BlockBefore

Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2, Spanning Zaca Creek at Jonata Park Road, Buellton

Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2, Spanning Zaca Creek at Jonata Park Road, Buellton, Santa Barbara County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CAL,42-BUEL.V,4-, with a 4,014-word written history.

From the record

“Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2 is significant because it is a rare example of a pre- World War I short-span reinforced concrete girder bridge once common in California.”

Written record, HAER CAL,42-BUEL.V,4- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CAL,42-BUEL.V,4- · the record runs 4014 words · one of 167 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

49 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,42-BUEL.V,4-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Jonata Park Road spanning Zaca Creek 3 .1 miles north of Buellton Santa Barbara County, California USGS 7. 5' Zaca Creek, California, quadrangle UTM Coordinates: ~ 1r 1 l"O '}Siz.+l.u. 313iH 7 1 N Date of Construction: Engineer: Edward L. Mayberry, Llewellyn Parker, and Fred L. Johnston Builder: Unknown

Significance

3893 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,42-BUEL.V,4-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2 is significant because it is a rare example of a pre- World War I short-span reinforced concrete girder bridge once common in California. Additionally, the important Los Angeles engineering firm of Mayberry & Parker designed the bridge-these engineers fashioned innovative concrete reinforced bridges and structures in various places throughout the western United States. The bridge is part of the original state highway system alignment that established an all-weather route in Santa Barbara County which makes Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2 locally important. Report Prepared By: Kevin (Lex) Palmer Applied EarthWorks, Inc. North Fruit Avenue Suite 101 Fresno, CA Date: July ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page2

Description

Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2 is an 88-foot-long three-span reinforced concrete girder bridge (Photos 1 and 2). The two-lane cantilevered roadway bridge is 23. 7 feet wide and has traces of a bituminous surface that once covered the poured concrete highway. The reinforced concrete 48-foot-long main span is a haunched rectangular girder with a curved soffit. This smooth-surfaced bridge has solid rails and no pedestrian walkway. Bronze commemorative plaques are located on the southeast and northwest pilasters (see Photos 3, 4, and The north road approach lacks guardrails. The south road approach has a historic wood post and steel guard rail on the southeast and a more current steel and wood post guardrail on the southwest side of the road (Photo 6). Zaca Creek Bridge No.

2 is located on Jonata Park Road, which takes its name from the Rancho San Carlos de Jonata land grant surrounding the study area. The bridge lies near the eastern terminus of the east-west trending Purisima Hills which are covered by oak savannah vegetation. The locale's characteristic topography consists of shallow canyons formed by seasonal streams. The hills, which border the study area on the east and west, rise an average of 300 feet above the bridge to a typical height of 900 feet above sea level. Highway engineers took advantage of this topographical break in the Purisima Hills formed by the effects of eight creeks that join Zaca Creek immediately north of the study area. These watercourses flow south approximately 2 miles and meet the Santa Ynez River.

Valley oaks and willows growing in Zaca Creek typify the study area. Highway 101 is 50 yards east ofthe bridge, a retail horse trailer supply business is located to the southeast, the road forms the north and south borders of the bridge, and private residences are found immediately to the southwest and northwest. On-site reconnaissance of the bridge, review of engineering drawings and reports, and archival research indicates that the structure retains its integrity. Although the main span is 1 foot longer (48 feet) than called for in the bridge plans, the field review revealed that the remaining bridge construction specifications are accurate. ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page3 II. ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING INFORMATION Zaca Creek Bridge No.

2 Station 472 was designed by Edward L. Mayberry, Jr. and Llewellyn Parker of Los Angeles in association with Fred L. Johnston of Santa Barbara. Unfortunately, no information is available on the construction or contractors who built Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2. Prior to the California Highway Commission required counties to build bridges for the new state highway system. With its rugged terrain that required over 100 bridges, Santa Barbara County hired the Los Angeles civil engineering firm of Mayberry & Parker during the State Highway 2 construction project to design county highway bridges. The engineers had an excellent reputation for designing reinforced concrete bridges and buildings. Working with specifications provided by Santa Barbara County Surveyor OwenH.

O'Neil, Mayberry & Parker and Johnston produced a series of bridge plans for the Zaca Creek area in the 3rd Road District, and the highway between Gaviota and Santa Barbara (Snyder 1). A notable extant example of their work in Santa Barbara County is the Arroyo Quemado Bridge on Highway north of Refugio State Park (Bridge No.

The Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors authorized Mayberry & Parker to design the six Zaca Creek bridges, three others near Los Alamos, and four in De La Cuesta Canyon in (Morning Press Other county bridge projects at the time included construction of a Santa Ynez River crossing; in the month of November 17 bridges were in various stages of construction (Morning Press County Surveyor O'Neil provided the following specifications for contractors constructing the Zaca Creek bridges. Concrete Proportions Coarse No.1 Coarse No. 2 Cement Sacks 1 Fine Aggregate Aggregate Class Use (no.) (cubic feet) (cubic feet) (cubic feet) A All reinforced concrete 1 2.0 2.0 1.5 B Caissons 1 2.5 3.0 2.0 1 94-pound sacks.

O'Neil required the contractors to mix concrete with a batch mixer and pour it into forms that had studding wired together with No. 10 galvanized wire. Upon completion of construction, the ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page4 abutments as well as the backs and ends of the wing wall received a coat ofasphaltic paint (Clerk of the Board File Agreement). Based on documents from contemporaneous bridges constructed on Zaca Creek, the bridge would have been built using subcontractors who supplied horse-drawn dump wagons to haul fill. Quarry sources included a supply at the mouths of Cuesta and Zaca canyons, while other contractors shipped crushed rock in by railcar.

Other tasks such as pile driving also were subcontracted (Clerk of the Board File Notice of Claim, Application for Extension). The completed bridge begins with a 20-foot-long span on the south that had a wing wall. A counterfort and abutment hold back soil on the south bank of Zaca Creek (Photo 7, Drawings This counterfort is more extensive than the north bank counterfort (Photo 8, Drawings 3 and 4). Both of the abutments have weep holes formed by 4-inch galvanized sheet iron pipe. The bridge ends with a 20-foot-long span between the north counterfort and north abutment. An expansion joint is situated on the north abutment (Drawing 7). The Arch Rib System the bridge engineers developed is apparent in all three spans (Photos Drawing 5).

A series of rectangular recesses appear in both sides of each span's rail. A curved soffit extends down from the exterior rails along all three girder spans. Pilasters cap the north and south ends of both rails and each abutment column. Bronze commemorative plaques were placed on the interior of the northwest and southeast pilasters (Photo Construction of the six Zaca Creek area bridges took place between February and October County plans indicate all the bridges possessed Mayberry & Parker and Johnston design qualities and technology, including the Arch Rib System they developed for the floor system (Clerk of the Board Files and Bridge Plans). On the southernmost bridge, local contractors M. R. Dominguez and H. E.

Walter entered into a contract with the County of Santa Barbara on 22 May to build an 85-foot reinforced concrete girder bridge at Station 310 The Santa Barbara based firm beat out five other Los Angeles contractors with a bid of$26,000 (Clerk of the Board File Bids for Construction). William M. Ledbetter of Los Angeles secured contracts to build three bridges at Stations 562 565 and 574 +75 by putting in three low bids. Ledbetter also constructed the extant Arroyo Quemado Bridge. Ledbetter bid on the Station 562 +50 bridge project, for the Station 565 +50 bridge, and for construction of the Station 574 +75 bridge (Clerk of the Board File Proposal for Construction; Clerk of the Board File Proposal for Construction).

During construction, Ledbetter utilized rock shipped by rail from a Pacific Coast Coal Company quarry and a second pit in Watsonville for construction of all three highway bridges (Clerk of the Board File Request for Extension). ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page 5 Zaca Creek Bridges Constructed in Station Bridge Traits Contractor Comments Station 310 +50 Two 41.8-foot-long and 23.8-foot- M. R. Dominguez and Demolished wide simple girder spans with central H. E. Walter of Santa pier and abutment wing walls Barbara Station 448 +00 Two 42-foot-long and 25-foot-wide Charles L. Krug and Extant, demolition simple girder spans with central pier Robert A. Sneathen, pending and abutment wing walls partners in Krug & Co.

Station 472 Three simple girder spans 88 feet No information Extant, demolition long and 23. 7 feet wide pending Station 562 +50 One simple girder span 45 feet long W. M.

Ledbetter of Demolished and feet wide with abutment Los Angeles wing walls Station 565 +50 One simple girder span feet long W.M.Ledbetterof Demolished and feet wide with abutment Los Angeles Extended feet long wing walls northeast wing wall Station 574 +75 One simple girder span feet long W.M.Ledbetterof Demolished and feet wide with abutment Los Angeles win walls State transportation officials authorized realignment of Highway 101 to the east in This decision forced motels and roadside businesses located on what became Jonata Park Road to close by the early (Santa Barbara News Press Four of the six Mayberry & Parker- designed bridges were demolished during the realignment. ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page 6

Id. Historical Information

Community History The study area lies within the Rancho San Carlos de Jonata land grant, one of nearly 40 ranchos granted in present-day Santa Barbara County between and Granted to Jose Covarrubias and Joaquin Carrillo in the 26,630-acre rancho extended north of the Santa Ynez River. The drought broke the Covarrubias and Carrillo cattle partnership, and they sold the tract to Rufus Thompson Buell in Rufus and his brother developed the former rancho into a diverse farming operation. The Buell ranch produced crops typical of contemporary late nineteenth-century farms in Santa Barbara County and coastal California.

