report 2nd Annual- Report Redding Courier Free Press, May 25, Red Bluff Daily Peoples' Cause, July 2, San Francisco Esaminer, March 11, (obituary); Sacramento Bee, March 10, Taylor, Eminent Californlans (Palo Alto, California, p. HAER CA-2 (page Red Bluff Dally Peoples' Causa, July 2, Red Bluff Daily Peoples' Cause, June 14 and July 26, Red Bluff Dally News, July 27 aad August 11, JE, v, 24 (June 11, p. The mechanical plant used for constructing Cpieman is described in Van Norden, "The Coleman Plant," JE, v. 27 pp.

see also Redding Courier Free Press June 6, In addition to increasing the mechanical power plant to reduce construction costs, there were also some wage cuts. The Red Bluff Weekly Peoples', Cause reported on July 2, that the wages of the Burleigh drillmen were to be reduced Van Norden, "The Coleman Plant," pp. Van Norden, "The Coleman Plant," pp. Valuation Survey Field Books 15 p* 18, and 25 pp. Van Norden, "The Coleman Plant," p. Redding Courier Free Press May 16 and. September 2, Redding Courier Free Press, May 16 and May 24, Decisions, v. 11 p. 60; Transcripts [of Hearing], application no. 156 (July 24, pp. 5, (CSA) JE, v. 26 (June 10, p. San Francisco Call, November 20, Redding Courier Free Press, November 20, CERC, Decisions, v. 1 (January 1, to December 31, pp.

and Transcripts [of Hearings], cases and v. 3 Dafea on the Coleman plant can be found in the following materials: Van Norden, "The Coleman Plant," JE, v. 27 pp. "The Coleman Hydroelectric Development on Battle Creek, California," Engineering Record, v, 64 pp. Van Norden, "New Hydroelectric Plant of Northern California Power Co.," Electrical World,* v. 59 pp. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. and Valuation Survey Field Books, especially Field Book 9 13 (E-33), and Rhodin to White & Co., July 6, (Rhodin Papers). The siphons are described by Van Norden, "Coleman Plant," p. see also Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. and Valuation Survey Field Books 1 2 and 3 HAER CA-2 (page Rhodin to White &__Co. August 22, Ehodin to A.S. Crane, December 6, (Rhodin Papers).

Rhodin had earlier noted that siphon #1 was of a "fair .class of manufacture", that the mortar work - was "good", but that the associated structures showed "lack of appreciation of important principles" (Rhodin to White & Co., July 6, Some of the faults were later corrected (see the December 6, letter). Ehodin to White & Co., August 22, and December 6, (Rhodin Papers) The North Battle Creek feeder is mentioned in Van Norden, "Coleman Plant," p. and "New Hydroelectric Plant," p. also in "Coleman Hydroelectric Development," p. But it is not mentioned in Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. nor does it appear in PG&E drawing (a map of the canals of the Battle Creek hydroelectric system) or the*Valuation Survey Field Books. Van Norden, "Coleman Plant," pp.

Valuation Survey Field Book 1 Redding Courier Free Press, November 20, San Francisco Call, November 20, Data on the Coleman forebay reservoir was drawn from: Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. "Exhibit L"; and Valuation Survey Field Book 13 pp. also Van Norden, "Coleman Plant," p> and "Coleman Hydroelectric Development," p. For the Coleman penstocks see the items cited in note above, and especially Valuation Survey Field Book pp. in addition to Fowler and Van Norden. Van Norden, "Coleman Plant," p. Ibid., p. Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. For a description "of the layout of the Coleman powerhouse I have relied on; personal inspection; Valuation Survey Field Book 9 esp. pp.

Vsa Norden, "The Coleman Plant," pp. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. and PG&E drawings and The Coleman turbines are briefly described by Van Norden, "Coleman Plant," p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. and Valuation Survey Field Book See also PG&E drawing BATTLE CREEK BAER CA-2 (page For example, the Snow Mountain Water & Power Cdnpany was persuaded in to install a Francis turbine for their third unit. This unit, which went into operation in operated under a head of 464 feet, not much below Colemaa's. See Pfau, "Francis Turbines," p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. See the discussion on the paper by E.G.

De Wald, "High Pressure Water Wheels, With Particular Reference to the Girard sad Francis Turbines," Pacific Coast Electrical Transmission Association, Transactions, v. 8 pp. See also, later in the same volume, pp. where Van Norden notes the high efficiency and the small space requirements of the Francis turbine vis a vis the tangential or impulse wheel. Fcwler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. Downing, "High-Tension Network of a Power System," Pacific Gas & Electric Magazine, v. 2 p. 15. For Coleman's electrical layout and design see: Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. Van Norden, "Coleman Plant,"419- Van Norden, "New Hydroelectric Plant," pp. and Valuation Survey Field Book passum,. White & Co.,, "Report," p.

42, 5th Annual Report ; Redding Courier Free Press, November 25, 2nd Annual Report Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Valuation Survey Field Book 16 (E-35) pp. FolVer, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Valuation Survey Field Book , pp. "Exhibit L". 2nd Annual Report 5th Annual Report Rhodin to White & Co., July 6, and December 6, (Rhodin Papers); these ^letters contain a sketch of Sutcliffe's plans and Rhodin's suggested modifications. Rhodin to A.S. Crane, July 26, Rhodin to White &*Co., July 6, and August 22, (Rhodin Papers) Rhodin to A.S. Crane, July 26, (Rhodin Papers); 2nd Annual Report Rhodin to White &.Co. July 6, and August 22, (Rhodin Papers) BATTLE CREEK EAER.

CA-2 (page Ehodin to White & Co-, December 6, - (Khodin Papers) Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, 3rd Annual Report Valuation Survey Computation Folder no. 47, supporting Valuation Folder no. 5, pp. 10; "Exhibit L". Fovlar, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. 2nd Annual Report Van Norden, "Northern California Power Company," p. Redding Courier Free Press, May 25 and July 1, San Francisco Call, May 11, Red Bluff Daily News, May 27 and June 15, Redding Courier Free Press, July 1, Redding Courier Free Press .May 8, San Francisco Call. May U, 1st Annual Report 3rd Annual Report Van Norden, "New Hydroelectric Plant," p. 237 for figures. The Volta-Chico line was the first Northern California Power Company 66 kV line.

5th Annual Report Redding Courier Free Press, September 2, BATTLE CREEK EAER CA-2 (page CHAPTER VII DECLINE: The Northern California Power Company in Its Lean Years With the completion of the Battle Creek system In and the future of the Northern California Power Company seemed bright. The power- houses at South, Volta, Inskip, and Coleman gave the company more generating capacity and a greater flexibility than it had ever-had before. The cop- per industry, oh which much of its revenues depended, was thriving. Noble seemed on the verge of a breakthrough with the electric smelting of iron ore at Herouli and had promised to purchase all the power the company could deliver.

So favorable did Northern California's prospects appear that it had become by an attractive investment for holding companies attempting to build up conglomerates ia the utilities field. In early the Byllesby Company of Chicago, one of the major holding companies in the utility field, solicited an option to purchase the shares of Northern California Power stock at $80 per share. Byllesby had already merged a number of California electric utilities, including the Stockton Gas and Electric Company, San Diego Gas and Electric Company, and the American River Electric Company, into the Western States Gas and Electric Company.

Western States was aggressively competing with Pacific Gas & Electric in the bay area, and Byllesby apparently felt that the addition of Northern California's generating capacity to Western States would make it an effective rival of PG&E. [1] The high load factor and favorable prospects for expansion of the Northern California system also made its acquisition attractive. Rumors of negotiations between Byllesby and the owners of the Northern California Power Company pushed the market price of Northern California stock up from $50 to $66 per share early in [2] on May 30, E.V.D. Johnson, General Manager of the Northern Calif Taia Power Company, announced the unsuccessful termination of negotiatio .

[3] Byllesby's abrupt withdrawal of the offer to purchase Northern CaL ornia stock seems to have been the direct result of a federal court injunc ion, issued on the previous day, which placed sharp restrictions on the s. siting of copper in Shasta County. This injunction and the subsequent with. .rawal of the Byllesby offer were but the first in a series of blows which was to cripple the Consolidated Company, transforming what had been a strong, aggressive, expanding company into a utility struggling to maintain a precarious existence. BATTLE CREEK EAEK CA-2 (page

The First Blows

The Northern California Power Company's decision to expand its generating capacity through the erection of three new hydroelectric plants and several new storage reservoirs had been based on two assumptions (1) that Shasta County copper mining and smelting would continue to expand, and (2) that Noble's electric iron smelters at Heroult would be as successful as he had predicted. The first assumption to prove false was the copper industry's continued expansion. Copper mining and smelting In the decade and a half following had brought new prosperity to Shasta County. But this prosperity had its shortcomings. It was estimated, for Instance, that the Keswick smelter of the Mountain Copper Company alone belched tons of sulphurous acid gas into the air per day.

Nearby Keswick was described as "a community without lawn mowers". "Not a leaf of foliage nor a spear of grass axe to be found anywhere thereabouts, and the streets are as dusty as the Hangtown crossroads . . ." [4] Since most of the population of Keswick was de- pendent on the copper mines and smelters for employment, these conditions raised no protests here. But the sulphur fumes also damaged vegitation in the surrounding regions [see HAKK. photo and eventually led to a major confrontation between farmers and copper producers. The first intimations of trouble came in even before the Keswick Electric Power Company had laid the foundations for its Battle Creek system at Volta.

A group of Shasta County fruit growers sued Mountain Copper, alleging that sulphur fumes from its smelter had damaged their orchards-and asking for in damages and an injunction against further smelting unless sulphur emissions were controlled. [5] These early efforts failed, but the struggle continued. In September farmers did secure an injunction against Mountain Copper, causing its average power draw from the Northern California system to drop from 806 to 104 hp between'September and January [6] A higher court dissolved the injunction in early and both Mountain Copper and other smelters continued expansion. In the United States government entered the fracas, claiming that emissions from Mountain Copper's Keswick smelter had destroyed a large tract of federal forest reserve. The U.S.

Forest Service secured an injunction prohibiting Mountain Copper from open roasting copper ores. This suit forced Mountain Copper to abandon the open roasting of their ores a Shasta County. The company subsequently dismantled their Keswick smelter and re-established operations at Martinez, California, north of San Francisco Bay and away from federal forest lands. Mountain Copper paid the government damages and surrended a tract of company-owned woodland equivalent in size to that decimated by the sulphur fumes. [7] i The outcome of > the suit against Mountain Copper initially had no direct effect on any of the other Shasta County smelters.

They kept their works in operation through and the record setting year of 1909-and throughout the opening phases of Northern California's expansion program on Battle Creek. While Mountain Copper's fate may have temporarily discouraged the remaining copper producers from expanding their plants, this was offset by other developments. In and farmers and smelter operators, after long negotiations, reached a tentative agreement. The' farmers 1ATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page withdrew suits pending against the smelter operators; the smelter operators agreed to install smoke condensing devices at their works. [8] In most Shasta County shelters briefly closed down to install or experiment with devices to desulphurize' emissions, resuming operations at expanded levels afterwards.

[9] These actions defused the dispute between smelters and farmers for a few months. But the failure- of most of the experimental desulphurizing systems prompted Shasta County fruit growers to return to the courts in late and early to obtain relief. Following the example of Montana farmers who had successfully fought copper smelters, Shasta County growers sought and obtained in May injunctions which pro- hibited the further operation of smelters In the county until operators installed effective smoke condensing and desulphurizing systems. It was this series of injunctions which prompted the withdrawal of Byllesby's offer to purchase Northern California Power. the injunctions against the Shasta County smelters had a deleterious affect on the copper industry.

In June just at the powerhouse at Coleman was completed, Bully Hill and Balaklala , the second and third largest smelters,closed down. Mammoth Copper, which had become the county's largest copper producer after Mountain Copper had abandoned the area, continued smelting since the company had installed a relatively successful smoke condensing "bag house" in But even its pro- duction was reduced and plans for expansion were curtailed. The collapse of smelting operations in Shasta County brought with it a decline in copper mining. Copper output, despite stable copper prices, plummeted almost 50 between and In production was pounds; in it was only pounds.

The sharp reduction in mining and smelting operations naturally had a major effect on Northern California's earnings, since these industries had long been the utility's -primary power market. Noble reported in that largely due Co the collapse of the smelting industry in Shasta County the coicpany's income had been reduced by around a month. Noble optimistically assured stockholders that within a few months the smelters would solve their pollution problems and resume operation at past levels. These assurances were repeated in subsequent stockholders' reports. But copper production in Shasta County declined steadily and did not begin to rise again until 1915,"when demand generated by war conditions in Europe finally pushed it over the pound mark again.

