BlockBefore

Sheldon Building, 9-15 First Street, San Francisco

Sheldon Building, 9-15 First Street, San Francisco, San Francisco County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,165-, with a 2,949-word written history.

From the record

“The Sheldon Building was built within a year after the earthquake and is an early example of a major downtown structure utilizing reinforced concrete as a building material.”

Written record, HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,165- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,165- · the record runs 2949 words · one of 382 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

2837 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,165-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Sheldon Building was built within a year after the earthquake and is an early example of a major downtown structure utilizing reinforced concrete as a building material. The architect of the building, Benja- min G. McDougall, was an important designer in the San Francisco Bay Area with the first Standard Oil building on Bush Street in San Francisco to his credit. Of equal if not greater importance was the building's engineer, John B. Leonard. Leonard was a leader in the use of reinforced concrete in California. The Sheldon Building is well proportioned and stands as a fine example of a turn-of-the-century office building. The building is rated "B" in Splendid Survivors, the com- prehensive historic resources survey of downtown San Francisco.

A "B" rating indicates eligibility for listing on the National Register of Historic Places. Although not evaluated as part of the San Francisco City Plan- ning Department's Architectural Inventory, the Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 2) Sheldon Building is included on the city's list of "Archi- tecturally and/or Historically Significant Buildings in the C-3 Zoning Districts" endorsed by the City Planning Commission on May 29, PART

Historical Information

Physical History Date of Erection: Architect: Benjamin G, McDougall Original Owner: Mark Sheldon Co. Subsequent Owners: The Sheldon Building has experienced a number of prop- erty transactions over the years. In the main, however, ownership of the property has been concentrated in relatively few hands: the Sheldon Office Building Com- pany, Sheldon Associates, and Sheldon Management Company retained ownership in different combinations until when the latter company sold the property to Milton Meyer. In the next ten years prop- erty ownership changed back and forth among three principal owners Fremont Properties, Walter H. and Phyllis J. Shorenstein, and Transameriea Title Insurance Company.

In two transactions took place: Trans- ameriea Title Insurance Company sold the property to Calishun, Inc. and a few days later on Calishun sold it to the present owners, Centra- land, Inc. Builder/Contractor: John B. Leonard, Engineer Lindgren-Hicks Company, Builders Original Plans and Construction: A microfilm set of building permit drawings exists for the building including floor plans, construction details, Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 3) elevations, and exterior and interior details. The full set, in microfilm and in 24 x 36 size reproductions, re- sides with International Land, Inc. (Ill Pine Street, San Francisco, California). A selected number have been reproduced for archival purposes and are a part of this record.

Alterations and Additions: The Sheldon Building has been remodeled over its 25-year history. The majority of alterations been made to the interior office floors and to the ground floor retail spaces to accommodate changing tenants with different needs for space. A major change to the exterior took place in when the metal cornice at the roof line was removed. Presumably, the decorative cartouches in the attic story were also removed at this time although no such mention is made of it in the building permit records. In and again in major changes occurred to the storefronts on Market and First Streets. In both years, existing storefronts were removed completely and re- placed.

In this was done with new aluminum and glass and, in addition, the building lobby was remodeled and extended through the building to a new adjoining plaza created by the demolition of the adjacent build- ing. Although the building permit records are not clear, it is presumed that windows were installed in the now exposed east facade at this time. Historical Context The present Sheldon Building is the second building to occupy the site replac- ing an earlier structure destroyed by the earthquake and fire. Prior to the earthquakes, the site and vicinity were fully developed with a mixture of uses including industrial, commercial, and residential. The site itself was gen- Sheldon Building HABS No.

CA-2203 (Page 4) erally under water before and was barely "on shore" by according to base maps showing the shoreline configurations for these two periods of time. The post-earthquake/fire period in San Francisco represented a time of rapid rebuilding and the increased use of more modern construction materials and methods such as reinforced concrete. Only two buildings built of reinforced concrete existed prior to 78 were built immediately after the earth- quake/fire. The Sheldon Building was among the first of the major reinforced concrete buildings built in the area destroyed by the disaster. Rebuilding in the vicinity occurred into the early Most of these buildings remained until the when high-rise office structures began to replace them.

