Cut Stone Bridge, Southern Pacific Railroad line spanning runoff channel at South Spruce Avenue, South San Francisco
Cut Stone Bridge, Southern Pacific Railroad line spanning runoff channel at South Spruce Avenue, South San Francisco, San Mateo County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CAL,41-SOSF,1-, with a 3,586-word written history.
From the record
“The Cut Stone Bridge is significant in engineering history.”
Written record, HAER CAL,41-SOSF,1- survey. Machine-read text.
Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CAL,41-SOSF,1- · the record runs 3586 words · one of 73 surveyed structures published for this county.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,41-SOSF,1-.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
South Spruce A venue near El Camino Real on the old San Francisco-San Jose Rail Line, South San Francisco, San Mateo County, California. USGS San Francisco South Quadrangle, UTM Coordinates: Date of Construction: Engineer: Unknown Builder: O.H. Rand South Spruce Avenue and Former Southern Pacific Railroad Crossing
Significance
3463 words
The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HAER CAL,41-SOSF,1-.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
The Cut Stone Bridge is significant in engineering history. It is eligible for the National Register under Criteria A and C, due to its age, associations, rarity and distinctiveness. It is an important example of California building practices in the The bridge is associated with the construction and operation of the San Francisco-San Jose railroad, a key event in the history of this section of northern California. The structure's construction, the materials used, its plan, architectural style, proportion and form are typical of the period. The basis of its historic significance is that it is one of few bridge structures that remain dating from the period. The bridge is considered to be of local significance. Report Prepared By: Hisashi B. Sugaya/Darlene Keyer/Laura Culberson Carey & Co.
Inc. 460 Bush Street San Francisco, CA Date: August 4, and January 19, CUT STONE BRIDGE HAER NO. CA-263 Page 2
Description
The Cut Stone Bridge was built by O.H. Rand in 1 and is considered a "structure significant in the theme of engineering history." Its construction is associated with the construction and operation of the San Francisco-San Jose Railroad, and is an important example of California building practices during the and characterizes details common to this type of resource. The bridge's method of construction, materials utilized, its style, proportion and form are distinctive. The Cut Stone Bridge or culvert was built to channel winter runoff under the old San Francisco-San Jose Railroad. 2 This assisted in alleviating the flooding of Colma Creek which halted this only means of transportation. 3 The bridge, located in South San Francisco, runs east-west and is perpendicular to South Spruce Avenue.
Water flows under the bridge in a culvert that runs north-south and parallel to South Spruce A venue. 4 The culvert is Marker #2 7 in South San Francisco's Historic Marker Program. The first train ran over the bridge in October, and the rail line was taken over by Southern Pacific in 5 A visual existing condition examination of the bridge was completed by Carey & Co. Inc. in June, The west side of the bridge was not visible. Underneath the bridge and leading out to the east, a cement culvert leading to an underground drainage system was constructed and covered with earth. Vegetation has subsequently grown over it. Th east side of the bridge was therefore not visible.
Visual observation of the south headwall revealed that the cut stone units appear to be in good condition with no visible cracking or other deterioration. One unit located at the top of the west headwall to the north is visibly displaced. The raised or beaded mortar joints are both intact and broken off in places. In several locations, the beaded joints have broken and fallen away, which has probably taken place gradually over time, and are not attributable to any singular event. 6 II. ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING INFORMATION General Statement The Cut Stone Bridge is a traditional, stone-coursed, ashlar bridge constructed of two similar headwalls and four wingwalls.
All stone faces at the West Headwall are bush hammered, a technique widely used in the United States by the early Century for finishing limestone and sandstone. 7 Most significant of this tooling technique is the contrast of the stippled finish and the chiseled margins at each joint. The East Headwall and all wingwall faces are rough-cut with a one-inch flat margin at the joints, with the exception of the East Headwall voissoirs being bush-hammered. CUT STONE BRIDGE HAER NO. CA-263 Page 3 Description of Bridge The bridge railroad span is approximately 18 feet long with a width of 27 feet 10 inches. The east and west headwall stone units vary between four to 20 inches in depth and are tapered.
