BlockBefore

Rock Creek Dam, East end of Rock Creek Road, Auburn

Rock Creek Dam, East end of Rock Creek Road, Auburn, Placer County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CAL,31-AUB.V,1-, with a 3,262-word written history.

From the record

“The Rock Creek Dam is the only known example of a double-hinged multiple arch dam in California and the only unaltered, unfixed hinge dam in the western United States.”

Written record, HAER CAL,31-AUB.V,1- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CAL,31-AUB.V,1- · the record runs 3262 words · one of 28 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

53 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,31-AUB.V,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

3. 5 miles north of Auburn, Placer County, California USGS Auburn Quadrangle, Photorevised UTM Coordinates: Zone 10, north end of dam N, E; south end of dam N, E Date(s) of Construction: modified Builder: Pacific Gas & Electric Company Present Owner(s): Pacific Gas & Electric Company Present Occupant(s): Pacific Gas & Electric Company

Significance

3147 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,31-AUB.V,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Rock Creek Dam is the only known example of a double-hinged multiple arch dam in California and the only unaltered, unfixed hinge dam in the western United States. Report Prepared by: Cindy L. Baker, Historian PAR Environmental Services, Inc. Street Sacramento, CA Date: April 16, ROCK CREEK DAM HAER NO. CA-238 Page2

Description

The Rock Creek Dam is a concrete multiple arch dam flanked by two earthen embankment dams near Auburn, California (see pages 9 and It is comprised of 34 arches, each with a 30-foot span, and associated supporting buttresses. It has a crest length of feet and a maximum height of 36 feet from foundation to crest. The buttresses are four feet long and 12 inches thick in plan on top and increase in thickness two inches for each five feet in depth. Oh the downstream face, the buttresses have a batter of one in twenty and in the plane of this face at 17 feet intervals horizontal reinforced concrete beams are used to brace them.

The ninth and tenth arched bays from the north end of the dam have a crest that is three feet lower than the rest of the dam and their sloped convex sides form the eastern exterior of the spillway (see photo CA-238-13). The width of the spillway is 60 feet. The area between the spillway and its associated arches is enclosed, forming a gallery accessed by gated doorways (see photo CA- A 30-inch-diameter sluice pipe extends beneath the spillway from the reservoir and drains into Rock Creek. The present structure reflects only one modification made to the structure since it was constructed in the addition of steel tension rods in attached to buttresses at the mid- section of the dam (see photo CA-238-23).

The original plan and construction, as well as subsequent modifications, are detailed in Section II. On-site examination of the dam, an analysis of engineering drawings and reports, and archival research indicate that the historical integrity of the original dam does remain largely intact. The percentage of intact historical fabric is estimated at between 95 and 100 percent. II. ARCIDTECTURAL AND ENGINEERING INFORMATION Original Dam The Pacific Gas & Electric Company (PG&E) constructed the Rock Creek Dam. The structure is part of the Drum-Spaulding Hydroelectric System located on the Wise Canal section of that system.

While work on the system began in construction on the Wise Canal section did not begin until At the time it was constructed, the Rock Creek Dam was noted in technical journals for its unusual double hinge design. Modifications In PG&E added steel tension rods to the central buttresses of the dam. This required notching the tops of the affected buttresses and drilling holes for anchor bolts. There have been no other modifications to the dam. ROCK CREEK DAM HAER NO. CA-238 Page3 III. HISTORICAL INFORMATION PG&E's Spaulding-Drum Power Development History Hydroelectric generation began to take hold in California during the As high voltage transmission technology evolved, the transportation of electrical power over hundreds of miles became possible and development surged.

Great Western Power Company, Oregon-California Power Company, Sacramento Valley Power Company, Oro Electric, Northern California Power Company and PG&E all rushed to secure rights for hydroelectric development on rivers in northern California. PG&E acquired important rights and began building power plants and reservoirs to use these rights (Fowler Hockett Means 12, Shoup and Cornford In the early PG&E began hydroelectric development of its water rights from the South Fork of the Yuba River. This water was captured at feet above mean sea level (amsl) and passed through a series of canals, tunnels and reservoirs to power three separate powerhouses before reaching an elevation of less than 500 feet amsl.

This massive project created a system that began with the construction of Spaulding Dam, near Emigrant Gap in Placer County. Known at the time as the Spaulding-Drum Power Development, the lower section of the project was later named for James H. Wise, one of the project's engineers killed in an unrelated accident during construction. Today the entire system is known as the Drum- Spaulding System (Sibley Vensano Water impounded behind Spaulding Dam was released to pass through Drum Canal to the Drum Powerhouse. The powerhouse released the water to the Bear River. Downstream near Colfax, the water was again diverted to the Bear River Canal, an artificial primarily earthwork canal, that led to the Halsey powerhouse fore bay. A penstock dropped the water to the Halsey powerhouse.

