BlockBefore

Scow Schooner ALMA, Hyde Street Pier, San Francisco

Scow Schooner ALMA, Hyde Street Pier, San Francisco, San Francisco County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,198-, with a 7,827-word written history.

From the record

“ALMA is the only extant San Francisco Bay scow schooner.”

Written record, HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,198- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,198- · the record runs 7827 words · one of 382 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

89 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,198-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

ALMA is the only extant San Francisco Bay scow schooner. More than four hundred of these craft were built for service on San Francisco Bay and its tributaries between and The scow schooners carried cargo and served to connect the many communities of the San Francisco Bay area before the construction of major bridges and the advent of widespread commercial trucking. The waterborne link provided by the scow schooners was a key to the region's economic growth. Researcher: Marc R. Porter, SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 2)

Written history

7566 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,198-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

This project is part of the Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) Eric DeLony, Chief, a long-range program to document historically significant engineering and industrial works in the United States. The HAER program is administered by the Historic American Buildings Survey/Historic American Engineering Record Division (HABS/HAER) of the National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior, E. Blaine Cliver, Chief. The project was prepared under the direction of HAER Maritime Program Manager Todd Croteau. The historical report was produced by Marc Porter, and edited by Richard O'Connor and Justine Christianson, HAER Historians. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 3) Significance ALMA is the only extant San Francisco Bay Scow Schooner.

More than four hundred of these craft were built for service on San Francisco Bay and its tributaries between and The scow schooners were flat-bottomed, shallow draft, centerboard vessels mounting a schooner rig. The scow schooners carried cargo and served to connect the many communities of the San Francisco Bay area before the construction of major bridges and the advent of widespread commercial trucking. The waterborne link provided by the scow schooners was a key to the region's economic growth. Principal Dimensions Length: 59' -0 11 Gross tons: 41 Breadth: 22' -6 11 Net tons: 39 Depth: 4 ' - 0 11 Designer There is no specific designer listed in any historical documents relating to the ALMA.

Most scow schooners were vernacular vessels built without formal plans and along lines dictated by the builder's prior experience. It is probable that the builder, with input from the eventual owner, constructed ALMA as he saw fit rather than according to a separate designer's specifications. 1 Builder and Location Men that took a turn at building scows ranged from anonymous amateur carpenters to noted luminaries of West Coast shipbuilding such as Matthew Turner. In addition to a multitude of builders, the industry was characterized by a plethora of building locations. Scow schooners were built throughout the San Francisco Bay area; they came together on ways in yards and 1Roger Olmstead, Scow Schooners of San Francisco Bay (Cupertino, CA: California History Center, 22; Barbara J.

Fetesoff, "San Francisco's Alma," WoodenBoat Magazine 1, no. 3 10. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 4) vacant lots from within sight of the Golden Gate to the banks of the Sacramento River. 2 Despite the decentralized nature of the industry, one area, Hunters Point in San Francisco, was a locus of building activity and home to many prominent scow builders. Throughout the last decades of the nineteenth century and the first decade of the twentieth century, dozens of these vessels were constructed or repaired in this neighborhood each year. 3 As is perhaps befitting the last of a once prolific breed, the ALMA took shape on the shores of Hunters Point in the heyday of scow building.

Fred Siemer built the ALMA in the yard behind his house in the Hunter's Point area of San Francisco for his son-in-law, James Peterson. In addition to ALMA, Fred Siemer built the scow schooner ADELIA, named after Siemer's daughter and Peterson's wife, for James Peterson. The ALMA and ADELIA were the only two vessels known to have been constructed from keel up by Fred Siemer. His normal activities centered on the repair of existing vessels rather than new construction. 4 Fred Siemer emigrated to the United States from Northern Germany in about His wife and six children accompanied Siemer in the move to America. There do not appear to be any surviving accounts detailing the route or modes of transportation used by the Siemer family in their move.

His first home in California was Tulare County and later the family moved to San Francisco. 5 Before moving to the United States, Siemer worked as a foreman in a Bremerhaven shipyard. His knowledge of shipbuilding stood him in good stead in his new home. Siemer first secured employment in San Francisco as a ship carpenter at the Montgomery Street Shipyard and later bought the Hunter's Point yard in which he built ALMA. 6 A loan of from Hanson's Hog Ranch furthered Siemer's efforts to establish a shipyard. 7 There is no explanation in the 2 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 19. 3 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 22; Anita Mozley, "Scow Schooners of San Francisco Bay," Sea Letter 5, no. 1 4 Fetesoff, "San Francisco's Alma," 10. 5 Barbara J.

Fetesoff, "The Scow Schooner Alma, A History" (Master's thesis, San Jose State University, 8. 6 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 7 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 8. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 5) historical record that offers insight into why a hog ranch was involved in providing start-up capital to a fledgling shipyard. It appears to be a somewhat incongruous financial relationship, and one that remains a mystery. Almost every source relating to the ALMA names Fred Siemer as the builder, his granddaughter as the vessel's namesake, and his son- in-law as the owner. There is, however, a single citation that contradicts the generally accepted scenario. An obituary published by the San Francisco Examiner on December 8, names the Anderson & Company Shipyard as ALMA's builder.

