BlockBefore

Grace Cathedral, George William Gibbs Memorial Hall, 1051 Taylor Street, San Francisco

Grace Cathedral, George William Gibbs Memorial Hall, 1051 Taylor Street, San Francisco, San Francisco County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,203A-, with a 7,887-word written history.

From the record

“Constructed in George William Gibbs Memorial Hall (hereinafter referred to by its common name, Cathedral House) is significant as the first permanent structure built in the Grace Cathedral close.”

Written record, HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,203A- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,203A- · the record runs 7887 words · one of 382 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

7799 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,203A-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Constructed in George William Gibbs Memorial Hall (hereinafter referred to by its common name, Cathedral House) is significant as the first permanent structure built in the Grace Cathedral close. Originally built for the Church Divinity School, the building was to be one part of a quadrangle of buildings adjacent to the cathedral. Cathedral House is, thus, also significant as a surviving remnant of the original close plan, designed by the famous English architect George Bodley, that included the quadrangle. Designed by the prominent San Francisco architect Lewis Hobart (after he had been appointed as the chief designer for the cathedral) , Cathedral House is also a rare, surviving example in the San Francisco Bay Area of the "academic" gothic style popular in the early century.

NOTE: To view the "Exhibits" referenced in the text, please see the Field Notes for this structure. To view the "Exhibits" referenced in the text, please see the Field Notes for this structure. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History l. Date of erection: A ceremony for laying the cornerstone was held January 25, (Exhibit 1). The San Francisco Daily Morning Call reported January 26, that the ceremony was attended by Bishop Nichols who "placed cement on the stone with a silver trowel and then handed the trowel to George W. Gibbs, who furnished the money to build the new school. 11 The cornerstone, near the west elevation entrance door, is dated for the anticipated date of completion.

Construction did not begin immediately after the cornerstone ceremony, given that the revised plans are dated March 13, On May 29, Bishop Nichols "unveiled a memorial tablet and formally accepted the completed structure." 1 2. Architect, Builder: Born in st. Louis in Lewis Parsons Hobart spent most of his boyhood in California. He studied architecture at the University of California, the American Academy in Rome and then from to at L'Ecole des Beaux Arts in Paris. After working in New York for a couple of years, Hobart came to San Francisco in in response to the demand for architects to rebuild the city.

Playing a leading role in the rebuilding of the city, Hobart designed many commercial buildings in downtown San Francisco, including Mills Tower, the Macy's building and the Bohemian Club building. Hobart also designed the California Academy of Sciences building in Golden Gate Park, and a number of large mansions on the San Francisco Peninsula. Hobart's most notable project was Grace Cathedral which he was involved with from to Hobart was also the first President of the San Francisco Art Commission in He died in George A. Bos was the engineer who worked with Hobart on the Cathedral House. Ferderer Construction Works was the contractor. 3.

Original and subsequent owners: The original owner of the building was the Church Divinity School of the Pacific who leased the land from the Episcopal Diocese of Louis Childs Sanford, The Province of the Pacific (The Church Historical Society, Philadelphia, p. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 3) California. The Diocese bought the building from the divinity school in and they have owned it since that date. 4. original plans and construction: Architectural plans and sketches, historic photographs and other related correspondence and documents related to the Cathedral House are in the Grace cathedral Archives. s.

Alterations and additions: Cathedral House has had no additions since originally constructed in The interior has received a number of minor alterations to adapt it from being used as a school to primarily offices. These alterations generally involved the addition of doors to facilitate access between rooms and the construction of minor partition walls. The original floor plans of each of the four stories are essentially intact.

Basement alterations include the range fuel room west of the kitchen in the basement being replaced by the cathedral gift shop in the early A storeroom in the northwest corner of the basement was converted into kitchen for the verger in the A door leading to the Cathedral was added in the west wall of the central hall in The wood paneling, window mouldings, built-in bookcases and sliding doors have been recently removed from the first floor. Apart from a couple of doors being added where the classrooms originally were, this floor had not been altered. The bathroom in the northwest corner of the second floor was converted into an office in the A bathroom was added into part of what was a kitchen in the southwest corner of the second floor.

On the third floor, a bathroom has been added to what was originally a shower area on the south side of this floor for the adjacent verger's unit. A kitchen was also added on the third floor in what was a bedroom at the southeast corner. B. Historical Context Episcopal Diocese of California Before and the Founding of the Church Divinity School of the Pacific GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 4) The Episcopal Church in California was founded before California had attained statehood, but after San Francisco had, in a few months, become an "instant city" during the early days of the Gold Rush.

The Grace Cathedral diocese had its origins with a group of San Francisco Episcopalians who petitioned the national Board of Missions for a clergyman in The board appointed Rev. Dr. Ver Mehr to lead the new congregation. Reverend Ver Mehr's departure from the East Coast, however, was delayed until October, because of illness. Another Episcopal congregation (Trinity Church) began having services beginning in July, under Reverend Flavel s. Mines. When Reverend Ver Mehr finally arrived in San Francisco in October, he decided that the city's population of almost could support two Episcopal churches, so he accepted his position as the head of the Grace Church congregation.