The Buells' operation included dryland grain (wheat, corn, and barley) farming, wine grapes, fruit trees, dairy cows, sheep, and cattle (Easton Gallery Mason A small community named Buellton grew on the north bank of the Santa Ynez River approximately 3. 5 miles north of the Buell Ranch. Buellton historically has been an unincorporated service community that catered to the local residents and highway travelers. The town's juxtaposition between the north-south Highway 101 route and east-west trending Highway 150 (today's Highway made it an ideal stop for those traveling between north and south Santa Barbara County and a destination for the residents of farming communities in the Lompoc and Santa Ynez valleys.

Buellton served as a stage stop for travelers heading east to Los Olivos on the stagecoach lines that serviced Santa Barbara County during the These lines connected to wharves at Gaviota and Lompoc where passengers could board coastal steamers. Travelers continued to pass through Buellton on their way to Los Olivos to catch the northbound Pacific Coast Railroad beginning in which allowed them to link up with a San Francisco-bound train (WPA Buellton' s service role grew as the automobile age fueled an increase in travelers during the early twentieth century.

A paved route spanning the Santa Ynez River, of particular importance to Buellton' s success, did not come until Crossing the river during the nineteenth century had proven fatal to a number of travelers on horseback and in stagecoaches who perished in high water or quicksand. With burgeoning automobile traffic in mind, state legislators authorized an $18 million bond issue in voters passed the measure the following year and a series of road building projects began. The State Legislature also created the California State Highway Commission to oversee this effort. The commission sought to establish a paved road from San Diego north to the Oregon border that would roughly follow El Camino Real.

Known as State Highway 2 in the route became today's Highway 1O1, one of the first major California highways. The drier interior weather of the Santa Ynez Valley and other factors prompted the State Highway Commission to place the road through ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page7 the smaller communities of Los Alamos and Buellton, rather than coastal burgs like Lompoc (Wilkinson Because the Highway Commission required counties to construct their own bridges, Santa Barbara County spent hundreds of thousands of dollars for bridge construction between and The County Board of Supervisors ignored County Surveyor Owen O'Neil's pleas for more personnel to aid in the bridge planning effort. O'Neil turned to consultants in Los Angeles for able bridge engineers.

By offering 2.5 percent of construction costs, O'Neil lured in quality engineers such as Mayberry & Parker, Thomas & Post, and Edward T. Flaherty. With over 100 bridges to construct, the County Board of Supervisors utilized designers from the California Highway Commission to expedite fashioning the reinforced concrete bridge at Arroyo Honda in (Federal Highway Administration Period newspapers contained numerous news articles regarding the establishment of new auto stages and road construction projects. Following completion of the new state highway and its series of bridges, automobile traffic naturally increased as auto camping and touring became popular. A Work Projects Administration (WP A) guidebook described the study area in " ...

the highway curves along the western rim of the Santa Ynez Valley, with the green-forested slopes of the La Purisima Hills dropping to the highway's edge" (WPA Buellton' s role as a farming supply center diminished as highway traveler services such as gas stations, motels, and roadside restaurants became prominent. In the late a tavern keeper gained notoriety for serving excellent split pea soup. Buellton established a reputation as the "Home of Split Pea Soup" with three competing restaurants by (WP A Roadside diners such as Anderson's Pea Soup and Mullen's Dining Cars served meals to auto travelers on Highway 101 during the post-Word War II boom years. The extant Dining Cars Cafe, a street car roadside diner, was established in a short distance south of the Zaca Creek Bridges.

State transportation officials had Highway 101 realigned to the east in This decision forced businesses on what became Jonata Park Road to close by the early and the area is now primarily residential and agricultural in nature (Santa Barbara News Press Technological History Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2 is significant because it is a rare example of a pre-World War I short-span reinforced concrete girder bridge once common in California. Between and bridges in this class accounted for 36 percent of California bridges, and 82 percent of all bridges were of reinforced concrete (Federal Highway Administration 14, Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2 exhibits popular construction techniques ofthe time and vernacular engineering techniques developed by consulting civil engineers. ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No.