According to the obituary, ALMA was built under the direction of Hans Peter Anderson, a shipbuilder originally from Denmark who arrived in San Francisco in aboard the clipper ship DAVY CROCKETT out of New York. The Anderson yard was founded in a year after the ALMA is generally thought to have been constructed. 8 There was a Hunters Point shipyard run by the Anderson family and it did, in fact, produce a number of scow schooners. 9 Moreover, Alma appears to be a family name in the Anderson family. 10 Despite these bits of corroborative evidence, the version of events offered in the Examiner article appears inaccurate. The preponderance of information, developed by several researchers using documentary, photographic, and oral history sources, points to Siemer as the builder.

There is no clear explanation for the errors printed by the San Francisco Examiner other than befuddled memory or misunderstanding by a newspaper reporter. 11 Date of Construction Fred Siemer completed ALMA in The exact date construction began is unknown, as is the date of completion. Original Price No extant records detail the cost of constructing ALMA. Likewise, there are no hints as to her original purchase price. 8 San Francisco Examiner, 8 December 9 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 22. 10 San Francisco Examiner, 8 December 11 Stephen Canright (San Francisco Maritime Park), Letter to Author, August SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No.

CA-60 (Page 6) Even if there were surviving records pertaining to this subject, the familial connection between builder and owner might obscure the costs incurred by the average purchaser of a scow schooner. Original Construction ALMA is an excellent example of a scow schooner; she is representative of the group as a whole and in one important construction detail as part of a distinct and significant subset. It is perhaps best to begin with the features ALMA has in common with the majority of the type before progressing to the unique feature found in a small number of peers. ALMA's design, while never formally recorded for posterity by her builder, was nonetheless anything but haphazard or coincidental. The planned use dictated the shape of the finished vessel.

She was meant to carry large amounts of bulk cargo in shallow waters. Not only would she need to clear shallow spots along trading routes but her travels would carry her into areas where tidal or seasonal fluctuations might often require the vessel to actually rest on the bottom during low tides. Her trips upon the area's waterways would involve maneuvering in confined areas. Trading voyages would also require ALMA to sail to windward at times. The nature of the cargo she would carry made deck loads the most suitable carrying method and required a high degree of initial stability to prevent the cargo from shifting or even toppling overboard as a consequence of a freshening breeze.

While the ability to navigate on San Francisco Bay was extremely important, the vessel was not intended for use on the open ocean and was not built to survive in that environment. Local mariners built and operated scow schooners as business ventures and, as such, economic efficiency was paramount. The costs of building the vessels could not be prohibitively expensive when compared with the income they would generate. Beyond construction costs, owners minimized operating costs by designing and building scow schooners so small crews could handle them. The shape resulting from these prerequisites was a typical scow shape: a beamy, shallow draft vessel with a flat bottom, transom ends, and hard chines. ALMA's length-to-beam ratio and flat bottom provided high initial stability.

The flat bottom and attendant shallow draft made it possible to access shoal areas and rest on the bottom in an upright orientation during loading SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 7) operations. The transom or square ends improved the vessel's maneuverability. While the flat bottom makes for ease of loading and shallow draft, it does have certain drawbacks. A keel-less vessel is very prone to leeway or sideways slippage when sailing. A vessel shaped like the ALMA and mounting no underwater appendages would tend to slip downwind as much as it would progress in the direction of its heading. To counteract this problem, scow builders constructed their craft with centerboards.

These long fins are raised or lowered through a trunk along the centerline of the vessel and serve to minimize leeway while sailing. In some sailing vessel designs, the centerboard is in an offset position. In San Francisco Bay scow schooners, however, the centerboard trunk typically passed through the keel. The greatest advantage of the centerboard design is that while it can serve the same hydrodynamic purpose as a fixed keel, it can also retract to minimize draft and allow intentional grounding. In the early years of sailing scow use in the region a few scows were sloop rigged, but the most common rig was a two-masted schooner carrying a topmast on the main. 12 AlMA's rig was typical. She outfitted as a gaff-rigged schooner, meaning she carried a mainsail, foresail, and jib.

The advantage of the schooner rig is twofold. First, the fore-aft orientation of the sails allows the vessel to sail to windward. Second, the division of sail area into several sails makes individual sails smaller and easier to manage by small crews, but incurs no loss of overall sail area. In addition to the three lower sails, there is evidence that, like the vast majority of her peers, ALMA carried a topmast atop the mainmast. 13 This offered the opportunity to fly a topsail when conditions were right. Many scow schooners on the West Coast could also mount a fisherman sail. This is a loose-footed sail flown off the deck between the masts. ALMA may have carried a fisherman, but if so, it went up the mast only rarely, as was the case with all scow schooners.