Even then, however, it was far below the record pounds of The collapse of the copper industry left Northern California in trouble. Prior to the closure of the smelters the company had been selling almost all the power it had available from the Volta, South, Inskip, and Kllarc plants. Reduced power consumption left the system with excess generating capacity and Coleman, nearly completed, scheduled to come on line with kVA of additional power. It transformed a moderate excess generating capacity problem into a major one. It is thus not surprising that Byllesby withdrew its offer to purchase the Northern California ?ower Company when the copper industry began to crumble or that the " BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page price of Northern California stock began to drop.

It had been priced at $66 to $80 in May during the Byliesby negotiations. By December of it. was being sold at $55 and by September of had dropped to Shasta1 s copper industry had been one of the legs on which the expansion program had been based. The other leg was Noble's iron smelter at Eeroult, expected to consume up to kW of power when it began regular commercial production o iron. But like Shasta1s copper industry, Heroult proved disappointing. Originally scheduled to begin production when Coleman went on line, the Heroult smelters did not achieve a continuous production lasting as long as two months until the summer of Even then only around kW was consumed in two furnaces. But these furnaces did produce 18 tons of pig iron a day.

Noble was again con- vinced that "all difficulties have been satisfactorily overcome", and Van Norden also declared that electrical iron smelters were "an assured fact, a commercially successful machine". Plans were made for four additional furnaces. But new problems continued" to emerge. In and the charcoal supply system for the smelters failed and Northern California Power was compelled by its financial difficulties to raise power rates at Heroult from around $12 per horsepower per. year to In his annual report to the stockholders of the Northern California Power Company in late Noble acknowledged difficulties but continued to be optimistic about Heroult.

He reported that the substitution of imported coke for charcoal would soon permit renewed operations and that the Noble Electric Steel Company "would "very "materially add to the profits of our company [the Northern California Power Company]." But Heroult never provided the load Northern California Power had expected of it. Electrical smelting of iron ore, even with cheap hydroelectricity, could not compete with the coke-fired blast furnace. Moreover, at the Heroult site only iron ore was cheap (especially after was compelled to raise the price - of power to make a profit). Everything else was expensive since most materials had to be hauled in by rail.

After Heroult ceased to warrant mention in Northern California annual reports as a significant power customer or a major potential power customer. In Noble abandoned attempts to produce pig iron. The Noble Electric Steel Company continued marginal operations producing ferrc alloys. After another abortive attempt at smelting pig iron in smelter operations were terminated in Harch By then most of the company's revenues were being generated by mining and shipping iron ore for processing to other California smelters.

When the company folded in it owed Noble and the Northern California Power Company The collapse of anticipated markets for power at Eeroult and in the Shasta copper belt were major blows to the stability of Northern California Power, especially since the company had borrowed heavily to finish Coleman and was left with considerable excess generating capacity. A bad situation was made even worse when.the utility was challenged for the remaining power market, a market scarcely sufficient to-support a single power company, by another utility in late and early BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page IKE RATE WAR Northern California Bower Company had been intermittently threatened with competition during the first decade of its existence.

The most serious crisis, that created by the formation of the Pacific Power Company, had been staved off by rushing construction of the eventually abandoned Battle Creek dam in But contemporary with this crisis, two other power companies had emerged: Shannon's Shasta Power Company and A.W. Smith's Northern Light and Power Company. Both of these utilities were small. The combined generating capacity of Shasta's plant on Snow Creek (on line June and Northern's on Cow Creek (on line May was only kVA. With limited capital these companies had succeeded in extending their lines only to Redding. They had competed with Northern California for the lighting market there with only limited success.

In an attempt to make the companies competitive and keep them financially solvent, Shasta Power and Northern Light and Power merged in March forming the Sacramento Valley Power Company, capitalized at The new company ran its lines south from Redding to Red Bluff and Chico in an attempt to increase revenues. Even these line extensions were not initially regarded as particularly threatening by Northern California. Sacramento Valley Power was hampered by lawsuits from farmers protesting the company's diversion of Lost and Hat Creek water from the Pit River watershed to the watershed of Snow Creek and inadequate capital.

An analysis of the threat posed by Sacramento Valley Power to Northern California Power made in by the White Company concluded that "the danger of serious competition in their territory is remote" and added:- ... as long as the company [Sacramento Valley Power] is under present management and until they increase capacity seriously, the competition will not materially effect the revenue of Northern California Power Company. Sacramento Valley Power could , however, harass Northern California. This it did. In a group of Shingletown area farmers, including a number of Sacramento Valley Power Company stockholders (A.W. Smith, President; his son; and stockholders E.J.

Smith and Benton) charged that Northern California was diverting through the Keswick ditch water that legally belonged to the Al Smith ditch and five other irrigation ditches further downstream,and E.J. Smith attempted to tear out the Keswick diversion dam. An injunction issued in September prohibited Smith and others from molesting the Keswick"dam and prohibited Northern California from diverting more than the 722 inches (18 second-feet) of water that were beyond dispute. The water rights controversy which ensued was characterized as "practically a dispute between the pioneer power company and Sacramento Valley Power". E.J. Smith was twice arrested for damaging the Keswick diversion dam, while E.A. Tedford, superintendent of the Northern California plants, was charged with stealing water.

Charges against both Smith and Tedford were subsequently dismissed. The acrimonious water rights trial which followed lasted twenty weeks and BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page involved over pages of testimony . Feelings were so strong that at one point opposing attorneys exchanged blows in the court room. The issues were extremely complicated, involving conflicting and over- lapping claims of water priority, amounts actually being diverted, and ditch capacity. An additional issue was whether or not the owner of a water right could divert water needed further downstream out of the watershed. At the end of the hearings in mid-1910 the presiding judge dictated a reallocation of water only mildly detrimental to Northern California.

The volume allotted to the Kesvick ditch was reduced from the to inches (46 to 50 second-feet) claimed by Northern California to inches (36 second-feet). The diversion rights of the Smith or Battle Creek Ditch Company ditch, claimed to be inches (60 second- feet) hy Smith,were set at inches (56 second-feet): Inches (41 second-feet) permanently, 690 inches (17 seccnd-feet) subject to sufficient flow. The decision, as a Redding paper commented, was "a victory . . . for neither" and both sides", equally displeased, filed for a retrial The Sacramento Valley Power Company was able only to snipe at Northern California's dominant position in the upper Sacramento Valley until But then matters changed.

The decline of the mine and smelter market made Northern California more dependent on the residential and commercial light and power load of the area's urban centers. In addition, an infusion of capital made Sacramento Valley n re competitive in this area. In late-1910 the Fleishhacker brothers of San Francisco purchased a 50% interest "in the Sacramento Valley Power Company and reorganized it as The Sacramento Valley Power Company. The Fleishhackers were experienced in the hydroelectric utility field.

They had either built or operated and then sold a number of early Cali- fornia utility companies, including the Truckee River power plant, the American River plant at "Polsom, the Stockton steam generating plant , the Central Traction Company, and the San Francisco Electric Lighting Company, To secure capital for their new enterprise the Fleishhackers mortgaged Sacramento Valley Power's assets in exchange for a line of credit. . With new capital~and new management, Sacramento Valley Power's latent threat to Northern California suddenly became a real threat. The first transfusion of cash into the utility provided Sacramento Valley Power with the funds to extend lines north of Redding and invade the copper mining territory around Kennett.

Poles were placed and, under cover of night, wires were strung across Northern California's trans- emission lines. There was little Northern California could do to stop this invasion. What could be done was done. Where Sacramento Valley power lines crossed Northern California's lines and right-of-way, Johnson, Northern California's General Manager, ordered the lines severed and obtained a restraining order prohibiting the reconnection of the. lines,, Sacramento Valley Power defiantly reconnected the lines the following night and posted guards with rifles and shotguns to protect the crossings. Sacramento Valley officials also filed for Johnson's arrest for the destruction of property.

HAER CA-2 (page Under prodding from the courts the two utilities reluctantly negotiated an arrangement for crossing lines in September of Conditions were aggravated, however, when the Sacramento Valley Company In November of extended its lines from Redding to Chico and then through Orland to Willows, initiating a rate cutting policy in these areas designed to lure customers away from Northern California. Having struggled for years to develop a market for electrical power in these agricultural communities, Northern California responded with rate cuts of its own. The competition between Northern California Power and Sacramento Power in late and early was ruinous.

Both companies had con- siderable excess generating capacity and were competing in a sparsely populated area with scarcely sufficient business to justify the existence of a single power company. Rates were cut drastically by both sides. Customers were permitted to make their own terms and in some cases rates were offered which were well below the actual cost at- rendering service. Some power was even distributed free. Northern California supplied Kennett (population and an undisclosed number of private customers without charge because the revenue did not warrent the employment of meter readers or collectors.

The California Railroad Commission in reviewing the rate war later concluded that for "aggressiveness and utter recklessness" it had "probably never been paralleled in the history of the state". The Sacramento Valley Power Company with its kVA generating capacity had little real hope of driving the larger, more firmly established, older utility from the field. The company's objective was apparently to use "well directed and ruthless competition" to force Northern California to "choose between financial loss or even financial ruin and the purchase of the property of the newcomer at a price far above its normal value". The tactic was successful.

Noble estimated that the rate war had decreased Northern California's gross earnings around per month between October of and January of Feeling that continued competition would result in increased revenue losses and already struggling with declining revenues from the copper industry, Northern California negotiated the purchase of Sacramento Valley in February The purchase price was considered by experts to be "greatly in excess of its real value". The California Railroad Commission argued later that the Sacramento Valley properties were worth around Northern California paid To finance this purchase Northern Cali- fornia issued of 6% interest Series A debentures, slated to mature in and assumed Sacramento Valley's in bonded indebtedness.

This purchase put burdens on finances that the company could ill afford. Between and sinking fund payments and the interest payments on bonds absorbed over 60X of Northern California's gross income. (see Table 23 on page BATTLE CESEK HAZE. CA-2 (page Northern California officials had urgent and -immediate reasons for terminating the rate war with Sacramento Valley, and these probably explain the somewhat inflated purchase price they paid. In order to ccqplete Coleman, Northern California had Been forced to take out short term loans amounting to around Declining revenues and cash flow problems, plus pressure from creditors, made it imperative for Northern California to consolidate this debt through the sale of bonds.

The war with Sacramento Valley, however, had a "disastrous effect on the company's credit", making it very difficult for Northern California to secure additional short term loans and impossible to sell securities to consolidate the company's indebtedness and extend payments over a longer period. The purchase of Sacramento Valley Power eliminated the difficulties. Within five months (by July Northern California had sold in five year Series B debentures, substantially reducing its immediate financial problems. There were other assets which Northern California secured with the absorption of Sacramento Valley which, undoubtedly also had an influence on its decision to buy. Sacramento Valley had water rights on North Battle Creek, amounting to inches (42 second-feet) of flow.

This could be used at the company's four Battle Creek plants and was, according to Noble, trying to justify the purchase to stockholders, "absolutely necessary to the operation of installed apparatus". Without this water, Noble claimed, the company would have had to construct a "vast and expensive storage reservoir". An additional bonus was that the Lost and Hat Creek water being diverted to"the Sacramento Valley's Snow Creek plant could be diverted into North Battle Creek instead. Because there were four plants on Battle Creek this water could be used under a total head of feet, versus only around 900 feet at the Snow Creek plant. Northern California immediately took advantage of this .

The ditch system which diverted water from Lest and Hat Creeks in the Pit River watershed" and carried it across the Battle Creek watershed to Snow Creek was modified to deposit its flow into Bridge Creek, a tributary of Battle Creek above the Macumber Reservoir,and in May the Snow Creek powerhouse was abandoned. This benefit, however, proved to be short lived. In the..courts ruled on the long-contested suit first filed by Hat and Lost Creek farmers against the Shasta Power Company around and now inherited by Northern California. Northern California was allowed to divert water from Lost and Hat Creeks only between September 15 and May 1, the non-irrigation season. Then in late and Mt.