Reverend Ver Mehr conducted his first service at Grace Church, a small wood shingle building on Powell Street, in December, From these humble origins, Grace Church grew to become the center for the Episcopal Diocese of California. 2 starting in a number of the Episcopal churches attempted. to form a diocese in Northern California, but these "unofficial" efforts were not recognized by the national church. In January, the national church recognized California as a diocese at the General Convention in New York, and they chose Dr. William Ingraham Kip to be its first missionary bishop and the rector of Grace Church. During his tenure, Bishop Kip established a number of new parishes and missions in both Northern and Southern California.

3 Another of Bishop Kip's major accomplishments was building the new Grace Church, a substantial granite and brick Gothic style building, at the corner of California and Stockton Streets. Upon its completion in Kip proclaimed the church to be Grace Cathedral, the third unofficial cathedral designation in the Episcopal Church. 4 The 2 A "diocese" is a larger administrative organization for the church which includes a number of local parish churches. A bishop is the head of the diocese and a "cathedral" is the seat, or home church, of a bishop. 3 "Cathedral Honors Bishop Kip," Cathedral Quarterly, Winter, pg. 1. 4 Bishop Kip, influenced by the Oxford Movement, felt that the American church should follow the English tradition of establishing cathedral churches in every diocese.

The cathedral concept had not been accepted in America at this time where many thought it was contrary to the evangelical role of the church (see Grace Cathedral GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 5) growth in church membership led to a split in the California diocese in a Diocese of Northern California generally included the counties north of Marin and Alameda Counties with the remainder of the state still part of the Diocese of California. After 35 years of service to the Diocese of California, Bishop Kip retired in and was succeeded by Bishop William F. Nichols who held this position until Under Bishop Kip, a number of church-sponsored institutions were founded that provided a variety of community services.

Bishop Nichols continued this tradition soon after his appointment by playing a strong leadership role in the founding of the Church Divinity School of the Pacific for training Episcopal clergy. George W. Gibbs, a wealthy San Francisco businessman and prominent church vestryman, also played a crucial role in assisting Bishop Nichols in the founding of the school. George Gibbs had been a trustee for the Missionary College of St. Augustine in Benicia which included a divinity school. 5 The Missionary College closed after only a few years, but Gibbs maintained his interest in theological ed~cation. He offered to help Bishop Kip start a divinity school in California in the but at the time the diocese had other "more immediate problems.

116 After his appointment, Bishop Nichols vigorously supported the idea of a college or theological seminary as part of the diocese. Gibbs offered the bishop a closed orphanage he owned on a four acre site in the City of San Mateo. Gibbs maintained that the main orphanage building could easily be renovated for the school, and he offered to donate to the school's endowment fund. The plan for the school was supported by bishops throughout the West, 7 and in the Church Divinity School, the first such school in the Western United states, opened in San Mateo. 8 Bishop Nichols was the guidebook by Michael Lampen, pg. 3; "Reflections from the Dean", Cathedral Quarterly, Winter, pg. 2.) 5 Henry H.

Shires, "History of the Church Divinity School of the Pacific", Historical Magazine of the Protestant Episcopal Church, June, p. 3. 6 Shires, p. 5. 7 A statement calling for the necessity for such a school was signed by bishops of Oregon, Wyoming, Idaho, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, New Mexico and Washington. Shires, p. 5. 8 n.a., The Church Divinity School of the Pacific, (Church Divinity School, Berkeley, CA, p. 2. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A {page 6) school's first dean, and he taught there regularly. 9 Subsequent grants from George Gibbs' widow allowed the school to build faculty houses and to develop plans for additional buildings on the campus.

The history of the Church Divinity School's San Mateo campus, however, abruptly ended when the earthquake severely damaged most of their buildings. The conflagration in San Francisco caused by the earthquake also destroyed the first Grace Cathedral at Stockton and California Streets. The Development of the Grace Cathedral Close after and the Construction of the George William Gibbs Memorial Hall The fire and earthquake of destroyed 25 per cent of San Francisco and all the buildings on Nob Hill, including the two houses owned by the Crocker family on the block now occupied by Grace Cathedral. William H. Crocker, a prominent member of the Grace Cathedral congregation, 10 lived in a house at the corner of California and Jones Street.

After his house was destroyed, William Crocker approached his family about donating the Crocker property (which had also included the Charles Crocker house at California and Taylor) to the Episcopal Diocese who now had to rebuild their cathedral. The Crocker family donated the property to the diocese in the latter part of and the process of designing a new cathedral began immediately. The noted English architect, George F. Bodley, was commissioned to design the new cathedral. Bodley was considered one of the greatest church architects of his day and an important advocate of English Gothic architecture. 11 San Francisco 9 Louis Childs Sanford, The Province of the Pacific (The Church Historical Society, Philadelphia, p. 99. 10 Born in Sacramento in William H.

crocker was the youngest son of Charles Crocker. Charles Crocker was one of the founders of the Central Pacific Railroad with Leland Stanford, Collis Huntington and Mark Hopkins - the so-called "Big Four" who built the transcontinental railroad. At the age of 32, William Crocker became the president of the Crocker-Woolworth (later Crocker) Bank, and he was an important civic booster, art patron and philanthropist. William Crocker also played an important role in the rebuilding of San Francisco after the earthquake. See David Warren Ryder, Great citizen - A Biography of William H.