Most accounts suggest that the fisherman only went up the mast on special occasions, such as races, when the extra crew could properly handle the sail. 14 Like virtually all scow schooners built in the area, ALMA was 12 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 14. 13 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 11. 14 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 72. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 8) built out of locally available wood. In ALMA's case the building material was Douglas fir, also known as Oregon pine, that was free of knots. ALMA's timbers came from the Pope and Talbot Lumber Company and almost certainly originated in that company's vast holdings in the Pacific Northwest. 15 The timbers purchased from Pope and Talbot were hand fashioned and joined to form a frame to which planks were joined.

Fastenings in the form of bolts came from the Hendry ship chandlery. The same supplier provided the oakum used to seal the gaps between planks. ALMA was built with ceiling and hull planking of varying dimensions. A single level deck stretched over the entire length and breadth of the vessel. This created a cargo hold, accessible by a hatch, and more important, created a large, flat main deck for carrying bulk cargo. The scow's hull was white as were all those in Peterson's fleet; most other scow hulls were red or green. 16 The steering mechanism consisted of a wheel linked to the rudder by a system of pulleys and lines led to a rudder stock. ALMA's wheel could be raised well above its normal position at deck level if the helmsman needed a new vantage point to see over stacked cargo.

In addition to the masts, ALMA's spars included booms for the gaff-rigged sails, a jib boom, topmast, and a bowsprit. There is no surviving historical information regarding these structures. However, the time period, their relatively small size, and the abundance of local timber suggest they were probably fashioned of solid lengths of Douglas fir or other pine rather than laminate or sectional construction. Mounted on the after portion of ALMA's main deck, just forward of the helm, was the vessel's only cabin. This space was roughly 8' x 12' and served as the living and galley space for the entire crew. It contained bunks, a stove, and a table. 17 As originally built, ALMA carried little in the way of machinery.

A hand-operated windlass provided the only source of mechanical advantage used by the crew other than simple block and tackle. 18 15 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 76; Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 10. 16 Olmstead, Scow Schooners," 48. 17 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 11. 18 Fetesoff, "San Francisco's Alma," 10. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 9) In the available sources there is no mention of pumps aboard the vessel. This probably reflects a gap in the historical record rather than reality as scow sailors would have needed some way to free the hull of water and most scow schooners mounted a diaphragm bilge pump with several intakes.

19 As noted previously, ALMA had much in common with other San Francisco Bay Scow Schooners of the day but she was also significantly different in one regard. The most common orientation for bottom planking on these vessels was fore-aft. This simply means that the hull planking on the scows ran parallel to the keel and perpendicular to the frames. ALMA did not have fore-aft bottom planking. Rather, she was planked athwartships, or "cross-planked." This type of construction was also termed "log-built" because of the thick timbers used for the bot tom planking. 20 "Cross-planking," much like any other choice of competing alternatives, carries with it certain advantages and certain disadvantages.

On the negative side, "cross-planking" resulted in a vessel that produced more drag as it passed through the water. It also necessitated removal of the entire plank if any portion suffered damage; fore-aft planked vessels could be patched without removal of entire planks. A third disadvantage was that fore-aft vessels could be finer in the ends while their cross-planked cousins were limited to a more boxlike shape. Finally, there was the perception that "log-built" scows were somehow less handy or maneuverable than other scows. 21 Positive attributes linked to "cross-planking" included a lower price tag for the construction of the vessel. Maritime historian Howard I. Chapelle, writing about scows in general, noted that construction" ...

requires cross-planking on the bottom; longitudinal planking almost invariably adds greatly to the cost and labor of construction. Scows with athwartships bottom planking were cheaper because their interior structure was simpler with fewer frames and an absence of floors. Furthermore, the planking itself did not require steaming to fit the shape of the hull. Beyond savings during construction, "cross-planked" scows were reputed to be sturdier than their counterparts. 23 19 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 72. 20 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, II 10. 21 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 76. 22 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 71. 23 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 71. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 10) Despite their economy and sturdiness, "cross-planked" scows were not the norm on San Francisco Bay.

According to the Historic American Merchant Marine Survey (HAMMS), most scows found in the area were of the fore-aft planked variety. 24 This is contrary to patterns seen elsewhere in North America. No historian has offered a fully developed explanation for this deviation from normal building patterns. The only proffered suggestions are those given by Roger Olmstead in his history of the type. Roger Olmstead, citing an old scow builder, suggests that ''cross- planking" may not have been as rare as suggested by the HAMMS reports. He also suggests that the "cross-planked" scow's reputation as poor performers limited its production in the San Francisco Bay area.

These explanations are intriguing but somewhat contradictory, and Olmstead does not offer an in-depth explanation of either in his history of San Francisco Bay scow schooners. 25 Pursuing two avenues of inquiry could solve the contradictions regarding the prevalence of the two bottom planking types. If a significant number of scow remains were located and studied, it could yield a determination about the incidence of each type. An examination of builder's plans would yield similar information. Both avenues, however, are closed. Builder's plans were rare or entirely nonexistent in the local scow building industry, and there are no scows left to study, not even derelict hulks. ALMA was a vessel well suited to her intended trade.