The Sheldon Building is one of the last "post-1906" structures left on this portion of Market Street. Both the architect, Benjamin G. MeDougall, and the engineer, John B. Leon- ard, must be credited for using reinforced concrete so soon after the earth- quake/fire. Benjamin G. MeDougall began his architectural career as a draftsman in his father's architectural firm of MeDougall and Son. He became an architect in and began his own firm two years later. In he went into partnership with his brothers Charles C. and George B. MeDou- gall. (The latter brother went on to become the State Architect for Cali- fornia, a position he held at the time of Benjamin McDougall's death in Benjamin G.

McDougall's practice included a number of buildings in Fresno, California, in addition to his designs for structures in the San Francisco Bay Area, A list of his work includes the Standard Oil Building at 200 Bush Street, the Central YMCA at 220 Golden Gate Avenue, and apartments at 800 and 901 Bush Street, all in San Francisco; in Oakland, the Federal Realty Building at Telegraph and Broadway and St. Paul's Church; in Berkeley, the Berkeley YMCA, St. Luke's Church, and the Shattuck Hotel. John B. Leonard was a native of Union City, Michigan. His educa- tion in civil engineering was at Michigan State, the University of Illinois, and the University of Michigan.

He came to California in during the "Boom of the After a year in Los Angeles, he came north to San Francisco in Employed as a draftsman and civil engineer by several firms through the Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 5) years, he opened his own office as a consulting civil engineer in Though his education had been in steel engineering, by he began to promote himself as specializing in reinforced concrete. For the next quarter century, Leonard was certainly among the leaders in the development of reinforced concrete technology in California, and may have been the material's leading proponent. Apart from his engineering work, he was an Associate Editor for Architect and Engineer, and used his position to promote reinforced concrete engineering.

He was instrumental in securing changes in San Francisco's build- ing codes to allow use of the material. He lectured up and down the West Coast, and in New York. He was frequently sought as an inspector in building failures. He worked to establish closer relations between architects and engi- neers, and to ensure quality control in reinforced concrete construction. From to he served as Superintendent of Building Inspection in San Fran- cisco, returning to private practice until his death in His legacy includes 46 bridges throughout California (many of which are still in use and one of which Fernbridge in Humboldt County has been designated a National His- toric Civil Engineering Landmark), as well as buildings in the Bay Area and in Los Angeles.

Mark Sheldon was a San Francisco businessman who like many others made his money initially in gold and silver and later invested in the city's real estate. Sheldon first arrived in San Francisco in and stayed on to work in Marysville, California, both as an employee of a mining company and as the proprietor of his own mining supply store. His return to San Francisco (exact date unknown) saw him engaged in minor commercial ventures including importing goods from the East Coast. In he and several partners (including H. G. Blaisdell, later governor of Nevada) built an ore mill in Seven Mile Canyon just below Virginia City, Nevada. The success of the mill led to other mining-related investments, the last of which was the Empire Mill and Mining Company. John Snyder, Unpublished paper on John B.

Leonard, Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 6) Sheldon's real estate activity in San Francisco began with the purchase of the southeast corner of Kearny and Commercial Streets. He subsequently owned property on Washington Street and purchased the southeast corner of Market and First Streets upon which, in he built the first Sheldon Building.

Part Ii. Architectural Information

General Statement The Sheldon Building is an eight-story office building with a basement and two interior light wells. As described by the architect in Architect and Engineer of California (November p. "It is to be of reinforced concrete faced with buff terra eotta [only the entranceway was treated in this way, the rest of the building was finished in cement], and will be feet deep with a frontage on Market Street of 91 feet 8 inches. The exterior is treated in a style that has been evolved for office buildings in this country and which lends itself well to a structure that must have abundance of light. The orna- ment has been concentrated at the first story and at the cornice.