Crocker (Historical Publication, San Francisco, 11 For background on Bodley' s work in England see Dav id Verey, "George Frederick Bodley" in Seven Victorian Architects, edited by Jane Fawcett (the Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park, Pennsylvania, 84 - Bodley's last major GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 7) architect Louis Hobart was hired in April, to be Bodley's local assistant. The program submitted to Bodley by Bishop Nichols in February, specified that this project would be "comprehensive" in that it included the cathedral and a quadrangle for cathedral buildings. 12 The cathedral was to be situated along Jones Street in a north/south orientation to take advantage of the dramatic view of the city.

In a May, letter to Bodley elaborating on the diocese's requirements for the quadrangle, Hobart indicates that a school is planned for the area along Taylor street: requirements for buildings of the quadrangle in a general way are the bishop's house on the corner of California and Taylor Streets; apartments for the resident and visiting clergy on California between the Cathedral and the bishop's house; and the general diocesan school with the refectory and student's rooms on Taylor Street and possibly extending from the corner of Taylor and Sacramento west on Sacramento. The interior court formed by these three sides might possibly be connected with an arcade, which would be most convenient in the rainy season.

13 These early plans for Grace Cathedral are typical for an English gothic cathedral. Unlike French cathedrals, English gothic cathedrals were often connected to monasteries which formed a quadrangle of ancillary buildings to the main cathedral. Given the area needed to accomodate the cathedral and related structures, English gothic cathedrals were typically set outside of towns in their own "close", rather than in a densely built-u~ urban environment, like the major French cathedrals. 4 From the commissions were for American cathedrals. In addition to Grace Cathedral, he also was the original architect (with Henry Vaughn) for National Cathedral in Washington. However, like with the Grace Cathedral project, Bodley's designs for National Cathedral were never realized.

12 Bishop Nichols, Letter to George Bodley, February 15, 13 Lewis Hobart, Letter to George Bodley, May 31, 14see Banister Fletcher, A History of Architecture on the Comparative Method (Charles Scribner's and Sons: New York, GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 8) beginning of the planning of the Grace Cathedral Close, the architects struggled to satisfy the program requirements of an English gothic cathedral on a constricted urban lot. Not surprisingly, the design of the close and the cathedral eventually became more French than English as it evolved over the next 23 years. 15 Bodley submitted a design for the cathedral in mid-1907, but he died in October, before completing revisions requested by the diocese.

Architect Cecil Hare took charge of Bodley's office and the Grace Cathedral project. Hare produced a final design for the cathedral and quadrangle that was approved by the cathedral authorities. The cathedral then hired Hobart to implement the Hare design. In one of his last letters to the cathedral authorities, Hare suggested in that the cathedral be oriented in an east/west direction along California Street, rather than along Jones Street, because the lot's depth of 276 feet was so confining. 16 This idea was rejected at first, and the cornerstone for the new Cathedral, laid in January, faced California Street near the corner of Jones.

17 Hobart became the official cathedral architect in April, and 15 When Hobart redesigned the cathedral close in the size of the cathedral increased substantially and the quadrangle was dropped from the plan. As the cathedral increasingly dominated the site, the emphasis in the close plan on ancillary cathedral buildings decreased. While the original English close plan was appropriate given the origins of the Episcopal Church, Hobart must have concluded that it was not practical given the site constraints. Given that Hobart was a graduate of the Ecole des Beaux Arts in Paris, when he took over as the project architect, his francophile tendencies may also had a role in the design changes.

Hobart and Cram's final design for the cathedral exterior reflects more the influence of the French cathedrals at Amiens and Paris than any English precedent. 16Hare increased the width of the Bodley cathedral design in response to critic isms that the building would not hold enough people. Given that English cathedrals tend to be much longer than they are wide, Hare undoubtedly found the design unsatisfactory because of the block's restricted depth. The block's length of 412 feet would accomodate a longer and narrower building. 17The cornerstone was eventually moved in the to the cathedral's main entrance at Taylor and California Streets. To view the "Exhibits" referenced in the text, please see the Field Notes for this structure.

GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 9) he immediately started working on the plans for Gibbs Hall to house the Church Divinity School. 18 George Gibbs had donated money for the construction of the new Church Divinity School to replace the school in San Mateo destroyed by the earthquake. The school was the first part of the quadrangle to be constructed adjacent to the cathedral still planned to be built in a north/south orientation. Construction of the school began in mid-1911 and was completed in early During Hobart began to rethink the plan of the Cathedral close possibly in light of Hare's suggestions and the need for a larger cathedral.

