First Street Bridge, Spanning Napa River at First Street between Soscol Avenue & Juarez Street, Napa
First Street Bridge, Spanning Napa River at First Street between Soscol Avenue & Juarez Street, Napa, Napa County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CA-340, with a 3,675-word written history.
From the record
“The First Street Bridge over the Napa River is believed to be the first rein- forced-concrete bridge in Napa County.”
Written record, HAER CA-340 survey. Machine-read text.
Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CA-340 · the record runs 3675 words · one of 10 surveyed structures published for this county.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HAER CA-340.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
The First Street Bridge spans the Napa River at First Street between Soscol Avenue and Juarez Street, in the City of Napa, Napa County, California. The bridge lies in an unplatted area of Township 5 North, Range 4 West, on the Napa, California, 7.5-minute U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) quadrangle (photorevised Universal Transverse Mercator Coordinates: Zone 10, N E (east approach); N E (west approach). Date of Construction: Architect/Engineer: John Buck Leonard and William Peyton Day Builder: Charles H. Gildersleeve
Significance
3506 words
The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HAER CA-340.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
The First Street Bridge over the Napa River is believed to be the first rein- forced-concrete bridge in Napa County. John B. Leonard, one of California's leading bridge engineers in the early twentieth century, designed the struc- ture. In the First Street Bridge was listed in the National Register of Historic Places. Report prepared by: Scott Thompson, Senior Historian Statistical Research, Inc. E. Speedway Boulevard Tucson, AZ Date: September First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 2)
Description
The First Street Bridge, California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) Bridge No. over the Napa River is a reinforced-concrete girder bridge located approximately 1/2 mile from the center of downtown Napa in Napa County, California (Figure 1). Currently, the bridge carries two lanes of local traffic over the Napa River. Commercial and residential areas border the bridge to the east, and a tourist attraction focusing on food and wine lies to the immediate west (Figure 2). Built in the bridge is believed to be the first bridge in Napa County constructed of reinforced concrete (Napa County Land- marks, Inc. Visual inspection of the bridge and a review of engineering reports indicate that the structure, despite its age, remains historically intact and retains a high degree of integrity.
Apart from the periodic roadway resurfacing and the placement of riprap around the piers, the City of Napa Department of Public Works reports no additions or alterations to the bridge (Mark Andrilla, personal communication In Caltrans conducted a survey of California's highway bridges to evaluate the structures for his- torical significance. The survey identified, documented, and evaluated hundreds of bridges across the state representing a wide range of construction dates, methods of construction, and uses. Caltrans staff developed a system for evaluating the significance of each structure that considered variables such as the date of construction, designer/builder, technological merit, special features, historical associations, and integrity.
The survey concluded that 118 bridges were eligible for listing in the National Register of His- toric Places including the First Street Bridge, which was 1 of 14 reinforced-concrete girder bridges considered eligible (Federal Highway Administration [FHWA] Later that year, the California State Historic Preservation Officer determined the First Street Bridge to be eligible for listing in the A formal nomination was not submitted until (FHWA Napoli In August the bridge was listed in the The First Street Bridge is significant because it represents an important step in the evolution and prolif- eration of a bridge type-the reinforced-concrete girder bridge. Moreover, it is an example of the inno- vative civil engineer John B.
Leonard who was a well-known bridge designer and an early proponent for the use of reinforced concrete as a building material.
Architectural and Engineering Information
The First Street Bridge over the Napa River is a reinforced-concrete, T-girder-type bridge that measures approximalely x 61' (Figure 3). It has three spans with lengths of and The bridge has two 2'-0"-wide parapets, two sidewalks with a width of each, and a roadway approxi- mately 42' wide for a total width of about 61 '. Transverse beams stretch across the underside of the deck and provide support to the structure. The wearing surface of the bridge is bituminous (asphalt). Beneath First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 3) the bridge, along the centerline, are three utility pipes measuring 8", and 12" in diameter (Caltrans Two piers support the bridge (Figure 4). Each pier consists of four x vertical members, or col- umns.