Lassen, long a dormant volcano, erupted- The lava and mud flows which ensued completely destroyed much of the Hat and Lost Creek diversions, the only water power development in the Waited States ever damaged by an active volcano. THE RATS WAR AFTERMATH Elimination of competition had proven expensive to the Northern California Power Company. But the bad luck and misplaced hopes that had plagued the company in and early continued. On the conclusion of negotiations for the purchase of The Sacramento Valley Power Company, Northern California announced that it would reinstall meters throughout BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page its territories and restore rates where possible to. pre-war levels. Utilities had long raised rates at their own discretion and Northern.

Califor- nia, anxious to make up for the losses it had taken during the rate war, expected to do so again. But in the California legislature had passed the Public Utilities Act, investing rate fixing authority in the California Railroad Commission. This act took effect on March 23, Thus when the Consolidated Company unilaterally raised power rates, it was ordered by the Railroad Commission to rescend the increases until a thorough inves- tigation established a formal rate structure based on a fixed return on invested capital. Thus Northern California was compelled to formally request the Railroad Commission to establish a uniform rate structure. Hearings were held in June When the Railroad Commission investigated Northern California, the utility encountered other problems.

The Commission, seeking to establish rates based on a percentage of the utility's real value, found that there was no reliable inventory of Northern California's properties to permit determination of worth (many company records had been destroyed during the San Francisco fire and earthquake of Moreover, the Commission complained that it was impossible to determine the real income and real value of the company, since proper funds had not b&en set aside for depreciation. And, in addition, the companies absorbed by Northern California (Northern Light and Power and Shasta Power through the purchase of The Sacramento Valley Power Company) had kept poor records.

An estimate by the secretary of the Northern California Power Company that the utility's properties were worth more than was apparently received with some scepticism. Because Northern California's rate system was in a "chaotic" con- dition and the entire company was "demoralized" as a result of the rate war, the Railroad Commission decided to act quickly on the company's request for a uniform ^rate structure even without reliable information on its worth. On December 30, the Commission set down a uniform rate system for the Northern California system.

The utility was compelled to reduce its rates to customers by amounts varying from 5 to The remainder of the utility's customers paid a higher rate than before the rate war, but a lower rate than that unilaterally imposed by the com- pany immediately afterwards. In addition, Northern California was ordered to make some refunds. Northern California agreed to give the new rates a fair trial. In July of Northern California applied to the Railroad Commission for permission to issue in five year bonds. The money from this issue was, as noted, to be used to pay off very urgent short term debts incurred in the completion of Coleman and to consolidate the company's growing indebtedness.

The Railroad Commission again complained of the difficulty of obtaining adequate information on the value of Northern California's properties and earnings, but authorized the bonds. But as a condition of the order the Railroad Commission assumed the right to require the Northern California Power Company to levy assessments against its stockholders. In justifying its position on this issue'the Commission argued: . _ _ jJAU.'l'J-_ _* HAER CA-2 (page The proper parties to bear losses of utilities as well as of any other corporations; are the stockholders.

To be sure, there is a stockholders' liability which legally holds the stockholders to account', but too often in the case of utilities at least, bad financial conditions brought about by high financing are cured by exploiting the public through high rates, or by more high financing, and through reorganizing and un- loading upon new stockholders and new bondholders securities that have nothing behind them except water and the desire of the promoters to reap a profit.

In order to satisfy the complaints of the California Railroad Com- mission and to prepare for future applications to the Railroad Commission, Northern California did undertake a valuation survey in and Another inventory and appraisal was carried out for the company in and by the White Company, In addition, the California Railroad Commission in made a valuation survey of Northern California on its owa when the rates set in were scheduled.to come up for review. Although various company officials in had estimated the value of properties at between and the valuation surveys yielded far lower figures.

In setting rates for the Northern California Power Company in the California Railroad Com- mission valued the companies properties at slightly under Part of this sharp discrepancy was due to the land and water rights purchased by the Northern California Power Company, Most electric utility companies had secured water for their hydroelectric plants by appropriation* Northern California was practically unique in having secured the bulk of its water by purchase. In order to secure these water rights Northern California had been compelled to buy the lands associated with the water, so that by the utility owned around acres.

Northern valued these .properties and associated water rights (and the franchises it had secured) as high as The Railroad Commission, on the other hand, viewed the lands as non-operative properties (and hence not relevant to the capital the company had invested in producing power) and valued the water rights at a very small fraction of Northern California's estimates. While the bond issue in relieved the company's most pressing debts, it was still faced with large interest payments and the need to begin retiring the in bonds used to purchase Sacramento Valley Power and due to mature in Thus Northern California continued the dividend suspension initiated in It also, either, on its own or prodded by the Railroad Commission, began to levy assessments on its.

stock- holders to meet pressing financial demands. There were eight assessments levied between and 1915,totalling per share. To bring in additional capital the stockholders voted in July of to increase capitalization from to by authorizing of 6% non-assessable preferred stock, to be issued immediately. In order to sell this ^.tock the company had to apply to the Railroad Commission. The Commission in October approved the sale of BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page in new stock, but in keeping with the philosophy promulgated in limited the sale to e:sisting~ stockholders. Since most of the company's stockholders were well aware of the company's financial position and had hot received any dividends in years, the issue was never sold.

Unable to bring in new capital, Northern California's financial plight steadily worsened. At the end of only of the bends issued to purchase the Sacramento Valley Power Company had been retired, and the remainder was due on February 1, Faced with a financial emergency, the utility requested, and secured, permission from the Railroad Commission to defer payment on the remaining bonds until after negotiating the delay with the bondholders. Adding to the major problems of Northern California Power were a series of minor disappointments in this era. For instance, in the Oro Electric Company agreed to purchase up to kW of power from the Northern California system. This would have significantly reduced Northern California's huge excess generating-<-capacity.

But, instead, Oro turned to the Pacific Gas & Electric system to supply their power needs, leaving Northern California with no recourse except legal action. To make matters worse, an attempted merger between Oro and Northern California failed n The cumulative result of the smelter closings ,Heroult's failure, the disastrous conditions under which the rate war was ended, and an assortment of minor disappointments was a rapid deterioration of Northern California's position between and For the year ending November 1, the companyTs earnings (surplus + dividends, if any) had been They declined to the following year and then dropped even further to for and for It was out of these meager funds that payments had to be made to the company's sinking fund for bonds and for system improvement.

By slighly over 48% of the-utility's gross revenue was being absorbed by interest charges alone, third highest among California's ten major electrical utilities. These conditions may have been responsible for Detert replacing Noble as president of Northern California Power in When the Railroad Commission reviewed the status of the Consolidated Company in it noted that due to the "vitiating effect" of the rate war it was practically starting all over again in developing its territory and stabilizing its securities. The Commission found that the Northern California system had an installed generating capacity of kW.

The system's peak load was only around kW, so that even with the ^logical 25% reserve, Northern California Power in the middle of the had over kW of generating capacity that was completely idle and unproductive*

The War Years

Northern California Povar did not begin to recover until when the war in Europe began to Sffect the American economy. Copper pro- duction in Shasta County, which had averaged pounds between BATTLE CREEK EAER CA-2 (page Table 22: Earnings of the Northern California Power Company, - Gross Gross SURPLUS* Fiscal Year Revenue Income (including dividends) Dividends > $ $ Mar. 1,1903-Feb. Max. 1,1904-Feb. $ Mar, 1,1905-Feb. Max. 1,1906-Feb. Mar. 1,1907-Feb. Mar. l,190&-Oct. Nov. 1,1908-Oct. Nov. 1,1909-Oct. Nov. Nov. "1,1911-Oct. Nov. 1,1912-Dec. Jan. 1,1913-Dec Jan. 1,1914-Dec Jan. 1,1915-Dec. Jan, 1,1916-Dec Jan. 1,1917-Dec. Jan. 1,1918-Dec, Jan. 1,1919-Sept.30,1919 (Fowler.. Hydroelectric Systems of Califomia. PP.

71) *SBBPLUS: Funds remaining from Income after interest payments, uncollectable bills, and a number of other "small items are subtracted; from these funds payments have to be made to the sinking fund to retire bonded indebtedness; pay maturing obligations; and made additions and betterments. HAER CA-2 (page Table 23. Interest Payments of the Northern California Power Company* Interest % of income Fiscal Year Gross Income on funded debt to interest March 1, 1902-February 28, March 1, 1903-February 29, March 1, 1904-February 28, March 1, 1905-Februaxy 28, March 1, 1906-February 28, March 1, 1907-February 29, March 1, 1908-October 31, Nov. 1, 1908-October 31, Nov. 1, 1909-October 31, Nov. 1, 1910~0ctober 31, Nov. 1, 1911-October 31, Nov. 1, 1912-December 31, Jan. 1, 1913-December 31, Jan.

1, 1914-December 31, Jan. 1, 1915-December 31, Jan. 1, 1916-December 31, Jan. 1, 1917-December 31, Jan. 1, 1918-Decmeber 31, Jan. 1, 1919-September 30* *part of a year Source for figures: Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. The exact dollar figures for interest payments, income, revenue, etc. differ somewhat between the Northern California Power Company Annual Reports, the California Railroad Commission's annual Report, and Fowler, but the deviations are not significant. BATTLE CREEK EAER CA-2 (page Table 24. Mean Monthly Loads an the Northern California Power Company System, (Fowler.

Hydroelectric Systems of California,, Plate XX) ^ i y/////^//A///^//////, * : 35 \ <0 O o Si wAonix iO SQNVSnOMi BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page and rose to as the price rose .from 17 to per pound- Even though copper output began to slowly decline again, beginning in due to the expansion of production In Chile and the increased recovery of copper from scrap, the utility's revenues from raining and dredging operations continued to rise steadily, increasing by between and and by between and The one other bright spot In the company's situation was a steadily growing agricultural demand for power in the upper Sacramento River valley.

Electricity had been used to power irrigation pumps in California as early as and, as we have seen, the Northern California Power Company had been aggressive in cultivating this market since when declining revenues from mining had convinced company officials that they needed a market that would "last forever". Northern California's campaign for agricultural electrification began to pay major dividends in the second decade of the twentieth century. Two extremely dry seasons and and the introduction of rice cultivation which required extensive irriga- tion hp of pumps per acres between April -sad September) sig- nificantly boosted the company's revenues from agricultural load.

By a decade after Northern California had initiated its campaign to encourage the use of electric pumps, irrigation customers accounted for of the utility's yearly average load and of the load between May and September. In Northern California was serving 531 agricultural power customers with a total connected power load of hp The agricultural load was further increased with the introduction of rice cultivation in the Sacramento River valley. By almost acres had been planted with rice. By the figure had increased to and by to around acres. In new rice cultivators alone required hp and made the construction of a new substation necessary.

Thus annual revenues for irrigation increased by between and and higher prices for agricultural products brought on by wartime demands led to a massive additional increase in revenues in this field for alone. Unfortunately the steady expansion of agricultural load was not uniformly beneficial to the company. It significantly increased the ex- penditures the company was forced to make for new equipment. The agricultural load increase came primarily from the southern part of the company's territory. JThe company's hydroelectric plants were in the north. To transfer steadily larger amounts of power south and keep line losses to an acceptable level. Northern California was compelled to raise the capacity of many of its lines from 20 or 22 to 60 or 66 kV.

Between and for example, the proportion of the company's lines that were operated at around 66 kV increased from 43% to And this trend continued. In 51 miles of 20 kV (or 22 kV) transmission line were dismantled, while 37 miles of new 60. kV (or 66 kV) line were strung. The replacement of 22 kV lines with 66 kV lines had begun even before but as power demand increased more rapidly in agriculture than anywhere else after the process was accelerated at the very time when the company needed ever dollar to help retire its huge bonded indebtedness. Raising the v::ltage of transmission lines from 22 to 66 kV BATTLE CREEK to EAER CA-2 it River (page Weaverville proposed Bumey Reservoir .Battle Ck.Res. &acumber Reservoir lanzanita Lake Anderson' Cottonwood Red Bluf approx. 10 mi.

Corning Orlaad Chics Table iaDj.e 25. ZD. Outline of the Transmission Wlilw5^ System of the Northern- - - ( J California Power Company, ( Consolidated, in (Some minor lines not shown) Mazwellv u % Williams PS u a ctf Hi fa based on map in $th Annual Report Dunnig an TOTTFTSEFX HAER CA-2 (page required not only the reconstruction of the lines themselves, but the installation of new transformers at powerhouses and substations, the purchase of new and more expensive switching apparatus to control the higher voltages, the use of better and more expensive insulators, and so on. Thus every expansion of power load in the south was partially offset by the increased expenditures which Northern California had to make to take advantage of the larger market.