The headwalls are approximately 14 feet across at each base with a height of ten foot seven from the top of the capstone to the springline. The springline is the approximate location of the creek bed. Mortar joints at the headwalls are one quarter inch wide and half an inch wide at the wingwalls. A capstone course tops the headwalls and wingwalls. The headwall capstones measures 18 feet six inches in length and consist of twelve to thirteen stones, approximately 2 13 11 x 2 13 11 x 11 The capstones overhang the headwalls by three inches. Two semi-circular arches and a stone rubble tunnel, with six foot radii, are centered in the headwalls. The West Headwall is more detailed than the East Headwall or the wingwalls because of its tooled finish and because of a monumental carved center stone.
The center stone, approximately 10 feet by one foot five inches, is bush-hammered with raised letters, "O.H. Rand, Builder." The West and East Headwall course stones vary in size, but are symmetrical at the centerline. At least eight courses stack up to form each headwall and these line up with the courses at the wingwalls. Foundation courses, perhaps three, continue down approximately four feet. The wingwalls, designated as northwest, southwest, northeast and southeast, extend approximately 16 to 18 feet from the headwalls at an angle of 120 degrees and buttress the hillside and the headwalls at an angle of three inches in every 42 inches. The southwest and southeast wingwalls run partially below Spruce Street. The mortar joints measure half an inch wide.
The rough-cut stones vary in size and the course heights vary between 10 inches to one foot seven inches. Alterations A concrete slab was poured at the creek bed through the tunnel and covers a 15 to 18 inch terra cotta sewer line. A 12 inch wide concrete retaining wall abuts the West Headwall near the southwest wingwall and runs sixteen foot four inches perpendicular to the headwall at a height of approximately four foot seven inches and then continues at a lower height towards another culvert under the dirt road to the west. At the East Headwall, an approximately 14 foot wide concrete box culvert abuts directly into the wall, obscuring the voissoir stones and directs all runoff water under the bridge. The box culvert and fallen topsoil obscure more than half of the East Headwall .
CUT STONE BRIDGE HAER NO. CA-263 Page 4 III. HISTORICAL INFORMATION San Francisco~San Jose Railroad In September the Pacific and Atlantic Railroad ( to run between San Francisco and San Jose and coast-to-coast thereafter) was incorporated, the first such venture in California. 8 It was organized by a committee of San Francisco and San Jose capitalists who had raised to survey a forty mile route. The firm closed in as it could not sell enough stock to fund the venture. In October of that year, the company was reorganized again with William Howard of San Mateo serving as a director. This second company also failed due to a financial slump. In a third group led by San Francisco investors also failed, due to unfavorable publicity.
9 Finally, on August 18, a new San Francisco and San Jose Railroad was incorporated, led by its President and San Francisco Judge Timothy Dame. Peter Donahue, a "whiz with machinery" was named treasurer, who was destined to become "one of the greatest railroad men of the West." 10 Charles Polhemus was also a director, and along with Donahue had purchased land around San Mateo near the proposed rail route. Congressman Timothy Guy Phelps was a third director who also purchased a large tract near the future town of San Carlos. 11 To supplement private capital, the City and County of San Francisco passed bonds for in railroad stock, San Mateo County passed bonds for and Santa Clara County for 12 In October Donahue hired Charles McLaughlin and Alexander H.
Houston as contractors to build and equip the railroad for $2 million. 13 According to their contract, they were to build a single track railroad from San Francisco to San Jose "in perfect running order, with all its bridges, viaducts, embankments, excavating, cars, engines, rolling stock, huildings, and equipment, and delivered within three years from the first day of October, A.D. 14 At this time, a group of San Franciscans launched the scheme of building a railroad from San Francisco to San Jose, with the hope of extending it later to the Mississippi River. 15 In May ground was officially broken for the new San Francisco-San Jose Railroad at San Francisquito Creek, near Palo Alto. Construction began and five base camps were built between San Francisco and San Jose.