The columns are connected by a cap section across the top and enclosed by a skirt wall on the sides. Concrete pile caps with timber piles support the four columns. Reinforced-concrete T-girders form the superstructure, with each pier supporting four girders. The girders are haunched at the piers to create a parabolic arch over the center span and half-arches over the end spans (Hodge Over the years, repeated scouring exposed the timber piles below the footings.
In riprap was placed in the end spans and around the piers to protect them from further erosion (Hodge In the absence of as-built plans of the bridge, the structural details reported by Hodge were based on several sources, including measurements made in the field, estimated loads and requirements consistent with design procedures used in and plans for the scour repair project. In elevation, the use of haunched girders gives the appearance of a center arch with two half-arches. Closed, incised spandrels with raised pilasters flank the center arch. Each pilaster rests on a capped pier adorned with a pyramid-shaped buttress. The half-arches have a single, closed spandrel. The end spans join the bridge abutments on the east and west banks of the river.
Beneath the point where the half-arches meet the abutments, the edges are scored to simulate quoins. Above the arches is a parapet with recessed, rectangular panels; the inner side of the parapet forms the railing. Four short posts are incorporated into the parapet-one at each end and two located at the edges of the center span above the pilasters. Atop the end posts are columns with wide bases, tapered shafts, and recessed vertical panels. On the south parapet at the west end is a plaque noting the date of construction and the names of those responsible for the bridge. The plaque reads: Mayor E. J. Drussel; Councilmen E. S. Henry, E. F. Hogan, R. P. Lam- din, C. F. Ross, J. H.
Shuppert; Leonard & Day, Engineers; Gildersleeve, Builder." The First Street Bridge is an example of the Neoclassical Revival style. The term "revival" is used be- cause the Neoclassical style dates to the eighteenth to mid-nineteenth century. It was revived during the early part of the twentieth century, when the bridge was built. Following the Neoclassical Revival style, the bridge's defining features are its simplicity, relatively plain surfaces, single piers, the haunched girders, and the square cap from which these girders spring. III.
HISTORICAL INFORMATION The first known bridge to span the Napa River at First Street was a masonry arch bridge constructed in the summer of Flooding during the winter of caused the east end of the bridge to settle, which resulted in cracks throughout the structure and caused the arch to drop about 4" (Napa Reporter On January 31, the bridge collapsed "and every vestige of the old structure went to the First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 4) bottom" of the Napa River (Napa County Reporter The masonry bridge was replaced by a wooden structure; however, the date of construction and other details are not known. A postcard, ca. depicts a truss-type bridge, with cross bracing above and below the traffic, spanning the Napa River at First Street (Figure 5).
Ostensibly, this was the bridge replaced by the current reinforced-concrete structure. Beginning in the late Europeans were experimenting with reinforced concrete-concrete rein- forced with wire mesh or metal bars to provide tensile strength-as a building material. By the mid- reinforced-concrete structures were being built in the United States. In Ernest L. Ransome, a San Francisco-based engineer, received a U.S. patent on concrete reinforced with cold-twisted, square iron bars. Five years later, Ransome designed the Alvord Lake Bridge in San Francisco, the first rein- forced-concrete bridge in the United States (FHWA Snyder The use ofreinforced- concrete for the construction of bridges in California proliferated during the early twentieth century.
The combined strength of steel and concrete-a significant advance in materials technology-allowed engi- neers to design and construct bridges with long spans that were capable of supporting large loads and were generally less expensive to build than the old combination of steel and timber (Leonard and Day One of the major proponents of reinforced-concrete technology in the western United States at this time was John Buck Leonard. Leonard was a native of Michigan who studied engineering at Michigan State College (later University), the University of Illinois, and the University of Michigan. He moved to Los Angeles, California, in and relocated to San Francisco the following year.