Relatively inexpensive to build, she was sturdy and a crew of two or three could safely man the vessel. The fore-aft rigging and the centerboard meant she could work her way to windward. Her shallow draft and flat bottom allowed her in any water deeper than 4'; the flat bottom also permitted her to rest upright while aground. ALMA looked like little more than a simple raft with sails, but she was, in fact, an efficient economic competitor able to move large amounts of freight at a low cost. Alterations and Additions From the time of her launch until July ALMA served as a sail powered, bulk cargo carrier. During this period changes to the vessel were limited to repairs required by normal wear and 24 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 71. 25 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 71. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No.

CA-60 (Page 11) accidental mishaps; no major modifications are recorded for the period. In James Peterson stripped ALMA of masts and bowsprit as a conversion from sailing vessel to barge. At this time the main hatch into the hold was enlarged. The vessel served as a barge carrying bulk cargo for eight years. 26 ALMA's owner converted her from barge to an oyster shell dredger in Her new occupation took advantage of the bay's numerous oyster beds, but not as a source of seafood. ALMA's owner was not trying to obtain live oysters for human consumption; instead, he was targeting the dead portions of the oyster beds. The empty oyster shells were hauled up and eventually sold as agricultural products or building materials.

The shells were most often sold to the egg industry based in Petaluma, California. The calcium rich shells became an important additive in chicken food, one that promoted the development of strong eggshells. The vessel's conversion to a dredger entailed extensive alterations. ALMA traded her sails for mechanical power with the addition of a forty-horsepower gasoline engine turning a single propeller. The engine was offset to port of the keel. Bulwarks reaching 8' above the main deck were added and shell washing machinery was installed. The conversion also included the construction of living quarters and a raised wheelhouse. 27 The conversion also included the installation of equipment for dredging operations.

A 4" column pump, powered by a four- cylinder gas engine, sucked shells off the bottom and fed them onto a trammel leading to the rinsing station. Twin gasoline powered pumps provided water for rinsing the shells. The rinsed shells moved to the holding bin via a conveyor belt suspended on one end by a newly installed mast and boom. Finally, a slip- scraper distributed the load within the holding bin. 28 Peter Gambetta bought ALMA in and put her through an overhaul in his shipyard. The mast and boom were removed. Any planks that showed signs of teredo damage were replaced. The dredging machinery was updated with the replacement or rebuild of all pumps and engines.

A flume system replaced the old conveyor 26 Allen Welts, National Register of Historic Places Inventory Nomination Form: Alma (San Francisco: National Park Service, Section 7, Page 1. 27 Welts, National Register, 7 /1. 28 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 11 19. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 12) belt distribution system. The improvements to ALMA's dredge equipment improved her efficiency dramatically. After the overhaul the time it took to load the vessel to capacity averaged four to five hours; before the change in ownership it took approximately ten hours to fill the holding bins with shell material. Garnbetta's alterations extended beyond the dredging equipment; he also worked to improve the vessel's handling characteristics.

The forefoot, which ran approximately one quarter of the hull's length, was removed to improve the vessel's ability to track through the water on a straight course. 29 Steering was improved when the rudder was modified with the addition of sister rudders mounted with outriggers on either side of the original rudder. The rudder modifications tripled the number of surf aces steering the vessel, and channeled the flow from the prop over those surf aces. 30 The overhaul cost an estimated but the investment appears to have been sound. ALMA spent the next thirteen years engaged in year round dredging operations until her replacement by a purpose-built vessel.

31 The state of California acquired ALMA in In the first years of state ownership workers removed the old scow's deckhouse and dredging machinery. Little other work took place during this time except covering her with fresh paint. 32 Restoration of the ALMA as a historic vessel began in At that time a crane lifted the hull out of the water and placed it on blocks at the end of a pier. Once the vessel was safely ensconced in its new terrestrial home, state employed shipwrights launched a slow but extensive restoration program. The restoration aimed to return ALMA's appearance to that of her time as a scow schooner. This effort was somewhat hampered by the absence of builder's plans for the vessel.

To overcome this lack of information the restoration team consulted drawings of 29 According to Fetesoff, the forefoot was not a historic feature and was probably an added feature. As a counterpoint to Fetesoff's analysis, Howard Chapelle mentions the utilization of a forefoot in his description of typical scow construction in The National Watercraft Collection, 3 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 79. 31 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 32 Welts, National Register, Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 28. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 13) other scow schooners done by the HAMMS teams and pored over historic photographs of scow schooners, including a few of ALMA. These observations were combined with measurements taken from the existing vessel.

33 The synthesis of historic research and contemporary measurements served as the basis for the restoration as it provided shipwrights with a 'best guess' estimate of ALMA's historic construction and appearance. The restoration program involved the replacement of a great deal of historic fabric, either because it was unsalvageable or because it was simply missing. Much of the replacement material was new lumber or fittings, material with no historic value but shaped and used in a manner consistent with the vessel's original construction. In addition to new material, ALMA's restorers tapped another valuable source during the restoration. During the mid-1960s a number of scow schooner remains lay derelict in the San Francisco Bay area. These were stripped for parts whenever possible.