16 By October there were nearly 250 men employed on the project. During the latter part of and early grading along the line was rapidly pushed ahead. Men were being hired as rapidly as they could be recruited and included over 300 laborers along the line. The men were paid $2 7 per month, along with their board. By mid-1862 almost all of the grading and bridging was completed. Predictions by the local press of early completion were thwarted with the wet winter of It has been referred to as "The Blessed Floods," as it halted much of the grading work and it taught engineers "truths that will be of immense service.
The engineers went up and down the line while the water marks were fresh and revised all their specifications for drains, culverts, and bridges." 17 Disruption in construction was caused by the Civil War due to the necessity to purchase iron and equipment from the East, disruption CUT STONE BRIDGE HAER NO. CA-263 Page 5 in the national economy and currency, and fear of British intervention. 18 By February all grading, masonry, and bridging were completed except for the Bernal Cut in San Francisco and two miles of line in San Mateo. By the end of September track was laid as far south as Redwood City. 19 On September 14, a special trial trip was held for the Mayor and Supervisors of San Francisco, along with the President and Board of Directors of the railroad.
20 As reported by the San Francisco Daily Call of September 15, "Taking their seats, the party was taken over the road at a leisurely gait - stopping occasionally to look at some superior specimens of masonry .m the shape of cu lverts - . On Sunday, October 18, regular passenger service was put into operation between San Francisco and Mayfield, with one train running each way daily. 22 The entire line would not be completed until early the next year. On January 18, the line was opened to the public between San Francisco and San Jose.
As the new line became so popular, after February 15, two trains daily were placed in operation each way 23 Southern Pacific Railroad The San Francisco and San Jose Railroad would not be in existence for very long, and was absorbed in into the original Southern Pacific Railroad, an organization formed three years earlier by Congressman Phelps to build a line from the Bay Area to southern California. In Southern Pacific was absorbed by the Central Pacific Railroad which was controlled by the "Big Four": Leland Stanford, Collis P. Huntington, Charles Crocker and Mark Hopkins. 24 (From Frontier to Suburb - Peninsula Portrait by Postel says this happened in The Peninsula route now became part of a regional transportation system. IV.
Sources
Bancroft Library. Researched bibliography citations from thesis completed by Louis Richard Miller. Bancroft. Chronicle of the Builders. 7 volumes, San Francisco, California State Library. Minutes of the San Francisco and San Jose Railroad and California State Railroad Museum Library. Master Index to Collections. Carey & Co. Inc. BART SFO Airport Extension Project. Visual Observation of Existing Condition Report. June 3, City of South San Francisco. Historic Marker Program. Marker#27, No date. Daily Alta California. "The San Francisco and San Jose Railroad". October 27, Daily Alta California. "The San Jose Railroad". October 18, Historic Resource Report for BART-San Francisco Airport Extension Project, Date unknown. Hynding, Alan.
From Frontier To Suburb, The Story of the San Mateo Peninsula. Star Publishing CUT STONE BRIDGE HAER NO. CA,263 Page 6 Company, Miller, Louis Richard. "The History Of The San Francisco & San Jose Railroad". San Mateo Junior College, June Obtained at the San Mateo County Historical Society. Miller, Louis Richard. "The History Of The San Francisco and San Jose Railroad". Master of Arts Thesis, University of California, 194 7. Obtained at the San Mateo County Historical Society. Moran, Kevin. Union Pacific Engineering Records. Interview December 23, January 7, and July 29, Postel, Mitchell P. Peninsula Portrait, An Illustrated History of San Mateo County. Produced in cooperation with the San Mateo County Historical Association. Windsor Publications, San Mateo County Historical Association.