During the he worked as a draftsman and civil engineer for several engineering firms specializing in iron and steel design and bridge construction. Through his association with the Technical Society of the Pacific Coast, Leonard probably knew Ransome and his work using reinforced concrete. After a brief stint as a concrete and artificial stone contractor, Leonard started his own civil engineering consulting firm in Over the next 10 years, Leonard's reputation as a bridge designer grew. Touting the economy, strength, and aes- thetics of reinforced-concrete bridges over those made of steel, Leonard received commissions to build bridges throughout northern California (Snyder By Leonard had teamed with William Peyton Day, a trained civil engineer and licensed architect.
Day complemented Leonard with his ability to resolve aesthetic issues. The engineering firm of Leonard and Day contracted with the City of Napa to design the First Street Bridge, which is a minor example of Leonard's work (Mikesell It is worth noting that in early-twen_tieth-century California, con- sulting engineers rather than civil servants designed most of the bridges. By the mid-1920s, state, county, and local engineers designed virtually every bridge.
The First Street Bridge is representative of bridges designed by consulting engineers, a common occurrence in the early twentieth century when expertise was lacking within the civil service (FHWA On June 17, the Office of the Clerk of the City of Napa issued a call for bids "for building a rein- forced steel and concrete bridge across Napa River" at the First Street crossing (Napa Daily Journal 1914a). Funding for bridge construction came from the sale of bonds to the State of California ( Napa Daily Journal Charles H. Gildersleeve, a California native who spent most of his life in Napa, First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 5) was awarded the contract. In at the age of 25, Gildersleeve embarked on a career as a building con- tractor, specializing in concrete construction.
Prior to receiving the contract for constructing the First Street Bridge, Gildersleeve's company built concrete bridges in Calaveras, Lake, and Solano Counties (Gregory It is likely that construction of the concrete bridge did not commence until the fall of possibly later. On September 1, Gildersleeve asked the City Council to close the temporary bridge across the Napa River at First Street. He stated t~at traffic across the existing bridge would interfere with framing the new bridge. The City Council instructed Gildersleeve to coordinate the bridge closure with the city engineer at the necessary time (City of Napa 1914a).
On September 8, the minutes of the City Council meeting noted the following: Two communications were received from Engineers Leonard & Day, who have the con- struction plans and specifications in hand for the new First Street Bridge. One recom- mending the change of the skew angle of the bridge from 16' 8" in 30' to 12' in said change to be made without extra cost to the City of Napa and another recommending the change of the beams in the bridge to correspond with accompanying blue prints, said change also to be made without any extra cost to the City of Napa [City of Napa These design changes strongly suggest that framing, the step whereby wooden falseworks are constructed to support the forms during the concrete pouring and setting phases of construction, had not begun.
On February 2, the City Council voted unanimously to condemn and remove the temporary bridge across the Napa River at First Street; however, exactly when the bridge was razed is unclear (City of Napa 1915a). Leonard appeared before the City Council on March 30, to report that the bridge was complete except for some formworks that remained while the concrete set. The City Council set a date of April 6, for accepting the work on the bridge (City of Napa Gildersleeve, under separate contract, was tasked with paving the deck of the bridge (City of Napa Meeting minutes from note that several of Gildersleeve's claims were approved and paid for by the Finance Com- mittee, but do not provide the total cost of bridge construction.
The First Street Bridge is an early example of bridge building in California using reinforced concrete to construct a permanent, low-maintenance highway bridge. Leonard and Day incorporated Neoclassical Revival design elements into the First Street structure: for example, the haunched girders, which suggest an arched form in a girder-type bridge, and the decorative (yet simple) fascia along the inner and outer sides of the parapets. In his evaluation of three nearby bridges, Mikesell argued that the First Street Bridge over the Napa River is a significant example of a reinforced-concrete bridge owing to the fact that it "was the work of a master designer and introduced this bridge form to a county that was in still wedded to stone masonry construction." First Street Bridge (Bridge No.