There it flowed to the Rock Creek Reservoir where it was impounded by the multiple arch dam. Water was then released from Rock Creek Reservoir to the Wise Powerhouse forebay and, ultimately, to the Wise Powerhouse (see page In the Drum-Spaulding project continued with construction of the Rock Creek Reservoir and Dam. PG&E engineer R. A. Monroe designed the detail work of the Rock Creek Dam with input from consulting engineers, including the noted multiple arch dam designer John Eastwood. The engineers decided on using the popular multiple arch technique.

At feet in length, it was hailed at the time as the longest multiple arch dam ever built (Downing 11; Jackson Monroe The dam was built across the channel of Rock Creek, creating a reservoir to store water and regulate its flow to the Halsey and Wise powerhouses. The dam was built in two sections; a multiple arch dam, consisting of 34 arches with 30-foot spans crossing the main channel of the creek, and an 825-foot-long earthen embankment dam that joined the south end of the arch dam (see page 12 and photo CA-238-18). The dam was designed to eventually be raised 17 feet to ROCK CREEK DAM HAER NO.

CA-238 Page4 increase storage capacity (see page At that time, the earthen embankment dam would have been replaced with another multiple arch dam (Monroe Construction began by late summer with the erection of a concrete plant at one end of the dam and a trestle five feet above the final length of the crest. Workmen pushed ore cars with a 20-cubic-foot capacity filled with concrete over the 8-foot-wide trestle. The concrete was poured through spouts to first fill the buttress forms, which were each filled in one pour. The arches were then poured in three 12-arch sections, the concrete being poured the entire length of the section.

Each section required two eight-hour shifts to complete (Monroe The recently completed dam was impounding water by February when PG&E led an official tour of the lower system. During the tour from just above the Halsey Powerplant to the Wise Powerplant, F. S. Myrtle described the Rock Creek Dam as the most interesting feature of the inspection writing, " . . . this multiple-arch structure . . . is more than worth the time and trouble of a visit.

It is said to be the longest multiple-arch dam ever constructed, and it possesses the additional distinguishing feature of having its arches hinged at their abutments, thus permitting the deflection of the arch without causing cracks at the points of attachment" (Downing Myrtle Sibley Concerns over safety in the led to the only modifications to the dam with the addition of steel tension rods. These rods are bolted to buttresses in the mid-section of the dam and intended to strengthen them. Other than this minor alteration, the Rock Creek Dam is visually unaltered, leaving it today a unique example of multiple arch dam technology.

Technological History Eastwood, an engineer from southern California, had pioneered the new multiple arch dam construction design while surveying a large hydroelectric program on Big Creek, a tributary of the San Joaquin River. Eastwood's design relied on a row of joined reinforced concrete arches resting at an angle against a triangular buttress. Water pressure on the upstream face weighted the arches to keep the dam in place.

The arch shape offered great strength even with thin walls and lower material costs, a major consideration in remote mountain regions (Hay The first dam constructed using this technique was the Hume Lake Dam built by Eastwood for a lumber company in (Coleman The multiple arch dam design continued to be used in the West throughout the and and was apparently not constructed elsewhere in United States. Other than Eastwood, only a few engineers used the multiple-arch dam design. These included western states engineers Jorgenson, Fred Noetzli, B. F. Jakobsen, H. C. Vensano, and R. P.

Mcintosh (Jackson The Rock Creek Dam was noted in technical journals of the time for its unusual double hinge design (see page In the editor of the Journal of Electricity wrote, "Multiple arch dams under certain definite conditions are finding broad applications throughout the West. ROCK CREEK DAM HAER NO. CA-238 Pages [The Rock Creek Dam] is a new advance in such design in that knuckle joints are made at the juncture of each arch with its support [see photo CA-238-1]. This provision makes possible a certain elasticity and freedom from strain not otherwise experienced in multiple arch installation. This . . .

should receive wide attention from engineers throughout the West" (Monroe Eastwood had first used a hinge feature in the design of the Kennedy Mining and Milling Company dam at Jackson in Amador County, probably the only comparable dam to the Rock Creek Dam. Eastwood used a three-hinge system (see page never the double hinge, during his dam building career. Eastwood used the hinge system hoping to relieve stress fractures at the arch-buttress junctions. Arch movement during temperature fluctuation, he believed, caused these fractures.

When post-construction inspections after seemed to indicate that arches didn't move, the hinge system proved unnecessary and was never used again (Jackson While PG&E's use of a multiple arch dam was not surprising, the Rock Creek design as a double hinge dam was both innovative and unique (see photo CA-238-2 and CA-238-3) (Jackson Typical multiple arch dams were built without hinges, the buttresses and arches creating one solid unit.

The Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas described the novel double hinge design as follows: Its unusual feature of design, which is the creation of the civil engineering talent of the Pacific Gas & Electric Company, is the freedom of motion that is given to each arch in order that it may properly adjust itself to varying strains and stresses that it may be required to carry. Each slanting arch being thus free in itself rests upon its own individual support. The pressure of water upon the arch seals the connection, thus making it water tight [Sibley Questions over the safety of multiple arch dams began to be raised within the engineering community as early as the However, real concerns emerged in after the disastrous failure of the St.

Francis Dam in Santa Clarita Valley killed 450 people. Although a study in concluded that the dam had been built resting on an unstable geologic formation, the immediate reaction in was to blame the dam's design. The State of California reacted by creating the Division of Dam Safety Office (DODS), known today as the Division of Safety of Dams, under the Department of Water Resources. Independently, a group of engineers and geologists formed the Multiple Arch Dam Advisory Committee and began inspecting numerous dams throughout California under the leadership of Walter Huber, a civil engineer in Los Angeles (Jackson Los Angeles Times 9 August The committee visited 19 multiple arch dams, thoroughly inspecting and photographing each of them.

The committee noted that all were of the fixed-end arch type, with the exception of the Rock Creek Dam with its two-hinged arch (Dennis Huber Jackson ROCK CREEK DAM HAER NO. CA-238 Page6 The DODS began annual inspection of the Rock Creek Dam in keeping a thorough accounting of the dam's condition over time and giving approval for any alterations that occurred. During initial approval by the Office, Dam Inspector Gerald McKinlay noted that the dam was, "the two hinged Eastwood type of exceptional heavy construction for such a low height. " McKinlay found only one buttress to be cracked 14 years after initial construction (McKinlay Other than the modifications, PG&E has made no visible alterations to the Rock Creek multiple arch dam.

It remains today a striking visual reminder of a short-lived dam design that spanned from the construction of the Hume Lake Dam in to the late It is also a singular example of the even shorter-lived hinge dam period that spanned from to and is the only known double hinge dam in existence.

Project Information

This documentation has been prepared at the request of PG&E, which is proposing to encase buttresses numbered 15 through 30 in nine inches of "shotcrete" as part of a seismic retrograde project. The shotcrete-reinforced jacket would be attached to the buttresses by a network of embedded dowels. The new shotcrete would extend the full height of each of the buttresses identified for strengthening. The Project Manager for the recordation was Glenn Caruso of PG&E. Cindy L. Baker of PAR Environmental Services was the Senior Historian and author of the written documentation. The photographer was David Devries of Mesa Technical of Berkeley, California.

The documentation is based on a previous investigation conducted by PAR Environmental Services reported in National Register of Historic Places Evaluation of Rock Creek Dam, Placer County, California III.

Sources

Barieau, J.E. "Irrigation System Recently Developed in Auburn-Newcastle Region, Placer County." In The Pacific Service, November Vol. IX, No. 6. On file, California State Library, Sacramento. Coleman, C. M. P. G. & E: The Centennial Story of Pacific Gas and Electric Company, McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., New York. ROCK CREEK DAM HAER NO. CA-238 Page7 Dennis, H. W. Correspondence with Walter L. Huber, August 24, On file, Water Resources Collection Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Downing, P. M. "The South Yuba-Bear River Development as Completed to Date" in Pacific Se-rvice Magazine, June On file, California State Library, California Room. Dreyer, H. Topograhical map of Rock Creek Reservoir. On file, Pacific Gas and Electric Company, San Francisco. Fowler, F. H.

Hydroelectric Power Systems of California and their Extensions into Oregon and Nevada. United States Geological Survey, Washington, D. C. Hay, D. Hydroelectric Development in the United States, New York State Museum. Prepared for the Task Force on Cultural Resource Management, Washington, D. C. Hockett, H. Report on the Pit River Development of the Pacific Gas and Electric Company. University of California, Berkeley. On file, Water Resources Collection Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Huber, W. L. Correspondence with Edward Hyatt, State Engineer. On file, Water Resources Collection Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Jackson, D. C. Building the Ultimate Dam: John S. Eastwood and the Control of Water in the West. University Press of Kansas.

Personal communication with Cindy L. Baker, PAR Environmental Services, Inc. Notes on file. PAR Environmental Services, Sacramento, California. Los Angeles Times Untitled article concerning the St. Francis Dam Disaster. Metro News Section, August 9, On file, California State Library, California Room, Sacramento. ROCK CREEK DAM HAER NO. CA-238 Pages McKinlay, G. "Memorandum to Mr. Hawley, Rock Creek Dam No. Inspected May 21, On file, Department of Water Resources, Sacramento. Means, T. H. Water Right Values - Pit River. On file, Water Resources Collection Archives, University of California, Berkeley. Monroe, R. A. "RockCreekMultipleArchDam." Journal of Electricity. June 1, No. 11, Vol. 38. On file, California State Library, California Room. Myrtle, F. S.