To a utility on a solid financial base this would not have been a serious burden.. But Northern California Power was not on a solid financial base. Nonetheless, the increased revenues from mining (after and agriculture enabled Northern California Power to stumble through the barely ahead of its creditors. Had other power markets grown to an equal extent, Northern California might have been successful in reducing its bonded indebtedness and overcoming its persistent cash flow and excess generating capacity problems. But other power markets did not grow at a corresponding rate. Revenues from commercial lighting, for instance, barely increased between and ia.,1913; in Another market which did not expand was bulk sales to other utilities, particularly PG&E with its access to the bay area.

Sales to PG&E had increased steadily from to undoubtedly contributing to Northern California's decision to expand generating capacity on Battle Creek. These sales had peaked in at accounting in that year for around 30% of operating revenue. But had been an exceptionally dry year. The demand for power in the bay area was higher than PG&E's hydroelectric system could supply. The following year, however, was not exceptionally and PG&E had completed its Drum hydroelectric plant (output kVA) .

Its dependence on outside generating capacity was reduced, and Northern California's revenues from bulk sales dropped by 12% or around for Between and sales to other utilities remained almost constant, averaging only per year, and in even dropped to America's entrance into World War I led to increased power consumption by both the manufacturing and agricultural sectors of the economy, and this resulted in increased revenues for electric utility companies everywhere, including Northern California Power. surplus for was over higher than that of But this benefit was offset in part by other developments.^ Northern California Power Company lost nearly a third of its regular employees to the draft.

Wartime shortages and high wartime prices for materials made Northern California's financial problems more acute. The price of copper wire rose between and cast iron pipe rose 10OX. In addition, wartime power demands forced Northern California to undertake line construction for which it did not have the necessary cash reserves. Wartime production in the San Francisco Bay area in created serious power shortages. In an attempt to alleviate these shortages the California Railroad Commission had carried out a study of power consumption in California, discovering that 70% of all electric power generated in the northern part of the' state was consumed within a 50 mile radius of San Francisco.

In order to bring more power into this area and reduce dependence on generators fired by scarce and high priced oil the Commission exerted heavy pressure on all electrical utilities in the state to inter- connect their transmission networks. EAER CA-2 (page This decision effected Northern California Power. One of the Commissions recommendations was that the California-Oregon Power Company, whose territory lay north of the Battle Creek.area along the California-Oregon border, link its lines with those of Northern California Power north of Kennett at Delta, California.

This interconnection would permit California-Oregon Power to supply kW to the northern end of system* freeing the Consolidated Company to supply an additional kW of power to Pacific Gas and Electric for distribution in the San Francisco Bay area through a new link with the PG&E grid at Colusa Corners. The Northern California Power Company was, at the time, preparing an application for a rate increase to be submitted to the California Railroad Commission. Company officials probably felt they had little choice but to follow a recommendation made at the "urgent insistence" of the body which would rule on their request.

A formal contract between the three parties (California-Oregon, PG&E, and Northern California) was signed in June Because of the acute cash flow problems of Northern California Power, arrangements were made for the California-Oregon Power Company to advance to Northern California. This money was used to pay California-Oregon crews to construct 17 miles of new power line from Kennett to Delta, where the Northern California and California-Oregon grids were Interconnected. The advance was also used to reinforce a transmission line from Hamilton City south to Colusa Corners,where the new interconnection was to be made to the PG&E grid (the interconnection had been made at Chico) and to build a new line between Coleman and Hamilton City.

The advance was to be repayed out of money received by Northern California as a carrying charge on electricity transferred south for California-Oregon and out of revenues from power which would sell California-Oregon's grid during the non- irrigation season. Unfortunately the advance proved insufficient. Lines expected to be adequate with reinforcement for the transmission of power south were found to be inadequate-, "perhaps due to insufficient maintenance during the financially-troubled years from to Some had to be completely rebuilt. This additional work cost the utility an additional and, as a company official noted, was "an expenditure that the Company would not have made under any other circumstances or for any but patriotic reasons.

The war years of and brought Northern California Power Company stockholders more bad news. The bonds issued in to consolidate debts incurred during the construction of Coleman matured on July 15, Attempts to negotiate a postponement on these bonds, similar to the postponement negotiated on the bonds used to purchase the Sacramento Valley Power Company, 1 failed. Assessments totalling were levied against Northern California stockholders, and the company secured in short term loans to carry it over this crisis. [Ill] Revenues did increase in and quite significantly.

The utility's surplusafter operating expenses, taxes, and interest payments were subtracted from gross income rose from In to in these funds were still insufficient to meet the cost of additions, improvements, maintenance, and payments due the company's sinking funds for outstanding bonds. Even though Northern California had BATTLE CREEK EAER CA-2 (page undertaken no major capital improvements since the completion of Coleman in late and even though dividend payments had been suspended since and despite assessments which' by totalled $14 per share, the company's financial situation had continued to decline and by was approaching total collapse. By June of Northern California Power Company, Consol- idated, was in arrears in payments to its sinking fund and owed in short term notes.

In addition, of the bonds used to purchase The Sacramento Valley Power Con^any were still unretired. These bonds, whose payment had already been postponed five years, were due to mature on February 1, Recognizing the acute nature of Northern California's financial problems, the Railroad Commission authorized a 10% surcharge on all power bills rendered by the company after May 1,

The Pit River

Northern California's future was clouded not only by the company's preearious financial position, but also by developments involving the Pit River, in the extreme northern part of its territories. Very early, as we have seen, Noble and his associates had seen the Pit as a logical area for expansion of generating capacity. In Noble employed a civil engineer, R.E. Johnson to locate potential hydroelectric plant sites on the Pit, and Johnson had filed for Noble notice of appropriation of inches second feet) of water. The appropriation was filed in the vicinity of the "Big Bend" of the Pit River. From the beginning of the "bend" to its termination was around 21 miles by water, but only 7 miles overland, with a vertical drop of around feet between.

Northern California's plans for the area initially called for a-large dam some miles upstream. This dam was to divert water into a 28 mile bng canal, which would eventually cross the bend and deliver water to a hydroelectric plant under a foot head, generating as much as hp Further studies and surveys, however, indicated that this plan was unfeasible and it was abandoned. - "" Johnson was next Instructed to survey a site for a smaller project, a project that would reduce the length of canal by positioning the water intake somewhere on or near the "bend" itself. These surveys were completed by or This project Involved a mile long tunnel to divert second-feet of water to a powerhouse on the downstream side of the "bend", permitting operation under a head of 940 feet.

Either in direct violation of instructions frc-a Noble or because the Northern California Power Company delayed implement .ion of his plans, Johnson, in conjunction with an associate, Gat , filed claim In on inches second-feet) of water in th area of the intake he had located for Northern California. The water v 3 claimed for use in the mining of building stone, a method sometimes . ;ed in California to reserve water rights'-for later development for other purposes. Although Northern California Power had neither the resources nor the need to develop Pit power in it regarded the Pit as a Northern California "preserve". Thus Noble responded quickly to the threat from Johnson and Gates.

In August Northern California altered its claim on inches second-feet) of water, moving the projected intake for its plant downstream,below the point at which Gates and Johnson planned to BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page appropriate water. In fcha. .'.ay 'iifcgsn extensive surveys, started small scale construction on one of tha i&fcls that its new plans required, and started to acquire the necessary l^iids for the project. In addition, in September Northern California challenged the Johnson-Gates claim.

Noble's lawyers argued that this claim for the use of water for mining building stone was a subterfuge made solely to secure "a reservoir site and not for any other purpose" and that development work on the site had been undertaken not to mine building stone but to "find a point for an intake of a tunnel to be used in connection with a power plait". The local U.S. land office examiner concurred with Northern California's claims and rejected the Gates-Johnson claim as filed, requiring a new application. His decision was upheld in late by the Commissioner of the General Land Office in Washington, throwing the question of who had placed the first valid appropriation claim up for grabs.

In the meantime Northern California had suspended work on the Pit site, transferring its crew south to Battle Creek for the expansion program there. This proved to be a wise move. In the Federal Government withdrew several large blocks of public land along the Pit from development for conservation purposes. These withdrawals affected both the Johnson- Gates and Northern California projects and forced both parties to reconsider development plans. Northern California responded quickly. In the company made new surveys to avoid power site withdrawal lands, established the first stream flow measurement and permanent gauging stations on the river, altered the location of its intake, and filed a new claim on inches second-feet) of water.

The new plans involved a ditch system around miles long, which would include five tunnels totalling feet in length. The Pit canal was to carry around second-feet of water. The tunnels were to be much larger than those used on the Battle Creek system ( 24 feet wide by 26 feet high) in order to permit the use of mechanical shovels. This system would develop a head of 464 feet and generate over hp Northern California officials believed that the new plant would cost approximately and re- quire two years for completion. By or Northern California had completed its surveys and had begun work on the new project, having purchased or filed claim on all necessary lands and waters. Preparatory work was stepped up in late as some crews were transferred to the Pit from Coleman.

Noble hoped all possible preliminary work could be finished at the site so that "as soon as there is a demand for power" the project could be rushed to completion. The decline of Northern California's financial situation in and and the collapse of copper smelting and Noble's experiment at Heroult, of course, all but prohibited any major capital investment on the Pit. Northern California Power thus deferred heavy construction work there, keeping only a small crew working after to sustain its water claims. BATTLE CREEK RAER CA-2 (page Because the Pit offered excellent , 'n:U: :& for large scale hydro- electric development. Noble's "preserve1' Jtu:>>,.ty invaded by other companies.

In for example, a Pit Sivev Poweii Company was formed to develop power on the stream, but collapsed, apparently due to failure to raise sufficient capital. La however, the Mt. Shasta Power Company was organized, based in part on the Johnson-Gates claims. This company, backed by mining entrepreneur John Hays Hammond, planned to divert inches second-feet) of water through a 7 mile tunnel. The projected intake of Mt. Shasta's tunnel was located 2 miles upstream from the intake planned by Northern California Power. Because the Mt. Shasta project would take in water 2 miles above the Northern California Intake and release the water 8 miles below, completion of the Mt. Shasta plant would have rendered Northern California's plant useless. Litigation ensued and both projects languished. By Mt.

Shasta had driven its tunnel only 1 mile. Northern California had dug only 700 feet of tunnel. In unable to develop the project on its own, the Mt. Shasta Power Company sold its rights and properties to the Pacific Gas and Electric Company, a corporation with sufficient capital resources to aggressively push litigation Involving conflicting water claims in the Big Bend area and to develop the site. A new impetus to develop the Pit came with wartime power shortages. These shortages prompted the California Railroad Commission to review in the power potential of the Pit. It was very impressed by Northern California's plans for the "Big Bend".

The Commission not only considered the plans to be feasible,but argued that of all the major power projects in the northern part of the state, the Northern California Pit River project was the one which should be developed first to alleviate present and future power demands. Costs were estimated at construction time at 18 months. The Commission strongly recommended that major con- struction work be initiated immediately. Northern California did move a seven man crew to the site in late or early and this crew carried on the work of blasting and driving tunnels and digging exploration pits and drifts. Northern California also continued to purchase land in the area. But the utility was reluctant to make any additional commitment.

Since litigation was pending with PG&E over water rights, Northern California did not want to invest heavily in a plant which might not have water to operate with. Moreover, the company's precarious financial condition ruled out any extensive efforts. Of the factors which limited Northern California's activities on the Pit, the company's poor financial condition was undoubtedly the most critical. In the Railroad Commission reviewed the financial position of Northern California Power in conjunction with a request for a rate increase. The Commission now estimated that it would cost the company around to complete its Pit River project, if unchallenged title to the waters could be secured, but noted that it was "doubtful" whether could raise this much capital.

To remain a "solvent up-to-date public utility," capable of 0 discharging its obligations to the pub He, the Commission concluded, Northern California needed an Influx of to Yet the company^ current Income limited any Increase of its bonded indebtedness to a meager an amount "scarcely sufficient to pay maturing obligations". Thus Northern California's Pit River holdings, while potentially very ^valuable, were clouded by the utility's precarious financial plight and by potential litigation with PG&E. PG&E AND THE SOSLTSBBN CALIFORNIA STSTEM Despite its financial problems, the Northern California Power Company still owned considerable asets in From a strictly technical point of view its Battle Creek hydroelectric system was one of the best medium-sized systems in the state.