HAER No. CA-340 (page 6) IV. PROJECT INFORMATION A. Project Purpose The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) and the City of Napa plan to replace the First Street Bridge over the Napa River with a structure capable of withstanding 100-year-flood events. The First Street Bridge was listed in the in August Because the demolition and removal of the bridge con- stitutes an adverse impact to this historic resource, mitigation measures are required to comply with Sec- tion 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (as amended).
Stipulation IV (3) of the Program- matic Agreement for the Napa River/Napa Creek Flood Control Project requires Historic American En- gineering Record (HAER) documentation of the bridge before replacement of the structure commences (Corps In May the Corps contracted with Statistical Research, Inc. (SRI), to record the First Street Bridge in accordance with National Park Service standards for HAER documentation B.
Report Preparation In August SRI Historian Scott Thompson conducted archival research at the following institutions and repositories: Cultural Studies Office, Caltrans, Sacramento; Library, Caltrans, Sacramento; California State Library, Sacramento; Department of Public Works, City of Napa; Napa County Historical Society, Napa; Napa County Library, Napa; and Office of the Clerk of the City Council, City of Napa. Mr. Al Edmister, a Napa resident and historian who conducts research on Napa County, provided additional information. As part of the historical-records search, an attempt was made to locate architectural and engineering drawings of the bridge. Cal trans ( and FHWA ( reported that no plans for the bridge were available at the time of their respective studies.
Similarly, archival research for this project failed to un- cover extant drawings. Thompson wrote and compiled this document. David G. De Vries, of Mesa Technical (under contract to SRI), completed the large-format photodocumentation of the First Street Bridge. First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 7) V. GLOSSARY 1 Abutment: The end support of a bridge. Falsework: Temporary support scaffolding used during construction. Form: A temporary timber or metal structure used to contain and support concrete while it hardens. Haunch: The side of an arch between the springing and the crown. Parapet: A low wall along the edge of the bridge deck that serves as a protective railing. Pier: A vertical support of a bridge deck span.
Pilaster: A vertical architectural member that is rectangular in plan and structurally functions as a pier but architecturally appears as a column that projects from a wall. Pile: Long posts of timber, steel, or reinforced concrete driven into the ground to support a vertical load. Quoin: Right-angle stone in the comer of a wall used to strengthen and join the comer together. Riprap: A layer of stones piled in water or on an embankment slope to prevent erosion. Spandrel: Area between the exterior curve of an arch and below the line of the deck. T-girder: Structural element that appears as a "T" form in cross section and provides support for the span. The bar and stem of the "T" resist bending caused by loads on the span.
Definitions of the architectural, engineering, and construction terms presented above were adapted 1 from Bennett Means and Mock First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 8) VI. REFERENCES CITED Bennett, David The Creation of Bridges: From Vision to Reality, the Ultimate Challenge of Architecture, Design, and Distance. Aurum Press, London. California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) Bridge Report, Bridge No. 30 July. Report on file, California Department of Transportation Library, Sacramento. City of Napa 1914a Minutes of the City Council, Book 8, p. 29. 1 September. Minutes on file, Office of the City Clerk of the City Council, Napa, California. Minutes of the City Council, Book 8, p. 31. 8 September.
Minutes on file, Office of the City Clerk of the City Council, Napa, California. 1915a Minutes of the City Council, Book 8, p. 74. 2 February. Minutes on file, Office of the City Clerk of the City Council, Napa, California. Minutes of the City Council, Book 8, p. 91. 30 March. Minutes on file, Office of the City Clerk of the City Council, Napa, California. Minutes of the City Council, Book 8, p. 20 April. Minutes on file, Office of the City Clerk of the City Council, Napa, California. Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) National Register of Historic Places Determination of Eligibility, Historic Bridges of California: Concrete Arch, Concrete Girder, Concrete Slab, Canticrete, Stone Masonry, Suspension, Steel Girder, and Steel Arch (Thematic).