The current ALMA's hawse pipes came from the HERMINIE BLUM. The MATILDA provided a sheethorse. Restoration workers found a serviceable windlass aboard ANNIE. Small fittings such as cleats and chocks came from a number of abandoned or unused vessels. A naval architect, working pro- bono, designed a new set of sails, and a ship chandlery that supplied sails to scow schooners in their heyday donated the sails. 34 There is a fine line between restoration of an existing vessel and replication of a historic vessel. The demarcation between the two categories can be argued ad infinitum, and ALMA could be considered either or both. ALMA is representative of the scow schooners once common to San Francisco Bay.

In her current incarnation she is an amalgam of old and new material, which occurs with any wooden vessel since the replacement process begins almost immediately after entry into service. The restoration effort made every attempt to rebuild her in a historically accurate fashion. She is not the same vessel that slid off the ways in but she is a reasonable representation of that vessel. Moreover, as is perhaps befitting for a museum craft, the inclusion of material from other local scow schooners, " ... make her more of a representative than she was originally. " 35 Over the years since the initial restoration, state, federal, and 33 Fetesoff, "San Francisco's Alma," 14. 34 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 35 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 32 SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No.

CA-60 (Page 14) private employees have pulled ALMA out of the water for periodic overhauls. In addition to these yard periods, professional caretakers maintain ALMA while she is afloat. Original and Subsequent Owners and Masters James Peterson was ALMA's original owner. He used the vessel as part of his fleet of freight hauling scow schooners operating on San Francisco Bay. The number of vessels in the fleet varied over time but at its peak numbered over a half dozen vessels. This was relatively rare in an industry where most scow schooner freight concerns were single-vessel and owner operated affairs. 36 The list of men who served as Master aboard the ALMA during the years of Peterson ownership is extensive but contains gaps.

Masters serving aboard the ALMA during this period included: John A. HAckney, Carl L. Aagar, William Jensen, F. White, Vincenzo Monteverd, and Erik Carlson, James Peterson himself is occasionally listed as master in archival records. Whether he actually filled in as a relief captain or simply listed himself as a bookkeeping convenience is unknown. 37 It is interesting that the names of men acting as master do not into any single ethnic category.

Maritime activity on the West Coast during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century is often characterized as dominated by a "Scandinavian Navy." While the majority of ALMA's masters appear to have been Scandinavian, the exceptions suggest that, while the "Sandinavian Navy" may have dominated maritime trades, it did not monopolize those trades. James Peterson operated ALMA as a sail powered cargo carrier until July At that time, her masts and spars were cleared away and the vessel became a barge towed by a Peterson owned tugboat. The barge phase of ALMA's career lasted until 38 36 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 30. See Appendix A for a list of scow schooners owned by James Peterson. 37 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 14. 38 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 15. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No.

CA-60 (Page 15) Frank Resech purchased the ALMA in for the sum of $10 cash as well as "other considerations." The other considerations were unnamed so it is difficult to judge the scow's value at that time. After Resech purchased ALMA, he had an engine installed and converted the barge to the role of oyster shell dredger. During her time as an oyster dredger, Resech and his wife operated ALMA. The owner-operators lived aboard ALMA during the dredging season.

39 Advancing age, both his and ALMA's, led Resech to sell the oyster dredger in April Peter Gambetta purchased the vessel for Gambetta followed up the purchase with an overhaul that cost 40 Gambetta personally operated ALMA as a dredger until August That year he completed building a newer dredge boat and no longer required the ALMA as part of his operation. Gambetta left ALMA aground on a mudflat near Alviso for the next two years. 41 The state of California purchased the derelict vessel in August Peter Gambetta received for the old scow and the state acquired the last floating remnant of the San Francisco Bay scow schooners.

42 The National Park Service assumed ownership of the vessel in Source of Original Name Fred Siemer or James Peterson named the vessel after Alma Peterson, Peterson's daughter and Siemer's granddaughter. She was three years old when her grandfather built ALMA. A historian interviewed the vessel's namesake in the Alma Peterson, at the age of ninety-seven, remembered the scow's construction, but, as can be expected from one who was a toddler at the time, her memory of the specifics surrounding the event was vague. 43 39 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 40 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 80. 41 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 81. 42 San Francisco Examiner, 22 August 43 Steven E.

Levingston, Historic Ships of San Francisco: A Collective History and Guide to the Restored Historic Vessels of the National Maritime Museum (San Francisco: Chronicle Books, 72. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 16) History of Vessel Type Two works constitute the main body of literature dedicated to scow schooners operating on San Francisco Bay. The husband-wife team of Nancy and Roger Olmstead carried out the most comprehensive work. Their published work, Scow Schooners of San Francisco Bay, is an invaluable source for any research involving scow schooners. This work also contains a useful history of San Francisco Bay and early maritime activity in the region.