In addition to the four hydroelectric plants the company had on Battle Creek and the two smaller Cow Creek plants (Kilarc plus South Cow Creek acquired with the purchase of The Sacramento Valley Power Company), it had a 584 mile long high voltage transmission network and almost miles of distribution lines. Its territory covered an area of approximately square miles (see map on the following page). Making the system even more attractive was its very high load factor. In addition, Northern California had a defensible claim to the waters of the Pit River with its immense hydroelectric potential, as well as a transmission system that could easily be linked to any plant established on that stream.

With these assets it is not at all surprising that a number of operating utility companies were interested in purchasing the system when Northern California's directors indicated in a willingness to dispose of the company to escape from its financial plight. Although negotiations were carried on with several firms, the best offer came from Pacific Gas and Electric. PG&E already had two interconnections with the Northern California grid and had purchased an average of kW continuously in In previous years purchases had been even higher (an average of kW in Thus acquisition of Northern California would not only increase the generating capacity of the PG&E system by almost but would substantially reduce its dependence on other utilities.

In addition, the absorption of Northern California would leave PG&E unchallenged on the Pit, and Northern California's lines would allow any new Pit River plant to quickly and cheaply be linked to the bulk of the PG&E distribution system. Because of the real and potential importance of Northern California's assets, Pacific Gas & Electric's offer was generous. PG&E agreed to purchase all outstanding shares of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, at $34 per share and to assume payment of the company's in bonded indebtedness. Northern California's board of directors unanimously voted to accept the offer, and all but the holders of 450 shares of stock concurred with its decision.

The sale, however, had to be approved by the California Railroad Commission,and the dissidents filed a protest with that body. They charged that the sale had been conceived and executed by individuals acting not In the interests of the Northern California Power Company hut in the lifcSC op-** Table 26. Approximate Boundaries of the Transmission System of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, c. BATTLE C&&EK CA-2 (pige 143 > Interests of Pacific Gas and Electric Company, giving PG&E valuable water rights, franchises, and properties without proper compensation to Northern California stockholders.

The protestants based their allegations on the Interlocking directorships and mutual stock ownership which existed between the sacageiseat of PG&E, and the Mercantile Trust Company of San Francisco- t&ey poiated out, for instance* that Detert, president of Hortftem Califcrraia^ was "also a large stockholder of Pacific Gas and Electric" and a director of the Mercantile Trust Company; that S. Waldo Colemaa and A.F. Kels two directors of Northern California, were also PG&E stockholders; and that several high PG&E officials were also officials of the Mercantile Trust Company.

The dissidents also complained that the purchase price of $34 per share did not fairly compensate them for the original cost of the shares plus the $14 in assessments levied on the shares to keep the company solvent between and The Railroad Commission, well acquainted with the precarious financial position of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, dismissed the protest of the minority stockholders and approved the sale. The Northern California Power Company with its Battle Creek system of hydroelectric plants was officially absorbed into the Pacific Gas and Electric Company on October 3, The Northern California Power Company system was by far the largest and most important addition to the PG&E system since the year after PG&E had been incorporated.

BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page * N0TES 52- [I] Redding Courier Free Press, April 28, / [2] Redding Courier Free Press. May 26, San Francisco Call, May 25 and May 26, [3] Redding Courier Free Press, May 27, [4] "The Northern California Power Company's Systems. - III. High-Tension Transmission System," Electrical World, v. 44 p. [5] Redding Searchlight. April 1, Red Bluff Daily News. November 15 and November 21, [6] 4th Annual Report [7] Redding Courier Free Press. March 4 and November 10, - Bulletin 23 p. 75. [8] Redding Courier Free Press, October 23 and November 1, February 23, April 4, and May 12, [9] Redding Courier Free Press. April 12, April 16, and May 2, ^0[1O] Redding Courier Free Press.

October 29 and December 12, February 4, 2nd Annual Report [II] Redding Courier Free Press, May 17, Redding Courier Free Press. May 27, Report p. 3rd Annual Report Report p. 3rd Annual Report Whaley, the company's secretary, later estimated that the Northern California Power Company lost around a year due to the closing of the three smelters Transcripts [of Hearings], application no. 62, v. 1 [June 24, p. Report p. For the declining price of stock see: Redding Courier Free Press, May 26, San Francisco Call. May 25, San Francisco Call , May 26, Redding Courier Free Press. December 16, and San Francisco Call. September 5, Also see Transcripts [of Hearings], application no. 62, v. 1 (June 24, p. 43. JE, v. 29 (November 23, p.

The smelter is described in some detail by Van Norden in "Electric Iron Smelter at Heroult on the Pitt," JE, v. 29 pp. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 ' (page m JE, v. 28 (June 29, p. Van Norden, "Electric Iron Smelter," p. JE, v. 28 (June 29, p. Bedding Courier Free Press, December 27, and February 11, April 17, and Hay 30, 4th Annual Report On the failure of the charcoal system see: 5th Annual Report for the price Increase see: Report p. and Stansfield, Electric Furnace, p. 5th Annual Report Stansfield, Electric Furnace, p. For the later history of Heroult's smelters see: Stansfield, Electric Furnace, p. San Francisco Chronicle, March 7, Report pp. Report p. Report pp.

"Financial Agreement between Noble and Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," August 11, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document 2092-a); "Statement of Edward Whaley regarding debt of ^t Noble to Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," February 25, W (PG&E, Secretary's Office, docuae Redding Courier Free Press, March 19 and March 25, Red Bluff Weekly Peoples1 Cause, March 27, Red Bluff Daily News, October 10, White & Co., "Report," p. 86. Redding Courier Free Press, July 23 and July 28, White & Co., "Report," p. 87. White & Co., "Report," pp. vi-vii, 87, 95. Redding Courier Free Press, August 10, Redding Courier Free Press, May 17, Red Bluff Daily News, September 9 and September 16, Red Bluff Weekly Peoples' Cause, September 9, Scrapbook," p.

89 ("Arrested for Tearing Out Dam on Battle Creek"). Red Bluff Daily News, September 30, Red Bluff News, September 29, Red Bluff Weekly Peoples1 Cause, October 2, Red Bluff Daily News, July 1, Redding Courier Free Press, June 4, Redding Courier Free Press, April 18, BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page Redding Courier Free Press. August 6, February 26 and June 4, White & Co., "Report,"pp. 33, 35, says that Smith was planning on taking his water out of the Battle Creek watershed to hostile power plants. Redding Courier Free Press, April 15 and April 26, Redding Courier Free Press, April 3, Redding Courier Free Press.

April 26, San Francisco Call, January 28, Redding Courier Free Press, December 24, "Deed of Trust: The Sacramento Valley Power Company to Anglo California Trust Company," July 1, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document Redding Courier Free Press. September 16, Redding Courier Free Press, September 15, San Francisco Call, September 17, Redding Courier Free Press., September 18 and September 19, Redding Courier Free Press, September 22 and September 25, Scrapbook" ("Power Companies Declare Truce" JE, v. 27 (November 11, p. Transcripts Fof Hearings 1, application no. 62, v. 1 (June 24, pp. Transcripts [of Hearings], cases v. 3 (February 2, pp. Transcripts Tof Hearings], application no. 62, v. 1 (June 24, p. 76; Decisions, v. 1 p. Decisions, v. 11 p. 44; Report (June 30, to June 30, p. 46.

Decisions, v. 11 p. 44. Decisions, v. 1 p. and v. 11 pp. 4th Annual Report Report (June 30, to June 30, p. 47. Decisions., v. 11 p. 57; 4th Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 57. Decisions, v. 11 p. 69; 4th Annual Report and 5th Annual Report BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page Transcript [of Hearing], application no. 156 (July 24, pp. Transcripts [of Hearings], cases v. 3 (February 2, pp. 4th Annual Report Transcripts [of Hearings I, cases v. 3 (February 2, p. This water was apparently the water Smith was planning to carry out of the Battle Creek watershed White & Co., "Report," pp. 33, Transcripts [of Hearings,], cases v. 3 (February 2, p. for a statement to this effect by Whaley, the company secretary; 4th Annual Report for Noble's assertion. Transcripts [of Hearings], cases v.

3 (February 2, pp. Decisions, v. 11 p. 46; 4th Annual Report JE, v. 32 (February 14, p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Mike Scott, "The History of the Hat Creek-Lost Creek Diversions, typewritten MS, 18 pp. (Tehama County Library). JE, v. 28 (February 24, p. JE, v. 28 (June 1, p. v. 29 (July 6, p. 20. Decisions, v. 11 pp. see also Decisions, v. 1 pp. Transcripts [of Hearings], application no. 62, v. 1 (June 24, p. 7 (testimony of Edward Whaley, company secretary). According to Whaley the company was worth a little more than not including distribution lines, substations, and property for the same. Report (January 1, to June 30, pp. Report (June 30, to June 30, p. 46. Report (June 30, to June 30, p. 47; Decisions, v. 11 pp. 45; v. 1 pp. Decisions, v. 11 p. 64. Decisions, v.

1 pp. (for authorization to issue notes), (for supplemental order regarding assessments. For strong complaint about inability to produce adequate financial records see "Hearing before , application no. 156 (August 14, comment of Commissioner Gordon (in "Opinions and Legal Documents," application no. 156 [CSA]) BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page ^une 3 . to June 30, p. See also Decisions. v. 1 pp. A number of the Valuation Survey Field Books are dated and 6th Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 p. 38. In its application for increased capitalization in valued its assets at around "Opinions and Legal Documents," application no. 156 [filed July 19, see also Transcripts kf' Hearings], application no. 62, v. 1 (June 24, p. 7, and JE, v. 29 (July 6, p. 20. Decisions, v. 11 pp. 38, Ibid., p. 48.

1st Annual Report JE, v. 29 (July 6, p. 20; Decisions. v. 11 p. 51; Transcripts [of HearingsU application no. 62, v. 1 (June 24, pp. Decisions, v. 11 pp. Decisions, v. 9 (January 1, to April 30, p. JE, v. 33 (July 25, p. 92; "Certificate of Increase of Capital Stock of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated from to August 3, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document 6th Annual Report Decisions, v. 5 (July 1, to December 31, pp. Decisions, v. 9 pp. 7th Annual Report As a further assist to the Consolidated Company the Railroad Commission in blocked the application of the Sierra Electric Company to construct two new hydroelectric plants on Digger Creek, a tributary of North Battle Creek.

The Commission noted in rendering its decision that the existing utility had sufficient surplus capacity to supply all the demands of the territory and that there was not sufficient business to permit both the existing utility and the petitioners to earn a reasonable return 8th Annual Report JE, v. 29 (October 26, p. 4th Annual Report 5th Annual Report JE, v 32 (January 31, p. Ill; 6th Annual Report Decisions, v. 3 (July 1, to December 31, pp. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page JE, v. 32 (January 31, p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, pp. and Annual Reports from to 6th Annual Report uses the term "income" instead of '"revenue", In Noble was the largest stockholder in the Northern California Power Company. He owned shares, his daughters Hebe and Grace more.

Detert did not even appear on a list of major stockholders. In Detert owned shares; Detert shares, and Noble only shares (he was the largest stockholder). For major stockholders in see: "Opinions and Legal Documents," application no. 156 (filed July 19, [CSA]; for stockholders see "Annual Report of the Northern California Power Co. to the Railroad Commission of California, for the 9 mos. ending September 30, p. 17 (CSA). Decisions, v. 11 p. 64. Transcripts fof Hearings 1, cases v. 3 (February 2, p. Decisions, v. 11 pp. 38, 49. For statistics on copper production see, Report p. for revenues see: 9th Annual Report and Annual Report Decisions, v. 11 pp. Ibid., p. 49.

For the growth of rice cultivation in the area and its demand for electric power see Adams, "Pumping Plants for Rice Irrigation," JE, v. 37 pp. See also, 8th Annual Report and Annual Report JE, v. 42 (March 15, p. 6th Annual Report through Annual Report For figures see Van Norden, "New Hydroelectric Plant," p. for figures see Decisions, v. 11 p. 48. 8th Annual Report There were also some minor line extensions in this period. In for Instance, lines were extended south from College City 10 miles to Dunnigan and westward from Balaklala towards Weaverville to link up with the Western States Gas and Electric Company (ibid.). See the revelant Annual Reports and Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page 6th AanualHaport ii9i4).

See the relevant Annual Reports, or Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Annual Report Ibid.* for Northern California's difficulties with higher materials prices; Pacific Gas and Electric Company, Annual Report (Fiscal Year ended December 31, p. 23, for the specific price increases for copper wire and cast iron pipe. Report (July 1, to June 3, pp. 94; and "Hydro-Electric Power in Northern and Central California," Western Engineering, v. 9 pp. Report (July 1, to June 30, pp. 67. Annual Report See also E.H. Steele, "The 'Pacific Service* End of the Oregon-California Chain of High-Tension Transmission Systems," Pacific Service Magazine, v. 11 pp. and Frederick S.

