BlockBefore

Washington Primary School, 1436 Polk Street, Napa

Washington Primary School, 1436 Polk Street, Napa, Napa County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,28-NAPA,3-, with a 2,454-word written history.

From the record

“Washington Primary School, 1436 Polk Street, Napa, Napa County, CA”

Survey record header. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,28-NAPA,3- · the record runs 2454 words · one of 10 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

2404 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,28-NAPA,3-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Polk Street Napa Napa County California Significance The Washington School is a heavily-modified school house near downtown Napa, California. It was designed by local Napa architect. Luther M. Turton. It served as a school building between and the early it has been used as a county administrative building since about The building was evaluated in by Dan Peterson, AIA and was determined not to be eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places. 1 This recordation under the standards of the Historic American Buildings Survey is being conducted in relation to a proposal to demolish the building. Description The Washington School is a wood frame two story building with a stucco exterior and plaster interior.

The building includes five separate interior levels -- a raised basement, the windows for which are above grow1d; a first story; a second story; and an office and mezzanine levels at the two-story entry pavilion, aligning with the entry and the landing for the stairway. In plan, the building is built around a central stair with large classroom spaces to the left and right on the first and second stories. The basement was used for bathrooms and utilit:--rian spaces. including maintenance ck sets. The two levels at the entry pavilion include small ' ffic::!s at the Dan Peterson. AIA, "Napa County Agricullural Building: Determination of Eligibility 1 Report," May, Washington Primary School HABS No. CA-2394 Page No. 2 entry level and an open meeting room at the stair landing.

The floor plans for the three primary levels are shown in the attached "Sketch Plans." The construction history of this building is recorded in an earlier "Determination of Eligibility Report," prepared by Dan Peterson, AIA. A school was built on this parcel in the mid-19th century, with the earliest school being called the Polk Street School. The pre-1909 building occupied the same parcel but not the same site as the existing building. 2 The existing building was constructed in a fact recorded in the cornerstone at the northeastern corner of the building. The architect was Luther M. Turton, the builder Peck & Coffield. The existing building includes the basic footprint of the original but has been modified through removal of many character-defining features.

The original design is shown in attachments 1 and 2, which are photocopies of historic photographs. 3 In the following, the building is described, elevation-by-elevation, emphasizing what is original and what is not among the dominant elements. The facade, as noted, includes classroom wings at either side (east and west) with a two-story entry pavilion, offset in section from the rest of the building. The windows in the classroom wings are 4 over 4 double hung wooden sash with moveable transoms, except at the basement level, where they are 8 over 8 double-hung. The building also includes gabled dormers, flanking the entry.

The entry pavilion includes 2 over 2 double hung windows at the first and second stories, with windows at either side of the entry and two windows at the second story atop the entry. The front doorway is recessed, with access gained through a covered porch. Entry to the porch is gained through open arches, supported by a single concrete column. This entry pavilion projects from the plane of the building and features a flat roof. A small pent roof shelters the main entry. The roof for the building is H-shaped, with a long side gabled element over the stairway and front gabled forms to either side. The front gable roofs include a broad overhang, supported on knee braces.

As built, the entry pavilion was adorned with nearly all of the character-defining Mission Revival style features for this building, including: a curvilinear parapet with belltower atop the entry pavilion; Mission tile roofing at the pent roof; a concrete coping over the pent roof; and curvilinear parapets at the dormers over the pavilion. The pent roof was originally carried on knee braces which, while not characteristically Mission Revival, helped unify the entry pavilion with the rest of the building. Virtually all of these elements are now gone. The tall parapet 2Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps.

These were inspected for the years and 3These photocopies were provided by the Napa County Historical Societv Attachnvnt 1 is a phot;:;c;::,py of a po:.;tcard, date for which has not been established. Attachment 2 is derived from the Napa Register, "Vintage Edition," again, the date of this photograph has not been established. Washington Primary School HABS No. CA-2394 Page No. 3 as well as the dormer parapets have been removed. The tile has been removed from the pent roof as well as the concrete coping and brackets for the pent roof. In addition, the original design included small windows over the entry, framed by the concrete coping. These were replaced with larger windows, which match the adjacent 2 over 2 double hung. The east elevation (right of the facade) is apparently unchanged.

