This document is part of the Yosemite Roads and Bridges Recording Project, undertaken in summer by the Historic American Engineering Record. Richard H. Quin, Historian, SUGAR PINE BRIDGE HAER No. CA-99 (page 2) II.
This is one in a series of reports prepared for the Yosemite National Park Roads and Bridges Recording Project. HAER No. CA-117, YOSEMITE NATIONAL PARK ROADS AND BRIDGES, contains an overview history of the park roads.
The Sugar Pine Bridge carries a limited-access road to Mirror Lake, a popular attraction in the upper end of Yosemite Valley. The single-span reinforced concrete arch bridge is faced with native granite in the characteristic "rustic style" adopted for the Yosemite Valley bridges. The structure was originally known as "Kenneyville Bridge No. 2* after the old livery stable and service complex of "Kenneyville," named for George Kenney, an early stage operator who in gained an interest in the stables. The stables, originally established by early Yosemite hotelier James Mason Hutchings, stood a little north of the bridge on the site of the luxurious Ahwahnee Hotel.1 [The nearby Ahwahnee Bridge (HAER No. CA-100) was "Kenneyville Bridge No.
The original construction drawings and park administrative records referred to the bridge by its original name. Construction of the Sugar Pine and Ahwahnee bridges was necessitated by the National Park Service's decision to relocate the north Valley road leading to Mirror Lake southward. The lavish new Ahwahnee Hotel was to be built on the old Kenneyville site, and the old road would be used as a dead-end spur road to serve the hotel. The new road would head east across Ahwahnee Meadow, where the Merced River made a northward bend, and the two new bridges were required to carry the new road across. Sugar Pine Bridge, like five others constructed in Yosemite Valley at the same time, was designed and built by the Bureau of Public Roads {U.S. Department of Agriculture).
The Bureau had taken responsibility for major park road projects under an agreement with the National Park Service signed in July The bridge was designed by George B. Whittle, Senior Highway Engineer for the Bureau' s San Francisco district office. A number of alternative designs were provided to the National Park Service, including two plans for steel trusses. Nathan W. Morgan, NPS Office Engineer, wrote Thomas C. Vint of the NPS landscape division, urging him to reject the steel trusses, as one would look all out of place in its setting. Morgan reported that Yosemite National Park Superintendent Washington B. Lewis "strongly favored" a stone arched bridge, but called the suggestion "impracticable" because of foundation conditions and "excessive cost." Morgan favored alternate plan No.
13, a suspension bridge with either "rustic* or stone-faced towers. I feel sure the suspension bridge will be perfectly suitable to the surroundings and will be one of the most picturesque places in the Park. I cannot see that it will in any way interfere with people seeing the scenery. Mr. Mather seemed to like this type and I hope Mr. Hull will favor it also. We can't use overhead structures here, as Mr. Hull points out, and for this long and important crossing it seems to me that this is the most desirable type and about the only thing left that is not really overhead construction. There is not enough to the towers to think of their obstructing the view and the cables surely will not. I would like to see a long span at this site.2 SUGAR PINE BRIDGE HAER No.
CA-99 (page 3) If an arch were employed, he suggested that it be a 90' or span with the east abutment extending some out from the bank in deep water. As an alternative, two 50' girders with a central pier would also do. A single arched girder bridge, would be, in Morgan's opinion, *a bad mistake." Morgan argued against alternatives Nos. 8, 9 and 12, exposed concrete bridges, stating "I do not favor the use of cement finished structures in the Park. I think [they] would ruin the appearance of these beautiful stream crossings.'3 In the end, a long single span reinforced concrete arch bridge with stone facing was adopted. Architectural details were prepared with the assistance of the National Park Service' s landscape architecture division.
This office, under division chief Vint, maintained its offices in San Francisco as well. The design was reviewed by two members of the National Commission of Fine Arts. The contract for the construction of the Sugar Pine Bridge and four others was awarded to the San Francisco firm of Rocca and Caletti.4 A construction road between the two bridge sites was built in the winter of Excavation work on the bridges began in July At Kenneyville Number 2, some wooden piles for the abutments were driven before Rocca and Caletti work crews were concentrated on Bridge Number 1. By the end of the year, the bridge abutments had been poured and the wooden arch centering was erected.5 Winter snows then put a halt to further construction.
Work resumed in March with the placing of the hand-cut arch ring stones or voussoirs. Next came the pouring of the concrete wing walls below the line of stone facing. Once the arch ring was complete, the arch centering was removed. Facing for the spandrel walls and wing walls was placed in April, and the form work for the concrete backing was installed.* The parapet walls were built in June, along with the concrete backs for the spandrel walls and the membrane waterproofing. Excavated material for the fill was taken from a gravel bar on the upstream side of the Kenneyville No. 1 Bridge site. Only a small amount of pointing work and the placing of riprap remained by the end of July.
The bridge was completed and accepted by the National Park Service in September total cost of construction was Following the demolition of the old Kenneyville stables and the erection of the Ahwahnee Hotel, the bridge became known as the "Sugar Pine Bridge" after a large sugar pine, quite unusual in the lower Yosemite Valley, growing to the north side of the east abutment.
The bridge approaches were landscaped by Emergency Conservation Works personnel in The bridge' s abutments were damaged three years later in the November flood of and substantial repairs had to be made by park maintenance crews.9 The road across the bridge, along with other roads in the eastern park of Yosemite Valley, was closed to automobile traffic in the summer of The National Park Service wished to reduce automobile traffic and its related problems and to provide more of a wilderness experience to users of this picturesque end of the Valley. Shuttles were instituted to Happy Isles, but the Mirror Lake Road was closed to all vehicles. Today, the Sugar Pine Bridge mostly carries hikers and cyclists.