Myrtle, "From the Mountains of Oregon to the Bay of San Francisco: By Inter-Connection of Three High-Tension Transmission Systems," Pacific Service Magazine, v. 10 pp. Annual Report The interconnection was not completed until early see JE, v. 42 (January 1, p. 46. [Ill] 9th Annual Report See the 8th Annual Report through the Annual Report to Decisions, v. 17 (June 30, to March 31, p. "Railroad Commission of the State of California, Application Decision September 23, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document 2092-e). Decisions, v. 16 (September 1, to June 30, pp. White & Co., "Report," p. 89. White & Co., "Report," pp. Redding Searchlight, July 1, "Chronology of Northern California Power Co. Activities in Big Bend of Pit River - Pit 5 Project," MS, 2 pp. (PG&E Library).

In the Scrapbook" of newspaper clippings relating to the Northern California Power Company there is an item headlined: "Pit River Power", dated November 10, [p. 43 of the scrapbook], referring to the creation of a Pit River Power Company. There is a handwritten note on the clipping which reads: [presumably Noble], These fellows going poaching on your preserve". BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page White & Co.* "Repoi'f:.," pp* "Chronology of Activities on Pit River". Redding Courier Free Press, July 1, Redding Searchlight. July 1, White & Co., "Report," p. 91. San Francisco Nee Bulletin, December 9, The history of "Big Bend" project up to is reviewed in White & Co., "Report," pp. Redding Courier Free Press, January 4 and July 13, "Chronology of Activities on Pit River".

3rd Annual Report Redding Courier Free Press, November 15, 3rd Annual Report JE, v. 27 (October 28, p. Report (July 1, to June 30, pp. Redding Courier Free Press, October 18, October 28, and November 15, 3rd Annual Report Scrapbook," p. 43 ("Pitt River Power," JE, v. 38 (May 15, p. Red Bluff Daily Peoples' Cause, May 17, JE, v. 38 (May 15, p. JE, v. 38 (June 1, p. PG&E, Annual Report p. 21. Report (July 1, to June 30, p. 63. "Pit River Construction Records," September - September The Northern California Power Company was purchasing land along the Pit in connection with its project as late as the summer of (JE, v. 43 [July 15, p. JE, v. 43 (July 15, p. 94. Decisions, v. 17 p. Ibid., p. "Railroad Commission of the State of California, Application Decision September 23, p.

6 (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document 2092-e). Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, see "Annual Report of the Northern California Power Co. to the Railroad Commission of California, for the 9 mos. ending September 30, 60 pp. for the holdings and status of the company at the time of the PG&E purchase. p !0 Decisions, v. 17 p. Fowler, Hydroelectric Systems of California, p. Decisions, v. 17 pp.

"Offer of Pacific Gas and Electric to Detert," June 12, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document "Resolution Duly Adopted by the Board of Directors of the Pacific Gas and Electric Company," April 19, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document "Letter to 'Stockholders of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated' explaining terms of sale to Pacific Gas and Electric Company," June 17, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document Decisions, v. 17 pp. "Protest and Objections of Stockholders of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated Before the Railroad Commission of the State of California," August (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document Decisions, v. 17 pp.

"Agreement Between Pacific Gas and Electric Company and Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," October 3, (PG&E, Secretary's Office, document PG&E, Annual Report pp. 12, 17. PG&E, Annual Report p. 12: "This is the most important addition to its system within recent years". See p. 13 for a year by year breakdown of the value of property acquired. HAW-OA POSTSCRIPT The Battle Creek Hydroelectric System in the PG&E Years The Battle Creek system was the heart of Northern California Power Company's system, providing almost 90% of the utility's generating capacity. It was, however* only a minor element in the much larger Pacific Gas and Electric Company's system. Hence after its relative importance was sharply diminished.

Some changes were made in the system and some new elements added, but none of these were as radical as the changes made between and when Northern California Power was actively at work on Battle Creek. The greatest of the changes which were made came at Volt a. By the middle of the the equipment in the section of the powerhouse was obsolete and In need of extensive repairs. Since these repairs would entail considerable expense, Pacific Gas and Electric elected to completely re-equip the old section of the powerhouse and make it compatible with the and equipment. Thus the three original 750 kVA, 500 volt units were replaced in with a single kVA, volt unit.

The higher |operating voltage of the new unit made it necessary to completely rewire the older portion of the station, but made it possible to consolidate the new switchboard with the and switchboards and to operate the plant as a single powerhouse with one operator instead of as two powerhouses under the same roof with two operators. At the same time the original air-cooled transformers were replaced by larger water-cooled transformers and the last remnants of the original Northern California Power Company 22 kV transmission system were abandoned. [1] There were several relatively significant changes In the water system.

The most important addition was the Wildcat Canal, constructed in This canal diverted around 20 second-feet of water from North Battle Creek, feeding it into the Coleman Canal before it entered either of its siphons. The most significant subtraction from the system was Manzanita Lake. It was deeded to the United States Government for the Lassen Volcanic National Park in February of In addition, the Al Smith Canal replaced the Upper Hill Creek Canal as one of the major feeders for diverting water from North Battle Creek to Millseat Creek. A number of other changes in the system resulted from the Battle Creek system's incorporation in a large, interconnected, electrical production and distribution system.

The most Important of these changes was the conversion of the Battle Creek plants to semi-automatic operation. This was possible because PG&E, unlike Northern California Power, could depend on the natural regulating characteristics of a large system and on a few large "live" hydro and steam units for frequency control. Conversion to semi-automatic I operation involved the installation of forebay water level controls and BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page systems to automatically shut down the plant in case of overloads. It required replacing the governors with hydraulic controllers equipped with motors to operate be aeedle nozzles and/or deflectors.

Conversion to semi-automatic operation also entailed the installation of either motor- generator exciter units with auxiliary storage batteries or belt-driven exciters in place of the original water-driven exciters (although the latter were sometimes retained as an auxiliary method for restarting the plants). South, the most inaccessible of the Battle Creek powerhouses, was converted to semi-automatic operation in [2] The other three plants were aodified in a similar manner in By the middle of the much of the equipment installed 1B the Battle Creek powerhouses was approaching obsolescence and requiring in- creasingly more frequent repair.

Thus in the Pacific Gas and Electric Company applied to the Federal Power Commission for permission to replace all four, of the original Battle Creek plans with more modern facilities which could be operated at higher efficiencies and with reduced labor forces. 13] The new powerhouses, located adjacent to the older powerhouses, are reinforced concrete structures, housing but a single generating unit and designed to be operated unattended. At Volta the three impulse wheel and generator units were replaced by a single unit with a two nozzle, hor- izontal impulse wheel, each nozzle independently connected to one of the two existing penstocks. At South and Inskip the impulse wheel units were replaced with single vertical-shaft Francis turbines.

Aid at Coleman the three old horizontal-shaft Francis turbines were replaced with a single vertical-shaft Francis turbine. A single three phase transformer at Volta, South, and Inskip replaced the banks of single phase transformers previously used. These modifications, according to PG&E estimates, should increase the capacity of the Battle Creek system, beginning in by around from kW to kW. BATTLE GEUKEK HAB& CA--2 (page NOTES [1] PG&E, Engineering Central File This has a memorandum on alter at Iocs planned or ta^de far Volta, plus several letters, work orders, md fisseraX Manager's Authorizations dealing with the modifications to folta.

[2] PG&E, Engineering Central File nS There are several letters dating from and a General Manager's Authorization dating from which discuss the conversion of South to semi-automatic operation. [3] Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Application of Pacific Gas and Electric Company for License, before the Federal Power Commission: Battle Creek System Project October 31, reviews the system as it stood in and outlines the changes proposed by PG&E for the system. See also: "New License Sought for U.S. Plant," Water Power, v. 23 p. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page ^ PENDIX I: CORPORATE FAMILY TREE OF NORTHERN CALIFORNIA POWER COMPANY ft H 5 H H O (T> . . ft a 5 p* 't- H- B (6 to Q tt 1 9 OP'SJ U) o H ? 91 ffM S?

O O (X bd V-N H- *" 00 H* < 00 hti UJ S (9 00 Cf rt W1 H C* C M O t-h W -3 H ffS rt M O S3 *-* ^ (_ p. 09 O 09 o o M ff 09 ^S o "M TO OO S3 <r. (a rt n H f ?3 -r o, rt H- OO *tf M i-> * HQH y3 *-^ t (D o (D O h- H rt -I O H- O O I?

ra H* 04 r* 00 w * 00 h-OQ 3 00 09 O O^ to BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page APPENDIX II # TEE BATTLE CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM BASIC DATA storage THE STORAGE RESERVOIRS width acres capacity dam type length height base crest flooded (acre-feet) Lake Nora earth fill 14 59 12 3.5 Lake Grace earth fill 16 67 10 6.5 Macumber part masonry; 187 27 26 8 part earth & rock fill 12 59 15 143 Manzanita earth fill #1 469 14 55 15 60 500 #2 212 5.5 18 4 Baldwin earth fill 25 84 7 23 Coleman Forebay earth and rock fill 20 69 11 North Battle masonry 439 56* 79 22 130 182 7 Creek Reservoir * with flashboarda 10 feet high; masonry portion is only 46 feet high # The data presented in this appendix has been gleaned from a number of sources, particularly: the and PG&E applications to the Federal Power Commission; Fowler's Hydroelectric Systems of California; Van Norden*s articles on the Northern California Power Company and other articles cm the company in the Journal of Electricity; and the Valuation Survey Field Books of the Northern California Power Company These sources of information often give conflicting data.

Hence the figures in this appendix must be regarded as approximate rather than exact in many cases. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page THE PLANTS: Head Installed Generating Average Output Capacity in kVA's - Volta South 516 Ins kip 378 Colenan 482 THE PENSTOCKS: .ength Construction Volta L. Nora Wood stave lap-welded steel L. Grace Wood stave lap-welded and lap-riveted steel South Lap-riveted steel In skip Wood stave lap-riveted steel Colemsn A. Lap-riveted steel B. Lap-riveted steel *The wood stave portion of the Lake Nora penstock was replaced with steel in **The old wood stave portion of the Lake Grace penstock was replaced in by feet of new wood stave penstock and steel pipe. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page ^

Water Turbines

Diameter of Output Speed Hake Rotor (in.) Arrangement Control Volt a 1-3 Pelton 64 self-mounted deflecting nozzle 4 Doble 86 single over- needle noz- hung zle w/bypass 5 Pelton 76 single over- deflecting hung needle noz- zle South 1 Doble 66 double over- needle noz- hung (2 zle rotors) deflector Ins kip 1 Pelton 48 triple rotor needle noz- dual nozzle zle w/hood deflector 2 Pelton 48 triple rotor needle noz- single nozzle zle w/hood deflector Coleman 1-3 Allis-Chalmers 34 horizontal wicket gate shaft "Francis" turbine (single run- ner,overhung)

The Exciter Units

Make of Make of Impulse Output speed dc gen- Output Wheel erator Volt a 1-2 Pelton 90 850 West. 45 3 Doble 92 850 West. 45 4 Pelton 90 975 G.E. 45 South 1 Doble 80 350 West. 55 Ins kip 1-2 Pelton 120 625 G.E. 60 Coleman 1-2 Allis-Chalm. 350 525 A-C 225 BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page

The Generators

Type Speed Output Make (revolving-) Voltage Volta 1-3 Westinghouse armature 500 400 750 4 Westinghouse field 300 5 General Elec. field 300 South 1 Westinghouse field 225 Inskip 1 Westinghouse field 225 2 Westinghouse field 225 Coleman 1-3 Allis-Chal. field 450

The Transformers

Primary/ Capacity No. Make Cooling Secondary Phases ^Volta 10 Westinghouse air kV 1 300 . 3 General Elec. water kV 1 875 4 Westinghouse water kV 1 3 General Elec. water kV 1 875 South 3 General Elec. water kV 1 Inskip 6 General Elec. water kV 1 Coleman 4 General Elec. water kV 3 BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page AVPENDIX III The Powerhouse Settlements of the Battle Creek Hydroelectric System Because the Battle Creek hydroelectric plants were far from established transportation systems and urban centers, and because transportation in the early twentieth century, when few had automobiles, was slow and uncertain, housing had to be provided for the operators, foremen, and line and ditch inspectors and repairman around each of the Battle Creek powerhouses.