Hobart convinced the cathedral authorities to accept an east/west orientation for the cathedral in January, Hobart's new close plan was published August, 19 Hobart's new plan retained the quadrangle concept with a cloister joining the various buildings, but with a longer, more slender cathedral oriented along California Street (Exhibit 3). According to this plan, the divinity school was to be flanked by a library and a refectory. In November, plans for a Founder's oriented in an east/west direction were approved, and,the was formally opened for services January 27, 20 ,The congregation held services in the for the next 18 years. Because of the World War and lack of funds, work on the cathedral close did not begin again until In Rev.

Edward Lambe Parsons became the bishop for the Episcopal Diocese. Working with Rev. Parsons, Hobart made a number of major revisions to the close plan in in consultation with the famous Gothic revival architect, Ralph Adams Cram. The size of the cathedral was increased substantially with the addition of a sanctuary at the west elevation, one more bay on the nave and a large entrance porch. Given the new cathedral design, the quadrangle was dropped from the close plan. A grand entrance stair rose directly from 18 n.a., "Divinity School to have new Home," San Francisco Daily Morning Call, April 16, p. 3.

This article indicated that "about 100 feet on the eastern side [of the cathedral block] will be given up to the building" as part of a quadrangle that will extend along California, Taylor and Sacramento. 19see "Grace Cathedral, San Francisco," The Pacific Churchman, August, 20The Cathedral's size increased substantially as the result of design changes made between and consequently, when construction began on the new Cathedral design in the Founder's was demolished. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 10) Taylor Street to the cathedral's front porch. Construction of the stair would require the demolition of the divinity school and its relocation to a new building along Sacramento Street.

The new divinity school would be one of four buildings now planned for the north side of the block. In response to the new close plan and other factors, the divinity school trustees, however, decided to move the school to Berkeley in when it became financially feasible. 21 According to a brochure produced by the divinity school in the late twenties, the move was prompted in part because: It was expected that the School would form part of the Cathedral group of buildings and a plan had been sketched providing that memorial buildings could be erected from time to time, forming one symmetrical whole. The growth of the Cathedral has caused the original plan to be greatly modified and it was decided to move the School to Berkeley.

22 The divinity school trustees also contended that the move to Berkeley would emphasize the provincial than the character of the school and make available to the school the resources of the nearby University of California and the Pacific School of Religion. Gibbs donated funds for the construction of a second George w. Gibbs Memorial Hall on the divinity school campus on Ridge Road in Berkeley where it still is today. The diocese paid the divinity school for the Taylor Street building on January 1, (the school leased the land from the diocese). After the divinity school moved, old Gibbs Hall became the Cathedral House. Meetings were held in the library and dining room, and Dean Gresham and his wife moved into the apartment previously occupied by the divinity school dean.

Much of the building, however, remained vacant. Although work on the redesigned cathedral began during the early the divinity school was not demolished. By the cathedral was completed to the third bay of the nave and walled off, and diocesan house was built north of the Cathedral House. Given the problems raising money to continue the building program during the Depression and recognizing that the cathedral house was not being fully utilized, the building became 21 Shires, p. 9 . ~ n.a., The Church Divinity School of the Pacific, no publication date, but since the impending move is discussed it must have been before To view the "Exhibits" referenced in the text, please see the Field Notes for this structure. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No.

CA-2352-A (page 11) a divinity school again, The School for Prophets, in The School for Prophets was founded in October, by Rev. Karl Morgan Block after the Grace Cathedral trustees agreed to make Gibbs Hall available for the school. Modeled after the "College of Preachers" at Washington Cathedral, the school provided post- graduate or "in-service training" for practicing clergy in the Western United States. 23 The school emphasized instruction in "practical homiletics," the art of "competent preaching", rather than technical theology.

The founders of the school maintained that "new competence in the pulpit" through "homiletical technique" would work to conquer the rising tide of secularism (see Exhibit 5) After Bishop Block died in the School for Prophets began to decline, and in the building again became the Cathedral House for the diocese. The diocese needed building for more office space because of staff increases during the late 24 In Weihe, Frick and Kruse were hired as architects to supervise the cathedral's completion using the original designs produced by Hobart and Cram (Hobart died in .. Construction on the cathedral began again in and the building was finally consecrated in From until recently vacated, the cathedral house continued to be used as a meeting space and offices for the diocese.

The building is now slated to be demolished and replaced with a new chapter house to be constructed along Sacramento Street on top of a multi-level underground garage. The grand stair Hobart designed in for the front of the cathedral is also included as part of current project. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement 1. Architectural character: The cathedral house is a rare, surviving example of an early twentieth century "Collegiate Gothic" style building in San Francisco. A comparison between the building's main elevations reveals a lively contrast between the formal symmetry of the east elevation, and the informal west elevation's inventive asymmetrical disposition of window and doors.