CA-259 Page 8 Use of reinforced concrete in the United States began in Although American engineers did not adopt the technology as quickly as their European counterparts, concrete gained universal acceptance during the early twentieth century. Reinforced concrete became popular in the United States following the Universal Cement Exhibit at the San Francisco Panama Pacific International Exposition. Factors such as economy, ease of construction, and fireproof qualities resulted in a popular craze for the building material.

County Surveyor O'Neil followed a common practice by public agencies when he hired Mayberry & Parker to design a series of bridges, a hiring practice which faded away after (Federal Highway Administration The Highway 2 construction project was one of the earliest major routes through the state, a factor that obviously challenged O'Neil. Construction ofapproximately 100 miles of road in Santa Barbara proved difficult due to the lack of an established procedure and high number ofrequired bridges. 0 'Neil's use ofconsultants both helped resolve the bridge problem and produced a series ofunique structures that represent the lack of civil service engineering expertise then available in the public sector.

This situation nearly completely reversed itself by when state-employed engineers designed the bulk of California bridges (Federal Highway Administration American reinforced concrete bridges tend to have larger massing than their European counterparts. In California, the shortage of steel was offset by the availability of local high-quality cement and resulted in the state leading the nation in number of reinforced concrete bridges. The engineers who fashioned the majority of California bridges used concrete in a spirit of vernacular engineering. Their innovation resulted in a number of new systems, many of which were patented, including the Arch Rib System that the Mayberry & Parker and Johnston team utilized in the Zaca Creek bridges (Federal Highway Administration Drawing 3).

The civil engineering team ofMayberry & Parker has been well documented (Snyder Edward Mayberry, had family roots in the California building trade that dated to the gold rush. Mayberry was schooled at the University of California and Massachusetts Institute of Technology (M.I.T.). After obtaining work experience, he formed a partnership in Los Angeles in with Llewellyn Adelbert Parker. Mayberry had met Parker while he attended M.I. T. The men appear to have had similar early career experiences with private architecture/engineering firms that led them to leave and start their own business. The Mayberry & Parker partnership lasted from to and was based in Los Angeles (Snyder During their partnership, the engineers focused on reinforced concrete and structural steel.

The men fashioned a number of large buildings throughout the west, including the Panorama Theater in Los Angeles and a series of reinforced concrete Santa Fe Railroad hotels and stations (Snyder Mayberry & Parker also became known for their bridge designs such as the Arroyo Seco Linda Vista Viaduct in Pasadena ( believed to have been the first reinforced concrete viaduct-style bridge in the United States. Other projects included the Prospect Avenue Bridge also in Pasadena, and the ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page9 Salt River Bridge in Phoenix, Arizona. The Salt River Bridge was the longest concrete girder bridge in the world when it was completed in To the south of the study area, the men fashioned a series of 10 reinforced concrete bridges in Ventura County.

In Santa Barbara County, Mayberry & Parker are known to have designed the San Antonio Creek Bridge (No. in a 54-foot- long reinforced concrete girder bridge (Snyder 1). The extant Arroyo Quemado Bridge (Bridge No. also designed in is north ofRefugio State Park and has two two-rib reinforced concrete open spandrel arches with 11 spans. William Ledbetter constructed this bridge in addition to the three Zaca Creek bridges (Snyder While the civil engineering team of Mayberry & Parker is well know, little could be obtained on engineer Fred L. Johnston. County documents indicate that Johnston joined Mayberry & Parker in (Clerk of the Board File Specifications).

It appears that Fred Johnston, a Santa Barbara engineer, served as the local contact for the Mayberry & Parker Santa Barbara County Highway bridge design project. No information is available on Johnston in engineer trade sources such as Engineering News, The Architect and Engineer of California, and other standard professional biographical sources. Santa Barbara city directories indicate that Johnston worked as a civil engineer between and Perhaps in response to a slow down in bridge construction projects following completion of the state highway, Johnston entered Santa Barbara's brisk real estate business (Santa Barbara City Directory Another factor may have persuaded Johnston to change careers-by only Division of Highways engineers designed highway bridges.

As previously discussed, Santa Barbara County Surveyor Owen Hugh O'Neil played a large role in bridging Santa Barbara County and warrants attention. During the early twentieth century, O'Neil gained practical engineering training through work as a transitman, draftsman, and field engineer in the offices of the Santa Barbara City Engineer and Santa Barbara County Surveyor. He became County Surveyor in a position he held until O'Neil was active in professional engineering organizations (Snyder He played an important is role in estimating the costs, drafting the bridge specifications, and overseeing construction of the Santa Barbara County State Highway bridges from to All of the above persons and circumstances contributed to the history ofZaca Creek Bridge No. 2.