Barbara Fetesoff' s unpublished master's thesis, -"The Scow Schooner ALMA, A History," focuses specifically on the ALMA and contains a wealth of information about that vessel. It also contains detailed information about the class as a whole. The San Francisco Bay scow did not develop as a wholly new type of vessel. It is a variant of a much larger group, the scows, that sprang up wherever there was a need for economical cargo carriers capable of accessing shoal waters. The origins of scows are unknown. They probably developed in different forms in different locales at different times. There is no evidence of a common ancestor or seminal design. The etymology of the word itself is Dutch (schouw) and signifies a large, flat-bottomed lighter or punt.

44 Its introduction to the United States came during the colonial period when several distinct scow types were developed and termed flats, radeux, or gondalows. 45 The scow was a success in the New World, where according to Chappelle it: ... was employed in great numbers and had an extraordinary spread throughout North America. Not only were there examples of the type in use along the entire Atlantic Coast, from the Maritime Provinces to Mexico, but on the Great Lakes, on Champlain, and on any river large enough to be used for small-craft navigation. Flat-bottomed boats and vessels of scow construction were used on the Pacific Coast and in the Canadian Northwest as well. 46 The first sailing scows employed in the colonies carried single spritsails, as was the norm in Europe.

From these 44 Oxford English Dictionary. 45 James P. Delgado and Kevin J. Foster, Scow Schooner Alma: A National Historic Landmark Study (National Park Service, 46 Howard I. Chapelle, American Small Sailing Craft (New York: Norton, SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 17) first North American sailing scows developed a number of rig types. Scows were built with ketch, brig, and ship rigging in a few instances. More commonly, they were sloops or schooners. 47 Early Americans knew sailing scows by a variety of colorful names that sometimes provide a clue as to their occupation. In Massachusetts, they were known as granite sloops. Square- toed frigates plied the coastal waters of Maine. Georgians operated rice flats. Texans referred to sailing scows as buttheaders.

48 As settlers spread across country they introduced sailing scows to new locales. Soon after San Francisco began a boom spurred by the promise of gold, scows were plying the waters of San Francisco Bay. The gold rush brought tens of thousands of new inhabitants to Northern California. These immigrants needed transportation from entrepots such as San Francisco to settlements throughout the region. Various and sundry goods arriving by ocean going ship required an inland distribution system. In the era before railroads and extensive road networks, the easiest way to accomplish the transport of people and material was to move them on the San Francisco Bay and associated river systems.

During the first years of the Gold Rush prices for small craft rose sharply even as oceangoing ships, abandoned by crews bound for the interior, rotted in local harbors. The initial scramble among entrepreneurial shipping concerns to acquire carrying capacity pushed wages earned by inland sailors well above their level. At the same time, the cost of small craft rose five to ten times their pre-Gold Rush level. The prices for vessels and crew stabilized in the early as local builders began producing suitable craft and a number of individuals decided to capitalize on the area's economic growth as sailors rather than as miners. 49 It was during this first period of local shipbuilding that the immediate predecessors of the San Francisco Bay Scow Schooners emerged.

These rough built scows were probably of numerous varieties, reflecting the scows in use wherever the builder 47 Delgado and Foster, National Historic Landmark Study, 48 Delgado and Foster, National Historic Landmark Study, 49 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 18) had learned his trade. 50 By the type had evolved to its fully developed form and was recognizable as a class of vessel. 51 Though significant variations remained in regards to hull shape within the class, the general trend was from cruder, boxy hulls to finer varieties. 52 The origins of the type remain unclear.

In the words of the foremost authority on the subject: The San Francisco scow could have been a descendent of one or more of the other scow types in use at the time, or it may have evolved from rigged barges and lighters. The San Francisco scow schooner apparently did undergo local development, and was not borrowed whole from some other locality, for not only was the type quite unlike the scows used in other parts of America, but scow men do not generally agree as to its origin. 53 From unclear origins the scow schooners grew to widespread use on the San Francisco Bay. They were well suited to their role as bulk carriers on inland waters and, though they carried a variety of cargoes, most commonly they were loaded with lumber, bark, salt, fertilizer, produce, grain, and hay.

The sight of a scow schooner loaded with hay became so common that they became widely known as 'hay scows. ' 54 'Hay scow' cargoes reflected a burgeoning agricultural industry rather than a mining boom. Though the Gold Rush was indeed wildly lucrative for some, the real economic value of California, as evidenced by the scow schooner's cargo, was as an agricultural center. As noted there was no truly typical scow but they did generally fall within certain parameters: "The average scow was sixty feet long and twenty feet in the beam. Size ranged from gross tons for the Star by to 142 gross tons for the Mono by Depth of hold was usually about four feet." 55 Life as a "scow man" was tough but not without its rewards.