La Peninsula. Journal of San Mateo County Historical Association. "The Coming Of The First Railroad, Vol. XII February Sola, Amadeo. Interview by Joan Serrata, South San Francisco Historical Project, May 5, South San Francisco History Room. A Short History of the Peninsula Commute Service. No date. Southern Pacific Bulletin. From Trail to Rail. The Story of the Beginning of Southern Pacific. March Stanger, Frank. South From San Francisco, San Mateo County, Its History and Heritage. San Mateo County Historical Association, The Western Railroader. Ocean View Line". Vol. 41, Issue September Obtained at the San Mateo County Historical Society. The Western Railroader. "In The Good Old Days. Peninsula Service, A Story of Southern Pacific Commuter Trains", No Date.
Obtained at the San Mateo County Historical Society. Wright, Richard. Southern Pacific Daylight Train History, Chapter 1. Vol. 1, Obtained from the San Mateo County Historical Society.
Project Information
This documentation has been prepared at the request of the Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART), which is proposing to demolish the structure and replace it with a new concrete structure in approximately the same location. As part of the plan, the historic west headwall and its wing wall will be disassembled prior to demolition and reassembled as part of the new structure. Due to planned BART extension construction in the Spruce A venue area, the bridge must be removed in order to construct the line. The Memorandum of Agreement for the extension of BART to the San Francisco Airport and Millbrae (BART,SFO Extension) listed several Stipulations for the removal of the bridge.
The first Stipulation states "Prior to any impacts to the Cut Stone Bridge, BART shall arrange to have an Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) prepared in accordance with National Park Service standards. BART shall ensure that CUT STONE BRIDGE HAER NO. CA-263 Page 7 unless otherwise agreed to by the National Park Service, all documentation would be completed and accepted by the National Park Services prior to any dismantlement and that copies of this documentation are made available to both the SHPO and the City of South San Francisco. 25 Project manager for the recordation was Hisashi B. Sugaya of Carey & Co. Inc. Darlene Keyer was Principal Researcher.
Laura Culberson, Architectural Conservator, provided valuable descriptive information as part of her involvement in the dismantlement of the bridge. The photographer was David Wakely of San Francisco, California. The documentation is based on previous documents, principally the Historic Resource Report prepared for the BART SFO Airport Extension Project. Darlene Keyer conducted additional archival research and oral interviews as part of the HAER recordation project. ENDNOTES 1. Inscription on cut stone bridge. Research has not uncovered any significant information about this builder. At the suggestion of John Snyder of the California Department of Transportation ( CalT rans), Carey & Co.
contacted Kevin Moran, head of Engineering Records for Union Pacific Railroad in Nebraska to determine if there may be any records of the builder or the bridge. Union Pacific purchased Southern Pacific Railroad and has all of its records. Mr. Moran said that the earthquake and fire destroyed most of Southern Pacific's previous records. Limited research was also completed at the Bancroft Library at the University of California, Berkeley and the California State Library in Sacramento to obtain bibliography citations from Louis Richard Miller's 194 7 thesis on the San Francisco-San Jose Railroad and from the Bancroft Library web site. The California State Railroad Museum Library in Sacramento was also contacted who provided a list of their collection.
There were not any appropriate records which discussed the culvert or its builder. Carey & Co. obtained a copy of an interview completed on May 5, by Joan Serrata, from the South San Francisco Historical Project with long-time South San Francisco resident Amadeo Sola. It seemed that Ms. Serrata was being taken on an historical tour by Mr. Sola for a project about the history of the City. His family traces its origins in South San Francisco to and he donated his historical and family history information to the South San Francisco History Room. Mr. Sola was active in the San Mateo Historical Society. In the interview, Mr. Sola refers to the bridge, saying "now this is the bridge of the Southern Pacific railroad at Spruce that came from 3"1 and Townsend, in San Francisco and went to San Jose.