The structure represents the rise in automobile culture, growth of transportation in Santa Barbara County, and ways vernacular engineering solved problems using reinforced concrete to bridge the Zaca Creek area in Santa Barbara County. ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page 10 IV.

Sources

Easton Gallery Ranchos Santa Barbara Land Grant Ranches. Jane Freeburg Publisher, Santa Barbara, California. Federal Highway Administration National Register Eligibility Determination for Historic Bridges in California: Concrete Arch, Concrete Girder, Concrete Slab, Canticrete, Stone Masonry, Suspension, Steel Girder and Steel Arch. Federal Highway Administration, Washington, Mason, Jesse D. Facsimile Reproduction of Thompson and West'sl883 History of Santa Barbara & Ventura Counties California. Howell-North, Berkeley, California. Morning Press [Santa Barbara] Supervisors to Provide for 13 Bridges. 7 December:10. Santa Barbara, California. Good Progress Is Made on Bridges. 7 November: 11. Santa Barbara, California.

National Park Service Historic American Building Survey/Historic American Engineering Record (HABS/HAER) Online Database. ParkNet, National Park Service Links to the Past, www.cr.nps.gov/habshaer. National Register ofHistoric Places, National Register Information System (NRIS)/Index to Listings. ParkNet, National Park Service Links to the Past, www.cr.nps.gov/nr. Price, Barry A. Historic Property Survey Reportfor the Jonata Park Road Bridges Replacement Project, Santa Barbara County, California. Applied EarthWorks, Inc., Fresno, California. Submitted to Santa Barbara County Department of Public Works, Santa Barbara, California. Santa Barbara Directory Company City Directory, Santa Barbara, California. Santa Barbara Directory Company, Santa Barbara, California.

Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors Clerk of the Board Records, Files On file, County Administration Building, Santa Barbara, California. ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page 11 Santa Barbara News Press Railroad Dining Car Cafe Still Stands Near Buellton. 2 March:B-1. Santa Barbara, California. Diner Serves Up Helping ofHistory. 10 July:D-1. Santa Barbara, California. Snyder, John W. California Department of Transportation Memo to Historical/Architectural File, San Antonio Creek Bridge, Bridge No. February 6. An Evaluation of Arroyo Quemado Bridge on P.M 39. 75. California Department of Transportation, Sacramento. Wilkinson, Nancy Lee Perpetual Frontiers of the Central Coast: The Lompoc and Santa Maria Valleys, Santa Barbara County, California.

dissertation, University of Oregon. Works Projects Administration Santa Barbara A Guide to the Channel City and Its Environs. Southern California Writers' Project. Hastings House Publishers, New York. Plans Reinforced Concrete Bridge on the State Highway over Zaca Creek at Station 472 (77-A-48-Z-1 to 77-A-48-Z-6), Drawings County Administration Building, Santa Barbara, California. ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page 12

Project Information

Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2 Station 472 on Jonata Park Road (see attached location map) will be demolished as part of the Jonata Park Road Bridges Replacement Project (Price A Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) has been approved by the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) and California State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO) and accepted by the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP). The MOA requires the County of Santa Barbara Public Works Department, the current bridge owner, to mitigate the project through Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) documentation. Project Manager for the recordation was Barry Price of Applied EarthWorks, Inc. Kevin (Lex) Palmer of Applied EarthWorks, Inc. served as Principal Investigator, and William B.

Dewey of Santa Barbara, California, was the photographer for the project. ZACA CREEK BRIDGE NO. 2 HAER No. CA-259 Page 13 16 Location Map Quad Name: Zaca Creek Bridge No. 2 Zaca Creek, Calif. T7N - USGS Quad 0 Jonata Park Road Bridges Mile Replacement Project 0 Santa Barbara County, CA Feet 05-SB-O-CR 0 5 BROS- E--------l E-=-i F3 E-3 Kilometer BROS- Contour Interval: 40 Feet Prepared by Applied EarthWorks, Inc.

In context

Buellton, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Santa Barbara County, California 294 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Buellton

3 records

The federal surveyors worked through Buellton building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Zaca Creek Bridge No. 1HAER CAL,42-BUEL.V,3-4,409 words
La Casa de Cota de la CuestaHABS CAL,42-BUEL.V,2-310 words
La Casa de Eduardo de la CuestaHABS CAL,42-BUEL.V,1-275 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CAL,42-BUEL.V,4-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.