The interior has two richly decorated ~ n.a, A Guide to Grace Cathedral, San Francisco, Canon Michael Lampen, Sr. personal communication with Ward 24 Hill, April, To view the "Exhibits" referenced in the text, please see the Field Notes for this structure. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 12) fireplace mantels and a handsome oak stair balustrade. 2. Condition of fabric: The building is solidly constructed and structurally in good condition. The limestone facing on the east and west elevations is badly deteriorated. A major crack is evident in the brickwork on the south elevation. Wall panelling and mouldings have been removed in the major rooms on the first floor. B. Description of Exterior 1.

overall dimensions: Cathedral house has a rectangular plan that measures 102 by feet, and a total interior square feet. The building has 8 window bays across the east and west elevations. The east elevation has three stories with a mansard, and because of the hill, the west elevation has two stories with a mansard (photos 3, 6). One enters the building at the first floor on the west and in the basement on the east. 2. Foundations: Perimeter concrete footing. 3. Walls: The north and south elevations are red brick laid in 5 course American bond with corner limestone quoins (photos 2, 6; exhibit 6). The east and west elevations are brick faced in Indiana limestone with a granite base (exhibit 7, 8).

A brick bel tcourse runs along the west elevation where the cloister would have joined the building, and a limestone beltcourse on the east elevation runs between the basement and first floor (photos 3, 4. structural system: The building has a reinforced concrete frame with brick infill walls. Reinforced concrete columns, about 12 inches square, are imbedded in the exterior walls at irregular spacing (10 to 18 feet) to accommodate the windows. The floor slabs and roof are reinforced concrete; the floor slabs span the building's 36-foot width, except for columns adjacent to the stairways. Interior partitions are of hollow clay tile masonry and brick. 5.

Porches, stoops, balconies: The Taylor Street entrance has a moulded, pointed arch porch entrance with a deep reveal (photo The building's original name, George William Gibbs Memorial Hall, is carved into the limestone wall in a medieval script above the porch. A square escutcheon decorated with acanthus leaves is above the building's name. The recessed porch is 4 feet deep and 7 feet wide. The inside surface of the porch is finished with limestone. The original stair at To view the "Exhibits" referenced in the text, please see the Field Notes for this structure. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 13) the side of the south elevation had small landings for the basement service entrances. 6.

Chimneys: Recently fabricated sheet metal chimney flues. 7. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: The most elaborate doorway is on the east elevation (photo Oak frame transoms and side lights surround the door which is also solid oak. The moulding (with rounded corners) above the door has inset within it a festoon of acanthus leaves. The door itself has side blocks and a central cross imposed on paired trefoil panels. The simple, main entrance door on the west elevation is set off center (photo 8) . This double door has pointed arch windows and a transom divided vertically into 5 lights.

The service doors at each end of the west elevation have pointed arch windows with 8 lights (photos 6, The two basement doors on the south elevation are original, but the doors themselves have recently been replaced. The first floor door on the south elevation (with its metal walkway) dates from the b. Windows: The main east and west elevations have tall, narrow casement windows. The windows are set in deep, limestone reveals. The east and west elevation first floor windows have central stone mullions. The east elevation basement windows have 8 lights, although they are smaller and narrower than the second floor windows which also have 8 lights (photo The east elevation first floor windows, wider and taller than the other stories, have 12 lights.

The east elevation has two projecting 45 degree angle bays - the north bay rises only to the first floor while the south bay ascends the full height of the building. The north bay had a balustrade on top that was removed in (photo The bays are equidistant from the central entrance. The windows on the east elevation are in turn symmetrically arranged in relation to the two projecting bays and the central entrance (photo 3; exhibit 7). Unlike the windows on the east elevation, the west elevation has a variety of window sizes asymmetrically arranged (photos 6, 8, 9 & 10; exhibit 8). The second floor windows are all paired round arch casements with 10 lights (except for one small window on the south), but only the windows on the north half of this floor are evenly spaced.

On the first floor, the To view the "Exhibits" referenced in t,he text, please see the Field Notes for this structure. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 14) off-center entrance door is flanking on the north by 3 closely spaced paired windows each with 12 lights. To the south of the entrance is one 8 light window, then two 10 light windows as on the second floor. The paired, tall, narrow windows in the recessed bay (projecting above the roof) have 16 lights. The south elevation has 4 small, round-arch windows of varying sizes and asymmetrically arranged - one at both the basement and first floor, and two windows on the second floor (exhibit 6) .

The north elevation has a recently added rectangular window that opens into the verger's kitchen in the basement. The north elevation 3 additional asymmetrically arranged, round-arch windows on the first and second floors (exhibit 6). s. Roof: a. Shape, covering: On the east and west elevations, the mansard roof covered with slate shingles on the east and west side. The flat top of the roof has a built-up roof system (photo 7; exhibit 9). b. Cornice, eaves: The carved limestone cornice on the east and west elevations has a cyma moulding above the soffit. The ends of the corbels (spaced 2. 5 feet apart along the soffit) are carved with a decorative shield and cross design. The south bay on the east elevation and the bay on the west elevation project above the cornice into the roof.

The downspout scuppers have a decorative, geometric design, and a metal gutter has recently been installed above the cornice (photo c. Dormers: The west and east elevations have 7 gabled dormers. The roofs and sides of the dormers are covered with slate shingles, and the roof ridges have metal flashing. The base of the dormer roof has a wooden eave moulding. Each dormer has a single, 9 light casement window. c. Description of Interior: 1. Floor plans: The basement plan (exhibit 10) is divided longitudinally by a central corridor that is bisected by the stair hall. The central corridor divides the basement into two functional halves. The north half of the basement has the verger's apartr,ent and the boiler room.