"Wise Power Plant Added to 'Pacific Service'," in Pacific Service Magazine, March Vol. 8, No. 10. On file, California State Library, California Room. Shoup, L. H. and D. Cornford The Caribou 1 Powerhouse: An Historic Overview and National Register of Historic Places Evaluation. Prepared for Pacific Gas and Electric Company, San Francisco. Sibley, R. "The Bear River Canal" in Journal of Electricity, Power and Gas, Vol. 37, No. 17, October 21, On file, California State Library, California Room. Vensano, H. C. Final Report of the Physical and Historical Data with Calculations on the Spaulding- Drum Power Development. On file, Pacific Gas and Electric Archives, San Bruno. ROCK CREEK DAM HAER No. CA-238 Page9

Area Enlarged

Project Vicinity Foresthill SACRAMENTO Scale 0 20 Miles Project Vicinity Map ROCK CREEK DAM HAER No. CA-238 Page 10 AUBURN, CA PHOTOREVISED 7.5 MINUTE SERIES (TOPOGRAPHIC) FEET 1 .5 0 1 KILOMETER E""3 E3 E3 E3 E""3 Project Location Map ROCK CREEK DAM HAER No. CA-238 Page 11 The Lower Section of the Drum-Spaulding Hydroelectric Development (Barieau This lower section was also known as the Wise System. 6n3 '...i Sufi~ i"l- ~ & ..v"..J,>La___ - - - - - -- - - . -- - / , ('ormal ofo;ch nng ,~ A ,; / // ~ .---------E.T - - ___ ! I ,. I : I 1 l: 1, 1 fomcrr10~ J foreachto ~I , ... , / // I r 1 1 'I' , ' 1 I ,. 1 I depfh / / /,' ,' 1 ~ I 1 I // : I ;1 :1 ; // ! ! I,! ~I: :~ , / /I' / I ;._ 16 I I I ~" <- .. - . -- - - - .

- - - __, ' ,~, / I - - '11 / / ,, / I I I I I / ,' ,,, / I 'I'' I I I ,,/ / // 1 II [ ! I I , ,, /,, I I I fim5h.lopof.:trchnnq ' . / l i If beYEI / x - , ' I j .. -wi---, - I; "- ,:- I ~ i .I .e-..,., A % :-. +::i.:---1 : j I ijr-T l i I1 0 I -~ i 'I , I 1 ' I I -t~ 0 I /Z J IS Circular I! - j. bor3 ~,. ch. l' ! =r - -A I I i - L"'?J-r<inf: . : i i I i "k. .~W_i I :~ &.:tmA-t. ~ L l Balter imzo I .. __ l"I /IMO 1 4- I ~ l, ou~Ftnc, I I m10 la:a 'Bvllros!> fo xlend ;,,fo -"Oli<I roe.If wilh ba:J~ nof'c~d o~ 1ffl:licol~d. S _ _ _ _ _ ao~o A RE.AR E.LEVATIDN SIDE. ELE.VATIDN OF BUTTRE.55 to ba built cu. shoV'tn by ~olid J linn COom Fufu re c.xf&n&ions indic.at.d by dottc.d . L ,.#kell..,OOCkef" ~ Buttress Elevation Drawing Depicting Future Extension Plans (Monroe ~ =o >n ~~ ~n z~ ?

~ >-c n ~ ~ > 0 (D N > ~~~ NQO ~ ROCK CREEK DAM HAER No. CA-238 Page 13 i I,. j' i I . :1 .1 .! I I I Double Hinge Detail Drawing, 1916(Monroe1916). Eastwood's influence is clearly evident when compared with the design below. - Hon-nol Section neorTop ~ Norma\ Pion at Top Eastwood's Three Hinge Detail Drawing,' i915 (Jackson Eastwood's design is strikingly similar to the Creek Design, with the additional hinge at the arch crown (Jackson ROCK CREEK DAM HAER No. CA-238 Page 14. Topographical Map of Rock Creek Reservoir at Completion (Dreyer

In context

Auburn, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Placer County, California 357 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Auburn

7 records

The federal surveyors worked through Auburn building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Henry Stone HouseHABS CAL,31-AUB,6-38 words
Fire House & Commercial BuildingsHABS CAL,31-AUB,5-35 words
Old Town City Hall (Ruins)HABS CAL,31-AUB,7-35 words
AuburnHABS CAL,31-AUB,2-34 words
Lincoln Way & Maple Street (Commercial Building)HABS CAL,31-AUB,4-32 words
Auburn (Chinese Section)HABS CAL,31-AUB,1-30 words
Commercial BuildingsHABS CAL,31-AUB,3-30 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CAL,31-AUB.V,1-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.