See a description of the west elevation for an enumeration of elements there. The rear (north) elevation is the most modified, at least in terms of number of important alterations. As originally designed, this elevation included the fire escape for the building. The fire escape was subsequently moved to the west, leaving useless many of the rear doors and windows. Two doors existed at the rear, second story. The door to the right has been blocked off and stuccoed; the left door still exists but cannot be used because there is no connecting stair. Two second story windows have been blocked off as well. The rear elevation also includes two small aluminum sliding windows. The remainder of the windows are the 4 over 4 with transom or 8 over 8, found on the facade and side elevations.

A basement entry is covered by an awkward timber enclosure which probably occupies the space of the bottom landing for the fire escape. As originally designed, the side elevations (east and west) were identical. The building included three bands of windows, at the basement, first, and second stories. Basement windows were 8 over 8 double-hung, as elsewhere, and first and second story windows were 4 over 4 with transoms. These windows were in groups of four, with timber mullions separating the sash. This condition still prevails on the unmodified east elevation. On the west, the 11 of the 12 windows are in place; the northern window at the second story has been blocked off and stuccoed. As noted, this elevation was modified through introduction of modern (ca.

fire escape with steel structure and concrete steps. This escape, of course, required the introduction of new openings as well to provide access to it at the south wide of this elevation. The interior of the building has been modified substantially since the early when it was converted from school to office uses. All of the classrooms have been subdivided, ceilings are hidden beneath dropped acoustical tile ceilings, and original flooring hidden beneath recent linoleum and carpet surfaces. The central stair retains some original features, including the baluster. This stairway has been badly damaged, however, through vandalism. The Washington School is located at the edge of the downtown commercial district, with offices and stores to the east and residences to the west.

Nearly all of the nearby commercial buildings were constructed after while the adjacent residential area is older. Washington Primary School HABS No. CA-2394 Page No. 4 Historic Context The Washington School was built in the second school at this site. The earlier school, called the Polk Street School, was the second primary school in the city of Napa. The existing building occupies the same parcel but is structurally unrelated to the earlier building, occupying a different part of the parcel. The Washington School appears to have operated as a primary school for less than 30 years. By it was identified in city directories as "Manual Arts- Science School.

"4 It continued to serve as a manual arts and science institutiorr until the early At some point between and the school was turned over to the County of Napa. In it served as offices space for a variety of county agencies, including the planning department. By however, the building had been largely taken over by the Agricultural Commission. It was occupied by the Agricultural Commission from the mid- until it was abandoned in 5 The building was designed by Luther M. Turton, a City of Napa architect, active in building design from the 18 80s through the early decades of the century.

Although not commonly mentioned in statewide secondary works 6 , Turton was an active designer in the city of Napa, involved with commercial, residential, religious, and public buildings, and utilizing a broad range of styles popular at the time. The "Historic Resource Inventory" for the City of Napa, completed in includes at least 14 buildings designed by Turton. The actual list of extant Turton buildings is probably much longer; the inventory, for example, does not include the Washington School. 7 The oldest Turton-designed building in this inventory dates to the youngest to The collection is dominated by masonry commercial buildings in the 4Polk City Directories for City of Napa, housed in the California State Library, Sacramento.

This collection begins with the year, The collection is nearly continuous between and the 5Polk City Directories, conversations with Jane Slattery of Napa County Public Works Department. The Sanborn Fire Insurance Map identifies it as the "Napa Community Child Care Center," a designation which does not match the city directory listing. 6 Turton's name is absent from such general surveys as A Guide to Architecture in San Francisco & Northern California by David Gebhard, et al, (Santa Barbara, Peregrine Smith, Inc., California's Architectural Heritage by Harold Kirker (Salt Lake: Gibbs M.

Smith, or the introduction to Sally Morgan, California Architecture (San Francisco: Chronicle Books, He does appear in the catalogue in Woodbridge's book for two buildings in Napa which were HABS-recorded prior to demolition. Turton is not mentioned in Henry F. and Elsie Rathbum Withey, Biographical Dictionary of American Architects (Deceased) (Los Angeles: New Age Publishing Co,, 7City of Napa, "Historic Resource Inventory," a copy of which is on file at the California Department of Parks and Recreation, Sacramento. Washington Primary School HABS No. CA-2394 Page No. 5 downtown area and Queen Anne and Colonial Revival residences in the close-in residential areas. The collection also includes several Gothic churches, a library, and several shingled houses.