The graceful arched bridge continues in service; however, concerns that the bridge is restricting the flow of the Merced River have led the National Park Service to consider replacing the structure. As of this writing the fate of the structure has not been settled. The Sugar Pine Bridge is a single-span reinforced concrete and stone masonry structure. The bridge is long and 42' 6" wide. This allows for two 13' SUGAR PINE BRIDGE HAER No. CA-99 (page 4) road lanes, a 5' sidewalk on the north side and a 7' bridle path on the south side. The single semi-elliptical arch has a clear span of , the longest span of any of the Yosemite Valley bridges, rising 12' 2 from the springing line. The concrete abutments rest on deep wooden piles; 111 piles were required for each abutment.
Class " B" concrete was used for the abutments, and Class "A" concrete for the arch vault and all other work." Once the abutments were completed, the hand-cut arch ring atones or voussoirs were placed and the arch centering was removed. The steel reinforcing rods were then laid in a grid to form the main arch and the backing of the spandrel walls. Longitudinal rods were 1 diameter rods on 6" centers; transverse rods were diameter on 24" centers. The two rows of rods were joined by diameter hoops. The concrete for the arches was then poured over four stages. First, the crown sections of the arch were poured, followed by the ring sections adjacent to the abutments. The intermediate sections of the ring were poured next, and the construction keys at the base of the haunches were poured last.
A waterproofing membrane was then applied to the concrete before the gravel fill was added. The roadway was surfaced under a separate contract. Stone curbs for the sidewalks and bridle path were then laid in place and 4" of rock screenings were applied as the base for the walks.10 Traffic over the bridge is restricted, and the bridge carries only occasional service or patrol vehicles. The structure appears to be in good condition, although the river is scouring the abutments. Sugar Pine Bridge is listed in the National Register of Historic Places as part of the multiple resources nomination for the Yosemite Valley Bridges. * Classes of concrete refer to the amount of Portland cement used in the mixture, with Class "A" having the highest proportion and so on. SUGAR PINE BRIDGE HAER No.
CA-99 (page 5) III. ENDNOTES 1. "Kite's Cove and Yo Semite," Mariposa Gazette, 15 April 2; "Incorporated," Marlposa Gazette, 3 November.1877; "The Yosemite Travel A Round Trip," Marlposa Gazette, 21 April 2; Homer W. Robinson, "The History of Business Concessions in Yosemite National Park." Yosemite Nature Notes XXVII (June 89. 2. Nathan W. Morgan, NPS Office Engineer, Yosemite, California, to Thomas C. Vint, NPS Landscape Engineering Division, 9 October National Archives, Record Group 76, Entry 22, Box 20. 3. Ibid,. 4. Robert C. Pavlik, "In Harmony with the Landscape: A History of the Built Environment of the Yosemite National Park" (Master' s Thesis, University of California at Santa Barbara, 5. Washington B.
Lewis, Superintendent' s Monthly Report, December 1; Superintendent's Monthly Report, October 8; E. P. Leavitt, Acting Superintendent's Monthly Report, November 7. 6. Leavitt, Acting Superintendent's Monthly Report, March 5; Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, April 4. 7. Idem, Acting Superintendent's Monthly Report, June 4; Acting Superin- tendent' s Monthly Report, July 4; Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, September 3. 8. Thomson, Superintendent' s Monthly Report, February 10. 9. Linda Wedel Greene, Yosemite, The Park and Its Resources: A History of the Discovery, Management, and Physical Development of Yosemite National Park, California, 3 vols. (Washington, National Park Service, 10.
Construction details taken in part from United States Department of Agriculture, Bureau of Public Roads, "Yosemite National Park, Plans for Five Bridges, Kenneyville Bridge No. 2 Over Merced River," construction drawings, sheet 6 and supplemental sheet 6A, December Measurements confirmed by HAER field survey, July SUGAR PINE BRIDGE HAER No. CA-99 (page 6) IV. BIBLIOGRAPHY PUBLIC DOCUMENTS Greene, Linda Wedel. Yosemite, The Park and Its Resources: A History of the Discovery, Management, and Physical Development of Yosemite National Park, California. 3 vola. Washington, National Park Service, Leavitt, E. P.
Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, September Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, October Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, November Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, March Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, April Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, June Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, July Acting Superintendent' s Monthly Report, September Lewis, Washington B. Superintendent' s Monthly Report, December Superintendent' s Monthly Report, August Solinsky, E. C. Acting Superintendent' a Monthly Report, May Thomson, Charles Goff. Superintendent' s Monthly Report, February Washington, National Archives. Nathan W. Morgan, NPS Office Engineer, Yosemite, California, to Thomas C.
Vint, NPS Landscape Engineering Division, 9 October Record Group 76, Entry 22, Box 20 ARTICLES "Hite's Cove and Yo Semite." Mariposa Gazette, 15 April 2. "Incorporated." Mariposa Gazette, 3 November "The Yosemite Travel A Round Trip." Mariposa Gazette, 21 April 2.
United States Department of Agriculture, Bureau of Public Roads. "Yosemite National Park, Plans for Five Bridges, Kenneyville Bridge No. 2 Over Merced River." Construction drawings, sheet 6 and supplemental sheet 6A, December SUGAR PINE BRIDGE HAER No. CA-99 (page 7) SECONDARY SOURCE DOCUMENTS Pavlik, Robert C. "In Harmony with the Landscape: A History of the Built Environment of the Yosemite National park." (Master' s Thesis, University of California at Santa Barbara, Robinson, Homer W. "The History of Business Concessions in Yosemite National Park." Yosemite Nature Notes XXVII (June