Quarters 1 is listed in the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A and C, in the areas of military history and architecture. The period of significance ranges from to Quarters 1 was built in as the Commander's Residence for the United States Naval Training Station, the only training station on the west coast at the time. It is an unusual example of a U.S. Naval residence in the Classical Revival style, which had become fashionable for private residences in the San Francisco Bay Area in the but was not typical of Naval base housing, most of which was built in later periods. The six adjacent Classical Revival Quarters are registered contributors to the designated eligible Senior Officers' Quarters National Register District.
They represent all of the major unmodified buildings on the island dating to its use as a Naval Training Station. ^ Description: Quarters 1 is a Classical Revival, two storey wood frame rectangular house of square feet, built on a brick foundation and clad in weatherboard siding. The main central element has a hipped roof with three dormers and is flanked by parapeted wings to each side set back from the front of the main building. The windows on the ground floor in the main section are primarily 1/1 double hung wooden sash with molded architraves with straight, molded cornices, where the wings are primarily solariums with multiple square lights.
A three-bay flat roof porch with fluted Doric columns and paneled square columns at the corners is centered on the main facade, with a canopied walkway at the front, and walkways at each side of the porch. A greensward sweeps down the hill from the house and formal gardens are built into the hillside behind the house. The main, ground floor rooms: living room, dining room, study, and central reception hall, have handsome Classical detail and other features such as Ionic Columns. Minor modifications were made after the fire that damaged the upper floor. The central dormer, originally larger that the other two, was rebuilt to match them, and the porches on the wings were closed in.
Quarters 1 and the smaller associated Classical Revival residences are in good condition and retain their historic architectural integrity. Historical Context: Quarters 1 was built as part of the initial wave of building construction that established the Naval Training Station, on what was then known as Goat Island in San Francisco Bay, as an active base between and Occupied by the Army beginning in President McKinley in issued an Executive Order to set aside a "goodly portion" of the island for ^. a Naval Station. The first barracks and the Commander's Quarters were completed in | At the time it was built, the Naval Training Station was one of four such facilities in the United States and the only one on the West Coast.
Typically, between four and five hundred trainees were present at the station at any given time. NAVAL TRAINING STATION, QUARTERS 1 (Naval Station Commander's Quarters, Nimitz House) HAER No. CA - 233-A (Page 2) Dozens of buildings were constructed there between and most have been demolished, but the Senior Officers' Quarters 1 -8 still remain in primarily original condition. The Training Station was a key facility for the Navy, ultimately too important to be housed on the limited usable land. During preparations for WWI the Navy developed a second California Training Station in San Diego and the operations at the Yerba Buena site were moved to San Diego in representing a large step in the transfer of major Navy installations from northern California to San Diego.
The island was renamed Yerba Buena Island in and the third decade saw the construction of the San Francisco- Oakland Bay Bridge Tunnel through its mid-section and construction of Treasure Island on adjacent land fill for the Worlds Fair and Exposition. After the Yerba Buena Naval Station and during WWII the Treasure Island Naval Station were used as a Receiving Ship facility. At the end of WWII the entire Yerba Buena Island- Treasure Island Naval Station was severely downsized and re-oriented to an unrelated training facility and all non-residential buildings on Yerba Buena Island were demolished or converted for residential use to serve the training center on Treasure Island.
The land was transferred to the City of San Francisco as part of the Military Base Closures in the mid Admiral Chester Nimitz, Commander of the U.S. Pacific Fleet during WWII, had full use of Quarters 1 from and died there in but his principal residence was in the East Bay, therefore it was not designated under Criterion B, associated with a notable person during its period of significance.