The south half was the main kitchen racilities and living units for the kitchen staff. Upon entering the first floor (exhibit 11) from the main To view the "Exhibits" referenced in the text, please see the Field No.tes for this structure. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 15) entrance door (on the west elevation), one enters the hall for the main stair. The hall leads into the reception room. The reception room and the flanking library and dining room occupy most of first floor area. A service pantry west of the dining room was connected to the basement kitchen through a dumbwaiter and a service stair. Access to the two classrooms along the west elevation was originally only through the library.

Like the basement, the second floor (exhibit 12) is divided by a longitudinal corridor bisected by a central stair hall. The north half of this floor was student rooms. The south half of the second floor was the apartment for the dean of the divinity school. The third floor (exhibit 13) was entirely students rooms. The 8 student rooms on the east side of the building and the 5 on the west are all arranged along the central, longitudinal corridor. Shower and toilet facilities are in the northwest and southwest corners of this floor. 2. Stairways: The building has 4 stairways. One stair that joined only the basement kitchen and the service pantry has been closed off.

Another service stair, constructed entirely of concrete, also starts in the basement near the kitchen and continues up to the third floor. There is second service stair, also constructed of concrete, that starts at the northwest corner of the first floor and continues up to the third floor. The main stair rises behind the central projecting bay on the west elevation. This stair has a particularly handsome oak balustrade and newels. The balustrade is formed by a series of oblong, round arch openings that recall the shape of the building's windows. Paired wooden "straps" join these inset pieces to the flat balusters supporting the hand rail. The square newels have moulded caps, inset panels and base mouldings. 3. Flooring: The floors in the basement are scored concrete.

The library, reception and dining room had oak hardwood floors. The floors in other parts of the building appear to be fir that was painted or covered with carpet. 4. Wall and ceiling finish: Generally, the walls and ceilings are plaster painted white with base boards and cornice mouldings. The walls of the main rooms of the first floor were recently removed. The walls in the first floor GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 16) dining room were covered with wood paneling. The walls in the reception room were plaster with a heavy, wood cornice moulding. The library walls were a combination of wood bookcases and paneling. s. openings: a.

Doorways and doors: The typical doorway on the basement, second and third floors is a standard 2.5 foot opening with a plain finish door and a simple architrave door moulding. The dean I s apartment has more elaborate architrave door mouldings. There were heavy wood, sliding pocket doors between the first floor reception room and the adjacent dining room and library. Two swinging doors opened out from the main entrance hall into the reception room. There were also swinging doors between the service pantry and the dining room. b. Windows: The windows on all floors except the first floor either have no mouldings or simple architrave mouldings. The first floor dining room and library had more elaborate wood mouldings designed to complement the wood paneling.

The third floor has 4 skylights: one over both the shower and the bathroom, the central corridor and above the service stair at the north wall. 6. Decorative features and trim: The kitchen and service pantry have plain, functional, built-in storage cabinets, drawers and glazed cupboards. There are also simple, built-in linen closets on the second and third floors near the south service stair. The first floor has two original decorative fireplace mantels. The dining room has an elegant sandstone mantel. The mantel has a pointed arch opening surrounded by oak leaves and acorns. The corbels lining the deep reveal provide an additional floral surround to the fireplace opening. The reception room mantel is more formal and classical than the dining room mantel.

This natural wood mantel has a moulded mantle ledge. A second moulding below the ledge forms a flat frieze above the fireplace opening. Inset panels on moulded bases flank the fireplace opening like classical pilasters. An elaborate decorative carving of a shell set on volutes with leaves and acorns descends down each of the inset panels. There is another classically inspired fireplace mantel in the dean's second floor apartment that dates from the This concrete mantel has a classical frieze across the top of the fireplace opening and simple pilasters flanking the opening. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 17) 7. Hardware: Casement windows have standard production latches for this period.

The Dean's apartment on the second floor had faceted glass doorknobs and decorative scutcheons on the doors. 8. Mechanical equipment: a. Heating, air conditioning, ventilation: Steam heat is provided by a gas boiler in the basement. The original cast- iron radiators are in the rooms on the second and third floors. There is no forced air ventilation or central air conditioning. Ventilation is provided by the building's windows which are all operable. b. Lighting: Circa circular light fixtures are suspended from the ceiling on first floor. Swan's neck decorative wall light fixtures were in dean's apartment on the second floor. C. Plumbing: The building has . its original steel galvanized piping. d.

Dumbwaiters, intercom system: The building was originally served by two dumbwaiters: one carried food from the basement kitchen to the service pantry adj a cent to the main dining room. This dumbwaiter has been removed. The second dumbwaiter, near the southwest corner of the basement, carried food and groceries from the basement kitchen and service area to the dean's kitchen on the second floor. The area where this dumbwaiter was has been closed off. The call boxes that were part of the building's original intercom system are also extant on the first floor. D. Site: 1. General setting and orientation: Cathedral house is set in a densely built-up urban environment in a prominent position at the top of Nob Hill.