Typically, the operation of a medium size hydroelectric plant like those on Battle Creek required three operators, one for each eight hour shift, plus a foreman and several men to periodically run the ditch and transmission lines. The number, arrangement, and style of the buildings which housed these men differed from plant to plant in the system. But each settlement contained at minimum a clubhouse, a barn, and several individual cottages, while most contained more. The clubhouse, generally a two-story wood structure, with four to six bedrooms, served as the residence, dining hall, and recreation center for unmarried employees at each plant. Ken residing at the clubhouse purchased their meals from the company.

The barn or barns were used to stable the horses used by the men who patrolled and repaired the ditches and high voltage lines. The individual cottages housed the foremen and employees jfith families. All of the Battle Creek settlement structures were wood framed and provided with running water, electricity, and a fireplace for heating. The clubhouses, barns, and the majority of the cottages were erected by company carpenters during the construction of the powerhouse itself. A few of the single family cottages, however, were constructed by their occupants later, using materials supplied by the company, but with Northern California Power retaining ownership of the structure.

In addition to the barns and houses, there were both private and company hen houses, meat sheds, pig pens, wagon sheds, wood sheds, vegetable gardens, and the inevitable outhouses. Volta long had the largest settlement, since it was from Volta that the entire system was controlled. In addition to the usual domestic and animal housing common to all the settlements, Volta had a machine shop, a sawmill, and a blacksmith shop. These supplied the rest of the system with finished lumber and spare parts. Inskip's settlement (the only one substantially intact today was nearly as large as Volta's and had a dancing platform and orchestra platform, built by the operators. [1] The most elaborate residence in the system was Noble's home.

In Noble built a massive circular stone "castle" on the ridge above Volta. [see HAER photo The Noble family resided there until fire destroyed the structure in [2] fee: HAER photos for pictures of the powerhouse settlements HAER drawing,isheet 3 of 20 for maps showing parts of the Volta and Inskip settlements BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page *1] Information on the powerhouse settlements has been gleaned from the following sources: Valuation Survey Field Book 2 Volta, pp. 3 Volta, pp. 5 South, pp. 7 Inskip, pp. 8 Inskip, pp. 10 Coleman, pp. 11, Coleman, pp. 12 Coleman, pp. [2] Sacramento Bee, October 18, p. 16. M.TTLE CREEK j-v & CA-2 ,&Age 8J3 J.0Gi&}?HX Guide: I. Articles, Books, Periodicals A* Articles specifically on the Northern California Power Company B.

Articles on California Hydroelectric Practice generally C. Books D. Newspapers and Periodicals II. California Railroad Commission and California State Mining Bureau Documents A. Published Documents B. Unpublished Documents (California State Archives, CSA) III. Northern California Power Company Annual Reports IV. Pacific Gas and Electric Company Records A. Pacific Gas and Electric Company Annual Reports B. Pacific Gas and Electric Company, Secretary's Office Documents C. Northern California Power Company, Consolidated, Valuation Records (Field Books, etc.), now in PG&E Rates and Valuations Records D. Pacific Gas and Electric Company, Engineering Central Pile Documents E. Pacific Gas and Electric Company, Federal Power Commission Applications F.

Miscellaneous Manuscripts in the Pacific Gas and Electric Company Library V. Other Manuscript Records I. ARTICLES, BOOKS, PERIODICALS A. Articles specifically on the Northern California Power Company "The Coleman Hydroelectric Development on Battle Creek, California," Engineering Record, v. 64 pp. "New License Sought for U.S. Plant," Water Power, v. 23 p. "The Northern California Power Company's Systems. - I. [The Volta Hydroelectric System], Electrical World, v. 44 pp. "The Northern California Power Company's Systems. - II. Kilarc Hydroelectric System," Electrical World, v, 44 pp. "The Northern California Power Company's Systems. - III. High-Tension Transmission System," Electrical World, v. 44 pp. "The Northern California Power Company's Systems. - IV.

The Mammoth Suction Dredge of Horsetown," Electrical World, v. 44 pp. BATTLE CREEK JIAER CA-2 (page "The Northern California Power Company1^ ' x Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas (JE), v. 12 pp. Myrtle, Federick S. "Northern California Power Link of the 'Pacific Service* Chain," Pacific Service Magazine, v. 17 (January pp. "The Volt Transmission Installation Supplying Current to Mines by the Northern California Power Company," Mining Reporter (March 26, pp. Van Norden, Rudolph W. "The Coleman Plant," Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas, v. 27 pp. . "^w Hydroelectric Plant of Northern California Power Co.," Electrical World, v. 59 pp. . "Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," Journal of Electricity. Power and Gas, v. 25 pp.

"The Water Power Plants of the Northern California Power Co.," Engineering Record, v. 50 pp. B. Articles on California Hydroelectric Practice generally and Other Miscellaneous Articles Adams, "Pumping Plants for Rice Irrigation," Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas, v. 37 pp. Chandler, A.E. "Western Laws of Electricity and Water," Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas, v. 28 pp. "The Copper Industry in Shasta County," Overland Monthly, v. 56 pp. De Wald, E.G. "High Pressure Water Wheels, with Particular Reference to the Girard and Francis Turbines," Pacific Coast Electrical Transmission Association, Transactions, v. 8 pp. [Discussion of Papers Presented at the First Hydro-Electric and Second Technical Session, June 9, National Electric Light Association, Convention Proceedings, [v.

3] pp. Doble Co., Aimer. "Doble Tangential Water Wheels," Bulletin no. 7 San Francisco, California, (Copy In PG&E Library) Doble, Robert "Hydro-Electric Power Development and Transmission in California," Association of Engineering Societies, Journal, v. 34 pp. I Downing, Paul M. "High-Tension Network of a Power System," Pacific Gas and Electric Magazine, v. 2 pp. -. "Report of Sub-Committee on Water Power Development on the Pacific Coast," National Electric Light Association, Convention Proceedings, [v. 3] pp. Durand, "The Pelton Water Wheel," Mechanical Engineering, pp. Elwell, "The Bedactloa of Iron Ores by Electricity," Journal of Electricity*. Power and Gas, v* 21 Galloway, John D. "The Design of Hydro-Electric Power Plants," American Society of Civil Engineers, Transactions, v. 79 pp.

. "Hydro-Electric Developments on the Pacific Coast," American Society of Civil Engineers, Proceedings, v. 48 pp. : . "Hydro-Electric Power Plants in California," Journal of Electricity. Power and Gas, v. 29 pp. Grimsley, "Electric Power Plants in the Mining Districts of Northern California," Engineering and Mining Journal, V. 72 pp. ) Henry, George J. "Some Recent High-Head Pelton Water Wheel Installations," Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas, v. 11 pp. , "Some Recent Tangential and Turbine Water Wheel Practice," Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas, v. 22 pp. Homberger, "The Development of the Tangential Water Wheel," Journal of Electricity. Power and Gas, v. 14 pp. Honn, "A County That's An Empire," Sunset, v. 10 (January pp.

"Hydro-Electric Power in Northern and Central California," Western Engineering, v. 9 pp. Jensen, Dave J. "Harnessing Shasta County's 'Liquid Gold,' " The Covered Wagon - (Shasta Historical Society, Redding, California), pp. 68. Jollyman, J. P. "Practice in High-Head Hydraulic Plants," National Electric Light Association, Convention Proceedings, [v. 3] pp. Marfcwart, A.H. "The Story of Power in California," Pacific Service Magazine, v. 17 pp. Martin* John. "Electric Line Distribution Conditions in the Pacific Northwestern States," National Electric Light Association, Convention Proceedings, [v. 3] pp. -_ , "Water-Pawer Developments in California," Pacific Gas and Electric Maaaglake. -y. 1 pp.

w Pelton Water WfaseS Cfer # Feltosi Impulse and Reaction Turbine Installations,' San Frs&el&c , Perrine, Federic A. C. "Hydraulic-Power Development on the Pacific Coast," Cassier's Magazine, v 35 pp. Pfau, Arnold. "High-Head Francis Turbines and Their Operating Records," Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas, v. 40 pp. Van Norden, Rudolph W. "Electric Iron Smelter at Heroult on the Pitt," Journal-of Electricity, Power and Gas, v. 29 pp. Whitney, "Hydro-Electric Power Plants of California," California Journal of Technology, v. 7 (February pp. C. Books Adams, Alton. Electrical Transmission of Water Power, New York: McGraw, Bonner, Frank E. Report to the Federal Power Commission on the Water Powers of California, Washington: G.P.O., California. Department of Water Resources.

Bulletin (Hydroelectric Energy Potential in California), March Coleman, Charles M. and E. of California: The Centennial Story of Pacific Gas and Electric Company New York, etc.: McGraw-Hill, Daugherty, A.H. Horton; and Davenport. Power Capacity and Production in the United States, Washington: G.P.O., [United States Geological Survey, Water-Supply Paper Fowler, Frederick Hall. Hydroelectric Power Systems of California and Their Extensions into Oregon and Nevada, Washington: G.P.O. , [United States Geological Survey, Water-Supply Paper Gannett, Henry. Profiles of Rivers In the United States, Washington: G.P.O., [United States Geological Survey, Water-Supply Paper Awarding, Water in California, Palo Alto, California: n-p Publications, W BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 t (page ^ Hunter, Louis C.

A History of Industrial Rower In the United States, v. 1, ffaterpower in the Century of the Steam Engine, Charlottes ville, Virginia; Eleutberian Mills-Hagley Foundation by the University Press of Virginia* McGlashan, im& . * He&shaat., ffiafcer Resources of California, pt. 1, Stream Measuressents in Sa.craaer.to Biver Basin, Washington: G.P.O., [United States Geological Survey Water-Supply Paper Mead, Daniel W. Water Power Engineering, New York: McGraw-Hill, 2nd ed., Pelton Water Wheel Company. The Pelton Water Wheel, San Francisco: Pelton Water Wheel Company, ed., (Copy in PG&E Library) San Francisco: Its Builders Past and Present, San Francisco: Clarke Publishing Company, Stansfield, Alfred. The Electric Furnace for Iron and Steel, New York: McGraw-Hill, United States.

Bureau of the Census, Historical Statistics of the United States: Colonial Times to - Part I, Washington: G.P.O., Wood, Gazetteer of Surface Waters of California, pt. 1, Sacramento River Basin, Washington: [United States Geological Survey Water-Supply Paper D. Newspapers and Periodicals Frequently Used Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas [JE]. Citations to large articles give only the volume number and year, plus the page numbers. Citations of news items in the Journal of Electricity give not only the volume number and page number, but also the date of the specific issue.

Red Bluff Daily News (Red Bluff, California) Red Bluff News Red Bluff Peoples1 Cause Red Bluff Daily Peoples1 Cause Red Bluff Weekly Peoples' Cause Red Bluff Sentinel Redding Courier Free Press (Redding, California) Redding Free Press BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page Redding Searchlight Redding Semi-Weekly Searchlight San Francisco Call (San Francisco, California) It. CALIFORNIA RAILROAD COMMISSION AND CALIFORNIA STATE MINING BUREAU DOCUMENTS A. Published Documents (page numbers refer to items on the California Railroad Commission Decisions: v. 1 (January 1, to December 31, pp. v. 2 (January 1, to June 30, pp. v. 3 (July 1, to December 31, pp. v. 5 (July 1, to December 31, pp. v. 9 (January 1, to April 30, pp. v. 11 (September 1, to November 30, pp. v. 12 (December 1, to June 30, pp. v.

16 (September 1, to June 30, pp. v. 17 (June 30, to March 31, pp. California Railroad Commission Report; January 1, to June 30, pp. June 30, to June 30, pp. July 1, to June 30, pp. July 1, to June 30, pp. July 1, to June 30, pp. 72, 97, July 1, to June 30, pp. 95, July 1, to June 30, pp. 47, 94, July 1, to June 30, pp. 41, July 1, to June 30, pp. 59, California State Mining Bureau Bulletin 23 (Copper Resources of California) Bulletin 50 (Copper Resources of California) Bulletin 129 (Iron Resources of California) Report of the State Mineralogist Report of the State Mineralogist Report of the State Mineralogist Report of the State Mineralogist Report of the State Mineralogist Report of the State Mineralogist BATTLE CREEK EAER CA-2 (page B.