It was built by O.H. Rand in 2. BART-San Francisco Airport Extension - "Finding of Effect, Historic Resource Report". (No date): 53. 3. City of South San Francisco. Historic Marker Program. Marker (No date): 2 of 2. CUT STONE BRIDGE HAER NO. CA~263 Page 8 4. BART ~San Francisco Airport Extension. "Finding of Effect, Historic Resource Report". (No date): 53. 5. City of South San Francisco. Historic Marker Program. (No date) 6. Carey & Co. Inc. "Visual Observation of Existing Condition." (June 3, 7. McKee, Harley J., Introduction to Early American Masonry, National Trust for Historic Preservation, Washington 8. South San Francisco Library History Room. "A Short History of the Peninsula Commute Service." (No date): 1. 9. Hynding, Alan.
From Frontier To Suburb, The Story of the San Mateo Peninsula. Star Publishing Company, 62. 10. The Western Railroader. "In The Good Old Days. Peninsula Service, A Story of Southern Pacific Commuter Trains." (No date). Obtained at the San Mateo County Historical Society. 11. Hynding, Alan. From Frontier To Suburb, The Story of the San Mateo Peninsula. Star Publishing Company, 62. 12. Stanger, Frank. South From San Francisco, San Mateo County, Its History and Heritage. ): 94. 13. The Western Railroader. "In The Good Old Days. Peninsula Service, A Story of Southern Pacific Commuter Trains." (No date): 1. Obtained at the San Mateo County Historical Society 14. Miller, Louis, Richard. "The History of the San Francisco and San Jose Railroad." Master of Arts Thesis. University of California, 39.
15. Southern Pacific Bulletin. "From Trail to Rail- The Story of the Beginning of Southern Pacific." (March 12. 16. The Western Railroader. "In The Good Old Days. Peninsula Service, A Story of Southern Pacific Commuter Trains."( No date): 1. Obtained at the San Mateo County Historical Society. 17. Miller, Louis, Richard. "The History of the San Francisco and San Jose Railroad." Master of Arts Thesis. University of California, 49, 50, Footnote 18. La Peninsula. Journal of San Mateo County Historical Association. "The Coming of the First Railroad, (Excerpt from Frank M. Stanger book). Vol. XII. No. 1. (February CUT STONE BRIDGE HAER NO. CA-263 Page 9 ): 1. 19. Miller, Louis, Richard. "The History of the San Francisco and San Jose Railroad." Master of Arts Thesis.
University of California, 52, 53. 20. Miller, Louis, Richard. "The History of the San Francisco and San Jose Railroad." Master of Arts Thesis. University of California, 53. The Western Railroader. Ocean View Line." Vol. 41. Issue (September says that the first trial run was on September 25. 21. The Western Railroader. "In The Good Old Days. Peninsula Service, A Story of Southern Pacific Commuter Trains."( No date): 2. Obtained at the San Mateo County Historical Society. 22. Miller, Louis, Richard. "The History of the San Francisco and San Jose Railroad." Master of Arts Thesis. University of California, 57. Stanger, Frank. South From San Francisco, San Mateo County, Its History and Heritage.says that the first regular passenger service was put into operation on October 17, 23.
Miller, Louis, Richard. "The History of the San Francisco and San Jose Railroad." Master of Arts Thesis. University of California, 68. Wright, Richard. Southern Pacific Daylight Train History, Chapter 1. Vol. 1 says the new rail line was completed in (June 6, ): 13. 24. Hynding, Alan. From Frontier To Suburb, The Story of the San Mateo Peninsula. Star Publishing Company, 64. Postel, Mitchell P. Peninsula Portrait, An Illustrated History of San Mateo County. Produced in cooperation with the San Mateo County Historical Society. Windsor Publications. says that Southern Pacific was absorbed in p. 64. 25. BART-San Francisco Airport Extension. "Finding of Effect, Historic Resource Report". (No date): 53. Visual inspection by Hisashi Sugaya, Carey & Co. Inc. (June 3, Cut Stone Bridge HAER No.
The federal survey recorded these other structures elsewhere in San Mateo County. These are the other structures
they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.
Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CAL,41-SOSF,1-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.