The area to the north and west is primarily three to four story apartment buildings. Across the street from Cathedral House (to the east) is a small, urban park (Huntington Park) and the Flood Mansion (now the Pacific-Union Club), the only pre-1906 mansion surviving on Nob Hill. The buildings to the east are large, multi-story apartment buildings and luxury hotels. The Masonic Auditorium is directly south across California Street. Cathedral house is oriented on a north/south axis parallel to Taylor Street. The main entrance faces west toward the front GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 18) portals of the cathedral. The auxillary entrance on the east elevation opens to the sidewalk along Taylor Street.

There are 3 doors along the south elevation, and no exterior doors on the north elevation. 2. Historic landscape design: There originally was a garden in front of the building's west elevation. A portion of the garden and several trees are extant at the northwest corner of the building. Ivy still covers much of the north elevation which is adjacent to an ivy covered slope. The west garden was removed when the plaza area between the cathedral house and the cathedral was constructed in the early The building's east elevation is adjacent to the "Crocker fence", a stone wall and decorative cast iron fence dating from when Charles Crocker built his mansion on this property. A few plants grow in the area between the fence and the Cathedral House. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A.

original Architectural drawings: Lewis Hobart's original floor plans, elevation drawings and roof plan are in the Grace Cathedral archives. Included in the plans is one sheet of interior details including a section showing the main stair, the library bookcases and the two first floor fireplaces (not built as drawn). The archives also have a number of Hobart's original sketches of various ornamental details (i.e. entrance on Taylor Street, cornices, fireplaces etc.) that were probably drawn during construction. Exterior details shown on the Hobart's drawings, but not built, include the label mouldings above the second floor windows of the east elevation and the main entrance at the west elevation.

Another detail shown on the drawings, but not built, is trefoil ornament along the top of the third floor windows of the east and west elevations. The west elevation also shows the outline of where the cloister was to be built, and the first floor plan indicates where the columns of the cloister would be in relation to the building. B. Historic views: Historic photographs of the cathedral house are in the Grace Cathedral archives. c. Interviews: Ward Hill met with Michael Lampen, the Grace Cathedral archivist for the last 10 years, 4 times during April, regarding the history of cathedral house and the cathedral close. on April 26, Ward Hill spoke with Canon GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 19) Michael Lampen, Sr.

who worked for the cathedral between and Ward Hill also spoke with Ronald Glens, archivist for the Church Divinity School of the Pacific, Berkeley, California. D. Bibliography Primary and unpublished sources Various files are in the Grace Cathedral archives regarding maintenance, alterations and purchase of the cathedral House, although there is no correspondence or other communications related to the design and construction of Cathedral House. A copy of the land lease with the Church Divinity School is also in these files.

The following correspondence referenced in this report is in the Grace cathedral archives: Bishop Nichols, Letter to George Bodle , February, 15, George Bodley, Letter to Bishop Nichols, March 5, George Bodley, Letter to Bishop Nichols, April 30, Lewis Hobart, Letter to George Bodley, May 29, Cecil Hare, Letter to Bishop Nichols, February 5, Bishop Nichol's office, Letter to Cecil Hare, June 8, Lewis Hobart, Letter to Cecil Hare, May 25, Cecil Hare, Letter to Lewis Hobart, January 1, Bishop Nichols, Letter to Cecil Hare, September 10, Cecil Hare, Letter to Cathedral Corporation, December 1, Hodgkin, Letter to Lewis Hobart, January 19, Loring A. Wyllie, Jr. Degenkolb Associates, Engineers, Letter to Douglas Day, Chairman, Fabric Committee, Grace cathedral.

The following unpublished manuscripts are in the Grace Cathedral archives: GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 20) Lewis Hobart, The Architectural Progress of the Cathedral, Rev. Eric Montizambert, Present Activities and Future Prospects (regarding activities of the School of the Prophets), January 20, Michael Lampen, Eight Decades of Cathedral House, no date. Supplemental Information Prepared by the Grace cathedral Archivist for the San Francisco Landmarks Board. Separate forms regarding cathedral House, Grace Cathedral and the Diocesan House, September, Notes on the Architectural Heritage of the vision of Grace cathedral, January 17, Secondary and published sources Bloomfield, Anne.

State Historic Resources Inventory Forms for the Grace Cathedral Close and Cathedral House. September, Bours, Rev. William. Turning Points in the Evolution of Grace Cathedral - Diocese of California. San Francisco, "Cathedral Honors Bishop Kip," Cathedral Quarterly, Winter, pg. 1. The Church Divinity School of the Pacific. San Francisco, CA, The Church Divinity School of the Pacific. Berkeley, CA, Clifton-Taylor, Alec. The Cathedrals of England. London: Thames and Hudson, The Diocese of California-Its Cathedral and its Institutions. San Francisco, "Divinity School to have New Home," The Daily Morning Call, April 16, pg. 3, col, 3. Fletcher, Banister. A History of Architecture on the Comparative Method, edition.