The effect of repetition is broken by a slight offset of the two bays at either end of the facade, these breaks being emphasized by the addition of cartouches immedi- ately below the capitals of the three end pilasters [a subsequent design change put the cartouches in the attic story above the capitals]. The ornamental treatment in the first story is confined to the entrances to the offices which occupy the six [later changed to seven] upper floors of the building. The main entrance which will be on First Street is given a simple Doric treatment, with banded columns supporting an entablature that ties in and lines up with the heavy belt course which marks the top of the first story.

The Market Street side, while a little smaller, is treated in the same general style, having pilasters instead of columns the entablature being the same as for the main entrance" (also subsequently changed Market Street had columns and al- though still considered to be the secondary entrance had a much more sub- stantial appearance than the First Street entrance). Both facades are divided into nine vertical shafts and three horizontal divi- sions consisting of a ground floor, a six-story shaft, and a one-story attic level. Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 7) The Market Street (north) facade is balanced, consisting of two end bays con- taining two vertical shafts, flanking five shafts of regular vertical strips of windows.

The First Street facade also consists of two bays flanking five shafts of, in this case, irregular vertical strips of windows. The Doric treatment of the entranceways and all of the ground floor including the belt course above it has been removed. The attic level has, in similar fashion, been modernized through the removal of the cornice and decorative cartouches. The capitals of the pilasters still remain showing the egg-and-dart treatment of the echinus. The integrity of the Sheldon Building has been compromised although its basic form remains intact. The building had little in the way of decorative elements and gains its strength from the overall composition of its major elements. Description of Exterior ! Foundation: Reinforced concrete 2. Walls: Reinforced concrete with cement finish.

Terra cotta was used in the entranceways 3. Structural Systems: Reinforced concrete with reinforced concrete walls and floors 4. Porches, Stoops, Balconies, Bulkheads; Not applicable 5 * Chimneys: Not applicable 6. Openings: All windows are double hung, one over one, and are found in four different compositions: singly, in equal pairs, three together either all equal or with two smaller flanking a larger, and four together all of equal dimension. Two light courts extend from the second floor to the top of the building! skylights on the second floor allow light to penetrate to the ground level retail stores. 7. Roof: A flat, composition roof. A small penthouse covers the elevator shaft. Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 8) Description of Interior 1.

Floor Plans: The ground floor was originally planned for five stores, four facing Market Street and one taking its entry off of First Street. The main corridor came back from First Street to the elevators and main stairway. It was joined at this point by the "entrance corridor" extending perpendicularly from Market Street. The main corridor was remodeled and extended through to the other side of the building in The demise of the entrance corridor is unknown although an educated conclusion might be that it was removed in when the ground floor was remodeled for a savings and loan office. It remains in that configuration today. The typical upper floor plan consisted of 27 offices all having exterior light from either the street facade or from a light court.

The original floor plan remains basically intact with varying degrees of modifications over the years. 2. Stairways; The main stairway in the main corridor/lobby consisted of Verde Antique marble walls, White Cloud marble base, treads, and risers with metal balustrade and mahogany rail. This has been remodeled so that only the marble tread and risers remain. The upper floors still have the original treat- ment although the walls were finished in plaster and not in marble. Several other minor stairways are located in various parts of the building. 3. Flooring: The original flooring was marble. Most floors are now covered with asphalt tile or are carpeted. 4. Wall and Ceiling Finish: Verde Antique marble was used in the lobby area; subsequently remodeled.

Original plans show special treatment for offices on the eighth floor (see drawing but none of this treatment remains. Typical office partitions were plaster with wood doors with either a Florentine glass panel or wood panel, and a glass transom of similar material. Ceilings were plaster, although now many are covered with acoustical tile. 5. Hardware: All hardware has been replaced, although the bronze mail chute is intact. Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 9) r Site and Surroundings The Sheldon Building occupies the southeast corner of Market and First Streets. It now sits among numerous new high-rise office buildings and is the last "post-1906" building fronting on Market Street for several blocks. PART m.

Project Information

Current plans call for demolition of the Sheldon Building in early This historical documentation was prepared by Hisashi B. Sugaya of Sugaya and Frej and Jane Lidz, Photographer, in November and includes a historical report, photodocumentation, and documentation of reproductions of the drawings filed for the original building permit.