Sailors made their way from port to port under sail when possible but if the wind died or blew from a contrary direction the scow sailors were not above poling themselves along through shallow 50 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 16. 51 San Francisco Maritime Museum, ALMA-Last of the San Francisco Bay Scow Schooners (San Francisco: San Francisco Maritime Museum, 52 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 17. 53 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 16. 54 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 11 8. 55 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 11 6. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 19) waters. In some cases they even pulled the vessel along by hauling on lines led to shore. Once in port, it was the crew's job to load or offload any cargo consigned to the vessel, there were no longshoremen.

There were several benefits to working in this physically demanding profession. First, scow sailors made more money than their deepwater counterparts. The discipline on an oceangoing ship was much harsher and sailors often suffered unwarranted punishments. Physical danger from the elements and accidental mishap was more prevalent on deep-sea voyages. Food aboard the scow schooners was generally better than that aboard merchant ships and could always be augmented by food acquired, legitimately or otherwise, from farms bordering the shoreline. Many men working on the scows shared in the prof its or even owned their own vessel, an economic opportunity virtually closed to crew on larger vessels.

Finally, scow sailors were home often and not forced to endure separations from family that stretched out over years rather than days. 56 Scow schooners and their small crews plied the inland waters of Northern California throughout the latter half of the nineteenth century and into the early years of the twentieth. Scows built at Hunters Point and elsewhere on the bay numbered between 200 and 400 by the early The sailing scows would, however, all but disappear within two decades of their peak. 57 Just as the sailing scow became popular due to its economic efficiency, it was doomed by more efficient technologies. The growing availability of internal combustion engines made sail power a less than ideal motive force.

Engine powered vessels were no longer reliant on the vagaries of wind and tide. At the same time, improved road networks and railroads began to offer a viable alternative to waterborne transportation in general. The sailing scow's demise was rapid. The last of the kind, EDITH, was ordered from Emil Munder's yard in By the number of sailing scows had dropped from its peak to a total of twenty-eight vessels. A mere five years later, only four scows operated under sail power alone. 58 Curiously, no work on the 56 John Kowalla, "The Scow Schooner James F. McKenna" (J. Porter Shaw Library, San Francisco, CA. photocopy), 57 Kowalla, "Scow Schooner James F. McKenna," 4. 58 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 59. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No.

CA-60 (Page 20) subject mentions the name of the last scow to operate exclusively under sail. This does not mean the hulls themselves disappeared at the same time as the rigging. Many scow owners converted their vessels to barges. Some were fitted with engines and served as motorized cargo carriers or shell dredgers. Indeed, scow schooner hulls mounted some of the earliest internal combustion gasoline engines available to the public. 59 Conversion to power scows extended the life span of many vessels but it was merely a temporary reprieve for the class. The remnants slowly fell by the wayside through a process of attrition and abandonment. By ALMA was the only working survivor of the once numerous fleet. 60 History ALMA's career, other than its length, was relatively unremarkable.

In her days as a sailing vessel, ALMA underwent yearly haulouts at the Peterson yard. During these yard periods, workers scraped the hull and painted it with anti-fouling paint, the masts received coats of oil, and the rigging benefited from fresh coats of tar. 61 It is also safe to assume that repairs to damaged portions of the vessel took place during these haulouts. A number of scow schooners were involved in mishaps during their sailing careers and ALMA was no exception. On the morning of April 20, the wooden steamer KVICHAK lost steerage while steaming past the Steuart Street Wharf. The out of control steamer collided with ALMA and capsized the smaller vessel. ALMA suffered worth of structural damage and lost a cargo of fertilizer worth in the collision and capsize.

Also consigned to the bottom were the citizenship papers of ALMA's master, Erik Carlson. The tug PILOT towed ALMA to China Basin for repairs. Carlson's citizenship papers were replaced, Peterson signed papers releasing KVICHAK to proceed to Alaska for the fishing season, and ALMA herself returned to service after repairs. The collision, though serious, did not end ALMA's career and appears to have been the only major mishap during her sailing days. 59 William Olesen, "Cargoes of San Francisco Bay Scow Schooners" Nautical Research Journal 43, No. 4 60 Olmstead, Scow Schooners, 64. 61 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 14. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 21) After conversion to a barge ALMA carried loads of salt and fertilizer for eight years.

Though this period could be viewed as less than glamorous, it has been suggested that the exposure to salt during this period served to preserve the wooden vessel and is at least partly responsible for its survival until the 62 ALMA's use as a barge ended when Frank Resech purchased the hull and converted it to an oyster shell dredger. During the dredging years ALMA steamed slowly across the oyster flats with Frank Resech working the dredge equipment and his wife manning the helm. In rough weather the Resech's steamed in a straight line; on calm days they followed a circular course. It usually took two days to fill the shell bin and once it was full ALMA steamed for Petaluma where the cargo was offloaded.