Perhaps the best known Turton building is the Noyes Mansion, a residence on First Street. There is some disagreement as to the architectural history of this particular building. In his eligibility report, Dan Peterson argues that the two story entryway was an addition to the design of the building. This two-story entry is shown as a solid element 'on all Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps after and is present in all known historic photographs of the building, although these photographs are not dated reliably. The author of this report concludes that the two-story entrance was an original element of the Turton design, based upon all available evidence. The building has been modified, however, in other important ways.

In its original (or, at least, the earliest known) design, it was a rather austere rectangle, enlivened by two elements: a broad Craftsman-like roof overhang supported by large brackets, and a Mission Revival style entry pavilion. The style of the central segment was defined by curvilinear parapets at the facade of the pavilion and at the dormers, a tiled pent roof at the first story entrance, and a bell tower element at the apex of the parapet. While somewhat awkward, the Mission Revival elements served to soften the otherwise boxy design. These Mission Revival elements have been removed entirely.

Other modifications, while less important than changes at the facade, are nonetheless substantial, including: removal of the two-story balcony at the rear; introduction of a new steel and concrete fire escape of the west elevation; blocking off of windows at the rear and west; and introduction of new square openings with aluminum sliding windows. The interior of the building has similarly lost its most character-defining elements: the classrooms. The large classroom spaces have been broken into smaller office-sized spaces. These rooms also included dropped ceilings and new flooring. The bulk of modifications, exterior as well as interior appear to date to the period in which the building was operated by the county.

Sources Gebhard, David, et al, A Guide to Architecture in San Francisco & Northern California (Santa Barbara, Peregrine Smith, Inc., Kirker, Harold, California's Architectural Heritage (Salt Lake: Gibbs M. Smith, Morgan, Sally, California Architecture (San Francisco: Chronicle Books, Peterson, Dan, AIA, "Napa Co:mty Agricultural Building: Determination of Eligibility Report," iv1ay, Washington Primary School HABS No. CA-2394 Page No. 6 Polk City Directories for City of Napa, housed in the California State Library, Sacramento. This collection begins with the year, The collection is nearly continuous between and the Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, on microfilm, California State Library. This microfilm series includes and Withey, Henry F.

and Elsie Rathburn Withey, Biographical Dictionary ofAmerican Architects (Deceased) (Los Angeles: New Age Publishing Co., Project Information The County of Napa proposes to demolish the Washington School building because it is substandard and cannot economically be brought to a useable condition. This documentation has been prepared as mitigation for demolition of the building. Historical Report Prepared by: Stephen D. Mikesell Photography by: Bill Agee JRP Historical Consulting Services 712 Fifth Street Davis, CA March 8, Washington Primary School HABS No. CA-2394 Page No. 7 ',: __ .. : ~ ,. .. ~" : .' . Attachment 1. Historic View of Washington School, Napa, Napa County, California. Postcard at Napa County Historical Society, date unknown. Washington Primary School HABS No.

CA-2394 Page No. 8 Attachmtin 2. distom of SchooL >f apa, :Nap::: County. California. FroIY, "Vintage Edition" of .\"apa Register. l Date of photograph unknown. Washington Primary School HABS No. CA-2394 Page No. 9 - I I ! l l 1 - I I I I I I - 1-1I iI 1 I I J Sketch Plan: Floor and Basement Washington Primary School HABS No. CA-2394 Page No. 10 I f I I I I [ L _J Sketch Plan: First Floor Approx. Scaie: l" = 10' Washington Primary School HABS No. CA-2394 Page No. 11 r I L - ilillll ,~ I I I I Sketch Plan: ~viezzanine and Second Floor A~p. 1Drox. - Scale: 1 = 1O' 11

In context

Napa, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Napa County, California 142 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Napa

5 records

The federal surveyors worked through Napa building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Napa River Railroad BridgeHAER CA-3227,511 words
First Street BridgeHAER CA-3274,528 words
First Street BridgeHAER CA-3403,675 words
Migliavacca BuildingHABS CAL,28-NAPA,2-56 words
Behlow BuildingHABS CAL,28-NAPA,1-37 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,28-NAPA,3-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.