Bibliography

The Architect and Engineer. Volume No. 2, August The Foundation for San Francisco's Architectural Heritage. Building and Architect files. Leonard, John B. "The Use of Reinforced Concrete In San Francisco and Vicinity," Architect and Engineer. Volume 25, No. 2, March McDougall, Benjamin G. "Seven-Story Reinforced Concrete Office Building." Architect and Engineer. November San Francisco City Planning Commission. Central Plaza Project Environmen- tal Impact Report. Sheldon, Mark. Mark Sheldon, an Autobiographical Sketch. The Murdock Press, San Francisco. No date. Snyder, John. Unpublished paper on John B, Leonard. Originals for the following reduced copies of drawings can be found in the Library of Congress. Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 10) itr ! : Liii I i 4L J ILilJLJ1:.

ii -1J U UllUlLi r L=L Bllu rriJirnaiiiJiDa^DE 8 : i if rill 'i^ ;Hfinuanni ^!. L i i liLDuiranmrcanLu^. lililL.!.M#, n T flu !; 11EJJ1 IIEME^ t- ; i, I "Hi :J i licul.li-.;."<'i; 1 !' > TT l!P 1 lf \ H/\i3S f^o. Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203~(Page 11) ' .,- y :'*&-?Ti-,:i --,"?-"Wi " ".-IT .r-ztotii - . "' i r. r-' IT n r. "t*co - ! ! !1 * :;; *; JM !- i-_ i'' li~^- i ' r. 5 -= [ ( i : ii i 1 :' : i ' - - i; ;' ' \ ; 1 ' 11 11 1 .. .J. . 1 i 1 i, Ill i-j" I. i 1 ' ^^Pllllliliill " ' an - . v<- T i. * *. H **S No.CA-2203 Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 12) Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 13) ... ... .-. r-rt---v^^5i^A ' * . :$m g&?>':i < , ' ; \:> _-^i Sheldon tfuixaxng HABS No. CA-2203 (Page 14) v . N * V ' 1 K 1 \ 1 i ' r - H i ;j _ - > atB " - ' '" , * i .

i .< -t -Si? -, i -. i-' ' J V$S-i!;|.*;rrri--r?--|!ir i: 4 Eiffel F;' " . . , .= ... , , USS (Jo- V' 1:. "I- Mo- CA-220? Sheldon Building HABS No. CA-2203 16) WAIs r^> CA-220J Sheldon Building HABS No. .GA-2203 (Page 17) Sheldon Building HAES No. CA (Page 18) c*-ZS.aj snej-don mulcting HABS No. CA-2203 19) , - ; v Ijj"-. . "jf ij ]iJi^.v:;'"H|lj.

In context

San Francisco, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Francisco County, California 67 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in San Francisco

24 of 381 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through San Francisco building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
San Francisco Oakland Bay BridgeHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,141-127,296 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHAER CA-227086,796 words
Ship BalcluthaHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,200-80,588 words
Market StreetHALS CA-16434,536 words
San Francisco Cable RailwayHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,137-30,695 words
Aquatic ParkHALS CA-11328,000 words
George Washington High SchoolHABS CA-293919,932 words
Sloop Yacht KathleenHAER CA-229919,410 words
Fort FunstonHAER CAL,38-SANFRA, 214A-16,940 words
Schooner C.A. THAYERHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,199-16,891 words
North Beach PlaceHABS CA-272716,167 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,211-14,693 words
Pier 16 & Bulkhead BuildingHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,142-14,202 words
Jewish Community Center of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,204-14,088 words
Knights of Pythias BuildingHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,172-13,633 words
City of Paris Dry Goods CompanyHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,135-11,407 words
Ferry EUREKAHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,194-11,248 words
Hunters Point Naval ShipyardHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,195A-10,629 words
Hunters Point Naval ShipyardHAER CA-227310,046 words
Steam Tug HERCULESHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,201-9,787 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,177-9,564 words
California State BuildingHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,202-9,200 words
Fort MasonHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,9A-9,188 words
Presidio Water Treatment PlantHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,197-8,476 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,165-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.