Federal Highway Commission, California Division, Sacramento. Copies available from the Cultural Studies Office, California Department of Transportation, Sacramento. Gregory, Tom History of Solano and Napa Counties, California. Historic Record Company, Los Angeles. Hodge, Christopher D. First Street Bridge over Napa River Rehabilitation vs. Replacement Study Addendum. Draft. T. Y. Lin International, Sacramento. Submitted to the City of Napa Department of Public Works, Bridge and Urban Drainage Division. Leonard, John B., and W. P. Day The Concrete Bridge: A Book on Why the Concrete Bridge is Replacing Other Forms of Bridge Construction. Press of H. S. Crocker Company, San Francisco. First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 9) Means, R. S.
Means Illustrated Construction Dictionary. Unabridged 3rd ed. R. S. Means Company, Kingston, Massachusetts. Mikesell, Stephen D. Bridge Evaluations: Bridge First Street over Napa Creek; Bridge First Street over Napa River Overflow; Bridge Third Street over Napa River, Napa County, California. JRP Historical Consulting Services, Davis, California. Mock, Elizabeth B. The Architecture of Bridges. Museum of Modem Art, New York. Napa County Landmarks, Inc. Correspondence from Merlin Wedepohl to Gary Lindowski, City of Napa Cultural Heritage Commission. 29 April. Letter on file, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Sacramento District, Sacramento. Napa County Reporter [Napa, California] A Bridge Falls In. 4 February: 1. Napa, California.
Napa Daily Journal [Napa, California] 1914a Call for Bids for Building Reinforced Concrete Bridge over Napa River on East First Street, Napa, California. 17 June:6. Napa, California. Bridge Bonds All Right. 8 August: 1. Napa, California. Napa Reporter [Napa, California] First Street Bridge. 7 March:3. Napa, California. Napoli, Donald S. National Register of Historic Places Registration Form, First Street Bridge. 31 March. Form on file, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Sacramento District, Sacramento. National Park Service Guidelines for Architectural and Engineering Documentation. Federal Register Snyder, John W. The Bridges of John B. Leonard, to Concrete International U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) Programmatic Agreement among the U.S.
Army Corps of Engineers, Sacramento District, the Federal Highway Administration, and the California State Historic Preservation Officer Reg- arding the Napa River/Napa Creek Flood Control Project, Napa County, California. Agree- ment on file, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Sacramento District, Sacramento. First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 10) U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) 7.5-minute quadrangle, Napa, California. U.S. Geological Survey, Washington, First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 11) ~ 3 o 125 250 375 500 m Scale Universal Transverse Mercator coordinate system and grid UTM Zone 1o projection North American Datum Clarke ellipsoid Napa, California 7.5-minute USGS quadrangle (digital raster graphic) Statistical Research, lnc.,August 3, m Figure 1.
Project location Napa, California, 7.5-minute USGS quadrangle [photorevised First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 12) Figure 2. Oblique aerial of the First Street Bridge over the Napa River, view to the north, (photograph courtesy of the City of Napa Department of Public Works). First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 13) t LPO:: ___ _ b! n.oec ELEVATION LOOKING DOWNSTREAM SCALE: 1 20' 42' 8' &' ;_ I . 9' UTILITY PIPES .-; HAUNCHED GIRDER, TYPICAL DECK SECTION SCALE: 1" 10' Figure 3. Elevation and deck section of First Street Bridge (Hodge First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 14) ~ 0 0 N Q) C, "C -0 :c Q) C, "C ;: - aJ Q) -- :;; ~ ... Q) Cl ( /) ... 1/j .91 i:I ii: ..: J Q) a -:: 0 Q) s; - E C: 0 -t (.) Q) (/) 0) & i:I ...
Q) ::I C, ii: First Street Bridge (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-340 (page 15) First Street Bridge, Napa River, Cal. Figure 5. Postcard, ca. depicting the wood-truss bridge over the Napa River at First Street (postcard courtesy of Al Edmister).
The federal surveyors worked through Napa building by building. These are the other structures
they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.
Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CA-340. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.