63 Frank Resech sold ALMA to Peter Gambetta in and though Gambetta carried out a thorough overhaul, the vessel's occupation remained unchanged. Gambetta was able to dredge from 55 to 60 cubic yards of bottom per hour on a year round basis. If the cargo was bound for Petaluma, he dredged off Bay Farm Island and if it was bound for Alviso, he worked on San Mateo shoals or off Palo Alto. 64 During Gambetta's ownership the dredger caught fire once, collided with a bridge, and ran aground on a levee. Despite these mishaps, ALMA was still in sound working condition when Gambetta replaced her with SOUTH BAY in ALMA could still work but she could not work as fast as the new vessel. SOUTH BAY was capable of dredging 200 cubic yards every hour. ALMA's working career had come to an end.

It was a career that spanned sixty-six years and three distinct occupations. The state acquired ALMA in but it was several years before the scow would return to its glory days as a sailing vessel. ALMA's first use under state ownership was as a floating work platform used to facilitate work on other historic vessels. In the mid the vessel was restored to the form of her sailing days and became a functioning museum piece operated by the state 62 Fetesoff, "San Francisco's Alma," 11. 63 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 19. 64 Fetesoff, "Scow Schooner Alma, 24. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 22) and after by the National Park Service.

The restored vessel was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 65 Today, ALMA ties up at the Hyde Street Pier along the San Francisco waterfront. The scow schooner benefits from professional maintenance, " ... with in-kind replacement of materials in the manner of her original construction. In its role as an educational vessel and floating symbol of San Francisco's maritime past the vessel makes regular trips on the San Francisco Bay under the supervision of a professional captain and volunteer crew. 65 Delgado and Foster, National Historic Landmark Study, 2. 66 Welts, National Register, 7 /2. SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 23) APPENDIX A A comprehensive list of the scow schooners owned by James Peterson:

Name Ownership Built Adelia

Until ALMA EMILY LUNDT Prior to EXCEDERE HECTOR Until MIAMI Pre

Pike County

Pre STAR unknown SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 24) Selected Bibliography Chapelle, Howard I. American Small Sailing Craft. New York: Norton, Chapelle, Howard I. The National Watercraft Collection. Washington, Smithsonian Institution, Delgado, James P. and Kevin J. Foster. Scow Schooner Alma: National Historic Landmark Study. National Park Service, Evans, Robert L. "The San Francisco Bay Scow Schooner: A Midwest Kit." Model Shipwright, November/December 64. Fetesoff, Barbara J. "The Scow Schooner Alma, A History." Master's Thesis, San Jose State University, Fetesoff, Barbara J. "San Francisco's Alma." WoodenBoat Magazine 1 , no . 3 ( 19 7 5 ) : 8 - 1 7 . Kowalla, John. "The Scow Schooner James F. McKenna." J. Porter Shaw Library, San Francisco, CA. Photocopy. Levingston, Steven E.

Historic Ships of San Francisco: A Collective History and Guide to the Restored Historic Vessels of the National Maritime Museum. San Francisco: Chronicle Books, Olesen, William. "Cargoes of San Francisco Bay Scow Schooners." Nautical Research Journal 43, no. 4 Olmstead, Roger. Scow Schooners of San Francisco Bay. Cupertino, CA: California History Center, Mozley, Anita V. "Scow Schooners of San Francisco Bay." Sea Letter 5, no. 1 San Francisco Examiner, 8 December San Francisco Maritime Museum. ALMA-Last of the San Francisco Bay Scow Schooners. San Francisco: San Francisco Maritime Museum, Tri-Coastal Marine Inc. Scow Schooner Alma, Historic Structure Preservation Guide. San Francisco: Tri-Coastal Marine, SCOW SCHOONER ALMA HAER No. CA-60 (Page 25) Welts, Allen W.

National Register of Historic Places Inventory Nomination Form: Alma. San Francisco: National Park Service,

In context

San Francisco, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Francisco County, California 67 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in San Francisco

24 of 381 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through San Francisco building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
San Francisco Oakland Bay BridgeHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,141-127,296 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHAER CA-227086,796 words
Ship BalcluthaHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,200-80,588 words
Market StreetHALS CA-16434,536 words
San Francisco Cable RailwayHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,137-30,695 words
Aquatic ParkHALS CA-11328,000 words
George Washington High SchoolHABS CA-293919,932 words
Sloop Yacht KathleenHAER CA-229919,410 words
Fort FunstonHAER CAL,38-SANFRA, 214A-16,940 words
Schooner C.A. THAYERHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,199-16,891 words
North Beach PlaceHABS CA-272716,167 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,211-14,693 words
Pier 16 & Bulkhead BuildingHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,142-14,202 words
Jewish Community Center of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,204-14,088 words
Knights of Pythias BuildingHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,172-13,633 words
City of Paris Dry Goods CompanyHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,135-11,407 words
Ferry EUREKAHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,194-11,248 words
Hunters Point Naval ShipyardHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,195A-10,629 words
Hunters Point Naval ShipyardHAER CA-227310,046 words
Steam Tug HERCULESHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,201-9,787 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,177-9,564 words
California State BuildingHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,202-9,200 words
Fort MasonHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,9A-9,188 words
Presidio Water Treatment PlantHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,197-8,476 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CAL,38-SANFRA,198-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.