New York: Charles Scribners and Son, Gillespie, Donald M., "Reflections from the Dean," Cathedral GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 21) Quarterly, Winter, pg. 2. "Grace cathedral, San Francisco," The Pacific Churchman, August, Grace Cathedral Building Fund. Grace Cathedral. San Francisco: Grace Cathedral, Grimes, Lyman. "New Grace Cathedral - Most Imposing Church in the West," Daily Morning Call, pg. 3, col. 1. A Guide to Grace Cathedral. San Francisco, Junior League of San Francisco. Here Today. San Francisco: Chronicle Books, Kelley, Rev. D. o. History of the Diocese of California-1849 to San Francisco: Bureau of Information & Supply, Lampen, Michael D. History Tour of Grace Cathedral. San Francisco, Lampen, Michael.

Grace Cathedral. San Francisco: Grace cathedral Corporation, "Laying the Corner Stone," The Daily Morning Call, January 25, pg. 3. Montizambert, Canon Eric. A Brief Guide to Grace cathedral. San Francisco. San Francisco: Grace Cathedral, Mullgardt, Louis Christian. "The Architecture of Mr. Lewis P. Hobart." The Architect and Engineer, August, Page & Turnbull, Inc. Cost study Cathedral House. Grace Cathedral, June 18, (copies available in the office of Page & Turnbull, Inc., San Francisco) Pan Pacific Who's Who, edition. Honolulu, Hawaii: Honolulu Star Bulletin, Parsons, Edward Lambe. The Diocese of California: A Quarter Century. Austin, Texas: Church Historical Society. GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No.

CA-2352-A (page 22) "The San Francisco Cathedral, " The American Architect, June 3, San Francisco City Planning Department. Grace Catheral Close Alterations -Final Environmental Impact Report. February 11, Sanford, Louis Childs. The Province of the Pacific. Philadelphia, PA: The Church Historical Society, The School for the Prophets. brochure published in Service, Alastair. Edwardian Architecture. New York: Oxford University Press, Shires, Henry H. "The History of the Church Divinity School of the Pacific," Historic Magazine of the Protestant Episcopal Church, June, 3 - 11. Verey, David. "George F. Bodley" in Seven Victorian Architects, edited by Jane Fawcett. University Park, Pennsylvania: Pennsylvania State University Press, Willard, Ruth Hendricks. Sacred Places of San Francisco.

Novato, CA: Presidio Press, "World's Fair Builders - Lewis P. Hobart," The Architect and Engineer, August, E. Likely sources not yet investigated Additional archival material related to the history of the Church Divinity School is available in the Diocese Archives at Taylor Street, San Francisco. PART IV. PROJECT INFORMATION This documentation of the Cathedral House was undertaken as a mitigation measure to reduce the significant impacts identified in the February 11, Grace Cathedral Close Alterations Final Environmental Impact Report. As part of the project planned for the Grace Cathedral Close by the Grace Cathedral Corporation, the Cathedral House will be demolished and approximately 130 feet of the "Crocker Fence" will be moved.

The California State Office of Historic Preservation has identified the Cathedral House and the "Crocker Fence" as contributing resources to a National Register eligible historic district that includes other structures in the GRACE CATHEDRAL, GEORGE WILLIAM GIBBS MEMORIAL HALL (Cathedral House) HABS No. CA-2352-A (page 23) Grace Cathedral Close. In the area where the Cathedral House and the "Crocker Fence" now stand, a new staircase will be built from Taylor Street to the main doors of Grace Cathedral. In addition to building the new staircase, a new square foot Chapter House and a two story subsurface garage will be built along Sacramento Street. Prepared by: Ward Hill Title: Architectural Historian Affiliation: Page & Turnbull, Inc. Date: 5 May

In context

San Francisco, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Francisco County, California 67 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in San Francisco

24 of 381 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through San Francisco building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
San Francisco Oakland Bay BridgeHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,141-127,296 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHAER CA-227086,796 words
Ship BalcluthaHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,200-80,588 words
Market StreetHALS CA-16434,536 words
San Francisco Cable RailwayHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,137-30,695 words
Aquatic ParkHALS CA-11328,000 words
George Washington High SchoolHABS CA-293919,932 words
Sloop Yacht KathleenHAER CA-229919,410 words
Fort FunstonHAER CAL,38-SANFRA, 214A-16,940 words
Schooner C.A. THAYERHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,199-16,891 words
North Beach PlaceHABS CA-272716,167 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,211-14,693 words
Pier 16 & Bulkhead BuildingHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,142-14,202 words
Jewish Community Center of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,204-14,088 words
Knights of Pythias BuildingHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,172-13,633 words
City of Paris Dry Goods CompanyHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,135-11,407 words
Ferry EUREKAHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,194-11,248 words
Hunters Point Naval ShipyardHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,195A-10,629 words
Hunters Point Naval ShipyardHAER CA-227310,046 words
Steam Tug HERCULESHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,201-9,787 words
Presidio of San FranciscoHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,177-9,564 words
California State BuildingHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,202-9,200 words
Fort MasonHABS CAL,38-SANFRA,9A-9,188 words
Presidio Water Treatment PlantHAER CAL,38-SANFRA,197-8,476 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,38-SANFRA,203A-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.