Unpublished Documents (stored in the California State Archives [CSA]) [These are arranged chronologically] California Railroad Commission.. Transcripts Tof Hearings], application no. 62, 2 vols., consecutively numbered, 44 v. 1: June 24, hearing v. 2: December 28, 1912,hearing California Railroad Commission. "Exhibits," application no. The primary item among the exhibits is: White & Co., "Report on Northern California Power Company Consolidated by White & Co. (to N. W. Halsey & Co., January 29, 102 pp. California Railroad Commission. "Memoranda and Correspondence," application no. California Railroad Commission. "Opinions and Legal Documents," application no. A) "Applicaton of Norther California Power Company for Order Authorizing it to Issue$500,000, 5 yr.

6% debenture notes," filed July 19, B) Transcript [of Hearing], August 14, California Railroad Commission. Transcript [of Hearing], application no. July 24, (filed with "Memoranda and Correspondence"). California Railroad Commission. Transcripts fof Hearings] case nos. and 3 vols., consecutively numbered, 200 v, 1: September 14, ,hearing v. 2: November 4, 1915,hearing v. 3: February 2, 1916,hearing California Railroad Commission. "General Order 38 Report of Northern California Power Company, California Railroad Commission, "Annual Report of the Northern California Power Co, to the Railroad Commission of California, for the 9 mos. ending September 30, 60 pp. III.

NORTHERN CALIFORNIA POWER COMPANY ANNUAL REPORTS (available CSA) Northern California Power Company: First Annual Report, for the Year Ending February 28, Second Annual Report, for the Year Ending February 29, Third Annual Report, for the Year Ending February 28, Fourth Annual Report, for the Year Ending February 28, Fifth Annual Report, for the Year Ending February 28, Sixth Annual Report, for the Year Ending February 29, 'Northern California Power Company, Consolidated: First Annual Report, for the Year Ending October 31, BATTLE CREEK EAER CA-2 (page Second Annual Report, for the Year Ending October 31, Third Annual Report, for the Year Ending October 31, Fourth Annual Report, for the Year Ending October 31, Fifth Annual Beport, for the Year Ending October 31, Sixth Annual Report, for the Year Ending December 31, Seventh Annual Report, for the Year Ending December 31, Eighth Annual Report, for the Year Ending December 31, Ninth Annual Report, for the Year Ending December 31, Tenth Annual Report, for the Year Ending December 31, Note: All of the above can be found in the California State Archives (CSA) with the records of the California Railroad Commission.

The PG&E Library has all of the reports except the First, Second Third, Fourth, and Sixth of the Northern California Power Company. IV. PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY RECORDS A. Pacific Gas and Electric Company Annual Reports Pacific Gas and Electric Company: Twelfth Annual Report, for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, Thirteenth Annual Report, for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, Fourteenth Annual Report, for the Fiscal Year Ended Decmeber 31, B.

Secretary's Office Documents "Agreement Between Pacific Gas and Electric Company and Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," October 3, (document "Amended Application - Application for an Order of the Railroad Commission Authorizing Northern California Power Company, Consolidated to Sell and Pacific Gas and Electric Company to Purchase," August 1, (document "Articles of Incorporation of Northern California Power Company," March 14, (document 2134-a).

"Articles of Incorporation of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," August 24, (document "Articles of Incorporation of the Keswick Electric Power Company," May 9, (document "Certificate of Increase of Capital Stock of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated from to August 3, (document "Certificate of Proceedings Authorizing the Creation of Bonded Indebtedness of Keswick Electric Power Company," March 5, (document BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page "Creation of Bonded Indebtedness of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," November 18, (document "Deed: Keswick Electric Power Company to Northern California Power Company Consolidated," October 26, (document "Deed of Trust: Keswick Electric Power Company to Mercantile Trust Co.

of San Francisco, Trustee," June 1, (document "Deed of Trust: Northern California Power Company," June 1, (document 2257-a). "Deed of Trust: The Sacramento Valley Power Company to Anglo California Trust Company," July 1, (document "Financial agreement between Noble and Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," August 11, (document 2092-a).

"Letter to 'Stockholders of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated* explaining terms of sale to Pacific Gas and Electric Company," June 17, (document "Letter to the Board of Directors of the Northern California Power Company, Consolidated from Edward Whaley, Manager, C," June 9, (document "Northern California Power Company: Certificate of Creation of Bonded Indebtedness," May 26, (docume "Northern California Power Company: Bylaws" (document "Northern California Power Company, Properties Conveyed by Deed, Land Department," October 12, (document "Offer of Pacific Gas and Electric to Detert," June 12, (document "Preamble and Resolutions of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," September 12, (document "Protest and Objections of Stockholders of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated Befone the Railroad Commission of the State of California," August (document "Railroad Commission of the State of California, Application Decision September 23, (document 2092-e).

"Resolution Duly Adopted by the Board of Directors of the Pacific Gas and Electric Company," April 19, (document "Resolution of Board of Directors of Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," July 12, (document "Statement of Edward Whaley regarding debt of Noble to Northern California Power Company, Consolidated," February 25, (document BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page .,:i California Power Company, Consolidated, Valuation v- ;ds -.(atw in Pacific Gas and Electric Company Rates and Valuations Department records) Note: The Rates and Valuations Department of PG&E has in its storage collection a large number of Valuation Survey Field Books (In pencil) dating from the period to The Field Books, apparently from several different valuation surveys, are interfiled and numbered in different ways.

Most are given a number prefixed by an e.g. plus a Field Book number (as Field Book 3). But some have only the "H" number; others have only a Field Book number. It proved impossible to arrange the books in any logical sequence using the numbers printed in Ink on the spines or front covers. Moreover, some of the books were missing. The materials used from the PG&E Rates and Valuations records are therefore listed below by "subject". Volta and Water System Above Volta: PG&E Rates & Valuations Records Box no. Field Book 1 Volta-Buildings (powerhouse) 2 Volta-Outbuildings 3 Volta-Camp Buildings 4 Volta-Factory, Strainer, Governor system, etc. 4 Volta-Penstocks, hydraulic equip. 13 Battle Ck.

Reservoir & ditch surveys 14 Ditches above Volta 15 Ditches above Volta 16 Macumber,Manzanita, ditches above Volta Volta: Ditches, Schooling ditch 17 Ditches above Volta Volta: Equipment, Tools, Stock 18 Macumber Reservoir and Dam 20 North Battle Creek Res. Volta: Forebay Reservoirs & Water System Volta: Misc. Mill Creek Ditch; Ditches above Volta Valuation Detail Folder no. 5: Volta South and South Water System: Field Book 3 Ditches from Volta-South 5 Ditches from Volta-South 5 South: Powerhouse building 6 South: ditches 6 South: Penstocks, Forebay, etc. 7 South Battle Creek Ditch 14 Miscellaneous ditches Computation Folder no. 16, Supporting Valuation Folder #3 (South: tJhion Canal) BATTLE CREEK : \ s HAER CA-2 (page R/V Box Computation Folder no.

17, Supporting Valuation Folder #3 (South: South Battle Creek Canal) Computation Folder no, 18, Supporting Valuation Folder #3 (South: Cross Country Canal) Computation Folder no. 19, Supporting Valuation Folder #3 (South: Fuller Ditch) Computation Folder no. 20, Supporting Valuation Folder #3 (South: Child's Ditch) Inskip and Inskip Water System: Field Book 7 Inskip: Buildings, Powerhouse, etc. 7 Inskip Canal 8 Eagle Canyon-Inskip Foregay 8 Inskip: Forebay, Penstocks, Exciter and Governor systems, etc. 9 Inskip: Ditches 17 Inskip: Equipment, Tools, etc. 20 Inskip: Outside wiring, tools, etc. Computation Folder no. 22, Supporting Valuation Folder #2 (Inskip Penstock) Computation Folder no.

24, Supporting Valuation Folder #2 (Inskip Ditch) Recapitulation (Eagle Canyon Ditch) Coleman and Coleman Water System: Field Book 1 Coleman Canal 2 Coleman Canal 3 Coleman Canal (incl* siphon #1) 4 Coleman Forebay and Canal 9 Coleman: Powerhouse, Buildings 10 Coleman: Outbuildings 11 Coleman: Camp and Outbuildings 12 Coleman: Outbuildings 13 Coleman: Temporary Buildings and Forebay 14 Coleman: Electrical Equipment; Penstocks 15 Coleman: Misc. tools and equip. 16 Coleman: Misc. equipment 21 Coleman: Ditch Apparatus 22 Coleman: Ditch Apparatus 23 Coleman: Ditch Apparatus 24 Coleman: Ditch Apparatus 25 Coleman: Ditch Apparatus Miscellaneous: Field Book 4 Cow Creek Powerhouse 10 Kilarc Powerhouse 11 Kilarc Powerhouse 12 Kilarc Powerhouse BATTLE GREEK.

HAER CA-2 (page -"* R/V Bex Field "Book ,15 Sao:1 Creek Fowejtfiuuae 16 Snow Creek Powerhouse 18 Miscellaneous 02 19 Miscellaneous #3 "Pitt River Construction Records" White Co. Valuation Survey: Power Plant Cost Data" D. Pacific Gas and Electric Company: Engineering Central File Documents Volta (Records Center Box no- South (Records Center Box no. Inskip (Records Center Box no. Coleman (Records Center Box no. Honfcerger, Heinrich. "Efficiency Test Units No. 1 & 2, Inskip Power House, December 1st and with attached letters from file Most of the data in these files are short letters which deal with alterations made to the Battle Creek powerhouses after PG&E's acquisition of the system. E.

Pacific Gas and Electric Company: Federal Power Commission Applications for the Battle Creek Hydroelectric System: Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Exhibits "I", and "H" of [Application to Federal Power Commission relative to Battle Creek System], November 10, (Attached to J.O. Burrage to A.H. Markward, November 10, Engineering Central Files) Pacific Gas and Electric Company. "Application of Pacific Gas and Electric Company for a License for Project No. California [Battle Creek System], filed September 12, Pacific Gas and Electric Company. "Application of Pacific Gas and Electric Company for License before the Federal Power Commission: Battle Creek System Project October 31, F.

Miscellaneous Manuscripts in the Pacific Gas and Electric Company Library: "Chronology of Northern California Power Co. Aativites in Big Bend of Pit River: Pit 5 Project," 2 page manuscript, May Downing, "Some Historical Aspects of the Development of Hydroelectric Power in California," 27 page manuscript. Prepared in for delivery to Newcomen Society of North America, never delivered due to World War II. BATTLE CREEK HAER CA-2 (page Goldsworthy, Paul A. ~ *^ro<-Electr c Development Pacific Gas and Electric Company and Subsidiaries". Basically installation records of PG&E hydroelectric plants with attached bibliographies. "Northern California Power Company Scrapbook of Newspaper Clippings". Clippings dated to source of clippings not indicated on most clippings; date not indicated on some.

Other Manuscript Records

Arthur Jeff coat. Letter Copy Book. Used with the permission of the present owner Mr. Leroy Freemyers, Red Bluff, California. Letters and requisitions dating from between August 13, and July 31, Lind, Nancy. "The Use of Manzanita Lake for Water Storage, 15 page MS, (Tehama County Library, Red Bluff, California) A high school term paper. Carl J. Rhodin Papers, California Water Resources Library, University of California, Berkeley. Rhodin was employed by the White Co. and reviewed construction projects of the Northern California Power Company in for White. There are four letters in the Rhodin papers dealing with the Northern California Power Company's work. Scott, Mike.

"The History of the Hat Creek-Lost Creek Diversions, 18 page MS, (Tehama County Library, Red Bluff, California) A high school term paper. ADDENDUM: Myrtle, Frederick S. "From the Mountains of Oregon to the Bay of San Francisco: By Inter-Connection of Three High-Tension Transmission Systems," Pacific Service Magazine, v. 10 pp. Steele, E.H. "The 'Pacific Service* End of the Oregon-California Chain of High-Tension Transmission Systems," Pacific Service Magazine, v. 11 pp. ADDENDUM TO: HAER CA-2 BATTLE CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM HAER CAL,52-REBLU.V,1- (Coleman Power House) (Inskip Power House) (South Power House) (Volta Power House) Battle Creek & Tributaries Red Bluff vicinity Tehama County California FIELD RECORDS HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD National Park Service U.S.

Department of the Interior C Street NW Washington, DC

In context

Red Bluff, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Tehama County, California 216 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Red Bluff

1 record

The federal surveyors worked through Red Bluff building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Red Bank Creek BridgeHAER CAL,52-REBLU.V,2-3,436 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CAL,52-REBLU.V,1-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.